100 Years Of RSS: Why Golwalkar Endures | India Today Conclave Mumbai
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 ต.ค. 2023
- Former professor Shamsul Islam questioned the claim that the RSS was not India's biggest cultural organisation, asking if they even maintained a membership record. He said that Golwalkar's ideas were "dangerous".
#IndiaTodayConclave23 #IndiaTodayConclave #Conclave2023 #ConclaveMumbai2023 #mumbai #indiatoday #conclave #conclaveMumbai23 #rss #SadashivraoGolwalkar #ShamsulIslam
Subscribe to India Today for NEW VIDEOS EVERY DAY and make sure to enable Push Notifications so you'll never miss a new video.
All you need to do is PRESS THE BELL ICON next to the Subscribe button!
India Today TV is India's leading English News Channel. India Today TH-cam channel offers latest news videos on Politics, Business, Cricket, Bollywood, Lifestyle, Auto, Technology, Travel, Entertainment and a lot more.
Stay tuned for latest updates and in-depth analysis of news from India and around the world!
Download App: indiatoday.link/wHaj
Follow us: Official website: www.indiatoday.in/
Twitter: / indiatoday
Facebook: / indiatoday
WhatsApp Channel: bit.ly/48EhNV8
Vikram Sampath brings sanity. Rajdeep is just happy lighting fires forgetting that perhaps this shouldn't be conducted like a TV debate.
It is said that his Rajdeep sardesai 's family member has fallen into jihadi trap?? 😅
😂😂😂
Shamsul Islam displayed hatred against Sanatan Dharma, which every Muslim on Rajdeep programme does
Sir this R sardesai 's brother in law is a jihadi trapper? That is why he is under jihadi control😅?
Islam is hate.
Shamsul Islam is dripping with hate and anatogonism! No pretence in being cogent, balanced and understanding!
Very well articulated Vikram Sampath. Much respect.
RSS is not a political party. It’s a party of honour and discipline. RSS is always the first society to come in front and help in any type of natural disaster or calamity . It teaches you to be down to earth and nationalism. Long live the principles of RSS❤
It was very clear in this conclave that the hindu speakers were trying to find a balance between extreme thoughts and liberal views of golwalker,but shamshul islam was trying his best to clearly drive a wedge not only between various sections of hindu community but between religions showing his frustration towards RSS and Hindus, no doubt he and his community has remained frustrated lot as citizen of this great democratic country.
Maybe be he is saying truth jaishankar telling lie in us that there is no minority killing in India
Think of what ALL the Muslim majority countries are doing to minorities carefully before you comment. Bharat’s treatment of minorities is fair and square.
@@gauravdey4163 Maybe read a little more rather than listen to TH-cam. Maybe you'll be able to make up your own opinion. Also, while reading try to get better at English as it is pathetic presently.
The race seemed to be between Rajdip and Shamsul Islam, as to who was more anti RSS and anti Guruji. 😂
same shit different smell 😂
U mean Shameful Islam?
India Today has hired Rajdeep just for anti Modi agenda
@@pinakinpatel5796 bjp =bideshi jismfaroshi parijivi party
@@Ranveersinghkohli1203 Anand rangasiyar
vikram sampath!!!!! what an amazing person!!
Vikram is brilliant as always! Sudhindra Kulkarni is also good here.
When Rajdeep asks RSS do they own or disown guruji due to hindu rastra view. I have question for Rajdeep and congress. Do they own or disown Rajeev Gandhi for sikh massacre? Where more than 7000 died?? Cant you call him butcher of sikh's??
RSS man was also involved in that
@@gauravdey4163 I am not aware, and I can't comment on it. But when PM say's when large tree falls, earth will shake, instead of condemning it. that shows how deep his involvement in the riots.
@@gauravdey4163as far as I know it was BJP and RSS who went around saving Sikhs and there are numerous article around it. Even when BJP came to power for first time they brought Akali with them in center to provide learship in Punjab.
@@gauravdey4163 Congratulations! You are now eligible for PHD in delusion from Whatsapp university. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@gauravdey4163 Evidence?
