Always glad to see a reactor watching one of my remastered versions, I made them because I didn't like to see people's first impressions with Rush being 10 year old 240p clips with bad audio, with music this complex every detail should be preserved. You also really know what you are talking about music wise, I would take lessons from someone like yourself, great job glad you enjoyed it :)
First, thank you for taking the time to leave a comment - and such a nice one at that. I (as well as many others) am appreciative of the time and effort you put into this remastered version. This video wouldn't have been the same without it so, kudos! Thanks again for stopping by and hope you're safe and well
@@jessicasopranonotes Thank you for the kind words, I watch a lot of Rush reactions but yours stood out as being very genuine and worth watching because you actually had valuable input and feedback rather than just sitting there watching it like a lot of lazier channels lol. If you get any more Rush requests take a look at my library as i've got enough HD Rush projects to last you about a century or so.. XD
Dear Sir or Madam, pardon if that offends, I'm old, not up on all the current pronouns. Thank you so much for this! This was the best sounding Rush live video I've ever heard. The bass snarls, the drums crack, the guitar crunches like hell in the verses and rings like a bell in the solo. Absolutely fantastic work, my deepest thanks and respect! Cheers!
I’ve listened to this song for 40 years...I’ve heard hundreds of reactions. I’ve never watched a reaction that was so good at breaking down a song than you. That was incredible! Please, please do Subdivisions by Rush. I learned so much about a song that I thought I knew by watching you...thank you! 😎
Absolutely true. I love Rush, lyrics and technical skill. I know they are supposed to be hard to play, but I know nothing about music. Loved the details on all these time signature changes. Watching others react, I have gained so much more respect for Alex. I especially appreciated all the love from a new fan. Welcome to the family.
Someone with her musical expertise being humble enough to acknowledge the otherworldly talent of Neil's drumming being beyond her is one of the best compliments I've ever heard.
@@jessicasopranonotes more Rush. Look at their wiki. The drummer died of brain cancer. He left a legacy of music. Check out his drum solos and the last song he made called The Garden. It's been know to bring some to tears. RIP Neil.
Neil Peart and Glen Frey are the only two musicians I've ever cried for when they passed. I really really felt a loss in my soul (I dont know what other word to use) ugh.. gonna need me some Tom Sawyer or Fly by Night or Roll the Bones after this! Lol.
I can’t even begin to explain or describe how much I enjoyed your analysis. RUSH is truly in a class all by themselves. Neil Pert (RIP) was an insanely talented percussionist
I've become a little numb by all the reaction videos out there. Yours is a breath of fresh air. Your response is uniquely yours, full of technical and honest details. I actually believe you had never heard the song, and it's lovely to hear what new listeners "think and feel" about the song. Thank you!
OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. I have never heard anyone explain how they do it before! Just makes my appreciation of this band even more! Thank You!!!!!!
This is a great breakdown especially for first listen. Also check out Rick Beato's "What makes this song great?" episode on Limelight studio version. He is able to play the vocals in isolation and it really highlights Geddy's *amazing* pitch quality. Rick also digs into the drum parts, 3 over 4 patterns switch up in the middle of a chorus, etc.
@@katskillz no offense to Rick Beato but I really like her breakdown more than his. He doesnt describe the theory he just tells you its there. Hes telling us what notes are being used and she tells us why...at least in her opinion and I really like that. Definitely need more Rush reaction videos here.
As someone who tries to enjoy the technical aspects of great music like this without formal education, I really appreciate you doing the hard work of breaking this down for us. I look forward to many more videos from you. I also thought it was great that you pulled in the work of a friend. That is class
There are tons of people who have never heard of this great band. Rush made fantastic music for over 40 years and I was a huge fan almost from the beginning. There will probably never be a three man band with this much talent ever again. RIP Neil!
Jess, I'm really glad I stumbled across your channel! Yours is the first reaction channel I've found to actually break down and explain what's going on in a song. I've been a Rush fan all of my life and I really enjoyed this breakdown. Thanks so much for providing a really fun and instructional reaction channel. Absolutely wonderful!
I just came across here too. It's the best analysis I think that I've ever witnessed to the complex structure of a Rush song. Your explanation seems to be dead on target with the only exception of mentioning the tempo changes. But, with this band, you might have made it a little easier on yourself by choosing one of the lesser complex ones. 😀 They did this for 40 years, and there are many, many more that you can break down. I can't wait for you to get there. I subbed in to watch you do it. Thanks for your lesson.
I have to say as a musician, it's so refreshing to watch someone react to these songs that actually is very knowledgeable of music and music structure.bravo! And being beautiful doesn't hurt either.lol
THE most musically aware and knowledgeable Rush reaction I’ve ever seen. Well done! If opera is your forte you will definitely enjoy: - Xanadu (based on an unfinished poem by Samuel Taylor Coleridge) The live performance from Exit…Stage Left will show you how Neil Peart was so much more than just a drummer. Also, if you choose to react to this one, pay special attention to Alex’s and Geddy’s feet. Both of them play full-octave pedal boards during this song while also playing their respective guitars. - Cygnus X-1 Books I and II are an exploration of the essence of humanity through the eyes of a quixotic hero, who travels into a black hole seeking answers. - 2112 is the tale of a young man living in a dystopian future society where music and individual expression have been cast aside. This was Rush’s follow up to an ambitious but poorly selling concept album called Caress of Steel. Their label instructed them to create an album with short catchy radio-friendly hits. Instead, Rush gave them 2112, and it blew the prog rock world away. Ironically, after this album their label gave them complete creative freedom, and Rush began writing more shorter, catchy radio-friendly songs. These are the most “operatic” of their works, but every Rush song tells a story or has a message. Hope to see more reactions and breakdowns! ❤️
THe thing about Xanadu is that it is rhythmically very interesting and orchestrated very uniquely, but the underlying harmony and music 'theory' part is rather simple, not sure a breakdown at that level would be worthwhile
I have followed RUSH for about 37 years, and I am learning new things by looking at them through the fresh eyes of new fans.. I love to see young people discover and appreciate great music! 🎼🎵🎵 🎤🎸🥁🎹
Good lord Jess, every video you post is a master class. Your observations and analysis are extremely valuable to anyone studying music. Thank you so much for the time and effort.
There’s another Canadian power-trio called Triumph, the lead singer/guitarist is a unbelievable. Normally if you are singing and playing the part you play while singing is not complicated. Rik Emmet can sustain a complex vocal line along with a challenging guitar melody.
Rush were always the musician's musicians. Much like De Kooning is the painter's painter or Kubrick is the film director's director. This deconstruction of yours is so good and comprehensive that if me and my band had seen this video 20 years ago we wouldn't even have bothered to try to cover Limelight ;)
This is the best thing I have ever seen on TH-cam. Thank you so much for taking such an in depth and intellectual look at this music. I have tried to have these conversations with people most of my life and the truth is most people would never want to spend this much time actually inside the music. Thanks so much.
