@@DanielHernandez-df6xk you tripping. It is the other way around. Bf4 should be C tier and Bf V should be A tier. Bf 4 is overrated as fuck, the maps and vehicles suck ass, while battlefield V had the best maps and really good vehicle gameplay and gunplay. In my opinion Battlefield 4 has nothing on Battlefield 1 and Battlefield V, it is inferior in pretty much every way. The only thing keeping Battlefield V from being S tier aswell, is the woke ass bullshit they did with the game that came at the expense of historical accuracy and athmosphere.
@@spacemanke3814 Delusional. Might be one of the most braindead, drone logic takes I've ever heard. Your opinion is objectively wrong. It's a known fact that Bf4 has the best vehicle mechanics and design in the entire series. Saying that Battlefield V has the best maps is just a piss poor troll attempt on your end. Literally regarded as one of the worst games in the franchise, due to the atrocious map design. Stop spouting nonsense and go back to your fortnite and apex modern shooter slop that you probably came from.
Bf4 getting only an A seems as crazy as rating 2142 as an S for me. I still play it to this day it is the best modern setting boots on the ground battlefield experience it beats bf3 in that category hands down imo because its more refined like you yourself pointed out in the video. The destruction, vehicles and gunplay still hold up to this day and thats where i go to get my modern battlefield fix. The only critisism i can level at it is that the melee system sucks but i rarely do melee anyway so its not that big of a deal for me.
As a person who grew up with bf3, I agree completely with your take. W video and w list but imo I think bf hardline and bad company 1 deserve a little more love. Nice video 👍
Amazing work with all those details you mentioned and clips you put in. Battlefield V is one of the first Ray Tracing games (maybe the first) which make it kinda important for the industry. BF V has a lot of ups and downs but I don't think C tier is fair for that title. Thanks for your great work!
Another unpopular opinion: I think BF5 is better than BF1. Majority of the bf5 maps are dukey but idk the gameplay feels much better than bf1 imo. I try so many times to get into bf1 but everytime I play it feels too loose or clunky
You are right ! I still think Heroes was not that bad it was fun and ok. I will place it for sure in D that's the only problem. And also Battlefield 4 is just a Battlefield 3 but better so i place these two in S.
my tier list S- bf3, bf4, bf2142 A- bf2, bfbc2, bf1 B- 1942 c- bf vietnam bf5 d- BFH, 2042 3 had amazing map design, graphics and gameplay that stand up today 4 had the best customization of all the franchise, go to any youtube comments about weapons and its never agreed on whats best, massive variety carried this game, also my personal favorite gunplay in the franchise. little biased by 2142 and 2 were my childhood but 2142 was the most balanced battlefield game, nothing was op nothing sucked, also had a more gloomy atmosphere that hasnt really been seen since, titan mode was the goat, and a lot of gadget customization. bf2 was awesome and i pay respects to it, however it had what was probably the most imbalanced gameplay of any battlefield, gunplay could be wonky, grenade spam was insane could kill tanks with those, and air balance was the worst in the franchise, commander would keep you perma map spotted with the ENEMY Spotted constantly going off blaring in your headset got annoying, no safe spawns because commander mode so people would just waltz in and steal your jets. however battlefield would not be where it is today without it and even other game titles like squad would be spawned by the influence of bf2 and by extension project reality. also had arguably the best maps of any bf in the franchise bf1 was amazing with the atmosphere, but the theme wasn't for me bfbc2 was solid but what holds it back for me was its limitation on PC players because console priority gadda pay respect for 1942 for starting this amazing franchise i liked Vietnam but like bf1 it wasnt for me bf5 was mediocre, it would eventually start to be on the road to a good game but dice pulled the plug before it could do that 2042 needs no explanation i never played BFH outside of the beta but it was a interesting take, however it was not a battlefield title and if it didnt have the battlefield title it would have been fine thank you for reading from this old bf vet, happy hunting
Your list is correct. Started my battlefield career with BF2 and BF2142 simultaneously, right after I got a gaming PC when 2142 came out. I was horrible at both games, but my god they were so amazing. Best time I've ever had in a shooter. I feel like no BF has come close to the vastness feeling of BF2. BF1 is a close 2nd for me, which I'm currently still playing everyday, with 2142 being 3rd. I have half a mind to get another gaming PC and start playing BF2 and BF2142 again lol (are they even still supported?????)
