SUPERMAN RETURNS: How it Could Have Been
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ต.ค. 2009
- A re-edit of the 777 sequence in Superman Returns. (It mistakenly says 747 in the titles of my edit)
I felt it was such an important part of the movie, it being the first time people had seen the Man of Steel for over 20 years, that I wanted to turn my disapointment of it around and do it my way. I wanted it to feel more like the old films with the late, great Christopher Reeve by focusing more on Superman himself and adding the music from the original movie. Some of the cuts arn't perfect, but I worked with what I had. Thanks for watching! - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
The sequence of the action cut short and went well with different tones of music that sets the viewers to a suspense, drama and action mode which felt exciting and victorious in the end. Always love to watch Superman heroics blend into John William's music composition.
Thanks for understanding what had actually been done here! I spend a lot of time convincing people to go back and see the original scene so they can see the difference as most people just say "it's the same." Thanks again and for commenting!
John William's Superman Theme is and will always be the BEST superhero theme of all.
It will always be the perfect theme ever. Period.
Easily. It's so stirring and it IS superman..
So why did they hardly use it in this film? There wasn't even a decent action scene it was all just very tame and boring.
❤😂😊
😮
The use of John Williams' "Superman Theme" makes ANY Super-rescue that much more exciting!
Amen to that!
And the fly by ..was definitely a tribute to the late Christopher Reeve.. the original man of steel 👌🤘
Aye
Why, in the name of all the good, they dont use John Williams song anymore?
I'd like to see some talented person add John Williams score to clips from the George Reeves series.
I am 67 years old and this brings tears to my eyes. I just love Superman . And the score just does it.
George Reeves, Christopher Reeve and Brandon Routh were all brilliant in their portrayal of Superman. This film was treated very unfairly by the critics. I think Routh was able to capture the spirit of Chris Reeve's comedic timing brilliantly. I also think that using the John Williams source music was a clever thing to do. Later iterations suffered because they did not have such an epic score.
I agree. Also ditching 3 and 4 and making this a sequel to the Donner films was great
Agreed
George reeves, Christopher reeve, and Brandon routh are my personal favorite actors to portray superman
@BASIL!!!!! The musical and pumpin' Seagull yes the 50s superman was for the 50s
but george Reeves is an all time classic superman --his portrayal of superman is timeless in my book
i grew up with chris reeve he is still my all time favorite superman
honorable mention as favorites
brandon routh
dean cain
tom welling (no suit)
I'm not quite sure why not liking the film is in any way unfair to it.
@BASIL!!!!! The musical and pumpin' Seagull TRUE TRUE especially about smallville lol
JOhn Glover is the real reason i love that smallville
and yes for the superman role, chris reeve put on real muscle
i read they had pitched the idea originally as he would wear a muscle suit
but Reeve refused , he said --no fake muscles--i will build the muscle. and yes he put in the work , plus no 'roids lol
I don’t care what anybody says this was a really good movie I liked it a lot Brandon Routh played really good superman
The Lex Luthor reboot in this movie was great, they got rid of the campy style and made him ruthless and cold hearted.
Ronald Hill you’re confusing ruthless with psychotic 😏
Ronald Hill offended.... bro you are living in another plane of existence 😂🤣😂🤣
@TOM PREE minta pilemindia
@TOM PREE mintapilem india
JESUS! I remember when this movie came out, I was in absolute awe, after waiting so many years for a Superman movie…this was amazing. I couldn’t care less what the haters say.
Probably the single best Superman scene ever filmed.
This is an amazing scene because for some of the young kids at the stadium, they have never seen Superman in action. And being that it was the baseball game, then his rescue was captured on TV also.
An amazing scene for
the world to know that Superman is Back
I teared up a bit when he exited the plane. This scene captured some magic from the Reeves era. Having said that, this movie was not very good. It killed the franchise yet again until "Man of Steel," which still wasn't that great. I guess I was spoiled by Superman 1978. Hollywood has yet to get it right like that regarding Superman.
