This was quite a monumental task to take on. I understood the Who Shot Johnny Joestar scenario, but exploring it in detail (locations of characters, which Alternate World each character was in at the current time, etc..) was a lot to think about. I'm glad to have gotten this video done and I really hope it sheds some light on the mystery for you guys. I also do Stand Analysis videos where I analyze as deeply as I can, various Stands and their mechanics. I have done Tusk, D4C and Boku no Rhythm wo Kiitekure from Steel Ball Run as of right now. Feel free to check them out!
I have a question umm when valentine uses the American flag diego got tangled and he shot someone and into the other universe it appears to be Johnny joestar and this confused me
i still can't believe how incredibly elaborate valentine went to just confuse tf out of everyone, and at the same time managed to pull everything off so smoothly and seamlessly as if he had practiced this entire plan like a hundred times before
He must have had this idea for fucking with people's heads ever since he got D4C but never got the opportunity to use it until the encounter in Philadelphia.
Well he doesn't actually NEED to do that Cause his ability here is to seemingly make parallel worlds coexist So in that sense, he could only allow those worlds to coexist where everything goes smoothly as infinite worlds mean infinite possibilities Picking and choosing which one is the most confusing combination
Killing Johnny Joestar regularly: Funny Valentine: *Hmph.* Transporting several people (the witness x3 and the shooter x3) into different alternate universe just to shoot Johnny several times Valentine: *Yes, Yes!*
maybe since colours aren't canon in JoJo they could use differing colour palettes to represent different versions of Wekapio, Diego, Johnny and Valentine, that way we can track who's in which dimension and who shot which version of Johnny
@@thesimpostor6251 or to make it more subtle, change only the color of the sky, so that normal watchers get confused, and we could have valentine EXPLAIN his plan after the encounter, and to lower the uncertainty, we could also have him imply hes gonna arrange this encounter, right before it happens, this way: 1: the viewers know somethings up 2: the viewers WILL be confused 3: the viewers Understand, depending on the execution, this last step should NOT be necessary, because GOOD directors will try their hardest to make the encounter make sense as it develops, show, dont tell (araki chose not to explain it directly, altho it may not have worked out so well)
@@Mreoewwmrow See it isn't that Araki didn't do a good job By reading, you do get a sense that some weird dimensional coexistence shenanigans are happening Valentine himself confirms this by saying that D4C allows parallel worlds to coexist The confusion comes from the latter D4C chapters where the ability seems different When you look at these 2 together, you can't help but thing that there is internal contradiction
After learning what D4C's true ability was, I looked at his initial exposition about "making multiple universes exist in the same space" not as ArakiForgot, but as Funny deliberately giving misinformation to hide the truth. It would make sense in universe too, as Funny would not want to reveal his hand until he was sure of victory and even then he would try and keep as much hidden as possible.
@@BizarreStarPlatinum glad to hear it. I also somewhat believe that Funny Valentine, at least the main antagonist of the main timeline with D4C, doesn't exist as we think he does. My theory posits that "Funny" actually has the same situation that Diavolo has, where the Stand is him. Not that the Stand is a manifestation of him, but that the Stand basically takes control of the body, erasing whatever ego might have existed prior and that is why only 1 version of D4C exists. It is a body-snatching parasitic Stand, and Funny is just a meat-puppet. I extend that to Diavolo, because I think the "Diavolo" persona is actually King Crimson assuming a puppeteering state over Dopio's body. Add in the Anime's way of handling the voices and you can see what I mean.
@@IansMentalOmega My only problem with the Diavolo analogy is that the 'Diavolo' personality probably existed before he unearthed the Arrows. As far as Valentine goes, there's a lot to unpack with that. It's said that every version of Valentine shares the same ideals, but that completely true? D4C definitely transfers memory, so what's to say it can't transfer will and ideals as well?
@@IansMentalOmega Before D4C gets shot by the infinitely spinning nail, Funny Valentine tells him to "get inside of the light", of which D4C takes a while to respond and stares at Johnny and Tusk ACT 4. I do agree D4C shows sentience through.