I couldn’t agree more with your take on Bf1. It’s so visceral and immersive, and I know that everybody says that but that’s because it’s true. Yes the shooting mechanics are very unique and the sniping specifically is maybe a little too casual, but it fits the time period so perfectly it just adds to the immersion so well. Getting hit center mass with a Martini Henry in 1917 would absolutely spell certain doom for any poor sod stupid enough to crawl out of the trenches and run through no man’s land. Comparing 1’s atmosphere and gritty feel to that of 5’s is absolutely night and day. BF1 deserves to be S tier, and deserves to be at the very top of S tier. Good tier list soldier 🫡
Bf1942-A Bf Vietnam-B Bf2-S Bf2142-A Battlefield heroes-C or D did what it was supposed to Bfmc-C Bfbc-C Bf1943- C- Bfbc2-A Bf3-S Bf4-S Bf1-S Bfv- C - Bf2042- as it sits now C and probably final verdict
@@PungglesI played it first week of release and it were epic. It had movable hangarships, submarines, B52 planes etc. On top of it, people made Total Conversions like Star Wars, Desert Storm etc. BF Games made later always felt more limited than 1942 for several reasons.
Bad Company 2 had one flaw. The campaign. I loved multiplayer and played the ass out of it, but the campaign was a ripoff of MW2. It's jarring to go from the "Three Kings"-like story about the gold and 4 stooges derping around Eastern Europe and risking their lives to get rich, but then switch to a darker, serious tone with really no relation to the first game besides a random conversation, when idle, about "what happened..." I liked the first BC online "story" implying that word got out about gold and both sides are battling to get rich and AWOL the fuck out of there. After losing a match and hearing "Damn it! Now we are stuck working for the Army!" always made me chuckle.
BF3 is quite of disappointment from me. Growing up with BF2 (despite playing it in internet cafe) and jump right to BF3, I see how far the gameplay was, seeing how casual it was. Blue filter made me nauseous. It bothered me so much that I'd switch BF3 for BF4. Not to mention excessive lightings in some occasion. It also introduce meat grinder maps. And to top that all, no offline game in MP maps. And taking nitpick route, I am very disappointed for the lackluster factions. I was remembering how BF2 got USMC, PLA, and fictional MEC, and then adding US Navy SEAL, MEC SF, SAS, Spetsnaz, Rebel, and Insurgents, and hoping BF3 could take some of them. But no, there are only Russia and US. Jeez, not even the opposing force we faced in SP? Iranian military could get some spotlight as a new OPFOR. Plus, Russian speaking English. Why? BF2 with native language and "subtitle" in chat box was spot on. Russian's one liner is as if not more cringe than BF2042's operator one liner. Another reason to switch BF3 to BF4. In the end, I think the one who deserves the S tier, beside BF2 and BF1 (I don't play BFBC2 much, though), is BF4.
Thats fair, BF3 did a lot to change fundamentally from BF2 but I still think its an incredible game in its own right. I can definitely understand why old school fans would be disappointed
I played every single battlefield, and the tierlist is quite accurate but to my taste: S tier: BFBC2, BF2,BF3,BF4 A tier: BF1, BF2142, BFV B tier: BF1942, BF Vietnam, BF1943, BF2042 (Absolute trash at start and did many things wrong but regained itself a little bit) C tier: BF2 modern combat, BF Bad Company D tier: Hardline(Its very solid but not a BF game) Trash: BF Heroes, BF Play4Free(worst bf game i played) The ideal game for me would be, a Battlefield game with the destruction and feeling of BFBC2, the management system of BF2, The graphics of BFV and experimental modes like the titan mode in BF2142 for example. BF2042 really fucked up, trash specialist system, Maps horrible, You can tag the enemy that killed you when you die which is ridiculous, you can see the glance of a sniper from accros the map...., a game pure based on solo play in its majority. They left so many great systems out that they had in the previous games. Oh and they should quit the subscription crap and just keep it to expansions with all the rest unlockable by gameplay.