That a trick
For those that might have been paying attention. The bartender in the scene where Clark sees the accident is happening is none other than the original Jimmy Olsen from the George Reeves Superman series.
No way! Really?
"Sorry About That, Chief."
They did something similar in the first movie. When Clark was racing the train, the two parents with the child watching him run was supposed to be a young Lois Lane and her parents were actors who appeared in the TV series.
@@Coxman It was actually Kirk Alyn and Noel Niel who had previously worked together in Two Superman Serials.
@@loanaoftheshellpeople7744 I'm a grown ass 50, something, I saw Reeve in the movie in 1977. I remember the entire movie, I know the scene. I only found out a couple of years ago about them two actors. It hit me like a train hearing that, what a brilliant touch and for all those years, I never knew.
And now I know their names. Solid!😎
Brandon Routh absolutely nailed his performance as Superman. Kevin Spacey was a great Luthor. I was really happy to see Brandon bring his Superman back in the Arrowverse crossover.
Importantly he got Clark right too, staying true to the beloved character so well established by Christopher Reeve.
@@juliapigworthy
Christopher Reeves and Brandon Routh are the greatest actor play as Superman..so perfect !
How about henry cavill?
“Reeve”
Routh & Cavill Cgi Sups@@Tygajakoleromoby
@@Tygajakoleromobycgi sups along with Routh
Superman Returns has the best flying sequences of any Superman film.
Yes
Yes!
tavares lowery it’s CGI not GCI
Looks so dated but still got very good story line that saves it.
Correction: best flying sequences in any movie history
Brandon Routh how much we long to see you even now , he came closest to the magnificent charisma of Christopher Reeve .
He played recently a Dark Superman in the Crisis on multiple Earths crossover where Louis, his son a the entire Staff of the Daily Planet were killed by the Joker during one of his rampages in the Metropolis...
@@asheer9114
There's a great deal of evidence that Superman is the same as the Returns one, just years later.
All due respect to the Great Christopher Rreeve, the one who can never be duplicated, My Superman is Brandon Routh. I was 27 years old in 2006 and saw it opening night with my Brother. If at the end of a movie, if me and my brother looked at each other at the same time and nodded, then the film was good, we did just that after we watched Superman Returns
Christopher Reeve's wife was consulted by the producer and director of Superman returns and was brought onto the set to oversee production. She commented on more than one occasion that Brandon looked like a young Chris.
I enjoyed Superman Returns, even with it's flaws. The one thing I enjoyed the most, is how Brandon Routh and Kevin Spacey put obvious effort into getting the mannerisms, and quirks of Christopher Reeves and Gene Hackman into their performances. That was a great way to honor those before them, and fans of the original movies.
The flying sequences were the best since Chris Reeve's.
I'm not a fan of how Henry's Superman is always having him whooshing everytime he flies..
*Its, not it's. Christopher Reeve, not Reeves.
"Even with its flaws"... you passive/aggressive types are everywhere. SR... was wonderful and full of heart.
Spacey's role was wayyy over the top and a very poor Lex Luther. Routh was bland and lacked personality and charisma.
@@chuckfinley4757 no one cares
Christopher. Reeves. Will. Be. Missed. But. Never. Forgotten
how true
Alken. Gray. JrAllen Gray Jr to the right ↪ the
ㅂㅂㅂㄱ..크리스토퍼 리브가 레알 슈퍼맨~
He is now turning to Atom, not Superman anymore.
Apparently you have already forgotten that his name was Christopher REEVE not Reeves. George Reeves played Superman in the 1950's on TV and in a single movie.
John Williams just makes every movie scene better. And I can’t believe he originally wrote this score over 40 years ago.
I don't understand the dislikes!!!
This scene is incredible,
Lex Luthor fans!
All the critics (fan & professional) that know nothing but how to hate.
This was done sooo beautifully it made this 63-year-old man cry!! Great job!
This 50 year old right there with ya!👍👍👍👍👍
I'm gladI'm not alone at 63. Grtz from Belgium
I'm only 45 but danm thats the real music.