RSS needs to grow globally as bharat take its rightful place in global affairs
😂
Hahaha it's about to get banned soon....the West equates it with ISIS noob
no thanks as they have already done enough damage destroying Hindus and turning them into total wimps and cowards.
@@RohitPatil-fw5nq don't make yourself look like a joker
Rsss pride of bharat they are real sanatanis
Conclave discussing RSS without any RSS representative????? Who are all these????RSS is Bharat for next 100 years.
RSS needs to modernise and connect sanathan dharma in today’s context and be more assertive
Real sanatan is Ambedkar Dravidian
@@gauravdey4163 Hey look what the "real" 'Sanathan" said about Vedas
BR AMBEDKAR
The Vedas are a worthless set of books. There is no reason either to call them sacred or infallible. Nobody has had the courage to ask why these worthless books which contain nothing but invocation to tribal gods to destroy the enemies, loot their property and give it to their followers, have been made sacred and infallible.
Also look what eminent quantum physicists said about Vedas
Albert Einstein ``Whenever I read Bhagavad Gita, everything else seems superfluous. I've made Vedas as the guide for the formation of my theories and scientific investigation"
Werner Heisenberg _ (One of the pioneers in the field of quantum mechanics) - "Quantum ideas which seemed so crazy made sense only after reading hindu/vedic metaphysics"
ERWIN SCHRODINGER (ONE OF THE FOUNDING FATHERS OF QUANTUM MECHANICS) Schrodinger's biographer Moore, wrote -- “His system - or that of the Upanishads/Vedas - is delightful and consistent: the self and the world are one and they are all. He rejected traditional western religious beliefs (Jewish, Christian, and Islamic) not on the basis of any reasoned argument, nor even with an expression of emotional antipathy, for he loved to use religious expressions and metaphors, but simply by saying that they are naïve--and will NOT understand Quantum theory and consciousness.
Now, you know what your 'real sanathan" is worth. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@gauravdey4163lol Dravidian is Christian country ideology they all need to be smashed Ambedkar was against this Dravidian shit.
@@gauravdey4163 This is false and you know it. Ambedkar became a Buddhist or actually created a branch of it before passing away.
Divisive , degraded ideologies cannot be modernized, they must be dumped
RSS - Pride of Bharat ❤
On what purpose???
What are their contribution to build our country????
@@sadhirshasalim366 First Read about Jungle Satyagraha and Liberation of Goa
And If you are netizens than read about 2013 Uttrakhand Floods and role of RSS
Their alots bro
@@SauravKumar-gs5tk almost all non government organizations do these type of relief works & annexation of Goa is carried out by our Indian army not by RSS.
bro I asked what is their role in nation building ???
They formed in 1924 & what are the contributions they given to our nation till now ????
@@sadhirshasalim366 Bro
I hope you are not getting information from WhatsApp University
See how Goa was liberated and role of RSS
Role of RSS in 1962 war and Nehru inviting RSS for 26 Jan 1963 Parade
Search History
And as a Hindu I can say Modi has done much more for Muslim Upliftment but almost none for Hindus
@@sadhirshasalim366 I am guessing you are Congress Supporter and even if Not
In past 75+ years of India Independence Congress ruled for 60+ years but According to Sachhar Committee they are most Backwards
Why?
Rss is very much needed for Bharat...♥️🚩
I admire SD and VS,both are great speakers
Bicasuse you are a boot licker of RSS we have Subash Bose
@@gauravdey4163 You are a boot licker of pappu and italy bar dancer
Ambedkar in one of his later interviews to a British journalist said he doesn’t believe Indian democracy will survive much long. So what does this crazy man named whatever Islam have to say to that? Also what does this crazy man have to say about his views on Islam?
He told about RSS also
@@gauravdey4163what he said
The basic fabric of Bharat is pluralistic , if any theology or ideology won’t synch with this basic fabric of Bharat it can be considered as working against the Bharat’s basic ethos, maybe this could be in the golwarkar’s mind . But RSS has grown big and it’s time for the leaders of RSS to think globally and shed its Bharat centric attitude “vasudaiva kudumbugam”🙏🙏🙏
so which religion's teaching to present day is directly opposite to vasudhaiva kutumbakam, isn't it islam?