If you put bf2 in S bf2142 has to objectively be A tier at least. In bf2 you rubber band while sprinting slightly uphill... and i have ptsd from Karkand nade spamming.
Personally i disagree with bf1 being on S tier, i think bf1 should be at C tier, bf 5 at A tier, and BF 4 at S tier, i played bf3 also, i didnt like it at all, i think bf3 should be C tier
you put hardline in d tier for not being a "battlefield" title but then go and put battlefield 1 in s stier... if battlefield hardline is in d tier (i think it's a c tier game) because it's not a good battlefield game, then with that same logic, battlefield 1 should be a or b tier. it's a great ww1 shooter with the best design of any world war game out there even to this day, but it was never a great "battlefield" game, let alone s tier worthy. battlefield fans of the time were saying this when it came out. i personally don't think it's anywhere near the level of battlefield 3 or bad company 2, let alone battlefield 2. still remember how it was considered one of the worst entries into the franchise at the time, then it was battlefield V and now it's battlefield 2042... i bet once the next battlefield game comes out, everyone one will be calling battlefield 2042 an a or s tier game lol.
@@Punggles I didn't test it when it first come out. But I put it on C because it was basically a downgrade of BF3, and BF3 was also a downgrade of Bad Company 2. So BF4 is a great game but for the Battlefield series it's not that great ! And it's also more arcade in it's gameplay. For the online the better Battlefield is bad company 2.
Despite it’s many many flaws, 2042 is not a trash tier at all, I think you’re overexaggerating here. I don’t know when was the last time you played it but the game has insanely improved since launch. I have more than 800 hours in 2042 since the early days and I must say that at lauch it would be a D-tier, now after many updates, bug fixes, content drops, reworks, optimalizing, it’s a C-tier. No way 2042 should be in the same tier as those joke-of-a-games Heroes and Play4Free.
I appreciate the comment, and okay maybe I was over-exaggerating a bit but I still stand by it being the worst mainline Battlefield game in the entire series. For me personally its more of how much it has destroyed the brand and any potential for things like BF Portal.
BF4 is S tier for me. The memories playing that game will stay with me forever 😁
▪︎S tier : BF3 , BF1 .
▪︎A tier : BF4 , BFV .
▪︎B tier : BC2 .
▪︎C tier : BFH .
▪︎D tier : 2042 .
(I started playing battlefield games since BF3)
BC2 a little low for me but not a bad list!
Bfv in A tier and same level as bf4? Lmao the game is slop.
@@DanielHernandez-df6xk you tripping. It is the other way around. Bf4 should be C tier and Bf V should be A tier. Bf 4 is overrated as fuck, the maps and vehicles suck ass, while battlefield V had the best maps and really good vehicle gameplay and gunplay. In my opinion Battlefield 4 has nothing on Battlefield 1 and Battlefield V, it is inferior in pretty much every way. The only thing keeping Battlefield V from being S tier aswell, is the woke ass bullshit they did with the game that came at the expense of historical accuracy and athmosphere.
BFV has trash gunplay and the worst maps in the series until BF2042. BFV guns feel like COD and its all it is - mag dumping
@@spacemanke3814 Delusional. Might be one of the most braindead, drone logic takes I've ever heard. Your opinion is objectively wrong. It's a known fact that Bf4 has the best vehicle mechanics and design in the entire series. Saying that Battlefield V has the best maps is just a piss poor troll attempt on your end. Literally regarded as one of the worst games in the franchise, due to the atrocious map design. Stop spouting nonsense and go back to your fortnite and apex modern shooter slop that you probably came from.
Bf4 getting only an A seems as crazy as rating 2142 as an S for me. I still play it to this day it is the best modern setting boots on the ground battlefield experience it beats bf3 in that category hands down imo because its more refined like you yourself pointed out in the video. The destruction, vehicles and gunplay still hold up to this day and thats where i go to get my modern battlefield fix. The only critisism i can level at it is that the melee system sucks but i rarely do melee anyway so its not that big of a deal for me.
