I switched from Hanafi to Sunnah, people say this is wrong & I must follow a sect or madhab assim
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ก.พ. 2025
- #assim
Instagram: / assimalhakeem
Follow the assimalhakeem channel on WhatsApp: whatsapp.com/c...
Website: www.assimalhake...
Ask a Question: www.assimalhak...
Facebook: / sheikhassimalhakeemteam
Twitter: / assimalhakeem
If you are not a student of knowledge (layman), it is is best to follow a madhab. What the sister is stating is not from Hanafi madhab but is cultural bidah that is common in desi communities. These things have become common and is wrongly attributef to the madhab, but when you study it properly it has nothing to do with it.
Agreed
Correct, brother or sister.
Can we dont follow a madhab en follow what autentic hadeeth is
Why not follow a scholar who follow sunnah like Sheikh uthaymeen or ibn baaz etc which is far better than following hanafi madhab filled with deviations and deviated scholars
Problem is hanbali destroyed most sect. Circular thinking to push us toward the same reasoning. All sect today descend from hanbali.
The title confused me!
Madhab is not a sect, its a FIQH SCHOOL! They each have a way to teach(priority of curriculum), Isnad & ways to discuss cases but they all teach depending on Quran & Sunnah
So Sunnah is an umbrella that have schools under it.
A sect is those whom refuse Sunnah saying Quran is enough, refuse it on political opinion or make their own innovation they claim is a way of worship, or those rejecting commandments to please the enemies of Islam.
Absolutely correct
That's the problem, Madhab is also a sect, people blindly follow madhabs and never try to actually look and learn that what they are practicing, is it part of Sunnah or not.
This is the problem with Muslims, what Madhab was Abu bakr, or Umar or Usman or Ali were following? Quran clearly tells that we should not be divided into sects, but noo why would we follow quran.
Become a Muslim, call your self a muslim, whoever tells the authentic thing, take it. Whoever tells something which is not part of Sunnah, then leave it. But for a person to determine whether something is authentic or not, he should pray to Allah to make it easy for him/her to accept the truth, and increase in knowledge, and be sincere to learning the truth whether it goes against your original beliefs.
@@ASADALI-vd4jj That's the problem only with Wahabis who want to call themselves as Muslims only and not follow any madhab and that's the reason why they call madhabs as sects like the title of this video. Wahabis think they can understand Quran and hadiths by reading the without knowing the context and often fail to comprehend the true meaning. That is why jurisprudence is necessary. The word fiqh is an Arabic term meaning "deep understanding or full comprehension"
Sahabas knew the context and were able to understand hadiths and Quran therefore they didn't had to follow any madhab. Later when new problems arised after the Sahabas it became necessary to be interpreted in the light of Quran and hadiths. For example if a woman is 9 months pregnant and dies then what to do, bury her or cut her stomach and take out the child alive. Now is there any such hadith or Quran aayat that mentions this exact situation? If you bury her you kill the child.
Understanding of Fiqh is therefore necessary to derive laws from Quran and hadiths.
@@ASADALI-vd4jj If they just do as you did, Looking at origins of which Madhabs were created, they would come to learn Madhab purpose is to soundly propagate the teachings of Islam as is!
Hence its actually healthy for many Madhab to exist.
Like many schools under one ministry.
Saying stuff like "Madhab is also a sect" is not correct~ rather they TRY to force it to be a sect (its own ministry)!!!!! by Work of Mudkhalis
The idea is you find trust worthy "just" people with good manners whom received "knowledge" from the Companions to CHAIN NARRATE from. once there are many students they discuss matters & actually CHAIN & record stuff to the following Generation but in a documented matter.
Notice the Hadith words are the same in those Madhab but they differ in Isnad & rulings over non-core creed stuff.
(There is room for ease)
Once the current generation Differ in core creed/ add their own from Greek philosophy/Hindu etc.. they are nothing but wolves in school clothes whom took over the school name to be a SECT that deviated from Islam. (Current Sufism as example rather than Madhab Sufi)
You can actually win argument against Sufism by their earliest Imams writings.
Ibn Taymiyya tried but they did not want to fix their "ways"
Masaa Allah. Nice explanation.
That last part is key. The layperson needs to understand that they are safe following the ppl who have the knowledge. If the Imam is wrong, it's the Imams problem on the day of judgment for giving you the wrong information.
But ppl aren't worried about being safe on that day. They are worried about fitting in with some ppl they know or getting a ruling on a matter that allows them to do something the way they want to do it.
nice, bruvva sulaiman
Unbelievable. Everything he said is completely wrong and satanic, yet look at how Muslims in the comments unknowingly praise this man for his falsehoods!
This guy, Assimal, is telling us to worship the imams and scholars besides Allah SWT!!! If you are a "layman" in Islam, simply open the complete Holy Quran and read it, it will tell you what's wrong and what's right! It has all the answers you need to know! You do not need to follow any imams, schools, sects, or the satanic hadiths!!!
Only follow the Quran!!! I am saying this as a warning to you! Do not take the imams as your lords besides Allah, like how the Jews would unknowingly take their rabbis as lords besides Allah!
You really think that people who blindly follow an Imam/scholar will be safe from any consequences if they were wrong!!!
Beware!
No Imam/scholar or anyone will be taking the entire blame for any of their followers. Every sane adult will be accountable for his/her actions/deeds and asked about how much they struggled/strived in the search for Truth and implementing it.
@hammadshah1096
You introduced the word "blindly". If my point ever had anything to do with "blindly following," then you would be able to quote me using the word "blindly" in what I initially typed.
@@BruvahSulaiman I am sorry to have misunderstood if you didn't mean it like that.
Brother. I mean to emphasize on the fact that even a Layman needs to put in effort to READ, reason and understand using his/her mind and heart. Not to just follow the Imams without reasoning.
