"I Don't Gripe To You." - Saving Private Ryan (1998)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 ก.ย. 2024
- #shorts #savingprivateryan #movieinsight
"I Don't Gripe To You." - Saving Private Ryan (1998) #shorts #savingprivateryan #movie #moviescene
Saving Private Ryan is a 1998 American epic war film directed by Steven Spielberg and written by Robert Rodat. Set in 1944 in France during World War II, it follows a group of soldiers, led by Captain John Miller (Tom Hanks), on their mission to locate Private James Francis Ryan (Matt Damon) and bring him home safely after his three brothers are killed in action. The cast also includes Edward Burns, Tom Sizemore, Barry Pepper, Giovanni Ribisi, Vin Diesel, Adam Goldberg, and Jeremy Davies.
P/S: All uploads are made for the purpose of serving the movie-loving community and do not have any additional purpose. Please enjoy.
The video takes a long time to make, so please subscribe to the channel and press the notification bell to know as soon as we upload it to the channel.
Because we do community purposes, we need your support. You can support us to maintain the channel via Patreon: patreon.com/RecapMovies
Thank you!
YOU CAN WATCH THIS MOVIE "SAVING PRIVATE RYAN" (1998), THROUGH OUR WEBSITE IN OUR BIO
NO SPANK YOU.
@@roccobavero332 ???
Thank you for sharing the movie title
Edelleen loistava Elokuva
1998…time flies
That was the exact moment when Dominic Torretto learned the value of family!
I think he learned about the value of family when he tried to save that little girl... Didn't work out too well
@@gunnison3681 At least he got that letter to his father, also, these guys are seasoned all the way from prob North Africa, 100% Sicily landings and Italian campaign. Shameful they got that far and France was their end.
Why he with them he biracial
@@haroldbrown893that was a stupid question the army didn’t differentiate and keep any other race but blacks in there own units everyone else was together Hispanics whites asians well except for the Japanese they all got locked up for Pearl Harbor
It fambly
I had a first sergeant say, "If the soldiers are complaining, then they are happy. It's when they stop complaining that you start to worry about them."
Explain the logic behind that statement? I don’t get it 😅
@@ILoveBinBandits even when everything is going great, people with have some complaints. People generally only stop voicing their complaints when they start contemplating doing something about them.
We started processing the quiet one for Section 8....First Sgt was completely coorrect.....usually was....
@@ILoveBinBandits zebschreiber is correct it means they lack care for a change for the better. they have given up and have lost the fight its a sad truth to it. you become a lability to your fellow soldiers.
In the Navy the saying was,
"An enlisted sailor's natural state is complaining, if they're complaining they're content. If they ever stop complaining it means they're plotting something and it's time to start worrying."
The real story is honestly more insane. Fredrick Fritz Niland, air dropped the night before DDay, fought with his comrades for 5 days behind enemy lines, eventually earning a bronze star with valor for his actions. No special mission was sent to save him. Instead they assumed him dead along with his 3 brothers. It was only after a brutal 5 days of fighting that him and his unit reconnected with US forces where he later learned of his brothers deaths. He was then ordered stateside because it has been since the end of the American Civil War a policy that should siblings be deployed to war and any of them are killed, the surviving siblings be returned to attend funeral services if possible. And should all but 1 sibling perish, then said sibling is not allowed to return to front line service for a period of no less than 6 months and even then can only return to front line combat with the express permission of their family and their chain of command. Private Niland would serve the rest of the war as an MP in New York with few notable events happening during his tenure as an MP. He was able to attend his brothers funerals at Arlington. Fredrick, the youngest of the 4 brothers, lived to the age of 63, dying in 1983, 15 years before the film based on his family's tragedy would be made.
Two childhood friends of mine, brothers, were in the artillery and getting ready to deploy to the first gulf war. Younger brother had his orders rescinded because of this policy. He was not a happy camper.
@@edwardskeva9307 The policy doesn't apply during war or national emergency as declared by congress, and is voluntary. If the younger brother's orders were rescinded he requested it.
