because PC culture and in order to keep the utopia of multiculturalism alive. France is very infected to the core by left extremists, ideologues and wanna be intellectuals from over-privileged high administration.
In France the word "racist" is an insult ,like in the others contry I think , but here it have a very important conotation and if you say something about minorities or differents people you can be categorize as "racist" ,and because of that ,this type of laws pop on our constitution. For exemple the peoples who are radicalized cannot be send back in their contry ,because "oh you are very bad ,you say something about foreigners ,you are racist". (I'm sorry for my English )
Doing stats on ethnicity is admitting it exists and make categorization of the population. Categorizing it, it is already segregation, and segregation leads to discrimination.
Big Pete Not as divided as the UK or USA. 60% of France wants out of the EU compared to the UK's 52% or how America's Trump lost the Popular Vote by over 2 Million having to win by Electoral College.
They don't want us to know how far it has gone. I have heard France is 1/3 non French (which includes other Euopeans). But the children population tells a different story.
@kay doyle The vast majority of people outside Paris is still ethnically French
5 ปีที่แล้ว +33
A brown person with a broad flat nose, thick lips, protruding mouth, nappy Afro hair, etc. is not a real French. Indigenous, true French do not resemble sub-Saharan black Africans.
Strange Boy French is a nationality bud. The ethnicity of French peoples isn’t lateral, it’s changed overtime like literally almost every other nationality. (Besides some Asian groups) Its very hard to not see how your using the words “ethnicity” and your nationality to cover up what your really trying to say *RACE*
Its very biased report. In the UK since the 1990s racial data has been collected for pretty much everything. Not so the non-whites can be rooted out and put in concentration camps, but to be used to look for supposed racial discrimination and under-representation. In fact it is non-white empowerment groups asking the French govt to collect racial stats, for the same reason.
I dont think you are paying attention. What France is doing is by removing the word ipso facto removing the fact that racism is being perpetuated by the state itself by it refusing the fact that races existis. Without race there can be no acts of racism and therefor France has no race problem...problem solved lets move on.
LEts try again.... according to this pieceFrance does not track employment by race....if your not looking at the top line then the bottom line is out of context.
Because while you can't collect statistics based on ethnicity or religion, the state's statistical agency can collect information based on nationality or the nationality of parents and grandparents. Also, the ban on ethnic statistics only concerns public agencies, there are privately funded studies.
I'm an American citizen with Indian origin but this makes me sad for France. America is a country founded by immigrants and colonizers and hence why it is so difficult to define what "American culture" exactly is. However, France is a country with centuries of tradition, history, art, and culture and they have every right to fight for their nationality. Tourists are drawn to France because of the FRENCH culture, not because of multiculturalism. If they want that, they can just visit the US.
@Geel Jire yo my baddd it was from 10 months ago chill - my stances have changed since then and I have also learned, as you so delicately pointed out, that TH-cam is not the place for me to express my political opinions or views
that's actually a much bigger point than most people realize. It would be one thing if WE WENT OUT OF OUR WAY TO ASK FOR THIS situation, but we didn't. This is gen0c!de against our will. Wars have started for reasons 1/100th the severity of this. This isn't just a crisis, this is an EXISTENTIAL crisis. Meaning if we don't solve this crisis it will be our last one.
@Abu Talha Indeed and they pushed the French back to Europe... within a few years (the big crisis) Africans will be pushed back to Africa... thats the point!
And in Italy the same... My best friends are going abroad (all with an university title) and are replaced by the "resources" not able to read and write too...
I’m French and have been living for 5 years in Boston, MA, I remember that when we moved, we were shocked to have to answer questions for state or federal forms about our ethnicity and race. We got used to it but it’s still weird to have to check these boxes.
Peaceful Day yeah, I know, but not in Europe. It’s considered a biais. Each method/culture has its advantages and drawbacks. I understand both ways now that I’ve been living in the US for many years.
What’s the taboo that France has been conquered by black population and they don’t want other countries to freaked out because they are next as England, Netherlands, Belgium ,Denmark, etc
Denmark 🇩🇰 when Denmark is an homogenous countries over 90% of the population are ethnic Danes and 4% are other European and denmark is 94% white and whiter than France and England and Belgium and netherland are full of immigrant
They banned ethnicity from the census since the 18th century because if they had it then people would identify as Britton’s, Norman’s and most notably Occitan. This made it easier to make them all identify as French. Otherwise Occitania and Normandy would have had 19th century national awakenings and France would have broken up
Yeah. They suddenly try to ignore the ethnicity question to erase the ethnocide they made over the last century. It is also an advantage for the French people to grow their linguistic, cultural and traditional rich heritage as this ethnocity is very artificial.
4 ปีที่แล้ว +4
Be ashamed of your heritage UNLESS you come from a failed, impoverished, dictatorial, anti Christian, brown nation.
@@slouma1998 Text can discribe, but can't make the reality. If constitution says France is a country full of yellow éléphants, It's still wrong. Same for French people, wich are white, celtic and catholic.
LONDON IS NOW LES THAN 40% ENGLISH,, LONDON DOES NOT REPRESENT ENGLAND OR THE ENGLISH ANYMORE, THE SAME CAN BE SAID OF MANY CAPITALS, CITIES AND TOWN'S ACROSS BRITAIN AND ACROSS WESTERN EUROPE.
this makes me very happy! If European countries just minded their own business decades ago and didnt colonize the world , the world wouldnt be knocking on their doorsteps today! When u decimate countries and steal their resources dont get mad when they come looking for it!!! hahahha
No problems with this in central and east Europe.. Problem is when some of these big European countries elect some nationalist and put him to power Hitler will be reborn, it's just matter of time.. Stop giving citizenship to every person that enters your country!
Every country has its myths and lies etc, but the french revolution was important, not only to france!!!But sometimes they go to far, but hey, they are french, not swedes!!!!