0:55 Phantom Scene 2:26 D4C’s Initial Tendency 4:41 The Main Crusaders 5:35 The Witnesses are Unbreakable 6:43 Wekapipo’s Golden Account 9:39 Diego Stone’s Account 14:17 Steel Valentine’s Account 16:20 The Conclusolion
This scene is more confusing the 2nd time reading it, the 1st time you understand that FV can "merge several realities and events", or at least that he is moving the culprits or the witnesses in different worlds as he wish, but then the story make it quite clear (/his abilities were modified) that he can transport people and obects, but he must do it manually by taking them with him. So when you read part 7 again, bc you forget the events, but remember the "final" D4C, it's a wilder cerebral ride than 1st time
Yep, I just noticed that too. It seems that many details in SBR are retconned later on. Mixing and merging universes; creating a sort of omniverse are later nerfed to manually transporting things and people using 2 surfaces, just like you said. Also 3 different Valentines were able to use their D4C simultaneously in a manga panel which is also limited down to 1 D4C per universe during the love train arc. Stand users in earlier parts were able to see, hear and smell, even talk and breath via their stand. But in part 6, Pucci momentarily blinds Jolyne so she couldn't fight properly while her stand was completely fine to throw punches on its own. Stand analogies are very inconsistencies at times.
@@BizarreStarPlatinum you deverse to get 10x more subs you have rn. Your theorys and stand analysis better than millions of yters. And you post vids on my fav anime! Keep up the good work!!
Phoenix and Edgeworth just holding their heads in their hands, wondering what in God's name they did to deserve this shit. It's all they can do just to not drink their woes away.
When you use your main villain's unique ability to create a masterfully crafted unsolvable crime, but the fans don't understand it and hate it because they couldn't solve it 😐
Finally! I knew you were going to tackle this at some point. Been waiting for a video on this since i can just send a link to people that don't understand
@@Ipetam Nah I don't think that happened, mostly because the clones seem to gain the og Funny Valentine's conscience after getting D4C (Idk if I explained it right, take it with a grain of salt) Edit: Maybe he went and asked his clones to get the random people, but still, only one of them has D4C, and if he sent each Valentine into each dimension, he would still need to retrieve them individually, since the alternate Valentine's can't travel dimensions without D4C.
The changes in relative space between universes is likely because the portal appears in the flag. If the flag is positioned in a different position, then the portals will still take them to the other flag (other valentines likely positioned the flags, or other subordinates disguised as civilians
Basically, Valentine used his universe shifting ability to trick Wekapipo and Diego into shooting Johnny to make them fight and get rid of all 3 if them.
Even with you carefully holding my hand and explaining it to me it was still a monumental task on my end to interpret it all lol. Thank you for the explanation, I can’t wait to see myself and other anitubers decipher this yugioh millennium puzzle 🧩 when it becomes animated years from now
One of the things which made me not like part 7 that much, was how Araki REALLY tried to make us confused. All the other parts made us get really confused because We didn't know the abilities or the causes for some event, but We got good explanations from the parts themselves, here We needed outside help, and even then it still is hard to get.
Congratulations on figuring this out and managing to explain it in video form. My brain was sadly too small to follow throughout the whole explanation, but I can tell you put a shit ton of time thinking this through, so yeah, great video! ✨✨
So judging from that Sponge analogy, Valentine had the power to manipulate reality in the aspect of fate. With his clone he created a scenario that was beneficial to his plan. Using his clone he made it to where a desired situation was happening in a alt world, which he wanted to happen in the root world, and then forced it to happen in 2 different realities making the root world also have the result as well.
Not fate, but space-time. The reason he was able to get these scenarios is because he has an infinite number of universes to choose from. One of them is bound to have the proper outcome
I just finished sbr manga and got really confused who shot Johnny (Important Version of Johnny) so thank you for making this video but it is also explained that Valentine can transport a person to alternate universe by putting them between two objects. Now, I understand how Valentine transported Wekapipo and Diego but how did he transported the 2 girls and 3 boys to the alternate universe and return them to the root world?
Hey there Star. First I wanted to say that your channel and content is absolutely awesome. It reminds me of Meti's but with a certain vibe that makes it a bit more enjoyable. And second. I wanted to know if there was anyway of letting you know recommendations about next stand analisys. Anyway, keep on the fantastic job man. I'll be here on every vid you upload!!!
Thank you! And yeah I always do my best to read through every comment I get, though it is getting harder as the channel grows. If you did want to leave a Stand Analysis suggestion, feel free to leave a comment on any video, or to tweet me at @BStarPlatinum. Thanks!
