I am not exaggerating, this is far more entertaining than anything put out by Disney . Excellent work, Dathomir was really unexpected. I assume we get to see Anakin use some of the dark-side magic he has learned ?
Actually Dathomir is the absolutely most logical place for Qui-Gon Jin to provide Anakin with exactly what he (Anakin) needs to fully master his "Darkness Within", plus abilities that no Jedi (and possibly even no Sith...) would have. Qui-Gon could not do this himself, but Mother Talzin most assuredly could! I look forward to seeing what Anakin could do with Night Sister Magic, along with Gray Jedi-type abilities.
I'm curious as to when Part 3 comes out, the story is if not one of the most interesting stories of an alternative timeline that I have not heard in a very long time.
Awesome Channel (Nostalgia Critic) did a longer alternative Star Wars timeline video series on this which extends to ROTS. After listening to both, this series seems far more plausible, complete, and intriguing.
The force deems that you bring us part 3 by sunset tomorrow. P.S. Keep up the good work bro because this "What If" is really killing all the other so far.
Rushing a part 3 by sunset tomorrow could ruin the story line and would be an act of the dark side of the force, patience and time to tell the story to the best that can be done is better and is a path of the light side of the force.
@@starwarsrebelain9020 Alright here it is verbatim: Ok guys, here's how it will end. As George Lucas said, "They fight!" Anakin and ya boy Qui Gon Jin be whoopin some butt. Qui dies, but it's cool. The chosen one is able to fight and defeat most of the baddies. Dooku, he's retreatin'. He ain't dumb, that chosen one just messed up most of his gang. Annie goes to the one man he can still trust, Obi Wan, the only one. They gon figure this out. Hope I didn't spoil part 3. Part 4 I have no clue... but we are waiting and these people are starving for what's to come.
What does one expect from a like begger? A person who says ... what if Quai Gon trained Anakin and spends two episodes making up a story about how they hide in the jungle and Dooku still finds them.. and not a single thing about what this so called training has altered
Thirty-one thousand and still no part three. And much like Dooku: "... My patience runs thin. We have been involved in this dance for far too long." UPDATE: Forty-Three Thousand and counting.
yeah thou i think dooku would not fall so far it pretty much outright said that he fell partly because of jinn death the clone army has no template yet and has just come up with as a idea. hell Sideous is still the apprentice at this time
Superbly done, and definitely worthy of a third episode! If this were a book, I would definitely buy it! A Temple Guard yellow-bladed lightsaber is the perfect weapon for Anakin; an ancient (and presumably accepted, but out of use) weapon of the Jedi, that would symbolize balance. I also think that the color of a Jedi Sentinel's lightsaber is the best choice for what Anakin Skywalker would become. The jungles of Dathomere would provide a near-ideal setting for Sentinel training as well as being the home of the Night Sisters. I suggest the following for the third episode: -- Anakin's lightsaber training would be more extensive under Qui-Gon Jinn. I am assuming that Qui-Gon Jinn would be at least highly proficient in Forms 1-4: Shii Cho (the most basic form, for multiple opponents), possibly mastered Makashi (he was Padawan to Count Dooku, THE Makashi master, best form for blade-to-blade combat), possibly mastered Soresu (his Padawan Obi-Wan Kenobi mastered Soresu, useful vs blasters), be a master of Ataru (likely adding Jar'Kai), probably master Niman (to unify everything else), and at least have learned Form 5 (both Shien and Djem So, useful defense/offense combination). -- Anakin would likely become highly proficient in Forms 1-4 first, master Ataru, learn Niman/Jar'Kai, and probably at least starting Form 5, Djem So. He would also gain proficiency with at least one Night Sister-preferred weapon. If Qui-Gon Jinn was suspected of being a Gray Jedi, this version of Anakin Skywalker IS definitely a Gray Jedi. His philosophy would probably read as follows: "The Light and Dark sides of The Force require different treatments; be at One with the Light Side, but also Master the Dark Side." -- Anakin's Jedi Force training would be more rigorous under Qui-Gon Jinn than it was under Obi-Wan Kenobi; probably including development of Precognition, Force Healing, Physical and Sensory Enhancement, Levitation, Tutamenus, Telekinesis (Force Push), and possibly even developing his Force Choke and Force Fire if these manifested. Force-based martial arts would be included, and "Jedi Mind Tricks" would be geared to provide Mind Control Invisibility and Silence instead of hypnosis. -- Anakin's gear could be augmented a bit. This could include a Night Sister Force-Augmented weapon in addition to his lightsaber, possibly made blaster/lightsaber resistant by Night Sister Magic. Building his lightsaber out of spaceship parts could also include using blaster/lightsaber resistant material such as Phrik or Beskar (Mandalorian Iron); possibly a two-piece model (allows Jar'Kai) with variable length blades on both ends This could be brought out in episode 3. Anakin loves to tinker and has no cybernetics.... -- Was Anakin's trial blindfolded/no lightsaber with the undead Rancors the traditional Night Sister initiation? You strongly implied "yes" on this question. It would be really good to have this come out on the third episode, or let Anakin be given the full initiation if he hasn't already had it. The test and the Night Sister training would make this Skywalker far more resistant to the Sith "Lure of the Dark Side", possibly even be immune to any Dark Side corruption. -- The confrontation between Anakin Skywalker and Darth Tyranus could be delayed; Anakin fakes his death (or Qui-Gon Jinn does this for him; IE: the hut blows up after Anakin escapes secretly) as Qui-Gon Jinn is killed (becoming a Force Ghost) or escapes. Then Anakin goes to "his second master" (Mother Talzin) who confirms that he had indeed passed the Night Sister initiation (or he is to be tested), and thus he is eligible for full-time Night Sister training under her tutelage. Expect Anakin to do a few off-Dathomer quests against a corrupt Republic as a lone Crusader or with a few Night Sisters. -- Anakin could encounter Darth Maul sometime during Mother Talzin's extensive training; defeating him easily, but sparing his life; using Jedi lightsaber skills/Force Abilities plus Night Sister Magic. Not wishing to make an enemy of Mother Talzin, he turns Maul (her son...?) over to "his second master" to face "Night Sister justice." Maybe Darth Maul could be brought back to Night Sister ways, or maybe not.... Doing appropriate quests, returning Darth Maul alive, and completion of Night Sister training would earn him respect from Mother Talzin. -- Anakin Skywalker's Night Sister training would be the full version of "Darkside Magic", including illusions, Night Sister healing (probably superior to what the Jedi have), better versions of Dark (possibly Gray) Jedi abilities (improved Force Choke and Force Fire come to mind), and eventually Force Lightning. Anakin trained as essentially a Gray Jedi fully versed in Night Sister magic would "wipe up the floor" with Darth Maul and make him equal to Darth Tyranus. -- A more fully-trained Anakin with Tutamenus, Force Fire, or possibly even (especially) Yellow Force Lightning equal to Sith Lightning would be able to battle Darth Tyranus on even terms (Anakin would probably have Djem So at this point). Darth Tyranus