Ranking EVERY Premier League Manager's Season.
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 พ.ค. 2024
- HelloFresh has generously provided me with an exclusive offer available for a limited time. Click here www.hellofresh.co.uk/JAMESF4L to enjoy 60% off your first box, along with 20% off the next two months plus FREE DESSERTS FOR LIFE. Alternatively, you can use my code JAMESF4L. This special offer is available for new customers as well as those who cancelled their subscription twelve months ago or more. For a limited time only!
If you missed the offer above, use this link www.hellofresh.co.uk/LAWRENCEHF to get 60% off the first box + 20% off the next 2 months, or use my code: LAWRENCEHF
In this video, James Allcott ranks every Premier League managers season!
JOIN THE DISCORD SERVER
👉 / discord
JOIN US ON THE JAFFN PATREON 🎧
👉 / jamesandflav
FOLLOW JAMES ON TWITTER:
👉 / jamesallcott
FOLLOW JAMES ON INSTAGRAM:
👉📸 @jlallcott jlallcott?...
James Allcott content focuses on Premier League, Champions League, EFL Championship talking about Manchester United, Arsenal, Liverpool, Man City, Tottenham, Barcelona, England, Chelsea, Jurgen Klopp, Erik Ten Hag, Mikel Arteta, transfer news, tactical analysis and much more. James has made content with Mark Goldbridge from the United Stand, Rory Jennings, Ben Foster, Spencer FC, The Club, Thogden, JaackMaate, ESPN and many more.
#PremierLeague #JLA #footballmanager
Terms and Conditions: This offer entitles you to 60% off your first box, and 20% off your next seven boxes when ordered in consecutive weeks during your first two months as a HelloFresh customer. One voucher per customer and household. Must be 18 or over. Once redeemed you will be signed up to a flexible rolling weekly subscription. Valid for UK residents only (including Jersey, Guernsey & Isle of Man), excluding Scottish Highlands and Islands." - กีฬา
The final answer you are looking for 👉 x.com/jamesallcott/status/1786065341505786250?s=46&t=H3N7QlA5Jn-6qc138Cbvkw
You tease
No metric has Emery done better this season than Arteta? Top of the League table, best defense and most goals scored. Even if emery won head to head, Arsenal have performed much better than emery’s team. Maybe the Arsenal haters in the poll voted. Emery has to successfully coach a top 6 team for me to say he is better.
@@theach84 Sure you arent a little biassed there? Emery is MOTY by fucking miles based on the expectations of the respective clubs.
@@PvtVallen based on expectations? This is Arteta’s first job managing. Emery has not only managed over 10 years but multiple jobs has managed in many different countries. Also it’s a lot harder to manage a big club than to manage villa. It’s a lot harder to juggle champions league and EPL title race. The pressure alone arteta has from a top club. In a top 4 race you can draw or lose a game and still be on course. Arteta has won last 16 lose 1 draw 1 and still may not win the league. Different pressure. Emery seem to always fumble when he is managing a big club. Was terrible managing PSG…. Could not handle that pressure.
Glasner deserves much more credit for what he is doing with that Crystal Palace side. They will be in contention for Europe next season if Olise and Eze stay.
Agreed, hea got palace playing well and think they will suprise next season
Yeh that assessment hasn't aged well already
Harsh on Glasner imo, Palace are playing with an identity, good tactics, high press and workrate. Very different from Roy's return last year which was more of just unleashing Eze in a free role.
I understand Burnley have been much better recently, but how is Kompany not in the bottom two tiers? For 90% of this season, he's shown no flexibility in tactics and been unable to set up even a passable defence
The goalkeepers have let him down all season
football hipsters love him because he pissed the championship with the best squad in the league
@@celtic69 didn’t have anywhere near the best squad😂 how many players in that team had you heard of before last season? Huh? Benson? Zaroury? Foster? Maatsen? Tella? Ekdal? Beyer? Al dakil? Vitinho? All main players who no one knew
Tbf his defence has let him down a lot
@@user-wy3vb4vl8c pretty much every single one of those players was an international or from a top club, Burnley had the best squad in the league by far
Gary o’oneil has transformed a team that everyone had to be relegated. Came in 4 days before the season, transformed the team and turned the talent that was there into actual production, and they should be 10-12 point higher without VAR. impressive job done by him
If Iraola is a MotY nominee then O'Neill has to be too!