Holy shit :0. You explained who shot Johnny joestar better than any TH-camr I've ever seen! You are criminally underated, this deserves more attention! BTW I subscribed :)
Great job man, you deserve so many more subscribers. I love your vids and really appreciate this video because of how confusing this arc was lol. Anyway keep up the great work and thank you so much for this great content!
Oh yes. I've certainly got some takes on this arc and what D4C's ability was originally meant to be. But first, we must discuss parallel universes-I mean timelines.
I remember another video done by someone who tried to explain this, it was nearly an hour long, also explaining about the witnesses seeing different people shoot him, though unfortunately I think is was either xforts or medinotthebadguy who has since deleted the video.
First you take the chance on analysis for made in heaven and it worked really well,and now explain the who shot johnny situation now this is great,i had a rough idea about it and kept reading but now i feel big brain because i will understand it easily when i read it again Good! Great video man,keep up the good good work,also,a shame thag chocolate disco was only a distraction,that stand was really cool
Wekipipo shoots an alternate Johnny and is brought back, Diego shoots an alternate Wekipipo in the base world but is lead to believe he shot base Johnny and valentine moves between objects to set these situations up and shoots the actual Johnny so the answer is clear it was valentine.
So basically a mind fuck kinda situation where they ALL shot johnny (well different versions of him aka not root world) and so every one shot Johnny Joestar
I think your explanation is closest to correctly explaining the tusk arc although I have one question. Johnny was able to get Tusk act 3 based on the corpse with Jesus guiding him, and the corpse only exists in the Root World. If so, alternate world Johnnys wouldn't be able to use Tusk act 3 to escape through the drain. How do you think about this?
Ok, so root valentine shot root johnny, so he shot johnny joestar. Wekapipo and diego shot alternate johnny's and were seen alternately by 2 groups split into the 2nd and 3rd world, respectively. Wekapipo was moved here by a 2nd valentine, and diego was moved here by root valentine. Diego shoots at a 2nd wekapipo before being moved, but there is no 2nd diego because diego disguised as a guard. Root valentine moves diego from independence hall to 3rd world johnny at the park before he shoots 2nd wekapipo, and then valentine goes between the horses in the root world to shoot root johnny, the painter sees this. Huff
Well now I want to know where Johnny's from Alternate Timelines got their stands since root world Johnny got his from the corpse (at least from what most say, since he loses Tusk when He loses the Left Arm). I can believe they got theirs from the Devil's Palm since I always read it as A) You get Stands from traveling through the area and B) The Devil's Palm is independent from the corpse given that it's caused by a meteor crash. If that's the case though, and it's merely the Devil's Palm that gives the alternate worlds their stand abilities, does that mean AW Valentine never traveled throw the Devil's Palm? Or did they all link together under D4C by doing so? Can Valentine not travel to a world where he doesn't exist or never traveled through the Devil's Palm? Does another Valentine get control of D4C if RW Valentine isn't using it? If not, how come AW Johnny always seemed to be having a problem fighting AW Valentine (like when RW Valentine kept trying to get away from the Infinite Rotation? I haven't seen the D4C analysis just yet when commenting on this.
I think D4C’s ability didn’t change. Diego and Wikapipo could have been walking in the Root World at slightly different times, with Diego being tailed by an Alternate Wikapipo. Diego gets attacked and brought to an alternate world where he shoots. Wikapipo does almost the same thing, following an alternate Diego after Diego had already been zapped to an alternate world. Wikapipo does his stuff and shoots an alternate Johnny. Then Diego could have been sent back through the portal (he had a good idea of the ability, so he may have noticed this happening), along with Wikapipo. All of the witnesses were taken to the Root world from the other worlds (except the Artist). The changes in position are because the Portals D4C uses are connected to the objects in other worlds (the earth he was trapped in during his defeat stayed in the same position because it’s the ground, so it wouldn’t have been moved). With an infinite amount of Man power, it is possible. And since transportation between the portals can happen so seamlessly the target doesn’t notice, everyone is thrown off because they don’t know what the President’s ability is. The scene superimposing Wikapipo and Diego is essentially a diagram, since Wikapipo is drawn with the blur Araki uses for thinking/narration and transitioning out of flashbacks.
I think Funny Valentine Shot Rootworld Jonny Joestar, it makes the most sense since he is the main Villain, which has to seem both powerful and threatening at the same time. in order to make a good villain.
