While I like Bob Bergen, I find it odd that Raven didn't get Mark Hamill for jedi outcast or jedi academy considering that they did get him for soldier of fortune 2 which was developed around the same time
DAMN. I was CERTAIN it was Hamil himself in Jedi Outcast and Jedi Academy. That guy was spot on. Now the guy they had voice Luke in the new Battlefront.....he doesnt sound ANYTHING like Hamil.
+LordDarthHarry In some lines he does and some lines he doesn't. All the VAs in Battlefront are very inconsistent. Some times they're spot on and sometimes they're like WTF?
+leftyfourguns If I had to rate the hero voice acting in battlefront id have to go like this: 1. Boba Fett: Original actor (for Jango and the clones before someone brings up the "orignal original" voice) 2. Han Solo: this guy did a great job. 3. Emperor Palpatine: Again, excelent job. 4. Vader: Its definatly Matt Sloa'sn im hearing....but the editic seems off..... he soudns like hes talkign through a pipe. 5. Leia: A few lines, especialy "its not over yet" soudn good, but overall not great. 6. Luke: Like i said, sounds nothing like Hamil.
+LordDarthHarry Totally agree with this ranking. Boba, Han, and Palpatine are top notch. Boba is definitely the best especially if we are going with in canon Boba. Vader you are right something is just a little off, like they didn't know how to edit the sound to make him sound more like regular Vader. It is too high pitch or something. I can't place my finger on it. And yeah Luke and Leia are just not right. I always found it funny how they never really get Mark Hamill to do Luke's voice in video games consider he does a lot of voice work, but I guess he wants to challenge himself and not just do his own voice.
+foorocker Not to mention, it would be hard for him to voice Luke from the original trilogy because of how old Hamil is. It would sound off, even if he tried his hardest.
Obviously Mark Hamill is best, but I really like Bob Bergen's take on the character, how he presents him as slightly older and more in tune with the Jedi ways.
Bob Bergen is the only choice. He's the only one that actually sounds like Luke should. His voice is calm and smooth, and similar to Hamill's. Much better than any of the VAs after him, that's for sure
SPOILERS FROM THE FORCE AWAKENS!! - 19/12/2015 I love how Mark has done the voice of Luke so many times, yet in TFA he doesnt even say a single word :/
Mark Hamill definitely takes the cake. He portrays the best Luke Skywalker in film and voice wise but I'd say Bob Bergen would be second to Mark's voice from the 1970s - 80s
Bob Bergan did so much more than Jedi Knight II... he was in Jedi Knight III and the Rogue Squadron games and Battlefront II. I hope he comes back for the next Battlefront game coming up next year
Bob Bergen is without any shadow of doubt the best impersonator. As another commenter here said; I really thought he was Mark Hamill, when I played Jedi Academy in my younger days.
Mark Hamill ofc. But to add an voice to this. Marc Thompson does a real good job in the Audiobook for Heir to the Jedi, as the book is all from an first person perspective, it sound almost like Luke telling the story himself.
Bob Bergen did a great job as luke skywalker, in starwars jedi outcast ll his acting while doing the voice made me really believe it was luke skywalker.
I like Bob Bergen cause I grew up with Rogue Squadron and the earlier robot chicken episodes, sometimes Mark Hamill doesn’t sound right cause his voice is too raspy and old now. He put a lot of effort into sounding younger in the mandolorian but every other instance of him voicing Luke he sounded way too old
There were also voiceovers of Star Wars characters in Star Wars Rebellion too, an old strategy game in the 90s. Could include those voices in there too.
Well my favorite Luke Skywalker voice is, well, Luke Skywalker (Mark Hamill, duh!) Lloyd Floyd is pretty cool though. Curious as to who did the Rogue Squadron games though, and more specifically why it wasn't on the list?
Mark Hamill took the role and turned it into the role that everyone used to joke about and did exactly what people have been joking about for years, guy loves his role as Luke.
Mark Hamill really loves to do fan service, which is why he is in many parodies of his character, Luke Skywalker. The pinnacle ones: Family Guy and Robot Chicken: "That's not true! That's... improbable!"
Ehh-hem, I believe you forgot baby Luke from Revenge of the Sith, helloooo? Kidding but besides the obvious choice, Luke from Jedi Academy is pretty spot on. Nice video.
There are so many of these where I have a favorite and someone I think did the best job, but let's be honest, no one can ever be Luke except Mr Hamill.
![BATMAN: THE ANIMATED SERIES (1992) Behind The Scenes - Voice Cast [HD] Mark Hamill](/img/n.gif)
There is only one Luke Skywalker: MARK HAMILL!
Soon shall he awaken..
