@@tokyodriftmon2014 Idk, to be fair, until Germa 66 came in to the picture, Sanji really did feel kinda one note and annoying. I can see where he's coming from in that regard. Its the same thing that bothers me about Chopper and Nami who just seem to kinda be there. Chopper especially kinda devolved into a mascot.
@@wmzer0mw Sanji has a lot of great moments like the mr prince in alabasta arc, the train sequence in enies lobby, he was able to think ahead and closed the gate in enies lobby and he was also great in skypea. He was my second favorite right after Luffy up until the thriller bark arc where he just fell off from there. It's still impressive that he was willing to be taken by Kuma to save the crew but Zoro's "nothing happened" just eclipsed it.
@@mdfarooq2317 9 months and no answer nor likes, just replying so you feel the dread of having basically nobody on your side ((wtf did you expect, it's a one piece channel))
holy shit, was that killer-b comparison bad.... thats like saying, wow the characters in this show are strong, but they are not AS strong as goku, since he can destroys planets, therefor its bad and pointless, i cant even...
@PP - 06MA 824124 Roberta Bondar PS I don't want to make a big argument but Goku can destroy universes in his base form, Saiyan arc Goku could destroy luffy in a millisecond watch all versions of Goku Vs all versions of superman to get a grasp on how strong Goku is.
@PP - 06MA 824124 Roberta Bondar PS it was shown in his fight against kaido future sight means shit if you aren't fast enough to dodge the attack so let's end this argument.
I don’t know if it’s because i love one piece but i just can’t imagine someone being able to properly seriously criticize the world building in this anime
@@userseef9314 naw if you watch other long running shonen they all fail in this aspect. Imo one piece is so good because unlike other shonen Oda is actually able to keep up with his own world. Naruto, Dragon Ball, and Bleach all suffer from introducing too many characters and not exploring enough of each one. One piece on the other usually uses each character to their fullest and they don’t just get forgotten.
As soon as he was like "The big problem with One Piece is the world building" I was like... Ah. I found your problem. You don't like the core concept of this series and you probably should have stopped following the series after Alabasta at the latest
I'm only 280 chapters into this story but everytime Luffy makes that first stand against the villain of the arc it literally puts a smile on my face. Luffy is hilarious, inspiring, and a goddammit badass
That's what i did punk hazard was the straw that broke the camels back for me had to switch to the manga and realised i actually hated the anime now enjoying the series much more than before
He didnt. He got to buggy, quit then ran to the wiki. He's guilty of what I call presumptive reviewing - the IGN technique.Sure he didn't read do the work but he wanted to call it onePISS He doesnt get the pacing because he never read past orange town he just says "look at all these episodes the world building must suck" hence why it's incoherent. He doesn't get the characters aside from their snippets on the Wiki. brook must be interesting if you just read a wiki of him. Found a criticism online and threw it in there.
Sbs is one of evidence how oda care about his reader. There he doing random qna, spoil something he want to spoil or joking around with his fans. He also liked to include fan art as part of onepiece volume/tankobon and recent chapter feel like oda playing around with fandom expectation.
@@andreaskarlsson5251 i do agree for episodes but for chapters i dont feel the same. Senor pink backstory might be feel like that since it just interesting backstory.
While he was arguing about that he even gave us a time frame, the first 50 episodes Which are like the first... 20 chapters or smth like that I can definetely see Oda in 1998 being so greedy for money that he'd do anything to... Wait what was his point again? Oh right, it didn't make any sense
He's basically saying that since it's good, no need to prolong it. Like heck? It obviously had to. Because if Oda cut the story, it won't be good anymore. I mean, he has been cutting story already, but that's already how much he can compromise. Any more attempt to shorten the show would compromise the quality of the story.
There's no way this guy got far enough into OP to actually get to Haki or Brook. I have a hard time believing if they even watched the 50 eps they mentioned early on.
"The most thorough, least thought out review" is a combination of words I could never think of myself, but my god is it a perfect way to describe this review.
My theory is that this guy feels obligated to watch OP bc his friends or some girl he likes watches it. In that scenario he watches the whole thing but hates every second of it
I don't believe this person actually watched all of One Piece, calling Sanji just One Piece's Brock and "just a generic character" I'll admit, refusing to deck some girl trying to kill him is kind of annoying. The constant horny Sanji has gotten old, but I would never say Sanji is a generic character.
Yeah cause I don't like one piece at all but the aníme fan in me has me checking in on the series every once in a while just so I can say I finished it(manga only now cause anime was never my thing)
I kinda feel bad for him, because that's how I feel about HxH and it's just so...incredibly mediocre and outright weak in comparison to almost any other shounen I've watched, _especially_ OP. But now it's too late to back out so I'm at a point where I'm kind of starting to hate it because even though I'd "objectively" consider it pretty decent, the fact that I'm forced to continue watching something I know just isn't for me when normally I'd say "hey, this is fine but not my cup of tea" is just...causing so much frustration x.x
i mean comparatively youll see things like "i was having a ton fo fun but the small distractions ruined the whole experience" in regards to game reviews. or the people who say "i spent thousands of hours having a blast but on retrospect it sucked"
“To make you feel that you are on a long journey” ...they _are_ on a long journey? That’s kinda the point? This guy makes it sound like they expect a homeless jobless child to become a millionaire in a week. It’s just not possible. Luffy is fighting strong people with his friends to become top of the world of course it’s gonna be long. I would lose interest if there was an anime that beats the villains in a short amount of time. Edit: Fairy Tale came AFTER One Piece. Edit 2: I am raging Chopper is my favourite character.
It’s like the dude took a comment about bad pacing and copy pasted it 12 times while simultaneously using a thesaurus for everything and Google translating it four more times per iteration.
I wanna say something. The world of one piece is huge and intresting and always amazing to see. I can agree that sometimes an arc can drag on but, the world building is so great, and at many parts is more important then the characters themselves. Examples being, the huge elephant that the animal people live on(completely forgot there name for some reason), the red line, the all blue, fishman island, and more.
It’s more likely if the person is just first getting into the anime, and they’re an anime watcher only, but they don’t want to read the manga until the anime is finished then that person should watch the first animated special then watch the episodes of the Luffy, Zoro, Usopp, and Nami crossing the Redline then watch the Alabasta special, then the Skypia special, then the Enies Lobby Special, then watch the anime from the Sabadody Arc to the MarnieFord Arc, then the Dressora special until it gets to the part of the end of that Special, and it goes back to the fight with Doflamgino and Luffy, and then watch from Zou all the way to the current Arc in Wano.
@@olavotoledo8870, I find my way the easiest to watch through all of One Piece if people don’t have the time to watch through all 952-953 episodes, and the animated specials are more closer to the manga stories than the episodes of the official anime itself.
@Anonymous individual, I plan on reading all of the One Piece manga series after I buy all of the box sets to do so because I’ve already watched the anime series, and the anime/manga series is great from I’ve seen of it.
5:00 To me they are fundamentally different. FMA and Death Note are very tightly written and are really 1 story. One Piece is much more loosely written and is not really meant to be 1 story. Rather it's a whole series of stories with a throughline connecting them together. To me One Piece largely feels like an episodic show where the episodes flow.
@@MrMarinus18 I disagree because arcs like enies lobby benefit from water 7, marineford benefits from impel down. What the other guy said about it being a saga is a much better way of putting it but I do get what you mean.
It's interesting to me because a lot of the things he criticizes aside from the pacing are things that I love about the series. I think Luffy, Zoro, and Sanji's antics are extremely entertaining, and the world building is slow but it definitely gives the feel of a much larger world beyond Luffy and his crew
“it definitely gives the feel of a much larger world beyond luffy and his crew” yea, ive noticed that thats why i dont complain on its slow pacing because what you said makes up for it
"Why can't One Piece be like FMA or Death Note, in being that they have their whole stories in less episodes?" Simple, because these other Shonen were already finished by the time the anime adaptations were rolling around, if One Piece was already up to the time skip when they started the anime there would probably only be like 200 episodes since it had enough content for that many episodes, the reason that there's 950+ episodes is because Toei keep catching up with the ongoing manga for like 21 years now, so they only use 1 chapter at a time to keep it going weekly for so long, unlike a series like JoJo's Bizarre Adventure which is already adapting a finished work, fitting around 3-4 chapters worth of material per episode.
