Ash Sarkar Smashes BBC Question Time
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ส.ค. 2024
- Novara Media broadcasts live every weekday from 6PM on TH-cam and Twitch.
_________________________________________________________
Support Novara Media for as little as £1 a month:
novaramedia.co...
Buy Novara Media merch here:
shop.novaramed...
Its a disgrace that water is privatised
Where were you people when this happened. There were enough warnings not to do it, but they where set aside by the ruling class as a socialist idea. Capitalist are afraid of socialist ideas and they happened to put fear to the public.
Maybe it is the public own fault.
Don't agree with her much at all but I do agree with her on this
@@gail9299 very strange
They never played Monopoly 😅 selling the utilities and trains
@@gail9299one does wonder why that might be gail 🤔
None of the utility companies should ever have been privatised in the first place.
Including internet. If the infrastructure was State owned and companies were allowed bandwidth to operate on it, then everyone's price would be lower.
@@Hollywood041 internet was never state owned in the first place.
Tell Sid......
@@twolessba1087 I think they means it *should* be a state owned utility as it’s essentially a necessity today and is woefully inadequate
@@karennelson4108 Don't...
was wondering how Nick Ferrari was managing to make so much sense and then he mentioned he had been affected personally... mystery solved!
I was wondering the same!
Any ordinary citizen would be charged with a crime, if caught polluting rivers, canals and seas. The fact that corporations, (which are large conglomerates of people), can get away with doing the exact same thing is insanity.
They don't get away with anything, its called 'Charges for Discharges' the water companies pay fines for polluting but these are factored in to your bill, so the ordinary citizen is being charged for their crime.
Indeed
"Hose pipe ban"
Yes, companies or individuals responsible for polluting watercourses are indeed prosecuted by the Environment Agency
@@evokestudiosbrighton Hence why Ferrari said "Prison"
Scottish Water is in state hands and non profit. This model is so much better than the one the English are dealing with. 🏴
Dŵr Cymru/Welsh Water isn't state-owned, but it is run by a not-for-profit private company which has no shareholders. Any money they do make is used to improve the service and to keep customer bills low. Personally, I'd like to see water and other utilities renationalised eventually, but the Dŵr Cymru model isn't a bad solution in the meantime.
At a time when 1 in 5 Scots couldn’t pay their water bill Scottish Water had £391 million sitting in a reserve fund.
Did they help anyone? No.
Oh and Scottish Water is over £3 billion in debt.
Great system we have.
@ftumschk
Sadly large areas of mid and North Wales come under Severn Trent, not Dŵr Cymru.
That company controls the reservoirs at Tryweryn, Elan Clywedog etc which feed Liverpool and Birmingham.
Despite Dŵr Cymru being non-profit we in Wales have some of the highest bills.
Privatisation was the worst idea anyone ever had. It's screwed over everything it's touched.
there are no more lands to conquer, the only places left to exploit are at home
All privatisations were never about being more efficient, they were about gravy trains and screwing the Public.
It would be smarter to privatise no more than 49%. They run it efficiently for profit (it’s not a bad word) and we are still in control
Privatization is legal theft.
It’s alright to privatise shoe companies and chocolate manufacturers. Just not fixed infrastructure and natural monopolies.
You know you're fucked when Nick bloody Ferrari looks like The Peoples Poet, champion of the little man.
Ferrari is a fool he don,t talk for people
I was thinking that..omg I'm agreeing with HIM!
it's true
When Ferrari out-lefts you, you should realise you and that sewage have everything in common.
@@berniethekiwidragon4382 Hahaha
Well said Ash!
Why not confiscate a proportion of the company instead of financial fines?
Good idea, but the idea we can't afford to renationalise them needs smashing for the lie it is. We can just print the money as we have forever to repay it and, as Michael said, absolute confidence it will be repaid because there's zero chance of the market for water & sewage disappearing.
Bravo Ash. So happy to see you on these programmes.
“The white British population has decreased by 600,000, while the minority population has increased by 1.2million. So yes, lads, we're winning!”
- Communist, Ash Sarker
How braindead must you be to support this woman.
Ash held their attention and spoke truth and even got Nick F to nod along - just wonderful.
