Debate between Amit Shah and Saugata Roy on J&K Reorganisation (Amendment) Bill, 2023
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ธ.ค. 2023
- Tuesday witnessed a heated debate between Home Minister Amit Shah and TMC MP Saugata Roy over The J&K Reservation (Amendment) Bill & J&K Reorganisation (Amendment) Bill, 2023 which were tabled in Lok Sabha.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our TH-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
![Mirrr x BUS5 - กี่เหตุผล (1000REASONS) [Live Session]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6Ta00hFr2qU/mqdefault.jpg)
What Amit Shah did is 100% the correct step.
Bhakt
@@Marxist215 Chamche
@@Marxist215 Bhakt is better than Corrupt...
First of all its Jammu & kashmir ..... not just kashmir valley...
their are also people of jammu, kargil,leh & ladakh....
when People talk about kashmir why only they talk about kashmiris ??
kashmiris dont represent all state of Jammu & kashmir they belong to 10 districts of Kashmir valley...
why they ignore people of jammu,kargil,leh & ladakh, Gujjars & bakarwals....
@@Marxist215mister bhosade Teri maki sale tum argument nahi kar sakte to bhakt yahi tumhara gandoo
@@Marxist215chamcha
Amit shah seems most patriotic person in BJP. Thats why he is making the hard earn victories for BJP.
First of all its Jammu & kashmir ..... not just kashmir valley...
their are also people of jammu, kargil,leh & ladakh....
when People talk about kashmir why only they talk about kashmiris ??
kashmiris dont represent all state of Jammu & kashmir they belong to 10 districts of Kashmir valley...
why they ignore people of jammu,kargil,leh & ladakh, Gujjars & bakarwals....
Ryte
Joke of the day🤣🤣🤣🤣
Sanjay leela bhansali ko yahi #Mughalput thapoad mara tha tab kaha the vidhwa vilaap krne wale..
Ravi godara aur lawrance ne Ghar me ghuskar goli mari hai ...Both are very brave and Both are real hindu🚩🚩🚩 हिंदू राष्ट्र बनने की शुरुआत हो चुकी है हिंदू राष्ट्र बनाने के लिए जाति को खत्म करना जरूरी है वह मोदी जी वह हम आपके साथ हैं यह मुग़ल पुट आपको वोट नहीं देंगे तो क्या हो गया हम बहुत संख्या में आपको वोट देंगे
Jai Rajputana. Akhand Bharat.
Talwar kabhi pakdi nahi aur aa gaye commentary maarne.
Mr. Sougata Roy should highlight what's happening in his own state of West Bengal.
The bill is about jammu kashmir, not west bengal. They have to do enough conversation about bengal in bengal.
@@mr.ganguly2624West Bengal is another Kashmir for Indian Army
@@mr.ganguly2624 Exactly, the bill is about Jammu and Kashmir and not west Bangladesh. Bongli Bois should be concerned about securing their borders first because your incompetence is costing usefull region of india
@@mr.ganguly2624This Bengalis let Britishers inside India ,
They broke Bengal into 2
And now they want j&k to remove from India ...
Biggest idiots ...
Dada u guys r nly good at literature... And do that nly . Leave country security matters to other ..
@@mathai5456 first its West Bengal, not west Bangladesh, which is a islamic extremist country run by extremist people like you. And border control is under the modi government, whose pettifogger is you. And of course outsider Rohingyas and Bangladeshi extremist are coming in west bengal to ruin India and your papa modi is failing to stop them.
That's why people voted BJP
Yes unemployed radicals do vote BJP.
@@subhrajitgupta5535 what is unemployment rate in WB and Kerala?
@@subhrajitgupta5535bro you dropped your this 🧠
Kya j&k ko India me shamil na kare ?? Congress to nhi kar paaye but bjp ne Kiya uspe bhi oppose kar rhe h , jo log(congress) India ke naa ho sakte h unko vote de kya , anti national ban chuki h congress party, 80% Hindus ko chhod ke 20% Muslims ko appease karna h waqf board Lana h ,minorities to shikhs Jain's Buddhists Christians h unko do , woh waqf board silently logo ki zameen hadaf rha h uska kya , Desh ko khatam karne ki baat sochti h congress, aur congress ko vote de kya hum??
