In Politically Sensitive Matters Justice Chandrachud Sometimes Disappoints: Dushyant Dave
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ต.ค. 2022
- #karanthapar #thewirenews #dushyantdave #supremecourtofindia #dychandrachud
Support The Interview with Karan Thapar - fij.mojo.page/support-the-int...
In a 33-minute interview to Karan Thapar for The Wire, Dushyant Dave said Justice Chandrachud as Chief Justice of India must follow the example of Justice P. D. Desai, a former Chief Justice of the Himachal Pradesh, Calcutta and Bombay High Courts. Mr. Dave said Justice Desai “didn’t give a damn about the executive”. As Chief Justice of India that is the example Justice Chandrachud should follow. This point was made when comments made by Justice Chandrachud in his P. D. Desai Memorial Lecture in February 2020 on dissent as “a safety valve of democracy” were being discussed.
Join The Wire's TH-cam Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
![ทททททททท #27 [หลุยส์ เค โตมายังไง ณ สระบุรี]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CaKoYw_Xmtg/mqdefault.jpg)
Three cheers for this extraordinary interview on the eve of Justice Chandrachud assuming the office of CJI for a two year tenure. A most objective assessment of the future of the Institution of Judiciary in India in the short term prompting optimism and hope in its revival from the disturbingly low level it has reached during the recent past. Thank you, Mr. Dave for a brilliantly structured analysis with alarming frankness. And thank you, Karan for your masterly handled interaction with your illustrious and highly respected guest, Sri Dushyant Dave.
We have confidence that the Indian Judiciary will be in good, safe hands of a highly capable CJI when we needed it most.
Correct -and delighted- as I was, you too are!- response! Karan Thapar has no comparable- and his subjects interviewed are so exclusive, erudite, exemplary! karan Thapar has been enriching us all along. My personal request to viewers- do contribute to the efforts of The Wire, and the likes of Kran Thapar- I have been doing my own.
It is his personal opinion . You call another lawyer , he may give different or may be same opinion . Every one thinks that he is right . The opinion of Judge counts .
Dushyant Dave: When I lose my cases, I'm disappointed the Judges !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@@sumanniv Will do, willingly. Constructive dissent from a strong political opposition and a bold media is essential for the success of the democracy of our Country. Wire, lead by KT fits.
Best review bro❤️👍🏻
Let's hopeTHE GOOD will come out from this TALK. Thanks Mr. Dave n Mr Karan for a wonderful discussion.
Dushyant Dave, as usual, is frank, outspoken to the T. His love and respect for the law is 100%. He calls a spade a spade rightly. We need such lawyers in today's India. May God bless our country with such upholders of the law.
Brilliant discussion. Dushyant Dave is the foremost lawyer protecting human rights and democratic principles and constitutional rights, facing threat from Modi regime. Karan Thapar does great service to India by bringing in such bright and freedom loving minds before public. Congratulations to both. Look forward to November 2024 program. I’m only 83 years old !
unfortunately destruction coming . manufactured terrorism, widespread incited genocides (guj model), emergency declared for "security/economic collapse". no limits, no qualms. cowards like chanda chood only lick boots.
I fully endorse the views expressed by Mr Bhatia। But I think we should have another opportunity of evaluating the CJI before Nov 202
2024
Did you see Gandhi , Nehru, ambedkar et al ?
It is a great relief to see we have intellectuals who are couragious and brave in expressing their opinion.
Great salute to Mr. Dave who boldly shared his honest opinion which will act as eye-opener to general public
I whole heartedly appreciate Mr Dushyant Davey's critical assessments about the CJji and forthrightly expressed to Mr Karan. Congratulations...
Justice Chandrachud gave judgements in respect of IPC Sections 377 and 497,which are of distinct orientation. The way bail application of Arnav Goswami was heard in a tearing hurry with the lofty ideas speaks in itself. SC has become pro-establishment. The trend is irreversible. This govt. will not give any moment to heave a sigh of relief by adopting various means.
Your apprehension is not without substance.👍
Wow!! I didn’t know lawyers like him existed or even how many of his own colleagues agree with him. Hope Mr. Dave isn’t in the habit of going out for morning walks alone!
