And so wrong. Shes harping on trying to make the point the Dr cant rule out the cause of the injury but all shes done is make the dr say over and over and over again that in his EXPERT opinion, it was very unlikely the vodka bottle did the damage. She did a PISS POOR job. He sounded 100% credible, she sounded desperate.
@@stephen2583 the questions are designed to lower his credibility, and cannot be taken individually but as a whole. He testified he could not rule out how the finger was injured and he did not take all information into account with determining how it got injured. If he took where it was found and in what environment, his professional opinion might have changed.
She's doing a good job of making Heards lawyers look foolish. It amazes me that they're considered to be a good legal team as they've said some stupid things especially Bredehoft.
@@carloandreaguilar5916 Have you... Have you seen Amber's lawyers? Camille is adored because she's great at her job and doesn't miss a beat, while Elaine and Rottenborn constantly fumble and are unprofessional to an absurd degree at times. All three are lawyers, yet Camille is superior.
So we have psychiatric giving expert diagnoses without ever talking to the patient, and a doctor that can say how an injury was caused without seeing the actual injury…wow
We have some serious telepathic and visionary work here with these experts 🤣 they should teach us all to be more intuitive, imagine if we could all diagnose people or solve accident scenes without ever seeing the person or being on the scene or looking at scene photographs!! Blimey, I am in the wrong business 🙈
I love when Camille says, “That’s not my question”… these people try to go around her questions…and she calls them out. This witness is so rude and arrogant.
In order for Depp’s accusation to be true, the bottle had to magically break before making a landing on his hand and produce a debris sharp enough to severe the tip of his finger with such precision. I believe Johnny Depp. I believe him when he said multiple times on audio recording that he cut his own finger. 😂😂😂
@@MaevaStardust No 🙈 it might be mind blowing to you but glass can and does break on impact and in doing so can cause those injuries. Your suggestion is like saying someone who crashes their car and goes through their window screen won't get cut because the window didn't break before they went through it..
I love Camille so much, she's so brutal and cut-throat in her questioning. She destroys any attempt at avoiding answers with such ease, catches them off guard every time. Absolutely killing it.
Camille Vasquez is a beast! I’d be scared to have any conversation with her about anything - I’d question my own reality. Love how quick and brilliant she is, I have so much respect for her.
@@troyjenkins3886 I appreciate your question and thought it over myself too. Regardless of “winning” the case, her brilliance isn’t diminished. Unfortunately, we have seen that cases can have outcomes regardless of guilt or innocence because of a legal team’s skill or lack thereof.
Well Done Camille, ridiculous that a Dr thinks he can say exactly what could not happen without being their or seeing the injury in real life /time ..totally crazy . Its the opposite to what other medical professionals have said
In order for Depp’s accusation to be true, the bottle had to magically break before making a landing on his hand and produce a debris sharp enough to severe the tip of his finger with such precision. I believe Johnny Depp. I believe him when he said multiple times on audio recording that he cut his own finger. 😂😂😂
@@MaevaStardust as a waiter who has seen many broken bottles, the moment of impact pieces of glass keep going in the same direction, if a bottle falls on a surface that surface can be cut by the pieces of said bottle. At the same time, if a bottle/glass is thrown, some shards will fly in other directions and can also cause cuts
@@MaevaStardust completely untrue, I have accidentally put my hand through a window before and my hand was cut badly at the exact spot that first went through it. Glass can cut you as it breaks
*_Isaiah 55.6 Seek the Lord while He may be found, Call upon Him while He is near. 7 Let the wicked forsake his way, And the unrighteous man his thoughts; Let him return to the Lord, And He will have mercy on him; And to our God, For He will abundantly pardon._* _Only Jesus Christ saves. Repent and be saved. Jesus Christ loves you. God bless you, and peace be upon you and your family in the name of Jesus Christ._ --
He did not testify about the place or circumstances of the injury. Heard's lawyers probably deliberately hid all that information from him, and told him to look just at the injury itself.
*_Isaiah 55.6 Seek the Lord while He may be found, Call upon Him while He is near. 7 Let the wicked forsake his way, And the unrighteous man his thoughts; Let him return to the Lord, And He will have mercy on him; And to our God, For He will abundantly pardon._* _Only Jesus Christ saves. Repent and be saved. Jesus Christ loves you. God bless you, and peace be upon you and your family in the name of Jesus Christ._ --
@@lbabytutorials4852 I wasn't aware they were public defenders. They certainly aren't on the same level as Johnny's team. I obviously don't know Amber, but from my impression of her behavior so far, I think she does everything for the way it looks - she wants to appear to be a poor, helpless victim, even if she says she doesn't. She's extremely manipulative. It's actually pretty scary. I wouldn't want to be in her life.
I don’t ever want to face this women OMG but I love how she put him and AH in there place. Make them question what they are saying!!! You go girl friend!!!!
Camille is so quick and yet modulated. She’s (to 63 year old me) very young… I had nowhere near her confidence and presence at her age. She’s challenging doctors & experts… and intimidating them. She is going to have a great career.
The unfortunate issue is that the majority of lawyers don’t make enough to pay off their student loans, and end up leaving the profession. But if someone has the gifts of witty articulation, abstract problem solving, vast recall, and are very likable & assertive- the sky is the limit. Johnny’s Lead Council, Ben Chew, has basically the most elite credentials and accolades an attorney can have, across the globe. Atop of that, he is dedicated to pro bono work and has won billions for minorities and marginalized groups. It can be an extremely rewarding profession for one motivated to put in 80-100hr work weeks. Camille is a great role model for young women & young men. Much better than any “influencer.” I’m glad this case gives her much deserved exposure.
I'll be graduating in a few months from law school and i follow the trial closely and i absolutely love camillie .She's quick , polite and absolutely amazing.
For those unfamiliar with the legal system, there is an entire industry of “experts” who get paid to testify whatever you want them to say. Their credentials are presented in an online marketplace and you can choose the ones based on your needs. They personally have nothing to do with the case. Their expertise is for sale.
So not only he is a terrible testimony to begin with, but Heard’s attorney didn’t even showed him all the evidence, all the information to properly give an “expert” opinion. What a joke.
That is very disgusting. I think all jurors need to be made aware of this. And the only doctors that should be believed are the ones that were actually there to see/treat a person.
Well...after this i bet all of these so called "experts" are going to ask the same question before they get retained by a client, and the question is : "Is Camille on the other side?"!!!!!
@@GriBlanco There would be a lack of availability in expert opinion (which is usually a key component) in many trials if this were the case. It is very common to have a ballistics expert or a scientist give insight as to why something specifically has happened in their opinion, why is this any different? Is his expertise being disproven here? Yes. However simply not allowing any expert opinion unless they were directly involved doesn't solve anything. You're just getting a verdict without the nuance and expertise of professionals. Imagine the other scenario, we only allow the specific doctor who came to the house to testify. Who would pay for his services if he must remain impartial? What if he specifically was hired by Heard and Depp had no medical expert to represent his side? I understand why you seem frustrated with everything seen in this process, but your simple solution isn't a remedy to the issue.
I don't get it myself! If experts are needed, they should be independent & paid for through an independent authority, even if their (reasonable) fees could be paid through that authority by both parties. How can you expect someone who is repeatedly hired by a client and paid outrageous fees to say anything that might incriminate that client?
He wasn’t even the treating doctor. Nor did he ever see the injury first hand. He should not be there testifying, especially since he is getting a hefty pay. He admitted he has testified for her law firm several times over the past few years. Her firm is a good source of income for him.
@@janeward722 I admire your optimism and I certainly hope you’re right or this will be a scandalous act by the justice system to not see through the obvious lies by Amber.
@@janeward722 no this is going to be very hard to win. Johnny's team are pushing the amber is the abuser narrative hard, which is great, and I do believe it, but it's almost irrelevant. Amber only has to "prove" that at any point Johnny was abusive even if it was a two way street. Johnny has to prove he was not, and proving something didn't happen is ALWAYS harder.
