i keep hearing praises for Cyberpunk's animations, but it seems to exist only in cutscenes with the whole mocap thing going on. in the open world the animations are still PS2 GTA tier.
cyberpunk excels at combat though. it compares very negatively to GTAV in a LOT of ways but put their combat side by side and cyberpunk blows it out of the water.
First attempt? Bro, they released three games before Cyberpunk including an open world game. Cyberpunk wasn't first attempt. Stop excusing bad developers. Lol
@@Thomas-e5t It was the first of its kind, anyone, any pro with years of experience, when you approach something for the first time they make a mistake, in fact the results of their skill have been seen with phantom liberty, go play Elden ring bro
@@Dansty1488 i don’t need to. Grand theft auto is about crime and murdering so there can’t a be a redemption story in there, and usually stories set in older times are more sad than in modern times
I like more in RDR2, Kingdom come and Witcher 3. Cyberpunk will movment is good is pretty much like every generic first person type movment. Objectively RDR2 has much better movment animations.
@@Ronuk1996 yeah, I know. I don't like it more because it's realistic. I simply like that you can move quicker and more efectively lol. Of course you move realosticaly in RDR2, but that's not a bonus but a contea for me personally.
@@12th977 *2 billion dollars budget** *Developers are working on this project for 10 years** *The trailer got instantly 150 million views on youtube** And here a fckin nobody saying it's a joke, even though it hasn’t even released yet. The level of clownery 📈
@@slobodantanasijevic711 Wait until the actual game is released, graphics and details are gonna be improved more than what you've seen in that trailer
No it won’t, R* said themselves they wouldn’t put as much attention to detail in another game because of the amount of development issues and grief it caused.
both are on pare at many things for me. 2 major companies. Theyr products are just gems. CP2077, RDR2, GTA's, The Witcher series. They are both great. i had the best times of my gaming time with them.
Project done by topper:with lots of research, love-->RDR2 Project done by our team:partying throughout semester then last day starting and submitting with whatever stuffing-->cyberpunk😂
I never felt Cyberpunk as an alive game. I don't like the NPC, they feel so AI generated. I literally refund my CB after Jackie's death. Bought a skin for CS2 and play a modded sim RDR2 again. 😂
And don't forget that Cyberpunk somehow havier than rdr2 for me i like rdr2 graphic more than cyberpunk,but the world i like cyberpunk more i like the building there,but man...my pc is pretty loud when playing cyberpunk but rdr2 is silent and i can play peacefully
You should do a shadow comparison with rtx 😂 biggest detail breaker, that and the goofy civilian interactions or wait when they randomly disappear in a 5 meter distance or when cars spawn in each other
RDR2 does better in terms of details. But Cyberpunk 2077 just looks visually amazing. They are two entirely different games with different aesthetics so its hard to compare, but Cyberpunk has raytracing and pathtracing which looks amazing on PC, but RDR2 is still using older light systems so interiors dont look the greatest. Landscapes still looks amazing though.
@@Простообзоры-с9б I mean that doesnt change anything. Wether u have low end specs or high end specs, the game still has good graphics, just not for you
or Cyberpunk lol. My pc runs RDR2 at ultra at 140 fps, but Cyberpunk at maximum + raytracing/pathracing max at only 40-60 fps. But it looks absolutely insane at maximum because the raytracing makes the lighting look more like real life. RDR2 doesn't have raytracing but I wish it did, it could look even better.
Why compare Cyberpunk to Red Dead or even GTA? Already the experience in this type of urban open world and the financial and staff resources of the two studios are not the same but above all Cyberpunk is an RPG. The GamePlay mechanics and priorities are not the same as for a Rockstar-style Sandbox game. It should rather be compared to a Bethesda game and CD Projekt wins hands down, especially on physics and the support provided to the post-launch game!! No but look at Starfield!!!! Cyberpunk remains a great game, if it suffers from comparison with Rockstar games because of players not understanding anything about the direction and ambitions, it's a shame because it was never a GTA Like!
This is definitely a skewed video towards RDR2. While both games are amazing, and RDR2 knocks it out of the park on immersion, npc behavior and small details, Cyberpunk clearly takes the cake on visuals and location detail given its scope. It’s important to keep in mind the scale of both games and what they’re aiming to tackle when comparing them.
