Confusion about moon sighting🌙 in Ramadan, should we follow Saudi Arabia 🇸🇦? assim al hakeem
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ก.ย. 2024
- #assim
Instagram: / assimalhakeem
Follow the assimalhakeem channel on WhatsApp: whatsapp.com/c...
Website: www.assimalhake...
Ask a Question: www.assimalhak...
Facebook: / sheikhassimalhakeemteam
Twitter: / assimalhakeem
![POLYCAT - ข้อความรูปยิ้ม [Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/lBhIgPGCgbI/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Re:all TREASURE] EP.6 in 방콕ㅣ🚩 쩡캠의 방콕 투어 빵 마이 와이 👍](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/uyFw-nItA_s/mqdefault.jpg)
Rabbana atina fi dunya hasanatan wa fil akhirati hasanatan waqina 'adhaban-nar
Our Lord, give us in this world [that which is] good and in the Hereafter [that which is] good and protect us from the punishment of the Fire.
Aameen
Aameen
I used to watch you on peace tv years ago, and am so delighted you're on TH-cam alhamdulillah 😊
Ramadan Mubarak to all 🌙🤲🏽
For the moon sighting my reason for WHY it is region specific and local Imams to me here in the UK have also said this is because following Saudi is a new innovation and a modern thing because for centuries we had no technology to allow us to communicate with people halfway across the world and people living far away from Makkah would just make their own prediction but now that we can contact people in Saudi Arabia people automatically think oh today is 1st Ramadan or Eid Ul Fitr in Makkah right now so I must also do my first fast or my Eid today too even though I live in the UK or USA etc... which is halfway across the world
Here in the UK because of our location on the earth compared to Saudi Arabia it is usually always the day after Saudi when we start the new Islamic months and only time you follow Saudi (technically) is for Hajj because that is a pilgrimage to that country but you would still do Eid Ul Adha according your local region. When there is no known moon sighting we still do it 1 day later. I personally think it is wrong to just keep following Saudi if it is something that not even the companions of the Prophet himself or other Muslims for centuries before us did because how were they to know the moon was just sighted in Makkah when they were currently staying/living in a place where the moon sighting differed from Saudi. As for things regarding well all these clouds and fog and so on make it harder for us in the UK to see the moon I will just say scientifically the moon is still there if you were to take the clouds out of the question using technology and Islamic months are always 30 days (unless the moon sighting is a day earlier) so you use the 30 days to determine if it is a new month or at the very least if scientifically the moon sighting in your country happens the day after Saudi then even when you don't see a moon due to the weather conditions just do it a day after Saudi knowing that it is supposed to be shining above you but is cannot be seen due to weather conditions
Makes sense because there are like 20 moons.
As salamu alaikum brother
Your answer makes sense but the thing is scientifically
if moon is sighted in Saudi Arabia then it is suppose to be visible in the UK (more accurately any country to the west of Saudi Arabia) even if you cannot see it because of weather
Excellent explanation brother.
great explanation, I agree with what you say
That was helpful and logical
The Reward of Giving
Food for Iftar
The Prophet (ﷺ ) said
He who gives food for a fasting person to break his fast, he will receive the same reward as him, and nothing will be reduced from the fasting persons reward.
(Tirmidhi: 807)
So make a habit this ramadan
Give something even one date
Also share with others
True but MBS in Saudi apparently has banned this
@@ZafarKhan-ip1umbanned food for iftar? what..
@@luzdani11 yes, he has ordered that people stop giving food including those in masjid. I've not verified this but several people have said this.
Issue is regionally mosques have different opinions 😢
Allah knows best..Which one is followed by most of the people we also followed that..Muslim committee what are told that's we followed..
@@thahithaibu4701 If people start settling on Moon .. . how will you decide Ramadaan ?
@@kumarakantirava429 In our area jamath Muslim community followed when will they saw moon in Tamilnadu that day night we start night pray
@@kumarakantirava429 this is a very interesting question, but it would be the same for what time zone they should use.. so conventionally they could simply follow Saudi Arabia
@@marilson84 Just for the argument sake, if all Saudi Arabians settle down on Moon, how will you decide ?? All I am willing to say is, this relig!on is something related to Saudi and not for entire mankind for eternity.