Nicely done! "Xanadu" is probably their most operatic, based on samuel taylor coleridge's poem "Kubla Khan". Also glad you found StickHits's remastered version... he's remastered Xanadu too (from "Exit Stage Left" tour)
I enjoy watching Rush reactions but really, this is the only one I've ever seen whose technical analysis does their musicianship justice. You took my old musician ass to school. Thank you.
I absolutely LOVE it when someone who has real musical training reacts to RUSH. They are masters of their craft on a technical and performance level. They use all the tricks in the book and invented quite a few of their own. Their music is insanely complex and yet easily approachable. The lyrics are not your typical rock lyrics at all. Many are based in literary works. And holy crap all that sound is coming from just 3 guys. Geddy (singer/bassist) once said that they were trying to be the worlds smallest orchestra.
In truth, Alex knows some theory but is more of an instinctive creator than a compositional musician. Geddy and Neil were the composition guys and Alex the instinctive genius who created things on the fly by ear, soul and spirit. That’s how you get this brilliant soulful guitar solo that at first doesn’t seem to fit the tempo but fills the song with the sadness and longing that he believed Neil felt in dealing with their stardom that he, Neil, wrote about in the lyrics. Yes; the drummer wrote their lyrics and he’s generally considered the greatest drummer in rock history and called The Professor for good reason (RIP - Jan 7, 2020 - his loss the terrible start to that terrible year).
@@bobespirit2112 Yes, hardly "steeped in music theory". Rush's music didn't venture beyond major, minor and 7th chords. They were definitely very creative within those parameters.
This is from Exit Stage Left, and they overdubbed his vocals in the studio, so not quite how he actually sounds live, and I've seen them live many times and he never sounds this crisp
Holy Smokes!! This is one of the best Rush reactions I've seen (and I've seen hundreds...). As a lifelong Rush fan (and musician) it was great to see this kind of breakdown. Thanks, Jess!!! Subscribed!! My favorite part of the song is at the end of the guitar solo with the song in 3 with Neil playing in 4 over top of it. AND...on top of the amazing music, you have Neil's lyrics....
Wow! This is the best reaction to Limelight I have ever seen, hands down. Rush are the godfathers of progressive rock, and are commonly listed as a significant influence. Their complex time signature changes and superb musicianship make a three-person band sound like 5 or 6 people. Most fans can tell that they are talented but don't really understand why. You did an amazing job explaining why. Pleeease do more Rush. Plus, there's 40 years of amazing music for you to discover. I suggest Freewill or Tom Sawyer for the next one. There's also a great documentary on Netflix called Beyond the Lighted Stage.
great analysis, very in depth at 15:28 Alex, holds the final note of the guitar solo as he did in the studio with an overdub. here he holds that note live, which is such masterly attention to detail. he holds the note all the way to 15:35 when Geddy resumes singing.
The most underrated, musically complex 3 person band in rock. Their level of professionalism extends into their live performances too. They never short change an audience with a mediocre performance. A true Canadian treasure. Listening to your analysis reinforces what I always appreciated, they were more “ than meets the eye”. They didn’t succumb to what the record labels expected, they produced what they were drawn to create and 40 year body of work that evolved, and survived is testimony to something more than a simple three piece band. The album Moving Pictures, the instrumental La Villa Strangiato, and the first side of 2112 are a glimpse at that statement that we don’t care what the music industry wants, it’s what they needed to share.
Aye, I have had the joy of seeing them in concert and it was indescribable. I missed seeing them back in the 70's, when they came nearby, because I couldn't afford it (despite how cheap tickets were then :O) but I settled for seeing them in the 90's
I've been a life long Rush fan since the seventies and even played their songs a hundred times and thought I'd figured it all out.. I was wrong! This is BY FAR the most in depth and accurate deconstruction of a song I've ever seen and heard. Made me go back and rethink all their songs again. Thank you.. BRAVO!
All I can say is WOW.. what a detailed reaction. There are over 160 Rush songs spanning a 40 year career. Here are some songs to gat will blow your mind with time signature changes, Xanadu, YYZ, Natural Science, LaVilla Strangiato, Subdivisions and on and on… Enjoy your journey!!
The drummer Neil Peart was called the professor for good reason! On top of being one of the most talented drummers to ever grace the stage, he wrote most of the lyrics for Rush including this song! He was a fascinating, intelligent, kind and talented man. He is God among many drummers (myself included) and is sorely missed every day. Amazing breakdown!
I cannot express enough how much I loved your deep dive into this! Your understanding of structure and appreciation of a genre that is not the one you trained is is absolutely beautiful
Like I said on the direct chat... What a great job have you done!!! You are crazy!!!. I've never seen such a well done analysis. Your explanations are perfect, your examples well picked up... I have no words to describe you. A very big hug from Spain
@@jessicasopranonotes Everyone can notice that it is not a video made on the fly, it is a very, very worked video, both in terms of documentation and editing. This is a lot of work. On the other hand, as I say, your explanations are masterful. I can even add another detail as a person who does not speak English well, your pronunciation, your diction ability is amazing, I am able to understand everything you say despite my poor level of English.
I’ve been listening to this song for decades, and never picked up on how Alex sustains that high note at the end of the solo, which you figured out the first time! (To be fair, I wasn’t usually watching a video, just listening. But still, even when I saw him do that pedal, I didn’t get the significance of it until you explained.)
Yasss!!! You mentioned that super sustained note in his solo. It keeps on plowing through new vocals and, really, just everything. I am old enough to have bought this album on cassette, shortly after it was released but, being in high school, I had junk headphones or I listened to it in my car. I never even knew about that sustained note until much later when I replaced my cassette collection with re-mastered CDs. My mouth about hit the floor when I realized, "Wait a minute! What's that sound? OMG that's his sustain!" To this day, I pretty much listen to Lime Light mostly to re-experience that sustain note. Yea, I'm a little weird that way. Also, you are the very first Rush reactor (and there are a ton!) I have seen, to even comment on, much less highlight that. Your reaction got a "like" from me. Your attention to that single note made me a subscriber. Bravo, my dear.
Jess, now starts your journey down the Rush rabbit hole.....If you choose to do it, you'll come out the other side a changed person. FYI, 95% of the songs they do were written by the drummer, Neal Peart (aka The Professor). IMO, the greatest rock drummer of all time. Along with all of their other songs, please watch Neal's drum solo in Frankfurt.......greatness. Unfortunately, he passed in Jan. of 2020. RIP to the G.O.A.T.
Jess, This is one of the most impressive reactions of my favorite band I have ever seen.... and trust me, I have seen a LOT of them. One of the things that really impressed me was your observation of Alex's extended note at the end of the guitar solo. Nobody has ever mentioned that note and it has always been a favorite part of the song for me. Rush is known for doing extremely impressive and complex instrument layering in the recorded version. In the live version, they could have hired more musicians to do the work, but instead they insisted on doing it themselves. Geddy Lee does the same thing for Bass parts. It is to allow them to do more and perform the song the way it was meant to be performed. I think I can speak for many, many Rush fans by saying it is one of the things that we love about them. Their artistic and personal integrity, hard work ethic, and the fact that they are just genuinely real people, who just happened to be the best of friends for over forty years. All of this done without a public blemish (except one that I remember) in their sparkling reputation. Thank you for the fine analysis and reaction!