I liked him as superman and with the sound track from the 70s/80s placed over it, that's just awesome.
Superman's line, "It's still the safest way to travel", is a reference to Christopher Reeve's comment in Superman (1978) after rescuing Lois from the falling helicopter. "Well, I certainly hope this little incident hasn't put you off flying, miss. Statistically speaking, of course, it's still the safest way to travel."
This scene look like cartoon... I miss Christopher Reeve ☺☺😌😌
Of course.
They were paying tribute to Christopher with that, as well as the close up and smile in Earth orbit.
DC movies and TV shows are good at that.
Examples:
Christopher Reeve and Margot Kidder guest starring in "Smallville."
Helen Slater and Dean Cain guest starring in "Supergirl."
Various TV show characters of the past putting in cameos in Arrowverse's "Crisis on Infinite Earths" (Robin, Huntress, the 90's Flash, Lucifer, Clark and Lois from "Smallville"). (I still hate that "Crisis on Infinite Earths" hasn't been released on DVD for American players yet!)
@@jimgilbert9984 In Man of Steel, they also paid tribute to Christopher Reeve when Henry's Superman is directly below the beam from the world engine right before he flies up and through it. His face essentially morphs to look like Christopher Reeve. Everyone that has played Superman has done a great job and portrayed him to what the writers provided, but I'd say Christopher Reeve has charisma the others lacked. Brendon did a great job, but he essentially just tried to copy Christopher Reeve's mannerisms, which worked great in some scenes and looked a bit to forced in others. Still liked the film. This airplane scene along with when he lifts half the ship and then holds it in mid air with one hand were my favorites. Tack on the John William's score and they get you in the feels...
@@LetsDIYIt
Do you know how Christopher audtioned for the Superman role?
He was a skinny guy, so he wore a big, bulky sweater to look like he had to build to play Superman.
After he got the part, he worked out like crazy to build up his muscles.
Brandon's look and costume reminds me so much of Christopher Reeves portrayal. This was very well edited video! Thanks for sharing.
Reeve, not Reeves.
also the voice,,, inside the plane scene
I was thinking🤔...
If Supes can run *faster* than the eye can see, then why would he run down a darkened alley to change into his supersuit?😕
The way it still should be. I thought this young man did an admirable job in the role and he deserved a second shot to make the sequel. He emulated Reeve in his portrayal and that’s the way it should stay. You can keep all this new dark modern nonsense and shove it. Superman is a hero who should uplift you and not make you depressed and moody. Long live Christopher Reeve! The greatest superman ever. And thank you Brandon Routh for doing a wonderful job channeling Reeve in this film.
Brandon Ruth - U were better even! Cheers Man.
I like this movie.... for many reasons....it was not mostly base about fighting....it was about saving lives and that is what super man does most.....I like to see lives get save.... for what I see Brandon Roth belongs in that suit.... somewhere along the way....he is the perfect image of super man and young Christopher Reeves.....so please give him back a super man role... even in a series or future movies.....his time is not yet over.... and we the whole world knows it.
Raymond Charles I too hope to see him as superman again!
Agreed.
He def sounds and looks more like the original supes than the new guy
Routh is too busy now being The Atom.
Very well said sir, Brandon Routh is the perfect guy for superman role.
I really enjoyed "Superman Returns" it was never a disappointment to me, as a matter of fact in my opinion I believe it ranks up there among one of the very best. Too bad the driving forces behind this one, did not give Brandon Routh another chance as the Man of Steel.
John Lee I for one would love to see Routh back as Superman! Like everyone else in this film (perhaps with the exception of Bosworth as Lois) the casting was spot on. There was so much good in this film, unlike the devisive newer ones being made now.
I enjoyed the movie, watched it a few times and enjoyed it even more as I caught on more details. But I am also disappointed because, having watched it several times like that, the major plot points were basically the first Superman movie, rehashed. That took away a few stars from enjoyment of the movie but still a good one.