It's so interesting because as someone who lives in Quebec, ethnicity is not taboo nor is it racist or a microagression and it's understood that people who identify as Quebecois are ethnically French. Quebecois and being French are interchangeable, and either or is acceptable as an ethnicity label in Quebec because it's ultimately understood you're ethnically French. People even make a point if they're not "pure laine" i.e descendant purely of French ethnic stock by saying my grandfather was an irishman or whatnot in Quebec. For example I'm French, because I'm ethnically French, and for some reason the French from France don't seem to understand that. They see French identity as belonging to everyone, which I can agree with on a cutural level but not an ethnic level as ethnicity is routed in historical commonality, thousands of years of ethnic blending which created a French whiteness and culture that fostered French spelt last names and a certain level of ethnic homogeneity. Anyway.
Just wait until you start thinking about begin Jewish. How is that that we refer to so many people as Jewish, when they nave never observed any religious ceremony or ritual, nor have their parents, nor do they observe any traditions that could be linked to Judaism. And yet they can bring up being Jewish and nobody even thinks to question that. Why is being Jewish this special property that is inherited, but being French or German or English not?
European person is not classified by politics but by ethnic background. To be European means to have white or slight olive skin, hair is straight or wavy brown , blonde, red or black hair and colored eyes.. People oc African , Middle Eastern or Asian origin will never be considered Europeans.
@Prince Henry The navigator what about white south africans and descends of european who kills millions of people during the colonial aerea in australia , usa ?
m Zaki Banyu People can grow and live wherever they choose to live, idealistically, meanwhile should also love the land they chose. It’s nothing about race.
"Equal before the law" but it has NOTHING TO DO WITH JUDGING SOMEONE. It is a census, it is just representation and not judgment. If you tell me that people cannot make that very basic and fundamental difference between representating and judging someone...
France should amend Article 1 of their constitution so that categorized analysis can be done of the population to address problems created by certain communities and resolve them at the earliest.
@10 OJay Yes and it's gradually increasing this is why the French governments is not allowing racial statistics data to be collected and publicly published
@@Icecold0505 Religion is not the issue , immigration is the problem. And the local whites are making less children than other races here in France. A typical arab or african family will have a minimum of 4-5 kids while the white French family will have 1 or 2.
When you go to Paris, Marseille or Nice or any big city you feel like you're in NY there's lot of diversity but when you go outside of of the big cities it's the Kentucky and I'm in this area
There is a interesting study done by the CIA where by 2050 you will have an islamic republic in the south of France and the capital will be Marseilles ... And thats not the only new country ... : ) look it up on the web
WELL IF IT IS ON THE WEB IT MUST BE TRUE OR INEVITABLE AND MAYBE THIS IS WHAT THE CIA WANTS, BUT IS IT WHAT THE FRENCH WANT????THE AMERICANS DO NOT RUN FRANCE YET!!!!!NOT QUITE YET!!!! THEY WOULD PROBABLY WANT TO RUN FRANCE, BUT THEY DO NOT!!!!!
@@tylert4827 When did they become "white" ? Who.were The Cagots ? When did Cagots arrive in France ? Louie XIV was "black" as was Bonnie Prince Charlie (Charles Stuart).
@@DanielJones-xj9nt Just because you're a citizen of France doesn't mean you're ethnically French Lol. So can I become Chinese or Pakistani if I become a citizen of those countries?
@@DanielJones-xj9nt LOL you call me racist because I said French people are white?! So is it also racist to say that Nigerians are black?? or that Koreans are Asian??
"Race" also has the meaning of "animal breed" in French. Using it would be to make scientific parallels between different ethnic groups and animal breeds, which is absurd. The word "race" in English came from French, but now it lost the meaning that French uses in most cases. That term is an insult towards humanity in general. We are free, not artificially bred and under the control of another species, like our domesticated animals.
You're obsolete in your interpretation. Race isn't about being free or shackled, it's about a BIOLOGICAL SCIENTIFICALLY ESTABLISHED AND PROVEN REALITY BASED IN FACTS not your petty feelings about the matter. Do you also take offence to the Evolutionary Theory by Darwin? Because you just might affirm it further.
Unconditional Freedom of religion Article 1 of French constitution is a gateway for trouble.. French renaissance gave France gateway into future..sharia is a gateway into the past.. Article 1 is nonsense without motive of a religion also present..
Don't think that our traitors elite represent ourself. We voted no by referendum to EU Constitution in 2005, we have it. Now all migration politics are decided by EU, plus schegen space that's a total free circulation for anyone... France once was "the country of civil wars and religious wars." Some people are saying there that France is reborning.
Damn France you guys not collecting racial data is a blessing. In the USA we get drowned in racial statistics and what they meant and don't mean. You guys are lucky.
If you’re going to say ‘North African origin’ then make your journalism even more accurate by saying ‘of Sub-Saharan African origin’ instead of ‘Black people.’ It’ll be more consistent and sound much more credible.
So everyone is equal and there is no discrimination, yet everyone has to follow very strict European cultural norms and traditions in order to be French. Not so subtly saying "You can be a different race or ethnicity, so long as you assimilate and act like ethnically French people."
@@Steven9567not really in america you go by your etnicity, you got people of mexican origin scream ing they are proud of being mexican when most of them have never set a foot in Mexico same with most latinos and asians the USA, in europe thats not the case, Black people in france are proud of being french first and most of all they arent africans they never set a foot in africa,
It makes no sense not to obtain demographic information on race and ethnicity. This will help people understand and learn more about the country. People already cling to separate community identities before the national identity and whether you gather this information or not will not change that.
I’ve heard Frances white population is low as 78% and high has 85%. If it is 78% than that’s critically low for France and need to do something about their immigration.
Thanks for that @Mylris, and apologies...your post was actually perfectly clear and I mistakenly replied to you when in fact my question should have been addressed to @It's Not The Vibe Stop, which I shall now do.
A society where people cling to separate community identities over a national identity can never be a strong society. However, the sad truth is that a certain religious group will always put it's own group and political identity over their nationality irrespective of which country they are living in. Their allegience is to their sect and their beliefs, not to their country. France needs to wake up to this fact.
