@@OhNoNotAgain42 Y'know, I've met plenty of Rush fans through the years, and there's one thing I've noticed about the vast majority of them: There ain't many dummies among 'em. :)
It does have a chorus, it just doesnt sound like one. There is a TH-cam vid where geddy talks about the structure of this song. The chorus is the heavier part, “jump to the ground as the turbo slows to cross the borderline.” Thats the chorus. It just doesnt have a typical chorus sound to it. But they do have other songs that legit dont have a chorus, such as closer to the heart. Another with a chorus that doesnt sound like one is enemy within. Does high water have a chorus? Cant remember one. I hate that song lol
Alex is one of the greatest and also one of the most underrated guitarists. That just goes to show how good this band really is, when someone as amazing as Alex is commonly overlooked :-)
@@Ferd414 Damn. That's hard to believe. I can understand people not caring for a genre, but even still one can't deny they are all three at the top of their craft (or were).
Oh it's actually kind of funny the way Alex is overlooked. Have you ever seen that documentary they did a few years before Neil died? And there is one scene where the crew is with Geddy and Alex, and they're just in a diner having food, talking about the impact of the fans and interacting with the public. And the waitress comes up to ask Geddy for an autograph, and literally shoves Alex out of the way to put the paper and pen in front of Geddy. Geddy even points to him and says "He's in the band too you know" and she just kind of glances at him, and then turns away like "yeah sure". The whole time Alex is just laughing his ass off at the whole situation.
Come on, that's a myth, he was never underrated or overlooked. But I guess you're an American who believes in any random poll. He was never up there, so he must be mediocre or worse. Polls are for idiots who wants to be entertained. And if you're American, switch on your TV and et your proof. Alex Lifeson was never underrated or overlooked, neither by his fellow musicians or the listeners.
The album is Moving Pictures. The movers are moving pictures, the bystanders are moved by the pictures. On the back cover, someone is filming the scene, taking moving pictures. Pretty cool.
Neil wrote this song after reading a short story about "after cars" in Road and Track magazine .. the short was called "A Nice Morning Drive" by Richard S Foster
The car represents freedom from tyranny of society and progress. How long before internal combustion engines are outlawed. More prophetic than I ever imagined.
How long until women's rights and the Constitution are outlawed? Maybe this November if a certain wannabe jan. 6 dictator is not stopped in his tracks.
@@lindaward5376 Good. Countries everywhere are setting record high temps and devastating droughts and hurricanes. Grandchildren won't have a planet to live on if we continue on this path.
Every musical passage/tempo is designed to reflect driving a racing car.... the shifting & drifting... the chase!... the gears shifting up... the gears shifting down... sitting by the fireside with his uncle... just listen! These Rush guys are freaking geniuses!
I used to blast through the Santa Cruz Mountains in my red Scirocco with this song turned up to 11. Not quite a Barchetta, but a bright red scalpel that could slice up a mountain road with the best of em. Perfect song to accompany a sprint towards San Gregorio.
What does this song and band mean to me? This band, to me, is the closest any of us will get to perfection... just watch them live. I joined the party late in 1987, and this was the first song I really "heard" from Rush. I asked my drummer friend how many members in this band like 10... he said 3... THREE ??!! Rush is thee greatest band in any universe... period 😎☝
@@patricknicolucci5073 The animated video for Rush's Spirit of Radio shows cartoon Neil driving a red barchetta of that vintage. Ferrari 166 MM's have sold for as much as $10,000,000 at auction.🤯
This came around 1980 about, and was written to future, 50 odd years. 1950 plus around 50 would put it to early 2000 at the earliest - could be later, we dont know when his uncle got it? Scifi story anyways. Rush at their sharpest.
Dear Rosalie, I can't say nothing but THANK YOU. Bieng a music and cars person, I have loved this song for 40 years, but watching your reaction just made me cry. Your beautiful interpretation of the lyrics represents exactly what my heart feels every time I listen to the song. Greetings from León, México.
I got that honor too in the Time Machine Tour (saw them in Chile, 2010), when they played this full album. A once-in-a-lifetime chance and a dream come true for thousands of South American fans!!
I've been fortunate to see Rush in concert multiple times before Neil Peart passed away. Often when they played this song, they played a video of the actual car flying around country roads, and then the chase by the futuristic Police trying to chase him down and impound the car, arrest him, etc. All sorts of special effects came with that movie/cartoon, often accompanied with lasers and such. Definitely an experience to be had. Sadly it ended with Neil's passing. Rush is still one of my all time favorite bands. My son and I traveled hundreds of miles to see Rush and those travel stories go along with this story too, when I hear this and most any other Rush song. It is a father/son experience I cherish to this day. Thanks for your review!
Rosalie, welcome to the Rush family, sister! You have just joined the most fantastical musical bandwagon known to mankind. Your life has changed, as you’ve said so already, “I think I just got smarter”. Buckle up for the ride of your life. As Rush fans we are all excited to watch your continued moments of speechless amazement, learning, and appreciation of 3 guys who never shied away from trying new things and pushing their limits. Absolute joy to watch your mind-blowing, jaw-dropping, SMH, “Are you freaking kidding me, already?” expressions as we’ve all had them ourselves and sharing them is a true gift for all. Thanks for letting us in. 🤙🏻😎
No question, no doubt. There has been many other bands that others would consider to be the best ever, but let''s face it - those bands required more players, had more members floating in and out, didn't as long and in most cases, were not nearly as poetic and conceptually driven.
Omg. I’m a big time Rush fan. I’m 59 I’ve been listening to them since I was 10. I love this song so much I love Ferrari and cars. I’ve never heard anyone describe a song like you just did unbelievable the way you did that. I loved it. You are so good at what you do thank you and keep doing rush.
We were blessed to have these three individuals come together to give us an amazing part of themselves. They've taken a fantastic explorational musical journey that impacts nearly everyone who experiences it. Thank you Alex, Garry(Geddy) and Neil for sharing.
Neil Peart! Not only an amazing drummer that inspired a generation, but an amazing lyricist as well. By all accounts he spent an inordinate amount of time reading, which would explain a lot.
Been following Rush since my first time seeing them in 1979, they are not just an amazing band but a religion. I appreciate you playing the whole song first. Love your page.
