This is so stupid, AZ was playing with more than 2000 cores and stockfish was using a quad core cpu. Mismatch of the century! This man's voice is very grating, he should get a job of dispersing riots...
alpha zero taught me that pawn are obstacles that need to be removed so my pieces can move freely now I have gone from 800 ranking to 600 ranking thx alpha zero
Hikaru: You shouldn't move these three pawns unless you absolutely have to. Me: [Gets backrank mated over and over again.] Gotham: Alpha Zero likes to let the king breathe. Me: [Rating jumps from 1200 to 1400 because I'm not getting backrank mated anymore.]
Nah, in the first two games pawns were absolutely necessary for the total blocade of Black pieces. If Nimtzovicz was alive he would've died of excessive ejaculation.
@@leonidtimofeev1178 400's: "Pawns get in the way of my pieces!" GMs: "Pawn structure is essential!!" AlphaZero: "Pawns get in the way of your pieces."
@@MrCrackheadst Quite interesting point! When we think about purest logic as a math, fundamental mathematical theories (e.g. Principia Mathematica) seem to have no room for assumption other than axiom. And the axiom is the only thing that can we assume but as seeing math working surprisingly well in this universe, at least there should be a logic which comes before experience, in other word "a priori" knowledge. But if we think about the other universe, I have no slightest idea what logic will be like lol Talking about these chess machines, what was unique about AZ was there was no input at first other than win = 1, lose = 0, still abled to be the strongest chess machine at that time. And AZ played very intuitively imo, it looked like a creative human player than any other chess machines, this i think partially suggest that experience is very useful in terms of your reduction of calculation. If humans were 100% calculation logic based animals, we might got extinct because each time we faced the complex situation, the brain stops and need to calculate lol. So, experience is the shortcutting method of the otherwise lengthy calculation, and extrapolating the solution based on previous experience. AZ only needed experience (win or lose input) to derive the winning strategy/ tactics to beat the stockfish. But after stockfish using the same architecture of NNUE grounded on the previous data, there was no competition for AZ to hold the crown.
@@drondasgupta9378 That's crazy. Star Wars is my all time favorite series. I've read every canon book and I'd imagine at least half of the "Legacy" books. But the only comics I've ventured into is Dr Aphra. I think it's time to redownload Marvel Unlimited and start reading more SW comics.
I just imagined a guy with both hands on a table and smashes his face on a table just sniffing cocaine into his nose like a mf. Not even using a straw or dollar anything lol
1400s: pawns are not that important 2400s: pawn structure defines middle game and end game strategy and great care must be taken to ensure that we do not leave weaknesses 3400s: pawns are not that important
For everyone out there who thinks they should attempt to emulate alpha zero or it's play/strategy, you're looking at a bird, and then jumping off a building to take flight
@@huymai7951 Magnus is building a plane. You don't have the skills to do that, you're just jumping. The point of the analogy is that you're too dumb to utilize the knowledge of alpha zero
"It loves material sacrifice" All fun and games until they implement AlphaZero in the military. 100 Soldiers and the enemy has 99 rounds? I see this as an absolute win.
I like that we have taught machines to learn so that we can try to learn what they discover. So many moves that even you as a strong player don’t necessarily understand and yet as you pick them apart you start to gain insight into a game you already know so well. Thank you for sharing on a level that is educational without being intimidating.
@@user-sicparvis well some people created machines able to learn and you can say that u gotta be smart to do something like that but then people still think we faked the moon landing... Humanity is stupid overall
I love how alpha plays. Its plays with so much flare, sacrificing pieces like its nothing, increasing its mobility while imprisoning its opponent aswell as regularly throwing in elegantly savage moves. Imo its the most beautiful play style that has ever existed.
Watch all 200 of those games and come back and tell me it's beautiful lmao. The vast majority of its play is laboriously shuffling pieces for miniscule advantage. Levy just spared us the pain of watching that stuff.
The straight up ridiculous amount of subtleties in it's slow improvements is still really beautiful though it does get admittedly boring when you can't understand any of it.
@@ColdSleepTo be fair, that's how you have to play if you want to beat Stockfish. If we were intelligent enough to grasp its play, maybe the shuffling would be just as beautiful.
Playing against AlphaZero must be like those dreams where you're running as fast as you can but don't go anywhere, all the time this really slow monster is just laughing and walking up behind you.
@@knockkek9808 If I were into dream therapy I'd tell you that this probably means you have something in your life that you feel nervous / stressed about, and you can't find a way to solve it. But I'm not into dream therapy, and basically everybody has something like that.
@@kshitiz6376what do you mean?Alphazero was discontinued. Its like saying Magnus surpassed Bobby Fischer. Ofcourse that will happen. Because Bobby IS NOT ALIVE anymore. Bozo.
Low Elo: Recklessly pushing pawns and losing pieces is great! Grandmasters: Recklessly pushing pawns and losing pieces is awful. AlphaZero: Recklessly pushing pawns and losing pieces is great!
21:15 - I literally got chills at this part. Your storytelling is next level. It's a bunch of chess pieces on a board, yet somehow I'm afraid for my life right now.
If you look at AlphaZero's moves one at a time they look very strange, but when you see the whole picture you understand that this is really how chess is meant to be played (if you have enough computational power to actually do it). And honestly it's also much more entertaining.
@@merzeporgoher yeah but alphazero is better at evaluating positions. Even now Stockfish isn't the best at evaluation, but it's still on top through raw calculation power.
"Oh, you're offering an exchange? (...) Yeah, no, f4 actually. You suck, you can't move." Goddamn AlphaZero is complete Chad. Lets have an anime version of this with levy's lines. Would be amazing.
They should give the engines additional neuronal networks to shit talk each other, fueled by dialogue data from levy. That would make chess engine matches so entertaining hahaha
@@nomdeplume9590 to be scientifically correct, it is a Machine Learning Algorithm, as it gets better the longer you give it time to learn. But it still works like an engine, as it still looks at a given position and then calculates - based on potential later threats and changes - how good or bad the position is for either side
@@hienable6933 during the romantic era of chess, it didn't matter how dogshit your move was, all that mattered was the intention behind it. Getting your queen out early without backup is bad, but, it was a sign from you preparing to launch an invasion.
I wouldn't say it seems more 'human' but it definitely is more comprehensible, ie we can understand the way it works. But the way Stockfish works is further away from how the human mind works than Alphazero.