Ash is the tops.❤️😎😎♥️
Simp
why didnt Ash do gooder say anything when someone in the audience said they dont want these strange men around them
@@Security848 Dunno, why don't you go on question time and make that point, then we can all sit around and ask you dumb whatabout questions that completely miss the point too.
@martinsheridan9206
Ash do gooder? I guess you're more of a do badder yourself!
Tory girl body language was hilarious - literally hanging her head in shame
They have no shame.
I doubt that
I can't bring myself to hate the useless tory on the panel because as much as she is involved up to her neck in a dire self serving regime,
i get a rabbit caught in the headlights vibe.
I would not be surprised if a story leaked of Valium addiction.
The kind of person who is too terrified to leave the cult as she isn't mentally equipped to function alone in the world.
She is no Michelle Mone.
Mone would have stole her lunch money and slept with her father whilst inducting her into an organised shoplifting gang at 12.
they trot her out every time they know they are going to get a kicking - hoping her doe eyed coquettish mannerisms will deflect some of the blame - the " What me?" shy schoolgirl act is wearing a bit thin now she is approaching 50
Tory girl who IV never even seen
Can anyone name one positive that this Tory party has achieved in the past 13 years?
Converted me to want Scottish independence.
Demonstrated that they can’t run their own party never mind the country which will now be remembered by everyone for the next 50 years.
Fulfilled the expectations of the daily mail reader.
Forced me to change my nationality and get an EU passport.
Brought peace?
What stands out to me is how Fiona Bruce is allowed to clearly exhibit her partisanship increasingly every week. She ensured that drip from the cabinet got to say everything she wanted (none of it worth hearing) whilst Ash was continually interrupted and questioned and asked to justify her statements by Bruce. It's a disgrace that the wife of a major Tory donor be allowed to chair a political discussion. Every week we hear more and more of her voice. This week it was taking 2 audience polls, in other weeks it's giving background information to the issues raised, information that everyone with a smidgen of interest in current affairs would have known anyway. STFU Bruce.
Bruce has been showing her colours for sometime now. During this episode I was fuming at the amount of time she gave the misplaced Tory.
Why do the Brits put up with such one-sided Fiona Bruce…? Are hers the only views of Britain…. Fascism on the way, for sure.
Totally agree !
@@vodatube2591the daily mail tells them to 🙄
Lets not forget Bruces husband earns millions advertising for the Tories. She is not impartial in the slightest.
This was so heartening, the smile on her face when she thought "this is going over brilliantly". She was clear and charming and also everything was honest and made sense. Bravo!
So you support a racist communist... this country has fallen far.
Scottish Water is a public company answerable to Scottish Ministers and the Scottish government; no shareholders, no private equity. All monies raised from bill payers are reinvested into the maintenance and improvement of the network. Why can't England do that?
"It cant be done overnight, so we will take 25 years"
They've been in power for 13 years, so it should be more than half done now
@@jillybe1873 In that time they've cut Environment Agency funding by over 50% leaving the water companies largely unchecked and often not fined for their pollution. If these companies had been truly held to account over this we wouldn't be in such a mess.
lol they might even be back in power by then!
So interesting to see the Question Time audience’s faces as Ash explains the racket of the water companies to them… great job Ash! Brava!
privatization of utilities is literally just the private landlord model applied to services. We could own them, meaning that all money we spend on them increases the value of the asset we own. And if a problem needs fixing we can get it fixed. Or we could have someone else own it, have a large portion of what we spend on them go to making someone else rich and leaving us with no assets. And if we want something fixed we are reliant on the good will of someone for who it's more profitable to let the problem continue unaddressed cause they know we have no alternative than to put up with it
Very good analysis.
It's what happened once we joined EU
@@leehenry5764 How so? Explain further
@@abdvs325 Because of competition it's why we have the big 6 energy companies who are mainly foreign.
@@leehenry5764 No. you fell right into the lies of the Tories on the EU which would oblige to privatize the public services. It's totally wrong. France, Germany, Italy and other EU countries own their train companies for example. In France, electricity also (public nuclear), EDF is a state company, the postal services belong to the State in France too, the same for water. More than 70% of water in France is governed by cities or groups of cities. They are public services. There are some private companies, but they have maintenance obligations, otherwise they pay heavy fines. Most decisions concerning the water market or water meter legislation are regulated by states to allow local authorities to harmonize their decisions. Whether it is public or private, the EU has no decision-making power. Competition is possible but not mandatory when it comes to an essential public services
Ash was very effective, probably not going to get many supporting shit in the sea but her highlighting the greed and profiteering of the privatisation companies was the stand out moment of question time.