I have enjoyed yet another video of you sharing your very intelligent analysis of this very classic song. I have listened to this song since it came out in 1981, and it's one of my all-time favorite songs. I like the idea of being able to enjoy something once again from a "better vanished time." We humans have gotten so restricted in so many ways that the things we once enjoyed years ago are almost out of our grasp. To experience one thing that I had really enjoyed in the past would give me such a sense of incredible enjoyment and make me feel so free, even if I just got to do whatever it was just one more time in life. Being free is something I treasure more than anything in life, and this freedom has been stolen bit by bit over the years to where I pretty much feel suffocated by the wide array of restrictions imposed on us by government. When I reach "old age" (and I'm approaching it too fast now that I'm about to turn 58 years old), I want to experience at least one last activity (which would maybe be frowned upon or even "illegal" at that time, yet would not cause harm to anyone at all). Of course, something like driving a Red Barchetta down a country highway and feeling the freedom and the adrenaline rush from that experience once more would really make life complete. :)
Rosalie, what is so interesting about Rush is their musical unselfishness. In this case, the guitar is the color, and frequently the bass carries the melody. But as great as Alex, Neil and Geddy were as musicians, lyricists and composers, they always made room for each other to feature, and were never afraid or unwilling to write their parts to compliment the others. That's how they survived as a band for over 40 years.
Completely agree that none of the three ever steps on the others. As complex and densely layered as their music is, the impression I always leave with is restraint. It never feels like anything is overdone.
Geddy: “The trick in Rush was always to be able to find a proud sound for the bass that still worked with the other instruments and didn’t hog too much of the spotlight. We tried to share the spotlight. To be aggressive and stay out of the way when you needed to stay out of the way was always a challenge for me."
Agreed. I heard a description of RUSH that nailed it pretty good . . . RUSH is composed of three musicians, always playing solos at the same time, yet it works.
What was great about seeing Alex Lifeson playing live was his facial expressions. Saw Rush live for the first time in 1988, he felt every chord and can bend a string better than any guitarist I've ever seen or heard. Thanks for keeping ads till the song ends, know you need them so we can watch your channel, appreciated
Consider this : "back to the farm to dream with my uncle by the fireside". This is almost like a Norwegian Wood moment for me. Did all this actually happen, or is it a dream of the narrator? Is it the dream of a person in a government controlled state pining for the old ways, or a dream of a person in the current reality worried about what might happen in the future ? Or did all these events actually happen ? Kinda fits with the whole triple entendre theme of the album cover. Thank you Rosalie for your wonderful commentary - you always come up with new ideas and insights into your reaction videos !
Rosalie, Love your intricate analysis. Shows you 'really listen' and feel the music and lyrics. Rush paints such visual stories lyrically and musically. Also, 3 Awesome musicians that all 'lead' and 'support' one another. Chemistry is Sooo important and in music-telling, Rush had such a unique all around chemistry that made them a one and only.
Neil wrote this song after reading a short story in Road & Track magazine. He implemented elements of the story in the lyrics. Many years later Neil arranged to meet the author of the story and he accompanied them on part of a tour. You are working your way through the best album recorded by the best band ever. They will continually blow your mind with their incredible music.
I was literally sobbing watching you listen to Red barchetta as a young man I listen to this album 100 * I came to the realization that a big part of me was because of this album being a musician came from this album thank you for enjoying it as much as I do
@@rimskykorsakov2892 yes … we both know the 1970’s tinny tone is much preferable to soft effeminate Rush fans as compared to the supercharged heaviest representation of Rush EVER seen in Rush history as displayed in the RIO version (only the best parts as PREFERRED by Rush) th-cam.com/video/3pLsvbLwTwg/w-d-xo.htmlsi=Zbq-5Q2pXvgW1oXF
Can I give your reaction and analysis more than one thumbs up? First, I agree that Alex really shows what he's capable of here. Beautiful performance all the way around. I have to say the combination of Rush's lyrics, chord progressions (i.e. the bridge section leading to the solo) arrangements, and production values (tip of the hat to producer, Terry Brown) are unmatched in my opinion in the Rock Era. Second, you've captured the essence of this story and the bigger questions posed about the relentless advance of technology vs. an unplugged, off-the-grid, simpler life and commentary on what we lose when we disconnect from that way of living, which has marked all but the past 150 years of human existence. Sadly, in many ways, too many have lost touch with each other, the natural world, and our shared history. It' also paints a dystopian future echoing works like Animal Farm, 1984, The Terminator, and The Matrix. And we are dangerously close to this police state type of reality 43 years after the release of this song. As a 12 year old in 1981, I never dreamed this kind of thing would ever stand a chance of becoming reality. But here we are.
When I need a story, I want it from the GOAT Neil Peart. One of my top 5 RUSH songs. RIP Neil😇 They didn't always play this in concert, but when they did there was a seriously cool video background to go with the story.
Great song and great analysis. Saw Rush do this on their Moving Pictures tour back when I was in High School, which is a show I remember to this day. Rosalie is so intelligent with her thoughts on the lyrics and music. Can't wait to hear her listen to YYZ!
Excellent song, excellent analysis!! Great job! Alex is an INCREDIBLE guitar artist...he crafts sound paintings with his guitar. He is one of a kind. Very few guitarists can do this.
Wonderful music and lyrics. I am glad you mentioned Alex. He is often lost amongst the greatness of Geddy and Neil. Those harmonics at the beginning and end are beautiful Geddy and Neil are great on this track but I love Alex contribution
I'm glad u brought up Alex on this reaction Rosalie. The riff u like so much is an expansion of harmonics. It's a technique used to give a bell-like quality to a note. It happens when u strike the string with your pick then lightly touch the string OVER the desired fret. You don't actually push the string down far enough to touch the fret. Alex used these to create a riff line that really grabs the ear. It seems to me that Rush has a penchant for inserting little "quirks" like that in many of their songs. The reggae change up in The Spirit of Radio for instance. They're just so surprising and delightful
Rush, three Canadian BFFs, who also just happen to be virtuosos, multiinstrumentalists, who like to write musically complex epic story songs in strange time signatures using some of the oddest phrasing, and arrangements. Every concert that they played was pure enjoyment like they were just playing in the garage and they were really thankful that fans just kept coming to listen to their music. Truly wondeful people. I have been listening to this band since moving pictures came out, and yes I own all of their albums. And yes Rush is in almost every playlist that I listen to. Rush: where every guy in the band, is THE BEST guy in the band.
