Amber Heard expert witness called Johnny Depp 'idiot' during deposition | LiveNOW from FOX
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ก.ย. 2024
- Dr. David Spiegel was undergoing intense cross-examination while testifying in the Johnny Depp and Amber Heard defamation trial when he was questioned about referring to Depp as an "idiot" during a deposition in this case. Spiegel said he was not being serious and it had nothing to do with his opinion in the case.
Subscribe to LiveNOW from FOX! www.youtube.co...
Where to watch LiveNOW from FOX: www.livenowfox...
Follow us @LiveNOWFOX on Twitter: / livenowfox
Raw and unfiltered. Watch a non-stop stream of breaking news, live events and stories across the nation. Limited commentary. No opinion. Experience LiveNOW from FOX.
I’m so happy the world is seeing how unhinged some psychiatrists can be. I hope we can come up with a way to ensure people aren’t being treated by doctors like this.
Some psychiatrists and doctors are mentally unstable.
And this is why many people who need professional help are hesitant to seek it
Remember in high school I had one that seemed off & she would compare me to a tv show
I usually take my old brother to psychiatrist, and I've been saying s lot if then need more a psychiatrist than the patients that are there. This guy really needs to be reevaluated.
Them just want that insurance money for the luxurious life
the secondhand embarrassment from his hostility, his generalisations, his backpedaling after being cornered, the “sorry I misspoke” smh
Its hilarious 😂
I was going through all 5 stages of grief watching this. He never gave up narrating even if he was wrong. Kinda like Amber.
@@sdsurfgirl60 😆
This has made me laugh all the way through!
FFS.. Where did they find this twat?!
Heards team are killing her.. This one & the hand surgeon are pathetic!
witness idiot so rude
I never thought that there was someone who is equally annoying as Amber Heard, well today I witnessed the impossible.
Desparate
😂
I'm gonna go out on a limb and say slightly more annoying. At least Amber knows a smidgeon about acting...
My thoughts exactly!!
There were a lot bunch of them around her and freeloaders as well.
who is gonna tell this guy that you don't need to be an expert in acting to know that actors practice before they film...
You don't need to be but to avoid the question his answer was fine.
If he knows nothing about acting, does he think that he’s been watching documentaries with Johnny Depp to then judge his character..?
Any film directors reading this? "Takes" aren't supposed to be practices or rehearsals, are they? Film actors don't practice on company time (as stage actors do.) My memory is that there's a read-through, and there are takes. But actors are expected to practice their lines at home. But someone in the business might know. How often are lines rehearsed on film?
@@florazuideveld2038 this witness should get an acting role as a doctor
One can only imagine how many people this quack 🦆 has harmed.
This man is a truly horrifying example of a "mad scientist". His whole behaviour, his gesturing, his repulsive way of making faces, his pompous way of speaking show an impressive mélange of various cluster a, b and c traits. Lord have mercy upon any poor patient that falls in his hands...
I could not agree with you more. I spent 20 years in prison counseling mental health with sub use issues. The prisoners would have been a better witness on the stand. This guy is a 🤡
He’s a great expert witness though. Look how flustered and exasperated the lawyer is. I don’t necessarily know if it plays well with the jury, but in terms of accuracy and technical precision, the witness is correct nearly 100% of the time he and the lawyer disagree.
Lmbo right!
exactly
😂😂😂
This “PROFESSIONAL” tried judging Johnny Depp’s baseline off of how he ACTED in movies/tv shows etc etc. The fact that he openly admitted this, and stood by it, is extremely scary.
....and he has been doing this for decades.
He actually says he never saw JD in movies/tv shows.
@@rajjar52 he walked back his original statement once he realized how stupid it sounded.
And he admitted he doesn't know that actors rehearse... 😂
Its like when he went to see the kids in the hospital he was in his acting mode the way he spoke but they were saying he was high or drunk.crazy how they base their findings on that.
The guy swears he is a consummate professional but he makes a psychological diagnosis on a person he has never met before using hearsay from the person he is suing. Gee I wonder what could go wrong with that.
I am with you . This guy is nuts ! His hair is even high 🤣🤣
Well if you are this professional and he says to JD, hey Mr Depp, I am an expert witness for AH, I am here to examine you - do you seriously think JD will say oh good, where is your couch? We have to be out of order to expect that.
He is nuts
Well said!
Uggg! I just want him to stop talking !
This expert is such a creep, cringe, my god, how many patients or ppl got ruined by this "expert". Glad he got called out
I can’t even imagine the monster of being thought of as an idiot for needing mental health treatment… he’s disgusting and I hope he loses his tenure and board standing immediately
That's so scary, that this guy is considered an expert. Imagine this guy being your therapist or your proffesor in school.
Well, you can think what you want about his work or what he says, but it doesn't sit right to call him a creep for the way he talks or looks like. I don't know, that's too much I think.
Yes the joker
Now that's a relevant question, how many lives has this clown ruined?
Johnny Depp's lawyer cornered him to say "I'm wrong" and he ended it on that note. This is brilliant!!
Imagine finding yourself in need of a psychiatrist and you get this guy! I'm speechless! He surely is a straight jacket candidate.
🤣😂
One of the patients got loose and answered the subpoena… 😂
@David Young well, there's always hope. If for real, however, it seems the lunatics have taken over the asylum. And that's no metaphor 😅😂😂
😂😂
😆😆😉👏🏻
best TV of the year Depps facial expressions are priceless and i know what he's thinking ''i'd love to get stoned with this guy he'd be hilarious''
He’s not only a member of the American Psychological Association he’s also a client.
😂🤣
😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 off to the loonie bin with him!!!
probably the one who needs it the most🤣
Got his certificates from ebay! 🤣🤣🤣🤣
👍🤣🤣🤣
My heart goes out to the lawyers. The ego of these “professionals” are mind boggling.