The president shot Johnny, due to D4C's ability of traveling to different dimensions, the president is able to clone himself by having him and the alternate him to come back to the main dimension
This was quite a monumental task to take on. I understood the Who Shot Johnny Joestar scenario, but exploring it in detail (locations of characters, which Alternate World each character was in at the current time, etc..) was a lot to think about. I'm glad to have gotten this video done and I really hope it sheds some light on the mystery for you guys.
I also do Stand Analysis videos where I analyze as deeply as I can, various Stands and their mechanics. I have done Tusk, D4C and Boku no Rhythm wo Kiitekure from Steel Ball Run as of right now. Feel free to check them out!
You will never be the first to comment
You have a beautiful reading voice
Please do a video on c moon I love your content keep doing what you love
EDIT: sorry im 5 hours late school
Ok
I have a question umm when valentine uses the American flag diego got tangled and he shot someone and into the other universe it appears to be Johnny joestar and this confused me
Plot twist: Johnny shot himself to assert dominance on everyone
he does that to activate act 's ability, so really all of them did
@@koopertrooper7008 yeah lmao
Again?
chad civil war move
It's obviously Diavolo, he is the only character with that shadowy figure.
Gyro your not wrong
*sad DIO noises*
@@_-A. S H U T
It would be canon if diavolo die at the end
The Zeppeli family are really good at dying
"imma mix three universes together so i can shoot a cripple and dont suffer consecuenses"
-Funny Valentine.
Everyone who has already read Steel Ball Run: Who shot Johnny?!
Valentine, Diego and Wekapipo: YES
The real culprit who shot Johnny were the friend's we made along the way
I don’t get it?
@@JMeisterV It's a joke on the overused "the real treasure is the friends we made along the way" trope.
You got me in the first half, ngl
So a friend that we made shot Johnny? Traitor!
I knew Slow dancer was the culprit
i still can't believe how incredibly elaborate valentine went to just confuse tf out of everyone, and at the same time managed to pull everything off so smoothly and seamlessly as if he had practiced this entire plan like a hundred times before
He must have had this idea for fucking with people's heads ever since he got D4C but never got the opportunity to use it until the encounter in Philadelphia.
He perfectly imagined it all in his head, and pulled it off perfectly. Something that can only happen in anime
Well he doesn't actually NEED to do that
Cause his ability here is to seemingly make parallel worlds coexist
So in that sense, he could only allow those worlds to coexist where everything goes smoothly as infinite worlds mean infinite possibilities
Picking and choosing which one is the most confusing combination
Well he probably *did* practice it
I promise you. After pulling this off he was fully erect for a few hours.
I think it was a gun that shoot johnny
This man has figured it out. Everybody go home.
@@BizarreStarPlatinum gimmie star platinum the world analysis and ill go home :))
This dude right here got 500 IQ
@E boi ;-;
@@BizarreStarPlatinum if did have to have a real idea for a stand analysis video, it would be King Crimson
Killing Johnny Joestar regularly:
Funny Valentine: *Hmph.*
Transporting several people (the witness x3 and the shooter x3) into different alternate universe just to shoot Johnny several times
Valentine: *Yes, Yes!*
I wonder how all of this is gonna look in the anime when it eventually gets animated a long time from now
maybe since colours aren't canon in JoJo they could use differing colour palettes to represent different versions of Wekapio, Diego, Johnny and Valentine, that way we can track who's in which dimension and who shot which version of Johnny
@@thesimpostor6251 oooooo, that would be great
@@thesimpostor6251 or to make it more subtle, change only the color of the sky, so that normal watchers get confused, and we could have valentine EXPLAIN his plan after the encounter, and to lower the uncertainty, we could also have him imply hes gonna arrange this encounter, right before it happens,
this way:
1: the viewers know somethings up
2: the viewers WILL be confused
3: the viewers Understand, depending on the execution, this last step should NOT be necessary, because GOOD directors will try their hardest to make the encounter make sense as it develops, show, dont tell (araki chose not to explain it directly, altho it may not have worked out so well)
@@Mreoewwmrow See it isn't that Araki didn't do a good job
By reading, you do get a sense that some weird dimensional coexistence shenanigans are happening
Valentine himself confirms this by saying that D4C allows parallel worlds to coexist
The confusion comes from the latter D4C chapters where the ability seems different
When you look at these 2 together, you can't help but thing that there is internal contradiction
i want it to be as confusing and scary as possible
The real question is how Johnny survive the shooting
Jesus
I think it's another dimension
Holy Spirit.
