Yup. No auto tune. No pitch correct. They had to nail the performance. Yeah, they could punch in and splice takes but they still had to nail each word sung.
Its fun watching todays folks try and grasp the music of our high school days. Countless mega talented players and singers. The music that made our lives, decades ago.
Moreover, there were only a few engineers that handled recording, and they made every note from every instrument sound crisp and clear. Now days, when the occasional real musician slips through the gate keepers, their talent goes to waste with a muddled recording, despite all the digital tools.
I like Dust in the Wind but it is kind of plain compared to this song. I would be more partial to The Wall or Miracles Out of Nowhere. There is a lot more going on in those songs to analyze than there is in Dust in the Wind. Also it feels like there are roughly 40,000 TH-cam reactions to Dust in the Wind and maybe a dozen between The Wall and Miracles Out of Nowhere combined.
17:25 Nobody ever mentions Steve Walsh as one of the best singers in rock, but I've always rated him that way. He can hit some notes so purely. I really love listening to him. 5
@@sjhoulihan9934nope, he came back from that to make another great Kansas album and two solo records, "judge him at his worst" no, he's one of the best males to ever pick up a microphone.
@@jamesburge1983 Yeah, I subscribed. Jess could teach a college course on technical analysis of music. I found it really informative to watch this video.
I honestly couldn't agree more!!. I've seen so many reactions. This one was exceptional when it came to genuine knowledge and breakdown. I will visit this channel again. Never been a musician but routinely listen to insane amounts of music. This video I was still able to follow quite a bit of what she was teaching, with no technical education and training.
Been a Kansas fan since the 70s. Much underappreciated band. Their muscianship is amazing. Still touring today with a few original members. Well worth seeing!
Kansas was the first band I got into. My mom bought me the cassette tape, AND a clock radio with a tape player for Christmas in like 1980 or some shit. I wore that cassette the fuck out. Next cassette was Asia. Then Prince. Then... I delved deep into punk rock, speed metal, death metal, and hip hop. Now... I'm all about classical music, old school country, Eastern European rock... Basically everything but modern country and hip hop. Auto-tune is the bane of my existence.
Kansas: One of the greatest composers of the history of rock n' roll. You Americans chould've appriciate their capacity and executions like we, of the rest of the world, done for decades.
One of the big 6 of the era, including Styx, Boston, Foreigner, Journey, and REO Speedwagon. First rate musicianship, songwriting, and my word, singing.
@@dougefresh7435queen had been around for a while and at the top of the top already by the time these “prog pop” bands came in. Queen are sort of in a league of their own for obvious reasons
this one of the best reaction and song analysis I've watched in a long time. I love it when musicians in one genre geek out over music in another genre. It's like hearing a song again for the first time. Great job!
I just found your analysis of "Carry On". I really enjoyed your breakdown. You might find it intetesting to watch Rick Beato's "What makes this song great, Episode 80" where he isolates all of the various instruments and explains what makes them significant.
The entire album this song is from, “Leftoverture” is a magnum opus. It’s amazing though, Jess, that somehow you’d never heard this until now. It’s one of the truly iconic songs of the rock pantheon. It’s one of those pieces that will simply never get old. As always, I love your in-depth musical analysis. I learn something new every time; even when I’m stupidly familiar with a particular piece - case in point here.
I, too, can’t believe I’ve never heard such a classic. I mentioned in the live that it played on the radio while I was driving shortly after editing this video. I blasted the music loudly and sang proudly along 😊
The album was to be named magnum opus(the best work by artist ) and the song magnum opus was titled leftoverture ( material left over after finishing album). Company execs changed them around.
You are incredible, Jessica. I love listening to music - all types of music. I have been watching many, many vocal coaches and performers doing reactions in an effort to learn more about the music I love listening to and to try to develop a better understanding and appreciation for what is involved in creating it. No other reactor I have found has your level of knowledge and none of them do nearly as much analysis in their video reactions. The detailed way you break the pieces down and use visuals to help understand them is remarkable. I am learning so much. You also have a wonderful personality which comes through all of your reactions. Thank you!
This was back when there was no Auto-tune, you just had to be GOOD. These guys are great musicians, great writers, great harmonizers.... The whole package. You should listen to other hits by Kansas: Dust in the Wind, Play the Game Tonight, Point of Know Return, Closet Chronicles, Hold On, Fire With Fire, Nobodys Home, Song For America, I saw them in consert a few years back (Dec 4th, '21) for their 40 year anniversary for their Point of Know Return album, where they played the whole album, in order, and then followed up with other hits. Small Classy venue. (Rialto Theater, Joliet, IL) No seats empty. We had first row, center balcony seats. They were fantastic, and had the same level of energy as witnessed here.
Love your analysis. Steve Walsh is amazing. One of the best, most overlooked singer of that time. I see you have just started your Rock journey. Rock has been gifted with legendary performances. Check out Boston “More Than a Feeling”. Brad Delp, the late lead singer, is unbelievable. Anne Wilson of Heart is one of the greatest singers you will ever hear, male, female, any genre or decade. Heart’s version of “Without You” brings me to tears. Queen Anne. Rick Emmit from Triumph is ridiculous. Nobody can cover their songs because nobody else can sing like that. Elite vocalist. Enjoy your journey!
How many original members r still in Kansas? Saw Kansas at cobo arena Detroit mi. Point of no return tour winter of 1978 (I think) in middle of a 2 foot snow storm...what a show !...band played their hearts out for those who braved the weather that night....
@@mreloo two original members, Rich Williams and Phil Ehardt, are left although Billy Greer has been with them a long time and is on 7 albums. Dave Hope and Kerry Livgren have sat in on a couple songs back in July. The current lineup is very, very good in my opinion.
My wife and I saw Kansas Saturday night at the Kiva Auditorium in Albuquerque. What a show! I've loved this band since 1977 when I bought an 8-track cassette of Point of Know Return. I was 11 years old and got instantly hooked.
@@quintonlane6560 The two founders of Kansas are still with the band and their contributions to the Kansas sound are undeniable. They are still Kansas and provide an incredible concert experience playing masterpiece after masterpiece.