Sudheendra Kulkarni Ji and Vikram Sampath, both are exceptional thinkers. I certainly agree with Sudheendra when he said, we must unite everybody on every fault lines we have. Comments of people like Stalin are anti-Hindu and anti-Nation as well. This is an era for India’s growth, no internal or external enemy must pose a threat to it.
It’s just amazing that none of the panelist have every attended rss shakha continuously in their childhood 🙄
One learns the practical meaning of unity in diversity (caste, creed etc never matter) in daily rss shaakha
The meaning of Hindu is who all consider themselves as part of the ancient civilization that is Bharat. No rules or qualifiers of belief in god or no belief in god are required.
No I'm a admirer of Guruji Golwalkar
people of Bharat should right articles about how evil is communism and how people like Kulkarni destroyed India. How India was destroyed by these evils of our society.
So you will dictate them what to write and topic? vow super
Forget about their opinion, nationalist Indians should ignore their existence. Stop debating or having conversations with this kind of individuals. Ignore them completely, they will never change.
Communists are more troubled by Guruji
CPM is the only party in India, which has reserved a Brahmin as the All India General Secretary,the No 1 post of the communist party . You can watch the list of their All India GS and believe yourself
Vikram is just absolutely brillant!
He is a propoganda machine
@@gauravdey4163bullshit. Refute him on fact. Prejudiced uncultivated mind
We must believe in our Constitution 😊
Golwalker was referring to the religous conversion. Swami Vivekananda also had the same view
What Guruji said....YES WE AGREE....Indian Constitution took everything from different countries.....BUT NOTHING FROM OUR OWN HERITAGE....THAT IS BIG LACUNAE
So much to learn from this debate .
Vikram Sampath ‘s hatred for Gandhi is so visible .
Mr . Vikram ,
Gandhi is like an ocean it depends on us whether in that ocean we search for precious pearls of wisdom OR fowl fishes .
Guruji Golwalkar should be worshipped by every Hindu now especially now …
Shamsul Islam please understand that varna has nothing to do with caste,
Let Islam talk about castes in muslim religion.
Poor fellow! He is just pedalling old, out of date and useless ideas. That there are no takers for his viewpoint shows in his aggressive behaviour, impatience and vehemence!
Param Pujya Doctorsaheb gave us a concept, Param Pujya Guruji gave us the philosophy to back up the concept and Param Pujya Balasahebji gave us a system called Sangh Pariwar to carry it out and now we are building on those three pillars set up by these three tall leaders.
Extreme hypocrisy at display ...Gandhi saying i will not salute tiranga without charkha silence.... Golwalkars positive views to kushwant singh on muslims .... pin drop silence 😂
everywhere pissful community wants to throw stones 😅
RSS is awakening the concept of Life. Rest all is absurd.
Rss is like Muslim League of Pakistan
ഹര ഹര. We need more from RSS.♥️
Beauty....of journalism🙏🙏🙏
100 years of RSS and no photos of Hegdewar ji? And there were/are other sangh chalaks too. Organizers of the event also didnt try to understand RSS
It's the RSS and several of it's sister organisations which hold Bharat together and making the country stronger and stronger
A civilization built over 5 millennium, destroyed in 100 years. Great job 😮
What is that description?
Very interesting debate.
very nice moderation from rajdeep ❤
I am worried that we have prof such as Prof Islam , god knows what venom they are spewing.
Very Very interested debate
Fine🎉
Much more respect for Vikram Sampat ji❤
Understanding the sangh is beyond normal people. Swamsevaks are sure and decisive on how they can serve India & patriotic Indians. It will continue to thrive and grow
Hindi Hindu Hindustan nothing else
@gauravdey4163 there you go! It's not either Hindu Hindi or Hindustan. A true Indian shud be able to grow abv all these distractions.
Just live with humanity. A small word to stay happy
Vikram takes the cake. Talks sense. Rest are mere contributors
Actually Rajdeep Sir likes the Anti- BJP & Anti -RSS views so much that he doesn't want views of his opponents to be said continuously,,, that's the reason of 30 seconds time bound to anyone...
