@@Ben-xm2sj yet rdr1 has less playtime than rdr2 so if we take that into consideration we're able to play as jack and arthur more. Then you have rdr2 epilogue, then to get play as John. You also don't realize that Arthur is the reason John has a life after the gang, so if anything Arthur had the biggest impact on the story more than anyone else.
It's so sad, because john story ended the same way arthurs did. They both sacrificed themselves to save their loved ones:( but at the end they both passed with honor
And both their sacrifices ended up meaning nothing. Arthur died so that John could live a normal with his family but only 8 yrs later he was killin Micah and another 4 yrs later, he got caught. John died so that his son could live a normal life without any complications. But jack killed Ross and became an outlaw on the run. Arthur and John failed to give their loved ones normal lives. That’s the tragic part.
Everyone realised after playing RDR2 that even though Edgar Ross forced John to find all the other members of the gang, he had his own reason entirely: Arthur Morgan. The man who gave his life so that John and his family could have one of their own. I think John is not just trying to make amends for all the wrongdoings he has done, but to honor an old friends dying wish.
Well wasn’t Arthur’s death wish was not to look back? He always says revenge is a fools game so I don’t think it’s really his death wish to go and hunt out all of his old gang members, but what you said could be a driving factor for John even if he went against Arthurs advice
@@nickwarfare1411 Yeah that's what I mean. Despite Arthur's advice about seeking out revenge as well as being forced to hunt down the other members of the gang, I think that was also John's way of making peace with himself. Much like how helping John and his family start a life for themselves was Arthur's.
@stephanieclark3506 either that, or its gonna be another prequel, the gang's life in the west including Armadillo, Tumbleweed and more, probably some northwest side of the map could be open seeing as the gang was pushed to the East, the 3rd game could show how shit went down on that boat heist which was mentioned in rdr1 and rdr2 that went terribly wrong and the gang lost a few members, perhaps we could have a connection to the gang when it was a full house in rdr3
The most amazing tribute I've seen made on one of gaming's best protagonists. Both the title and the video encapsulate John's entire arc across both RDR games so beautifully and the end is just harrowing to watch. Great job!
1:12. You can clearly see by Dutch's face that he knows the gang is falling apart. The music at that moment as well seems to capture it perfectly. Absolutely amazing work man.
In my opinion john is the main protagonist because he is in two games as a playable character and arthur is a supporting protagonist, i do love them both though
This is such a great edit. I know it’s an older video but I still wanted to comment. I see a lot of people comparing John and Arthur, saying Arthur is better or upset about having to play John at the end of RDR2. I’m not sure if they just never played rdr1 or not but Arthur being a well written character doesn’t make John any less of a great character. I love both of those cowboys, it just kind of makes me sad to see all this love and support for Arthur and none for John, I played Rdr1 years ago and fell in love with it. And without it we wouldn’t even have Rdr2 or Arthur Morgan.
God dammit, i dont know how but you could make a tribute about literally anything and it would be incredibly amazing. (This is my way of saying that i dont understand how, but you are incredibly good at these tributes kyan, amazing job)
Yess. I constantly see people comparing Arthur and John, saying that now John isn’t a good character. I love them both but I did play Rdr1 first so I may be a bit biased towards John but just because Arthur is a good and well written character doesn’t mean John isn’t.
one of the best protagonists in gaming, rdr2 was a total love letter to the original red dead redemption fans. being as it was dan housers last game i can honestly say i couldn't have chose a better one.
''An honest man is the most dangerous person in the room. He will always act to defend his point of view, even when other folks don't necessarily see things the same way. A dishonest man hides behind lies and deception and never says what he thinks or feels. You never know where you stand with him and that makes him a walking joke that nobody holds any stock in. He is a rumor and is about just as trustworthy as his word and his word counts for nothing. But the honest man, you may not like what he has to say about what he believes, but ultimately you know exactly where you stand with him. Because he is honest in all things, especially how he feels about those around him.'' ~ EastSideDude
Thank god for red dead redemption I think personally cause, when I was younger back in early 2000s I was a kid love video games still do, I said to myself after playing wrestling lol I was like man it would be so fun if there was some sort of outlaw western game that would be fun I said 😂, now here we are all these years later actually playing a outlaw western game thank you ❤😇 it was as if someone herd me say that all those years ago, I’m grateful for this game it’s fun I still play it 😇✊🏽 doesn’t get old for me nothing I just keep playing it ❤
Jack: i cant think of a title for this damn book! *sees john and abigals wedding photo then sees Arthur’s hat. Jack: thanks pa you too uncle Arthur Month later OUT NOW RED DEAD a story of two gunslingers and the road to redemption
John Marston reminds me of myself I relate alot to him having a woman in my life growing up around guns having a back bone and even leaving my family going to other states I didn't know I nearly died in Tennesee its like Blackwater down there In the end I made it home cause I had family pray for my safe return
if it weren't for arthur john probably would've never gone straight or atleast tried arthur saved his life yes but was jack was taken that when john really realized how bad of a father he was and he saw how bad arthur wanted a family like john and the main reason arthur helped john was because john had exactly what arthur wanted and was throwing it away.