@@MrCheerios2011 The way I mean is, for example when alphazero sacrifices pawns stockfish seems to always take them. The way it values material advantage seems more human, we don't see stockfish sacking pawns left and right, just the way most humans don't.
@@forbiddenlies1938 Yes but Stockfish still makes many moves that are not human at all. It's just that Alphazero is able to see the long term positional advantages and therefore evaluates the position differently.
Stockfish is more more human because people taught it to play. It learned from human games and we taught it how to evaluate the situation. AlphaZero learned just by playing against itself.
@Black Swan55 Just because it was beaten doesn’t mean it’s not strong. Plus, I bet it would absolutely obliterate you if you had played a game with it lmao
I never fully watch videos longer than 15min and will always skip around or play on 2x speed, but for this 30 minute video I watched the whole thing straight. What I love about Levy is he covers and explains games/moves in such an accessible and entertaining manner, where even 800 newbies like me can actually learn and enjoy.
Hikaru's basically already at 1 mill, but Levy's channel is growing much faster. In a couple weeks Levy will surpass him, but not until after 1 mill. Sadge
Here are the Levy highlights: 3:57 AB-SO-LUTE SAVAGE 5:49 This is where he clearly starts to go insane. Man, that's early. 7:36 Levy has to doubletake on this nonsense. 8:16 "HAVE YOU EVER SEEN A QUEEN IN JAIL?!" 10:27 Oh no, Levy's been broken... 11:10 Oh, right, Levy is an IM. 11:24 That's straight-up computer bigotry. 18:38 Levy takes this one personally. 19:12 It hurts his soul. 20:34 Am I a game to you, AlphaZero? 22:01 "Are you ever gonna be able to push any of your... FOUR EXTRA PAWNS, BOZO?!" 22:14 30 seconds of pure disrespect 25:28 And another 40 seconds of disrespect. Honestly, Levy is just so fun to watch trash talking computers.
I'm From India and I can't thank you enough for your generous donation of 10000 US $ towards Covid Relief in India as we've been badly hit. Just want to take this moment to remind you that you're worth more than a king. And many here love your channel ❤️
Me: I once sacrificed a pawn and recaptured in the next move to take my turns. Alphazero: I once sacrificed all my pawns to get a narrowly winning endgame after 36 moves.
AlphaZero is the start of a new era for chess. Its strength seems godlike, not just tactically which is typical for engines but also positionally - normally a human trait. It is on a completely different level than anything in the history of the game.
Alphazero is unfortunately non open source, and the team behind the AI have stopped doing chess (I believe). The newest stockfish would crush this version of alphazero. This sucks, I'd love to see what AZ could have done if it was trained for longer and focused more on chess.
@@dead_man7 That's because AZ beat Stockfish with an elo difference of about 50. The latest versions of Stockfish are capable of beating Stockfish 8 by a difference of about 150 elo. "In chess, as of 2022, newer engines are generally agreed to have surpassed AlphaZero's playing strength" Moreover, there's one thing people don't quite realize. The point of these matches was not to show that AZ is better than Stockfish. AZ was running on 4000 CPU cores, and Stockfish on your average "weak" CPU. That's an immense advantage for AZ. If both engines were to run on the same hardware, it is predicted that any strong engine would have beaten AZ. The point of these matches was to show that an AI can achieve incredible feats not brute forcing the game. It goes to show how strong AI's potential is, given a lot of effort and hardware are dedicated to it.
@@cantcatchme6749 Another very important element was that AlphaZero does not need to be developed by people who know how to play chess. Stockfish is developed by and with the help of masters and gm of chess with enormous knowledge of chess theory. You can't just take stockfish, tell him the rules of Go or Poker and ask it to play these instead of chess. To develop AlphaZero, there is no need for someone actually good at chess helping. Just tell him "Here are the rules of chess, play yourself and git gud mf!" and it just does.
Actually if you skim through various chess channels,you can find they are more or less all sublime in their commentary. We all know what kind of a monster stockfish actually is, so if there was someone to come along that would probably lay that stinky little fish over its knee and paddle his cheeks for a bit... man that would be some kind of quite fascinating ^^
I love how Gotham's commentary gives our new computer chess overlords vibrant personalities, "AlphaZero is an absolute SAVAGE...AlphaZero does not like e4... I'll take your soul!" Very entertaining overall, also RIP Stockfish.
"Have you ever seen a queen in jail? Well maybe in some other countrys." Gold commedy. Learning Chess and laughing can it get any better? You are the best chess streamer keep it up.
2000 rated players be like: NOOOO He got me out of my prep I'm gonna lose! Me, a 1300: I give my best and try to remember everything Levy told me. LEVY YOU ARE MORE WORTH THAN THE CHESSBOARD
I think you can find games of alpha zero against other professionals. I’m not too sure but I know you can find some games between Magnus and very strong chess engines
Alpha zero is literally my dream playstyle. Extremely aggressive, giving your opponent zero break. But i know even if i get to 2000 elo i will be absolutely destroy if i play like it
The alpha zero engine is just mean. That's all there is to it. It does everything in its power to be a dick to its opponent, and make them suffer. It's awesome.
Stockfish is like a cold robot mathematically choosing how to kill you while alphazero is like a alien being that surpassed the universe and just wants to cause pain while it destroys you with perfect logic
I got scared even without the description. If stockfish feels like a super smart could guy, alpha zero truly plays like a snake, just lurking and doing things that don't make sense, and when you realize, you're already trapped. That bishop d3 in the third game was so scary, cuz i firstly went "what the fuck? Why" and feel moves later stockfish was already fucked because of the light bishop position.
I mean it's more like "Slow, gruelling, and soul-crushing endgame in which your mobility and then material is completely killed" but that wouldn't be as good of a one-liner
It looks to me like AlphaZero is using literal military tactics to win these, defeat in detail, anvil and hammer. Pinning down superior enemy forces with a small part of its own forces so it can go around and smash the enemy in some other place. Also restricting opponents movements and opportunities. This is literally how a small modern army would deal with a bigger older army.
13:13 Well when AlphaZero saw the French Defence it got inspired by two major events in history and went *around* it. Like the germans went around the maginot line.
