Yes it’s called straw manning, he deliberately misrepresents what his guests say when they disagree with his far right ideologies in an attempt to appear to win the exchanges
Pierce Morgan really needs to decide whether he wants to interview or be interviewed. He's literally dominating the discussion, not allowing Ash to finish one single sentence.
I never sang the australian national anthem when I was going to school I was the only indigenous person there, My mother told me when I was a kid You can sing the song if you want to, but you don't have to if you don't want to,, There was a lot of people in the school who didn't like it Including the teachers but I didn't care! , Because australian national anthem doesn't represent the Indigenous people! of australia , That's why we got 3 different flags in australia for each race
@@ravd8082 no. Ash is trying to ensure a better nation like many more before her to enable the takemeupstairs of the world to be able to come to the UK, vote, work, own businesses and indeed be elected, become Home Secretary, Chancellor and PM. These were not 'traditions' but hard fought rights.
I'm not British, but you want to take a moment and sign the British National Anthem, what's the problem? Regardless of what country you live in, the citizens there should be allowed to sign their National Anthem without any issue. What can't you in your own country?
It's not people aren't allowed to. It's mandating everyone in schools to do so as a matter of government policy. Piers is fantastic at muddying the water on this and other non issues.
You are allowed to, if you want to sing it at break time as an individual then nothing stops you, but we don’t go out of our way to do it all together, we think education is more important than singing the national anthem (which really isn’t that good of a song) and we aren’t interrupting the lessons just for that reason, nor are we cutting break times short for that reason either.
In 🇨🇦 we sing the national anthem every morning in elementary school. Standing at your desk and if your walking halls you stop and wait till its over then you continue walking. I❤🇨🇦
This woman is "literally a communist", apparently. So of course she's gonna critique British law and culture. I agree, if she doesn't like our way of life here and our rules, why won't she LEAVE?
@@MichaelCHorler She's British and we are a democracy. She is entitled to her opinion, if you don't like our way of life here and our rules then LEAVE 🤪
All countries teach their history in a nationalist way. How is this controversial? People confuse the government and the country. The loyalty is to the country. Symbols like the flag and anthem are weaponized heavily by governments. Unity is not always a good thing. Unity around what? Andrew Rosindell actually thought he caught Ash Sarkar in a gotcha moment when she implied she isn't in love with the institution of monarchy in Britain. And he has the gall to scoff at her? In 2023! What a fool! It really boggles the mind. I'll leave you with a quote from Mark Twain responding to those calling him disloyal and unpatriotic for disagreeing with the actions of his government... "You see my kind of loyalty is loyalty to one's country, not to its institutions or its office-holders. The country is the real thing, the substantial thing, the eternal thing; it is the thing to watch over, and care for, and be loyal to; institutions are extraneous, they are a country's mere clothing, and clothing can wear out, become ragged, cease to be comfortable, cease to protect the body from winter, disease, and death. To be loyal to rags, to shout for rags, to worship rags, to die for rags--that is a loyalty of unreason, it is pure animal; it belongs to monarchy, was invented by monarchy; let monarchy keep it
The discussion was about another school mandate. In a world where an experimental vaccine was mandated on school children, a mandatory anthem may be wrong-headed but quite mild by comparison.
@@bleddynmorgan8012 that is a good argument but what would we sing on special events because it’s not fair if the Americans can do it and the French. The monarchy is the only thing that unites this country
To be honest I thought piers would be on the other side😂 ,, not forcing kids to sing a governmental anthem,, you shouldn't force kids to do anything ,, there's a reason we don't do it and America does
I won’t sing or stand for the national anthem. The Windsors were great friends with Jimmy Saville and they knew about his dark side. Also we need an anthem about the people and the country not about one person.
Ash: 1 in 6 schools are begging for money for basic equipment. Focus on policies that actually matter. Piers: Let's waste time with cheap nationalism at the expense of tax payers' money.