I feel sad at the lack of John tributes, considering he is still the main character of the series, thanks for making a great one
Thank You!
@Noodle Nick no lol
There is no one main character. There are 3, Arthur, John and Jack.
@@lukekvistian no john is the main character of the series
@@Ben-xm2sj yet rdr1 has less playtime than rdr2 so if we take that into consideration we're able to play as jack and arthur more. Then you have rdr2 epilogue, then to get play as John. You also don't realize that Arthur is the reason John has a life after the gang, so if anything Arthur had the biggest impact on the story more than anyone else.
John: “I’m always honest.”
“What’s your name?”
John: “Jim Milton.”
Haha true!
John: I can always start tomorrow
🤣🤣 how the hell did u remember that
Rip van winkle
So true
It's so sad, because john story ended the same way arthurs did. They both sacrificed themselves to save their loved ones:( but at the end they both passed with honor
If you live by the sword you die by the sword
Isn’t that all there really is in life? Ensuring you leave behind some form of evidence of your existence?
And the same ending sentence for them both... "run, and don't look back"
Although I like arthur more, I think johns story is sadder he did most everything for jack only for his boy to become just like him
And both their sacrifices ended up meaning nothing. Arthur died so that John could live a normal with his family but only 8 yrs later he was killin Micah and another 4 yrs later, he got caught. John died so that his son could live a normal life without any complications. But jack killed Ross and became an outlaw on the run. Arthur and John failed to give their loved ones normal lives. That’s the tragic part.
Heartwarming how both Arthur and John told the people they loved to go and not look back right before their death
Everyone realised after playing RDR2 that even though Edgar Ross forced John to find all the other members of the gang, he had his own reason entirely: Arthur Morgan. The man who gave his life so that John and his family could have one of their own. I think John is not just trying to make amends for all the wrongdoings he has done, but to honor an old friends dying wish.
Well wasn’t Arthur’s death wish was not to look back? He always says revenge is a fools game so I don’t think it’s really his death wish to go and hunt out all of his old gang members, but what you said could be a driving factor for John even if he went against Arthurs advice
@@nickwarfare1411 Yeah that's what I mean. Despite Arthur's advice about seeking out revenge as well as being forced to hunt down the other members of the gang, I think that was also John's way of making peace with himself. Much like how helping John and his family start a life for themselves was Arthur's.
“Ain’t no trouble, Abigail, Ain’t no trouble.”
That shit kills me
R.i.p my favorite fictional character of all time from my favorite piece of fiction rdr 1
Damn straight. John marston is the OG badass
@@r3idmcread212 you've gained my respect just took 1 year
Arthur sacrificed himself to save John, John sacrificed himself to save his family.
They are best characters ever made in video game history. Period
Then if rdr 3 comes out jack will probably sacrifice himself
@stephanieclark3506 either that, or its gonna be another prequel, the gang's life in the west including Armadillo, Tumbleweed and more, probably some northwest side of the map could be open seeing as the gang was pushed to the East, the 3rd game could show how shit went down on that boat heist which was mentioned in rdr1 and rdr2 that went terribly wrong and the gang lost a few members, perhaps we could have a connection to the gang when it was a full house in rdr3
@@stephanieclark3506 I'm sorry to say but rockstar games will not be same whit out Dan Houser
@@osmanozyldz2545 did he die or retire
"The day John Marston stopped shooting."
Thank you all so much for the love and support!! Greatly appreciated!
Listen mate I like the video. I think John deserves more. Because he is the main character and let’s face it he still is the best.
One of the greatest video game characters of all time!
“I’m always honest, not always good. But always honest” not the worst code to live by
This deserves a million views. Very well done man. I love how you connected both of the games to John’s dialogue
Thanks man, means a lot!
