Teaching English without Teaching English | Roberto Guzman | TEDxUPRM
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 พ.ค. 2016
- In this talk Roberto discusses his three phase system which he uses to teach English without teaching English, to improve the learning experience for students and the teaching practice for professors.
Robert Guzman is a full professor at the University of Puerto Rico, Aguadilla Campus. Guzman teaches undergraduate English courses in which he stresses the development of critical thinking skills and hands on language development skills. He’s also a freelance writer and political commentator on the WPRA 990 AM radio show Comunicando with host Toti Figueroa. So far Guzman has published, among other books The Devil’s Advocate Reader, Tropical Tales of Terror, Mitos y Conflictos en la Biblia and Heroes.
This talk was given at a TEDx event using the TED conference format but independently organized by a local community. Learn more at ted.com/tedx
He was my professor and I can reassure you that his class was the best english class I ever had.
Hola, puedes compartirnos tu experiencia en la sesión de aprendizaje? - el inicio, el desarrollo y el cierre? - lo que recuerdes... gracias!
Edwin Soto nice to know you. I am really happy to hear your nice words about your teacher.
Karlin Ana Claro que si. El inicio de su clase es dedicado a las falacias lógicas, algo llamado los "FiLCHeRS" (que son un método deobservar lo que reclama un escrito), y cómo estas pueden ser vistas en alguna publicación ( cabe notar que esto es crucial para el contexto de un escrito). Uno de sus cursos principales es "Technical Writing" así que tiene mucho sentido que el siguente paso sean los tipos de ensayos técnicos y sus partes. Lo siguiente es la aplicación de estos a traves de ensayos, casos,etc.
gracias!! aprecio que hayas respondido.
An American state that can't speak english! Weird, isn't it? I bet Puerto Ricans envy the Filipinos!
"You cannot fake content. You cannot fake passion."
This is exactly how I teach English, for the same reasons - I want my students to be able to use and enjoy the language, not just pass an exam! Roberto explains it so well, and his passion shines through. Love it. :-)
he has great experience. .very useful talk
Can you explain it what he did talk about content and form? That see what the content first is not the form
How to teach like this when all my students book are just full of Grammer and it's the same for me. They know they're Grammer but struggle in speaking English
I always wanted to have a professor who would help us as English major unleash the language within us.
how about begginers?
"We never use textbooks".
Such soothing words.
As a newbie teacher I sometimes feel really anxious about teaching my students the correct form that I neglect what they want to express. This was really eye-opening, thank you so much.
"Specificity entails responsibility. " Super on point.
"Fear people who fear questions" this should apply to all things in the dimension.
all teachers should use content-based teaching methods. great point
I think the most effective part of this method is the fact that it's meaning-making. Meaning-making has been shown to be a highly effective method of motivating students to learn a language, and he seems to be utilizing that aspect of language learning very effectively.
Kannada's itihasa
content based emerged with communication ..
This is harder with students who know nothing of the language and are just starting out, but it is still doable.
@@lifeismeaningful6561 then communication is supported by content especially real or real-like materials which aren't actually created for teaching a language such as videos, news article taken from a newspaper
When the teacher does his job with love... this is creativity
Such a humble title. This man's biggest flex is how he get the students to be interested enough to work with each other to actually learn something. And learning is a painful process that's why not many gets much enthusiasm towards it.
Such a wonderful human being 🥺.
Japan needs this. Hard.
I've been an English 'teacher' here for a number of years. But the traditional methods always leave the students (and me) scratching their heads. I've executed a number of the points mentioned in the talk, but never really put them all together. Maybe I should learn how to cook.
Hang in there friend. It takes time to change deep seated ideas and narratives. The proof however is in the pudding. Our students are in the end our best judges. They know what works and all we have to do is listen.
It's all over not just in Asia
Would never work in Japan.
Their minds don't work like that.
They have zero imagination. They can't think in abstract or creative ways at all..
@@Sean.Q You've clearly never watched anime.
Sean Quick explain to me manga and anime then???
"Specificity entails responsibility."
This is gold .... thanks so much for inspire all of us.