Though I'm a musicsl illiterate, i thoroughly enjoyed listening to your analysis of this classic. Great stuff! I'd love to see you do some Rush (if you haven't already)....maybe Xanadu live...? Red Barchetta...? Changing gears....I have not seen very many Reaction Videos for Tim Buckley. He was such an incredible vocalist, that so few people know about! His album Dream Letter- Live In London 1968 is a real gem! Wayfaring Stranger, I've Been Out Walking, Pleasant Street, Hallucinations...etc. are all great! His studio album Blue Afternoon is also gorgeous, front to back...try Blue Melody maybe?
As a musician and kind of a music snob at times, I appreciate your reactions so much. Your knowledge, breakdown, and appreciation of arrangements are such a breath of fresh air in the reaction scene. You, Elizabeth (charismatic voice), Ken Lavigne, and KnoxHill are actually helping people understand music and what actually goes into making a song “good or bad”. Thank you so much..
I loved your in depth analysis of this great song. Steve Walsh was never given the credit he deserved for being the great vocalist he was. The band hits me emotionally even today, some 45+ years after I fell in love with their music.
Yeah, the Kansas boys were showing off a bit on this one. And they were having FUN! 🙂 Thank you for this reaction. It's nice to see how much you really enjoyed it! I think back in the day most of us didn't really know what we were hearing, but we knew we were hearing something special.
Kerry threw five hooks (as riffs) in the song, great song writer, exceptional lead guitarist but also played piano and other keyboards within it and most Kansas material. My favorite songs on the Left Overture album were Miracles Out of Nowhere and Magnum Opus.
What a great analysis. I love reactions like this, where the reviewer provides insight into what the musicians are doing. Carry On Wayward Son is, in my opinion, just an objectively good song. Personal tastes vary wildly, but no matter your preferences, you can't deny this is just a great composition and performance. If I remember right, Kerry Livgren composed it over a weekend by himself when they needed one more track for the album. I love the tempo changes, and the lyrics are inspiring yet vague enough to apply to just about anything. Just carry on. Maybe you have been on a dark path, or took a wrong turn, but just keep on and be true to yourself and you'll get there. There'll be peace when you are done.
Please take a listen to Steve singing Journey From Mariabronn on their first album. His vocal will mesmerize you. He sails between A4 and B4 towards the end. Really something else. He is one on my biggest vocal influences.
Love this song! Kansas was a great band from the 70's. Their musical style is a fusion of hard rock, southern rock & progressive rock. "Carry On Wayward Son" & "Dust In The Wind" are their 2 biggest hits. But they had other good songs such as "Point Of Know Return", "Hold On", "People Of The South Wind", "Play The Game Tonight", "Fight Fire With Fire", "All I Wanted" etc.
For the channel, Hold On & People of the South Wind are probably better for analyzing - more ProgRock. But yeah the slower change-up tune Dust in the Wind is gorgeous with a chill vibe. Of course all the lyrics have touching insights of the human condition. As a suggestion for another artist, I'd like to hear Christopher Cross or Carol King -who I consider to be tune-smiths.
In the 70's, WPLJ in New York would play entire albums the day they were released. I can remember hearing it for the first time and thinking this is a hit. I remember thinking that this is one of the best rock songs I have ever heard. I saw them in concert twice in the 70's. They were so professional and provided a wonderful experience. This was rare at the time. Most groups would show up so inebriated that the performance was not enjoyable. Kerry Livgren would later become a Christian. He was so professional and knew the technical aspects of the music industry that he single handedly revolutionized Contemporary Christian music. Kansas is a pivotal group in rock music on so many levels it begs you to spend more time on them. You will love "Dust in the Wind". My favorite is "Icarus - Borne on Wings of Steel".
Such musicianship! Very insightful commentary! ❤Lead singer was Steve Walsh who also played percussion and organ.I’m guessing they were classically trained. ❤ Dust In the Wind is going to KILL you with its gorgeous melody and the big red dude’s violin playing!!!
Robby sadly passed in 2021. His dad was the director of music history at the University of Kansas. I don’t think people realized just how good they were. They were originally signed by Don Kirshner’s label. I remember hearing of how it took them many years to pay back Kirshner and before they started making money. It’s a crazy business.
@@stevenewcomer8837 They got totally screwed by Kirshner, but keep in mind they didn't have to sign... He got rights to their first 5 albums & they each got $250 per week. edit: They each lived on a dollar a day when creating their first LP, as stated in the lyrics of Steve's solo effort "Every step of the way" (my favorite tune by him). They all lived together either in Wichita or Topeka KS, don't remember... To earn money they used stencils to spray paint addresses on the curb of homes for $10 per address... They pooled their money for food & rent out of this, & only kept $1 each for cigs & whatever...
I watched Steve grow up beginning with his grade school bands. He was extremely talented from the get go, but it wasn't until high school when he really took off vocally. That's because he was trained by his high school concert choir instructor Marvin Ginch, who also trained my oldest sister to sing like an angel.
Kansas is one of the very best rock bands ever. Top notch musical composition and lyrics. Great instrumentals and singers. There's only a few bands that could match them when you compare all those aspects of their incredible talent.
Back in the late 80's I was going through a stressful divorce and my parents were deeply concerned for my future and well being. For therapy (I guess) I cut a CD for my parents that featured this song. It was like I was telling them my story about how I came to this moment and where they fit in. According to my dad (who told me years later) when mom heard this song she started crying. After all these years, I still do too. Even now "I heard the voices when I'm dreaming. I can hear them say..."
Love watching you younger people react to the fabulous music and talent those of us who were fortunate enough to grow up in the 60’s,70’s, and 80’s got to experience first hand. Wish younger people would keep that in mind the next time they encounter those of us that are now in our 60’s, 70’s and 80’s in age. It was amazing then and it’s still amazing today.
I loved your comments about Steve Walsh switching between instruments, but he's not the only one. Kerry, along with the great guitar solos, is switching to the piano as well. Very talented musician and composer as well.