Never ever cut short a Rush outro you will miss some amazing stuff. They left the listener wanting more and gave them it when they played live. Excellent review though keep up the Rush rabbit hole it will absolutely blow your mind. You are absolutely right Neil's lyrics were way ahead of their time. He was somewhat of a modern soothsayer.
The song is based on a short story Neil had read in Popular Mechanics, or one of those mags. Yes, the story is about how the protagonist breaks the law by driving a car with a motor (I suppose gasoline engines are illegal?) but ditches the alloy air-cars "two lanes wide" at the one lane bridge.
You really need to watch/hear Rush's live album "Exit Stage Left". I was lucky enough to see them on that tour ,London 1981.....and honestly its the greatest gig ive ever seen,and ive been to plenty over the years......there will never be another band like Rush.....they,in particular around that time were truly amazing. What im finding amazing is your reaction is similar to mine when i first heard this....40 years ago!!!!
Just EPIC musicianship by Geddy Alex and Neil.... This album though not the first time hearing Rush got me into them hardcore. I have 3 bands that I will always listen to... Chicago Steely Dan and Rush .... All 3 have epic musicians and awesome music... 🔥🔥🔥
Re-listening to this just now, I am continually reminded at how well each instrument is heard in the recording. Especially the drums. Especially the concert toms (the really high-sounding toms that have amazing the ability to bounce your sticks off of to get that rapid stick hit) (Yes, an amateur drummer here!) the sound of every instrument is so clear. (I consider each tom, snare and kick drum an instrument)
One of my favorite memories was back when I lived in Colorado Springs and owned an old Porsche that I used to love shooting up US 24 through Ute Pass to drive to Woodland Park (and get breakfast at The Hungry Bear) and then fly back down the pass. With this song blaring.
Each man is an artist of their craft. Fortunate to have seen them numerous times in Ontario. As well had the pleasure of doing some landscape lighting at Alex’s house. Very nice man.
The song was inspired by the futuristic short story "A Nice Morning Drive ", written by Richard Foster and published in the November 1973 issue of Road & Track magazine.
What I love about this track is how cinematic it is. You're right in there with the protagonist, experiencing the thrill of it all with him. It's an exhilarating track and also at times beautiful and calm.
I think this song expresses the spirit of adventure. Imagine a world where everything is controlled for your own good and safety but there is no freedom. Some people willingly give up their freedom for security and some chafe under rules that bind. I tend to feel a strong sense of nostalgia with this song also (esp with the lyrics about a "better vanished time"). When a commonplace drive in the country is a risky adventure, what does that say about the society you live in and have built? Just like the cover art, expect meanings within meanings within meanings for Rush songs.
Thank you for recognizing Alex Lifeson's brilliance; he often gets overlooked when talking about "The Best..." where Neil & Geddy are always at the top of those lists. May I recommend MY favorite Rush song, "The Trees", especially the Exit...Stage Left version with the beautiful "Broon's Bane" lead in !
So pleased you are discovering what we love about RUSH music. Layers upon layers of well crafted music with well thought out storytelling. I see another fan has annotated the short story Neil based the lyrics on. We’ll never see their like again. 😢
Who knew Rush would be so prophetic with this one as there are now "powers that be" wanting to outlaw internal combustion engines. Listening to music with you and hearing your thoughtful commentary is always such a treasure!! 💛
I learned this on guitar at age 15. I used to crank it when my parents were gone, so much that my neighbor four houses away heard it. The solo is tricky with that delayed entrance. Later, several decades, I played it at a bar with a professional drummer. He was a Neil Peart disciple and played it very accurately. I'm proud to say I nailed the solo.
You sound like my husband. We were childhood friends. He's a drummer and would practice very loudly to Rush so the whole neighborhood could enjoy it. He's 60 and can still play every Rush song to perfection. Of course, he's in a band too.
Neil loved cars. This story is based on a short story based in some potential future from a car magazine that Neil read. A car for Neil was a symbol of freedom. Individuality and freedom are frequent subjects in Neil’s writings. Neil wrote the vast majority of Rush lyrics. Occasionally he would co-write with friends outside the band and Geddy occasionally provided lyrics but most are Neil with Geddy collaborating in an editorial capacity so he was comfortable singing what Neil wrote. They loved working together, all 3 of them. Alex is the spontaneous one and many of his solos starting around Permanent Waves (Spirit, Freewill, etc) were built from multiple takes then composited together by Geddy and whatever producer they were working with at the time.
More than anything, I’ve always love how the bridge jam transitions into the last section, it has the riding feeling like your on top of the world. It’s a fantastic tune to jog to!
Hi Rosalie, I appreciate your analysis of these songs and understanding of the deeper aspects of the lyrical prose of Rush. They are unique in this way in that the stories in the songs are a whole other universe of content that need to be revisited after the initial listening to the music. The Story of Red Barchetta is taken from a Road and Track article the Neil read while on tour and thought it was a great topic for a song. Rush used their time travelling on the road to be inspired to write new music. It is amazing I can hear these songs as you mentioned "years later" and still have new insights, hear nuances in the music and have a deeper relationship in general. I love the Band! I am spoiled having Rush paint the soundtracks to my youth
I’ve been very fond of driving home on old country roads blasting this song…. The music fits the narrative perfectly “ride like the wind, stretching the limits of machine & man” BTW, your analysis is spot on… well done!
Always love the depth of your analysis! It really allows me the chance to “go deeper” on a song that probably went over my head, hearing it for the first time back in the 80’s, while I was still in middle school.
I listened to this song many times while flying across a desert in the southwest. Hard not to push yourself and the car to the limits while listening to this. This was based upon an article Neil read in a car magazine based on the Ferrari Barchetta. The Giant Alloy Air Cars are 2 Lanes Wide, aka they are too wide to go across a 1 lane bridge.
@@jeffjohnson8444 yeah we head up to Logan and Ute Lake a lot and go by Soccoro. And White City and the No Scum Alowed is neat. Take the side bys out to the old silver mines and ghost towns.
WOW, Rosie..... You GOT IT!!! You're Amazing! I LOVE your RUSH Reactions!!! Keep that Open Mind, Expanding with More RUSH!!! I'll be here to Watch & Listen to your Reactions!!!