You're a Great Professor
Yes it is
Profesor :D cool
Oooh Teacher Alejo is right here😂
You can’t consent for all
This is information that soooooo many people need to hear right now. It doesn't matter whether they're English Language Learners or not. We are all lifelong learners. This teacher does a great job of explaining how to speak in public even when expressing differing ideas. He's amazing!
This is one of the most inspiring talks I've ever watched. Thanks a million professor Guzman for sharing your experience on here.. hats off!
Wow!!..............
Thank you Shaban for your kind words...
@@robertguzman337 Thanks for this professor!
I am teaching English, currently, and think that it's a great point to let students make mistakes, but it's so different from the modern, standard educational system. You're right. Content is far more important than form. Being able to communicate--even grammatically incorrectly--is the motivation needed to continue to copy those who speak more "correctly." But even then, language is always changing, and English hasn't always been English. There are no hard and fast rules except those we agree to.
CreolioLife ...sooo true
The problem is that most students in Europe have to obtain a B1 o B2 certificate in order to be accepted on further education courses. Cambridge is responsible for these exams and they expect students to produce very specific, rigid, grammatical forms and phrases, and do ridiculous tricks with the grammar to get the certificate. If you want to work in the English teaching game you generally have to bow to their rules and use their stupid, boring, overpriced books. I think they make their materials boring on a purpose so that it takes students longer to learn and consequentially, their profit margin is greatly increased. As you can see I've been trapped working in this job for a while and all I can say is, "lucky you" to people who have the freedom to teach in this way as the majority of students taught in Europe have to pass through the official Cambridge exam system :(
englishtearose challenging the fossilized institutions that are not open to change is part of the problem.
englishtearose So, this is helping it spread, right? What exactly is your point bc I'm smelling some bs.
I think it is good when my ESL students make mistakes; is shows that they are trying and therefore learning. Of course, we need to correct the mistakes. Often in Asia students are afraid to try in fear of making mistakes in front of their collleagues and losing face. Thus I reiterate that they are making face by trying - often more than the students not losing face - and therefore not trying - and learning, more or less that is ;)
OMG!!! I was your student too!! I loved your class. Even though I already knew how to speak and write English, I loved being in your class because I learned how to improve reading and writing skills.
I still remember that I was going to travel to NY to visit my fiancée at that time, and you kept recommending me to go see the Play: The Capeman. Ironically, I am currently a Spanish teacher at a Middle school in New Jersey. I moved to NJ shortly after I graduated in 2002 and I've been here since. It is such a great pleasure being able to listen to your voice again and being able to see this video because you still show the same passion towards teaching that you had back then when I was your student. You are a true inspiration to me!!! I wish that I show the same passion towards teaching in the future. I would like to teach Spanish without Teaching Spanish -Jackie Valle (López-Acevedo)
Jackeline Valle nice to hear from you and know you're doing well. If you ever come to PR look me up.
@@robertguzman337 this is so wholesome ;.;
Well I am an English teacher too and found this man greatly inspirational as a teacher. Do not feel you learning a language rather you are living the language 😊
This TedTalk is brilliant! I’m an English Language&Literature graduate and I can say that I would have loved this kind of professor! His approach to language is amazing. He also uses some Psychology concepts and strategies and apply them to teaching English. I admire him and his passion for English language. ♥️ Thank you for sharing your knowledge! 🙏
I have been teaching English for four months now and this was definitely an enlightening talk. I have been trying to get the students out of their shells, to talk more, to have conversations with them. I often take TED Ed videos to the classes for them to have a little debate, but it's very hard to get them to come out, but when it finally happens, it reminds me of why I love my job, and why I shouldn't give up on my students, because they and I know they can.
"Ask questions, always questions" I found my best students are always the ones who ask many questions, as well as the ones being very confident in their learning, not being afraid of mistakes and always keep on going. I am on my way to change the way I teach French here in Taiwan. I am also pretty frustrated of the traditional way. From what I observed when I learnt language myself, and also in my students or polyglots, the traditional method is not efficient. Students should "dive into the language" and the teacher is there to guide them and give them the keys to understand how other people communicate....not the grammar. Thank you very much for your talk!! Muchas Gracias!
Marion Batard I thought I have written me any question. baychance mistakes then what can I do. I am indian men be you talk Indians is not good. but mail problem I understand some word English now a days talk to speaking very impossible. thank you for your teaching sentence.