This is my second trial. First one was with the murderer Jodi Arias. I was obsessed with the prosecutor Juan Martínez! He shredded her. I guess Latinos have what it takes
This doctor needs to be investigated and reviewed because he is paid large amounts of money to testify on behalf of the defense. I wonder how much money he accepted to make false testimony and it impacted the ruling. This man didn't even see Johnny Depp injuries , just pictures. How can his testimony be even accepted
Funny thing is, they got all these so called expertise paid doctors . And YET, she NEVER consulted a doctor or seek medical help in ALL HER CLAIMS that she’s been physically assaulted by Johnny over and over again. Professional medical ethics, he never assessed JD on the time of the injury, he wasn’t there when it happened and he never did the surgery on Johnny’s finger. He never assessed him right after the accident and surgery. He based it only via photos and written information given to him. Are doctors allowed to diagnose now by merely looking at the photos without seeing the actual patient????
That’s what I’m asking myself. It’s bugging me that all these doctors are coming out of left field diagnosing JD but they’ve never seen him as a patient of their or have even met with the man at all. How are they getting away with that nonsense
I honestly bet Camille is working around the clock. She is so intentionL, so precise, so specific, and referencing so many pieces that are already in evidence. She is a force to be reckoned with.
@@truthbringer-6748 yes, absolutely. But you can't perform the way that she does, without being a very involved part of the process. And, credit where credit is due - she is absolutely killing it, at the podium. That's worth celebrating. It's a talent, and a skill... and, she is exceptional.
@@missbarbaralove I'm literally giving credit where it's due... To all of them. It's hundreds of pages worth of document and hours of audio and video, she couldn't possibly due all that on her own. Even while she is crushing front stage her team is giving her instructions, handing her notes, finding inconsistencies. It's a well oil machined and most likely Camile isn't doing the lionshare of the dirty work.
Wow, what a joke the legal system is, you can purchase "experts" to come and say BS in your favour. Ridiculous. Well done to Camille for owning another one.
This doctor strikes me as the kind of guy that would have a completely different opinion if the check was coming from Johnny's attorneys instead of Ambers.
that's the whole point AH hired him to disprove Johnny's account of the injury. If he was hired by the court he would have given a neutral opinion with just the facts,
Camille is an incredibly wise, smart , Intelligent and dedicate. compassionate attorney. She did everything she should to find justice for her client. We need more human being like her in all areas. 🙏🏻🙏🏻❤️
Facts are: - He never seen the injury in person - He earned a lot of money from AH - He can't make an accurate diagnosis from pictures or videos That testimony looked very bad.
Amber claimed that he cut it while smashing a phone next to her head, so they are spinning the angle that it couldn't have happened with a thrown bottle, therefore Ambers version must be true.
@@cassiedjandbellaschannel1366 but he's not a witness. He was not present at the time of the incident, nor at the hospital. All he saw was photos of the injury.
The fact that the US allows these “expert” witnesses with people who have nothing to do with the case but use their accreditation and titles to sway the jury is literally mind boggling to me that it’s allowed. Please someone make me me familiar with a time that this was useful?
I believe it's used to discredit the opponents argument. It's easy to say " X did Y" but when somebody is an "expert" in that area is either able to support or eviscerate that statement it would give one side more weight. I'm no lawyer and don't really know much about it but that's just my observation.
Even the fact that they are highly paid to testify. That to me is conflict of interest. $5000 per day in court, he’s fired if he states anything that gives more strength to the “opposition”.
@@freckledmelon And you clearly are a millennial. You use letters like "u" and don't start your sentence with a capitol and are clearly uneducated when it comes to the English language and sentence structure and punctuation. Back to school young lady.
@Jack Shite he embarrassed himself in front of the entire world, I’m following this case from Egypt, and the case is very popular here too! Everyone talks about it, so this is LITERALLY an international embarrassment 😂 And btw, no one here believes her too, people here can spot a liar a mile away
I can’t believe how cool, calm & collected, Johnny Depp has been through all of this trial. To me he has acted like a Gentle Person, throughout it all. He has his own failings with drink & drugs, I can’t see him be aggressive to people!
Maybe he takes valium to stay cool and friendly! He has lost against the SUN because 12 of 14 points against him are true! He is not so innocent! It's proved that the structure of the brain of drug addicts is changing and that drug addicts are not able to control their emotions and that they are hallucinating, what explains, that he was shouting at her and at the same time at a person who was not there!
It is women like Camille Vasquez I would rather trust and admire, and see as the face of women empowerment, rather than somebody who claims to be that face AND abuses men.. That one (you know who) is the face of Narcissism.
@@wiredvibe1678 I mean p*** stars know what they do for a living and don't have any kind of delusions otherwise. As far as I'm concerned they are the face of empowerment because they do what they do and have no issue with what they're doing and they're making mad bank off of it so at least they're not trying to pull the wool over anybody's eyes.
It's a shame they can't use the audio that was recorded following the incident where Amber is heard in the background saying incriminating things like howling "is Johnny okay?", "what have i done", and "I didn't mean to" and basically crying hysterically while Johnny team discuss the incident and aftermath. Obviously it can't be played in court because of the other voices on the tape. But if you listen to it it's obvious what happened.
Omg this attorney is slick I love how she confuses them and just keeps them going and going and then confuses them and then makes them tell the truth team Johnny Depp 100%
@@Contemplativeman101 so his position was lying under oath and telling the story about the injury that Johnny Depp himself never said? It's weird how you think the jury can go either way after watching this lawyer completely dismantle him and destroy his credibility on the stand and expose him for lying about the injury at hand. No pun intended. Do the world a favor and never have a kid. If you can't use your brain and you cannot see the things that happen in front of you for what they are while they're happening you definitely shouldn't put any kind of baby out in the world that will inherit that kind of ignorant point of view just because you don't want to see Amber her get sued for 50 million dollars.
@@Contemplativeman101 The Doc has done nothing wrong, he was asked by Heard's to examine Johnny's injury based upon testimony and pictures they provided to him alone, which is what he testified to. But by not having him actually view Johnny injury diminishes his credibility to provide an accurate assessment. This is more or less the basis of this court action where opinions are formed, judgements made, without being aware of the full facts.
@@Contemplativeman101 Really? I don’t think so If he didn’t review very pertinent information like where blood and chopped finger were found, a broken vodka bottle around the bar area, shape and condition of the bottle etc.. then his whole analysis is pointless to be honest.
@@billdover3165 Exactly, I think the most important of the factors, pictures, conditions were not provided to him even.. he also mistated JD’s positioning of finger and testimony… with all these factors missing he just gave a half assed assessment that has been discredited before he even left the stand.
People say Camille is being cocky or overly aggressive, all she’s doing is her job to get concise answers. If there was nothing to lie about or cover up, her rounds of questions would be over with in quick succession. If someone was being honest in response to rapid questions, it wouldn’t leave much room for anything else other than question and answer.
What people ? The ones who don't like Johnny or the ones who don't like a women who is kicking but in the court room and doing better than most men defe her client who she knows is innocent. Lol
Camille Vasquez, you utter legend! You go girl and rip him a new one!! The arrogance of this doctor is disgusting! Not what we’ve all signed up for when pledging the oath. No matter how good he think he is at his chosen specialty, a doctor stops being a good doctor, when he thinks he knows it all. A good doctor admits that he will learn something new every day of his working life. That’s the beauty of physiology. No two people’s bodies work the same. Interesting to see how much he charges. Why practice hands on medicine, when a piece of paper allows him to charge $5000 per day for his “expert” opinion. Disgrace to his profession!!!😡😡
I do understand the need for expert testimony, but this so-called expert is highly payed by AH and NEVER looked at any real evidence. This is gross misuse of expert testimony in the worst way possible. Having said that, this was a great example of how to demolish worthless testimony. Great cross-examination!