👍👍👍🙏
everyone will face the justice of the Creator of justice.
better go out head held high on morning walk than on knees licking boots
Agree 100% on Dave. The judge make more noise outside the courts than inside. Not much expectations from new cji
Dushyant sir is such an articulated & brave personality with wisdom that it's a treat to listen to his words ! Uncompromisingly forthright analysis in most of the scenarios.
But he was crying at the farewell of ramanna! I do not remember the name where he was snubbed at the farewell of CJI. He resigned as president SCBA. He vowed never to attend any function of SCBA/ farewell.
Please read and watch Snakes in the Ganga videos by Rajiv Malhotra
@@rnmishra7001 At least he is speaking honestly now.
I guess for a judge , courage is more important than knowledge. A judge is expected to be intellectually strong anyway. It's his/her courage and neutrality that sets him/ her apart.
Very true !!
Mr Dave is clear and forthright in his views. Interesting interview
Good information. Such judges will not be forgiven by History like their masters
Magnificent interview.Dushant Dave is a highly respected and highly regarded as a SC lawyer.He is brave,bold & fearless and speaks his mind clearly.May his tribe increase.
An extraordinary interview. I must say if every lawyer and every judge is as honest like Mr Dave India will have an exemplary judicial system. Thank you mr Thapar for this interview.
Mr Dave is spot-on on Justice Chandrachud. Most, if not all, judges are totally divorced from the reality on the ground. His prompt availability to the Arnab Goswami case, his granting an extension to Jay Shah despite a previous judge denying such extensions, smack of fear of the executive or something not quite right in the judgment handed down, esp given the circumstances surrounding our lives today.
He saw through the injustice in Arnabs case.Do not certify the judge because you do not agree with the verdict and you t have a difference in political views
Kindly see my comments.
He wears nagpur half knickers so he needs to support 56 party
He has overruled his own judgements in adverse reaction of vaccine case & his own son case.
I love your program, Mr Thapar, you really know how to take out the best from your guests, without putting them in trouble.
Absolutely true
Wow. I was wow hearing this man.
This is A True Indian. I wish all judges are like him.
Thank you Karan and The WIRE for this interview.
Karan Thapar has no comparable- and his subjects interviewed are so exclusive, erudite, exemplary! Karan Thapar has been intellectually enriching us all along. My personal request to viewers- do contribute to the efforts of The Wire, and the likes of Kran Thapar- I have been doing my own.
I have unconditionally love and respect for indipendent journalism.
Haha independent my foot. Tainted Wire forgery bast***s
By far the best interview by Karan Thapar. He gets A plus. Dushyant Dave gets A plus plus. He soars.
lol no
Wonderful interview..... wonderful questions by Karan. Brillient answers as well nice background . Sailute both of great figures.
Mr. DAVE, you Hit the Nail on its Head, with PRECISION.
No words except appreciation. The courage, wisdom and dynamism expressed by Dushyant Dave infact and indeed rekindles ray of hope. Still there are individuals brave enough in this country to rise to the occassion.
Highly impressed with both of you. Mr. Karan for asking probing questions, which would not hv been possible without some research and home work. And Mr. Dave for answering your questions very honestly based on fundamental principles of law without any if and but. Great show. My compliments as enjoyed every second of show 👌👌👌👌👌
Thanks to both of you. We the helpless lot who watch and weep in silence over the decline though not total decay of democracy as the pillars are being eroded overtly...we pray and hope that our ONLY HOPE who can HOLD the death knell for our DEMOCRACY in DEATH BED Is His Lord ship Justice CHANDRACHUD.. ALL the eyes are on you sir, and all our prayers will surely back you up ,please please see that the most reputed chair that you are about to occupy regains it's past GLORY that was lost..GOD BE WITH YOU !!😴
Excellent insights. Bold, clear thoughts about what to expect from the new CJI.
Once again Duahwant Dave is valuing the degree of the justice to the highest point what should have been to. Accolades to the intellect of his equalling to the highest moral conduct so far as just is concerned . What would world be thinking of fall and decline of the core parameter upon which the human world has been kept going eversince sustenance.
Mr. Dave, always a delight to hear. 😇
Hats off to Adv Dave & Karan for a meaningful discussion.
Yes Mr.Dave is absolutely right after 2016/17 Supreme Court is going down,down&down.