These rituals 14 days ,40 days after death are considered bidah in hanafi too
Followed by majority Ahnaaf
This things followed by barelvis not all hanafis
@@AliRaza-rh7jm if followed then it doesn't mean that it's in Teaching of Hanafi
And that's mainly followed in barelvis
Yes but not majority it's followed by minority
These things are not part of Hanfi Madhab....these things are from non Muslim of Indian Subcontinent.....and most of the Indian Muslim which follows Hanfi Madhab are converted from non Muslim to muslim but their old culture is still in there but our Ulema try to solve these problems and alhamdulillah they are doing their work
Perfect explanation from the sheikh! allahumma barik
@@jean-pierresteenberg before speaking about anyone and anything, you should be sure that your information is 100% right and you are benefiting someone by sharing it. None of it applies in your case. You information is wrong and nobody ever benefited from a fault accusation. How would you react if someone would say the same about your close female members? Aisha, may ALLAH, swa, be pleased with her is closer to us than your mother.
Unbelievable. Everything he said is completely wrong and satanic, yet look at how Muslims in the comments unknowingly praise this man for his falsehoods!
This guy, Assimal, is telling us to worship the imams and scholars besides Allah SWT!!! If you are a "layman" in Islam, simply open the complete Holy Quran and read it, it will tell you what's wrong and what's right! It has all the answers you need to know! You do not need to follow any imams, schools, sects, or the satanic hadiths!!!
Only follow the Quran!!! I am saying this as a warning to you! Do not take the imams as your lords besides Allah, like how the Jews would unknowingly take their rabbis as lords besides Allah!
@@jean-pierresteenbergMay Allah punish you for your fitnah
What sister mentioned has nothing to do with Hanafi Madhab.
Those are bidah people added themselves.
By barelvis
@@Kaif_qureshi_778 right 👍
What's wrong is to think that imam Abu Hanifa and his students didn't know the Sunnah.
💯
but sunnah is greater than any imam and their madhab
@@1eV it's ignorant statements like yours that makes me fear for the Ummah.
May ALLAH SWT grant us knowledge of the religion and knowledge of the Sunnah.
Ameen.
My statement is unquestionable. If you have problem with it, then you are in grave danger.@@junaidijaz2067
@@junaidijaz2067how is the sunnah not more greater than a imam
Imam goes to the Quran and sunnah
The 6 pillars of iman one of them is the belief of the prophets in the sunnah is what we learn from prophet Mohammed صلى الله وسلم
And also is the basis of them rulings it’s so important not as much as the Quran but right below it so how is it not greater?
I love that explanation!
I always here this extreme words (I say words bcs I don't even want to call it an opinion): "No no I don't know about Imam ..., I'm going to learn it myself" bla bla... and not even knows arabic and reads the version translated to his language by someone he doesn't know 😂 Doesn't trust any imam but has 100 % trust in a translator 🤣
But the explanation in this video is great, the first part about Allah just asking about following the Prophet but then the additionial point that we as laymen cannot differentiate properly between right and wrong is such a great view to this topic. Jazakallah Khairan!
Unbelievable. Everything he said is completely wrong and satanic, yet look at how Muslims in the comments unknowingly praise this man for his falsehoods!
This guy, Assimal, is telling us to worship the imams and scholars besides Allah SWT!!! If you are a "layman" in Islam, simply open the complete Holy Quran and read it, it will tell you what's wrong and what's right! It has all the answers you need to know! You do not need to follow any imams, schools, sects, or the satanic hadiths!!!
Only follow the Quran!!! I am saying this as a warning to you! Do not take the imams as your lords besides Allah, like how the Jews would unknowingly take their rabbis as lords besides Allah!
As long as as a Muslim practising Islam according to the teachings of Qur'aan and sunnah Prophet sws, ignore all those sects and rejects those scholars who identify themselves from particular sect and ask ti follow his teachings.
There is so much misunderstanding especially in local areas. Most of Hanafi scholars know the true hanafi fiqh but don't teach people on the ground. The innovations that are ascribed to Hanafi madhab can't be found in Hanafi madhab. I am a general student and try my best to follow Quran and Sunnah while ascribing to a madhab. But when I don't do actions that are innovations i get attacked. Onece my mother told me that people everywhere talking about me just because i don't do the congregational prayer after obligatory salah which I mostly blame the hanafi scholars for if you ask on the internet tgey will say it's not part of salah if you don't do there's no problem but they don't teach it on the ground to laymen. Just because of this i have been labelled as 'Thief' in my village. There are much innovation after the death of a person, in the memory of a righteous person, qatm e younus, Quran qatm feeding, milad and others which actually you can't find in the hanafi madhab and the scholars emphasize on these innovatory acts instead of Salah, Quran recitation, authentic zikr, reading tafseer, teaching tafseer doing dawa etc
and also to add when you are following one imam for example Imam abu hanifa that doesn't necessarily mean that other 3 imams and their followers are wrong path
There is nothing wrong for lay people, especially non Arab speakers to follow any one of the four schools of thought. If I heard the lady correctly, the things she mentioned are not teachings or practices of the Hanafi Mathab. These are innovations that are practiced on the sub continent. Imam Abu Hanifa said that if you find any of my fatwas to go against Quran and Hadith, then fling it on the wall.
Entire hanfi madhab is against sunnah.
@@AbdulMalik-dm5tvthat's the wahabis
@@AbdulMalik-dm5tv your comment shows how little you know.
@@mr.khorsani8740hahahah talking like jahil
@@AbdulMalik-dm5tv you dumb?
In Hannafi, there is no such things that the sister mentions. For example, 40 days after death or Qur'an khaani.
However, there are some groups who claim to follow the Hannafi madhab and do such things. You have such groups that claim to follow Imaam Maalik as well.
Follow Hannafi Madhab as you re living in Pakistan and it will be easier for you. You have Muftis like Tariq Jameel, Tariq Massood to follow the proper Hannafi madhab. Thanks
I must say, this was the most level headed response by this Shaykh that I've ever heard. It was on point. The whole premise of the sister was wrong to begin with by attributing those bid'ah to the Hanafi madhab. Very ignorant on her end and I wish the Shaykh did correct her and educate her on that aspect. Following 1 of the 4 madhabs for us laymen is crucial.
lol might as well make it fard
I wouldn't say negative things like that about her as she grew up not knowing any better. The sub continent has definitely added things to hanafis teachings and unfortunately a lot of South Asians do these innovations unless they seek knowledge. Please try to think better of people InshāAllāh and pray for their guidance
Shaykh kills me quoting a line from Hall & Oates 😂
True spoken sheikh. Imam knows best because he is an expert on Islam.