would be killed in combat, not merely slaughtered out of hand. Anakin would be doing more off-planet quests on behalf of the Night Sisters toward the end of breaking the Empire's blockade. He would stay hidden from the Jedi Order (except Obi-Wan Kenobi) while doing the things the Order could not/would not do. --A fully trained and battle-hardened Anakin Skywalker with all of the above abilities and experience would be a match for Darth Sideous; particularly Sideous without assistance from Darth Maul or Darth Tyranus. Anakin could also utilize the other Night Sister advantage of sorority (Night Sisters trust each other, Sith do not) and bring a few Night Sister backups to help him get through Imperial Guards/other henchmen while remaining "fresh and ready to fight." This would be a hard-won victory, preferably in single combat. -- The part of the story arc involving Padme needs to be tied up. I doubt it if Qui-Gon Jinn would have problems with Anakin Skywalker marrying, especially if Anakin kills Darth Sideous first, with peace, or at least co-existence, between a reformed/revised Jedi Order (more gray) and the Night Sisters. It would be interesting to have Leia meet Luke's Dathomerian "family." A twist could be, if at some point Leia was in exile on Dathomer due to Palpitine/Darth Sideous, and took Night Sister training....
@@solidspider2, glad you liked. It took me until today to put everything in that I wanted. I tried to use my best extrapolation on the Lightsaber skills, and on Night Sister magic. Hopefully my style was not too difficult to follow; it's been awhile since I've written something not work/science and technology - oriented (I'm a retired US Army Special Forces veteran who got an education as a chemist; and yes, my screen name is my last name). If your screen name is your own name, you have more online courage than I do!
Standing Wolf Personally I think this version of Anakin Skywalker is better than episode 3 Anakin in every way EXCEPT for lightsaber combat. If you look at Qui-Gon Jinn’s style it looks to be a very technical and strength based version of Ataru which is why it’s my belief he actually uses a Shien-Ataru hybrid. As a Jedi master Qui-Gon would have (at the very least) proficiency with 6 of the 7 lightsaber forms (obviously he probably didn’t want anything to do with Juyo) but he would be able to give Anakin extensive training in Shien (most of Qui-Gon’s adversaries were blaster wielding), Ataru (Qui-Gon’s main form), and Makashi (Qui-Gon was the apprentice of THE master of the form he probably just disliked using it) as well as plenty of skills in the other forms. Personally I think this new Anakin’s favorite form would be Niman as it would allow him to use all of his skills at once (both physical and in the force), and similar to Qui-Gon a Shien/Ataru hybrid allowing him to use his youthful strength and speed. However I doubt his version would be as grounded as Qui-Gon’s. I doubt he would be a fan of Makashi though I think he would realize it had its uses. Shii-Cho would be interesting as Kit-Fisto had to release himself into the Force to access its full power. Even getting close to the dark side. But Anakin wouldn’t have to worry about that as he already uses the dark side, just in a different form. This would create a highly versatile style built on using the Force as much as possible while combining the best parts of everything he’s learned. But the main reason I think this Anakin isn’t as good as Episode 3 Anakin is simply because of experience he’s never fought anyone outside of a training session. At least that’s my opinion.
@@gameovervirus2384 I wholeheartedly agree that Anakin Skywalker needs to be more "battle-hardened" before he encounters (or goes after) either Sith Apprentice, let alone the Emperor. Since this was not done in episode 2, it should be done in the beginning of episode 3. Other character changes would be the Night Sisters consisting of Humans, Zabrak, and Human/Zabrak hybrids, with Padme being Force - Sensitive and in exile on Dathomer. Anakin would acquire combat experience in the same manner as a Jedi Shadow or Jedi Sentinel, dealing with the jobs off-Dathomere that most Jedi could not/would not do. I would expect this alternate timeline Skywalker to be far more pragmatic than mainline-version Anakin. This could be done with Qui-Gon Jinn, if Qui-Gon survives the Darth Tyrannis encounter starting at the end of episode 2. If Qui-Gon was not around (for whatever reason), Anakin could do these off-Dathomere missions in concert with a few/or even one Night Sister (possibly even his "Second Master", Mother Talzin, as her "sword arm"). If well-enough trained/Jinn absent, he could even go off-planet on solo missions at some point. Doing any of these well in the cause of Dathomere would earn Skywalker some respect, if not liking, from Mother Talzin. If Padme was in exile on Dathomere, their first meeting when Anakin was a kid would be much like the main timeline except substitute "exiled on Dathomere; starting Night Sister Training" for "the royal court of Naboo." This Padme would have a little harder "edge." Work together could be Skywalker's first adult meeting...with Padme having survived her Night Sister Initiation. As for Qui-Gon's lightsaber combat, our ideas of style are not that different. I agree that Qui-Gon could be an "up-to-six-form master" with both Djem So and Shien for Form 5, and possibly even Jar'Kai acquired with Ataru or Niman (depending on whether old/new continuity is being followed). Juyo would not be a likely choice for him; however, depending on his relationship with Mace Windu, Vaapad might be possible. I would expect Qui-Gon Jinn to be very systematic in thoroughly training Anakin, training him well in the first four forms, but with first mastery being Ataru. Either Soresu or Shien would work for Anakin when dealing with Blaster fire, and Niman would most likely be Skywalker's second Mastery after he has a variety of Forms to attach to Niman, with Force Abilities and Night Sister Training. Before Anakin faces Darth Maul, he will need to have Djem So mastery to handle what Maul has. However giving Skywalker Vaapad and/or advanced Night Sister abilities would turn him into an unstoppable killing machine. Giving Anakin Juyo would make him too much like Maul. I would recommend bringing Maul back alive to Mother Talzin, in chains, especially if Maul is her son. Anakin having more Force Abilities (including Tutamenis)/more Night Sister Magic, possibly with Shien for handling Force Lightning, would make him a match for the Emperor's second apprentice, Darth Tyrannis, as a second major foe. This should be a first-encounter "solo-kill-as-a-consequence-of-single-combat" with the Emperor not present and no vengeance involved. Tyrannis was significantly more dangerous than Maul due to greater discipline and Force Abilities. The climactic battle should be Skywalker vs. Sideous with Anakin performing another "solo-kill-as-a-consequence-of-single-combat", this time with having full Night Sister training on par with that of Mother Talzin for power but not variety or experience. If Anakin had Vaapad (or especially) Juyo; it would have been acquired after facing Darth Tyrannis, but before facing Darth Sideous. The theme after killing both Darth Tyrannis and Darth Sideous should be "I did this because it was necessary to defeat the Sith once and for all." The expressions on the faces of any of these Sith foes when Anakin wields Night Sister Magic and/or Form 7 (either) without corruption would be priceless. As a parting note, most likely Luke and Leia would be raised/trained in both Jedi and Night Sister traditions in this alternate time line.