@@Ronuk1996 while I don’t disagree, I just don’t think that comparing these two games is very fair. Obviously rendering and designing a city-based game taking place in an alternate universe is gonna make compromises in other areas.
@@editorkamrankhan9338 i mean they stopped updating it so the game is officially fully fixed. i just liked that the story is more straightforward than rdr2, also its heartbreaking and sad as hell and the expansion/DLC is amazing too so i recommend it
@@DeXio94nothing can beat Rockstar in sheer amount of detail, but PL and the 2.0 polish were a huge step up in creating a believable and immersed ambience. And in relation to quest design, there's no contest, cp2077 PL trumps Rockstar's outdated quest design any day of the week.
@@12th977 erh... Not so fast choom. I'd say that Rockstar's mocap is better and more universal than CD red's. Outside of cutscenes, for example, the animations are blocky in cyberpunk. In rdr2, everything is very smooth. Also in general detail and individual systems, no one can beat Rockstar. Animals putrify, clothes have extensive physics and don't clip, every single npc has a daily schedule that makes sense, there are animations both in fp and tp for drinking, eating, sitting, playing cards, playing dice, riding horses and everything, etc
Its stupid to compare this games. Cyberpunk It's mainly a role-playing game with plot and missions, so it doesn't have so many stupid details like in rdr because this is not game for having fun in open world
Have you played cyberpunk? There’s plenty of gore among other things you wouldn’t want children seeing. Lots of nudity and sexually explicit content. I’d feel far more comfortable showing rdr2 to a kid than cyberpunk.
cyberpunk's gameplay and storytelling is way better than rdr2 but small details are better in rdr2 and its the best game for western genre. both games are great but i like cyberpunk more.
bro i'm 5 hours into cyberpunk and i still don't know what's going on but it's definitely funner i'll give you that and i truly believe it's only because the game has badass cars horses just suck when they're the main mode of transportation in any game.
Nah RDR2 is far better game with what it allows the player to do in its world, Physics, AI, Interactivity are some of few things you can look at objectively you also can have more of an impact on Arthur's Chracter development then you can on V.
Yes, and it is extremely overrated. Most of its praise comes from little details that no one actually pays attention to. The game is clunky and repetitive, and has outdated level design. @AkashaKumarSwain
@@AkashaKumarSwain I have completed the game 2 times and not gonna lie it just sucks cause it's too damn repetitive and boring. Started cyberpunk just last week and it's really 10 times more fun than red dead
@@Saurabh-cy4pwwht a joke.. cyberpunk is not at all realistic..it's like a joke..it's fast paced so people enjoy it but rdr 2 is god tier and masterpiece..best game ever
@@Gamingtest-RTX4050 who tf cares about realism when you can cut incoming bullets in half using katanas or You can kill your enemies by frying their brains out. Like dude Just stop Just stop meat riding red dead , it's a slow ass horse simulator aim and shoot game.
This is biased. Compare combat, where the actual fun of a game is. No on gives an f about footprints when you can air slice an enemy through the head from the air with a mantis blade
i keep hearing praises for Cyberpunk's animations, but it seems to exist only in cutscenes with the whole mocap thing going on. in the open world the animations are still PS2 GTA tier.
its a big step up for cyberpunk but red dead still takes the cake
@SirVonLoutevinno in terms of NPC interaction or physics its not.
The lighting in the city is awesome is cyberpunk, they use rt in a great way. But overall rdr has more going on under the hood in terms of simulation
@SirVonLuitenwyl cap, game from 1899 is more immersive than 2077. 🤣
@SirVonLuitenwylCDPR glazer
@@kta_0187and we dont talk about story Mode , rdr2 slams
Cyberpunk lack a lot of things but also remember Rockstar produce games on another level, no company is close to quality od RDR or GTA
cyberpunk excels at combat though. it compares very negatively to GTAV in a LOT of ways but put their combat side by side and cyberpunk blows it out of the water.
no shit, cyberpunk is a futuristic world game with advanced tech, and rdr2 is based on the 1800s which limits combat options@@dessertstorm7476
Wdym?
@@dessertstorm7476Bruh, hows?
@@slobodantanasijevic711How so?!
This video should be called "decades of practice vs firs atempt"
Brilliant idea lol
Lmao witcher 3 was a masterpiece. Still couldn't create another one like cdpr. Amateurs.
