Why EV repair and insurance is a NIGHTMARE | MGUY Australia

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 ธ.ค. 2024

ความคิดเห็น • 2.4K

  • @albertsmith1048
    @albertsmith1048 ปีที่แล้ว +552

    In the UK a battery for a Porsche Taycan EV is £40,000 British pounds or AU$ 76,216 Australian dollars. Be afraid, be very afraid.

    • @mguytv
      @mguytv  ปีที่แล้ว +32

      Far out…! That’s insane!!

    • @hawkboy451
      @hawkboy451 ปีที่แล้ว +34

      It's all about the greater good.....

    • @petew8388
      @petew8388 ปีที่แล้ว

      Yep... LOL !......@@hawkboy451

    • @bobbrown8661
      @bobbrown8661 ปีที่แล้ว +16

      Tell 'em they're dreamin...

    • @czechmate6916
      @czechmate6916 ปีที่แล้ว +12

      Tesla batteries are expensive I can’t afford that or the car.

  • @lesliecarter4295
    @lesliecarter4295 ปีที่แล้ว +415

    Ironically, speed bumps and kerbs are the biggest cause of battery floor damage. Most BEV’s have too little ground clearance.

    • @hudsonbear5038
      @hudsonbear5038 ปีที่แล้ว +11

      EVERY time I see the new word for EV's BEVs it makes me think of the really old films that shows Coal minervillages and the wife with a tea clothe on their heads often called BEV or Mavis lol ALwys chatting about nothing and going Nowhere. Bit like BEV's lol

    • @roberthuntley1090
      @roberthuntley1090 ปีที่แล้ว +26

      I've seen pictures of scrap yards moving cars round with fork lift trucks - could be an interesting 'experience' if they try that with a written off EV.

    • @lesliecarter4295
      @lesliecarter4295 ปีที่แล้ว +16

      @@roberthuntley1090 structural batteries will bring a much higher risk when the vehicle reaches a breaker’s yard.

    • @petergosney6433
      @petergosney6433 ปีที่แล้ว

      What garbage. Why would their clearance be different? Clown.

    • @erroneouscode
      @erroneouscode ปีที่แล้ว +21

      @@roberthuntley1090 They will introduce tighter controls sooner or later on who can even touch them. The days of having unskilled labor working for peanuts in salvage yards dealing with something so dangerous will come to an end.

  • @sterobloc6645
    @sterobloc6645 ปีที่แล้ว +203

    But is it going to be the EV owner’s paying for the massive increase in insurance . . . Or will our wonderful governments put pressure on to spread the risk across all vehicle owners?

    • @josephberrie9550
      @josephberrie9550 ปีที่แล้ว +21

      you know the answer to that question already

    • @ausforaus7617
      @ausforaus7617 ปีที่แล้ว +13

      My money is on governments mandating that insurance companies spread the risk.

    • @tmaxyb
      @tmaxyb ปีที่แล้ว +5

      My insurance doubled this year. The rep said costs had gone up throughout the industry.

    • @chucklesthered2338
      @chucklesthered2338 ปีที่แล้ว

      Just wait until they start taxing you by the mile. EV's don't buy gas or diesel so the government doesn't collect taxes to fix roads and build bridges with. The only solution to that problem is to start charging by the mile. Just another avenue for the government to control our movement.

    • @Chris.Davies
      @Chris.Davies ปีที่แล้ว +5

      Insurance companies assess each vehicle's insurance rates independently.
      If they did not, they would lose a lot of customers very quickly.

  • @andrewless4067
    @andrewless4067 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +12

    I changed a engine in my neighbours corolla in 2007. Engine cost $350 AUD from the wrecker and the same in a new timing chain, filters, hoses, oil etc. It was a 1 day change over. She was elderly and couldn't afford much so it was great we could fix it so easily.

  • @StealthGTI
    @StealthGTI ปีที่แล้ว +110

    I replaced the engine in my daughter's 2015 Golf. It would have cost $10,000 for a new long block, but we opted for a salvaged engine at $6500. Some argued that it was too much for the car's value. They obviously didn't see the crazy car market prices in 2022! Sometimes, it's more economical to fix the car that you have. 😊

    • @gadgettrendsarkar2050
      @gadgettrendsarkar2050 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      You have done the right thing boy! Save on costs instead of buying a brand new car engine you went for a old salvaged engine that costs like a part of your vehicle when you have bought it. But it's more than your IDV Value, it just made sense. You saved the hassle on nit buying a EV in the 1st place and take your vehicle in a fun ride.

    • @sarahthompson5082
      @sarahthompson5082 ปีที่แล้ว

      th-cam.com/video/-UfsEj7AOGI/w-d-xo.htmlsi=os1QadMaxGl2rVCK

    • @jianbinchen8243
      @jianbinchen8243 ปีที่แล้ว

      6500 for used engine?what kind vehicle?

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@jianbinchen8243 - It's right in the first sentence: 2015 Golf. That's a VW, if you are not aware.

    • @m.b5777
      @m.b5777 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      If you have bought a Toyota you didn't need to replace the engine

  • @reginaldscot165
    @reginaldscot165 ปีที่แล้ว +345

    This reinforces my realisation that anything the government thinks is a good idea (after some small research) turns out to be an absolutely terrible idea!

    • @xpusostomos
      @xpusostomos ปีที่แล้ว +9

      A bit of an exaggeration, but not by much

    • @xraylife
      @xraylife ปีที่แล้ว +13

      EV's are a great idea for the world government - because the end result is to remove your right to vehicle ownership.
      If they could get rid of ICE's then the real cost of the rare elements will be imposed and then a EV car will cost 200K.

    • @treelineresearch3387
      @treelineresearch3387 ปีที่แล้ว +13

      ​@iscadean > I thought in a capitalist society the market determined everything.
      You might have forgotten about the subsidies to EV manufacturers and the tax incentives for consumers that made BEV into the barely-market-viable thing it is now, but I didn't. Really the only problem I have with BEV is how much tax money is handed out in corporate and upper middle class welfare to try to force BEV to happen before the tech is ready.
      The environmental argument doesn't hold any water even if you buy the climate nonsense. With a BEV you still mostly just burn the fossil fuels somewhere else, and the efficiency of the plant is only 10-20% higher than a car engine, before factoring in transport and conversion losses.

    • @Theweouthereforrealclub-
      @Theweouthereforrealclub- ปีที่แล้ว

      @iscadeanMore like there is top down control that no western govt can ignore. They bust it out sometimes for important shit, I don’t know how good your memory is but you may recall Covid being complete bullshit and every western govt toed the line? There were even several African leaders assassinated for refusing to comply. If you want to know more find out about central banking and go from there.

    • @scottw5315
      @scottw5315 ปีที่แล้ว

      Look what they did during the pandemic. Lockdowns, masks and even mandatory vaccinations of a junk experimental gene therapy. Yes, they conspired together.@iscadean

  • @allomony4010
    @allomony4010 ปีที่แล้ว +200

    love your calm and considered delivery of the facts. The EVangilists always feel a need to yell to get their point across.

    • @grant1352
      @grant1352 ปีที่แล้ว +8

      EVangilists ...great comment thanks !

    • @vinbar35
      @vinbar35 ปีที่แล้ว +16

      I suspect it's a sense of embarrassment. Let's be honest, the main (and probably only) reason that they bought an EV wasn't to play their part for saving the environment, it was so they could go to the pub with their friends, look smug and partake in self-righteous conversations about how cheap their vehicles are to run: no road fund licence, 50 pence to do a thousand miles by charging at home. Now those cheap costs are becoming more and more expensive costs and so they have to shout down anyone who disparages an EV powered vehicle.
      They have now hit the wall and probably feel like chumps who have fallen for a technology that has not been tested anywhere near enough for real world purposes.

    • @treelineresearch3387
      @treelineresearch3387 ปีที่แล้ว +9

      @@vinbar35 Only reason BEV became affordable even to the fart huffing tech dork segment of the upper middle class is subsidies and tax incentives.

    • @vinbar35
      @vinbar35 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      @@treelineresearch3387 Agreed but they are slowly being cut back so that, together with extortionate electricity costs, means the EV rose coloured glasses bought from Virtual Signalling R Us are beginning to lose their lustre somewhat.

    • @seannewman5391
      @seannewman5391 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@vinbar35 I'm an EV owner and I'm not smug or embarrassed. Mainly I'm just much better off financially. My EV is £1800 a year cheaper to run than a fossil fuel powered car. Most of what you read here is hyperbolic sensationalism. I hate this subject has become so hate filled and tribal.

  • @laurocaramanico2596
    @laurocaramanico2596 ปีที่แล้ว +183

    There' s One more thing to say: lithium battery are classified as DANGEROUS GOODS, so the lorry/van driver who transport them need to have a SPECIAL LICENSE FOR DANGEROUS GOODS, in Italy is called ADR. Is the same you need to transport petrol, explosive, chemical etc. But, if you drive and EV who carry THOUSENDS of battery no cops will ask you this license. I wonder why...

    • @rhys6165
      @rhys6165 ปีที่แล้ว +15

      I drive a petrol car and have never been asked to produce a special license to transport the fuel in my tank. 😂

    • @mikethespike7579
      @mikethespike7579 ปีที่แล้ว +21

      @@rhys6165 Yes, because your tank holds maybe 40 or 50 litres, well within the maximum capacity for licence free transport.

    • @WS-vk5tg
      @WS-vk5tg ปีที่แล้ว +3

      LM2596, the license has more to do with protecting emergency personnel who have to deal with these vehicles after crashes.

    • @laurocaramanico2596
      @laurocaramanico2596 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      @@WS-vk5tg Well, the fact is that you can crash with a van or lorry transporting lithium battery , but you can crash also with your lithium battery powered EV car, so why you need a special ADR license in one case and nothing in the other...

