I noticed many covers where they say "why is THIS bedroom so cold" yet in the original it goes "why is THE bedroom so cold" Seems like a minor change, but whenever I hear "this", it sounds so accusatory, like he is asking her directly, as if it is her fault... Whereas, in the original, the question sounds much more rhetorical and reflective.
D L I guess Ian Curtis has chosen the words with caution, lyrics are poems somehow, changing a word makes a big difference. Maybe I biased, cause I'm French, and here we are using so many different words to say the same things, but I really think words, even small ones, matters, and even more when it's Art. After, it's only my point of view.
i'm actually so freaking happy with this cover, they were able to honor the original while still getting their own unique feel across. Couldn't say the same thing for Allday's cover of Never Tear Us Apart...
I love this Joy Division song and I have heard many, mostly terrible covers....this was GREAT! I actually felt emotional listening to this version, the same way I feel when listening to Joy a Division. I think the reason most covers fail is that the singers are trying to hard to sound like Ian from Joy Division, this singer uses his own voice.
I First heard this song on WLIR in '81. I have heard many covers over the years, you all managed to pay homage to the Joy Division and make it your own . you nailed it. Bravo, and well done.
Thanks the J's ... Im old enough to have loved the original version..... But ... The holy's version is ...well ....superior.... ! Love it....just like Love will leave, and tear you apart..! But just learn to appreciate it when it is with you...!
When the routine bites hard And ambitions are low And the resentment rides high But emotions wont grow And were changing our ways, Taking different roads Then love, love will tear us apart again Why is the bedroom so cold Turned away on your side? Is my timing that flawed, Our respect run so dry? Yet theres still this appeal That weve kept through our lives Love, love will tear us apart again Do you cry out in your sleep All my failings expose? Get a taste in my mouth As desperation takes hold Is it something so good Just cant function no more? When love, love will tear us apart again
Great job, it's a very difficult song to cover- I heard the original shortly after it's commercial release, and have heard many covers over the years, most of them crap For me, this is a haunting, deeply evocative song. Every time I hear it, it brings me back to that period in my life, and a lover who died Sadly, love did tear us apart..Thank you for a beautiful homage- to the this song, and the Joy Division.
This is a song that is impossible to cover and these guys did an admiral job, but I think the sound, vibe, and the sort of emotion in Curtis' voice in the original can't be replicated.
The effects used on Curtis' vocals give this weird "disconnected but still involved" feel that completely connects with the lyrics. There's a crap-tonne of baggage that goes with the song.
As every great cover should do... it just highlights what an unbelievably important, beautiful, transcendent song the original is. It'll never quite capture the sadness but thats ok, i don't think any reasonable human should be able to do what Ian Curtis did. Great job
When routine bites hard and ambitions are low And resentment rides high but emotions won't grow And we're changing our ways, taking different roads Love, love will tear us apart again Love, love will tear us apart again Why is the bedroom so cold turned away on your side? Is my timing that flawed, our respect run so dry? Yet there's still this appeal that we've kept through our lives Love, love will tear us apart again Love, love will tear us apart again Do you cry out in your sleep, all my failings exposed? Get a taste in my mouth as desperation takes hold Is it something so good just can't function no more? But love, love will tear us apart again Love, love will tear us apart again Love, love will tear us apart again Love, love will tear us apart again
Whenever “Love will tear us apart” ends, I always think of “Then He Kissed Me” by The Crystals. I believe it’s a subtle nod to the song inserted by Joy Division. Give the last 20 seconds a listen and then compare...
I noticed many covers where they say
"why is THIS bedroom so cold"
yet in the original it goes "why is THE bedroom so cold"
Seems like a minor change, but whenever I hear "this", it sounds so accusatory, like he is asking her directly, as if it is her fault...
Whereas, in the original, the question sounds much more rhetorical and reflective.
Walter5850 it really doesn’t matter. The song is somewhat accusatory in the first place, so I find the minor change to fit well.
I agree
D L I guess Ian Curtis has chosen the words with caution, lyrics are poems somehow, changing a word makes a big difference.