@@subhrajitgupta5535How much investment is coming in jihadi bengal
We, bengalees are happy when we see TMC is being insulted in national level 😊😊😊😊
ABSOLUTELY 💯 VERY VERY VERY HAPPY 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 OLD PSYCHO MAN
Chawanni leke Bhesh badalne wale😅😅😅
He’s not talking for Bengal😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@AM-jr9lglike u talking about Bangladesh 😂😂😂
@@karanraj9237 😃😄😄😁😆🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 IOB 😄😀😀😁😆
Only Modi No Compromise against traitors
Sanjay leela bhansali ko yahi #Mughalput thapoad mara tha tab kaha the vidhwa vilaap krne wale..
Ravi godara aur lawrance ne Ghar me ghuskar goli mari hai ...Both are very brave and Both are real hindu🚩🚩🚩 हिंदू राष्ट्र बनने की शुरुआत हो चुकी है हिंदू राष्ट्र बनाने के लिए जाति को खत्म करना जरूरी है वह मोदी जी वह हम आपके साथ हैं यह मुग़ल पुट आपको वोट नहीं देंगे तो क्या हो गया हम बहुत संख्या में आपको वोट देंगे
@@StopEmptyBoastingSuch a naive , India is democratic cause one community is majority.
TMC is following the Congress route.
Tmc was formed by splitting from congress
more dangerous than congress
TMC is far worse than INC... INC was fairly competent national party for most of its history and even gave us great leaders like Indira, nehru and narsimha rao, whereas TMC literally been enabling separatism in Bengal and have used the border to demographically alter Bengal's vote base.
Ladak is very much happy with ut status. Kashmir mai jab tak terrorist katam nahi hota tab tak president rule hona chahiye.
First of all its Jammu & kashmir ..... not just kashmir valley...
their are also people of jammu, kargil,leh & ladakh....
when People talk about kashmir why only they talk about kashmiris ??
kashmiris dont represent all state of Jammu & kashmir they belong to 10 districts of Kashmir valley...
why they ignore people of jammu,kargil,leh & ladakh, Gujjars & bakarwals,kashmiri pandits....
Ye Aisa he ki tu keh raha hai. Ki jab tak tumhara DNA test na karwaya Jaye tab tak tum ko ham sab harami he kehenge 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
TMC has lost the plot in Indian national integrity context. Its time to vote them out in Loksabha election please
A voter from Coochbehar
Seriously What's wrong with TMC??
@@shubhojeetinspires what's right?
আমাদের দুর্ভাগ্য বাংলায় আজ দেশদ্রোহীদের রাজ
@@shubhojeetinspirestmc ek gali ban chuki h
Irrespective of what you say, illegal migrants from neighbouring has been promised of Indian citizenship and they promised vote to TMC and Bengalis being divided in all frame and structure will never vote this party out as they help to maintain the division. Mostly they stand against the unity country that's why they keep emphasis the power to Faruk and Mehbooba sponsored by Pakistan.
Most educated youth of WB have to travel beyond their state to have a job. Industry is non-existent in WB.Job of teachers in government schools even colleges have been sold to highest bidders of illicit money to education minister and other ministers, and he is worried about Kashmiri youth.
You should ask Mamta di…she completely sold out WB
Setwi to bhai nijer pocket phutk ache seita na dekhe bolche dada apnar botam khola
Dada chadar hatalae koti koti Taka 😂
That's why we want Congress mukt bharat ❤❤
Tmc mukt also
Idiot He is TMC Mp not congress
Once Bengal minds are pride .. now it's a curse to india .