Spin.
Uh quite literally got advice from a specific person
“Who shot Johnny Joestar? EXPLAINED”
*sees 20 minutes
Oh boy this is gonna be fun
Mista did it
@@johnnyjoestar3198 yes
@@johnnyjoestar3198 bruh you joined a day ago nani
The homework: **Johnny Joestar was shot**
The quiz: **three people shot Johnny Joestar**
The test:
After learning what D4C's true ability was, I looked at his initial exposition about "making multiple universes exist in the same space" not as ArakiForgot, but as Funny deliberately giving misinformation to hide the truth. It would make sense in universe too, as Funny would not want to reveal his hand until he was sure of victory and even then he would try and keep as much hidden as possible.
I like this theory!
@@BizarreStarPlatinum glad to hear it.
I also somewhat believe that Funny Valentine, at least the main antagonist of the main timeline with D4C, doesn't exist as we think he does.
My theory posits that "Funny" actually has the same situation that Diavolo has, where the Stand is him.
Not that the Stand is a manifestation of him, but that the Stand basically takes control of the body, erasing whatever ego might have existed prior and that is why only 1 version of D4C exists. It is a body-snatching parasitic Stand, and Funny is just a meat-puppet.
I extend that to Diavolo, because I think the "Diavolo" persona is actually King Crimson assuming a puppeteering state over Dopio's body. Add in the Anime's way of handling the voices and you can see what I mean.
@@IansMentalOmega My only problem with the Diavolo analogy is that the 'Diavolo' personality probably existed before he unearthed the Arrows.
As far as Valentine goes, there's a lot to unpack with that. It's said that every version of Valentine shares the same ideals, but that completely true? D4C definitely transfers memory, so what's to say it can't transfer will and ideals as well?
@@IansMentalOmega Before D4C gets shot by the infinitely spinning nail, Funny Valentine tells him to "get inside of the light", of which D4C takes a while to respond and stares at Johnny and Tusk ACT 4.
I do agree D4C shows sentience through.
Dude, the amount of people who think that D4C has two abilities...
0:55 Phantom Scene
2:26 D4C’s Initial Tendency
4:41 The Main Crusaders
5:35 The Witnesses are Unbreakable
6:43 Wekapipo’s Golden Account
9:39 Diego Stone’s Account
14:17 Steel Valentine’s Account
16:20 The Conclusolion
W comment
@@maileraineadao7377 fr
19:38 Outrolands
This scene is more confusing the 2nd time reading it, the 1st time you understand that FV can "merge several realities and events", or at least that he is moving the culprits or the witnesses in different worlds as he wish, but then the story make it quite clear (/his abilities were modified) that he can transport people and obects, but he must do it manually by taking them with him. So when you read part 7 again, bc you forget the events, but remember the "final" D4C, it's a wilder cerebral ride than 1st time
Yep, I just noticed that too. It seems that many details in SBR are retconned later on. Mixing and merging universes; creating a sort of omniverse are later nerfed to manually transporting things and people using 2 surfaces, just like you said. Also 3 different Valentines were able to use their D4C simultaneously in a manga panel which is also limited down to 1 D4C per universe during the love train arc.
Stand users in earlier parts were able to see, hear and smell, even talk and breath via their stand. But in part 6, Pucci momentarily blinds Jolyne so she couldn't fight properly while her stand was completely fine to throw punches on its own. Stand analogies are very inconsistencies at times.
Your channel is underrated. Keep doing what you do man❤️❤️
Appreciate it!
@@BizarreStarPlatinum you deverse to get 10x more subs you have rn. Your theorys and stand analysis better than millions of yters. And you post vids on my fav anime! Keep up the good work!!
@@coltonPW I agree
@@blackbabyboybene.o ty!! :DD
@@coltonPW is your life jojo?
Everyone is asking "who shot Johnny", bruh. It happened in like chapter 2
Bro, did you even read the manga
@@dookan755 yes I did, why are you asking?
@@ragebrage it happend way later,and we still dont know who killed him for sure.
@@dekarmeryalmar8774 no one killed him. I am talking about the kid that shot Johnny outside the theatre, which was coincidentally named in the video.
I think they don't get the joke, but either way the video already mentioned that so your joke really isn't relevant.