As a revert this is the best advice, follow a single Imam. Study and grow.
Stop imam worship,just read the quran and follow the establisbed sunnah is society i.e how to pray,fast,zakaat....imams forbid women many thing and always use hadith to curse them
@@Naadirah_abdool They follow their culture more than Islam.
yeah, agreed, don't listen to people who hate imams and Islamic scholars, most of them are arrogant and have shallow knowledge about their religion.
That's best to follow a scholar.
@@Naadirah_abdoolWth. Which four of the imams forbid women from doing certain things and that thing is permissible by Allah SWT and when they used the hadhits to curse them? Stop lying
Madhab means sect is the greatest lie told by Salafi people. May Allah have mercy on the Greatest Imams who have gathered the knowledge for the Ummah.
"What do you know? You don't have the knowledge to discredit an Imam." Subhan Allah. I follow school of Imam Malik and I have read all the 6 book of hadiths. 99% of Ahlul-hadith who come to argue with me haven't even read 10% of the hadiths and they claim that they know more than Imam Malik or Imam Hanifa.
If you claim to be Ahlul-Hadith, you should AT LEAST read all the hadith and then we can discuss if you have the wisdom of a sage or the wisdom of david woods which you use to determine the context of the hadith.
Just an fyi those are better read with a school or scholar because we as laypeople do not have the ability to interpret the Hadith into fatwas or takeaways
@@sabrsabrsavr Egg sackedly
Jazak Allah!
I’m a revert, almost 10 years ago. I’m struggling to gain correct knowledge. Al Hamdulli ALLAH, today I stand in a better position from my start point, however so much questions not answered yet. If anyone can advise me good books to read, I would appreciate it. It’s hard for me to attend any school due to my family situation.
What type of questions,sister? If you can be more specific about your queries, it’ll be better
@@FarhaanKaais thank you for your reply. I would like to know, daily things the best way to do. ( for example, I know that you leave your house saying a specific Dua); I would like to know different types of prayers (I just heard that Eid prayer is different); how to seek ALLAH, swa, help for different types of situations. Thank you in advance.
ia601408.us.archive.org/10/items/dailydua/dailydua_text.pdf
This one is for duas of daily tasks
Online Islamic university google it you can learn everything about Islam virtually
Unbelievable. Everything he said is completely wrong and satanic, yet look at how Muslims in the comments unknowingly praise this man for his falsehoods!
This guy, Assimal, is telling us to worship the imams and scholars besides Allah SWT!!! If you are a "layman" in Islam, simply open the complete Holy Quran and read it, it will tell you what's wrong and what's right! It has all the answers you need to know! You do not need to follow any imams, schools, sects, or the satanic hadiths!!!
Only follow the Quran!!! I am saying this as a warning to you! Do not take the imams as your lords besides Allah, like how the Jews would unknowingly take their rabbis as lords besides Allah!
Great answer ❤❤❤❤❤...
That's why people, especially Muslims need to read the Quran. Quran came to all humanity, not only for scholars and Muslims
for me its simple i follow what the og Arabs of Mecca Madina follows and they clearly follows Salafi madhab cuz prophet was from there not from Iran, India or pakistan which changed the Aqida to their own preferences while Islam was spreading. Altho i grew up in tablique circle but I changed myself as i gained maturity over right and wrong. Jhazak'Allah min khair.
People of Mecca Medina (saudia) follows Imam Ahmed bin Hambal. That's means they are Hambali.
Salafiyyah isn't even a madhhab. Salafis are mostly non-denominational or non adherent to the madhahib (la madhhabiyyah) since they are reformists and reject them. That's the real bid'ah, to reject what has been traditionally legitimate and practiced and believed.
وَإِذَا قِيلَ لَهُمْ لَا تُفْسِدُوا۟ فِى ٱلْأَرْضِ قَالُوٓا۟ إِنَّمَا نَحْنُ مُصْلِحُونَ
أَلَآ إِنَّهُمْ هُمُ ٱلْمُفْسِدُونَ وَلَـٰكِن لَّا يَشْعُرُونَ
«And when it is said to them, "Do not cause corruption on the earth," they say, "We are but reformers." Unquestionably, it is they who are the corrupters, but they perceive [it] not». (2:11).
@XD_SPIDER
Sry but your Statement doesn't fit to the requirements.
Salafi madhab is build on the school of Imam Ahmed ibn Hanbal, who came from Iraq. Imam Malik was from Medina. And you find most of the Malikis in Africa. Therefore the Prophet made dua for Al Sham which includes countries of Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, and Palestine, as well as the regions of Hatay, Gaziantep, and Diyarbakir in modern Turkey.
but if we are laymen than how are we supposed to know who is the imam that we should follow in the first place? Whats the picking criteria since all 4 are of sound mind and don't have weird beliefs?
please add subtitle to this beautiful channel
Following any of the 4 schools of taught is correct. If you claim it to be wrong then YOU are in the wrong. How could you know more than those who learned directly from the Sahabas.
Very good question.
The sister didn't know these are cultural bidaah's and have nothing to do with Hanafi madhab. Follow any 1 of the 4 imams and you are safe.😊
There is no such thing as cultural bid'a. As for following, then the safest way is to follow the prophet saws and the soghaaba. That's the safest.Even the 4 Imaams has advised their followers like Imam Aghmad Ibn Hambal who said,Don't take from Abu Ghaneefa, Maaliek,Shafee'e or Aw Zaaie but rather take where they took from, from the first generation of this ummah. Like the prophet saws have said,after predicting about the ummah that will be in 73 sects which only 1 will be upon the truth. When He saws,was asked who they were,He replied, "It is those who will follow what I and my companions are upon today."