Standing Wolf i dont think ive ever seen someone write so much or know so much about star wars 😂 dude does George Lucas double check things with you? The way the lightsaber forms are built into your brain, you went full nerd bro but its cool i guess
@@lapplandkun9273 it's more like the rest of the Jedi order hindered Anakin, all of the people who supported him, trusted him, and believed in him either died, left, or received unfair or unjust treatment. For example yodal a member of the Jedi council died protecting Anakin and a city by absorbing or containing a seperatist bomb. Yodal was the only member to have consistently believe and support Anakin. Her death ratlled Anakin as did Fives and the image of Padme dying during childbirth disturbed Anakin deeply. The point in trying to make is if the Jedi council and order wasn't thinking Anakin was a mistake or would become some evil person, Anakin wouldn't have been tricked by Palatine and or wouldn't have hesitated during the fight between palpatine and mace windu.
Id buy it aswell!!. Isnt all the star wars books non cannon now anyway🤷♂️ wonder who has the rights to that. Hasbnt been a new star wars book in a while
Yo you did an excellent job with this can’t even lie. All your decisions for the story are very practical & make sense. Plus that yellow/gold saber is a genius choice , & connects Anakin & Rey the one who almost brought the balance & the one who did ,very nice touch!
Nathan Arsenault But like Luke said “there was balance but then there was Kylo Ren” Kylo would have killed Palp, Luke & the whole galaxy if if leia & rey didn’t stop him
Alex Sedmak Rey is dope because she begins where all the others before her peaked at, she reminds me of the original pioneers of the force who had to figure out how to use the force & wield a lightsaber(at the time Proto-sabers). Plus her and Kylo are a dyad once Kylo tried to enter her mind and she fought back & entered his in Episode 7 it awoke the connection between them which is a big reason why she learned to use her abilities so fast as well because she basically picked up on his skills as he was using them on her which is actually dope af
This what if keeps getting better and better. Qui-Gon Jinn is by far my favorite Jedi and it was sad to see him go so soon in the trilogy. In my opinion, he showed us in the few scenes he was in how a Jedi should be interacting with the galaxy. Neutral but still peaceful
I’m really loving the “what if”. It’s very refreshing from what’s going on with Star Wars currently. I really hope you make part 3 I’m really excited where this is going!
FBI Agent #420 oooooh that would be a good one!! Or if Yoda trained him instead, the vibes between yoda & Anakin were dope in the end of season 6 clone wars
It was a nice "twist" for them to go to Dathomir and train with Mother Talzin. I like that route since Mother Talzin gave Mace Windu a strong challenge, demonstrating her power. This is well-done and intriguing. Thanks.
Please bring us part 3. It would be awesome to see Anakin intervene between Dooku and Quigon by just using the force and then saying, “How about some tea.”
I probably said this in part 1, but I'm saying it again....thank you. It's so refreshing to see a theory where you don't play it safe, you just follow a path you see it heading in your head instead of regurgitating the same story line with only minor character changes. An example of that is Channel Awesome. They came up with the same theory as you days later, but they instead killed Obi Wan for Qui gon, and regurgitated the story line so exact, I wanted to vomit! I am looking forward to seeing your part 3.
Everyone asking for Part 3 :D Love this series of yours, as it satisfies me way more than the canon stuff that happened. Keep up the great work, much love!
Dude I know this is like the bazillionth comment asking for part 3. But you did such a good job with the first two parts. I was more than impressed when I first listened to them. In all honesty I know these videos take a lot of work and I am prepared to wait. I'd rather you delay the video in order to make it good than to just rush it out. I think everyone here would understand and appreciate your decision if that is the case. It would just be nice to get an update or something in order to know if you are working on it or not. Sidenote: you have great narrative skills, maybe you should consider releasing the rest of the narrative in the form of a published book, I would absolutely buy it. I love this channel!!!
I imagine that the Nightsisters would come to the aid of the Jedi Master, and his apprentice. Because of the hostile presence of those Dark Jedi. Either that, or intervene as a third party.
We are ready for parts 3 and 4 please. It's great storyline that needs to continue. At his loss to Qui-Gon, Dokoo would be forced to align himself to Palpatine...