The complexity, and genius of these three guys is amazing!!!!!! The time signature changes, and the lyrics are incredible in all their music!!!!!! Check out Freewill, lyric version. Incredible
i love a thorough analysis like this. It really brings the point home that the complex concepts they utilize, their efforts to challenge themselves, all ultimately serve the song.
I’m 44 years old and saw RUSH 13 times over the years, starting in 1994 on their “Counterparts” Tour. I’m also a drummer and I was devastated when I heard of Neil’s death last year. I’m blown away by the analysis given here, as this is how *I* hear songs, too! I’m constantly picking the whole thing apart, and sometimes it’s hard for me to just ENJOY a song. RUSH will forever be in my heart and mind. “With the heart and mind united in a single… perfect… sphere”.
so awesome you were able to see them that many times! I have seen many comments over the passing of Neil. He seemed to have a very large impact on many people. very nice to have met you!
To watch these guys in concert is an absolute treat. Saw them a week before their last show. The fact that Alex plays guitar and does the bass lines with a pedal synth when Geddy is doing keyboard parts and Geddy does synth parts with foot pedals while he plays bass. They write songs that require more than 3 players and then figure out how to play them.
Wow!! This intelligent, educated, and beautiful lady just painted a masterpiece of an explanation of a view point which I was so impressed by her interpretation. To have the background in opera, to jump into R & R, and watch her emotions spill out for the camera was a treat! I have been listening to that song for about forty years (give or take a year), and she painted a picture that I could never have imagined. And respectfully of her courage to cross over a boundary to explore... I can only smile in amazement. I wish this classy lady all the best in the world!! Stay safe.
This has got to be the best musical breakdown of this song I have ever seen. I have been amazed at this song as with all of Rush's compositions since it was first released. The fact that only three guys on stage can make such complexed music like this is out of this world. Keep in mind that both Alex and Getty are multitasking with foot peddles synths and keyboards on top of playing their guitar and bass guitar, and singing is nothing short of incredible.
Good ear, that you caught Alex catching that held note in a loop. This song is one of their most sublime and has one of the best melodies they've ever written.
You said "I don't know if I fully understand what is going on with the drums..." I don't think anyone truly comprehends Neil's drumming. He's one of, if not the greatest drummer in rock history. I would love to see a reaction of "Jacobs ladder".
You and Neil Peart (drummer and writer of most of their songs) would've got along famously. Brilliant critical analysis. I imagine you two rambling on until dawn. Love it.
Alright, I’ve never been so captivated by something being explained to me that was so beyond my comprehension. That analysis was so thorough and informative and it didn’t hurt that the “Opera Singer” was stunning... anyhow, mind doing a similar analysis of another song from the same concert called “Xanadu”? It’s entirely a different beast, less poppy more conceptual.
I've never heard such an in-depth and detailed analysis of one of their songs before. What a joy to listen to you dissect music! Also, I'm very glad you picked out a recording from their earlier period. They played for 40 years. Once he was much older, it was a strain in concert to replicate the singing he did when he was much younger. It's nice to hear the choice of recording being something that was performed roughly the same time it was first written and recorded. He had such a warm and rich voice (well, once he mastered it, LOL). Oh, and they are three of the finest rock musicians to ever team up and grace a stage. And with Neil Peart (the drummer), he's widely considered to be one of the top drummers in history.
You've done an amazing job of deconstructing a song that I've loved for decades, I had no idea of its complexity. I learned a lot, you're an absolute joy to watch!
Wow!!! Outstanding breakdown lol! My jaw dropped when I saw that you reacted to this band. I’ve been a fan of Rush for 30 yrs. You are the s@!t Jess! Your technical knowledge when it comes to music is awesome. I even gave you a standing ovation at the end of your reaction. 👏👏👏 May I suggest these Rush songs for your next reaction: Xanadu or Camera Eye. Both are masterpieces. imho Thank you!
Superb analysis, very detailed and accurate. Not sure if you are aware, not only is Geddy a great vocalist but he is recognized as one of the greatest bass guitar players of all time. He also plays keyboards very, very well. Thank you for your reaction to my hometown band.
My pleasure. New subscriber and I really enjoyed seeing your reaction when you discovered just how talented and dedicated these guys are, it was beautiful to see.
I really love your analysis. You broke it down in such an understandable way for a music dummy like me. I've always loved this song for the feelings it evokes in me, not realizing how structurally difficult it is to play. RUSH does this with such finesse. I'm very grateful for your musical artistry as a opera soprano to appreciate Rush's complex song Limelight. Their fantastic body of work will amaze you.
Please please PLEASE look for Xanadu, from Exit Stage Left. Probably their best live performance showcasing their musicianship, and just how complex they can get.
My gosh. This has to be THE BEST review and commentary of my all time favorite band. Thank you, thank you thank you for the explanations of the techniques in the production if this song. Your genuine appreciation of their abilities and arrangement is appreciated and means so much coming from an artist of your caliber. It only further proves out why I feel they are one of the best bands in history. Not to mention, your reactions and your facial expressions were just adorable to watch. They’re the same for me even after all these years. It never gets old. Thank you!!! I am grateful to have found this review. I would love to see you review one of their other songs , La Villa Strangiatto. I think you would be blown away by it as well. You are a beautiful soul! Thank you!!
That was an amazing breakdown. I too have followed Rush since the 70’s and if you get into their music library, you will see they are the masters of time shifting…..all over the place!!!
I have just seen your reaction for the first time today, about 7 months after you released it, so you might have heard much of what I am about to tell you about Rush. Neil Peart, who passed away in 2020, is considered by many the best drummer in the history of rock and roll, and certainly a consensus top five best ever. He was also highly intelligent and very well read, and served as the band's lyricist. He was very uncomfortable in the spotlight and this song is his recognition of the trappings of fame. Geddy Lee is considered one of the ten best bass guitar players in rock history, later adding masterful synthesizer playing. He is also the only one of the three who sang and his distinctive voice lets the listener instantly know they are listening to Rush. Alex Lifeson is a master guitarist who never really got the recognition he deserved because he was in a band with two legendary musicians. Rush is considered prog (progressive) rock and was known in their early years for 20 minute epic story songs. Even as they began to create more radio friendly songs, you can take most any Rush song, read the lyrics without music, and be the better for having done so.
It’s always great to see folx be introduced to your favorite band and appreciate them. ❤️ What a terrific reaction, Jess. I hope you do more Rush. Thanks. 🙏🏼
Very impressed. You really know your music. Alot of people that try to analyze or breakdown a song don't really have a clue what their talking about. Btw....The effect Alex is using is a sustain petal that keeps that high note in his solo going as he starts picking the strings to end the solo.
All 3 members of this band have a Doctorates degree in music. This entire album, as well as several others, are iconic Hard/Progressive Rock albums. I'm glad you've found them, their music is some of the best we've ever heard. May I suggest The Spirit of Radio, Freewill, Tom Sawyer, or the entire A Side to the album 2112.