    • @WS-vk5tg
      @WS-vk5tg ปีที่แล้ว +4

      @@laurocaramanico2596 It is obvious to the emergency person what they are dealing with in the case of cars, they need to have placards on transport vehicles to inform them of hazardous materials they can't see..

  • @jevgeniardassov
    @jevgeniardassov ปีที่แล้ว +131

    My childhood friend just had a similar quote from Mercedes on his 4 years old 140 000 km EQC, 45600.- eur to replace the battery. He asked what the 8year/160000 km warranty stands for then. Mercedes replied, warranty does not cover battery capacity degradation, there is no promise in the warranty booklet on the capacity. Since battery is not bricked, it just drives 150-200 km at best instead of 450 km brand new. Mercedes said he ruined it by using fast chargers too many times… My god this battery warranty is like Swiss cheese.

    • @simony2801
      @simony2801 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      The warranty is 70% available after 8 years.

    • @elduderino7767
      @elduderino7767 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      If the warranty doesn't cover the battery then it's because the manufacturer know it's not going to last
      Stick to a competent EV manufacturer, hardware is nothing without the right software
      There is a reason Tesla warranty the batteries for up to 70% over 8 years
      Even if you abuse your battery in supercharged constantly drain it to zero and fill it to 100% it's still going to have 70% capacity after 8 years
      However, if you don't do those things and only charge to 80%, then you're probably only going to have 5% degradation
      Very easy for a Tesla original battery to our last and ice vehicle lifespan
      It all comes down to using it right

    • @jevgeniardassov
      @jevgeniardassov ปีที่แล้ว +4

      @@elduderino7767 somehow Tesla gives same 8 year / 160 000 km warranty, stating up to 70% battery capacity remaining, but UP TO is the key. NOT BELOW 70% would be a warranty to recommend.

    • @elduderino7767
      @elduderino7767 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@jevgeniardassov well you have to consider consumer battery abuse and neglect
      guaranteeing at least 70% battery capacity is pretty good considering how badly batteries can be abused
      it illustrates the self preserving mechanisms that tesla have built into battery management - the vast majority of which is unavailable from other manufacturers
      so i am not surprised by stories like the one mentioned in this video, great hardware demands great software - if the later doesn't exist then there is no point spending big on hardware, it's money down the drain

    • @cline1972
      @cline1972 ปีที่แล้ว +7

      I rebuilt my first engine in 1977(4cyl Nissan). I have rebuilt 15 engines. A man with avg mechanical can do it..an ICE engine can easily last 1million miles

  • @Seanmirrer
    @Seanmirrer ปีที่แล้ว +270

    We are a 6 figure income couple and had very little saved and not much cash lying around the preverbal".
    '...don't have $500 for an
    emergency" that was us. The big thing was debt all kinds of it, cars mortgage (although our home isn't a high price one), student loans for our kids, and of course credit cards.
    One day we just got sick of being broke and went total scorched earth and became frugal overnight. Paid it all off, it took almost 5 years but now we have no debt and this year our savings rate is 50% on basically the same income that had us perpetually broke. So for us it is mainly staying out of debt and watching our spending, at first it was a real effort to save in our HISA and 401Ks but now it's actually fun watching our money grow. No car or vacation or neighborhood is worth being broke or financially unstable.

    • @MichealTanner141
      @MichealTanner141 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Congratulations on taking the steps necessary to get yourself out of the financial bind you were in.

    • @GaryWinstonBrown
      @GaryWinstonBrown ปีที่แล้ว

      Facing your medicine can be difficult. However, with commitment, you'll ultimately reach a highly satisfying place. It's all about the actions you're willing to take.

    • @AnnaKrueger809
      @AnnaKrueger809 ปีที่แล้ว

      Your financial journey is truly inspiring, and I'm currently striving to achieve the goals you've reached. Could you please share some tips to help others learn and navigate their own paths to financial success? Your insights would be invaluable.

    • @Seanmirrer
      @Seanmirrer ปีที่แล้ว

      Samuel Peter Descovich that's whom I work with

    • @Seanmirrer
      @Seanmirrer ปีที่แล้ว

      I believe everyone could benefit from having a personal financial advisor. They can assist you in reaching your customized financial objectives at any point, ensuring you remain profitable.

  • @grahamidle1244
    @grahamidle1244 ปีที่แล้ว +122

    My worry is that insurance companies will start to push in cost of EV insuance on to owners of ICE vehicles.

    • @jeff6450
      @jeff6450 ปีที่แล้ว +7

      Unfortunately if an ICE is at fault with an EV-ICE accident, the ICE insurance will have to pay. Since there are more EVs, the chance of an accident with one is higher.

    • @scottw5315
      @scottw5315 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Count on it...

    • @grahamidle1244
      @grahamidle1244 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      I wasn’t talking about claims but I meant premiums with all the talk about the cost of insuring EVs.

    • @onevastanus
      @onevastanus ปีที่แล้ว +10

      "Of course! This will force people to pay more to drive freely, and thus restrict everyone's freedom while making everyone poorer and killing millions through that same poverty. Do you think we are stupid?" - a government thinktank member, this morning

    • @oldmate99
      @oldmate99 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      So they bloody should

  • @listairgin
    @listairgin ปีที่แล้ว +79

    Thank you for exposing this world wide con job . 💕🕊.

    • @geoffreyveale7715
      @geoffreyveale7715 ปีที่แล้ว

      People are incredibly gullible. First they believe the lie that using ICE cars is causing a planet disaster. Next they believe the lie that an electric car is the solution. Next they believe that electric cars are safe and effective, just like the jab which was also a lie. So many lies.

  • @GoCreatehms
    @GoCreatehms ปีที่แล้ว +299

    I'm told EVs have much fewer moving parts than ICE cars so much less to go wrong. But 7000+ individual batteries equals 7000 potentially explosive failure points. Give me an old school ICE any day, no fancy electronics, just straight forward DIY repairable mechanical common sense.

    • @petew8388
      @petew8388 ปีที่แล้ว +21

      Absolutely spot on..... I have 3 vehicles on the road, 2 are 17 years old and 1 is 54 years old.

    • @seanworkman431
      @seanworkman431 ปีที่แล้ว +12

      I knew a bloke that had catastrophic engine failure in the outback and got towed into the nearest town in his 64 Chev by a Chevy towtruck. Timing gear failure, rod through cylinder and a general mess. The tow guy had a workshop and the two travellers were mechanics and drove away 3 days later in a V7 powered Impala. I will resist boring you with the details.

    • @erroneouscode
      @erroneouscode ปีที่แล้ว +16

      And those cells are often sealed with gunk like a washing machines circuit board. It's a throwaway part. There's no comparison to an engine and gearbox etc that can readily be dismantled and replace individual worn parts. When an engine goes it doesn't take the rest of the car with it.

    • @encinobalboa
      @encinobalboa ปีที่แล้ว +10

      The only advantage ICE has is no oil changes, no differential oil changes, and so on. EV batteries are a big problem.

    • @sinirliadam
      @sinirliadam ปีที่แล้ว +24

      "Moving part" is the magic words EV lovers adore. Too bad a part doesn't need to move to fail.

  • @tcook6759
    @tcook6759 ปีที่แล้ว +100

    I’m happy to hear someone finally talking about the immense down side of EVs. I won’t be owning one anytime soon.

    • @haku8135
      @haku8135 ปีที่แล้ว +7

      I physically couldn't get one if I did want one.
      I'd literally have no way to charge it. I live in an apartment complex, I couldn't run a fucking cable from my apartment to my car if I parked it illegally!
      And I've literally never seen any charging stations in my entire life. There's a gas station on just about every corner though. My current car is a massive piece of crap and I'm saving steadily to get a new one. But if someone offered me a brand spanking new Tesla for literally no cost, I'd laugh in their face.

    • @Andreabay90
      @Andreabay90 ปีที่แล้ว

      so youre laughing at free 50.000 dollars. @@haku8135 just get a house if you have that much money lol

    • @THE16THPHANTOM
      @THE16THPHANTOM ปีที่แล้ว +1

      soon you wont have a choice. there are so many ways to make it extremely inconvenient to drive non electric. and they would implement all of them if electric cars themselves weren't their own worst enemy.

    • @HaruHaruman
      @HaruHaruman ปีที่แล้ว +1

      ​@THE16THPHANTOM no way it will be anytime soon. Maybe in 15-20 years, which is no way near anytime soon.

    • @Sal3600
      @Sal3600 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@haku8135 lmao you are a dill. i'd take that brand spanking new free tesla in a heartbeat. i currently drive a BMW 3 series.

  • @MISTERLeSkid
    @MISTERLeSkid ปีที่แล้ว +3

    There is another fellow up here in Canada recently (in the province of BC) who bought a NEW Ionic for $56K CAD. He ran over a piece of road debris and it caused some minor scratching to the battery's protective shield. He took it to the Hyundai dealer who said that damage voided the battery warranty and told the driver that the battery HAS to be changed for fear of explosion, fire etc... With tax and installation, it was over $60K to put a new battery in his new $56K car. He had no choice of course but to pass it on insurance and his rates will now be doubled for the next 10 years. All because of a little bit of scratching on the bottom of the car..... which is where EVERY EV's battery is.

  • @poliziagrammaticale9430
    @poliziagrammaticale9430 ปีที่แล้ว +83

    I own a 1999 Citroen Saxo with 265,000 km. A couple of years ago I had to replace the head gasket and the chain drive. Apart from that, no other major issues. It still has its original clutch.

    • @xraylife
      @xraylife ปีที่แล้ว +6

      My Toyota SUV is at 400K original engine and autobox nothings ever gone wrong with it - it is a Japan made model though.

