That's an interesting criticism. What in particular would you say is toxic about this video? Is there a particular concept or claim, or anything specific that justifies the label for you?
Mister Opera is totally drowning in a sea of intense hatred and frustration, thinking he can bring everyone down, just like he did with the original TIO. And guess what? His video only got 7 likes. No surprise to me! Bullies like him always end up getting a dose of their own medicine. Double the drama, double the karma! 💅
Ok we get it, you don't like mister opera. But we did ask if anyone has anything specific, and it does look like nobody can name even one thing he's actually done or said wrong...
@@Thisisopera Oh, seriously? Like, duh! Nobody's into bullies. It's such a downer when people use this platform to spread hate. By the way, whoever is running this account seriously needs to stop promoting and defending hate. Let's keep it real, everyone should have the freedom to express themselves on their own channel, and no one has the right to shame them like that. Period!
Instead of ridiculing these individuals, who, by the way, I don't believe were informed that you used their video materials without their consent, it would have been truly helpful if you had created your own videos explaining the correct position of the tongue. You can educate your audience without harming anyone's reputation. I respect Mr. Sirianni, and I don't understand why he is featured in this clip without his consent. The truth is, This is opera, and it seems that I'm not the only one who shares this opinion. It has become highly irrelevant since this Mr. Opera took over. I have no idea whether you will consider my advice, but I believe you should start making genuinely useful videos and refrain from causing harm to anyone.
That's amazing how a concerned citizen showed up to defend these teachers. They must be so inspiring that they don't even need to defend themselves. The whole community will unite to defend their good names.
That makes sense Mister O. They are a vital part of the community and without them we wouldn't be in the second golden age of opera, totally unsure of what to do with all the surplus of old school singers who sound like Corelli, Tebaldi, Callas and Macneil.
"the tongue" can mean anywhere on an organ that can basically span the entire length of the vocal tract when all the parts are considered. It has more than one function in singing at the same time, and there's different sounds to be made. Mister Opera seems to be saying the idea of one universally best position is kind of retarded in the first place.
Hi! I watched your videos and i saw elena obraztsova as an example of proper singing,could you please listen to Tamara Sinyavskaya too, she is a close friend of Elena, when i listen to her i really don't understand if her technique is old school so i don't know if i should keep watching her masterclasses, i really like her but i need a professional's opinion
Ok great I'll take a look. I saw one that looked interesting, buy I'm not sure how to download the subtitles so we may have to watch it right off the internet for a live stream.
I learned a lot from the original TIO channel despite the litany of allegations against the former owner. My gripe with this video is that it doesn't seem to do anything but sow confusion. After watching a video like this, one should expect either to have a better grasp on the subject, or, at least, be able to decipher what the poster believes and wants us to take away. I'm honestly not sure what the curator of this video thinks is the right placement for the tongue after watching this, thus making real conversation about HOW to improve our understanding of this fundamental element of our technique unproductive.
@Thisisopera my apologies, if I thought you were someone else. My point regarding how confusing your video is remains. They're usually far more clear than this one. What should we as the audience have pulled from this video as the right position of the tongue?
@@DavidSmith-dl8jcthe channel did change ownership. They're lying to get you to trust them. It's mister opera (or another rando) running the channel now. Maybe TIO will come back someday. Thankfully we have TIO - archive !!
Toxic. Whoever stole this channel from the original owner is toxic indeed.
Totally agree!
That's an interesting criticism.
What in particular would you say is toxic about this video? Is there a particular concept or claim, or anything specific that justifies the label for you?
Mister Opera is totally drowning in a sea of intense hatred and frustration, thinking he can bring everyone down, just like he did with the original TIO. And guess what? His video only got 7 likes. No surprise to me! Bullies like him always end up getting a dose of their own medicine. Double the drama, double the karma! 💅
Ok we get it, you don't like mister opera.
But we did ask if anyone has anything specific, and it does look like nobody can name even one thing he's actually done or said wrong...
@@Thisisopera Oh, seriously? Like, duh! Nobody's into bullies. It's such a downer when people use this platform to spread hate. By the way, whoever is running this account seriously needs to stop promoting and defending hate. Let's keep it real, everyone should have the freedom to express themselves on their own channel, and no one has the right to shame them like that. Period!
Instead of ridiculing these individuals, who, by the way, I don't believe were informed that you used their video materials without their consent, it would have been truly helpful if you had created your own videos explaining the correct position of the tongue. You can educate your audience without harming anyone's reputation. I respect Mr. Sirianni, and I don't understand why he is featured in this clip without his consent. The truth is, This is opera, and it seems that I'm not the only one who shares this opinion. It has become highly irrelevant since this Mr. Opera took over. I have no idea whether you will consider my advice, but I believe you should start making genuinely useful videos and refrain from causing harm to anyone.
Molon labe
That's amazing how a concerned citizen showed up to defend these teachers. They must be so inspiring that they don't even need to defend themselves. The whole community will unite to defend their good names.
That makes sense Mister O. They are a vital part of the community and without them we wouldn't be in the second golden age of opera, totally unsure of what to do with all the surplus of old school singers who sound like Corelli, Tebaldi, Callas and Macneil.
I agree with you, this new Mister Opera channel is a complete non-sense … the videos are stupid and useless
@@iacobellus❤
And what is the best position for the tongue? I read in the book "your voice" that the tongue should be raised from the base.
"the tongue" can mean anywhere on an organ that can basically span the entire length of the vocal tract when all the parts are considered.
It has more than one function in singing at the same time, and there's different sounds to be made. Mister Opera seems to be saying the idea of one universally best position is kind of retarded in the first place.
Hi! I watched your videos and i saw elena obraztsova as an example of proper singing,could you please listen to Tamara Sinyavskaya too, she is a close friend of Elena, when i listen to her i really don't understand if her technique is old school so i don't know if i should keep watching her masterclasses, i really like her but i need a professional's opinion
Do you have a link to a specific video? We can watch it tonight on the stream.
th-cam.com/video/W4zKP6dcyp0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=GyQsTNG6idfbLOoA
This one id interesting also she still does masterclasses
Ok great I'll take a look. I saw one that looked interesting, buy I'm not sure how to download the subtitles so we may have to watch it right off the internet for a live stream.
I learned a lot from the original TIO channel despite the litany of allegations against the former owner. My gripe with this video is that it doesn't seem to do anything but sow confusion.
After watching a video like this, one should expect either to have a better grasp on the subject, or, at least, be able to decipher what the poster believes and wants us to take away. I'm honestly not sure what the curator of this video thinks is the right placement for the tongue after watching this, thus making real conversation about HOW to improve our understanding of this fundamental element of our technique unproductive.
This account has not changed ownership since it was created. There are no "allegations" against us that we are aware of.
@Thisisopera my apologies, if I thought you were someone else. My point regarding how confusing your video is remains. They're usually far more clear than this one. What should we as the audience have pulled from this video as the right position of the tongue?
This one is highlighting how confusing the voice teachers are.
@@DavidSmith-dl8jcthe channel did change ownership. They're lying to get you to trust them. It's mister opera (or another rando) running the channel now. Maybe TIO will come back someday. Thankfully we have TIO - archive !!