If ace attorney and jojo were in the alternate world then this would be the most god damn confusing case in ace attorney
Phoenix and Edgeworth just holding their heads in their hands, wondering what in God's name they did to deserve this shit. It's all they can do just to not drink their woes away.
Would make a great Case 6 for a Danganronpa game
When you use your main villain's unique ability to create a masterfully crafted unsolvable crime, but the fans don't understand it and hate it because they couldn't solve it 😐
Finally! I knew you were going to tackle this at some point.
Been waiting for a video on this since i can just send a link to people that don't understand
Good stuff! Thanks for sharing and for the support :)
every single video you release is wonderful!
you're the most informative jojo youtuber
Thank you :)
The only part that confused me was the random people who clearly came from other timelines. HOW DID HE SWITCH THAT MANY PEOPLE
Hard work
I know only one Valentine has D4C, but he could always have his doubles select victims, and all he has to do is go down the list and switch them all.
@@Ipetam Nah I don't think that happened, mostly because the clones seem to gain the og Funny Valentine's conscience after getting D4C (Idk if I explained it right, take it with a grain of salt)
Edit: Maybe he went and asked his clones to get the random people, but still, only one of them has D4C, and if he sent each Valentine into each dimension, he would still need to retrieve them individually, since the alternate Valentine's can't travel dimensions without D4C.
The changes in relative space between universes is likely because the portal appears in the flag. If the flag is positioned in a different position, then the portals will still take them to the other flag (other valentines likely positioned the flags, or other subordinates disguised as civilians
I remember being so confused the first time I read it lmao
Literally the best jojotuber and so underrated! The editing is phenomenal and the different segments on the progress bar are the cherry on top
tysm, I've have been struggling to figure this out. This whole situation was like trying to figure out the king crimson and epitaph situation x 100
Basically, Valentine used his universe shifting ability to trick Wekapipo and Diego into shooting Johnny to make them fight and get rid of all 3 if them.
Even with you carefully holding my hand and explaining it to me it was still a monumental task on my end to interpret it all lol. Thank you for the explanation, I can’t wait to see myself and other anitubers decipher this yugioh millennium puzzle 🧩 when it becomes animated years from now
Tbh one of the best channels that explain all the things most people misunderstood about stands from Jojo. Could you do King Crimson next???
One of the things which made me not like part 7 that much, was how Araki REALLY tried to make us confused. All the other parts made us get really confused because We didn't know the abilities or the causes for some event, but We got good explanations from the parts themselves, here We needed outside help, and even then it still is hard to get.
Congratulations on figuring this out and managing to explain it in video form. My brain was sadly too small to follow throughout the whole explanation, but I can tell you put a shit ton of time thinking this through, so yeah, great video! ✨✨
Who shot johnny joestar: *yes*
If ever this arc is animated in a single episode then we will watch Johnny attacked 3 times and then another 1 for the final explaination. Bruh
'' Who shot Johnny Joestar? EXPLAINED ''
Me : Yes.
You make such great explanation videos. I cannot express how you brighten my day. Keep it on level!
I'm glad to hear it, and your support is greatly appreciated!
Hopefully when the anime adaptation comes out in 3031 they can make this arc less confusing!
"Yada yadadada
It is good day to be Not Dead"
"Pow you are dead"
"I am dead!"
And thats how kids...Johnny was shot
how does he edit and have better qualitty than 1m subs and he has 28k why isn't thiS man at 10m
the answer: Johnny shoot himself with the infinite rotation
Ah yes Jojolion
This just made me think that shooting himself with the infinite rotation should've created Act 5
@@judgementkazzy5976 also civil war arc
Fantastic video and it’s the best explaining of what happened I’ve seen so far
Glad you enjoyed it
So judging from that Sponge analogy, Valentine had the power to manipulate reality in the aspect of fate. With his clone he created a scenario that was beneficial to his plan. Using his clone he made it to where a desired situation was happening in a alt world, which he wanted to happen in the root world, and then forced it to happen in 2 different realities making the root world also have the result as well.
Not fate, but space-time. The reason he was able to get these scenarios is because he has an infinite number of universes to choose from. One of them is bound to have the proper outcome
YES!!!! i needed an explanation for this!!! to have you tackle this is amazing, im real happy!!!
This man really took this task
I saw in "Doctor who" same thing, multiple worlds placed in the same spot, in the same time.