Yo I didn’t realise that John said don’t look back when Jack and His wife was on the horse Just like Arthur 🥺🥺
He did!?
The most amazing tribute I've seen made on one of gaming's best protagonists. Both the title and the video encapsulate John's entire arc across both RDR games so beautifully and the end is just harrowing to watch. Great job!
Thank you! I really appreciate that.
1:12. You can clearly see by Dutch's face that he knows the gang is falling apart. The music at that moment as well seems to capture it perfectly. Absolutely amazing work man.
Came here by a recommendation from thestorm, they clearly have great tastd. Instant sub.
Great tribute for John Marston!! It's very deep and emotional 😥 Thank you for making this tribute😃
Oh thank you! No problem man 😉
Finally a tribute to John
I watch this once in a while. This tribute is a goddamn masterpiece!
Oh appreciate that man!
Can't fight it John, we just can't no more.
Wonderful man, I love that someone actually made a tribute to marathon this time
Thanks man!
Rdr is a series that I came to love and cherish seeing john and Arthur left me empty
"He loved you. He did. He wasn't perfect, but he did."
Phenomenal editing man! John's one of my favourite fictional characters, period.
Favorite video game character of all time.
I adore Arthur, but I have to admit it is nice to see John get some attention too.
In my opinion john is the main protagonist because he is in two games as a playable character and arthur is a supporting protagonist, i do love them both though
@@Hamburger-re3fw fair enough.
@@GreatOldOne9866 thank you for being reasonable, you are a lot better than most people online, i appreciate that
Intercutting Arthur and John’s last sacrifices was on point. The entire series in a moment, imo. Very well done. Thanks.
Everyone likes Arthur more and I agree yes he’s a good character but John is the better character and has been through the most.
"It's just a game" this video right here
Finally Someone make something on John !
I've seen a lot of rdr tributes and other videos but this one really hit me
Thanks man!
This makes John life way sadler
I have a whole playlist with red dead redemption tributes happy to say this has been added
You're welcome! ;)
This is such a great edit. I know it’s an older video but I still wanted to comment. I see a lot of people comparing John and Arthur, saying Arthur is better or upset about having to play John at the end of RDR2. I’m not sure if they just never played rdr1 or not but Arthur being a well written character doesn’t make John any less of a great character. I love both of those cowboys, it just kind of makes me sad to see all this love and support for Arthur and none for John, I played Rdr1 years ago and fell in love with it. And without it we wouldn’t even have Rdr2 or Arthur Morgan.
"keep riding and don't look back"-john
"go, and look back"-arthur
John really became like Arthur, they both lost their lives saving their family.
Red Harlow, John Martson, Jack Martson and Arthur Morgan, damn bro what a great list of character's ,a beatiful franchise , thanks you Rockstar Games
The best tribute I have watched about John. There is a lot about Arthur but not about John, this was the first one that I liked.
Can't run, can't herd, can't swim
God dammit, i dont know how but you could make a tribute about literally anything and it would be incredibly amazing. (This is my way of saying that i dont understand how, but you are incredibly good at these tributes kyan, amazing job)
I really appreciate that, thank you!
the facts that there is no dislikes shows how good it is
Haha, appreciate that. Wonder how long that will be.
@@KyanTheAmazing that one dislike was a rat
John is still one of my favorites even tho the second game did really well with Arthur.
Yess. I constantly see people comparing Arthur and John, saying that now John isn’t a good character. I love them both but I did play Rdr1 first so I may be a bit biased towards John but just because Arthur is a good and well written character doesn’t mean John isn’t.
one of the best protagonists in gaming, rdr2 was a total love letter to the original red dead redemption fans. being as it was dan housers last game i can honestly say i couldn't have chose a better one.
The best rdr2/rdr1 edit
This gave me chills
I get addict on this beautiful tribute thank you for existing 👏👏👏👏😍❤
Thanks man, appreciate that!
My fellow brazilian
@@arroz6200 oh yeah my friend I'm here all always
All jokes aside, this is amazing
Appreciate that!
Wow, people are paying tribute to me over 100 years after i died. I must be a legend
You sure are! 😉
You are john, you sure are
The day John Marston stopped shooting.
Amazing, absolutely amazing! Thank you for this tribute
Thanks M!K3, appreciate it!
This is the masterpiece I’ve been waiting for holy
Ah Thanks!
This is so incredibly
Beautiful, just beautiful you gained a subscriber
We just, keep running. Never looking back.
