ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
Why France Hates Poor Muslims but Loves the Gulf: French Sociologist Explains Abaya and Hijab Ban
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ส.ค. 2024
- 00:00 - France tried to ban long dresses since 2012!
02:46 - France's stances against religion through history
04:46 - France fears more Muslims than Islam
06:13 - "Secularism" targets a specific ethnicity
07:45 - Why France is obsessed with North Africans
10:12 - Secularism and Islamophobia serve a specific politicial purpose
12:38 - How ordinary French people are fooled
Literature in English:
Islamophobia in France: The Construction of the "Muslim Problem"
Abdellali Hajjat and Marwan Mohammed - 2023
ugapress.org/b...
Raphael Liogier on Islamoparanoia
politicstoday....
www.academia.e...
The Paranoid Logic of Hatred by Frédéric Baitinger, Raphaël Liogier, The Lacanian Review 2020
In French:
1905 debate about whether the priests' thobes should be banned from public spaces:
Séance du 26 juin 1905, Annales de la chambre des députés, Paris, 1905, p. 989.
www.assemblee-...
Histoire de la laïcité en France, Jean Baubérot, 2010
www.cairn.info...
Laïcité 1905-2005, entre passion et raison, Jean Baubérot, 2004
www.seuil.com/...
Scruter la loi de 1905, la République française et la Religion, Emile Poulat, 2010.
1905-2005. Les enjeux de la laïcité, Emile Poulat, 2005
L'intégrisme républicain contre la laïcité, Jean Baubérot, 2006
ABOUT ME:
Hello and welcome! I'm a Sociologist at the University of Warwick, UK. I'm passionate about understanding people, social and economic justice, mental health and the outdoors.
My publications and other creative projects are on my website williambarylo.com . To get in touch, email me at hello@williambarylo.com
PS: This channel is eligible for monetisation. However, I have chosen not to depend on TH-cam for income and not make money out of TH-cam so 1. I can have creative freedom and 2. Offer ad-free videos to my viewers.
Thank you to everyone posting anti Muslim comments for boosting the engagement rates of this video! TH-cam is the only place where I can thank racists because they're genuinely helping me getting more visible. Crazy times.
To be more accurate and be credible, France bans all religious signs in public schools and public governmental offices. That is the French law based on her secular constitution. Any one wants to break the law, is betrayder and should be detained. "What is so difficult for mu slims to understand?
when did criticizing somebody becamo racist, and why are you lying so much, read some news , in pakistan recently overs 1000 christians are killed and their homes are burned just on a fake news of blasphemy. gets ur facts right.
ohhh, you are momin, then its ok, its in quran and hadith to lie and deceive in order to project your religion as superior.
It is not anti muslim, it is anti practice that restricts the freedom that Muslim women seek in West and come for free breethings, thinking and movement. Religion is not in clothers. it is in public and personal conduct in open world.
Hijab or Burca does not give extra thinking rather restricts open thinking with constrainsts of segregation in society. It never existed in British ruled countries so much but spread like wild fire after formation of Pakistan with nothing in Arab world. There is much more in life to be accomplished and achieved than in Burka and Hijab that restricts outreach than it teaches for freedom that Muslims come to seek in Western world.
I am a Russian Muslim convert living in France. I have never worn abayas for personal preferences but I have found other types of modest clothing, even traditional Russian style head scarves. So I just wanted to confirm and to reiterate that we don't have a uniform in Islam. People can wear whatever kind of clothes or colors they like as long as it's within the guidelines of the religion. Modest, non-tight fitting, non transparent etc ... Obviously this ban is rediculous and the level of hatered and ignorance about Islam in France is staggering.
100%!!
What about the situation in Russia? Do they love muslims? Why do you live in France instead of Russia? France is a good country with a good amount of freedoms and you know it.
Sorry but you dont understand . It is not about islam, it is about religions signs for minors at school. No abaya, no catholic crosses, no kippas and no « i love jésus « T shirts. It is not about hate, it is about state neutrality and this is very important in the french culture . Why are you asking for a special treatment ? All thé french follow french rules, even muslims…
@@Jonathan-rt8dx Doesn't William make the point in the video that an abaya is not a religious garment? In other words, it is culturally associated with a religious group but is not in itself a religious garment, since (as he says) there are other ways of fulfilling any religious obligation in terms of clothing - it needn't be by means of the abaya.
So the abaya and kippah (or Sikh pagri) are not directly comparable with a Catholic cross because the first is a cultural or contingent item which fulfils a religious criterion, while the second is a religious item which may be worn as part of one's clothing but (correct me if I'm mistaken) is not required to be worn by a Catholic.
You seem to be arguing that, by banning certain items along these lines, France is maintaining a position of neutrality. The counter-argument is that the French government has determined that some people may wear what they would have worn anyway, while others may not, and so logically it is difficult to claim that this is "neutral". I am not getting into subjective rights and wrongs about forms of clothing, merely questioning whether this can be deemed neutrality.
