Canada's population density is far too low for high speed rail to be economically viable.. they keep taking about it but it will NEVER happen because of this.
Speaking as a Canadian, this isn't even a comparison. India wins hands down. Things like comfort and cleanliness can be judged according to a similar standard, but what's not mentioned here is the vitality of the railway to everyday life in each country. In Canada, taking the train has become somewhat of an anachronism. Sure, some people still use it for practical purposes to go a few hundred kilometers (primarily between major cities in the east) but far more people drive since it is a smaller population with more money and more room to do so. Anyone going by train across the country is doing it for the experience of the journey rather than for practical transportation reasons. Otherwise they fly, which is also considerably less expensive. In India, however, the life of the nation depends very much on trains. Villages rely on the railway to stay connected to the rest of the country. Even local economies are fueled by the vendors etc who make their living selling goods to passengers. Indeed, I love the trains in India for this reason. It is more than just transportation. It is a way to experience life in India like none other. I will always love India for its trains:)
You kind of screwed Canada over, since we get snow and we’re in mountains it’s harder to electrify train travel, get high speed rail etc. So this is kind of unfair.
I don't think you can really compare two countries railwaysystems when India has 1324 million people in population and Canada only 36,29 million, and the second largest country in the world. That gives Canada a very low people per square kilometer, which is very important in railway context, also Canada has alot of mountains and step hills + ice cold weather under the winter. Don't forget India is soon gonna be one of the world's fastest growing economy's (if not communist China stop it) that give India the choice and economycal strength to re-invest in their railwaysystem, which Canada impossible can match. So it's very hard to make a fair comparison of these two countries railwaysystems. /A Swede.
That's true. India is way more Economically powerful than Canada. India is already the third largest economy in the world. I think Canada comes in top 20. Check this video. You will understand who were the richest from 1980 till 2020. I hope it helps. th-cam.com/video/O1WC2Sl2jgg/w-d-xo.html
@@antonberglund117 www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=www.visualcapitalist.com/visualizing-the-composition-of-the-world-economy-by-gdp-ppp/&ved=2ahUKEwiy67O81sLtAhUzzTgGHclgBLkQFjADegQIAhAE&usg=AOvVaw1YWZsb9z1FhbuH15h9jrzF&cshid=1607578062004 Check this out. In here it is also said what is GDP(PPP). Economists mostly prefer the Data of GDP ppp , cause they provide accurate results. Other way of measuring the Economic might of a country ( which is less accurate ), is GDP nominal. In GDP nominal india is currently the fifth largest economy in the world but it will become the third largest economy in the world by 2027. But remember GDP ppp is always more accurate and precise than GDP nominal. Thank you
I do not want to visit India. because India is a backward country. and I will not care for the people of India the country backs out. and the indian railway was not as good as Amtrak American and canadian trains. and I will always hate India. better i visit china
If Canada Relied on trains, im sure they would be very good. People have money to buy plane tickets, which is the equivalent there to the India's rail network (when people want to travel from Point A to B)
Canada has a large portion of his territory that is inhabited, so it is normal that our tracks seem underdeveloped. Also, you need to take in fact that India is an overpopulated country while we Just have below 40 millions inhabitants. Also also, our big cities have such a large distance between them (except Toronto, Montreal and Quebec/ Vancouver and Victoria) that we Will travel the distance in plane most of the time. The trans canadian train is a train that takes more than two week to Do and is a tourist train. And finally, here we don't travel on top of trains Because The interior is overpacked.
Just wondering why electrification is a factor as Canada is 3 times bigger and remotely populated in northern part. Electrification is not a benefit considering cost, maintenance and revenue from each train..with number of trains on the track and considering 5 months of snow Diesel engines are best and economical. No wastage of electricity and unnecessary power transmission wires from power plants.
Canada doesn't have the population density to build a big rail network since it'll be hard to maintain and much more expensive then flights and lastly it'll be much more expensive to build rail networks in Canada due to its geographical conditions may be someday when it has 200million people.