JelloDemon indeed
+pikppa fukin a right the joker and the best jedi in 1
But not the one from the holiday special
Francesco Brosolo I agree with you
Bob Bergen was the best Hamill impersonator. I always thought he WAS Mark Hamill when I played Jedi Outcast.
When I was a kid I thought the same thing
Apparently many people did. :)
It wasn't Mark Hamill?! I played that the other week! xD
I don't know why they don't bring him back... no one else (except Mark) sounded more like Luke. It's not even close.
While I like Bob Bergen, I find it odd that Raven didn't get Mark Hamill for jedi outcast or jedi academy considering that they did get him for soldier of fortune 2 which was developed around the same time
When Hamill voiced Luke in Robot Chicken he sounded more like his Joker voice. Weird.
Lukimus Prime age
Radioactive Skull Exactly age!
I think the voice was supposed to be shitty. But age definitely adds to that.
So Family Guy got the official voicer but the official games didn't.
That's an issue with pay disputes. The people running the games aren't willing to pay him what he's worth.
their loss
@@jon3s115 and ours
Sadly yes!
@@Fiiwse5676 true
Mark Hamill is the best known Luke Skywalker.
Nico Sy he is Luke sky walker
Water is Wet
He will never be truly replaced
DAMN. I was CERTAIN it was Hamil himself in Jedi Outcast and Jedi Academy. That guy was spot on.
Now the guy they had voice Luke in the new Battlefront.....he doesnt sound ANYTHING like Hamil.
+LordDarthHarry In some lines he does and some lines he doesn't. All the VAs in Battlefront are very inconsistent. Some times they're spot on and sometimes they're like WTF?
+leftyfourguns If I had to rate the hero voice acting in battlefront id have to go like this:
1. Boba Fett: Original actor (for Jango and the clones before someone brings up the "orignal original" voice)
2. Han Solo: this guy did a great job.
3. Emperor Palpatine: Again, excelent job.
4. Vader: Its definatly Matt Sloa'sn im hearing....but the editic seems off..... he soudns like hes talkign through a pipe.
5. Leia: A few lines, especialy "its not over yet" soudn good, but overall not great.
6. Luke: Like i said, sounds nothing like Hamil.
+LordDarthHarry Totally agree with this ranking. Boba, Han, and Palpatine are top notch. Boba is definitely the best especially if we are going with in canon Boba. Vader you are right something is just a little off, like they didn't know how to edit the sound to make him sound more like regular Vader. It is too high pitch or something. I can't place my finger on it. And yeah Luke and Leia are just not right. I always found it funny how they never really get Mark Hamill to do Luke's voice in video games consider he does a lot of voice work, but I guess he wants to challenge himself and not just do his own voice.
+foorocker Not to mention, it would be hard for him to voice Luke from the original trilogy because of how old Hamil is. It would sound off, even if he tried his hardest.
Yeah exactly
The force is strong with Mark Hamill
Belen .G And it always will be. I look forward to seeing him in Episode VII.
@@JCBro-yg8vd How do you feel now?
@@ajet0452 They really did him dirty.
@@JCBro-yg8vd Thank god for the Mandalorian for saving Luke
Obviously Mark Hamill is best, but I really like Bob Bergen's take on the character, how he presents him as slightly older and more in tune with the Jedi ways.
Mark Hamill and Bob Bergen are the best.
Agreed. Though I also like Lloyd Floyd.
That Mark Hamill guy sounds nothing like Luke Skywalker. ;)
But he his Luke skywaker
+Patrick Fox Well, nowadays, true, because he's a lot older than he used to be.
He is the original casting for Luke in the original trilogy
Guys, his comment wasn't serious.
some people need a sarcasm detector
Mark Hamill is the best of course, but I like Bob Bergen and Christopher Cory Smith as well.
That Hamill clip from Robot Chicken sounds more like he's doing his Joker voice, haha.
That’s just how his voice sounds now
Age
Wonder if doing the Joker voice took a toll on his normal voice
Bob Bergen is the only choice. He's the only one that actually sounds like Luke should. His voice is calm and smooth, and similar to Hamill's. Much better than any of the VAs after him, that's for sure
SPOILERS FROM THE FORCE AWAKENS!! - 19/12/2015
I love how Mark has done the voice of Luke so many times, yet in TFA he doesnt even say a single word :/
SPOILER ALERT (I GUESS):
I wonder how it'll sound
rpandya97 SPOILER ALERT (BECAUSE IT HINTS AT THE PREVIOUS SPOILER)
Probably like when the trickster is talking normally.
You don't need voices to make a good part in the movie
+Death0908 Wish Lucas had thought of that with the Vader saving Luke scene in ROTJ...