@@koatam but at the same time does FMAB or death note have the world building of one piece and the list goes on, different lengths suit differently depending on what you as a writer want to add to the story, death note is an intense thriller,FMAB has a tightly knit narrative
There is that. Also that One Piece is quite different story altogether. I think after a decade of finishing the manga we will have a fillerless 400-450 episode anime (of course that depends on how long one Piece will run).
I think The anime should Be around 600-700 Episodes. That's basically every awkward standstill now removed from The story along with useless still shots and VERY slow wideshots
I liked one piece simply hated that there was a lack of danger. Even when people died they usually come back. So it was hard to feel for the characters when they were in “danger”
One sentence for that guy "Luffy is Stretchable and so the story is giving us more of its extended contents of empathy and its own bizarre way of presenting."
Well I could think of an old man with a backwards cap and jean shorts trying to skate board with teens. That would be someone trying to be a young man. But yeah guy writing the review doesn't have a great grasp of words and their meanings.
Obviously this is a clever joke about Luffy being voiced by a woman in Japanese... either that or the person who wrote the review is kind of a moron. To quote: "Take your pick."
“Wannabe.” I’m pretty sure Luffy has shown that he’s very child like but when it comes to the fights of One Piece with Luffy look at the amount of bloody battles he’s gone through. Luffy against Lucci is the best example in my opinion. That was one hell of a fight. And if I’m correct, Luffy then was 17 years old. So yeah... hardly a “wannabe.” - He is.
Hahaha. The guy that wrote that was actually pretty popular or let's say infamous, in the anime websites like 10 years ago. He slated most shounen anime and truth is he had some fair points about them and produced some pretty funny lines. He did have reviews like these for all popular shounen anime, and they were all... let's say pretty negative! He got abuse from fanboys/girls and defended his views in a fierce way. Well it was pretty funny from a spectator point of view. His profiles are now private and he got banned from some forums but with some googling you can still find some of his reviews. I won't name him for privacy reasons, but if you were floating around the anidb community back in the day, you can't have missed this guy.
@@vinsmokejadzki7346 I know I was Just saying that cause female character design argument is very controversial and I wanted to say it made sense for them
This is a rule: if a guy doesn't like One Piece, you can mistrust him, unless he hasn't seen it yet, because that's a chance for you to convert a new fan
seen? Are you an Anime watcher? What's that like? From what I've seen from the anime it holds up alright compared to others but that's only because Oda is such a massive genius that even if only a % ends up in the Anime it still ends up being pretty good. If you read the manga tho you're as close to Oda's head as you can get and it's amazing. Not to mention you're behind like 50 chapters at all times when restricted to Anime. I'm just not sure if I would recommend anyone to watch the OnePiece anime start to finish. That's just a massive undertaking riddled with fillers and dragged manga scenes. But reading 1000 chapters? That's doable, also very enjoyable ;D.
@@Broockle I watched the anime this year and pre timeskip it isn't difficult to get through. Getting someone into the series through the anime is perfectly fine IMO and by the time it becomes an issue most people will be invested enough to keep going. Dressrosa was painful though.
i didnt like the show based on the length and its genre. GLR convinced me to give it a chance and im glad i did. however i will argue that for a single narrative as opposed to multiple narratives in the same universe its a bit long. based on my limited experience with manga expecting someone to read that much story to appreciate it is not feasible. its like the people arguing FF13 gets good after 20 hours. and one pieces average hook point of baratie based on everything ive seen is hard to justify
I may be wrong but I get the feeling English isn’t the dominant language of the person who wrote this hence the nonsensical aspects of it as it probably went through a web translator.
Ice and speed are the same thing. You could say Aokiji does snow/blow. Based on his personality though it would be either weed or opiates. Same with Kizaru, ironically
2:12 Lmao I can just imagine a Shakspearean actor doing a monologue like that "Is this a dagger which I see before me, The handle toward my hand - Dammit! Why does Oda hate Sanji?!: - Come, let me clutch thee"
"To be, or not to be, that is the question, Whether 'tis nobler in the mind to suffer, The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune, Or to take arms against a sea of troubles, And by opposing end them? To die: to sleep; No more; and by a sleep to say we hit the nail on that one"
*critic The critique is the criticism itself that a critic forms around whatever it is which they are criticizing. It doesn’t make much sense to describe an individual as being a “critique”
@@زينبعقيلي-ط1ب no problem, I figured it was a sincere mistake, which is why I gave a brief explanation to help you understand the difference since the words are so similar. I hate English speakers who get offended or impatient with others who don’t fully grasp the language. I hope my original correction didn’t come off as condescending or rude. If it did, then I apologize Huh that’s weird there seems to be a glitch where when I’m typing out my comment on my phone, your username is at the very beginning of the comment, before all the text. Yet once I upload the comment, your name suddenly shifts near the end of the first line. I can’t seem to fix it
It's honestly amazing that this guy can watch the whole one piece while hating it and write a 2000 word essay about it. It almost feels like he's actually enjoying it but looking for attention
My only real problem with one piece is that the first half of each episode in the anime version is basically a recap of the previous episode. It sometimes take so long that part of the recap of the previous episode gets included in the current recap.
Thats a problem of an anime that adapts an ongoing manga, they have to keep the gap between the ongoing chapter and the anime episode so the episode wont catch up to the manga, that's why they sometimes stretch and drag the episode and why there is filler and the 4-5 mins recap to make the episode adapt the chapter as less as possible but to keep it as 20 mins episode, but in reality its just a 15-17 mins of episode. Just read the manga if you annoyed with that
@@juliuism its not even 15 minutes, you can often trim episodes down to less than 5 minutes of actual content! and yeah i dont watch the anime ._. I just cant, its too painful, if i had to review one piece based off the anime alone, id sound just like the guy grandlinereview is talking about in this specific video, thank god i love the manga to death, no complaints whatsoever everything is perfect my eyes are rose tinted for the manga, its kinda insane to me how toei animation can make the worst adaption iv ever seen, based off the best manga iv ever read… okay that might be my feelings exaggerating, i probably have seen worse but you know the anime deserves a lot of criticism.
Obviously this reviewer hasn't even read One Piece. He merely read some trivia about it and decided to make an opinion based on what he think is going on.
It’s absolutely some child who made this, the way they type is just completely embarrassing, “Sanji is like brock from pokemon” pretty much confirms this, like seriously lol
Homestly thinking tho, he had actual critisism about the series but just didn't know to present them and also he just didn't understand some concepts. I mean, I've heard worse from other people but I've never seen a worse review.
to me thats what haki is...a stall tactic by shounen jump forced upon oda to make his series redo the power system from devil fruits to something more badass so they have a easy to market ability with a name like nen spirit energy ki or chakra... ...we didn't need haki to get a good show...that changed the show and ruined the fights imo....its so stupid and came out of nowhere an made the show longer...
@@razkable Personally I kind of dislike haki because it made devil fruits less impactful. It used to be way more fun seeing people come up with creative ways to beat logia users rather than simply hitting them with enhanced arms. Sure Oda needed something to make logias less overpowered but I don't think that haki was the right answer.
Plus the introduction of haki comes so late into the series. I wish it was introduced earlier. The issue especially being Ace vs Smoker, where he says that the fight will be neverending because their DFs cancel each other out. That basically ignores the existence of armament haki, and Ace has been confirmed to have all 3 haki types.
@@scrollingdownonlytofindcom2663 confirmed to have ≠ confirmed to be able to use it properly, that's just how I see it. Example:- Luffy pre-timeskip has been shown to be able to use both conquerors and observation, but he didn't know what Haki was nor was he aware that he used conquerors until Rayleigh brought it up.
@@scrollingdownonlytofindcom2663 Haki WAS introduced earlier, all the way back from Luffy's flashback with Shanks, Shanks used Conquerors Haki very early on when the sea monster tried to come after him a second time, it was already foreshadowed, just explored much later on.
I'm pretty sure the "greedy approach" this guy meant was that the show is long because the Manaka wants to make more money thus intentionally drags the series without actual progress. this is wrong for so many level for One Piece if he had read the manga himself. the pacing is great and even compact with no unnecessary panels.