First attempt? Bro, they released three games before Cyberpunk including an open world game. Cyberpunk wasn't first attempt. Stop excusing bad developers. Lol
@@Thomas-e5t It was the first of its kind, anyone, any pro with years of experience, when you approach something for the first time they make a mistake, in fact the results of their skill have been seen with phantom liberty, go play Elden ring bro
they both took the same amount of time and this isnt their first attempt lol
I ❤❤❤ Red Dead Redemption 2! The best video game ever I've played! No one can beat RDR2!
How so?
gay ass
@raran-md8cn
It's better call that, cyberbugs😂😂 @Naran_doanh
@@matin_ghassemi_60😂😂
Rdr 2 for people who want an interactive movie. Cyberpunk 2077 for people that want a video game with player agency.
if cyberpunk hired rockstar to fix them then this game would look like it came in 2077
I love CP77 and for what they did to turn it into something better, but details wise, RDR2’s still unmatched.
RDR 2 is on another level.
Cyberpunk obliterate Red dead in combat and gore
@@Pierce-Dante Have you ever seen Cyberpunk character in combat 3th person mode except driving motorcycle :D
@@hasanuguz6868 uh t cyberpunk is a first person game dawg
@@Pierce-Dante Yea they cant even add third person mode because they cant do it.
@@hasanuguz6868lol, they can, they did it with the witcher 3. Its their decision to make CP2077 as a First Person and Witcher as a Third Person.
Gta 6 is coming so a game will finally beat rdr2
In most aspects* because when it is Rockstar's game Vs Rockstar's game, the competition is tough and both games take many points from each other
It will be better but not in all aspects like story
@@Docnew Agree with you.
@@Docnew bro already played it
@@Dansty1488 i don’t need to. Grand theft auto is about crime and murdering so there can’t a be a redemption story in there, and usually stories set in older times are more sad than in modern times
keep up the good work mate, great comparison
Thank you🙂 Glad you liked it
@@swiftycrimsonin your opinion what game won
Unpopular opinion: I like the character movement of cyberpunk more than RDR2
I like more in RDR2, Kingdom come and Witcher 3. Cyberpunk will movment is good is pretty much like every generic first person type movment. Objectively RDR2 has much better movment animations.
@@Ronuk1996 yeah, I know. I don't like it more because it's realistic. I simply like that you can move quicker and more efectively lol. Of course you move realosticaly in RDR2, but that's not a bonus but a contea for me personally.
Nothing could possibly beat rdr2, not even I think, rdr3
Gta6
@@12th977
*2 billion dollars budget**
*Developers are working on this project for 10 years**
*The trailer got instantly 150 million views on youtube**
And here a fckin nobody saying it's a joke, even though it hasn’t even released yet. The level of clownery 📈
@@12th977ur a joke lol
Why are yall so gullible
@@slobodantanasijevic711 Wait until the actual game is released, graphics and details are gonna be improved more than what you've seen in that trailer
Cyberpunk promised to be the greatest open world ever with features RDR2 already had
Just copped both games and I can’t decide which one to play first lol.
Only GTA 6 will be more realistic than Red Dead Redemption 2
No it won’t, R* said themselves they wouldn’t put as much attention to detail in another game because of the amount of development issues and grief it caused.
@@DrilleDeLesee LOL Rockstar never stated anything themselves like that since many years ago. Stop listening cheap TH-camrs
@@DrilleDeLeseeSource: McDonald's menu
@@DrilleDeLesee 2 billion dollar budget, don't forget that
@@DrilleDeLeseerockstar literally never said that. Rockstar said gta 6 will be their biggest and most immersive game they ever made
both are on pare at many things for me. 2 major companies. Theyr products are just gems. CP2077, RDR2, GTA's, The Witcher series. They are both great. i had the best times of my gaming time with them.
