Absolument magnifique. Un grand poète du piano comme l'époque actuelle n'en fait plus. Des myriades de pianistes à la technique époustouflante. Mais... sans âme.😔
I came here to listen to the Schumann, found your comment, Googled the book title and listened to the audio version of First Person Singular. Thank you for introducing me to these short stories!
You have no clue what "underrated" means lol... FYI, Carnaval is certainly NOT underrated. Pretty much everyone who has heard it rates it highly, and it's one of the works Schumann is most known for. Educate yourself, my man.
This is his best performance of Carnaval ever. And the best of all time. The way those hands just dance over the keys, the way those hands just caress the keys, the way those fingers roll over the keys like pearls rolling over velvet. And how many textures of sound there were. The colours. And the whole body of the man moulds the music. Rubinstein is the best and this is the best Rubinstein.
Ironically, that is a problem in playing and interpreting Schumann's Carnaval, imho. Rubinstein's characteristic elegance and poetry does not work well in this piece and the dynamic contrasts necessary to fully realize Schumann's split personality inherent in this piece are missing.
It is more subdued and lyrical because his life’s experience is reflected through the impulse of his harp string of his heart which is reflected in the Touch of his Fingers. I am a 67 year old African American male pianist who has been playing the piano since I was 8 years old. I was also told my the people who guided me through life that my life experience with be reflected through the touch of my fingers by which the Audience will polarized in the Spiritual Kingdom if they are Spiritually Atune to my psychic vibrations.
Rubinstein's performances of this work have always been a cut above the others. He understands the young Schumann's changing moods and poetic architecture perfectly. I wonder what Richter would have made of this had he palyed it?
Excelente interpretación de un gran pianista como lo fue él. La mejor versión grabada de esta obra es del pianista Andrei Gavrilov en un CD Emi classics. Esta opinión es del prestigioso sello Deutsche Gramophon, la comparto plenamente! Escucharla es algo de otro mundo!
¡Felicitaciones! Por compartir este excelente vídeo de uno de los más grandes pianistas del mundo. Otro gran pianista que merece igual atención, lo fue el insigne pianista de Vladimir Horowitz. ¡Saludos desde México! GRACIAS!!!
Hearing any performance by Artur Rubinstein, I do not pay attention to his technique; I am overwhelmed by the sheer musicality (I once read that the top ten Russians [for example] in a given competition can meet any technical standard, but they are unable to play at a Rubenstein-level. This recital is an example of artistry at its absolute highest echelon)
Fluffed notes? I heard maybe one or two, but playing this incredibly difficult piece, at 79, while making it incredibly musical and engaging, is quite a feat.
I saw Rubinstein play the Schumann concerto in London in the mid-1970s. He had lost a lot of vision from macular degeneration, and he missed many notes. I saw his finger come down next to the key rather than on it. The loss to the musicality of the performance was zero.
Really though? For a live performance this is pretty tight - by any standards. Yes he himself underplayed his technique and goes on about it in his autobiography, but its a rock solid technique. Clean passage work, incredibly nuanced, always a gorgeous tone. I’m conservatory trained so I’m quite picky.
Let me get this straight: You’re damning the entirety of Western classical music for everyone in the world who adore it because you have no aptitude for it and don’t understand it, and that it is _YOUR_ lack of understanding of and aptitude and ear for music which makes the genre “boring”?? Is that not weirdly amusing and frankly appalling?? Because you have-shall we say-the “confidence” to damn an entire genre of art simply because of _you personally_ don’t get it. You might want to keep this information to yourself in future, if you get my drift.
@@voraciousreader3341 I am a great composer of classical music myself and your assertions of are the pathetic trite cliche variety. Did it ever occur to your myopic mind that perhaps my opinion was based on vastly superior knowledge and experience than yours? Beethoven often goes through long winded boring sections of great tediousness in order to accentuate his explosive finales. In todays action packed digitial world there is so much more to pack into our listenning and viewing, that the old standards have been blown out of the water. What I'm looking for today is a Biography of Buxtehude. I'm been listening to his organ pieces and they are extrodinary. Go and listen to the Conclusion of 150, fantastic jumping section effect.