Sad truth
Bro Bengal not the political party is the curse for BENGALIS, POLITICAL PARTYS DIVIDED BENGAL INTO MANY PART LIKE BIHAR ODISHA ASSAM TRIPURA , CHHATTISGARH, & HOLE NORTH EAST WAS PART OF BENGAL.
Modi is a panauti a curse.
It was also first time in the history that the non Muslim citizens of an Indian state were forced to flee by the fundamentalist Muslims of that state. Extraordinary action is required in extraordinary situation. This is simple common sense. Anyone unable to understand is actuality not fit to represent the people of this country.
First time??😂😂
Bhai history padho thoda 🙏
Its was the 7th genocide of Kashmiri Hindu Pandits and it was a full and final nail in the wall
Moplah and Naokhali are saying Hi
What about fundamentust hidus like modi and amit shah. The evil twins.
Well said Mr. HOME Minister
Dada umer ho gye h... Epic line😅😅😅
No wonder by West Bengal is so doomed 😂😂
Well said Anurag Thakur... he said the truth...
What is the 60 yrs of Congress done..??
@mohank941
Keep india poor ,make sure thst everyine depends on the state to rule them
BHAI CHAMCHO KO POOCHO BTA DENGE
they did nothing
kept us poor
kill the actual secularism
Has he lost all his senses? I feel ashamed to call him a fellow Bengali.
So far after abrogation of 370 I trust this governments fully integrate to India
Chor TMC. Wrong data given to us make fool.
No Vote to Mamata .
Vote for youth's job.
Sugata Roy sathiya gaya hai.
Being tutored by this bloddy fellow whose 3 generations enjoyed J&K as CMs and brought Kashmir to the brink.
Amit shah just spoke 2 lines and made final statements that's it ✌️
It's not Pakistan occupied Kashmir or Indian occupied Kashmir. It's MOK( Muslim occupied Kashmir).
How exactly did Muslims occupy Kashmir?
Just like how they're now occupying many areas across India, especially in Kerala, West Bengal and Assam .
Kashmir is Muslim and will be muslim always , you Brahmins were the one who occupied India and made the indigenous populations your slaves . Hinduism was brought to India by foreign Brahmins .
Now because of congress Karnataka no Development our tax money siddramull cm want give money ther brothers racal fellow
Kashmir is much peaceful, developing fast. Walk around Lal chowk and see for yourself old man. No more shut downs. Business is booming.
Bengalis have lost it
Truly a crazy fall. Unreal.
Stupid.17 seats given to bjp last election where more than 30% never vote for bjp. 5 to 77 in assembly election. If bengal has lost it do Kerala, tamilnadu Punjab even telengana is winning it for bjp. Don't mess up chances by calling entire population. You are absolutely boka chele
Ye budda ko 370 se pehle kon sa peace dekai deta ta? Inn jaise logon ka intellegent brain ko tarif karna hoga.😂😂
Prof. Roy , there is always a first time, that should be known by you at your age.
Discard these thiefs in disguise of AITC.
Dada noi Dadu আপনার অত্যধিক বয়স হয়েছে। এবার পদটা ছাড়ুন ।
People of bengal support BJP decision Abrogration of article 370. J&K are an integral and inseparable part of India. Under the leadership of PM Modi ji, G20 meeting gave new sight of Kashmir. Massive development work is going on in Kashmir.
Then why defeat bjp in 2021
@@aatmanshah8011 BJP is new party in Bengal.. and 2021 was not defeat for BJP, they increased their seats from 3 MLA to 77 MLA with 38% Vote Share 😂 where 35 years ruling Party CPIM became 0
cause the BJP in Bengal is basically the TMC only@@aatmanshah8011
Who is Suvendu if not a TMC lapdog?
@@somjitchakrabarty3145 but didn't he become giant slayer by defeating mamata....do check suvendu n himanta biswa show talent n get space in bjp....n both have given interviews to india today mentioning their association with rss n ram temple agitation
@@somjitchakrabarty3145 also now revanth reddy telangana cm has abvp background
Saugata Roy has gone senile and delusional. What's he trying to say?