Maybe I biased, cause I'm French, and here we are using so many different words to say the same things, but I really think words, even small ones, matters, and even more when it's Art.
After, it's only my point of view.
Oh and Walter5850 : your profile pix and the small animal on it, are just adorable xD what kind of cuttie is "it"?
The Oysterband with June Tabor do the best cover f this song.
i'm actually so freaking happy with this cover, they were able to honor the original while still getting their own unique feel across. Couldn't say the same thing for Allday's cover of Never Tear Us Apart...
That bass...that bass speaks truth.
The bass can make or break this tune, the bassist did good.
it did my friend. indeed.
n_y_p_e To me, Bass is life. Love comes from the Drums, and that's definitely why DnB is a huge part of my life ^^
Graham Ritchie is his name.
Back here in 2022. Still incredible.
Awesome, love the instrumentation, the drumming is brilliant, great tribute.
This is a great cover, they really did a great job of keeping that melancholy melody of the original but still made it sound like their own
I love this Joy Division song and I have heard many, mostly terrible covers....this was GREAT! I actually felt emotional listening to this version, the same way I feel when listening to Joy a Division. I think the reason most covers fail is that the singers are trying to hard to sound like Ian from Joy Division, this singer uses his own voice.
awsome song well covered
The cover from the movie"the girl from the song" is brilliant
@@Cam___587 I agree
Agreed!! they change the key and make it their own.
Absolute best version is Nerina pallot ….better than the original imo
I just re-visited this again and remembered why I absolutely loved it first time. Breathtaking.
at first I wasn't a fan of this cover, then the drums and the rest of the instruments kicked in and WOW, now we're talking!
I’m not a cryer but this song gets me every time
I First heard this song on WLIR in '81. I have heard many covers over the years, you all managed to pay homage to the Joy Division and make it your own . you nailed it. Bravo, and well done.
I couldn't agree more.
The bass player kept this valiant cover, honorable and true... we done Sir.
Ok, Galahad 🙄
Such a good cover boys! Still loving it 4 years later!
I was so scared to watch it because this song is like a classic that cant be covered to me but holy craaaaap it sounds good they did great job
!!!!! 👍
So much emotion. Simply breathtaking.. I might've shed a tear or two :)
Thanks the J's ... Im old enough to have loved the original version..... But ... The holy's version is ...well ....superior.... ! Love it....just like Love will leave, and tear you apart..! But just learn to appreciate it when it is with you...!
Man! Whenever I hear love will tear us apart, it’s far between listenings. I forget what a powerful song it is in and kind of rendition.
They truly gave it their own spin, and IT WORKS!! Love it!! Love Holy Holy so much!
That drums are mixed so beautifully
I'm in love with this.
This was a Beautiful Like a version been waiting so long for someone to do this song and they certainly did it justice!
I love this music so much! 🇧🇷
Legendary Ian Curtis....
the song begin 1:02
Really great cover, always come back to this
Great live cover.Love the vocals on this version.
love this! the original is probably my favourite song ever and this is such a fabulous tribute to it. thanks so much boys!
This is just awesome💜 love Joy Division and these guys treated this song with the respect it deserved
so good Holy Holy
When the routine bites hard
And ambitions are low
And the resentment rides high
But emotions wont grow
And were changing our ways,
Taking different roads
Then love, love will tear us apart again
Why is the bedroom so cold
Turned away on your side?
Is my timing that flawed,
Our respect run so dry?
Yet theres still this appeal
That weve kept through our lives
Love, love will tear us apart again
Do you cry out in your sleep
All my failings expose?
Get a taste in my mouth
As desperation takes hold
Is it something so good
Just cant function no more?
When love, love will tear us apart again
Great great cover. Holy Holy, you guys will be big one day! Be ready 👏👏👏
Great job, it's a very difficult song to cover- I heard the original shortly after it's commercial release, and have heard many covers over the years, most of them crap For me, this is a haunting, deeply evocative song. Every time I hear it, it brings me back to that period in my life, and a lover who died Sadly, love did tear us apart..Thank you for a beautiful homage- to the this song, and the Joy Division.
This is brilliant. My favourite like a version in a long time.