If that is what he meant then thats very ignorant bc the creator of HxH has serious health issues so he cant push out chapters like that and without chapters theres no episodes bc the want to keep a gap so that it doesn’t end up like op with filler episodes
@@zerokura yea binging one piece isnt that bad even the fillers and specials kind of fly by. The one time the story dragged for me was the whole enies lobby saga
@@jayydexter also if someone wants a quick run down of what happens the Pirates warriors games do a great job with that.the 4th one have a fun wano ending to it but you miss side characters and the guy who betrays white beard becomes a common mob character not like how they look in the manga but they still tell the story pretty well and fast.
as someone who enjoys writing a lot, to "stall" in certain arcs or episodes and stil having your story be that good is fk hard. writing an arc and "stalling" is something I and probably a lot of writers have a lot of trouble with. side note, when i say stalling i mean continuing an arc for longer than planned from a writers POV/expected from an audience POV. you have to come up with new dialogue, plot points, fight scenes and sometimes even whole characters. that is fk difficult. he also mentions that its a weakness on the writers point. my boi Oda foreshadowed something from chapter 400+ in chapter 1. not only that but he also was "stalling" before it was revealed?! the amount of patience this author has is incredible. there is not a single character or plot point in the series that doesnt have a purpose. Lola was introduced in Thriller Bark and she became very important 400 chapters later in Whole Cake while not even appearing in that arc for the most part. also also, like i said "stalling" is not a good critisism for a show this good. it is able to make 1000 chapters of very consistent and good quality is something very few manage to do. a story that i have been working on for years now, i only expect it to have 50 chapters max, and i havent even started writing it yet. also also also, i think its funny how people critisize the show and pretend to be a genius big brain critic, meanwhile the show is one of if not the most popular and best received show in its genre style, medium, and even country. its one of the most critically acclaimed manga of all time meanwhile you are in your bedroom crying about how the worldbuilding of the anime is ruining the pacing of said anime and how that is somehow the fault of the... mangaka? nevermind, forget everything I said, his favorite straw hat is Brook... I see he's a man of culture
maybe saying the reviewer is a naruto fanboy is an overgeneralization, but he was definitely lying about liking One Piece, he obviously said that in an attempt to make himself sound objective, but in reality, he's probably a fan of another shounen and trying to undermine One Piece, that's my assumption, and I'm not gonna say that it's probably a naruto fan, but I'm just saying, he probably is edit: I just finished the video, the reference to killer bee, the implication that he probably wants villains that people can sympathize with (just like with Zabuza, Haku, Pain, etc.) now I'm still not gonna say that he's definitely a Naruto fanboy, but the evidence points towards it
@@user-vf3rn8cp5o bruh I was talking about the reviewer, why don’t you conform to society and learn to read just like most of us with a functioning brain
@Anonymous individual i want to agree with you, but dora's worldbuilding is to deep for main brain capacity. So i dont want to make a wrong assumption.
Dora's world have forest as a hub to go anywhere you want, animal who at least bilingual, talking bag, paper map with gps features, blue pointer, and also the world is galaxy level big since stars can hiding in the bush or tree in this world.
It's kind of sad that the guy who requested this rebuttal had to rely on a big One Piece youtuber's authority to defend his beloved series instead of just doing it himself and going on with his life. While the critique wasn't well put together at all, it just reeks of someone reading a negative review of something he loved, not liking it, not being able to make a decent defense by himself, and asking for validation from someone he gives authority to, a big youtube, in the form of a video responding to the review and validating his opinion. Also, ideally, the shorter a story is and the more efficient it is in communicating information and events, the better. Obviously not every series can or should be reduced to a 12-24 episode run but still, they should always strive to at least not drag on. And as GLR admitted in the Wano being the worst arc video, the story does do that at some points, which is bad craft. And that's without mentioning filler, which isn't really the fault of the story itself or the author but is a fault of the anime. Finally, world-building and pacing are related to one another. To show a new part of the world and how it functions, the main plotline usually has to slow down as to not overwhelm the reader/watcher. This means that usually, world-building in the short term is harmful to the immediate progression of the main plot, altho it usually makes the plotline better in the long term. Again, this was admitted in the Wano video.
I started with 4kids thats how i got into one piece back in the day.though i still thought they say gotta go gotta go in the rap not the pirate yada oh since i thought gotta go sounds better because its hurry up their adventures to do feeling to it.
@@heyoyo10gaming4 haha dont remember do remember sanji have a Brooklyn accent that was fun.did found out franky voice actor in funimation is same actor for nekomaru from danganronpa 2 plus is monokid from v3 so now i can picture franky yellowing its a Suuuppppeeerrrrr rager sssshhhhiiiiitttttt!!!!! Lol
IF this reviewer was able to give an arc-by-arc analysis of what they think is the problem in the first three arcs that keeps a viewer from either getting invested in the characters or staying invested in the overall conclusion of the story, then I would be willing to give them some point. We often say that you gotta give an anime 3 episodes to explain itself, and you WILL be hooked if you make it to Ep 7. And in a shonen ADVENTURE story, I appreciate "First 3 arcs analysis" from YTers. How does Naruto's first three arcs stack up to engaging the audience? How well does Bleach transition from slice-of-life with ghosts to a full action story? Yes, One Piece's beginning has a lot of filler episodes. But the actual story: the additions of Zoro, our Lord and Savior Usopp, Nami, Sanji, and Tony Tony Chopper are incredibly engaging stories that I have not yet seen a YT reactor not enjoy. And once this team is assembled, how they fight for Alabasta and against Crocodile is amazing. IF they made a genuine argument that the pacing of this 1999 anime was hurt by too much filler and pacing that robs from some enjoyment of how this family, this nakama, became, then I could give them some credit for actually having a point. But they don't do that. They compare One Piece and Hunter x Hunter, shonen ADVENTURE STORIES, to Death Note, a seinen psychological thriller and Fullmetal Alchemist, a shonen political thriller. No self-awareness of how completely off the mark it is to criticize the genre for its own purpose, to the point of saying the "flaw" he sees in One Piece, he sees in most shonen anime, and he blames it on economic troubles. I get it. This review likes thrillers. He likes the fast pace and crisp attention to detail of a story that is meant to grip you with plot tit-for-tat and not let go. Why settle for Death Note and Fullmetal? Magika Madoka is 13 episodes! FLCL (was) six episodes! It's clear that this reviewer simply doesn't like adventure stories, and has no idea how to simply say THAT. Who watches the Straw Hats walk to Arlong Park or Luffy's third battle against Crocodile and wonders, "So, when are they going to find One Piece?"
These are the worst. Claiming to actually like something, so that their rant suddenly becomes more legitimate. They dont even have the backbone to admit their dislikes.
FMA brotherhood is the worst example you could give as the first few episodes have very few details that are arguably needed even cutting out full arcs from the manga towards the start of the story
BRUH YES! what did he just use a thesaurus to make his words better, because even so, his sentences don't even make sense. It's like mixing up words in a sentence. Like...BRO...just like you said, Fix his own sentence structure before criticizing another persons writing
To be fair, you don't actually need to be able to draw even stick figures to be able to recognise great art. ... You probably should learn basic communication skills, if you wish to share your thoughts, though.
So this guy at least got to the point in the series where they explain King's Haki, or give it a name for the first time. When was that? Amazon Lily? And he still doesn't grasp other basic concepts of One Piece, and doesn't understand characters, Devil Fruits or the villains character development. Wow. Amazing... That's a feat in itself. Watching blindfolded
Wow they make so much sense. Their review was so much better than Grand Line Review. I am now going to stop watching One Piece after this, I can't believe I was wasting my time.
"I like it but in all honesty it isn't good" Huh, my boyfriend has said this exact same thing about pizza before 😂 I asked him to explain himself and got a similarly inexplicable explanation about texture and flavor and nutritional value....
His points are like: 1) i hate pirates 2) i hate kings 3) i hate magical fruits 4) i don't understand what the "world building" is 5) i don't understand the concept of "intimidation aura" 6) women 7) forcing myself to watch the show 8) the episode is too slow 9) the anime is too long 10) the main character is too childish for my taste 11) not enough swords 12) the overall sound design is so-so 13) i can't feel for the characters (see above for reasons why) 14) (aren't i amazing at writing reviews)? 15) i won't explain anything Proves that anyone can be an anime reviewer. No special skills needed. Only the ability to write basic sentences.
I think... I THINK... that this person is saying the story is longer than it needs to be for the sake of earning lots of money by making lots of books for fans to buy, when Oda could apparently just end it quickly by having the Straw Hats get to Laugh Tale immediately.
