Taking Advantage
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 มี.ค. 2023
- The plaintiff says the defendant is her former landlord, who she claims is keeping her security deposit without cause. The defendant says the plaintiff painted the walls dark brown and damaged them, so he owes nothing because he has to repaint.
Case #27346
#PeoplesCourt #RealityTV #Court - บันเทิง
The Defendants seem like decent people
They did seem nice, but he did lie to the judge. Totally honest people don't do that.
I don't think he ever really knew which color it was but the wife knew the original color was white like she had chosen it.
@payableondeath9091 The defendants were nice, except that both the husband and wife tried to cover being caught in a lie.
When you paint the walls a different color, it is usually with the landlord permission and must be painted back to the original color when you vacate the rental property.
Why is judge trying to find a reason to help the plaintiff get her money? It is a straighforward case - clearly written into the contract. She should have held him to his first offer of $650 - those walls were ruined. I am surprised it didn't cost the entire security amount.
Because JM likes to rule based more on her feeling in the moment as opposed to facts
@@angelakurik3436umm that’s not true. She is literally let him know to NOT lie in his statement.
@@angelakurik3436 Don't be a child, both sides were less than truthful, and the fact that Judge Milian went thru and caught the defendants in a lie hurt the amount of the security deposit that they were allowed to withhold.
After 6 years he would have had to paint it anyway. That's definitely what Judge Judy would have said.
Yes, and no. When you are a heavy smoker inside it needs much more cleaning and painting in a different way than from just regular daily living
Do you know how hard it is to get rid of the smoke residue from inside of a house and the smell she should not have gotten any money none at all
not that bad unless someone is sensitive to every single smell on earth. most of that in the pictures looked like orange mold, orange
Aspergillosis, a lot of people confuse it for tar residue.
Yes ,I agree. I've been in the renovation business home and business ... Some people just don't understand how much third hand smoke gets on everything and how hard it is to clean. Smokers loose their sense of smell and taste buds too.
@@Anglynn74 she smoked in the house for 6 years it's really bad
@@spacepanda9037 I smoked in my house for 20 yrs, my family smoked in their homes for well over 40 yrs, never stained never stunk, blinds never turned yellow walls never changed color. This landlord is yet another one who SPENT the security deposit, it's a textbook case.
@@Anglynn74 yeah right lmfao I've been in plenty of smokers homes and you can tell by the smell and the walls you an your family members according to you are the only expectations okay lmfao you can even smell it on y'all's clothes
He's absolutely right, if you smoke it will turn the walls brown around the pictures not to mention the smell.I advise if you smoke don't smoke in your house it runs everything.
I’m a smoker but refuse to smoke in our house.
I always go outside to our covered deck or into our heated (50 degree) garage during our well below freezing temperatures.
I also refuse to smoke in my wife’s car out of respect for her.
The windows in my car or our pickup are always cracked (we have window vents on all 3 of our vehicles so that the rain and snow can’t get into our vehicles).
Every 2 years our vehicles are professionally cleaned and detailed on the interiors to rid them of smells.
That is very honorable of you. I’ve been with my bf 7 years and he knows how sensitive I am to cigarette smoke. He uses my car often and I’ve always felt like it smelled like smoke but thought I must be wrong. I ended up catching him smoking in the car the other day,he’s been smoking in it the entire time and telling me he wasn’t.
@@AtonalApple It’s not my business, but if he’s dishonest with you about him smoking in your car, then what else is he deceptive with you about?
If I ever say or do anything that I shouldn’t have, I own up to it.
I’m very selective on who I allow into my life. If they’re dishonest, they’re gone.
I’ve been secretly stashing money back and a couple of weeks ago my wife found my stash (in my nightstand). She asked me about it, so as always I was truthful about it and told her that I’d been saving money as I could to buy her something as a gift just bc I love her.
I’m thinking about a pair of Diamond ear rings.
ADVICE: 1. Take pictures before you move into a place or someone moves into your place 2. Make sure you read the lease carefully and have everything in writing 3. Anytime anything is going to change (like the fence/gate in this case) you get it in writing..
I bet the apartment was white and the plaintiff (as an ex-smoker) had enough experience to know that white paint turns yellow/brown with smoke. She must have thought that the cocoa-brown paint would hide the yellowing caused by smoke; and she would have been wrong.
This old woman wouldn't know the truth if it bit her on her lying back side.
I guess you missed the part where the defendant first said the walls were brown when she moved in. Seems they both tell stories.
1) should always take pictures before and after
2) any modification to property must be approved first
Tenants should stop with the "" Sense Of Entitlement"" regardless of how long you are there, you are a renter, she struck me as that type, but Judge Milian upset me in this case, instead of wasting so much time focusing on the paint color change, like the landlord why were all the holes, in the walls, she is far too old for children, so was there domestic violence, what happened and we never got the reason 😡
she likely hung pictures like most people do, and then tried to cover it because landlords go ape shit over the smallest holes in the walls, she was screwed either way he'd sue her for that as well. all he had to do & grab some good grit and sand it down but those paneled walls will be ripped out anyway. He likely spent the deposit & doesn't have it anymore & is likely having trouble selling it, this is textbook, a lot of them do this shit.
