Due to quantum physics there is a change in everyone’s mind including [REDACTED] and Yugoslavia takes control of the entire world with 100% stability and a loyal army and population
@@Iniquitous1that history is what you rejected as a society and country. You don't get to claim it when a figure like Paanini is forgotten but celebrated in India.
Trust me when I say this, all Indians and Pakistanis will agree with the fact that the best timeline for their nation would be that they best the the other one in every cricket match they have played.
It was close actually,in 1962 Pakistan sent diplomats to India regarding "the northern threat", as they were west aligned they were fearfull of a larger Communist state,but these were rejected by india
not very unrealistic, it would be more unrealistic for afghanistani government and pakistan to work together against any one than that, afghan republic hated the durand line and thus pakistan and every afghan gov since has the exact same view, if kashmir didn't become an issue pakistan and india would most likely coexist with similar relations of greece and trukey, but especially when muslims or hindus are persecuted then tensions would rise
The country's "What if everything went perfect for..." I really want to see is Italy's for plenty of reasons. Italy had many lost opportunietes of unifying earlier (in modern era it's the First War of Italian indipendence in 1848 but the revolt in Hungary was repressed and other italian states stopped supporting Savoy) and creating a decent colonial empire (Tunisia being taken before France, Giovanni Cerruti's proget in New Guinea going well and Italy winning against Ethiopia in the first Italo-Ethiopian war, buying North Borneo by Austria-Hungary and being considered in the Scramble for Africa). Italy could have been richer too (even if internal affairs are not what you talk about in this videos) thanks to better developing programs in the South or earlier industrialization. Also this video would be very interesting for all italian irredentist claims. It may also be because I'm italian
@@bosphiii as an American, watching this from a distance, it’s kind of nice watching this rival situation, not evolve into most toxic of raging flame wars… *I just hope your governments don’t nuke each other…*
@@bosphiiiTrust me when I say this, all Indians and Pakistanis will agree with the fact that the best timeline for their nation would be that they best the the other one in every cricket match they have played.
Actually from what I've heard The Prince Of Jammu and Kashmir didn't really want to join India either, but rather just remain independent. However when Pakistan invaded, India basically coerced him into joining India in exchange for protection from Pakistan.
Mountbatten coerced India to sign the accession. Nehru wanted Kashmir, but not like this. Pakistan was sending tribal pusthuns to kashmir valley and Jammu and they were creating havoc on the local population- specially hindu and sikh dominated Jammu. Kashmir valley itself had a sizable Hindu and Sikh population which were driven out in a Israeli-style exodus settlements from 1960s-1990s. A similar exodus of Buddhists happened in Kargil, Leh. India had no choice but to intervene. Maharaja wanted to stay independent it was naive to think that anyone wld value Kashmir's sovereignty
There were anti-Muslim riots in Jammu in early to mid-1947 where up to 100k Muslims were massacred. Pakistanis could just sit still that early on in its journey when the country was made for the Muslims in the Muslim majority regions of India. Kashmir is also part of the acronym of Pakistan so you know that it was important to them.
@@JTR253 100k Muslims were massacred in Jammu? that's a huge number... Can you please give a reference to some source? Any credible report or article would.
I edited this comment because apparently too many Impatient Nationalist Indians bombarded the reply sections with things that didn't even match/ counter my opinion properly.
Lithium, among other precious minerals are to be found there. It is not useless. Besides, in the absence of conflict, it is an awesome tourist destination.
Great video! I think it would be awesome if, in the near future, you look up to a "What if Everything went perfect..." in South America. We are easily forgot in alternate history, mostly because we are seen as the least changing continent (and the fact that we mostly didn't have any significant wars since the dawn of the 20th century)
You could’ve included the Afghanistan-Pakistan Confederation. The Afg-Pak Confederation was a proposed union between Pakistan and Afghanistan. This would mean a full on union, with one Government. I also find it a bit interesting, as Pakistan said that they would accept the King of Afghanistan as the head of state of this entire new country. I believe the Pakistani President at the time said something along the lines of “Pakistan will have a brown Muslim man as a King, instead of a white Christian lady as Queen (referring to Queen Elizabeth II).” This new union could possibly mean peace, since the whole purpose of the union was to unite Pashtuns and Balochis split by the Durand line, which led to lots of Afghan-Pakistani conflict in real life.
@2107SlashGive Kashmir to Muslims along with Hyderabad. Give Punjab To the Khalistanis ...Make Manipur and Gujrat Independent...Also,Delhi should also be Divided😊
This video is really interesting and great ! Just one little error which in fine doesn’t change the scenario: 10:45 -> east Penjab is not majority hindu but majority sikh
actually east punjab itself got seperated into three states. punjab - sikh majority and haryana and himachal pradesh [hindu majority]. So yeah it was majority hindu.
Little bit of correction: Iskander Mirza was not ethnically Bengali, his family had settled in Bengal with the help of the British Empire and were of Irani origin and their language was Urdu. He was a direct descendent of Mir Jafar and Mir Sadiq and came from a long line of Nawabs that had ruled over Bengal for centuries. They were considered Urdu speaking and had ties with the nawabs of Lucknow. In the entire time that Pakistan was united not a single Bengali was elected to power despite their politicians winning elections. It was one of the things that created resentment in East Pakistan.
@@professionalmexican7919 no it is a real thing. It's a memetic human species that rejects its own DNA to co-opt DNA of others. It has been Iranian, Greco-Bactrian, Arab and is currently a Turk. I heard there are issues with the current meta and a new one is about to drop, the tentative title is "Silk route Mongolian with Chinese characteristics"
This video isnt banned in India. As an Indian i think the "best" pakisthan would be a pakisthan where british people never came to harm us, or a pakisthan that never seperated from India we would find some way to work together. I love pakisthani people but the government they had were unfortunately mostly bad
if the british never came, there'd be no india or pakistan and the whole subcontinent would essentially be more messier than germany before unification
@@vynicle2284 while true, india got a unified country and lost a lot of money. When Mughals were in control India was the centre of commerce and had the biggest GDP(maybe china was bigger but not sure).
Of course they will be.I am a Pakistani,but this is simply a video meant for fun,speculation and alternate history.No politics at all.The India video will also be very fun alternate entertaining as well.👍
This was really fascinating! I'm an American, and we rarely get good info about Southern Asia like this, Even being a history buff, I really learned some good stuff. Pakistan would probably also not feel the need to develop nukes in this timeline, which would help their economy a lot. As for the earlier one, it shows that if 1 country had taken the entire continent instead of a scramble for Africa, it would have been just as chaotic, given what Britain did with the Indian subcontinent and Persia/Afghanistan.
Before I watch the video I will tell you about the least discused part of south asian history by Americans. In the late 1970's Pakistan began atempted an un-named plan that would unite all of the land under what most americans call the "stan countries" essentially, the idea was that as soon as the soviet union collapses, set up such a rock solid connection between pakistan and the other "stan countries" that rather than gaining independence the "stan countries" unite with pakistan and afghanistan forming a super-state to rival modern russia. The plan was going well, and after the soviet collapse top secret documents revealed that pakistan expected to form this super state by the early 2000's. As we know Osama Bin Laden single handedly ruined the enitre plan, but an ideal timeline for pakistan would simply envovle that plan working. IMO.
I would like to recommend a concept for a new series you could do. The idea is that you take the place of a historical leader, and you choose what decisions to make as that historical leader based on what would be the most beneficial for the nation the historical leader you chose ruled over. The way you would go about doing this is you would base your decisions off of the knowledge you had at your disposal at the time. For example, you could do a video where you take the place of Louis XIV and you choose how you would expand the size, influence and power of France in the 17th and 18th centuries. Or you could take the place of Louis XV and decide how you could preserve the French empire in America and India. Perhaps you could even take the place of Louis XVI and decide how you could prevent the french revolution if you were in his position. A criticism you could levy at this idea is that it’s too similar to the series you’re already doing on “What if everything went perfectly for X”, but I disagree. Firstly, this series is about making decisions as a single person, not for an entire nation over the course of hundreds of years. Secondly, with your “What if everything went perfectly for X” series, you utilize the benefit of hindsight. With this series, you limit yourself to the knowledge of your chosen leader. You Don’t HAVE to do it this way, you could utilize the benefit of hindsight for this series too, but limiting yourself this way would help differentiate this series from your “What if everything went perfectly for X” series. You might as well try this idea on for a video and see how it performs. If it performs badly, you don’t have to continue it. But if it performs well, you could have another successful series on your hands. It is low risk, high reward. With how many historical leaders there are, the possibilities for this series are limitless! Some ideas for historical leaders to make videos on are Seleucus, Justinian, Louis the Pious, John I, Charles V, Phillip II of Spain, Charles XII, Peter III, Napoleon, Charles X, Napoleon III, Kaiser Wilhelm II, and so many more!