The state is who has to be neutral, not the individuals @@Jonathan-rt8dx
When I explain to my colleagues in the US what I went through for 25 years growing up as a French Muslim, they are confused and shocked... It completely changes their perception of France. I had to leave France to enjoy basic freedom rights. At long term, French will pay the price of their complex of superiority.
I hope you're enjoying a better life in the US! - despite the lack of social protection. If I had a job offer in the US, I would definitely consider it, at least I feel if you have the right skills and experience, they can value it regardless of your religion and skin colour more than on the continent.
@@williambarylo I found peace of mind overseas. I am in a managing role for a multi billion dollar corporation and I have never felt unwanted nor discriminated like I did in France. There is a dedicated room at the office where I am able to pray at any time. I have a (very) long beard which would have automatically disqualified me from any CAC40 firms in France. But here, it is all about inclusion, and your skills matter the most regardless of your ethnicity, religion, sexual orientation, and so on. Thanks for putting this video together 🙏
@@AmineAmine-vd2fs I'm really happy for you Alhamdulillah. I'm sure there are downsides in the US but if you're able to sustain yourself in a nurturing environment, that's huge
@@williambarylo 100%, there are downsides against my values such as gun violence, healthcare cost, or lately LGBTQ lobbying to add their beliefs into public school programs... But overall, the freedom of religion is incredibly protected in the US!
You just dont understand and respect Laïcité which is the foundation of France. Dont be surprise if we reject muslim like you, because you hate us and dont respect our laws. Like you said stay in USA. We are not interested to live with people who hate us.
It's a strange law to Americans because we wouldn't do this in America since it would violate the constitution's protection of freedom of religion.
France, in theory, has freedom of religion in its constitution. And it has been condemned by the European and World Courts of Human Rights many times (also with cases related to Sikhs). But since these condemnations are only symbolic, France doesn't really care and interpret the law as they please
France Napoleon hated muslims and colonized most of Africa
@@williambarylo But wasn't the hijab ban in 2004 also confirmed and deemed legitimate by the European Courts?
@@tbouni legitimate by the European court but not the United Nations Human Rights Committee, which found that France violated the right to freedom of religion
USA is a recent country and is multicultural. Not France, which is a country with millenar history and culture. If you come here dont try to impose your religion or your symbols. It is really offensive, we are one community.
I’m English living in France, I’m a Christian, and also haveexperienced racism for being English. I have nothing against any religions, and feel people should be more tolerant of each other.
Oh man, I agree, the French can be horrible towards the English! Sorry you've had to go though that!
😂😂😂
European tribe's relationship is fascinating.. because the word Tribal wars is associated with other countries but not European Tribes...It's amusing when is witness their interaction in the office.. especially France and Britain
It's mind boggling how much hatred a French person contains within himself It's sick they are the worst throughout history
I think it's a superiority complex. In the official curriculum, French students are taught that France "invented" Human Rights and modern democracy with the Revolution. And that it invaded Africa to grant people the "gift of civilisation."
@@williambarylo thank you for your comment great work
@@williambarylowait seriously..?it would definitely explain some things from some people’s reaction to this though
@@bubblessera I went to school and uni in France. My generation had to learn crazy things. I don't know if it's different now.
Im a Muslim please don't say all France people most of the comes from the government I'm sure most France are wonderful people. It's very ignorerent like I'm the Muslim community there are a few crazy person's.
I just discovered your channel,very informative!
I'm a psychology student and I really want to study this type of behavior and way of thinking about muslims and the same from Muslims and about religion in general.
You've encouraged me!
Thank you. There are already plenty of works done around racism, anti-Muslim hatred, supremacists groups and the far right however... one area of knowledge that needs exploring is: what makes people change their views so they cease hating others?
@@williambarylo True,I think modern technology can play an important role in solving such issues,this hatred as you mentioned in the video comes from the almost nonexistent contact with Muslims and the small amount of knowledge about islam,so by teaching people to let go of prejudice and prejudgment and to only form an opinion after gaining enough knowledge and experience would make a good first step.
I personally feel as if people nowadays live extremely isolated due to the media in general,even though they go out and they have social media that makes connection easier people still tend to show symptoms of loneliness and a superficial level of knowledge about a variety of topics.
I hope I can learn and make ways to stop this hatred from its roots.
Thank you so much:)
ää ööö öö big deal Allah allows child marriage and sxx with children chapter 65 verse 4 -
The Iddah of Those in Menopause and Those Who do not have Menses
Allah the Exalted clarifies the waiting period of the woman in menopause. And that is the one whose menstruation has stopped due to her older age. Her Iddah is three months instead of the three monthly cycles for those who menstruate.The same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation. Their Iddah is three months like those in menopause.....The same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation.
@@muhammadibnwaraqa not to be rude..but I don't think you understand what your talking about..OR, you're intentionally spreading falsehood, because surha At-Talaq doesn't talk about child marriage or whatever,talaq literally means divorce,the surah has a total of 12 verses in which none contain references to marriage or marriage to children,it explicitly says "woman/women" , hopefully you understand what a woman is.