Their ego is truly mind boggling
Which lawyers? If you mean AH's lawyers I'd argue they're just failing at their job and/or made a very poor decision deciding to take AH's case.
As if lawyers did not have egos.
Johnny depp has talked carefully, slowly and methodically since he was young. It’s just how he talks. My god
Exactly. All anyone has to do is watch interviews from back when he was on 21 Jump Street, Edward Scissorhands etc to see the only differences are that his voice and his vocabulary have matured.
Actually, judging by the cross interrogation, this psychiatrist should have talked slower when answering the questions he got. Would have saved him a lot of shame afterwards!
One of the few witnesses that JD actually looked at. Looked at, open mouthed, unbelieving and laughing, but looked at!
Incredulity
Who brought the dog to the court? :) Humour aside, it is scary to see so many con artists depositing their prepaid “expert opinion” in the court. We should not allow this. For me, it was enough to see Johnny, Amber and unbiased witnesses like police officers, along with video, photo and audio evidence. The rest is just a very expensive noise
It's more like who brought this dog out!!
It’s really disheartening to see this going on in the court systems today..
At least Heard’s attorney are wasting their limited time with testimonies that accomplishes nothing.
This lawyer did a rly good job with this witness!! The witness energy & testimony was all over the place- the lawyer did a great job handling all of this
The judge did a horrible with this witness. Ridiculous. Everyone else has to cowtow to judge and jury and courtroom and he gets to act like a child. Herd gets to lie, her attorneys get to suborn perjury. Anyone who lives in that county, if they ever get charged for perjury, contempt or lesser charges should demand Amber Herd and Co. treatment.
@@nottellingyou14 in cross-examination, sometimes it is actually better to let the witness spew nonsense than to interrupt. This is so we can show how credible or incredible the witness.
yes guy made himself look awful.. lawyer did good job
😂😂😂
@@nottellingyou14 you are like this psychiatrist 🤡🤡🤡
It horrifies me to think that this "Dr" is surrounded by similar professionals who think and behave like him. Lord help us all
And then the Gov’t says “TRUST THE SCIENCE”
This is really shining the light on the unethical, aggressive and incompetent "professionals" in the mental health field. Psychiatry is a position of such power and there are people like this that exist within it. Just another upsetting and sickening thing this trial has brought to light for the public.
What’s wrong with everything he said lol
Don't compare all psychiatric professionals to this narcissist.
Initially, I came here to comment that Johnny needs to slouch more to achieve the classic "Michael Corelone Effect", but then I got a load of this fool on the stand.
Are we supposed to take this clown seriously? To think: this morning, he had a viable practice to go back to. Not anymore...
Many people go into psychiatry because of and to understand their own mental health issues.
Nothing wrong.
That guy claimed he was a better actor than Johnny then literally says he ‘has no idea what an actor does’. 🤣🤣🤣
Are AH's legal team just dragging crazies off the street??! it sure AF looks like it!
The verbal traps on this guy is genius! Because people who talk too much, talk 💩… Also: I can’t help but put HIM as a narcissist himself, getting so angry & defensive over *QUESTIONS?!*
Clearly a narcissist.
He lost all credibility as an "Expert" the
second he opened his mouth. He's far
from believable and is "using". Put this
Clown in Anger Management - he's not
safe and appears unpredictable.
Christopher Lloyd is an amazing character actor. Always wanted to see him in a movie with Depp. What an unexpected treat 😂
🤣🤣🤣
Yes, a cross between Christopher Lloyd and Larry David (the comedian). They could definitely play this kind of crazy…maybe John Malkovich too, except he speaks a lot slower. LOL
@@melaniejackson-cracchiolo356 I definitely see that too. What a character, this guy is.
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Great Scott
When this guy proclaims he has no idea whatsoever. I believe him. In fact, I would move to make this guy an expert in no ideas....
Kudos to Johnny's lawyer for putting up with this jerk....I'm screaming in my head.
It's so funny to see Camille laugh and also shake her head throughout this guy's testimony 😂😂 She just can't believe her ears 😂
This man's understanding of statistics is terrifying, given he's a medical professional. His explanations of Correlation and Causation were off the mark, and saying "Invariably" and "there is .05% chance" in the same breath is another brilliant take. And oh my Lord, that reversal of conditions on the probabilities (around @18:10). It is such a classic mistake people make, but a doctor should never make. If 80-90% of IPV offenders have a personality disorder, it doesn't say anything about the chance of a person with personality disorder to commit IPV.
Yes. Thanks for pointing out that fallacy. I knew there was something wrong there.
I'm a doctor, and I think exactly the same like you. How can he make such a basic mistake. This person can't be trusted to interpret any research using statistics lul 😂.
What he should look for is the predictive positive value. lmao.
Yes! That was a very manipulative use of the statistic! I was hoping the lawyer would point it out.
Exactly
THANK YOU. I legit paused the video I was so appalled by this mistake 18:10
Isn't it just PERFECT that Amber Heard's attorneys would hire this guy, Dr. David Speigel, to be an "expert witness" and diagnose borderline narcissistic personality disorder, only for him to appear in court and demonstrate he's likely suffering from borderline narcissistic personality disorder: He thinks he's the smartest person in the room, and meanwhile, he has no idea he's disqualifying himself by acting like a complete TOOL.
I had the very same thought! 😂
This is Real life "Rick" from rick and Morty 😂😂😂😂
This Dr. Needs to stick to mastering the Flux Capacitor!. bahahaha
He tore this guy apart. Now it's obvious this guy in NOT an expert. He should not be on the stand. He got so worn out he just wanted to come off the stand. With the right questions asked this guy actually apologized several times for the testimony he gave.
I could just imagine sitting in his office and being spoke AT and feeling so much anxiety. he is so harsh! and proud of himself. I would seek another doctor. Just watching this guy is making me feel so much anxiety.