@@faroukanthony4761 Bro listen to what the Sheikh has said you completely missed the answer then.
@Happy_Potato0
My reply is aimed at your response regarding following 1 of the 4 imams and you are safe.I heard what the imam have said,no problem.
@@faroukanthony4761 you must be stupid and dont have the intellect to understand. You can't read hadees and blindly follow. We really live in the end of times.
@faroukanthony4761 I know what you mean but I commented according to the Sheikhs answer bro.
I don't know how people can not follow the biggest scholars in Islam, people that used every bit of energy and their whole life to study Islam and Fikh... There are 4 madhab Hanafi, Safi, Maliki and Hanbeli. Allah Celle celaluhu tells us in the Quran in Sura Nahl 43 to ask scholars and to get information from them. How can we try to give meaning to Ayah and Hadis with our own minds? Who are we compared to the biggest scholars in Islam? Our beloved prophet Muhammad Mustafa SallAllahu aleyhi ve sellem says: The scholars are the heirs of the prophets, that means they inherit the knowledge that the prophets taught. When the beloved companions had a question they went straight to Resulullah aleyhisselam. There's no doubt that we should follow madhab. Otherwise shaytan and your nefs might trick you so be aware of that. Be careful of any "sheikh" nowadays that tries to tell you not to follow one of the 4 big madhabs. Think about it, how dare these "sheikhs" try to mock the biggest scholars in Islam? May Allah guide us and forgive us.
how sheikh kept low his gaze truly how a man should do ❤
What if imam's madhab rule against authentic hadith (like not doing Raful-Yadain, which we should do), still we gonna follow blindly? you can be a part of any madhab, but when it comes to authentic hadith we should follow our Prophet (SAW) . In sub continent people do a lot biddah in the name of madhab. and always ignore Quran and hadith.
Those fatwas going against the hadees has been already corrected by later hanafi scholars there are no remaining .
@@CricketEditz12-ev3ed most hanafis i know prefer abu hanifas view although they know its weak. Asr time for example
@@egorex7735jahil asr time was something even sahaba differed so it's not weak proving you're the ignorant idiot here
@@egorex7735the idiot comments again even the sahaba differed on asr view hence it is a difference of opinion where prophet saw remained silent to give this message to the ummah something you clearly never learnt
As for rafa yadain many authentic narration prove prayers without rafa yadain including the four Khalifa rashideen especially ali ra who proffered to lead Sarah without rafa yadain when he was the calipha in kufa
Prophet muhammad never said that he's shia or sunni or he follows hanafi safi and all.
Are you as knowledgeable or a prophet of islam? No, you're not.
اللهم صلى وسلم وبارك على سيدنا محمد وعلى آله وصحبه آجمعين
Follow any one of the four Imams and you are safe!
This is confusing. Picking one imam to follow all of his opinion IS making a sect. What if one learns of two differing opinions? This is the crux, THE CORE, of the question when it comes to following a madzhab or not.
Actually she is not know about Hanafi Fiqh, because what he said quran khani ya bla bla, and sheikh even don't know because he didn't refuse and didn't correct the girl.
It should be retitled as switching from hanafi to Hanbali. Although am a Maliki who was previously hanafi but the hanafi madhab is the most misunderstood one
Only follow Quran and Sunnah.
READ.
For doubts in any matters, research the teachings of scholars/imams or ask people of knowledge but with references from Quran and Hadith. And then follow what you understand/believe at the end.
Do NOT follow a single Imam or Scholar just thinking that they are right in everything.
ALLAH says in the Quran that HE has made it easy to understand, yet some ulemas/scholars try to put the layman card out.
Use the teachings scholars/imams etc, only as tools to better understand the Quran and Hadith. So at the end, use your own thinking to reason and understand.
Do NOT be a sheep following the herd blindly.
READ yourselves. We need to READ.
always research for yourself on hadith and Quran
Jews and Christians made the exact mistake of putting their Ulema above books
you're not able to do ijtehad. if that were the case everyone would be a mijhtahid faqeeh
@@1eV It is not to be taken in that sense. The idea is to READ ourselves and where needed, reason and discuss. But follow only what we understand with our heart and mind and are ready to face the consequences for it. Because the excuse of "I was only following Imam so and so and the scholars said so...." will not work for someone who was a sane adult and could have strived to research/reason. Ask the sheikh about this point 😉
I will try to keep it very brief even though there are so many points that I would like to share to clarify this.
Did the Imams/scholars get a degree or certificate which makes them undisputed champinions of the Deen knowledge?
So, what is the difference between people who blindly follow their elders/scholars and fall astray from the right path and those who use their own mind/hearts to dig deeper for the truth? Just like the people in comments above mentioned the Christians and Jews who don't bother to study their own books properly and folloe their preachers.
Simple question.
Could the Imams have misunderstood or make mistake in some areas?
Were they 100% perfect?
Did they get a certificate from ALLAH or the messenger (PBUH) stating that we have to follow whatever they say without any objections/reasoning?
Yes, they most likely undertood a lot of it better and have more knowledge. However, thst does not mean that they could not be wrong in things. 😊
Are you statisfied with your logic to be presented infront of the angels in grave when asked about Deen and on the day of Judgement infront of ALLAH?
That you entrusted the thinking to the Imams/scholars, trusted and followed only their teachings without bothering to reason, ponder upon the Deen yourself ?
Even though ALLAH says in the Quran to think/ponder upon HIS verses.
Religion is to each there own.
Each one will pay for their own actions/deeds. If you want to depend solely on the Imams/scholars, then feel free.
They will not be able to take the blame for you if needed (on Judgment day).
I am happy to use research and follow what my mind and heart gets directly from the source (with help from scholars where needed) In sha ALLAH. In this way I can tell ALLAH that I didn't follow anyone blindly and strived to follow HAQ.
May ALLAH guide us and bless all such that HE is always happy with us. Aameen.