    • @treelineresearch3387
      @treelineresearch3387 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      @iscadean Timing chain is specifically a wear item, and for the most part is not that hard to replace....unless it's German. On my Honda it's a hundred dollar part and a few hour job to do in the driveway, and like an hour for a mechanic to do. If your trans and transfer case is blowing up at 100k that's probably more a how you abuse it thing unless that generation is just particularly bad.

    • @bunsw2070
      @bunsw2070 ปีที่แล้ว

      One car isn't a representative sample. Stop cluttering the thread will irrelevant points.

    • @jeremyradford5103
      @jeremyradford5103 ปีที่แล้ว

      The problem EVangelists have is all the BS and false information spread on social media and in the gutter press. Rather than listen to the propaganda, find out for yourself. Big oil has spent more than $60 million on social media influencing over the last 6 years. Think about it!?

    • @peeemm2032
      @peeemm2032 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@bunsw2070 one car isn't statistically conclusive, but it IS an example of what ICE technology is capable of.
      It's also a countexample to the ridiculous claims of some EV fans that ICEs are inherently unreliable because of the hundreds of moving parts in their drive train......while failing to mention the thousands of electrical and electronic components in the EV drive train, all of which are subject to failure....
      There are many examples of ICE models that have reputations for reliability, and that are known for regularly lasting for many hundreds of thousands of miles (e.g. Mercedes diesels, some Toyotas etc)...
      This thread was about individual examples of ICEs reaching high mileages, so the poster you chided wasn't being irrelevant.
      Stop being an ass.......

  • @tonysheerness2427
    @tonysheerness2427 ปีที่แล้ว +102

    If batteries did not go into thermal runaway they would be repaired, but no one is going to take risks with a 70kvh ticking time bomb. Which begs the question should mechanics work on the cars or army bomb disposal teams?

    • @kevinrice7635
      @kevinrice7635 ปีที่แล้ว +9

      India sandal mechanics could repair it.

    • @tonysheerness2427
      @tonysheerness2427 ปีที่แล้ว

      Life is cheap in India.@@kevinrice7635

    • @JoeOvercoat
      @JoeOvercoat ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@kevinrice7635Rather, they *would* repair it. Just like they will “repair” damaged batteries.

    • @LEOGermanHybrid
      @LEOGermanHybrid ปีที่แล้ว

      The fundamental logic in the design of electric vehicles is safety. There are interlock mechanisms, insulation detection mechanisms, maintenance switches, and other features to ensure safety. Both drivers and passengers are protected from electric shock, and maintenance personnel are also safeguarded against electric shock.

    • @allangibson8494
      @allangibson8494 ปีที่แล้ว

      You obviously haven’t seen an LPG or CNG vehicle fire…
      20m fireballs are fairly common with parts thrown half a kilometre.

  • @snappingclam8801
    @snappingclam8801 ปีที่แล้ว +101

    Recently saw a video of a Rivian pickup with cosmetic damage to a side panel near the tailgate. The quoted repair cost was US$42,000. There 's also the US$5,600 bill for replacing a damaged Ford Lightning taillight. I'll stick with ICE vehicles, thanks.

    • @bwalker4194
      @bwalker4194 ปีที่แล้ว +10

      Just to be clear, the $5600 Ford tail lights are across the entire F150 line. After watching the video, I went out to my 2017 2.7t version, pulled both tail lights, drilled 2 small holes in each lens and schmeered dielectric grease on all the connectors.
      Edit: I drilled the holes in the bottoms of the tail lights to facilitate any water intrusion having the ability to leak out.

    • @bm4751
      @bm4751 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Seems repairs cost 10 to 15 times more to repair in amazing EV technology.

    • @anekinoo7
      @anekinoo7 ปีที่แล้ว

      Most common cars have pieces where u can remove to repair/replace. Rivian choose to make panels in large peices.

    • @ohger1
      @ohger1 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      That Ford wasn't an EV. All modern cars are getting ridiculous. My wife's headlight required the front bumper cover to be removed on her Lexus. A $300 job for a headlight..

    • @anekinoo7
      @anekinoo7 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@ohger1what car doesnt? Even my old honda civic from the 90s required front bumper removed to replace.

  • @TheFastday
    @TheFastday ปีที่แล้ว +17

    Good point. We have a year 2000 Honda Civic still in the family; with 346,000 km proudly on the clock and have never had to replace the engine,, but yes the 12Volt battery had to be replaced a few times :)

  • @louisvillaescusa
    @louisvillaescusa 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I've had to replace several engines in my ICE cars. For the 1990 Miata and 1995 Tercel, it was about $3500 (USD) each to have used engines installed. Five years ago, I had the engine in my 1986 Nissan D21pulled, rebuilt and reinstalled for $2500 (USD)

  • @JustaGuy_Gaming
    @JustaGuy_Gaming ปีที่แล้ว +147

    This is also ignoring the massive potential for abuse by companies. Everything on an EV is controlled by software, which is usually linked directly to the company. If they wanted to put in planned obsolesce into the car it wouldn't take much to have the batteries "die" right after the warranty. Much like many people accused Apple of ages ago when soon as a new Iphone came out suddenly all the old ones started to have battery issues, run slower etc...

    • @richardjohnson8009
      @richardjohnson8009 ปีที่แล้ว +27

      wasnt accused they were caught

    • @rickybobby7276
      @rickybobby7276 ปีที่แล้ว +7

      Yea it's not like a software company has never gotten people to buy new hardware through software updates. Oh wait Apple did this by slowing down their phones. And through pushing software updates that filled the hard drive of older perfectly functional phones with smaller hard drives so literally not a single app could be installed in order to update and maybe one or two apps could be installed after updating.

    • @twitchew
      @twitchew ปีที่แล้ว

      ICE is getting that treatment too along with locking in OEM parts (see John Deere products)

    • @Workaholic42
      @Workaholic42 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Fortunately, conventional cars with combustion engine use no software at all nowadays

    • @JustaGuy_Gaming
      @JustaGuy_Gaming ปีที่แล้ว +5

      @@Workaholic42 Oh it's a problem for sure but Ev's take the lead in this obviously. While a ICE car having kill switches in them these days, often able to be used by the police or other parties at will is bad enough (never mind potential hackers). Ev's tend to have a bigger issue of just downgraded performance and planned obsolescence.
      Much like your Iphone battery suddenly refusing to charge and dying quickly after an update when the newest model comes out... Expect your EV battery to die fast after the warranty runs out. If you want to go a step further the software could lie to you, saying you have more range than you do up till that warranty expires.
      Hence stories of cars saying they had 300+ miles of range one day and then 50 the next after the warranty expired.

  • @rhysenna
    @rhysenna ปีที่แล้ว +87

    You can imagine these damaged write offs getting into the wrong hands and end up back on the road. 😬

    • @hawkboy451
      @hawkboy451 ปีที่แล้ว +11

      It won't be "Cut and shut" - it will be "Slash and burn " in the future .

    • @erroneouscode
      @erroneouscode ปีที่แล้ว +6

      That's already very difficult with an insurance write-off. However, with cars that call home to the manufacturer or authorities it will be all but impossible. Remote kill switches are also coming under the guise of protecting the public from drunk drivers.

    • @edb3877
      @edb3877 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@erroneouscode Funny how they ALWAYS have an excuse for infringing on OUR liberty. Such people should not be in government in any capacity.

  • @-SuTen-
    @-SuTen- ปีที่แล้ว +124

    It would not surprise me if car makers, like others, also have a countdown clock in the batteries when they are supposed to stop working...

    • @jessicahitchens6926
      @jessicahitchens6926 ปีที่แล้ว +11

      Of course they do.

    • @AnthonyTolhurst-dw1nc
      @AnthonyTolhurst-dw1nc ปีที่แล้ว +7

      Via good ol’ microchips!

    • @russingersoll5761
      @russingersoll5761 ปีที่แล้ว +16

      Like the HP inkjet printer 🖨 cartridge scam.

    • @erroneouscode
      @erroneouscode ปีที่แล้ว +14

      The technology is there to do it if they want. The charge cycles in power tool batteries is internally stored nowadays.

    • @rickmalaschenko3046
      @rickmalaschenko3046 ปีที่แล้ว +9

      They don't need to plan obsolescence into battery life spans, it occurs naturally. Even with solar systems, that store power in batteries ,their is a limited shelf life
      I got three years out of a deep cycle battery ,at $300 per unit they're not cheap.😢

  • @cjzito
    @cjzito 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Owned a 2003 Prius for 17 years and 180,000 miles. Battery lasted pretty much the entire lifetime, well past warranty. Still driveable but had some battery error messages in the last year. This was fixed with replacing a few cells and overall reconditioning, costing $900 in 2020. My insurance the entire time was the same as any equal-priced ICE car.
    2017 bought a RAV4 Hybrid. Now at 75,000 miles and going strong. All battery cells indicating normal. Completely reasonable insurance cost.
    2023 bought a Fisker Ocean Extreme. Too early to assess the traction battery, but the insurance I have is the same I would pay for an equal-priced ICE car.
    Bottom line, I'm not seeing ANY markup in insurance costs for Hybrids or EVs that I've owned, and I'm in California, US, where insurance companies just love to nickel-and-dime us.

  • @grahamrankin5557
    @grahamrankin5557 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Thank you, thank you, thank you, for doing such forensic analyses on EVs. I was tempted to buy a Hybrid in January 2023 well before becoming aware of all the issues about EVs in general, but bought the ICE version instead because of the ridiculous price of the Hybrid versus the ICE version, and I'm glad I stayed with the mature technology. Cheers!

  • @blobfishking9143
    @blobfishking9143 ปีที่แล้ว +41

    I have never had to replace an engine but I did have to replace my 2006 Prius battery for $2500 in about 2018. I think it’s a nickel metal hydride. Still got my Prius and running well at 200000km . Had my catalytic converter stolen in 2021. Never buying an EV or hybrid again.

    • @einfelder8262
      @einfelder8262 ปีที่แล้ว +9

      NiMh batteries are safe, and much lower voltage than Li EV batteries. Not comparable at all.