Encouragement & making it compulsory are very separate things, Morgan shouts down anyone who disagrees with him, shame his bias is blatant preventing a proper debate! If you don’t recognise the dangers of nationalism as we watch a genocide being carried out due to colonial nationalism.
her views are tipical indian/pakistani/bangla muslim. they never put their country of residence before religion. in india too, muslims refuse to say vande mataram, they oppose nationa anthem.
…and rightly so. Your anthem is about Scotland. The National Anthem is about a God I don’t believe in protecting a privileged human being I have no respect for. The first line excludes me. The first line! 😂
Ahh that song about England? Well I'll just let you know it's not actually your national anthem, you don't really have one. I hope you do soon, and when you do, please choose a better song. One about Scotland rather than that one about England. Scotland the Brave or Highland Cathedral are far better options already.
Piers: [0:51] "you're completely 'whataboutery' on this..." 25 seconds earlier... Piers: [0:26] (paraphrase) ...but what about America, they sing the national anthem (and potentially in France under Macron) so why not here?
Comes above repairing school buildings, cheap stunt by Tory’s ! Shame they don’t appear to care about our educational system? But then they don’t use it!
Absolutely be forced to sing the Anthem. It will turn the youth away from the right wing faster than anything, to be obliged to mouth nonsense in order to get a few crumbs of knowledge.
Although I am very patriotic and proud to sing the National Anthem I don’t think it should be government policy to make schools have it sung although why not sing the anthem at the end of school assemblies which are already organised
Well to be fair in Portugal we sing the National Anthem as well at school and its mandatory for every Portuguese national to know it back and forth. Being patriotic and proud of my country is a good thing.
If you took a poll, I would guess that anyone in the world wouldn't know the second or subsequent verses of their National Anthem. This is because it is rarely, if ever, sung further than the first verse. Only a tenner? Are you extremely poor, or are you not that confident?
I was in school from the early 70s to the early 80s and I wasn't taught it either, but I still knew it when I was young. There are other ways to learn something other in school.
@@TaySplatoon Ever thought of learning it for yourself? Given the amount of times you must have heard it, shouldn't the penny have dropped long before now? It's only 28 words for heaven sake.
Ashna has got a point. Imagine British people of ethnic origin singing the anthem "God save the King". The royal family symbolises colonialism. I wouldn't sing it and i'm british.
Sorry Poers, but you are totally out of touch on this ie there's a HUGE connection between Nationalism and Patriotism, So enevitably having Patriotism as a Policy will leed to increase Nationalism, and i don't think i need to explain what that is linked to..p perhaps the events after the horrific Southport stabbings, should make you realize she was right.
Im proud of Britain and our Empire we got the whole world out of the Jungle shared all our development Technology and Prosperity with the entire world we got Enemies because Success has always had Enemies....many people suffer from Envy and jealousy they never climb or succeed at anything pity for them
Let me be very vlear while my single mother did her absolute best to be all things to me both mother and father and i can tell u she did her best however! I am absolutely capable of saying that there are a good amout of things both can do and I even used to give my mom fathers fay gifts but i didn't say happy father's day DADDY i said happy father's day MOM n that is bec she did her best to play both roles but in the reality she was not daddy just because I did have a dad she was a mom who did her best to fill all the roles i as a child needed filled but that means one yhing only n that is that she was an awesome mother it didn't make her a father
I still say Collin kapernik took a knee because he was upset that they weren't starting him at qb and then when asked why he took a knee he came up with the racism of Cops but I truly believe it had nothing to do with and he was just being a baby that the team didn't want to play him
Porque é que eles não assumem que querem ser mais donos que o próprio dono? Afinal de séculos já deveriam ter conseguido o que reclamam, mas no seu próprio país que continua a ser um dos que explora a mão de obra infantil, mantém um elevadissimo grau de criminalidade e de estupro e venda de jovens mulheres, ...
Piers argues like he prepared a speech of what he thinks he's going to argue against
And when you're as politically illiterate as he is, that is a HORRIBLE strategy. He got completely exposed by Ash. Big L, rest in peace.