👍🙏
Dave sir you are common peoples saviour in this present crisis of injustices . Need many more interviews of you sir 🙏
Excellent, bold and clear 👌
From what I heard from Dhave's evaluation of Justice Chandrachud's performance, I tend to be skeptical about his role as CJI where he has to stand up to the Executive. Except for one case ie Mohammed Zubair's Acquittal, all other pivotal cases which mattered to India's democratic interest, he has failed. Therefore, Zubair's case is a flash in the pan and future of the highest court's independence leaves no room for hope.
Zubairs case was also heard after a long time, unlike Arnab's whose case was heard immediately.
Justice Chandrasud should revisit 2002 Gujarat riots and best backery case and should consider the report of Supreme court appointed Raju Ramachandran where the currupt RK Raghavans view giving clear chit and and should be punished who were involved. He should also investigate Justice Loya suspicious manner he was died. He should take the Election Commission where the EC contention that they burnt the VVIP pad. The justice should survive the 2024 general election as the people have lost faith in EC and revisit the Election Law where Modi go away all constitution and fixed time till the expires his term from party in which he was elected and those person should not allowed to contest from another party for nearly 10 years as present govt purchased MLAS AND MPS are purchased from opposition parties with the currupt money and also bring the PMCARE FUND AND ELECTROAL BOND under GAG audit
Education means justice, but today which type of education we have, God knows,,
Yes but "education means justice" ?
It was a very honest and brilliantly articulated discussion between 2 highly qualified veterans of Law.
It was the exact reflection of the same thoughts and fears and apprehensions, that each Indian is currently going through.
It is almost more than 3 months since Justice Chandrachood has taken the highest position in our Judiciary.
As a person from Kerala, I was expecting him to give immediate attention to the high profile Lavalin Bribery case of Pinarai Vijayan, the Chief Minister of Kerala, which has dramatically and deliberately been dragging for more than 25 years and which has been shamefully postponed more than 32 times, during these 25 years.
Pinarai is even involved in smuggling gold bars through the Diplomatic Cargo of a Foreign Consulate.
The NIA and the ED seem to have pushed these cases under the Carpet, because of the Governmental pressure from the Central Executive, as Pinarai is very much the blue-eyed boy of Modi.
It appears that Justice Chandrachood has already succumbed to the pressure of the Prime Minister ; this case is therefore likely to drag on for another 10 years, depending on Modi’s tenure.
It appears that we are not going to see any positive change or progress with our Judiciary ; it appears that it is the same old wine in a new jar.
👍🏼❤️ Kudos to Justice Dushyant Dave and Karan Thapar for the enlightening discussion in detail and no one can judge but pray Justice shall prevail in these difficult days for the Judges to deliver..
Good Luck to our future CJI Justice Chandrachud ❤️👍🏼
Among recent CJs it was Justice. U. U. Lalit who turned out to be a welcome surprise. He doesn't have an aura of a liberal judge. But he constituted multiple constitution benches to take up sensitive matters which were languishing for years. It was a great loss to our country that his tenure is only 77 days
Mr Dave shows how we can better understand what is at stake and the value of democracy and TRUTH
One of the most constructive assessment of Chief Justice designate Dr. Justice D.Y Chandrachud I've ever seen. Albeit his ineffectiveness in politically sensitive matters as put forth by Mr. Dave, I presume my belief that after commencing his tenure as the Chief Justice(an office of tremendous responsibility and duty), Justice Chandrachud will exercise his powers as a true custodian of constitutionalism judiciously by making the executive accountable and thereby reinforcing the vibrant democracy. Moreover, his dissenting opinions in highly illiberal judgements of the Supreme Court like Elgar Parishad, Aadhar Act, Hadiya etc where he disagreed with the majority decision to truly uphold fundamental rights as enshrined in the Constitution. Even as the Chief Justice, I believe in Justice Chandrachud's intellectual prowess as it is...
I thanks both of you being intellectual discussion on present issue of the day,Dy Chandrachud is the Costodian of Judiciary SYSTEM,He has guts to stand with the people n follow the Rul of Laws in all respects Thanks,
Mr. Dushyant Dave kudos to u and yr honesty n how forth right n fearless you are. We definately need more lawyers like you.
