Hong Kong at this time was very politically unstable, his reaction and the reason he probably reiterates following election law is because he is afraid of widespread riots.
I love how he switches from Mandarin, to Cantonese, to English and back Edit: I haven't checked on this comment for 9 months, and there's a whole political debate here (and people calling me a communist)
I doubt you could find many places where Jiang and Trump disagreed (of course lots of places where interests are contrary, but that's not really solved through debate)
@@marcusatiusvirilis7723 They are both non ideological pragmatists focused on their own national interest, as opposed to the more ideologically driven who have succeeded Jiang and preceded Trump. Jiang's was the hand picked successor to Deng Xiaoping who famously said "don't care if it's a black cat or a white cat, as long as it catches mice, it's at good cat". Jiang presided of China's fastest period of growth, and though the US is a mature market, we're also seeing the results of a leader focused on economic growth and ultimately jobs. Surely would they would disagree about what they would like to see happen, as China and US interests are largely a zero sum game, but as for a debate, I'm pretty sure they would mostly agree about what should be done and why, with the exception of Trump and the US being very open to public disagreement and protest. These two would be more suitable for a "panel discussion" than a debate. For full disclosure, there's reason to believe that Zhu Rongji was actually the one working behind the scenes to make Jiang look successful.
lethal hipster 请你有点汉语语言学常识。中文分为官话，吴语（包括上海话），赣语，晋语，湘语，粤语，不同种类的闽语，客家话。四川话属于官话中的西南官话。粤语就是一种独立的语言。 If you do not have any linguistics knowledge you’d better not argue about this topic. Under the Chinese languages there are Mandarin, Wu (including Shanghainese), Gan (Jiangxi), Jin (Shanxi), Xiang (Hunan), Yue (Cantonese), the Min Languages (including Hokkien, Taiwanese, Teochew) and Hakka. Sichuan speaks Mandarin. Cantonese is a separate language FROM MANDARIN.
Skylab the reporter was setting up a trap, asking Jiang whether he “supports” that Hong Kong official or not. If Jiang said yes, the headline next day would be Mainland government appoints Hong Kong SAR’s top official, breaking the agreement of Hong Kong’s freedom of election. If Jiang says no, the headline would be chairman of China is openly against official elected thru democratic process in Hong Kong. Consequently no matter how Jiang answers the question, he would be painted in a bad way by that reporter. Jiang sees thru that, which is why Jiang calls the reporter too simple, too naive, compared the reporter to Wallace, who also tried to set up trick questions like this during his interview with Jiang but had done so more sophisticatedly (Jiang did not fall into Wallace’s traps either). Jiang then proceeds to very clearly explain that his support doesn’t mean appointment from the government itself, and whether he supports or not doesn’t matter because the official was elected by Hong Kong people, answering the trick question without leaving any loose end for defamation. If this kind of questions were asked to Xi, he wouldn’t bother to answer at all. So could Jiang, but Jiang in this video couldn’t resist to teach the reporter a lesson.
exactly, that’s the only thing that makes a leader good. Politics? How he’s running the country? Nah those don’t fucking matter. Hey trump seems really human! Vote for him and keep him on!
Here in China we have made up a race between him and other political leaders or head national figures who were born around the same time to see who’s going to stay in this world longer than other “competitors” Right now Mrs.Tatcher, mr. Wallace have lost the race, and Queen Elizabeth seems to be the easy winner of this race😂
This dude is the very reason why china transformed from very poor third world country to rich modern country He was sincerely a genius. No matter if you like or not Thats like if someone makes haiti a rich country 20 years later
lol what kind of Chinese restaurants you've been to? they definitely don't look like this. Oh, unless you're talking about certain decorations or patterns? stop trying to be edgy
You know what? This is refreshing. I don't care what this man is saying or who he is. The fact that a politician is speaking from heart and not being a robot about it is totally refreshing! Heck, I'm pretty sure the usual robotic tone all politicians use is another way of making politics boring and deterring people away from getting into how countries are truly run. Still, this happened, and I'm happy. Peace from Saudi Arabia. :) EDIT: Perhaps the way this man is talking could be fabricated to deter the questions away from him, meaning this reprimanding style of speech is another old and classic tactic of dealing with the media, meaning perhaps I praised this as a refreshing video for nothing. lol
He lost control because he thought that Hongkong reporters didn't get to ask HIM tough questions, so he decided to teach them a lesson. And that is because he thought Hongkong was already part of China and the reporters there should behave themselves, more or less like those from the mainland. That's the real reason he showed his true side (I suspect there was no western media present on that day). If a reporter from the Chinese Central Television dared to ask him a similar question, Jiang would immediately fire the chief of that TV station and call this a serious political incident.
i think u r wrong. Jiang met many reports, especially Wallace, an American interviewer. u can find some videos about him and Wallace who mentioned autocracy, Fa Lungong,and etc. In this video in Hong Kong, it does not mean he didn't dare to answer the question put forward by the young reporter, but mean those young reporters of Mandarin and Hong Kong are supposed to improve their questions' quantity because the question in the video is so easy to Jiang, and Jiang must thought you are too naive to ask much experienced politician, or someone having higer status abroad. It's my opinion to Jiang , and, only Jiang, not to today's CCP . ( yet maybe i don't know him enough)
From at least what it sounds like here even if that is partially his point I don't think that this is his full argument. I think he found the way they would ask the questions to be lazy, leading / pointed. @@wujijianchuqiao
@@marcteenhc9793 All countries do bad things, most probably even yours. In fact, KSA's problems are quite tame in comparison to so many other nations. Don't blindly follow the media, dear.
He made a good point. Media is nothing but trying to provoke a reaction through accusation and make a big headlines based on conjectures. I would not agree with him when he said "naive". Twisted would be a better word.
He might have said naive because they jump to such conclusions without truly understanding the gravity of the situation at hand. This media has always existed. Their job is to generate money for their company, so at a certain point they dumb it down to broaden things
Their job is to keep leaders in check. If they are asking questions and the politicians are getting annoyed, that's how you know they are doing their job right. You people are idiots
Joker try missing one question on the test and Asian dad is scolding ur preemptively for that pontentail day u get an A-. Lol my comment should be in an Asian comedy.
As corrupt and as bad as Jiang Zemin was, this could never happen today. Reporters would never ask hard questions or talk back to the Chinese leader today.
Ian Hay China beautiful country beautiful culture one of the best in the world in fact amazing nature. But have always had shit government that works against the people not for. It’s a tragedy
"Just imagine what would have happened if US President Barack Obama freaked out like this" Let see we have James Rosen, his friends, his family, investigated by the intelligence community by the direction of Obama, Michael Hastings whos car exploded after going 150mph and running from the FBI. Loretta Fuddy dies in a plane crash after signing Obamas fake birth certificate when nobody else on the plane had more than a scratch. On and On. It wasn't just China.
He has a point though. “Does the CCP support the sitting executive of Hong Kong?” Was a pretty obvious question all those years ago. Jiang was right, we were all too naïve, and we missed the big picture for a very long time.
看到这些的 香港 轮到人。他们跟来一样澳洲的轮到。。是是的人 lam 真的不懂的事， 为什么该干煸法律， 还有不能够准备未可老年的病例新光病毒。。。regardez quelle incompétence et franche bêtise, la Dame Lam 1. Ne comprend pas l’importance de changer la loi, d’arrêter les criminels, y compris les agents secrets de s’infiltrer à 香港。 2。 retrait absolument gaffe de promulger cette loi. Et 3. Ne pas comprendre que les criminels se réorganizent et cause tellement de destruction. Et hypocrisie de médias occidentaux, utilisent l’occasion pour encor une fois faire la travestie de la véritÈ. COMME D’HABITUDE..4.. epidèmie de COVID19 VARIANTS OMECRON多。 La Dame Lam n’a rien donné. En matière de vaccins etc pour tous les vieux, abondonnés , comme on le voit partout le monde. De cette façon , elle me rappelle les Authorités de quarantine du GULAG AUSTRALIE, qui accueillent le paquebot de plaisance , en plein ville, n’ont rien préparé. En nimporte quelle façon..sauf qu’elles accusent la guerre biologique .. et voilà. Tant et tant de vieux et d’autres meurent , de la façon la plus irresponsable, et de leurs enfants .. qui ne se sentent en aucune faÇon obligÉ de s’occuper de leurs parents, qu’ils abondonnent dans des maisons Asiles..ils n’en veulent pas. In no way do they want to be responsible for them..triste n’est ce pas ? Enfin voilà, La Dame Lam est très proche de la gouvernance GULAG AUSTRALIE . Too late not enough. ELLE A BIEN FAIT DE QUITTER SON POSTE. par contre les gens d’ici continuent à se donner des récompenses !! 😄😄😢😢
@@gsurtos6588 Many were, and still are, overly concerned with the short game, the headlines, and day to day metrics. Jiang was president of China at a moment where Chinese soft power and economic might was growing quickly, and not many people back then asked about what a superpower China would be capable of. Now, much of that has changed, and the CCP is faltering in its leadership of China, but back then they were doing their hardest to play the long game and gain enough power to be the empire they used to be.
Zylo Thecat Trump is obviously not qualified. He is only interested inter-reacting with his club, people like Elizabeth II, Fidel Castro etc. A completion started in 1926 between them, only Jiang and the Queen qualify the final. Who will be the winner, history will tell you the answer. Let's wait for the answer
If you actually think about what he said... his rant 100% applies to American journalism today. lol. Tons of sensational legwork, but little to no substance.
That's exactly his point! I'm not chinese, but from his reaction I can tell he's super pissed they are picking up the bad habits of western journalism, and he's utterly disappointed that she's too stupid to even do it well since it was evident it was best to ignore her.
HAHAHA FVCK U.S.A YOUR LEADER ARE SHIT AND STUPID. AND YOU ALL SAY EVERY LEADER IN THE WORLD IS BAD. JUST LIKE MOST OF U.S MEDIA SAY CHINESE GOVERNMENT FOR PREVENTING CORONA VIRUS IS BAD. BUT WHEN CORONA VIRUS ENTER THE U.S YOUR GOVERNMENT AND LEADER ARE THE WORST. STUPID CITIZENS AND GOVERNMENT
@@mastermarco1723 Agreed. At this point, they're not doing genuine journalism. They're doing business. It all depends on what their target market wants at this point. Though, to look in their perspective, they need a way to get food on the table.
Not only American journalism. Here in India the situation is so divided that one section of the TV media sucks up to the government while the other section is busy dissing the government at every step. There is a genuine lack of neutral and factual journalism.
This was actually the good old time, before the financial crisis, before the political crackdown, before the HK unrest, and before the trade war. Now I understand, back then I was too young too simple, sometimes naive.
This is the good old time? You are keen to romanticize oppression and despotism in HK? You are no better than the mediaeval times nobility if you cry about HK unrest- you are keen to live your life on the behalf of someone else that is exploited and continuously abused.
Virgin Xi: *censors memes calling him Winnie the Pooh* Chad Jiang: _"Madame reporter, I find the question you are asking me to be politically disingenuous and I advise you, not as your paramount leader but as an elder, to word your questions correctly from now on."_ *R.I.P. Jiang Zemin*
@@greed5891 what do you think happens in American hospitals when they make profit on donated organs? Healthcare in America is privatized, so donated your organs is simply allowing a private company to sell those organs and procedures. Its easy to make something seem horrific with little to no information about the details of those transactions. We sell organs in horrific was as well, we also take advantage of organ donors and the uninsured because selling their organs is more profitable than them having unpaid medical debt.