Yes it’s called straw manning, he deliberately misrepresents what his guests say when they disagree with his far right ideologies in an attempt to appear to win the exchanges
Pierce Morgan really needs to decide whether he wants to interview or be interviewed. He's literally dominating the discussion, not allowing Ash to finish one single sentence.
She's speaking absolute nonsense, I
@@AndrewHindley Hardly
He loves the sound of his own voice and firmly believes himself to be always right. 😠
I think she had long enough to spout her bike.
She just chatting complete waffle
I never sang the australian national anthem when I was going to school I was the only indigenous person there, My mother told me when I was a kid You can sing the song if you want to, but you don't have to if you don't want to,, There was a lot of people in the school who didn't like it Including the teachers but I didn't care! , Because australian national anthem doesn't represent the Indigenous people! of australia , That's why we got 3 different flags in australia for each race
Why should crowdfunding for schools prevent children from learning the National Anthem? Totally ridiculous argument.
I'm an Indian and i was born here its tradition and something I'm proud of, however you don't need to be here if you don't like it
Exactly !!!
So when Indians face racism, should they be happy about that too or go home?
Thank you because here in US Indians are the most bigoted rudest people. In England blacks say Indians are the rudest too I agree
Freshy ash doesn’t like anything about Britain
@@ravd8082 no. Ash is trying to ensure a better nation like many more before her to enable the takemeupstairs of the world to be able to come to the UK, vote, work, own businesses and indeed be elected, become Home Secretary, Chancellor and PM.
These were not 'traditions' but hard fought rights.
When I was in primary school in my country, we use to sing the national anthem.
Good for you that’s why you’re now a brainwashed nationalist. You’re probably conservative and religious too.
Every school in Canada sings the anthem as well. I am very surprised to hear Britain doesn't
Yea but freshly Ash doesn’t seem to
Cringe behaviour tbf.
@@SOak145Brits have self destructing behaviours.
in indonesia WE From Kids and High School we love sing national anthem in monday morning before study
Good for you
I'm not British, but you want to take a moment and sign the British National Anthem, what's the problem? Regardless of what country you live in, the citizens there should be allowed to sign their National Anthem without any issue. What can't you in your own country?
It's not people aren't allowed to. It's mandating everyone in schools to do so as a matter of government policy. Piers is fantastic at muddying the water on this and other non issues.
@@rondrajaeev2957 I don't think there js a ",britixh' national anthem..
You are allowed to, if you want to sing it at break time as an individual then nothing stops you, but we don’t go out of our way to do it all together, we think education is more important than singing the national anthem (which really isn’t that good of a song) and we aren’t interrupting the lessons just for that reason, nor are we cutting break times short for that reason either.
Excellent Morgan and thank you too to Mr. Rosindell!
👏👏👏❤
In 🇨🇦 we sing the national anthem every morning in elementary school. Standing at your desk and if your walking halls you stop and wait till its over then you continue walking. I❤🇨🇦
Some people won't sing it because they've NO INTENTION of being British.
They are by geography and will always be
Aye thats right, a lot of us vote to tell you that at every election. Saor Alba.
It you don't like our National Anthem, leave our Country and live where you agree with their Anthem
I’m an immigrant in this country and I’m happy to adapt the countries customs and tradition while living here,❤❤❤
She is London-born.
When in England abide by our rules, if not get out
This woman is "literally a communist", apparently. So of course she's gonna critique British law and culture. I agree, if she doesn't like our way of life here and our rules, why won't she LEAVE?
@@MichaelCHorler She's British and we are a democracy. She is entitled to her opinion, if you don't like our way of life here and our rules then LEAVE 🤪
All countries teach their history in a nationalist way. How is this controversial? People confuse the government and the country. The loyalty is to the country. Symbols like the flag and anthem are weaponized heavily by governments. Unity is not always a good thing. Unity around what? Andrew Rosindell actually thought he caught Ash Sarkar in a gotcha moment when she implied she isn't in love with the institution of monarchy in Britain. And he has the gall to scoff at her? In 2023! What a fool! It really boggles the mind.