Project done by topper:with lots of research, love-->RDR2
Project done by our team:partying throughout semester then last day starting and submitting with whatever stuffing-->cyberpunk😂
both great games idk which ones better it's personal taste at that point
I never felt Cyberpunk as an alive game. I don't like the NPC, they feel so AI generated. I literally refund my CB after Jackie's death. Bought a skin for CS2 and play a modded sim RDR2 again. 😂
And don't forget that Cyberpunk somehow havier than rdr2 for me i like rdr2 graphic more than cyberpunk,but the world i like cyberpunk more i like the building there,but man...my pc is pretty loud when playing cyberpunk but rdr2 is silent and i can play peacefully
Loud pc matches with the city noises it should be ok😂
I don’t mind cyberpunk at all but it’s an insult to even try and compare it to RDR2. An insult to RDR of course
Cyberpunk is the better game.
@ far from it in my opinion. In the meantime I’m enjoying metro exodus and dead space remake
You should do a shadow comparison with rtx 😂 biggest detail breaker, that and the goofy civilian interactions or wait when they randomly disappear in a 5 meter distance or when cars spawn in each other
Ikr 😂
Wdym?
How so?
We Need RDR2 vs Bully only fair comparison.
What about GTA 4?🙂
@@swiftycrimson GTA4 is great but i was thinking more about NPC intetaction. RDR2 vs Kingdom come would be a good one.
@@swiftycrimson do it against Sleeping Dogs
Rdr2 is goat
both games are great
RDR2 does better in terms of details. But Cyberpunk 2077 just looks visually amazing. They are two entirely different games with different aesthetics so its hard to compare, but Cyberpunk has raytracing and pathtracing which looks amazing on PC, but RDR2 is still using older light systems so interiors dont look the greatest. Landscapes still looks amazing though.
Oh yeah but not everyone can afford rtx 4090.
@@Простообзоры-с9б I mean that doesnt change anything. Wether u have low end specs or high end specs, the game still has good graphics, just not for you
Let's be honest: 95 percent gamers don't have the rig to play rdr2 on ultra😂
Rdr2 is less demanding than cyberpunk
meanwhile most popular gpu on steam is rtx3060 which can run rdr2 easily on high-ultra 1080/60
or Cyberpunk lol. My pc runs RDR2 at ultra at 140 fps, but Cyberpunk at maximum + raytracing/pathracing max at only 40-60 fps. But it looks absolutely insane at maximum because the raytracing makes the lighting look more like real life. RDR2 doesn't have raytracing but I wish it did, it could look even better.
@@fxsupermaster what gpu do you have to run rdr2 at ultra at 140 fps?
@@zw6512 RTX 4070 Ti
Not buying cyberpunk until it actually because playable
Rockstar should buy Cyberpunk
And people put cyberpunk most 7 best open world game what is good
Why compare Cyberpunk to Red Dead or even GTA? Already the experience in this type of urban open world and the financial and staff resources of the two studios are not the same but above all Cyberpunk is an RPG. The GamePlay mechanics and priorities are not the same as for a Rockstar-style Sandbox game. It should rather be compared to a Bethesda game and CD Projekt wins hands down, especially on physics and the support provided to the post-launch game!! No but look at Starfield!!!! Cyberpunk remains a great game, if it suffers from comparison with Rockstar games because of players not understanding anything about the direction and ambitions, it's a shame because it was never a GTA Like!
So why do they claim it's an open world game if it were an rpg??
GTA 6 is rdr2 but it’s not back in the day😂😂
RDR2 has better character models and animations.
Is like the animations in cyberpunk we're made by kids.
Ultimate?
This is definitely a skewed video towards RDR2. While both games are amazing, and RDR2 knocks it out of the park on immersion, npc behavior and small details, Cyberpunk clearly takes the cake on visuals and location detail given its scope. It’s important to keep in mind the scale of both games and what they’re aiming to tackle when comparing them.
Yeah but all that does not matter much without Interactive worlds.
@@Ronuk1996 while I don’t disagree, I just don’t think that comparing these two games is very fair. Obviously rendering and designing a city-based game taking place in an alternate universe is gonna make compromises in other areas.
game from 2017 compared to a game from 2019
2018
2018 and 2020, you got both dates wrong
Lmfao wdym
well cyberpunk is still the best game of all time and no one can change my mind :P
Serious is it worth it ?
@@editorkamrankhan9338 i mean they stopped updating it so the game is officially fully fixed. i just liked that the story is more straightforward than rdr2, also its heartbreaking and sad as hell and the expansion/DLC is amazing too so i recommend it
kcuf diputs
Ngl this video has some heavy bias :/
Should be instead titled: "Reasons why RDR2 is better than CP77."