I completely agree. The cast was great in this film. Except for Lois. The story was good. It deserved a sequel.
Brandon Routh is definitely the best next to Reeve. Yes, Lois Lane in this movie is awful. A very bad casting.
Brandon Routh was the only thing I didn't enjoy to some degree about this movie. His effeminate acting/look is one of the reasons I couldn't stand the movie!
The world could really use Superman now!!!
Superman was always dropping some knowledge at the end of whatever he was doing. I'm upset they took that out of the movies. He always had these witty one liners.
I have always loved that movie. I don't care what the others say.
Chistopher Reeve and also Brandon Routh were the greatest Superman that I ever seen in my life... 👍 I'm so enjoy to watch them...
Agree
I highly enjoyed it when I saw it and didn't have a problem with it at the time. The plane sequence is awesome. Watching it years later, the most trouble I had with it was that he lifted a continent made out of kryptonite or I think he did, whish doesn't make a whole lot of sense. Rest of the movie is just fine.
I love this movie didn't have any main issues with. Recently when I watch it last, I cringe at the Kevin Spacey's scenes. However that is the only issue that I have with that movie, is that Spacey is in the movie.
This movie is better than Man of Steel
Williams's music takes this scene to a whole new level !!!!
What? It's in the fucking film. This is weird.
A prime example of how editing and the proper music cues are very* important. Modern films have lost sight of this fact.
Awesome movie!! Thanks for sharing. Have a great day. 👍
in 1978 me and my twelve year old friend sat through the whole movie superman with our mouths wide open with shock that a man could fly and talked about this for weeks after .
😄👍
@Ronald Hill 😁👍
@Ronald Hill mate you just trumped my story well done !
michaelstarwars66
I did too and at 12 in 1978 lol. Like star wars it was ahead of its time.
Now THAT is Superman 😀
Why didn't they keep that classic Williams score?
They did. They blended it nicely with new stuff.
John Williams is the greatest movie composer in history. I know most people think Star wars was his best, but I think the Superman theme is the best
@dislike injustice I feel sorry for you.
Brandon.routh también hubiera sido un mejor
Superman pero hizo lo
mejor que pudo
@@thomasfleig1184 indeed Superman theme is a classic!
The Use of the music in this scene, opens soft, comes on strong in the middle, and the perfect fulfillment at the end
I cannot imagine a superhero world without him.
You mean her/cake/pufter.
This has so much more emotion with the original John Williams score. Love it and thanks for doing this.
Wow! Adding the John Williams score to those scenes made them look allot better!! Amazing!
This is one of my most favorite Superman scenes in any movie. I wish I could see more of THIS!!!
Routh did a great job its not his fault the script was pretty dam poor 😕 supes is the greatest superhero and deserves better scripted films!!!
So true. The trailer actually did a slightly better job than the movie itself with Supes approaching the plane. The Air Traffic Control cut scene should have been done better, more shock or fear on their faces. They did a good job showing him catch back up to the fuselage after the wing broke. THAT part and the catch were nicely done. But the approach needed something more. He had been gone for 5 years. Something was just missing.
Totally agree, his Superman was one of the best
I felt the same with Ryan Reynolds as GL.
Routh was perfect as Clark Kent. I wasn't sold on him until I saw him as Kent. Now I can't see anyone else playing Superman. Beats the shit out of Henry Cavill 🤦🏻♂️
But this "edit" is shite 😂
I still cant see how some1 would think the SPACE SHUTTLE launching from ontop a passager plane be a safe idea.
Moral of the Story: Always hang out with Lois Lane, for that emergency get out of jail free card.
Great reply!!
or a near death experience.
On the other hand, if you don't hang out with her, you're way less likely to get into an emergency in the first place.
for me brandon routh really fits to superman. his charisma was there. its just so sad that critics hadnt see it right
I loved both Brandon and Kate as Clark/Superman and Lois in this movie. I thought they were both fantastic. I'm so disappointed that they never made a sequel with this cast.