UK isnt always cloudy. If Birmingham is cloudy then Cornwall might be clear. We saw the Ramadan moon here in the UK. Even if it is always cloudy why do we have Solar panels throughout the year? Muslims should stick to the hadith and the sunnah. And Muslims in the UK should join the UK Muslim Moon sighting committee. And see how many Muslims are sighting the moon each month of the year throughout the UK.
All these are lame excuses since a committe of moon sighting in the UK has been established with actual pictures of the MOON. Scholars in the UK need to back the committee and unite the Muslims. Following Saudi isnt a valid excuse anymore!!
Couldn't have put it better myself.
Dear Sir
No relationship between solar panels to generate electricity or provide heating and moon sighting
New generation of more efficient solar panels generate electricity in winter when no sun but cloudy
Well well Leicester is
Thank you Sheikh for answering this. I am aligned with the Regional view
It seems everyone in the UK follows Saudi except much of the south Asian community
Same experience in the U.S. with the tablighi jamaat
@@snowstreams7503 The SA community here have started fasting and observed Eid on the wrong days on multiple occasions, the month is still Ramadan regardless if you can't see the moon
@droson8712 But this is one thing the South Asian community gets right! You can follow nearby European countries for moon sighting instead of following saudia.
If that's the sunnah then why change the rulings of it?
🇯🇴
Pakistani*
Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) as saying: Whenever you sight the new moon (of the month of Ramadan) observe fast. and when you sight it (the new moon of Shawwal) break it, and if the sky is cloudy for you, then observe fast for thirty days.
The question is really ‘did Saudi Arabia actually see the new moon?’ , according to crescent watch, the only geographical region in the world that could have seen the new moon on Sunday night was North America, and they did NOT see the new moon, so how did Saudi see a new moon? Or is the Saudi method still based on calculation?
But according to sheikh uthman he says that all of the scholars such as hanafi, Maliki, etc, say global, because it unites everyone as well
Tbh idek anymore, I just saw another video on TH-cam where he says local that was uploaded 2 years ago, there was a video I watched today on Instagram where he says the opposite which is why I made the initial comment
@@viper3d11man8a fatwa depends on Who is asking and when the question is asked
All of them may allow but that doesn't mean it's the preferred or sunnah opinion. Malikis definitely have a strong emphasis on a local moonsighting
Hear until the end bro/sis. Sheikh already mentioned it
Just follow Pakistan time. Arabs have deviated from Islam.
Scientifically speaking, all places in the world see the exact same moon phase. So if the crescent is sighted somewhere in the world, then the whole planet will sight the same crescent under similar visibility. as the earth rotates. This is where some scientists and scholars draw their conclusion regarding moon sightings and start of Ramadan. The moon does not change from 1 country to another.
but the visibility does
No not like that the time zone are different just take usa and india as a example it's almost one country night and other day so how will the country having day time see the moon
Bro this not how moon sighting works for Ramzan
Apart from the fact that because of the clouds we cannot see the moon, I do not know when the first day of Ramadan is if in the country where I am currently, the moon rises after an hour from Fajr. In this case I remain confused... I wish it was explained to me (says me) al this thing in detail. Jazak Allahu Khairun! I hope that I do disturb now on with this thing that for me is important to know about
You don't sight the moon at fajr. You sight the moon at maghrib. The new moon will be at the horizon and will actually be setting along with the sun.
The argument of 'Unity' of muslims in regards to moonsighting should be within their own country,not with saudi .
This issue of mass amounts of countries following Saudi moon sighting seems (with all due respect) laziness on the parts of these countries in not making attempts to sight the moon.
Sighting (or attempting to sight)the moon is a sunnah in itself
What about the different moon sighting state from state in an same country
Ramadan Mubarak!
What about following the closest Muslim country, which is Morroco?
Morocco itself follows Saudi Arabia
when did morroco become muslim ?