    • @jeremyradford5103
      @jeremyradford5103 ปีที่แล้ว

      All modern petrol cars have catalytic converters, and theft is common because of the rare metals they contain.

    • @einfelder8262
      @einfelder8262 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@xpictos777 The Prius he speaks of has an ICE engine because it's a hybrid, hence the catalytic converter. Ever heard of looking stuff up in Google?

    • @bennylava8717
      @bennylava8717 ปีที่แล้ว

      why? didn't prious gave you good driving life for not too much cost?

  • @ceismulcastle
    @ceismulcastle ปีที่แล้ว +32

    only car i have ever had that had a "reconditioned" engine already fitted was a 1956 land rover i bought around 2005 that engine was still going strong when i sold it in 2021

  • @emilcost8613
    @emilcost8613 ปีที่แล้ว +647

    You will own nothing, and you won't be happy.

    • @SubTroppo
      @SubTroppo ปีที่แล้ว +13

      Are you looking down at your EV insurance bill in your thumbnail photo? Either way, you're looking down.

    • @judechopper
      @judechopper ปีที่แล้ว +4

      Least I have 2 million dollar double block in Kirrawee Australia 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @SubTroppo
      @SubTroppo ปีที่แล้ว +16

      ​@@judechopper In matters of real-estate "I have" or "I own" usually means that "the bank" still has the upper-hand and there remains a hefty loan that needs to be paid off. It is a rhetorical question, but ...[cont'd on page 94]

    • @SubTroppo
      @SubTroppo ปีที่แล้ว +7

      @@sickofthebullshit1967 That reminds me I recently was talking with someone who was roped in to provide counseling to people burnt-out due to recent bush-fires in SE Qld. Keep a grab-bag handy.

    • @mikeyblueeyes8449
      @mikeyblueeyes8449 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@sickofthebullshit1967 boss quote mate!!:)

  • @stephenfriedenthal8312
    @stephenfriedenthal8312 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    On the engine replacement question. We have a 2006 Toyota Sienna and due to some bad maintenance on my part if was critically low on engine oil. We got no warning and the engine seized. So, yeah, new engine. BUT -- The cost was only about US $3,500 for remanufactured engine. Not a bad deal at all.
    Oh, one other thing. We still drive the nearly 19 year old Sienna today.

  • @dont_hit_trees
    @dont_hit_trees ปีที่แล้ว +1

    4:25 Being in the business I can assure you engine or transmission failure is the #1 reason for scrapping a car. Rot is second where I live.

  • @damienmilk6309
    @damienmilk6309 ปีที่แล้ว +12

    I have a 2003 105 Landcruiser with 630,000 klm, with the reliable old 1HZ diesel engine. It does not use any oil and runs just as reliably as when I purchased it at 420,000 klm for 8k. Why would I change to any other vehicle? And it only takes 5 minutes to put 134 litres in it good for over 1000 klms.

    • @tomkimber9072
      @tomkimber9072 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      I had a 94 1hz for 5 years and it was an absolute money pit in diesel costs alone, let alone the new gearbox and rust repairs.

    • @damienmilk6309
      @damienmilk6309 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@tomkimber9072 Yes, the 105 coming from the Pilbara, I agree rust has been a bit of a thing, but I have never had any issues with the drivetrain except for a crack in the rear diff. One hour with a welder and grinder and as good as new. I do drive like nanna though!

    • @tomkimber9072
      @tomkimber9072 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@damienmilk6309 oh mate I was getting tailgated by nannas with my 1hz troopy!

    • @damienmilk6309
      @damienmilk6309 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@tomkimber9072 Yep, not fast, but ultra-reliable. But what was needed in the North West of WA.

  • @richardsmith579
    @richardsmith579 ปีที่แล้ว +30

    I’m glad you said this. I’ve always bought cars with decent ground clearance, in case of road debris like exhausts, bits of tyre, dead animals, bricks, bits of tree and other random stuff. Curbs and ramps also need consideration. These electric cars have their most vulnerable and expensive - and potentially dangerous - component slung very close to the road. No thank you.

  • @Inkling777
    @Inkling777 ปีที่แล้ว +45

    As someone who drives older ICE cars, I'll add another of their advantages-their modest market values compared to a shop repair for the body work. When I've got into an accident with the other guy at fault, his insurance totaled my car even though it was perfectly safe to drive. I was paid $2200 and spent about $200 restoring the body to the previous condition. Being an ICE, there was no expensive battery needing replacing.

    • @FECosta-ei6pv
      @FECosta-ei6pv ปีที่แล้ว +4

      That is one of the several reasons I'll never buy an EV.

    • @carsyoungtimerfreak1149
      @carsyoungtimerfreak1149 ปีที่แล้ว

      Very true! Been there, done that too!

  • @kenwickes2497
    @kenwickes2497 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    As a dealer mechanic I've replaced several engines for various reasons. Most times if it is customer pay, we quote and end up using a "used" engine assy from a junk yard. It costs much less than 5k with our labor and additional parts if needed. Can you get a used battery from a junk yard?? Nope.

  • @vlp888
    @vlp888 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Thanks for your video. The engine in my Porsche 911 996 failed in 2012, just outside of the warranty period. The initial quote for replacement was ~$30K. At the time I was able to negotiate a better financial outcome by selling the car back to the Porsche dealer. I share your concerns with EVs, but thought I should share my experience.

  • @Mike_221
    @Mike_221 ปีที่แล้ว +34

    I just checked the premium for a model 3 in Au the cheapest was over $2600 p.a
    That's actually insane. Surely this negates the savings from not having to use petrol or diesel for the life of the vehicle.

    • @tomber1
      @tomber1 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      My EV insurance in aus is $1200...

    • @davidbrayshaw3529
      @davidbrayshaw3529 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      Now have a look at the depreciation on a 3 year old Model 3. It makes the insurance premium look cheap.

    • @tomber1
      @tomber1 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@davidbrayshaw3529 Cheapest I can see in Australia is 39k private for a 2019 with 84k?

    • @evangiles4403
      @evangiles4403 ปีที่แล้ว

      Please enlighten this son of a mechanical engineer costs 2600 per annum
      Well take this from an ex courier driver
      In one year at 160000 Klm my LDV cost me the better part of $ 50000 to keep on the road
      $ 7000 for turbo
      $ 8000 for timing fix
      $ 3000 for EG valve
      $ 500 for power steering
      Plus $ 7000 dollars each time for renting a another vehicle
      Don't try to tell a combustion engine is cheaper than an EV because I have been there unlike the morons
      EV are new there will always be problems but the main problem is having them produced in china
      China doesn't have any quality control so that's why the batteries exploded
      Once they seal them up nobody has any idea what the hell the chinese put in them

    • @seannewman5391
      @seannewman5391 ปีที่แล้ว

      I save £1800 a year with an EV over a diesel. Thats $3600.

  • @DCGreenZone
    @DCGreenZone ปีที่แล้ว +23

    If an ICE vehicle gets in a fender bender, scrape, whatnot the engine will almost never need replacing. It may need a quarter panel, fender, bumper..... but not a $20,000 battery.

    • @MeaHeaR
      @MeaHeaR ปีที่แล้ว

      that becuase itt dusunt be have a é PôWéŘ-PhÛľĽ largé batterié. untt itt be usé diffeřúnt éngúnns

    • @DCGreenZone
      @DCGreenZone ปีที่แล้ว

      @@MeaHeaR Yes, you are correct, whatever that was.

  • @madcatter9484
    @madcatter9484 ปีที่แล้ว +11

    Except higher insurance costs will be passed on to ALL vehicle EV and ICE

    • @brucetownsend691
      @brucetownsend691 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      Yes. Insurance for all cars is increased because at least part of the premium is to cover damage to another persons car if the insured driver is deemed at fault. Both comprehensive and third party property insurance has to cover damage to other people’s EVs. The greater the proportion of EVs on the road, the greater the risk of damaging one and the greater the average payout.

    • @garypowell1540
      @garypowell1540 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      This can only happen by a change in the law. Insurance underwriters need business so will do all possible to insure the car according to its individual specifications and trace record, due to the competitive nature of the business.

    • @Shakerhood69
      @Shakerhood69 ปีที่แล้ว

      Also higher purchase prices on ICE Vehicles to subsidize the costs of EV's

  • @BLUEZz73
    @BLUEZz73 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I'm changing my engine today Mate. its easy on Holdens it only cost me $1000 for the reco engine. The other one had a cracked block timing issues. They say a change is like a holiday Mate.

  • @coryaronson2678
    @coryaronson2678 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Put a 350 big block in my old car because I wanted the upgrade ... Did it in my garage in a day and cost a little over $3000 all in....

  • @RayJones-p7s
    @RayJones-p7s ปีที่แล้ว +16

    We had a remanufactured 6 cylinder Jeep engine installed the total cost was $8,000. This included the testing of the old engine and putting the external parts on the new engine, such as the power steering, alternator, air cleaner, ac unit and etc. This also included engine oil, antifreeze, and charging the air conditioning and making sure it was ready for the road.

    • @ginaorsini3312
      @ginaorsini3312 ปีที่แล้ว

      Shouldn't of bought a jeep, junk

    • @kensmith2796
      @kensmith2796 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@ginaorsini3312 The pre-2007 Jeeps are good Jeeps. I've owned 2 of them. The first I bought new in 2006 and drove it 8 years and 90k miles. The only non-wearable part that broke was a $15 cable. My current Jeep is almost 30 years old and only costs me an average of $100/month in maintenance and repairs. They are known for lasting 250k miles plus.

    • @chuggynation8275
      @chuggynation8275 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@ginaorsini3312 Better than buying a EV literally money/ death trap. Those battery fires are no joke you cannot put them out.