An exceptional piece of songwriting and storytelling. I've always adored this song. Theres a british T-shirt producer called Danforth And Pape who have done some Rush themed t-shirts one of them being "The Sunday Racing Club, Running The Deadly Race Since 1981" Those who know will know.
"an alloy air car, two lanes wide", that's why they got stranded at the one-lane bridge. I suppose that implies they are more like hovercraft rather than flying vehicles. A completely safe and controlled society, for all it protects our physical well-being, is soul-crushing for the human spirit. Governments can't understand that because it's not quantifiable, so rules can't be made to accommodate that side of being human.
Just hearing you talk about the song and then hearing it again helps me feel so much better. Ive been feeling down because of my finances. Last week I was feeling good and now I’m not so good. I started back with a new training I’ve been in for many months and it felt good to Zoom with the people in the program and it felt like coming Home, and Rush also feels like Home. It’s a new and different direction and purpose but I know it’s a good addition to everything I’ve been doing and I’m not quite sure how to process it all to make sense. Guess I’m just having doubts about my abilities and my fears of paying bills while I’m learning this new thing. Thank you for your Light and Love which I find refreshing and very inspiring! I know I’ll be OK because I’ve been through worse! ❤
I love how well they replicated the feel of a revving engine, and the rush of wind and passing terrain with their instruments in this song. It really does give you the feeling of driving fast through a bit of wilderness.
The name "Moving Pictures" refers to the elusive triple entendre. Movers are "moving" (verb) the pictures. The people watching are crying because they find the pictures moving (adjective). ...and the back cover shows a movie set recording the scene as a Moving Picture (noun)
This song has meant so much my whole life, 42 years since I first heard it. But with your analysis @rosalie, you have rounded up and explained so many of my own feelings, it has now taken a whole Full Life Anythem meaning for me. Thank you.
My personal story with this song goes back to 1982 when I was a kid with a Walkman cassette player and a Yamaha three wheeler and time on my hands. I was riding down a county road I’d never been on and listening to this song and as the part in the song about the one lane bridge is playing I round a curve and there’s a one lane bridge right in front of me. It was a good day.
I see this song as about their instruments and music. People have tried to tell them what they can and can't do with music, and they have broken all the rules, and cross the bridge to a place never imagined, where the wind is in their hair, and they are just feeling it, machine and man together.
I love your insights Rosalie. I especially like that you appreciate the story. This is my favorite RUSH song (maybe next to Subdivisions or Limelight) and you really get it! A wonderful, emotional and even spiritual song. Thank you for your impression and review! 😊
Thank you for another great video and expressing older music to a new generation. The story of Red Barchetta is based upon a stort story "A Nice Morning Drive" which was published by Road and Track magazine, written by Richard Foster. There were many liberties taken and it's loosely based upon the original story. But Neil works his magic and made it one of my favorite songs. The imagery is simply amazing and I can see in detail how they describe the story. And that is exactly why it's one of my favorite Rush songs.
This song is so well written that almost no one notices that it is missing a chorus! Musical phrases repeat, but never words. Pure Genius!!!
Ummmm.. I think a lot of Rush fans recognize that many of their songs are stories with no chorus
@@OhNoNotAgain42 Y'know, I've met plenty of Rush fans through the years, and there's one thing I've noticed about the vast majority of them: There ain't many dummies among 'em. :)
It does have a chorus, it just doesnt sound like one. There is a TH-cam vid where geddy talks about the structure of this song. The chorus is the heavier part, “jump to the ground as the turbo slows to cross the borderline.” Thats the chorus. It just doesnt have a typical chorus sound to it. But they do have other songs that legit dont have a chorus, such as closer to the heart.
Another with a chorus that doesnt sound like one is enemy within. Does high water have a chorus? Cant remember one. I hate that song lol
A song without a chorus is a Ballad
40yr fan...yes! No chorus...amazing cinematic song...who needs a chorus...my fave Rush song...by far🤘
Alex's problem is that in most bands the bass and drums are there to support the guitar. Rush was three god-level musicians supporting each other.
Yea!!! Neal plays lead drums!!!
Alex is one of the greatest and also one of the most underrated guitarists. That just goes to show how good this band really is, when someone as amazing as Alex is commonly overlooked :-)
Rolling Stone just left him off their top 50. Such a sham! The list was ridiculous!
@@stevenmonte7397 Rolling Stone has made no secret that they despise the band Rush for decades.
@@Ferd414 Damn. That's hard to believe. I can understand people not caring for a genre, but even still one can't deny they are all three at the top of their craft (or were).
Oh it's actually kind of funny the way Alex is overlooked. Have you ever seen that documentary they did a few years before Neil died? And there is one scene where the crew is with Geddy and Alex, and they're just in a diner having food, talking about the impact of the fans and interacting with the public. And the waitress comes up to ask Geddy for an autograph, and literally shoves Alex out of the way to put the paper and pen in front of Geddy. Geddy even points to him and says "He's in the band too you know" and she just kind of glances at him, and then turns away like "yeah sure". The whole time Alex is just laughing his ass off at the whole situation.
Come on, that's a myth, he was never underrated or overlooked. But I guess you're an American who believes in any random poll. He was never up there, so he must be mediocre or worse. Polls are for idiots who wants to be entertained. And if you're American, switch on your TV and et your proof. Alex Lifeson was never underrated or overlooked, neither by his fellow musicians or the listeners.
The album is Moving Pictures. The movers are moving pictures, the bystanders are moved by the pictures. On the back cover, someone is filming the scene, taking moving pictures. Pretty cool.
triple entendre.
And definitely not band members! LOL
I don't like puns 😅
The guy filming the scene is taking ‘moving pictures’ of ‘moving pictures’.
@rickschlosser6793
...taking moving pictures of movers moving moving pictures.
(3x fast)
Neil wrote this song after reading a short story about "after cars" in Road and Track magazine .. the short was called "A Nice Morning Drive" by Richard S Foster
Yes!
Picked up the original issue a few months ago. Happy to have it.
A quick google will give you several places to download/read the story. It's worth the effort.
No he wrote the lyrics..Alex and Geddy wrote the music
@@rimskykorsakov2892 Baammmm!
The whole album is Fantastic.
More than any other song I can think of, this one sounds exactly like what it is about. Another 10/10 masterpiece by Rush!