For the India video, you can give them ⅓ Sindh during the partition which had 29% Hindus, including the city of Karachi, and Lahore in Punjab. And maybe make them annex parts of Bangladesh in the 1971 war, like the northern portion and Chittagong Hill tracts, with perhaps even some coastal lands.
Oh boy wait till you verify what I am about to say and you will find out how much of an idiot Nehru was to think India was a new nation state instead of thinking of it as a civilisation. (I will obviously assume partition never happened and keep it reasonable). 1. Indian reserve Bank keeps the Gulf rupee alive instead of killing it off in the 60's. This currency was serving the Eastern side of the Gulf states(Qatar, Oman, UAE) which did not find oil and become rich till the 70-80's. So India benefited from the seigniorage of some of the currencies with the highest values today when the oil trade started. 2. RSS becomes the KMT of India. KMT never suffered fools that Congress or Mahasabha did. They have provided all of the strategic vision the CCP has today like one china policy, greater china(which led to its current borders but even today's Taiwan has a bigger vision than CCP if reunification happens, check the ROC map of a United China). This however would entail an early civil war with muslims which would be won with violence. 3. India works towards becoming a cultural bloc like Russia/USSR instead of a nation state in its structure and constitution. This means identification of any regions that would be of strategic interest. We would be democratic but under a central command. Think today's structure with extra states. 4. Gandhi never convinces Patel to give up his election and nominate Nehru. If it's not Patel it's someone with a vision that does not include Congress vision of "Colonialism so bad. We will never be colonisers or even aggressive". This means a closer alignment to the US instead of non alignment nonsense. We use our knowledge of English to convince them out of helping Chinese in the 60's and 80's. Which gives us all a UN security council veto when Taiwan was kicked, a weapons program, and the outsourced manufacturing China got.
So sad that your kind of colonial mindset is still so prevalent in Indians today. You immediately think of partitioning up and annexing the different parts of india when the obvious thing that would have been best for India is if they had never fallen for the British colonisers enacting their divide and rule policy and agreed to their country being split up in the first place. Pakistanis, Bangladeshis and Indians were all one people and should have stayed unified instead of being pitted against each other by our former colonisers. The Brits and Americans are STILL trying to divide us to this day and were behind many of the regime changes and millitary coups in Pakistan and recently interfered to oust popular Prime minister Imran Khan from power, against the publics wishes, in favour of returning their former PM_ a western installed puppet, who was on trial for corruption & looting the country to stash money in offshore accounts in England.
@@homeuse-ec7eitbh, without the British we may not have unified. It's their oppression which made us what we are today. Indian subcontinent was cut up into thousands of kingdoms. We were basically inviting countries to invade us. We needed a great emperor but couldn't get one
Very suspicious indeed on how many people have requesting for Pakistan. Definitely not because I called everyone from my discord to come say it with me.😓😅
Not sure how trustworthy it was due to learning this information from CaspianReport, but in 90s Pakistan had ambitions to expand their political and economic influence in Central Asia after USSR dissolved with some transnational projects being discussed. Maybe with frendly-aligned Afghanistan that doesn’t become massive territoral block for Islamabad, Pakistan could successfully create its own sphere of influence in this region that rivals interests of other powers like Turkey, Russia, China and US?
The answer is a resounding negative. The stans despise Pakistan unless you are talking about pan-islamist ulema. The Stans are still very clan based and racist. The go to epithet for Pakistanis in Afghanistan and Tajikistan is some version of "Indian/Hindu" or "even the Indians/Hindus are better than you" or "you are not even a Muslim".
@@rutvikrsI agree. Only turkey and russia could achieve good amount of influence over stans. Turkey for pan-turkic ideals and russia for its militaric and regional ties with stan. Also the reason behind the turkey achieving influence over stan easily By using pan turkism is that stan countries lived under soviets for so long that most of their government isnt even muslims. Tho, they all support pan turkism.
Would you mind sharing why you’ve found CaspianReport to be unreliable in the past? I’ve watched some of their videos in the past and didn’t get the sense that it was particularly suspect, but I’m probably missing something.
Really nice video! Maybe a potential country for you to do this sort of video with could be Canada, since there's definitely some territory that, if history had gone differently, could have become a part of the country. Also I swear I'm not a Canadian nationalist, I just really like seeing the realistic potential a country had in history, and I thought it would be nice to see this series that I really enjoy cover my home country.
British west indies particularly the Turks and Caicos A little bit more land in Oregon and maybe the us not being as successful in the American revolution or the war of 1812 Alaska possibly being sold to Canada too maybe (not entirely sure about this one).
@@rehanakhund2578 Russia & Britain were not exactly the best of friends back during the sale of Alaska, which is why it was sold to the US instead of Britain. I could however potentially see it being potentially sold to Britain and by extent Canada if the US never managed to push towards the Pacific and/or Russia and Britain have better relations (i.e. The Great Game never happens)
These videos are really fun, but it’s cool to see a pivot away from Europe focused alt-history, could you do a “What if everything went perfect” for Ethiopia or Egypt? :)
Cuz everyone knows it's not actual thing and this guy did well research as Nationalist Hindu we always appreciate proper research but as always mostly time Western creators have no idea 🗿 so commenterors just suggest or flag missinfo that's what commentators duty to keep information clear as it can !
@@svanimation8969 they dont necessarily flag missinfo they litterly say on every video on Pakistan that whole of Jammu Kashmir and Gilgit belongs to India when after 48 it was split that is not fact that is in fact missinfo
@@copiusgrimus6671 it's not official split ! It was illegal still till date Pakistan didn't showed Kashmir as there official province the day they will say officially India will invade ! Cuz then we will get reason to take it back cuz at this time Pakistan cry for independence of separate country name Kashmir (which they already know that they can't absorb Kashmir officially) India signed treaty of accession even if today plebiscite happened common Kashmiri by default vote to stay in India ! 😂
@@svanimation8969 yea no split happened thats a fact pakistan and india both occupy kashimir thats a fact india doesnt controll all of kashmir thats a fact so they cant say that india controlls all of kashmir even in the UN recognized map kashmir is split but under a disputed region
Can we get a what if everything went perfect for modern Greece? It would be interesting to see some of the crazy Greek ideas you've mentioned in other ideas put into action and the flow-on effects they'd have.
I remember seeing a comment that was featured in 0:08 (Regonized the Profile Picture) and it has been ingrained in my memory ever since, i always thought you would never do one in Pakistan, i was wrong, im not Pakistani but my Grandfather (Dads side) was from Pakistan before he moved here in Malaysia so i think its a nice concept
10:42 Do not forget the Sikhs. They could have decided (in the context of this unrealistic scenario) that they were better off under a Muslim majority than a Hindu majority
I think it would be intresting to see "What if everything went perfect for Sweeden" because, they used to have an empire, almost beat russia in the great northern war, and had a lot of potential to influence europe. I'd love to see that!