In all Honesty Jiang Zemin did seem sincere to the reporters when he said “I’m worried for you all” I think he was trying to give them advice on how life works in China
VICTOR Austria What the west doesn’t realise about the CCP is that it’s a ruthless blood bath of people trying to kill each other and take there power.
@@ihk2421 they realize that the ccp is ruthless and committed all these crimes... Its just the west doesnt care, since money is king. Look at WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION ccp only paid a few corrupt WHO officials and look what they did, they almost destroyed mankind.
@Victor Austria Sounds like correction is only exclusive in China. LOL. Don't you know that Covid is probably made by US? Have you heard the documentary "plandemic"?
Rest in Peace Jiang Zemin. we are too young, too simple, sometimes naive to judge you when comparing to the current one that looks like Winnie the Pooh.
The kinda question reporter asked is “do you support your manager?” With you standing next to your manager who just hired you being asked this question, haha.
I don't think he is being asked about his "manager", he is the "boss of the company" here. The reporter is asking whether he "supports" him to continue being one of his "store manager" for next year.
ya he is the manager, but it was still a bad question bc there would have been a set line to respond and he said it, "hes currently running honk kong so i support him, in the next election the election laws will judge"
nah it is as if the reporter is trying to lead jiang to say yes to china has internally arranged and appoint who the next hk manager is, which if he followed down the path would mean china meant to break the 1 country 2 system at that time. of cz being intelligent as jiang is, he saw through the trick and fuk the reporter over
Roman I don’t think you guys got the point, which is understandable since you are likely not familiar with the relationship between China and Hong Kong SAR. Hong Kong is a special region in China that has a different political system granted for 50 years. During which Hong Kong would have a democratic system. At the time of this video, the new top official of Hong Kong, who was sitting next to Jiang, was just elected. What happened was that the reporter was setting up a trap/trick question, asking Jiang whether he “supports” that Hong Kong official or not. If Jiang had said yes, the headline next day would be “Mainland government appoints Hong Kong SAR’s top official”, breaking the agreement of Hong Kong’s freedom of election. If Jiang had said no, the headline would be “chairman of China is openly against official elected thru democratic process in Hong Kong.” Consequently no matter how Jiang answers the question, he would be painted in a bad way by that reporter, which is what the reporter was clearly trying to do here. Jiang sees thru that, which is why Jiang called the reporter “too simple, too naive”, and compared her to Wallace, a famous American reporter at the time, and the first person to have interviewed the chairman of China. During that interview, he also tried to set up trick questions like this but had done so more sophisticatedly (Jiang did not fall into Wallace’s traps either). Jiang then proceeded to very clearly explain that his support doesn’t mean appointment from the government itself, and whether he supports or not doesn’t matter because the official was elected by Hong Kong people, answering the trick question without leaving any loose end for defamation. If this kind of questions were asked to Xi, he wouldn’t bother to answer at all. Likewise Jiang didn’t have to either, but Jiang in this video couldn’t resist to teach the reporter a lesson.
That's where press secretary or spokesperson is supposed to come into - to give clarity to what the head of the government is implying! Note 'implying' because he is trying to mean something he isn't saying! For me, that's arrogance. But then again these are powerful and old people. As such, arrogance is second nature to them.
@@LarryfromPH Jiang Zemin experienced the Sino-Japanese War, the Cultural Revolution, and the 1989 turmoil. Many people died in these incidents. We can’t look at a 70yearold man from a 20yearold perspective
@Julia he couldn't handle it because china during that period would have socially cast him out for one misstep on showing the world the power and might of "china" When in reality he was nothing more then a crook that got caught up with his own karma and got scared
@@keard558 litterally giving the ccp credit for being a good government. Are your brains fucking mush you troglody? That guy could have had that reporter killed in cold blood by the secret chinese police force. If anything the speaker let a moment of authenticity slip out from the sheer stupidity from the question. Of fucking course he supports the chairman for a second term. "HES STILL ON THE FIRST TERM AND CAN KILL ME IF I SAY NO"
Yeah bc China doesn't surrender to the west under the current leadership. As a Westerner (or banana) of course you don't like someone who makes China strong and with dignity.
He's not freaking out. He's just speaking normally like an actual chinese person. This is literally how chinese people converse or have an discussion with each other. The tone might sound very hostile but this is just how they talk.
so saying "I am angry" while running around like some Mickey Mouse on cocaine is actually "a normal Chinese conversation"? Nice, Im gonna try that next time at my local takeaway!
Jiang Zemin was being truthful and honest because we were all once sometimes too young and too simple, sometimes naive. He was actually concerned about the standard of journalism in Hong kong and China. I see no problem with that. He just wants them to improve although his reaction may be overboard. Rest in peace Jiang Zemin
That'0s what I thought. Adressing the journalists "disrespectfully" is better than ignoring them and asking security if they say too much, which most US president or elsewhere would do.
@@numuves Trump doesn't aim to be articulate, he has been like that since forever. He just want people to see him just as another down-to-earth guy and not some Harvard doctor of law above everyone and everything. Appearance is everything.
after all, he's one of the few (maybe the only one?) Chinese political leaders who expressed his emotion in front of media. Unlike Hu JinTao and Xi JinPing, who only read out load the well prepared manuscript... All Chinese politicians are the same, but Mr Jiang is just the funny one.
Yeap, the man's just right. Whether you like or dislike him he's expressing himself from a place of honesty and i agree on atleast this one point alone. The world has become full of dimwitted people and he knows it.
@@BloodInTheStrawberries no the level of foolishness and stupidity has risen exponentially in the last few decades. The millennials have been duped with a poor education system not to mention their time is spent mainly on applications of social media that feeds the brain zero advantage in critical thinking skills. Logic and reasoning have been abandoned by this generation of fools and you sound like one as well. Being young has nothing to do with it as you have stated so wrongly, it's not the age of a person that matters it's the quality of information being transmitted, processed and received from the individual. We are living in a age of deception and deliberate dumbing down of the masses. I can't tell you how many people I interact with on a daily basis that get stuck on the irrelevant points of conversations just like you did here. You have proved my point once again.
A very rare thing where a leader will speak what’s actually on his mind Edit: excluding Donald trump I know he speaks what’s on his mind most of the time when it comes to CNN reporters
Colm Moloney he was sharing what he thinks about the media. Quite a straightforward stance. It's like when someone wrongly accuses you. You get worked up. I disagree with your assessment
As far as Chinese dictators go, he was by far the most charismatic, intelligent and likeable one. He repaired some of the mistakes made by earlier leaders, massively improved the Chinese economy and was the only realistic competitor to Xi Jinping. He will be missed.
The era of asking CCP leadership hard questions was a relatively short period in the CCP timeline. Emperor Xi does not tolerate being questioned like that. China has reverted to feudalism.
buzzcrushtrendkill man you got a bunch of people speaking Chinese at you and I have no idea what they’re saying, but I would assume either pissed off or laughing/agreeing.
That’s the most influential meme on the internet of modern China. The government has never been able to stop it from spreading, everybody can understand that nowadays.
I'm guessing you're Chinese? Can you explain the context of this meme? I don't quite understand it. I guess it shows how speech was more free back when he was president of China? But that is just a guess
@@ahmedwan6528 Thank you for explaining! I hope China becomes more hospitable to free speech. It is really sad to see a wonderful nation of smart and strong people subjected to this oppression :(
@@user-pc1hk1cn4y It is to counter extremism that has plagued China since the war on terrorism however, Western media tends to dilute to context and coverage of the terrorist issues in the PRC and overly sensationalise western incidents. It labels China's re-education centres as islamaphobic attempts simmilar to concerntrayion camps yet China retains unwaivering support in the UN from 17 majority Muslim nations includong Saudi arabia. Not to mention how the western double standards initiated by the US and the UK for example, US Internment camps of japanese minorities, Latinos in ICE facilities along the mexican border treated inhumanely and racked into cages. Let alone the absurd proposition and prospect of ''freeing'' HKSAR and Xinjiang autonomous reigon is the equivalent of declaring independance for Puerto rico and Hawaii who face repression by the US central government. No I am not a BOT employed by any government or institution, but a patriotic Chinese citizen studying abroad. Who infact appreciates rather than disregard the power China has acclaimed from its predecessors embarrasement.
@@jhtang5441 Hawaii is not oppressed it is a full fledged state has equal rights and has been with America for over a hundred years. Hawaii doesnt allow non Hawaiians from moving into the island in order to preserve their culture so I highly doubt we oppress them. Also with Puerto Rico we support them during hurricanes and we dont even rule them. They have their own leadership and rule themselves almost they are merely an American territory and have access to citizenship. I will say the Philippines which we occupied during Teddy Roosevelt was wrong and we did merely use them for natural resources however, America has been doing better and has helped far more than it hurts
Jiang is one of the most charismatic leaders in modern history. He doesn’t mind sharing his emotions and occasionally making a fool of himself. It’s really rare among Chinese politicians.
@@Alfa_Chef Winnie needs inglish to run the country? I guess you are used to talk shows too much. while eatting bamboo and sleeping his country has become the world's No.2 economic power. You can dislike them, but you can't be ignorant.
@@Alfa_Chef then don't give a fk. don't pretend to be a Chinese expert here. I dont even know where u are from, and i certainly dont give a fk about the shithole u r from. mind your own business. stop picking on China that you neve been to like a hypocrite
Man was making points. That was a stupid question. Of course the Communist Party is going to support a member of the Communist Party over members of other parties. I'm trying to imagine a journalist getting mad at Joe Biden for supporting a Democrat as governor and accusing him of appointing people like an emperor.
Why saying evil dictator I still don't understand this typical western comportment you know it's not because a country have a dictatorship system that they are the bad guys, when you say this words you are speaking like Bush junior or Trump, you are demonizing, you should stop watch media. One phrase from Thus spoked Zarathoustra even tho I don't like Nietzsch : Nothing is true everything is permitted. Don't be fools guys
Majdoud Miry 1. Saying “what about Trump” isn’t a factual defense of a leader. 2. He factually was a totalitarian dictator, which already is pretty evil in my opinion. To deny the people their right to choose their own representatives via a democratic vote, is inherently evil. 3. He was General Secretary of the Communist Party during the Tiananmen Square Massacre, which means he is at least partially responsible for the deaths of potentially thousands of innocent protesters who only desired for China to become a democracy.
As unprofessional as this was, it's pretty interesting to see a Chinese leader be so upfront and straightforward with these reporters. He might have been shouting them down but he was still almost entertaining a conversation about the topic with them where he defended his actions and views. He let his guard down with them and acted like a human. He seems like a guy you can almost talk to. Xi today, as most of the other comments said, would ignore the question flatly, if the reporters were able to or even wanted to ask him.
At that time Hong Kong still mattered so Jiang give them so advices just to shut them up. Now it doesn't, heck, it is a negative asset for China so why would Xi give a f**k. He has 1.4 billion Chinese to attend to.
How so? She was pointing out how aristocratic the Chinese government was and its excessive power over HK. Should journalists just stay silent, since that has worked so well in the past?