So how would you judge if a hadith js saheeh or not?? And what if a layman does not know arabic? 😂😂
4 ijtihad - meant to explain not to cause dispute .. sincere muslims should not allow these ijtihads to be a reason for divisions as long as aqeedah is correct
Any Uply May Any Uply Any Love Any Of Allaahu Any Uply Be Upon Allaahu,Any Uply Be Upon Any Prophet Any Uply Any Nonstop Any Uply Any No Any Matter Together.
There is a difference in time of Asir prayer time as calculated by Hanafi method and that calculated by others - Imam Hambal, Imam Shafai. The difference is almost 1 hour.
So if I am offering my prayers at home, then which time should I follow
I see, that's why my friend who lives in BD pray Asr "so late" according to me. His environment follows other school of thought. I understand now, thanks brother.
Since I'm just layman here, I would suggest like Sheikh Assim said, follow whichever you think is right and keep learning so if there's deviation, you know when to "get out of the ship". At the day of judgment, the Imams are responsible for their mistakes.
@@v-alfred Right brö
It is permissible to pray asr early in the hanafi madhab but it is afzal (better) to delay it by little time. And the one of the factor of the timing of the salah is the convenience of people. And in some countries people are more convenient to pray asr late like BD.
Follow whatever your mosque does
Hanafi is not a sect but a madhab (school of thought within the Islamic jurisprudence. Imam Abu Hanifa is a taba’een, so he followed the sunnah. Many Muslims of the sub continent following cultural acts, nothing to do with the Hanafi Madhab.
DUTY TO DEFEND THE CREED (the pristine teachings of Islam)
When some people mentioned to Imaam Ahmad Ibn Hanbal (Rahimahullaah) that they felt uneasy about criticizing people (who had deviated in their beliefs) He replied 'If I were to remain silent, How then would the masses know truth from falsehood' (Reported by Imaam Ibn Taymeeyah in Majmoo'ah ar-Rasaail Wa al-Masaail, Vol 4: Page 10- Arabic).
According to the unanimous agreement of the Muslim scholars, those who introduce deviant writings and religious rites; contrary to the Qur’an and Sunnah MUST be exposed and the Muslim nation made aware.
When Imaam Ahmad Ibn Hanbal (Rahimahullaah) was asked if one who fasted, prayed and secluded himself in the Masjid was dearer to him than one who spoke out against people involved in deviations, he replied ‘When one fasts, prays and secludes oneself, he does so for himself alone, But if he speaks out against deviations, he does so for the Muslims in general which is more noble’.
Another fun fact, all these quotes that are from Ahmed ibn Hanbal are said during time of fitna where the amir at that time introduced a strange opinion (Astaghfirullah) that Quran is the creation of Allah and not the speech of Allah. Many scholars had died fighting such fitna.
What’s interesting is that though this might seem like a small thing, however People like Ahmed Ibn Hanbal defended the authenticity of Islam with their life. Subhanallah.
@@lifematch May Allah be pleased with him and all the scholars who fought against Muatazilites.
@@lifematchif allah didnt create the quran then who did?
@@DrLifeGamer what’s the difference between speech and creation? The Quran is the direct word of Allah.
@@lifematch as far as I understand, the implication is that a creation can have faults/imperfections like you and I. Allah is perfect, so the speech of Allah is perfect and cannot have faults, hence the Quran cannot have faults. But if they were to say the Quran is a creation then people would say it could have imperfections Astaghfirullah.
What if i follow Sheikh aasim al Hakeem??
Me too
He’s not a Faqih, and he doesn’t claim to be either. The 4 Aimma were all qualified Ulema and that’s why they’ve been accepted for centuries. Many people criticise Imam Abu Hanifa RA without even being close to an actual Student of knowledge.
Can someone tell me the names of individual that sheikh was telling about ? I want to know about them.
So can I follow a sect and reject what is considered a bidah.
sister should better turn to ahlul hadith ulema of her country on this issue. no one could respond to the question better than them as they have spent decades with Hanafis and are very well acquainted with the fiqh of ahnaaf
People saying following the sunnah is wrong is _wild_ bro lmao. That tells you all you need to know, they can wallow in their ignorance, no need to stoop to their level
Sunnah is only from the 4 Imams of Salaf i.e. Hanafi, Maliki, Shafie and Hanbali which is called as Ahlul Sunnah Wal Jamaah.
Absolutely not. There were many more Imams and Madhabs which don't exist today. Sunnah is not bound to be found in only those 4 madhabs.
Imam Abu Hanifa ❤❤❤
@@1eVthose madhab didn't survive example thawri madhab was said to be 2 3rd the same as hanafi meaning it was almost the same hence most of his students became hanafi later on
Sheikh isn't there An ayat in the Quran which says who ever makes A Sect O prophet He is not One you
She stepped away from scholars of Salaf and followed him 😅
So she switched from Ahle bidah to Ahle Sunnah.
Some people want to pick and choose. They like the shafi ruling about seafood, they like the Hanbali ruling about salaah, etc, etc
Our duty is to follow "Deen" ,not a Mazhab. The Mazhab is a persian word meaning thereby to polish a cheaper metal with high cost metal like brass with gold polish. In religion Mazhab is only collection of rituals which is branded as Fiqah that is school of thought like we the Muslims have four school of thought ( Maliki, Hanfi ,Shafie, and Humbli) for Sunnis and one school of thought ( Jaifery or Imami) for Shias.
Sunnis are at liberty to follow any of the school of thought but Shias are bound to follow only one School of thought, which they suppose from Imam who is branded to be appointed by Allah .
However Tawheed ideology is repeated at 2698 times in Alquran , therefore , a so-called Muslim if he created share holders in the authority of Allah or in the prophecy of Prophet Pbuh ,he cease to be Muslim and he will be called a Mushrik in the court of Almighty Allah like in case of prophet Pbuh.
Why is it so difficult for Muslims to understand that one can follow any imam till he is in accordance with the Qur'an and hadith.. And ignore when what the imam says is not accordance with the Qur'an and hadith.. These days you can check within mins.. Blindly following any imam is plain dangerous.. Very dangerous
Blindly following?! Do you have any doubt on the Great Imams of the Ummah? You can trust Bin Baz and Uthaymeen but not Imam Azam Abu Hanifah, Imam Malik, Imam Shafi and Imam Ahmad?!