Probably. But that just shows that 1. he doesn't understand the core concept of One Piece 2. didn't really read/watch long shounens (I think he didn't read One Piece at all) 3. fails to understand any storytelling I wonder what his thoughts are on Got and Lotr.
Finally, no sponsor (even though they are good) But my time seems to have come, ladies and gentlemen, get ready, for me, to be, PINNED!!!
Woo hooo next time it's my turn!!! 😂
My wishes have been answered, thank you, Liam!
Woah you got pinned congrats!
Gg m8, and may you never win again
@@Evarq_ yay i remember u from the old video remember me?? :)
this review is what Roger was laughing at Laughtale
hahaha thats a good one mate
ps: dr. yogi bitch
touche
Lmao
😂😂😂😂
XD
I hope the dude who wrote this review finds this video somehow.
well... there are 12 dislikes at this point... XD
Yeah true
I hope people don't harrass him over this, even though he seems to be an asshat.
@@hansnase364 I agree. He might have been drunk or on drugs while writing this.
He sounds like an egdy 13 year old to me
This is like Judge criticizing Sanji in front of Luffy. Everything he pointed out is what we love
"I'm probably not the only one" yeah im sure you are
@@tokyodriftmon2014 Idk, to be fair, until Germa 66 came in to the picture, Sanji really did feel kinda one note and annoying. I can see where he's coming from in that regard. Its the same thing that bothers me about Chopper and Nami who just seem to kinda be there. Chopper especially kinda devolved into a mascot.
@@wmzer0mw Sanji has a lot of great moments like the mr prince in alabasta arc, the train sequence in enies lobby, he was able to think ahead and closed the gate in enies lobby and he was also great in skypea. He was my second favorite right after Luffy up until the thriller bark arc where he just fell off from there. It's still impressive that he was willing to be taken by Kuma to save the crew but Zoro's "nothing happened" just eclipsed it.
Mid piece
@@mdfarooq2317 9 months and no answer nor likes, just replying so you feel the dread of having basically nobody on your side ((wtf did you expect, it's a one piece channel))
holy shit, was that killer-b comparison bad....
thats like saying, wow the characters in this show are strong, but they are not AS strong as goku, since he can destroys planets, therefor its bad and pointless,
i cant even...
loltrue
“He cant even destroy a lousy planet” -Shithead
“I destroyed your mother which is a much bigger accomplishment” -My crappy comeback
Can he beat goku tho
@PP - 06MA 824124 Roberta Bondar PS I don't want to make a big argument but Goku can destroy universes in his base form, Saiyan arc Goku could destroy luffy in a millisecond watch all versions of Goku Vs all versions of superman to get a grasp on how strong Goku is.
@PP - 06MA 824124 Roberta Bondar PS it was shown in his fight against kaido future sight means shit if you aren't fast enough to dodge the attack so let's end this argument.
of all the things you cant criticise the world building in one piece..
yep, there is nothing that even comes close to that of one piece in that aspect.
I don’t know if it’s because i love one piece but i just can’t imagine someone being able to properly seriously criticize the world building in this anime
@@userseef9314 naw if you watch other long running shonen they all fail in this aspect. Imo one piece is so good because unlike other shonen Oda is actually able to keep up with his own world. Naruto, Dragon Ball, and Bleach all suffer from introducing too many characters and not exploring enough of each one. One piece on the other usually uses each character to their fullest and they don’t just get forgotten.
@@apostle9209 i'd say the old canon of Star Wars comes a close second but yea, Oda is the king of world building.
As soon as he was like "The big problem with One Piece is the world building" I was like... Ah. I found your problem. You don't like the core concept of this series and you probably should have stopped following the series after Alabasta at the latest
I'm only 280 chapters into this story but everytime Luffy makes that first stand against the villain of the arc it literally puts a smile on my face. Luffy is hilarious, inspiring, and a goddammit badass
Thank you kind sir. Also question, where am i? What is this endless white void of random performances and comments?
@@Luffy-un5du uhhh did you follow zoro again?
@@sinpfiec1047 but where is zoro?
@@nalaikou9742 probably got lost again
Lmao when he said luffy is a "dumbass and raging constipated man child" I can imagine most one piece fans thinking that's what we love about him
This reviewer is literally the embodiment of “my mom says I’m funny so it must be true”
Lol true
r/rareinsults
Holy shit.
I almost choked while laughing when i read this Lol🤣
That’s true
imagine watching 900+ episodes on a show you don't even like.
That's what i did punk hazard was the straw that broke the camels back for me had to switch to the manga and realised i actually hated the anime now enjoying the series much more than before
He didnt. He got to buggy, quit then ran to the wiki. He's guilty of what I call presumptive reviewing - the IGN technique.Sure he didn't read do the work but he wanted to call it onePISS
He doesnt get the pacing because he never read past orange town he just says "look at all these episodes the world building must suck" hence why it's incoherent.
He doesn't get the characters aside from their snippets on the Wiki. brook must be interesting if you just read a wiki of him.
Found a criticism online and threw it in there.
@@xavmanisdabestest thats basically 90% of manga readers I think. The best way is probably to watch until timeskip and then change to the manga. Imo
@@akiakos this is what i keep trying to tell my older brother who is still trying to catch up to the wano arc
i mean iv tried to watch naruto like 3 times cant get past episode 50 i just get bored however iv rewatched one piece for years lol
Unironically "I don't want to learn more about this Doctor Yogi Bitch" is one of the greatest lines ever written
NO ITS NOT
@@marco7gold574 it's funny
it so is i was sold on this guy when he said that
imagine thinking Oda is writing One Piece this long for the money when he's already the wealthiest mangaka ever
Sbs is one of evidence how oda care about his reader. There he doing random qna, spoil something he want to spoil or joking around with his fans. He also liked to include fan art as part of onepiece volume/tankobon and recent chapter feel like oda playing around with fandom expectation.
@@mutesgraveyard6733 To be fair, some chapters/episodes sure do feel like a moneygrubbing moneygrub. xD
@@andreaskarlsson5251 i do agree for episodes but for chapters i dont feel the same. Senor pink backstory might be feel like that since it just interesting backstory.
While he was arguing about that he even gave us a time frame, the first 50 episodes
Which are like the first... 20 chapters or smth like that
I can definetely see Oda in 1998 being so greedy for money that he'd do anything to... Wait what was his point again? Oh right, it didn't make any sense
@@mutesgraveyard6733 Well, its all subjective. :D
“If this cake is so good, why does it need to be so big?”
Bro , that legit sums up this bad review .
If anyone asks why one piece is too long then you should say this comment to them 😀😀😀
Obviously a tiny portion of said cake should be able to satisfy a truly cultured individual like himself
He's basically saying that since it's good, no need to prolong it.
Like heck? It obviously had to. Because if Oda cut the story, it won't be good anymore. I mean, he has been cutting story already, but that's already how much he can compromise. Any more attempt to shorten the show would compromise the quality of the story.
@@seulgi1211 and he complains why it's so popular basically. Probably cause so many people love it, and it's the largest selling comic in the world
There's no way this guy got far enough into OP to actually get to Haki or Brook. I have a hard time believing if they even watched the 50 eps they mentioned early on.
His opening statement sounds exactly like *I'm not racist but*
true
Frr
right
Or just no offence but
“I hate to be that guy here”
*Proceeds to be that guy, possibly worse..*
One piece makes me happy.
Until Oda decides to cut your heart, chop it to pieces and then proceed to dance over it.
One piece is not bad
:)
@@karandev9316 aka Oda performs Mess on your emotions
Thats all we need to know
"I don't want to learn more about this doctor yogi bitch"
- Chad, the art of quotes
"The most thorough, least thought out review" is a combination of words I could never think of myself, but my god is it a perfect way to describe this review.
My theory is that this guy feels obligated to watch OP bc his friends or some girl he likes watches it. In that scenario he watches the whole thing but hates every second of it
I don't believe this person actually watched all of One Piece, calling Sanji just One Piece's Brock and "just a generic character"
I'll admit, refusing to deck some girl trying to kill him is kind of annoying. The constant horny Sanji has gotten old, but I would never say Sanji is a generic character.