The problem with the question lies in the answer because each answer could be interpreted differently by that same reporter... There fore he answered that the reported gave a naive question that can not be answered in a proper way and might even cause dispute among viewers, might cause misunderstandings of the current situation or may lead in panic slight propaganda among the masses over the non existent matters... Indeed reporters should learn what some of their questions lead towards and what kind of double meaning they could lead to..
@K. Prisca He's wise because he's the one that conducted the Tiananmen Square Massacre of 1989. Edit: got my facts wrong. He didn't do that... he did the persecution of Falun Gong
He’s right. Most reporters operate at about a grade 10 high school level of both intelligence and understanding of the issues they’re supposedly asking questions about.
He is a classic narcissist. He has a sense of superiority and grandiosity. She asked him a curly question and he shut her down by belittling her and playing the goodguy, the victim, the suffering martyr, the smart guy with all the wisdom there is on earth and the hero that wants the best for everyone. His body language too when he got out of his chair and indignantly approached her in an intimidating manner was narcissistic. The anger and rage that was simmering in him too is narcissistic. Enablers will blame the reporter and side with the narcissist and that shows their dangerous naivety. As with all cluster b's they are very dangerous creatures and even more dangerous when they are in government positions controlling the weapons.
@@tellercyde looks like Jey JoJo is yet another enabler. Enablers are as dangerous as narcissists themselves. When Joey JoJo has been the scapegoat target of a narcissistic abuser and copped the unrelenting and deliberate horror of their abuse Joey JoJo will likely change ITS tune. Until then Joey JoJo can remain the ignorant enabler IT is.
Protofx 原型 A mix of both for sure, he commented that “he’s seen too much” of “simple” and “naive” questions. If he’s known this for a long time it wouldn’t make sense for him to suddenly be super pissed off at the question (it’s also not a good look for him). He’s surely disappointed that after all this time they haven’t changed. Ofcourse since they continued to persist through his rant he became angry too.
Don’t eat Tide Pods Yeah I agree that would be against freedom of press. Well in the future you can just automate the news. Many reporter will be out of a job or work as bloggers or small time new coverage on the web. Meanwhile the machine run by the government controls what we are allow see or to be expose to.
For those who see this for the first time, this is one of the famous moments for "the elder". Some golden words from this have been incorporated with young Chinese internet subculture for years. This is the homework you need to do if you want to understand and enjoy the Chinese internet subculture.
I know, right I found freaking SCIENTIFIC study on Moha meme by Kecheng Fang in 2017 ". I collected and analyzed more than 100 toad worship memes, interviewed 24 creators and sharers of the memes, and conducted participant observation in two toad worship online communities." Just look at this, this is amazing
Can you recommend a video that will educate a westerner on Chinese pop culture, and mindset? I kind of drew on what he said about naivety... from all of the Chinese media outlets I follow, I get the impression that, culturally, china is super ...straight-laced, for lack of a better phrase.
@@davidjolley2468 When the whole world is against you, you naturally become straight-laced. Imagine when you decide to post a video on China on TH-cam, the first thing comes to your mind is to refute all those rumors on China and CCP, which are mostly nonsense yet still widely believed by a majority of the users. Currently Tiktok and Bilibili are 2 of the most vital video hosting communities in China. But even you know much formal Chinese, don't expect fully understand what's going on on them. I believe both are accessible outside of mainland China, so check them out if you're interested.
@@tapist3482 Oh I have, I follow China closely from the western perspective, and I do it through the lens of knowing the western perspective is biased. China has done a lot of great things since the Xiaoping economic reforms, and continues to do so, but to people like me, that isn't the issue. The collectivism; the utter lack of regard for the individual is what bothers most of us. For instance: on the surface, I like the social credit philosophy. We all want to see the assholes punished for being assholes, but a line has got to be drawn. Compulsory reeducation, and compulsory organ harvesting really rankles westerner's sensibilities. If you tote the line, and obey the laws, your life can be great in China, but what if you're in the wrong place, at the wrong time, or know something you shouldn't, and you become a liability, or inconvenience, to the party? That happens to perfectly good people over there, and the lack of adherence to basic human justice for the sake of collective harmony is what I find troubling. Speaking to China against everyone: I believe the West shares some responsibility in the political isolation that has griped mainland China, but the CCP shares as much, or more responsibility for the Chinese people feeling threatened by the west with nationalistic rhetoric. Just opinions
Not dictator, but with a lot of power nonetheless. Look at Egypt, Saudi Arabia, or modern day China. There if you spoke against the leader you mysteriously disappear the next day.
XP_Studios well first of all a good leader is not necessarily elected by the people because citizens make poor decisions sometimes and if it’s the matter of billions of population, we can’t simply choose whoever , it’s a very tricky thing.and btw democracy is never gonna work for China cut all the bias thoughts honestly same politics don’t work on all the countries that’s what I found people nowadays , cut that aside, people need to at least respect the laws and rules of one individual country , who is gonna judge the Arab kingdom for some of their extreme law enforcement that other places wouldn’t accept ? There is no perfect form of policies that satisfy everyone at the same time , things are improving and don’t get brainwashed by the west , the America era is almost ending and the world is evolving u can’t just simply think that the world is still working base on American standards . Free of speech doesn’t work on many many countries and don’t misunderstand the meaning of it and abuse it .that’s what many people do nowadays . Sometimes people have to pay for what came out of their mouth. That’s why u can’t speak recklessly in the court and then simply change your statement because of “freedom of speech” and don’t forget China is China , it has their own set of rules and way of life which might has a conflict with the west but eventually China is not putting their standard against the west , which means we expect the west should at least respect it . U may find many Chinese are speaking or defending for the country or the ccp especially in the topic of human rights. Some of their statement might have conflicting your ideas which makes you think they are brainwashed . But standing on the other side on a different perspective , why not at least try to understand why . World media is not reliable and people get to see what they are apportioned to see. That’s the universal rules . So keep your head clear and try to look at the world more precisely u may find many different stuff that you would’ve never expected. China has gotten rid of the title of communism that’s what many people know but don’t wanna accept. It’s fully capitalism and socialism which completely go against communism . I know there is no point of saying it but look, the world fear communism and even us we feared the past communist 30 years ago , the west media surely over exaggerate too much and thats why when Chinese people see these stuffs and westerners comments they feel unbelievable. Because it’s not really true all the time. Step out of your comfortzone and go out go actually be in China u will find the difference .
There are a lot of these comments here, and most of them have weird names like bo840 or BZ, without a profile picture. I can't tell if they are edgy kids or bots.
@Hugo Dahlström Bäckängsgymnasiet HU19L murderous dictator? Do you have any idea of what happened during his (very brief) presidency? Which murders are you talking about? He only applied some reforms and developed the green energy industry, there were no disorders or killings during his presidency. Stop shitting from your mouth and misinforming people as you clearly have no clue what you're talking about
In this video, Jiang said he was a supporter of Mr. Dong, but the reporter intentionally rephrased it as Jiang would internally appoint Mr. Dong. Jiang was very disappointed that the media intentionally misrepresented his opinions in order to get a piece of "breaking news", so he reiterated that "if you asked me whether I'm a supporter of Mr. Dong, I would say yes. However, the election must follow the law, including the basic law and the law of election." Despite his explanation, the reporter would just not give up misinterpreting Jiang's opinions, which made Jiang angry. Jiang made it very clear that if the reporter insisted on falsifying his opinions in her coverage, she would have to be responsible for any consequences related to it. Jiang also hoped all the reporters could improve their professional skills and stop being "too young, too simple, sometimes naive". He used Wallace, who interviewed him once, as an example of a "high level" journalist and said that Wallace was way higher than those reporters. Jiang has three very popular videos among the young people of mainland China, and this is only part of the first one (1: HK Reporter, 2: Visiting Eryuan, 3: Interview with Wallace). All three videos are available on TH-cam. The videos were initially used by some people (FLG) to portray Jiang as a bad figure. Contrary to their expectation, people very soon realized Jiang was only telling the truth and started to appreciate his charming personality. These videos, as well as his personal experiences, have been inspiring young people in mainland China to be knowledgable and rise to challenges in their lives. Just like what Jiang said in this video, the description of this video, though I'm not sure it was written by which "reporter", is kind of misleading. Nothing Jiang said was insane, but some comparisons between his true opinions and the reporter's interpretation, and his expectation of professional journalism. The reporter could be a bit scared back then, but she was definitely happy about this 20 years later as I saw her helping sell Jiang-related souvenirs online around 2018.
Thank you for this nuanced explanation. So absurd how this is framed to once again demonize China and even to make dumb points about the lack of press freedom.
Transfusions the reporter set up a trap. If he says he support Mr. Tung, the news next day will be CCP appoints leader of HK and ignore the democratic process. If he says no then the news will be CCP is against the leader elected by HK. If he refuse to answer and keep silent then the news will be CCP secretly intervene HK democratic process.
I know this for a fact: when elder chinese can’t answer a question, they usually say bullshit in roundabout, meandering ways to skirt the issue, then accuse you of being too young, etc.
@@chengejshi5523 Jiang said himself he should not reply... Yet he replied!!! Jiang did not choose none, he chose one, one he admitted he should not choose. How delusional are you? Or rather, please explain to me how Jiang "chose none".
How would you reply in his place then? If you say you support, I will say you made an inside decision which is an infringement of the democratic right of HK people, if you say you don’t support, I will say you are against the democratically elected leader of HK and by extension against democracy. It is not a question, it is rhetoric. And your failure to see that proved his point.
the irony is he talks about The jounalists having to gain more knowledge about the world , well they are kinda hampered by the great firewall of China LOL
There was no firewall back then, China was one of the most open societies in Asia, just without anarchy. unless you wanted to form a riot, there was literally nothing anyone couldn’t say or do in those days.
@@charlescxgo7629 like to disagree , check this article The evolution of China’s Great Firewall: 21 years of censorship , this clip is after 1987 within the time frame of the great firewall www.hongkongfp.com/2017/09/03/evolution-chinas-great-firewall-21-years-censorship/
Mike Wallace: *HEAVY BREATHING INTENSIFIES!* 😂😂😂😂 No seriously, I was not expecting that name drop. That hit just as hard as that Waazup Beijing meme.😂😂😂😂😂😂
![🔴 ฟุตบอลแชมป์กีฬา 7HD แชมเปียน คัพ 2024 [รอบรองชนะเลิศ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zPm8ClLVhoE/mqdefault.jpg)
Several years ago, we all made jokes of him. Now, we understand we were too young too simple, sometimes naive.
Hao Chen in what sense?
@@jambomambo3808 china now is stronger than ever
圖森破，上台拿衣服。
Hahaha. True. He was actually the easy going one.
Hao Chen best comment
Doesnt sound like anger sounds like genuine disappointment
Well it was genuine disappointment.
but there is some paranoia in it too
Exacly. This is not a freak out.
Finn C Thornhill that‘s true
Hong Kong at this time was very politically unstable, his reaction and the reason he probably reiterates following election law is because he is afraid of widespread riots.
I love how he switches from Mandarin, to Cantonese, to English and back
Edit: I haven't checked on this comment for 9 months, and there's a whole political debate here (and people calling me a communist)
We call that schizoid.
I thinks its supposed to be spiteful, as in "have i made it easy enough for you to understand". Thats my guess based on his usage and demeanor.