100% agreed! Such a waste of talent and possibilities. Never could bring myself to see MoS.
the music score was brilliant made the scene .
z
michaelstarwars66 , from the original Superman, 1978.
It's John Williams.. pure class...
John Williams' music TOTALLY saves this scene from being a load of toss! Such a legend.
I watched this and aside from the blurriness I thought to myself, "isn't this originally how it was? What was changed?" After reading the description all I can say is this edit is perfect. Spot on.
Nice job. I was hoping for a sequel with Brandon Routh
He is the only one who can play that role next to Christopher Reeve! Give him that role again! He deserves to be SUPERMAN!❤
Eis Sirf Onaamid Thankfully he is reprising the Superman role for CW’s Supergirl Show for an episode or two this month :D
@@skylertrapa Really? I'll have to check that out!
William's score brings the awesomeness in that scene! Goosebumps all over.. Good job, thank you!
Brandon Routh did an excellent job !!! I love superman returns, his superman is in my heart .. Christophere Reeve and Brandon Routh are my favorite superman ❤❤
Out"damn"standing!!!! Excellent!!! Great scene and actual superman theme!!!
ive been a fan since i was 7 im now 65 this sequence is my idea of superman beautifully edited and you could see him fly not just disappear in a nanosecond well done young man
Thank you. It's been clear to me from the comments that people have very different views of the character and many are unaware of what I was trying to do here but I'm so glad that so many others like yourself share the classic version of Superman.
Because of this I rewatched the whole film and I can say with conviction that the musical score made a whole lot of difference to this one scene.
Love the musical score when he finally stops it... Then the action reaction force effect causes the plane to vibrate... Then he gently let's it dwn... That beat is glorious!!!!!?
This took me back. Right back home.
I love that I can watch it 1000 times and never get tired of it
Brandon Routh made a great Man of Steel.
Routh Has True Heroic Bearing! His Arrowverse Appearances, Including The Crossover Where He Reprises His Superman Performance Show That It Was The Script And NOT His Portrayal That Made "Superman Returns" The Disappointment Everyone Thinks It Is.
The only scene that works in this movie!! Spectacular👍🏽👍🏽
I don't understand why it wasn't a hit ! I loved the way it played like a sequel to the original first four movies! It deserved a sequel to!!
It's really the difference in passion, I think the fan edits show off how people really feel about Superman more than the movie did
Thank you for fixing this scene. It is short sweet and has a very nostalgic feel to it and I feel that a lot of people would have reacted differently if it was made this way.
Loved it, loved it, loved it ... Well Done ... Christopher Reeve in my opinion was and will always be the best Superman ...
🇬🇧🙋🏾♀️Yes 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾I got chills when he said "statistically flying is the safest way to travel" Rip Christopher 😢
There’s something about the original theme song that a superman movie can’t do without. When I hear those trumpets my heart pounds harder, my chest swells, I sit up straight and I’m ready to take on the world!
I totally agree. The Henry Cavill Superman theme was lacklustre in my opinion. It would have been better if they got the John Williams theme.
The Superman March gives me the chills..where are you Superman we need you now!
Gotta say when Superman leaped into the air and saved the plane, I got excited and teary eyed. It's that music I swear. R.I.P. Christopher Reeves.
Reeve, it's Reeve, not Reeves.
The Best Superman since Christopher Reeve!
he looks a lot like him.
Balls he the worst best is Henry Cavill the Tom selling then Christopher Reeves and I grow up with Christopher Reeves superman even saw superman 2 in the cinema but this is the best superman scene in this movie in Reeves day helicopter cavil oil rig Brian picked a man that was two skinny to be superman
+Nick white honestly i love brandon better than henry.. brandon looks so close to christopher
I agree
Betul
The score is magic. It is so perfectly superman, and evokes such great emotions.
Wow. What a huge improvement. Thank you for creating this!
so much better with that original score!! Omg
I don't say the word hero very often, but you are the greatest hero in American history.
Peter Brazier Woo-Hoo!
Ο?Κ?
This is the best 👌 of superman, ever.❤
Always been a fan for decades love it
God I still love that music.