Great video as always I think it would be neat to see a video regarding if Charles the Bold didn't die/if Burgundy won the Burgundian wars Could we see a strong power arise between France and Germany? Or would they just get carved up by Napoleon or the Congress of Vienna, if they last that long that is.
its to my understanding that his holdings were under a personal union and not one kingdom. if his line does survive and assuming the house of valois still dies out in france that would mean burgundy would become king of france. in order to create a burgundan state that survives until the modern era would mean he would have to have a male heir, have his kingdom not be destroyed, and so but i do agree it would be a cool idea
What if everything went perfect For spain: beggining with miguel da paz surviving! Love your work and channel man! One of my all time favorites!😊😊😊😊😊❤❤❤❤❤
As someone of Indian descent, if everything truly went perfect for Pakistan then: - They'd have gotten Kashmir and Ladakh when they had the chance - Their Khalistani friends would've succeeded in winning over enough hearts and minds beyond a loud and out-of-touch minority of Punjabi diaspora in a country 11,000 kilometers away for East Punjab to successfully secede from India - They'd have direct rule over Junaganrh (a region in southern Gujarat that was ruled by a nature-loving Muslim king who tried very hard to join Pakistan against the wishes of his overwhelmingly-Hindu populace until India effortlessly invaded it) - The former kingdom of Hyderabad would become "South Pakistan", whose Razakars would've somehow succeeded in forcing its predominantly-Hindu Telugus, Marathis and Kannadigans to give up their faith, languages and cultures so that India might not want it anymore. - Their constant attempts to convince Indian Muslims outside of just Kashmir to sell out their own country by playing the religion card and patronizingly insisting that "Hindustan me musalmaan xaṭre me hain" would at least come close to bearing fruit instead of simply being responded to with chants of "Hindustan zindabad!" ("Long live India!") They understandably hate the right-wing Hindus' prejudice of them that's increasingly weaponized by politicians, yes, but they love their home country more and see themselves as superior to Pakistanis. - The Rohingya separatists in northern Arakan would've succeeded in joining East Pakistan (they're Muslim, mostly Indo-European, their language is close to Bengali and they were historically part of the Bengal Sultanate)- and this helps Pakistan if we assume that they keep their exclave.
As a Kashmiri Pakistani supporter who the only good ending would be for India to stop occupying us, no Shabaz shrieef and no more Afghan refugees (which would prevent terror attacks)
The thing about the Urdu - Bangali language situation is that even in West Pakistan, Urdu was not necessarily the main language spoken (though many can speak it to varying levels of proficiency). A huge part of West Pakistan had its own languages such as Punjabi (which is statistically the language with the most native speakers today), Pushto, etc. Urdu was a language spoken by Muslims spoken throughout India, including places like Lucknow. It had a lot of history amoungst Muslim Indians, even going as far as being an official language in a great capacity in India, and developed into what it is today from throughout India, not just in what is today Pakistan.
At the time of independence,only 7.8 percent Pakistani speak Urdu...then why other are forced to learn and speak Urdu... isn't it unfair....this leads to fall of other spoken languages in current day Pakistan...sad🤐
@Vladimir_Putin_2021 Because a national language has a lot of practical importance. Plus, urdu is still the minority when it comes to native speakers in Pakistan, though most have it at least as a second language.
@Vladimir_Putin_2021 Well, it's not like Pakistan forced people to abandon their native languages. However things are the way they are rn, it's a reflection of what the people of Pakistan care about and don't care about more so than anything the "state" of Pakistan cares about.
Nahg, even if they won this isnt their perfect timeline. The taliban and Afganistan in general has suffered greatly due to mismanagement and pure bad timing. There certainly could be a better timeline
@@sigmaentrepreneur5018 Sure, there were numerous things wrong when they were formed. They had to many links to more radical groups that plauged their upbringing, they should have never sided with al-qaeda if they were to take form. They also should have focused more on stabilising Afganistan instead of fighting the soviets as post-war Afganistan was just a huge mess. If they had centralised that power they would probably be influencial enough to coup the weak republic and establish the Emirate years before the taliban become prominant irl. It would have given the taliban more time to reform and develop the nation possible 10x its curent state possibly rivaling Iran or Pakistan. That is my take though, if they had knew the situation Afganistan would be in alot better form.
Where’s the video about unifying all language groups into single countries? You said you’d do it a bit back and you’ve yet to mention it again? Did you decide it was too complicated or argumentative to do, or have you just never gotten back around to it? It would really be a cool video if you did end up returning to it!
11:12 Keep in mind that the narrow corridor between Nepal and Bangladesh r muslim majority and was given to India only for this reason, inexchange of hindu majority districts in East Bengal. Also Pakistan did want Calcutta and muslim league chief minister of bengal tried to ethnically cleanse Bengali Hindus in Calcutta, this is known as the Calcutta massacres of 1946. He was however successful to ethnically cleanse Hindu majority cities of Dhaka, Khulna, Jessore, Sonargaon and Buddhist majority Chittagong hills. In any timeline, the only muslim league establishes a muslim majority Pakistan is by driving out or killing non muslims of the subcontinent. Same in Punjab, there wasnt any single city or district that had more than 55% of any religion. 70% of all properties in Lahore was owned by Sikhs and Hindus during partition which later was very unceremoniously distributed to party workers of the muslim league as a reward for looting and rioting. Jinnah himself was from Mumbai. Such a nation was never meant to be successful, only reactionary. India established itself on historical roots and cultural diversity rather than religion and thats the only reason it is a stable nation.
The Calcutta Massacre had genocide on both sides, and it was started by Hindus. Don't forget the Trains arriving in Pakistan from Indian Punjab, that were full of dead bodies, innocent women and children, massacred in India by Angry Sikh and Hindu Mobs, not happy about breaking up and split up of Punjab and also all of India. Many Millions of Muslims were murdered, due to this rage and demand for a separate Nation. When people in Pakistan saw the dead bodies arriving on Trains, they also took some revenge, but not as massive scale as India did. You can put 2 and 2 together, look at Indian Hindu Population percentage and Muslim percentage of pre-partition India. Muslims only made less 30% of population while Hindus and rest were 70% or so. So, in a massacre Majority always commits more murders.... which in India's partition case was Hindu/Sikh community, which was Pi$$ed off, due to breakage of India., so they murdered way more Muslims, then the other way around
@@redfordrn Source :- Trust me bro . Lol ! First killing of Hindus and sexually assaulting Hindu Women and forced conversions started in Noakhali (which is now in Bangladesh) which was leaded by Sohrawardi and orders given to him by Muslim League & Jinnah . Then in retaliation Gopal Patha started killing Muslims from Bihar & Bengal . This has been acknowledged by many British officers in their books . Even if Nizam and his Razkar forces killed and forcefully convert lots of Dalits and massacred lot of freedom fighters . And please also say something about Moplah riots . Wherever there is Muslim population there is always a problems . Don't play victim card .
Hindu Nationalists are far more sound minded than leftists , pseudo-seculars & Islamists . Atleast they supports neutral research & alternate history .
As an Indian I can guarantee that the second scenario was EXTREMELY unrealistic. India wouldn't fall apart just like that even if Pakistan is much larger and stronger. If anything Hindu nationalism would have been much more stronger in the scenario of a much more powerful Pakistan and it would have kept the rest of India even more united than in our real timeline.
That is indeed an utterly MONSTROUS Pakistan and its sphere of influence at the end. I am moderately surprised, however, that it is clearly shown that Odisha is a major center of Naxalite rebellions, but no Naxalite puppet of Pakistan is created there when India collapses.
i am talking about the first part of the video, there are some changes you could such as adding the whole of afghanistan in the pakistan, as there was a proposed ferederation between them, then you could have add the whole of bengal to Pakistan or give the city of calcutta to pakistan, also adding the whole of gurdaspur and ferozepur as they were majority muslims before partition. Also giving hyderabad to Pakistan as the ruler of hyderabad wanted to join pakistan at that time, and also giving junagadh to pakistan, because it was illegaly occupied by the indians, and is still claimed by Pakistan in the official political map of Pakistan.
I am Pakistani and by pointing the weaknesses you have first nipped in the bud and started from where we went wrong and a Bengali President Iskander Mirza derailed democracy and took extra constitutional measures. But you again undone that mistake and look where our fate would have been pushed us in near future had that coup never happened. Thanks for the detailed video now we can share it with our Bangladeshi brothers who often accuse us of mass scale oppression but they did not know that the very course set for us was by non other than their bengali leader of the united Pakistan Iskander Mirza when he abrogated the 1956 constitution and imposed martial law for the first time on this infant nation. Ideally this outcome which you have predicted could have been the ultimate destiny of Pakistan in the absence of the historic blunders we as a nation committed and turned our borders into a meagre state.