The sole survivor policy wasn't officially enacted until 1948. It was brought about by a series of events during World War II.
Four of the Borgstrom brothers were killed within a few months of each other in 1944 and the parents petitioned successfully to have the fifth brother sent home and the sixth brother who was not yet old enough for the draft to be exempted from it.
Two of the Butehorn brothers were killed and the army air forces opted to send the third state side over it.
The case of the Niland brothers you described. However, his unit didn't "reconnect" he was taken prisoner and held in Burma and later when the camp was liberated he was discovered to still be alive.
Every single Sullivan brother was killed in the war.
US DoD Directive 1315.15 "Special Separation Policies for Survivorship"It is an entirely voluntary policy in which the service member or their family must apply for it, it is not automatic, but it cannot be denied. Bolding is emphasis mine. "4.1.1. Enlisted members who become surviving sons or daughters after having enlisted or after having been inducted *may apply* for and promptly *shall be* discharged or separated
except under the following circumstances:"
@jacobcombs1106 you are mistaken. Niland was never in Burma nor was he fighting the japanese. Niland landed over France and its specifically stated in his record that he and his unit carried out operations against the germans for 5 days before reconnecting with the US Army. He was never captured, and he especially was never sent half away around the world to Burma.
@jacobcombs1106 1. yes they do apply during war time. 2. despite their names. The Global War On Terror was not a declared war. Congress never declared war on Iraq or Afghanistan. All operations in the middle east have been carried out under the same legal pretense that took us to Vietnam. A war in all but name and therefore a war in all but official policy.
"specially you reiben" 😂
Funny that Reiben was the only one to survive at the end 😂, apart from Ryan and Upham
@@edgarmedina300 and Upham didn't deserve to live. But I'm assuming the point was to show that war isn't fair.
@@poppinlochnesshopster3249 That might be a little harsh. Upham wasn't a ranger and wasn't a rifleman, he served in a non combat role. He was conscripted into the squad for the sole purpose of translating.
@@thaneoffife6904 It's definitely harsh, especially by today's much softer standards, but he was still a man in a war, he had completed combat training, he was a coward and got people killed while failing to even deliver a single bit of ammo to anyone, then senselessly shooting a defenseless POW near the end to try to take some of the burden off of his soul for failing so badly. He was a shithead.
@@poppinlochnesshopster3249 I'm sure some of the guys back then went over seas but prayed they wouldn't see combat. I guarantee you there was probably a situation here and there that resembled Uphams... not backing what he did but also not looking down on it either
"Anybody wanna answer that"
I just realized that this is a typical teachers answer to drive up a discussion. RIP Miller
Yup, that is the hint about Miller civilian job. He was a good teacher.
Seen this movie atleast 20 times in my life. Never noticed. Thats a great catch buddy
"Now pay attention, this is the way to gripe"
@@King-ci8sk Me too, so obsessed in this Movie. "He's good" love that catch.
Adam Goldberg: "he's good... "
Vin Diesel: " I am Groot.."
😂
Iam dead😂
Your nothing without family😂
Tom Hanks: *”WILSON!!!”*
Dom's grandpa understood family and changed everything for how things were done in this hood back home
For this movie , the stars alighned , great character writing , with a very thoughtful premise and the direction of the goat Steven Spielberg, and top of thier game actors .
Spielberg is not the goat at all
@@anthonyinzerillo2804 one of , hes definitely up there . If you don't agree you don't know what a directors job is
@@nihaalsandim9986 Spielberg has made a lot of mass appealing and financially successful movies (Jurassic Park, The Terminal..) some really great ones (ET, Raiders of the Lost Ark, Catch me if you can, Jaws) and a lot of trash (Ready Player One, Warhorse, Hook, Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull, The BFG...).
Most of the movies he was involved don't have particular genius on the part of the director and only few of his movies are artistically outstanding.
Just compare Spielberg to Scorsese, Kurosawa, Kubrick, Fellini, Godard, Renoir or Bergman (and many other great directors). Huge difference. Guy is not even in the top30 and far away from being goat...