We were in an absolute mess at the start of the season and the Refs have done their worst trying to relegate us!
Also that injury table may be technically correct on days lost overall but we lost Cunha AND Hwang at the same time and that coincided with our worst run of the season for obvious reasons!
What a cliff hanger
Emery took us from relegation fodder to 4th and in a European semi final (tonight) in a season and a half. The Man is unreal. UTV
Sounds like Eddie Howe. European semi yeah but that’s a third tier competition that West Ham won
true but villa was never a relegation side per say. great manager still
Villa’s injury stats also don’t truly reflect their injury issues this season as they don’t include Mings or Buendia since they were never registered for the team. Granted, he had the ability to find loan replacements (Lenglet and Zaniolo), but these replacements took some time and investment to adapt to Emery.
Emery was good for us (AFC) in the initial phase as well, but the drop off afterwards was real. Jury's still out for me.
@@cheeliang_cl You do know emery has now managed more games for villa than he did for arsenal.
Thanks for respecting Eddie Howe! Considering the injuries, the suspension, and the very hard CL and cup fixtures It would be more impressive to finish the season in 6th than the champions league spot we got last year.
so basically injuries are only an excuse if it's NOT united. Right.
@@Drwn4945no just when half the squad were relegation fodder 2 seasons ago and this season they’ve had to deal with the addition of European football for the first time in 20 years. Also when your entire squad is a quarter of the value of Manure’s, or to put another way, our entire back line is worth less than one Harry Maguire 😂😂
Ye but injuries matter regardless of the club...
@@TPHB5011 eddie howe had to use bottom half prem level players because of injuries and managed to get to 6th, ten hag had to use europa league level players because of injuries and could only get to 8th. thats the difference.
Sean Dyche for improving Everton who would be relegated with the deductions in other seasons. Iraola for improving Bournemouth. Postecoglou for almost being top four in his first season at Spurs even after losing Kane. Emery for continuing momentum at Villa.
Postecoglou in the last 25 games after that initial manager bounce cooled off: 34 pts, -3 goal difference. United same period decimated by injuries for all 25 games: 39 pts +2gd (even after yesterday, yes)
Sean dyche so underrated
Howe also lost Tonali for the full season in addition to the injury days lost. That Tonali suspension along with the loss of Pope and Joelinton for huge periods are why Howe isnt in the mix for top 4
Yeah, if Newcastle get top 6 that’s very very impressive given the difficulties with injuries and the extra games. At the beginning of the season lots of pundits said they expected 6th at best, to do that with a horrendous set of injuries and the Tonali ban shows how good Howe is as a manager, it’s crazy that some Newcastle fans (a very small group though) are unhappy.
If the board back him in the summer and the injuries are more normal next season I’d be very surprised if Newcastle don’t get top 4 again.
Newcastles & some other clubs injuries have been well documented in the media,but as a Villa fan I believe our problems with injured players have hardly been mentioned cos Unai Emery never complains about it or uses it as an excuse when results have gone against us, he's just got on with it & given other squad players a chance to prove their worth. Considering we've had key players out all or for big parts of this season the job he has done has been incredible,what a manager he is. 😊⚽👍
@@amlmorris. Every team loses players to injuries but why would a manager use injuries as an excuse when his team has statistically had a below average level of injuries? Newcastle have had over 60% more injuries than Villa. Put that into perspective, for every 10 injuries Villa have had this season Newcastle have had 16-17.
I get your point about missing key players but some teams have had it bad in both ways.
@@andrewcharlton6080 compare that against Man Utd, they've had around 60 injuries throughout the season, including key players like Lisandro or Luke Shaw, yet people take it as a no excuse for them... in the past games the only natural center back has been Maguire, and only Eddie Howe gets empathy. There's an extremely positive bias towards Newcastle, very good team, very good manager, but it's ridiculous how much people hate ETH for the sake of being Man Utd's manager.