Yes Alex's guitar is crafted so that every sound and every beat is the sound of mechanical precision and automotive performance
Yea! Cause it seems that most of their songs don’t even say the title in the songs.
Red Barchetta is one of the greatest unknown rock songs and prediction that is near to reality. Thanks for the review!
This song is so cinematic to me. The narrative, the supporting music all create a visual to me that is the most cinematic of all Rush's songs.
Absolutely agree. I can practically see the movie running through my mind. It's one of my favorite Rush songs ever!
The car represents freedom from tyranny of society and progress. How long before internal combustion engines are outlawed. More prophetic than I ever imagined.
Many jurisdictions have banned the sale of ICE cars past 2035. Europe for one. But also Canada, where Rush is from.
This was them seeing the future.
How long until women's rights and the Constitution are outlawed? Maybe this November if a certain wannabe jan. 6 dictator is not stopped in his tracks.
The Canadian Government has already mandated that by 2035, all new cars must be 100% electric, so that time is coming.
@@lindaward5376 Ya I wouldn't hod your breath on that or hang your hat upon it.
@@lindaward5376 Good. Countries everywhere are setting record high temps and devastating droughts and hurricanes. Grandchildren won't have a planet to live on if we continue on this path.
My Absolute Favorite Rush song...I can cliterally close my eyes and see it unfold...Such Great Lyricism and Storytelling...
Every musical passage/tempo is designed to reflect driving a racing car.... the shifting & drifting... the chase!... the gears shifting up... the gears shifting down... sitting by the fireside with his uncle... just listen! These Rush guys are freaking geniuses!
I used to blast through the Santa Cruz Mountains in my red Scirocco with this song turned up to 11. Not quite a Barchetta, but a bright red scalpel that could slice up a mountain road with the best of em. Perfect song to accompany a sprint towards San Gregorio.
What does this song and band mean to me? This band, to me, is the closest any of us will get to perfection... just watch them live. I joined the party late in 1987, and this was the first song I really "heard" from Rush. I asked my drummer friend how many members in this band like 10... he said 3... THREE ??!! Rush is thee greatest band in any universe... period 😎☝
The Red barchetta is a 1950 Ferrari 166 MM Barchetta Neil did own one of these beauties.
That's a cheap car...not😂
No Neil never owned a 1950 Ferrari 166 MM - it was his dream car - he had an amazing colleciton of cars but this was not one of them.
@@patricknicolucci5073 The animated video for Rush's Spirit of Radio shows cartoon Neil driving a red barchetta of that vintage. Ferrari 166 MM's have sold for as much as $10,000,000 at auction.🤯
This came around 1980 about, and was written to future, 50 odd years. 1950 plus around 50 would put it to early 2000 at the earliest - could be later, we dont know when his uncle got it? Scifi story anyways. Rush at their sharpest.
But he could barely pay for it and then it only cost about $2000 dollars!
Dear Rosalie, I can't say nothing but THANK YOU. Bieng a music and cars person, I have loved this song for 40 years, but watching your reaction just made me cry. Your beautiful interpretation of the lyrics represents exactly what my heart feels every time I listen to the song.
Greetings from León, México.
I got the honor of seeing them perform this live shortly after Moving Pictures was released. There are no words.
I got that honor too in the Time Machine Tour (saw them in Chile, 2010), when they played this full album. A once-in-a-lifetime chance and a dream come true for thousands of South American fans!!
RIP Professor. 😢
I've been fortunate to see Rush in concert multiple times before Neil Peart passed away. Often when they played this song, they played a video of the actual car flying around country roads, and then the chase by the futuristic Police trying to chase him down and impound the car, arrest him, etc. All sorts of special effects came with that movie/cartoon, often accompanied with lasers and such. Definitely an experience to be had. Sadly it ended with Neil's passing. Rush is still one of my all time favorite bands. My son and I traveled hundreds of miles to see Rush and those travel stories go along with this story too, when I hear this and most any other Rush song. It is a father/son experience I cherish to this day. Thanks for your review!
Rosalie, welcome to the Rush family, sister! You have just joined the most fantastical musical bandwagon known to mankind. Your life has changed, as you’ve said so already, “I think I just got smarter”. Buckle up for the ride of your life. As Rush fans we are all excited to watch your continued moments of speechless amazement, learning, and appreciation of 3 guys who never shied away from trying new things and pushing their limits. Absolute joy to watch your mind-blowing, jaw-dropping, SMH, “Are you freaking kidding me, already?” expressions as we’ve all had them ourselves and sharing them is a true gift for all. Thanks for letting us in. 🤙🏻😎
We enjoy you enjoying these wonderful musicians. RIP Neil. The professor.
Simply...the best band ever.
Yep
No question, no doubt. There has been many other bands that others would consider to be the best ever, but let''s face it - those bands required more players, had more members floating in and out, didn't as long and in most cases, were not nearly as poetic and conceptually driven.
@@micron001 Spot on accurate, on all points.
Omg. I’m a big time Rush fan. I’m 59 I’ve been listening to them since I was 10. I love this song so much I love Ferrari and cars. I’ve never heard anyone describe a song like you just did unbelievable the way you did that. I loved it. You are so good at what you do thank you and keep doing rush.
We were spoiled back in the day. Had the best music.
3:49 from a better vanished time… could not be more prophetic.
Don’t give up the fight!
And if your foot doesn’t go hard to the floor at “drive like the wind, straining the limits of machine and man” , you may want to visit a physician.
Welcome to the Rush rabbit hole, you are in for a journey, especially if keep reading Pearts's lyrics, best drummer and lyricist EVER
We were blessed to have these three individuals come together to give us an amazing part of themselves. They've taken a fantastic explorational musical journey that impacts nearly everyone who experiences it. Thank you Alex, Garry(Geddy) and Neil for sharing.
Neil Peart! Not only an amazing drummer that inspired a generation, but an amazing lyricist as well. By all accounts he spent an inordinate amount of time reading, which would explain a lot.
: )...I was the generation he "inspired" in the mid 70's...He's done a few more since then too...:)
not Pert, Peaert
Red barchetta was my favorite song to see them do live in concert, I saw rush eight times from 1981 to 92 in St Louis MO.
I don't think that there has ben a better reaction to anything.Ever. Rosalie you absolutely RULE! Great job GREAT song!
Been following Rush since my first time seeing them in 1979, they are not just an amazing band but a religion. I appreciate you playing the whole song first. Love your page.