A battle between dooku's force and the night sisters erupts. Qui Gon killed. Anakin finds Obi wan. Dooku is a pawn of Sidious. Clone wars break out. Anakin becomes what Rey became. Healing and becoming Godlike! Anakin is strong with the living and cosmic force. Detects the chips in the clones preventing order 66. Anakin battles darth sidious. Yoda battles dooku. Anakin replaces Yoda as grandmaster. Returns the Jedi back to being servants of the living force NOT the Republic!
What a nice and keen buildup of hype in the ending of part 2, truly wish for a part three, such an interesting alternative timeline by you, kindly send part three
Me - Searches for part three of this epic what if story.
Also me - Doesn’t find it
Me - Impossible. Perhaps the archives are incomplete.
They cause this guy is a fuckinf shitter
I just looked for part three as well with how many videos he has posted at this point you think he would have made it by now
Is there a way to keep track or know when Part 3 finally does come out?
Agreed
@@benduck9480 He also said he would make part 3 after 8k likes. Its at 34k when I'm seeing it.
IM BEGGING YOU TO FINISH THIS.
THE FORCE EMPLORES YOU TO COMPLETE THE SERIES
BRING BALANCE AND GLORY TO THE FANDOM
"He didn't even need to see his face due to his stance."
Me: Signature look of superiority
Chad stance
T posing dooku
This is where the “What If” lore deepens.
And who gives a flying toot?!?!?
Yyes!
I am not exaggerating, this is far more entertaining than anything put out by Disney . Excellent work, Dathomir was really unexpected. I assume we get to see Anakin use some of the dark-side magic he has learned ?
I was expecting degoba tbh but dathomir actually makes sense
Lol I thought it would be Mustafar.
Actually Dathomir is the absolutely most logical place for Qui-Gon Jin to provide Anakin with exactly what he (Anakin) needs to fully master his "Darkness Within", plus abilities that no Jedi (and possibly even no Sith...) would have.
Qui-Gon could not do this himself, but Mother Talzin most assuredly could! I look forward to seeing what Anakin could do with Night Sister Magic, along with Gray Jedi-type abilities.
S Sharma so true
I was expecting that dumb planet from the sequels from the ocean, lol, but I assume he's just taking stuff from Jedi: Fallen Order
Sadly I believe there will never be a part three, this was amazing and I was hooked from the beginning. Hope to maybe see it some day
I'm loving these "what if" stories, hopefully you make a part 3.
Mahdi Nur beacuse he tends to never continue it on after two episodes
@@johnnybulldog1322 He is Gaben in disguise
What if Rey had to face believable motivations, character development, and training BEFORE she was an all powerful "strong female character".
@@mitchellsedmak impossible.
True
I'm curious as to when Part 3 comes out, the story is if not one of the most interesting stories of an alternative timeline that I have not heard in a very long time.
For real man. I'm liking this timeline. I want to know what happens next
same here. there's so many ways the story could go even with what he's already confirmed.
Awesome Channel (Nostalgia Critic) did a longer alternative Star Wars timeline video series on this which extends to ROTS. After listening to both, this series seems far more plausible, complete, and intriguing.
Please make part 3
The question is
Will anakin like sand?
Hopefully one day we will get a part 3, I hype this story up to everyone when we talk about what if star wars.
What If Qui-Gon Jinn Trained Anakin PART 3 Please!!!
Ikr
Cmon
I needit
I dont need it.. i dont need it.... I NEEED IIIITTT
I agree
Anakin would have definitely developed a “certain set of skills....”
I think he already has, and he'll be a nightmare for people like Dooku.
Oh haha! that took me a second to get the Liam Neeson pun
Lmao that a good 1
W. R.: Nice _Taken_ reference! Well played.
Force heal?
I don’t think it’s appropriate that this man would leave a great story like this unfinished
The force deems that you bring us part 3 by sunset tomorrow.
P.S. Keep up the good work bro because this "What If" is really killing all the other so far.
Rushing a part 3 by sunset tomorrow could ruin the story line and would be an act of the dark side of the force, patience and time to tell the story to the best that can be done is better and is a path of the light side of the force.
*Master Yoda voice* ‘ Hm patience you must have ‘
@@ethanmckinstry6601 indeed, also I hope this gets a part four and more. It has so much potential
@@danielblair4413 but there must be balance! A quicker upload with a good story line
I sense the force deems he must bring part III when the sun is on the equator
I’m Darth Revan, and you’re watching the stupendous wave
*what if?*
Anakin Skywalker what if what?
@@darthrevanthedestroyer9003 Hmm.
Train me
@@srami004*Have you ever heard the tragedy of Darth Plagueis the wise?*
Guys, stupendous wave is working on What if Qui-Gon trained anakin par 3 RIGHT NOW, it said on his Twitter!
Please do that for all us
I'll erase my prediction then.
I need to know now come don't keep me wait
@@starwarsrebelain9020 Alright here it is verbatim: Ok guys, here's how it will end. As George Lucas said, "They fight!" Anakin and ya boy Qui Gon Jin be whoopin some butt. Qui dies, but it's cool. The chosen one is able to fight and defeat most of the baddies. Dooku, he's retreatin'. He ain't dumb, that chosen one just messed up most of his gang. Annie goes to the one man he can still trust, Obi Wan, the only one. They gon figure this out. Hope I didn't spoil part 3. Part 4 I have no clue... but we are waiting and these people are starving for what's to come.
Thanks dude I need any information about this you're the guy I can't wait for part 3 and 4 come out thanks again dude
“8 thousand likes and I’ll come out with part 3” *28 thousand likes later still no part 3*
@Pizza 34,000 now
@@josehernandez-arce5296 35,000 now
At the time i am reporting its 36000 now
37000
What does one expect from a like begger? A person who says ... what if Quai Gon trained Anakin and spends two episodes making up a story about how they hide in the jungle and Dooku still finds them.. and not a single thing about what this so called training has altered
Anyone else hear Liam Neeson and Christopher Lee when Qui-Gon and Dooku's lines are read? These characters are written spot-on.
No, the prequels are perfect and it shows every day, you mean.
@@urjnlegend wha?
@@thewitchofsloth death sticks are a hell of a drug
An unfinished story is worse than a bad ending
Where’s part three I need it this is amazing story so far
still waiting on this cliff hanger.... could of given birth to the chosen one by now...