@@Aeway100 Eddie Howe has been slated at times this season by some fans and the media, really unfairly given the injuries. There was a run of about 6-8 weeks where we only had 12-13 senior players and he was still getting criticised for poor performances.
I agree that Man Utd has had nearly as many injuries as Newcastle this season, Newcastle have still played some decent football at times, the reason Newcastle aren’t higher is due to that really awful run of 8 losses in 10 games, that was during that crazy injury run and the players were exhausted with games every 3-4 days.
Newcastle had a group of death in Europe and would have come second if not for that awful injury time penalty decision against PSG.
In comparison Man Utd have chugged along for most of the season and haven’t really had some of the performances Newcastle have had, they were awful in Europe too in a much weaker group. They’ve had a similar defence but scored far fewer goals and have a poor goal difference. There’s been some disappointing performances for Newcastle but some really good ones too which has helped keep the fans and pundits onside.
I think you also need to consider where the 2 teams have come from in the last few years, when Howe took over Newcastle we’re favourites for relegation, we have a small squad which can’t cope with Europe or these injuries yet, half of the current squad were from the Bruce era and were generally considered to be Championship level players a few seasons again.
Man Utd have been a European side for decades, ETH has spent as much as Howe and inherited a much better team than Howe did but the squad is arguably worse than it was 3-4 seasons ago, there’s been big money signings like Anthony, Mount and Casemiro that haven’t been good while other players have fallen out with the manager.
As a Newcastle fan I can see that the players all enjoy being at the club, they like Howe, Howe for the most part has got the team playing good football and if it wasn’t for a bad spell due to severe injuries we’d be fighting for top 4. The club is still moving in the right direction.
A lot of the same can’t be said for Man Utd this season even taking into account the injuries
I think Glasner deserves more credit than you’re giving him. I understand the comparison to Roy coming in at the end of last season and Palace finishing strong, but the victories Palace have had under Glasner are way more impressive. When Roy came back last year, 3 of the 5 wins were against the relegated teams (Leicester, Leeds, Southampton) with the other wins against West Ham and Bournemouth.
This year recently under Glasner, Palace have gone 6 games in a row unbeaten with wins against Liverpool at Anfield, Newcastle, and Man United. They’ve also had convincing wins against Burnley, West Ham, and Wolves. The team under Glasner just passes the eye test too, the tactics are good and the attacks are well set up.
There was some difficulty adjusting when Glasner first came in though, with some draws and losses to mediocre teams, but now that his tactics and play style have been fully implemented, Glasner has got Palace playing in great form.
So glad you respect Thomas Frank. And I'm glad you did the research. Basically, our best back four have maybe played 40 games COMBINED this year. And we have a new keeper. So building that chemistry between the back line and keeper I extremely hard if players are constantly going down with injuries. And with our finances our depth is extremely shallow and we've had to start players who were meant to develop this year; and we've shifted players around, starting a cdm and a winger as fullbacks at times. He's basically had to squeeze every last ounce out of our players and for us to not get relegated this year is amazing. And that's not even considering our top three scorers all being out for considerable time. I love Thomas Frank and hope we keep him forever, honestly.
Glad you gave Eddie a fair assessment.
The fact Newcastle are in a conversation for 6th with the season they’ve had us insane.
For about a 3rd of the season out midfield included a 17 year old and an injured Longstaff playing through pain. With Bruno playing 1 yellow from a 2 match ban for 13 games.
Not to mention of our summer signings Barnes spent half a season out injured and Tonali has been suspended most of the season.
If this is what he can do this season I can’t wait to see what happens next year with a fully fit squad plus some additions.
Yet if united bring our injuries we up we get grilled by the media. United have one cb (a 38 year old Johnny Evan’s) and zero left back.
Dyche manager of the season and it’s not close. We have one of the smallest squads in the league, have had 8 points deducted, have gone through owner issues, have had a large holder in the club literally die and we statistically the worst attack in the league. He’s taken all of that, to a place where without the PDs we’d still mathematically have a chance at getting Europe. No other manager in world football could have done what he has.