I'll leave you with a quote from Mark Twain responding to those calling him disloyal and unpatriotic for disagreeing with the actions of his government...
"You see my kind of loyalty is loyalty to one's country, not to its institutions or its office-holders. The country is the real thing, the substantial thing, the eternal thing; it is the thing to watch over, and care for, and be loyal to; institutions are extraneous, they are a country's mere clothing, and clothing can wear out, become ragged, cease to be comfortable, cease to protect the body from winter, disease, and death. To be loyal to rags, to shout for rags, to worship rags, to die for rags--that is a loyalty of unreason, it is pure animal; it belongs to monarchy, was invented by monarchy; let monarchy keep it
What is wrong With being proud of the country you live in
can't feel proud, you would rather hate them. If you came from precolonial country background.
Nothing, if there is anything to be proud of.
The discussion was about another school mandate. In a world where an experimental vaccine was mandated on school children, a mandatory anthem may be wrong-headed but quite mild by comparison.
I've never sung the British national anthem in my life and I never will. I'm an atheist and anti-monarchist so I can't say the lyrics speak to me much
Out of all the people that are not like the other girls, you are the most not like the other girls.
If you don't like the National Anthem then change countries, simply just Foxtrot Oscar. It's like arguing with a school kid, she's an embarrassment.
England highest standards of education in litrasy & much high maths stranding
😂😂😂
We should be proud to sing our national anthem 🇬🇧🏴
Nationalism is a disease
No we shouldn't for many reasons my anthem is better Wales why should we sing about a man who takes our money
@@bleddynmorgan8012 that is a good argument but what would we sing on special events because it’s not fair if the Americans can do it and the French. The monarchy is the only thing that unites this country
You can be proud of something you worked for but not for you happen to be born in xyz
@@Britain1707 it's doesn't really tho but for what reasons do they unite
To be honest I thought piers would be on the other side😂 ,, not forcing kids to sing a governmental anthem,, you shouldn't force kids to do anything ,, there's a reason we don't do it and America does
The National Anthem is not an anthem for the nation. It is a song about one person, ie the monarch. It should be changed.
If it was, would you be more enthusiastic about it?
Rule Britannia, Britannia rules the waves with love from Tanzania.
Never! 🇬🇧🏴
I won’t sing or stand for the national anthem. The Windsors were great friends with Jimmy Saville and they knew about his dark side. Also we need an anthem about the people and the country not about one person.
National anthem is patriotic, so what is the problem
Azerm sounds Muslim
Are you happy that the same govt considers Muslim men to be rapists and groomers?
Take your time.
In what way ?
@@rayg4360Because we take pride in our country's monarchy and the song includes British values such as grace, happiness, glory etc etc.😊🏴🇬🇧👍
‘There’s nothing nationalist about the national anthem.’ 😂 piers you got owned
They force them to do that! THAT'S WHY THEY SHOULDN'T! They should sing the anthem only if they want to!!!
Ash: 1 in 6 schools are begging for money for basic equipment. Focus on policies that actually matter.
Piers: Let's waste time with cheap nationalism at the expense of tax payers' money.
The debate was about children singing the National Anthem,NOT about the state of UK schools.She was sideskirting the topic.
Ash 1 in 6 schools are begging for money for basic equipment focus
@@adyg5402 The debate is about mandates, though compared to vaccine mandates, this one is mild.
Encouragement & making it compulsory are very separate things, Morgan shouts down anyone who disagrees with him, shame his bias is blatant preventing a proper debate!
If you don’t recognise the dangers of nationalism as we watch a genocide being carried out due to colonial nationalism.
Btw, in America, all kids DO NOT sing the national anthem in school. That's COMPLETELY untrue.
her views are tipical indian/pakistani/bangla muslim. they never put their country of residence before religion. in india too, muslims refuse to say vande mataram, they oppose nationa anthem.