The first scenario really fell off a cliff in the Afghanistan section. Way too oversimplified, thats not what happened. Literally all rebel factions in Afghanistan recieved support from not just the US and Pakistan, but also Iran and China. These groups weren't just a vague collection of "radicals", there was a wide ideological range from Muslim Brotherhood types to Maoists and Shia Hazara rebels. It was never one unified movement but a large collection of local mostly tribal militias. When the Soviets withdrew and the DRA govt collapsed the country broke out into a massive civil war between the various warlords and their militias. Then in 1994, as a response to the rampant lawlessness and regular crimes caused by the warlords the Taliban was founded in Kandahar by a local quran teacher called Mullah Omar. The Taliban didn't exist during the Soviet occupation and they weren't vague "radicals", they represented the conservative elements of Afghan society that was tired of chaos and lawlessness.
heres an idea for another : what if everything went perfect for france? for example in your video about future predictions from france in 1453, although some parts not too realistic, if you accounted for every chance they had, not just once, to be a massive global power, it would probably add up
Giving Kashmir to peak would not resolve the China conflict. The China conflict exists because China saw the British designated border as illegitimate.
As a overseas Pakistani i approved this vlog is informative and interesting as well ...hope one day Pakistan will stands along with most successful and developed nation on the world 🌎 map
Pakistan's main influence was over Arab world and all the stans that broke off from USSR. If things went right for it Pakistan it would have related to that sphere of influence. I feel like you have completely missed the mark with this video.
was about to write a very angry essay until he mentioned he was gonna make a video like this on india love from india, ya make great videos ❤ also, a little suggestion:maybe you could have made the 1947 massacre slightly less bloody. just a question, if you even could.
I mean I don't get why you must write an angry essay in the first place. This is a fictional imaginary scenario in which it never happen. This is only used for fun, not serious politcal filled scenario.
9:08 I really appreciate you trying your best to pronounce everything correctly and impressed by how good you are But Balochistan is just a “ch” cound such as that of chapter instead of “kh”
Can you create an alternate timeline if the mythical continents of Atlantis, Lemuria, and Mu exist? At the same time, can you also create an alternate timeline if the fantasy creatures such as beastmen, demihuman, elves, orcs, etc. exists?
I’d really like to see another ‘what if everything went PERFECT for’ with a country like Sweden 🇸🇪. It would be pretty cool for Sweden to win a war like the second great northern war and for Sweden to not have 200 years of neutrality, and rather be a more active country in European history. But this is just my opinion and there is DEFINITELY better options but it’s your choice.
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA W2D5 | Fall | พลาดวันนี้ จะต้องเสียใจ](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/A5-Cuo12p6A/mqdefault.jpg)
Video immediately banned in India and this video immediately promoted in algorithm Pakistan😂
😂😂😂😂
fr?
So far that hasn't happened
@@shadowfighter8861nah but there is going to be a war in comments for sure
@@waterliftingI am not immune to propaganda, you too? Since you also aren't
I would love to see a “What if everything went perfect for Yugoslavia”
What about "What if Nikola Tesla ruled over Yugoslavia?"
We could have an Ultravisionary Yugoslavia.
Tito become immortal.
Due to quantum physics there is a change in everyone’s mind including [REDACTED] and Yugoslavia takes control of the entire world with 100% stability and a loyal army and population
BASED BALKAN FEDERATION!
Yes! Please!
As a Pakistani, thanks a lot! Pakistan is rarely discussed in the history tube. Looking forward to the Indian one.
Probably because it one of the countries who history can be debated on whether they only have modern history.
@@masonhandforth1369Yeah, not like the Indus River civilisation, or many other states and provinces existed
@@Iniquitous1that history is what you rejected as a society and country. You don't get to claim it when a figure like Paanini is forgotten but celebrated in India.
I literally cried of happiness when i saw this
@@truesurvivor585Embarrassing
Trust me when I say this, all Indians and Pakistanis will agree with the fact that the best timeline for their nation would be that they best the the other one in every cricket match they have played.
This is a certified Halal moment.
Also,I am eager for the India video as well.
Love to India from Pakistan.
😂😂
Pog
@@Robert_austiashut, people like you do not respect others peace
How is it halal?? Tho by your TH-cam videos I can understand your ideology. No need to fucking lie in the comment section.
@@gamerdude7800 Ever heard of a joke.
@@yasirnazirbutt8240
Leave the halal part. But your last sentence is a lie.
The most unrealistic part is Pakistan and India, getting together against China.
It was close actually,in 1962 Pakistan sent diplomats to India regarding "the northern threat", as they were west aligned they were fearfull of a larger Communist state,but these were rejected by india
not very unrealistic, it would be more unrealistic for afghanistani government and pakistan to work together against any one than that, afghan republic hated the durand line and thus pakistan and every afghan gov since has the exact same view, if kashmir didn't become an issue pakistan and india would most likely coexist with similar relations of greece and trukey, but especially when muslims or hindus are persecuted then tensions would rise
The country's "What if everything went perfect for..." I really want to see is Italy's for plenty of reasons. Italy had many lost opportunietes of unifying earlier (in modern era it's the First War of Italian indipendence in 1848 but the revolt in Hungary was repressed and other italian states stopped supporting Savoy) and creating a decent colonial empire (Tunisia being taken before France, Giovanni Cerruti's proget in New Guinea going well and Italy winning against Ethiopia in the first Italo-Ethiopian war, buying North Borneo by Austria-Hungary and being considered in the Scramble for Africa). Italy could have been richer too (even if internal affairs are not what you talk about in this videos) thanks to better developing programs in the South or earlier industrialization. Also this video would be very interesting for all italian irredentist claims. It may also be because I'm italian
*Worst mistake of italy is existing dude*
I am a Brazilian, but my family is italian and they *come to Brazil* after ww2
I would definitely love to see a video for Italy.
agreed
@@GAarcherfalse info Italy existing is very important for modern geopolitics and technological development
@@awildcrusader5033Sounds like something an Italian would say
Don't worry my Indian brothers! We shall have our turn as well!
No hate to our north-western neighbours, love you guys
Yeah you guys are annoying as all hell, but I wouldn't have anyone else as a better rival. Cheers bhai
@@bosphiii cheers to you too mate
@@bosphiii as an American, watching this from a distance, it’s kind of nice watching this rival situation, not evolve into most toxic of raging flame wars…
*I just hope your governments don’t nuke each other…*
@@bosphiiiTrust me when I say this, all Indians and Pakistanis will agree with the fact that the best timeline for their nation would be that they best the the other one in every cricket match they have played.
@@shubhanjalshukla3879real
Actually from what I've heard The Prince Of Jammu and Kashmir didn't really want to join India either, but rather just remain independent. However when Pakistan invaded, India basically coerced him into joining India in exchange for protection from Pakistan.
Even then India never wanted to invade JK but they don't want people to be oppressed like east Pakistanis
Mountbatten coerced India to sign the accession.
Nehru wanted Kashmir, but not like this. Pakistan was sending tribal pusthuns to kashmir valley and Jammu and they were creating havoc on the local population- specially hindu and sikh dominated Jammu. Kashmir valley itself had a sizable Hindu and Sikh population which were driven out in a Israeli-style exodus settlements from 1960s-1990s.
A similar exodus of Buddhists happened in Kargil, Leh.
India had no choice but to intervene. Maharaja wanted to stay independent it was naive to think that anyone wld value Kashmir's sovereignty
There were anti-Muslim riots in Jammu in early to mid-1947 where up to 100k Muslims were massacred. Pakistanis could just sit still that early on in its journey when the country was made for the Muslims in the Muslim majority regions of India. Kashmir is also part of the acronym of Pakistan so you know that it was important to them.
@@JTR253 100k Muslims were massacred in Jammu? that's a huge number... Can you please give a reference to some source? Any credible report or article would.
@@JTR253bros spreading false Pakistani propaganda 💀, where is the proof of any of this?
I edited this comment because apparently too many Impatient Nationalist Indians bombarded the reply sections with things that didn't even match/ counter my opinion properly.
Thanks man
Good wishes from your Pakistani brother💙💙
Lithium, among other precious minerals are to be found there.
It is not useless.
Besides, in the absence of conflict, it is an awesome tourist destination.
@@curious_one1156 So never.