D4C was in effect no one just saw it
I just finished sbr manga and got really confused who shot Johnny (Important Version of Johnny) so thank you for making this video but it is also explained that Valentine can transport a person to alternate universe by putting them between two objects. Now, I understand how Valentine transported Wekapipo and Diego but how did he transported the 2 girls and 3 boys to the alternate universe and return them to the root world?
Johnny: *gets shot by an unknown person in the choclate disco chapter*
The whole JoJo community: *WRITE THAT DOWN, WRITE THAT DOWN*
Hey there Star. First I wanted to say that your channel and content is absolutely awesome. It reminds me of Meti's but with a certain vibe that makes it a bit more enjoyable. And second. I wanted to know if there was anyway of letting you know recommendations about next stand analisys. Anyway, keep on the fantastic job man. I'll be here on every vid you upload!!!
Thank you! And yeah I always do my best to read through every comment I get, though it is getting harder as the channel grows.
If you did want to leave a Stand Analysis suggestion, feel free to leave a comment on any video, or to tweet me at @BStarPlatinum.
Thanks!
I just finished reading the Colored Steel Ball Run manga. Might be my favorite part between 1-7. Haven't started part 8 just yet.
How is Part 8
Johnny: Da da ia da ta ta, it is good day to be not dead ;)
💥
?: You are dead
Not the hero we deserve, but the hero we needed
Holy shit :0. You explained who shot Johnny joestar better than any TH-camr I've ever seen! You are criminally underated, this deserves more attention!
BTW I subscribed :)
Dude now thats one less mystery on my life. I can die in peace now
Great job man, you deserve so many more subscribers. I love your vids and really appreciate this video because of how confusing this arc was lol. Anyway keep up the great work and thank you so much for this great content!
Oh yes. I've certainly got some takes on this arc and what D4C's ability was originally meant to be. But first, we must discuss parallel universes-I mean timelines.
I dont know why but this dude is the best jojo youtuber I've ever seen..
Wow thank you!
I love your content, it sucks that jojo isn't relevant at the moment and i hope you get the recognition you deserved.
I'd say it's very relevant due to the David Productions anime. Plus the hype for this Jojo Animation event in April.
This man deserves more subs, great video
araki made me realize no matter how weird odd or wacky your manga is it can always be peak
This is the most complete breakdown of the mistery, thank you!
valentines stand intro being him essentially trolling everyone is so funny to me, dude couldve just shot him but he played some 4d chess instead
I remember another video done by someone who tried to explain this, it was nearly an hour long, also explaining about the witnesses seeing different people shoot him, though unfortunately I think is was either xforts or medinotthebadguy who has since deleted the video.
Awesome content man, I seriously love the explanations for the confusing aspects of JoJo.
Who would have thought that the greatest mistery in a bizarre adventure would be who shot a crippled.
This made everything clear. You sound so formal as well.
Love your vids bro...!
With how the story explains it EVERYONE shot jonny joestar including himself XD
My brain hurts
"Who shot johnny joestar?"
The blond guy with a gun.
This was one of the most confusing fights that I've ever seen on JoJo. And man did I think King Crimson's ability was confusing LMAO
funny valentine's stand is the embodiment of "me when i spread false information"
YES. Always happy to see peoples interpretation of this Arch.
Love hearing a recount. Great video.
The real question is what was Valentine's angle. Lol I need to knowwwww
Love the channel wish you more subs
*Jhonny appears*
Everyone: So anyway I started blasting.
I still don't understand, why Valentine did this, instead of sneaking and shooting Johny
I mean, if i had the ability to alter dimensions and mindfuck my enemies, i would pull this shit everytime the chance shows itself.
now this is a "But first, we need to talk about parallel universes" moment
D4C works because its user knows about half a button press
First you take the chance on analysis for made in heaven and it worked really well,and now explain the who shot johnny situation now this is great,i had a rough idea about it and kept reading but now i feel big brain because i will understand it easily when i read it again
Good! Great video man,keep up the good good work,also,a shame thag chocolate disco was only a distraction,that stand was really cool
13:26 "Diego and the bois are transferred back to the root world"
I can't wait to see this animated and anime-only viewers be confused af.