If you wanna learn,ask politely for the sake of knowledge,but if you have ill intentions, you're getting nowhere in life.
@@HydeCorvus oh no problem please be rude pedo son of Mut'ah you know extly it is about child marriage. Iddah is waiting period after divorce and the rule includ. prepubescent girls who are too young for menses , Pedo Muslims call them women bc even those pedos are too ashamed to call them children. chapter 65 verse 4 -
The Iddah of Those in Menopause and Those Who do not have Menses
Allah the Exalted clarifies the waiting period of the woman in menopause. And that is the one whose menstruation has stopped due to her older age. Her Iddah is three months instead of the three monthly cycles for those who menstruate.The same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation. Their Iddah is three months like those in menopause.....The same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation.
On the topic of the human rights of the Gulf countries, they are among safest countries in the world in part due to the punishments they doll out for the violation of someone's human rights. I would argue the privatized prison system is a greater violation of human rights.
From that perspective, they are rather safe. Not so much if you're a journalist or a critique of the royal family. Or both
You are right. The Gulfs are not worse regarding human rights. They just have different perspective than the west. Judging them based on how they treat journalists is incorrect because we ignore how certain societies will react when hearing certain news. In they west, people will not start a revolution eventhough their government is selling their country. Sarkozy could still peacefully having his breakfast when 1 million French demonstrated on the street. Soeharto was removed from his power with only less than 100 thousand demonstrans. If the people in the Gulf are as ignorant as the western people, high probably their government will not be much different than the western.
@@williambarylo Sure, I agree there, but those laws are not part of Sharia nor a part of Islam. There are restrictions on criticizing the ruler in Islam, but they are to prevent back-biting which leads to growing discontent and a rebellion against a ruler who isn't explicitly an apostate. The main goal there is to prevent Muslims from shedding the blood of other Muslims. If the ruler remains a Muslim but is otherwise a tyrant, then you shouldn't rebel for the greater good, which is peace despite the tyranny. Someone knowledgeable about the religion is allowed to criticize the ruler under the circumstance that it is done publicly and in a place and time where they ruler has an opportunity to immediately provide a defense for themselves. If you want, I can share a detailed and extensively cited lecture on this topic.
@@Yeah_I_Exist. Regarding rebellion, I know there are various opinions and again, every situation is different. Religion aside, what was done to Jamal Khashoggi was really extreme. No wonder no one wants to criticise them.
@@williambarylo I will say it again, I agree with you that what they have done with their handling of journalists and critics of their policies is extreme. Being a Muslim, as you are too to my understanding, my morality is derived from Islam. What they have done is immoral and unjust based on Islam's doctrine, thus these particular actions of theirs are immoral and unjust to me as well.
France always talks about human rights and freedom, but this is how they are. They don’t leave them alone in Middle East either.
Accurate.
oh people in middle east ( or islamic states in generally ) are not leaving their minorities alone either trust me XD so yes muslims are not poor innocent victims.
Minorities in there actually are often treated worse than in the west (slave labour, sex slavery: female porta potty slaves which they often recruit through instagram, no access to food/water etc). Qatar olympic stadium was pretty much built with slave labour without human rights + Dubai is also build with slaves and the slavery in there is still on going!
they sure love slavery and have difficulties to let go of their old, traditional practise!
hmm is there anything else to add oh right forgot to mention kids who are forced to ride camels in races they live in awful conditions and often die during races! :D
so yes muslims should look themselves in the mirror and watch how they treat THEIR minorities first before going in others countries start to demand special treatment
and how every non-muslim are racist.
عندما دخلت فرنسا الى الجزائر وجدت شعبا متحضرا متعلما ثم حولته خلال قرن من الزمن الى شعب جاهل ...استعمرته بشعار نشر الحضارة ...ولا يزالون لحد الان يعاملون هذه الشعوب بنفس الطريقة ...للعلم ايها الدكتور ان تعاليم الاسلام وفرائضه مثل الحجاب تعد اولوية عند المسلم من لائكية الدولة وعلمانيتها ...شكرا لك على مجهودك.
شكرًا لك!
Excellent video! I appreciate the knowledge and expertise and mastery of the craft shown in your analysis, i am Algerian and have friends and family members in France and i see the weight of the pressure put on them mentally by the french islamophobia, i have lived in Canada and experienced islamophobia and racism yet the french people i knew there regardless of their race or ethnicity or beliefs all told me that this is a ride in the park compared to france!
Damn! Yes I've heard Quebec is really going sideways. Ontario seems better but haven't lived there to see.
@@williambarylo i ve been to Ottawa but lived mostly between Laval and Montreal, and in ramadan for example in Laval as we prayed taraweeh a group of men and women would gather facing the mosque and put on the music and drink alcohol while shouting insults at us! That's one example lol. Ottawa was so much better when i visited it, nicer people cleaner streets, cheaper prices hahaha, anyways. Thanks for the reply
Oui la France ne veut pas devenir islamique. Pour vous c'est de l'islamophobie , mais vous êtes francophobe en voulant changer un pays car il ne correspond pas à votre vision islamique. Laissez la France etre française. Nous ne voulons pas vivre sous les lois islamiques.
