I agree, you notice more of the nuisances which are so revealing of their feelings for each other. Each time she rebuffed him, bumping his arm, lightly touching his coat or sleeve or glancing at him, she was telling him her true feelings.
I think it's adorable the way Werner is nervously playing with his cap behind his back before he attempts to talk to Jeanne and her grandfather again. He's trying so hard, poor boy. He just steals my heart.
At the end of the movie instead of just saying farewell she should have told him what she did Christmas night in his bedroom......everything! And she should have apologized for reading his letter. And she should have told him that she fell asleep in his bed and awoke when she heard his vehicle arrive. And that she went back to her room immediately and shut her door. And then she should have given him a long hug and a kiss on his cheek and said farewell. That would have made much more sense and would allow him to know how she felt about him. It would have let him know that she loved him.
At 2:54 it can clearly be seen that Werner was flirting a little bit with Jeanne when he put his hand through his hair while smiling at her. He noticed she looked at him,even though Jeanne never wanted to make eye contact with Werner and he smiled at her. It's funny how Jeanne tries to look like she doesn't care about him but it can be noticed she's just trying really hard not to fall in love with him. Werner makes Jeanne nervous, and he knows it.
Throughout their interactions Jeanne gives away her true feelings. Bumping him as she leaves the kitchen, brushing his coat and sleeve, stealing glances then quickly looking away all tell him she is hiding, which leads to his “silence of the sea” moment.
at 8:04 in this clip, note that Jeanne is reading a book entitled "L'amour Humaine" or something like that, sorry the screen is not very clear. I think it means "the love of humans"? what irony..
That s one of those very rare movies nowadays which goes on about a woman -man interaction without involving bloody sex (the act in itself). It is so rare now. And this is a masterpiece of subtlety! the male character is someone highly aware of the war context with an upbringing based on honour and duty - something that nowadays is very difficult to find in men simply because they are not educated as such. However, although now a character like that of capt. Werner might look like a fairy tale one, such people did exist .... and oddly (enough- oddly for our times of course) they were the result of a society and of an education which now is rejected and thrashed and labelled as being tough or political incorrect or racist or ..... or whatever other iideological crap they have invented now.
Honor and duty are immutable and respected, today as much as before. They are becoming rare qualities, but it’s not because of political correctness. Political correctness is something honorable people recognize as ways to be kind and polite, which also are honorable qualities, despite the scorn heaped on them by the ignorant.
I dont get it?love is stronger than everything. Jeanne was struggling with her feelings for him.War has no power in front of love' .jeanne should have told him how he make her feel also before saying farewell . Beautiful movie!
Why does he go and look in the kitchen window before he goes to the front door? I am assuming he is wondering what is going on in there because the light is not usually on
Perhaps Werner knew something about her stolen bicycle? It gave him the opportunity to offer her a ride in his car. Jeanne chained and padlocked her bike in a very public area. The thief would have had to use bolt cutters to break the chain. Who but a German soldier would have access to bolt cutters and break the chain in broad daylight in public and no one would dare question what he was doing? Werner’s orderly, Franz?
So are you saying Werner ordered Franz to steal Jeanne's bicycle so Werner could offer her a ride home? Or that Franz stole the bicycle without Werner knowing about it? For what motive?
Amy M Werner knew she depended on her bicycle. He needed to get her alone if he hoped to begin a conversation with her. It may have been Franz’s suggestion. To whom would you go to report a crime committed by a German soldier, perhaps his commanding officer? Maybe that’s why Werner was a bit nervous when he was spinning his hat as he went to the library. I’m guessing he already knew what had happened. 😉
@ Amy M The relationship between an officer and an orderly was generally pretty close if they had been together for some time. Franz would have heard things he was never at liberty to divulge. He may have suspected that Werner had feelings for Jeanne and was trying to be helpful. We will never know but it is fun to speculate!