I skipped to the end because I didn't trust you. I'm proud to say I was wrong, your list is perfection.
🤩
As a person who grew up with bf3, I agree completely with your take. W video and w list but imo I think bf hardline and bad company 1 deserve a little more love. Nice video 👍
Glad you enjoyed! I think I might have rated Bad Company 1 a bit harshly as well
Unpopular opinion: my fav is bf hardline
That is less of an opinion and more of a fact
indeed
@@thebigsam
More power to you it’s a fun game! I wish it was its own franchise with sequels
Same. Battlefield community didn't deserve that game. The amount of flak it got was undeserved.
Well, there are some guys into ugly fat chicks. It was bound to happen.
Bf3 is litteraly my first shooter and my fav game in the franchise
Amazing work with all those details you mentioned and clips you put in. Battlefield V is one of the first Ray Tracing games (maybe the first) which make it kinda important for the industry. BF V has a lot of ups and downs but I don't think C tier is fair for that title. Thanks for your great work!
Riyal, the true tier list, btw the new pfp is fire [ 🗿🗿 fr ]
Thank you! I love it 🗿
Another unpopular opinion:
I think BF5 is better than BF1. Majority of the bf5 maps are dukey but idk the gameplay feels much better than bf1 imo. I try so many times to get into bf1 but everytime I play it feels too loose or clunky
I can see that, I don't agree personally but I can see the argument
You are right ! I still think Heroes was not that bad it was fun and ok. I will place it for sure in D that's the only problem.
And also Battlefield 4 is just a Battlefield 3 but better so i place these two in S.
Move bad company up to B tier and yea that list is spot on.
Honestly a change I would make to my list after more though
my tier list
S- bf3, bf4, bf2142
A- bf2, bfbc2, bf1
B- 1942
c- bf vietnam bf5
d- BFH, 2042
3 had amazing map design, graphics and gameplay that stand up today
4 had the best customization of all the franchise, go to any youtube comments about weapons and its never agreed on whats best, massive variety carried this game, also my personal favorite gunplay in the franchise.
little biased by 2142 and 2 were my childhood but 2142 was the most balanced battlefield game, nothing was op nothing sucked, also had a more gloomy atmosphere that hasnt really been seen since, titan mode was the goat, and a lot of gadget customization.
bf2 was awesome and i pay respects to it, however it had what was probably the most imbalanced gameplay of any battlefield, gunplay could be wonky, grenade spam was insane could kill tanks with those, and air balance was the worst in the franchise, commander would keep you perma map spotted with the ENEMY Spotted constantly going off blaring in your headset got annoying, no safe spawns because commander mode so people would just waltz in and steal your jets. however battlefield would not be where it is today without it and even other game titles like squad would be spawned by the influence of bf2 and by extension project reality. also had arguably the best maps of any bf in the franchise
bf1 was amazing with the atmosphere, but the theme wasn't for me
bfbc2 was solid but what holds it back for me was its limitation on PC players because console priority
gadda pay respect for 1942 for starting this amazing franchise
i liked Vietnam but like bf1 it wasnt for me
bf5 was mediocre, it would eventually start to be on the road to a good game but dice pulled the plug before it could do that
2042 needs no explanation
i never played BFH outside of the beta but it was a interesting take, however it was not a battlefield title and if it didnt have the battlefield title it would have been fine
thank you for reading from this old bf vet, happy hunting
Your list is correct.
Started my battlefield career with BF2 and BF2142 simultaneously, right after I got a gaming PC when 2142 came out. I was horrible at both games, but my god they were so amazing. Best time I've ever had in a shooter. I feel like no BF has come close to the vastness feeling of BF2. BF1 is a close 2nd for me, which I'm currently still playing everyday, with 2142 being 3rd. I have half a mind to get another gaming PC and start playing BF2 and BF2142 again lol (are they even still supported?????)
Yes you can still play both bf2 and 2142 online.
Unpopular opinion: BFH over TF2 anyday. BFH on trash tier is illegal.
Sorry
BFH and BFP4F were both enjoyable. BFP4F was quite P2W but captured many battlefield elements successfully for a free game.