Mr.Worldwide
He sflexing on thoose whoernalists.
@@here7ic 对 因为有些人不懂中文
"Too simple, sometimes naive". Jiang Zemin will be truely missed.
One of his most iconic moments lol.
Слава Советской Армии !
th-cam.com/video/CAutQJ004bQ/w-d-xo.html
Did I ever miss a communist? No way 😂
@@studiobencivengamarcusbenc5272 we do miss an interesting guy who destroyed the biggest cult in Chinese history. 識唔識得啊？ 你們哪，NAIVE.
@@canpek545Wait, did he destroy the CCP? I haven't heard of such.
everybody gangsta until a chinese dictator start speaking english and cantonese
I'd shut up and listen 👂
Far from a dictator unfortunately.
That Guy id shut up and pack my bags
Down with Stalinism party dictatorship and Dengism!
Free Chinese proletariat..
@@gangsheit6501 Says the guy with Pol Pot as his pfp
What Xi learned from this? Just smile and say nothing. Everything can be taken care of later.
hes a wise man
You are too superficial
the chosen winnie
Poo bear
事实上，他并没有学到什么。
I'd pay 1000 dollars just to see him debating with Donald Trump.
I doubt you could find many places where Jiang and Trump disagreed (of course lots of places where interests are contrary, but that's not really solved through debate)
Considering Jiang's teetering on the edge of the grave, I somehow doubt you'll be spending that grand on the spectacle anytime soon.
A bit difficult since he is nearly dead!
@@erwin7540 That's interesting, what do you find similar in their beliefs?
@@marcusatiusvirilis7723 They are both non ideological pragmatists focused on their own national interest, as opposed to the more ideologically driven who have succeeded Jiang and preceded Trump. Jiang's was the hand picked successor to Deng Xiaoping who famously said "don't care if it's a black cat or a white cat, as long as it catches mice, it's at good cat". Jiang presided of China's fastest period of growth, and though the US is a mature market, we're also seeing the results of a leader focused on economic growth and ultimately jobs. Surely would they would disagree about what they would like to see happen, as China and US interests are largely a zero sum game, but as for a debate, I'm pretty sure they would mostly agree about what should be done and why, with the exception of Trump and the US being very open to public disagreement and protest. These two would be more suitable for a "panel discussion" than a debate. For full disclosure, there's reason to believe that Zhu Rongji was actually the one working behind the scenes to make Jiang look successful.
In front of the mistery of the death, we are all too young and too simple, sometimes naive
Rest in peace Jiang Zemin
What a guy.
Xi got rid of WenjiBao first now it is him
Not sure abt mystery of death but i wouldn’t be surprised if china has a ministry of death… ;)
I WILL SEE HIM IN HELL BECAUSE I HAVE A RESERVATION WAITING THERE FOR ME
Well he was 96 years old. I don't doubt it it the possibility ever crossed Xi's mind, but I find the speculation redundant
I love how he talks to the reporters in three different languages.
@lethal hipster Wrong!
@Jeffrey Gu taiwan is part of china according to the 1992 consensus
lethal hipster
请你有点汉语语言学常识。中文分为官话，吴语（包括上海话），赣语，晋语，湘语，粤语，不同种类的闽语，客家话。四川话属于官话中的西南官话。粤语就是一种独立的语言。
If you do not have any linguistics knowledge you’d better not argue about this topic. Under the Chinese languages there are Mandarin, Wu (including Shanghainese), Gan (Jiangxi), Jin (Shanxi), Xiang (Hunan), Yue (Cantonese), the Min Languages (including Hokkien, Taiwanese, Teochew) and Hakka. Sichuan speaks Mandarin. Cantonese is a separate language FROM MANDARIN.
@lethal hipster in fact i cannot understand the person's speak who just cross a mountain, even we are in the same county.....
@Joe Franklin He was in hong kong using their dialectal slang
Translation: "I'm not mad at you, I'm just disappointed..."
good headpicture
star ice im disappointed, u were born a pervert
@@tomato-v8x *I'm disappointed OP's profile picture has more breast in it than forehead, the eyes are two pixels from being clipped too ffs*
Troll 😂
I'm not disappointed
Jiang had a “Did these mothafuckas seriously ask me that dumbass question” moment.
Skylab Lmao
Skylab the reporter was setting up a trap, asking Jiang whether he “supports” that Hong Kong official or not. If Jiang said yes, the headline next day would be Mainland government appoints Hong Kong SAR’s top official, breaking the agreement of Hong Kong’s freedom of election. If Jiang says no, the headline would be chairman of China is openly against official elected thru democratic process in Hong Kong. Consequently no matter how Jiang answers the question, he would be painted in a bad way by that reporter.
Jiang sees thru that, which is why Jiang calls the reporter too simple, too naive, compared the reporter to Wallace, who also tried to set up trick questions like this during his interview with Jiang but had done so more sophisticatedly (Jiang did not fall into Wallace’s traps either).
Jiang then proceeds to very clearly explain that his support doesn’t mean appointment from the government itself, and whether he supports or not doesn’t matter because the official was elected by Hong Kong people, answering the trick question without leaving any loose end for defamation.
If this kind of questions were asked to Xi, he wouldn’t bother to answer at all. So could Jiang, but Jiang in this video couldn’t resist to teach the reporter a lesson.
@@haotianxie6684 棒！👍👍👍
@@haotianxie6684 This was a joke not a political statement
@@haotianxie6684 well said
Hate him or love him, he's speaking straight facts
but he was very corrupted too lol
he is dodging the question whether Hong Kong deserves it's own set of democrats
More like straight dodging questions
@@Hulbetley no.
Nah, he's just a dictator like the others
at least he acts like a human…not a creepy smily bear…
exactly, that’s the only thing that makes a leader good. Politics? How he’s running the country? Nah those don’t fucking matter. Hey trump seems really human! Vote for him and keep him on!
@@jiaruiyan870 lol fucking relax.
Guy Mcface Arrogant leftists are usually consumed by politics, as they believe it is the answer to the world’s problems.
@@jiaruiyan870 first time i see someone saying that Trump looks human. Not with that orangey face and the squirrel on his head.
@@jiaruiyan870 why do you have to bring trump into this?
Fun fact: This guy is still alive and is 94 at the time this comment was written.
Here in China we have made up a race between him and other political leaders or head national figures who were born around the same time to see who’s going to stay in this world longer than other “competitors”
Right now Mrs.Tatcher, mr. Wallace have lost the race, and Queen Elizabeth seems to be the easy winner of this race😂
@𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙𒈙 fancy seeing you here
@@wangxx6970 the queen will probably live another hundred years at this rate
Fa Long Gong organs are very healthy and readily available!
chinese people say "+1s" for wishes of his long life
After the interview, some names were added to some lists.
Deleted the woman who asked the question, She commited suiced, She was found dead with 3 bullet holes
@@moinkallo689 what's her name??
@@awol6574 She has no name. Didn't you hear, she was deleted.
Megan H What?
扯淡！
We are all at times too young, too simple, sometimes naive, RIP Jiang Zemin
never forget
I WILL SEE HIM IN HELL BECAUSE I HAVE A RESERVATION WAITING THERE FOR ME
@@ov_alp never forget how evil he was
This dude is the very reason why china transformed from very poor third world country to rich modern country
He was sincerely a genius. No matter if you like or not
Thats like if someone makes haiti a rich country 20 years later
@@retrogaminggenesis6102 who isn't?
Does every room in China look like a Chinese restaurant?
Well not really.
lol what kind of Chinese restaurants you've been to? they definitely don't look like this. Oh, unless you're talking about certain decorations or patterns? stop trying to be edgy
@@ChrisGugliuzza I didnt think making an obvious observation was edgy?
I dont think you know what edgy means.
Yes 😂😂😂
@@ChrisGugliuzza ok sjw
It looks like a Command and Conquer cutscene. Lol
Tho H. Ho ROFL!!!! Well said.
He was teaching young children how the power run。Those journalists lived in western discourse systems
Sarthak Panda How brainwashed are you.
Shame that video games these days pay large money to motion capture actors for cutscene... we have gone a full circle
More Tanks,Generuu
Good God I’m surprised he lectured the media. The current one would’ve just ordered to have them disappear.
They didn't quite have enough power in HK to do it back then. Which is also why she had the nerve to ask it.
@Hans Kammler on what?
That's why they faked goodness because all the evidence are buried and leave no base for world to know. And some idiots trust them.
@@dawatsering1608 You are that idiot
Villa -Canislupus i hope that dictator eats lead in the near future and that the people of china may be freed from his wrath of an iron fist
You know what? This is refreshing. I don't care what this man is saying or who he is. The fact that a politician is speaking from heart and not being a robot about it is totally refreshing! Heck, I'm pretty sure the usual robotic tone all politicians use is another way of making politics boring and deterring people away from getting into how countries are truly run.
Still, this happened, and I'm happy. Peace from Saudi Arabia. :)
EDIT: Perhaps the way this man is talking could be fabricated to deter the questions away from him, meaning this reprimanding style of speech is another old and classic tactic of dealing with the media, meaning perhaps I praised this as a refreshing video for nothing. lol
He lost control because he thought that Hongkong reporters didn't get to ask HIM tough questions, so he decided to teach them a lesson. And that is because he thought Hongkong was already part of China and the reporters there should behave themselves, more or less like those from the mainland. That's the real reason he showed his true side (I suspect there was no western media present on that day). If a reporter from the Chinese Central Television dared to ask him a similar question, Jiang would immediately fire the chief of that TV station and call this a serious political incident.
i think u r wrong. Jiang met many reports, especially Wallace, an American interviewer. u can find some videos about him and Wallace who mentioned autocracy, Fa Lungong,and etc. In this video in Hong Kong, it does not mean he didn't dare to answer the question put forward by the young reporter, but mean those young reporters of Mandarin and Hong Kong are supposed to improve their questions' quantity because the question in the video is so easy to Jiang, and Jiang must thought you are too naive to ask much experienced politician, or someone having higer status abroad. It's my opinion to Jiang , and, only Jiang, not to today's CCP . ( yet maybe i don't know him enough)
From at least what it sounds like here even if that is partially his point I don't think that this is his full argument. I think he found the way they would ask the questions to be lazy, leading / pointed. @@wujijianchuqiao
Saudi person not being shocked by a dictator rant... not surprising at all.
@@marcteenhc9793 All countries do bad things, most probably even yours. In fact, KSA's problems are quite tame in comparison to so many other nations. Don't blindly follow the media, dear.
He made a good point. Media is nothing but trying to provoke a reaction through accusation and make a big headlines based on conjectures. I would not agree with him when he said "naive". Twisted would be a better word.
He might have said naive because they jump to such conclusions without truly understanding the gravity of the situation at hand. This media has always existed. Their job is to generate money for their company, so at a certain point they dumb it down to broaden things
@@HumanShoot
Media is about power alway has been always will be only ever cared about money as a tool for power...
As the good man said.... naive
Very true... Medias nowadays were utter rubbish... For entertainment it is fine...
Their job is to keep leaders in check. If they are asking questions and the politicians are getting annoyed, that's how you know they are doing their job right. You people are idiots
Vincent if they don’t who will
"Too young too simple, sometimes naive". The first English sentence that I learned.