Yes, exactly, he’s so aggressive in his manner, condescending... just, unpleasant to listen to, i can’t imagine being his patient
Omg tell me about it this video is making me cringe so hard I couldn't imagine actually sitting front of him. :/
Facts. He calls his patients victims..
I am SHOCKED at this doctor's attitude !!!! SHAME ON THE JUDGE FOR ALLOWING THIS DISRESPECTFUL BEHAVIOUR IN COURT !!!!
I’m all for it. He matches Ambers team. Lol…smh
I think there's likely a very good reason as to why she has allowed this man to ramble and make an "idiot" out of himself.
Hi! Teachable moment for me here…can judges stop a testimony? This guy is awful!
@@fairytale8209 The Judge should have compelled him to answer.
@@fairytale8209 no
This is a man who, imo, already sided with Amber Heard before taking the stand. I think this man isn't used to people who question his assessments. It's great to see how JD's lawyer is able to get under this witness his skin and make him look condescending, unwilling to answer any question directly and hostile by just asking simple questions.
He thinks his intelligence is far superior to anyone else & likely doesn't give any credibility to any questions of his "professional" opinion. Meanwhile he comes off as a creepy condescending d bag. I believe at one he said his opinion on one matter was "irrefutable". Last I checked, opinions are not fact & largely based on emotion.
"Isn't he dead" never fail to chuckle me
What an Idiot🤣🤣🤣
Wayne: a person can have npd traits and substance use disorder and never commit IPV, right?
Spiegel: about 80-90% of people who commit IPV have a personality disorder. So the answer is less than 10% obviously do not.
Spiegel just said that less than 10% of people who commit IPV do not have a personality disorder. Which is not what Wayne asked him. He asked him about people who have personality disorders who do not commit IPV, which is NOT the same thing.
To use the smoking/lung cancer analogy. If less than 10% of smokers get lung cancer that does not mean that less than 10% of people who get lung cancer smoked cigarettes.
This man is not all there. It's completely frightening to think he treats mental illness in others. Truly mind boggling!
He look like one of his own clients….
I’ve noticed several psychologists seem unhinged themselves. I don’t know if there’s something that rubs off the patients on them or what.
All psychiatrist start behaving as their patients as time goes by.He is nuts
He should be locked away. What a scary world we live in😱
Meth is a hell of a drug
This Dr is so narcissistic himself, watch how angry he gets when confronted or challenged about his answers
His hair gets crazier as he testifies! 😂😂😂
He and Amber needs to have a date together to do us a favour to destruct both of them for society hahaha
What's that crazy thing he does with his mouth. Scares the hell out of me. Weird!!
@@glendak4093 yeah wtf was at 0:54
He totally is and I suspect he is addicted to some kind of pharmaceutical drug too. His dry mouth is typical of an amphetamine user.
Being a psychiatrist doesnt make one immune from becoming a psycho themself at some point.
This one, clearly needs to be checked before being used as a reference
Hahahahahhaha exactly
hahaha!!!! so well said!!
😂
That’s what I was thinking. Did they check his identity? Is he really who he says he is?
You're so right! He's a psycho! Where does the defence get these experts??? From the looney bin?
The fact that this guy has access to vulnerable people who are in fragile mental state is terrifying 😳
Truly I hope they take away his license if he has any
I agree.. does not need to be treating people...
This was a google review posted 3 years ago
"Dr Speigle killed my step father. My step father was suicidal. He was an alcoholic as well. He had been a patient of Dr Speiegle for years with medication thrown at him. After rehab he never followed up or returned our calls. We called stating he was locked in a room suicidal and he never called us back. When he finally did and said he would follow up and never did. My step dad is dead. Speigle does bare minimum treatment to push meds and then doesn’t care if you die or not."
After someone goes to see him, they leave there shaking their heads. Wonder if 'they' should go back to help Him.
He is harmless, the only reason you are processing him as aggressive is because johnny depps lawyer is nervous, flimsy, and anxious, and the witness is not. He is one of the smartest people in the room. If you can’t see that, you are probably a fragile very unintelligent human being.
this guy is literally me as an 8 year old trying to convince my parents I never called my brother an idiot just so i wouldnt have to apologise
He seems to think a “fast answer” is a sign of a “smart person” or a “healthy mind” ? Definitely not as smart as the average 5th grader . All that psyc worked against him . “Idol hands are the devils work place” . He “graduated “ got a diploma, and hasn’t been “accountable” since then for ANYTHING he thinks, says or does . Total brain rot .
He's simply very very nervous of being caught out in court that too publicly on national television being watched across the globe.
Pure pressure.
Lol 😅 lol 😅 yes.
😂
@@jonbenetramsey0806 HAHA -😂 wrong Dr. David Spiegal. Did you not even look at the photo on Trending? Its your own source, what was that about 'thinking a “fast answer” is a sign of a “smart person” or a “healthy mind".'
I feel sorry for every person who has had the misfortune of crossing paths with this sorry excuse of a doctor.
Agree. I made a mistake in another comment when I meant to say , "Where did they find this guy, "Shrinks R Us???"
My sentiments exactly
Was he was expelled from AMA? Can a doctor practice without approval from AMA? This is strange :(
OMG THIS GUY IS A DOCTOR??!!
This guy is so crazy that he is just funny…
I laughed a lot!!!
Amber shots her knee with this withness🤣
This guy was batshit crazy and the thought of him diagnosing patients in his current practice is frightening, truly.
Anyone who has ever been diagnosed by this man should immediately seek another professional to look into their notes. My god, wow, just wow.
So you are an expert on judging experts😁
@@ruthwikbg277 i think we’re all experts at judging experts when those experts are disgraceful
what makes you believe he is incapable of his profession? the thing he says sound perfectly reasonable to me, his mannerism are somewhat frantic but so what?.. it is a high stress situation...