She had a great reason to talk about the painted walls, for the plaintiff did not have permission and was to return the walls to original state. Every lease states that. And who says her adult children are too old or herself to put holes in the walls. Even when you hang stuff and make holes with nails, you are to return the rental to original states, by putting the holes that were made by the nails. Gues you have never rented a place, or never rented out property.
I'm a nonsmoker and I would never take an apartment where a previous smoker lived without the entire place having been cleaned of the nicotine. In the pictures it is very clear the plaintiff was a heavy smoker.
nicotine doesn't leave stains, that's not where the stains come from. Tar does it. Nicotine is a stimulant. If I spill my soda I'm not going to say the caffeine stained my rug.
Don't listen to her she also stated under my comment that she smoked in her house for 20 years an her other family members smoked in their homes for 40 years an she had no build up or smell lmfao she lying you can stand next to someone outside that smokes and smell that they are smokers based on their clothing alone but according to this person lol it doesn't effect the house lmfao
@@spacepanda9037 so you' actually think nicotine stains walls? just want to make sure that's what you concur with.
@@Anglynn74 and also ‘SpacePanda90’ should learn how to punctuate his/ her comments because it’s hard to understand what he/she wants to say.
My Father smoked 2 packs a day and my Mother was always having to wash the curtains among other things.
Jesus, the paint color does not matter. Let it go Judge. She smoked and put holes in the walls.
The wall color was a very important part of the case because if she painted it brown when the walls were originally white, she would’ve been responsible for painting the rooms back to the original color. That would then mean that the landlord could have had the right to keep back more of the security deposit due to brown having to be covered with multiple layers of paint. She got on the plaintiff and defendant on their lies. She handled this case fairly.
I'm in Love with THE COCO🤣🤣🤣
All I can hear is that song🤦🏾♀️🤦🏾♀️
Or coo coo for coco puffs
That plaintiff must have married a Sasquatch. Her daughter is a foot taller than her.
Tenants should always check with the landlord before painting or making any repairs on the apartments.
today yes, year sago it wasn't like that, most tenants painted & carpeted apartments, smoked inside, put down contact paper etc. Only in the last 20 yrs have landlords not allowed tenants to do anything on these places.,
True
Exactly
Always get permission in writing
being a land lord is hell! There are no longer good tenants. the laws in ALL north east states are anti land lord. not do it.
It was white, but nicotine turned it coco 😝
🤣🤣
the tar in the cigarette does it, not nicotine, nicotine doesn't leave stains it's a stimulant. That would be like saying caffeine stained my table when I spilled my coca cola.
@@Anglynn74 girl you on every comment lmfao
@@spacepanda9037 is there a quota here? by all means fill me on on what it is...girl.
@@Anglynn74 it was a facetious comment not to be taken scientifically 😁
Judge, I don’t know about now, but under WA state law every time a tenant moves out after at least a year, the landlord must repaint the interior of the property.
Same in Arizona.
In Ohio it's not required for Landlords to paint their rental units. In some cities it is, but other than that they aren't required by any means...
@@jaynebutler3342 Actually in Arizona it's only in certain cities they're required to do so.
See in NY law a rental unit is to be painted every 3 years by law he would have had to paint twice on his dime if he was in NY.
Who paints there walls brown!? Thats not a good choice. The landlord seems to be a good person who is one of the good ones and the plaintiff is in the wrong here.
When we bought our house they had painted the hallway DARK chocolate brown with black floors and no Windows.... needless to say, we repainted....
IT WAS COCO 😂😂
Yes, that spakle is ridiculous. That looks horrible. Of COURSE they have to repaint it.
There's a store called desantas where I live , And you can buy what's called A chem sponge ( good size) And it takes nicotine and cigarette smoke off of walls furniture everything , For like 20$, i used to clean fire and smoke damage for a company rhat goes in after a house fire And we use them all the time, they work. Great and it's not hard to get off the walls. And the store is open to anyone not just contractors and Companies, What i'm saying is if he's "in the business " Then he should be able to find a cheaper easier way To clean Nicotine stains off of the walls.What landlord doesnt have pictures b4 someone rents from you?! Who lives there for 9 years and doesn't have any pictures that may prove the wall color in the background atleast ?!🤔
We're in the same situation. On a month to month lease after being in the house for 10 years. Our landlord wants paint the house, replace the carpet, and do some repairs beforehand. We've been giving two 30 day notices over the past 6 months and in both cases we've been allowed to stay in the house beyond the 30 days. The painting and carpet hasn't been addressed since we moved into the house.
Check the laws in your state each state says after x amount of years the carpets have to be replaced..mine for instance says each 8 years it must be replaced
doug dealin chipper shade. doug so shady.
The plaintiffs voice sounds like Joe Pesci's in "Goodfellas".