For a moment I thought he'd say "John Marston can't swim."
this is only game that got few thousand tributes and all of them are icredible
Johnny Marston deserves more respect bro he get 💩 on by community just cause Arthur exists.
if charles was there, the day the showdown happened with ross, he would’ve lived no doubt in that.
This is beautiful
Appreciate it!
Sad when you realized John died like Arthur in the end sacrificing himself to save his beloved ones 😔
Great video, very well done editing. I appreciate your efforts.
Keep these up man, with how high quality these are you'll stand out, just keep at it.
Thanks man, i really appreciate it!
I have no idea how that one person could dislike this
Love you John 😔
One of the best tribute ever, that’s describes the legendary story of John marston.
This is absolutely amazing, it made me tear up 😥.
Rob Wiethoff, the most positive person and a great work he did 👍
Just amazing tribute!
Thanks!
Better name to the video. John Marston | Can't swim | Red dead redemption tribute
I always call john "The WolfScar"
we need a remaster
''An honest man is the most dangerous person in the room. He will always act to defend his point of view, even when other folks don't necessarily see things the same way. A dishonest man hides behind lies and deception and never says what he thinks or feels. You never know where you stand with him and that makes him a walking joke that nobody holds any stock in. He is a rumor and is about just as trustworthy as his word and his word counts for nothing. But the honest man, you may not like what he has to say about what he believes, but ultimately you know exactly where you stand with him. Because he is honest in all things, especially how he feels about those around him.'' ~ EastSideDude
Fantastic video!
Thank you!
The tribute to the last outlaw/bounty hunter of the Wild West.
Thank god for red dead redemption I think personally cause, when I was younger back in early 2000s I was a kid love video games still do, I said to myself after playing wrestling lol I was like man it would be so fun if there was some sort of outlaw western game that would be fun I said 😂, now here we are all these years later actually playing a outlaw western game thank you ❤😇 it was as if someone herd me say that all those years ago, I’m grateful for this game it’s fun I still play it 😇✊🏽 doesn’t get old for me nothing I just keep playing it ❤
Emotional and it wasn’t focused on Arthur
Jack: i cant think of a title for this damn book!
*sees john and abigals wedding photo then sees Arthur’s hat.
Jack: thanks pa you too uncle Arthur
Month later
OUT NOW RED DEAD a story of two gunslingers and the road to redemption
Beautiful tribute.
Inferno: The Tragedy of John Marston
Thanks
Thank you.
It's important to remember that John ended up being a better gunslinger than Arthur in the end (in accuracy).
John Marston reminds me of myself I relate alot to him having a woman in my life
growing up around guns having a back bone and even leaving my family going to other states I didn't know
I nearly died in Tennesee its like Blackwater down there
In the end I made it home cause I had family pray for my safe return
I really hope that rockstar is remastering red dead redemption 1 cause I need to re play it
its the first edit of john that made me sad just like Arthur
rockstar games should remake rdr1 john's death didn't even had a Soundtrack
John.🌹💔
He was a good father
What I think would be new for Red Dead 3 is it maybe they go back to the start where you play as Hosea
John Marston Can’t Run And Can’t Swim. Ah Shit.
That was absolutely wonderful and ive always like john better than arthur tbh
Amazing ❤❤❤
Thank you 😊
I try to go straight~ jhon Marston
alternate title: John Marston | Can't Swim | Red Dead Redemption Tribute
He told he’s family exactly what Arthur told him so he thought about Arthur before he died
honestly I think John story was much sadder the Arthur because he's force to kill he's own gange or thell hurt he's family
I get the feeling that adult jack marston's jacket (Default outfit) is the same one arthur used in a way, but at the same time no. It looks similar.
It would be a cool detail but they are sadly not the same
I’m surprise that John‘s daughter was not mentioned in the second game wonder if it’s a retcon
She died in between rdr2 and rdr1
@@DogGettingHaircut like after the epilogue
@@youreashishkebab4766 yeah
th-cam.com/video/fQuYgix-gmw/w-d-xo.html
Well in this video it hints she died between 1899 and 1907 (between Arthur's death and epilogue).
if it weren't for arthur john probably would've never gone straight or atleast tried arthur saved his life yes but was jack was taken that when john really realized how bad of a father he was and he saw how bad arthur wanted a family like john and the main reason arthur helped john was because john had exactly what arthur wanted and was throwing it away.
I play this game with the young guns soundtrack in the background 🤠😎
Nice video
Looks like John and Arthur are brother