Karan Thapar & Advocate Dushyant Dave both are fantastic person. Karan Thapar took the Interview very specifically to the point and the replies were great.
THE WIRE NEWS NETWORK 🙏🇮🇳
An eye opening discussion which will increase the confidence in judiciary. Really wonderful discussion. Thanks both of you and hope our judicial system will be one of the best judicial system.
ALL OUR Supreme judges and Supreme journalists for that matter all Supreme souls should remember constantly is Supreme lord is watching all 24-7
Good morning sir,
The analysis delighted me very much.
Thank you Mr Dave and Mr. Karan for forthright analysis about our new C J I .
If justice Chandrachud sticks to his skills and not worry about executive, it has the potential to tilt the whole political scenario in India for good. That's the kind of scenario he is becoming CJI for 2 good years. Time will answer.
I salute Mr Dushyant Dave for his transparent unbiased in-depth account of his assessment of CJI Chandrachud 🌿🌺👌
I profusely thank Mr Karan for his extricatoing questions; of course he is known for it ! ThanQ U for both 🙏🌿🌺🙏
hats off to Mr Dave, this is nationalism. proud of you Sir
I requests judiciary to work & inspire people's of this country to rule of law. If they work under pressure, then people are gone
What an interview. Mr. Dave was on roll today. Cherished it completely for its honesty, professionalism and candidness. As a lawyer, I just hope Mr. Dave is as just to his juniors as he is on screen. Cheers
Brilliant interview.👍 independent journalism & a brave intellect in the capacity of Sr.Advocate Deve is the need of an hour.
When you appeal to subscribe, please remember the common people has more option to join it. Every one donot hold visa card. Keep more option to pay Bheem, G pay, phone pay etc.
Another great interview regarding judicial integrity under the present circumstances. Being highly intelligent, well educated, well informed, and a highly regarded legal authority does not mean that a jurist will always deliver a just verdict. This is the reason verdicts delivered by eminent jurists are critically evaluated and reevaluated the world over for their pros and cons. Advocate Dave has very succinctly and objectively analyzed the judicial record of justice Chandrachud.
Indeed we can pray for Justice Chandrachud to stand up to upheld the constitution with courage and ethics.
Why judges should be afraid of powerful executive? Are they not protected by the constitution of the India? One thing I noticed in the new incumbent CJI is he lacks consistency. One day he gives landmark judgement rising the bars and on another day he delivers a lackluster judgement.
We had a chief justice....bjp has made it as just ice
Fully agree with comedian Kunal Kamra “I have more respect for Food Courts than for Supreme (Saffron) Court! Shame on selective justice! Love your honesty Adv. Dushyant Dave…an pure soul.
Kindly see my comments.
Thanks Karan for this wonderful interview, by which you are trying to bring out real face of present judiciary systems in our country.
Senior Advocate of supreme court Mr. Dushyant Dave rocks.
बहुत सुंदर साक्षत्कार।
Karan brings out the best from Dushyant Dave. It's a pleasure to watch their discussion.
Mr.Dave has brilliantly, courageously called a spade Spade.
It appears CJI Designate is great Judge except when top executive in picture. For a layman viewer like me it appears top executive may be knowing some secret about him and won't be hesitant to use it. Hope CJI Designate will rise above it and prove me wrong.
Dave claimed last CJ as people's judge, that was a wild blind praise. Justice is gone with judge loya.
Very well expounded the current political situation by Dushyant Dave.
What great interview by this great personality called Mr. Karan Taper.
Hats off to mr Thapar 👍
Very well said, Dave. EVERY judge of SC should have zero tolerance of wongful attempts to buldoz judiciary.
Salute to you Sir Dave !
Great to hear mr Dushyant Dave
Dushyant Dave is saying that the Ayodhya judgment was erroneous by justice Chandrachud which means that the bench caved in to the pressures from the saffron government and gave the judgment which went not against hindus or Muslims but against the secularism and unity of the country. Also Dave is absolutely right when he says every single mandir masjid case should be thrown out of the window and never reopened again. This country needs Jobs, economic revival, strengthening of the rupee, the lowering of the costs of petrol, diesal, gas and other basic commodities used by the common man for everyday consumption. All these rebuilding of temples and other sites is not going to help the majority of the poor sections of this country who have been struggling for the last few years surviving with a hand to mouth existence.