@@Breezey_Dubz lmao I just watched this and was thinking the same thing
Dang this is a coincidence, me too
So we all just seein this today
Ay 34k likes tho
Thirty-one thousand and still no part three. And much like Dooku: "... My patience runs thin. We have been involved in this dance for far too long."
UPDATE: Forty-Three Thousand and counting.
Every single star wars chanel does this they say they will make another part and then they just forget
What are you wait for we not get younger
42,000+ souls in unity request you honor your word.
We need more likes now
606 hundred thousand now and 44k likes
Gonna need parts 3, 4, 5, and 6 pronto! This is too good to have it end
I love the fact that I can actually imagine everything happening exactly the way you narrated! The characters, their lines and so on...
yeah thou i think dooku would not fall so far it pretty much outright said that he fell partly because of jinn death the clone army has no template yet and has just come up with as a idea. hell Sideous is still the apprentice at this time
Superbly done, and definitely worthy of a third episode! If this were a book, I would definitely buy it!
A Temple Guard yellow-bladed lightsaber is the perfect weapon for Anakin; an ancient (and presumably accepted, but out of use) weapon of the Jedi, that would symbolize balance. I also think that the color of a Jedi Sentinel's lightsaber is the best choice for what Anakin Skywalker would become. The jungles of Dathomere would provide a near-ideal setting for Sentinel training as well as being the home of the Night Sisters. I suggest the following for the third episode:
-- Anakin's lightsaber training would be more extensive under Qui-Gon Jinn. I am assuming that Qui-Gon Jinn would be at least highly proficient in Forms 1-4: Shii Cho (the most basic form, for multiple opponents), possibly mastered Makashi (he was Padawan to Count Dooku, THE Makashi master, best form for blade-to-blade combat), possibly mastered Soresu (his Padawan Obi-Wan Kenobi mastered Soresu, useful vs blasters), be a master of Ataru (likely adding Jar'Kai), probably master Niman (to unify everything else), and at least have learned Form 5 (both Shien and Djem So, useful defense/offense combination).
-- Anakin would likely become highly proficient in Forms 1-4 first, master Ataru, learn Niman/Jar'Kai, and probably at least starting Form 5, Djem So. He would also gain proficiency with at least one Night Sister-preferred weapon. If Qui-Gon Jinn was suspected of being a Gray Jedi, this version of Anakin Skywalker IS definitely a Gray Jedi. His philosophy would probably read as follows: "The Light and Dark sides of The Force require different treatments; be at One with the Light Side, but also Master the Dark Side."
-- Anakin's Jedi Force training would be more rigorous under Qui-Gon Jinn than it was under Obi-Wan Kenobi; probably including development of Precognition, Force Healing, Physical and Sensory Enhancement, Levitation, Tutamenus, Telekinesis (Force Push), and possibly even developing his Force Choke and Force Fire if these manifested. Force-based martial arts would be included, and "Jedi Mind Tricks" would be geared to provide Mind Control Invisibility and Silence instead of hypnosis.
-- Anakin's gear could be augmented a bit. This could include a Night Sister Force-Augmented weapon in addition to his lightsaber, possibly made blaster/lightsaber resistant by Night Sister Magic. Building his lightsaber out of spaceship parts could also include using blaster/lightsaber resistant material such as Phrik or Beskar (Mandalorian Iron); possibly a two-piece model (allows Jar'Kai) with variable length blades on both ends This could be brought out in episode 3. Anakin loves to tinker and has no cybernetics....
-- Was Anakin's trial blindfolded/no lightsaber with the undead Rancors the traditional Night Sister initiation? You strongly implied "yes" on this question. It would be really good to have this come out on the third episode, or let Anakin be given the full initiation if he hasn't already had it. The test and the Night Sister training would make this Skywalker far more resistant to the Sith "Lure of the Dark Side", possibly even be immune to any Dark Side corruption.
-- The confrontation between Anakin Skywalker and Darth Tyranus could be delayed; Anakin fakes his death (or Qui-Gon Jinn does this for him; IE: the hut blows up after Anakin escapes secretly) as Qui-Gon Jinn is killed (becoming a Force Ghost) or escapes. Then Anakin goes to "his second master" (Mother Talzin) who confirms that he had indeed passed the Night Sister initiation (or he is to be tested), and thus he is eligible for full-time Night Sister training under her tutelage. Expect Anakin to do a few off-Dathomer quests against a corrupt Republic as a lone Crusader or with a few Night Sisters.
-- Anakin could encounter Darth Maul sometime during Mother Talzin's extensive training; defeating him easily, but sparing his life; using Jedi lightsaber skills/Force Abilities plus Night Sister Magic. Not wishing to make an enemy of Mother Talzin, he turns Maul (her son...?) over to "his second master" to face "Night Sister justice." Maybe Darth Maul could be brought back to Night Sister ways, or maybe not.... Doing appropriate quests, returning Darth Maul alive, and completion of Night Sister training would earn him respect from Mother Talzin.
-- Anakin Skywalker's Night Sister training would be the full version of "Darkside Magic", including illusions, Night Sister healing (probably superior to what the Jedi have), better versions of Dark (possibly Gray) Jedi abilities (improved Force Choke and Force Fire come to mind), and eventually Force Lightning. Anakin trained as essentially a Gray Jedi fully versed in Night Sister magic would "wipe up the floor" with Darth Maul and make him equal to Darth Tyranus.
-- A more fully-trained Anakin with Tutamenus, Force Fire, or possibly even (especially) Yellow Force Lightning equal to Sith Lightning would be able to battle Darth Tyranus on even terms (Anakin would probably have Djem So at this point). Darth Tyranus would be killed in combat, not merely slaughtered out of hand. Anakin would be doing more off-planet quests on behalf of the Night Sisters toward the end of breaking the Empire's blockade. He would stay hidden from the Jedi Order (except Obi-Wan Kenobi) while doing the things the Order could not/would not do.