That’s the one question on Americas immigration policies for which your answer should disqualify many of the Muslim faith. Allegiance to country first, and if you’re cultural views do not align with ours then you can and should be denied> women are not equal, shame on the western world for not upholding the equality of women as the #1 reason to deny entry for men coming from that religion 😢
Does that make them less french ? When you say this you kinda exclude a lot of people who've been there for generations. Now being french is more a citizenship than anything.
@@jvdv4940 Do you not think it is sad how all West European countries are now just melting pots of the rest of the world. In 50 years time most nations will still have distinct ethnicities and cultures where as Europe will be a just be a dumping ground of all other cultures. We Europeans are already a Global minority, where is the sense in becoming a minority in our home region?
The French are bound to cultural independence by its necessity to have its own language. They should use that as a unifying tool for better future. The teachings of there ancestors will lead them to the democratic decision of the people..vive le france
Cette section commentaire est immonde, presque uniquement des racistes fermés d'esprit et tristes, vous n'êtes pas supérieurs aux autres. Le peuple français s'est toujours composé par rapport aux migrations sur son sol et vous ne faites pas exception à la règle
Rico Taline Je ne dis pas qu'il faut accepter tout le monde, c'est impossible, je ne dis même pas qu'il faut accueillir plus de gens (notre état n'est pas en mesure de le faire dignement pour l'instant) je dis simplement que c'est profondément stupide et inutile de mépriser et de dédaigner les autres en fonction de leurs origines
Apolline Moi ce qui m’énerve c’est ce flot d’anglais \ américains débiles qui viennent déverser leur flot de haine envers la France, alors qu’ils sont ignorants, qu’ils se connaissent rien de la France
K1LL3R268 Apolline MERCI je descend le flot de commentaires depuis tout à l'heure pour essayer d'en trouver un avec une opinion mesurée et non haineuse
Perso, la couleur de la personne, je m'en tape comme de l'an 40. Ce qui m'inquiète, c'est la perte d'identité de la France. J'habite maintenant en Suisse. Les gens ici sont fiers d'être Suisses, fiers de leur traditions, leur coutumes et leur Histoire. Quand je reviens en France voir ma famille et mes amis, j'ai la réelle sensation d'arriver dans un pays du Tiers Monde, tout particulièrement quand je passe par Paris... Et non, ma grande, la France ne s'est jamais composée d'une telle disparité raciale et culturelle. Qu'on arrête ce mythe effroyable d'un multiculturalisme de tout temps et fonctionnel.
Excuse me but "equality of all nationalities and religions" does not justufy no demographic data collection! How exactly are minoritirs discriminated against just because the government has data on their numbers? Absurd.
For me France is a symbol of Civilization and World Culture but in fact today it's very shameful what's happened to French people and why they are too Humans that accepts such things what's happening in France today.. No-Go-Zones and this beautiful place became a place of crime..
Classifying people on race, ethnicity, or religion can only lead to division among the population. About the only thing I have heard in French policy that I completely agree with.
Classifying people based on ethnicity is what creates Nations. Without a ethnicity to tie the identity of the nation to it becomes a meaningless term and the state becomes a tyrannical machine of oppression, no more than a economic zone. It's semi-smart of the elite rulers to run with radical individualism and deny the people their ethnicity because people become much easier to control, and easier to steal from, in the short run as they will be able to impose any will they might have, but in the long run it will lead to their destruction, treachery always does. History is a invaluable teacher.
Bjørn Erik Aunan Incorrect. A nation can exist based on common principles. That is actually the most important feature of a nation, cultural cohesion. Cultural cohesion can exist between people of unique genetic heritages. This is probably how you got here anyway. Your ancestors were not one people for all of eternity.
+Roger Acton People can choose how much importance they place on phenotypic differences. Likewise, you probably consider Greeks and Swedes generally "white" and you're okay. Anyone with eyes can see the differences between these peoples maybe eight times out of ten. They are also historically distinct groups genetically, linguistically, philosophically, and so on.
Yes classifying leads to division so let's leave it up to the population to deal with prejudicial and discriminatory practices...What???? Colorblindness does not work. Ignorance and ethnocentrism are never dealt with that way. Classifying using statistics only becomes meaningful when used positively. But I guess that's subjective too...
Ridiculous there are loads of No go areas in France. A lot of places where the police dare not go. You needs stats on ethnicity to find out how many different races you have how many religions to determine the unemployment underemployment rate amongst the different groups.
French president not obeying the 1st article of their own constitution. Where there it is mentioned that there will be no discrimination among race or religion. But what we see now those are happening? What will be the answer? We want to know.
@@Steven9567 look how many invasions they did in africa, how much did they steal from us What did they do to our women, this universe is just and the whatever u make the cycle will spin for you. But this time is harsh because look what uk did to egypt and the money they stole from it
there has never been such a thing as "the french" the country has always been an amalgamation of different peoples always speaking tens of different languages. if anything, the current french culture, once a product of one small central region, is a direct threat to other cultures having already assimilated all the minorities in france and currently ravaging in africa, destroying ethnicities village by village, from generation to generation
typical leftard, until the mid part of the twentieth century france was almost all white and almost all spoke the language of french and you have the temerity to say something as ridiculous as that. french culture a direct threat to other cultures? if it wasn't for france and other western countries the third world(africa and the middle east etc.) would never be able to live a high standard of life at present. you are an anti-white fool.
I went to Paris once, honestly I think I would find more white people in Australia than I ever did in France.
France is the most visited country in the world, Paris is one of the most visited cities in the world, those non whites could have been tourists.
Paris is not the whole of France, same thing can be said about London or Barcelona.
And?
Yüša Kuzgun you got a problem with that boyo?
Mada Mada Yes, France belongs to the French.
The ban on statistics on ethnicity is astonishingly stupid French peculiarity. No reason for that.
because PC culture and in order to keep the utopia of multiculturalism alive. France is very infected to the core by left extremists, ideologues and wanna be intellectuals from over-privileged high administration.