Ash, you have my vote! Keep up the GOOD work for Novara Media!! Thank you!
So you have not heard the claims that this might be a fake left-wing media outlet?
Amazing! Incredible segment. Thanks everyone at Novara 💚🙏🏼
Nick Ferrari is right for once but only because he was personally impacted.
His ‘solution’ was grandstanding to deflect from the fact it’s systemic by presenting it as the individual choice of ceos.
If Weil's disease only affected sub-saharan africans I doubt he'd have even known about it.
@@aries6776 nor care. He shills for the system and interests that almost killed his child.
For once. He is usually a dose
Nice on Novara really respect what you are doing and the clarity is refreshing.
The Irish government tried to charge for water, even putting in meters for all buildings. The Irish people said NO, There should never be profit made from water. No charges for water in Ireland.
Margaret Thatcher has so much to answer for
Horrible woman I hope she in hell
More the capitalist class that funded the right wing think tanks that led to the likes of Reagan and thatcher.
Including the current Labour party's economic policies, which are basically watered down thatcherism.
She even stole the milk from the school kids....slag.
The legacy of hers & Reagan's has completely f***** everything
Ash, you are a Mega Star... long may you shine.
Didn’t she indeed. Well done Ash, mind you, I knew it would be a good one with her on it.
Keeping these industries in private hands makes politicians jobs easier.
Like ash says they would be accountable, they really don’t want that.
They just say it’s to expensive and blame faceless CEOs
Their friends families own shares in these companies don’t forget.
This is a symptom of the "financilisation" of the Globe. Financial corporations control political parties, politicians, and government policy. Corporations rob the taxpayer blind and provide no value in return, while minimising the tax they pay on their vast bloated profits. They act as a great funnel sucking money out of communities across the world and delivering it into the coffers of the Elite. Action needs to be taken to end this exploitation, but don't look to the politicians as they are bought and paid for corporate lackies.
That's what it's all about. Something goes wrong? They're not responsible, it's out of their hands...
@@cehaem2 it’s not ALL about that, because why would they even become politicians then? Oh yes, it’s because they actually work for the corporations - the members are paid off by corporate interests to do their bidding instead of the voters’ bidding.
It’s the right wing economic ideal of worshipping the markets. That makes politicians powerless.
Ash is getting better and better on these appearances. She turns up with the facts, calmly dismantles any arguments against them, engages the audience. Fantastic.
So you support a racist communist... this country has fallen far.
@BrianT Please provide evidence of this anti-white rhetoric Brian or are you just making spurious claims for the hell of it?
@@djturbine7565 Brown skin attracts idiots and their puerile comments
You sound really thick
@@Matt-pn1ce begone troll
She is rather very clever isn't she? Concise, Cogent and Precise.
“The white British population has decreased by 600,000, while the minority population has increased by 1.2million. So yes, lads, we're winning!”
- Communist, Ash Sarker
How braindead must you be to support this woman.
Yeah course🤣
Ash Sarkar is a cool name.
I can’t believe Ash went on Question Time! She’s amazing - the Left is lucky to have her 🔥
Ash goes everywhere 😎
Very well spot on message.
Hopefully she doesn't identify as left or right. Such a binary, and thus limiting outlook..having said that, Ash is awesome
@@swampy1234 every enlightened centrist:
Where else would a communist go? The USSR is over and China embraces aspects of capitalism. She could try North Korea but don't know what they would make of her there.
Amazing how quickly nick Ferrari turns on his corporate buddies when his son gets sick😂
It's embarrassing that so few journalists in this country talk common sense on these issues. Atleast Ash is there to do so incredibly articulately and charismatically
Im embarressed that I stayed at a sanitary Pádraig for 30 seconds thinking wow....what a beautiful fish...😂
@Keith Brighouse she came up with a solution then on the video. You can renationalise the water because it's an asset and there will always be people paying into it as we need water to survive. It's a safe business and an asset.