@@anthonyinzerillo2804bro really said the bfg is bad opinion doesn’t matter
@@anthonyinzerillo2804Jaws, Et, Saving Private Ryan, Raiders of the lost Ark, Jurassic Park are some of the most fun, famous and great movies ever made.
What sorta stuff u smoking over their?😅😅?
Jaws alone puts him in GOAT status ?
“Gripes go up shit comes down”
So when my wife complains to me, is that gripes going up or shit coming down?
@@Hunpecked Do you command her or does she command you?
@@HunpeckedHonestly, I don't think any married man WANTS to answer that...
@@Hunpecked it's shit coming down. If it's gripes going up then she may leave you
This shit is a pyramid since time immemorial
I still remember the words of one of my gunny’s while I was in the Marines. “A bitching Marine is a happy Marine, when he stops bitching he’s either going do something about it or has already done it.”
Partially correct.
Or he has given up and is in a state of disconnect where he is now a liability to unit coherence /success!
Jez hasn't some one out there EVER actually been an NCO /leader???
@@stephencolley334 That falls under the umbrella they set up.
Are you alright?
I've barely been through these comments and that's twice I've seen you picking fights over essentially inconsequential details while prognosticating doom all over the state of our armed forces.
Only true in America, really;
Keep your soldiers unhappy, but not *_TOO_* unhappy - until they become a vet, at least.
Another play on that phrase "take care of your men and they'll take care of you, don't take care of your men and they'll TAKE CARE of you"
@@stephencolley334😂 🤡
I learned so much watching this movie. As an Army NCO I kept in mind that gripes go up not down. Never let your subordinates hear you gripe about the mission. It’s horrible for morale and it makes the leader seem incompetent and incapable of demonstrating resiliency in leadership.
My only question is:
How did you get to NCO without understanding this to begin with?
It took a freaking movie for you to figure it out?
Crap! With leadership (NCO's are the backbone of leadership) like this, our military is in deeper trouble than I thought!
@@stephencolley334 it was a lesson that learned from watching the movie guy. I never heard anyone explain it like this before. It stuck that’s all I’m saying.
@@stephencolley334 Nothing was stated about the sequence of events, my dude.
@@stephencolley334
The real question is why you feel compelled to be an asshole??
Everyone HAS to be critic on line.
@@stephencolley334good. I couldn't care less about US military. Your country dont exists without wars, conflicts etc.
I never understood this as a kid, but as a adult it all so clear
Understood what;?
This scene?
Or the whole film?
@Andy-ub3ub lol tbh probably the whole film, but this scene . How it's unprofessional to gripe to your subordinates, spewing bs to your bosses
@@Capthrax1 away fron this clip, did you notice the words carved in the wooden post above uphams head when mellish is being killed upstairs.
@@Andy-ub3ub no i didnt.
@@Capthrax1 ok. Its a really long story, an i dont wanna bore you with it, but it says comfortable street in french.
I always get interested when people say they understand this film thats all.
Am I the only one who thought Vin Diesel was like100% Italian when this movie came out?
What a career he's had since saving Private Ryan!
Vin Diesel is 100% whatever race he wants to be
FAMILY!
@@ksaechao97 he's everyone's family haha
I mean they did call him Caparzo.
i thought hes furyan 😜
The frequent use of "Sir" and the detailed clarification of everything being staked on such a mission (his life and the lives of his men) IS the gripe, incidentally. He's not sucking up in this hypothetical situation. He's making his objections known while giving himself the cover to say he *wasn't* arguing with his superior officer.
Between the lines, y'know.
😂 I noticed this "this is an excellent mission "cur" 😅😂
My thoughts exactly 💯
To be honest, I missed that. Very nicely done.
I thought the use of sarcasm was obvious.
Right. He’s saying, “Yea I’ll do it even though it’s dumb”.
"ONI thinks that a deployment of a Spartan Team is a gross misallocation of valuable resources. I disagree" - Colonel Holland
(Sorry had to edit it for some people)
That’s exactly what I was thinking
Good god. It fits perfectly.