4th best defence in the league, Pickford has a decent chance at the golden glove at this stage.
How you lot moved him down I will never know
It's because of the "vibe and eye test" rubes in the comments. "OH can't be dyche... I mean c'mon it's dyche" people
Even as someone who's not a fan of Dyche Ball, what he has done is worthy of the MOTS award, full stop. It's going to be given to either Guardiola or Arteta, when neither would have been able to do what Dyche did. If you want to get the best out of a beat-up Hummer, you don't get the guys who are used to driving Ferraris. They're not worse at all, but it takes a different man for the job. Mr. Dyche, take a bow, sir.
City fan here, i would vote for Unai Emery as my manager of the year. Just a very impressive season all round, and for the best performance against us in league since the 2016/17 season or something like that.
gary oneil moty defo. had 0 prep time, club seemingly abandoned by owners, poor transfer window, garbage var luck yet theyre still comfortably mid table. from genuine relegation contenders to outside europe contenders with little spend i mean come on
With a squad like that, no chance
Iraola for me. He's done a fantastic job. Will certainly be keeping an eye on him. I can see him going to a top club, though not necessarily in the PL, possibly La Liga. Somewhere with a good DoF where he can just focus on coaching the team.
I found a days lost to injury table on sky sports and the top 5 was Newcastle, Brentford, Brighton, Chelsea, Sheffield
With Brighton though it's not just the numbers but the number of key players out and days lost to those key players.
@@timphillips9954Yep, March, Mitoma, Joao Pedro, Estupinian all missing large chunks of the season. At times this season we’ve been without all 3 wingers and all 4 full backs
James, being weird for a moment, you are one of the healthiest looking youtubers. You ever thought about expanding in to some lifestyle stuff? Perhaps you could make some little football shaped treats.
Or his face on a magnet
Vincent Kompany should definitely be in "Gone by November," glad Burnley stuck with him, but you're spot on, he refused to bend his tactics and switched out a decent keeper in Muric for mediocre English pudding in Trafford, and destroyed Muric's confidence.
i dont know how you can put Howe in cat 2 and poch in cat 3. Both teams have had significant injuries however Howe has an experienced squad at a club he's been at for a number of years. Poch has only been at Chelsea for 1 season with a group of players that are new to the club.
chelsea are only 3 points behind newcastle but got to a cup semi final and final while newcastle flopped in Europe.
Fax
Not gonna lie, I think if David Moyes got the Manchester United job now/in the coming summer, I think he would do relatively well.
Because the status and reputation of the club is now different. We are essentially a top 8 side not competing for the league - no different to west ham now, and Everton in 2013. In 2013, united were a powerhouse that Moyes wasn’t equipped for. Top 10-4 sides are his level, so would do a job for united now but won’t get them to the top.
@@tobyhellewell5981 no manager in the history of football will ever compete with fergie, Thats your problem. Just like emery at arsenal. Transition periods are incredibly hard to deal with. Even as a top manager.
@@tobyhellewell5981 ten years later and you've still not recovered from fergie
All the best teams press high up the field. Man utd are doing the same thing the difference being when half of the squad is consistently injured and the back up's do not have the physicality required it becomes a problem. People may well be suprised how much better the football looks with more physicality and the board don't want to make a decision until key staff have finished gardening leave.
For pep to be MOTY with that squad and budget he would have to get a 100 points or go invincible. City haven't beaten liverpool, arsenal, chelsea or spurs this season btw
O'Neil definitely impressive. Threadbare squad that was on track to make Europe before the injuries killed them. He's done an amazing job, with some depth in the summer I think next season will show his true level, and I think they'll make Europe.
Great video❤
Bournemouth fan here, he has done so well for the team, we love him he’s fantastic.
Jim's never looked as happy as when he was told he looks a bit like Rob Edwards 😂 19:57
Howe goes in impressive, nice one. I don't think most people realise how ridiculous our injuries/bans have been this season and in that context how ridiculous us fighting for 5th/6th/7th is, we've still been really good at times.