Absolument magnifique. Un grand poète du piano comme l'époque actuelle n'en fait plus. Des myriades de pianistes à la technique époustouflante. Mais... sans âme.😔
Came from Murakami's First Person Singular
Me too
Igual yo 😅
Ja też
I я так сама.
I came here to listen to the Schumann, found your comment, Googled the book title and listened to the audio version of First Person Singular. Thank you for introducing me to these short stories!
0:31 - Préambule
2:43 - Pierrot
3:47 - Arlequin
4:27 - Valse Noble
5:53 - Eusebius
7:25 - Florestan
8:27- Coquette
9:29 - Replique
10:17 - Papillons
10:57 - A.S.C.H S.C.H.A (Lettres Dansantes)
11:43 - Chiarina
13:05 - Chopin
14:26 - Estrella
15:04 - Reconnaissance
16:45 - Pantalon et Colombine
17:41 - Valse Allemande
18:29 - Paganini
19:32 - Aveu
20:38 - Promenade
22:22 - Pause
22:39 - Marche des Davidsbundler contres les Philistins
Thank you ...
@@ozgedur2718 @Ozge Dur no problem man, I like Carnaval a lot. I m learning Chiarina in these days, it s my favourite
Thank you
Thanks
감사합니다!
Came here from first person singular. Man this is an underrated masterpice
Me too
It's not underrated. It's considered to be one of Schumann's greatest piano works.
You have no clue what "underrated" means lol...
FYI, Carnaval is certainly NOT underrated. Pretty much everyone who has heard it rates it highly, and it's one of the works Schumann is most known for. Educate yourself, my man.
This is his best performance of Carnaval ever. And the best of all time. The way those hands just dance over the keys, the way those hands just caress the keys, the way those fingers roll over the keys like pearls rolling over velvet. And how many textures of sound there were. The colours. And the whole body of the man moulds the music. Rubinstein is the best and this is the best Rubinstein.
Murakami nunca decepciona
Também cheguei aqui por causa do Murakami
He never makes an ugly sound. Such a beautiful quality in it. It completely seduces me. Lovely!
Ironically, that is a problem in playing and interpreting Schumann's Carnaval, imho. Rubinstein's characteristic elegance and poetry does not work well in this piece and the dynamic contrasts necessary to fully realize Schumann's split personality inherent in this piece are missing.
@@dlphcoracl9645Nonsense.
More subdued and lyrical than the usual performance. Beautiful as only Rubinstein could do.
It is more subdued and lyrical because his life’s experience is reflected through the impulse of his harp string of his heart which is reflected in the Touch of his Fingers. I am a 67 year old African American male pianist who has been playing the piano since I was 8 years old. I was also told my the people who guided me through life that my life experience with be reflected through the touch of my fingers by which the Audience will polarized in the Spiritual Kingdom if they are Spiritually Atune to my psychic vibrations.
И Мураками спасибо🙏❤️
Thank you so much, Schumman is my favourite composer
Il suono di Rubinstein è unico
incredible song
Абсолютная фантастика. Просто человек с другой планеты. 100 % попадание в образ этого произведения. Лучшего исполнения Шумана я и не слышал ❤
Rubinstein's performances of this work have always been a cut above the others. He understands the young Schumann's changing moods and poetic architecture perfectly. I wonder what Richter would have made of this had he palyed it?
Sorry, I don't know.
So mesmerizing. Wonderful. Hoomeyow!!
Excelente interpretación de un gran pianista como lo fue él. La mejor versión grabada de esta obra es del pianista Andrei Gavrilov en un CD Emi classics. Esta opinión es del prestigioso sello Deutsche Gramophon, la comparto plenamente! Escucharla es algo de otro mundo!
ルービンシュタインだけなんか他のピアニストと違う楽器弾いてんのか、ってくらい異次元に演奏する姿がエレガントで美しい。
¡Felicitaciones! Por compartir este excelente vídeo de uno de los más grandes pianistas del mundo. Otro gran pianista que merece igual atención, lo fue el insigne pianista de Vladimir Horowitz. ¡Saludos desde México! GRACIAS!!!