--A fully trained and battle-hardened Anakin Skywalker with all of the above abilities and experience would be a match for Darth Sideous; particularly Sideous without assistance from Darth Maul or Darth Tyranus. Anakin could also utilize the other Night Sister advantage of sorority (Night Sisters trust each other, Sith do not) and bring a few Night Sister backups to help him get through Imperial Guards/other henchmen while remaining "fresh and ready to fight." This would be a hard-won victory, preferably in single combat.
-- The part of the story arc involving Padme needs to be tied up. I doubt it if Qui-Gon Jinn would have problems with Anakin Skywalker marrying, especially if Anakin kills Darth Sideous first, with peace, or at least co-existence, between a reformed/revised Jedi Order (more gray) and the Night Sisters. It would be interesting to have Leia meet Luke's Dathomerian "family." A twist could be, if at some point Leia was in exile on Dathomer due to Palpitine/Darth Sideous, and took Night Sister training....
Standing Wolf That sounds really good
@@solidspider2, glad you liked. It took me until today to put everything in that I wanted. I tried to use my best extrapolation on the Lightsaber skills, and on Night Sister magic. Hopefully my style was not too difficult to follow; it's been awhile since I've written something not work/science and technology - oriented (I'm a retired US Army Special Forces veteran who got an education as a chemist; and yes, my screen name is my last name). If your screen name is your own name, you have more online courage than I do!
Standing Wolf Personally I think this version of Anakin Skywalker is better than episode 3 Anakin in every way EXCEPT for lightsaber combat. If you look at Qui-Gon Jinn’s style it looks to be a very technical and strength based version of Ataru which is why it’s my belief he actually uses a Shien-Ataru hybrid. As a Jedi master Qui-Gon would have (at the very least) proficiency with 6 of the 7 lightsaber forms (obviously he probably didn’t want anything to do with Juyo) but he would be able to give Anakin extensive training in Shien (most of Qui-Gon’s adversaries were blaster wielding), Ataru (Qui-Gon’s main form), and Makashi (Qui-Gon was the apprentice of THE master of the form he probably just disliked using it) as well as plenty of skills in the other forms. Personally I think this new Anakin’s favorite form would be Niman as it would allow him to use all of his skills at once (both physical and in the force), and similar to Qui-Gon a Shien/Ataru hybrid allowing him to use his youthful strength and speed. However I doubt his version would be as grounded as Qui-Gon’s. I doubt he would be a fan of Makashi though I think he would realize it had its uses. Shii-Cho would be interesting as Kit-Fisto had to release himself into the Force to access its full power. Even getting close to the dark side. But Anakin wouldn’t have to worry about that as he already uses the dark side, just in a different form. This would create a highly versatile style built on using the Force as much as possible while combining the best parts of everything he’s learned. But the main reason I think this Anakin isn’t as good as Episode 3 Anakin is simply because of experience he’s never fought anyone outside of a training session. At least that’s my opinion.
@@gameovervirus2384 I wholeheartedly agree that Anakin Skywalker needs to be more "battle-hardened" before he encounters (or goes after) either Sith Apprentice, let alone the Emperor. Since this was not done in episode 2, it should be done in the beginning of episode 3. Other character changes would be
the Night Sisters consisting of Humans, Zabrak, and Human/Zabrak hybrids, with Padme being Force - Sensitive and in exile on Dathomer.
Anakin would acquire combat experience in the same manner as a Jedi Shadow or Jedi Sentinel, dealing with the jobs off-Dathomere that most Jedi could not/would not do. I would expect this alternate timeline Skywalker to be far more pragmatic than mainline-version Anakin. This could be done with Qui-Gon Jinn, if Qui-Gon survives the Darth Tyrannis encounter starting at the end of episode 2.
If Qui-Gon was not around (for whatever reason), Anakin could do these off-Dathomere missions in concert with a few/or even one Night Sister (possibly even his "Second Master", Mother Talzin, as her "sword arm"). If well-enough trained/Jinn absent, he could even go off-planet on solo missions at some point. Doing any of these well in the cause of Dathomere would earn Skywalker some respect, if not liking, from Mother Talzin.
If Padme was in exile on Dathomere, their first meeting when Anakin was a kid would be much like the main timeline except substitute "exiled on Dathomere; starting Night Sister Training" for "the royal court of Naboo." This Padme would have a little harder "edge." Work together could be Skywalker's first adult meeting...with Padme having survived her Night Sister Initiation.
As for Qui-Gon's lightsaber combat, our ideas of style are not that different. I agree that Qui-Gon could be an "up-to-six-form master" with both Djem So and Shien for Form 5, and possibly even Jar'Kai acquired with Ataru or Niman (depending on whether old/new continuity is being followed). Juyo would not be a likely choice for him; however, depending on his relationship with Mace Windu, Vaapad might be possible.
I would expect Qui-Gon Jinn to be very systematic in thoroughly training Anakin, training him well in the first four forms, but with first mastery being Ataru. Either Soresu or Shien would work for Anakin when dealing with Blaster fire, and Niman would most likely be Skywalker's second Mastery after he has a variety of Forms to attach to Niman, with Force Abilities and Night Sister Training.
Before Anakin faces Darth Maul, he will need to have Djem So mastery to handle what Maul has. However giving Skywalker Vaapad and/or advanced Night Sister abilities would turn him into an unstoppable killing machine. Giving Anakin Juyo would make him too much like Maul. I would recommend bringing Maul back alive to Mother Talzin, in chains, especially if Maul is her son.
Anakin having more Force Abilities (including Tutamenis)/more Night Sister Magic, possibly with Shien for handling Force Lightning, would make him a match for the Emperor's second apprentice, Darth Tyrannis, as a second major foe. This should be a first-encounter "solo-kill-as-a-consequence-of-single-combat" with the Emperor not present and no vengeance involved. Tyrannis was significantly more dangerous than Maul due to greater discipline and Force Abilities.
The climactic battle should be Skywalker vs. Sideous with Anakin performing another "solo-kill-as-a-consequence-of-single-combat", this time with having full Night Sister training on par with that of Mother Talzin for power but not variety or experience. If Anakin had Vaapad (or especially) Juyo; it would have been acquired after facing Darth Tyrannis, but before facing Darth Sideous.