Stockfish: chat, chat, i don't care guys, i'm literally an engine with no emotions, i literally don't care, that's just bad sportmanship by Alphazero, but i don't care
I love the fact that he is giving computers personalities, like: "StockFish was too scared and did not take the pawn" "AlphaZero was like, yeah take my pawn"
amazing how it seems Alphazero pointedly plays for choking off the opp's activity, enhancing it's own rather than burying tactics deep in unclear lines with chances on either side. very original way of cyberplay
Gary Kasparov quote : "Tactics is knowing what to do when there is something to do. Strategy is knowing what to do when there is nothing to do.” Levy Rozman quote: It went beep beep boop and said shut up Gotham
Oh my gosh. I was already amazed at how beautiful the first game was but that king move in the second game......that was watching an intelligence completely different than a human grandmaster. Wow. Awesome. Truly awe inspiring.
I was part of the Leela dev team, and watched it experiment with openings over and over again. It always ended up with either the Nf3 QG (the NiD equalized too easily) or the Catalan.
![ร้อยพ่อพันแม่ - WanMai [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XY2pNYASEbg/mqdefault.jpg)
This is so stupid, AZ was playing with more than 2000 cores and stockfish was using a quad core cpu. Mismatch of the century! This man's voice is very grating, he should get a job of dispersing riots...
Pin of shame
PIN OF SHAME
Pin of SHAME
Pin of SHAME
sHaMe oF pIN
alpha zero taught me that pawn are obstacles that need to be removed so my pieces can move freely now I have gone from 800 ranking to 600 ranking thx alpha zero
You need to know what your doing first😂
😂😂🤣
Eventually you'll be able to reach rank 1!
Some here
soon #1
Philidor: pawns are the soul of chess
AlphaZero: pawns get in the way of my pieces
Also AlphaZero: pawns get in the way of your pieces.
Chess beginners: Pawns get in the way of my pieces
Chess masters: Good pawn structure is essential
AlphaZero: Pawns get in the way of my pieces
@@ericzhu6620 what?
@@descendency underrated comment
you made a blunder in your grammar
Alphazero: pawns get in the way of my pieces and pieces get in the way of my pawns, but I'll win anyways
Chess Grandmasters: It is very important to have a safe King
Alpha Zero: King devlopment
When some random nerd does king development you just think the nerd is dumb
But if alphazero does it, it is literally going to take your soul
King goes brrr
my man alpha zero is slowly , but surely evolving towards bongcloud
*boss music starts playing*
The king goes skrrrrra
Hikaru: You shouldn't move these three pawns unless you absolutely have to.
Me: [Gets backrank mated over and over again.]
Gotham: Alpha Zero likes to let the king breathe.
Me: [Rating jumps from 1200 to 1400 because I'm not getting backrank mated anymore.]
400's: "Pawns get in the way of my pieces!"
GMs: "Pawn structure is essential!!"
AlphaZero: "Pawns get in the way of my pieces."
400s are secretly superior
xD
We've come full circle
Nah, in the first two games pawns were absolutely necessary for the total blocade of Black pieces. If Nimtzovicz was alive he would've died of excessive ejaculation.
@@leonidtimofeev1178 400's: "Pawns get in the way of my pieces!"
GMs: "Pawn structure is essential!!"
AlphaZero: "Pawns get in the way of your pieces."
Anyone: Don't blunder
AlphaZero: SAC A ROOK LET'S FUCKING GOOOOOOOO
lol ;D
@@toan--HoangVuGiaHuy The most low-key response possible
It’s like alphazero is throwing for content and still winning
@@poobman6 Its easy to play like alphazero.
1. Feeds pawns.
2. Feed more pawns.
AlphaZero: *rails line of coke*
AlphaZero: SAC TIME LFGGGG
Stockfish: Sophisticated, calm, classical
Alpha Zero: *hmm yes delayed bongcloud gives me 120% chance of victory*
To be fair even stockfish understood the power of the delayed bongcloud, as it recommended capturing with the king
did u catch the game last night?
did u catch the game last year?
did u catch the game last decade?
@@allysson_ I appreciate the originality, but chances are I still likely didn't haha
"The way it understands piece formation is fascinating"
Meanwhile AZ:" I have no idea what I'm doing, but moving this piece has worked before"
Exactly! It's actually what is going on in NNUE
They ground on experience not logic
So AZs move looks more intuitive one
@@Gingnose if we get very philosophical one may argue logic is formed from experience.
@@MrCrackheadst Quite interesting point!
When we think about purest logic as a math, fundamental mathematical theories (e.g. Principia Mathematica) seem to have no room for assumption other than axiom. And the axiom is the only thing that can we assume but as seeing math working surprisingly well in this universe, at least there should be a logic which comes before experience, in other word "a priori" knowledge. But if we think about the other universe, I have no slightest idea what logic will be like lol
Talking about these chess machines, what was unique about AZ was there was no input at first other than win = 1, lose = 0, still abled to be the strongest chess machine at that time. And AZ played very intuitively imo, it looked like a creative human player than any other chess machines, this i think partially suggest that experience is very useful in terms of your reduction of calculation. If humans were 100% calculation logic based animals, we might got extinct because each time we faced the complex situation, the brain stops and need to calculate lol. So, experience is the shortcutting method of the otherwise lengthy calculation, and extrapolating the solution based on previous experience. AZ only needed experience (win or lose input) to derive the winning strategy/ tactics to beat the stockfish. But after stockfish using the same architecture of NNUE grounded on the previous data, there was no competition for AZ to hold the crown.
@@Gingnose Thank you.
"Understanding" is kind of used metaphorically here.
AZ playing a retreating move before the attack is like loading a crossbow.
Or loading guns especially Alekhine's
Stockfish: plays the first move in the French Defense
AlphaZero: hmm looks like I'm completely winning already
Sounds like Germany
Just go through the Ardennes 👌
@@dekippiesip ggez
Just make Vichy France and .be invaded by the allies
best response
Alphazero: *loses 4 pawn*
Also Alphazero: "oh, I'm completly winning now"
But what impresses me is that Stockfish doesn't lose its cool.
I've never seen Stockfish kicking the table or throwing pieces after losing a match.
@@cinegraphics that would've been awesome to see
Sounds like GM Hikaru.
Å: oh yeah, it's all coming together.
th-cam.com/channels/-ex3ieZJ0T52aFAMNgb4gQ.htmlvideos
Stockfish with +4 material: "You are surrounded!"
AlphaZero: "All I am surrounded by is fear. And dead men."
Is that an og quote or is it from something? It's badass.
@@Jeffrey_Tyler It's from a Star Wars comic, said by none other than Darth Vader.