You've said it all. Thank you for this complete analysis. I subscribe to your chanel right now. Muslims in France have also the feeling that they should not complain because, it could get worth. As a muslim woman, I m scared they could take my kids away from me for no reason just because I expressed my opinion towards those topics. This feeling is increasing I have to say. When french government (castaner as I remember) describe muslims terrorists, he, in fact, describe a practicing muslim for example : praying regularely and numerously, the dot on the forehead...
Us, french Muslims, could not believe what we were hearing !!! Something is really wrong and hate towards muslims makes some people blind.
Yes indeed. And in recent years it also happened to Jewish people who the judge found "too orthodox". This is scary
XD the hatred towards muslim? are you serious? oh the famous victim mentality... so let me ask you what you think
1. inbreeding ( cousin marriages )
2. child marriages
3. taqqiya
4. FGM
5. BACHA BAZI
opinions? and you wonder why people dislike islam? who would have thought people dislike inbreeding that is harming children and future population :O
who would have thought that people dislike liars who mislead people into death cult where is easy to join but people are discouraged to leave because of honor killings?
who would have thought that people prefer peaceful environment and not environment where youre not sure who is nice and who potentially harass, rape or kill you + your kids?
WOW so odd that people prefer safety! :O
MaashaaAllah. Very informative as usual. Jazaakallaah khairan for freely giving out your knowledge. May Allah increase you in goodness and knowledge and bless you and your family and protect you all from every harm. Aameen.
Ameen. Thank you
@@williambarylo To be more accurate and be credible, France bans all religious signs in public schools and public governmental offices. That is the French law based on her secular constitution. Any one wants to break the law, is betrayder and should be detained. "What is so difficult for mu slims to understand?
@@laylamajdi6620 Exactly, just like Iran, Saudi and Afghanistan impose a dress code on women based on their religious constitution. When people break the law, they get detained, and the authorities say: "What is so difficult for Muslims to understand"?
@@williambarylo France is a western country, and in that country the values, the concept of freedom refers to being free from all religious ideology
@@adrianfelipelopezbaltodano7902 the state is, in theory, free from religious authorities since 1905. On the other end, the UK is another western country but has a state religion. In Denmark, Austria, Switzerland, Germany, Finland and Sweden, all citizens regardless of their beliefs, still pay a "church tax". Even if they don't believe in anything.
So spot on ! I lived in France for 23 years and left in 2005 after the introduction of the law against hijab. I moved to London and that was the best decision ever. I live my faith openly and happily and it has never caused me any issues in my professional career . It’s so sad to see my native country dismiss such a huge part of their population’s heritage and culture . Islam is a beautiful religion for those who know . Thanks for sharing this video ❤
thank you! Good luck in the UK. It's been a tough journey for me (for other reasons). But happy to chat about it. I was wondering about making a video about French Muslim's experiences in the UK!
I agree but France are more “ conservative” and less LGBT 🏳️🌈. I prefere than California , or UK. But for business I préfère USA
"Those who love to see immorality spread among the believers-for them is a painful punishment, in this life and in the Hereafter. God knows, and you do not know." Sura Nur.
Thankfully there will be justice at some point indeed
☪️✡️ : those who love to see immorality spread among the Believers :✝️☦️
What is the connection of morality with abaya? Muslims are fighting over the big piece of cloth, like it is something sacral! God requires a modesty in appearance , and for that you don’t need to put a big ugly sack on woman’s body. And please ,don’t quote an aya without knowledge, just because it’s literally suit to situation. As a Muslim I agree with French authorities , no abays at schools!
Muslims are. The most modest even according to other religious structures ❤️❤️❤️ perhaps that's why the Jews and Christians jealous of them and try theiir best to make it impossible for anyone to be moral in their countries.
@@abirhossain183 Lol! Muslims are into 7th Century fancy dress, yes; and it does make me a Christian, wanna dress up like a Visigoth, bruh! But does dressing up like someone's great-great grandmother - or as a ninja-witch - really mean modesty? especially if she's walking 1 meter behind her Abdool who dresses like a pimp?
As a Northern African muslim who used to live in France and now lives in Poland, I highly recommend everyone your analysis on these topics, dziękuję bardzo za analizę, ale wolę powiedzieć Jazaka Allahu Khayran
Thank you!
Salam bro, how's it over there? Aren't they right wing? Against immigration and stuff..?
how are you in poland rn, i heard they were extremely against muslims and stuff
France is à very open mind country. French respect all religions. We just ask youth to be not religious only at school.
I love France so much!!!!
@@riazdoby1445 French people are, in general, open minded. The government much less, and very disconnected from its citizens in general.