Wonderful insight Marion. Thank you for sharing your experiences as an educator. We are all in a very real sense students even if we happen to be teachers.
I remember my french teacher (a non native speaker) the first lessons he gave us was how to pronounce the french words(by the way in spanish is similar, you learn a few rules and you can pronounce decently most of the spanish language), we used to study with books without dialogs just the characters in given situations. The other common tool he employed a lot was repetition: "Répétéz avec moi" and with our participation from day one we had to open up our mouths and say the sentences aloud(when you heard "et vous monsieur" it was your turn to repeat. I must say we learned a lot of grammar without knowing it and without the formal study of grammar. At the same time we had english with native speakers with traditional methods. I was able to have a talk with french speakers at a basic level and my english skills were far, far from that. Je pense que l'apprentissage d'une lange étrangère c'est une aventure où nous sommes hereux d'être invités, à bientôt
Marion Batard , hello hello how are you
Omg ...u r flowing like a river
Kindly throw light on teaching English for primary school students pl
Hi Roberto,
I am a qualified English teacher in the UK.
I stopped teaching in mainstream immediately after completing my training,
not as a result of bad behaviour, not as a result of hours of preparation and marking before and after school, on holidays, on the weekends,
Not because the school I worked in was mismanaged or because the teachers were apathetic. (I loved and still loved my training school!)
I stopped teaching in main stream education because our government decided that grammar, above all else, (particularly learning grammar terms and identifying them) was, above all, THE most important part of the English curriculum.
It was depressing and upsetting to watch students who were, had been, and had the potential to be, incredible thinkers, debaters, philosophers, writers, and so on, become apathetic, bored, and disinterested in my lessons. I empathised - because I was too.
I had a teacher during secondary school who behaved and taught in ways that you do - she taught us correct use of grammar, syntax, sentence style, form etc. through newspaper articles and interesting novels, poetry and plays. I did not know that I was learning grammar and all of the skills required for the language paper until, a month before the exam, I rushed to her office in a panic, telling her WE DID NOT PRACTISE anything for any of the language papers.
I had interrupted her as she was writing an important paper. Instead of shouting at me, or berating me, she calmly raised one eyebrow and said 'didn't we?'
We looked through a few past papers and the mark scheme and I realised that I had been learning language while learning literature, in much the same way as you are teaching expression and voice and confidence, while quietly teaching all of the 'language' parts in the background.
I would love to say that I could be that teacher, I wanted so desperately to be that teacher, I believe that I am to the number of students I currently teach. I hope that the next government senses the mistakes of today and reverts back to understanding that great writing, speaking, and thinking are so much more important than knowing the difference between a noun and a pronoun. That will come, and if it does not for some, who cares!
... so darn interesting
What country are you in?
It's OK to make mistakes. The mistakes I make as an advanced speaker have nothing to do with those I made when I was a beginner or an intermediate learner. Besides, I now intuitively know that something is not right with some sentence, even if I can't detect the mistake immediately. Sometimes, I even correct mistakes to native speakers, teachers, and advanced speakers like me. I find this quite impressive and this has encouraged me further to continue practising my English. Thanks for the talk.
Thanks for your experience.I study English two years.But my level improve too slowly.I've make a lot of mistakes .I don't like study grammar,but I like listening music in English and I like reading books in English,also I like watching interesting films in English.End the and thats all give me the power to continue to learn English.But my speaking conversation doesn't not develop.
practicing*
@@lenkavisnich4228 slow progress is progress. Also, you need to practice speaking to improve. Have someone discuss something with you, like a news article.
@@lenkavisnich4228 If you don't mind me asking, what kind of books did you read to improve your English?
@@NugihanDeniz I like reading fairy tale for children.I believe it is the best way for learning .If you want,we can speak each other for improving our skills.
This is one of the best presentations I've ever seen in TEDx
This has inspired me to open my own English academy in my country. Thanks for the push I sorely needed.
As a 4th grade teacher, I took his approach (without knowing of Roberto Guzmán or having watched this video) 3 years ago with a student from México. It works. Immersion into the language with cooperative learning, casual conversation and inclusion into the school’s culture.