She's Hindu.
OMG when i always wear my england shirt i always sing our sweet national anthem & even i when watch the game when im in the pub drinking my pepsi.
The Marseillaise is something different. They know the Internationale, too. 😂
The Woman is Wrong; however Piers should still allow her to speak without interference 💯
I'm Scottish. And always stand for my national anthem. Flower of Scotland... love it❤
Yes but you have a good anthem. In England we do not.
@SOak145 I have no udea I have go say.. the English anthem . Js not my anthem,
…and rightly so. Your anthem is about Scotland. The National Anthem is about a God I don’t believe in protecting a privileged human being I have no respect for. The first line excludes me. The first line! 😂
Ahh that song about England? Well I'll just let you know it's not actually your national anthem, you don't really have one. I hope you do soon, and when you do, please choose a better song. One about Scotland rather than that one about England. Scotland the Brave or Highland Cathedral are far better options already.
Being An Indian, I Feel Ashamed Of This Girl's Behaviour 🙄
As a child in Canada in the 50's, we sang our national anthem AND recited the Lord's Prayer. No harm done to any child.
We are proud of our National Anthem we are British and if you dont like it leave.
I'm British. I'm not !
Piers: [0:51] "you're completely 'whataboutery' on this..."
25 seconds earlier...
Piers: [0:26] (paraphrase) ...but what about America, they sing the national anthem (and potentially in France under Macron) so why not here?
Wow, I like her! So calm and confident!
Singing the national attempt is high priority
Comes above repairing school buildings, cheap stunt by Tory’s ! Shame they don’t appear to care about our educational system? But then they don’t use it!
I am Asian and I am with Piers Morgan. I am so ashamed because of her.
Absolutely be forced to sing the Anthem. It will turn the youth away from the right wing faster than anything, to be obliged to mouth nonsense in order to get a few crumbs of knowledge.
Although I am very patriotic and proud to sing the National Anthem I don’t think it should be government policy to make schools have it sung although why not sing the anthem at the end of school assemblies which are already organised
My God. You're so reasonable.
We could enjoy your company in America, though I don't think you'd like it as well.
Well to be fair in Portugal we sing the National Anthem as well at school and its mandatory for every Portuguese national to know it back and forth. Being patriotic and proud of my country is a good thing.
Royal Britannia > God save the King
This women forgets, its our country country not hers hers
She was born here
What's wrong with singing national anthem in school?
I bet £10 Piers doesn't know verse 2 of the National Anthem. Says a lot about how much he cares about it.
If you took a poll, I would guess that anyone in the world wouldn't know the second or subsequent verses of their National Anthem. This is because it is rarely, if ever, sung further than the first verse. Only a tenner? Are you extremely poor, or are you not that confident?
@@Psmith-ek5hq not vietnamese people. we used to sing it every Mondays in school
Every child and person who come to live in the UK should learn the anthem its one part of making what is great Briton
No need to give this girl a voice.
I've been in school from 2000-2011 and still don't know the national anthem of by heart as we were never taught it!
I was in school from the early 70s to the early 80s and I wasn't taught it either, but I still knew it when I was young. There are other ways to learn something other in school.
That is terrible, my school 2010’s, 2020’s never taught me either!
@@TaySplatoon Ever thought of learning it for yourself? Given the amount of times you must have heard it, shouldn't the penny have dropped long before now? It's only 28 words for heaven sake.
I imagine you could find the words to our National Anthem if you took the trouble to look
Piers Morgan very frustrated 👎
Men speaking over women, suprised?
Get her Piers Morgan... She sounds crazy... She should get her stuff straight..
im 31 and i have no idea what our national anthem is.
If i we're too sing a national anthem it would be flower of Scotland
Ashna has got a point. Imagine British people of ethnic origin singing the anthem "God save the King". The royal family symbolises colonialism. I wouldn't sing it and i'm british.
anthem should be land of hope and glory or rule britannia anyways
This guy wants to win every debate by being loud and constantly interrupting the guests.