No it doesn't @@NAZEER_SA
It's a muslim country.@@user-ue4fh5mv9s
best is to follow moon sightings according to your own town. if you are unable to then follow the closest. now there are apps that do calculations... by seeing apps you can calculate and verify.
That may be a sound fatwa if Saudia genuinly followed moon sighting.
It’s always best to follow your own regional ruling, unless otherwise like the Sheikh explained.
Not really. There is only one moon. The month begins and ends with a moon sighting. If you miss the first fast you miss the night of power. Imagine a whole lifetime of missing the night of power. 😢
Think a little bit...people back in the time didn't have a way to know if theerevwas moon signing in another region so of course each region used to observe their own moon.....plus you need to be united among your own country first....the way you are doing it now will have part of the country fasting and another not which is just crazy...just follow what your country tells you...if you miss a day it will be on them not you @@niqbal
@@niqbalHow would you miss the night of power when it is the last 10 days of ramadan
Three questions:
1.If moon sighting was global, how in the time of Prophet Muhammad S.A.W.S. Muslims in Mecca, could know that Muslims in Sham spotted moon since the fastest way to travel was horse, which most likely could not react Mecca before those in Mecca saw moon. Its not like they had phones and telecommunication to just send message or such?
2.When do we start to look for moon, its very confusing, I know it is beggining of month of Ramadan, but when exactly?
3.How did Prophet Muhammad S.A.W.S. and Companions May Allah S.W.T. be pleased with them, woke up at Tahajjud or Fajr, they didn't had alarm or such?
as for the third question they wake up for fajr by timing their sleep right, so if they sleep 8 hours they sleep 8 hours before fajr, and if only one person wakes up he starts waking up his family and they start waking up the rest. or maybe some people stay up to pray qiyam el layl and they stay awake till fajr and they would wake others up.
Humans do have circadian rhythm which can act as a type of body clock. If you form a habit to wake up at a certain time you pretty much always will, even if sometimes you go to sleep later than usual.
There's nothing wrong with UK weather. Leave the lazy Muslims who stay in their houses waiting for Saudi to announce moon sighting. The so called self tagged salafee brothers don't even care on striving to look for the moon but rather take Saudi moon as the their authority. Even if they sight the moon close to them they won't fast expect they hear Saudi sight the moon.
I can say most of these guys started fasting on Monday which is 30 of Shaaban. It is crystal clear that the first day of Ramadan is Tuesday in almost 80% part of the world including UK and North America because I sighed the moon myself.
Most of them will end up fasting in Shaaban and also celebrate Eid in Ramadan due to their ignorance.
*12th March*
No, it is 11th
@@10ken1012th in The sub continent
I see people doing it living in UK, like the last year, everyone feasting 3id and they are the only ones fasting. Is ridicolous@@Spadegaming321
Thank you sheikh. This is always a problem in Indonesia, where there's almost always different opinions among a certain organization and the government who did moon sighting.
As Salaam Alaakum. Either you see the Moon or not, following the lunar Calendar on the 29th day. It should not be that hard.
Time of Rasul Ullah (saw) jews used to follow the calendar. But we Muslim we follow the moon.
Now today it's a great day
Today we have technology and knowledge to see or predict the moon phases and I have heard of an agreement that wherever on earth moon appears it counts. This unites the umma. For maybe 20 years ago often in same european country people started and ended on different days but it has been better the last decade.
Well noone does that. Because one time moon was sighted elsewhere and not in saudi and saudi didnt follow. So majority of world ofc didnt do eid also.
@@AbdulHaq11901 I think it was Afghanistan that moon sighted first. Nobody followed this. But when it comes to Saudi they follow.
@@omarali8382 exactly. Its more a case of people just following saudi even if moon is seen somewhere before
@@AbdulHaq11901 No people tend to follow form their roots but you didn't get the point that today we know when moon appears and where despite wheater.
Filipinos Muslim communities also devided. Some followed ksa while others aren't.