Wow this women is no joke Johnny got the best of the best when it comes to an attorney she really does her homework this is what’s considered in text book as a “super lawyer”
This wasn't even the actual "super lawyer" JD wanted. It was kind of advised to not take her and was actually referred to Camille from the same firm to take this case instead. Now i guess we can see why 🙌
Wonderful cross exam by JD's lawyer - she was able to elicit the response from this doctor that he made his conclusions without examining the evidences. Bravo!
I’m exploding out of my chair... they are playing word games. The shattered glass probably did not cause that injury, but the impact of the bottle hitting the tip of a finger curled over the edge of a counter CAN totally cause that avulsion fracture and laceration. It is a crush injury. From Depp’s standpoint he saw a bottle thrown at him, hit his finger, glass shatter, and his finger is hanging and bleeding. JD is not a medical expert, he knows glass is sharp and his finger is cut so Johnny probably thinks the glass cut his finger which is why he describes his injury that way. So this expert is focusing on that the shattered glass cannot cause the injury, which is true. But the crush from a bottle on a finger curled over the edge CAN. Source: physician
I think Camille point is just that. That the bottle actually caused the finger cut. It was up to the expert to have examined all these pictures to draw a good conclusion and he did not. Hence he can't say with all confidence that the bottle did not cause the injury.
Thanks for the clarification. I haven't seen the direct examination of the doctor. I'm watching a video of the cross-examination, and I was wondering why Amber's team hired a doctor to refute Johnny's testimony that Amber threw a vodka bottle that severed the tip of Johnny's finger. I don't think there's really much doubt that she did it.
Yeah I just wish she hammered that point that it could certainly be the bottle, and not necessarily the shattered glass. Because the doc kept repeating that the ‘glass’ could not have caused that injury. I think the way it was done will leave some doubt for the jury.
@@jonstone9741 I'm guessing what she's driving at is the fact that the expert can't give an accurate opinion as to the injury sustained by Depp because he didn't review all the footage. And had incorrect knowledge of where Mr Depps finger was actually lost. She also discredited him by showing that even though he said with confidence that a glass bottle can't shatter a finger tip, that he has no idea what could have cause the damage.
Amber hasn't been abused. She is lying. My ex husband use to beat me. No makeup covered my broken nose, black eyes or split lips. I stayed at home, didn't see family or friends because I was scared of what he would do. JUSTICE for Johnny Depp.
Thank you for your kindness. I was a young girl back then. I had 2 very small children that I had to protect from him too. I'm 65 now but still have nightmares of him. Amber hasn't been abused. She would never had done the things that she did & said to Johnny. I've been praying for God to let Johnny win his court case. He is a victim of her abuse. God bless
I love that Ms. Vasquez is getting so much positive exposure through this case. It's wonderful to see this bright young woman performing so well! 👏👏👏👏👏
It wasn't a cut, it was the bottle hitting the finger causing a crush injury. The bottom of a glass bottle is extremely strong causing huge impact damage before it shatters.
This “expert” is so incredibly wrong when he says that a vodka bottle couldn’t have caused that type of injury. My violent, abusive ex husband threw a very large, thick drink glass at me and it not only hit my foot, it shattered upon impact bc it was thrown so hard and it broke and fractured a lot of bones in my foot. He is so full of crap
You should charge $5,000 a day to be an expert on thrown glass injuries. They are not uncommon. Ive had glass thrown after me, ducked just in time though, so no injury.
Oh I’m so sorry. Geez. I can’t believe how people are so violent and how common this domestic violence is. I mean I can believe it, but you know what I mean.
he has clearly denied or “ruled out” Vodka bottle” and said the injury was like “crushed” like caught in door. He also accepted that his opinion was based on pictures of the injured finger and description provided by JD. However miss CV quietly proved by showing the photo of the bar floor - shattered glasses and scattered blood stains … that if he would have seen these then, he would not have ruled out the “Vodka Bottle” that AH thrown at JD and chopped his finger off ! Jury should have now got the very clear understanding of the incident. Well done miss CV 👏👏👏
It’s a damn shame they don’t allow standing ovations after cross examinations like that. What a flawless line of questions from Camille. She is such a badass
9:12 His arrogance is astounding, especially so for an "Expert" witness. Your job is not to decide what is important for the court to hear, your job is to answer specific questions asked by both sides with specific answers, scientifically, objectively, factually and without opinion.
Wow, his rate for deposition is $1000/ hr. And over the years he has provided “expert witness” with one of Amber’s law firms. He is making good money from her law firm…
Don’t forget 5000$ a day to testify. Funny how turds lawyers were going at his accountant for charging 700$ a hr for his time regardless of what he was doing. The man however has worked for Johnny for years and was clearly honest. This guy is a pay to play prostitute of a witness.
Seriously!?! Even when there's audio of her admitting and even apologizing hysterically??? Damn, AH ruining more than just her own career at this point
Oh boy. Camille is absolutely unstoppable, she is so focused! She uncovers every little inconsistency. And let’s not forget about the rest of the JD’s lawyers, this is the best representation of symbiosis. They are working together to bring justice. Doesn’t matter the outcome of the trial, people can create opinion on who is a real victim based on all the evidence.
This is literally ridiculous. Depp didn’t say that the bottle crushed the finger he said that the bottle smashed and he noticed that the finger was bleeding. It could have been lacerated by a heavy shard.
I would have thought also that shards of glass could have simply lacerated the finger. I did something similar when I was picking up broken glass from the floor and badly lacerated my finger. It was really deep and bled a lot. And that was glass just sitting there. If the shards were flying at speed imagine the damage that would do. And how can you pull away in split seconds of a bottle smashing.
More likely the force at which it was thrown and gotten shattered, the fragments are enough to cause massive tissue damage... You don't wanna be near that when it happens.
Go to a liquor store or a bar and look at the base of many liquor bottles. it is solid thick glass. And when thrown at a high speed at close range it will absolutely crush and/or sever a tiny appendage
God I love this female lawyer she is absolutely on top of the game she knows when someone's playing the role to get paid for his services and doesn't admit the truth to how he should be able to describe how the injury occurred what possible about it he changed his deposition for Johnny's deposition of where his hand was at at the time I used to work in a bar and I know when someone throws something there's always a Shard of glass that's going to hit and it's going to hit an area and no other glass particles is going to hit it or hit other parts of your body so this doctor need to start doing his research a whole lot better or somebody needs to start paying him less money for his unprofessional opinion
Fr when glass shatters it goes everywhere. I was cleaning glass though I had got it all. next day felt like I had a splinter on my hand sure enough tiny glass shard, but I had no cuts only a tiny dot. You can't know what the broken glass will do or where it will end up, brother and cousin was playing (lil kids at the time) ball in the house(got in trouble) broke the light fixture no one was hurt but later that day found some small pieces on the blankets of his bed and stuff . I just taking a long time to say no one can predict broken glass
Why is he even there?.. He's just discredited himself and he was NOT THERE.... "IDIOT'S"! Plus she must have got the "Cheapest"! Lawyers possibly lol! As she still has to pay 6, million to her charity's 🤔 AH said she couldn't pay because she was getting sued 🤔 she had the settlement 14/16 months before she knew about a court case...🙄 Anyway's have a nice day 😊 xx.
Wow. Her cross examination was like a series ending finale. She is literally the embodiment of drama television lawyers but in real life. Seldom do people get to witness this high level of legal acumen. She makes her much more opposing seasoned legal veterans seem like overcooked unflavored beef…while she is Wagyu Ribeye cooked to perfection.
@@arcanemoonjewelry Some of can. You don’t have to be mega wealthy. But it certainly helps. I’ll put this way, any hired counsel for any legal matter, generally criminal since it’s a right, is going to be better than a court appointed counsel or public defender. However, that’s not always the case, of course, there are exceptions.
The doctor described a completely different scenario to what Depp had described. Depp said his hand was on the edge with his fingers going over the ledge and that the bottle came at an angle pinching his finger between the edge of the table and the bottle. The doctor is describing situation where the hand is flat on the table and a bottle falls from directly above.