I believe you could benefit a lot from some reflecting.. maybe you have been driven away with mob mentality and is incapable of rational thought on this matter, sure seems to be a large bias.
Including Johnny Depp
I was diagnosed with unipolar depression at 15 years old, and after nearly 4 decades later, I am still living with it. I have seen countless therapists and psychologists. But in all my years, I have never seen anything like this lunatic. If I had to see someone like this guy? I'd run as fast as I could. Reminds me of some mental patients I met in the psyche ward....jeez.
So, this guy actually has a license to practice as a psychiatrist? I feel bad for all his patients.
he is a patient himself
What a clown
If his patient see this the shou run away from him fast .
😅😅😅😅😅😅 poor patients of him😅😅
This guy is clearly a psychiatric patient pretending to be a psychiatrist
I think this so called "expert" needs therapy. He comes across as unhinged.
Guys I so agree with you all who are saying the same thing!!!
Lol this guy is high on his own supply prob adderal
I think the doctor sent one of his patients instead 😂
🤣🤣😂😂
It’s the hair for me🤣
This guy is actually the epitome of why it’s you need to be wildly careful with picking a psychiatrist. This guy really thought he was playing 4D chess while everyone else was struggling to understand 3D chess. Like even when he was AGREEING WITH THE LAWYER he argued. That was baffling.
You’re on point! I worked in the mental health field and these doctors can be seen a mile away. They’re licenses kept them employed. Patients hated them and so did the staff.
Agree. He thinks he's smarter than anyone else when in fact he's demonstrating substandard cognition himself.
He's spent too much time in a position of authority where people feel they can't give him honest feedback.
This is like watching a speed train crashing at full speed 😂😂
😂😂😂
@@elipotter369 I actually thought this guy was very smart.
He's just a combative asshole...and he doesn't seem to be a very likeable witness...
This guy reminds me of a Count Olaf character from a 'Series of Unfortunate Events'..
"I've never heard that actors rehearse." There goes his credibility as a normal person.
Hahahahahahah exactly this dude doesnt know ACTORS WORK... they act lol
I guess the doc has never been to a play or maybe he has and just thought the actors all did their job spontaneously.
Top comment and facts!!!!🤣🤣🤣🤣😂
hahaha
Wakaaakakakakaaaakakaaaaa....I"m on the floor dying. LOLOL>>>Llkhsl;fh;qkn34lk5yu8solslllOLOOLLLLLLLLL>>..
Depps team has to be loving this guy, wow. He literally will be famous from this by being crazier than everyone in the world. Be careful what psychiatrist you go to for help. They might be more insane than you.
Hhhhhh true
Lmao 🤣
😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 this “doctor” is a clown 🤡
Your so right and so funny!!😁
This so called psychiatrist has my anxiety through the roof really feel for anyone that has had the displeasure of being his patient
Same here ☺️
I can’t imagine it!
He started doing that thing with his mouth, and I was instantly put off. Like please keep your lips within a mile of your face!
My anxiety levels are also very high by watching this circus.
I cannot imagine he will have many in the future. Perhaps he has been loosing too many already and hence money from Amber might come in handy. There is a word for those mouth movements it is called Gurning.
“You have to answer questions, yes, sir.”
The best line here 😂
This so-called “expert” is so unprofessional and look unhinged the entire time. Watching the reaction of Johny's team as this clown self-destruct is so funny LOL
hell yes... their reactions are everything. Utter disbelief
Literally a clown 🤮
Me too, I was laughing my ass off. This guy digs his own and Amber hearts grave ridiculously fast. What was Ambers defense thinking?
They need to revoke his license
When he takes off that suit he transforms back into a troll, living under a bridge, waiting for the next gold coin.
This was the most migraine inducing witness to date. My sympathy goes to the judge and the jury. AH’s team should be charged for the paracetamol prescriptions they will have to use after this.
😂😂😂 it's hilarious
Same! I had to turn it off and close my eyes until the headache went away.
He's running down the clock. They now have 4 hous left
For reals. Migraine and vomit inducing.
LOL!!!!!!
This guy is a perfect example of everything that is wrong with my field and why so many psychologists and psychiatrists are perceived as nut jobs. What a disservice to our profession.
So true! Surely they could have found someone less arrogant and creepy.
what's "wrong with your field" is that an anti-Scientific shyster like Freud is revered as one of your leading lights.
Exactly. Unfortunately, most 'mental health care' doctors are ABSOLUTE NIGHTMARES. They have NO bloody idea what they are doing, are ARROGANT as F, pretentious, presumptuous, and absolutely convinced that because THEY haven't seen 'X', it cannot ever possibly be so.
They completely wreck themselves when they start talking about professions (or scientific topics) of which they have absolutely NO understanding. His response about acting was a PERFECT EXAMPLE OF WHAT AN IDIOT HE IS. I have acted for 30+ years. This guy should have never said a bloody thing about it, other than admitting to the banal, pedestrian, OBVIOUS facts that--yes--actors rehearse. Go figure. BUT YOU KNOW WHAT?! Sometimes, an actor *CANNOT* rehearse with the group. Sometimes, you only have a day to memorize lines. Sometimes, you don't memorize at all. SOMETIMES, YOU READ OFF A TELEPROMPTER.
This guy was *SO* pretentious, it makes me wonder about society, in general. Christ on a UNICYCLE, he pissed me off. I wanted to shove that gatorade bottle right up his MDMASS.
Freakin' WEASEL.
Look at Dr Curry to make you feel good again
Hence the nutty professor haha
This guy should be an actor. He plays a court jester admirably.
Bufón es la palabra !!!
This man is a prime example of why mental health care in this country is hopeless. If he can't hold it together on the stand how can he counsel patients
Imagine how horrible he is behind closed doors
Psychiatrist don’t do much counseling they focus on medication management, and the therapist provides the counseling
nor do I watch Johnny’s crappy movies. he is an idiot, cocaine addict & alcoholic.