These people who are saying global sighting the time difference is so much it’s impossible to follow this method
Problem is Shaykh it goes one step further the division in the UK is that then should you follow the closest Muslim country or Saudi due to the lack of visibility of the moon sighting?
1 thing is true and a fact.
The u.k is always cloudy ⛅️
At this time of month..!
I wouldn't say always but most times it is
What about in Sri Lanka where, regardless of moon sighting, the local committee declares ramadan and eids because it was 'printed on the calendar'? There are other silly superstions about changing the calendar dates is bad for our president . If the local moon sighting commitee is politically motivated such as Sri Lanka, who do we follow? My family and I still follow the local dates even if we know there might be some misguidance by our commitee since we cannot see the moon ourselves. Please help.
You may ask him this in any of his life session.
C’mon guys it’s not that hard. Yes there is one moon and one sun. But they come out At different times in different places. How can you follow Saudii. Pakistan or any other place that has different time zone. And one day ahead. If they have isha there it is our morning of that day. If you follow their moon then read isha with them and not your fajr. Think about it. Does that sound logical? And it is in Hadith to follow the moon in your region.
We muslim had many and best astronomers in the past. They taught and made books about it. Hilal is a common astronomy event and can be predicted. Is it wrong to use akl'/knowledge when sight failed us?
No it's not wrong. But read between the lines. When the prediction parameters are wrong (such as the case of Saudi yesterday), you'll get wrong results.
As we say in programming, "garbage in, garbage out".
So best to validate predictions with actual sightings.
@@iwatchwithnoads7480 Why do you trust the moon visibility forecasts over the eye witness accounts of muslims.
Last year, my friends cousin was in Saudi and personally saw the new moon when it was supposedly impossible according to moon visibility maps.
Additionally if Saudi is faking the moon sighting, firstly why would they do that amd secondly why did Qatar, UAE, Iran, Syria, Iraq and Turkey too sight the moon on the same day?
We don't follow Saudi sunset for maghrib so why follow their moon.
Jazak-Allahu khairan shayke for answering this important question, there's so many timetables to choose from , and as a revert it can be difficult to assertain what is the correct one to follow, it's so much easier and simpler to follow Saudi alhamdulillah ❤
If you follow day of Arafat as per saudi for haj ,then what is the issue about Ramadan moon day ?
Same question 🙋
when saudi pray fajr do you pray fajr at the same time as them or break your fast when saudi is praying maghrib
Every month starts the same way, by the sighting of the moon. The whole Muslim world does not celebrate Eid Al Adha on the same day as Saudi!
No brother, Australia is doing Eid Ul Adha on Tuesday, whereas Saudis are doing on Sunday. But within Australia, people are divided, some are doing on Sunday and some on Tuesday. And Asian countries are doing their Eid on Monday.
What about all the timetables they print a year in advance?
If you are using science instead of your eyes, be consistent and don't pick and choose.
We need to be united. Certain people have hatred towards others for following Saudi, but remove the hatred and unite instead.
There is a specific hadith related to fasting that states the moon sighting must be visual. There are no such qualifications for the rest of the year with the exception of the month of hajj. So calculations can be used to calculate the other months or the times of Salah.
Give us Hadith or a ayat saying that it is fine to follow Saudi Arabia in seeing the moon
We follow local in Australia Aswl
12 months in a Muslim calendar. Not a single Muslim cares about moon sighting or even discusses it. Only time we become so religious and want to look into Quran, Sunnah, Fiq, Physics, Geography, geology, astronomy is when Ramadan or Eid start. We are seasonal Muslims. We can never be united.
Actually there are jobs for this, moon sighting, they become notable on the important months occasion yes
But they do evaluate every month
Calendars can be difficult to be updated with some schedules of certain jobs
@@DE123456123456Add to that that we now follow the solar calendar, which is not ours nor is it right to do so. But here we are… unfortunately.
For the other months there are no Islamic obligations attached to them. It's only Ramadan which is really affected and why there's a difference of opinions. The other month affected is the month of hajj but as the Saudis host the hajj they determine it and that ends the discussion.