(They don't really have doctorates..I think you are just being complimentary of their skill but some may take this as truth. In fact, Alex and Geddy are high school drop-outs.)
Great reaction and analysis. Also, another nice touch in the song is the end of the guitar solo section where Alex exits the solo and plays his arpeggiated part in 3/4 while Neil on the drums exits that section playing a driving 4/4 rhythm until they all sync up again. Beauty, eh?
Well damn this is impressive. Breaking down so much going on is great to see. Rush were one of a kind making them the last of their kind, sadly. But 40 years of studio and live music is remarkable. Hope you do more Rush. La Villa Strangiato and The Camera Eye would be great to see you cover one day. Subscribed as this is my jam.
@@jessicasopranonotes I hope so.. your reaction was the best I’ve ever seen. You broke it down like a boss.. this was fantastic and I sent it to all my friends. Thank you!!
Gonna subscribe hoping you continue with this band. Your detail on their music is much more unique from other reactors. I would suggest "Xanadu" Exit Stage Left 1981.
Love the technical analysis. I've listed to Rush for decades and have always loved how they challenge themselves musically and seem to feel unconstrained by conventions like time signatures. In many Rush songs, they change signatures to better fit a melody instead of adjusting the lyrics to fit into a bar. Unless you dig, and listen for the changes, it sounds so natural because the music so closely follows the lyrics. Their talent musically is simply unmatched. Geddy's voice is very mouth-forward and controlled, it's even more amazing to realize he's controlling his voice to accentuate words while, at the same time, playing bass and often keyboards via foot-pedals... genius! As for Alex and Neil, they are (were) also the top of their crafts. They're all crazy good!
Rush is such a hidden gem. I cosider myself an average guy but luckily I have some musician friends that introduced me to this band when I was in my teens and I appreciate them more and more as time goes by. Both my friends and the band.
I'm so glad you got into this. Rush fans are so incredibly passionate about this band, there's nothing that floats our collective boat more than watching somebody enjoy their music.
Thank you for the breakdown of this song. I've been a Rush fan since 1980, and Limelight is my all-time favourite song. Watching your reaction to different sections was very entertaining, and this song still captivates me when I hear it. That's why this song is my #1. Your analysis is wonderful and spot-on because you provide the proper detail to explain what's going on without giving too much detail or over-explaining it so that you come across as the "smartest-person-in-the-room". There are many other Rush songs that would be interesting for you to breakdown for us, many of which are provided in the comments. I haven't investigated your other videos, but Led Zeppelin, or Pink Floyd might offer some interesting analyses, too. Thank you!
Just a note on the tremolo bar - the reason its used is because on a fretted instrument you only raise pitch with the fretting hand, not lower it, but the bar can raise and lower pitch so you get a different flavour of vibrato than when wiggling the string with the fretting hand.
I think it's sweet that she wants to know if anyone else has heard of this band. Yes, child we have. Would you like a brief history of the band or other musical suggestions?
Ok Jess, now watch the entire concert 'Exit Stage Left' - it's the best rock concert in history - one hour of your time will change your life. This band is responsible for inspiring more people into music - what 3 guys can do live for 40+ years is beyond words. Rush is incredible because they blend rock, jazz, & classical into a hybrid - and with masterful songwriting - create a soundscape very few people in history have ever done. Again, watch the entire concert!
In St Catharines ON in the 70s, all status was measured in degrees from The Professor. Like, if your cousins girlfriend's brother washed his car...that's better than if your aunt's sister used to do yard work for his Mom..
I've been a Rush fan for over 30 years and this is among the best analysis of one of their songs I've seen. Breaking down the sheet music was very illuminating to me, as I'm not a musician and it was cool having all of those technicalities explained. You should definitely do more Rush, they're fantastic and full of layers.
Always glad to see a reactor watching one of my remastered versions, I made them because I didn't like to see people's first impressions with Rush being 10 year old 240p clips with bad audio, with music this complex every detail should be preserved. You also really know what you are talking about music wise, I would take lessons from someone like yourself, great job glad you enjoyed it :)
First, thank you for taking the time to leave a comment - and such a nice one at that. I (as well as many others) am appreciative of the time and effort you put into this remastered version. This video wouldn't have been the same without it so, kudos! Thanks again for stopping by and hope you're safe and well
@@jessicasopranonotes Thank you for the kind words, I watch a lot of Rush reactions but yours stood out as being very genuine and worth watching because you actually had valuable input and feedback rather than just sitting there watching it like a lot of lazier channels lol. If you get any more Rush requests take a look at my library as i've got enough HD Rush projects to last you about a century or so.. XD
@@jessicasopranonotes BTW i'm also a Jess lol
Dear Sir or Madam, pardon if that offends, I'm old, not up on all the current pronouns. Thank you so much for this! This was the best sounding Rush live video I've ever heard. The bass snarls, the drums crack, the guitar crunches like hell in the verses and rings like a bell in the solo. Absolutely fantastic work, my deepest thanks and respect! Cheers!
pretty decent mix mate
I’ve listened to this song for 40 years...I’ve heard hundreds of reactions. I’ve never watched a reaction that was so good at breaking down a song than you. That was incredible! Please, please do Subdivisions by Rush. I learned so much about a song that I thought I knew by watching you...thank you! 😎
Ditto!
Yes PLEASE..do Subdivisions!
I love this reaction so much I’ve watch this a few time and suggested it to others to watch!
Absolutely true. I love Rush, lyrics and technical skill. I know they are supposed to be hard to play, but I know nothing about music. Loved the details on all these time signature changes. Watching others react, I have gained so much more respect for Alex. I especially appreciated all the love from a new fan. Welcome to the family.
Me too.... absolutely amazing breakdown. A very intelligent young lady. Btw. Today is Alex lifeson's birthday
I fell down the RUSH rabbit hole in '75 and they are the greatest 3 piece rock band ever
Someone with her musical expertise being humble enough to acknowledge the otherworldly talent of Neil's drumming being beyond her is one of the best compliments I've ever heard.
They asked Neil Peart what time signature he wanted to use and he said…. “Yes”
Lol
@@jessicasopranonotes more Rush. Look at their wiki. The drummer died of brain cancer. He left a legacy of music. Check out his drum solos and the last song he made called The Garden. It's been know to bring some to tears. RIP Neil.
@Lance Williams My Favorite Headache
Neil Peart and Glen Frey are the only two musicians I've ever cried for when they passed. I really really felt a loss in my soul (I dont know what other word to use) ugh.. gonna need me some Tom Sawyer or Fly by Night or Roll the Bones after this! Lol.
@@batman1169 Garden can do it for sure, but Time stand Still gets me every time .
I can’t even begin to explain or describe how much I enjoyed your analysis. RUSH is truly in a class all by themselves. Neil Pert (RIP) was an insanely talented percussionist
"Insanely talented" doesn't even come close! This man was other-worldly! Rest in peace, Neil.....
And possibly an even better poet/lyricist.