This is the actual studio recording that is being scheduled up to a like stage performance. There is a full-on live stage performance tha does show how good they were in-concert
Immy Hendrix said, he's never heard a band that was so in sync as these guys. Kansas opened several times for Hendrix, because he loved this band so much.
👨🏻🦱As a musician, ALL your "geeky" comments especially from 3:29-4:56 (and how the words "land" on offbeats) are well received by this geek! Well said, great analysis!👍🏻 You are officially a Classic Art Progressive Rock Chick!🤘🏻
Hello, Jess! My first time seeing you come up in my feed. ☺ I don't know if you've ever covered Prog/Progressive Rock bands before but Kansas was one of them, though they also leaned heavily into Rock and Folk, even Spiritual. The majority of Prog bands were Classically trained musicians who turned that influence to other forms. The different sections of this song are similar to the sections of a Classical piece, compressed and tightened into a radio friendly Rock song. One of the great aspects of older music, something newer efforts have lost, is the wide array of differing styles that have influenced the music. One single band can display deep knowledge of Classical, Jazz, Blues, Folk, World, R&B, Doo Wop and even Opera. These varied styles kept the music fresh and interesting, as opposed to the stale repetition of modern.
Hello, I did not grow up listening to rock. I am learning about the genre and its bands because of this channel and all of the wonderful subscribers. Thanks for all of the information, it is useful when I do my analysis 😊
@@jessicasopranonotes Welcome to the world of Rock, my friend. I hope you enjoy your journey. There are hundreds of great bands to explore, from the one hit wonders to the groups that have survived decades. ☺
I saw Kansas live in San Francisco in the late 70's. they were (unbelievably), just as crystal clear live as they were on their recordings. Their mixing was just as perfect. Every word could be heard, and nothing was too loud or too muted. Still my all-time favorite band to this day!!!
You just listened to a fraction of the music I grew up listened to. I'm glad we have younger people out there showing their appreciation for this great music.
I'm so glad that I lived and enjoyed these songs when they came out - but now I'm sad because we're all getting old and these wonderful musicians are passing.
Could you imagine a band like this today? I know I can’t and this band is still not in the rock ‘n’ roll Hall of Fame. They deserve it if you want to hear a great song, do a reaction to a song called Miracles Out Of Nowhere.
I saw Steve Walsh singing and doing a handstand on the keyboard with a cast on his right arm in 1978. This band is ingrained in my brain and influence the notes I play in a big way.
Really enjoyed this, thank you. Great insight and analysis. By the way, in my opinion, Steve Walsh stood alone amidst the great singers in the 70's. Staggeringly good. As is your wonderful reaction video
It's so great to see young people listening to and dissecting these songs, groups and singers from the 60s and 70s. These people had talent, musical education, creativity and they practiced. It's rare to find that combination these days and I think that is why so many young people are listening to this music. It will train your ears to appreciate something more complicated than what you will find in todays music. And it's inspirational.
Just so you know, the music for the video was the studio recording. For the video, they had the band play the song in an empty studio/performances space. Then the studio recording was matched to the "live" performance.
This is the first time that I've seen you in my feed and what a wonderful surprise! As a writer, what pulls me into a piece, whether it's cinematic, literary, or musical, is the story. This has long been a favorite song due to the profound prose of the piece. I've always understood how music adds dimension to words and leads the listener toward a desired emotion, but I always felt that the words were the foundation. This is hubris, of course. After listening to you explain the genius of the musical composition of this song, I can see how intrinsically words and music are bound together and how each uplifts the other. Brava!
You've NAILED one of the greatest parts of the Prog Rock music movement. Particularly Kansas and a band called Yes utilize this to great effect. Thanks for an actual analysis along with a reaction. Great job! You should go listen to "Lamplight Symphony"! Old Fuzzy (Robbie Steinhart) fires up his violin for a real treat! Pure MAGIC!
Great analysis, glad you liked them. Kansas is my favorite band. I've probably seen them at least six times. Twice in the front row. If i'm not mistaken, this is the studio version overlaid on a live performance That was close to the release of the song. And being such a tight band ,it looks like the live performance. They still perform today with only 2 original members. The drummer and the curly haired guitarist. But they still put on a hell of a show. They have so much music you would enjoy. I would check out.. dust in the wind, Nobody's home, cheyenne anthem, Song for america.. And many more..🤗🎶🎙🎸🎹🎻🥁🎶
I enjoyed your enthusiasm! There is only a handful of songs that still give me the same thrill that I got upon first listen, and this song is in it. Every time it starts, my brain warns me: “Steve and the boys stopped by to take you for a ride… STRAP IN.” 🎤🎸🎹🥁
I enjoyed your video very much. I loved your reactions and the depth in which you analyzed and explained the music etc. Fantastic! I’ll be back to watch more videos.
Where I'm from When you graduate, you have a class song. This was my class song in 1977. I encourage you to listen to much more Kansas. I think you're going to be really surprised how amazing this band really was. As popular as they were, I still think they have been overlooked but incredible band great reaction keep spreading the music,check out hold on,the wall, point of no return,just a few to name...❤
I only know Kansas because of Supernatural, but i loved this Song ever since, i even made a Translation for my TH-cam Channel Years ago, and im still listening to it every once in a while.. just a perfect song...
I envy you Jess. Oh to be young again and get to listen to such great artists perform their masterpieces again for the first time! Kansas, Styx, Boston, Queen, and the list goes on. Dig in and enjoy the chills!
Hello Jess, I'm a new subscriber and former rock vocalist. I wanted to tell you what a great job of analyzing and reacting you're doing. As a vocalist, it's clear you appreciate great harmonies as I do. If I may be so bold as to recommend Crosby, Stills & Nash Live "Helplessly Hoping". This was the first supergroup created from members of several very successful early rock bands and features David Crosby (The Byrds), Stephen Stills (Buffalo Springfield), and Graham Nash (The Hollies) on high-harmony. I believe you'll enjoy their tight harmonizing and hope you'll dive into this amazing group's song list.
Hi Albert, Welcome to the community. Always lovely to have musicians as part of the conversations in the comments of videos. Thanks for the recommendation!
