Many Kazakhs fled Soviet Central Asia to escape repression, collectivization, and famine. Some of these Kazakhs sought refuge in regions of China, such as Xinjiang. I dont think that being refugee is invasion. Also Dzungar Khanate that did have a complex relationship with Tibet. And since Dzungar and Kazakh (+ they even hate each other) look alike maybe tibetans were confused them considering the turmoil of Chinese civil conflicts. But nevertheless kazakhs never hated tibetans. Wish you luck 🤞
Please watch the previous volume of this segment for further context. In it, I *explain that the Kazakh exodus from Xinjiang absolutely did not constitute an invasion in its entirety, as there were many women, children, elderly and infirm fleeing genuine persecution.* However, elements (mostly young men) did resort to open warfare, mostly as an act of desperation, but became prominent enough in the region that the Tibetan army at Lhasa and the Chinese nationalist government of Qinghai and Gansu considered them a threat to their power. This is what I aim to shed light upon.
@@eclectic.explorationsdidn't watch the first video, got general opinion based on timestamps. Thank you for making a video about kazakhs and hope you dont hold grudges against kazakhs.
@@trueordrue There is nothing for anybody to hold a grudge about, so no need to mention it. Tibetans and Kazakhs are nomadic Central Asian brothers and sisters with very similar lifestyles. Please see the statement at the beginning of the description: *I want to preface by stating that although certain parts may seem like I am revisiting old conflicts or stirring division, my only intention is to shed light on a fascinating tale in recent history that has been seldom told.*
Many Kazakhs fled Soviet Central Asia to escape repression, collectivization, and famine. Some of these Kazakhs sought refuge in regions of China, such as Xinjiang. I dont think that being refugee is invasion. Also Dzungar Khanate that did have a complex relationship with Tibet. And since Dzungar and Kazakh (+ they even hate each other) look alike maybe tibetans were confused them considering the turmoil of Chinese civil conflicts. But nevertheless kazakhs never hated tibetans. Wish you luck 🤞
Please watch the previous volume of this segment for further context. In it, I *explain that the Kazakh exodus from Xinjiang absolutely did not constitute an invasion in its entirety, as there were many women, children, elderly and infirm fleeing genuine persecution.* However, elements (mostly young men) did resort to open warfare, mostly as an act of desperation, but became prominent enough in the region that the Tibetan army at Lhasa and the Chinese nationalist government of Qinghai and Gansu considered them a threat to their power. This is what I aim to shed light upon.
@@eclectic.explorationsdidn't watch the first video, got general opinion based on timestamps. Thank you for making a video about kazakhs and hope you dont hold grudges against kazakhs.
@@trueordrue There is nothing for anybody to hold a grudge about, so no need to mention it. Tibetans and Kazakhs are nomadic Central Asian brothers and sisters with very similar lifestyles. Please see the statement at the beginning of the description: *I want to preface by stating that although certain parts may seem like I am revisiting old conflicts or stirring division, my only intention is to shed light on a fascinating tale in recent history that has been seldom told.*
Thank you for information
Agree with your rationale and motivation for shedding light on this untold history
Thank You!
Bollywood actor Jackie Shroff's mother was a Kazakh. they escaped to Ladakh around the same time i think. not sure if they came through Tibet tho
They did come through Tibet and her mother was a part of the exodus.
Never heard such violent refugees
Desperate times call for desperate measures.