Canada is mostly dependant on cars and air for travel due to the low population density and relatively high average incomes per person which allow Canadians to own cars or afford air travel; plus the vast distance between regions and some cities encourage people to rely more on air travel to save time and money because air travel in Canada is much cheaper than rail travel for long distance destination and also faster in terms of time. All these factors makes investing in passenger railway system not economically feasible for companies. The existing railway system in Canada fall into three categories: short distance railway, mostly in southern ontario and the golden horse shoe with the highest population and strongest economic and industrial hubs. Railway that carry goods and commercial products which cover the country east-west. And passenger leisure rail travel where people travel mostly for the enjoyably experience and that is more costly than air travel even at the standard economy class. That being said, due to the relatively high population density, still there's demand and need for passenger rail travel in the short distance category specifically in the golden horse shoe from Windsor to Montreal passing thru Toronto, Kingston and Ottawa.
Gud work brain chow , u hav gone to 34k subscribers , even m motivating my ppl n there is no need 2 tell u but anyways u r also motivating u r unsubscribers
I have just subscribed your channel. After watching it for a long unsubscribed. Wish you will compare #Ranchi and #Karachi someday as they bears similar names and probably having comparable stasticts. #Hope you won't disappoint me !!!
According to central vigilence commission. most complaints got in a system in india is... railway system.... so canada got a point... compare all the pblms to make a video
INDIA already have the fastest train more than 250 kmph. The trains name is talgo express. It has been stopped because of the same reason you have told. The tracks
Canadian trains are better then India’s. In Canada we actually have real nice seats. And the cars are actually clean. This is just bias because it’s an Indian channel.
34,000 subscribers! Will be amazing to reach 1,00,000 subscribers by the end of this year 🙏
Hardwork and consistency pays !!
Brain Chow sure👍 all the very best
Triple of this
Ya sure. You r so popular
Brain Chow of course...... But hme bhul mt jana😂😂😂😂😂
Canada's population density is far too low for high speed rail to be economically viable.. they keep taking about it but it will NEVER happen because of this.
Lol Don't make excuses. I know canadians are racists
@@mathematicsforall4168 ? Damm you guys are salty..
@@rbd6039 Then you guys are the worst
YOU GUYS ARE BITTER!
No excuses 😂
Speaking as a Canadian, this isn't even a comparison. India wins hands down. Things like comfort and cleanliness can be judged according to a similar standard, but what's not mentioned here is the vitality of the railway to everyday life in each country. In Canada, taking the train has become somewhat of an anachronism. Sure, some people still use it for practical purposes to go a few hundred kilometers (primarily between major cities in the east) but far more people drive since it is a smaller population with more money and more room to do so. Anyone going by train across the country is doing it for the experience of the journey rather than for practical transportation reasons. Otherwise they fly, which is also considerably less expensive. In India, however, the life of the nation depends very much on trains. Villages rely on the railway to stay connected to the rest of the country. Even local economies are fueled by the vendors etc who make their living selling goods to passengers. Indeed, I love the trains in India for this reason. It is more than just transportation. It is a way to experience life in India like none other. I will always love India for its trains:)
Is this a professor's lecture 😂
You kind of screwed Canada over, since we get snow and we’re in mountains it’s harder to electrify train travel, get high speed rail etc. So this is kind of unfair.
Lol Don't make excuses. I know canadians are racists
India wins by size !
Canada wins by quality!
Right but maintaining a rail service in a overpopulated country itself is a feat.
Congrats for 34000 subscriber.
I'm your one of the first subscriber...
Thanks for sticking to us so long :)
thanks for making this video and your every video is great and your channel is my favorite channel on TH-cam
One of my favorite channel.
00:32 tejas express with wag9!
your videos are amazing and you will obviously get 1,00,000 subscribers just keep working hard and we will always be with you 😊
Congratulations for 34000 subscribers
India vs Australia military comparison
Quality versus quality... in real life Australia is covered by NATO ans it’s many allies
Congrats for 34,000 subscribers
I don't think you can really compare two countries railwaysystems when India has 1324 million people in population and Canada only 36,29 million, and the second largest country in the world. That gives Canada a very low people per square kilometer, which is very important in railway context, also Canada has alot of mountains and step hills + ice cold weather under the winter.
Don't forget India is soon gonna be one of the world's fastest growing economy's (if not communist China stop it) that give India the choice and economycal strength to re-invest in their railwaysystem, which Canada impossible can match.