Seriously? 😂
@@crappyaccount it's like a meme over in china, its become a classic saying
@@jiabaohuang5597 哇，有生之年遇到了同叫家宝的？？
@@user-tq8vd2xj6z thanks for enlightening us on that!
One of the first Chinese sentences I learned was "我爸是李刚" XD
He isn’t really freaking out, he’s more lecturing the reporters lol
clasic Chinese boomer
And he is more experienced, elder, wiser - by orders of magnitude. But what the hell? Journos want attention!
well done jiang Zemin
yea... becuase that reporter try to set a trap on his speech, that's why he stand out.
@@andyyu5973 lol don't know if you're joking or not, but he's not a boomer
Honestly it’s quite amazing that he switched to English then Cantonese in his rant lmao
@@DioStole ???
Most multilingual around the world can do that.
Asian dads when their kids gets a B+ for their test
Literally an Asian meme lol
Joker try missing one question on the test and Asian dad is scolding ur preemptively for that pontentail day u get an A-. Lol my comment should be in an Asian comedy.
Nobady
Asian dads: 我 很 生 氣
omg so true
My dad uses belt too
As corrupt and as bad as Jiang Zemin was, this could never happen today. Reporters would never ask hard questions or talk back to the Chinese leader today.
He was still a murderous evil bastard who genocided his own people.
Ian Hay
Zao medong
@@fahoodie1852 Yeah, you misspelled his name
Ian Hay China beautiful country beautiful culture one of the best in the world in fact amazing nature. But have always had shit government that works against the people not for. It’s a tragedy
@@banger2998 Sounds like Russia
This video must be archived and declared Intangible Cultural Heritage of China.
"Just imagine what would have happened if US President Barack Obama freaked out like this" Let see we have James Rosen, his friends, his family, investigated by the intelligence community by the direction of Obama, Michael Hastings whos car exploded after going 150mph and running from the FBI. Loretta Fuddy dies in a plane crash after signing Obamas fake birth certificate when nobody else on the plane had more than a scratch. On and On. It wasn't just China.
Haha, people made memes from this all over.
and Xi Jingping will burn it
You’re rude and that’s your country’s culture heritage.
Justin Wong Those ppl are a joke, instead.
He has a point though. “Does the CCP support the sitting executive of Hong Kong?” Was a pretty obvious question all those years ago. Jiang was right, we were all too naïve, and we missed the big picture for a very long time.
看到这些的 香港 轮到人。他们跟来一样澳洲的轮到。。是是的人 lam 真的不懂的事， 为什么该干煸法律， 还有不能够准备未可老年的病例新光病毒。。。regardez quelle incompétence et franche bêtise, la Dame Lam 1. Ne comprend pas l’importance de changer la loi, d’arrêter les criminels, y compris les agents secrets de s’infiltrer à 香港。 2。 retrait absolument gaffe de promulger cette loi. Et 3. Ne pas comprendre que les criminels se réorganizent et cause tellement de destruction. Et hypocrisie de médias occidentaux, utilisent l’occasion pour encor une fois faire la travestie de la véritÈ. COMME D’HABITUDE..4.. epidèmie de COVID19 VARIANTS OMECRON多。 La Dame Lam n’a rien donné. En matière de vaccins etc pour tous les vieux, abondonnés , comme on le voit partout le monde. De cette façon , elle me rappelle les Authorités de quarantine du GULAG AUSTRALIE, qui accueillent le paquebot de plaisance , en plein ville, n’ont rien préparé. En nimporte quelle façon..sauf qu’elles accusent la guerre biologique .. et voilà. Tant et tant de vieux et d’autres meurent , de la façon la plus irresponsable, et de leurs enfants .. qui ne se sentent en aucune faÇon obligÉ de s’occuper de leurs parents, qu’ils abondonnent dans des maisons Asiles..ils n’en veulent pas. In no way do they want to be responsible for them..triste n’est ce pas ? Enfin voilà, La Dame Lam est très proche de la gouvernance GULAG AUSTRALIE . Too late not enough. ELLE A BIEN FAIT DE QUITTER SON POSTE. par contre les gens d’ici continuent à se donner des récompenses !! 😄😄😢😢
What was the big picture?
@@gsurtos6588 Many were, and still are, overly concerned with the short game, the headlines, and day to day metrics. Jiang was president of China at a moment where Chinese soft power and economic might was growing quickly, and not many people back then asked about what a superpower China would be capable of. Now, much of that has changed, and the CCP is faltering in its leadership of China, but back then they were doing their hardest to play the long game and gain enough power to be the empire they used to be.
True
@@jamesmoran8294 bro are serious, how is ccp faltering now
That magical era when China was led by a meme.
yes, that's why china is full of memes today
now the US has entered into this ear
I wish he could engage in tweet war with our president trump.
Zylo Thecat Trump is obviously not qualified. He is only interested inter-reacting with his club, people like Elizabeth II, Fidel Castro etc. A completion started in 1926 between them, only Jiang and the Queen qualify the final. Who will be the winner, history will tell you the answer. Let's wait for the answer
苟利国家生死以 岂因祸福避趋之
China in 90s: the president and reporter can have discussion openly.
China in 20s: talking about winnie the pooh and then become history
true
History implies being recorded and acknowledged as having existed at all
I mean... only America is becoming history.
@@brandon9327 and how is that?
Biji Mon take a wide look at today’s world. Stop dreaming.. even though I kinda want America to continue.😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
If you actually think about what he said... his rant 100% applies to American journalism today. lol. Tons of sensational legwork, but little to no substance.
That's exactly his point! I'm not chinese, but from his reaction I can tell he's super pissed they are picking up the bad habits of western journalism, and he's utterly disappointed that she's too stupid to even do it well since it was evident it was best to ignore her.
HAHAHA FVCK U.S.A YOUR LEADER ARE SHIT AND STUPID. AND YOU ALL SAY EVERY LEADER IN THE WORLD IS BAD. JUST LIKE MOST OF U.S MEDIA SAY CHINESE GOVERNMENT FOR PREVENTING CORONA VIRUS IS BAD. BUT WHEN CORONA VIRUS ENTER THE U.S YOUR GOVERNMENT AND LEADER ARE THE WORST. STUPID CITIZENS AND GOVERNMENT
Journalism in america is bad... My country too has bad journalism. You cant trust media anymore.
@@mastermarco1723 Agreed. At this point, they're not doing genuine journalism. They're doing business. It all depends on what their target market wants at this point.
Though, to look in their perspective, they need a way to get food on the table.
Not only American journalism. Here in India the situation is so divided that one section of the TV media sucks up to the government while the other section is busy dissing the government at every step. There is a genuine lack of neutral and factual journalism.
May you Rest In Peace, dear elder.
This was actually the good old time, before the financial crisis, before the political crackdown, before the HK unrest, and before the trade war. Now I understand, back then I was too young too simple, sometimes naive.
“69” ...heh
LOL
Dude this was like just 4 years ago
This is the good old time? You are keen to romanticize oppression and despotism in HK? You are no better than the mediaeval times nobility if you cry about HK unrest- you are keen to live your life on the behalf of someone else that is exploited and continuously abused.
@@qlon dude, this footage was posted here 4 years ago, it was recorded way longer before, alright.
Virgin Xi: *censors memes calling him Winnie the Pooh*
Chad Jiang: _"Madame reporter, I find the question you are asking me to be politically disingenuous and I advise you, not as your paramount leader but as an elder, to word your questions correctly from now on."_
*R.I.P. Jiang Zemin*
Well chad jiang also sold harvested organs sooooo....
@@greed5891 ...and George Washington had slaves, what's your point?
@@greed5891 and they are still doing it, its a chinese tradition! wouldnt be fair to only hold him under it
@@greed5891 what do you think happens in American hospitals when they make profit on donated organs? Healthcare in America is privatized, so donated your organs is simply allowing a private company to sell those organs and procedures. Its easy to make something seem horrific with little to no information about the details of those transactions. We sell organs in horrific was as well, we also take advantage of organ donors and the uninsured because selling their organs is more profitable than them having unpaid medical debt.
Xi just would have sent them to those Uigur camps, or just disappeared forever
Apparently the “too young, too simple” line is a meme over in China
Cool
It's already out of time, maybe five years ago it's all over the internet
As well as “the elder”
Not just "too young, too simple" but also "sometimes naive".
Really? anyone who used the that memes would disappear.😤😤😤
I remember him mostly because of this video this is classic RIP Jiang Zemin
I WILL SEE HIM IN HELL BECAUSE I HAVE A RESERVATION WAITING THERE FOR ME
th-cam.com/video/oO0zy30n_jQ/w-d-xo.html
If accurate, he's right, you know.
Media take a small detail and try to make it bigger than it really is, rather than report on it.
*Then
@@liquidbraino okay bob ross
@@liquidbraino Theng
@@padmosss.voidstellar2525 Then'g*
@@liquidbraino *When you thought this was Reddit*
As much as I hated Jiang his English is excellent compared to other leaders
Vulpes Inculta this guy seems so much more educated and wise compared to the Pooh bear.
Ave ! True to Caesar !
Who cares about his English? Ranting like a loon.
He can also speak a dozen languages.
U should watch his video with Mike Wallace, he even recited the speech of Lincoln
When he’s angry, the English comes out.
Most chinese grandparent talk like that so to tell us young people they're smart and many poem too
RIP JIANG ZEMIN! You would be remembered as the friendliest and funniest Chinese president.
Слава Советской Армии !
th-cam.com/video/CAutQJ004bQ/w-d-xo.html
@@CCCP-2918 idi nahui
I WILL SEE HIM IN HELL BECAUSE I HAVE A RESERVATION WAITING THERE FOR ME
Not much friendly about this mf
he did the Tiananmen square massacre
In all Honesty Jiang Zemin did seem sincere to the reporters when he said “I’m worried for you all” I think he was trying to give them advice on how life works in China
So True
True, that they will get exterminated if they dont stfu or be their slaves.
VICTOR Austria What the west doesn’t realise about the CCP is that it’s a ruthless blood bath of people trying to kill each other and take there power.
@@ihk2421 they realize that the ccp is ruthless and committed all these crimes... Its just the west doesnt care, since money is king.
Look at WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION ccp only paid a few corrupt WHO officials and look what they did, they almost destroyed mankind.
@Victor Austria Sounds like correction is only exclusive in China. LOL.
Don't you know that Covid is probably made by US? Have you heard the documentary "plandemic"?
If the guy was Italian this would be categorized as slightly upset political discourse in italu
Slightly upset?
It would be just a regular conversation.
😂
Lol... the first time I went to Italy I thought ‘why is everyone always yelling at each other’? 😆
Lol
*"Italu"*
Honestly speaking I kinda prefer him to Winnie the Pooh
Honestly, I prefer your mother.
lol one of winnie the poohs honey jar is mad XD
I guess ur not watching China Unsensored Videos then!!
@@VaRag98 he does look like winnie the pooh but not cute at all XD
@@AntezPH LMAO
Rest in Peace Jiang Zemin. we are too young, too simple, sometimes naive to judge you when comparing to the current one that looks like Winnie the Pooh.