Yeah cause I don't like one piece at all but the aníme fan in me has me checking in on the series every once in a while just so I can say I finished it(manga only now cause anime was never my thing)
@@SagaEf I like sanjis weakness
I kinda feel bad for him, because that's how I feel about HxH and it's just so...incredibly mediocre and outright weak in comparison to almost any other shounen I've watched, _especially_ OP. But now it's too late to back out so I'm at a point where I'm kind of starting to hate it because even though I'd "objectively" consider it pretty decent, the fact that I'm forced to continue watching something I know just isn't for me when normally I'd say "hey, this is fine but not my cup of tea" is just...causing so much frustration x.x
@@sleepysera just stop watching it, man
He legit said world building is one piece's weakness.....Never have i laughed so hard
"I like it,but in all honesty its not good."
SPEECH 100
It could be a guilty pleasure for him idk..
Bruh I hear the shitty MHA fandom say their anime is better but i just cringe because its so damn predictable
@@onyxxvenom9198lol. mha was good, at least the first three seasons, but the the fourth season was not only mid, but kinda bad.
@@mediatech1588 that Your opinion but I like one piece of the beginning
i mean comparatively youll see things like "i was having a ton fo fun but the small distractions ruined the whole experience" in regards to game reviews. or the people who say "i spent thousands of hours having a blast but on retrospect it sucked"
A guy that obviously doesn't know anything about the topic he's hating on. Well that makes a large percentage of internet discussions nowadays.
Yeah i had a guy say he watched 300 episodes, and he didn’t need to watch more to get it.
Even though I know nothing about you, I will hate on you.
@@koatam Right, thats what the critic was basically saying
Ok but you're wrong because you couldn't beat Goku in a fight
Cough cough*flat earthers anti vaxer*cough cough
this is the guy that "only watched like 100 eps" but had to look up most of everything to write the review
Imagine how miserable someone can be, to become jealous of one of the most famous animated heroes in the world
It felt like he was Zoro, just with words, thoughts and logic.
Yes this is what i think he actually did and is evident enough by the way how he described haki and luffy as a character
They need to watch all the episodes before they could give a proper criticism of this massive story
The reviewer sounds like they love One piece but they were paid to slander it
Nah, the reviewer sounds like a Narutard who's pretending to like One Piece to try to come off as objective.
@@McMannigan Also very possible😂
@@McMannigan Naruto is my favorite anime but I love one piece too its my second fav.
@@McMannigan well naruto is long
@@McMannigan I love Naruto, yet One Piece is my favourite anime 🤔 I don't understand this generalization of Naruto fans
This reads like one of Uwe Boll's reviews, I love it.
I want this dude to write a book about stuff he doesn't like, I will buy it.
Didn't expected you into One Piece
@@phantomgamer4463 Fax
Make videos again or explain why you don't.
😂😂😂😂😂😂
To DigbyTheGoat cool interesting profile picture & name 👍
“To make you feel that you are on a long journey”
...they _are_ on a long journey? That’s kinda the point? This guy makes it sound like they expect a homeless jobless child to become a millionaire in a week. It’s just not possible. Luffy is fighting strong people with his friends to become top of the world of course it’s gonna be long. I would lose interest if there was an anime that beats the villains in a short amount of time.
Edit: Fairy Tale came AFTER One Piece.
Edit 2: I am raging Chopper is my favourite character.
People dont want long animes anymore even tho its what makes one piece great because Oda can really go deep with each character :(
One piece would have become one punch kid
@@philippezevenberg1332 lazy kids nowadays... can't even touch grass
Senna flowey , if chopper reads your comment he'll say
' Your compliment won't make me happy you fool😇🤗😆😃😄😊😀'
I am 10 billion percent sure that this would be his response .
"Luffy is the most uninspiring main character in the history of Shonen"
Celebcity: *Ooh I almost punched you in your face*
that feels like someone whose never watched/read one piece....luffy legit is super inspiring...
@@jdx478 actually there are more videos that says luffy is superior
@@razkable exactly bullshit
@@jdx478 ??Luffy is not inferior to anyone you named imo
... he says chest, if we're talking about the pigeon video
That guy sounded like a complete clown most of his statements made no sense and his reasonings for hating the power system was just dumb 😂
yeah, i just feel like he was looking at the anime from a different angle that made him too blind about some important facts
@Anonymous individual i doubt that what he said was true
@Anonymous individual and none of them are true ...lol
@@sailo8681 i disagree, some of them are valid criticism. Atleast... Somewhat of it.
@@jecise fair enough bro,I have no prb with that ... can you tell which just curious
Nah what he said about sanji and robin was actually funny
Chopper made me laugh LOL
I genuinely laughed 😂
Fr? I thought it was kinda lame and bland he was pushing it to much
@@dannymejia280 Same
At least I did not get any bad character rewiew like the other straw hats
I’m waiting for the day GLR reads us a poorly written One Piece Fan Fiction
Those are *chef's kiss*
I call dibs on a ZoroxSanji yaoi fanfic
GLR and internet Historian team up to read.... Bad One Piece fan fiction
@@pats3212 everytime I searched for zoro + sanji wallpapers, I get to see these yaoi fanarts. GODDAMMIT
That HAS to happen
It’s like the dude took a comment about bad pacing and copy pasted it 12 times while simultaneously using a thesaurus for everything and Google translating it four more times per iteration.
I wanna say something. The world of one piece is huge and intresting and always amazing to see. I can agree that sometimes an arc can drag on but, the world building is so great, and at many parts is more important then the characters themselves. Examples being, the huge elephant that the animal people live on(completely forgot there name for some reason), the red line, the all blue, fishman island, and more.
Huge elephant = Zou arc.
easy to conclude: read the manga if you dont want slow pacing
return to anime: for epic battles, impactful and emotional moments
It’s more likely if the person is just first getting into the anime, and they’re an anime watcher only, but they don’t want to read the manga until the anime is finished then that person should watch the first animated special then watch the episodes of the Luffy, Zoro, Usopp, and Nami crossing the Redline then watch the Alabasta special, then the Skypia special, then the Enies Lobby Special, then watch the anime from the Sabadody Arc to the MarnieFord Arc, then the Dressora special until it gets to the part of the end of that Special, and it goes back to the fight with Doflamgino and Luffy, and then watch from Zou all the way to the current Arc in Wano.
@@RoronoaZoro-ur6hr if you want to ruin the experience then you could do that
@@olavotoledo8870, I find my way the easiest to watch through all of One Piece if people don’t have the time to watch through all 952-953 episodes, and the animated specials are more closer to the manga stories than the episodes of the official anime itself.
I actually caught up with anime. And moved to manga
@Anonymous individual, I plan on reading all of the One Piece manga series after I buy all of the box sets to do so because I’ve already watched the anime series, and the anime/manga series is great from I’ve seen of it.
5:00
To me they are fundamentally different. FMA and Death Note are very tightly written and are really 1 story. One Piece is much more loosely written and is not really meant to be 1 story. Rather it's a whole series of stories with a throughline connecting them together. To me One Piece largely feels like an episodic show where the episodes flow.
@Overdose Yeah. Episodic was kind of the wrong word to use. What I meant was that the arcs are fairly standalone.
Its a saga. A great journey where many stories takes place in one large story
Bold of you to say One Piece is an episodic show. 😂
@@MrMarinus18 I disagree because arcs like enies lobby benefit from water 7, marineford benefits from impel down. What the other guy said about it being a saga is a much better way of putting it but I do get what you mean.
@@MrMarinus18 there are a alot of build up arcs like water 7 impel down punk hazard so i dont completely agree
It's interesting to me because a lot of the things he criticizes aside from the pacing are things that I love about the series. I think Luffy, Zoro, and Sanji's antics are extremely entertaining, and the world building is slow but it definitely gives the feel of a much larger world beyond Luffy and his crew
“it definitely gives the feel of a much larger world beyond luffy and his crew” yea, ive noticed that
thats why i dont complain on its slow pacing because what you said makes up for it
"Why can't One Piece be like FMA or Death Note, in being that they have their whole stories in less episodes?"
Simple, because these other Shonen were already finished by the time the anime adaptations were rolling around, if One Piece was already up to the time skip when they started the anime there would probably only be like 200 episodes since it had enough content for that many episodes, the reason that there's 950+ episodes is because Toei keep catching up with the ongoing manga for like 21 years now, so they only use 1 chapter at a time to keep it going weekly for so long, unlike a series like JoJo's Bizarre Adventure which is already adapting a finished work, fitting around 3-4 chapters worth of material per episode.