This is one of the best TED talks I have viewed. Mathematics is a language too. Mathematics should be taught this way.
How would mathematics be taught in this way? In English there are newspapers and articles so what would be the equivalent for math? Genuinely curious because I teach math as well
@@loreanalankister3756 Mathematics is fundamentally about patterns, describing and predicting them. Puzzles are an equivalent to newspaper articles for example. Exercising the ability to see patterns. The puzzles can be in any medium. Word, picture, sound, etc.. Games are another example. Recognizing patterns and developing strategies. Prediction.
One of the best ted talks I've seen, very inspiring and as a teacher of English myself, (starting today!!) I'll definitely use your method, I couldn't agree more! Thank you Roberto Guzman.
I look forward to one day traveling the world and using my skills to build bridges between myself and people of all languages. This video was really encouraging.
Damn, Roberto, I've actually been teaching like you for the last year. I think it's because I was never educated as an english teacher, my education was in literature. So I wanted to aim my english classes towards that sort of literature education rather than grammar. This was basically my instinct from my first month as a high school teacher and I thought I was doing something wrong because I was not teaching grammar or using textbooks, and also because well, I didn't have teaching education and this is my first year on the job. Listening to this talk by an experienced teacher who reached the same conclussions as me reassures me on the path I want to continue as a teacher.
Teaching grammar is important too. Roberto explains that his students already knew a lot of grammar.
Probably the Best Ever presentation I ever seen on How to Teach... anything, to anyone.
It really make me to whish having Roberto Guzman as my teacher.
One way to motivate is talking about what is their passion/ interest and learning to talk about it in English. Ask questions - that is what learning is about.
I do this as a tutor, and yes, they seem to enjoy the class more 👍
I so agree. I do not teach grammar because I find it an unnatural way to learn another language.
For me, INTUITION is the key word.
Just as babies use intuition to figure out what their parents are saying, I encourage my students to develop this essential skill: intuition.
No translation, no grammar rules to remember. Learn from pictures, movements, sounds, acquire a language.
Never "study" it.
and I welcome mistakes as a natural part of the learning process.
Through mistakes, we learn.
im new in teaching turkish and the grammer part is really being a bit boring, besides it we listen turkish short audio, read texts and translate unnknown words. But id like to improve my teaching, to make my lessons more funny. What sourse i can use for having this kind of knowledge. İ'd be really glad if u share😊
Professor Roberto Guzman, I've watched your talk repeatedly and the more I do it, the more interesting I find it. You seem to be the kind of teacher who has devoted a lot of time to thinking and trying to figure out how to teach better. You remind me of the teacher I will become in some years. Thank you professor.
I am a language teacher and I totally agree with Roberto. In my class, I emphasize that linguistic competence is secondary to communicative competence.
It depends highly on the purpose of language learning. If the purpose is academic, the form and linguistic competence are very important. If your students only want to use English for travelling purpose... fine, you may focus mainly on the oral communication.
This guy fucks.
I agree. It is and should be secondary, competence and skills will follow led by confidence.
love him!! I learned english by not learning English, to find that this is an actual technique used by this professor was so cool! this was so eye-opening for me
I teach English with communicative method..İt works.
I felt inspired just listening to him. His passion for language and learning for his approach. My favorite is sticking to the content instead of insulting. People get so side tracked at times and start making it personal. I don't know why it has to get to that point and can't just stay on the topic at hand.
I thoroughly enjoyed listening to him speak.
Awesome job brother. I'm a PR from NY teaching Eng. in Poland. Everything you said is spot-on!
Wonderful talk! I wish so very nuch that he were my teacher. His priorities are correct, and not even touched on in many classrooms, even with kind and helpful teachers, because these skills aren't even on school districts' radar. Let us all together go to school board meetings and advocate (in a collegial spirit) for the fostering of these skills.
Excelente!!! Ahora mismo, as a Peace Corps Volunteer, I am learning Spanish in a foreign country and gearing up to teach English for the first time in my life. This talk is a true inspirationl. Muchas gracias!
I feel as though I'm listening to myself. I'm so happy this exists and that there are teachers out there with whom I can agree with completely. Keep up this excellent work!