I WILL SEE HIM IN HELL BECAUSE I HAVE A RESERVATION WAITING THERE FOR ME
โกหก เพื่อน ทำได้ อย่า โกหก ตัวเอง เกินไป ไม่สำคัญหรอกว่านายจะหลอกฉัน แต่ฉันหวังว่าคุณจะ เช็ด มุมของตา หลังจากเสร็จสิ้น ข้อความนี้ อย่าปล่อยให้ น้ำตา บนหน้ สิ่งที่คุณกล่าวว่า เพื่อน เชื่อว่ามัน ไม่มีอะไร นอกจากนี้คุณยัง สามารถมี หัวใจ ของความสะดวกสบาย แต่ คำพูด ดังกล่าวจะ โกหก พี่น้อง เกือบ มาก เพื่อน เชื่อว่าคุณ จะ เพื่อน มันไม่สำคัญว่า คุณจะ หลอกลวง พี่ชาย หัวเราะ ใน อดีตที่ผ่านมา ฉันไม่ได้ พยายามที่จะทำลาย การป้องกันของคุณ คุณเช็ด น้ำตา คิดเกี่ยวกับมัน
You sound like Winnie the pooh
@@mrsir6000 Nothing wrong with Winnie The Pooh, unless you are the Chinese DICKtator
@@WolfSS88 Yes, ur right.
The kinda question reporter asked is “do you support your manager?” With you standing next to your manager who just hired you being asked this question, haha.
It was as he stated a dumb and naive question in my opinion. I can't do anything but agree with this man.
I don't think he is being asked about his "manager", he is the "boss of the company" here. The reporter is asking whether he "supports" him to continue being one of his "store manager" for next year.
ya he is the manager, but it was still a bad question bc there would have been a set line to respond and he said it, "hes currently running honk kong so i support him, in the next election the election laws will judge"
nah it is as if the reporter is trying to lead jiang to say yes to china has internally arranged and appoint who the next hk manager is, which if he followed down the path would mean china meant to break the 1 country 2 system at that time. of cz being intelligent as jiang is, he saw through the trick and fuk the reporter over
Roman I don’t think you guys got the point, which is understandable since you are likely not familiar with the relationship between China and Hong Kong SAR. Hong Kong is a special region in China that has a different political system granted for 50 years. During which Hong Kong would have a democratic system. At the time of this video, the new top official of Hong Kong, who was sitting next to Jiang, was just elected.
What happened was that the reporter was setting up a trap/trick question, asking Jiang whether he “supports” that Hong Kong official or not. If Jiang had said yes, the headline next day would be “Mainland government appoints Hong Kong SAR’s top official”, breaking the agreement of Hong Kong’s freedom of election. If Jiang had said no, the headline would be “chairman of China is openly against official elected thru democratic process in Hong Kong.” Consequently no matter how Jiang answers the question, he would be painted in a bad way by that reporter, which is what the reporter was clearly trying to do here.
Jiang sees thru that, which is why Jiang called the reporter “too simple, too naive”, and compared her to Wallace, a famous American reporter at the time, and the first person to have interviewed the chairman of China. During that interview, he also tried to set up trick questions like this but had done so more sophisticatedly (Jiang did not fall into Wallace’s traps either).
Jiang then proceeded to very clearly explain that his support doesn’t mean appointment from the government itself, and whether he supports or not doesn’t matter because the official was elected by Hong Kong people, answering the trick question without leaving any loose end for defamation.
If this kind of questions were asked to Xi, he wouldn’t bother to answer at all. Likewise Jiang didn’t have to either, but Jiang in this video couldn’t resist to teach the reporter a lesson.
The famous quote: TOO YOUNG TOO SIMPLE, SOMETIMES NAIVE!
sometime i agree with this pharse
That's where press secretary or spokesperson is supposed to come into - to give clarity to what the head of the government is implying! Note 'implying' because he is trying to mean something he isn't saying!
For me, that's arrogance. But then again these are powerful and old people. As such, arrogance is second nature to them.
Actually he isnt wrong, but “sometimes naive” is an understatement
@@LarryfromPH Jiang Zemin experienced the Sino-Japanese War, the Cultural Revolution, and the 1989 turmoil. Many people died in these incidents.
We can’t look at a 70yearold man from a 20yearold perspective
Better than “you are fake news. Next question.”
It’s over when they drop the “I’m speaking to you as your elder,” line.
Why? Is not even your culture. There's clearly a tradition of respecting the elders in Asia, specially in country's like China and Japan.
@@KamuiPan doesn't have to be part of their culture, for them to understand the meaning.
@@KamuiPan ohhhh shuuut uppppp
@@guy_in_ashopping_cart-sfs967 for real all these people like him just wanna argue
@@KamuiPan India and then this culture spread to China and Japan through bhudhism
The "freakout" was actually justified and everything he said was correct. And this kind of candidness in politicians is a good thing.
yeah that was literally a trap question
It wasn't justified at all. It was more like an outburst of the guilty party
He's actually a really competent speaker; calling this a "freakout" is the kind of inflammatory narrow mindedness he is speaking against.
Yeah too bad China still got internment camps
No, everything he said amounts to 'shut up and stop asking questions'
honestly, he had a point. plus he did give his answers but the media just wont stop yapping
@Julia he couldn't handle it because china during that period would have socially cast him out for one misstep on showing the world the power and might of "china"
When in reality he was nothing more then a crook that got caught up with his own karma and got scared
@@keard558 litterally giving the ccp credit for being a good government. Are your brains fucking mush you troglody?
That guy could have had that reporter killed in cold blood by the secret chinese police force. If anything the speaker let a moment of authenticity slip out from the sheer stupidity from the question. Of fucking course he supports the chairman for a second term. "HES STILL ON THE FIRST TERM AND CAN KILL ME IF I SAY NO"
I feel better on this man than the current one.
Lol same
yeah cuz he looked like a real person who has feelings, smart and interesting
Jeff The Wonderkid you know nothing
Same thing but you're a kid so you don't realize it yet! The reporter could have been paid to ask that question on purpose!
Yeah bc China doesn't surrender to the west under the current leadership. As a Westerner (or banana) of course you don't like someone who makes China strong and with dignity.
If only Winnie the Pooh was this entertaining.
he wouldn't have done that, instead you would have been turned up in a ditch dead somewhere because he secretly ordered the death of u lol
@Tuxedo jiang isn't like xi Jinping he developed china to the superpower it is today and didn't inter fear with hong kong
@@ksedo thats not his style, you are more likely to face interrogation, intimidation, persecution and imprisonement
@@cisco8257 That's one way to justify all of that wasted money in Africa. Clearly China has learned nothing from Europe.
more like whiny the pooh at this point
RIP Jiang ZeMin 1926-2022 who lived a fruitful 96 years
Wow!
He's not freaking out. He's just speaking normally like an actual chinese person. This is literally how chinese people converse or have an discussion with each other. The tone might sound very hostile but this is just how they talk.
AnimeFallenFan seems passive-aggressive at the same time.
so saying "I am angry" while running around like some Mickey Mouse on cocaine is actually "a normal Chinese conversation"? Nice, Im gonna try that next time at my local takeaway!
I was in Aldi last week and it sounded like a Hong Kong riot
Lol, good one.
You are so right my parents and I speak like this all the time
"I am not angry just disappointed"
*Some moments later*
"I am angry"
Emosilah, masak tanyaaaa yerus 😅
Hahaha he’s adorable
It's like you might not be happy yesterday, but happy today, and his mood change is calculated in seconds
@@Miliyaliyahe he's an as**"***. Do not judge a book by the cover, do some research on him. You will be shocked.
When did he say "I'm not angry just disappointed?"
This just showed up in my recommendations in 2019.
same lol
This showed up on my feed many times already, eventually i gave in and watch it
Something fishy about TH-cam recommendations
Because CCP and Google are having some troubles right now.
ozzy they they are best friends?
Jiang Zemin was being truthful and honest because we were all once sometimes too young and too simple, sometimes naive. He was actually concerned about the standard of journalism in Hong kong and China. I see no problem with that. He just wants them to improve although his reaction may be overboard.
Rest in peace Jiang Zemin
He acts less demeaning than most other officials, at least he doesn't ignore the journalists.
+Haaklong Nguyệt That doesn't stop officials trying to cover the camera lens as well as stopping the questioning though, because you know, he's Angry!
The main reason people don't talk to journalists is because there isn't much you can do about hard headed people.
Colby Thornton 😃😃
That'0s what I thought. Adressing the journalists "disrespectfully" is better than ignoring them and asking security if they say too much, which most US president or elsewhere would do.
No, the US president would most likely just shit on you and move on the next person. Like it was in the 2016 elections.
This looks like something straight out of a movie
That's what I thought as well lol
yeah lmao the camera shots look kinda cinematic too
It's also similar to how Trump would answer a question although I'd argue Jiang Zemin is much more articulate. (I make vids from China by the way)
Straight up gangster kung fu movie lol
@@numuves Trump doesn't aim to be articulate, he has been like that since forever. He just want people to see him just as another down-to-earth guy and not some Harvard doctor of law above everyone and everything.
Appearance is everything.
after all, he's one of the few (maybe the only one?) Chinese political leaders who expressed his emotion in front of media. Unlike Hu JinTao and Xi JinPing, who only read out load the well prepared manuscript... All Chinese politicians are the same, but Mr Jiang is just the funny one.
然而习近平连稿子都读错，没办法，民国的教育总是比文革的教育好
李德胜 兹磁兹瓷
Yeah I was just thinking of if xi acted like this Americans would be begging to grow closer to China.
you should watch young xi report ,he is also very funny guy.
You mean wut he read mistaken word"farm" into "wearing"? lolz
"Mr BIDEN What kind of ice cream are you eating?!" American journalists
Yeap, the man's just right. Whether you like or dislike him he's expressing himself from a place of honesty and i agree on atleast this one point alone.
The world has become full of dimwitted people and he knows it.
I wouldn't say has become, I'd argue always has been.
@@jeffchiqui2642 hmmm this one. I like what you said
True
Her question is simple but the reaction speaks for itself! She touched on the truth, amd the truth burnt bright!
@@BloodInTheStrawberries no the level of foolishness and stupidity has risen exponentially in the last few decades. The millennials have been duped with a poor education system not to mention their time is spent mainly on applications of social media that feeds the brain zero advantage in critical thinking skills. Logic and reasoning have been abandoned by this generation of fools and you sound like one as well. Being young has nothing to do with it as you have stated so wrongly, it's not the age of a person that matters it's the quality of information being transmitted, processed and received from the individual. We are living in a age of deception and deliberate dumbing down of the masses. I can't tell you how many people I interact with on a daily basis that get stuck on the irrelevant points of conversations just like you did here. You have proved my point once again.
A very rare thing where a leader will speak what’s actually on his mind
Edit: excluding Donald trump I know he speaks what’s on his mind most of the time when it comes to CNN reporters
True sometimes you have to be honest but there's a place and time tho
Trump enters the chat.
Castlefaber333: true sometimes you have to be honest but there's a place and time tho
Trump: it's free real estate
Yeah and he looked unhinged
Colm Moloney he was sharing what he thinks about the media. Quite a straightforward stance. It's like when someone wrongly accuses you. You get worked up. I disagree with your assessment
He gave a very honest answer to an attempted trick question. To freak out is something completely different.
China Uncensored uses just about anything to make china or (ccp) look bad. It's 50/50 sometimes its a reach
As far as Chinese dictators go, he was by far the most charismatic, intelligent and likeable one. He repaired some of the mistakes made by earlier leaders, massively improved the Chinese economy and was the only realistic competitor to Xi Jinping. He will be missed.