This panelist’s are here to TALK ABOUT 100 YEARS STICK TO THE POINT 🙏🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳🙏 28:48 JAI BHARATHIYA 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Can't this prof. Islam behave like a civilized man 🙄🙄🙄
Let Shamsul talk about Muslim league who got the partition of the country done. The Muslims staying in India is pro Pakistan and getting the appeasement politics work.
Let the muslim show papers else get out to Pakistan.
Vandemataram friends
India to day and invited panel are eligible Meritoriously to discuss the business of devoted selfless sons of motherland?
🇮🇳भारत भारतीय तनमन जिवनसे जुडो मातृभूमीसे🙏 जा ग ते र हो वंदे मातरम्🇮🇳
Very simple
We have invaders came to takeover Bharat and entirely through violence
Brahims and killed
Brahims women and children and others Hindus leaders
There was no fair play
RSS saved Bharat and Hinduism.
Muslim invaders did walk in preaching peace..
So RSS should play and important part in our lives.
RSS cant even save themselves so what nonsense are you refering to ? The RSS never saved Bharat or Hinduism but it was because of warriors like Shivaji and others. Its because of the RSS in the last 100 years the Hindus ended up being total cowards and wimps like Sita Ram Goel said
"The RSS is the biggest collection of duffers that ever came together in world history":
India Today has hired Rajdeep just to do some anti Bjp narrative
What Sharad pawar is doing in this debate 😂😂😅😅
વંદે ભારત માતરમ્.
The channel should have avoided an anchor like Rajdeep for any subject of high sanctity…..a blind leftist can’t discuss, worse moderate, a subject like RSS.
Only Golwalkar needs context... others did what they did in the past because they were pure evil!
Rajdeep mastered the art of pushing his words in people’s mouth.
Why joker like Rajdeep is here! 😂
Why is Swapan Dasgupta using a western metaphor of 'ogre' and 'Santa Claus' for a hindutva icon?
He was so right about muslims and communists - amazing....
Sir first simple question to you is,why there is a single panelist from rss while discussing their history of 100years of their journey.that shows your channel and it's intentions .
Rajdeep has to learn nuanced journalism. He is a polarised journalist in today's parlance. Vikram Sampath has summed it well. Swapan Dasgupta is eloquent and polished . Kulkarni is balanced and treads carefully. I can understand Islam where he is coming from, but he has to be rest assured that muslims have contributed well to India's well being. There are pockets of distress and healing is the only way out.
Vikram Sampath ❤
If Article 371(A) is not removed from nagaland then very soon the hindus n muslim in nagaland will leave nagaland
अभिनेता हैं ये लोग इनमें से कोई शाखा में नहीं जाता। ये क्या विश्लेषण करेंगे।
That Islam fellow is making strawman arguments with zero depth and substance!
he is a average leftie... just shouting...
देशवासियों की रक्षा में rss सदा संलग्न रहा।भारत में भारतीयों को जीवित रखने वाली संस्था है राष्ट्रीय स्वयं सेवक दल।इनके महान कार्यो पर नतमस्तक हम
Congratulations from Israel
🇮🇱❤🇮🇳 Good luck in our common fight against radical Islamic terrorism and Christian missionaries!
100 years of Cahddin😂😂😂
People are created by God equally. And he gave everything freely to human beings to survive.
But after some time some people started dividing people for their benefits and beliefs. Where equality gone.
After that people thought of equality must be there for survival of human beings.
So democracy came in.
All thoughts of people which donot give equal rights to the people are against the humanity and God's will.
So in democracy we can feel and find God's will and humanity.
Ramesh Bhiduri’s Favourites hate RSS to the core and Cite numerous reasons to be one…😂😂😂😂 , they just hate it and reasons follow
Rajdeep, why do you unnecessary interrupt people while they speak.
believe me its just start after 100 year .
What Else Could We Expect From Respected Professor Shamshul Islam. It Would Be Surprising If He Praises An Organisation Like Rashtreeya Swayam Sevak Sangh
By setting up a narrative that there are many questions that are not raised in public, host has either shown his ignorance or raised a bogey of dark organization for RSS!