@@atashakgem oh i understood ..so the next day he followed her to let her use his car..he kept trying different ways to approach her...but the girl didnt respond AT ALL😯😯😯
The captain saw her sexy legs, accidentally, as she was adjusting her thigh high. He felt flushed and started circling his cap. Who could blame him? Pascal and his buddy noticed her hot legs too as they gave her a ride back home. The captain could do a monologue about how German and French men appreciate women’ sexy legs as a common “humanity” trait. Ha ha!
![The Wall Song ร้องข้ามกำแพง | EP.213 | กรีน อัษฎาพร | 3 ต.ค. 67 [1/5]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3KrlLbCsadI/mqdefault.jpg)
I keep watching this film over and over. And each time I enjoy it even more.
I agree, you notice more of the nuisances which are so revealing of their feelings for each other. Each time she rebuffed him, bumping his arm, lightly touching his coat or sleeve or glancing at him, she was telling him her true feelings.
omg same T_T
Me too.... I do the same thing. Just love watching his face staring at her and then gives him a hard-to-get look in return.
I think it's adorable the way Werner is nervously playing with his cap behind his back before he attempts to talk to Jeanne and her grandfather again. He's trying so hard, poor boy. He just steals my heart.
He thought they might close the door showing unwillingness to see him. He was anxious 🥺. Touching moment!
@ Morgan Mills About playing with his hat, was it a gesture of nervousness or teasing them?
@@SG-wq4rm He's nervous. He's going to try and start a conversation again, but he doesn't know if they'll respond.
@@morganmills13 he's so cute. I have watched this movie like 100 times already and still finding new details
@@SG-wq4rm I've watched it quite a few times, myself! It's one of my favorite movies.
Love this film.
Exquisite experience.
Thank you so much for uploading the movie with English subtitles.
Why does Werner turn his hat around and around with his fingers in his hand? Is he nervous to see her?
At the end of the movie instead of just saying farewell she should have told him what she did Christmas night in his bedroom......everything! And she should have apologized for reading his letter. And she should have told him that she fell asleep in his bed and awoke when she heard his vehicle arrive. And that she went back to her room immediately and shut her door. And then she should have given him a long hug and a kiss on his cheek and said farewell. That would have made much more sense and would allow him to know how she felt about him. It would have let him know that she loved him.
At 2:54 it can clearly be seen that Werner was flirting a little bit with Jeanne when he put his hand through his hair while smiling at her. He noticed she looked at him,even though Jeanne never wanted to make eye contact with Werner and he smiled at her. It's funny how Jeanne tries to look like she doesn't care about him but it can be noticed she's just trying really hard not to fall in love with him. Werner makes Jeanne nervous, and he knows it.
Throughout their interactions Jeanne gives away her true feelings. Bumping him as she leaves the kitchen, brushing his coat and sleeve, stealing glances then quickly looking away all tell him she is hiding, which leads to his “silence of the sea” moment.
Al1
@Amy M 2:32-3:32 pure flirty or happiness on his part to see her.
Oh boy,his smile makes my heart melt🥰
@@sharyncarr4279i
at 8:04 in this clip, note that Jeanne is reading a book entitled "L'amour Humaine" or something like that, sorry the screen is not very clear. I think it means "the love of humans"? what irony..
Yes,she was falling in love with him.
"L'amour humain, de l'enfance au mariage" Charmot François 🙂
@@silentsea2956 But she did not want to fall in love with a German.
@@user-rf9gs1by3kc Je suis d'accord avec vous.
@@thomasphillips96 But she did eventually. Even if she didn't wanted to.
That s one of those very rare movies nowadays which goes on about a woman -man interaction without involving bloody sex (the act in itself). It is so rare now. And this is a masterpiece of subtlety! the male character is someone highly aware of the war context with an upbringing based on honour and duty - something that nowadays is very difficult to find in men simply because they are not educated as such. However, although now a character like that of capt. Werner might look like a fairy tale one, such people did exist .... and oddly (enough- oddly for our times of course) they were the result of a society and of an education which now is rejected and thrashed and labelled as being tough or political incorrect or racist or ..... or whatever other iideological crap they have invented now.