@@drondasgupta9378 That's crazy. Star Wars is my all time favorite series. I've read every canon book and I'd imagine at least half of the "Legacy" books. But the only comics I've ventured into is Dr Aphra. I think it's time to redownload Marvel Unlimited and start reading more SW comics.
i am batman
@@Jeffrey_Tyler *shields from nerd emoji comments*
*Me hanging a pawn*
Stockfish: "Oh man, that's a blu-"
Alphazero: "YEAH BRO, GREAT MOVE, KEEP PUSHING THIS MF" *Snorts cocain from the table*
I just imagined a guy with both hands on a table and smashes his face on a table just sniffing cocaine into his nose like a mf. Not even using a straw or dollar anything lol
@@Mike-we3rb yeah, accurate 100%😂
😂
Man this one got me, the image I got from this comment got me laughing for 5 minutes straight!
Alphazero: AaaaaAAAAAAAA
Robots have no emotions
Stock fish:I have known fear...
Stockfish: "I fear no man. But that thing..."
*AlphaZero*
"...it scares me."
First game: 1. Nf3 Nf6 2. c4 b6 3. d4 e6 4. g3 Ba6
5. Qc2 c5 6. d5 exd5 7. cxd5 Bb7 8. Bg2 Nxd5
9. O-O Nc6 10. Rd1 Be7 11. Qf5 Nf6 12. e4 g6
13. Qf4 O-O 14. e5 Nh5 15. Qg4 Re8 16. Nc3 Qb8
17. Nd5 Bf8 18. Bf4 Qc8 19. h3 Ne7 20. Ne3 Bc6
21. Rd6 Ng7 22. Rf6 Qb7 23. Bh6 Nd5 24. Nxd5 Bxd5
25. Rd1 Ne6 26. Bxf8 Rxf8 27. Qh4 Bc6 28. Qh6 Rae8
29. Rd6 Bxf3 30. Bxf3 Qa6 31. h4 Qa5 32. Rd1 c4
33. Rd5 Qe1+ 34. Kg2 c3 35. bxc3 Qxc3 36. h5 Re7
37. Bd1 Qe1 38. Bb3 Rd8 39. Rf3 Qe4 40. Qd2 Qg4
41. Bd1 Qe4 42. h6 Nc7 43. Rd6 Ne6 44. Bb3 Qxe5
45. Rd5 Qh8 46. Qb4 Nc5 47. Rxc5 bxc5 48. Qh4 Rde8
49. Rf6 Rf8 50. Qf4 a5 51. g4 d5 52. Bxd5 Rd7
53. Bc4 a4 54. g5 a3 55. Qf3 Rc7 56. Qxa3 Qxf6
57. gxf6 Rfc8 58. Qd3 Rf8 59. Qd6 Rfc8 60. a4 (Game may have continued) Kh8
61. a5 g5 62. a6 g4 63. Qe7 g3 64. a7 Rxe7
65. fxe7 f6 66. Bd5 gxf2 67. a8=Q Rxa8 68. Bxa8 f1=B+
69. Kxf1 c4 70. e8=Q#
@@Tortoisaurus thx
@@mark85gmballerbattleship39 ok
Stockfish should be renamed Marvin as im pretty sure its complete trouncing caused it to know depression 😒
1400s: pawns are not that important
2400s: pawn structure defines middle game and end game strategy and great care must be taken to ensure that we do not leave weaknesses
3400s: pawns are not that important
There is a meme using this joke
400's: pawns get in the way of my pieces!
Does 900 elo players were right after all
@@Galoric 😂😂 i laughed out loud
Stockfish: I will go ahead and move my first pawn
AlphaZero: *This was your first mistake, and the game is already over for you*
nice reference
i have found out this comment section is solid gold
@@kemcolian2001 It is a reference to what?
This is exactly how a future war with AI will look like, except we are no where as strong as Stockfish.
alphazero: “that was your second mistake! your first mistake was of course challenging me in the first place
For everyone out there who thinks they should attempt to emulate alpha zero or it's play/strategy, you're looking at a bird, and then jumping off a building to take flight
And yet airplanes where inspired by watching hawks.
@@sebastiang7394 fr bro really forgot the existence of the indomitable human spirit 💀😂
@@sebastiang7394 Airplanes arent operated by people jumping off buildings.
Works in 400s after i dropped to 400 emulating that style
@@huymai7951 Magnus is building a plane. You don't have the skills to do that, you're just jumping. The point of the analogy is that you're too dumb to utilize the knowledge of alpha zero
AlphaZero feels like an enhanced 400 rated player.
Like the most basic weapon in the game upgraded to max stats + enchantments.
@@numeric9834you are somehow both right
I play hypixel skybolck and maxed aotj isn't scary
@@snivydream not yet
@@_xxmidnight5351 I don't think it will reach the highs that it on e reached
@@snivydream wdym, it the best sword
"It loves material sacrifice"
All fun and games until they implement AlphaZero in the military. 100 Soldiers and the enemy has 99 rounds? I see this as an absolute win.
Oh my word...🤣🤣🤣🤣
Soviet Russia enters the chat
50 soldiers on each side
This comment made my week lol!
@@gorkemaykut5230 Modern day Russia enters the chat.
I like that we have taught machines to learn so that we can try to learn what they discover. So many moves that even you as a strong player don’t necessarily understand and yet as you pick them apart you start to gain insight into a game you already know so well. Thank you for sharing on a level that is educational without being intimidating.
All of this and still the are people who still think that we don't land on the moon
@@brm3175 how is that related
@@user-sicparvis well some people created machines able to learn and you can say that u gotta be smart to do something like that but then people still think we faked the moon landing... Humanity is stupid overall
@@brm3175 is English your first language?