Because we need to fast exactly when Ramadan month start and. Need to end it when 1 syawal start( it's haram to fast on 1 syawal). Therefore it's very important to be precise on this month.
Guys its fine whether fast started at 11 or 12 march.
What about laytul qudr night that will end up being the wrong night for the ones who started on the wrong day !
i think countries like uk can follow the nearby european countries
We ALL Should follow Morocco no doubt. As it is the closest muslim country. Saudi is farrr
@@fwplayz_0why only Muslim country. You can also follow nearby non Muslim countries where you can see the moon
@@mdrakibulhasan5489bcs we are muslims😂
@@fwplayz_0 I know that but can't we just follow the moon sighting from non-muslim countries? It's the same moon 🤦.
@@fwplayz_0the uk is more islamic then morocoo could ever be
What defines a region? Can I declare my house and it's neighborhood as a region and celebrate our own eid?
Sheikh.. please don't spread misinformation. Fear. Allah.
after each new moon, the phases thus begin!
We follow from Moon App which shows 0.2% Waxing 10 minutes after Magrib. Very accurate Ramadan began evening of 10th March.
How much accurate is it?
You stated a Hadith which confirms follow your region. If UK is difficult to sight the moon, you should follow the closest muslim country which is closest to your region, which would be Morocco, not Saudi Arabia.
Saudi Arabia themselves even say follow your own country/region because they have falsified moon sightings on many occasions and got it wrong.
Mufti Menk even says follow your own country, or the closest muslim country to you.
There is a community dedicated to sighting the moon in the UK known as the `New Crescent Society` whose sole purpose is to sight the moon with photographic evidence.
This answer needs reviewing in more detail
use calculation and we don't have this problem - we have made it hard for ourselves , obligation is to fast in ramadan , as long as its ramadan then there is no problem !!! Quran says when you attain the month of ramadan , then fast , attaining is achieved by the birth of the moon and validation of birth is by sight or calculation - why are these scholars making it difficult for the ummah ? Allah commands " TO FAST IN RAMADAN "
The saudis get it wrong most of the time and Saudis tell you don’t follow us follow local or regional sightings but there people here they will follow Saudis regardless
❤Advice نصيحة
The need for ruqyah Legitimacy ، has become legal
It is necessary due to the many problems that people suffer from
(health, social or financial)
God described the Qur’an as a cure, meaning a quick and effective treatment.
Perhaps you do not know the cause of your problems or the faltering of your interests. It may be caused by a mistake, sin, or accident that you do not know about.
The month of Ramadan is an opportunity to perform ruqyah according to Sharia law
It has a spiritual atmosphere and blessing
It helps in healing and solving problems.
Even if you read Surah Al-Fatihah and wipe your body , and read it on the Water and drink it , and repeat it every day.
God has benefited many people with ruqyah
There are many stories about those who tried it.
This can be confusing in New York today is April 9th does Eid fall on this day or on the 10th like in Saudi Arabia. Is it the same or no
But I fail to understand how here in Morocco we started fasting just today while algeria our neighbor started fasting yesterday the same as KSA.
these 2 countries are not even far aparts, and most website and tools that show the moon phases of countries had them similar phase (2.5% cresent yesterday) yet they are 1 day apart from each other.
Someone made a mistake (or deliberately) and I think its from the moroccan side especially knowing this country is being ruled by a zionist family.
I"ll trust Algeria and fast with them. I just have to break ramadan 1 day early and make up for yesterday which I didn't fast.
KSA started Monday, so did Syria, but Jordan which is kinda between them started on Tuesday. Trust your local sightings and make a good niyah
What you do not realise is, when Saudi makes an announcement, there are many countries that just follow Saudi. It does not mean those countries seen the moon. Algeria simply follows Saudi. On the other hand Morocco actually looks for the moon in its own country and only then decides to start a new month.
How can we follow Saudi Arab.we have follow prophet salaalawailawasalam..
Why can't we take astronomical new moon which around the world is at one time. In the ancient times moon sighting was the only option and caused many confusion
In UK we don't have one Ummah
We have a moon for London a moon for midland and a moon for North and if we can't see this then we follow Saudi
This means we have multiple eids.