❤❤
That is very civil of you to understand that it was just a scenario not the history
Great video! I think it would be awesome if, in the near future, you look up to a "What if Everything went perfect..." in South America. We are easily forgot in alternate history, mostly because we are seen as the least changing continent (and the fact that we mostly didn't have any significant wars since the dawn of the 20th century)
He should do what if everything went perfect for Gran Columbia
What if everything went perfect for Paraguay would be interesting,so it could show them winning the war against Brazil,Argentina and Uruguay.
It's pretty much just argentina, brazil, paraguay and colombia. Maybe you can add peru-bolivia, but that is stretching it too much
@@elpepe9193 Chile (Patagonia), Venezuela (Guyana), the Gran Colombia nearly unified with northern Perú. There is a lot to do.
@@Uriel4-9-476 yeah, but how many of those ideas can do a 10/15 minute video?
You could’ve included the Afghanistan-Pakistan Confederation. The Afg-Pak Confederation was a proposed union between Pakistan and Afghanistan. This would mean a full on union, with one Government. I also find it a bit interesting, as Pakistan said that they would accept the King of Afghanistan as the head of state of this entire new country. I believe the Pakistani President at the time said something along the lines of “Pakistan will have a brown Muslim man as a King, instead of a white Christian lady as Queen (referring to Queen Elizabeth II).”
This new union could possibly mean peace, since the whole purpose of the union was to unite Pashtuns and Balochis split by the Durand line, which led to lots of Afghan-Pakistani conflict in real life.
I heard about that it is crazy
Honestly, that could've saved a LOT of troubles for everyone involved.
There was one problem that was preventing this plan from being executed.
The fucking Soviet Union.
@2107SlashGive Kashmir to Muslims along with Hyderabad. Give Punjab To the Khalistanis ...Make Manipur and Gujrat Independent...Also,Delhi should also be Divided😊
@2107Slash go back to your call center
AYYY
Being a Pakistani I'm happy you made this video, especially since we rarely come up in alt history.
Bhojan 🥺🤲🏿 tiech bidio iz rial 🥺🤲🏿
Well Dominic, this isn't banned in India.
Just posting here so everyone can see easily.
What
@@आईएनडीमैपिंग500Yes
@@आईएनडीमैपिंग500Yes
This video is really interesting and great !
Just one little error which in fine doesn’t change the scenario:
10:45 -> east Penjab is not majority hindu but majority sikh
actually east punjab itself got seperated into three states. punjab - sikh majority and haryana and himachal pradesh [hindu majority]. So yeah it was majority hindu.
East Punjab back then also included Haryana, Himachal & Chandigarh not just today's Indian Punjab
Nope east Punjab was hindu majority, it was after Punjab suba movement and separation of Haryana and himanchal that Sikhs became majority
Little bit of correction: Iskander Mirza was not ethnically Bengali, his family had settled in Bengal with the help of the British Empire and were of Irani origin and their language was Urdu. He was a direct descendent of Mir Jafar and Mir Sadiq and came from a long line of Nawabs that had ruled over Bengal for centuries. They were considered Urdu speaking and had ties with the nawabs of Lucknow. In the entire time that Pakistan was united not a single Bengali was elected to power despite their politicians winning elections. It was one of the things that created resentment in East Pakistan.
As a Pakistan I can confirm this is true
Are u Pakistan ? 😂
@@austro-prussianempire7056I think I that was the joke
Ah yes, you're the entirety of the country xd
@@professionalmexican7919 no it is a real thing. It's a memetic human species that rejects its own DNA to co-opt DNA of others. It has been Iranian, Greco-Bactrian, Arab and is currently a Turk. I heard there are issues with the current meta and a new one is about to drop, the tentative title is "Silk route Mongolian with Chinese characteristics"
@@rutvikrs indeed that is what I am
This video isnt banned in India.
As an Indian i think the "best" pakisthan would be a pakisthan where british people never came to harm us, or a pakisthan that never seperated from India we would find some way to work together.
I love pakisthani people but the government they had were unfortunately mostly bad
if the british never came, there'd be no india or pakistan and the whole subcontinent would essentially be more messier than germany before unification
@@vynicle2284 while true, india got a unified country and lost a lot of money. When Mughals were in control India was the centre of commerce and had the biggest GDP(maybe china was bigger but not sure).
Oh boy, these comments will be extremely respectful, I'm sure of it!
ofc they will be
indeed
Oh definitely
Of course they will be.I am a Pakistani,but this is simply a video meant for fun,speculation and alternate history.No politics at all.The India video will also be very fun alternate entertaining as well.👍
Yeah, it's relatively peaceful
This was really fascinating! I'm an American, and we rarely get good info about Southern Asia like this, Even being a history buff, I really learned some good stuff. Pakistan would probably also not feel the need to develop nukes in this timeline, which would help their economy a lot. As for the earlier one, it shows that if 1 country had taken the entire continent instead of a scramble for Africa, it would have been just as chaotic, given what Britain did with the Indian subcontinent and Persia/Afghanistan.
Before I watch the video I will tell you about the least discused part of south asian history by Americans.
In the late 1970's Pakistan began atempted an un-named plan that would unite all of the land under what most americans call the "stan countries"
essentially, the idea was that as soon as the soviet union collapses, set up such a rock solid connection between pakistan and the other "stan countries" that rather than gaining independence the "stan countries" unite with pakistan and afghanistan forming a super-state to rival modern russia.
The plan was going well, and after the soviet collapse top secret documents revealed that pakistan expected to form this super state by the early 2000's. As we know Osama Bin Laden single handedly ruined the enitre plan, but an ideal timeline for pakistan would simply envovle that plan working. IMO.
@@randomdams9179Osama my boy done us bad
@@mistyydagoat Bro single handedly destroyed 3 nations in his lifetime, he also created one and got it destroyed as well so destroyed 4 nartions.
I would like to recommend a concept for a new series you could do. The idea is that you take the place of a historical leader, and you choose what decisions to make as that historical leader based on what would be the most beneficial for the nation the historical leader you chose ruled over. The way you would go about doing this is you would base your decisions off of the knowledge you had at your disposal at the time. For example, you could do a video where you take the place of Louis XIV and you choose how you would expand the size, influence and power of France in the 17th and 18th centuries. Or you could take the place of Louis XV and decide how you could preserve the French empire in America and India. Perhaps you could even take the place of Louis XVI and decide how you could prevent the french revolution if you were in his position. A criticism you could levy at this idea is that it’s too similar to the series you’re already doing on “What if everything went perfectly for X”, but I disagree. Firstly, this series is about making decisions as a single person, not for an entire nation over the course of hundreds of years. Secondly, with your “What if everything went perfectly for X” series, you utilize the benefit of hindsight. With this series, you limit yourself to the knowledge of your chosen leader. You Don’t HAVE to do it this way, you could utilize the benefit of hindsight for this series too, but limiting yourself this way would help differentiate this series from your “What if everything went perfectly for X” series. You might as well try this idea on for a video and see how it performs. If it performs badly, you don’t have to continue it. But if it performs well, you could have another successful series on your hands. It is low risk, high reward. With how many historical leaders there are, the possibilities for this series are limitless! Some ideas for historical leaders to make videos on are Seleucus, Justinian, Louis the Pious, John I, Charles V, Phillip II of Spain, Charles XII, Peter III, Napoleon, Charles X, Napoleon III, Kaiser Wilhelm II, and so many more!
While this isn’t one of the ideas that came to mind for me, I absolutely love this video! It’s an interesting pivot away from Europe-focused content
You forgot Junagadh, which acceded to pakistan but was invaded and annexed by india.
I am a Pakistani and this was amazing, Pakistan is barley discussed across TH-cam and again this was amazing.
As a Pakistani 🇵🇰, we aren't discussed enough by intellectuals like you.......
You have my thanks for this video.... ❤
Pakistan: *mentioned*
Indians: Hello saar ji this is adam smith from Microsoft
What actually this blud tryna a explain?
Pakistan is just waiting for Indian army to march in 😂
It's just a matter of years
@@bladey_0_10who told you that? Indian news?