It's heartening indeed as always Big Thank you Karen Thapar and advocate Dave.
Justice Chandrachud is remembered for his firm stand on the Adhar.
Hope this CJI doesn't bend down to the Executive and for the sake of democracy takes up the issue of payment to political parties through opaque bonds and counting of all ballot papers alongside counting of votes through EVMs. Under such rapid success of Electronics, computing and related fields it becomes doubtful to many that fully transparent system of voting is being adopted
Extraordinary interview... Respect this man
Sir Dushyant Dave very erudite & eloquent & bold as always & very rightly at the climax his comment to wait & watch for the final verdict as Justice Chandrachud is a sensitive judge.
Mind Begs the Question:
If under a PM/Govt
Judges removed,murdered
If Judgement not favorable
Judiciary - not Pressured,Pressured?
India deserves and needs a CJI like sri .Dushyant Ďave.
I completely agree.. the smiles that I saw on Mr Chandrachud face after his ascension to CJI just showed 'I me myself'.. there was no maturity in that smile.. sad but the stark reality..
Awesome discussion
We Indian citizens are looking forward to Mr Chandrachud protecting "citizens" from Govt misusing powers as Electoral Bond, EVMs, CBI/Ed/EC misuse, "wrongful/illegal" holding in jail of leaders of opposition/Social Activists etc..
And bring back corrupt UPA era of corruption, minorites appeasing favouring judiciary etc to make India a Pak!?
A brilliant interview. Kudos to Karan Thapar and Dushayant Dave for an objective, logical and legally erudite discussion. You miss such talks on main stream media now in #Newindia.
Many sections of Ayodhya judgement are laughable.... according to Prof Faisan former Vice Chancellor of Nalsar Law University
We want good journalism as well as nutran justice; Indians are in danger during Modi time
Dear The Wire, i request you to never loose this man, Karan Thapar from your group. Such a intelligent man he is.
I really appreciate Mr. (Advocate) Dushyant Dave frankness, fearless, never mince his words and to the point.
We wish we had all the responsibile citizens (Lawyers, Judges, Politicians and Election Commissioners) similar to him.
Thanks Karan and My best D Dave for this discussion
Let's hope for the best
Thank you. Very few and far between 🙏🏽
It was an enriching discussion. Except, review performance of going to be CJI Chandrachur only after he is done with his tenure, ie, Dec 2024, will be waste and only academic in nature. An interim and periodic assessment will be informative and a feedback to the CJI for self assessment and course correction.
Academic acumen has to be proven with actions ie judgements in more sensitive cases in which central government is directly involved, like Article 370, Electoral Bonds, CAA, misuse of ED&CBI, challenge to protection to places of worship act, Hijab issue, Rafael and other corruption cases against ruling party and Pegasus etc.
Hope under him, the executive doesn't have a free run and SC acts as a supreme check to balance undemocratic actions of any govt, that too well in time. Justice has to be done in time.
We wish him all the best.
Karan Thapar and Shri Dushyant Dave is well done.
Thank you both for a open discussion.... Hope Justice prevails , our Constitution and people of our great Country are Protected by our Judiciary... Thanks a lot
Wonderdul person. I wish he could one day be our Chief Justice.
Yes, in your dreams
Well said Mr. Dave ❤❤❤❤
And Mr.Dave,very fearless and outspoken legal mind.
This remarkable, extraordinary, bold interview is quite interesting.
How about fatwas and parallel courts and slap on free speech in case of Nupur Sharma case ?
Very meaningful discussion.
So, Mr Chandrachur
1. has tremendous knowledge of law, is a jurist and brilliantly interprets the law.
2. Does this mean he did what he did for Babri Masjid, gyan vapi and justice Lohia's case despite knowing and interpreting law with such brilliance?
3. Minorities, particularly Muslims shud rest their case.
Judiciary should bind the government with chains of constitution when later crossing its limits...
All the best to CJI-designate ...
Well educated person honest person , for democracy we need this lawyer to supreme cort
Glad , positives and negatives of judgements of the our future Hon. CJI . Thank u so much. Hope he will stick to law and constitution , for better future of India