Is Amber's team trying to refute the fact that Amber threw the bottle that severed the tip of Johnny's finger? I heard an audio tape in which Amber can be heard crying and saying she was sorry while the doctor and the nurse were trying to find the severed tip of the finger so it could be grafted back onto Johnny's finger.
This woman is incredible. She's so sharp and precise.
dont ever ever ever think to cheat on her
And so wrong. Shes harping on trying to make the point the Dr cant rule out the cause of the injury but all shes done is make the dr say over and over and over again that in his EXPERT opinion, it was very unlikely the vodka bottle did the damage. She did a PISS POOR job. He sounded 100% credible, she sounded desperate.
@@stephen2583 Ahhh the arm chair lawyers out in force xD
@@stephen2583 Did you only listen to a small segment of it?
@@stephen2583 the questions are designed to lower his credibility, and cannot be taken individually but as a whole.
He testified he could not rule out how the finger was injured and he did not take all information into account with determining how it got injured.
If he took where it was found and in what environment, his professional opinion might have changed.
Camille is someone to be reckoned with. She’s so good. Her career is about to blow up. Happy for her.
Amber heard is dumb for continuing this trial. It will be the last mistake she’s ever made with all that $$$$
Tbf working with Johnny Depp her career has probably beeeeeen blown up
Ikr! Everyone is going to want to hire her
She's doing a good job of making Heards lawyers look foolish. It amazes me that they're considered to be a good legal team as they've said some stupid things especially Bredehoft.
@@carloandreaguilar5916 Have you... Have you seen Amber's lawyers? Camille is adored because she's great at her job and doesn't miss a beat, while Elaine and Rottenborn constantly fumble and are unprofessional to an absurd degree at times. All three are lawyers, yet Camille is superior.
So we have psychiatric giving expert diagnoses without ever talking to the patient, and a doctor that can say how an injury was caused without seeing the actual injury…wow
exactly!!!!
Welcome to Clown Court
“TRUST THE SCIENCE” 😝🤓😜
@@ryansterling17
We have some serious telepathic and visionary work here with these experts 🤣 they should teach us all to be more intuitive, imagine if we could all diagnose people or solve accident scenes without ever seeing the person or being on the scene or looking at scene photographs!!
Blimey, I am in the wrong business 🙈
As a doctor, why would someone stake his credibility on a case he never reviewed in person?
Greed !
$$$, I guess. $1000/hour, $5000 for a day in court.
For one, why is this even allowed? Relevance?? 🤦♀️These people are exhausting
Indeed!
$1000/hour for depositions; $5000/day for trial testimony.
I love when Camille says, “That’s not my question”… these people try to go around her questions…and she calls them out. This witness is so rude and arrogant.
@#PrisonForJohnnyDepp u a 🤡
He's nervous, most of the people working on Absurd Turd's case don't deserve any negative effects to their careers. Focus on the Turd.
@#PrisonForJohnnyDepp oh you poor deluded baby
In order for Depp’s accusation to be true, the bottle had to magically break before making a landing on his hand and produce a debris sharp enough to severe the tip of his finger with such precision. I believe Johnny Depp. I believe him when he said multiple times on audio recording that he cut his own finger. 😂😂😂
@@MaevaStardust No 🙈 it might be mind blowing to you but glass can and does break on impact and in doing so can cause those injuries. Your suggestion is like saying someone who crashes their car and goes through their window screen won't get cut because the window didn't break before they went through it..
I love Camille so much, she's so brutal and cut-throat in her questioning. She destroys any attempt at avoiding answers with such ease, catches them off guard every time. Absolutely killing it.
Felt like she hit a home run at the end.She is so good.
I think she is a good lawyer also but will your opinion change if Johnny looses his case?
Camille Vasquez is a beast! I’d be scared to have any conversation with her about anything - I’d question my own reality. Love how quick and brilliant she is, I have so much respect for her.
@@troyjenkins3886 I appreciate your question and thought it over myself too. Regardless of “winning” the case, her brilliance isn’t diminished. Unfortunately, we have seen that cases can have outcomes regardless of guilt or innocence because of a legal team’s skill or lack thereof.
@@ChristenSapnas So true,she is a good lawyer regardless the outcome
I absolutely love it when Camille says "that's NOT my question" 🥰
Crush!
Makes my day!
Makes my mini John happy
John
I start smiling like a mad man when she says that 🔥🔥🔥🔥
She is funny as well !
Well Done Camille, ridiculous that a Dr thinks he can say exactly what could not happen without being their or seeing the injury in real life /time ..totally crazy . Its the opposite to what other medical professionals have said
He's an overpaid smuck with doctors license 🙄 😂🤣😂🤣
In order for Depp’s accusation to be true, the bottle had to magically break before making a landing on his hand and produce a debris sharp enough to severe the tip of his finger with such precision. I believe Johnny Depp. I believe him when he said multiple times on audio recording that he cut his own finger. 😂😂😂
@@MaevaStardust as a waiter who has seen many broken bottles, the moment of impact pieces of glass keep going in the same direction, if a bottle falls on a surface that surface can be cut by the pieces of said bottle. At the same time, if a bottle/glass is thrown, some shards will fly in other directions and can also cause cuts
@@MaevaStardust completely untrue, I have accidentally put my hand through a window before and my hand was cut badly at the exact spot that first went through it. Glass can cut you as it breaks
@@eggshapedisraelioperative6317 Depp admitted on multiple Audio that he did it. I believe him, 🤣
How can he be on the stand and give his “expert “opinion if he has not seen all of the evidence which include the photographs? That’s ridiculous!
You'd be surprised the standard for calling a witness, an "expert" witness. Our justice system is laughable.
It's called getting $1000 per hour
*_Isaiah 55.6 Seek the Lord while He may be found, Call upon Him while He is near. 7 Let the wicked forsake his way, And the unrighteous man his thoughts; Let him return to the Lord, And He will have mercy on him; And to our God, For He will abundantly pardon._*
_Only Jesus Christ saves. Repent and be saved. Jesus Christ loves you. God bless you, and peace be upon you and your family in the name of Jesus Christ._
--
He did not testify about the place or circumstances of the injury. Heard's lawyers probably deliberately hid all that information from him, and told him to look just at the injury itself.
agree! To AHs witnesses I can say, one is worse than the other.
Camille career is about to blow up. Incredibly fascinating to see how she's putting everyone in their place. What a lady!
It honestly feels like she is tasked with taking down their best witnesses and she does it every single time flawlessly
Man …she will bulldoze u over !!!
Agree…
She's inthrilling to watch
*_Isaiah 55.6 Seek the Lord while He may be found, Call upon Him while He is near. 7 Let the wicked forsake his way, And the unrighteous man his thoughts; Let him return to the Lord, And He will have mercy on him; And to our God, For He will abundantly pardon._*
_Only Jesus Christ saves. Repent and be saved. Jesus Christ loves you. God bless you, and peace be upon you and your family in the name of Jesus Christ._
--
@@williammunny9916 Thank you? ... Tell Jesus to help J.D. out with some of that blessings.
People are losing their own careers trying to prove AH right... This is just ridiculous!
I agree completely
There doing it for the money when that’s gone they have no one
@@denisekeating2770 I guess this is where AH is spending the 7 million donation money..😅
There's a zero percent chance this man loses his career, he'll be back in court giving misleading testimony in a jiffy!
@@joelprathap4768 Good response😆👍🏽!
This woman is a force to be reckoned with. She's amazing.
She’s earned respect from the judge aswell amber isn’t poor I wonder why her council is public defenders
Dynamite comes in small packages😂
@@lbabytutorials4852 I wasn't aware they were public defenders. They certainly aren't on the same level as Johnny's team. I obviously don't know Amber, but from my impression of her behavior so far, I think she does everything for the way it looks - she wants to appear to be a poor, helpless victim, even if she says she doesn't. She's extremely manipulative. It's actually pretty scary. I wouldn't want to be in her life.
@@user-j91uaT9O So true! 😂
@@kellyjk1126 I'm sure Lbaby was being condescending/sarcastic about AH's lawyers.