@@bladey_0_10yea only in Bollywood😂😂
For the India video, you can give them ⅓ Sindh during the partition which had 29% Hindus, including the city of Karachi, and Lahore in Punjab.
And maybe make them annex parts of Bangladesh in the 1971 war, like the northern portion and Chittagong Hill tracts, with perhaps even some coastal lands.
Oh boy wait till you verify what I am about to say and you will find out how much of an idiot Nehru was to think India was a new nation state instead of thinking of it as a civilisation. (I will obviously assume partition never happened and keep it reasonable).
1. Indian reserve Bank keeps the Gulf rupee alive instead of killing it off in the 60's. This currency was serving the Eastern side of the Gulf states(Qatar, Oman, UAE) which did not find oil and become rich till the 70-80's. So India benefited from the seigniorage of some of the currencies with the highest values today when the oil trade started.
2. RSS becomes the KMT of India. KMT never suffered fools that Congress or Mahasabha did. They have provided all of the strategic vision the CCP has today like one china policy, greater china(which led to its current borders but even today's Taiwan has a bigger vision than CCP if reunification happens, check the ROC map of a United China). This however would entail an early civil war with muslims which would be won with violence.
3. India works towards becoming a cultural bloc like Russia/USSR instead of a nation state in its structure and constitution. This means identification of any regions that would be of strategic interest. We would be democratic but under a central command. Think today's structure with extra states.
4. Gandhi never convinces Patel to give up his election and nominate Nehru. If it's not Patel it's someone with a vision that does not include Congress vision of "Colonialism so bad. We will never be colonisers or even aggressive". This means a closer alignment to the US instead of non alignment nonsense. We use our knowledge of English to convince them out of helping Chinese in the 60's and 80's. Which gives us all a UN security council veto when Taiwan was kicked, a weapons program, and the outsourced manufacturing China got.
Maybe even Nehrus hopes for Punjab since india was hoping to get most of what’s is now Pakistans Punjab
So sad that your kind of colonial mindset is still so prevalent in Indians today. You immediately think of partitioning up and annexing the different parts of india when the obvious thing that would have been best for India is if they had never fallen for the British colonisers enacting their divide and rule policy and agreed to their country being split up in the first place. Pakistanis, Bangladeshis and Indians were all one people and should have stayed unified instead of being pitted against each other by our former colonisers. The Brits and Americans are STILL trying to divide us to this day and were behind many of the regime changes and millitary coups in Pakistan and recently interfered to oust popular Prime minister Imran Khan from power, against the publics wishes, in favour of returning their former PM_ a western installed puppet, who was on trial for corruption & looting the country to stash money in offshore accounts in England.
@@homeuse-ec7ei What the fuck? He's talking about India FOR WHAT IF EVERYTHING WENT PERFECT.
@@homeuse-ec7eitbh, without the British we may not have unified. It's their oppression which made us what we are today. Indian subcontinent was cut up into thousands of kingdoms. We were basically inviting countries to invade us. We needed a great emperor but couldn't get one
Very suspicious indeed on how many people have requesting for Pakistan.
Definitely not because I called everyone from my discord to come say it with me.😓😅
Crazy
I am one of them (I am Indian)
Can you do a What If History went perfect for the Ottoman Empire?
Not sure how trustworthy it was due to learning this information from CaspianReport, but in 90s Pakistan had ambitions to expand their political and economic influence in Central Asia after USSR dissolved with some transnational projects being discussed. Maybe with frendly-aligned Afghanistan that doesn’t become massive territoral block for Islamabad, Pakistan could successfully create its own sphere of influence in this region that rivals interests of other powers like Turkey, Russia, China and US?
The answer is a resounding negative. The stans despise Pakistan unless you are talking about pan-islamist ulema. The Stans are still very clan based and racist. The go to epithet for Pakistanis in Afghanistan and Tajikistan is some version of "Indian/Hindu" or "even the Indians/Hindus are better than you" or "you are not even a Muslim".
@@rutvikrsI agree. Only turkey and russia could achieve good amount of influence over stans. Turkey for pan-turkic ideals and russia for its militaric and regional ties with stan. Also the reason behind the turkey achieving influence over stan easily By using pan turkism is that stan countries lived under soviets for so long that most of their government isnt even muslims. Tho, they all support pan turkism.
Would you mind sharing why you’ve found CaspianReport to be unreliable in the past? I’ve watched some of their videos in the past and didn’t get the sense that it was particularly suspect, but I’m probably missing something.
@@Heinz-gv8rm China can, and has.
@@user-cx9nc4pj8w ah yes forgot about that
Really nice video! Maybe a potential country for you to do this sort of video with could be Canada, since there's definitely some territory that, if history had gone differently, could have become a part of the country.
Also I swear I'm not a Canadian nationalist, I just really like seeing the realistic potential a country had in history, and I thought it would be nice to see this series that I really enjoy cover my home country.
British west indies particularly the Turks and Caicos
A little bit more land in Oregon and maybe the us not being as successful in the American revolution or the war of 1812
Alaska possibly being sold to Canada too maybe (not entirely sure about this one).
@@rehanakhund2578 Russia & Britain were not exactly the best of friends back during the sale of Alaska, which is why it was sold to the US instead of Britain. I could however potentially see it being potentially sold to Britain and by extent Canada if the US never managed to push towards the Pacific and/or Russia and Britain have better relations (i.e. The Great Game never happens)
@@BrendaK7200 yeah
These videos are really fun, but it’s cool to see a pivot away from Europe focused alt-history, could you do a “What if everything went perfect” for Ethiopia or Egypt? :)
Ancient Egypt, Ptolemaic Egypt, Ottoman Egypt or Post Inepenence Egypt?
@@stefanofeblesverastegui8869 either ottoman or modern
What if everything went perfect for Australia
@@Wizardoushazard True
Love your work man! You deserve way more subscribers!
Please make Austria take its turn on this series! Long live the habsburgs!🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
All hail the big chin kings
Austrian-unified and Habsburg controlled German Empire moment.
@@yasirnazirbutt8240 *Habsburg controlled Europe
Wow 1 whole day and no radical hindus or pakistanis in sight it is so refreshing to see proper discussions and respectful behaviour from both parties
I know there is no hate and stupidity in the comment section just respectful educated behaviour this is quite literally a miracle!
Cuz everyone knows it's not actual thing and this guy did well research as Nationalist Hindu we always appreciate proper research but as always mostly time Western creators have no idea 🗿 so commenterors just suggest or flag missinfo that's what commentators duty to keep information clear as it can !
@@svanimation8969 they dont necessarily flag missinfo they litterly say on every video on Pakistan that whole of Jammu Kashmir and Gilgit belongs to India when after 48 it was split that is not fact that is in fact missinfo
@@copiusgrimus6671 it's not official split ! It was illegal still till date Pakistan didn't showed Kashmir as there official province the day they will say officially India will invade ! Cuz then we will get reason to take it back cuz at this time Pakistan cry for independence of separate country name Kashmir (which they already know that they can't absorb Kashmir officially) India signed treaty of accession even if today plebiscite happened common Kashmiri by default vote to stay in India ! 😂
@@svanimation8969 yea no split happened thats a fact pakistan and india both occupy kashimir thats a fact india doesnt controll all of kashmir thats a fact so they cant say that india controlls all of kashmir even in the UN recognized map kashmir is split but under a disputed region
Can we get a what if everything went perfect for modern Greece? It would be interesting to see some of the crazy Greek ideas you've mentioned in other ideas put into action and the flow-on effects they'd have.
That means they would have eastern thrace and smyrna as well as constantinople
I remember seeing a comment that was featured in 0:08 (Regonized the Profile Picture) and it has been ingrained in my memory ever since, i always thought you would never do one in Pakistan, i was wrong, im not Pakistani but my Grandfather (Dads side) was from Pakistan before he moved here in Malaysia so i think its a nice concept
Do a "what if everything went perfect for the world"
- Humans don't exist
Not possible.
No humans. Done.
@@shadowfighter8861 also dinosaurs dont die
who dont love dinosaurs
10:42 Do not forget the Sikhs. They could have decided (in the context of this unrealistic scenario) that they were better off under a Muslim majority than a Hindu majority
We are seeing in reality what is happening with Pakistani Sikhs living in West Punjab .😂😂😂😂
I think it would be intresting to see "What if everything went perfect for Sweeden" because, they used to have an empire, almost beat russia in the great northern war, and had a lot of potential to influence europe. I'd love to see that!