No, this witness didn’t come across as aggressive, he was sharp to see where Johnny’s lawyer was going with his trap questions. this expert witness doctor is good.
@@arianneygrullon9416 even worse
don’t be stupid! this doctor witness is good. he dismantled this cunning lawyer’s trap questions,
This guy was epically, and conclusively humiliated and disgraced on the stand. The whole cross-examination of this fool is worthy of watching again and again by law students and pundits alike for how to completely annihilate and impeach a so-called ‘expert witness’ in front of the jury. Part of me is wondering why Heard’s team didn’t try and shut this down. I think there was maybe one objection and a ‘may we approach?’ through his entire cross-examination. I think some of these witnesses called by the Heard team will never be able to work in their field again nor will be called as experts in court because Amber is the kind of person who looks to get even in the most dirty ways she can. Even her own attorneys will be spanked over this mess.
Yeah the whole team turd should never work again.
Currently in law school and loving this! Haha
I hope they don't i hope they get fire. They are unethical unprofessional they sold them selves out disgusting
Unfortunately I think they will be able to work and make obscene amounts of money. But they will never be asked to be a expert witness again though because all these experts are ridiculous people.
He mistakes the old lawyer's soft spoken nature and stutter for weakness. Tried to school him but fall into his own trap
Did anyone notice this guy got EXTREMELY awkward when he was reminded Depp was Willy Wonka? He had to pretend like he hadn’t seen it, but he actually got REALLY excited for a sec when he realised that Depp was Willy Wonka. 😂
As a student of psychology, this man is a disgrace! Be objective not defensive…being defensive is an indication that you’re hiding something. Depp’s lawyers have style! It shows they know their onions!
This man doesn't understand that being a MEGA super awesome movie star has its privile... Opposed to being a Psychologist.
and I didn't mean to look down upon psychology, but it's the truth. So I apologize if I hurt your feelings.
Or, he's being defensive because he knows that the lawyer is basically trying to trick him into answering questions categorically, when the reality is far more nuanced and complex, and then use those answers against him. One would expect that "as a student of psychology" you would show a bit more nuance in your analysis of people's defensive behaviour.
@@killedbyLife I understand your perspective. What I mean is that he could pass his professional opinion in far more professional constructive ways rather than going into full attack mode. That will even render the lawyer defenceless.
It might be his personality to interact like that but if you confidently know what you’re saying, you won’t stress to pass your opinion.
Lawyers are also well versed in psychology, the more agitated you are in responding to them…the more they poke you with questions to discredit you. As a psychologist, he should know that.
@@ChristianaWinters-pu3vw 😂😂
I feel sorry for those jurors...I'd have thrown a shoe by now. This is ridiculous.
🤣🤣🤣
Lol
lol...
I made an assessment on this guy and decided that he is bipolar and in a manic state. How can I pass such a judgement based on what he looks like and 5 min watching him. This is what he did to JD. The guy is not even an expert in addiction. 😠
He looks like he may be an "expert" ON addictives.🤔
🤣🤣🤣
Same. I think it’s reasonable as he clearly thinks it’s fine. 🙄. Jesus this is horrendous.
On adderal. He acts just like my aunt.
He's probably on something himself
I've met so many psychological professionals just like him. They're pure ego, and incapable of being wrong, just ask them.
lol
Lol
Me too. Some of them are great but there are some can be very arrogant and dismisive.
They would deny
Specifically right for psychodynamic therapists. Cognitive behavioral therapists don't have to rely on their willingness to be in the right.
This is pure gold. Love how this doctor is getting demolished and yet he is too arrogant to see what’s happening. He is so full of himself that he can’t see how idiotic he looks in making those stupid faces and gestures.
Priceless performance. It's a free circus for the whole world to enjoy, we should thank Amber for paying the entertainer 😆
😂 😂 Agreed. He looks quite smug and thinks he's doing well. In reality he looks like a manic mess
@@verabolton :) yep. Thanks AH lol.. we really needed this distraction right now, covid, war, natural disaster, bloody monkey pox !!...
He been writing his own prescriptions.
You hit the nail on the head about him not understanding that he’s the one looking the fool because of his arrogance.
This guy scares me. He should NOT be making judgements about people's mental health.
He clearly has misjudged himself as being mentally sound enough to care for others.
@@kingayy9267 wish someone would tell him that.
I'm a mom scrolling through my son's social media journey to ensure his safety and out of curiosity (with his knowledge), as I do once in a while, who got lost in a rabbit hole of this man's testimony, I am terrified. I am a DV survivor, diagnosed with C-PTSD and am a current patient of psychiatric care. l am aware my kids need counseling (and are currently reviewing) and may need psychiatric care at worst from our past. Knowing there are psychiatrist out there like this who seem more interested in twisting words and showing his superior intelligence by all this double talk and psycho babble is absolutely gut wrenching. If you don't get on this man's good side, he has in some cases where mental institutions and court ordered evaluations for sentencing ect. are concerned great power and you could potentially be locked away and possibly medicated till you drool and don't know who or what you are and let rot, or have your children taken away and handed over to your abuser ect. Because you triggered his need to prove his superiority and based on his word alone. This should not be ok, is not funny and is borderline criminal. Scares the hell out of me. I truly hope someone sees this testimony and checks his caseload, all his patients and then monitors his practice. I'm not saying his diagnosis is wrong, however his combative behavior and his belittling of someone who potentially is a survivor of DV (jd) is appalling. If my abusers had someone testify like this about me when he was on trial I would have been a basket case. The though of it is making my palms sweat and my stomach knot up now. It's not ok, and I hope the jury knows this is not right, and ignores his testimony. Just wrong. Smh.