  • @stevewallace1387
    @stevewallace1387 ปีที่แล้ว +10

    The battery cost more than a complete new combustion engine so less moving parts means nothing and here in the uk one insurance company has refused too insure EVS

  • @scoobyflew
    @scoobyflew ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Great channel!
    I'm a coder and database designer and I see this type of issue with complex systems over and over again.
    People say something like: "prototype me this system, collecting data from 10 sensors and display the data in a portal". Pretty straightforward.
    Then they will go "right we have the approval, let's scale it up to 100k sensors, ready next week?"
    The transition from prototyping (Tesla, etc.) to mass usage (all the rest coming in) is super complex.
    People fail to understand the vast array of supporting structures that have to be in place all the way along the lifecycle of the vehicle.
    They only think about the visible bit, not the foundations.

    • @JoeOvercoat
      @JoeOvercoat ปีที่แล้ว +1

      As the man said, in America, “Facts are stupid things”.

    • @xraylife
      @xraylife ปีที่แล้ว

      Most of Tesla's tech is given to them by DARPA anyway.

  • @Iosifavich
    @Iosifavich ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Fair video, one of the other major issues with EV driving cost is the fact that Manufactures are trying to control access to repair parts making it incredibly difficult for independent 3rd party repair shops to gain access to the parts, knowledge and tools to be able too effectively service these vehicles. This is the EV manufactures trying to control the parts supply and repair pipeline similar to how John Deer and other consumer electronics manufactures have basically exclusive repair rights to their products. As a result it is hard to find independent repair shops that can work on EV's and often time their repair timelines are much longer than taking it to the dealership resulting in much more expensive repairs due to lack of competition.

    • @quokka7555
      @quokka7555 ปีที่แล้ว

      Even if you did find independent shops,
      “Damages or failures caused by maintenance or repairs performed by non-Tesla certified technicians are not covered by the warranty”

  • @f1pro910
    @f1pro910 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    My brother ev has minor accident where the car hit from behind at 10 miles per hour. There is just minor dent in the back. But when he claimed for insurance, they told that car is totalled as the frame bent little bit and hit the battery. Its just a mith calling EVs needs less maintenance and less hassle because of less moving parts. The battery is the full value of you car. Even it has minor damage, you can’t fix it.

  • @MarkWorsnop
    @MarkWorsnop ปีที่แล้ว +17

    I had to replace an engine in my Ford Laser TX3 in the late 1990s after it had done over 250,000km. The cost surprised me - pleasantly. A reconditioned 'as new' 2 litre engine was replaced for just under $900 - equivalent to about $1750 today. The cost was recoverable since it boosted the re-sale value of the Laser which went on to lead a happy second life.

  • @chefbink61
    @chefbink61 ปีที่แล้ว +12

    One thing that I would like to add is the liability a repair shop would have in a traction batt repair. If you take your car to a shop for an engine replacement they will give you some sort of a warranty. If the engine fails the shop will have to replace the engine or repair it. The likelihood that the engine will destroy the car or anything is extremely low. But a tarction batt on the other hand,,, well just one bad connection could burn the car and anything else around it. That is a huge liability, and many shops will not want to take that on. Like I have said here before a Tesla long range batt has 7000 cell at 2 connection per cell, that is 14,000 modes of failure, and all it take is one bad connection!

    • @erroneouscode
      @erroneouscode ปีที่แล้ว +2

      If the OEM of the car considers the battery a non serviceable part then anyone disassembling a battery pack in order to repair it is on shaky ground anyway. The average small business is not going to have the financial resources behind it to cope with possible litigation if there's a fatality due to non compliance or incompetence. Governments live for making new laws and regulations, and lawyers and the courts rub their hands together in anticipation of a payday. It's still early days.

  • @onemoremisfit
    @onemoremisfit ปีที่แล้ว +10

    I just recently bought a new replacement crate engine from GM for a 2006 Chevy Impala SS I'm restoring. I didn't have to replace the old engine because it was still in good running condition, but it had mileage on it and I wanted a new one for the restored car. It is an all aluminum 5.3L V8, exact OEM replacement crate engine, and is a "long block" configuration which is complete with cylinder heads, valve covers, oil pan, and only needs the intake and ignition coils to be complete. It cost $4000 US after core exchange. I will be doing the installation, but if I had to pay for installation I would estimate that might add $1500 to $2000 to the total cost. So if I were to drop the car off at a dealer and have them replace the engine I would expect to have the entire job covered for no more than $6000.
    For 15 to 20 grand, I could hire a custom engine builder to make me a very nice high performance engine for my 1968 Camaro I will restore someday. For 50 grand I could buy one hell of a no-compromise shoot-the-works full race engine. Some people might even think 4 grand to re-power my Impala is a little extravagant, but there is no way I would spend 50 grand, or even 10 grand to re-power a Hyundai
    of any model.

    • @mguytv
      @mguytv  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Absolutely correct. Enjoy!

    • @xpusostomos
      @xpusostomos ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Wow what a bargain

  • @rafamichalak2314
    @rafamichalak2314 ปีที่แล้ว

    My father had to replace engine in his salon bought Skoda Octavia after 5,1 year (so just after guarantee), but solon took the car and sent it to manufacture. They said that this was production failure and that in this 5 years he "used" 10% of it and he just have to pay 10% for new one, so all in all he got nice deal. It's been driving to this day, around 16-17 years now, with no problem.

  • @jph8291
    @jph8291 ปีที่แล้ว +8

    A relative in the Vancouver, Canada area bought a Tesla. While backing out of a parking stall at a shopping centre, she had a minor collision with a guy driving down the lane. Both cars had tiny dent or scratch. The other guy being a turd, insisted that the incident be reported to the insurer. My relative told her Agent that she would pay for the damage, rather than the insurer. She was told to take the car to a specialized body shop. A day later they told her the repair estimate was $20K CAD. The actual body repair was $500.00. The rest was for checking the battery pack. No repairs needed. $19,500K just to complete the safety check.

    • @onevastanus
      @onevastanus ปีที่แล้ว +2

      So profits will still be made, and the only real result is less freedom of movement for the slaves who don't know they are slaves.

    • @allangibson8494
      @allangibson8494 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      A complete new Tesla battery pack is $20,000…

    • @billymacktexasdetective5827
      @billymacktexasdetective5827 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      I'm not buying what you are selling...
      $19.5k to check a battery?
      You should try using more believable numbers when you make stories up...

    • @onevastanus
      @onevastanus ปีที่แล้ว

      @@billymacktexasdetective5827 You don't need to buy anything because google is free.

  • @pommieMJ
    @pommieMJ ปีที่แล้ว +18

    Over 30+ years and many many ICE vehicles (both cars and motorcycles), I’ve never had to replace an engine. I did have one motorbike that seized the big end, but I got a new crankshaft, some bearings and piston rods and voila - all done and it cost way less than the bike was worth - so, economically speaking it was worth doing.

    • @erroneouscode
      @erroneouscode ปีที่แล้ว

      What frequently makes ICE engines uneconomical to recondition or replace is the labor rate. People out in the wild with any sort of manual labor skill sets willing to have a go themselves to save costs is increasingly rarer. Thanks to the modern electronics it's also very complex.

    • @treelineresearch3387
      @treelineresearch3387 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@erroneouscode What's making ICE vehicles increasingly *economical* to overhaul is the staggering price of new vehicles. When the cheapest shitbox on the KIa lot is over $25k it makes a LOT more sense to dump $5000 into your paid off Honda for an overhaul that will take you another 200k. I recently bought a 20 year old high miles (literally almost been to the moon and back) diesel truck with the full expectation I might eventually need to pay someone $15k to overhaul it, and even if I do I'm still all-in for less than HALF of an equivalent current generation diesel truck - and it has a straight pipe out the back with no DPF nonsense.

    • @allangibson8494
      @allangibson8494 ปีที่แล้ว

      What makes ICE engines unrepairable is the combination of fires and aluminium blocks (although polymer intake manifolds come a close second).

    • @venomfang8560
      @venomfang8560 ปีที่แล้ว

      Replaced seized engine in my 2007 Lexus IS350 for $3000 CAD for used engine with 75k kms.

  • @MrBigbangbuzz
    @MrBigbangbuzz ปีที่แล้ว +10

    Mate had his Tesla hit first day of ownership.. 8 month wait for repairs

  • @shadowangel8005
    @shadowangel8005 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I had a new engine once, it was a large holden rodeo. about 3k plus allot of labour to change it. expansive but not 50k.
    How does EV battery swaps effect this though ? The chinese NIO cars can be bought without batterys then you subscribe to a plan (per month) for battery swap subscription, if you did hit the battery you could maybe swap it.

  • @lp9280
    @lp9280 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    4:43 - to add to this, engines not only fail extremely rarely as you said, but even then it is mostly preventable failures, usually in form for neglect, simple things like not replacing oil, or another common one - not replacing leaking water-pump in time and causing overheating.
    Yes there are some bad engine designs, but usually we know what they are, they get extended warranties, they get subsidised repairs, but even when they fail they don't cost as much as batteries to replace. For example one of bad designs I am familiar with is Lexus/Toyota 2AD-FHV, this is the engine found in Lexus IS220d and they just blow all the time, this is particularly interesting example as most people buy Lexus/Toyota for their reliability, but if one doesn't do research they are in for nasty surprise with this one (that being said Lexus extended warranty to 160,000 miles for these engines in particular). But the engine costs £600-800... still it usually totals the car, because complete job is £1500-£2000 and these cars nowadays are only worth that much, but it isn't £50,000 job for sure, so this is more of a matter of worthless car... yet battery faults can write off even £15,000 or £20,000 worth car and that is the biggest worry. If you have to write off £2000 worth car and then you probably get £700 for scrapping it, that is not big deal, but if you bought £20,000 worth used BEV and few years later you have to write it off that is big deal. Obviously, this sort of worries are for second hand market, but that is why BEVs don't really have good second-hand market, they are just too much of a risk.
    Normal cars usually have few stages in their life - 1st - brand new sold on lease or finance for 3-5 years, 2nd - (this is where I prefer to buy) sold at huge discount (usually 60%) with 20-30k miles and used for another 3-5 years, 3rd - now with ~60k miles and 6-8 years cars become accessible to most of society with maybe 80% discount and are used until they fail, 4th - finally, most of the cars by now fail, but some brands and models are still very viable (Honda, Toyota, Lexus) here is where you can pick-up cars for £2000 and they usually have 100k+ miles, perhaps 10 years+... and this is very important from environment perspective, this means each car is reused at least 3-4 times, the resources put into making them is fully consumed and only then the car is scrapped. With BEVs only 2 steps exist, by the time they get to step 3, they are just too much risk and nobody wants them, this is particularly bad, because that is the step when most of society can access the car, meaning until this is resolved there will be no wide-spread adoption. Remember by step 3 car still maintains 40% of it's original price, so that is likely to be £20,000 for BEV (as they are more expensive to begin with) and reality is that nobody is willing to pay £20,000 for 6-8 years old BEVs.