Impressed with you review. Very in depth. Makes me appreciate the complexity some bands had over the just 3 or 4 chords. Some of what you say is over my head, but is still interesting.
Great catch on the offbeats, etc. The one hallmark you're going to find in all progressive rock bands is expert musicianship, which allows the capacity to write much more complicated music.
I have listened to this song hundreds of times…but I have never heard it like this. Excellent breakdown! I normally have no patience for in-depth analyses of rock standards…but you kept my interest with your (obvious) knowledge of music structure.
The very first time that I saw Kansas in 1975, I came away from the show with one very clear description of the band I had just enjoyed. The best word I could use to describe them was precise. Everything that they did was so well constructed and masterfully performed in perfect rhythm and harmony. They are truly amazing to witness live and in person. ✌🏼😎🇺🇸
Jess, if only for yourself take a listen to the following track after "Carry On Wayward Son" off this album called "The Wall." Yet, instead of just focusing on the vocal range & harmonies, kickback & chill & feel the vibe of Steve's voice & the message in the lyrics. I think you'll dig it my friend. Cool ✌️😉
I was a music major in college and taught guitar and bass over 27 years. I really appreciate your analysis. Kansas was a favorite band along with so many other progressive bands from the 70's. I love your reaction to this. My reaction was almost the same the first time I heard this.
Kansas was a must on the highschool keg party scene back in the 70's. I noticed most guys into the band YES seemed to listen to this more complicated rock music. That said try the song "Dust in the wind"
Excellent critique of this song! Very smart and I learned so much. I like how you bring your opera knowledge to rock in a down to earth accessible fun way. Thanks!
Welcome to the ridiculously high quality sound of the 70s, when insanely good musicians wrote and performed their own music, and producers decided to elevate, rather than dumb down, what they created for the listening public.
I saw them live in a theater, in Kansas City. You are right, they were awesome live. Respect I didn’t know how complicated. I was young, but could tell that there was some classical training or something going on with these guys.
Kerry Livgren’s lyrics with Steve Walsh’s vocals are hard to beat. I saw them on this tour in 77, unforgettable. Kansas were are group of serious musicians, and entertainers. The Wall, Dust in the Wind, and Miracles Out of Nowhere, are all worth listening to. The long haired guy, Robbie Steinhardt was a classically trained violinist, and he is show cased on a lot of their music. Really made them like no one else.
You will love to analyze the incredible Steve Walsh of KANSAS. He is considered by many as one of the top five singers of this era. I highly recommend "Journey From Mariabronne" which is an astounding composition in either the studio or their live version from "Two For the Show" album. Also "Angels Have Fallen," "Miracles Out of Nowhere," “Song For America” and their only blues track where Steve absolutely kills it called "Lonely Street."
I would like you reacting to Tommy Johansson - You raise me up (one octave up challenge/rock version). It is Tommy, you have seen him as the guitar player in Sabaton but he can sing.
I luv The fact that you as a Trained Voicelest recognize that These Classic Rock Voicelest who are untrained have a gift from above that allows them to have the born gift to do what comes naturally to them. Lady you have my Respect , Many Blessings for you
So many talents in one group, the voice, the musical skill at high levels, different riffs, OMG all in one band. Used to own (in long play) the Boston, The Eagles, the Doobie Brothers, etc.
This is from the 70s!! No computers, straight talent!! They are real musicians!!!
Yup. No auto tune. No pitch correct. They had to nail the performance. Yeah, they could punch in and splice takes but they still had to nail each word sung.
And its not quantized. Forget the grid, rhythm should be human.
Its fun watching todays folks try and grasp the music of our high school days. Countless mega talented players and singers. The music that made our lives, decades ago.
Moreover, there were only a few engineers that handled recording, and they made every note from every instrument sound crisp and clear. Now days, when the occasional real musician slips through the gate keepers, their talent goes to waste with a muddled recording, despite all the digital tools.
@@rushfan9thcmd still makes my life today and I'm 51!! Thankfully I have two teenage daughters that have embraced this era of music!!!
Dust in the wind is another great hit by Kansas. Big Red Plays the violin and sounds amazing.
I second Dust in the Wind 😎
Agreed. I think she would really appreciate this beautiful haunting ballad. The Violin stands out with the amazing vocals.
I like Dust in the Wind but it is kind of plain compared to this song. I would be more partial to The Wall or Miracles Out of Nowhere. There is a lot more going on in those songs to analyze than there is in Dust in the Wind. Also it feels like there are roughly 40,000 TH-cam reactions to Dust in the Wind and maybe a dozen between The Wall and Miracles Out of Nowhere combined.
Yes, I would love to see her analysis of Dust in the Wind.
@@88wildcat Go with Point of Know Return or Closet Chronicles
Showcases Robbie Steinhardt's violin
17:25 Nobody ever mentions Steve Walsh as one of the best singers in rock, but I've always rated him that way. He can hit some notes so purely. I really love listening to him. 5
WAS...listen to Live at the Whiskey. His voice has been shot since the early 90s.
I'm right there with you Brother. His voice was incomparable. Right up there with Freddie Mercury and Steve Perry as the greatest voices in rock.
@@sjhoulihan9934nope, he came back from that to make another great Kansas album and two solo records, "judge him at his worst" no, he's one of the best males to ever pick up a microphone.
He was @Oragnar no question about it and in his prime arguably the best male vocalist in Prog to ever be recorded.
100% agree!
Unlike a lot of touchy-feely reaction videos, this lady brings real next-level music interpretation and understanding to the table. So well done!
She knows what she is talking about, that is why I am here.
@@jamesburge1983 Yeah, I subscribed. Jess could teach a college course on technical analysis of music. I found it really informative to watch this video.
I honestly couldn't agree more!!.
I've seen so many reactions.
This one was exceptional when it came to genuine knowledge and breakdown.
I will visit this channel again.
Never been a musician but routinely listen to insane amounts of music.
This video I was still able to follow quite a bit of what she was teaching, with no technical education and training.