He is off the rails! This is a MASTER CLASS in cross-examination. He is so frustrated and defensive. He actually shows signs of having a personality disorder too!
please stop being an armchair psychologist, acting defensive is a regular human trait, not everyone you don’t like or agree with has a personality disorder, it’s much more than that
I thought it looked like he'd taken a bunch of cocaine.
His patients should demand a refund.
@@thegreenmanofnorwich he definitely snorted 5lines before coming to court😹
It shows how unethical he is..his diagnosis need to be questioned from every case he's had cause he sounds okay with misdiagnosing a person
Wow this is horrific to watch - who thought it was a good idea to put this guy on the stand. It’s like watching a car accident…I want to look away but can’t!
Hehehehe
😆👍👏👏👏👏
🤣😂
This is what I have been feeling... I couldn't explain it.... This is exactly what it was watching this
😅😂😅
MUCH RESPECT TO THIS LAWYER BECAUSE HE IS SO PATIENT WHILE THE PSYCHO DR SEEM NEEDS DIAGNOSIS, HE IS LIKE HE IS ONTO SOMETHING.
It seems like He always cross examine the expert one. Like another Doctor, the hashtag expert (whatsoever). He is very patient I guess.
Oh boy, what's your education again?! 🤔
Something off the street
What is the name of this lawyer??? They should mention his name
All the nose rubbing made it seem like he was either lying or on drugs himself- cocaine/ oxys ...he needs to be tested lol
I have watched this twice. I love to observe human behavior and I have never seen anyone act like this.
He is absolutely fascinating to me. His over the top ego? His quirks...his know it all attitude, his facial expressions...just everything about him.
He doesn't know that actors rehearse before their being in a movie? Does he just think they show up on the day of shooting" Cold?"
He's like a character out of Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events...
Just so strange.
Wow. AH's witnesses, friends and "experts" are just like her
lol, I just commented exactly this in another video.
Indeed 😊😊😊 Same feathers flock together
Yes we attract people with the same energy we are vibrating at and she's clearly doing that.
can't answer a simple yes or no they have to go beating arnd the bushes
I know, it’s crazy … birds of a feather flock together.
This doctor is exactly why people think all shrinks are nuts. He's an embarrassment to the profession.
I...I don't think that at ALL. I think this guy looks like a crack head and he strikes me as a quack.
They are,exactly!
He surely is an embarrassment.
I definitely don't think all shrinks
are crazy. I think some are poor at their job, but many value their very expensive education, and work very hard at their jobs.
The MMSE (the test Johnny took) cannot be used in this way. My gf gives these exams (batteries) and they are hours long, and the MMSE is just one of a dozen or more tests that they give in order to diagnose someone with mild cognitive impairment or dementia.
I think what they do is take the MMSE score and change the structure of the battery you then take depending on how you perform, if anything at all. By the way, what Johnny messed up on is a task where they asked him to remember a set of words (5 words I think) but didn't say for how long, and then asked him what the words were 5 minutes later. ADHD is just one of many things that could cause someone to mess up on such a small task.
That's why lengthy batteries are used to diagnose these types of disorders, not a simple exam like the MMSE.
Dr. Quack calling Johnny an idiot, show's just how "unprofessional" he is. If anything, this guy is going to sink any hope Amber had.
Plus looking like Lemony Snicket is making this trial even more whacked.
I think that's case closed, we rest our case your honor
I'd like to input my expert opinion that this witness is a giant dumpster fire.
I think Tim Burton could use him though, he's sure to be looking for a new job
Fully agre, using an insult as testify in a court case is very unprofessional
From the other hand, showing up intoxicated and a few hours late to work is something what i would describe as making poor decisions, so i kind of understand why he did call him that.
This lawyer is soo good. The nutty professor thought he would talk circles around him, thought he could play stupid... and the lawyer brought him..exactly where he wanted him using his own words... impressive.
Yes!!!!! It was absolutely brilliant
Rather, it IS absolutely brilliant!! Such a talent, the attorney's way with words!
The jurors have my complete sympathy in trying to follow this confusing exchange and make sense of this.
their gonna need therapy ....I feel bad for them!
The jury should come back within less than an hour with a decision in favor of Johnny.
@@dmang3 I hope they don't go to this guy for therapy 🤦🏽♀️
Man I wouldn't be able to do it. I'd be writhing in my chair wanting to argue with the witnesses
I have a feeling they’re going to completely disregard this guy‘s testimony, he came off as arrogant and unreliable.
This guy looks at judge: “Do I have to answer that question?”
Judge: “yes…you have to answer questions.”
🤦🏻♀️
Has anyone ever noticed that 90% of the people who are representing Amber are morally and ethically corrupt? Looks like this trial is exposing a lot more than Johnny's innocence. I don't know how legally this guy can move forward with his license. He should have it removed. Same goes to the rest of them the world needs less of these people seriously I'm in SHOCK
She has crooked used car sales reps for a legal team
What’s he doing with his mouth? Weird.. I can’t believe he’s a psychiatrist and then calls people “idiots”. He’s arrogant, rude and demeaning. A narc himself.
Surely he has not got a wife, blimey I would of beaten myself up living with him.😵
Dude looks like he needs psychiatrist himself
He thinks he is superior ...just like Amber Turd wants to intimidating people... that's why he is arrogant
Not the only psycho psychiatrist i know... lol
Yes! That was so weird 😆
This guy comes across as a privileged arrogant know it all. I wouldn't feel comfortable going to him as a patient. He shows no empathy or interest in humanity.
You will be crazy going to this doctor
this attorney’s temperament is perfect for this type of “expert”. he is easy going, doesn’t take this guy’s arrogance and patronizing personal but keeps moving forward with his questions and points
This psychiatrist is so arrogant…he’s throwing out a lot of verbiage like someone who is never questioned. I love this lawyer…his questions are so pointed and revealing. This guy is cornered.
He's also just plain nuts.