@Keith Brighouse Firstly what makes you think it's immigrants that are causing the problems in this country? Secondly, you need to wake and smell the coffee. This country isn't all that and the whole world isn't desperate to come here, despite what the Daily Mail keeps telling you.
As for Sarker - she gives a solution right there. The money would be spent on an asset that's profitable and something that should be run for the benefit of people in this country.
You seem to think immigrants are the problem, but you don't seem to have an issue with investors in Australia taking piss out of British people. Maybe take your head out of your arse and learn how the Tories AND New Labour alike are taking the piss out of us.
@@jayturner90 Sadly right wingers know the cost of everything but the value of nothing. They'll come out and bat for foreign based corporations and their shareholders while still complaining about the treatment of "indigenous people" - whatever the f**k that means on this island.
@Keith Brighouse so for starters a lot of the wars they're Fleeing were wars funded by uk. You found the money to fund the wars so you could find the money to fund the refugees also... you don't have to keep them in hotels ...you could pay and employ english people at a decent was eto process them so that they can work and be productive att a low wage which people need. We need plumber builders electricians seamstresses etc and we don't have qualified people and many of the people coming are qualified they need their quallifications stamped for approval for the uk and they need their papers processed then they would very happily get a job and pay rent and bills rather than be a burden. It is the government fault that they're not processed in a timely manner it is the government fault they are a burden and it is the government fault their waulfications are not validated because rthey have not put infrastructure in for this. They were too busy selling weapons and organising conspiracies to speak of weapons of anss destruction and all to happy to invest in failed war endevours which now they suddenly are too poor to fund the consequences of those wars. And I might add that you are reliant on other people from outside the uk for the food you eat the clothes you wear most of your technology you use and a vast amount of things and products which you nó longer produce yourselves. You thankfully have a thriving service and financial sector that makes you have some wealth and plenty enough wealth for all the uk citizens ... but unless you manage that wealth properly it will not trickle down by magic to your poor and unemployed in the uk. You do actually have to have good government to see employment stimulated to see bussinesses supported and to see production raised. THat does happen in a vaccuum and only happens with a government who is competent. You have had it before when you created the nhs and many other amazing things the uk should be proud of. THe national rail the bbc the nhs all amazing achievements and amazing production and behind all that amazing government funding the whole engine and the people who made it function. Now you government funds something else. War and globalisation and banking and media and corruption and financial tomfoolery. All of which could be stopped tomorrow and we would not miss it. There is nothing so dispicaable as a slave who praise his master for beating the darker slave harder my dear.
_"Its too expensive to save all that money with that money saving policy, making services cheaper and better for everyone!"_
*~Politicians who think you're stupid*
And constantly proved right on that thought.
When nationalisation comes up, the Tories always cite British Rail. Ironic since they were the ones that underfunded it to the point where privatisation looked attractive to rail users
Too much common sense for the government to handle
Nick Ferrari talking sense??? And Ash going what she does best, breaking it down clearly and concisely! Well done Ash!!
Ferrari did it as more a deflection. Pretending it’s individual choice of some ceos and not the system.
Honestly don't know what we'd do without Ash - she has the magic formula
Shill away 😂
@@PoldarkGodzilla- lots of people agreeing with her. Yeah, definitely a "shill"
Nice one, bruv.
Yeah her magic forumla is being a champagne communist and hanging out with mao in her spare time who killed millions and bragging about it , shes so awsome.
She's sussed it out. All you have to do is listen.
Yeah, what ever would you do comrade.
Communists are always very persuasive to simple folk, it’s only when the mass murder begins and you’re lined up against a wall that you think “oooh right, so this is why people mentioned 120 million deaths last century and the over 60 times communism and socialism were tried and failed.. damn”.
Glad we have scottish water here in Scotland. Was never privatised so we don't see higher bills like England nor profits going abroad or dividends going to shareholders. We knew privatisations would be a disaster
Ash Sarkar speaks the truth 👍
You must be joking she is awful
When?
She's been the best (or at least my favourite) political commentator for years now
A broken clock is right twice a day.
“The white British population has decreased by 600,000, while the minority population has increased by 1.2million. So yes, lads, we're winning!”
- Communist, Ash Sarker
How braindead must you be to support this woman.