The last phrase of "or humne kar bhi dia"
The sheer areogace, I love it 😂😂
People of India know what BJP is doing in Kashmir for the good of India. And Mr Roy need not teach them. Go back to Kolkata and rest for the rest of your life Mr. Roy
Sougata Roy trying to do everything to appease his vote bank.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Mr. Sougata Roy has
lost his mental equilibrium nowadays.
HM Amit Shah 🔥18:56
Words of Amit Shah shows that BJP are genuinely invested in the well being of this country... Congress on the other hand just want to win the argument whatever it takes even if it means splitting the country in half!!!
Congress is questioning about investment, employement, development etc in Kashmir... but did they even bother about Kashmir in the last 70 years when they were in power? And how Congress just ignored this complicated state How the State and the youth there were living in state of emergency from last 70 years because Congress did not have the guts to take a strong decision like Abrogation of Article 370 fearing Pakistan and international pressure!!
The power hungry opposition will not hesitate to sell out the whole of India
they already sold lands to china even after 62
Is mr Roy smoking something?
Salute to Amit shah ji❤🎉
Kashmir is in a much better shape compared to what it was. The no nonsense approach to JnK is what we need. TMC should concentrate on improving bengal and not do cheap stunts at a national level
How can a sane sensible educated indian reject the idea of one nation, one law, one constitution, one election, one flag etc.
Mad fellow
"Duality is not a story.
Duality is just a
complexity."
- Edward Norton.
Buddha satiya Gaya he Amit Shaha ji ne bahut accha rpl diya 😂😂
Amit Shah Rocks
🤟
Saugata da....talk about West Bengal issues. What has changed after CPM ousted....
1. Gundaraj... at peak
2. Corruption...at peak
3. Ministers....in jail
4. Post poll killing.
.highest in India
5. Cultural capital....dead
6. Benhali pride...demolished as everyone now thinks that all Bengalis are chor.
7. Industry....nothing
8. Tustikaran of Bangladeshi and Myanmar Muslims....highest level....
List goes on.
Parliament should have dedicated session day on West Bengal situation..
Sorry, forgot, Mohua takes money to ask question in Parliament.
Exactly pal.
Just want to ask Mr. the so-called professor, how many factories have been inaugurated into the state of West Bengal, and the question was asked on behalf of an MP, who asked voters to vote for her so that they can see her in their locality in place of film.
this guy is not a professor, he is an abomination.
There could be local body elections which will bring in grassroot democracy. As for sovereign matters are concerned regarding the UT of Kashmir, there shall be no compromise. State elections can wait atleast for 2 decades. The nation must be vigilant that Bengal wouldn't drift and become another Kashmir.
She is the worst dectetor INDIA has seen.He should be shameful to have a worst CM.
There should not be any election in kashmir but President rule
This is why Amit is known as Chanakya ❤ of present India 🇮🇳
When Lion Roars in then end , dogs stop barking 😢
Please send Saugata Roy and his family to live there... let's see what his family has to say... after living there for 3 years.. I mean, he should try to look for volunteers from his extended families as well.
Amit shah is most brutal politician i have ever seen.....his use of words is impeccable
Hat's off Mr Amit Shah...❤
Unemployment rate got raised after abrogation of article 370.
I think Roy should physically travel to JK and see the developments under BJP
We want congress mukt bharat
It felt like listening to an MP from Karachi
Saugata Roy is an aging fleet of TMC Airways & he should be grounded, otherwise passengers ( read nations) safety will be at high risk 😂
TMC leader Shri Abhishek Banerjee said that old leaders of the party should retire.
What is wrong with Bengalis?
Those who once used to give persons like Subhash Chandra Bose to the country who lead the whole country are now giving such parasites.
You better retire .You cannot think straight and. understand meaning of abolition of 370 . Think for united India .
The TMC gang has completely destroyed WB! Now this senile Saugata Ray wants to add J & K TMC's machinations !
Sougata Roy is from Dum Dum constituency and but Dum Dum takes a very different meaning next to his name.