th-cam.com/channels/-ex3ieZJ0T52aFAMNgb4gQ.htmlvideos
Damn… AlphaZero is like… that guy who is so cocky that you think it’s an act, but in actuality he’s cocky because he knows he is undoubtedly better
me
@@oskain 😱😱
@@oskain you fr
@@oskain has to be u bro 💯💯💯💯💯💯💯
Undoubtedly confident
Around 7 minutes Levi is straight up commentating like a sports caster, it's glorious
I enjoyed StarCraft commentaries just because of that :)
@ alpha zero also plays starcraft funny enough
@@NeostormXLMAX yup, watched the matches with Serral live :-)
First game: 1. Nf3 Nf6 2. c4 b6 3. d4 e6 4. g3 Ba6
5. Qc2 c5 6. d5 exd5 7. cxd5 Bb7 8. Bg2 Nxd5
9. O-O Nc6 10. Rd1 Be7 11. Qf5 Nf6 12. e4 g6
13. Qf4 O-O 14. e5 Nh5 15. Qg4 Re8 16. Nc3 Qb8
17. Nd5 Bf8 18. Bf4 Qc8 19. h3 Ne7 20. Ne3 Bc6
21. Rd6 Ng7 22. Rf6 Qb7 23. Bh6 Nd5 24. Nxd5 Bxd5
25. Rd1 Ne6 26. Bxf8 Rxf8 27. Qh4 Bc6 28. Qh6 Rae8
29. Rd6 Bxf3 30. Bxf3 Qa6 31. h4 Qa5 32. Rd1 c4
33. Rd5 Qe1+ 34. Kg2 c3 35. bxc3 Qxc3 36. h5 Re7
37. Bd1 Qe1 38. Bb3 Rd8 39. Rf3 Qe4 40. Qd2 Qg4
41. Bd1 Qe4 42. h6 Nc7 43. Rd6 Ne6 44. Bb3 Qxe5
45. Rd5 Qh8 46. Qb4 Nc5 47. Rxc5 bxc5 48. Qh4 Rde8
49. Rf6 Rf8 50. Qf4 a5 51. g4 d5 52. Bxd5 Rd7
53. Bc4 a4 54. g5 a3 55. Qf3 Rc7 56. Qxa3 Qxf6
57. gxf6 Rfc8 58. Qd3 Rf8 59. Qd6 Rfc8 60. a4 (Game may have continued) Kh8
61. a5 g5 62. a6 g4 63. Qe7 g3 64. a7 Rxe7
65. fxe7 f6 66. Bd5 gxf2 67. a8=Q Rxa8 68. Bxa8 f1=B+
69. Kxf1 c4 70. e8=Q#
Everything changed when AlphaZero attacked
*Salutes*
Only GothamChess master of all positions could stop it
@@rohankrishna5786 when the chess community needed him most he vanished
This is so perfect, I don't wanna ruin anything
the joke here is that its kinda like avatar, not funny 😐 ( joke)
Alternative title : When you lose playing best engine moves...
If you lost were they the best moves?
@@michaelrhodes258 if your opponent is god then yes
@@michaelrhodes258 "It is possible to commit no mistakes and still lose. That is not weakness. That is life."
@@michaelrhodes258 he said the best ENGINE moves
th-cam.com/channels/-ex3ieZJ0T52aFAMNgb4gQ.htmlvideos
*Alpha Zero is a 3400 rated player with the spirit of a 400 player*
XD
XD
XD
XD
XD
Me after realizing how it slowly locked in the queen:
"Holy shiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii"
It literally built a cage and then many moves later put the Queen in it. So savage
Rook to c8 was kinda weird from stockfish
@@jaredjenkins99 That was the gnarliest set up to trap the king AND queen in a cage ive ever watched!!
Yes that was terrifying to watch . . . :-O
And that's how you get classy girls. Slowly...
I love how alpha plays. Its plays with so much flare, sacrificing pieces like its nothing, increasing its mobility while imprisoning its opponent aswell as regularly throwing in elegantly savage moves. Imo its the most beautiful play style that has ever existed.
Watch all 200 of those games and come back and tell me it's beautiful lmao. The vast majority of its play is laboriously shuffling pieces for miniscule advantage. Levy just spared us the pain of watching that stuff.
The straight up ridiculous amount of subtleties in it's slow improvements is still really beautiful though it does get admittedly boring when you can't understand any of it.
@@ColdSleepTo be fair, that's how you have to play if you want to beat Stockfish. If we were intelligent enough to grasp its play, maybe the shuffling would be just as beautiful.
Playing against AlphaZero must be like those dreams where you're running as fast as you can but don't go anywhere, all the time this really slow monster is just laughing and walking up behind you.
WTFFF, I have these kind of dreams all the time, didnt know it was a common thing?!?
@@knockkek9808 If I were into dream therapy I'd tell you that this probably means you have something in your life that you feel nervous / stressed about, and you can't find a way to solve it.
But I'm not into dream therapy, and basically everybody has something like that.
@@isaakvandaalen3899 This just made me to study dreams.
@@knockkek9808 yeah it is common.
Stockfish: A pawn is worth one point
AlphaZero: A pawn is worth negative one point
it is so hard 4 stockfish to win against AZ like I
@@ziggo_pro What do you mean? Stockfish has already surpassed Alpha 0.
@@kshitiz6376 I said chatgpt to count from 4 to 1 in a sentence about Alphazero and stockfish in this video
@@kshitiz6376what do you mean?Alphazero was discontinued. Its like saying Magnus surpassed Bobby Fischer. Ofcourse that will happen. Because Bobby IS NOT ALIVE anymore. Bozo.
@@harshrajbasant Do you have any idea how dumb you sound or do I need to explain that to you?
Your pawns get in the way of your other pieces, Give them all away
funny to see you here
nice to see you, minecraft chess when?
good to see you
Lmao
Play sea of thieves again.
Low Elo: Recklessly pushing pawns and losing pieces is great!
Grandmasters: Recklessly pushing pawns and losing pieces is awful.
AlphaZero: Recklessly pushing pawns and losing pieces is great!
Normal distribution meme in text form. Love it.
return to monke
Alphazero has got the spirit of a beginner and the mastery of a super GM
So a low elo player is as good as alpha zero
@@sakshamsinghal5418 It's more likely to think that alpha zero is just the greatest low ELO player ever.
22:05 Levy has ascended to a level of calling stockfish a bozo
21:15 - I literally got chills at this part. Your storytelling is next level. It's a bunch of chess pieces on a board, yet somehow I'm afraid for my life right now.
Yeah 0~0'''
@@Marsh370 who are you warrior?
bro same
It's only a matter of time until someone puts Alpha Zero or even more powerful AI in the Military.
AlphaZero: *plays a move*
Levy: 'AlphaZero LOOOVEEES that kind of move!'
Alpha zero taking the knight with the king instead of queen is just savage.
you just lose a queen after Bb4 pinning the queen against the king so its either king takes or knight takes
nice profile pic
5:53 move. Why didn't the queen take the A2 pawn?
@@marinhosantos1929 Because of Pawn to h5
You would lose the queen after Bb4, but it could've taken with the knight
When AlphaZero sends a copy of itself back in time to kill Stockfish's creator I'll be impressed
When?