In France the word "racist" is an insult ,like in the others contry I think , but here it have a very important conotation and if you say something about minorities or differents people you can be categorize as "racist" ,and because of that ,this type of laws pop on our constitution.
For exemple the peoples who are radicalized cannot be send back in their contry ,because "oh you are very bad ,you say something about foreigners ,you are racist". (I'm sorry for my English )
Doing stats on ethnicity is admitting it exists and make categorization of the population. Categorizing it, it is already segregation, and segregation leads to discrimination.
Dirty Sweds
It does not stop them from being racist either.
You are already a divided nation.
Big Pete Not as divided as the UK or USA. 60% of France wants out of the EU compared to the UK's 52% or how America's Trump lost the Popular Vote by over 2 Million having to win by Electoral College.
You must be feeling like an idiot right now, right?
Eryk Pyts Big Pete
Battalion he didn't lose it, Hillary had 3 mil illegal votes
true
They don't want us to know how far it has gone. I have heard France is 1/3 non French (which includes other Euopeans). But the children population tells a different story.
Exactly. Buckle up!
Politics isn't about voting. It's about who controls the streets.
Europeans messed the whole world up. They deserve it
Scott Ritter just said in a video I listened to that 2/3 of the male population is Arab Muslim.
Multi racial. So non French. Got it, thanks.
Majority is still French
@kay doyle The vast majority of people outside Paris is still ethnically French
A brown person with a broad flat nose, thick lips, protruding mouth, nappy Afro hair, etc. is not a real French. Indigenous, true French do not resemble sub-Saharan black Africans.
Strange Boy French is a nationality bud. The ethnicity of French peoples isn’t lateral, it’s changed overtime like literally almost every other nationality. (Besides some Asian groups) Its very hard to not see how your using the words “ethnicity” and your nationality to cover up what your really trying to say *RACE*
@@brunovaz not for long
This is the most incredible Orwellian rubbish ever..... Why not stop cataloging traffic accidents so that you can say there are no traffic accidents.
Its very biased report. In the UK since the 1990s racial data has been collected for pretty much everything. Not so the non-whites can be rooted out and put in concentration camps, but to be used to look for supposed racial discrimination and under-representation.
In fact it is non-white empowerment groups asking the French govt to collect racial stats, for the same reason.
so for you cataloging people like traffic accident doesn't sound rubbish at all ?
I dont think you are paying attention. What France is doing is by removing the word ipso facto removing the fact that racism is being perpetuated by the state itself by it refusing the fact that races existis. Without race there can be no acts of racism and therefor France has no race problem...problem solved lets move on.
Armon Mitchell they are lawsuits and jail sentences or fines every year for racism, check your facts
LEts try again.... according to this pieceFrance does not track employment by race....if your not looking at the top line then the bottom line is out of context.
how do you know France has the largest Muslim population in Europe.
I hear that all the time.
maybe watch the whole video next time
Because while you can't collect statistics based on ethnicity or religion, the state's statistical agency can collect information based on nationality or the nationality of parents and grandparents.
Also, the ban on ethnic statistics only concerns public agencies, there are privately funded studies.
it's most maghrebis. french colonize their land and now we share history
Even maps showing the percentage of Islam shows France in a light green, lol.
they don't give any answer to that, merely say that they use names to guestimate
I'm an American citizen with Indian origin but this makes me sad for France. America is a country founded by immigrants and colonizers and hence why it is so difficult to define what "American culture" exactly is. However, France is a country with centuries of tradition, history, art, and culture and they have every right to fight for their nationality. Tourists are drawn to France because of the FRENCH culture, not because of multiculturalism. If they want that, they can just visit the US.
@Geel Jire yo my baddd it was from 10 months ago chill - my stances have changed since then and I have also learned, as you so delicately pointed out, that TH-cam is not the place for me to express my political opinions or views
America is a country founded by white people lol
they have culture and laws which the fouding fathers layed out
America is an outpost of Europe. Your paper citizenship does not make you part of it.
Agreed France culture not Multi culturism
@@preussianblau5595 cry. Whites are a minority now
'The original' population never asked for multiculturalism! Something many people often forget!
that's actually a much bigger point than most people realize. It would be one thing if WE WENT OUT OF OUR WAY TO ASK FOR THIS situation, but we didn't. This is gen0c!de against our will. Wars have started for reasons 1/100th the severity of this. This isn't just a crisis, this is an EXISTENTIAL crisis. Meaning if we don't solve this crisis it will be our last one.
Africa didn't ask for colonialism.
@@hotdogflavoureddrink True! so Africans pushed europeans out of Africa, no doubt Africans will be pushed out of Europe in the near future....
@Abu Talha Indeed and they pushed the French back to Europe... within a few years (the big crisis) Africans will be pushed back to Africa... thats the point!
@@hotdogflavoureddrink the cause of colonialism are Rothschild and other massonic
"France Iq decline due to biological factors" Search the scientific paper. Immigration is a biological factor.
Provide us with the link please! It has to come from a journal to be a scientific paper, not from a random blog though.
And in Italy the same... My best friends are going abroad (all with an university title) and are replaced by the "resources" not able to read and write too...
yes
I know someone who visited Paris last week, she said the residents were about 90% black 10% white.
Sad!:'(
Damn, I really wanted to visit France not Africa...
sad
But it isn’t true 😭😭
@Mohammed Sabeer north africans aren't black tho
Paristan, capital of l'Afrance.
Selamün aleyküm from swedestan
@@captanphillips7794 Sweden Arabia. -stan is an Iranian term, not Semitic.
@@nagihangot6133 Yh true. But srry bro the Swedistan jokes are just too funny
I’m French and have been living for 5 years in Boston, MA, I remember that when we moved, we were shocked to have to answer questions for state or federal forms about our ethnicity and race. We got used to it but it’s still weird to have to check these boxes.