I would put Klopp in manager of the year candidate. Liverpool started the season with a brand new midfield. Then they lost one of their midfielders to the Asian Cup and their talisman to the AFCON, who got injured during this time. At one stage during February and March, they had 11 players out, won the League Cup with their youth team, while maintaining a push for the title while still playing the youth team. At the start of the season, most people had them to be getting top 4, but not challenging for the title. Liverpool under Klopp have made it the most exciting Premier League title race in history. By March, they were still in the hunt for the quadruple and yes it has fallen off and they won't win the title now, but he's got to be in the talk for Manager of the Season.
Yes I would put Klopp in the MOTY nominee too.
Also Klopp has had to deal with the PGMOL throwing out SEVERAL "once in a lifetime" screw ups. Liverpool should have a stack of referee apology letters, but they unapologetically do not like him specifically. The team is dead tired now because they had to play multiple games early in the season a man down for the softest red cards of the whole season. You forget Klopp pulled out most of those, and then only lost to totty after one of the worst decisions of the decade for Diaz offside and an unlucky own goal. They won against Newcastle 2 men down, that takes a lot out of a team, and the prem doesn't have a winter break. Klopp rebuilt a midfield, and doesn't have the budget to have enough world class players to deal with those kinds of stressors. If the Doku penalty was given as it ABSOLUTLY should have, Klopp would be manager of the season hands down.
@@evanducker7814 exactly, only thing I would pick up on that is against Newcastle, we were only one man down, that was when Virgil got sent off. The game we were down to 9 men was against Tottenham, which I actually have no issue with either sending off in that game. I have the problem with Luis Diaz being one metre onside and still being called offside and the farce that was VAR that game.
What Mr Emery has done in 18 months is inspiring
I am a Chelsea fan but I wasn't impressed with Ange tho, he started well but as soon as the opponent realised he only uses one tactic, Tottenham started to fall off, got beat by a mediocre Chelsea team twice
Iraola all the way. Stunning football from the smallest club in the PL. Phenomenal stuff in his first season. Pep, Arteta doing what is expected.
Hi James, I'm feeling a little blue, could you cheer me up and do a comparison of Man U's present team and Alex Ferguson's last team, and then see where the current squad would finish in Ferguson's last season?
Looking at that injury time lost chart, it is pretty impressive what LFC has done despite being that high on the injury list. Compared to them, City and Arsenal have had a fairly good.
As a villa fan, Emery being MOTY should be nailed on in my mind but if Arteta were to bring home the title for Arsenal and do what they couldn’t last year (arguably in an even better position then as well) I’d do nothing to stand in the way of that decision
Nice one, James. Disagree with a couple but love that you gave old Roy H. some much-deserved kudos for a great career even though we will probably all agree he is gone forever now. Then again, would any of us be surprised if some desperate club called on his services ONE LAST TIME sometime in the near future? Also agree with respect towards Eddie Howe. I think he is a terrific young manager. Of course, as an Arsenal fan I think we've got the BEST young manager.
Arsenal fan - Unai Emery done an epic job at Villa.
agree
Emery deserves all the flowers. What a season he's had.
And Arteta has built an absolute juggernaut. It'll be sad if he doesn't win a title this year, but that squad has silverware just around the corner.
Has to be emery, 4th place double over assna and the first team to batter city in god knows how many years. Plus we beat them both in the same week
Not to be or sound like a Poch apologist or anything, but this Chelsea team has been completely obliterated by injuries. Captain and Vice-Captain out most of the year. Fofana, Lavia, Nkunku have barely featured (0 and 1 appearance for the two former). First keeper been out half the season at this point (not at all a big point as I am, not entirely convinced by either, but I prefer Petrovic, worth mentioning anyways). Gusto, Chalobah, Badiashile, Colwill, Cucurella, Chukwuemeza all with significant time lost to injury. The midfield trio of Enzo, Gallagher and Caicedo have been forced to play more or less every minute as there are no other senior options and now even Enzo is out with an operation. No manager would be able to deal with the chaos, injuries and incompetence in and around the club so judging Poch on this is very difficult. I am not convinced by him, but I dont think sacking him will solve much except maybe help with injuries as his training intensity/requirements might be a contributing factor, but we have struggled with overbearing injuries under Potter and Tuchel as well.