Always been fascinated that Neal wrote most of their songs
I've become a little numb by all the reaction videos out there. Yours is a breath of fresh air. Your response is uniquely yours, full of technical and honest details. I actually believe you had never heard the song, and it's lovely to hear what new listeners "think and feel" about the song. Thank you!
OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. I have never heard anyone explain how they do it before! Just makes my appreciation of this band even more! Thank You!!!!!!
I agree! She’s the best
This is the best reaction analysis of a Rush song I’ve seen on this platform. Very well done. Please do more Rush.
Thank you John! And you got it!
This is a great breakdown especially for first listen. Also check out Rick Beato's "What makes this song great?" episode on Limelight studio version. He is able to play the vocals in isolation and it really highlights Geddy's *amazing* pitch quality. Rick also digs into the drum parts, 3 over 4 patterns switch up in the middle of a chorus, etc.
Yes, very well done. Very interesting and informative
@@katskillz no offense to Rick Beato but I really like her breakdown more than his. He doesnt describe the theory he just tells you its there. Hes telling us what notes are being used and she tells us why...at least in her opinion and I really like that. Definitely need more Rush reaction videos here.
@@jessicasopranonotes Subdivisions would be great, but Red Barchetta too ;)
As someone who tries to enjoy the technical aspects of great music like this without formal education, I really appreciate you doing the hard work of breaking this down for us. I look forward to many more videos from you. I also thought it was great that you pulled in the work of a friend. That is class
Thank you Alan!
And one of the greatest things about Rush was that huge wall of sound from just 3 guys.
The same thing could be said for Led Zeppelin and The Who and other bands that had a lead Singer who didn’t play an instrument.
@@wesleywalker5436 Actually Robert Plant plays harmonica and tambourine.
@@wesleywalker5436 Rogers Daltrey from the who plays on some songs too.
There are tons of people who have never heard of this great band. Rush made fantastic music for over 40 years and I was a huge fan almost from the beginning. There will probably never be a three man band with this much talent ever again. RIP Neil!
Jess, I'm really glad I stumbled across your channel! Yours is the first reaction channel I've found to actually break down and explain what's going on in a song. I've been a Rush fan all of my life and I really enjoyed this breakdown. Thanks so much for providing a really fun and instructional reaction channel. Absolutely wonderful!
Wow thank you Tim! So glad that you are now a part of the community! Your compliments are very much appreciated ☺️
@John Wallace Thanks for the suggestion.
I just came across here too. It's the best analysis I think that I've ever witnessed to the complex structure of a Rush song. Your explanation seems to be dead on target with the only exception of mentioning the tempo changes. But, with this band, you might have made it a little easier on yourself by choosing one of the lesser complex ones. 😀 They did this for 40 years, and there are many, many more that you can break down. I can't wait for you to get there. I subbed in to watch you do it. Thanks for your lesson.
Check out also classical composer reacts...Doug Helvering....the daily Doug show ...
@@gabbyramirez4852 I just put a comment here without seeing your comment right godamn above it! His channel is great! God damn I wish I had his ear.
I have to say as a musician, it's so refreshing to watch someone react to these songs that actually is very knowledgeable of music and music structure.bravo! And being beautiful doesn't hurt either.lol
Uh, yeah. I've heard of RUSH. Only the best rock band in the world.
This amount of intelligent analysis and raw enjoyment combine to make one beautiful piece of humanity! Thanks
THE most musically aware and knowledgeable Rush reaction I’ve ever seen. Well done! If opera is your forte you will definitely enjoy:
- Xanadu (based on an unfinished poem by Samuel Taylor Coleridge) The live performance from Exit…Stage Left will show you how Neil Peart was so much more than just a drummer. Also, if you choose to react to this one, pay special attention to Alex’s and Geddy’s feet. Both of them play full-octave pedal boards during this song while also playing their respective guitars.
- Cygnus X-1 Books I and II are an exploration of the essence of humanity through the eyes of a quixotic hero, who travels into a black hole seeking answers.
- 2112 is the tale of a young man living in a dystopian future society where music and individual expression have been cast aside. This was Rush’s follow up to an ambitious but poorly selling concept album called Caress of Steel. Their label instructed them to create an album with short catchy radio-friendly hits. Instead, Rush gave them 2112, and it blew the prog rock world away. Ironically, after this album their label gave them complete creative freedom, and Rush began writing more shorter, catchy radio-friendly songs.
These are the most “operatic” of their works, but every Rush song tells a story or has a message. Hope to see more reactions and breakdowns! ❤️
The camera eye is my favorite.
THe thing about Xanadu is that it is rhythmically very interesting and orchestrated very uniquely, but the underlying harmony and music 'theory' part is rather simple, not sure a breakdown at that level would be worthwhile
i love that irony about the creative freedom. They did the shorter songs only when they were damned good and ready.
Thank you so much Paul! I had a lot of fun making this video.
I have followed RUSH for about 37 years, and I am learning new things by looking at them through the fresh eyes of new fans.. I love to see young people discover and appreciate great music! 🎼🎵🎵 🎤🎸🥁🎹
Wow wow wow, what an excellent technical analysis! Kudos to you for knowing your shit and the effort you put in this video!
Thanks a bunch!
I feel like I learned this song all over again, what a great real reaction and lesson in music! Thank you for this….
It’s a wonderful song! Thank you for watching, I’m soo glad you enjoyed it!
Totally agree
You explain this better than anyone I've ever heard you should be a teacher gee your knowledgeable, I really appreciate that
Thanks William!
Teacher was the first thing I thought of. She is easy to listen to. Explained a lot.
@@brianfogle2743 she broke it down so well. Needs more Rush and classic prog reactions!
What I enjoyed about this reaction is that you're a professional and you treat the artists with respect. "What I like is when Mr. Getty..."
Good lord Jess, every video you post is a master class. Your observations and analysis are extremely valuable to anyone studying music. Thank you so much for the time and effort.
There’s another Canadian power-trio called Triumph, the lead singer/guitarist is a unbelievable. Normally if you are singing and playing the part you play while singing is not complicated. Rik Emmet can sustain a complex vocal line along with a challenging guitar melody.
Rush were always the musician's musicians. Much like De Kooning is the painter's painter or Kubrick is the film director's director.
This deconstruction of yours is so good and comprehensive that if me and my band had seen this video 20 years ago we wouldn't even have bothered to try to cover Limelight ;)
lol, thanks Vincent!
This is the best thing I have ever seen on TH-cam. Thank you so much for taking such an in depth and intellectual look at this music.
I have tried to have these conversations with people most of my life and the truth is most people would never want to spend this much time actually inside the music.
Thanks so much.
Nicely done! "Xanadu" is probably their most operatic, based on samuel taylor coleridge's poem "Kubla Khan". Also glad you found StickHits's remastered version... he's remastered Xanadu too (from "Exit Stage Left" tour)
I enjoy watching Rush reactions but really, this is the only one I've ever seen whose technical analysis does their musicianship justice. You took my old musician ass to school. Thank you.
This is probably one of their most straight-forward, 'simple' songs Rush has!
Oh really! Haha well this is good to know moving forward!
@@jessicasopranonotes Time signature changes are their motto. Wait til you see some of the off time 5/4 and 7/4 incorporated....