I'm White. There now you know.
Lara Gravenor ?????????????
@@christianmarcel7766 that's weird. In America it's a norm to ask "what are you" referring to race or ethnic background
Peaceful Day yeah, I know, but not in Europe. It’s considered a biais. Each method/culture has its advantages and drawbacks. I understand both ways now that I’ve been living in the US for many years.
One day france will become islamic nation
I went to the South of France on holiday. Believe me, it's a total dump.
Tourism in mass lead to make place dirty.
Compared to what? Alabama/Oklahoma/Mississippi? Surely not.
Idiot. Tourists are not responsible for making a place impossible to live. It is due to minorities. Yes, directly due to minorities!
Imigration in mass lead to make place dirty!
It’s because southern France is practically North Africa.
well looking at french national football team and sports teams in General i think 90% are Africans
Who have the french nationality
Prince Henry The navigator Some of them are French by blood but they’re mixed race.
Well France did invade countless African countries...embrace your new black Frenchmen!
@@jokbok995 they are not africans at all. They are mostly from France. They are french. These comments are very racist.
@@ytuber971 It is not racist to say that a black person is african in the aspect.
France is Africa
UK is Pakistan
Why is that
USA is Bhutan
UK is Pakistan and India!
@@skp8748
because that is where they had colonies.
What about discrimination against whites? No one ever talks about that.
White people are most racists. Who can discriminate them😂😂😂
That's because the french word "race" does not translate as "race" but as "breed". There is no actual equivalent of the english word "race" in french.
oh yes, there must be...because french leftist politicians and media use the term "racisme" all the time.
@@mdser86 I didn't think it was possible to be this dumb
IY's G7 that’s pretty much what race means bro.
md86 Racisme is racism but race isn’t race in French
IY's G7\
What's the difference?
What’s the taboo that France has been conquered by black population and they don’t want other countries to freaked out because they are next as England, Netherlands, Belgium ,Denmark, etc
Well... The French only have themselves to blame... They shouldn't have gone about conquering and Gallicizing whole swathes of Africa.
As a French I agree.
Denmark 🇩🇰 when Denmark is an homogenous countries over 90% of the population are ethnic Danes and 4% are other European and denmark is 94% white and whiter than France and England and Belgium and netherland are full of immigrant
They banned ethnicity from the census since the 18th century because if they had it then people would identify as Britton’s, Norman’s and most notably Occitan. This made it easier to make them all identify as French. Otherwise Occitania and Normandy would have had 19th century national awakenings and France would have broken up
France will reawaken.
Yeah. They suddenly try to ignore the ethnicity question to erase the ethnocide they made over the last century. It is also an advantage for the French people to grow their linguistic, cultural and traditional rich heritage as this ethnocity is very artificial.
Be ashamed of your heritage UNLESS you come from a failed, impoverished, dictatorial, anti Christian, brown nation.
The city of light has become a city of black.
A little bit, I guess.
French people are white, catholic, celtic.
Well, not according to the constitution
@@slouma1998
Text can discribe, but can't make the reality.
If constitution says France is a country full of yellow éléphants, It's still wrong.
Same for French people, wich are white, celtic and catholic.
Celtic + germanic + latin
@@kultigin1998
80% celtic, with latin influence in the south and germanic influence in the north
@@ricotaline how about black citizens of france? You wanna get rid of them?
The head-in-the-sand French. What a waste of the Enlightenment.
Keep France Catholic
Where are you from? Did you fled from Isis?
@@akunlama89 at least he knows the real islam
Let the inquisition begin !
It's so no-one will be aware of the rising percentages of non-French.
Not being able to call out a colour, race, or religion for causing mayhem within a country amounts to legalized subterfuge by the perpetrators.
LONDON IS NOW LES THAN 40% ENGLISH,, LONDON DOES NOT REPRESENT ENGLAND OR THE ENGLISH ANYMORE, THE SAME CAN BE SAID OF MANY CAPITALS, CITIES AND TOWN'S ACROSS BRITAIN AND ACROSS WESTERN EUROPE.
That is so sad 😢 I am sure your imported slave labourers are really sympathising with you now 😔
this makes me very happy! If European countries just minded their own business decades ago and didnt colonize the world , the world wouldnt be knocking on their doorsteps today! When u decimate countries and steal their resources dont get mad when they come looking for it!!! hahahha
No problems with this in central and east Europe.. Problem is when some of these big European countries elect some nationalist and put him to power Hitler will be reborn, it's just matter of time.. Stop giving citizenship to every person that enters your country!
*MACARON is the most appropriate name for French president...
Welcome to francistan.
Well rather francistan then frandia
I like islamic state of france
Go read France's history. Especially what they did in Africa
@@shahsaud2625 and
@@petarlipovan350 Live
The French wrap themselves in liberté égsité et franernité so much until there's no liberté égalité fretermité left.
Every country has its myths and lies etc, but the french revolution was important, not only to france!!!But sometimes they go to far, but hey, they are french, not swedes!!!!
They be squeezed to oblivion.
Their uniformity within cultural customs and the expectations therein also removes the liberté already in choice.
Hahaha, she made me laugh when she said “treating all individuals equally”. The best joke of the century.
It's so interesting because as someone who lives in Quebec, ethnicity is not taboo nor is it racist or a microagression and it's understood that people who identify as Quebecois are ethnically French. Quebecois and being French are interchangeable, and either or is acceptable as an ethnicity label in Quebec because it's ultimately understood you're ethnically French. People even make a point if they're not "pure laine" i.e descendant purely of French ethnic stock by saying my grandfather was an irishman or whatnot in Quebec. For example I'm French, because I'm ethnically French, and for some reason the French from France don't seem to understand that. They see French identity as belonging to everyone, which I can agree with on a cutural level but not an ethnic level as ethnicity is routed in historical commonality, thousands of years of ethnic blending which created a French whiteness and culture that fostered French spelt last names and a certain level of ethnic homogeneity. Anyway.