It is amazing how just the sound track could of fixed so much wrong with that movie.
If the used this music in the new movie people would lose their minds in joy
I really enjoy this movie, that’s why I bought my super man T-shirt though I’m 51 years old.
I shared this. Thank you so much for posting this!
This is still my favorite action sequence, it has everything.
The music is simply awesome!!. It changes a lo the movie! Great job!
Our need for supermen, has become even more urgent.
Great to watch! Thanks.👍🙂❤❤❤
Brandon rough is the strongest Superman we’ve seen in a movie. He’s also my favorite Superman of all time. He embedded the character better than anyone in my opinion. This movie is just phenomenal
That "Can you read my mind" theme when Lois saw a flying object out in the planes window was right on cue... Fantastic Job you did here! Routh was amazing in this movie.
It's wasent louis,,it was another woman
I never get bored watching the Superman movie.
This is superb! Thank you.
You put the music in just the right areas,well done!.
Rebecca Labs Thank you!
I can't even imagine Indiana Jones or Star Wars without John Williams.
Superman bringing the airplane down in the baseball stadium is one of my all time favorite movie scenes.
WoW!! Thank you for that. That was awesome!
Perfect! , just perfect!.
Aaw man!!! The chills when that music came on and he hit the sonic boom!!!!!!
Hearing that music, I really really miss Mr Reeve's Superman. RIP, my man and thank you !
That music score. Perfection.
This version was truly very good..
Brandon routh was really good actor.. great emotional.. this version of Superman franchise is the best
Actually out of all the movies I have to say Superman 2 and man of steel or the best in my opinion
I still believe Brandon Routh is the best modern day Superman!
Mark Metzler agreed. I feel that he captured the nerdiness of Kent, and the essence of Superman. Second only to Christopher Reeves.
Mark Metzler reeve is the tire Superman
Totally agree.
he looked the part
That’s very true I actually like him better than the superman that they have now and even changed his outfit but the best of all time of course is Christopher reeve I’m sure everyone can agree on that but the modern day superman should have been continued by Brandon Routh I was so upset when they got this other guy he really doesn’t fit the superman look I think they just went with him because he’s a big boy
I came close to crying when I watched this and thought why didn't I get this feeling when I watched it in theatre. The main thing I was thinking was how awesome that in her real time of need Superman was there Unexpectedly. And how because he was gone for so long when people saw him back it was like seeing him for the first time again and back just when they need him. Then I realized why it felt that way, because of the music. Why did they not use this music, that was a crime
Now I want to go back and watch the original movie. You brought back the magic. Great job.
My daughter was four when we picked up Chinese food and a DVD of the original SUPERMAN and settled in for the evening. I honestly didn't know what to expect her reaction to be. I was 12 when it came out in theatres, and I already knew the story and character well, having grown up with the comics and TV shows. She enjoyed the early scenes (with a 4 year old, it's easy to tell if they're not engaged). But nearly an hour in, at the first appearance in Metropolis (the crashing helicopter scene), she literally jumped up and cheered seeing Superman fly up to catch the falling Lois Lane. And she burst out in excited laughter when Superman assures her that he's got her and she replies "You've got me? Who's got YOU?" SUPERMAN RETURNS was released just a couple of years later. No enthusiasm. Afterward, she dryly asked, "Why did they make that?" I had no answer.
my favorite Superman and Superman movie
Excellent job. You really captured the feel of the something that was missing.
Music is everything! 👍🙏🇺🇸❤️🦸🌎
This was a WONDERFUL job
I loved the addition of the original theme music
It really brought it to the power of what Superman is supposed to be
Seriously, this scene you put together is better than the entirety of any of the new Superman renditions
This one scene had more heart and epicness and FEELS than I got from ANY of the new movies including Superman Returns
Thank you
Thankyou so much James because, we aren't going to see another Superman movie with such an epic music and awsome scenes again. I'll remember this all life. Sup Rules and we grew up watching him and no other Superhero can take his place.