Did he record the "I have the force, my father had it, my sister has it, you have it too" line in the trailer?
Mark Hamill definitely takes the cake. He portrays the best Luke Skywalker in film and voice wise but I'd say Bob Bergen would be second to Mark's voice from the 1970s - 80s
I met Bob Bergen once on a cruise ship. He got me interested in imitating and overall voice-acting.
Mark Hamill, Bob Bergen & Eric Bauza.
eric bauza sucks compared to lloyd.
As Mark's voice changed with age, Bob Bergen does a great young Luke.
The greatest hero in the history of cinema.
amen
+C.Funk99 And yet, people want him to be evil in Force Awakens.
carloswachuwa13 Because grimdark is a mode
pikppa What's "grimdark"
carloswachuwa13 My apologies, it's a internet/fandom term. It indicates a dark turn on previously good or innocent characters and stories
My very favorite voice of Darth Vader's son, Luke Skywalker is Mark Hamill.
Mark Hamill is THE CHOSEN ONE
+MsLm97
G.L. Said Anakin is the Chosen One, and he killed the emperor, so Luke is the chosen one's Son.
***** it was just a play on words to prove my point, man, not dissing Anakin
Hayden is the original chosen one!
+Manuel Amaya
HE WAS THE CHOSEN ONE! HE WAS SUPPOSED TO MAKE THE PREQUELS BETTER NOT WORSE!
no. Anakin was always the chosen. After all, he did destroy the sith. The movies have been mostly focused on Anakin/Vaders story
1. Mark Hamill (because he's the best one and moste recognizable)
2. Bob Bergen (sounds exactly like Hamill)
3. Lloyd Floyd (does his best impression)
Bob Bergen does a good impression, I had to check if it really wasn't Mark for a lot of his work
Did u know that Hamill also voiced Obi-Wan for that Family Guy cutaway gag?
Mark Hamill also played the role in the NPR radio series, except for ROTJ; the role was played by Joshua Fardon.
Wow, when I was a kid playing the Jedi Knight games, I never knew that it wasn't Mark Hamill voicing Luke....
Bob Bergan did so much more than Jedi Knight II... he was in Jedi Knight III and the Rogue Squadron games and Battlefront II. I hope he comes back for the next Battlefront game coming up next year
Mark Hamill of course! Also Bob Bergen and Lloyd Floyd
Don't you EVER bring up the dreaded holiday special
Mark Hamill and bob Bergen
Bob Bergen is without any shadow of doubt the best impersonator. As another commenter here said; I really thought he was Mark Hamill, when I played Jedi Academy in my younger days.
Mark Hamill ofc. But to add an voice to this. Marc Thompson does a real good job in the Audiobook for Heir to the Jedi, as the book is all from an first person perspective, it sound almost like Luke telling the story himself.
Obviously Mark Hamill did the best job as Luke Skywalker because he does one of the best jobs of portraying a Star Wars character.
Bob Bergen did a great job as luke skywalker, in starwars jedi outcast ll his acting while doing the voice made me really believe it was luke skywalker.
Bob Bergen has done so much work as luke Skywalker. He stands number 2 to mark, no question
Lloyd Floyd does sound like Mark Hamill a lot more than I would think
Bob bergen and Lloyd Floyd are my favorites besides Mark, they both have their own way of sounding like a proper luke
like everyone else is saying...Mark Hamill.
I like Bob Bergen cause I grew up with Rogue Squadron and the earlier robot chicken episodes, sometimes Mark Hamill doesn’t sound right cause his voice is too raspy and old now. He put a lot of effort into sounding younger in the mandolorian but every other instance of him voicing Luke he sounded way too old
The guy who voiced him in classic Battlefront 2 was pretty good too.
I believe that was also Bergen. Also the new BF2 voice is ok, but 2015 not so much. Even though they're the same actor.
Mark Hamill will always be number one
Mark Hamil is the best.
There were also voiceovers of Star Wars characters in Star Wars Rebellion too, an old strategy game in the 90s. Could include those voices in there too.
0:30 huh, personally didn’t expect Mark Hamill to voice Luke in Family guy of all things
With the first one I wasn't paying attention at all, so I thought "wow, this guy really sounds like Mark Hamill"...
It’s not a matter of who your favorite Luke was, it’s a matter of who did a better Hamill impression
Bob Bergen is a nice choice for Luke, he surely reminds me of him.
Mark Hamill
No questions asked. He was first and he still is the best :D
How is Lloyd Floyd not getting any love? I thought he sounded exactly like Luke.
For me, Mark Hamill will always be my very own Luke Skywalker. ❤
Bob Bergen was perfect. I always though the voice in Jedi Outcast and Jedi Academy was Mark Hamill.