Conocemos a Horowits des niñas 🇲🇽🫶🏻
México. ( Yucatán. ). 🇲🇽 🎶🖐️Esta parte me enloquece. ,,,,,🎶🎶🎶🎶
Crees que nadie lo. conoce?
Horowitiz. No fue accesible ..piensa bien lo.que escribes.
Tengo mucho de Horowitiz.
Maravilloso a todo color...muchas gracias!!!
😁
Murakami me trajo.❤
Какой звук!!!❤❤❤ Фантастика!!!
Absolutely electrofiying. What a performance!!!
Extraordinatia interpretación y actuación.
¡Bravo!
Bellissimo video. Grazie.
Thank you for uploading👍
😁
What a versatile pianist Rubinstein is ！
Да! Лучшее исполнение цикла !
Браво !!!!
Прекрасное исполнение, нет спору. Но точно лучше, чем у Софроницкого и Микеланджели?
Who came after Haruki Murakami
eu haha
Hearing any performance by Artur Rubinstein, I do not pay attention to his technique; I am overwhelmed by the sheer musicality
(I once read that the top ten Russians [for example] in a given competition can meet any technical standard, but they are unable to play at a Rubenstein-level. This recital is an example of artistry at its absolute highest echelon)
It is all about the love.As simple as that.
Back in my day Steinway had no sons!
Extraordinaire !
Mexico 🇲🇽 🫶🏻 ❣️ 🎶🎶🫶🍀
Così suona un grande pianista.
Here because of the last book of murakami
Polska Łódź ❤🎶🎶🥰
This is when i was 6. Thanks TH-cam.
Rather fast for a march of the Davidsbündler?
Un dio.
А в каком зале он играл ? Очень красивый звук
Варшава. Национальная филармония, реконструированная после войны.
@@constantinemelmoth7678 Благодарю!
Composer went nuts and killed himself.
Браво!
Most pianists don't feel their fingers... They have a health condition I guess..
19:00 swan dive!!!
The colours are awful. He didn't look anything like that.
카니발은 언제나 나에게는 난해하다 듣고 있으면 정병올거 같다 ㅜ
Always poetic but, as he himself would admit, so many fluffed notes. Our ears are too refined because of recorded music.
A little fluff matters little amidst so much magic.
Fluffed notes? I heard maybe one or two, but playing this incredibly difficult piece, at 79, while making it incredibly musical and engaging, is quite a feat.
I saw Rubinstein play the Schumann concerto in London in the mid-1970s. He had lost a lot of vision from macular degeneration, and he missed many notes. I saw his finger come down next to the key rather than on it. The loss to the musicality of the performance was zero.
Really though? For a live performance this is pretty tight - by any standards. Yes he himself underplayed his technique and goes on about it in his autobiography, but its a rock solid technique. Clean passage work, incredibly nuanced, always a gorgeous tone. I’m conservatory trained so I’m quite picky.
Too many boring sections. Most classical music has too much boring meandering.
Let me get this straight: You’re damning the entirety of Western classical music for everyone in the world who adore it because you have no aptitude for it and don’t understand it, and that it is _YOUR_ lack of understanding of and aptitude and ear for music which makes the genre “boring”?? Is that not weirdly amusing and frankly appalling?? Because you have-shall we say-the “confidence” to damn an entire genre of art simply because of _you personally_ don’t get it. You might want to keep this information to yourself in future, if you get my drift.
@@voraciousreader3341 I am a great composer of classical music myself and your assertions of are the pathetic trite cliche variety. Did it ever occur to your myopic mind that perhaps my opinion was based on vastly superior knowledge and experience than yours? Beethoven often goes through long winded boring sections of great tediousness in order to accentuate his explosive finales. In todays action packed digitial world there is so much more to pack into our listenning and viewing, that the old standards have been blown out of the water. What I'm looking for today is a Biography of Buxtehude. I'm been listening to his organ pieces and they are extrodinary. Go and listen to the Conclusion of 150, fantastic jumping section effect.
Какой звук!!!❤❤❤ Фантастика!!!