Honestly, EtH IS an amazing coach based on his past. I get it - its easy to put him into the lower ranks. And its probably true based on the ranks you use (which are weird ranks I think). Give EtH Liverpool and theyll become champs within the next 2 years I honestly believe. ManU has just been a shitpile for managers for years. Managers with great records like Mourinho, Van Gaal & Rangnick
Man Utd have conceded the most shots in the entire PL and they're currently on course for top 3 in PL history. Look at the Expected Points league table and Man Utd are 15th. His tactics simply don't work and he's refusing to change them. I genuinely poor tactically and a bad man manager (see Sancho for example) who wouldn't get into any top half job and would probably struggle to find a mid table PL job now.
@@ImmuneGEORGEUnited are 6th in terms of goals conceded, with the crazy defence they have had, that's quite good. Last year most clean sheets in the league. So Ten Hag is capable, but just needs the right players/fitness/mentality to succeed.
Something's wrong with that time lost chart. Timber for Arsenal alone lost more than 21 games. Mings and Buendia lost a lot games for Villa. I don't know how that stat was calculated.
Mings buendia kamara Ramsey cash digne moreno
A few vibes ratings here, Brentford are low on injuries in the league, and yet are below teams with less depth and more injuries. Palace have had Ward and Clyne at cb for half the season, losing guehi, eze and olise for months each as well as losing doucoure for the entire season, even depth players were injured and yet are 5 points above Brentford. Wouldn’t call that a fantastic season for frank seen as people expected them near the top half
James how are Nottingham and Burnley (haven’t gotten to Luton yet) going to stay up !? 😂
As a Villa fan of 35 years I want to base a new religion on Unai Emery. The man is unbelievable and may well be our Sir Alex.
Happy for Villa fans and Emery. Gerrard did you guys so dirty. You have a decent amount of solid players
Context,Unai Emery 100%,from where Villa were to what position they're currently at,a semi final of a European competition & UCL qualification looks very likely,I can't look beyond Emery for the best manager of the season.
I don't personally like Klopp but cannot deny his ability. His organisation of the team and his substitutions against Newcastle when Liverpool were 1-0 down with ten men after only 20 odd minutes to achieve a victory was massively impressive. I actually believe that this affected the confidence of the Newcastle team so much that they never really recovered throughout the season.
Gary O’Neill is my manager of the year. I had them to go down and they’ve been incredible, especially with Cunha and Neto missing key parts of the year
Would you share how the data collected on time loss + days lost due to injury?
Arsenal fan so maybe I am biased but to me Arteta should be manager of the year and with one point I will say why. When they have made a team out of city arsenal and Liverpool there are usually very few arsenal players included often just saliba so you can’t tell me if only one arsenal player makes that list then the success isn’t down to the manager and if he out performs that well then he deserves it. Second place for me is Unai and third is a tougher choice
I think it's a bit harsh on Glasner. Yes, he hasn't been in the Premier League for long, but he won the Europa League with Eintracht Frankfurt, so he must be pretty good.
Ten Hag has some of the players to thank that he's still in a job. we're 16th on expected points. SIXTEENTH!!! the system relies too heavily on having great players in every position, and it doesn't even try to cover up anyone's weaknesses either. injuries are becoming a weak excuse when nothing has changed all season. he's making (one of) the best ball playing keepers boot the ball long every game to a striker who isn't a target forward and a midfield full of players who struggle to and are poorly positioned to counter press. so fed up of it
Wtf was that ending?!?!? 😂
Gary O'Neil deserves a lot more credit than you gave him here. The Wolves squad looked so thin at the start of the season and a lot of people had written them off. He's unlocked the likes of Cunha, Hwang, and Ait Nouri and Wolves have played great football even when they've lost games. Easily upper end of Impressive tier if not MOTY nominee.
Emery Moty… honestly I wanted him at Liverpool
As a chelsea fan: Poch is good but is he good, too many defensive injuries leading to a lack of reliability at the back with a striker up top who is clearly a winger, you’re bound to struggle to put runs together to get any higher than where we are rn. Watching the games it doesn’t feel dry or slow at all I feel we can win any given game.