Honor and duty are immutable and respected, today as much as before. They are becoming rare qualities, but it’s not because of political correctness. Political correctness is something honorable people recognize as ways to be kind and polite, which also are honorable qualities, despite the scorn heaped on them by the ignorant.
The grandfather knew what was going on !
She said to the grandfather:"why are you looking at me like that?"
Tnx Celia for the clips 🙏🙏
You use the symbol of Thanks like the Thai.
👍👍👍🤗💞💕 love untouchable ♥️
Bach german musician:prelude
❤❤❤
He caught her smoking!
I dont get it?love is stronger than everything. Jeanne was struggling with her feelings for him.War has no power in front of love' .jeanne should have told him how he make her feel also before saying farewell . Beautiful movie!
Why does he go and look in the kitchen window before he goes to the front door? I am assuming he is wondering what is going on in there because the light is not usually on
Perhaps Werner knew something about her stolen bicycle? It gave him the opportunity to offer her a ride in his car. Jeanne chained and padlocked her bike in a very public area. The thief would have had to use bolt cutters to break the chain. Who but a German soldier would have access to bolt cutters and break the chain in broad daylight in public and no one would dare question what he was doing? Werner’s orderly, Franz?
So are you saying Werner ordered Franz to steal Jeanne's bicycle so Werner could offer her a ride home? Or that Franz stole the bicycle without Werner knowing about it? For what motive?
Amy M Werner knew she depended on her bicycle. He needed to get her alone if he hoped to begin a conversation with her. It may have been Franz’s suggestion. To whom would you go to report a crime committed by a German soldier, perhaps his commanding officer? Maybe that’s why Werner was a bit nervous when he was spinning his hat as he went to the library. I’m guessing he already knew what had happened. 😉
@@sharyncarr4279 so Franz knew Werner's feelings for her.
@ Amy M The relationship between an officer and an orderly was generally pretty close if they had been together for some time. Franz would have heard things he was never at liberty to divulge. He may have suspected that Werner had feelings for Jeanne and was trying to be helpful. We will never know but it is fun to speculate!
I would like to know please what the captain was looking at inside when jeanne was soaking her leg and why she rusched in the living room?
i'm liking violen more, now
Each person searching for the line .... what are the limitations? She refuses to play piano!
Poor thing, dealing with people with no manners or at least use a little bit if diplomacy.
You need to understand the times; the Germans were occupying France. The Germans, by and large were not benevolent Occupiers.
Anyone knows the song at the beginning?
I do not understand what happened with my message below
could someone please tell me the title of the tune played in the particular scenes and radio here? can't find it anywhere...
R Sin it plays another scene too, I am sure is listed in the sound track, but I can’t find the movie sound track?!!
Can i know why he keeps turning the hat after he saw she treated her legs???
Janice Kang I think he is just mad she has hurt herself, and he can’t stand it,
@@atashakgem oh i understood ..so the next day he followed her to let her use his car..he kept trying different ways to approach her...but the girl didnt respond AT ALL😯😯😯
Probably a way to portrait his sensitive personality as he knows rejection awaits!
@@mswonwongo 😮u described it accurately...
@@mswonwongo totally agree. Werner's reactions are sooo cute! I am fond of him a lot
The captain saw her sexy legs, accidentally, as she was adjusting her thigh high. He felt flushed and started circling his cap. Who could blame him? Pascal and his buddy noticed her hot legs too as they gave her a ride back home. The captain could do a monologue about how German and French men appreciate women’ sexy legs as a common “humanity” trait. Ha ha!
Que de stupiditesces reflexions de jambes!! Cette attraction est a un niveau autre.
What the captain was doing standing on the bridge?