Being ethnic french anywhere means you are white. You cannot be black and Ethnically french, French citizen but not ethnically
Just wait until you start thinking about begin Jewish. How is that that we refer to so many people as Jewish, when they nave never observed any religious ceremony or ritual, nor have their parents, nor do they observe any traditions that could be linked to Judaism. And yet they can bring up being Jewish and nobody even thinks to question that. Why is being Jewish this special property that is inherited, but being French or German or English not?
As they say in France Alluha Ackbar
Learn to spell
European person is not classified by politics but by ethnic background. To be European means to have white or slight olive skin, hair is straight or wavy brown , blonde, red or black hair and colored eyes..
People oc African , Middle Eastern or Asian origin will never be considered Europeans.
and vice versa and its not a bad thing
What about Spanish people? They’re white but many have black hair and brown eyes. I’m British and I have the same features and I’m still white.
@@goodheavens1 not the same
@@masnwrdl0511 How about Africans or middle easterners who have light eyes or light hair?
You wanna know the statistics, please check the French national football team.
Wise man
If you want to go on vacation to Africa, save your money and go to France.
Would have to agree there, went to Paris last year,might have well have gone to Africa.
@@Arhats_Corner what? black people make up less than 5%
@@rayanomar4832 africana are not just black north africans are like 20%o of france
@@rayanomar4832 black people make up 8% of Frances population, and North Africans make up 15% of Frances population. That's 23% African
Black populations is only 7%!
Welcome to Francistan! Just look at their national soccer team lol none of them is French.
all of them are french
Just griezman 😂
But together the won the World Cup 🏟..I love france 🇫🇷
@@ibrahimissahjabi597 lol even u r muslim..
@Prince Henry The navigator what about white south africans and descends of european who kills millions of people during the colonial aerea in australia , usa ?
....being a citizen in France is not the same as being a true French person....
@@Raphael-ed3zs no its not
Anyone has French citizenship is French 100%
It’s time to defend your own land and own culture.
ttt ttt Did I mention anything about race? Grow an eye honey.
ttt ttt btw French is ethnicity and nationality.
@@rcourtney1152 black people can't born in France?
m Zaki Banyu ? Again where did you comprehend this line from what I said?
m Zaki Banyu People can grow and live wherever they choose to live, idealistically, meanwhile should also love the land they chose. It’s nothing about race.
Yeah like 40 million actual french
"Equal before the law" but it has NOTHING TO DO WITH JUDGING SOMEONE. It is a census, it is just representation and not judgment. If you tell me that people cannot make that very basic and fundamental difference between representating and judging someone...
France should amend Article 1 of their constitution so that categorized analysis can be done of the population to address problems created by certain communities and resolve them at the earliest.
.
France Demography 2020 : 30% Black, 30 % Arabs, 40% white , France Demography 2050 : 15% White, 43% Arab , 42% Black
@10 OJay Yes and it's gradually increasing this is why the French governments is not allowing racial statistics data to be collected and publicly published
Colour is not the issue. Islam is.
@@Icecold0505 Religion is not the issue , immigration is the problem. And the local whites are making less children than other races here in France. A typical arab or african family will have a minimum of 4-5 kids while the white French family will have 1 or 2.
@@Icecold0505 religion is not the issue its all about the white race staying dominant.
@@jkmcgregor7797 Religion isn’t the issue? Didn’t a teacher just get beheaded over a free speech class or did I miss sometimes?
They don’t want to tell the french that they are being replaced.
I was just in Paris, and as a Swede i have to admit it was worse than many parts of Africa
Swedes are beta males
When you go to Paris, Marseille or Nice or any big city you feel like you're in NY there's lot of diversity but when you go outside of of the big cities it's the Kentucky and I'm in this area
most western europe is like that london birmingham and Manchester its the trío of england then outside that its very in general homogeneous
Yes its VOMIT inducing, all the scum come
There is a interesting study done by the CIA where by 2050 you will have an islamic republic in the south of France and the capital will be Marseilles ... And thats not the only new country ... : ) look it up on the web
WELL IF IT IS ON THE WEB IT MUST BE TRUE OR INEVITABLE AND MAYBE THIS IS WHAT THE CIA WANTS, BUT IS IT WHAT THE FRENCH WANT????THE AMERICANS DO NOT RUN FRANCE YET!!!!!NOT QUITE YET!!!! THEY WOULD PROBABLY WANT TO RUN FRANCE, BUT THEY DO NOT!!!!!
French people are white. its not controversial.
or at least it shouldn't be controversial
@@tylert4827
When did they become "white" ?
Who.were The Cagots ?
When did Cagots arrive in France ?
Louie XIV was "black" as was Bonnie Prince Charlie (Charles Stuart).
@@DanielJones-xj9nt Just because you're a citizen of France doesn't mean you're ethnically French Lol. So can I become Chinese or Pakistani if I become a citizen of those countries?
@@davidmilton5887 Louie the 14th was not black lol
@@DanielJones-xj9nt LOL you call me racist because I said French people are white?! So is it also racist to say that Nigerians are black?? or that Koreans are Asian??
France doing the Latin American model of race relations.
Marine Le Pen desperately needs to win the upcoming election!
yes
the great replacement
yes
France is crazy lol
france need to change. very fast. until it is too late.
"Race" also has the meaning of "animal breed" in French.
Using it would be to make scientific parallels between different ethnic groups and animal breeds, which is absurd.
The word "race" in English came from French, but now it lost the meaning that French uses in most cases.
That term is an insult towards humanity in general. We are free, not artificially bred and under the control of another species, like our domesticated animals.
You're obsolete in your interpretation. Race isn't about being free or shackled, it's about a BIOLOGICAL SCIENTIFICALLY ESTABLISHED AND PROVEN REALITY BASED IN FACTS not your petty feelings about the matter.
Do you also take offence to the Evolutionary Theory by Darwin? Because you just might affirm it further.
@@protestantsfailurend7890 Darwin's theory is not a fact. It's a theory.