Everyone asks: Who shot Johnny Joestar, and not, Why shoot Johnny Joestar 😔😔😔😔
Wekipipo shoots an alternate Johnny and is brought back, Diego shoots an alternate Wekipipo in the base world but is lead to believe he shot base Johnny and valentine moves between objects to set these situations up and shoots the actual Johnny so the answer is clear it was valentine.
So basically a mind fuck kinda situation where they ALL shot johnny (well different versions of him aka not root world) and so every one shot Johnny Joestar
Good one. I prefer Hamon beats explanation as it’s much more simpler but this one did make me look at this scene a bit differently.
Ngl, im pretty surprised that you start barely a year ago. You have my high respect. I am a Closet Weeb. You know your manga kid.
I think your explanation is closest to correctly explaining the tusk arc although I have one question. Johnny was able to get Tusk act 3 based on the corpse with Jesus guiding him, and the corpse only exists in the Root World. If so, alternate world Johnnys wouldn't be able to use Tusk act 3 to escape through the drain. How do you think about this?
Mais no é só no mundo raiz que dar pra ter stands.
Ok, so root valentine shot root johnny, so he shot johnny joestar.
Wekapipo and diego shot alternate johnny's and were seen alternately by 2 groups split into the 2nd and 3rd world, respectively. Wekapipo was moved here by a 2nd valentine, and diego was moved here by root valentine. Diego shoots at a 2nd wekapipo before being moved, but there is no 2nd diego because diego disguised as a guard.
Root valentine moves diego from independence hall to 3rd world johnny at the park before he shoots 2nd wekapipo, and then valentine goes between the horses in the root world to shoot root johnny, the painter sees this.
Huff
Who really shot Jonny Joestar?
- It was me DIO!!!
Well now I want to know where Johnny's from Alternate Timelines got their stands since root world Johnny got his from the corpse (at least from what most say, since he loses Tusk when He loses the Left Arm). I can believe they got theirs from the Devil's Palm since I always read it as A) You get Stands from traveling through the area and B) The Devil's Palm is independent from the corpse given that it's caused by a meteor crash.
If that's the case though, and it's merely the Devil's Palm that gives the alternate worlds their stand abilities, does that mean AW Valentine never traveled throw the Devil's Palm? Or did they all link together under D4C by doing so? Can Valentine not travel to a world where he doesn't exist or never traveled through the Devil's Palm?
Does another Valentine get control of D4C if RW Valentine isn't using it? If not, how come AW Johnny always seemed to be having a problem fighting AW Valentine (like when RW Valentine kept trying to get away from the Infinite Rotation?
I haven't seen the D4C analysis just yet when commenting on this.
If D4C is the acronym, then Dimes 4 Crimes is the true shortened name
I think D4C’s ability didn’t change. Diego and Wikapipo could have been walking in the Root World at slightly different times, with Diego being tailed by an Alternate Wikapipo. Diego gets attacked and brought to an alternate world where he shoots. Wikapipo does almost the same thing, following an alternate Diego after Diego had already been zapped to an alternate world. Wikapipo does his stuff and shoots an alternate Johnny. Then Diego could have been sent back through the portal (he had a good idea of the ability, so he may have noticed this happening), along with Wikapipo. All of the witnesses were taken to the Root world from the other worlds (except the Artist). The changes in position are because the Portals D4C uses are connected to the objects in other worlds (the earth he was trapped in during his defeat stayed in the same position because it’s the ground, so it wouldn’t have been moved). With an infinite amount of Man power, it is possible. And since transportation between the portals can happen so seamlessly the target doesn’t notice, everyone is thrown off because they don’t know what the President’s ability is.
The scene superimposing Wikapipo and Diego is essentially a diagram, since Wikapipo is drawn with the blur Araki uses for thinking/narration and transitioning out of flashbacks.
My brain stopped thinking
this will be hell for anime only’s when it gets animated
I think Funny Valentine Shot Rootworld Jonny Joestar, it makes the most sense since he is the main Villain, which has to seem both powerful and threatening at the same time. in order to make a good villain.
I had to go back and reread the chapters about 3 times a piece
Answer: everyone
The president shot Johnny, due to D4C's ability of traveling to different dimensions, the president is able to clone himself by having him and the alternate him to come back to the main dimension
Can't wait another 50 years when part 7 gets animated so I can watch this whole cluster fuck.
Araki really said “fuck animators, no one will animate this part”
And made part 7 all about horses
There are 3 impostors among us...
>>>Di-S-co was ejected