The theme after killing both Darth Tyrannis and Darth Sideous should be "I did this because it was necessary to defeat the Sith once and for all."
The expressions on the faces of any of these Sith foes when Anakin wields Night Sister Magic and/or Form 7 (either) without corruption would be priceless. As a parting note, most likely Luke and Leia would be raised/trained in both Jedi and Night Sister traditions in this alternate time line.
Standing Wolf i dont think ive ever seen someone write so much or know so much about star wars 😂 dude does George Lucas double check things with you? The way the lightsaber forms are built into your brain, you went full nerd bro but its cool i guess
I need a part 3 immediately. This is actually a really interesting story and I really like what you did with Qui-gon and Anakin. Please give us more
Qui-Gon would have been the best thing for Anakin. I truly felt that Obi-Wan shut him down more than building him up.
Yeah I feel like there relationship was more to Obi-Wan’s benefit than to Anakin’s.
Obi-Wan’s growth was exponential while Anakin’s was hindered.
Very true that
i thought obi wan tried his best and was decent master, for all that he was given. Was he ready for him? Unfortunately no. Yet he still did his best.
@@lapplandkun9273 it's more like the rest of the Jedi order hindered Anakin, all of the people who supported him, trusted him, and believed in him either died, left, or received unfair or unjust treatment. For example yodal a member of the Jedi council died protecting Anakin and a city by absorbing or containing a seperatist bomb. Yodal was the only member to have consistently believe and support Anakin. Her death ratlled Anakin as did Fives and the image of Padme dying during childbirth disturbed Anakin deeply. The point in trying to make is if the Jedi council and order wasn't thinking Anakin was a mistake or would become some evil person, Anakin wouldn't have been tricked by Palatine and or wouldn't have hesitated during the fight between palpatine and mace windu.
Yeah, it felt less like a "Master/Apprentice" relationship and more like a Rivalry.
(In Kylo Ren voice): “MOORRE! MOOORRREE! MOOOOOORRRREEEE!!!”
calm down,sonnie
😂😂😂😂
Video is two years old, one year ago comments asking about part 3.
The year is 2022 and we still anxiously await part 3...
Are you writing a book. This sounds like you're writing a book. And I would buy
Hell yeah
I'd buy
Same
@The Stupendous Wave PLEASE WRITE A BOOK BECAUSE YOU CAN SEE WE WOULD ALL BUY
Id buy it aswell!!. Isnt all the star wars books non cannon now anyway🤷♂️ wonder who has the rights to that. Hasbnt been a new star wars book in a while
Yo you did an excellent job with this can’t even lie. All your decisions for the story are very practical & make sense. Plus that yellow/gold saber is a genius choice , & connects Anakin & Rey the one who almost brought the balance & the one who did ,very nice touch!
What if Rey had to face believable motivations, character development, and training BEFORE she was an all powerful "strong female character".
Nathan Arsenault But like Luke said “there was balance but then there was Kylo Ren” Kylo would have killed Palp, Luke & the whole galaxy if if leia & rey didn’t stop him
Alex Sedmak Rey is dope because she begins where all the others before her peaked at, she reminds me of the original pioneers of the force who had to figure out how to use the force & wield a lightsaber(at the time Proto-sabers). Plus her and Kylo are a dyad once Kylo tried to enter her mind and she fought back & entered his in Episode 7 it awoke the connection between them which is a big reason why she learned to use her abilities so fast as well because she basically picked up on his skills as he was using them on her which is actually dope af
Thank you anakin has always been my favorite character and you just put his potential his true destiny in air
This what if keeps getting better and better. Qui-Gon Jinn is by far my favorite Jedi and it was sad to see him go so soon in the trilogy. In my opinion, he showed us in the few scenes he was in how a Jedi should be interacting with the galaxy. Neutral but still peaceful
Cmon with part 3 bro! Dooku and Jin head to head. Please make it a truly badass fight
Part 3 please. This is incredibly enjoyable to listen to.
I’m really loving the “what if”. It’s very refreshing from what’s going on with Star Wars currently. I really hope you make part 3 I’m really excited where this is going!
New “what if” idea what if anakin took the fathers place
FBI Agent #420 oooooh that would be a good one!! Or if Yoda trained him instead, the vibes between yoda & Anakin were dope in the end of season 6 clone wars
@@thothofthemorningrisesWthesun the gods would need to nerf him
PenguinBoy 09 Rey would have to go back to in time & nerf him lol
I really enjoyed this series until I realized you never made Part 3. Now I wish I had never seen them. You got my hopes up man.
It was a nice "twist" for them to go to Dathomir and train with Mother Talzin. I like that route since Mother Talzin gave Mace Windu a strong challenge, demonstrating her power. This is well-done and intriguing. Thanks.
What if Rey had to face believable motivations, character development, and training BEFORE she was an all powerful "strong female character".
Please bring us part 3. It would be awesome to see Anakin intervene between Dooku and Quigon by just using the force and then saying, “How about some tea.”
Year 2 of waiting for pt 3. I think this is my favorite what if.
What if Anakin defeated the High Ground?
Impossible
Obi wan has the lowground
@@redacted6090 hi modest pelican... I mean eagle
That was already shown in the Xbox game star wars revenge of the sith
@@eggworksfan9859 whats going on lads and lasses
I probably said this in part 1, but I'm saying it again....thank you. It's so refreshing to see a theory where you don't play it safe, you just follow a path you see it heading in your head instead of regurgitating the same story line with only minor character changes. An example of that is Channel Awesome. They came up with the same theory as you days later, but they instead killed Obi Wan for Qui gon, and regurgitated the story line so exact, I wanted to vomit!
I am looking forward to seeing your part 3.
Can we please have a part 3? Genuinely enthralled by this
Arguably one of the best “what if” ive listened to, I can’t wait for the next one!
Still anxiously awaiting part 3!!!
please we need part 3
may the force be with you
Ugh where is this part 3 huh
Please make a part 3! This story is very intriguing!
"these are not the droids you're looking for" wait i mean " you shall bring part 3 to us"
Still waiting for part 3!! Sooo good! Love this story you're crafting!