I for one feel heartfelt sorrow for the mother of pvt.Jenkins and am willing to lay down my life and the lives of noble team, especially you Kat, to ease her suffering.
And retrieve him for further study aboard the Mona Lisa.
Is a gross misallocation*
Not trying to nitpick you, just wanted to flesh out the whole quote 😅
@@KazzoKiller3890 get a load of this guy 🤓
Probably the greatest movie (about war) ever made. 110% emotion, all the way through.
My dad's uncle was a DS during the war (ww2) and I talked to him about this movie one day when I was still a teenager who thought he knew everything.
I asked him what he thought about this movie waaay back in the 90s when it came out.
That grizzled old man got REAL serious instantly and I could see his eyes fix on something in the distance as he stood there thinking about another life and time...
"...too real." I heard him whisper and his eyes glazed over as his mind catapulted to a place and time I could only imagine.
Over 30 years since that moment in his living room, and now I understand so much that ignorant teen never could.
"Thank you for your service, Uncle Marvin Grant."
You are deeply loved and deeply missed....
This is an incredibly important piece of wisdom for commanders
Let's also add to the fact that the captain is on the front lines leading his troops
Tom Sizemore was a glue that pieced together every scene of this movie. All the way to the end. Rest in peace, Tom.
He was being drug tested daily, was told if he failed one time he'd be fired and would have to pay his own way home.
@@scottposey1793 Damn... I didn't know that...
Instant classic,one of his best movies
Crap movie
@@dobbersanchez1185okay.
Funny enough, Reiben is one of the few that live.
@no1bandfan, Other than Ryan and Upham, the only one, IIRC.
there was still a lot more war happening after the Battle of Ramelle. he could have very well died before Germany surrendered. Imagine that, going through what Reiben went through to save Private Ryan and he still dies in combat before the war ends.
@@TheBarber5550 Well practically his whole unit died trying to complete this mission, I wouldn't think it's impossible that he got a ticket home for this, especially considering how important the mission was to begin with, not to mention the trauma this may or may not have caused.
@@98cents ehh idk, he probably would have got something like a Silver Star and a promotion. If we're going with real world scenario, he probably was seen as a valuable asset on the frontline as a good soldier.
You get sent home because your skills are valuable to train the next to fight, or because you're injured. Not getting sent home as a pat on the head for a job well done.
Tom Sizemore's smirk is priceless as was he
Agreed. RIP
Especially you Reiben.... I love that line.
Tom Hanks sounds like Denzel Washington giving these lines.
Good ear
I usually don't like Hollywood movies about WW2 because of how ridiculous they are, but this is a straight up masterpiece and one of the greatest war movies of all time hands down
Even though there's the usual final showdown, the movie also defies the typical arc and opens hard with D-Day then follows just one squad through all the chaos to save one man.
Yup.
Tom Hanks has always been one of my favorite actors
The greatest thing about this entire movie is the unique grainy & faded color lenses he used ❤
It makes it feel dark & gloomy even when the sun is out
Sizemore is in need of his fix. Amazed me he made it all the way. But he kept his end of the bargain.
Yes he did! A great actor! Too bad drugs took him out not long after this movie! Such a waste!
Great movie. One of Tom Hanks best movies.... only my opinion.
It's not an opinion...it's a fact.
@dickgrayson4325 trust me, I've been corrected for viewing my opinion. That's why I say, " Only my opinion." I agree with you, it's Tom Hanks' best movie.
Has he done anything else that doesn't stink? This movie sucks too, chauvinist just love chauvinism, and this movie allows them to confuse their obsessive love of the US with film
That's how he got to be a captain....😂
" ...especially you, Rieben." 😁 Too good.
Gripes just become more technical and eloquent with rank.
Spoken like a true english teacher
“Especially you Riben” 😂
To me it’s a compliment to be handpicked. It’s your own fault for being too good. Curse of a gift.🎁
The sarcasm admitting from this man is amazing
emitting*
@@jacobcombs1106eminating
One of my favorite scenes in the whole movie. It was so fluid and great chemistry between everyone.