I couldn’t agree more with your take on Bf1. It’s so visceral and immersive, and I know that everybody says that but that’s because it’s true. Yes the shooting mechanics are very unique and the sniping specifically is maybe a little too casual, but it fits the time period so perfectly it just adds to the immersion so well. Getting hit center mass with a Martini Henry in 1917 would absolutely spell certain doom for any poor sod stupid enough to crawl out of the trenches and run through no man’s land. Comparing 1’s atmosphere and gritty feel to that of 5’s is absolutely night and day. BF1 deserves to be S tier, and deserves to be at the very top of S tier. Good tier list soldier 🫡
Bf1942-A
Bf Vietnam-B
Bf2-S
Bf2142-A
Battlefield heroes-C or D did what it was supposed to
Bfmc-C
Bfbc-C
Bf1943- C-
Bfbc2-A
Bf3-S
Bf4-S
Bf1-S
Bfv- C -
Bf2042- as it sits now C and probably final verdict
I I agree to the tier list, but you did battlefield 2042 a bit dirty
Eh just a bit hyperbolic :)
It’s due time for Bad Company 3!
I don't trust DICE to make it lol
nah, they are gonna fuck it up.
You should know there's something fucked up somewhere when you enjoy Battlefield heroes more than 2042
My list would look extremely similar
BF 1942 on S Tier.
Battlefield Hardline B Tier. Still a unique online game in 2023.
1942 being S tier is a unique take, why do you place it so high I'm just curious
@@PungglesI played it first week of release and it were epic. It had movable hangarships, submarines, B52 planes etc.
On top of it, people made Total Conversions like Star Wars, Desert Storm etc.
BF Games made later always felt more limited than 1942 for several reasons.
Everything you said is correct.
Bad Company 2 had one flaw. The campaign. I loved multiplayer and played the ass out of it, but the campaign was a ripoff of MW2. It's jarring to go from the "Three Kings"-like story about the gold and 4 stooges derping around Eastern Europe and risking their lives to get rich, but then switch to a darker, serious tone with really no relation to the first game besides a random conversation, when idle, about "what happened..."
I liked the first BC online "story" implying that word got out about gold and both sides are battling to get rich and AWOL the fuck out of there. After losing a match and hearing "Damn it! Now we are stuck working for the Army!" always made me chuckle.
Agreed 100% although I didn’t consider campaign for BC2 while discussing. It was too seriously taken and pretty mid as a campaign
dam i like 2042
It is hilarious how bad BF 2042 still runs on modern systems and your summary about the game is absolutely perfect, Battlefield 2042 is pure trash.
Yep
BF3 is quite of disappointment from me. Growing up with BF2 (despite playing it in internet cafe) and jump right to BF3, I see how far the gameplay was, seeing how casual it was. Blue filter made me nauseous. It bothered me so much that I'd switch BF3 for BF4. Not to mention excessive lightings in some occasion. It also introduce meat grinder maps. And to top that all, no offline game in MP maps.
And taking nitpick route, I am very disappointed for the lackluster factions. I was remembering how BF2 got USMC, PLA, and fictional MEC, and then adding US Navy SEAL, MEC SF, SAS, Spetsnaz, Rebel, and Insurgents, and hoping BF3 could take some of them. But no, there are only Russia and US. Jeez, not even the opposing force we faced in SP? Iranian military could get some spotlight as a new OPFOR. Plus, Russian speaking English. Why? BF2 with native language and "subtitle" in chat box was spot on. Russian's one liner is as if not more cringe than BF2042's operator one liner. Another reason to switch BF3 to BF4.
In the end, I think the one who deserves the S tier, beside BF2 and BF1 (I don't play BFBC2 much, though), is BF4.