  • @pookatim
    @pookatim ปีที่แล้ว +11

    It is worse than you are saying. A minor "fender-bender" on a Tesla that doesn't even involve the battery will cost thousands of dollars to repair. I saw this when a Tesla was being used by a Car Magazine for testing battery range and the author accidentally backed into the garage door frame at low speed. The damage was barely noticeable but the repair cost $14,000. This type of repair in almost any ICE car would have been under one thousand dollars but the problem with the Tesla had something to do with the way the frame is designed and manufactured making it nearly unrepairble.

    • @brucetownsend691
      @brucetownsend691 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      I believe it’s the gigacasting technique. It reduces production costs but makes the car very expensive to repair.

  • @Charonupthekuiper
    @Charonupthekuiper ปีที่แล้ว +11

    After my mini engine failed I got an engine from a scrapyard and refurbished it (with the help of a friend, because I was clueless). I also bought a recon engine for a Vauxhall Viva, but both these were 40 years or more ago. You could get a gold plated engine for the cost of an EV battery.

    • @regbarnard2866
      @regbarnard2866 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      Many replacement engines for ICE vehicles are sourced from accident damaged vehicles.
      This large source of used spares is not available for EVs.

    • @erroneouscode
      @erroneouscode ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@regbarnard2866 and likely never will be.

    • @JoeOvercoat
      @JoeOvercoat ปีที่แล้ว

      @@regbarnard2866An excellent point.

    • @treelineresearch3387
      @treelineresearch3387 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      50 grand is like 20 rebuilt Honda K series motors, or two or three performance built 7.3PS or 5.9 Cummins diesels.

  • @erroneouscode
    @erroneouscode ปีที่แล้ว +5

    I have three ICE vehicles and one of which is a Volkswagen Polo GTi which I bought with a relatively low 115,000K's but the engine had very serious issues that needed replacement or reconditioning. I decided to rebuild the engine myself. I was a motor mechanic over 30 years ago so it was just a matter of dusting off the tools and putting that hat on again to get the work done. All the machining of head-valves, block, crank, balancing was around $2000 and parts to replace literally everything was an additional $2400. So for under $5000 I returned that car mechanically to new condition. I could have got a secondhand engine from a wreckers for less than half that price but then the car wouldn't have been matching numbers original. People are NEVER going to be in a position to do that with EV's. They're a disposable throw away vehicle and a traction battery replacement with rare exceptions will always be priced where they're uneconomical and very dangerous to repair. Expect regulations sooner or later where there's very tight controls on the salvage and resale of second hand EV batteries. Take a hint.. they don't want you fixing them.

  • @cdrone4066
    @cdrone4066 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I had a 94 eagle talon and popped the timing belt. It was a 16 valve zero clearance motor. It cost 1700 to do the timing belt and the valves. I put 55000 miles on it afterwards and drove it back and forth from Florida to New York.

  • @Mackcolak-xf5bk
    @Mackcolak-xf5bk 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

    4:14
    Among my friends, I've had at least three of them: a radiator leak and therefore head deformation, one because of timing chain failure, and a head gasket coolant leak all on not-so-old cars around 100k.
    Other reasons often are:
    1. Overheating: Excessive heat can cause engine components to warp, crack, or fail. This may be due to a malfunctioning cooling system, low coolant levels, a faulty thermostat, or other issues.
    2. Lack of Lubrication: Insufficient or contaminated lubrication can lead to increased friction and wear on engine parts, eventually causing catastrophic failure. This can be caused by low oil levels, dirty oil, or oil pump failure.
    3. Timing Belt or Chain Failure: A broken timing belt or chain can cause the synchronization between the engine's components to fail, leading to severe damage to valves, pistons, and other vital components.
    4. Cylinder Head Gasket Failure: A blown head gasket can result in coolant leaks, overheating, and contamination of the engine oil, leading to catastrophic failure.
    5. Piston Ring or Cylinder Wall Damage: Poor lubrication, overheating, or contaminants in the oil can cause excessive wear on piston rings and cylinder walls, leading to loss of compression and catastrophic failure.
    6. Engine Knock/Detonation: Persistent knocking or detonation can damage pistons, connecting rods, and other components, resulting in catastrophic failure. It may be caused by poor fuel quality, incorrect ignition timing, or other factors.

  • @andrewgraham7659
    @andrewgraham7659 ปีที่แล้ว +13

    Thanks for being EV Realist.....

  • @johnzee691
    @johnzee691 ปีที่แล้ว +62

    evs are still both niche and novelty at this stage. with the car fires and realities of the batteries not even needing to be damaged to catch fire ( as evidenced by the car carrier fires) LOTS more work needs to happen. the power infrastructure is far more of an issue than talked about. the weight of the vehicles will impact parking structures if too many are piled into one structure where it's doubtful the structures can be re-engineered. that as well as the fire hazard with them.
    if a new power source can't be engineered / developed soon I seriously think the insurance costs are going to kill the ev. as cars age and people live / witness the realities the ev will die. that's unless a large building burns down or a crazy tunnel fire occurs. like one under water. then the ev will die much quicker.

    • @peterengland6153
      @peterengland6153 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      BYD joined a series of automakers including SAIC Motor, GAC Group and FAW Group in buying RORO ferries and setting up their own auto insurance arms.

    • @obviouslytrollmster1532
      @obviouslytrollmster1532 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Figure everything out. Solve all the other problems.
      The energy efficiency of electric vehicles will always be significantly less than gasoline and even more significantly less than diesel.
      Think about it like this to move a car with an electric battery. You need four times minimum the amount of energy, then an equivalent gasoline.
      So to get 200 miles of range you are essentially wasting 600 mi of gasoline range. Or think about it like this. You are wasting that much energy when you are charging your f****** vehicle. The way we produce energy you are literally burning that much more and if you want to go green like windmills and s*** well hey.... Remember the four times as much thing? It keeps getting worse. At that point you would need exponentially more energy infrastructure to provide the same amount of energy.
      It is criminally inefficient

    • @johnzee691
      @johnzee691 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@obviouslytrollmster1532 well said, especially the last sentence. I wonder if any politicians might be involved........

    • @peterengland6153
      @peterengland6153 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Parking structures for the last 40 yrs have been deigned for 2.5Kn/m2 plus engineers safety margin (20%) that equates to an average of 2,500kgs + 20% so 3,000kgs. This was when the most popular in the USA was the Ford Escort, now it is the F150 pick up. So while vehicles particularly USA have gotten heavier, they are also physically bigger, BUT less per floor plate. say 200 Ford Escorts, now 150 F150, so overall loadings same, even with EV's. Just paint larger bays.

    • @12pentaborane
      @12pentaborane ปีที่แล้ว

      ​@@obviouslytrollmster1532 I'd like to see the math on the 4:1 electrical energy to gasoline energy conversion.

  • @agatemaster1998
    @agatemaster1998 ปีที่แล้ว +15

    A long block for an ice car is cheap as chips compared to this

  • @lijie2511
    @lijie2511 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I pay insurance around 1500 pounds per year, a wire fix costed 87 pounds in a dealer approved garage.

  • @markir9
    @markir9 ปีที่แล้ว

    I've owned approx 15 cars. I've had 5 motor failures. These (and their remedies) were: 1 motor swap (Mazda Rx3 10A - 12A after water seal failure) and 4 rebuilds (Alfasud after snapping connecting rod, Mazda Rx7 13B after apex seal failure, Ford Falcon after very low oil pressure, Subaru B4 after piston skirt sheared off - under warranty). The costs were typically NZ$2000-$3000 ($0 for the Subaru).
    I bought all of these cars 2nd hand - so in some cases the rebuild/swap cost was similar to the value of the vehicle, but because the overall cost was so low, it did not matter too much if I had the cost/benefit calculus 100% correct, I ended up with a vehicle that I could drive for several (perhaps many) more years.
    Looking at the list, it looks like I kill cars! I think most of the failures were simply due to age related wear and tear (buying used performance cars that have likely been thrashed previously). However in the Alfasud case it was all me - over revved overtaking up a hill and bang!.
    This video highlights to me the totally different risk calculation involved with buying a used EV! In the cases above if the repair cost had been of the order of a *new* version of the car I would have had to scrap them...

  • @jamesblair9614
    @jamesblair9614 ปีที่แล้ว +26

    I guess any shop that takes an EV in for any sort of repair will want to have a close look at the under floor, to see if it’s had any contact. Just thinking of how snowy and icy our streets can be sometimes, not too unusual to see a car high centered on a median, potentially fatal for n EV.

    • @edb3877
      @edb3877 ปีที่แล้ว

      "... potentially fatal for n EV."
      Indeed. Not to mention anyone riding in it at the time.