@@lillie3029 lmao
@@lillie3029 Judgement day.
There's no fate but what we make...
@@lillie3029 You know it's gonna happen. Just a matter of time.
If you look at AlphaZero's moves one at a time they look very strange, but when you see the whole picture you understand that this is really how chess is meant to be played (if you have enough computational power to actually do it). And honestly it's also much more entertaining.
Stockfish calculates 60 million moves per second, alphazero calculates 60 thousand moves per second, ai is insane
@@AF-mv8hq so stockfish had a higher calculation ability ?!
@@merzeporgoher both stockfish and alphazero simulate possible moves. AlphaZero just picked the smarter moves.
@@merzeporgoher yes, but it's not mean higher quality of calculation, which in AlphaZero better
@@merzeporgoher yeah but alphazero is better at evaluating positions. Even now Stockfish isn't the best at evaluation, but it's still on top through raw calculation power.
What strikes me is how Alpha focuses on restricting its opponent's movements - and then has patience before attacking.
AZ is also called python because of their slow torture
For a second I thought it's programming joke about how Python is slow
So it is better than some humans
"Alpha zero annihilated the French defense"
Germans: Yeah, you just go around them.
It’s like a kitten with killing a mouse. They pat them around playing with it and wound it very slowly then just rip it apart lol
"Oh, you're offering an exchange? (...) Yeah, no, f4 actually. You suck, you can't move." Goddamn AlphaZero is complete Chad. Lets have an anime version of this with levy's lines. Would be amazing.
They should give the engines additional neuronal networks to shit talk each other, fueled by dialogue data from levy. That would make chess engine matches so entertaining hahaha
I actually laughed so hard when alpha zero bong clouded the king LMFAO
Timestamp??
When?
@@jaitelyaditya03 10:30
10:33 I think
10:33- 10:40
Stockfish is an AI trained with people and chess theory as a base, AZ just feels like it's completely brute forced the concept of chess as a game
That's how it was, made. It learnt by playing thousand of games against itself
@@chrisdawson1776 🤡
@@chrisdawson1776 🤓🤡 or is it 🤡🤓 either way 🤡🤡
@@chrisdawson1776 🤡🤡
@@krishnachoubey8648 🤓
"Somebody should report AlphaZero for cheating."
I agree, it's pretty obvious they're using an engine.
Nice
I'm fairly sure that Alphazero isn't an engine in the conventional sense of the word, as it doesn't brute force. So... maybe it counts, but maybe not.
I know AlphaZero ia a big cheater
@@nomdeplume9590 it's still an engine, just not in the classical sensd
@@nomdeplume9590 to be scientifically correct, it is a Machine Learning Algorithm, as it gets better the longer you give it time to learn. But it still works like an engine, as it still looks at a given position and then calculates - based on potential later threats and changes - how good or bad the position is for either side
The coolest thing about AlphaZero is that it plays the romantic era perfectly.
It plays like it's really orchestrating a war.
What the heck is the romantic era?
@@hienable6933 during the romantic era of chess, it didn't matter how dogshit your move was, all that mattered was the intention behind it.
Getting your queen out early without backup is bad, but, it was a sign from you preparing to launch an invasion.
@@blushingbutterfly7742 woah that's cool
Alphazero is Napoleon confirmed
@@Opanker_ it'd be actually interesting if AlphaZero deploys the Napoleon attack. I tried it before, it's an okay beginner move.
Stockfish: Makes a logical move
AlphaZero: Unfortunately for you, I'm having a very bad day.
AlphaZero: "I reject your reality and substitute my own."
@@cinegraphics dungeon master! Nice!
@@NotjustRian01 what? no... mythbusters
@@kyro8581 what no
I am so happy to see a saoa reference here :')
Game starts
Stockfish: best move is e4 or knight f3
Alphazero: Mate in 100 😁
add another two 0s
Levy be uploading content faster than we can watch it
th-cam.com/video/UXFOMo4igL8/w-d-xo.html so true
Ahaha yes
His subscriber count is approx. increasing @6k per day so why not!
"a small price to pay for salvation"
we all know it and we all love it
Isn't it insane that even stockfish seems more "human" compared to alphazero?
I wouldn't say it seems more 'human' but it definitely is more comprehensible, ie we can understand the way it works. But the way Stockfish works is further away from how the human mind works than Alphazero.
@@MrCheerios2011 The way I mean is, for example when alphazero sacrifices pawns stockfish seems to always take them. The way it values material advantage seems more human, we don't see stockfish sacking pawns left and right, just the way most humans don't.
@@forbiddenlies1938 Yes but Stockfish still makes many moves that are not human at all. It's just that Alphazero is able to see the long term positional advantages and therefore evaluates the position differently.
@@MrCheerios2011 I never said stockfish seems human, it seems more human compared to alphazero. Of course it makes moves we do not understand.
Stockfish is more more human because people taught it to play. It learned from human games and we taught it how to evaluate the situation. AlphaZero learned just by playing against itself.
"have you ever seen a queen in jail!?" Love the enthusiasm
Maybe in another country 😂
france lol
anne boleyn?
GM Maurice Ashley has a similar infectious attitude in his commentary.
where does he say that?
its a basic overflow problem: if you do a very lot of blunders, its transform into an excellent position
*AlphaZero plays any move*
Levy: ALPHAZERO JUST LOVES DOMINATING ITS OPPONENT
@Black Swan55 Just because it was beaten doesn’t mean it’s not strong. Plus, I bet it would absolutely obliterate you if you had played a game with it lmao
@@Amadeus1291 I think we would all lose to Alpha Zero, I can't even beat stockfish.
@@avaanoliah2984 Drawing stock fish is already a feat
@Black Swan55 because the engine don’t have time to calculate and he is using a shit processor idiot
@Black Swan55 "speed chess master" so he's shit at classical huh
Low elo player: recklessly loses pawns
AlphaZero: reckfully loses pawns
you stole this comment
Yeah he stole it
No he stole it
You fuckin stole it
He captured the comment
Okay but can we take a moment to appreciate just how good that shirt is, I love it so much
@77thSOUND lmao clan tho
Levy drip
Levy been spending them dollars wisely.
Idk that rlly looks like levy just gone holiday from hawaii
Chess rating: 2450
Fashion rating: 3000
😂😂
I never fully watch videos longer than 15min and will always skip around or play on 2x speed, but for this 30 minute video I watched the whole thing straight. What I love about Levy is he covers and explains games/moves in such an accessible and entertaining manner, where even 800 newbies like me can actually learn and enjoy.