Best ww2 movie to this day
You haven't seen cross of Iron have you?
@@CuchulainAD I haven’t. What war and time period is it based on?
@@VaderzBane WW2 eastern front. Sam Peckinpah directed it.
One of the best movies, period.
It was good, I prefer The Thin Red Line
r.i.p. tom sizemore.
“You should know that as a Ranger.” 💯Always teaching.
Biehn is easily one of my most favorite action stars. Glad to hear he's happy and healthy.
I learned all the way back in Jrotc before I join3d the corp this -
Gripes go up the chain, but BS only goes down the chain. So make your gripes count and your BS better be worth it
"Complain about the mission sir?"
"I can't I am your superior officer l"
"Pretend I'm your superior officer, do you have any complaints about this mission?"
It's a chat gpt break before it's time.
This is the all time best war movie! I have watched it countless time and still whenever it comes on screen couldn't resist watching it to the end!
"Reiben pay attention. This is the way to gripe"
It sure is the gold standard.
the thompson looks dope asf
IRL the “real” Private Ryan was forced to go back home, however not all his brothers died. One survived in a Japanese POW camp and was returned home after the war
The POW was presumed dead, at the time.
They did NOT send a small squad behind enemy lines to get.
An enlisted man with a jeep. Not that the driver took no risk, there was a war going on. But they wouldn't have done this IRL.
Still, great movie.
@@corbinmcnabbactually it’s very common to be sent on missions like this with very vital side missions such as recon, battlefield reporting, search and destroy, planting mines and explosives, blowing bridges etc etc. remember this was in a time before satellites and current electronics used for logistics.
@@Winddancer1991 Recon, search and destroy et al, sure.
But not JUST an extraction of a PFC.
They might have done it for a general, or some politically important person.
@@corbinmcnabb right, that’s where the movie got kind of cheesy because they didn’t have any other motive. Hell the directors could’ve even said that they were going there to get Ryan, and relieve his company off the front until further assessment and reinforcements came.
@@Winddancer1991 It felt like a commentary and a tour of the war after the D-Day scene which would've been hard to narratively introduce any other way while it also seems like they didn't want to lead up to a big final battle.
GREAT SCENE GREAT FILM
Shit film
They don’t make conversations like these anymore for modern films… now it’s all just filled with quips, banters, squeeze in forced laughter, etc.
This is banter?
This is all banter
No, they still do. You’ve just been watching garbage by the sounds of it.
@@whothehellarewe I’m convinced everyone who makes these kinds of complaints only watches blockbuster hollywood films because they wouldn’t be saying it otherwise.
I believe that this whole scene was essentially adlib. I think Spielberg as the cast to just talk amongst themselves as their characters during some downtime. (May have been for other scenes as well) while it was being recorded. The cast wasn't sure about it but crested some banter with some suggestions for topics.
The next day they were given a new script page with the banter written in to be filmed.
When he says “ anybody want to answer that ? “ is the first indication of him being a school teacher
like so many others I saw this in theaters. a nearly new Showcase Cinema with a huge screen and what sounded like an illegal sound system. I was dead center in that theater. looking straight ahead I could only see war. after that
opening beach landing scene (that seemed like it lasted forever.) I was shaken. I could feel my hands sweating and shaking. my ears were ringing. my heart was pounding. I thought to myself that if I was that mentally and physically
effected by that one scene I couldn't even begin to imagine what an 18yo kid must've been going through actually being there? those soldiers have my utmost respect, appreciation and gratitude.
The funny thing is Vin Diesel was a last minute edition, and the script was finalized, so they snuck his chatacter in where it would not interfere with the story. This was why he was one of the first killed off
Spielberg wanted him in the movie.
They edited vin diesel last minute?
@@dobbersanchez1185more like a last minute addition to the cast and a couple tiny last minute additions to the script.
God how I miss my grandparents. The greatest generation.