I don’t know if you still watch this but this is Randy , Sir Robert you are the best English prof I’ve ever known.
You learn a language by studying it. You acquire a language by using it.
Inspiring! I always tell my students same thing:" l just give you the keys that open the world for you"..they go and open them and it won't be my job any more..Great speech!
I have been learning English for more than one year and when I started I made many mistakes and until now I do make mistakes but the mistakes are not the same I used to make mistakes about the easiest grammar now I use them correctly and that`s the most important thing ! my English is increasing day by day
The question is, which method is correct?
9:31 “Ideas are not people. Ideas don’t have rights.” Perfect formulation!
The true key for learning English language is to be motivated in order to achieve your goal.
Roberto, you have changed the way I run my own Ela class room
He reminds me of my high school Spanish teacher. She introduced us the history, arts, culture and philosophy.
after watching this video i feel like he's my professor now. i wish him the best
Had I seen it right away, it would have been a great birthday gift :) Roberto Guzman, thank you for this talk, I wish you had been my ESL teacher back in the 90s. Right now, I teach English too and I'm really thankful for this inspiration.
Irina, all English teachers should share their experiences and create a new method to make English teaching perfect.
Mr Guzman! No sé si me lea algún día, pero le comento. Soy maestra de inglés, acabo de empezar mi carrera, tengo solo 23 años. A veces me sentía igual que como usted lo describe, "incómoda" por el hecho de que algunos alumnos no quieren participar. Pero usted me ha dado herramientas valiosas en su TED Talk para aplicar como maestra. Muchísimas gracias! Le agradezco mucho.
Espero no solo mejorar yo cómo maestra, sino que mis alumnos mejoren en el hábito de preguntar y cuestionar. Gracias!
No te preocupes, sé que puedes encontrar o sé que pudiste encontrar una buena forma de dar tus clases de ingles; sé que este comentario es de hace 4 años, pero yo como estudiante de ingles, me doy cuenta lo difícil que tiene que ser dar clases de ingles
Roberto Guzman, I absolutely love your talks and your intelligent, tender spirit. I am going to be starting school in the Spring, and I aim to get a degree in ESL. You inspire me to no end.
janejuliet .. Hi there. I want to thank you for your very kind words. Teaching is an adventure not really a job.
Thank you for your response, Mr. Guzman. I love adventure, and I think that is what draws me to teaching. I love history, culture, connection to others... I have watched "Are You Sure About That?" many times and posted it on my Facebook account multiple times because it embodies all of those things. Is there a way I can contact you personally?
+janejuliet you can write to me at my regular address mofongo4@gmail.com. Have a great Sunday Jane.
Robert Guzman
I am from PR (Camuy) and I have a home in Rayme Base but I live now in El Paso Tx. about 10 years. I don't speek English with fluency. I went to took ESL for adult. I have 5 moths taking that class but the sistem isn't better, is focous only in grammar. Personally, I try to deeping (immerses) in the language, using all in my environment but still need more. Like speek and speek with other, for me that's the most hard part..
+Elia Deida thank you writing. Communication must be meaningful to the language learner. Identify areas in which you are interested in. Explore them for the sake of their content not their form. As you do this more and more you will acquire vocabulary, grammar and content. Find others that share your same interests and are equally motivated. Learning will be inevitable. Explore Sugata Mitra's wonderful research in this are. His talks are at TED and TH-cam. Tell me what you think.
Unbelievable!!! What this man is doing is a miracle!
Roberto your: again, again, again is lovely. And: "I want my students to learn how to cook not to learn how to read a book."
SUCH A BEAUTIFUL SOUL!!!
Roberto, eres un genio man!!! me has inspirado!!
I really loved listening to this talk. It's crucial to establish classroom rules, emphasizing the separation between ideas and individuals. Preventing the potential harm caused by unchecked bad ideas is a thought-provoking concept.
One of the best college professors I've ever had
You are absolutely right! Thank You for this speech!
After watching this video I realized I'm going in the right direction. I wish every educator thought this way, we would have so many English speakers around the world! Thank you for that!
He shines while speaks. Fascinating speech, man.
I could hardly agree more with Professor Guzman. We need more teachers--and more people--like him in the world!