You are showing your low IQ, what's your ethnicity???
Unconditional Freedom of religion Article 1 of French constitution is a gateway for trouble..
French renaissance gave France gateway into future..sharia is a gateway into the past..
Article 1 is nonsense without motive of a religion also present..
Those who are not willing to defend themselves deserve to be destroyed.
True! As Barry Goldwater said, "Extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice!"
Co-existence with some is impossible !
Islam is not a race !
+Didier Lemoine Iq of France declined from 102 to 94. Why? Oh, yes.
Christien Scheepers Yes islam is not a race so stop putting a diverse group of ethnicities and cultures under the same “Muslim" umbrella.
It’s all coming home to roost in France now isn’t it? Ignoring the elephant in the room, brushing things under the carpet.
R.I.P France 🇲🇫⚰
...madness
glad they are at least talking about the issue
took till 10secs from the end of the talk to finally get to the whole reason for the segment ....Islam
Thou Art That ...Wow that long.....Got it straight away and just admired Flo's pure beauty for the rest......
Madness? THIS IS SPARTA!
Au revoir France.....Le Pen was your last chance.
Not really. The father could have helped, but the daughter is just an incompetent.
The RN (FN) is absolutely *not* a chance..
Actually I don't think there is any politic party that has a solution
How France become africa,.
MUSLIMS ALWAYS BE MUSLIMS ..but french to stopid understood this things ....
Don't think that our traitors elite represent ourself.
We voted no by referendum to EU Constitution in 2005, we have it. Now all migration politics are decided by EU, plus schegen space that's a total free circulation for anyone...
France once was "the country of civil wars and religious wars."
Some people are saying there that France is reborning.
Damn France you guys not collecting racial data is a blessing. In the USA we get drowned in racial statistics and what they meant and don't mean. You guys are lucky.
WillyTheComposer Move to France.
There's a reason they beat you over the head with it. We live in a racial bolshevik communist state.
If you’re going to say ‘North African origin’ then make your journalism even more accurate by saying ‘of Sub-Saharan African origin’ instead of ‘Black people.’ It’ll be more consistent and sound much more credible.
So everyone is equal and there is no discrimination, yet everyone has to follow very strict European cultural norms and traditions in order to be French. Not so subtly saying "You can be a different race or ethnicity, so long as you assimilate and act like ethnically French people."
That's why Europe works
@@ARUchannel1 but not working though you can't assimilate them
@@ARUchannel1 thats how every country works
If they didnt it would just be another culturless hellhole.
@@Steven9567not really in america you go by your etnicity, you got people of mexican origin scream ing they are proud of being mexican when most of them have never set a foot in Mexico same with most latinos and asians the USA, in europe thats not the case, Black people in france are proud of being french first and most of all they arent africans they never set a foot in africa,
It makes no sense not to obtain demographic information on race and ethnicity. This will help people understand and learn more about the country. People already cling to separate community identities before the national identity and whether you gather this information or not will not change that.
It would be great for deporting all the scum
Flo looking beautiful as always.
I’ve heard Frances white population is low as 78% and high has 85%. If it is 78% than that’s critically low for France and need to do something about their immigration.
Well you really need to define your term 'white', otherwise it can mean anything.
@ White means anyone from Europe.
Thanks for that @Mylris, and apologies...your post was actually perfectly clear and I mistakenly replied to you when in fact my question should have been addressed to @It's Not The Vibe Stop, which I shall now do.
@It's Not The Vibe Stop. Well you really need to define your term 'white', otherwise it can mean anything.
A society where people cling to separate community identities over a national identity can never be a strong society. However, the sad truth is that a certain religious group will always put it's own group and political identity over their nationality irrespective of which country they are living in. Their allegience is to their sect and their beliefs, not to their country. France needs to wake up to this fact.
That’s the one question on Americas immigration policies for which your answer should disqualify many of the Muslim faith. Allegiance to country first, and if you’re cultural views do not align with ours then you can and should be denied> women are not equal, shame on the western world for not upholding the equality of women as the #1 reason to deny entry for men coming from that religion 😢
Soon will become Franfica
30-40% of the population are not ethnic French. Just face the truth.
verry possible, sadly.
Does that make them less french ? When you say this you kinda exclude a lot of people who've been there for generations. Now being french is more a citizenship than anything.
@@jvdv4940 Lol of course they are not French. Might aswell not even call it France anymore. Same with England when in 30 years max.
Ok thank you for letting us know your opinion
@@jvdv4940 Do you not think it is sad how all West European countries are now just melting pots of the rest of the world. In 50 years time most nations will still have distinct ethnicities and cultures where as Europe will be a just be a dumping ground of all other cultures. We Europeans are already a Global minority, where is the sense in becoming a minority in our home region?
The French are bound to cultural independence by its necessity to have its own language. They should use that as a unifying tool for better future. The teachings of there ancestors will lead them to the democratic decision of the people..vive le france
la france it is called la France, stupide!!!
WoW! France is so very much bigger than Britain but has about the same sized population!
You should look at European demographics between 1700 and 2000 you'll be shocked.
France made his demographic transition faster than any other country
There should be ethnicity and religious data in france.
*Multi-problematic*
even the chinese said there are too many blacks in france hahahahahahha
Cette section commentaire est immonde, presque uniquement des racistes fermés d'esprit et tristes, vous n'êtes pas supérieurs aux autres. Le peuple français s'est toujours composé par rapport aux migrations sur son sol et vous ne faites pas exception à la règle
Apolline
Ce n'est pas parce qu'on est en partie issue soi même de l'immigration qu'on doit accepter tout le monde 🤔
Rico Taline Je ne dis pas qu'il faut accepter tout le monde, c'est impossible, je ne dis même pas qu'il faut accueillir plus de gens (notre état n'est pas en mesure de le faire dignement pour l'instant) je dis simplement que c'est profondément stupide et inutile de mépriser et de dédaigner les autres en fonction de leurs origines
Apolline Moi ce qui m’énerve c’est ce flot d’anglais \ américains débiles qui viennent déverser leur flot de haine envers la France, alors qu’ils sont ignorants, qu’ils se connaissent rien de la France
K1LL3R268 Apolline MERCI je descend le flot de commentaires depuis tout à l'heure pour essayer d'en trouver un avec une opinion mesurée et non haineuse
Perso, la couleur de la personne, je m'en tape comme de l'an 40. Ce qui m'inquiète, c'est la perte d'identité de la France. J'habite maintenant en Suisse. Les gens ici sont fiers d'être Suisses, fiers de leur traditions, leur coutumes et leur Histoire.