I had no idea he voiced Luke in Robot Chicken. But that just sounds like such a Mark Hamill thing
to do.
Well my favorite Luke Skywalker voice is, well, Luke Skywalker (Mark Hamill, duh!) Lloyd Floyd is pretty cool though. Curious as to who did the Rogue Squadron games though, and more specifically why it wasn't on the list?
Mark Hamill took the role and turned it into the role that everyone used to joke about and did exactly what people have been joking about for years, guy loves his role as Luke.
1 : Mark Hamill
2 : Bob Bergen
3 : Christopher Corey Smith
Mark Hamill will always be the one true Luke Skywalker.
Mark Hamill is the only Luke Skywalker...
It's not about who had the best voice. It's about who can make the best impression of Mark Hamill, and that is Hamill himself.
Time to add Sebastian Stan to that list now.
He haven't voiced or played Luke
@@kamil.p5134
Not yet. But he will soon.
2:06 WOW. THAT MODEL LOOKS NOTHING LIKE LUKE.
Bob Bergen sounds more like Luke than Mark Hamill. I don't know why, I just think the voice suits Luke MUCH better
Bob Bergen is definitely a good successor for Luke (after all he did voice Luke in Rouge Squadron, RS 2, and RS3) and I played the shit out of those.
Bob Bergen was just on the ABC Show 'To Tell A Truth'
Well at least you did say "Who's your SECOND favorite" xD
So that was good! Nice video!
Man that Mark Hamill guy looks like Luke Skywalker!
It’s so cool the Hamill did the voice on Robot Chicken.
Bob Bergen, when I was a kid I thought that it was Mark Hamill, for Rogue Squadron.
Marc Thompson from the audiobooks. Best second Luke, Han, and C-3PO voice period.
Joker does it best!
Wow mark did family guy and robot chicken holy shit
I love luke's yellow jacket
In robot chicken Mark Hamil sounds like his joker character lol
Bob Bergen did do a pretty good job.... but that R2 unit in the background. XD
Eric Bauza sounded nothing like Luke Skywalker at all. Bob Bergen is the best (Mark Hamill notiwithstanding)
i agree with first sentence
Don't have to sound exactly like someone to do a good voice
Bergen was pretty on point
2... hm? christopher! :)
Wow Lloyd Floyd sounds really convincing as Luke.
Mark Hamill, Bob bergen and Lloyd floyd are my favorites!
Mark Hamill really loves to do fan service, which is why he is in many parodies of his character, Luke Skywalker. The pinnacle ones: Family Guy and Robot Chicken: "That's not true! That's... improbable!"
Lloyd Floyd looks like an aging Tobuscus lmao
Mark Hamill will *FOREVER* be my favorite Luke!!!!!!! 😍❤️😍❤️😍❤️
1.)Mark Hamil (duh)
2.)Bob Bergen
3.)Lloyd Floyd
1)Mark Hamill
2)Lloyd Floyd
3)Eric Bauza
4)Bob Bergen
5)C Andrew Nelson
6)Christopher Corey Smith
You should do a voice comparison for Obi-Wan Kenobi
Carlisle the Cinephile He did
Luke starts cackling like Joker mid battle of Hoth
Bob Bergen and Eric Bauza get my vote.
I guess we have to add "Robot Mark Hamill" from Mandalorian/Book of Boba Fett to the list now.
Ehh-hem, I believe you forgot baby Luke from Revenge of the Sith, helloooo? Kidding but besides the obvious choice, Luke from Jedi Academy is pretty spot on. Nice video.
I cant believe mark hamill actually did the robot chicken one omg
There are so many of these where I have a favorite and someone I think did the best job, but let's be honest, no one can ever be Luke except Mr Hamill.
I'll always remember Luke from the Jedi Knight series
*mark hamill is iconic*
*THE ONLY LUKE SKYWALKER I KNOW*
Bob Bergen is actually convincing enough for me.
Wait Mark Hamill voiced Luke in a Family Guy episode?! MIND BLOWNNNNN💥💥💥💥
1. Mark Hamill
2. Lloyd Floyd
3. Bob Bergin
4. Christopher Cory Smith
5. C Andrew Nelson
6. Eric Bauza
This really needs a 2020 update
6.Eric Bauza
5.Christopher Corey Smith
4.C Andrew Nelson
3.Lloyd Floyd
2.Bob Bergsen
1.Mark Hamill
They got C Andrew Nelson to voice Luke in video games!? I thought he only portrayed Luke in the movies!
Eric bauza also voiced as luke in disney infinity
the moment that Luke sounds like the Joker ;-)