@@jessicasopranonotes Only thing you missed is that Geddy is also playing the keyboard part with his feet
I absolutely LOVE it when someone who has real musical training reacts to RUSH. They are masters of their craft on a technical and performance level. They use all the tricks in the book and invented quite a few of their own. Their music is insanely complex and yet easily approachable. The lyrics are not your typical rock lyrics at all. Many are based in literary works. And holy crap all that sound is coming from just 3 guys. Geddy (singer/bassist) once said that they were trying to be the worlds smallest orchestra.
This whole band was all virtuoso musicians well steeped in music theory.
In truth, Alex knows some theory but is more of an instinctive creator than a compositional musician. Geddy and Neil were the composition guys and Alex the instinctive genius who created things on the fly by ear, soul and spirit. That’s how you get this brilliant soulful guitar solo that at first doesn’t seem to fit the tempo but fills the song with the sadness and longing that he believed Neil felt in dealing with their stardom that he, Neil, wrote about in the lyrics. Yes; the drummer wrote their lyrics and he’s generally considered the greatest drummer in rock history and called The Professor for good reason (RIP - Jan 7, 2020 - his loss the terrible start to that terrible year).
@@bobespirit2112 Yes, hardly "steeped in music theory". Rush's music didn't venture beyond major, minor and 7th chords. They were definitely very creative within those parameters.
Geddy is one of the few rock singers that you can understand every word - a characteristic of his clear sharp voice and solid annunciation.
That's Mr. Geddy!
enunciation, but, yeah.
This is from Exit Stage Left, and they overdubbed his vocals in the studio, so not quite how he actually sounds live, and I've seen them live many times and he never sounds this crisp
Holy Smokes!! This is one of the best Rush reactions I've seen (and I've seen hundreds...). As a lifelong Rush fan (and musician) it was great to see this kind of breakdown. Thanks, Jess!!! Subscribed!!
My favorite part of the song is at the end of the guitar solo with the song in 3 with Neil playing in 4 over top of it.
AND...on top of the amazing music, you have Neil's lyrics....
Wow! This is the best reaction to Limelight I have ever seen, hands down. Rush are the godfathers of progressive rock, and are commonly listed as a significant influence. Their complex time signature changes and superb musicianship make a three-person band sound like 5 or 6 people. Most fans can tell that they are talented but don't really understand why. You did an amazing job explaining why. Pleeease do more Rush. Plus, there's 40 years of amazing music for you to discover. I suggest Freewill or Tom Sawyer for the next one. There's also a great documentary on Netflix called Beyond the Lighted Stage.
Thank you!! And I will definitely do more Rush! I have to write that documentary down! Thanks again!
great analysis, very in depth at 15:28 Alex, holds the final note of the guitar solo as he did in the studio with an overdub. here he holds that note live, which is such masterly attention to detail. he holds the note all the way to 15:35 when Geddy resumes singing.
The most underrated, musically complex 3 person band in rock. Their level of professionalism extends into their live performances too. They never short change an audience with a mediocre performance. A true Canadian treasure. Listening to your analysis reinforces what I always appreciated, they were more “ than meets the eye”. They didn’t succumb to what the record labels expected, they produced what they were drawn to create and 40 year body of work that evolved, and survived is testimony to something more than a simple three piece band. The album Moving Pictures, the instrumental La Villa Strangiato, and the first side of 2112 are a glimpse at that statement that we don’t care what the music industry wants, it’s what they needed to share.
Going to a rush concert, was like a night at the Opera...3 musicians who sound like they have an orchestra behind them...
They do have a big sound!
Aye, I have had the joy of seeing them in concert and it was indescribable. I missed seeing them back in the 70's, when they came nearby, because I couldn't afford it (despite how cheap tickets were then :O) but I settled for seeing them in the 90's
@@dallassukerkin6878 saw them twice in toronto, they have gotten better with age, if that is possilble...
I've been a life long Rush fan since the seventies and even played their songs a hundred times and thought I'd figured it all out.. I was wrong! This is BY FAR the most in depth and accurate deconstruction of a song I've ever seen and heard. Made me go back and rethink all their songs again. Thank you.. BRAVO!
That is awesome!! Thank you soo much!
I was raised on Rush, Rainbow & Led Zep, my fathers choice of music 😄🤘 Loved this analysis!!
It's always a treat to see someone's first reaction to something you yourself love. Loved it.
All I can say is WOW.. what a detailed reaction. There are over 160 Rush songs spanning a 40 year career. Here are some songs to gat will blow your mind with time signature changes, Xanadu, YYZ, Natural Science, LaVilla Strangiato, Subdivisions and on and on… Enjoy your journey!!
The drummer Neil Peart was called the professor for good reason!
On top of being one of the most talented drummers to ever grace the stage, he wrote most of the lyrics for Rush including this song!
He was a fascinating, intelligent, kind and talented man.
He is God among many drummers (myself included) and is sorely missed every day.
Amazing breakdown!
I cannot express enough how much I loved your deep dive into this! Your understanding of structure and appreciation of a genre that is not the one you trained is is absolutely beautiful
Best analysis of Limelight ever.
Like I said on the direct chat... What a great job have you done!!! You are crazy!!!. I've never seen such a well done analysis. Your explanations are perfect, your examples well picked up... I have no words to describe you.
A very big hug from Spain
Thank you Javier! I put an incredible amount of time into this video and I am very happy that it is being well received ☺️
@@jessicasopranonotes Everyone can notice that it is not a video made on the fly, it is a very, very worked video, both in terms of documentation and editing. This is a lot of work.
On the other hand, as I say, your explanations are masterful.
I can even add another detail as a person who does not speak English well, your pronunciation, your diction ability is amazing, I am able to understand everything you say despite my poor level of English.
I’ve been listening to this song for decades, and never picked up on how Alex sustains that high note at the end of the solo, which you figured out the first time! (To be fair, I wasn’t usually watching a video, just listening. But still, even when I saw him do that pedal, I didn’t get the significance of it until you explained.)
Yasss!!! You mentioned that super sustained note in his solo. It keeps on plowing through new vocals and, really, just everything. I am old enough to have bought this album on cassette, shortly after it was released but, being in high school, I had junk headphones or I listened to it in my car. I never even knew about that sustained note until much later when I replaced my cassette collection with re-mastered CDs. My mouth about hit the floor when I realized, "Wait a minute! What's that sound? OMG that's his sustain!" To this day, I pretty much listen to Lime Light mostly to re-experience that sustain note. Yea, I'm a little weird that way. Also, you are the very first Rush reactor (and there are a ton!) I have seen, to even comment on, much less highlight that. Your reaction got a "like" from me. Your attention to that single note made me a subscriber. Bravo, my dear.
Jess, now starts your journey down the Rush rabbit hole.....If you choose to do it, you'll come out the other side a changed person. FYI, 95% of the songs they do were written by the drummer, Neal Peart (aka The Professor). IMO, the greatest rock drummer of all time. Along with all of their other songs, please watch Neal's drum solo in Frankfurt.......greatness. Unfortunately, he passed in Jan. of 2020. RIP to the G.O.A.T.