Shame of these people. One day in one country. That's it
Just follow the Sunnah please .
Also we are at technological advances where we dont even need to follow anyone. But still
Ramadan Mubarak y'all
We follow our own moon, but some of us follows the saudi moon in our country.
How many moons do we have up there 😂?
I’m confused why we used telescopes , should the moon is more visible to the eyes?
Sorry for my grammar i hope you understand what i mean.
❤ Useful
what hadith and number please
I don't know what all the thanks is, he said the sunnah is to follow regionally, failing that you can follow the religious authority but let's be honest house if Saud follow political Zionism
How would someone close to the Arctic circle fast or even pray when the day is 6 months long ???
They should move from that god forsaken land
We in Wales follow Saudi Arabia because of this difficulty
Strange though, that even Saudi has everyone has a difficulty sighting the moon, only 1 or 2 Bedouins from the remote desserts claim to have see it when the sky is clear across the whole country. There is no way they saw the Ramadan moon in Saudi when it was just under 6 ours new moon.
What if it has been scientifically calculated, and I would think that it would be accurate if its been calculated.
An example is a app I have because I do like astronomy and also have a telescope and am on forums with people that do this as a living and hobby.
If these people who know the science and as far as I can tell are accurate. Would this not be a way to confirm a new moon?
The Prophet (saw) said fast when you sight the moon... The word used here means with the eyes. So calculations are not allowed and has to be a visual sighting.
In India Bihar there was same situation then ulema of deobandi, barelvi and ahlul hadith met and say they will announce moon after discussion with each other
I think the reason everyone follows the moon sighting is because saudi always confirms the moon sighting to initate the ramadan Long ago, no technologies existed to let neighbours know so some had to travel by horse or camel or carrier birds just to pass the message along, once the neighbours are notfied, they wait to see the moon and then they can initate the ramadan. With todays tech, Because we all can notify the whole world on a whim with tech I do ask myself the reason to continue this way. I think we all should follow the one route and not complicate things now tech has eliminated the difficulties of establishing communications.
Saudi fakes moonsighting. Their prediction parameters are off but they stick by it.
Morocco with BETTER conditions and more mature moon failed to sight the moon yesterday. That should tell you something about the Saudi claim
Saudi makes up moonsighting. Their prediction parameters are off but they stick by it.
Morocco with BETTER conditions and more mature moon failed to sight the moon. That should tell you something about the Saudi claim
Saudi prediction parameters are off but they stick by it.
Morocco with better conditions and more aged moon, didn't sight the moon. That should tell you something about the Saudi claim
@@iwatchwithnoads7480nobody cares about morocoo because that is not a muslim country or has anything to do with islam to begin with
@@iwatchwithnoads7480Was it off for Qatar, UAE, Syria, Iraq, Egypt and Turkey too because they also sighted the moon.
Why do you selectively target Saudi for?
If the sunnah is to sight the moon regionally then why is this guy saying to follow saudi?
Are you stupid? He explained both
If the knoledge ones get together and decide whats best for unity, then let it be follow obey because this is best for all. Dont disunite as this only creates disunity and more corupption within muslims. BECAUSE THAT IS NOT ISLAM TEACHING - Get to know islam before you know a muslim (every soul will be judged) - work towards good m ake your scales heavier w i th good not wrong
Where is the sunnah of our prophet on moonsighting???
James Webb and Hubble have entered the chat
Lol its funny though. Because the same people who follow Saudi bang on about authentic and weak hadiths, even calling people Kafr off the back of people following weak Hadith, but when there is a strong Hadith, they choose to ignore it. Hypocrites.
I disagree, even the Saudi scholars say, follow the country you're in. If you go by majority scholars, then most are from the sub continent and not from Saudis.
U disagree with whom ?
@@jamworthy14the opinion of not taking from your local region and instead taking from Saudi.
So what about countries east of Saudi or they don’t exist...please stick with sunnah and not politicians
Difficult to understand why Sheikh charges for counseling people. 🤔🤨I have never seen scholars do that.