I was thinking the same thing! Amber is also very arrogant when she is not sitting before jury. So i guess that explains why he is here
@@Mystro84 He's eccentric
@@ayeu520 he is I agree eccentric and eclectic and a class A whack job smart guy but too cocky & definitely a nut job
I absolutely love this Lawyer!! What's his name? Does anyone know? He is an expert at ripping the quote on quote experts ! 😩
The cross examining lawyer is doing a remarkable job with witnesses like this, who are extremely unpredictable with the answers they will provide, going off tangent... Speech overload that will make most normal people loose their train of thought.
The lawyer is able to pick up on key statements and bring attention to that. He needs a round of applause seriously👏👏👏👏👏
I agree
Now I know why some people talk so much bs in such a short time. This guy is 🤡, I'm not a very smart person but come on, even Stevie Wonder could see this man is full of 💩
couldn't agree more👏👏
👋👋👋👋👋
A lawyer is a master at what he does.👍
Not enough recognition here for the lawyer doing the cross. Irrespective of the witness's odd behavior, the lawyer constantly had the witness backpedalling or contradicting the statements he'd just made. He absolutely obliterated the guy's credibility with every single question. Fine, fine work.
Perfect - the way to handle a Narcissist ( who's actually testifying about narcissism - HA!) is to feed him and let him go. This guy attempted to rule the courtroom, and he failed miserable. The jury, I am sure, was unimpressed.
@ Eugene Botting
If the jury was still awake 😴🥱
It was very ironic listening to him list narcissistic traits and try to apply them to Depp when in fact he was explaining Amber and even himself.
👏🏽
Eugene Botting The Judge was also unimpressed. This guy was so full of himself.
thanks santa
As a psychology student, with a great deal of hours of experience working with trauma survivors... Depp's testimony was "slower" not in cognitive function, but in speech, as is consistent in trauma survivors who are asked to recount abusive experiences - he was trying to make strong statements, without imbuing a tonne of chaotic energy and emotion... Which is very difficult to overcome in a situation where all eyes are on YOU, the person who may not be believed. He was speaking slowly because his mind is managing the images of those memories, the emotions felt at the time those events occurred and current emotions about them, and is likely to feel like he wanted to be anywhere else, not talking about how he was treated by the person who verbally, physically, psychologically messed with his wellbeing. Depp's drug use does not make him an abuser, nor does his abusive childhood. Sure, stats, figures, risk factors etc... but not everyone fits the bell curve, and high likelihood does not make it entirely probable. Depp's experience makes him more susceptible to being abused... More so than becoming an abuser. Science
@coconut grove thank you! (Edit) also, that this was all happening at the hands of someone who said "I love you". It adds to the gaslighting in a major way. Cruel behaviour followed by kind appealing language of "I didn't mean it, I love you, just hug me?" Is so messed up. And it retraumatises survivors to retell their experiences and not be believed. Johnny has her voice in his head too, telling him he would not be believed.
Guess that didn't work out so well because AH relied on DV being a gendered concept, rather than one of relational issues...
I hope for Johnny that he gets peace 💜
Your great
Ok so JD scored 27 out of 30 and couldn't remember 3 things.....I also couldn't remember the 3 things a Dr asked me once and I assume because those 3 things had no relevancy to what he ( Dr) and I were discussing in the first place. This Dr S was making me believe that anyone who can't remember the 3 things/words asked at the beginning of a "test" has cognitive issues and possibly early onset dementia!! Even though JD is an actor, rehearsed lines and has to perform in front of many people doesn't mean that he's comfortable to speak in a situation as this. He may very well be nervous knowing that he has to be explicit in what he says or his meanings would/could be misconstrued.
Precisely 👏👏👏… Why are the comments so much MORE INTELLIGENT than these witnesses called up for examination??? Embarrassing….
What a hoot if this guy is a huge secret FAN of Johnny’s work…. 🤣🤣🤣
Wow Dr Curry set the standard for how a professional or expert should testify and everyone after her just seems to lack in how to give testimony. This guy is killing me. Johnny is Johnny. He's always the same. Even when he was young he still talked the same way. Isn't it important to know whether someone IS under the influence or didn't sleep etc before the mental exam?
I agree it is very important to take possible impairments into account.
Plus he speaks slowly to control his stutter
"Isn't it important to know whether someone is under the influence or didn't sleep etc...". No, it isn't. The mini mental awareness test does NOT and has NEVER factored this in.
It is not ethical let alone legal to " diagnose" someone whom you have not met. This man needs to be reported to licensing.
Yeah Hhe explained repeatedly on that point and it made sense in some loophole way which was why the lawyer didn't get an "igotcha' moment.
He was ordered by the court not to exam JD because he's not the defendant here.
His testimony is unethical in more than one level.
Unprofessional in every level.
His mannerism is unacceptable in a high level.
And the real problem in the problem is that he's not able to realise it.
It was hilarious how he called himself unethical
He never said he made a diagnosis. You clearly haven payed attention
He did not diagnose anyone with anything. He’s being paid to provide his opinion and he is doing so. Saying someone appears to be slow for whatever reason or that certain traits seem to be present are not diagnoses. 🤦🏻♂️
HE is a psychiatrist?! Holy heck, anyone that has been treated by him needs to get a second opinion right away!
Truth!!!!
Absolutely
They need to run to 2nd opinion ASAP
He's probably Amber's psychiatrist, and it shows.
Lol..Allright now!!😅
Guys like this are why I gave up my dream to be a psychologist and left the industry altogether after ten long years of school, internships, field practicums, and employment positions in mental health. I saw / heard a lot of things said / done to patients by guys exactly like this during that time that didn’t sit well with me. This is an actual thing, and it’s sad.
Shouldn't that have inspired you to be a mental health worker rather than the opposite ?
What are you doing now?