So it's very hard to make a fair comparison of these two countries railwaysystems.
/A Swede.
That's true.
India is way more Economically powerful than Canada.
India is already the third largest economy in the world.
I think Canada comes in top 20.
Check this video. You will understand who were the richest from 1980 till 2020.
I hope it helps.
th-cam.com/video/O1WC2Sl2jgg/w-d-xo.html
@@thecuberian2887 Thanks for the video. Didn't even know India was the 3rd largest economy, I thought they were 5th or atleast in the top ten.
@@antonberglund117 www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=www.visualcapitalist.com/visualizing-the-composition-of-the-world-economy-by-gdp-ppp/&ved=2ahUKEwiy67O81sLtAhUzzTgGHclgBLkQFjADegQIAhAE&usg=AOvVaw1YWZsb9z1FhbuH15h9jrzF&cshid=1607578062004
Check this out.
In here it is also said what is GDP(PPP).
Economists mostly prefer the Data of GDP ppp , cause they provide accurate results.
Other way of measuring the Economic might of a country ( which is less accurate ), is GDP nominal.
In GDP nominal india is currently the fifth largest economy in the world but it will become the third largest economy in the world by 2027.
But remember GDP ppp is always more accurate and precise than GDP nominal.
Thank you
India have launched the first semi speed at fed 2019 its speed is 200 kilo meter per hour
I'm rail fans from America and this not fair
Steve Adham i love americans trains
Come to india
India is the best country in the world
I do not want to visit India. because India is a backward country. and I will not care for the people of India the country backs out. and the indian railway was not as good as Amtrak American and canadian trains. and I will always hate India. better i visit china
I like Indian design for bullet train and I hate Indian railway. Because is not 🙅fair bro
At 0:10 that’s not even a regular train service. That was a special train for Canada 150
If Canada Relied on trains, im sure they would be very good. People have money to buy plane tickets, which is the equivalent there to the India's rail network (when people want to travel from Point A to B)
Congrats for 34k subs.
Congrats brain chow for 34 k subs
Canada has a large portion of his territory that is inhabited, so it is normal that our tracks seem underdeveloped. Also, you need to take in fact that India is an overpopulated country while we Just have below 40 millions inhabitants. Also also, our big cities have such a large distance between them (except Toronto, Montreal and Quebec/ Vancouver and Victoria) that we Will travel the distance in plane most of the time. The trans canadian train is a train that takes more than two week to Do and is a tourist train. And finally, here we don't travel on top of trains Because The interior is overpacked.
Where do you guys stay
do canadian metro/subway comparisons
And
A Nice Video Brain Chow
You did not mention anything about cleanliness very partial viewpoint.
Yes.... India needs a lot of work in that area...
Hi I love your video's
But what's the fastest train in Canada? Plz tell me. Is it Via rail?
Please make Indian railways Vs Portugal Railways.
Ma'am aap hamesh comment ko reply kyo nahi karte Ho matlab I know you reply but not in every video can you tell me why
Kabhi kabhi time nahi milta hai isliye nahi Kar paate :)
Brain Chow oh so ma'am if you upload videos in Hindi then your subscribers will grow up so why you uploades video in English
Naresh Haldankar bro in South Indian can't understand but Maharashtrian can understand hindi
What about cost of tickets
Wow, thanka for that video
You are forgetting that more than half of Canada is ice .
Jabardast video :)
I live in Canada. And Canadian train obviously don't really have electric trains other than light rail.
Brain chow your show is the best but can you do one thing for me do indian railways vs German railways
What about platforms poty and no ticket travelling
plz make uae and indian railway comparisons
Tejas express is capabel of running at 200 kmph
Congrats... I'm proud of you
Please put the video of northern Railways vs southern railway of India..
India is No.1.... No need to do any comparation
Hi
Canada has the technology to build high speed railway by its own, India hasn't, so I think the second point goes to Canada.
100K Waiting for You
34,000 subscribers! It Will Definitely reach 10M subscribers by the end of this year 🙏
Can you make vedio of Mumbai vs Navi Mumbai
Congratulations Brain Chow for reaching 34K Subscribers.