Ils existent plusieurs raisons à ce comportement de la majorité des français vis à vis de l'islam et surtout des musulmans:
- une haine ancestrale des musulmans transmise de génération en génération et qui remonte aux croisades.
- une différence des cultures.
- le comportement ou les comportements de certaines personnes cataloguées ou qui se revendiquent comme musulmanes.
- une méconnaissance de la religion musulmane.
- la colonisation des pays musulmans.
- les différents attentats revendiqués par des prétendus musulmans
- le tapage médiatique incessant par la presse de droite ou de l'extrême droite contre l'islam et les musulmans.
- utilisation des musulmans et de l'islam comme bouc- émissaire par les politiciens pour détourner l'intention de la population des échecs et de la mauvaise gestion du pays.
- et bien d'autres........
Bien vu!
"l attention"
tout est dit
Le comportement de personnes aui se trouvent être muslim c'est des conneries pour moi, c'est comme si tu détestais les chrétiens à cause des prêtres pédocriminels
@@JoJoboiWav Bien vu!
What do French feminists say to all that please? Do French feminists give any agency to Muslim women or they rather choose to rescue them on secular terms?
Here's the irony. All of them are suddenly silent when it comes to Muslim women!
@@williambarylo peculiar…well, better to avoid the danger of women wanting such an uncomfortable thing as the ability to live the way they choose to.
If feminists ignore their own moto ( her body her choice) and want Muslim women to be forced to uncover for alleged health and freedom; why they don’t force other women not to wear the unhealthy high heels and toxic makeup products and do dangerous plastic surgeries for beauty sake..
@@nisahmed9121 well said
french feminists don't say anything when a woman is victim of Islamism: women harassment, murder by fire they say anything
Thank you for this! So refreshing to see somebody talking sense and breaking down the hypocrises and subversion of power to create the 'Muslim enemy'. Your description of the French being scammed is so insightful, I've always felt this obsession with secularism is contradictory to human rights and something the French elite have costructed quite sinisterly. Amazing video!
thank you!
Can the French go any lower or they have reached the bottom already
It's worse than going lower. It's going nowhere
LoL
Of course the Abaya would be worn by girls with developed bodies..teenagers!! That is the point of it. This being a deal to the French or others is crazy!! Thank You🌸
French politics is full of paradoxes
Islam is not dependent on a certain type of “uniform” yet it asks both men and women to have modest dressing. Clothes are more of a cultural/regional thing than religious and Abaya in particular is typically Arab dressing. I don’t understand why people can’t understand the simple fact that Islam is not confined to abaya or a particular dressing. Modesty can be practiced in many ways
Yes
fact is that in political islam the difference how muslims dress compared to westerners .. there is a meaning behind it: to spot who is "us " and who is " infidel". No matter how much muslim try to twist this as long as islamic states wont change their laws ( separate religion and politics from each others ) the conquest of attempting to revive ottoman will continue by islamists whenever you like or agree with it yourself or not
you should check history for example what happened to iran after islamic revolution. Did you knew that before the revolution they lived like other europeans? until muslims took power and replaced shaira there they DESTROYED womens lives there. Go and check it OUT
if thats so then why muslims have so hard time to accept western modest clothes? ( and no I dont mean mini skirts or bikini etc ) mean hoodies, long pants etc that cover skin
@@pastelmoon9118 that’s so unfortunate. I can only tell about immigrants who have left their land but have hard time leaving their culture and accepting the culture of land they migrated to. Not sure about the natives converted to Islam
if they are not dependent on any specific clothing as long as its modest then why they demand muslim clothes or throw tantrums when they banned some clothes anyways? why not use european clothes? there are a lot options to choose that are not showing skin. it Shouldnt be that big deal to you if there is chance for modest clothes
The haters' efforts to promote your channel worked! I found your channel and subscribed. Great analysis and thank you for stating the facts!
Yayyy! Thank you!
Calling someone a hater or a racist doesn't have all end the conversation, it just shows that you have no counters and that you have reached your maturity boundary
My dear Ex Muslims, let’s gather together and rebut this man and defenders of anti-women practices!
I think everyone should join the fight, not only Ex Muslims
In France, the government do not prohibit the abaya but they prohibit purity
In 🇺🇸 this would be considered as an infringement of the first amendment !
The French think they've invented democracy and human rights first
me looking for non french people that love france is like me looking for 13 yo that are not edgy 💀
French politics are just so trash
@@williambarylocompared to what other politics .North African , Eastern European maybe Middle Eastern or Turkish 😂 France is still a Damn site better
@@PoldarkGodzilla True. Even better than some other European countries
@@williambarylo❤❤❤❤mochas gracias
@@williambarylobecause of african wealth they steal.