And to be clear I'm not saying he was a good person, just in comparison to the other Chinese leaders.
He are good man@@brandon3872
You are a naive child with the Harry Potter worldview if you refer to the leaders of capitalist/socialist countries as “dictators”
@brandon3872 Not a dictator, not a bad man, China is and always will be more democratic than any Western nation unless they become socialist.
@@brandon3872 那你们民国如今能代表大陆吗？你们会争取大陆人民的利益吗？你们在做吗？并没有。
President Jiang looks like a guy I could hang out with.
haha
@@wing-ro8nf nice pun
A good grandpa
You hang out with strange people...
good luck then
He just went full Asian Dad on those young punks 😂
Yea he did, show the young that sometimes to crawl is better then running everyone over
He's a JEW too, a Freemason too! Jiang Zemin is a KABBALISTIC JEW!!!
@Bas Wenmakers hello Alan how is the Every Damn Day Fitness channel going??? As$hole.
I was having flashbacks of being lectured by my Asian mother.
@Robo Redneck as TH-cam is blocking my comments, I advise you to Google
The era of asking CCP leadership hard questions was a relatively short period in the CCP timeline. Emperor Xi does not tolerate being questioned like that. China has reverted to feudalism.
buzzcrushtrendkill 哎 挣个钱不容易啊 老哥
@@sunny3036 为政府工作，轻松赚钱。
Russell Yan 这个sunny明显看不懂英文 lol
sunny 他的话毫无毛病
buzzcrushtrendkill man you got a bunch of people speaking Chinese at you and I have no idea what they’re saying, but I would assume either pissed off or laughing/agreeing.
He spotted the media hypocrites before most the the world did👏
Virgin xi: Noo u can't just let reporters talk
Chad zemin: Chinese elder power go brr
@Vladimir Putin Chads dont get triggered over winnie the Pooh
@@davekorus agreed and doesn't get triggered by saying Taiwan isn't part of China
@@vertvart2724 China is part of Taiwan
jessie what the fuck are you talking about?!
@@mordapl1641 that doesn’t make sense
That’s the most influential meme on the internet of modern China. The government has never been able to stop it from spreading, everybody can understand that nowadays.
I'm guessing you're Chinese? Can you explain the context of this meme? I don't quite understand it. I guess it shows how speech was more free back when he was president of China? But that is just a guess
@@ahmedwan6528 Thank you for explaining! I hope China becomes more hospitable to free speech. It is really sad to see a wonderful nation of smart and strong people subjected to this oppression :(
@@ahmedwan6528
does uyghur in detention camp is extremist? chinese official said they are not but those in detention don't get any trial either.
@@user-pc1hk1cn4y It is to counter extremism that has plagued China since the war on terrorism however, Western media tends to dilute to context and coverage of the terrorist issues in the PRC and overly sensationalise western incidents. It labels China's re-education centres as islamaphobic attempts simmilar to concerntrayion camps yet China retains unwaivering support in the UN from 17 majority Muslim nations includong Saudi arabia. Not to mention how the western double standards initiated by the US and the UK for example, US Internment camps of japanese minorities, Latinos in ICE facilities along the mexican border treated inhumanely and racked into cages. Let alone the absurd proposition and prospect of ''freeing'' HKSAR and Xinjiang autonomous reigon is the equivalent of declaring independance for Puerto rico and Hawaii who face repression by the US central government. No I am not a BOT employed by any government or institution, but a patriotic Chinese citizen studying abroad. Who infact appreciates rather than disregard the power China has acclaimed from its predecessors embarrasement.
@@jhtang5441 Hawaii is not oppressed it is a full fledged state has equal rights and has been with America for over a hundred years. Hawaii doesnt allow non Hawaiians from moving into the island in order to preserve their culture so I highly doubt we oppress them. Also with Puerto Rico we support them during hurricanes and we dont even rule them. They have their own leadership and rule themselves almost they are merely an American territory and have access to citizenship. I will say the Philippines which we occupied during Teddy Roosevelt was wrong and we did merely use them for natural resources however, America has been doing better and has helped far more than it hurts
"I'm ang-"
*Video cuts as he turns into the hulk and destroys the entire room*
Lol
angry or Ang Lee?
Nice imagination
Lol.
They cut off to the best part damn it 😂
Jiang is one of the most charismatic leaders in modern history. He doesn’t mind sharing his emotions and occasionally making a fool of himself. It’s really rare among Chinese politicians.
Jiang : You guys are good at one thing.. You always run faster than Western Journalist! LOL!
Not anymore.
Not sure if the translation was misleading, he meant arrive faster, not running away faster.
He is trying to criticize them from arriving other countries super fast but reporting fake and overstate news.
Western journalists, with very few exceptions, do not know shit.
@@jessicajiang4881 yeah but they mostly reports facts, the chairman just want to undermine them, typical ccp tactics
too young too simple!!!
sometimes naive
Those lines were gold
Gillan Baclayon Are you Chinese?
@@guoruiwei292 I must admit that I'd use that myself.
sometime naive
At least he acknowledged that “internally decided” is a bad thing and wouldn’t want to be associated with it.
Yea, even it's a lie, it just delivers in a better way than Winnie the Pooh
And he could even speak in English fluently. Winnie The 🐼 doesn’t really do much than eat bamboo and sleep.
@@Alfa_Chef Winnie needs inglish to run the country? I guess you are used to talk shows too much. while eatting bamboo and sleeping his country has become the world's No.2 economic power. You can dislike them, but you can't be ignorant.
dOob Tom China can be no.2 economy in the world but it’s still a shithole. I really don’t give a fuck.
@@Alfa_Chef then don't give a fk. don't pretend to be a Chinese expert here. I dont even know where u are from, and i certainly dont give a fk about the shithole u r from. mind your own business. stop picking on China that you neve been to like a hypocrite
Man was making points. That was a stupid question. Of course the Communist Party is going to support a member of the Communist Party over members of other parties. I'm trying to imagine a journalist getting mad at Joe Biden for supporting a Democrat as governor and accusing him of appointing people like an emperor.
Evil dictator aside, I’m kinda impressed that he was able to have a meltdown in three different languages.
Lmao I'm ded XD
@@landonorris6 your profile picture confuses me
he speak also three or four other languages,
Why saying evil dictator I still don't understand this typical western comportment you know it's not because a country have a dictatorship system that they are the bad guys, when you say this words you are speaking like Bush junior or Trump, you are demonizing, you should stop watch media. One phrase from Thus spoked Zarathoustra even tho I don't like Nietzsch : Nothing is true everything is permitted. Don't be fools guys
Majdoud Miry 1. Saying “what about Trump” isn’t a factual defense of a leader.
2. He factually was a totalitarian dictator, which already is pretty evil in my opinion. To deny the people their right to choose their own representatives via a democratic vote, is inherently evil.
3. He was General Secretary of the Communist Party during the Tiananmen Square Massacre, which means he is at least partially responsible for the deaths of potentially thousands of innocent protesters who only desired for China to become a democracy.
As unprofessional as this was, it's pretty interesting to see a Chinese leader be so upfront and straightforward with these reporters. He might have been shouting them down but he was still almost entertaining a conversation about the topic with them where he defended his actions and views. He let his guard down with them and acted like a human. He seems like a guy you can almost talk to. Xi today, as most of the other comments said, would ignore the question flatly, if the reporters were able to or even wanted to ask him.
At that time Hong Kong still mattered so Jiang give them so advices just to shut them up. Now it doesn't, heck, it is a negative asset for China so why would Xi give a f**k. He has 1.4 billion Chinese to attend to.
not unprofessional at all
Xi is like a statue
With Xi, the reporters would just disappear mysteriously the next day
Xi would ignore the question, and the reporters would disappear afterwards.
He was not wrong about the reporter being too naiive tho. She really asked quesions like a kid writing for school paper...
How so? She was pointing out how aristocratic the Chinese government was and its excessive power over HK. Should journalists just stay silent, since that has worked so well in the past?
Yoh should try to avoid a direct question like that i guess, thats why he call western journalist was better
The problem with the question lies in the answer because each answer could be interpreted differently by that same reporter... There fore he answered that the reported gave a naive question that can not be answered in a proper way and might even cause dispute among viewers, might cause misunderstandings of the current situation or may lead in panic slight propaganda among the masses over the non existent matters... Indeed reporters should learn what some of their questions lead towards and what kind of double meaning they could lead to..
nice username
@@pezpeculiar9557Here is the thing first ，hongkong is part of china，center government absolutely have power over HK
Jiang Zemin was truly an insightful and wise leader. A far cry from Xi Jinping. RIP ❤
I WILL SEE HIM IN HELL BECAUSE I HAVE A RESERVATION WAITING THERE FOR ME
@@stevengegar9709 also with Kim Il Sung and Kim Jong Il.
I laughed at him and thought he was a joke. It took me years to realize that he is truly a wise man.
may I ask what you mean by wise?
K. Prisca No, you may not
@@zhongzhenfan8648 damn boii
@K. Prisca He's wise because he's the one that conducted the Tiananmen Square Massacre of 1989.
Edit: got my facts wrong. He didn't do that... he did the persecution of Falun Gong
@@thomassynths Look at the dates closer. He started after that.
He’s right. Most reporters operate at about a grade 10 high school level of both intelligence and understanding of the issues they’re supposedly asking questions about.
He is a classic narcissist. He has a sense of superiority and grandiosity. She asked him a curly question and he shut her down by belittling her and playing the goodguy, the victim, the suffering martyr, the smart guy with all the wisdom there is on earth and the hero that wants the best for everyone. His body language too when he got out of his chair and indignantly approached her in an intimidating manner was narcissistic. The anger and rage that was simmering in him too is narcissistic. Enablers will blame the reporter and side with the narcissist and that shows their dangerous naivety. As with all cluster b's they are very dangerous creatures and even more dangerous when they are in government positions controlling the weapons.
it's not like political leaders have the intelligence to understand the issue they're asking
Well what use is a leader like that. Somebody like that is no use in office
@@raccuia1 "narcissist" is the go to buzzword of simpletons.
@@tellercyde looks like Jey JoJo is yet another enabler. Enablers are as dangerous as narcissists themselves. When Joey JoJo has been the scapegoat target of a narcissistic abuser and copped the unrelenting and deliberate horror of their abuse Joey JoJo will likely change ITS tune. Until then Joey JoJo can remain the ignorant enabler IT is.
*I still can’t figure out if he feels anger or disappointment.*
Protofx 原型 A mix of both for sure, he commented that “he’s seen too much” of “simple” and “naive” questions.
If he’s known this for a long time it wouldn’t make sense for him to suddenly be super pissed off at the question (it’s also not a good look for him). He’s surely disappointed that after all this time they haven’t changed.
Ofcourse since they continued to persist through his rant he became angry too.
How Asian kids feel when they get their marks back
I'M ANGRY!
Jiang Zemin oh jesus ok xD
both
Who is here after he passed away
Trump be like:”You’re a terrible reporter, I don’t like you. Next.” 😂
No he would be “You are fake news!”.
Do you ever listen to the questions and out of content bullshit the reporters spew?
@@patchweaver19 Atleast he doesn't sensor the news
@Grass and you are a BLM and Antifa supporter good for you.