I love how he gives emotions to chess so game gets more dramatic and impressive.
Getting levy to 1 million is worth more than a queen! So let’s do it.
For him, worth more than a King.
I wonder if he’ll beat Hikaru
@@DivinePlant nah he won't Hikaru is at 990k already so. id like if levy got there first tho.
@@praneelgogoi7769 maybe he will beat him long term
Hikaru's basically already at 1 mill, but Levy's channel is growing much faster. In a couple weeks Levy will surpass him, but not until after 1 mill. Sadge
"sacrifice material to damage your soul" got me rolling 😂😂😂
and when he says stuff like “ i will take, i will take again, and you *die* “
"I don't just take your king, I take your soul!"
Here are the Levy highlights:
3:57 AB-SO-LUTE SAVAGE
5:49 This is where he clearly starts to go insane. Man, that's early.
7:36 Levy has to doubletake on this nonsense.
8:16 "HAVE YOU EVER SEEN A QUEEN IN JAIL?!"
10:27 Oh no, Levy's been broken...
11:10 Oh, right, Levy is an IM.
11:24 That's straight-up computer bigotry.
18:38 Levy takes this one personally.
19:12 It hurts his soul.
20:34 Am I a game to you, AlphaZero?
22:01 "Are you ever gonna be able to push any of your... FOUR EXTRA PAWNS, BOZO?!"
22:14 30 seconds of pure disrespect
25:28 And another 40 seconds of disrespect.
Honestly, Levy is just so fun to watch trash talking computers.
I'm From India and I can't thank you enough for your generous donation of 10000 US $ towards Covid Relief in India as we've been badly hit. Just want to take this moment to remind you that you're worth more than a king. And many here love your channel ❤️
I didn't know Levy did that. It's awesome!!
@insert username You mean gothamchess
@insert username Bothamchess 💀💀
Thanks levi the king
Really when he did that. I don't believe it
700 Friend- *plays KB1, KB2*
Me- “He has no clue what he’s doing”
AZ- *plays KB1, KB2*
Me- *Worried Laughter*
Chuckles... I'm in danger
he hide his King from my bishop who can do nothing because of all my white square pawn... ooooh! those pawn are gonna disappear
Me: I once sacrificed a pawn and recaptured in the next move to take my turns.
Alphazero: I once sacrificed all my pawns to get a narrowly winning endgame after 36 moves.
AlphaZero: Bong Botez strategy go BRRRRRRRRRR.
Alpha 0 taught me that It is OK to sacrifice random pieces and when they take just switch the side of the board I'm attacking
alpha zero: *sacs 700 pieces of material"
stockfish: " why you bully me"
No replies
@@srbhatia703 lies and deceit
"beep beep bop shut up Gotham" ~AlphaZero 2021
Based
AlphaZero is the start of a new era for chess. Its strength seems godlike, not just tactically which is typical for engines but also positionally - normally a human trait. It is on a completely different level than anything in the history of the game.
AlphaZero was* the start. The games are from 2017.
Alphazero is unfortunately non open source, and the team behind the AI have stopped doing chess (I believe). The newest stockfish would crush this version of alphazero. This sucks, I'd love to see what AZ could have done if it was trained for longer and focused more on chess.
@@cantcatchme6749 how do you know that newest stockfish will destroy this AZ?
@@dead_man7
That's because AZ beat Stockfish with an elo difference of about 50. The latest versions of Stockfish are capable of beating Stockfish 8 by a difference of about 150 elo.
"In chess, as of 2022, newer engines are generally agreed to have surpassed AlphaZero's playing strength"
Moreover, there's one thing people don't quite realize. The point of these matches was not to show that AZ is better than Stockfish. AZ was running on 4000 CPU cores, and Stockfish on your average "weak" CPU. That's an immense advantage for AZ. If both engines were to run on the same hardware, it is predicted that any strong engine would have beaten AZ.
The point of these matches was to show that an AI can achieve incredible feats not brute forcing the game. It goes to show how strong AI's potential is, given a lot of effort and hardware are dedicated to it.
@@cantcatchme6749 Another very important element was that AlphaZero does not need to be developed by people who know how to play chess. Stockfish is developed by and with the help of masters and gm of chess with enormous knowledge of chess theory. You can't just take stockfish, tell him the rules of Go or Poker and ask it to play these instead of chess.
To develop AlphaZero, there is no need for someone actually good at chess helping. Just tell him "Here are the rules of chess, play yourself and git gud mf!" and it just does.
This might be my favourite Gothamchess video of all time, commentary is sublime and pure gold
I keep on coming back
Actually if you skim through various chess channels,you can find they are more or less all sublime in their commentary. We all know what kind of a monster stockfish actually is, so if there was someone to come along that would probably lay that stinky little fish over its knee and paddle his cheeks for a bit... man that would be some kind of quite fascinating ^^
I love how Gotham's commentary gives our new computer chess overlords vibrant personalities, "AlphaZero is an absolute SAVAGE...AlphaZero does not like e4... I'll take your soul!"
Very entertaining overall, also RIP Stockfish.
"Have you ever seen a queen in jail? Well maybe in some other countrys." Gold commedy. Learning Chess and laughing can it get any better? You are the best chess streamer keep it up.
Samay Raina : Hold my beer !
"it's all about suppression" - Gothamchess
Marie Antoinette before she was executed?
2000 rated players be like: NOOOO He got me out of my prep I'm gonna lose!
Me, a 1300: I give my best and try to remember everything Levy told me.
LEVY YOU ARE MORE WORTH THAN THE CHESSBOARD
Us 800s don’t even what prep even is! xD
@@warrant1250 our prep ends with e4 e5 nc3
Well I mean have a chessboard which is worth 3$. And Levy is obv worth more than that
Cant be thrown off your opening if you dont know any openings.
Would love to see AlphaZero beat the crap out of cheaters or pros.
I think you can find games of alpha zero against other professionals. I’m not too sure but I know you can find some games between Magnus and very strong chess engines
Wouldn't that just be like launching all of earth's nukes at like a bug?
@@killmine1235 I mean alpha makes it so that his chances are the same as a cockroach surviving a nuke apocalypse.
The gangster move at 10:30 is the most absolute savagery I've ever seen
5:53 move. Why didn't the queen take the A2 pawn?
@@marinhosantos1929 The war is on the other side and you wanna take a pawn?