I don’t ever want to face this women OMG but I love how she put him and AH in there place. Make them question what they are saying!!! You go girl friend!!!!
Not even for $5000 a day lol
I'm so sorry but it's bothering me sm... not "there", it's meant to be "their"
I LOVE her!
Camille is so quick and yet modulated. She’s (to 63 year old me) very young… I had nowhere near her confidence and presence at her age. She’s challenging doctors & experts… and intimidating them. She is going to have a great career.
Very clever
yea I was thinking, she's a doll.she doesn't look so bad, she's an educated bomb waiting to explode.
VV 60 is the new 40!!!
God bless! Pray for wisdom and confidence and it's yours!!
Camille has been in courts for 12 years already. That seems crazy to me.
She crushes them with facts.
My cousin has decided to become a lawyer because of this woman! She’s someone young girls should look upto not these influencers
Amazing! All the best of luck to your cousin! 🙌
Dr Curry as well, and Waldman, just great fighters for treatment and justice
The unfortunate issue is that the majority of lawyers don’t make enough to pay off their student loans, and end up leaving the profession. But if someone has the gifts of witty articulation, abstract problem solving, vast recall, and are very likable & assertive- the sky is the limit.
Johnny’s Lead Council, Ben Chew, has basically the most elite credentials and accolades an attorney can have, across the globe. Atop of that, he is dedicated to pro bono work and has won billions for minorities and marginalized groups. It can be an extremely rewarding profession for one motivated to put in 80-100hr work weeks.
Camille is a great role model for young women & young men. Much better than any “influencer.” I’m glad this case gives her much deserved exposure.
I'll be graduating in a few months from law school and i follow the trial closely and i absolutely love camillie .She's quick , polite and absolutely amazing.
exactly
She is a top of the line predator. Smart , low key , and thorough . She is awesome .
Yeah she completely destroyed his credibility…. Amazing lol
Lol don’t call her a predator
Predator of predators!
True
For those unfamiliar with the legal system, there is an entire industry of “experts” who get paid to testify whatever you want them to say. Their credentials are presented in an online marketplace and you can choose the ones based on your needs. They personally have nothing to do with the case. Their expertise is for sale.
So not only he is a terrible testimony to begin with, but Heard’s attorney didn’t even showed him all the evidence, all the information to properly give an “expert” opinion. What a joke.
That is very disgusting. I think all jurors need to be made aware of this. And the only doctors that should be believed are the ones that were actually there to see/treat a person.
Well...after this i bet all of these so called "experts" are going to ask the same question before they get retained by a client, and the question is :
"Is Camille on the other side?"!!!!!
@@GriBlanco There would be a lack of availability in expert opinion (which is usually a key component) in many trials if this were the case. It is very common to have a ballistics expert or a scientist give insight as to why something specifically has happened in their opinion, why is this any different? Is his expertise being disproven here? Yes. However simply not allowing any expert opinion unless they were directly involved doesn't solve anything. You're just getting a verdict without the nuance and expertise of professionals.
Imagine the other scenario, we only allow the specific doctor who came to the house to testify. Who would pay for his services if he must remain impartial? What if he specifically was hired by Heard and Depp had no medical expert to represent his side?
I understand why you seem frustrated with everything seen in this process, but your simple solution isn't a remedy to the issue.
Now that explains a lot.
Standing ovation for Camille Vasquez for brutally throwing out this expert’s arguments👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Someone needs to write a song about this amazing woman. She crushed this Doctor, like a Vodka bottle to a finger.
🤣🤣🤣🤣
See what you did there😂😂
Was there no CV camera in bars why a million dollar condos has no cvs in hall's or bars
😂😂😂🤭
Indeed!
I really don’t understand why it’s legal to pay a doctor to testify in trials on behalf of your clients
I don't get it myself! If experts are needed, they should be independent & paid for through an independent authority, even if their (reasonable) fees could be paid through that authority by both parties. How can you expect someone who is repeatedly hired by a client and paid outrageous fees to say anything that might incriminate that client?
To compensate for the time they are going to spend to testify instead of practising which is their source of income
It is his profession and is worthy of payment, but not 5 times hos going rate
He wasn’t even the treating doctor. Nor did he ever see the injury first hand. He should not be there testifying, especially since he is getting a hefty pay. He admitted he has testified for her law firm several times over the past few years. Her firm is a good source of income for him.
Yet jury members are compelled under threat of penalty to miss their regular employment and serve, unpaid, compensated only for mileage.
The lawyer is amazing. She’s so fierce, firm and precise. She asks important questions and is never rude. Johnny will win!
WOW this lady is on the ball nothing is getting passed her. Anyone coming up against her must be shaking in their boots.
It’s quite obvious he’s ruling out a bottle for no particular reason other than a paycheck. You’d think doctors would have more dignity than this. Sad
There are bad doctors always unfortunately
All corrupt
Never mind dignity even just a little touch of integrity this is grimy
But what has this to do with what the case is about
Charging 5k dollars a day as a witness is all his Integrity.
What’s impressive, is the matter of respect the Judge has with Camille. She’s straight up textbook.
That is just doing her job…
Incredible lawyer, so confident and smart, I am really hopeful that Johnny is going to win, she's a force to be reckoned with.
Not too fast. I'm hearing that it's extremely difficult to prove defamation. I hope he wins though.
@@msnandimarie7023 not in Virginia, he will win
@@janeward722 I admire your optimism and I certainly hope you’re right or this will be a scandalous act by the justice system to not see through the obvious lies by Amber.
Indeed Camille is a force to be reckoned with.
@@janeward722 no this is going to be very hard to win. Johnny's team are pushing the amber is the abuser narrative hard, which is great, and I do believe it, but it's almost irrelevant. Amber only has to "prove" that at any point Johnny was abusive even if it was a two way street. Johnny has to prove he was not, and proving something didn't happen is ALWAYS harder.
This is the first time I've ever fallowed a trial. One can learn so much from this; always tell the truth.
And how to read it in between the lines
This witness can’t tell the truth. He’s been hired not to.
It’s a common practice in high dollar cases.
This is my second trial. First one was with the murderer Jodi Arias. I was obsessed with the prosecutor Juan Martínez! He shredded her. I guess Latinos have what it takes
If Amber would have been truthful and honest, this trial would have never occurred. Her letters to J.D are very telling of her character.
This lady is a incredible professional .
He is irresponsible, how can a Dr go and testify on an injury that he never treated Lol 😤😤
@@carloandreaguilar5916 "Seems like" So Amber's lawyers may have skipped the lecture at the time?
Camille as always hits bulls eye.. no iir or err.. just straight to the point. She is an example of being a professional in one’s profession.
i dont buy it.. unless she doesn’t ask about muffins.. she is nothing
.....she's equivalent to a expert, sharp shooting sniper. And she's worth every single penny she earns.
@@kanwalbedi4706 lol I think you mistook Camille with Amber turds attorney..
@@halfsmart7 jokes buddy jokes
@@georgegraham6507 exactly..
This doctor needs to be investigated and reviewed because he is paid large amounts of money to testify on behalf of the defense. I wonder how much money he accepted to make false testimony and it impacted the ruling. This man didn't even see Johnny Depp injuries , just pictures. How can his testimony be even accepted
This is standard practice.
Amber obviously pledged him a large sum of money
@@jacquimiller2827 In her mind she's already paid him though.
Its part of their racket, along with over diagnosing ppl and shoving pills down their throat.
@@jerrodbutali3990 hardly, these types never actually do real practice
Funny thing is, they got all these so called expertise paid doctors . And YET, she NEVER consulted a doctor or seek medical help in ALL HER CLAIMS that she’s been physically assaulted by Johnny over and over again.
Professional medical ethics, he never assessed JD on the time of the injury, he wasn’t there when it happened and he never did the surgery on Johnny’s finger. He never assessed him right after the accident and surgery. He based it only via photos and written information given to him. Are doctors allowed to diagnose now by merely looking at the photos without seeing the actual patient????