Still waiting for James’ apology to Mbuemo.. never has someone criticised him more not rated a player before this season than James and Mbuemo
Spurs have suffered from a paper thin squad
I’m excited for an Ange-picked summer transfer window. Hope Levy backs him and spurs don’t just sign countless extra ‘rotation players’
gone by november just proved to me that jim watches always sunny
He definitely does, the Jabroni
Nuno deserves more credit for the atmosphere he’s navigated. Crazy turnover of the squad over 18 months. They’re not his players. Wasn’t able to do much in Jan to shape things in his image. VAR controversy constantly overhanging. Points deductions, Clattenberg…
Dyche no debate
The disrespect on David Moyes. Won West Ham their trophy in basically forever. He's onky spent 1 weekend O/S the top 10 and theyre constantly qualifying for Europe
Basically, if you are Spanish you have a high chance of MOTY
Pep is the manager of the year. He is going to win the EPL again this season
There should only be two contenders for moty imo - Emery and Arteta. Man City could end up without a trophy this season. Iraola very much an unkown quantity with two different halves of the season. Next season it will be better to judge. I'd nudge O'Neil down to good, but is he good. He's had a full squad available all season so I would say Wolves are exactly where they should be. I'd also nudge Ange down to good, but is he good. After a good start he was good, but take away his jovial demeanor and take their recent form into account - is he good?
I think Iraola is right because Bournemouth have been amazing this season for a team that fought relegation last year. O’Neil has not a had a full squad, wolves have a pretty small squad and at one point had their front three out and resulted in playing 7 defenders and lemina up front.😂
Too much hate for ange based on the last couple of months when we’ve had players drop in form and lineup issues due to injuries. He also hasn’t had a summer transfer window of his own yet so we’ll see how things go next season
Gary O'Neill should be manager of the season, Wolves sold all thier best players and didnt bring many in at all. O'Neil has improved every single player when on the bench is youth players. Pedro Neto injured for half the season but he won vs city and other big teams. Everton spent a lot more. Most people said wolves would get relegated but midtable and should be higher cos of bad ref decisions.
The protection Eddie Howe and Poch get compared to ETH, despite factually having a worse season.
I thought he was going to put Klopp at "Good, but is he good?" You would have gotten a lot of criticism from me
“Why aren’t Man U linked with Iraola”
James please shush 🤫 🍒
Man U does feel like a poisoned chalice atm. Any manager could break their career there.
i have no horse in the nottingham rating, but why is cooper above nuno?
Dyche and Klopp >> Guardiola this season! The difference between the squads must count!
think this is spot on
Can't help but feel Klopp below MOTY nominee is too low, He had a Liverpool team a lot of people thought would only challenge for Top 4 in a title race until April and spent the longest at the top of the table with way way way more injuries than City and Arsenal, Not to mention the numerous games refs cost Liverpool the win in
I totally agree with every word you've said. Thank you for saying it 🙇
yeah, wanted a world class cdm, cudnt get one, made one. Allison out for ages, afcon, trent out for a while, jota out for ages too, The in game changes have been SO clutch, our 2nd halves have been incredible, multiple academy graduates doing wonders, he's had the season we needed to carry on after klopp, regardless of the trophy count.
Exactly he had way lower expectations than Arsenal and Man City, had so many injuries, had to reshape the team and still was almost as good as them
I don’t know anyone who thought they would struggle to get top 4… they spent close to £150m in the summer. He did deal with injuries well though.
@flynn7671 liverpool were awful last season and had to re-sign the entire midfield so I'm sure it wouldn't have suprised many if man utd and Newcastle finished higher again
ARTETA IS MANAGER OF THE YR IF NOT PEP! The one that challengws City, beats Klopp to the race, beats all top 6 and doesn't lose against them is the obvious manager of the year! if not the winner which most likely will be Pep! Hopefully it will be Mikel!
The disciple is trying to force the master(+best squad+115) to the last game of the season. Ask other managers if they can do that or not.
Klopp did several seasons on the bounce.