I suppose they aren't familiar with the original Full Metal Alchemist anime, where that exact thing happened.
@@koatam but at the same time does FMAB or death note have the world building of one piece and the list goes on, different lengths suit differently depending on what you as a writer want to add to the story, death note is an intense thriller,FMAB has a tightly knit narrative
There is that. Also that One Piece is quite different story altogether. I think after a decade of finishing the manga we will have a fillerless 400-450 episode anime (of course that depends on how long one Piece will run).
I think The anime should Be around 600-700 Episodes.
That's basically every awkward standstill now removed from The story along with useless still shots and VERY slow wideshots
I get the feeling he didn’t understand what adventure anime was
And now for the best One Piece Review: TotallyNotMark's Blind Review
(PlsCollabSoon)
I agree it would be pretty lit
Yesss that would be awesome
someone give this man award for the best advise in this channel
@Jotaro Kujo With A Mustache "Mark at the Movies" sounds like a great series for him, watching anime movies and all that.
@@oblivious8868 but it’s NotMark
I liked one piece simply hated that there was a lack of danger. Even when people died they usually come back. So it was hard to feel for the characters when they were in “danger”
Bro u just have emotions issur
Issue
@@Sylvashfit Nah bro. His issue is valid. Oda literally brang back every character in Alabasta.
@@davidnwaokolo1905 nah
@@davidnwaokolo1905 didn't y'all felt danger when big mom and kaido teamed up
Of course HxH is greedy, it even has an arc called Greed Island 🧠👀
Screw you and take my life
Lol
@@Gorpolon you clearly missed the joke .-.
Genius
Episode of Dr Yogi Bitch: Bloom in the Winter
One sentence for that guy
"Luffy is Stretchable and so the story is giving us more of its extended contents of empathy and its own bizarre way of presenting."
"One _Peice_ sucks!"
Every OP fan: *...get him*
*Lynch him
@Sahid Hernandez
No, that's too expensive for him
Put him in a Marine uniform, with a gun, and make him fight against the Whitebeard crew in the war
"Wannabe young man" excuse me, what?!
You're either young or not. It has nothing to do with your wants and wishes. It's not a choice. lol
Well I could think of an old man with a backwards cap and jean shorts trying to skate board with teens. That would be someone trying to be a young man.
But yeah guy writing the review doesn't have a great grasp of words and their meanings.
Obviously this is a clever joke about Luffy being voiced by a woman in Japanese... either that or the person who wrote the review is kind of a moron. To quote: "Take your pick."
Wannabe young man: How do you do, fellow kids?
That's trans-age-phobic
“Wannabe.” I’m pretty sure Luffy has shown that he’s very child like but when it comes to the fights of One Piece with Luffy look at the amount of bloody battles he’s gone through. Luffy against Lucci is the best example in my opinion. That was one hell of a fight. And if I’m correct, Luffy then was 17 years old. So yeah... hardly a “wannabe.” - He is.
Hahaha. The guy that wrote that was actually pretty popular or let's say infamous, in the anime websites like 10 years ago. He slated most shounen anime and truth is he had some fair points about them and produced some pretty funny lines. He did have reviews like these for all popular shounen anime, and they were all... let's say pretty negative! He got abuse from fanboys/girls and defended his views in a fierce way. Well it was pretty funny from a spectator point of view. His profiles are now private and he got banned from some forums but with some googling you can still find some of his reviews. I won't name him for privacy reasons, but if you were floating around the anidb community back in the day, you can't have missed this guy.
Stupid Reviewer: All women in one piece look the same
Big Mom: hold my wedding cake
Bunch from Whole Cake and Amazon Lily too.
He must have skipped it, i assume.
Yeah just off the top of my head Dadan, Lola, smoothie (pretty much all of BM’s daughters) and like you said the Amazon Lily sister and. Shinobu.
The way the women on Amazon lily looked made sense
@@clarencehemphill3403
Yah I know am just sayin the Reviewe must have missed that arc
@@vinsmokejadzki7346 I know I was Just saying that cause female character design argument is very controversial and I wanted to say it made sense for them
Guy: “I like One piece”
Also guy: “the world building of one piece is bad because the show has bad pacing” 💀
That statement made me wanna commit non living 😂
His IQ is off the scale fr.
@@generalyousif3640 Ah, but I'm already dead. YOHOHOHOHOHO
@@generalyousif3640 i wanted to commit scooter ankle
To be fair to this degenrate the pacing of the anime is kinda bad since the first half of most episodes are basically recaps of the previous episodes.
2:36 there's even a swedish king who became a pirate
This is a rule: if a guy doesn't like One Piece, you can mistrust him, unless he hasn't seen it yet, because that's a chance for you to convert a new fan
You need to strap him to a chair and force him to watch one piece till he does
seen?
Are you an Anime watcher? What's that like? From what I've seen from the anime it holds up alright compared to others but that's only because Oda is such a massive genius that even if only a % ends up in the Anime it still ends up being pretty good.
If you read the manga tho you're as close to Oda's head as you can get and it's amazing.
Not to mention you're behind like 50 chapters at all times when restricted to Anime.
I'm just not sure if I would recommend anyone to watch the OnePiece anime start to finish. That's just a massive undertaking riddled with fillers and dragged manga scenes.
But reading 1000 chapters? That's doable, also very enjoyable ;D.
I would never force someone to watch One Piece anime. Manga is where it is.
@@Broockle I watched the anime this year and pre timeskip it isn't difficult to get through. Getting someone into the series through the anime is perfectly fine IMO and by the time it becomes an issue most people will be invested enough to keep going. Dressrosa was painful though.
i didnt like the show based on the length and its genre. GLR convinced me to give it a chance and im glad i did. however i will argue that for a single narrative as opposed to multiple narratives in the same universe its a bit long. based on my limited experience with manga expecting someone to read that much story to appreciate it is not feasible. its like the people arguing FF13 gets good after 20 hours. and one pieces average hook point of baratie based on everything ive seen is hard to justify
I may be wrong but I get the feeling English isn’t the dominant language of the person who wrote this hence the nonsensical aspects of it as it probably went through a web translator.
I don't think so, I just think they are that dumb that they can't even try to spell things right
@@MrPF Thank god he reads it so we don't have to.
I don't think I could sit through 2000 words worth of cringe
0:48 hmm yes the ceiling is made of the ceiling
Drugs the pre time skip admirals take
Akainu- steroids
Aokiji- ice
Kizaru- speed
Hehehe
Fujitora - Snails
Akainu - meth
Aokiji - sober
Kizaru - stoner
Ice and speed are the same thing. You could say Aokiji does snow/blow. Based on his personality though it would be either weed or opiates. Same with Kizaru, ironically
@@CMClaudio1989 Kizaru could always be under a constant buzz as well, I think.
2:12
Lmao I can just imagine a Shakspearean actor doing a monologue like that
"Is this a dagger which I see before me,
The handle toward my hand - Dammit! Why does Oda hate Sanji?!:
- Come, let me clutch thee"
"To be, or not to be, that is the question,
Whether 'tis nobler in the mind to suffer, The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune, Or to take arms against a sea of troubles, And by opposing end them? To die: to sleep; No more; and by a sleep to say we hit the nail on that one"
Greedy being togashi always has plot points that he forgets or just straight abandoned lol
that's what happened when someone gets told he's a good critique to make him feel good
*critic
The critique is the criticism itself that a critic forms around whatever it is which they are criticizing. It doesn’t make much sense to describe an individual as being a “critique”
@@formerctgovernordannelmall1452 that was due to my english not being as sharp as it used to be.
@@زينبعقيلي-ط1ب no problem, I figured it was a sincere mistake, which is why I gave a brief explanation to help you understand the difference since the words are so similar. I hate English speakers who get offended or impatient with others who don’t fully grasp the language. I hope my original correction didn’t come off as condescending or rude. If it did, then I apologize
Huh that’s weird there seems to be a glitch where when I’m typing out my comment on my phone, your username is at the very beginning of the comment, before all the text. Yet once I upload the comment, your name suddenly shifts near the end of the first line. I can’t seem to fix it
@@formerctgovernordannelmall1452 no you were awesome, thank you very much.