Been a Kansas fan since the 70s. Much underappreciated band. Their muscianship is amazing. Still touring today with a few original members. Well worth seeing!
Same fan since the 70's. I've seen them live twice once with the original members and again in the late 80s with some of the new members. Great shows
Kansas was the first band I got into.
My mom bought me the cassette tape, AND a clock radio with a tape player for Christmas in like 1980 or some shit.
I wore that cassette the fuck out.
Next cassette was Asia.
Then Prince. Then...
I delved deep into punk rock, speed metal, death metal, and hip hop.
Now...
I'm all about classical music, old school country, Eastern European rock...
Basically everything but modern country and hip hop.
Auto-tune is the bane of my existence.
Saw them earlier this year...still absolutely amazing to see and hear! Also, their latest album Absence of Presence is terrific.
Kansas: One of the greatest composers of the history of rock n' roll.
You Americans chould've appriciate their capacity and executions like we, of the rest of the world, done for decades.
One of the big 6 of the era, including Styx, Boston, Foreigner, Journey, and REO Speedwagon. First rate musicianship, songwriting, and my word, singing.
Big 7 , unless Queen is in a league of their own 😊
@@dougefresh7435queen had been around for a while and at the top of the top already by the time these “prog pop” bands came in. Queen are sort of in a league of their own for obvious reasons
Rush?
this one of the best reaction and song analysis I've watched in a long time. I love it when musicians in one genre geek out over music in another genre. It's like hearing a song again for the first time. Great job!
I just found your analysis of "Carry On". I really enjoyed your breakdown. You might find it intetesting to watch Rick Beato's "What makes this song great, Episode 80" where he isolates all of the various instruments and explains what makes them significant.
The entire album this song is from, “Leftoverture” is a magnum opus. It’s amazing though, Jess, that somehow you’d never heard this until now. It’s one of the truly iconic songs of the rock pantheon. It’s one of those pieces that will simply never get old.
As always, I love your in-depth musical analysis. I learn something new every time; even when I’m stupidly familiar with a particular piece - case in point here.
I, too, can’t believe I’ve never heard such a classic. I mentioned in the live that it played on the radio while I was driving shortly after editing this video. I blasted the music loudly and sang proudly along 😊
@@jessicasopranonotes As it should be!
👏🤘
@@jessicasopranonotes The 70's Bands: Kansas Boston Led Zeppelin Journey Styx ect... were master musicians and singers
It used to be the most requested classic rock song.
The album was to be named magnum opus(the best work by artist ) and the song magnum opus was titled leftoverture ( material left over after finishing album). Company execs changed them around.
You are incredible, Jessica. I love listening to music - all types of music. I have been watching many, many vocal coaches and performers doing reactions in an effort to learn more about the music I love listening to and to try to develop a better understanding and appreciation for what is involved in creating it. No other reactor I have found has your level of knowledge and none of them do nearly as much analysis in their video reactions. The detailed way you break the pieces down and use visuals to help understand them is remarkable. I am learning so much. You also have a wonderful personality which comes through all of your reactions. Thank you!
This was back when there was no Auto-tune, you just had to be GOOD. These guys are great musicians, great writers, great harmonizers.... The whole package. You should listen to other hits by Kansas: Dust in the Wind, Play the Game Tonight, Point of Know Return, Closet Chronicles, Hold On, Fire With Fire, Nobodys Home, Song For America, I saw them in consert a few years back (Dec 4th, '21) for their 40 year anniversary for their Point of Know Return album, where they played the whole album, in order, and then followed up with other hits. Small Classy venue. (Rialto Theater, Joliet, IL) No seats empty. We had first row, center balcony seats. They were fantastic, and had the same level of energy as witnessed here.
Takes me back to High School in 1977 - blasting this and my dad coming into my room yelling, "Turn it down!!!" Great Analysis!!!
Love your analysis. Steve Walsh is amazing. One of the best, most overlooked singer of that time. I see you have just started your Rock journey. Rock has been gifted with legendary performances. Check out Boston “More Than a Feeling”. Brad Delp, the late lead singer, is unbelievable. Anne Wilson of Heart is one of the greatest singers you will ever hear, male, female, any genre or decade. Heart’s version of “Without You” brings me to tears. Queen Anne. Rick Emmit from Triumph is ridiculous. Nobody can cover their songs because nobody else can sing like that. Elite vocalist. Enjoy your journey!
Titans from a golden age. Legendary figures to contend with forever.
Just saw Kansas play to a sold out theater two days ago. Amazing. Never been better live. The new violinist is crazy talented.
How many original members r still in Kansas? Saw Kansas at cobo arena Detroit mi. Point of no return tour winter of 1978 (I think) in middle of a 2 foot snow storm...what a show !...band played their hearts out for those who braved the weather that night....
@@mreloo two original members, Rich Williams and Phil Ehardt, are left although Billy Greer has been with them a long time and is on 7 albums. Dave Hope and Kerry Livgren have sat in on a couple songs back in July. The current lineup is very, very good in my opinion.
My wife and I saw Kansas Saturday night at the Kiva Auditorium in Albuquerque. What a show! I've loved this band since 1977 when I bought an 8-track cassette of Point of Know Return. I was 11 years old and got instantly hooked.
Wasn't the orginal all of the orginal band members unfortunately
@@quintonlane6560 The two founders of Kansas are still with the band and their contributions to the Kansas sound are undeniable. They are still Kansas and provide an incredible concert experience playing masterpiece after masterpiece.
Nice to see this song analyzed to this level. Well done.
Something special about young people discovering the music of my youth. Feels good.
Though I'm a musicsl illiterate, i thoroughly enjoyed listening to your analysis of this classic. Great stuff! I'd love to see you do some Rush (if you haven't already)....maybe Xanadu live...? Red Barchetta...?
Changing gears....I have not seen very many Reaction Videos for Tim Buckley. He was such an incredible vocalist, that so few people know about! His album Dream Letter- Live In London 1968 is a real gem! Wayfaring Stranger, I've Been Out Walking, Pleasant Street, Hallucinations...etc. are all great! His studio album Blue Afternoon is also gorgeous, front to back...try Blue Melody maybe?