I was playing it at 1.5x speed. Sougata da's speech still seemed painfully slow.
This guy Mr. Roy is a traitor. Neglect him
@@badmanshortsPM with illegal voters
@@badmanshortsdon’t divide people here. Stay united
Most probably it was the last political speech of the Communist Party of India...but we r living in BHARAT... RIP for hypocrits soCPI
Jai ho Amit Shah....
How did he even qualify to be a Professor?
Why they speak so slow ? Ask them to only read important points - both opposition and especially BJP MPs - take so much time 😢
Anurag thakurs speech gave me chills🔥
Yar unko to actor hona chiye tha hes so good looking yar😊
পচিমবঙ্গ এর অবস্থা নিয়ে শুনতে চাই......
Absolutely right Sir... so called leaders like Saugata Roy should be dealt more firmly...
With force.
The home minister is not correct steap.
Burhouu ko accha dhobi patkaa mila 😂
This serppent of mamta is shedding crocodile's tear for Kashmiri Pandits ,!!!!!
Soughata Babu should resign immediately resign due to his age and nonsense.
Very sad to see these kind old stalwarts in our parliament never tried to solve Pakistani problem in JK. New HM atleast tried to annex JK with India. Shame on this politicians and those voters must recognize and never vote him.
This is shame for the people of West Bengal that we supply highest number of labours to other states. Because there is no job in West Bengal 😮
This government is not correct steap , and miss guide all people.
Such a horrible people.. such a waste opposition’s
Prof Roy lives in south Kolkata... The law and order is so bad that 2 houses away from his house 2 building syndicate goons faught with each other over who will supply construction meterial and bullets were fired.
25 meter from his house on the opposite foothpath a Jamtara style call centre was looting people of their money till one of the employees defected due to rivelary.
Prof Roy should focus on the law and order in his home state specially his own area. J&K is too over the top for him. There are professionals handling J&K
Name those guys
Name those guys? As if i hang out with building syndicate goons.
What about in West Bengal?
In many places of West Bengal Students cannot sing National Anthem in the school, cannot organise Saraswati Puja, even cannot celebrate Independence Day and hoist National Flag.
How many employment have been given in last 13 years.
Not only Bangalis ( MP Shatabdi Roy also) are going to Kashmir as a tourist, Bangalis are also going there for job also as migrant labourers.
First make elections in West Bengal Violence free, rigging free without central force.
Any update on Mahua Moitra Suspension Bill tabled or not?
Saugata babu please talk with some sense . Abolition of 370 is a right decision by Amit Shah . Do you love India ?
Should debate and provide public report upon unemployment, malnutrition, and poverty first since 9yrs governance
This debate should unsettle Pakistan and the terrorists. The beauty of it is that it is a healthy debate in the true spirit of a vibrant democracy. As long as democracy remains vibrant, there will be no need to use force to bring back PoK into India.
I don't understand why the Speaker intervened? Why did he wish to be a participant n not a moderator?
Nationalist Amit shah 🔥
Jammu Kashmiri is not just Kashmiris ok there are Hindu Dogras, Muslim Dogras, Gujjars, Bakarwals, Kashmiri pandits, Kashmiri sikhs, Ladakhi budhist, Kashmiri Shia' muslims, Kargili shias, Shinas, Baltis etc so don't paint J & K as one identity
How he asking question about unemployment?
Mr Roy first see your Bengal how you are exploiting small business, education system.
Day by day youth of Bengal going out from your state.
Dnt teach about democracy.
Probabaly he is dreaming of spoiling JK .
No one dared to talk on kashmir since last 75 yrs the way they are asking questions today.... how on the earth they can't see the good changes in kashmi
Just looked at Birla ji 😅
They never answered the legitimate questions he asked though
There cannot be overnight treatment of a cancer in the name of J&K. What is the status of employment in WB where few lakhs posts are vacant ans abolished.
Calling Farooq Abdullah a nationalist 😂😂😂... Sougata roy what does he smoke 😂😂😂