    • @Gregory-Masovutch
      @Gregory-Masovutch ปีที่แล้ว

      The gigacasting now with Tesla makes the battery system replacement nearly impossible. Enjoy your disposal cell phone and EV to boot

  • @geoffrees4750
    @geoffrees4750 ปีที่แล้ว +26

    Great work Simon. I was just wondering about the ANCAP tests that are carried out to give the EVs their safety rating. I wonder how many of the EVs have caught fire / exploded in the front or side impact test. Can you get information from ANCAP or do they withhold those results.

    • @brandonfromlondonuk3484
      @brandonfromlondonuk3484 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      good point

    • @davelowe1977
      @davelowe1977 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      This.

    • @Ottomanmint
      @Ottomanmint ปีที่แล้ว +3

      I'm convinced the ANCAP tests were done, with a COMPLETELY DISCHARGED BATTERY for safety reasons 😅

  • @markahad6583
    @markahad6583 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    Thank you so much for delivering the facts. I often wonder, does an ev owner or potential owner really knows what they are getting in to????? Think people, think!!!

    • @softwarephil1709
      @softwarephil1709 ปีที่แล้ว

      Liberals feel; they don’t think.

    • @onevastanus
      @onevastanus ปีที่แล้ว +1

      The ones I have spoken too seem to take great pride in somehow saving the world, like a kid in a superhero costume. They don't ask relevant questions, such as where does the magic energy actually come from. If people did not fall for lies in marketing, there would be no marketing.

  • @matthewclifford2509
    @matthewclifford2509 ปีที่แล้ว

    I am replacing one at the moment, it’s an ls1 I am rebuilding the whole thing. Reusing everything except for rings, oil pump, seals and bearings plus the timing chain. Total cost $2500, for a brand new motor. It has done 350,000 kms and will do that again. I’m not a mechanic and it’s taken me 3 weeks. Easy, cheap and reliable x.

  • @bootroota1394
    @bootroota1394 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    It sounds like EVs need to be leased by drivers as opposed to bought. That way when it's time to replace the battery the driver just takes the car back to the company and get another one. (As a previous comment said, "you will own nothing and you won't be happy).

  • @PackMan-t7c
    @PackMan-t7c ปีที่แล้ว +13

    I have replaced several motors over the years. You are right though. All of them could have been disassembled and repaired somewhat easily. It was just simply less expensive, easier and faster to buy a motor from the junkyard and slam it in every case. A lot of cars you can do a one for one swap in a day or two. Dealing with machine shops on the other hand is much more complicated.

  • @geoffredmond730
    @geoffredmond730 ปีที่แล้ว +10

    The future of evs, any sort of accident or mechanical repair of the vehicle is going to cost big bucks, and insurance costs will blow out. Only the rich will be able to afford and run these types of vehicles.

  • @nheather
    @nheather ปีที่แล้ว +6

    And remember, these spiralling EV repair costs impact us all, because the insurance companies cover their risk by increasing premiums for everyone. In the UK, after another year of driving without claim, the insurance on my modest petrol car has risen by 54%. Yes I did use a comparison website to check that my insurer wasn’t trying it on but found that this was competitive.
    Sure there has been a high general inflation but that alone does not account for a 54% increase - I can only presume that I am having to bear some of the massively increased repair costs for EVs even though my car is petrol powered.

    • @New_Zealand_
      @New_Zealand_ ปีที่แล้ว

      Well, soon, you will also pay ULEZ daily travel tax for being a bastard petrol/diesel user. 60 pounds a week ish :) I hope you have deep pockets or own a bicycle.

    • @peterbartels316
      @peterbartels316 ปีที่แล้ว

      Not in any way trying to defend EV’s here… but the premiums will also increase due to nature disasters such as floods and fires (aka bushfires in Oz) and this will be averaged across all motor vehicle policies. Though I suspect as more EV’s spontaneously combust this will have a specific impact on EV insurance. Bit like house premiums if you live in a flood prone area your premium skyrockets even if you were not directly affected.

  • @MorganBrown
    @MorganBrown ปีที่แล้ว +2

    My in-laws bought hybrids before they were cool. A Prius and a Honda Insight. Both were deemed total losses after minor accidents, due to the cost of battery replacement

    • @georgesbv1
      @georgesbv1 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

      you gave no details about what was the car value prior to the events. A 15-year old average car of course has almost no value in it if you have to change an expensive part. If you add in some bumper and a paint job of course it exceeds the insured value.

    • @MorganBrown
      @MorganBrown 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      @@georgesbv1 both vehicles less than 5 years old if memory serves. Incident with the Insight happened a long time ago, probably 2003. Incident with the Prius perhaps 2010. Body damage minor in both cases.

  • @DeepSpaceNinja
    @DeepSpaceNinja 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I’ve had to replace a 350 cu long block, the quote was 12K. About a quarter compared to this battery

  • @garykendall3776
    @garykendall3776 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    I recall a few years ago in Australia a battery replacement quote of $36,000 for a Nissan leaf.

    • @xpusostomos
      @xpusostomos ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Nissan leaf was a dog, no battery cooling

    • @xpusostomos
      @xpusostomos ปีที่แล้ว +1

      ​@iscadeancompletely different car, i should think Nissan would fix that dog

  • @geoffb3240
    @geoffb3240 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Yep - 40 or so cars since I started driving (1978) and never needed a new engine. We need to campaign that EV repair costs through insurance are not smeared across all insurance policies - I don't want to pay for EV repairs, although I suspect it's already happening (in UK anyway) - my insurance rose by an eye watering 57% this year despite no increase in my risk (no accidents, convictions or claims - just a year older!).

  • @zooker7507
    @zooker7507 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    my last cars engine had 350,000 miles on it when I sold it and It was still running as well as when it was new. I still miss that car, but after 18 years I thought I needed something new.

  • @perryallan3524
    @perryallan3524 ปีที่แล้ว

    I changed an engine once (Long Block). I purchased a used full size Ford Econoliner Van perhaps 2 decades ago. It had not been properly maintained and it was obvious that the engine was worn out (it ate oil, and very poor gas mileage. Compression readings were very bad so it was more than a case of valve seals - which I had personally replaced myself once on a 1983 Escort GT once).
    It cost me about $3500 US to have a premium rebuilt long block engine replacement done at my local shop that routinely changes engines in older vehicles. That would probably be closer to $4500-$5000 today. I also ended up rebuilding the transmission a year later.
    My current car is a 2009 Hyundai Sonata with 300,000+ miles on it. I'd change engines in a heartbeat vs buying a replacement car if the engine died given the condition of the rest of the car.

  • @rippenburn
    @rippenburn ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Yeah ... having owned a number of laptops over the past 3 decades I can tell you the part that ALWAYS fails first. Thankfully I was never too far away from a socket to have to rely on the battery.

  • @SubTroppo
    @SubTroppo ปีที่แล้ว +17

    I wait for the reports of the first EV dumped because it is too expensive to send it to the junk-yard, but I maybe already be behind the times as usual.

    • @xpusostomos
      @xpusostomos ปีที่แล้ว +2

      If people can't repair them, then there's little need for spare parts either

    • @xraylife
      @xraylife ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Too dangerous for the scrap yard to accept - aside from the obvious fire risk, who would want to work parting-out anything attached to 400-800v DC ?

    • @xpusostomos
      @xpusostomos ปีที่แล้ว

      @@xraylife people would.
      . Carefully... But if they're being junked after 5 years, there won't be much point

    • @petewright4640
      @petewright4640 ปีที่แล้ว

      ​@@xraylifeThe batteries are isolated from the vehicle with an internal circuit breaker. Its impossible to get a shock if the ignition is off. The battery has to have an external signal to connect to the outside. Its failsafe.

    • @xraylife
      @xraylife ปีที่แล้ว

      @@petewright4640 Its not failsafe when the car is being stripped by unskilled workers.

  • @lushnads
    @lushnads ปีที่แล้ว +11

    I worked for Auxillis for a while. A customer had a hire car for 6 months. The hire of that vehicle came to over £40000, because their Tesla had taken so long to repair! That 40k was in basic hire costs, didn't include other charges and vat. So that's how such things can affect everyone

  • @trevorgale1176
    @trevorgale1176 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    If you owned a panel beater shop and an EV rolled in with even a minor love bump, surely you can't store it at your shop, given the O.H&S requirements.

    • @mguytv
      @mguytv  ปีที่แล้ว +3

      No you’re right you couldn’t.

    • @gamewizard1760
      @gamewizard1760 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      I wouldn't do it, because paint and body shops deal with hazardous and flammable substances. An EV fire would grow into nightmarish proportions when all the paints and chemicals catch light.

  • @MikeBaxterABC
    @MikeBaxterABC 10 หลายเดือนก่อน

    4:39 I have owned dozens of vehicles and only needed an engine replaced ONCE .. and it was under warrantee .. and they actually rebuilt the engine even welding up and girding down the existing crankshaft,

  • @williamwigfield7296
    @williamwigfield7296 ปีที่แล้ว

    Years ago bought a '99 Dodge half ton 4×4 w/ 50k light use miles. Crank broke at 100k (bad factory parts) Replaced it with a used low miles engine from wrecking yard for $1800.00 total cost. I junked truck to a dismantler who paid me $400 for it then he sold everything good on it for others to use after I put 331k on it in total. Longevity AND recyclable parts can't be overstated!

  • @Gumbatron01
    @Gumbatron01 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    My missus totalled her ICE car by hitting a pothole. It bottomed out on the engine sump and smashed the block and gearbox housing.
    It probably could have been repaired, but insurance wrote it off.
    The pot hole was... bad.

    • @onevastanus
      @onevastanus ปีที่แล้ว

      Time for a new Missus?