Klopp has to be MOTY nominee, he took the team, ripped out the midfield, replaced it with an entirely new one which would destabilize most teams. Proceeded to take this team which people were even doubting that he'd reach UCL spots with, and challenged for the title, and was in fact on top of the table for a while until injuries and refereeing errors combined with fatigue due to squad size ultimately cost him. Any other manager barely scrapes top 4 if even under these conditions.
Perfectly said!
L O L he had actual money unlike Iraola and Dyche
@@jamesbaurus5928and Pep, Arteta and Emery didn’t have money?
Arteta or emery for moty. If city win then emery gets i, if arsenal then arteta should.
Dyche moty
Klopp in the same tier as Kompany is wild
don't agree on Nuno,the games have been great,been done by bad goalkeeping and bad finishing from the teams,the advanced stats show it too,the game against City,Liverpool etc..
The clip cuts off before you name the Manager Of The Year!
33:50 Pep
Emery definitely manager of the year for me
Moyes has to be in good but is he good
I don't understand why Ten Hag is at risk of being sacked and Eddie Howe is 'impressive', are they not in the exact same boat? Great season last year, both knocked out of the CL groups, both suffered massively with injuries and missing personnel, both fighting for European spots, Man United into another cup final too. I'm not saying ETH has had an impressive season, far from it, just that Eddie Howe and Newcastle are having an almost identical season but one manager is being slammed and the other praised.
Expectation levels are much different
Newcastle have been playing well but unlucky with a lot of results. Man Utd have been absolutely dreadful all season and based on performances should be below Chelsea
one of these teams has a billion pound squad, and the other was playing with a 17yo in midfield.
@@NorseBoi_saying that like united don’t have the most minutes played by teenagers is so fucking funny
The whole year United's wins have been shrugged at and losses/draws painted like end of the world. Other teams losses are treated like just an off day.
Arsenal, Villa, Spurs, Chelsea, Liverpool, Brighton, Newcastle all been knocked out of cups. Watch them win at Wembley and the silence will be amazing.
But early for this no?? A manager at the bottom could take his team on a winning run etc..
Ange ranked 22:41
Hmmmm that time lost, days lost table isn't exactly the most helpful metric.for measuring injury issues. Villa have lost three first team players to ACL. That is worse than say a fringe player who has a had a long term injury propping up those stats.
This season has been defined by inconsistency from every side. Eddie Howe the only one with a half decent excuse. But then I’m biased. Very.
I don't understand the time/days loss though.. is that average time players have been missed or..? Because Brentford's is 24.. yet Rico Henry has missed 30 games on his own 🤷♂️ so it makes 0 sense.. and it wasn't explained particularly well @JamesLawrenceAllcott
I was thinking exactly the same. The middle column makes no sense whatsoever. I think it might be total players that have missed a game through injury at some point this season but not sure.
David Moyes been hugely disrespected, expected better James.
Postekoglou still hasn't paid the gyros and souvlakia he had devoured back when he was a looser(still is ) manager in one of the greatest and historical teams in greece and destroyed them !!!! He is a criminal !!
Oliver Glasner will be top next season.
Very poor take on Glasner..... The fitness levels and style change since Roy went is like chalk and cheese....
You've done dyche dirty
If kompany wasn't the former cpt of city he would got sacked longtime ago and struggle to get another decent job,he get rated only because the player he was rather his management,at anderlecht he was really bad,he has one good season his whole carreer as manager ,he should just stop dreaming about city job and get actually good at coaching
If arsenal win the league arteta will win it(big if course) if not emery will win,special mention to O'Neil and Ireola
I don't think Wilder will manage or be in position to manage a Premier League side ever again. Being associated with a season this historically terrible is the kind of thing that at this stage of his career, even Championship clubs will be hesitant to give him a call. Billy Davies is the example I think of here. Got Derby promoted, next season, sacked during the worst Premier League season points-wise in history. He wouldn't get another job for 4 years, and has not managed since 2014. By 2030, I see Wilder done with management altogether.
You should have renamed MOTY nominee to "tier Spanish"
There’s a specific region in Spain where they produce great managers