Great video as always
I think it would be neat to see a video regarding if Charles the Bold didn't die/if Burgundy won the Burgundian wars
Could we see a strong power arise between France and Germany? Or would they just get carved up by Napoleon or the Congress of Vienna, if they last that long that is.
its to my understanding that his holdings were under a personal union and not one kingdom. if his line does survive and assuming the house of valois still dies out in france that would mean burgundy would become king of france. in order to create a burgundan state that survives until the modern era would mean he would have to have a male heir, have his kingdom not be destroyed, and so but i do agree it would be a cool idea
@@avarinball Yes, even with that though it'd be interesting to see Burgundy survive
This man is so underrated, out here making the best content on TH-cam and still doesn’t have 100k. Tragic
What if everything went perfect For spain: beggining with miguel da paz surviving!
Love your work and channel man! One of my all time favorites!😊😊😊😊😊❤❤❤❤❤
Hi
that would be awesome
As someone of Indian descent, if everything truly went perfect for Pakistan then:
- They'd have gotten Kashmir and Ladakh when they had the chance
- Their Khalistani friends would've succeeded in winning over enough hearts and minds beyond a loud and out-of-touch minority of Punjabi diaspora in a country 11,000 kilometers away for East Punjab to successfully secede from India
- They'd have direct rule over Junaganrh (a region in southern Gujarat that was ruled by a nature-loving Muslim king who tried very hard to join Pakistan against the wishes of his overwhelmingly-Hindu populace until India effortlessly invaded it)
- The former kingdom of Hyderabad would become "South Pakistan", whose Razakars would've somehow succeeded in forcing its predominantly-Hindu Telugus, Marathis and Kannadigans to give up their faith, languages and cultures so that India might not want it anymore.
- Their constant attempts to convince Indian Muslims outside of just Kashmir to sell out their own country by playing the religion card and patronizingly insisting that "Hindustan me musalmaan xaṭre me hain" would at least come close to bearing fruit instead of simply being responded to with chants of "Hindustan zindabad!" ("Long live India!") They understandably hate the right-wing Hindus' prejudice of them that's increasingly weaponized by politicians, yes, but they love their home country more and see themselves as superior to Pakistanis.
- The Rohingya separatists in northern Arakan would've succeeded in joining East Pakistan (they're Muslim, mostly Indo-European, their language is close to Bengali and they were historically part of the Bengal Sultanate)- and this helps Pakistan if we assume that they keep their exclave.
As a Kashmiri Pakistani supporter who the only good ending would be for India to stop occupying us, no Shabaz shrieef and no more Afghan refugees (which would prevent terror attacks)
Jinnah's wildest wet dreams 😅
Now make a video on what if India and Pak were united and would they have remained United post independence?
There's already one, what if everything went perfect for india
i think china, india and pakastan should sign a peace treaty recognizing the current line of control over kashmir and any other territorial dispute.
this is exactly what I want
Keep day dreaming
I remember hearing that during the partition of India rohingya Muslims in rahmanland asked to join Pakistan but this offer was rejected by Pakistan.
Where is rahmanland?
@@AshRock-dt7hb northern arakan it borders Chittagong I think, the rohingya Muslims live there.
The thing about the Urdu - Bangali language situation is that even in West Pakistan, Urdu was not necessarily the main language spoken (though many can speak it to varying levels of proficiency). A huge part of West Pakistan had its own languages such as Punjabi (which is statistically the language with the most native speakers today), Pushto, etc.
Urdu was a language spoken by Muslims spoken throughout India, including places like Lucknow. It had a lot of history amoungst Muslim Indians, even going as far as being an official language in a great capacity in India, and developed into what it is today from throughout India, not just in what is today Pakistan.
At the time of independence,only 7.8 percent Pakistani speak Urdu...then why other are forced to learn and speak Urdu... isn't it unfair....this leads to fall of other spoken languages in current day Pakistan...sad🤐
@Vladimir_Putin_2021 Because a national language has a lot of practical importance. Plus, urdu is still the minority when it comes to native speakers in Pakistan, though most have it at least as a second language.
@Vladimir_Putin_2021 Well, it's not like Pakistan forced people to abandon their native languages. However things are the way they are rn, it's a reflection of what the people of Pakistan care about and don't care about more so than anything the "state" of Pakistan cares about.
@@Vladimir_Putin_2021 there is no Punjabi script. Punjabi was originally written in Landa script.
@@bhanupratap1063 In Pakistani Punjab punjabi is written in shahmukhi script ( urdu )..
In Indian Punjab it's written “ gurmukhi ” script
next what if everything went perfect for the taliban pls 🙏🙏
oh wait thats the canon ending
Nahg, even if they won this isnt their perfect timeline. The taliban and Afganistan in general has suffered greatly due to mismanagement and pure bad timing. There certainly could be a better timeline
@@kraijom319 you cookin you cookin, go on and elaborate please
@@sigmaentrepreneur5018They're facing sancations.
@@sigmaentrepreneur5018 Sure, there were numerous things wrong when they were formed. They had to many links to more radical groups that plauged their upbringing, they should have never sided with al-qaeda if they were to take form. They also should have focused more on stabilising Afganistan instead of fighting the soviets as post-war Afganistan was just a huge mess. If they had centralised that power they would probably be influencial enough to coup the weak republic and establish the Emirate years before the taliban become prominant irl. It would have given the taliban more time to reform and develop the nation possible 10x its curent state possibly rivaling Iran or Pakistan. That is my take though, if they had knew the situation Afganistan would be in alot better form.
Make what if everything went perfect for the British Empire next
I mean he basically did that in the imperial federation video
Pax Britannica intensifies.
Whwt if everything went wrong for the British Empire (realistically)? Specifically, after 1815.
@@aaronTGP_3756 we don’t need a downer scenario
@@MCLegend13 Consider it a triumph for India, the Egyptians, Germany, Russia and more.
You forgot to mention how Rakhine State should have also been part of Pakistan.
Where’s the video about unifying all language groups into single countries? You said you’d do it a bit back and you’ve yet to mention it again? Did you decide it was too complicated or argumentative to do, or have you just never gotten back around to it? It would really be a cool video if you did end up returning to it!
11:12
Keep in mind that the narrow corridor between Nepal and Bangladesh r muslim majority and was given to India only for this reason, inexchange of hindu majority districts in East Bengal.
Also Pakistan did want Calcutta and muslim league chief minister of bengal tried to ethnically cleanse Bengali Hindus in Calcutta, this is known as the Calcutta massacres of 1946.
He was however successful to ethnically cleanse Hindu majority cities of Dhaka, Khulna, Jessore, Sonargaon and Buddhist majority Chittagong hills.
In any timeline, the only muslim league establishes a muslim majority Pakistan is by driving out or killing non muslims of the subcontinent.
Same in Punjab, there wasnt any single city or district that had more than 55% of any religion. 70% of all properties in Lahore was owned by Sikhs and Hindus during partition which later was very unceremoniously distributed to party workers of the muslim league as a reward for looting and rioting. Jinnah himself was from Mumbai.
Such a nation was never meant to be successful, only reactionary. India established itself on historical roots and cultural diversity rather than religion and thats the only reason it is a stable nation.
Cool, now let's discuss the Hindu massacres of Muslims in India
@@abdullahbinsajjad4070 please go ahead I am eager to hear it
The Calcutta Massacre had genocide on both sides, and it was started by Hindus. Don't forget the Trains arriving in Pakistan from Indian Punjab, that were full of dead bodies, innocent women and children, massacred in India by Angry Sikh and Hindu Mobs, not happy about breaking up and split up of Punjab and also all of India. Many Millions of Muslims were murdered, due to this rage and demand for a separate Nation.
When people in Pakistan saw the dead bodies arriving on Trains, they also took some revenge, but not as massive scale as India did. You can put 2 and 2 together, look at Indian Hindu Population percentage and Muslim percentage of pre-partition India. Muslims only made less 30% of population while Hindus and rest were 70% or so.