Thats fair, BF3 did a lot to change fundamentally from BF2 but I still think its an incredible game in its own right. I can definitely understand why old school fans would be disappointed
I played every single battlefield, and the tierlist is quite accurate but to my taste:
S tier: BFBC2, BF2,BF3,BF4
A tier: BF1, BF2142, BFV
B tier: BF1942, BF Vietnam, BF1943, BF2042 (Absolute trash at start and did many things wrong but regained itself a little bit)
C tier: BF2 modern combat, BF Bad Company
D tier: Hardline(Its very solid but not a BF game)
Trash: BF Heroes, BF Play4Free(worst bf game i played)
The ideal game for me would be, a Battlefield game with the destruction and feeling of BFBC2, the management system of BF2, The graphics of BFV and experimental modes like the titan mode in BF2142 for example.
BF2042 really fucked up, trash specialist system, Maps horrible, You can tag the enemy that killed you when you die which is ridiculous, you can see the glance of a sniper from accros the map...., a game pure based on solo play in its majority. They left so many great systems out that they had in the previous games. Oh and they should quit the subscription crap and just keep it to expansions with all the rest unlockable by gameplay.
Yes yes. I am very aware what Battlefield 2 brought to the FPS genre. Hm. Indeed.
Yes of course you do..
If you put bf2 in S bf2142 has to objectively be A tier at least. In bf2 you rubber band while sprinting slightly uphill... and i have ptsd from Karkand nade spamming.
I miss battlefield 4 man
Still very much alive on PC
@@PungglesWith some troubleshooting
BF3 have better filing of war then BF 5 and 2042 i was disapointed with last 2 BF
Bad Company 2 is the best out of all the bf games
Personally i disagree with bf1 being on S tier, i think bf1 should be at C tier, bf 5 at A tier, and BF 4 at S tier, i played bf3 also, i didnt like it at all, i think bf3 should be C tier
you put hardline in d tier for not being a "battlefield" title but then go and put battlefield 1 in s stier... if battlefield hardline is in d tier (i think it's a c tier game) because it's not a good battlefield game, then with that same logic, battlefield 1 should be a or b tier. it's a great ww1 shooter with the best design of any world war game out there even to this day, but it was never a great "battlefield" game, let alone s tier worthy. battlefield fans of the time were saying this when it came out. i personally don't think it's anywhere near the level of battlefield 3 or bad company 2, let alone battlefield 2.
still remember how it was considered one of the worst entries into the franchise at the time, then it was battlefield V and now it's battlefield 2042... i bet once the next battlefield game comes out, everyone one will be calling battlefield 2042 an a or s tier game lol.
battlefield play4free was the best thing ever, you were just too young to understand that
Brother I’ve been playing these games since 1942 was in beta
Want to know why Battlebit is so successful? They copied BF2 almost 1:1 with Project Reality mechanics.
Blud puts BF1 above BF4.. Opinion rejected
For me BFV is on D (it's really near trash), Bf4 is on C and Hardline is on C. I judge these game while being neutral not emotional
I can definitely get the arguments for that, however BF4 as a C is interesting unless you consider how broken it was at launch.
@@Punggles I didn't test it when it first come out. But I put it on C because it was basically a downgrade of BF3, and BF3 was also a downgrade of Bad Company 2. So BF4 is a great game but for the Battlefield series it's not that great ! And it's also more arcade in it's gameplay.
For the online the better Battlefield is bad company 2.
Despite it’s many many flaws, 2042 is not a trash tier at all, I think you’re overexaggerating here. I don’t know when was the last time you played it but the game has insanely improved since launch. I have more than 800 hours in 2042 since the early days and I must say that at lauch it would be a D-tier, now after many updates, bug fixes, content drops, reworks, optimalizing, it’s a C-tier. No way 2042 should be in the same tier as those joke-of-a-games Heroes and Play4Free.
I play every season to check it out. Still trash imo. The game just feels bad man
At best D tier ..
I appreciate the comment, and okay maybe I was over-exaggerating a bit but I still stand by it being the worst mainline Battlefield game in the entire series. For me personally its more of how much it has destroyed the brand and any potential for things like BF Portal.
@@Pungglesthis abswer is an even worse take than the video itself...
@@thebigsam 🤷
по большей части все части батлфилд дерьмо
BF3 is B at most. 2142 is definitely A or S.
Kinda agree. I see it lower since it introduces meat-grinding maps. And it created a simpler gameplay.