Who are you even to check who is right and who is wrong? What kind of qualification does a Layman posses to Think that this man is Legit?
As if a patient asking Doctor if he is a real Doctor. Only the Scholars underdtand the Whole picture not a layman and they never will unless they dive into the ocean of knowledge.
@@MrXlee1967 tell that to mullahs
Unbelievable. Everything he said is completely wrong and satanic, yet look at how Muslims in the comments unknowingly praise this man for his falsehoods!
This guy, Assimal, is telling us to worship the imams and scholars besides Allah SWT!!! If you are a "layman" in Islam, simply open the complete Holy Quran and read it, it will tell you what's wrong and what's right! It has all the answers you need to know! You do not need to follow any imams, schools, sects, or the satanic hadiths!!!
Only follow the Quran!!! I am saying this as a warning to you! Do not take the imams as your lords besides Allah, like how the Jews would unknowingly take their rabbis as lords besides Allah!
@@MrXlee1967 The religion is complete with the Quran. Sunni and Shia Islam are cancer. We must have Orthodox Islam.
How do you check if something is in accordance with Quran and Sunnah? What do you do when two ahadith seem to contradict each other? This is why the madhahib exists! To have a set methodology to favour one opinion over another. Please have some respect for the 'ulama. A simple Google search on the qa sites doesn't have the same integrity as the methodology of the madhahib. Do you have a mastery of old arabic to know what the ahadith meant? Islamic knowledge is multiple advanced sciences
There are a lot of evidences from Quran and from sunnah that people should follow one of the greatest mujtahid imams. For this there are lots of reasons. This is called Taqleed, so people who are not a mujtaheed, should do taqleed, even muftis, sheikhs etc because they ARE NOT MUJTAHEEDS.
I recommend everybody who doesn't do taqleed, read books about "Why taqleed is so important"
These days all the hadith a are available..so why do you have to follow a IMAM... YOU CAN ASK ANY IMAM LIKE YOU IF YOU HAVE ANY DOUBTS..IF YOU GO TO ANY HANAFI MASJID AT FAJR SALAH WHEN THE JAMA IS STARTED ANY BODY COMES TO THE MASJID START TO PRAY SUNNA..TGUS IS TOTALLY WRONG WHEN THE HADITH SAYS YOU HAVE TO JOIN THE FARD WITH IMAM...WHY?..
The question was not answered
I am confused where I live we follow imam alshafai but I never identify as a follower of imam non of the 4 is infallible I see what is the majority opinion and go with that. That is if there is something that is not explicitly explained by a hadith like most things.
How do I choose between the four schools?
Asalamu aleykum.
If you read the Qur'an every month, watch videos of islam by bin baz and ibn uthaymeen, it's fine.
Forget which school of thought to follow. Once you gain knowledge, you will understand why I said it. I can tell you now, but it's unnecessary too much information. Just please trust in your muslim brother.
Lastly, if you want to gain knowledge, sign up for the online muslim course by Dr.Bilal Philips
Follow the fiqh which is prevalent in your local community. Follow you local authentic Scholars.
Just read and follow the Quran.
@@YorkerEli the Qu'ran clearly states "if you don't know then ask the people of dhikr"
Laymen can't derive rulings.
Bro if you will leave either one of the 4 madhabs you will fall into the lap of shaytaan. Dont act like we are more knowledgeable than imam shafii maliki hanafi or hanbali. The one that does not have a guide will be guided by shaytaan.
Not true. A layman has no knowledge so he should simply follow a learned trustworthy scholar who will normally be following a madhhab.
He basically didn’t want to understand the Sunnah through the Salaf scholars!
It's not a sect it's a fiqh school and if u r talking like that now it's not weather u r following a madhab or quran and sinnah cause the 4 imams just told there understanding of quran and sunnah now we need to see weather our understanding of quran and sunnah is better or there's and we already know the answer to that
There are no sects we are all Muslims Ahle Sunnah Wal Jamaat
the problem is that if we follow someone then we are subjective of their mistake. there is a surat in the quran that says return to the quran if the scholars are saying different things and this must apply to the hadith also as most madhab have different hadith they claimed are authentic.
scholars have said that if you follow one imam and he ends up being wrong, it is his sin and not yours
no the surah says to the scholars to return to the quran and sunnah if they differ on something, the scholars not us. what is said to us is to take it to the people of knowledge when we're in doubt.
@@jaskocalakovic387 no neither you or the imam are sinful, because it is ijtihad, if he intentionally misguides you then yes he is sinful for it
@@jaskocalakovic387 two replies that may be wrong. The first is in thinking the differences in opinion about the quran and hadith are black and white. The apparent meaning of the ayah is to refer back to Allah and His messenger for the evidence of this opinion or that. You can have two opinions that have strong support in the Qur'an and hadith so there is no clash. If an imam gives an opinion that is not supported or is contradicted by the Qur'an and sunnah then it is likely a bida'h, so stay away from it.
The second error is saying that if the imam/scholar makes a mistake then the sin is on him. We know from the scholars that they are rewarded double and if they get something wrong they are still given a single reward, not a sin. This is because they are making a decision to the very best of their islamic knowledge, out of piety. It is only a sin if they intend to misguide the people or ignore the quran and sunnah to make their own desires the priority. There may be exceptions to this but this is the general understanding and Allah knows best.
At the end of the day we are all worshippers, in the comment section, and we do not have the knowledge to start declaring this and that, so follow a trust imam and in sha Allah your worship will be accepted
@@jaskocalakovic387If the scholar doing ijtihad does a mistake, he still gets rewarded for his work same to his followers, but if they are correct then they get rewarded even more.
Correction Sheikh : Ajam in these days are 1billion times better than arabs especially Scholars. I advise you arab scholars to start studying under them so you catch up.