So, in a massacre Majority always commits more murders.... which in India's partition case was Hindu/Sikh community, which was Pi$$ed off, due to breakage of India., so they murdered way more Muslims, then the other way around
@@redfordrn Source :- Trust me bro . Lol ! First killing of Hindus and sexually assaulting Hindu Women and forced conversions started in Noakhali (which is now in Bangladesh) which was leaded by Sohrawardi and orders given to him by Muslim League & Jinnah . Then in retaliation Gopal Patha started killing Muslims from Bihar & Bengal . This has been acknowledged by many British officers in their books . Even if Nizam and his Razkar forces killed and forcefully convert lots of Dalits and massacred lot of freedom fighters . And please also say something about Moplah riots . Wherever there is Muslim population there is always a problems . Don't play victim card .
@@redfordrn BS history. The Muslims always started it, but of course your Pakistani textbooks will teach you propoganda.
i cry myself to sleep knowing how diff we could have been lol.great vid btw happy to see my country in these type of vids
We should have a video about "What if everything went perfect for the Subcontinent of India?"
Great video, is it possible you could make one about Denmark? :)
HINDU NATIONALIST BOTS ON THEIR WAY TO THE COMMENTS 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Vice-versa 😂
Pakdog 😂
Hindu Nationalists are far more sound minded than leftists , pseudo-seculars & Islamists . Atleast they supports neutral research & alternate history .
I came here mainly to see the Indians and Pakistanis arguing with each other in the comments
Ngl as a Pakistani, it feels like everything went wrong with Pakistan so far.
Do you prefer Democracy or the rule of the Military?
As an Indian I can guarantee that the second scenario was EXTREMELY unrealistic. India wouldn't fall apart just like that even if Pakistan is much larger and stronger. If anything Hindu nationalism would have been much more stronger in the scenario of a much more powerful Pakistan and it would have kept the rest of India even more united than in our real timeline.
Nice video, thanks wonder how this Pakistan would develop religiously
Please do an alternate history of Yugoslavia
I love Pakistani’s people delusional world ❤ !
They are amazing at it !
The comments are definitely going to be 100% rational and peaceful...
Please make a video on what if everything went perfect for Poland or Ukraine
Just one mistake in the thumbnail:
It's إيمان, not يمان
I have power. I changed the like count from 2k to 2.1k
As a kashmiri i respect pakistan ❤🎉
pakistan is the successor for rome for people who don't know
Thank you for spreading the message.
Pakistan should rename Islamabad to new rome
Is that a pakistani cover of "Shape of you" playing in the background in the second half lol?
That is indeed an utterly MONSTROUS Pakistan and its sphere of influence at the end. I am moderately surprised, however, that it is clearly shown that Odisha is a major center of Naxalite rebellions, but no Naxalite puppet of Pakistan is created there when India collapses.
Maybe you should do a What if everything went perfectly, with the Ottoman Empire
As an ottoman hater, No he shouldn't do this.
this was great! what about India? personally, I think a timeline with no partition is probably the best case scenario
Yeah but we are talking about Pakistan right now and for a best scenario for Pakistan we first need Pakistan to exist
i am talking about the first part of the video, there are some changes you could such as adding the whole of afghanistan in the pakistan, as there was a proposed ferederation between them, then you could have add the whole of bengal to Pakistan or give the city of calcutta to pakistan, also adding the whole of gurdaspur and ferozepur as they were majority muslims before partition. Also giving hyderabad to Pakistan as the ruler of hyderabad wanted to join pakistan at that time, and also giving junagadh to pakistan, because it was illegaly occupied by the indians, and is still claimed by Pakistan in the official political map of Pakistan.
I am Pakistani and by pointing the weaknesses you have first nipped in the bud and started from where we went wrong and a Bengali President Iskander Mirza derailed democracy and took extra constitutional measures. But you again undone that mistake and look where our fate would have been pushed us in near future had that coup never happened.
Thanks for the detailed video now we can share it with our Bangladeshi brothers who often accuse us of mass scale oppression but they did not know that the very course set for us was by non other than their bengali leader of the united Pakistan Iskander Mirza when he abrogated the 1956 constitution and imposed martial law for the first time on this infant nation.
Ideally this outcome which you have predicted could have been the ultimate destiny of Pakistan in the absence of the historic blunders we as a nation committed and turned our borders into a meagre state.
What if everything went perfect for China (monarchist or nationalist victory)?
what if everything went perfect for sweden please
Profile picture checks out
Add Pakistan's attempt to create a Superstate with the Central Asian stans in 1990 and you have an even bigger Pakistan
The first scenario really fell off a cliff in the Afghanistan section. Way too oversimplified, thats not what happened. Literally all rebel factions in Afghanistan recieved support from not just the US and Pakistan, but also Iran and China. These groups weren't just a vague collection of "radicals", there was a wide ideological range from Muslim Brotherhood types to Maoists and Shia Hazara rebels. It was never one unified movement but a large collection of local mostly tribal militias. When the Soviets withdrew and the DRA govt collapsed the country broke out into a massive civil war between the various warlords and their militias. Then in 1994, as a response to the rampant lawlessness and regular crimes caused by the warlords the Taliban was founded in Kandahar by a local quran teacher called Mullah Omar. The Taliban didn't exist during the Soviet occupation and they weren't vague "radicals", they represented the conservative elements of Afghan society that was tired of chaos and lawlessness.
Pls do one for POLAND or LITHUANIA ( but those need to be from medival times )
heres an idea for another : what if everything went perfect for france?
for example in your video about future predictions from france in 1453, although some parts not too realistic, if you accounted for every chance they had, not just once, to be a massive global power, it would probably add up
Napoleon god mode video lmao
The Habsburgs would still be a big hurdle for Medieval France to overcome
Giving Kashmir to peak would not resolve the China conflict. The China conflict exists because China saw the British designated border as illegitimate.
Now it’s time for: What if everything went perfect for China (Ming or PRC or ROC or Qing)
We Pashtuns and Baloch will never stop resisting Pakistani occupation of our land
Full support to you brother
Like how the Kashmir protect them self from radicle indian
As a overseas Pakistani i approved this vlog is informative and interesting as well ...hope one day Pakistan will stands along with most successful and developed nation on the world 🌎 map
Even tho I am an Indian I love the idea Pakistan is rarely discussed in history
Pakistan's main influence was over Arab world and all the stans that broke off from USSR. If things went right for it Pakistan it would have related to that sphere of influence. I feel like you have completely missed the mark with this video.
was about to write a very angry essay until he mentioned he was gonna make a video like this on india
love from india, ya make great videos ❤
also, a little suggestion:maybe you could have made the 1947 massacre slightly less bloody. just a question, if you even could.
I mean I don't get why you must write an angry essay in the first place. This is a fictional imaginary scenario in which it never happen. This is only used for fun, not serious politcal filled scenario.
@@R_02alcb honestly i just wrote it for fun. i didn't actually mean to write a very angry essay :p
@@Yomesto ah alright fair enough
This video is banned in india 💀
bro i'm indian I can see this video😂
Among all this chaos Dravida Nadu would have got their independent nation
As a Malaysian I approved
if you are okay with more obscure topics then what about "what if evereything went perfect for Emirat of Sicily"
Sounds interesting
9:08 I really appreciate you trying your best to pronounce everything correctly and impressed by how good you are
But Balochistan is just a “ch” cound such as that of chapter instead of “kh”
I wish the first one would be actually true, Kashmir was predominantly Muslim
Can you make a video?
What if everything went perfect for the USSR
What if everything went perfect for Britain
The based timeline
Next do “What if everything went perfect for Brazil” 😊
Can you create an alternate timeline if the mythical continents of Atlantis, Lemuria, and Mu exist?
At the same time, can you also create an alternate timeline if the fantasy creatures such as beastmen, demihuman, elves, orcs, etc. exists?
I’d really like to see another ‘what if everything went PERFECT for’ with a country like Sweden 🇸🇪. It would be pretty cool for Sweden to win a war like the second great northern war and for Sweden to not have 200 years of neutrality, and rather be a more active country in European history. But this is just my opinion and there is DEFINITELY better options but it’s your choice.
Everything went perfect for Soviet union?
Gigachad Pakistan 😎