Fun fact : When you play like alpha zero, you find all of your moves as blunders because Stockfish is jealous of alpha zero.
@@ShreyAeroSpace ohhh that's why
8:16 "HAVE U EVER SEEN A QUEEN IN JAIL?!"
"Idk Maybe in some countries.."
😂😂😂
Alpha zero is literally my dream playstyle. Extremely aggressive, giving your opponent zero break. But i know even if i get to 2000 elo i will be absolutely destroy if i play like it
my dream playstyle is slowly taking all the pieces, lifelines, moves until they admit defeat
Levy: Alphazero can sacrifice material to take your soul
Me: Bluntly gives away material to save my soul
“You’re not alpha zero at all, you’re a bozo who submitted their game to my guess the ELO series.” LMAOO I’M DEAD 😂
th-cam.com/channels/-ex3ieZJ0T52aFAMNgb4gQ.htmlvideos
The alpha zero engine is just mean. That's all there is to it. It does everything in its power to be a dick to its opponent, and make them suffer. It's awesome.
It’s like Magnus Carlsen, but also good at chess!
Stockfish is like a cold robot mathematically choosing how to kill you while alphazero is like a alien being that surpassed the universe and just wants to cause pain while it destroys you with perfect logic
@@isaacalzate8262 YOU BELIEVE I BLUNDER WHEN IT IS YOU WHO HAS BLUNDERED
I think stockfish sees and simulates the game 10-30 moves ahead. But α⁰ seemingly simulates the game several hundred moves ahead.
@@六工業のカービィ more wrong that ever
Stockfish can see 150k notes on a fricking phone
The way levy described moves of alphazero I'm literally scared of alphazero even though it's a machine and it's just chess game
Well you should coz az has determined all of those moves he probably already determined the way you will before you parents have been born
I got scared even without the description. If stockfish feels like a super smart could guy, alpha zero truly plays like a snake, just lurking and doing things that don't make sense, and when you realize, you're already trapped. That bishop d3 in the third game was so scary, cuz i firstly went "what the fuck? Why" and feel moves later stockfish was already fucked because of the light bishop position.
"I didn't ask AlphaZero it would've gone **Beep Beep Boop Shut Up Gotham**" LMAO
timestamp?
@@shiralea 21:02
Outros of TH-camrs
TH-camr1: Cya next time
TH-camr2: I hope you enjoyed
Gotham:gEt oUT oF hErE!!
Gamechamp3000: Finally, a worthy opponent
Crime Pays But Botany Doesn't: ...
Critical Drinker: go away now!
He sounds like a sports coach
Jesus: that's about it, see ya
10:35 I like how both Levy and I individually laughed our lungs off after Kxd2
That wheeze is solid gold
Same here :D
It's almost like... it's funny
Same here
The queen lock-in is something from another dimension. Absolutely baffling, brutal and ruthless. This game is a gem.
Stockfish: "What the hell is he playing, what kind of move is that"
Alphazero: "Look behind you, CHECK MATE HAHAHA."
give alpha zero or any of these NN engines the personality of Eric Rosen, "oh no my pawn, oh no my knight"
I mean it's more like "Slow, gruelling, and soul-crushing endgame in which your mobility and then material is completely killed" but that wouldn't be as good of a one-liner
@@NormCantoral Exactly.
@@aa01blue38 right.
Everyone: "Don't just give away material."
Alphazero: "Hehe, pawn sac go brrr."
Wouldn’t it be funny if we got Levy to 1 million subs before Hikaru? LETS DO THIS!
YES
th-cam.com/video/UXFOMo4igL8/w-d-xo.html
GODSPEED LEVY
We shouldn't do that, Levy might get copystriked for that and ultimately lose his channel.
@@aleksadamczuk3160 nah hikaru wont even care
It looks to me like AlphaZero is using literal military tactics to win these, defeat in detail, anvil and hammer. Pinning down superior enemy forces with a small part of its own forces so it can go around and smash the enemy in some other place.
Also restricting opponents movements and opportunities. This is literally how a small modern army would deal with a bigger older army.
Sounds very immoral
I mean chess was originally invented in India for preparing better military tactical plans
2:35 That classic Ludwig vs. Hikaru Bot be like:
8:16 Maire Antoinette: I'm in danger
"It's not a fork, it's a whole spoon" 😂
11:28 "absolutely scumbag computer move"
One of the greatest quotes in chess history
Stockfish: I fear no man, but that "thing"... it scares me...
13:13 Well when AlphaZero saw the French Defence it got inspired by two major events in history and went *around* it.
Like the germans went around the maginot line.
They didn't?
👀
@@carboncompounds9377 they went through the Ardennes
I absolutely fucking love this man's energy when talking about chess matches.
Stockfish: "I don't even care, I literally don't care"
Stockfish: chat, chat, i don't care guys, i'm literally an engine with no emotions, i literally don't care, that's just bad sportmanship by Alphazero, but i don't care
Hikaru
@@randomorange6807 yes 😂😂🤣
I love the fact that he is giving computers personalities, like:
"StockFish was too scared and did not take the pawn"
"AlphaZero was like, yeah take my pawn"
Yeah personalizing them made it hilarious
@@psychwolf7590 it was also awesome
Yes alphazero definitely tamed stockfish’s pawns.
Alphazero casually developing his king 💀
This was astonishing. It felt like watching a surgeon dismembering someone.
I can't count how many times gotham said "Loves" in this video
With a capital L
13:51 alpha zero take the king all across the board and promotes it to emperor
amazing how it seems Alphazero pointedly plays for choking off the opp's activity, enhancing it's own rather than burying tactics deep in unclear lines with chances on either side. very original way of cyberplay
Gary Kasparov quote : "Tactics is knowing what to do when there is something to do. Strategy is knowing what to do when there is nothing to do.”
Levy Rozman quote: It went beep beep boop and said shut up Gotham
afaik that's Tartakower's quote
Kasparov can't make that sort of epistemological quotes. He is too thick for those fine stuffs.
P.S. The quote is due to Gerald Abrahams.
Oh my gosh. I was already amazed at how beautiful the first game was but that king move in the second game......that was watching an intelligence completely different than a human grandmaster. Wow. Awesome. Truly awe inspiring.
Creative can play a role in god level ELO
I was part of the Leela dev team, and watched it experiment with openings over and over again. It always ended up with either the Nf3 QG (the NiD equalized too easily) or the Catalan.
Ooh, what was that like? Anything interesting to share, perhaps?