I know but Cyberpunk fans would be mad at me lol
jesus - cyberpunk was released in 2020 and still is like a trash xD
Have you played Phantom Liberty?
@@vipergaming7078 yeah, still super flat and empty comparing to Red Dead Redemption 2 :)
@@DeXio94nothing can beat Rockstar in sheer amount of detail, but PL and the 2.0 polish were a huge step up in creating a believable and immersed ambience. And in relation to quest design, there's no contest, cp2077 PL trumps Rockstar's outdated quest design any day of the week.
@@DeXio94 No lol It is not as great as RDR 2 but it is definitely one of the top tier games
@@12th977 erh... Not so fast choom. I'd say that Rockstar's mocap is better and more universal than CD red's. Outside of cutscenes, for example, the animations are blocky in cyberpunk. In rdr2, everything is very smooth. Also in general detail and individual systems, no one can beat Rockstar. Animals putrify, clothes have extensive physics and don't clip, every single npc has a daily schedule that makes sense, there are animations both in fp and tp for drinking, eating, sitting, playing cards, playing dice, riding horses and everything, etc
Its stupid to compare this games. Cyberpunk It's mainly a role-playing game with plot and missions, so it doesn't have so many stupid details like in rdr because this is not game for having fun in open world
Bro is on extreme copium 💀
Bro cyberpunk is a futuristic open world game.... what are u taking about...
@@towfiqelahi2187 Yes, but the game is mainly based on the plot and completing missions, so it is not as varied in some details as rdr
@@Arisalix rdr2 is an open world with an amazing story, graphics, and details, it's just better
Having fun in open world? There is very little to do in the open world of Cyberpunk which has a real lack of interactivity.
Holla
Have you played cyberpunk? There’s plenty of gore among other things you wouldn’t want children seeing. Lots of nudity and sexually explicit content. I’d feel far more comfortable showing rdr2 to a kid than cyberpunk.
@Schmeevene sorry I will delete this comment for you brotha 🗿👍
cyberpunk's gameplay and storytelling is way better than rdr2 but small details are better in rdr2 and its the best game for western genre. both games are great but i like cyberpunk more.
Storytelling better??😂
Bro what sort of meatriding is that😂😂😂
Bro is meatriding
bro i'm 5 hours into cyberpunk and i still don't know what's going on but it's definitely funner i'll give you that and i truly believe it's only because the game has badass cars horses just suck when they're the main mode of transportation in any game.
@@stevekaufmann8109 duh did you expect Tesla's in the 1889 lmao
i prefer cyberpunk
red dead is great and beats cyberpunk in terms of physics and attention to detail but cyberpunk is still a better game.
No.
@@7Luis7 yes
how? explain me
Nah RDR2 is far better game with what it allows the player to do in its world, Physics, AI, Interactivity are some of few things you can look at objectively you also can have more of an impact on Arthur's Chracter development then you can on V.
Cant more bias than this.
Rdr 2 is overrated
Have you played the game though??
Yes, and it is extremely overrated. Most of its praise comes from little details that no one actually pays attention to. The game is clunky and repetitive, and has outdated level design. @AkashaKumarSwain
@@AkashaKumarSwain
I have completed the game 2 times and not gonna lie it just sucks cause it's too damn repetitive and boring.
Started cyberpunk just last week and it's really 10 times more fun than red dead
@@Saurabh-cy4pwwht a joke.. cyberpunk is not at all realistic..it's like a joke..it's fast paced so people enjoy it but rdr 2 is god tier and masterpiece..best game ever
@@Gamingtest-RTX4050 who tf cares about realism when you can cut incoming bullets in half using katanas or
You can kill your enemies by frying their brains out.
Like dude Just stop
Just stop meat riding red dead , it's a slow ass horse simulator aim and shoot game.
This is biased. Compare combat, where the actual fun of a game is. No on gives an f about footprints when you can air slice an enemy through the head from the air with a mantis blade
This might shock your Brain but, *there weren't gay ahh star wars blades in the 1899*
You clearly haven't had a proper gunfight in rdr2 yet
Realism vs ai generated like cartoonistic models
Combat is highly subjective but Maxpayne 3 and The Warriors beat both in terms of Physics and Depth.
Ayūn gdisí jsiœs ists js enishúw