May be he gives major part of amount to dawah works
Probably because it's his job? He can't earn a living? Is it haram to charge for counselling sessions?
@@littleoctober29 I have seen many scholars giving free counseling sessions to needy muslims.
@@cryptidv It definitely is his job. He rather must earn a living. It ain't haraam to charge for counseling sessions. It's just that the scholars I have seen do not charge at all for the counseling sessions.
@@importantinfovideos824 You may be right.
Saudi???
Where was Saudi during the Seerah times.
Saudi is a recent birth.
What does that have to do with anything??
@@cryptidvit’s just blind hate 😑
No comment about Saudi Arabia ,
But why Saudi Arabia?
We have a hubble telescope. Its quite easy to sight the moon 😪
But it was never based on calculations but actual sighting by the eye thats why when there are clouds you do not fast......
Charging people $$$ to help them go to jannah? What a hypocrite.
How much did this Clip cost you to watch?
@@SteveBundalston-nq1us he's posting this clip to make money from TH-cam. Yet another sign of hypocrisy. Claiming he wants to spread Islam but he really wants $$$$.
Why is it hypocrisy if he makes money from youtube?
His TH-cam channel is not monetized. @@KarimSadek-ch9uo
@@KarimSadek-ch9uoshut the fuck up. Everyone has their means of making money
Why open comments ... just close it
They didn’t have means to communicate at that time so obviously moon sighting remained regional. Nowadays if moon is sighted at any location on earth should be enough to begin the new month all over the world. Because political boundaries were made by colonial powers 100 years ago. Also, just like prayer times, lunar calendar can be calculated and published for the entire year in advance. Moon sighting has nothing to do with religious scholars they should stay away from it and leave this matter to the meteorologists. 50 years ago scholars told us that loudspeakers, photograph, and TV are haram and now they have their own channels.
As the Arab proverb says: Follow the Arabian Peninsula and you will not be disappointed 😉🇸🇦
nope. follow the sunnah
@@newbsidian The Sunnah of the Prophet from the land of Saudi Arabia, which happens to be the Arabian Peninsula ! Wow, what a coincidence
@@NAZEER_SA The Arabian peninsula then was far better than the Nicky minza inviting Saudi Arabia now. don't make equal
This guy is flooding TH-cam with each and every topic. Most of them are extreme wahabism. How to avoid these videos from TH-cam when searching
Hadith is not like what he is explaining...
Everyone tends to follow Saudi, it's mainly just mirpuri pakistanis the ones unfortunate to follow a mirpuri Pakistani mosque. They're the ones who decide to do it their own way. If they could, they'd do hajj on their own terms too.
Just do a bit of research and you will realise Saudi does not even sight the moon! They follow calculations and it is pretty much a fact. Anyone who learns even a little about the science behind moon sighting will be forced to come to this conclusion.
I follow my masjid, dont follow saudi
no one in Saudi force you. Keep cring
Got it you're a 🐑.
Morocco is the best country in regarding moon sightings
Sticking with soudi Arabia will keep our unity anyone asking us to change unfortunately will only divide the community further
not really. if you want to follow saudi, do your prayers at saudi's time.
The problem with a regional moon sighting or using calculations is that there is only one night of power. You miss the first fast and you will miss the night of power.
You won't miss laylatul Qodr if you wake up all ten and not rely only on odd numbers due to the probability of miscalculation
@@Alquroouonline that's true but how many Muslims wake up only on the odd nights and how many stay awake only on the 27th?
This is a surely plain ignorance from our muslim brothers
You're right 👍. May Almighty Alloh make us among those who understands
What about when a country time is day time and the other is night time and it sees moon and the country having day time cannot see the time
@@Study-tm4iv in that case they missed the first fast of Ramadan and make it up afterwards.
it's always dark and gloomy in London because of the vampires that live there
😭😭
3 out of 4 madhab go for global sighting, and this guy is lying
I'm from uk
❤
Wahabis being funny as always 😂
Do you even know what Abdul Wahab taught?