I love Ash. I'm so happy y'all keep getting invited on programs to explain how they actually do not understand the world and what is happening. Across the pond we have moved away from hosting differing opinions and have not had experts on in years. If you are a conservative, you go to the conservative "news" program, where they invite conservative reporters, to cover the conservative portion, of a report written by a conservative person, who just found out about something that might be true.
You love a communist?
Not the sharpest knife in the drawer are you?
Conservatism is dead in UK it was the so-called conservatives who killed it
And the same can be said about the neoliberals too.
Someone hinted at this below: change the fine from cash to shares. Persistent infringements will eventually result in loss of control of the company.
I agree with Nick. Never thought I'd say that!😂
Ash is brilliant as usual.
Ash casually delivering Stone Cold Stunners. For gawd sake.
Sarkar! Sarkar! Sarkar!
Sarkar 3:16 says I just nationalised your @$$!
“The white British population has decreased by 600,000, while the minority population has increased by 1.2million. So yes, lads, we're winning!”
- Communist, Ash Sarker
How braindead must you be to support this woman.
You really did a great job Ash. At the start of the show there was a large applause for anti migrant rhetoric, but by the end they were leaning to your every word. This doesn't happen often. Next, the world! ❤️🖤🚩🏴
They are all Marxist Lefty's it's the bloody BBC
Funny how the BBC vet people who go on QT.
£400 a year average one bedroom flat - even if you don't use it?? All for what ? Greedy bastard water companies?!
Why we did not have the same pollution problems when we were in EU?
The bills and pollution both up... service and protection down!
I live on the other side of the Channel in France. No water pollution here. Guess what? No Tories
What the hell are you talking about?
You clearly haven't ever been to Blackpool
The madness of our society leaving essential stuff in the hands of private individuals
Now, if Question Time invited Ash on as often as they invite the likes of Fartage on, we'd be living in a much fairer and more contented country.
that tory lady headlined "£141m in fines paid since 2015". Ash quotes the FT that the water companies paid out £1.4 BILLION to shareholders in 2022. the fines are meaningless
The crowd’s panto enthusiasm really does show a total shift in public opinion.
A bit too late, we would have nationalised in the cheap under Corbyn
My iritation with Question Time is something that I've been moaning about down the pub going back years, so much so that a mate says these days "just dont watch it mate". Thanks to Ash this week, my experience was lifted.☺
Fiona Bruce just backs whichever Tory is speaking making sure they have more time than anyone else, even speaking up for them!!
Her blatant bias is getting nauseous!!
When even Nick Ferrari is mocking you...
Ash has been absolutely brilliant on the media rounds, last night was no different. Her analysis has been and was once again superb. As much as I dislike him, Nick Fararri did a brilliant job of destroying the Tories on this issue.
Ash is fast becoming a superstar in British political public discourse, with a knack of making issues accessible. I loved how the audience responded to her questions, that they understood these were not rhetorical.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
She already is a superstar.
@@chrishyde1216 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@netcurtains 👍
I watched that on catch up. She had them eating out of her hand! And she was actually explaining to them what's wrong with capitalism!
It's terrifying to find oneself agreeing with Ferrari.
No it's.progress, unite with each other
Ash for prime minister!
Well agree
No thank you
I have been doing my families head in saying exactly what Ash was saying about southern water for years. So good to hear it on TV in the main stream
3:40 Go on Ash. Tell them how it’s done. At last a voice of sanity and reality!
i never thought i'd see nick ferrari nodding along with ash sarkar
Smashed it!!
Nick Ferrari really does have his moments
Yep
Only because his son caught a rat disease wouldn't give a f*ck otherwise 🤣
He went to Israel for a documentary and sided with Palestinians. I can't for the life in me find any clips of this. Was a good few years ago.
@@MT-kx2uc heard about that he's a freedom fighter on the low
@@colostomybag69 on the whole I don't agree with his takes. But I do think that he mostly acts in good faith. He might be a massive boomer with terrible takes. But I actually think he says what he thinks.
So well said by Ash! 🎉
Ash is amazing!
“The white British population has decreased by 600,000, while the minority population has increased by 1.2million. So yes, lads, we're winning!”
- Communist, Ash Sarker
How braindead must you be to support this woman.
Ash was the voice of sanity and reality for the first time in ages on QT. Absolutely right to call Labour out for saying the same crap as the Tories around nationalisation of water companies!
brown cliffs of dover
Well done ash ✊
What do our taxes pay for, then? Long live the Republic of Scotland.