I keep seeing people liking and praising the law but Alhamdulilah people like you come out saying this. Thank you truly may Allah protect you from evil, guide you to the most righteous path, and grant you the highest level in paradise.
thank you. Ameen. There are also non Muslims in France who disagree with the law because they know they're being lied to
@@williambarylomost non muslims seems to agree. But younger french look on our side tho.
kkkkkkk Allah makes me puke Allah allows child marriage and sxx with children chapter 65 verse 4 -
The Iddah of Those in Menopause and Those Who do not have Menses
Allah the Exalted clarifies the waiting period of the woman in menopause. And that is the one whose menstruation has stopped due to her older age. Her Iddah is three months instead of the three monthly cycles for those who menstruate.The same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation. Their Iddah is three months like those in menopause.....The same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation.
yes in paradise to fuck virgins and drink alcohol
Je suis Français de confession musulman et je peux vous garantir que la vie ici est de plus en plus dure...
Ca m'attriste d'entendre ça. Je prie que vous trouvez les bonnes personnes autour de vous qui vous rendront la vie moins difficile
❤❤❤❤ mochas gracias hermano desde hoy me he inscrito en tu canal y lo recomendaré a mis amigos
Gracias hermano
Just came across this amazing channel, amazing content ❤
Thank you!
France is literally the Only-Place I've ever been that I regret going.
France treats its minorities horribly however, French Muslims are amongst the most supportive and welcoming Muslims I've ever met. That's one aspect I miss after moving to the UK.
@@williambaryloyou are a lier. Les français n'aiment pas le communautarisme. C'est leur droit. Tout pour l'individu. Rien pour la communauté.
@@thegezmarin7376 Les Musulmans Français sont beaucoup plus chaleureux et solidaires que les Musulmans dans d'autres parties du monde. Je pense que parce que beaucoup ont été influencé par la culture Française qui est une culture conviviale (à l'opposé du royaume uni, allemagne, etc qui sont très individualistes). La problème est que pendant que les politiciens s'attaquent aux gens dans les barres HLM, la France déroule le tapis rouge à l'Arabie Saoudite, qui finance la propagation de l'extrémisme religieux dans les mosquées française.
@@williambarylo oui ça c'est vrai.
What a great insightful analysis! Looking forward to hear more from you, Dr Barylo.
thank you, much appreciated!
I shared your video with french muslims and told them its translated to french (they usually dont speak English)
I've done a video in French on a similar angle some time ago th-cam.com/video/stZcPhuk988/w-d-xo.htmlsi=ibRdPeK2fF9qwC81
Africa and Islam are taking over France slowly but surely, check the birth rate and also check how 70% of all “ white “ French have some African blood in their DNA !
This is whyAncestral DNA tests are banned in France !
Hahahah , All France is already African!
Thank you for your contest! Great Analyse
Thank you!
Long dresses are not allowed but short dresses are....
Very good culture..
Exactly
in Indonesia I see hijab and without hijab women every day and I don't care, the thing that needs to be known is mostly they start wearing the hijab when they no longer need beauty validation from other people for example because they are married or aging and sure because "i respect my religion, its my time to wear this", as a man I see women wearing hijab still attractive, the difference is I can't fantasize about their bodies and I really respect their motherly nature contrary to western culture which is like "show your pretty skin"
what I don't like is the some of westener dont know and dont want to know anything but want to teach us how muslim should treat women
so how to treat woman, should i go to p*rnhub or what? 🤔lmao
why france not ban wearing bikini in church or doin sex in public, its disgusting, just save your kid save ur generation save ur country
It looks like in countries with multiple cultures for a long time, people are able to understand that there's no political agenda and only people going on with their lives
We Muslims young or old wear hijab and modest attire because our creator ordained in the holy Qur'an and we are adhering to Gods law!! We dont put it on because of pressure or because we are getting old what nonsense 😂 you say!!
@@rab251tawaquf, read again... There are many scholarly views on hijab and the most common is covering the aurat except the hands and face, the most important thing is how the hijab inside and out is in sync, hijab over consciousness is better than forced, many young people wear hijab but they get drunk and dancing on TikTok, it's useless And also I'm not talking wrong or right, I'm just talking about reality in our lives
@@Pram4 true and valid openion, the root of the problem is not teaching the kids the real reasons for wearing hijab
I was blessed by being born in a religious family, i went to masajid and religious youth clubs to memorize quraan, and i was taught the real reason why we wear hijab, its our creator order, we follow and obay, its makes more protected, but not fully, hijab has an etiquet, its not just a fashion choice, its a life style of modesty and haya'a
you are in western world if youre migrant you need to adapt to their ways they dont need to change their laws for you. Islamic states never did that either to their minorities and in fact they treat them the worst far more worse than europeans. so yes:
no special treatment you adapt or leave if you dont like their ways, Its so funny to see muslims complain awful " mistreatment " when...meanwhile in islamic states look what they do to chirstians, atheists, gays/lesbians XDD pfffff people seriously need to look at the actual places where there are STILL death penalties for so simple things as apostasy and just you happen to like the same gender and then they roleplay knight in shining armor in europe to fight for their freedoms... freedom of what? to force ladies under hijabs with laws?? XD
hypocrites
"why france not ban wearing bikini in church or doin sex in public, its disgusting, just save your kid save ur generation save ur country"
lols well for once agreeing with you.. wearing bikini in chruch is not appropriate never seen that myself but yes I dont live in france so could be there been such situations
sounds nasty if thats the case but about having s* in public... muslim men dont seem to be that shy about it for sexually assaulting westerners in public places right? : )
Thank you for your analysis Dr William.. greeting from Indonesia 🇮🇩 ... i m your fans now 😊😊
Thank you
JazakAllahuKhayr for the post
Thank you!