That’s what I’m asking myself. It’s bugging me that all these doctors are coming out of left field diagnosing JD but they’ve never seen him as a patient of their or have even met with the man at all. How are they getting away with that nonsense
Funny thing is, she’ll still win the case if any ONE of those jurors believe her
Excellent point
Didn’t that crazy psychologists did the same ? Base her opinion on stuff amber said and not even meeting Johnny ?😂 these so called experts are a scam
Smile in the photo or they declare you dead and sign the Death Certificate!
I honestly bet Camille is working around the clock. She is so intentionL, so precise, so specific, and referencing so many pieces that are already in evidence. She is a force to be reckoned with.
She also want to avoid to waste time, so she can destroy all of those liars.
The entire team is working equally hard.
No, I would say they have been working on this case for years! Just wait8ng for the right time to strike!
@@truthbringer-6748 yes, absolutely. But you can't perform the way that she does, without being a very involved part of the process. And, credit where credit is due - she is absolutely killing it, at the podium. That's worth celebrating. It's a talent, and a skill... and, she is exceptional.
@@missbarbaralove I'm literally giving credit where it's due... To all of them. It's hundreds of pages worth of document and hours of audio and video, she couldn't possibly due all that on her own. Even while she is crushing front stage her team is giving her instructions, handing her notes, finding inconsistencies. It's a well oil machined and most likely Camile isn't doing the lionshare of the dirty work.
Wow, what a joke the legal system is, you can purchase "experts" to come and say BS in your favour. Ridiculous. Well done to Camille for owning another one.
This doctor strikes me as the kind of guy that would have a completely different opinion if the check was coming from Johnny's attorneys instead of Ambers.
Exactly!
Exactly ! 🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼
Agree!
that's the whole point AH hired him to disprove Johnny's account of the injury. If he was hired by the court he would have given a neutral opinion with just the facts,
All AT witnesses are of the same type.
She completely dismantled him… Wow… His credibility is gone…
I mean if you want a doctor to say whatever you want...
@@wiredvibe1678 He's charging $1.000/hr 😉
@@NazareAmorim pledged*
@@wiredvibe1678 😅
This lawyer just degraded the doctor from an expert to an amateur 😹😹😹 she is just amazing. Now i wanna be a lawyer 😹
Me too but my brain wouldn’t 🧠
Camille is an incredibly wise, smart , Intelligent and dedicate. compassionate attorney. She did everything she should to find justice for her client. We need more human being like her in all areas. 🙏🏻🙏🏻❤️
Camille destroyed him.
His opinion is based solely on whether or not his check clears.
Its been pledged.
Absolutely.
😃🤣😅🤡🐭🐁
@@edfran2040 🤣
@@edfran2040 imagine if they worded it that way, have they...pledged to pay you or have you actually been paid? So have you been paid?
Facts are:
- He never seen the injury in person
- He earned a lot of money from AH
- He can't make an accurate diagnosis from pictures or videos
That testimony looked very bad.
If he wasn't there and haven't seen his finger, why is he relevant to this case ?
They want to know if Johnny is lying about the cut they want to make it like Johnny do it himself not Amber
They just want to show they have witness. Lol
Amber claimed that he cut it while smashing a phone next to her head, so they are spinning the angle that it couldn't have happened with a thrown bottle, therefore Ambers version must be true.
@@cassiedjandbellaschannel1366 but he's not a witness. He was not present at the time of the incident, nor at the hospital. All he saw was photos of the injury.
This lawyer is a force of nature. She really is amazing! Johnny is really lucky to have her.
Imagine a “expert” stuttering like he is… it’s like AH whole team can’t answer yes or no but tries to justify lie after lie
Well said...
Justice for Johnny!!
Stuttering has nothing to do with his qualifications you mook
The fact that the US allows these “expert” witnesses with people who have nothing to do with the case but use their accreditation and titles to sway the jury is literally mind boggling to me that it’s allowed. Please someone make me me familiar with a time that this was useful?
Great question. Only conclusion is that we are living in clown world.
I believe it's used to discredit the opponents argument. It's easy to say " X did Y" but when somebody is an "expert" in that area is either able to support or eviscerate that statement it would give one side more weight. I'm no lawyer and don't really know much about it but that's just my observation.
Bro, The US is the biggest hypocritical joke in history. Are you only now becoming awake? Lol
Even the fact that they are highly paid to testify. That to me is conflict of interest. $5000 per day in court, he’s fired if he states anything that gives more strength to the “opposition”.
Swaying the jury is how you win a case. And when you don't have a case, swaying the jury is literally all you can try to do.
Camille's face of satisfaction when she was done with her questions 👉☺✨
She's a queen! 👸💃
As a hand surgeon, its not possible to accurately determine the object causing the injury even if you examine the injury in person, most of the time
Omg!! What a hell of a cross examination! She literally killed it!
She is truly awesome...MK South Africa
"She literally killed it". No, no she didn't "literally" kill anything. But she put him in his place.
@@NovaSupernova wow u must be fun at parties
@@freckledmelon Why? Because I'm educated and don't speak like a hillbilly? I was at one last night thank you. And yes, I am a blast.
@@freckledmelon And you clearly are a millennial. You use letters like "u" and don't start your sentence with a capitol and are clearly uneducated when it comes to the English language and sentence structure and punctuation. Back to school young lady.
She discredited him in every way possible!! Go Camille!!
@Jack Shite he embarrassed himself in front of the entire world, I’m following this case from Egypt, and the case is very popular here too!
Everyone talks about it, so this is LITERALLY an international embarrassment 😂
And btw, no one here believes her too, people here can spot a liar a mile away
Camille my Goodness tore his testimony apart. She is incredible and full of confidence
I can’t believe how cool, calm & collected, Johnny Depp has been through all of this trial. To me he has acted like a Gentle Person, throughout it all. He has his own failings with drink & drugs, I can’t see him be aggressive to people!
Maybe he takes valium to stay cool and friendly!
He has lost against the SUN because 12 of 14 points against him are true!
He is not so innocent!
It's proved that the structure of the brain of drug addicts is changing and that drug addicts are not able to control their emotions and that they are hallucinating, what explains, that he was shouting at her and at the same time at a person who was not there!
If I was going through this, I couldn't keep my calm.
That man has more class in his little finger (no pun) than amber heard has in her entire, disingenuous, lying, cheating toxic body.
@@reesedesigns dream on..!
He lost against the SUN because 12 of 14 points against him are true!
That's because he's sober... The violence depended on what drug he was on, according to other side.
It is women like Camille Vasquez I would rather trust and admire, and see as the face of women empowerment, rather than somebody who claims to be that face AND abuses men.. That one (you know who) is the face of Narcissism.
Sadly... Strong, smart women are not looked as role models, it's time for a change.
@@giulianacr2638 idk, I prefer to live in a world where I can look up porn made by average women because "empowerment"
@@wiredvibe1678 I mean p*** stars know what they do for a living and don't have any kind of delusions otherwise. As far as I'm concerned they are the face of empowerment because they do what they do and have no issue with what they're doing and they're making mad bank off of it so at least they're not trying to pull the wool over anybody's eyes.
Just imagine how good she is at making dinner 🤤🤤🤤
@@John-qt8km I'll set the table and wait to be crossed examined and then eat.
It's a shame they can't use the audio that was recorded following the incident where Amber is heard in the background saying incriminating things like howling "is Johnny okay?", "what have i done", and "I didn't mean to" and basically crying hysterically while Johnny team discuss the incident and aftermath. Obviously it can't be played in court because of the other voices on the tape. But if you listen to it it's obvious what happened.
Omg this attorney is slick I love how she confuses them and just keeps them going and going and then confuses them and then makes them tell the truth team Johnny Depp 100%
“Dr. Mor there is no question pending, thank you though”. 😂
I was screeeeaaaaming!!! damn! she's savage 😂
Mor got more than enough today. 😂
I absolutely love the way camile teaches differences between right and wrong even to those people who are experts...Justice served cold
i would not be surprised if she becomes a high value attorney with a HUGE salary
Go Camille!!! Oh my😻😻😻
She’s got Doc mumbling and countering his own testimony under two minutes.