This Shuffer Islam guy has completely missed what Guru Golvalkar wanted to say. Cross breeding always creates superior human beings. This is proved from Human Civilization homo sepians and Neanderthals cross breeding etc. This has nothing to do with inferior than Northern Bramhins . It is about how genes take shape and brings best part from different streams. We all know what is happening in some of the interbreeding societies there are many youtube videos you can search. This Shuffer himself is well learned to know that from his own community where cousins can marry. His main motive was to divide everybody and poison the minds of muslims. He had no answer to Surprisingly stance on Sudhendra Kulkarni who talked about how Guru Golavalkar wanted Harmony and how he was against uniform civil code . This talk was surprisingly enlightening and against Rajdeep's will he was taken aback and shocked by Kulkarni's(especially becuase this Kulkarni is brother of Ketkar and Kuber and Khandekar and Vagle If I may LOL) reply. in Hinduism still Gotra ie what Sage you origenated from , Nadi that is some kind of stream is always checked in arranged marriage to make sure they are not interbreeding. This was ancient knowledge which was lost in Islamic invaders when the burned Nalanda and Takshsheela . Remember Chanakya was Bramhin and Chandragupta was not. Now do not say there is no proof Chandragupta was not groomed by Chanakya just like there is fashion now a days that Ch Shivaji Maharaj did not learn from anything from Samarth Ramdaas Swami just because he was Bramihin.
Vikram sampath is brilliant!!
Professor Islam must also speak about divide in in Islam between man and woman. Every individuals thinking evolves by the time. During 1947/49 there was alot going on. But later most of things were settled down.
I'm expecting Rajdeep to do some verbal diarrhoea... let's see if I'm right.
Shamsul Islam asked "Has the RSS ever criticized Guru Golwalkar for his ideas about the Muslims?" The correct counter question would have been 'Have the Muslims ever criticized Muhammad for marrying his adopted son's wife; an obnoxious act that undermines the very concept of adoption?'
Have the hindus ever criticized brahma to marry his own daughter saraswati ? Have ever criticized krishan to did raas leela with 16108 ?plz reply this if u people have guts
@@khurshidahmed5052 these characters are mythical. And there is no such injunction in the scriptures which say that we have to follow each and everything they did. For me, Krishna the politician is far more interesting a case-study than Krishna the godhead. As for Brahma, I simply don't care what the hell he did. He is certainly not my creator as I am a product of 'evolution'. There is nothing as 'words cast in stone' in our scriptures. We have the right to pick and choose as per our convenience. I hope that answers your question. But it’s good to see that you couldn’t deny the point I made about Muhammad as you yourself know that I was refering directly to Qur'an 33:37. And following the example of the prophet is a religious injunction for the Muslims.
@@khurshidahmed5052 and one more thing. Krishna did Raas Leela with his 'gopinis', he had 16000 'patnis', not 'ardhanginis' (call them wives, if you so like) and he had 108 names. You mixed it all up.
Can someone ask the commies in this debate (host included) if they reject Gangadhar Adhikari's proposal?
The thumbnail has wrong image of Dr. Sudheendra Kulkarni
Dr Islam seems to be well prepared for the discussion, also talking more about what he said and wrote while Rajdeep seems to be missing the Moderator skills and the other panelists are making lame points and not related to the discussion.
Anchor just ignite fire.
Why Hitler endurs
Manusmriti is far advanced and fair document compared to Abrahamic concepts minus the propaganda
@RajdeepSardesai52 You should give your position as the moderator to someone else and sit amongst the panelists!!!
You will be far effective as a panelist rather than as a moderator
Swapan da should take retirement now
No Individual can be 100% accepted, such losers like Kulkarni and the Prof on the panel. If People read Gandhi in totality it will be cringe.
India today , you should have more relevant discussions and not something that has happened pre independence...
Where did this sampath joker appear out of nowhere..he definitely has been planted
Secular sir let’s talk about your ideological father sir Syed who started two nations theory
Mr Islam....When M divided n snatched broke India....based on religion n again u want special pampering in India toooo....y shud H always be at receiving end...all the butchering, all violence etc etc
How can a biased person compere a program like this. How long can these spokespersons of different ideologies and hatred for others continue to put on neutral journo hats
Kalkarne please keep ur thoughts to ur self
RAM NOT SANTACLAUS...