They rock up with this multi-million dollar cast, all acting to be regular joe's and kids from the bronx. The unsung heroes bla bla bla. Americans love this hero stuff.
RIP Tom Sizemore...your suffering is healed ✝️
God is stupid
The best war movie ever
And Ryan lived a long great life thanks to these men.
That there is the beauty of leadership
The interesting part of this movie is why an infantry captain leads a squad to a high risk mission behind enemy lines directly after dday. A second Lt. Would've been sufficient for this role.
And no comm! Just out traipsing around in enemy territory
That's where Dominic learnt, it's all about family!
Seen 100 times for this Captain . 👍
This was a glorious movie, but so painful ultimately that I could only watch it once.
That "Especially you Reiben" goes so har.d
It’s been so long since I’ve watched this movie that I forgot Vin Diesel was in it.
Tom Sizemores face 😂. Rest in peace, sir.
Fish: He's good.
Carpy: I love him.
Fish: 😊
Carpy: 😙
Always one of my favorite scenes. As military and a NCO/SNOIC i relate to tom hanks as with staying afloat while keeping my marines well. Also i always made my marines geuss my homestate and what i did before 😅
Being an NCO must be cool, we're you ever been on a deployment?
Tom Sizemore involuntary and indirectly showing off his cocaine addiction, by rubbing his nose. Great actor none the less. A real pity we lost him so early.
It's the
"I love him" that sold it
Would you believe that Ridick was present in that scene.
Remarkable warrior.
I love the old day. Muzzle control wasn’t as important as fire control. Sweeping someone was looked down on but didn’t alarm us. Where did all those who think bike helmet are so necessary come from?
Reiben had a good point.
Cpt. has a good point also
cause he gripes to his superiors above him.
I have this DVD it's a great movie
This lesson should be learned in all types of trade. If you’re griping to the people who work under you how do you expect them to follow you when the job needs to be done?
Now that's a True Leader exhibiting Real Leadership ❤❤❤❤
That one casing stuck in the bolt of Ryan’s gun was the only thing I could focus during that entire short.
Well said Capt.
Rip Tom Sizemore
Not all of this movie is well, but some scenes are true art. Like this one: It explaines one of the key principles or any hirararchical big organisation in most of it´s nuances in a minute.
Bro must have been part of Doms family for him to say “I love him” 😅
when he asked: "anybody wanna answer that", was clear he was a teacher.
funniest part of the movie was where they told the wimp not to salute the CAPTAIN in the field yet the CAPTAIN had shiny silver bars for the whole world to see mounted on his helmet.
Damnnnnn Miller, throw that shade at Reiben 😂
This movie is just packed with greatness. Even the small talk on a long patrol.
Just realized.. this Reiben guy is Lt. Turner in COD when he was young 😮
Great dialogue great actor great scene great movie!! Saving Private Ryan
Hanks should of got Best Actor Academy for Saving Private Ryan.
This deserved Academy award for Best Movie too.
I just realized where the inspiration for some cod ww2 characters came from
Well looks like i gotta rewatch the whole movie again
I would have also said, "Out of all the teams you could have chosen, we are the only ones capable of completing such a mission."
Easily one of my favorite movies all time
Later Vin Diesel's character is shot and his final thoughts are of his father. He never stops thinking about family.
Humor is the best way to get thru a shitty mission.
Remind me of that sarcastic conversation with Walker and Chruch COD Finest Hour when they are looking for the bridge
"Pay attention, this is the way you gripe"
Dom learned a lot from his grandfather’s experience in WW2, mostly that family is everything.
Superb actors!
Vin Diesel turns up in the oddest places.
Yer hes good and everyone loves him
I like that the squad directly addresses the biggest plot hole in the movie. It was a very bad misallocation of resources 😄
He was being sarcastic. Saying its stupid to waste the lives of his men for 1 guy in a formal way.
One of the greatest world War 2 movies ever made thank you Tom Hanks 🙏🏼👊🏻👏🏼🫡 the other being Schindlers list which surprisingly I found out Tom Hanks was also involved in production