As a musician and kind of a music snob at times, I appreciate your reactions so much. Your knowledge, breakdown, and appreciation of arrangements are such a breath of fresh air in the reaction scene. You, Elizabeth (charismatic voice), Ken Lavigne, and KnoxHill are actually helping people understand music and what actually goes into making a song “good or bad”. Thank you so much..
What a compliment, thank you!
YES!!!!!!!!!!!! I'm actually close to tears how much I love this analysis!!!
@@richardcorona3564
❤️
Thank you for commenting this. I feel the same way
I loved your in depth analysis of this great song. Steve Walsh was never given the credit he deserved for being the great vocalist he was. The band hits me emotionally even today, some 45+ years after I fell in love with their music.
It's kind of addictive watching, listening, how you pick out all the nuances of what made this song so great.
When an expert is blown away - that's a good song! 8 D
This wonderful vintage piece has also ended up being the official unofficial or unofficial official theme for the TV show SUPERNATURAL.
Yeah, the Kansas boys were showing off a bit on this one. And they were having FUN! 🙂 Thank you for this reaction. It's nice to see how much you really enjoyed it! I think back in the day most of us didn't really know what we were hearing, but we knew we were hearing something special.
Kerry threw five hooks (as riffs) in the song, great song writer, exceptional lead guitarist but also played piano and other keyboards within it and most Kansas material.
My favorite songs on the Left Overture album were Miracles Out of Nowhere and Magnum Opus.
What a great analysis. I love reactions like this, where the reviewer provides insight into what the musicians are doing. Carry On Wayward Son is, in my opinion, just an objectively good song. Personal tastes vary wildly, but no matter your preferences, you can't deny this is just a great composition and performance. If I remember right, Kerry Livgren composed it over a weekend by himself when they needed one more track for the album. I love the tempo changes, and the lyrics are inspiring yet vague enough to apply to just about anything. Just carry on. Maybe you have been on a dark path, or took a wrong turn, but just keep on and be true to yourself and you'll get there. There'll be peace when you are done.
Kerry Livgren, the guitar player with the blonde hair wrote most of if not all of their songs. A real genius. Queens favorite band.
Indeed most but that does a disservice to Walsh who wrote almost as many of them and some were collaboration between the two.
Please take a listen to Steve singing Journey From Mariabronn on their first album. His vocal will mesmerize you. He sails between A4 and B4 towards the end. Really something else. He is one on my biggest vocal influences.
Love this song! Kansas was a great band from the 70's. Their musical style is a fusion of hard rock, southern rock & progressive rock. "Carry On Wayward Son" & "Dust In The Wind" are their 2 biggest hits. But they had other good songs such as "Point Of Know Return", "Hold On", "People Of The South Wind", "Play The Game Tonight", "Fight Fire With Fire", "All I Wanted" etc.
Dust in the Wind - hit replay and keep it going! 😊 🌬️
For the channel, Hold On & People of the South Wind are probably better for analyzing - more ProgRock. But yeah the slower change-up tune Dust in the Wind is gorgeous with a chill vibe. Of course all the lyrics have touching insights of the human condition.
As a suggestion for another artist, I'd like to hear Christopher Cross or Carol King -who I consider to be tune-smiths.
I believe Kerry studied classical music in college.
Great analysis and modal explanations. Wow.
In the 70's, WPLJ in New York would play entire albums the day they were released. I can remember hearing it for the first time and thinking this is a hit. I remember thinking that this is one of the best rock songs I have ever heard.
I saw them in concert twice in the 70's. They were so professional and provided a wonderful experience. This was rare at the time. Most groups would show up so inebriated that the performance was not enjoyable.
Kerry Livgren would later become a Christian. He was so professional and knew the technical aspects of the music industry that he single handedly revolutionized Contemporary Christian music.
Kansas is a pivotal group in rock music on so many levels it begs you to spend more time on them. You will love "Dust in the Wind". My favorite is "Icarus - Borne on Wings of Steel".
I feel so blessed having grown up with music such as this.
I really loved your reaction and I learned alot more about this song I grew up with.
Such musicianship! Very insightful commentary! ❤Lead singer was Steve Walsh who also played percussion and organ.I’m guessing they were classically trained. ❤
Dust In the Wind is going to KILL you with its gorgeous melody and the big red dude’s violin playing!!!
Robby Steinhardt on violin
Robby sadly passed in 2021. His dad was the director of music history at the University of Kansas. I don’t think people realized just how good they were. They were originally signed by Don Kirshner’s label. I remember hearing of how it took them many years to pay back Kirshner and before they started making money. It’s a crazy business.
@@stevenewcomer8837 highly classically trained.
@@stevenewcomer8837 They got totally screwed by Kirshner, but keep in mind they didn't have to sign... He got rights to their first 5 albums & they each got $250 per week. edit: They each lived on a dollar a day when creating their first LP, as stated in the lyrics of Steve's solo effort "Every step of the way" (my favorite tune by him). They all lived together either in Wichita or Topeka KS, don't remember... To earn money they used stencils to spray paint addresses on the curb of homes for $10 per address... They pooled their money for food & rent out of this, & only kept $1 each for cigs & whatever...
I watched Steve grow up beginning with his grade school bands. He was extremely talented from the get go, but it wasn't until high school when he really took off vocally. That's because he was trained by his high school concert choir instructor Marvin Ginch, who also trained my oldest sister to sing like an angel.
Yes, it's a lot to handle. Great reaction and commentary. Glad I found you here.
Your analise, I like it. I like to watch these videos. But you are realy to the point.
RIP Robbie Steinhardt. The two part harmony of Kansas misses you.
What's On My Mind.
My graduating class chose Dust In The Wind for our class homecoming song (class of 79)
My first concert were these guys in the 70's with backing band Thin Lizzy. Kansas lyrics were sheer poetry.
Kansas is one of the very best rock bands ever. Top notch musical composition and lyrics. Great instrumentals and singers. There's only a few bands that could match them when you compare all those aspects of their incredible talent.