My favorite song of theirs. The imagery is amazing to me.
I have enjoyed yet another video of you sharing your very intelligent analysis of this very classic song. I have listened to this song since it came out in 1981, and it's one of my all-time favorite songs. I like the idea of being able to enjoy something once again from a "better vanished time." We humans have gotten so restricted in so many ways that the things we once enjoyed years ago are almost out of our grasp. To experience one thing that I had really enjoyed in the past would give me such a sense of incredible enjoyment and make me feel so free, even if I just got to do whatever it was just one more time in life. Being free is something I treasure more than anything in life, and this freedom has been stolen bit by bit over the years to where I pretty much feel suffocated by the wide array of restrictions imposed on us by government. When I reach "old age" (and I'm approaching it too fast now that I'm about to turn 58 years old), I want to experience at least one last activity (which would maybe be frowned upon or even "illegal" at that time, yet would not cause harm to anyone at all). Of course, something like driving a Red Barchetta down a country highway and feeling the freedom and the adrenaline rush from that experience once more would really make life complete. :)
Rosalie, what is so interesting about Rush is their musical unselfishness. In this case, the guitar is the color, and frequently the bass carries the melody. But as great as Alex, Neil and Geddy were as musicians, lyricists and composers, they always made room for each other to feature, and were never afraid or unwilling to write their parts to compliment the others. That's how they survived as a band for over 40 years.
Agreed, an not only why they had a 40 yr discography but also what made them one of the greatest bands ever.
Completely agree that none of the three ever steps on the others. As complex and densely layered as their music is, the impression I always leave with is restraint. It never feels like anything is overdone.
It's like a 10-string guitar played with four hands.
Geddy: “The trick in Rush was always to be able to find a proud sound for the bass that still worked with the other instruments and didn’t hog too much of the spotlight. We tried to share the spotlight. To be aggressive and stay out of the way when you needed to stay out of the way was always a challenge for me."
Agreed. I heard a description of RUSH that nailed it pretty good . . . RUSH is composed of three musicians, always playing solos at the same time, yet it works.
What was great about seeing Alex Lifeson playing live was his facial expressions. Saw Rush live for the first time in 1988, he felt every chord and can bend a string better than any guitarist I've ever seen or heard. Thanks for keeping ads till the song ends, know you need them so we can watch your channel, appreciated
He's the only guitarist I've seen making guitar faces even when playing rhythm and chords!
Consider this : "back to the farm to dream with my uncle by the fireside". This is almost like a Norwegian Wood moment for me. Did all this actually happen, or is it a dream of the narrator? Is it the dream of a person in a government controlled state pining for the old ways, or a dream of a person in the current reality worried about what might happen in the future ? Or did all these events actually happen ? Kinda fits with the whole triple entendre theme of the album cover.
Thank you Rosalie for your wonderful commentary - you always come up with new ideas and insights into your reaction videos !
Or does he have the car but the race is a dream for one day? Ahhh imagination 👍
Best band ever. This album is a trip, should be fun ride. 😎
Put me on a desert island and THIS is the only album I need.
Alex's guitar work is sublime.
Rosalie, Love your intricate analysis. Shows you 'really listen' and feel the music and lyrics. Rush paints such visual stories lyrically and musically. Also, 3 Awesome musicians that all 'lead' and 'support' one another. Chemistry is Sooo important and in music-telling, Rush had such a unique all around chemistry that made them a one and only.
"Red Barchetta" is an example of a Rush's story telling. Another is "By-Tor and the Snow Dog" musical ear candy and great story telling.
Such a great but underrated song.
And Alex wrote the lyrics for both of these -- Fact. Neil is supreme lyricist, but Alex nailed these
Neil wrote this song after reading a short story in Road & Track magazine. He implemented elements of the story in the lyrics. Many years later Neil arranged to meet the author of the story and he accompanied them on part of a tour.
You are working your way through the best album recorded by the best band ever. They will continually blow your mind with their incredible music.
Alex wrote the lyrics for Red Barchetta
I was literally sobbing watching you listen to Red barchetta as a young man I listen to this album 100 * I came to the realization that a big part of me was because of this album being a musician came from this album thank you for enjoying it as much as I do
Most underrated guitarist, in my humble opinion.
It just sparkles!
Such a well constructed song! Always a great listen, great reaction!
2112 overture is a musical masterpiece.
Best represented in RIO
She's not ready for that yet...
Gotta do the full thing with the official video when she gets there. I know she'll dig the themes.
@@thatsnice99 No Billy the original recording.
@@rimskykorsakov2892 yes … we both know the 1970’s tinny tone is much preferable to soft effeminate Rush fans as compared to the supercharged heaviest representation of Rush EVER seen in Rush history as displayed in the RIO version (only the best parts as PREFERRED by Rush)
th-cam.com/video/3pLsvbLwTwg/w-d-xo.htmlsi=Zbq-5Q2pXvgW1oXF
Can I give your reaction and analysis more than one thumbs up? First, I agree that Alex really shows what he's capable of here. Beautiful performance all the way around. I have to say the combination of Rush's lyrics, chord progressions (i.e. the bridge section leading to the solo) arrangements, and production values (tip of the hat to producer, Terry Brown) are unmatched in my opinion in the Rock Era.
Second, you've captured the essence of this story and the bigger questions posed about the relentless advance of technology vs. an unplugged, off-the-grid, simpler life and commentary on what we lose when we disconnect from that way of living, which has marked all but the past 150 years of human existence. Sadly, in many ways, too many have lost touch with each other, the natural world, and our shared history.
It' also paints a dystopian future echoing works like Animal Farm, 1984, The Terminator, and The Matrix. And we are dangerously close to this police state type of reality 43 years after the release of this song. As a 12 year old in 1981, I never dreamed this kind of thing would ever stand a chance of becoming reality. But here we are.
Thank you! Thank you! Alex rarely gets his due. I love you are going through the whole album.
When I need a story, I want it from the GOAT Neil Peart. One of my top 5 RUSH songs. RIP Neil😇
They didn't always play this in concert, but when they did there was a seriously cool video background to go with the story.
Great song and great analysis. Saw Rush do this on their Moving Pictures tour back when I was in High School, which is a show I remember to this day. Rosalie is so intelligent with her thoughts on the lyrics and music. Can't wait to hear her listen to YYZ!