The Sanji and Brock comparison killed me lmfao
11:00
OMG I CAN'T bELIVE THIS, i was in my online class and this thing popped in my mind this morning xD
I was laughing hysterically at all their criticism/opinion especially at the pacing and timing opinions.
It's honestly amazing that this guy can watch the whole one piece while hating it and write a 2000 word essay about it. It almost feels like he's actually enjoying it but looking for attention
Hate watching/reading/existing is a thing. Proof: Twitter.
This man managed to use both the words “constipated” and “inspiring” in one sentence and it still makes sense
When I get constipated, I'm inspired to consume laxatives.
My only real problem with one piece is that the first half of each episode in the anime version is basically a recap of the previous episode. It sometimes take so long that part of the recap of the previous episode gets included in the current recap.
Thats a problem of an anime that adapts an ongoing manga, they have to keep the gap between the ongoing chapter and the anime episode so the episode wont catch up to the manga, that's why they sometimes stretch and drag the episode and why there is filler and the 4-5 mins recap to make the episode adapt the chapter as less as possible but to keep it as 20 mins episode, but in reality its just a 15-17 mins of episode. Just read the manga if you annoyed with that
@@juliuism its not even 15 minutes, you can often trim episodes down to less than 5 minutes of actual content! and yeah i dont watch the anime ._. I just cant, its too painful, if i had to review one piece based off the anime alone, id sound just like the guy grandlinereview is talking about in this specific video, thank god i love the manga to death, no complaints whatsoever everything is perfect my eyes are rose tinted for the manga, its kinda insane to me how toei animation can make the worst adaption iv ever seen, based off the best manga iv ever read… okay that might be my feelings exaggerating, i probably have seen worse but you know the anime deserves a lot of criticism.
I just skip the recap, thankfully on crunchyroll that's quite painless to do
People tell why it has so many episodes..but they can't think of "if this has so many episodes there must be a solid story"
Obviously this reviewer hasn't even read One Piece. He merely read some trivia about it and decided to make an opinion based on what he think is going on.
Most of the reviewers/haters do exactly as you said. It has been a while since I've read a valid criticism.
It’s absolutely some child who made this, the way they type is just completely embarrassing, “Sanji is like brock from pokemon” pretty much confirms this, like seriously lol
Sounds like he got his info from GameRant or CBR
They judge literally by the details of drawing not by the story.
Homestly thinking tho, he had actual critisism about the series but just didn't know to present them and also he just didn't understand some concepts. I mean, I've heard worse from other people but I've never seen a worse review.
tbh he had a fair point about jump purposely stalling out stories, it was exposed by people like Toriyama
to me thats what haki is...a stall tactic by shounen jump forced upon oda to make his series redo the power system from devil fruits to something more badass so they have a easy to market ability with a name like nen spirit energy ki or chakra... ...we didn't need haki to get a good show...that changed the show and ruined the fights imo....its so stupid and came out of nowhere an made the show longer...
@@razkable Personally I kind of dislike haki because it made devil fruits less impactful. It used to be way more fun seeing people come up with creative ways to beat logia users rather than simply hitting them with enhanced arms. Sure Oda needed something to make logias less overpowered but I don't think that haki was the right answer.
Plus the introduction of haki comes so late into the series. I wish it was introduced earlier. The issue especially being Ace vs Smoker, where he says that the fight will be neverending because their DFs cancel each other out. That basically ignores the existence of armament haki, and Ace has been confirmed to have all 3 haki types.
@@scrollingdownonlytofindcom2663 confirmed to have ≠ confirmed to be able to use it properly, that's just how I see it. Example:- Luffy pre-timeskip has been shown to be able to use both conquerors and observation, but he didn't know what Haki was nor was he aware that he used conquerors until Rayleigh brought it up.
@@scrollingdownonlytofindcom2663 Haki WAS introduced earlier, all the way back from Luffy's flashback with Shanks, Shanks used Conquerors Haki very early on when the sea monster tried to come after him a second time, it was already foreshadowed, just explored much later on.
"World building "21 years later and we still dont know all the ilands
I'm pretty sure the "greedy approach" this guy meant was that the show is long because the Manaka wants to make more money thus intentionally drags the series without actual progress. this is wrong for so many level for One Piece if he had read the manga himself. the pacing is great and even compact with no unnecessary panels.
If that is what he meant then thats very ignorant bc the creator of HxH has serious health issues so he cant push out chapters like that and without chapters theres no episodes bc the want to keep a gap so that it doesn’t end up like op with filler episodes
The pacing for me was long in some parts but it was probably because of waiting next week.
@@zerokura yea binging one piece isnt that bad even the fillers and specials kind of fly by. The one time the story dragged for me was the whole enies lobby saga
@@jayydexter also if someone wants a quick run down of what happens the Pirates warriors games do a great job with that.the 4th one have a fun wano ending to it but you miss side characters and the guy who betrays white beard becomes a common mob character not like how they look in the manga but they still tell the story pretty well and fast.
Wow One Piece is a long as journey, REALLY I DIDN'T THINK THAT 990+ CHAPTERS WAS A LIGHT WEEKEND READ !!!
as someone who enjoys writing a lot, to "stall" in certain arcs or episodes and stil having your story be that good is fk hard. writing an arc and "stalling" is something I and probably a lot of writers have a lot of trouble with. side note, when i say stalling i mean continuing an arc for longer than planned from a writers POV/expected from an audience POV. you have to come up with new dialogue, plot points, fight scenes and sometimes even whole characters. that is fk difficult. he also mentions that its a weakness on the writers point. my boi Oda foreshadowed something from chapter 400+ in chapter 1. not only that but he also was "stalling" before it was revealed?! the amount of patience this author has is incredible. there is not a single character or plot point in the series that doesnt have a purpose. Lola was introduced in Thriller Bark and she became very important 400 chapters later in Whole Cake while not even appearing in that arc for the most part.
also also, like i said "stalling" is not a good critisism for a show this good. it is able to make 1000 chapters of very consistent and good quality is something very few manage to do. a story that i have been working on for years now, i only expect it to have 50 chapters max, and i havent even started writing it yet.
also also also, i think its funny how people critisize the show and pretend to be a genius big brain critic, meanwhile the show is one of if not the most popular and best received show in its genre style, medium, and even country. its one of the most critically acclaimed manga of all time meanwhile you are in your bedroom crying about how the worldbuilding of the anime is ruining the pacing of said anime and how that is somehow the fault of the... mangaka?
nevermind, forget everything I said, his favorite straw hat is Brook... I see he's a man of culture
That reviewer would go ham on HxH it would be so funny to hear his opinion
9:55 I laughed my ass off at the constipated ragging man child.
Okay that's it. I'm now always calling Chopper "Doctor Yogi Bitch".
I can't help but feel this is a naruto fanboy
@@user-vf3rn8cp5o past speaks for itself
@@user-vf3rn8cp5o you see why you have no likes cause no one agrees with you
maybe saying the reviewer is a naruto fanboy is an overgeneralization, but he was definitely lying about liking One Piece, he obviously said that in an attempt to make himself sound objective, but in reality, he's probably a fan of another shounen and trying to undermine One Piece, that's my assumption, and I'm not gonna say that it's probably a naruto fan, but I'm just saying, he probably is
edit: I just finished the video, the reference to killer bee, the implication that he probably wants villains that people can sympathize with (just like with Zabuza, Haku, Pain, etc.) now I'm still not gonna say that he's definitely a Naruto fanboy, but the evidence points towards it
@@ronaldolawyer3865 I’d bet my life that his a narutard
@@user-vf3rn8cp5o bruh I was talking about the reviewer, why don’t you conform to society and learn to read just like most of us with a functioning brain
I think dora the explorer world building is a match made in heaven for this reviewer taste
@Anonymous individual i want to agree with you, but dora's worldbuilding is to deep for main brain capacity. So i dont want to make a wrong assumption.
@Anonymous individual Dora’s world-building is an anomaly scientists can’t explain...
Dora's world building is better because it's done faster
"El árbol es verde. The tree is green"
See! Sooooo much quicker!
Dora's world have forest as a hub to go anywhere you want, animal who at least bilingual, talking bag, paper map with gps features, blue pointer, and also the world is galaxy level big since stars can hiding in the bush or tree in this world.
@@mutesgraveyard6733 don't forget about the Arch Villain Swiper!
I'm sorry but i can't finish this vid; the stupidity radiating from my screen is astronomically unbelievable
Someone says OP is bad
.