If following pure Tawheed, with no saint or grave worship or glorification, makes me a wahabi then 100% I'm a proud wahabi.
If getting rid of deviances and heretical innovations in the religion makes me a Wahabi, I'm a Wahabi.
If returning to the Sunnah of the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, and the ways of him and his companions, may Allah be pleased with them all, make me a wahabi, then I'm a proud Wahabi.
@@cryptidvthis is a deviant person. He needs attention and has no value in his personal time, so he makes dumb comments
Mohammad thought world was falt that's why he made such ridiculous rule
Fix your grammar first
Oh Asma
How innocent you are
Elaborate? And look, if you left islam, please get lost and do whatever from your nafs made you leave islam. You're clearly seething by wasting your time here.
May Allah guide you.
I don't know this person/shaykh and it is sad that he gives an opinion with no daleel according to the sunnah. Why only a weak answer for the UK? Why not calculate 30 days as the hadith state? There would be more unity that way and in accordance to sunnah and not the excuse of difference sects. Very saddening to hear such poor reasoning. I hope this guy isn't a mufti! Allah guide and protect this Deen from weak people.
The brother is not a mujtahid but a muqalid. He's conveying the opinion of the mujtahid he follows.
@@littleoctober29 brother it's Ramadan. Show the proper Islamic etiquettes. There's no need for this.
@@littleoctober29 this is a matter of ikhtilaf (difference of opinion). We are all muqalid (learners) here. All he is asking for is evidence and his desire is for more unity amongst Muslims.
"You guys"? "Fed by others?" Says the person who is being fed by this person. It's not about being fed but being told an answer that the intellect finds weak and contradictive. This person talks about the clouds and not being able to sight the moon. What about when Ramadan fell in Summer and the moon was easily sighted. People still followed Saudi out of ignorance. He also mentioned "so many sects, groups and opinions?" There are only TWO opinions. Sight the moon regionally or follow Saudi. It's not complicated. The words he spoke were not entirely true and can only divide the ummah and not unite. And yes, if regionally you are unable to see the moon on the 29th then implement the sunnah. If you can sight the moon then great. All avenues should have been exhausted in order to unite the ummah because you have a group following Saudi and a group following the ways of the Sahaba. Sadly, this happens every year and our aim should be to unite. May Allah unite the Ummah and protect the Sunnah way. @@littleoctober29
In the UK people seem to mainly follow Saudi or Morocco (and a small minority Pakistan/India), not too sure why they follow Morocco instead of just following the sighting in the UK..something about Morocco being a "muslim country" , although recent trips to Marrakesh and Agadir would suggest otherwise😂😂
Everyone should follow Pakistan. That is where the only true muslims live. The people of Saudi have fallen to the west unfortunately.
What true Muslims do you mean ? Don’t just say what you don’t know . If you want to know true Muslim , then go to Syria , Palestine, Yemen . Prophet (s) prayed for Syria . How blessed is Syria . And don’t get me wrong . I am from Bangladesh. And don’t say what you don’t know . Allah knows the heart of a Muslim and mu’min.
@@brightmakerchannelofficial2134 the best and truest muslims are from Pakistan, India, Bangladesh and Srilanka. The rest of the muslim world have fallen
being someone with a pakistani background, we’re getting there too and pakistanis definitely aren’t the greatest muslims around
@@amazingamx1255 stupid . They are most ignorant in terms of religious knowledge. Just look around yourself , you will understand: I don’t want to criticize. I am just telling the truth . Don’t be deluded.We shouldn’t fight during Ramadan
What a Joke!!! You mean the place of Shirk? Praying on graves and shrines? Where the people don't even know what they are reciting! Even the Mullahs don't even know what they are reciting. A Mob of 100+ men with mullahs inciting them were about to kill a woman to death because her clothes had arabic writing. They thought it was some holy verse from quran 😂😂😂. When it just said Halwa.
NO MUSLIM SHOULD FELLOW SAUDI GOVERNMENT AND THERE WAY
UK muslim either follow Saudi or Morocco obly tecrnt they been going out way to find in uk