Don’t eat Tide Pods Yeah I agree that would be against freedom of press. Well in the future you can just automate the news. Many reporter will be out of a job or work as bloggers or small time new coverage on the web. Meanwhile the machine run by the government controls what we are allow see or to be expose to.
His style is unmatchable.. This guy knew what fake news is.. 😂😂😂😂
Yes. But he is classless. I dare him not to flip out against foreign press.
Johnny W. Too young too simple!
Donald trump of China's version?!
@@kongfooyee2508 research further. That toad is a (evil) monster, Trump is golden (good).
Kong Foo Yee tell me one thing if you could answer tell me one thing whats evil about president trump? Go on google is allowed
For those who see this for the first time, this is one of the famous moments for "the elder". Some golden words from this have been incorporated with young Chinese internet subculture for years. This is the homework you need to do if you want to understand and enjoy the Chinese internet subculture.
I know, right
I found freaking SCIENTIFIC study on Moha meme by Kecheng Fang in 2017
". I collected and analyzed more than 100 toad worship memes, interviewed 24 creators and sharers of the memes, and conducted participant observation in two toad worship online communities."
Just look at this, this is amazing
Can you recommend a video that will educate a westerner on Chinese pop culture, and mindset? I kind of drew on what he said about naivety... from all of the Chinese media outlets I follow, I get the impression that, culturally, china is super ...straight-laced, for lack of a better phrase.
应该把剩下几个也翻译成英文给外国仔种学习一个
@@davidjolley2468 When the whole world is against you, you naturally become straight-laced.
Imagine when you decide to post a video on China on TH-cam, the first thing comes to your mind is to refute all those rumors on China and CCP, which are mostly nonsense yet still widely believed by a majority of the users.
Currently Tiktok and Bilibili are 2 of the most vital video hosting communities in China. But even you know much formal Chinese, don't expect fully understand what's going on on them.
I believe both are accessible outside of mainland China, so check them out if you're interested.
@@tapist3482 Oh I have, I follow China closely from the western perspective, and I do it through the lens of knowing the western perspective is biased. China has done a lot of great things since the Xiaoping economic reforms, and continues to do so, but to people like me, that isn't the issue. The collectivism; the utter lack of regard for the individual is what bothers most of us. For instance: on the surface, I like the social credit philosophy. We all want to see the assholes punished for being assholes, but a line has got to be drawn. Compulsory reeducation, and compulsory organ harvesting really rankles westerner's sensibilities. If you tote the line, and obey the laws, your life can be great in China, but what if you're in the wrong place, at the wrong time, or know something you shouldn't, and you become a liability, or inconvenience, to the party? That happens to perfectly good people over there, and the lack of adherence to basic human justice for the sake of collective harmony is what I find troubling.
Speaking to China against everyone: I believe the West shares some responsibility in the political isolation that has griped mainland China, but the CCP shares as much, or more responsibility for the Chinese people feeling threatened by the west with nationalistic rhetoric.
Just opinions
Rest in peace big toad
We were too simple, perhaps naive to realize you were speaking the truth
Слава Советской Армии !
th-cam.com/video/CAutQJ004bQ/w-d-xo.html
If he was friendly he would have dismantled the corrupt system
I WILL SEE HIM IN HELL BECAUSE I HAVE A RESERVATION WAITING THERE FOR ME
@@amazin7006 You can't just dismantle a corrupt system lol. There are necessary evils in this world.
@@clementchung919 Tell that to Gorbachev
Sure he's a communist dictator, but I respect the open emotions
Not dictator, but with a lot of power nonetheless. Look at Egypt, Saudi Arabia, or modern day China. There if you spoke against the leader you mysteriously disappear the next day.
@@TattiePeeler I bet you're not even payed to say that pro-CCP garbage, you're a loser and a troll.
Far cry from today
@@nadlax5920 Being unelected and having absolute power seems dictatorial to me
XP_Studios well first of all a good leader is not necessarily elected by the people because citizens make poor decisions sometimes and if it’s the matter of billions of population, we can’t simply choose whoever , it’s a very tricky thing.and btw democracy is never gonna work for China cut all the bias thoughts honestly same politics don’t work on all the countries that’s what I found people nowadays , cut that aside, people need to at least respect the laws and rules of one individual country , who is gonna judge the Arab kingdom for some of their extreme law enforcement that other places wouldn’t accept ? There is no perfect form of policies that satisfy everyone at the same time , things are improving and don’t get brainwashed by the west , the America era is almost ending and the world is evolving u can’t just simply think that the world is still working base on American standards . Free of speech doesn’t work on many many countries and don’t misunderstand the meaning of it and abuse it .that’s what many people do nowadays . Sometimes people have to pay for what came out of their mouth. That’s why u can’t speak recklessly in the court and then simply change your statement because of “freedom of speech” and don’t forget China is China , it has their own set of rules and way of life which might has a conflict with the west but eventually China is not putting their standard against the west , which means we expect the west should at least respect it . U may find many Chinese are speaking or defending for the country or the ccp especially in the topic of human rights. Some of their statement might have conflicting your ideas which makes you think they are brainwashed . But standing on the other side on a different perspective , why not at least try to understand why . World media is not reliable and people get to see what they are apportioned to see. That’s the universal rules . So keep your head clear and try to look at the world more precisely u may find many different stuff that you would’ve never expected. China has gotten rid of the title of communism that’s what many people know but don’t wanna accept. It’s fully capitalism and socialism which completely go against communism . I know there is no point of saying it but look, the world fear communism and even us we feared the past communist 30 years ago , the west media surely over exaggerate too much and thats why when Chinese people see these stuffs and westerners comments they feel unbelievable. Because it’s not really true all the time. Step out of your comfortzone and go out go actually be in China u will find the difference .
I thought it was impressive that he addressed the journalists directly and from the heart. Just sayin'.
@Hugo Dahlström Bäckängsgymnasiet HU19L Yes but Obama murdered more.
There are a lot of these comments here, and most of them have weird names like bo840 or BZ, without a profile picture. I can't tell if they are edgy kids or bots.
@@BedtimeASMR_stories Classic Whataboutism
@Hugo Dahlström Bäckängsgymnasiet HU19L murderous dictator? Do you have any idea of what happened during his (very brief) presidency? Which murders are you talking about? He only applied some reforms and developed the green energy industry, there were no disorders or killings during his presidency. Stop shitting from your mouth and misinforming people as you clearly have no clue what you're talking about
@@sieben8724 lol how much is CCP paying you little poodle eater?
In this video, Jiang said he was a supporter of Mr. Dong, but the reporter intentionally rephrased it as Jiang would internally appoint Mr. Dong. Jiang was very disappointed that the media intentionally misrepresented his opinions in order to get a piece of "breaking news", so he reiterated that "if you asked me whether I'm a supporter of Mr. Dong, I would say yes. However, the election must follow the law, including the basic law and the law of election."
Despite his explanation, the reporter would just not give up misinterpreting Jiang's opinions, which made Jiang angry. Jiang made it very clear that if the reporter insisted on falsifying his opinions in her coverage, she would have to be responsible for any consequences related to it. Jiang also hoped all the reporters could improve their professional skills and stop being "too young, too simple, sometimes naive". He used Wallace, who interviewed him once, as an example of a "high level" journalist and said that Wallace was way higher than those reporters.
Jiang has three very popular videos among the young people of mainland China, and this is only part of the first one (1: HK Reporter, 2: Visiting Eryuan, 3: Interview with Wallace). All three videos are available on TH-cam. The videos were initially used by some people (FLG) to portray Jiang as a bad figure. Contrary to their expectation, people very soon realized Jiang was only telling the truth and started to appreciate his charming personality. These videos, as well as his personal experiences, have been inspiring young people in mainland China to be knowledgable and rise to challenges in their lives.
Just like what Jiang said in this video, the description of this video, though I'm not sure it was written by which "reporter", is kind of misleading. Nothing Jiang said was insane, but some comparisons between his true opinions and the reporter's interpretation, and his expectation of professional journalism. The reporter could be a bit scared back then, but she was definitely happy about this 20 years later as I saw her helping sell Jiang-related souvenirs online around 2018.
Could you tell us who the reporter is?
thank you for this information
You get your50 Mao today?
@@darrylkassle361 u just cannot handle the truth. Labeling others does not help your argument.
Thank you for this nuanced explanation. So absurd how this is framed to once again demonize China and even to make dumb points about the lack of press freedom.
Description aged like pro democracy china sentiment
Camera work like the Office. This could be “The Office CCP”
Oh gosh you’re right 😂
LMFAOOOO IM HOLLERING he could be michael scott
@@scoringbox2176 @111
“The committee”
There used to be a German Version of the Office which in turn got another parody with the setting being the nazi Headquarter of Obersalzberg
Uhm, comrade, this is a Wendy’s.
Kit Johnson Omg that’s hilarious 😂
to be honest, he's right, no problem with his speak.
ikr
.
the real truth is most often left untold.
Transfusions you dont understand what they are talking
Transfusions the reporter set up a trap. If he says he support Mr. Tung, the news next day will be CCP appoints leader of HK and ignore the democratic process. If he says no then the news will be CCP is against the leader elected by HK. If he refuse to answer and keep silent then the news will be CCP secretly intervene HK democratic process.
Try this with Winnie the Pooh! 😂
Hardly "freaking out", rather annoyed at being probed by reporters.
I agree, its warranted
Barrios Groupie exactly! But that’s someone’s opinion when headlining it!
More like throwing a tantrum like an elderly toddler..
He was a political leader, he needs to be probed
Politicians really shouldn't be freaking out when asked hard, or even biased, questions by the media. This goes for Trump as well.
I know this for a fact: when elder chinese can’t answer a question, they usually say bullshit in roundabout, meandering ways to skirt the issue, then accuse you of being too young, etc.
Victim mentality in a nutshell
@@micheleeeable lol, have you looked at how the ccp views history?
They are.. or want to be... the biggest victims ever
@@chengejshi5523 Jiang said himself he should not reply... Yet he replied!!! Jiang did not choose none, he chose one, one he admitted he should not choose.
How delusional are you?
Or rather, please explain to me how Jiang "chose none".
They all ethnicity. Lol they do that all around.
How would you reply in his place then? If you say you support, I will say you made an inside decision which is an infringement of the democratic right of HK people, if you say you don’t support, I will say you are against the democratically elected leader of HK and by extension against democracy. It is not a question, it is rhetoric. And your failure to see that proved his point.
the irony is he talks about The jounalists having to gain more knowledge about the world , well they are kinda hampered by the great firewall of China LOL
This comment is sponsored by [insert VPN service]
@@officialstevenma Nord VPN LOL
There was no firewall back then, China was one of the most open societies in Asia, just without anarchy. unless you wanted to form a riot, there was literally nothing anyone couldn’t say or do in those days.
@@charlescxgo7629 like to disagree , check this article The evolution of China’s Great Firewall: 21 years of censorship , this clip is after 1987 within the time frame of the great firewall
www.hongkongfp.com/2017/09/03/evolution-chinas-great-firewall-21-years-censorship/
Will get kidnapped and tortured.
Mike Wallace: *HEAVY BREATHING INTENSIFIES!*
😂😂😂😂
No seriously, I was not expecting that name drop. That hit just as hard as that Waazup Beijing meme.😂😂😂😂😂😂