Such a great cover. Saw them play this at the Newtown Social Club
Love this so much.
Love this so much, my favourite for the year!!
Thank you Triple J for having like a version!
Beautiful.
Wow! Nailed it! So well done! I'm sure Ian Curtis would've been proud!
Love this!
Me encanta este coverrr
Awsome job dudes!!! 🙌🏻👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻
The bass lines get me in the heart bone!!!!
This is a song that is impossible to cover and these guys did an admiral job, but I think the sound, vibe, and the sort of emotion in Curtis' voice in the original can't be replicated.
The effects used on Curtis' vocals give this weird "disconnected but still involved" feel that completely connects with the lyrics. There's a crap-tonne of baggage that goes with the song.
the band loves the song...so i loved the cover....
the singer about to go into a boxing match.
omfg this made me laugh so hard
Kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk im dead
Luis Martínez quê
His channeling Connor McGregor 😂
Lol, well, im all for whatever helps a singer get into the vibe of a song.
Awesome that I stumbled across such a great performance. This reminds me of Nouvelle Vague's cover and they made it their own with class.
As every great cover should do... it just highlights what an unbelievably important, beautiful, transcendent song the original is. It'll never quite capture the sadness but thats ok, i don't think any reasonable human should be able to do what Ian Curtis did. Great job
When routine bites hard and ambitions are low
And resentment rides high but emotions won't grow
And we're changing our ways, taking different roads
Love, love will tear us apart again
Love, love will tear us apart again
Why is the bedroom so cold turned away on your side?
Is my timing that flawed, our respect run so dry?
Yet there's still this appeal that we've kept through our lives
Love, love will tear us apart again
Love, love will tear us apart again
Do you cry out in your sleep, all my failings exposed?
Get a taste in my mouth as desperation takes hold
Is it something so good just can't function no more?
But love, love will tear us apart again
Love, love will tear us apart again
Love, love will tear us apart again
Love, love will tear us apart again
Incredible.... Love love love this version... Wonderful ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Joy Division still lives.
Been waiting for a Like a Version of this song for ages. Killer cover
We’ll done
this is the best like a version to date.
Esse cover é muito bom, meu deus
absolutely brilliant rendition loved it!
R.I.P Ian. Amazing Cover Guys, i love this song ,and i love Joy Division ....
This makes me wanna start my own band
Buenisismo!!!!!! great cover!!!!
Full body chills
Maravilhosa interpretação!
So much love for this cover! Looking forward to hearing what these guys do next.
Awesome. I really want to hear the November Rain cover though!
why isn’t this on spotify? :)
this is so dope. I keep coming back! #OnRepeat
Fantastic version
Holy Holy Hell...this was good
Excellent!
I arrived late to the party, but glad I made it !!!
Very tasteful version.
Beautiful cover. So very beautiful.
A intensidade dos periféricos os efeitos voz tudo é mágico
This IS SO GOOD !!!
Wonderful cover.
Love a song with the bass as lead...
Best like a version ever
what a wonder rendition
Surprisingly good cover.
Really liked this cover of a classic. Bravo!
This is so good! One of the best covers we came across!
love this version
This is bloody amazing.
Awsome cover. Brilliant job holyholy. Peace
Didn’t like the beginning at first but I’m glad I went through it, amazing cover!
That drumming pattern makes it sound like Coldplay’s Clocks.
Whenever “Love will tear us apart” ends, I always think of “Then He Kissed Me” by The Crystals. I believe it’s a subtle nod to the song inserted by Joy Division. Give the last 20 seconds a listen and then compare...
They nailed it.
Good cover of a great song
This is actually GOOD! I enjoyed listening to this!
Great cover , not pretentious, I really like it ,bravo
Whilst it's not exactly for me, I certainly don't hate it, and the rearrangement of the song is very creative and unique.
First time I've heard all the words!
hard song to do justice to they nailed it
Me encanta
Beautiful.
You nailed it guys.
Let's dance to this
That guy is awesomeeee👏👏
Wish these guys could play this at my funeral
What a great cover!
GREAT BEARDS that OWN this! Way to go!!
Great....really great....!