One of best childhood memories was in France. We were in Toulouse and me and my dad canoed over the Dordogne river. My family didnt wear muslim clothes but I do now and wanted to bring my kids to the same place but I rather travel somewhere else now because of this going on.
Sadly, you never know whether people wouldn't mind or call the 17
Very informative and well presented. Thanks
thank you!
Great content! God bless!
thank you!
Next time French MP criticise Iranian draconian rule on wearing headscarfs and dictation what women must wear, they need a look in the mirror
exactly
Wael Hallaq vindicated every day with his quote: "Let us remember what secularism is. Secularism is not just segregating religious life into the private sphere. It is rather the determination of the state of what religion is and is not, where and how it can be exercised. In terms of political theology, secularism is the murder of God by the State. The state can delimit, limit, exclude or curtail any religious practice, and thus has the power to determine the quality and quantity of the religious sphere as it sees fit."
Very accurate!
Truly appreciate your analysis. Great video.
Subscribed.
Thank you!
To be more accurate and be credible, France bans all religious signs in public schools and public governmental offices. That is the French law based on her secular constitution. Any one wants to break the law, is betrayder and should be detained. "What is so difficult for mu slims to understand?
Ditto
I support France,,,,,In India we also want to ban burqa... France has guts to do it... I love him
Hello Modi!
You love him lol🤣
You resemble a swine too just like the French
France and India same fight ✊✊
@@rowenn1729 And China. Actually China is the only one who does what everybody wants to do but nobody dares: sending Muslims to concentration camps.
Perhaps France needs to leave all its ex-colonies in Africa... Especially the 14 African countries it still influences.... And they need to get over themselves.
yes!
Even though I am muslim, I believe People should respect where they are
Don't say that to Muslims in China, I'm not sure they will agree
@@williambarylo Though there are Muslim communities other than Uighurs
@@naveedhasan5365 I think respect applies when the state respects you. Treating citizens differently because of their beliefs or ethnicity is not really respect
So if where u r say u should walk naked so u will.
@@williambarylo most of them are propaganda I believe. Of course they use to prosecute not just Muslims but others too. Kashgar is right next to afghanistan and Pakistan so have to be strict. On the other hand hui Muslims are pretty okay. Now I don’t live in kashgar so I couldn’t tell you.
You are doing a great job. Many thanks.
Thank you
Il faudra peut être envisager de faire plus de vidéos en français pour le public français.
@@williambarylo you are more than welcome
@@donomar4815 Je suis ouvert à toute suggestion! Sur quels sujets en particuliers?
@@williambarylo il y en a tellement, si un sujet pertinent me vient à l'esprit je me ferai un plaisir de te le proposer. Ta conférence sur le système technicien et le musulman performant était superbe.
I was born in France, I’m Catholic, half Lebanese, and from what I am learning by following Mufti Menk on Instagram and TH-cam, I believe Islam is a good religion.
I think the problem in France is that the people from North African background have always been treated badly by the French due to the war of Algerian independence who didn’t end well for the French. From the last 3 generations, there were an accumulation of frustration from both side and, clearly we created so much frustration and exclusion towards Algerians that now we have to deal people who fell excluded and clearly hate France. I have the impression that many of them leaving in poor suburbs choose the religion as a tool of provocation and rebellion. Now it’s out of control, so I understand French have to put a stop on it by creating these laws.
Quite right. However, I don't think religion is used as a tool for provocation and rebellion - the vast majority of French Muslims, like elsewhere on the planet don't fully understand or follow religion and adopt mainly a cultural identity claimed to be religious. North Africans in France know that adopting certain clothing is shooting themselves in the foot, it is for most a very personal issue. It can be in certain case rebellion against their (not very religious) parents at most. In France, when people from the banlieue want to provoke and rebel, they burn cars.
And isn't a lot of the disgusting misogyny of the banlieues rooted less in Islam and more in black American ghetto culture?
@@williambarylo Over 95% of french muslims are not actually french, they are immigrants from Affrica, Turkey and other non-white countries. Converts are roughly estimated to be 100000-150000 overall.
What about Sikh men, they wear a tulband,and a face mask, is just like niqab, you cover your Face and nose😂😅
@@bibisalarbux6357 If you have a consistent Sikh population in your contry, your at risk of diplomatic incidents because
of Sikh nationalists wanting an independant state referred as "Khalistan" made on northern India several states.