PS. I have seen few examples of these Arab people showing pride that you non-arabic speaking people "don't know". It shows their Jahiliya that has not left them thinking just because they are Arabs they are more pious or scholarly. I hope they are able to see this Jahiliya and correct it (it's already late for them but there is always hope) inshaAllah and appreciate and respect non-arab people since without doubt non-arab people is where real deen IS and HAS BEEN for over 1000 years.
Just follow any 4 imam all are eqully correct
Assalamualikum shaikh. This is my response to one of your video titled "Why there are so many contradictions between hanafi madhab and authentic hadith".Comment section of this video currently turned off. In this video , you stated that(@3:40secs) that, imam abu hanifas school is based on logic.But this is totally wrong. In this video you referred to one of the book of imam ibn taimiah.This same Imam menaing ibn Taimiah written in his book "Majmu Al Fatawa" volume 20 that,whoever thinks that abu hanifa and any other imams (of that time) deliberately contradicts authentic hadith due to qias or any other reason then he is mistaken and he is talking with his conjecture and own desire. He also said, Imam abu hanifa was the one who gave fatwa on doing wudhu by nabeez and laughing in salah which was against the human logic. So accusig hanafi school and imam abu hanifa by saying that their thought is based on logic and against sahih hadith then it is totally a wrong argument. As a result ,in that video two great imams in this ummah Imam abu hanifa and shaikhul islam imam ibn taimiah was misrepresneted . I hope you will bring corrections in those videos. Jazakallahu Khairan.
did Shaykh say they contradicted sahih hadith "deliberately"? Why are you putting words into Shaykh's mouth?
@@1eV plz read the comment carefully and then reply. I mentioned the quotation of what the shaikh said and also mentioned what the imam Ibn Taimiah said in this book and then refered the accused video. Please don't mix up the things.
I read comments that I reply to very carefully so no thanks for the unwarrented suggestion. And yes, you did put words into shaykh's mouth which is equal to false accusation. If you can please address that. Shaykh never said "deliberately". Maybe the hadith didn't reach him or other else prevented him from reaching the sahih hadith. How can we know?@@md.tasnimbinharoonrupak419
@@1eV Why you are running after the the word deliberately or the respective line. This quote was said by the imam Ibn Taimiah in his book. I went against when the shaikh said " the Hanafi school is based on logic".Or in other words,the fatwa the imama Abu hanifa gave or by the other imams in this school is based on logic. Then I came up with what imam Taimiah said and how rejected these type of allegation on imam Abu hanifa...by saying the line "whoever thinks that Abu hanifa and other imams deliberately contradicts authentic Hadith due to Qias or any other reason...."And later he(imam) also proved that imam Abu hanifa never gave fatwa using human logic. It shows that saying Abu hanifa school based on logic is a wrong allegation. This is the focal point.
Lastly I also suggest you don't mix one quote with other one's. In my comment two person's quote was mentioned.One is shaikh and one was the imam Ibn taimaiah. If you willingly or unwillingly mix with another it will create nothing but misunderstanding.
@@md.tasnimbinharoonrupak419 so you accept thay Shaykh Assim never said that Imam Abu Hanifa contradicted sahih hadith deliberately?
And about the "based on logic" part, it is a well known fact that Hanafi madhab gave more importance to Qiyas than other madhabs. Hence, thay are also known as "Ahlur Rai"
I challenge anyone in the world no one can pray without copying one of 4 madhabs. you definitely need one of 4 Sunnah Madhab. imam Hanafi learns everything from the Sahabas. like these fake imams make all the people go to Quran read and pray. there is not much information in Quran about the praying, an example in Quran there is no word saying "Allahuakbar". All madhab imams learnt and practised from sahaba and tabiins. please be careful this kind of very bad imams at the and you might lose your iman.
Can I just follow IslamQA?
Yes
we all do tbh
Yes
Imam Ahmad Imam of Ahlussunnah
Nice answer...but these Quran khwani and other types of bidah is not a part of hanafi madhab...these are part of Barelwi sect in subcontinent
What do you mean changed from Hanmafi to Sunnah? Really stupid question. Follow Bin Baz as he said, and just realise what his views were and be ready for a shock 😅
That's right no one want wahabism.
You have a disease in your heart for being so rough and lewd. You make me want to believe you're deviant. Otherwise why the behavior?
@@milenkapitanov8464what is wahabism?
@@maharlikanaonkudarat7928 An evil ideology funded by the enemies of Islam, which is inside Islam with the purpose to destroy it.
Bin Baz used to believe in flat earth. He gave fatwa that Yazid was just ruler and Imam Hussain was wrong.
Hanafis also believe that Prophet Muhammad PBUH still have ability to intercede in his grave and request Allah to fulfill the supplications. They also believe that Prophet Muhammad PBUH is hazir nazir.
Another idiot makes his entry
Sharh at-Tahaawiyyah by Ibn Abil-'Izz, from the Hanafi school of jurisprudence, reads, “Abu Haneefah and his two companions said, 'It is disliked for a person who supplicates to say, 'I ask You, O Allaah with the virtue of so and so, or with the virtue of Your Prophets and Messengers, or with the virtue of the Sacred House or Al-Mash'ar al-Haraam,' and so forth,' to an extent that Abu Haneefah and Muhammad (ibn al-Hasan) disliked for a man to say, 'O Allaah, I ask You with Ma'aqid al-'Izz min 'Arshik (i.e. the joints of power and glory in Your Throne).'”
Also, Radd al-Muhtaar reads, “Abu Haneefah said, 'No one should supplicate Allaah except with Allaah or with the approved (confirmed) supplications that are permissible and which are derived from the saying of Allaah (which means): {And to Allaah belong the best names, so invoke Him by them.} [Quran 7:180]'”
Dr Zakir Has much better answer than this
The image of the video is extremely bad adab towards imam Abu Hanifa رحمه الله. Please change it.
👏 👏 👏
It sounds like shes confusing madhabs and sects.
Why not follow imam hanafi. He says dont follow a school but follow these imams. Is this imam a wahabi. Would explain a lot
Yes, he is a Wahabi.