As long as he teaches me English it's fine.
Go cry about it
One of the few things I agree with Piers on
Sorry Poers, but you are totally out of touch on this ie there's a HUGE connection between Nationalism and Patriotism, So enevitably having Patriotism as a Policy will leed to increase Nationalism, and i don't think i need to explain what that is linked to..p perhaps the events after the horrific Southport stabbings, should make you realize she was right.
God save our precious King
lol in Canada we had to sing it every morning
Piers let's the man finish his sentence.
Im proud of Britain and our Empire we got the whole world out of the Jungle shared all our development Technology and Prosperity with the entire world we got Enemies because Success has always had Enemies....many people suffer from Envy and jealousy they never climb or succeed at anything pity for them
Let me be very vlear while my single mother did her absolute best to be all things to me both mother and father and i can tell u she did her best however! I am absolutely capable of saying that there are a good amout of things both can do and I even used to give my mom fathers fay gifts but i didn't say happy father's day DADDY i said happy father's day MOM n that is bec she did her best to play both roles but in the reality she was not daddy just because I did have a dad she was a mom who did her best to fill all the roles i as a child needed filled but that means one yhing only n that is that she was an awesome mother it didn't make her a father
Sing the national attempt every day
I’m not a fan of Ash Sarkars politics ..but as a young woman I applaud her 👏🏻
Yes
Should'nt have royals in this day an age. Proud of royals , Andrew? Seen Brtain's true monarch? By Tony Robinson
we don’t sing the national anthem in american schools. we recite the pledge of allegiance (unfortunately).
Why is it unfortunate I don't get it
@user-pu4bk7bf1g Mandatory mouthing of words is actually dubious under the First Amendment, which is America's single greatest accomplishment.
It's embarassing to impose it because if you are an Anti-Monarchist and Atheist the words mean nothing 🤣
Embarrasing woman that one, whataboutism at it’s saddest
shush
Yeah referencing Colin Kommiedick is not a winning argument.
@lesnessmanwkrp4762 learn what a traitor is before your childish rant
@@Cincinnatus77😂😂😂😂😂
@@tomservo75 tell you are racist without telling me..
Confound his knavish tricks!
England is Christian ✝️🤍 god save the king the god is Jesus Christ
Another one
yeah um we don’t sing the anthem in american schools
Can we sing the Romanian Anthem in British schools, please
La Marseillaise. It's the only anthem. 😊
I still say Collin kapernik took a knee because he was upset that they weren't starting him at qb and then when asked why he took a knee he came up with the racism of Cops but I truly believe it had nothing to do with and he was just being a baby that the team didn't want to play him
Why do they keep dragging this waste of space British hater out she has nothing to say apart from anti British diatribe
Go to india
Sri Lankan
Should Sunak and Braverman go first?
no bro we do not want her, we already have many ungreatful people iving here.@@RankinMsP
She's from Sri Lanka which was colonized by Britain. Idiot
She was born in London.
Nowt noble about Charlie (Diana, Camilla)
Any national anthem should not be alloes. Sing nMe of the lord 😂 Jesus
She is deluded but would still get it
Do you know the words to God Save the King? They are servile, actually.
Cristiano Laila Dwayne Elon And Maylee Colin Pokemon Go leaders and team rocket
Is it a national anthem or a prayer for the king? Ive got other things to pray for, i don't care for the royal family.
Hell no
Porque é que eles não assumem que querem ser mais donos que o próprio dono? Afinal de séculos já deveriam ter conseguido o que reclamam, mas no seu próprio país que continua a ser um dos que explora a mão de obra infantil, mantém um elevadissimo grau de criminalidade e de estupro e venda de jovens mulheres, ...
Sarkar was born in London. It is her country.
“It represents everybody”
It doesn’t though does it 🤦♂️
who is she? where is she from? tell her to ef off
She is from London.
This women will be my first victim of the cheesewire, now where did i put it😊.