Excellent song, excellent analysis!! Great job! Alex is an INCREDIBLE guitar artist...he crafts sound paintings with his guitar. He is one of a kind. Very few guitarists can do this.
This is my all-time favorite song from RUSH I just love Geddy Lee's bass playing on this one here
Wonderful music and lyrics. I am glad you mentioned Alex. He is often lost amongst the greatness of Geddy and Neil.
Those harmonics at the beginning and end are beautiful
Geddy and Neil are great on this track but I love Alex contribution
The song creates an emotion of a slightly sad nostalgia, longing for simpler times with people we care about.
I'm glad u brought up Alex on this reaction Rosalie. The riff u like so much is an expansion of harmonics. It's a technique used to give a bell-like quality to a note. It happens when u strike the string with your pick then lightly touch the string OVER the desired fret. You don't actually push the string down far enough to touch the fret. Alex used these to create a riff line that really grabs the ear. It seems to me that Rush has a penchant for inserting little "quirks" like that in many of their songs. The reggae change up in The Spirit of Radio for instance. They're just so surprising and delightful
Rush, three Canadian BFFs, who also just happen to be virtuosos, multiinstrumentalists, who like to write musically complex epic story songs in strange time signatures using some of the oddest phrasing, and arrangements. Every concert that they played was pure enjoyment like they were just playing in the garage and they were really thankful that fans just kept coming to listen to their music. Truly wondeful people. I have been listening to this band since moving pictures came out, and yes I own all of their albums. And yes Rush is in almost every playlist that I listen to. Rush: where every guy in the band, is THE BEST guy in the band.
Never ever cut short a Rush outro you will miss some amazing stuff. They left the listener wanting more and gave them it when they played live. Excellent review though keep up the Rush rabbit hole it will absolutely blow your mind. You are absolutely right Neil's lyrics were way ahead of their time. He was somewhat of a modern soothsayer.
On the fade to Tom Sawyer are some of NP's best drum fills.
They never wasted a measure
The song is based on a short story Neil had read in Popular Mechanics, or one of those mags. Yes, the story is about how the protagonist breaks the law by driving a car with a motor (I suppose gasoline engines are illegal?) but ditches the alloy air-cars "two lanes wide" at the one lane bridge.
You really need to watch/hear Rush's live album "Exit Stage Left". I was lucky enough to see them on that tour ,London 1981.....and honestly its the greatest gig ive ever seen,and ive been to plenty over the years......there will never be another band like Rush.....they,in particular around that time were truly amazing. What im finding amazing is your reaction is similar to mine when i first heard this....40 years ago!!!!
Just EPIC musicianship by Geddy Alex and Neil.... This album though not the first time hearing Rush got me into them hardcore. I have 3 bands that I will always listen to... Chicago Steely Dan and Rush .... All 3 have epic musicians and awesome music... 🔥🔥🔥
Excellent song!! I think it's about so much more than most people realize. Absolutely love rush!! 👍
Re-listening to this just now, I am continually reminded at how well each instrument is heard in the recording. Especially the drums. Especially the concert toms (the really high-sounding toms that have amazing the ability to bounce your sticks off of to get that rapid stick hit) (Yes, an amateur drummer here!) the sound of every instrument is so clear. (I consider each tom, snare and kick drum an instrument)
One of my favorite memories was back when I lived in Colorado Springs and owned an old Porsche that I used to love shooting up US 24 through Ute Pass to drive to Woodland Park (and get breakfast at The Hungry Bear) and then fly back down the pass. With this song blaring.
Each man is an artist of their craft. Fortunate to have seen them numerous times in Ontario. As well had the pleasure of doing some landscape lighting at Alex’s house. Very nice man.
The song was inspired by the futuristic short story "A Nice Morning Drive ", written by Richard Foster and published in the November 1973 issue of Road & Track magazine.
The most underrated rush song of all times my all time favourite
What I love about this track is how cinematic it is. You're right in there with the protagonist, experiencing the thrill of it all with him. It's an exhilarating track and also at times beautiful and calm.
I think this song expresses the spirit of adventure. Imagine a world where everything is controlled for your own good and safety but there is no freedom. Some people willingly give up their freedom for security and some chafe under rules that bind. I tend to feel a strong sense of nostalgia with this song also (esp with the lyrics about a "better vanished time"). When a commonplace drive in the country is a risky adventure, what does that say about the society you live in and have built? Just like the cover art, expect meanings within meanings within meanings for Rush songs.
Thank you for recognizing Alex Lifeson's brilliance; he often gets overlooked when talking about "The Best..." where Neil & Geddy are always at the top of those lists.
May I recommend MY favorite Rush song, "The Trees", especially the Exit...Stage Left version with the beautiful "Broon's Bane" lead in !
this is the reaction I was waiting for.......music and lyrics explained.....10 out of 10
Thank you very much! :)
So pleased you are discovering what we love about RUSH music. Layers upon layers of well crafted music with well thought out storytelling. I see another fan has annotated the short story Neil based the lyrics on. We’ll never see their like again. 😢
Alex is a beast on the guitar for sure. I can't wait for Witchhunt. That song will make your stop and think for sure.
Who knew Rush would be so prophetic with this one as there are now "powers that be" wanting to outlaw internal combustion engines.
Listening to music with you and hearing your thoughtful commentary is always such a treasure!! 💛
I learned this on guitar at age 15. I used to crank it when my parents were gone, so much that my neighbor four houses away heard it. The solo is tricky with that delayed entrance. Later, several decades, I played it at a bar with a professional drummer. He was a Neil Peart disciple and played it very accurately. I'm proud to say I nailed the solo.
Alex recorded the solo in the control room on a little 10 watt practice amp so the solo would sound like an AM radio in a speeding Ferrari...
You sound like my husband. We were childhood friends. He's a drummer and would practice very loudly to Rush so the whole neighborhood could enjoy it. He's 60 and can still play every Rush song to perfection. Of course, he's in a band too.
Neil loved cars. This story is based on a short story based in some potential future from a car magazine that Neil read. A car for Neil was a symbol of freedom. Individuality and freedom are frequent subjects in Neil’s writings. Neil wrote the vast majority of Rush lyrics. Occasionally he would co-write with friends outside the band and Geddy occasionally provided lyrics but most are Neil with Geddy collaborating in an editorial capacity so he was comfortable singing what Neil wrote. They loved working together, all 3 of them. Alex is the spontaneous one and many of his solos starting around Permanent Waves (Spirit, Freewill, etc) were built from multiple takes then composited together by Geddy and whatever producer they were working with at the time.