Their voices blend perfectly
Back in the late 80's I was going through a stressful divorce and my parents were deeply concerned for my future and well being. For therapy (I guess) I cut a CD for my parents that featured this song. It was like I was telling them my story about how I came to this moment and where they fit in. According to my dad (who told me years later) when mom heard this song she started crying. After all these years, I still do too. Even now "I heard the voices when I'm dreaming. I can hear them say..."
Steve Walsh's delivery of that line "But I flew too high..." always reminded me of Nina Simone for some reason
She'd beat him with her shoe - he's that good.
Love watching you younger people react to the fabulous music and talent those of us who were fortunate enough to grow up in the 60’s,70’s, and 80’s got to experience first hand. Wish younger people would keep that in mind the next time they encounter those of us that are now in our 60’s, 70’s and 80’s in age. It was amazing then and it’s still amazing today.
OMG...There is so much Kansas you need to check out.
I loved your comments about Steve Walsh switching between instruments, but he's not the only one. Kerry, along with the great guitar solos, is switching to the piano as well. Very talented musician and composer as well.
i usually hate those "reacts to" videos but I actually learned something from you and enhanced my love of this song.
This is the actual studio recording that is being scheduled up to a like stage performance. There is a full-on live stage performance tha does show how good they were in-concert
Doesn't sound as good as this
I loved it when came out, and I still love it. After all these years it doesn't loose anything. I enjoyed your reaction.
Immy Hendrix said, he's never heard a band that was so in sync as these guys.
Kansas opened several times for Hendrix, because he loved this band so much.
👨🏻🦱As a musician, ALL your "geeky" comments especially from 3:29-4:56 (and how the words "land" on offbeats) are well received by this geek! Well said, great analysis!👍🏻 You are officially a Classic Art Progressive Rock Chick!🤘🏻
This was a great analysis. Also, your enthusiasm is really contagious! ☺
Hello, Jess! My first time seeing you come up in my feed. ☺
I don't know if you've ever covered Prog/Progressive Rock bands before but Kansas was one of them, though they also leaned heavily into Rock and Folk, even Spiritual. The majority of Prog bands were Classically trained musicians who turned that influence to other forms. The different sections of this song are similar to the sections of a Classical piece, compressed and tightened into a radio friendly Rock song.
One of the great aspects of older music, something newer efforts have lost, is the wide array of differing styles that have influenced the music. One single band can display deep knowledge of Classical, Jazz, Blues, Folk, World, R&B, Doo Wop and even Opera. These varied styles kept the music fresh and interesting, as opposed to the stale repetition of modern.
Hello,
I did not grow up listening to rock. I am learning about the genre and its bands because of this channel and all of the wonderful subscribers. Thanks for all of the information, it is useful when I do my analysis 😊
Are you going to review more Kansas?
@@jessicasopranonotes Welcome to the world of Rock, my friend. I hope you enjoy your journey. There are hundreds of great bands to explore, from the one hit wonders to the groups that have survived decades. ☺
I saw Kansas live in San Francisco in the late 70's. they were (unbelievably), just as crystal clear live as they were on their recordings. Their mixing was just as perfect. Every word could be heard, and nothing was too loud or too muted. Still my all-time favorite band to this day!!!
Growing up in the 70's THEY were the masters! I never missed a concert and they never disappointed. Loved your reaction......Tammy
You just listened to a fraction of the music I grew up listened to. I'm glad we have younger people out there showing their appreciation for this great music.
I'm so glad that I lived and enjoyed these songs when they came out - but now I'm sad because we're all getting old and these wonderful musicians are passing.
Could you imagine a band like this today? I know I can’t and this band is still not in the rock ‘n’ roll Hall of Fame. They deserve it if you want to hear a great song, do a reaction to a song called Miracles Out Of Nowhere.
1976 was a huge year for music some of the greatest songs from the 70s came from 76 and this song was one of them.
I saw them the year this came out. They didn't use effects. What they play is what you get. Raw and unfiltered. Such perfection.
One of the most underrated bands ever, real musicians and pure talent
Back from when music required talent. No autotune kids....
It's one of those songs you hope will never end.
I saw Steve Walsh singing and doing a handstand on the keyboard with a cast on his right arm in 1978. This band is ingrained in my brain and influence the notes I play in a big way.
Really enjoyed this, thank you. Great insight and analysis. By the way, in my opinion, Steve Walsh stood alone amidst the great singers in the 70's. Staggeringly good. As is your wonderful reaction video
Kansas' album, "Two For The Show" is one of the best live albums I've heard. Check it out.
I saw Kansas live in 1982...they were fantastic.
It's so great to see young people listening to and dissecting these songs, groups and singers from the 60s and 70s. These people had talent, musical education, creativity and they practiced. It's rare to find that combination these days and I think that is why so many young people are listening to this music. It will train your ears to appreciate something more complicated than what you will find in todays music. And it's inspirational.
Just so you know, the music for the video was the studio recording. For the video, they had the band play the song in an empty studio/performances space. Then the studio recording was matched to the "live" performance.
This is the first time that I've seen you in my feed and what a wonderful surprise! As a writer, what pulls me into a piece, whether it's cinematic, literary, or musical, is the story. This has long been a favorite song due to the profound prose of the piece. I've always understood how music adds dimension to words and leads the listener toward a desired emotion, but I always felt that the words were the foundation. This is hubris, of course. After listening to you explain the genius of the musical composition of this song, I can see how intrinsically words and music are bound together and how each uplifts the other. Brava!
Live is just as clear as the recording! I have seen them a few times started in 1980 then over the years!
You've NAILED one of the greatest parts of the Prog Rock music movement. Particularly Kansas and a band called Yes utilize this to great effect. Thanks for an actual analysis along with a reaction. Great job! You should go listen to "Lamplight Symphony"! Old Fuzzy (Robbie Steinhart) fires up his violin for a real treat! Pure MAGIC!