Even though I know Judge Milan's family did construction, she was wrong about it 'taking many coats of paint to go over brown with white.' Sorry Judge, but It doesn't. It only takes one extra quick coat of a fast-drying white primer/sealer - such as BIN - NOT multiple coats, and no matter what the colors are. Again, since these primer/sealers dry so fast - only 15 minutes or so - the painter could only bill the customer a couple few hours at best for their labor (per room), for the cost of the extra coat of paint being applied, along with the additional primer.
SpACkle😂
Extremely handsome defendant wow 😍
Really?!🤔
@@wynottgivemore9274 yeah masculine average Joe's are the best
Yeah......no.
I'll never understand why the word ask is so hard for so many people to pronounce. Just say ass then add a K at the end. An axe is something you use to chop down a tree, not to inquire about something.
Man, her dentures did not fit her mouth
Smokers destroy apartments
It must be the coco
Great job judge you definitely let the defendant explain himself.....
Cocoa Brown. Aounds like a strippers name. Lol
Didn't give me enough time to move
You got 30 days
Honestly, I think she doesn't know the meaning of that word.
Not giving her money for the fence🕵" l would have moved it and trash especially after l didn't buy the house
after six years, the average amount of time you should paint your walls is probably 20 to 25 years.
Six years thats laughable, what she thinks its every two years?
Twenty to twenty five years is laughable.
I’m getting 5 to 10 years you should re-paint the walls in your home upon research. 20 sounds way too long.
Noal wear and tear is NOT the renters responsibility. Six years requires repair for new apartment lease.
New York accents are so grating. 🫠
I bet a thousand bucks the judge is a landlord.
She is. She has stated that.
@@barbarat5729 I say that because as a "judge" she has clear bias.
Bad teacher 58
Judge is hot as f!
losing his sh*t over spackle on PANELING...grow up, that panling will be ripped out anyway. go take sanding paper and SAND IT DOWN. it's not that hard. This is another guy who likely doesn;t have the security anymore, spent it. When they fight this hard over petty garbage it's GONE
Too all these people advising to take sand paper and sand the spackle ...NO!!! I've done home repairs,finish carpentry for years. If you simply want to remove the spackle or drywall mud that someone has mistakenly put on the wall or whatever... Take a pail of soapy warm water and a flannel cloth ,dampen the cloth slightly wring it out and go over the spot or spots. Let the water soak in and continue the process of lightly rubbing the cloth over until gone.,what you should be left with ,is just a white spot where thehole once was. Spackle dissolves with water. This only works ,if no one has painted over it.
I’m sorry. But she sounds like a smoker and that sounds like the Coco Brown was from cigarette smoke.
Plaintiffs daughter is 🔥.
U like that eh?
It has always bothered me why white is the default color, for the inside of 99.9 percent of all dwellings, when it is the most easiest color over an extended period of time to become dirty, and my assumption is that most property owners do that on purpose, to keep a certain percentage of a tenants, security deposit, the overseer is always attempting to gain leverage, in contracts, that way, and then label it as good business, when it truly only equates to what is considered, A LICENSE TO STEAL, SMH💯
It’s because white can go with any decor or style more or less. That makes it more marketable
@@kkallsop We - a light gray would work just as well, they both being neutral colors, so not believing that one, what i'm really interested in knowing , and maybe I need Google for my answer, but I am under the impression as people began to think, in terms of modern housing, because prior to that i'm assuming prior to that happening, the inside of housing related, to the log cabin being that is where i'm assuming it all started, i'm just more curious as, drywall and sheet rock began coming into play, as a part of the dynamic, what made white the default color, just curiosity more than anything you know💯
Always a conspiracy theory, right? Put the crack pipe down and listen to yourself. You sound absolutely crazy right now. Literally speechless here. Buy your own house/townhouse if you don’t want to have to deal with a landlord. That simple
Because white is the easiest color to cover up. Most other colors require more coats to cover completely.
@@keyeviondavis9647 But gray doesn’t match everything. If tenants have tan furniture it will clash
landlords are always greedy, I hope she wins!.... smoking inside??Gross!
Nnb
Harvey ,just gave people great free advice .. I have to say judge. Marilyn is more fair than Judge Judy. Judge Judy would give people $5000 for crazy things but then she would complain about people on Social Security blah blah blah blah. I don’t know why they canceled the show. They should’ve canceled Judge Judy ,Justice Judy. Cause of justice Judy she’s allowed to give them $10,000 now.
Nothing beats ownership of a home. Renting is for losers because you stay going through shit like this. Life's way too short to be dealing with all this. Gotta live easy out here
Buying a house in this economy is big NO. Plus not everyone can afford to buy a home and just because they can’t, doesn’t make them losers. Your comment is definitely classist
renting after owning is better, when landlords give you excuses you can tell when they're handing you bullshit. Plus the older you get you no longer care about owning anymore, it's not as big of a deal as it was when you were younger, you don't have to deal with all the repairs garbage, it's actually very liberating.
@@lupinaocean4326 mr Prince was gifted a home after his mum died, that’s why he has a house, would be a different story if he had to get a mortgage like the rest of us🙄🙄🙄🙄
there are advantages and disadvantages to both