Song is a trip, plus somewhat spikey, jumpy, chill-bump producing.
More than anything, I’ve always love how the bridge jam transitions into the last section, it has the riding feeling like your on top of the world. It’s a fantastic tune to jog to!
Hi Rosalie, I appreciate your analysis of these songs and understanding of the deeper aspects of the lyrical prose of Rush. They are unique in this way in that the stories in the songs are a whole other universe of content that need to be revisited after the initial listening to the music. The Story of Red Barchetta is taken from a Road and Track article the Neil read while on tour and thought it was a great topic for a song. Rush used their time travelling on the road to be inspired to write new music. It is amazing I can hear these songs as you mentioned "years later" and still have new insights, hear nuances in the music and have a deeper relationship in general. I love the Band! I am spoiled having Rush paint the soundtracks to my youth
I’ve been very fond of driving home on old country roads blasting this song…. The music fits the narrative perfectly “ride like the wind, stretching the limits of machine & man”
BTW, your analysis is spot on… well done!
You are an inspiring person. This is one of my favorite songs. I hope you keep doing what you do.
Always love the depth of your analysis! It really allows me the chance to “go deeper” on a song that probably went over my head, hearing it for the first time back in the 80’s, while I was still in middle school.
I listened to this song many times while flying across a desert in the southwest. Hard not to push yourself and the car to the limits while listening to this.
This was based upon an article Neil read in a car magazine based on the Ferrari Barchetta.
The Giant Alloy Air Cars are 2 Lanes Wide, aka they are too wide to go across a 1 lane bridge.
As some who has lived his 53 years in South Eastern New Mexico, totally feel you on those desert drives!
@@robertherring9277 Yep, I spent a lot of time on those roads as well. Lots of empty space, aka Roy, NM
@@jeffjohnson8444 Im in Roswell!
@@robertherring9277 Nice ride from there over to Socorro
@@jeffjohnson8444 yeah we head up to Logan and Ute Lake a lot and go by Soccoro. And White City and the No Scum Alowed is neat. Take the side bys out to the old silver mines and ghost towns.
WOW, Rosie..... You GOT IT!!! You're Amazing! I LOVE your RUSH Reactions!!! Keep that Open Mind, Expanding with More RUSH!!! I'll be here to Watch & Listen to your Reactions!!!
An exceptional piece of songwriting and storytelling. I've always adored this song.
Theres a british T-shirt producer called Danforth And Pape who have done some Rush themed t-shirts one of them being "The Sunday Racing Club, Running The Deadly Race Since 1981" Those who know will know.
"an alloy air car, two lanes wide", that's why they got stranded at the one-lane bridge. I suppose that implies they are more like hovercraft rather than flying vehicles.
A completely safe and controlled society, for all it protects our physical well-being, is soul-crushing for the human spirit. Governments can't understand that because it's not quantifiable, so rules can't be made to accommodate that side of being human.
Love your lyrics breakdown afterwards...great reaction. Thank you and keep it up!
Just hearing you talk about the song and then hearing it again helps me feel so much better. Ive been feeling down because of my finances. Last week I was feeling good and now I’m not so good. I started back with a new training I’ve been in for many months and it felt good to Zoom with the people in the program and it felt like coming Home, and Rush also feels like Home. It’s a new and different direction and purpose but I know it’s a good addition to everything I’ve been doing and I’m not quite sure how to process it all to make sense. Guess I’m just having doubts about my abilities and my fears of paying bills while I’m learning this new thing. Thank you for your Light and Love which I find refreshing and very inspiring! I know I’ll be OK because I’ve been through worse! ❤
"Alloy aircar shoots towards me, TWO LANES WIDE"... "at the ONE LANE BRIDGE, I leave the giant stranded at the riverside"😉
I'm 59 and this is still my favorite track of theirs. Still kills.
I love how well they replicated the feel of a revving engine, and the rush of wind and passing terrain with their instruments in this song. It really does give you the feeling of driving fast through a bit of wilderness.
The name "Moving Pictures" refers to the elusive triple entendre. Movers are "moving" (verb) the pictures. The people watching are crying because they find the pictures moving (adjective). ...and the back cover shows a movie set recording the scene as a Moving Picture (noun)
This song has meant so much my whole life, 42 years since I first heard it. But with your analysis @rosalie, you have rounded up and explained so many of my own feelings, it has now taken a whole Full Life Anythem meaning for me. Thank you.
My personal story with this song goes back to 1982 when I was a kid with a Walkman cassette player and a Yamaha three wheeler and time on my hands. I was riding down a county road I’d never been on and listening to this song and as the part in the song about the one lane bridge is playing I round a curve and there’s a one lane bridge right in front of me. It was a good day.
I see this song as about their instruments and music. People have tried to tell them what they can and can't do with music, and they have broken all the rules, and cross the bridge to a place never imagined, where the wind is in their hair, and they are just feeling it, machine and man together.
I love your insights Rosalie. I especially like that you appreciate the story. This is my favorite RUSH song (maybe next to Subdivisions or Limelight) and you really get it! A wonderful, emotional and even spiritual song. Thank you for your impression and review! 😊
Thank you for another great video and expressing older music to a new generation.
The story of Red Barchetta is based upon a stort story "A Nice Morning Drive" which was published by Road and Track magazine, written by Richard Foster.
There were many liberties taken and it's loosely based upon the original story. But Neil works his magic and made it one of my favorite songs. The imagery is simply amazing and I can see in detail how they describe the story. And that is exactly why it's one of my favorite Rush songs.
Classic. There is nothing broken that cannot be fixed or moulded into something new of value.
Everyone always notices Neil's phenomenal drumming but some don't realize what a great poetic lyricists Neil was! Modern day poet!
FYI this is dangerous to drive too. Lol. Such a great song. Telling such a beautiful story of nostalgia and freedom.
Love the reaction...could tell you were mesmerized...caught up...yup...this is my favorite Rush song...chills every time🤘
Thank you so much for going down the Rush rabbit hole! I love your musical analysis, and subscribed to your channel last week! ☺️