To be fair the Doc did a fair job of maintaining his position. Jury could go either way on this one
@@Contemplativeman101 so his position was lying under oath and telling the story about the injury that Johnny Depp himself never said? It's weird how you think the jury can go either way after watching this lawyer completely dismantle him and destroy his credibility on the stand and expose him for lying about the injury at hand. No pun intended. Do the world a favor and never have a kid. If you can't use your brain and you cannot see the things that happen in front of you for what they are while they're happening you definitely shouldn't put any kind of baby out in the world that will inherit that kind of ignorant point of view just because you don't want to see Amber her get sued for 50 million dollars.
@@Contemplativeman101 The Doc has done nothing wrong, he was asked by Heard's to examine Johnny's injury based upon testimony and pictures they provided to him alone, which is what he testified to. But by not having him actually view Johnny injury diminishes his credibility to provide an accurate assessment.
This is more or less the basis of this court action where opinions are formed, judgements made, without being aware of the full facts.
@@Contemplativeman101 Really? I don’t think so
If he didn’t review very pertinent information like where blood and chopped finger were found, a broken vodka bottle around the bar area, shape and condition of the bottle etc.. then his whole analysis is pointless to be honest.
@@billdover3165 Exactly, I think the most important of the factors, pictures, conditions were not provided to him even.. he also mistated JD’s positioning of finger and testimony… with all these factors missing he just gave a half assed assessment that has been discredited before he even left the stand.
People say Camille is being cocky or overly aggressive, all she’s doing is her job to get concise answers.
If there was nothing to lie about or cover up, her rounds of questions would be over with in quick succession. If someone was being honest in response to rapid questions, it wouldn’t leave much room for anything else other than question and answer.
They wouldn't say that if she was a man! Agreed, she's just a freaking excellent attorney.
What people ? The ones who don't like Johnny or the ones who don't like a women who is kicking but in the court room and doing better than most men defe her client who she knows is innocent. Lol
wait...what people??
She is very smart
She sometimes revises changes and omits evidences to confuse witnesses. Which is dirty play
You just have to love it when she says ''That was not my question'', it's music to my ears
Camille Vasquez, you utter legend! You go girl and rip him a new one!! The arrogance of this doctor is disgusting! Not what we’ve all signed up for when pledging the oath. No matter how good he think he is at his chosen specialty, a doctor stops being a good doctor, when he thinks he knows it all. A good doctor admits that he will learn something new every day of his working life. That’s the beauty of physiology. No two people’s bodies work the same. Interesting to see how much he charges. Why practice hands on medicine, when a piece of paper allows him to charge $5000 per day for his “expert” opinion. Disgrace to his profession!!!😡😡
I am loving Depp’s attorney who is ripping into Heard’s expert on his finger injury.
I do understand the need for expert testimony, but this so-called expert is highly payed by AH and NEVER looked at any real evidence. This is gross misuse of expert testimony in the worst way possible.
Having said that, this was a great example of how to demolish worthless testimony. Great cross-examination!
I completely agree. He was paid well to lie under oath.
All her witnesses are dodgy. Most of them act like they’ve had some training.
Wow this women is no joke Johnny got the best of the best when it comes to an attorney she really does her homework this is what’s considered in text book as a “super lawyer”
This wasn't even the actual "super lawyer" JD wanted. It was kind of advised to not take her and was actually referred to Camille from the same firm to take this case instead. Now i guess we can see why 🙌
Wonderful cross exam by JD's lawyer - she was able to elicit the response from this doctor that he made his conclusions without examining the evidences. Bravo!
"Theres no question pending Mr. Moore, thank you though" 🤣🤣🤣 killed me
I don't know what JD is paying her, but she is worth every penny! She is incredible!! 🥰🇨🇦
I’m exploding out of my chair... they are playing word games. The shattered glass probably did not cause that injury, but the impact of the bottle hitting the tip of a finger curled over the edge of a counter CAN totally cause that avulsion fracture and laceration. It is a crush injury. From Depp’s standpoint he saw a bottle thrown at him, hit his finger, glass shatter, and his finger is hanging and bleeding. JD is not a medical expert, he knows glass is sharp and his finger is cut so Johnny probably thinks the glass cut his finger which is why he describes his injury that way. So this expert is focusing on that the shattered glass cannot cause the injury, which is true. But the crush from a bottle on a finger curled over the edge CAN. Source: physician
I think Camille point is just that. That the bottle actually caused the finger cut. It was up to the expert to have examined all these pictures to draw a good conclusion and he did not. Hence he can't say with all confidence that the bottle did not cause the injury.
Thanks for the clarification. I haven't seen the direct examination of the doctor. I'm watching a video of the cross-examination, and I was wondering why Amber's team hired a doctor to refute Johnny's testimony that Amber threw a vodka bottle that severed the tip of Johnny's finger. I don't think there's really much doubt that she did it.
Yeah I just wish she hammered that point that it could certainly be the bottle, and not necessarily the shattered glass. Because the doc kept repeating that the ‘glass’ could not have caused that injury. I think the way it was done will leave some doubt for the jury.
Totally agree, also not forgetting the bottom of any bottle is far more dense that the sides. Thrown with force would definitely cause said injury.
@@jonstone9741 I'm guessing what she's driving at is the fact that the expert can't give an accurate opinion as to the injury sustained by Depp because he didn't review all the footage. And had incorrect knowledge of where Mr Depps finger was actually lost. She also discredited him by showing that even though he said with confidence that a glass bottle can't shatter a finger tip, that he has no idea what could have cause the damage.
Amber hasn't been abused. She is lying. My ex husband use to beat me. No makeup covered my broken nose, black eyes or split lips. I stayed at home, didn't see family or friends because I was scared of what he would do. JUSTICE for Johnny Depp.
I'm so sorry you had to go through that ,i hope you are in a better place now.
This breaks my heart. I’m sorry you went through that. I hope you’re better now! 🥰
Thank you for your kindness. I was a young girl back then. I had 2 very small children that I had to protect from him too. I'm 65 now but still have nightmares of him. Amber hasn't been abused. She would never had done the things that she did & said to Johnny. I've been praying for God to let Johnny win his court case. He is a victim of her abuse. God bless
She’s tearing his testimony apart! He won’t be worth 2 cents an hour after this 😂
I've noticed that after Camille gets a witness to agree to what she says four or five times......she goes for the kill shot.....she's scary good....
YES!
Ahh Dr. Moore there’s no question pending. Thankyou though 😂😂
Get him Camille 😂🙌👏👏
For 5k, the expert witness should allow a bottle be thrown at his finger to prove his point.
5k per day
LOL.... Totally agree!
Agreed!!
LOL... Totally agree he should conduct the test in his own hand.
🤣
I love that Ms. Vasquez is getting so much positive exposure through this case. It's wonderful to see this bright young woman performing so well! 👏👏👏👏👏
So he can review an incident without reviewing the FULL case is unbelievable actually. Literally unbelievable.
This is absolutely ridiculous! This doctor should lose his license for any false statements he said in this trial!
Perhaps he just wasn't fully informed by the AH team.
Think he must have miss heard 🤣
All of these so-called experts for Amber are being exposed.
@@soniavadnjal7553 Kinda what I am thinking. I think he was only shown portions of the deposition and other parts left out.
@@sharonempath9364 😂👍
Why do you need a finger injury expert for? He got cut by that witch there's the audio for that 🙄
The audio is inadmissible cos there’s the voice of other people in it, including the late security guard who can’t testify.
It wasn't a cut, it was the bottle hitting the finger causing a crush injury. The bottom of a glass bottle is extremely strong causing huge impact damage before it shatters.
@@estherkonan3644 why can't he testify?
@@soniavadnjal7553 Cos he’s late/dead.
Do you have a link for the audio?