The sister is a jahila. The things she mentions are not from the hanafi madhab. Nowhere is there 40 days after death in the hanafi school.
This is barelwism and cultural so dont say as if its hanafi school.
TRULY THE RELIGION WITH ALLAH IS ISLAM. I. E. "INNAT DEENA INDALLAHIL ISLAM" Al-QURAN 3:19 .
Well in all honesty alot comes from cultural agendas and also all this 14 days and 40 days it is a bidah thats a fact , alot originated from the india/ Pakistan side which is from the deobandi side of things . There are many different cultural ways also but mostly alot from the asia side ! Islam is simple dont complicate it as follow the sunnah and Quran and the salaf but dont twist the salaf bit as salaf mean’s predecessors ie , sahaba , tabiieen and tayabien !
such an irritating when kids play and make noise when Sheikh is speaking
ALLAH N HIS PROPHET MOHAMMAD (PBUH) ORDERED US TO FOLLOW OR PURSUE DEEN E ISLAM. NOT ANY OTHER SUFI OR FUQI MAZHAB (RELIGION).
If all is equally right, does this means you are free to flip flop madhabs?
Are you saying abu hanifah was not following the sunnah. ?
In almost his every video he deliver the same message
He was following sunnah more than this sheikh. And some of his fatwas going against the hadith and is already corrected by hanafi scholars.
same to me
The man seems I'll informed, Presently these are not problems of Muslims in the world,
Pse guide him anyone hear pse discuss big issues of Muslims,
Can he say something about non - islamic moves taken by their Saudi wahabi regime presently.
I think he can not, because they are their product.
He is a Malaysian or Indonesian not a Saudi
No i don’t agree with you, how can you say ‘you have to follow an imam’? I dont need to follow any imam, i can consult but i have to knowledgeable myself and i am only obligated to follow Allah and His prophet (PBUH). All the people who say you have to follow an imam, they just want money to keep rolling in their schools. I discourage that completely! Well done sister, I’d say. Moreover these 4 imams, didn’t even pray behind eachother, so what are you talking about??? These are the ambassadors of the prophet? No!
That's exactly what the Sheikh said. If you are knowledgeable, can cross reference and have knowledge of Arabic, you don't have to follow an Imam, but if you are a layman like me, then you need to seek advice from a person who has integrity etc.
Brother if you are qualified to understand the Qur'an and Hadith you are most welcome to directly follow Qur'an and Hadith, but you are layman don't even know Arabic and Qur'an, so follow the person who has knowledge
Can anybody tell the names sheikh mentioned at 4:16
@Sam1Saikat Assalamualaikum. Can you please tell me how to follow them?? I mean Is there any books or something ???
@@_StrivingSoul_there are apps in arabic
@@_StrivingSoul_their lectured are translated on youtube
@@_StrivingSoul_go to your local muslim area or mosque and follow any of the 4 madhab's imam to learn islam. Hanafis are more than 60% of whole Ummah and there are Shafi, Maliki and Hanbali schools of thought also.
wrong. They are just people. They are layman. They just follow their local sheikh. You can't call them hanafis, shafi etc@@brace_yourself
Hanafi madhab is a legitimate understanding of the Quran and Sunnah, what every individual does who calls them selves Hanafi is not attributed to the madhab.
Each madhab already follows what they believe is the strongest opinion of the Quran and Sunnah based on a consistent methodology of understanding.
The salafi understanding in practice is just another madhab derived in recent times, so the argument “follow only Quran and Sunnah” is a shallow argument and catch phrase.
All madhabs already follow Quran and Sunnah, 1400+ years of scholarship and 10000s of scholars agree
Every sectarian thinks their madhab is perfect
@@AliRaza-rh7jm only Allah swt is samad, doesn’t mean that a madhab is not a legitimate understanding of the Quran and Sunnah, a madhab is not a sect.
@@alir1902 what's the difference between madhab and sect?
Good question, a sect holds different beliefs when there are clear cut verses on which there is consensus and no room for anyone to have a second opinion, such as the Ahmadiyyas who believe in a prophet after the prophet Mohammed saw., even though the Quran clearly says he saw. is the seal (last) of all prophets.
The madhabs do not differ on the foundations and clear cut verses, rather they come about because there is a difference of opinion in interpreting/understanding ambiguous verses/hadith and usually to do with minor details of the religion.@@AliRaza-rh7jm
@@AliRaza-rh7jm these are not sects because our lord is one our prophet is one. We dont BELIEVE different things the slight difference between the madhabs lies in the Fiqh. And these are slight differences
So this means the imams are responsible for our guidance as laypeople ,what about Allah is he not the one that is supposed to guide us these sheikhs sometimes cause confusion just because they claim to know arabic why in the quran Allah says even prophet muhammad us not responsible for our guidance that is the responsibilty of Allah then he comes and claims that we should follow an imam is imam Ahmad God or just a servant like you and me no offense its that these teachings don't make sense if you compare with what is said in the quran
I said sura bukhari verse no.1😤😂
The sad thing is that nowadays scholars will cuss each other on the public platforms when they have the means to contact the scholars who have a different position than them
Scholars should be mature and have the patience to listen to other views
The ummah is divided greatly today, look at Gaza, the genocide
But we are so far apart even with the broad daylight killings
Our ulama still can't unite
May Allah guide us
So abu hanifa and hanafis are not ahlu sunnah?
There is a difference between Hanafis and "Hanafis"
No need to follow anyone if you are a Mujtahid.if you not ,then follow a Mujtahid. Imaam abu hanifa,shafee,maliki,hambali these are 4 giant realible Mujahideen. Follow the mazhab of a Mujtahid, will lead you toward quraan and sunnah.
Sheikh bin baz, uthaymeen, assim al hakim these sheikh are only scholar of deen but not Mujtahid.
Madhab is not a sect it's fiqh school
Youre a Malayan Muslim from a Lost Sultanate of Deli. Your current Kingdom of Nejd bring back the Jahiliyyah the Idol the Majusi back to the Hijaz, what say you?
for me its a wrong answer.