Great analysis, glad you liked them. Kansas is my favorite band. I've probably seen them at least six times. Twice in the front row. If i'm not mistaken, this is the studio version overlaid on a live performance That was close to the release of the song. And being such a tight band ,it looks like the live performance. They still perform today with only 2 original members. The drummer and the curly haired guitarist. But they still put on a hell of a show. They have so much music you would enjoy. I would check out.. dust in the wind, Nobody's home, cheyenne anthem, Song for america.. And many more..🤗🎶🎙🎸🎹🎻🥁🎶
Thanks. I can actually learn more music theory from your reaction. Greatly appreciated.
Just a bad ass song!!! I will always give time to hear this masterpiece!
I enjoyed your enthusiasm!
There is only a handful of songs that still give me the same thrill that I got upon first listen, and this song is in it. Every time it starts, my brain warns me: “Steve and the boys stopped by to take you for a ride… STRAP IN.” 🎤🎸🎹🥁
I enjoyed your video very much. I loved your reactions and the depth in which you analyzed and explained the music etc. Fantastic! I’ll be back to watch more videos.
Where I'm from When you graduate, you have a class song. This was my class song in 1977. I encourage you to listen to much more Kansas. I think you're going to be really surprised how amazing this band really was. As popular as they were, I still think they have been overlooked but incredible band great reaction keep spreading the music,check out hold on,the wall, point of no return,just a few to name...❤
I only know Kansas because of Supernatural, but i loved this Song ever since, i even made a Translation for my TH-cam Channel Years ago, and im still listening to it every once in a while.. just a perfect song...
I envy you Jess. Oh to be young again and get to listen to such great artists perform their masterpieces again for the first time! Kansas, Styx, Boston, Queen, and the list goes on. Dig in and enjoy the chills!
One word describes this song for me MASTERPIECE!
Hello Jess, I'm a new subscriber and former rock vocalist. I wanted to tell you what a great job of analyzing and reacting you're doing. As a vocalist, it's clear you appreciate great harmonies as I do. If I may be so bold as to recommend Crosby, Stills & Nash Live "Helplessly Hoping". This was the first supergroup created from members of several very successful early rock bands and features David Crosby (The Byrds), Stephen Stills (Buffalo Springfield), and Graham Nash (The Hollies) on high-harmony. I believe you'll enjoy their tight harmonizing and hope you'll dive into this amazing group's song list.
Hi Albert,
Welcome to the community. Always lovely to have musicians as part of the conversations in the comments of videos. Thanks for the recommendation!
Impressed with you review. Very in depth. Makes me appreciate the complexity some bands had over the just 3 or 4 chords. Some of what you say is over my head, but is still interesting.
Great catch on the offbeats, etc. The one hallmark you're going to find in all progressive rock bands is expert musicianship, which allows the capacity to write much more complicated music.
I have listened to this song hundreds of times…but I have never heard it like this. Excellent breakdown! I normally have no patience for in-depth analyses of rock standards…but you kept my interest with your (obvious) knowledge of music structure.
The very first time that I saw Kansas in 1975, I came away from the show with one very clear description of the band I had just enjoyed. The best word I could use to describe them was precise. Everything that they did was so well constructed and masterfully performed in perfect rhythm and harmony. They are truly amazing to witness live and in person. ✌🏼😎🇺🇸
Jess, if only for yourself take a listen to the following track after "Carry On Wayward Son" off this album called "The Wall." Yet, instead of just focusing on the vocal range & harmonies, kickback & chill & feel the vibe of Steve's voice & the message in the lyrics. I think you'll dig it my friend. Cool ✌️😉
As per usual, I have no clue what you're saying... but I like it! My vote is for song for america, next. You get to hear both voices on their own!
I was a music major in college and taught guitar and bass over 27 years. I really appreciate your analysis. Kansas was a favorite band along with so many other progressive bands from the 70's. I love your reaction to this. My reaction was almost the same the first time I heard this.
Kansas was a must on the highschool keg party scene back in the 70's. I noticed most guys into the band YES seemed to listen to this more complicated rock music. That said try the song "Dust in the wind"
Ya did I see you on that farm outside of Lawrence at a keg party / Kansas band. That's for real❤
I graduated in 85. We were still listening.
Excellent critique of this song! Very smart and I learned so much.
I like how you bring your opera knowledge to rock in a down to earth accessible fun way.
Thanks!
They sound just like the record in concert! They are SO GOOD!!
Welcome to the ridiculously high quality sound of the 70s, when insanely good musicians wrote and performed their own music, and producers decided to elevate, rather than dumb down, what they created for the listening public.
Check out the entire album--you will be amazed! T
I saw them live in a theater, in Kansas City. You are right, they were awesome live. Respect I didn’t know how complicated. I was young, but could tell that there was some classical training or something going on with these guys.
Kerry Livgren’s lyrics with Steve Walsh’s vocals are hard to beat. I saw them on this tour in 77, unforgettable.
Kansas were are group of serious musicians, and entertainers. The Wall, Dust in the Wind, and Miracles Out of Nowhere, are all worth listening to. The long haired guy, Robbie Steinhardt was a classically trained violinist, and he is show cased on a lot of their music.
Really made them like no one else.
You will love to analyze the incredible Steve Walsh of KANSAS. He is considered by many as one of the top five singers of this era. I highly recommend "Journey From Mariabronne" which is an astounding composition in either the studio or their live version from "Two For the Show" album. Also "Angels Have Fallen," "Miracles Out of Nowhere," “Song For America” and their only blues track where Steve absolutely kills it called "Lonely Street."
I would like you reacting to Tommy Johansson - You raise me up (one octave up challenge/rock version). It is Tommy, you have seen him as the guitar player in Sabaton but he can sing.
Thank you for your detailed analysis!
Their song Dust in the Wind evolved from an acoustic guitar finger picking exercise. It’s probably one of their most popular songs.
I luv The fact that you as a Trained Voicelest recognize that These Classic Rock Voicelest who are untrained have a gift from above that allows them to have the born gift to do what comes naturally to them.
Lady you have my Respect , Many Blessings for you
So many talents in one group, the voice, the musical skill at high levels, different riffs, OMG all in one band. Used to own (in long play) the Boston, The Eagles, the Doobie Brothers, etc.