This “expert” is so incredibly wrong when he says that a vodka bottle couldn’t have caused that type of injury. My violent, abusive ex husband threw a very large, thick drink glass at me and it not only hit my foot, it shattered upon impact bc it was thrown so hard and it broke and fractured a lot of bones in my foot. He is so full of crap
Dear God...So happy you're ok!
You should charge $5,000 a day to be an expert on thrown glass injuries. They are not uncommon. Ive had glass thrown after me, ducked just in time though, so no injury.
Oh I’m so sorry. Geez. I can’t believe how people are so violent and how common this domestic violence is. I mean I can believe it, but you know what I mean.
he has clearly denied or “ruled out” Vodka bottle” and said the injury was like “crushed” like caught in door. He also accepted that his opinion was based on pictures of the injured finger and description provided by JD. However miss CV quietly proved by showing the photo of the bar floor - shattered glasses and scattered blood stains … that if he would have seen these then, he would not have ruled out the “Vodka Bottle” that AH thrown at JD and chopped his finger off !
Jury should have now got the very clear understanding of the incident.
Well done miss CV 👏👏👏
Amber Heard doesn’t want to answer any the questions she’s asked,wonder why?😂
Because women know women , especially when they are lying 🤥
She might trip up
It’s a damn shame they don’t allow standing ovations after cross examinations like that. What a flawless line of questions from Camille. She is such a badass
i love the objection followed by a witness testifying that he must have misspoke the one or two times LOL
This was awesome lol
"Misstated, misspoke..." seems common on Amber's side...
and wrong synonymous...
And of course " I don't recall," one of Amber's favorites. What a bunch of BS filled nonsense they've been selling. Smh..
It's unbelievable that a professional will not cover his butt, by making a complete review just to confirm his employer view. It's unprofessional.
9:12 His arrogance is astounding, especially so for an "Expert" witness. Your job is not to decide what is important for the court to hear, your job is to answer specific questions asked by both sides with specific answers, scientifically, objectively, factually and without opinion.
Im getting REALLY tired of these wordgames coming from heards witnesses. Good on Camille for calling it out - i hope the jury sees what’s going on
I agree they just talk in circles and it’s so exhausting.
I love the way she makes people stumble over words it awesome
Run for the hills if Camille is against you. That hellcat is determined.
Wow, his rate for deposition is $1000/ hr. And over the years he has provided “expert witness” with one of Amber’s law firms. He is making good money from her law firm…
Don’t forget 5000$ a day to testify. Funny how turds lawyers were going at his accountant for charging 700$ a hr for his time regardless of what he was doing. The man however has worked for Johnny for years and was clearly honest. This guy is a pay to play prostitute of a witness.
Right, and $5000 for showing up in court. Completely unbiased, I would say.
Seriously!?! Even when there's audio of her admitting and even apologizing hysterically??? Damn, AH ruining more than just her own career at this point
Oh boy. Camille is absolutely unstoppable, she is so focused! She uncovers every little inconsistency. And let’s not forget about the rest of the JD’s lawyers, this is the best representation of symbiosis. They are working together to bring justice. Doesn’t matter the outcome of the trial, people can create opinion on who is a real victim based on all the evidence.
This is literally ridiculous. Depp didn’t say that the bottle crushed the finger he said that the bottle smashed and he noticed that the finger was bleeding. It could have been lacerated by a heavy shard.
I would have thought also that shards of glass could have simply lacerated the finger. I did something similar when I was picking up broken glass from the floor and badly lacerated my finger. It was really deep and bled a lot. And that was glass just sitting there. If the shards were flying at speed imagine the damage that would do. And how can you pull away in split seconds of a bottle smashing.
What a heavy shard though
@@jonathankabasele985 It would be heavy if it was the bottom of the bottle perhaps? thicker glass
More likely the force at which it was thrown and gotten shattered, the fragments are enough to cause massive tissue damage... You don't wanna be near that when it happens.
Go to a liquor store or a bar and look at the base of many liquor bottles. it is solid thick glass. And when thrown at a high speed at close range it will absolutely crush and/or sever a tiny appendage
That moment when Camille Vasquez asks you "Isn't it true?" you're already screwed...lol
Camille is a sweet savage! Love watching her in her element!
Yes!
She’s not only a superb lawyer, she is Sherlock Holmes quality as well!!
Dude, she just removed all doubt. Rock on, Camille!
God I love this female lawyer she is absolutely on top of the game she knows when someone's playing the role to get paid for his services and doesn't admit the truth to how he should be able to describe how the injury occurred what possible about it he changed his deposition for Johnny's deposition of where his hand was at at the time I used to work in a bar and I know when someone throws something there's always a Shard of glass that's going to hit and it's going to hit an area and no other glass particles is going to hit it or hit other parts of your body so this doctor need to start doing his research a whole lot better or somebody needs to start paying him less money for his unprofessional opinion
….and BREATHE
Even more annoying when someone like that is getting paid with money stolen from JD.
Did you forget how to use punctuation?
Fr when glass shatters it goes everywhere. I was cleaning glass though I had got it all. next day felt like I had a splinter on my hand sure enough tiny glass shard, but I had no cuts only a tiny dot. You can't know what the broken glass will do or where it will end up, brother and cousin was playing (lil kids at the time) ball in the house(got in trouble) broke the light fixture no one was hurt but later that day found some small pieces on the blankets of his bed and stuff . I just taking a long time to say no one can predict broken glass
Why is he even there?.. He's just discredited himself and he was NOT THERE.... "IDIOT'S"! Plus she must have got the "Cheapest"! Lawyers possibly lol! As she still has to pay 6, million to her charity's 🤔 AH said she couldn't pay because she was getting sued 🤔 she had the settlement 14/16 months before she knew about a court case...🙄 Anyway's have a nice day 😊 xx.
Lawyers like her are the reason why i wish i had pursued my desire to be a lawyer!! She is "vicious".. love her!!
Ditto
Her rates better go up after this trial!
@@themetaphysicalrev99 they will double
me too!!
Why didn't I? I regret my own laziness and STUPIDITY😭😭😭😭
Wow. Her cross examination was like a series ending finale. She is literally the embodiment of drama television lawyers but in real life. Seldom do people get to witness this high level of legal acumen.
She makes her much more opposing seasoned legal veterans seem like overcooked unflavored beef…while she is Wagyu Ribeye cooked to perfection.
@@betterthangoat Umm, no. She’s a highly trained attorney. She’s NOT an actor. Come back to reality.
thats because normal folks like us cant afford lawyers that are worth their salt in spades like her.
@@arcanemoonjewelry Some of can. You don’t have to be mega wealthy. But it certainly helps. I’ll put this way, any hired counsel for any legal matter, generally criminal since it’s a right, is going to be better than a court appointed counsel or public defender. However, that’s not always the case, of course, there are exceptions.
@@betterthangoat Who is the shady attorney? To whom do you refer?
Well damn, that was quite the show. Great job, to JD 's legal team.
The doctor described a completely different scenario to what Depp had described. Depp said his hand was on the edge with his fingers going over the ledge and that the bottle came at an angle pinching his finger between the edge of the table and the bottle. The doctor is describing situation where the hand is flat on the table and a bottle falls from directly above.
Then he changed his mind was forced to
Is Amber's team trying to refute the fact that Amber threw the bottle that severed the tip of Johnny's finger? I heard an audio tape in which Amber can be heard crying and saying she was sorry while the doctor and the nurse were trying to find the severed tip of the finger so it could be grafted back onto Johnny's finger.
This all is so scary, weird. Two people must make everything public and the whole world can watch it live on TH-cam. How they must feel?
Now she says he did it by smashing a vintage telephone against the wall next to her head. 😴
@@jonstone9741 yes and just awful they cant use that tape!!!
Dr. Moore…there’s no question pending! 🤣……………😌……..😎👍 Camille rules! 👏👏👏
Damn... did they try to throw their own expert under the bus? They did not inform him properly.
She nailed it. Amber's lawyer held evidence from the doctor testifying