Slight correction - Peart wrote 95% of the lyrics. The music was mainly Alex and Geddy (they always took joint credit).
Best Rush reaction video I've seen yet , love it ❤❤
Rick Beato has a amazing video on this song too in his section called What Makes this Song Great? and it is Ep.63.
Wow very interesting and thank you.
yeah it's worth watching just to hear Geddy's pitch quality in isolation!
Rick is so awesome
While watching this I was thinking that if Rick Beato and her ever collaborated on a video breaking down 2112 it would break the internet.
Jess, This is one of the most impressive reactions of my favorite band I have ever seen.... and trust me, I have seen a LOT of them. One of the things that really impressed me was your observation of Alex's extended note at the end of the guitar solo. Nobody has ever mentioned that note and it has always been a favorite part of the song for me.
Rush is known for doing extremely impressive and complex instrument layering in the recorded version. In the live version, they could have hired more musicians to do the work, but instead they insisted on doing it themselves. Geddy Lee does the same thing for Bass parts. It is to allow them to do more and perform the song the way it was meant to be performed. I think I can speak for many, many Rush fans by saying it is one of the things that we love about them. Their artistic and personal integrity, hard work ethic, and the fact that they are just genuinely real people, who just happened to be the best of friends for over forty years. All of this done without a public blemish (except one that I remember) in their sparkling reputation.
Thank you for the fine analysis and reaction!
The complexity, and genius of these three guys is amazing!!!!!! The time signature changes, and the lyrics are incredible in all their music!!!!!! Check out Freewill, lyric version. Incredible
i love a thorough analysis like this. It really brings the point home that the complex concepts they utilize, their efforts to challenge themselves, all ultimately serve the song.
I’m 44 years old and saw RUSH 13 times over the years, starting in 1994 on their “Counterparts” Tour. I’m also a drummer and I was devastated when I heard of Neil’s death last year. I’m blown away by the analysis given here, as this is how *I* hear songs, too! I’m constantly picking the whole thing apart, and sometimes it’s hard for me to just ENJOY a song. RUSH will forever be in my heart and mind. “With the heart and mind united in a single… perfect… sphere”.
so awesome you were able to see them that many times! I have seen many comments over the passing of Neil. He seemed to have a very large impact on many people. very nice to have met you!
To watch these guys in concert is an absolute treat. Saw them a week before their last show. The fact that Alex plays guitar and does the bass lines with a pedal synth when Geddy is doing keyboard parts and Geddy does synth parts with foot pedals while he plays bass. They write songs that require more than 3 players and then figure out how to play them.
Well done, Jess! Do more like this.
Wow!! This intelligent, educated, and beautiful lady just painted a masterpiece of an explanation of a view point which I was so impressed by her interpretation. To have the background in opera, to jump into R & R, and watch her emotions spill out for the camera was a treat! I have been listening to that song for about forty years (give or take a year), and she painted a picture that I could never have imagined. And respectfully of her courage to cross over a boundary to explore... I can only smile in amazement. I wish this classy lady all the best in the world!! Stay safe.
This has got to be the best musical breakdown of this song I have ever seen.
I have been amazed at this song as with all of Rush's compositions since it was first released. The fact that only three guys on stage can make such complexed music like this is out of this world.
Keep in mind that both Alex and Getty are multitasking with foot peddles synths and keyboards on top of playing their guitar and bass guitar, and singing is nothing short of incredible.
Good ear, that you caught Alex catching that held note in a loop. This song is one of their most sublime and has one of the best melodies they've ever written.
You said "I don't know if I fully understand what is going on with the drums..." I don't think anyone truly comprehends Neil's drumming. He's one of, if not the greatest drummer in rock history.
I would love to see a reaction of "Jacobs ladder".
Yes! Jacob's Ladder!
Natural science is even more challenging
You and Neil Peart (drummer and writer of most of their songs) would've got along famously. Brilliant critical analysis. I imagine you two rambling on until dawn. Love it.
Alright, I’ve never been so captivated by something being explained to me that was so beyond my comprehension. That analysis was so thorough and informative and it didn’t hurt that the “Opera Singer” was stunning... anyhow, mind doing a similar analysis of another song from the same concert called “Xanadu”?
It’s entirely a different beast, less poppy more conceptual.
Thanks a bunch! I have gotten a lot of requests for this song so I have written it down!
@@jessicasopranonotes
I'm looking forward to seeing your reaction to that classic...
I've never heard such an in-depth and detailed analysis of one of their songs before. What a joy to listen to you dissect music! Also, I'm very glad you picked out a recording from their earlier period. They played for 40 years. Once he was much older, it was a strain in concert to replicate the singing he did when he was much younger. It's nice to hear the choice of recording being something that was performed roughly the same time it was first written and recorded. He had such a warm and rich voice (well, once he mastered it, LOL). Oh, and they are three of the finest rock musicians to ever team up and grace a stage. And with Neil Peart (the drummer), he's widely considered to be one of the top drummers in history.
Greatest rock band ever!!!!
You've done an amazing job of deconstructing a song that I've loved for decades, I had no idea of its complexity. I learned a lot, you're an absolute joy to watch!
Thank you, Ben!
Wow!!! Outstanding breakdown lol! My jaw dropped when I saw that you reacted to this band. I’ve been a fan of Rush for 30 yrs. You are the s@!t Jess! Your technical knowledge when it comes to music is awesome. I even gave you a standing ovation at the end of your reaction. 👏👏👏
May I suggest these Rush songs for your next reaction: Xanadu or Camera Eye. Both are masterpieces. imho
Thank you!
Holy smoke, what a breakdown. Giving Beato a run for his money. Terrific video; thank you.
She totally smokes Beato.
@@edwardx.winston5744 [This reply has been self-censored]
Superb analysis, very detailed and accurate. Not sure if you are aware, not only is Geddy a great vocalist but he is recognized as one of the greatest bass guitar players of all time. He also plays keyboards very, very well. Thank you for your reaction to my hometown band.
Yes, this is something I failed to mention in the video, thanks for sharing!
My pleasure. New subscriber and I really enjoyed seeing your reaction when you discovered just how talented and dedicated these guys are, it was beautiful to see.
I really love your analysis. You broke it down in such an understandable way for a music dummy like me. I've always loved this song for the feelings it evokes in me, not realizing how structurally difficult it is to play. RUSH does this with such finesse. I'm very grateful for your musical artistry as a opera soprano to appreciate Rush's complex song Limelight. Their fantastic body of work will amaze you.
Please please PLEASE look for Xanadu, from Exit Stage Left. Probably their best live performance showcasing their musicianship, and just how complex they can get.
I would highly recommend listening to the entire album that Limelight is from. Moving pictures. Album is a masterpiece.