Part 3? Because I'm really loving this series.
Everyone asking for Part 3 :D Love this series of yours, as it satisfies me way more than the canon stuff that happened. Keep up the great work, much love!
Please, Stupendous Wave, give us part three of this, because this has been fascinating.
Being apprenticed to the trolling master might've not been the council's wisest decision for lil Annie.
Absolutely loving the story, hopefully part 3 comes out soon
Dude I know this is like the bazillionth comment asking for part 3. But you did such a good job with the first two parts. I was more than impressed when I first listened to them. In all honesty I know these videos take a lot of work and I am prepared to wait. I'd rather you delay the video in order to make it good than to just rush it out. I think everyone here would understand and appreciate your decision if that is the case. It would just be nice to get an update or something in order to know if you are working on it or not.
Sidenote: you have great narrative skills, maybe you should consider releasing the rest of the narrative in the form of a published book, I would absolutely buy it. I love this channel!!!
I need a part 3 omg this story is getting so good I would love to see you explore anakin's new powers and abilities
1 months later, me having "what if" withdrawls.
Yeah. Still waiting for part 3
20k likes nothing
I know, I'm still waiting for part 3
Yeah I feel your pain my man. PT 3 needs to be made
👀 anything yet?
Please make a part 3 to have watched this what if so many times hoping there will be a part 3
Really enjoying this story! Please make a part 3 soon!
I just want to say I love this content. I hope to force guides you toward part 3 in the coming months. My the force flow through you my old friend.
We need part 3 my guy!
12:55 "very soon"
Ur killin me mate plz i need a part 3. This is amazing i wish this would be made into a movie or something. Please keep up the amazing work
very interesting. Would enjoy a continuation on this
I have been loving this story so far it gives an interesting twist on how everything ends up and I am really interested to see where you take it
I imagine that the Nightsisters would come to the aid of the Jedi Master, and his apprentice. Because of the hostile presence of those Dark Jedi. Either that, or intervene as a third party.
That was awesome can't wait for the next one
These “what if” stories are so cool, I really hope you make a part three and keep up the good work
when is part 3 coming out
Seriously. 2 months later and no part 3.
*RAGE*
3 months later.........
It takes time to make you know
Emerald noob Yt well the first two came out in the same month so it’s understandable that they are asking
3 months later plus 1 day damn...... The story is so good
i'm not really a Star Wars fan but since finding this channel, and from it others, i've gotten more intrigued. Please make a part three to this!
I would love to see the converse of this as well. See how Maul's training has progressed in the way of the sith
can we get a petition going to Disney to make a ALTERNATE universe where this happens ?????
facts its sos good
Nah, Disney would fuck it up
@@toad8275 no no hes got a point
@@theonethatgotaway3475 Wdym? I mean we could get lucky and they don't mess iti up. But let's be honest, they're like chiefs that burn their food...
@@toad8275 someone could make it a fanfilm
there's some impressive stuff out there
We are ready for parts 3 and 4 please. It's great storyline that needs to continue. At his loss to Qui-Gon, Dokoo would be forced to align himself to Palpatine...
Still wating for that part 3, 2 weeks after.
2 months, 2 weeks.
2 months, 3 weeks,1 day
@@nitzel9909 2 months, 3 weeks,2 days
Speedy 2 month 3 weeks 2 days and 8 hours
A battle between dooku's force and the night sisters erupts. Qui Gon killed. Anakin finds Obi wan. Dooku is a pawn of Sidious. Clone wars break out. Anakin becomes what Rey became. Healing and becoming Godlike! Anakin is strong with the living and cosmic force. Detects the chips in the clones preventing order 66. Anakin battles darth sidious. Yoda battles dooku. Anakin replaces Yoda as grandmaster. Returns the Jedi back to being servants of the living force NOT the Republic!
This amazing story needs it’s part 3!!!
Way more creative and interesting than Disney's "what if" story arcs. When is part 3 happening?
Very good storytelling! Part 3 please!
WE NEED PART 3 OF THIS SERIES!!!
I'm intrigued and would wish that you would continue this, "What if?" Story.
It’s been a year and there’s still no part 3 video. What a shame, this was a good what if.
Where is part 3! I need it in my life. This is more interesting than the actual story.
👀👀 “will come out with part 3 very soon” insert voice from spongebob...” 2 months later..”
Lol it’s funny that this comment was 2 months ago
"6 months later"
8😢
This is getting out of hand, now there is 2 of them!
A part 3, we need
I would really like to see Anakin participate in the clone wars and fight along the Jedi in the next part
When do you plan to complete part 3? It’s been rather interesting so far…I’d hate for it not to be completed.
A double bladed light sabre with two different colours representing his true self would be fantastic.
Please, can we get part 3 soon? This is fascinating
We need part 3. I hope he can get together with padme still and maybe save his mother in this timeline.
Where's part 3. I like the direction you are going so far. It feels right.
It feels worthy of a novel.
love the what if Qui-Gon Trained Anakin, is there a part 3? can we watch the part 3 please, thank you stay safe
Wheres part 3😭😭😭 this is so good
Sometimes at night, I pretend part 3 is out, and then I manage to fall asleep eventually. #whereis3
Loved this, really hoping part 3 is in the works!
looking forward to part 3
Place your bets everyone: Qui Gon vs Dooku. How will this confrontation go down?
Dooku wins every single time, unless plot armour happens
Joshua Kei true
I call plot armour till anakin shows up. (:
Anakin will show up. Qui Gon will get injured. Anakin gets enraged. They defeat Dooku. The rest can buggar off.
That’s true
WE NEED A PART 3
*Hmmmmm.....*
Yeet him
Yeet the younglings
We really need a Star Wars what if animated series
What a nice and keen buildup of hype in the ending of part 2, truly wish for a part three, such an interesting alternative timeline by you, kindly send part three
It has been 3 months when is part 3 coming out
5 months now, still nothing
In one of his videos he said he was working on it
Oh Yeah Yeah i hope so
Bro part 3
@@ohyeahyeah4945 9 months now