As I listen further to this “back to the future look alike”, this is the second psych “expert” for AH’s team that I strongly believe needs to be evaluated by the APA and ethical standards with this testimony!! I’m, again, mind blown by this man and his unbelievable assumptions, diagnosis, stating the traits of a disorder assuming he’d commit IPV … and his memory thing leading to a cognitive disorder… like, this is scary in a whole different sense outside this trial !! Everyone better listen to this “expert” testimony more then once and look at the big picture outside this courtroom and be scared to death of the psychiatric healthcare system ….. unbelievable!!
🤣🤣🤣🤣 I was thinking the exact ,same thing
i thought i was the only one who thought he looked like Doc Brown.
Don't do Christopher Lloyd like that. This dude is a clown lmao
@@kurtboswell8278 an insult to Doc .
This guy looks like a giant baby bird before it has feathers.
Don't be mean. He doesn't look like Doc Brown. But he look like Count Lad's twin. 😁
"I'm not being difficult, I can't hear you."
"I was asking you about cognitive decline."
Classic 😂
Yep, spit my coffee at that point.
Did not catch that lol, what time stamp?
@@GGBel1 around 5:44 🤣
Oh my God. How could her team think this was going to help. This guy is unbelievable. I wouldn't trust him to feed my dog or water my house plants let alone testify.
Word 😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣
I wouldn’t trust him to pass me a pencil sitting side by side at a desk.
Probably her drug dealer. At this point, nothing about her or her friends seems impossible.
Amber picked a lawyer who behaved like her, which in turn picked the experts that behaved like her.
All clinical cases, it's such a rare gathering!
Most of the comments here are about this psychiatrist, however,I believe that this whole show belongs to this well spoken lawyer who repeatedly made this psychiatrist to admit that he was wrong!! Well done
My skin crawls watching him answer... he has such an air of arrogance and grandeur. And the way he shifts his jaw and moves his mouth when he's annoyed or impatient... ugh 😖
Even his voice sounds scummy. Just listening to him and not watching his actions made my skin crawl
I think he is on somthing that's making him so aggressive
I feel like it could be drugs too.. The way his jaw is moving is suspicious as hell
Yes he’s very odd
Meth mouth
Can you imagine how many times this man diagnosed his patients wrong?
Agreed!
Can you imagine how many patients bailed after one session with him? I know I would.
Ha ha ha. He doesn't seem like reliable. I feel sorry for his patients.
The MMSE (the test Johnny took) cannot be used in this way. My gf gives these exams (batteries) and they are hours long, and the MMSE is just one of a dozen or more tests that they give in order to diagnose someone with mild cognitive impairment or dementia.
I think what they do is take the MMSE score and change the structure of the battery you then take depending on how you perform, if anything at all. By the way, what Johnny messed up on is a task where they asked him to remember a set of words (5 words I think) but didn't say for how long, and then asked him what the words were 5 minutes later. ADHD is just one of many things that could cause someone to mess up on such a small task.
That's why lengthy batteries are used to diagnose these types of disorders, not a simple exam like the MMSE.
He needs mental help real bad wow he is a wack job
Oh my ..and his BS is all hear say .....
I'm sure this doctor and Amber share a lot of things in common. Stunningly shocked here, myself. Can doctor give opinions like this? 😅
Maybe they are dating...
Maybe even a cell if he's a fraud and she's an abuser?🤡
She must be promise him and say to him if u lie for me I gv u more money or maybe this doctor got dir.. secret that amber know so he got no choice to help her🤔
They are psychologically related, narcissistically fit for each other
Like crack....🤣🤣🤣
Ms. Vasquez is fighting for her life holding back laughter
This guy is an awful witness!! Johnny's lawyers aren't making him look awful, he's doing that all on his own. They are just giving him the platform!
I imagine Johnny and his team are wanting to die laughing!
For sure. That's why they allow him to keep talking. He's a tool.
@@denisebomhoff1155 The JD team looked like they couldn't wait for the session to be over and roll on the floor laughing!
He just seems like he’s on drugs… I feel like there’s someone in there who is normal.
He's literally NEVER talked to Johnny himself? How is this man even credible? On anything? They basically picked someone out...said read these NOTES or little exam and pass your worse judgment upon this person...am I right? Or?
Haha it would be something a turd could’ve done. And paid with some drugs, payed before the sitting of course. Stage frightened waiting for his turn… well why not take them now, just a bit.. it will take the edge of and nobody will notice😂
Half the country and most of the media did this to Trump frequently for 4 years. No one minded then.
Right
The comments by the jurors after this trial are going to be INTERESTING!
He can’t be. You can’t know a patient from just chart notes. Even in therapy. I’ve seen many of my charts notes and even tho they list diagnoses, concerns, high points I’ve brought up. It’s not like when you have a full conversation with a person and sit across from them. Watching body language, listening to changes in tone, seeing the facial expressions that go with what emotions. He is a hack! He is also arguing about those who use drugs being more likely to be abusers. Percentage wise yea for those with substance abuse issues, but he can’t say based off of random peoples ideas of what they’ve seen JD do and what AH has told them that JD was using, as much as those people have claimed. Even if JD did abuse drugs while with AH to the level she claimed, there’s also always exceptions to rules. Dr. Here is leaving out JDs history of being abused and pattern of relationship behavior. JD is always been know to come from a abusive mother so it’s very unlikely he would become an abuser after what he endured knowing how it felt. He also has no past “victims”, at his age and dating as long as he has he should have at least 1 female to testify that he beat her. No abuser just picks one partner to abuse. They have a long trail of bodies behind them. All JDs exes speak his praise, even those that don’t like him like Ellen Barken still stated he wasn’t abusive. Jealous and maybe a little controlling but they also dated when he was very young. All his other exes think highly of him still.
This ‘expert’ witness needs to be the one getting a psychological examination
I know right.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
😆😆
😂😂😂
Indeed ...I believe he need Dr. Curry😂😂