You need to check out the song, “Xanadu” on the Exit Stage Left tour by Rush. Great reaction btw. 😁
My gosh. This has to be THE BEST review and commentary of my all time favorite band. Thank you, thank you thank you for the explanations of the techniques in the production if this song. Your genuine appreciation of their abilities and arrangement is appreciated and means so much coming from an artist of your caliber. It only further proves out why I feel they are one of the best bands in history. Not to mention, your reactions and your facial expressions were just adorable to watch. They’re the same for me even after all these years. It never gets old. Thank you!!! I am grateful to have found this review. I would love to see you review one of their other songs , La Villa Strangiatto. I think you would be blown away by it as well. You are a beautiful soul! Thank you!!
That was an amazing breakdown. I too have followed Rush since the 70’s and if you get into their music library, you will see they are the masters of time shifting…..all over the place!!!
MASTERCLASS is right. Masterclass in Performance and a Masterclass in Performance analysis
I have just seen your reaction for the first time today, about 7 months after you released it, so you might have heard much of what I am about to tell you about Rush. Neil Peart, who passed away in 2020, is considered by many the best drummer in the history of rock and roll, and certainly a consensus top five best ever. He was also highly intelligent and very well read, and served as the band's lyricist. He was very uncomfortable in the spotlight and this song is his recognition of the trappings of fame.
Geddy Lee is considered one of the ten best bass guitar players in rock history, later adding masterful synthesizer playing. He is also the only one of the three who sang and his distinctive voice lets the listener instantly know they are listening to Rush.
Alex Lifeson is a master guitarist who never really got the recognition he deserved because he was in a band with two legendary musicians.
Rush is considered prog (progressive) rock and was known in their early years for 20 minute epic story songs. Even as they began to create more radio friendly songs, you can take most any Rush song, read the lyrics without music, and be the better for having done so.
It’s always great to see folx be introduced to your favorite band and appreciate them. ❤️ What a terrific reaction, Jess. I hope you do more Rush. Thanks. 🙏🏼
That was a really interesting break down. I learned alot. Thank you. Rush is my favourite band Cheers
Very impressed. You really know your music. Alot of people that try to analyze or breakdown a song don't really have a clue what their talking about. Btw....The effect Alex is using is a sustain petal that keeps that high note in his solo going as he starts picking the strings to end the solo.
All RUSH songs must have a minimum of 4 time signatures each. That's the rule. One of their greatest songs imo.
Wow. Actual analysis. Thank you.
All 3 members of this band have a Doctorates degree in music. This entire album, as well as several others, are iconic Hard/Progressive Rock albums. I'm glad you've found them, their music is some of the best we've ever heard. May I suggest The Spirit of Radio, Freewill, Tom Sawyer, or the entire A Side to the album 2112.
(They don't really have doctorates..I think you are just being complimentary of their skill but some may take this as truth. In fact, Alex and Geddy are high school drop-outs.)
I really appreciate how you actually analyze the music. When you were analyzing the verse, I knew you were going to LOVE the chorus.
Great reaction and analysis. Also, another nice touch in the song is the end of the guitar solo section where Alex exits the solo and plays his arpeggiated part in 3/4 while Neil on the drums exits that section playing a driving 4/4 rhythm until they all sync up again. Beauty, eh?
Yes!
Can you believe there are only THREE guys in the band? And all so incredibly talented. What a phenomenal band!
Brilliant. Amazing production values. Thank you for furthering music education! Hit or miss, Rush is rarely boring.
Best Rush reaction on TH-cam hands down.
Thank you, John!
@@jessicasopranonotes You’re welcome. May I suggest you listen to the song Time Stand Still by Rush. I think you’ll really enjoy it.
Well damn this is impressive.
Breaking down so much going on is great to see. Rush were one of a kind making them the last of their kind, sadly. But 40 years of studio and live music is remarkable.
Hope you do more Rush. La Villa Strangiato and The Camera Eye would be great to see you cover one day.
Subscribed as this is my jam.
Definitely more Rush!
@@jessicasopranonotes I hope so.. your reaction was the best I’ve ever seen. You broke it down like a boss.. this was fantastic and I sent it to all my friends. Thank you!!
Best reaction iv ever seen!!!!! Would love to see you do more classic/prog rock
Gonna subscribe hoping you continue with this band. Your detail on their music is much more unique from other reactors. I would suggest "Xanadu" Exit Stage Left 1981.
Love the technical analysis. I've listed to Rush for decades and have always loved how they challenge themselves musically and seem to feel unconstrained by conventions like time signatures. In many Rush songs, they change signatures to better fit a melody instead of adjusting the lyrics to fit into a bar. Unless you dig, and listen for the changes, it sounds so natural because the music so closely follows the lyrics. Their talent musically is simply unmatched. Geddy's voice is very mouth-forward and controlled, it's even more amazing to realize he's controlling his voice to accentuate words while, at the same time, playing bass and often keyboards via foot-pedals... genius! As for Alex and Neil, they are (were) also the top of their crafts. They're all crazy good!
Yes! This is my all-time favorite Rush song!
Fantastic analysis!!
Rush is such a hidden gem. I cosider myself an average guy but luckily I have some musician friends that introduced me to this band when I was in my teens and I appreciate them more and more as time goes by. Both my friends and the band.
Probably my favorite version of Limelight ever. Geddy's vocals were incredible here.
I'm so glad you got into this. Rush fans are so incredibly passionate about this band, there's nothing that floats our collective boat more than watching somebody enjoy their music.
Thank you for the breakdown of this song. I've been a Rush fan since 1980, and Limelight is my all-time favourite song. Watching your reaction to different sections was very entertaining, and this song still captivates me when I hear it. That's why this song is my #1. Your analysis is wonderful and spot-on because you provide the proper detail to explain what's going on without giving too much detail or over-explaining it so that you come across as the "smartest-person-in-the-room". There are many other Rush songs that would be interesting for you to breakdown for us, many of which are provided in the comments. I haven't investigated your other videos, but Led Zeppelin, or Pink Floyd might offer some interesting analyses, too. Thank you!
Thank you, Glen!
Just a note on the tremolo bar - the reason its used is because on a fretted instrument you only raise pitch with the fretting hand, not lower it, but the bar can raise and lower pitch so you get a different flavour of vibrato than when wiggling the string with the fretting hand.
I think it's sweet that she wants to know if anyone else has heard of this band. Yes, child we have. Would you like a brief history of the band or other musical suggestions?
Ok Jess, now watch the entire concert 'Exit Stage Left' - it's the best rock concert in history - one hour of your time will change your life. This band is responsible for inspiring more people into music - what 3 guys can do live for 40+ years is beyond words. Rush is incredible because they blend rock, jazz, & classical into a hybrid - and with masterful songwriting - create a soundscape very few people in history have ever done. Again, watch the entire concert!
'Celebrity' deaths generally do not affect me...Neil's did. To borrow so much from a man I never met.
In St Catharines ON in the 70s, all status was measured in degrees from The Professor.
Like, if your cousins girlfriend's brother washed his car...that's better than if your aunt's sister used to do yard work for his Mom..
I've been a Rush fan for over 30 years and this is among the best analysis of one of their songs I've seen. Breaking down the sheet music was very illuminating to me, as I'm not a musician and it was cool having all of those technicalities explained. You should definitely do more Rush, they're fantastic and full of layers.