Pls give latest information about bullet train in India
First rail route of bullet train is mumbai to amahadabad second one will be Delhi to amritsar
please compare the bangladesh railways vs canada railway in this style
Train18 present running at 180km/hr
You could show the interior of Tejas express.
make a video on indian railway vs Singapore railway
where is t 18 and t20
Delhi to Bhopal route can handle 180 kmph
Yes you are really right
Please
Please a make a video of Indian railways VS Australian railways
Can You Do An Underground Metro Race Of The Fastset Underground Train
Just wondering why electrification is a factor as Canada is 3 times bigger and remotely populated in northern part. Electrification is not a benefit considering cost, maintenance and revenue from each train..with number of trains on the track and considering 5 months of snow Diesel engines are best and economical. No wastage of electricity and unnecessary power transmission wires from power plants.
what is your name sister
Knowledgeable
Military??
Being a rich country however not uptomark in railways. Why??
Simple demand and supply theory...
Hey mad India has train 18 which has the speed of 200
Canada doesn't have the population density to build a big rail network since it'll be hard to maintain and much more expensive then flights and lastly it'll be much more expensive to build rail networks in Canada due to its geographical conditions may be someday when it has 200million people.
Awesome
Nice video
What about talgo high speed
100k *nah* ..... *It will be 1M by the end of the year*
Can you do Indian Railways vs Italian Railways?
Please give us clear information
Canada is mostly dependant on cars and air for travel due to the low population
density and relatively high average incomes per person which allow Canadians
to own cars or afford air travel; plus the vast distance between regions and some cities
encourage people to rely more on air travel to save time and money because air travel
in Canada is much cheaper than rail travel for long distance destination and also faster in
terms of time. All these factors makes investing in passenger railway system not
economically feasible for companies.
The existing railway system in Canada fall into three categories: short distance railway,
mostly in southern ontario and the golden horse shoe with the highest population and
strongest economic and industrial hubs. Railway that carry goods and commercial products
which cover the country east-west. And passenger leisure rail travel where people travel mostly
for the enjoyably experience and that is more costly than air travel even at the standard economy class.
That being said, due to the relatively high population density,
still there's demand and need for passenger rail travel in the short
distance category specifically in the golden horse shoe from Windsor to Montreal
passing thru Toronto, Kingston and Ottawa.
Vande bharat express can run at 180 kmph
Gud work brain chow , u hav gone to 34k subscribers , even m motivating my ppl n there is no need 2 tell u but anyways u r also motivating u r unsubscribers
take a comparision of culture with India and Europe
where are metro train
I have just subscribed your channel. After watching it for a long unsubscribed. Wish you will compare #Ranchi and #Karachi someday as they bears similar names and probably having comparable stasticts. #Hope you won't disappoint me !!!
According to central vigilence commission. most complaints got in a system in india is... railway system.... so canada got a point... compare all the pblms to make a video
Please make a video on army train please request for a video
The maker of video is Indian and completely biased on one side otherwise no chance of winning against Canada railways
So we're just gonna take safety of the list eh
INDIA already have the fastest train more than 250 kmph. The trains name is talgo express.
It has been stopped because of the same reason you have told.
The tracks
See this video .
Why talgo is not coming to India after three trials successfully.
Heart plzz...
Good video
Canadian trains are better then India’s. In Canada we actually have real nice seats. And the cars are actually clean. This is just bias because it’s an Indian channel.
In india it is against law of top speed so you have to 1 point to india
Indian Railways vs Mexican Railways
Biased channel. Always change criteria to give point to India.
Indian railways vs Brazil railways please.
Next video also railway comparison
stop telling false info. Canada is much developed than India and the trains in canada are much cleaner and better than indian trains.
Golden chariot train in india is my favourite
Now do US railways Vs Canadian railways
Did anyone notice wag 9 hauling tejas
Also in Indian railways there are lots of accidents.
So India gets a point even though it is so overcrowded and some times you sit on the roofs of the trains
That's the local train
Subscribed
I'm still waiting for Germany rail comparison
Ok the rocky mountaineer is a much better train than that Indian one. They actually close the doors too.
Making video comparation of kenya India
Canada ki train jyada luxury hai India ki simple train bhi dikhao
India is best
Canada is best
@@jamesjayaraj395 LOL JOKE