.
"No matter what happens, Don't fight back"
6 mins in and it already hurts me so much!! One Piece is the first anime I rly watch seriously and I started watching this when im still 4-7
It's kind of sad that the guy who requested this rebuttal had to rely on a big One Piece youtuber's authority to defend his beloved series instead of just doing it himself and going on with his life.
While the critique wasn't well put together at all, it just reeks of someone reading a negative review of something he loved, not liking it, not being able to make a decent defense by himself, and asking for validation from someone he gives authority to, a big youtube, in the form of a video responding to the review and validating his opinion.
Also, ideally, the shorter a story is and the more efficient it is in communicating information and events, the better. Obviously not every series can or should be reduced to a 12-24 episode run but still, they should always strive to at least not drag on. And as GLR admitted in the Wano being the worst arc video, the story does do that at some points, which is bad craft.
And that's without mentioning filler, which isn't really the fault of the story itself or the author but is a fault of the anime.
Finally, world-building and pacing are related to one another. To show a new part of the world and how it functions, the main plotline usually has to slow down as to not overwhelm the reader/watcher. This means that usually, world-building in the short term is harmful to the immediate progression of the main plot, altho it usually makes the plotline better in the long term. Again, this was admitted in the Wano video.
man this guy was salty he probably started off with the 4kidz dub
I started with 4kids thats how i got into one piece back in the day.though i still thought they say gotta go gotta go in the rap not the pirate yada oh since i thought gotta go sounds better because its hurry up their adventures to do feeling to it.
@@zerokura Man, you must have been really underwhelmed by Shanks at the start
@@heyoyo10gaming4 haha dont remember do remember sanji have a Brooklyn accent that was fun.did found out franky voice actor in funimation is same actor for nekomaru from danganronpa 2 plus is monokid from v3 so now i can picture franky yellowing its a Suuuppppeeerrrrr rager sssshhhhiiiiitttttt!!!!! Lol
@@zerokura Shanks has the most jarringly cockney accent in the universe
LMAOOOO
Lol
This guy single handedly picked up all the good points that make it the absolute best
And called it bad
This man is from the shadow realm
IF this reviewer was able to give an arc-by-arc analysis of what they think is the problem in the first three arcs that keeps a viewer from either getting invested in the characters or staying invested in the overall conclusion of the story, then I would be willing to give them some point. We often say that you gotta give an anime 3 episodes to explain itself, and you WILL be hooked if you make it to Ep 7. And in a shonen ADVENTURE story, I appreciate "First 3 arcs analysis" from YTers. How does Naruto's first three arcs stack up to engaging the audience? How well does Bleach transition from slice-of-life with ghosts to a full action story?
Yes, One Piece's beginning has a lot of filler episodes. But the actual story: the additions of Zoro, our Lord and Savior Usopp, Nami, Sanji, and Tony Tony Chopper are incredibly engaging stories that I have not yet seen a YT reactor not enjoy. And once this team is assembled, how they fight for Alabasta and against Crocodile is amazing. IF they made a genuine argument that the pacing of this 1999 anime was hurt by too much filler and pacing that robs from some enjoyment of how this family, this nakama, became, then I could give them some credit for actually having a point.
But they don't do that. They compare One Piece and Hunter x Hunter, shonen ADVENTURE STORIES, to Death Note, a seinen psychological thriller and Fullmetal Alchemist, a shonen political thriller. No self-awareness of how completely off the mark it is to criticize the genre for its own purpose, to the point of saying the "flaw" he sees in One Piece, he sees in most shonen anime, and he blames it on economic troubles. I get it. This review likes thrillers. He likes the fast pace and crisp attention to detail of a story that is meant to grip you with plot tit-for-tat and not let go. Why settle for Death Note and Fullmetal? Magika Madoka is 13 episodes! FLCL (was) six episodes! It's clear that this reviewer simply doesn't like adventure stories, and has no idea how to simply say THAT. Who watches the Straw Hats walk to Arlong Park or Luffy's third battle against Crocodile and wonders, "So, when are they going to find One Piece?"
When you read that "OMG!", I felt that
i’m anime only, even when the pacing got sort of slow i never got bored of watching one piece.
Fax brother
The only time i got bored was in thriller bark and fishman island
These are the worst. Claiming to actually like something, so that their rant suddenly becomes more legitimate. They dont even have the backbone to admit their dislikes.
His whole rant:
“I hate to be that guy here but”
*Proceeds to be that guy, possibly worse..*
Yes but did I mention the world building?
FMA brotherhood is the worst example you could give as the first few episodes have very few details that are arguably needed even cutting out full arcs from the manga towards the start of the story
What if brooke learns haki in the next arc
He will become wither skeleton
@@ivanrios4110 he is a soul king after all
I think he already knows how to use haki but we just don't see it because he doesn't posses any SKIN......YOHOHOHOHOHO
@@yashaskulkarni2959 LOL
Black bones brook
Cool
What I really find funny, is that person who can barely structure a coherent sentence has the audacity to criticize another person's writing.
BRUH YES! what did he just use a thesaurus to make his words better, because even so, his sentences don't even make sense. It's like mixing up words in a sentence. Like...BRO...just like you said, Fix his own sentence structure before criticizing another persons writing
To be fair, you don't actually need to be able to draw even stick figures to be able to recognise great art.
... You probably should learn basic communication skills, if you wish to share your thoughts, though.
He really said “very stupid which in turn leaves his three sword style”
Him: doesn't like one piece
Also him: watches 900+ episodes
LMAO😂
He likes the probably the 2 least featured straw hat characters in the shown
Everyone like tham expect robin,robin is amazing to just to say reason that they are not like luffy is tima when did robin do something last time?(
@@togenix3084 yea but he dislikes all the rest so its not really worth watching something with characters you don't like
I love all of the straw hats, but brook is my all time favorite and he gets probably the least amount of screen time 😭
That was actually pretty funny. Especially what he called Namis pet dog
So this guy at least got to the point in the series where they explain King's Haki, or give it a name for the first time. When was that? Amazon Lily? And he still doesn't grasp other basic concepts of One Piece, and doesn't understand characters, Devil Fruits or the villains character development. Wow. Amazing... That's a feat in itself. Watching blindfolded
"You're nitpicking and biased, I win bye bye"
"Female viewers in the comments, please feel free to confirm or deny this."
Me at this point: *dying of laughter*
The best way to handle this is to strap the person to a chair and force them to watch one piece till they enjoy it 😅
I really felt like the guy who did this review is just one of those people on CBR who pretend they actually read/watch it
Wow they make so much sense. Their review was so much better than Grand Line Review. I am now going to stop watching One Piece after this, I can't believe I was wasting my time.
"I like it but in all honesty it isn't good"
Huh, my boyfriend has said this exact same thing about pizza before 😂 I asked him to explain himself and got a similarly inexplicable explanation about texture and flavor and nutritional value....
Pizza is a special case. It's impossible to not like pizza. But there is defiantly good pizza and bad pizza.
His points are like:
1) i hate pirates
2) i hate kings
3) i hate magical fruits
4) i don't understand what the "world building" is
5) i don't understand the concept of "intimidation aura"
6) women
7) forcing myself to watch the show
8) the episode is too slow
9) the anime is too long
10) the main character is too childish for my taste
11) not enough swords
12) the overall sound design is so-so
13) i can't feel for the characters (see above for reasons why)
14) (aren't i amazing at writing reviews)?
15) i won't explain anything
Proves that anyone can be an anime reviewer. No special skills needed. Only the ability to write basic sentences.
I think... I THINK... that this person is saying the story is longer than it needs to be for the sake of earning lots of money by making lots of books for fans to buy, when Oda could apparently just end it quickly by having the Straw Hats get to Laugh Tale immediately.
I think I think, the fans dont care how long it is because they enjoy every chapter
Probably. But that just shows that 1. he doesn't understand the core concept of One Piece 2. didn't really read/watch long shounens (I think he didn't read One Piece at all) 3. fails to understand any storytelling
I wonder what his thoughts are on Got and Lotr.
imagine thinking Oda writing for money when he already is the richest mangaka
@Mark Esteven Federis bruh I’m talking about ODA extending her story because of money 🧍🏻♀️
Take a shot every time he says world building
I told my buddy to do that... his funeral is Tomorrow