02:04 I completely agree with Nick Ferrari. CEOs of water companies that don't care or fix this sewage problem that is polluting our waters must face prosecution, not limp fines. We need to start making businesses, business owners, CEOs, boards, executives accountable for their decisions. If we are happy to make Doctors and Nurses accountable for every patient they see, why should we not see these multi-millionaires accountable for potentially damaging our environment and our health? We need to stop glamourising business hustlers and make them responsible, including landlords.
Well done Ash, you said what needed to be said.
You are one of the only reason I now watch this programme. It has really slipped recently into almost a party political broadcast for this Fascist Tory government. That is said in jest of course, at least Mussolini got the trains to run on time. 😀😀
That trains thing is another myth. Reality was the nationalised trains prior to Mussolini produced a service the population was happy with, and Mussolini privatising it destroyed that.
Absolutely love Ash. She is quite brilliant.
“The white British population has decreased by 600,000, while the minority population has increased by 1.2million. So yes, lads, we're winning!”
- Communist, Ash Sarker
How braindead must you be to support this woman.
Ash is awesome. Nailin' it. Utter brilliance.
Lady like Aash - smashed it as per ❤
I worked for one of the particularly bad water companies for almost 10 years, and I can say that the waste of money is staggering, the management of the waste water treatment centres is a joke and the M+E department have been stripped to the bone....gotta get those profits for the share holders smh
I gotta give it to the BBC, they have balls to invite Ash on their programme again. Every time she gets on their show. She gives them a good beat down.
They haven't got much choice now 😂
Ash has arrived. Ash is boss.
@@JohnSilver-un8qy she still needs to explain how she can be a “libertarian communist “ in 2023
@@briandelaney9710 - what’s wrong with that?
@@briandelaney9710Aharrr... Brian lad.
I always think becoming state owned should always be part of non compliance penalties. Especially for essential goods.
Nick Ferrari was probably the last person I expected to go on a "Stalinist" rant.
🤣🤣🤣
Ash absolutely smashing it on QT. Ash the Smash
Amazing woman...Inspirational..Ash that is..not weak Whately nor the Red Tory woman.
Incredible camp delivery from Bastani at 3:29 got an actual lol out of me
Billionaire execs? They're going straight in my basket. 💅
The only reason I stayed up to watch this tripe is because Ash was on, she didn't disappoint 👏💅
56 billion over 25 years? 25 years? They need to spend 56 billion yesterday! This pollution problem must be fixed immediately!
She’s simply fabulous.
Jesus. When Nick Ferrari starts to make sense we really know we're trawling the depths! And Ash is brilliant.
Ms Sarkar is on fire. She nailed the truth for the audience and panelists.
I want to be Ash when I grow up! ✨
“The white British population has decreased by 600,000, while the minority population has increased by 1.2million. So yes, lads, we're winning!”
- Communist, Ash Sarker
How braindead must you be to support this woman.
no better leftist tv personality/communicator than Ash
I am far from being a lefty & I am not a righty. What I would like to say is that I watched Ash Sarkar last night on Question Time & without her usual ranting, she laid in to the Labour Party & the Conservatives in equal measure. The points she raised/ challenged were good. Fair play…
I’m waiting patiently for 25 years in the future when I can safely take a dip where I choose. I’ll only be 75. Whoopee!!
Ash, if somehow you read this, you're a legend and we love you for it 👍
Brilliant Ash and Novara media.
“The white British population has decreased by 600,000, while the minority population has increased by 1.2million. So yes, lads, we're winning!”
- Communist, Ash Sarker
How braindead must you be to support this woman.
What shocked me the most watching this aside from agreeing with Nick Ferrari was Thangam Debbonaire's pathetic attempt to brush off Labour doing anything about this issue because it will cost to much and I'm not even going to start ranting about Helen Whately's lies, her party have slashed the EA's power over the last few years, the fines water companies get do nothing to solve the problem, public services should not run for profit. Good to see Ash hammering home figures that are rarely mentioned.
Love you Ash you goddess .watching from Scotland peace and love to all
Ash is just brilliant like 100% of the time ;)
Ash is a national treasure 🙏🏾👏🏽🙏🏾👏🏽