Quand je reviens en France voir ma famille et mes amis, j'ai la réelle sensation d'arriver dans un pays du Tiers Monde, tout particulièrement quand je passe par Paris...
Et non, ma grande, la France ne s'est jamais composée d'une telle disparité raciale et culturelle. Qu'on arrête ce mythe effroyable d'un multiculturalisme de tout temps et fonctionnel.
I noticed major stratification based on race in France. North Africans were often singled out by police simply for being in public spaces.
It’s because statistically they are more likely to commit a crime so police are more suspicious of them.
some cities like lyon or marseille are 80% muslim
Excuse me but "equality of all nationalities and religions" does not justufy no demographic data collection! How exactly are minoritirs discriminated against just because the government has data on their numbers? Absurd.
For some reason I thought France had more people.
France New Saoud-Arabia.
And Africa, see their football team 70% - 80% black or middle eastern or north African, rest white, with some from Spain or other country.
We all know what is about to happen..
10 years I been saying it..
You don't want people knowing the truth, better to keep that sort of thing suppressed.
May be time to rethink this and start tracking ethnicity and religion. Once you hit 30-40% total It is over. No coming back.
Or less than 90% white.
We're already over.
There's 30% already and it's over.
The results of the current election proved it.
For me France is a symbol of Civilization and World Culture but in fact today it's very shameful what's happened to French people and why they are too Humans that accepts such things what's happening in France today.. No-Go-Zones and this beautiful place became a place of crime..
You are in the middle of the worst crises since 1940. Lets hope you don't do the same thing this time.
No statistics on race or religion? Why? Thats crazy!!!
I lived in France, there are ALOT of middle eastern people in there
let them get out of your country
@@你好神奇 no, we are vanishing their culture cuz what they stole from our lands
Their women are freaking easy that's how it works 💪
North Africans
Multiculturism and diversity is French biggest strength❤
Classifying people on race, ethnicity, or religion can only lead to division among the population. About the only thing I have heard in French policy that I completely agree with.
Classifying people based on ethnicity is what creates Nations.
Without a ethnicity to tie the identity of the nation to it becomes a meaningless term and the state becomes a tyrannical machine of oppression, no more than a economic zone.
It's semi-smart of the elite rulers to run with radical individualism and deny the people their ethnicity because people become much easier to control, and easier to steal from, in the short run as they will be able to impose any will they might have, but in the long run it will lead to their destruction, treachery always does.
History is a invaluable teacher.
Better start seizing people's eyeballs then...
Bjørn Erik Aunan Incorrect. A nation can exist based on common principles. That is actually the most important feature of a nation, cultural cohesion. Cultural cohesion can exist between people of unique genetic heritages. This is probably how you got here anyway. Your ancestors were not one people for all of eternity.
+Roger Acton People can choose how much importance they place on phenotypic differences. Likewise, you probably consider Greeks and Swedes generally "white" and you're okay. Anyone with eyes can see the differences between these peoples maybe eight times out of ten. They are also historically distinct groups genetically, linguistically, philosophically, and so on.
Yes classifying leads to division so let's leave it up to the population to deal with prejudicial and discriminatory practices...What????
Colorblindness does not work. Ignorance and ethnocentrism are never dealt with that way.
Classifying using statistics only becomes meaningful when used positively. But I guess that's subjective too...
I ain't ever going to france, before I get beat up ☠☠
Ridiculous there are loads of No go areas in France. A lot of places where the police dare not go. You needs stats on ethnicity to find out how many different races you have how many religions to determine the unemployment underemployment rate amongst the different groups.
I agree with France who cares about your race or religion
French president not obeying the 1st article of their own constitution. Where there it is mentioned that there will be no discrimination among race or religion. But what we see now those are happening? What will be the answer? We want to know.
There is discrimination against radicals.
@@BS-rm1hv yes, nationalist radicals.
Europe goes to crisis identity 😕😕
Karma
@@hadys.6538 for what for doing everyone been doing when the middle going to get it karma
@@Steven9567 look how many invasions they did in africa, how much did they steal from us
What did they do to our women, this universe is just and the whatever u make the cycle will spin for you.
But this time is harsh because look what uk did to egypt and the money they stole from it
@@Steven9567 look what france did to other africans countries, this is karma
I actually kinda like the French Constitution's first article
chaosXpert i like it too. But I think that France is for the French. Otherwise thats a lot of history and culture lost.
do you perheaps think that lets say Congo could embrase a similar approach?....not in a million years isnt it?
there has never been such a thing as "the french"
the country has always been an amalgamation of different peoples always speaking tens of different languages. if anything, the current french culture, once a product of one small central region, is a direct threat to other cultures having already assimilated all the minorities in france and currently ravaging in africa, destroying ethnicities village by village, from generation to generation
chaosXpert enjoy it because it will be removed when Frenchmen become a minority in france
typical leftard, until the mid part of the twentieth century france was almost all white and almost all spoke the language of french and you have the temerity to say something as ridiculous as that. french culture a direct threat to other cultures? if it wasn't for france and other western countries the third world(africa and the middle east etc.) would never be able to live a high standard of life at present. you are an anti-white fool.
A brit, an a bi-lingual american walk into a studio 🇫🇷 🇬🇧 🇺🇸
France looks like north africa
yes north africa should do the same, reject european white christian back to Europ !