One thing: I think he misunderstands the term "cognitive dissonance." It refers to something different from what he was talking about. Specifically, it refers to holding two mutually contradicting ideas or beliefs in one's mind.
But that's a very minor thing. Besides, like he said, it's OK to make mistakes!
This is the best way to teach! Thank you, Roberto, for opening doors for teachers, too! Muchas gracias!
Proud of Roberto, one of my favorite professors!
Roberto gave a very good argument for how vital content is rather than the form of the language.
Remarkable 'teacher' in the true sense of the word. My hat off to you sir!
This makes me cry~ :) Thank you, professor.
This is one of the best ted talks that I've seen. Gracias sr. Roberto
One of my favorite talks ever!!!
there is no way you can’t love this man.. amazing❤️
This is what we need in every language school! Thank you so much professor, I love your teaching style. I'd love to be your student!
Great, great talk!!! Such precious lessons from this thinking professor.
A great teacher! Thank you for teaching people not just English, but to think and ask!!
Se nota que es el mejor profesor de ingles del mundo... Con la facilidad que habla y lo bien que habla.
Definitely one of the best TEDx talks I've seen, thank you for sharing your ideas. As I prepare to teach overseas this gives me extra motivation and a semblance of confidence :)
This man is a freaking genius... Wish I could take this class
His*
Ili Rueda where are you from?
Sir, I stumbled upon this video and loved every word you spoke. Thank you for such a brilliant explanation.
I’m getting ready to spend time with my nephews in order to teach them English. With the pandemic in 2020 they ended up being raised just in Indonesian and Sundanese. I’m hoping that at 4 and 2.5 years old it’s not too late to start.
I absolutely agree with the inclusion of a b.s. detctor for students. The emphasis on analyzing, questioning, and investigating is something that should be a bigger part of educating students to create a smarter society, ready to defend against a sea of flawed information surrounding the world. Plus upon analyzing information in English, students can have an easier time using English once they are trained in their expressions of thought and analysis.
Amazing!
Richly resonant with my experience and conviction too.
Thank you for sharing
best teacher I ever seen....thank you professor for inspiring me to live my life better....
What a great man.
Amazing talk! I tutor in ESL online and there is so much that I've learned and can use to help my students.
Please, how can I be a tutor online?! Wjat should I do?? Please help me out and I'll be thankful for u 😊
Perfect.
I'm glad I watched this video as I am an English teacher as well.
Thank you.
I'm so glad I found this! I'm a language teacher and I don't know what to do to my students. I'll apply this system and see the magic!
absolutely brilliant I am blessed to share with this man . thank you 😃
What a great talk--so holistic even though it's supposed to be about learning English, it covers a lot of education!
One of my favorite TED Talks
I'm truly inspired. Thank you for incredible talk Mr. Roberto.
Thank you for the lecture! Although this video is from 6 years ago, the content is timeless!
Excellent...I love the way he thinks. Mandatory viewing for all educators, tutors and instructors.
I found this video on the 2nd day of trying to teach a kid English who has taken it in school for 5 years and can't speak or understand jack shit, lol. This video confirmed what I already knew to be true, which is having a reason to learn something greatly enhances your ability to learn it!
GainsbourgSerge parabéns por isso
If your students started talking in your classroom, you can't forget to give the credit to those 5 years of grammar study in school - without that basis there is no way that people will just start talking out of the blue... Professor Guzman´s method only works in classrooms where people already have some basic English grammar and syntax understanding, otherwise they will just go on using their native structures with English vocabulary which is very damaging for their future language development and progress. There is nothing worse than fossilized errors in advanced students.
Absolutely! Motivation is the most important factor when it comes to language learning. Language, after all, is not an end in itself, but a means to an end. Languages should not be taught as other subjects.
I have never watched this inspiring and touching talk before. Thanks a lot for your sharing, I must try to memorize them all
I want to thank him so much. Such a great teacher❤❤❤
Thank you sir! That was fantastic and so important!!!
This is all a process, and we have to develop and change in order to learn well.
Great speech! So much valuable advice in a short video.
Love your sense of humour and your wisdom. Thank you so very much!!!
Content before form - what great advice for teaching!
Gracias profesor!