  • @brucetownsend691
    @brucetownsend691 ปีที่แล้ว +8

    Only part of the story about the Ionique has been told. When Hyundai Canada found out what had happened, they said the issue ought to have been escalated to them despite the car being just out of warranty. They reached out to the owner and gave him the market value of the car.
    My sister had a similar issue years back with her Kia Carnival. The ICE engine blew up when it was just out of warranty. It was not an isolated occurrence for that particular model. Kia replaced the engine as though still under warranty because they were concerned about their brand reputation.
    I don’t think all manufacturers would step up to pay out the car value or replace the EV battery if it fails outside the warranty period. In the case of an EV, the market value once the warranty has expired is going to be dismal, so you would still find yourself suddenly without a car and having only a small part of the purchase price of replacement.

    • @cp4512
      @cp4512 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      You’re right about Hyundai Canada but they only helped once the story was out in the media and going viral. They’re also having problems selling EVs at the moment (like most car brands!). I think they were helpful for PR damage limitation and I don’t think they’d be as helpful after the warranty ends for most people most of the time. The moral of the story is that an aged EV without full warranty is pretty much worthless!

    • @noseboop4354
      @noseboop4354 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      They probably did it only because it was on the news, without the news crew asking questions they probably would have never given market value.

    • @Inkling777
      @Inkling777 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Giving him the market value of the (working) car illustrates the problem with EVs. When it comes to batteries, their cost to repair exceeds that market price.

    • @JoeOvercoat
      @JoeOvercoat ปีที่แล้ว

      Credit to Kia!

  • @hookenz
    @hookenz ปีที่แล้ว +11

    Finally another guy talking sense. And giving some other angles to consider. I'd be a fan of EV's if it wasn't for the batteries.

  • @lozza2272
    @lozza2272 ปีที่แล้ว

    Thanks for making this video. We need to know both sides of the story.

  • @kenshepherd7168
    @kenshepherd7168 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Thank you MGUY, a voice of sanity in a sea of confusion.

  • @kcgunesq
    @kcgunesq ปีที่แล้ว +7

    I"ve never had to replace an engine, but I am also convinced that any engine I've owned would have cost more than $10,000 to replace. Also, a complete engine replacement in an ICE is something that typically happens past 150,000 miles and 10 years if at all. Not at 50,000 miles.

    • @carsyoungtimerfreak1149
      @carsyoungtimerfreak1149 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      150000 miles? I have driven many cars, all petrol Volvo's, with many more miles and still engine nr. 1 in it. One of them had over 400.000 miles on it and was still running fine. Proper maintenance will get you a long way!

    • @kcgunesq
      @kcgunesq ปีที่แล้ว

      @@carsyoungtimerfreak1149 I don't disagree.

    • @Noah_E
      @Noah_E ปีที่แล้ว

      My F350 has 254k miles and engine hasn't been touched other than to replace the valve cover gaskets and replace the bolts with studs as preventive maintenance. It even has the original turbo.

  • @cyruslupercal9493
    @cyruslupercal9493 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    Full engine replacement in ICE cars is rare. Usualy they can be fixed.
    EVs are bs because the battery isn't repair able and has many failure points.

    • @oldbloke204
      @oldbloke204 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Not really in modern cars as they're usually all alloy so when they pop they're usually scrap.
      Check out the price to replace a modern Turbo Diesel or Petrol engine and I think that you will be very surprised.
      I'm not defending EVs but ICE vehicles aren't that much better often from what I've seen.
      I've known of a few relatively modern engines that haven't been serviced properly or something has failed and the vehicle has been scrapped.
      Check out the replacement cost of a Toyota Turbo Diesel V8 that has been dusted for example.

    • @xraylife
      @xraylife ปีที่แล้ว +1

      ​@@oldbloke204 Only time I've seen an ICE engine blow up is when they converted it to run on Nitro and drove it to 900Hp.
      The rest of the time they can nearly always be repaired.

  • @jeremyashford2145
    @jeremyashford2145 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    Yes. I cooked an engine. Polished it’s bores.
    The water dropped out somewhere on my 100 mile journey but it did not register on the temperature gauge so I just kept driving until there was no power left.
    Replaced with a second hand engine for under NZD1000. Honda Civic.
    I recoed the engine of my first car, a L15 Citroen.
    I Rembrandt taking the engine out of my Triumph Herald at some stage but can’t remember why. (40 years ago.) It was a fun one because I stood on the front wheels and lifted the engine out without assistance.
    You can’t have this fun with a BEV. You can’t really do anything yourself but fill the window washers.

    • @malcolmwhite6588
      @malcolmwhite6588 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      Don’t be silly you can’t fill the window washers- that requires a technician but an alert on the in car car screen will tell you😂

    • @malcolmwhite6588
      @malcolmwhite6588 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      Also as a random aside, what a lot of people don’t realise is that if you lose water quickly, the temperature gauge will not rise and in fact will drop as it can only measure liquid water. Not steam ,so small leak will show a temperature rise as the water temperature increases, but a quick one like a hose failure, There will be no indication if you don’t notice or smell the coolant vapour.

    • @jeremyashford2145
      @jeremyashford2145 ปีที่แล้ว

      @malcolmwhite6588
      That’s exactly what I thought so I didn’t beat myself up about it. Twas about thirty years ago now.

    • @malcolmwhite3567
      @malcolmwhite3567 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@jeremyashford2145 well done, no good, crying over spilt milk - or split radiators and dropped water ay😭😂👍 A lot of people been caught. That way I remember a number of motorbike racers when water cooling was quite a novelty with street bikes and overheated, I think they were Kawasaki 900 and got caught out because the temperature hadn’t increased

  • @pippacarron1861
    @pippacarron1861 8 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I have a 20-year old SAAB. Two years ago the timing chain went and my mechanic suggested that a 'new' (i.e reconditioned second-hand) engine be put in. The total cost was $6000 which was a helluva lot cheaper than a new car, or a new EV battery.

  • @carsyoungtimerfreak1149
    @carsyoungtimerfreak1149 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    Very good points, thank you. In an older ICE car you never put a new engine, certainly not if it is a popular model. Good engines can be found for reasonable prices. On average you will be able to replace a worn engine by a used one for around 3000 EUR (I'm from Europe)... Back in the day I swapped the engine in VW Beetle for another one. If you know the Beetle you know this swap is pretty easy. I bought a complete engine for around 125 EUR. And it took me half a day to fit it. Seriously. Those were the days 🙂.

    • @georgesbv1
      @georgesbv1 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

      with an old car with an old engine replacement you old gain several years of use on a shitty car. On a new EV you get the same performance and life expectancy as if new.

    • @carsyoungtimerfreak1149
      @carsyoungtimerfreak1149 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@georgesbv1 my old car is very wellicht maintained and far from shitty. Your commentaar is pure BS.

  • @yurikislytsia8596
    @yurikislytsia8596 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    Would be useful to see some stats on battery failures and compare/contrast with that of an ICE engine

    • @andreyche193
      @andreyche193 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Battery failure is 100%. It is only a matter of time. "The problem" is that a battery will always fail sooner and fixing it will always cost more than an owner expect. Because if he knew he would never buy the thing in the first place!

  • @chrisgermann6658
    @chrisgermann6658 ปีที่แล้ว +19

    I had a massive debate with the wife of an EV engineer online over this exact topic lol. She was convinced these things are insurance friendly.

    • @peejayem4700
      @peejayem4700 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      I did an online insurance quote for a Model 3 and it was only slightly higher than my current combustion car despite being worth over twice as much

    • @jessicahitchens6926
      @jessicahitchens6926 ปีที่แล้ว

      For now...

    • @hudsonbear5038
      @hudsonbear5038 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      @@peejayem4700 For some reason I find that hard to believe but ok of you say so.

    • @MrT5D5
      @MrT5D5 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Many people believe what suits them...often deceiving themselves.

  • @colinjameslichtwark513
    @colinjameslichtwark513 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    Yes, I have replaced a couple of ICE engines good used engine for about $1200 changed in less than a day. Good for another 300,000 km

    • @YuckFoutube-e1z
      @YuckFoutube-e1z ปีที่แล้ว +1

      I rebuilt my Holden Commodore 202 (blue block) straight six by myself when i was 16 years old. Cost me around $500 in parts.
      True it took me about 2 weeks but it was the first time.

  • @bellaggio1770
    @bellaggio1770 ปีที่แล้ว

    Great video, concise and to the point, no endless bla bla.

  • @DeeDee-pw9pm
    @DeeDee-pw9pm ปีที่แล้ว

    I have an '01 Volvo V70 (2.4l 5cyl 10v) with 352.000 km/218.000 miles.
    It doesn't consume oil at all.
    A used replacement engine will cost between 400 and 1200 euros, depending on the mileage and the type.
    Extremely reliable car.

  • @madmaxsdog8040
    @madmaxsdog8040 ปีที่แล้ว

    On two occasions I've blown an ICE engine and you mentioned both, once was a timing belt failure which wrecked the valves and piston crowns in some cyls, the other one was my own fault, forgot to check the oil level and took out the bottom end.
    On both occasions I got a temporary engine from a wreckers yard for £50 UK which I fitted while stripping and rebuilding my original engine, total cost each time was way under £500 uk. The timing belt one was early 90s, the bottom end was very late 90s.
    Both engines were Ford, the failures however were caused by incorrect maintenance, NOT the engine itself.
    The reason for rebuilding my original engines? The ones from the wreckers had very little documentation eg service history etc, about the only thing I knew of them was the milage.
    Edit. My apologies, on re reading the comment those dates are the wrong way round lol.

    • @allangibson8494
      @allangibson8494 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      And I have had two cars written off due to engine failures, one a Mitsubishi Magna because of a timing belt adjuster that wasn’t tightened properly when the belt was changed (by a “professional mechanic”)(and no replacement parts having ever been manufactured) and the other a Ford Ka because of an engine fire - neither were covered by insurance because they were “mechanical failures”.