Don’t come here on France if they don’t integrate French culture,that is only solution.It is not French citizens to adjust for coming immigrants.It’s too much freedom for immigrants.What about French citizens ,we have rights to choose who we like to live with us in our country.
the problem is that is that French citizens are not even able to make their own decisions. The 49.3 shows us who really decides on all matters.
indeed like come on... as if islamic states would listen what minorities want right? they will continue their traditions anyways
why France should change their ways then?
Your explanation of this topic is on point.
May Allah bless you.
Thank you! Ameen
Well French have full reason to ban any dress which they find inappropriate...
If only they would apply the same rule for everybody
Jazakallah kheir for a very balanced and informative talk on the situation there. When I read of the ban on the abayas in school, my first thought was : if Christian Dior or Givenchy et al decide that long dresses are the order of the day, will the ban still apply? or will it only apply to those girls with 'duskier' skins or Arabic sounding names? I agree completely that it's more of the right wing, liberal narrative that is gaining traction globally and one wonders why? Is it related to the spread of access to the media? Is it a monster than has always been there, simply stepping out of the darkness called the WEF? and backed by BIll Gates et al? Are we all locked into the scariest Hollywood movie? It's time to have our eyes well and truly open, brother .... Shukran jazeelan - a Scot living in the Gulf :(
Thank you. It's scary indeed
Q. If Christian Dior converted to Muslim Dior, what would his new advertising slogan be?
A. "J'adore Chador!"
@@GCarty80 that would be a hell of marketing strategy
@@williambarylo- an excellent video. Bravo for such a clear-cut explanation.
m m m big deal Allah allows child marriage and sxx with children chapter 65 verse 4 -
The Iddah of Those in Menopause and Those Who do not have Menses
Allah the Exalted clarifies the waiting period of the woman in menopause. And that is the one whose menstruation has stopped due to her older age. Her Iddah is three months instead of the three monthly cycles for those who menstruate.The same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation. Their Iddah is three months like those in menopause.....The same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation.
Very interesting, thanks you so much for your brilliant explanation.
Thank you!
A question for William BARYLO, if as you stated Abaya does not hold any kind of religious significance then why banning Abayas would be Anti Muslim and why putting in the title that "France hates poor Muslims"? Since Abaya is not a Muslim clothing...It doesn't add up to me.
Abaya is not a religious clothing means it's never mentioned in the religious texts. Muslims can shop modest fashion at uniqlo. However, the Abaya is exclusively worn by certain Muslims following a certain culture. When France targets the abaya, it doesn't target any other people but these Muslims. Just like if it was to ban the shtreimel. It is not in Jewish religious texts, but everyone would know that it targets the Jews because it's the only people wearing shtreimels.
YES...BUT "Laïcité" does not only ban religious clothes, It also ban "signes de reconnaissance et d'appartenance" so Abaya fit this criteria since "it is exclusively worn by Muslims" as YOU stated and that's the gouvernment main point.
@@Thallakar ...which is subject to interpretation by the authorities. Hence the controversies since 2012 about all sorts of long dresses or even kimonos. There is no textual proof that long dresses are used a symbol of religion or belonging - it is down to the person's intentions or, when impossible to know, the holder of authority has to decide when to send the person back home.
Yes but Laïcité does not care about textual proof, just about facts. It's about showing "signes of appartenance". They don't want you to show any signs that show tour faith. Pretending that Abaya is not AT all is hypocrit.
@@Thallakar How does a kimono factually relates to any religion?
Je suis marocaine, je ne réside pas en France, je suis voilée et le seul pays où je me sens en insécurité est la France. Ils ont un sérieux problème avec l islam est les musulmans et spécialement le port du voile.
En Espagne par exemple, on ne sent pas cette tension ...il suffit de voir les médias français ..
La France est vraiment une exception avec leur radicalisme anti-Musulman
@@williambaryloc'est pas du radicalisme anti musulmans. La loi est la même pour tout le monde. Ce sont les musulmans qui ont un problème avec notre laïcité. La loi sur la laïcité dans nos institutions date de 1905. Les musulmans sont arrivés après, ce sont eux qui veulent afficher leur religion à l'école. Parce que en dehors ils font ce qu'ils veulent. Tu le dis ça dans ta vidéo ??
@@thegezmarin7376 Les travaux de l'historien Emile Poulat démontre que ce que les politiciens utilisent n'est pas la loi de 1905. Durant les débats, certains voulaient bannir la soutane dans l'espace public pour les même raisons que le voile a été interdit en 2004. L'assemblée avait rejeté l'interdiction de la soutane des prêtres dans l'espace public disant que les vêtements religieux n'ont aucune valeur aux yeux de la République (voir liens dans la description).
les musulmans savent être les victimes apparentes tout en faisant des trous de partout dans la société. si les musulmans sont si mal en France pourquoi fuient ils par milliers leurs pays pour la France ???
Great content Dr. I find this issue is very confusing.
Thank you. It is indeed very confusing
There was never a 9/11 (Inside Job) in France so has to demographic disparity (Threat) which is causing all this. Many know Muslims breed well. They usually have more than 2 or 3 kids rich or poor.
Thanks that you’re so open too new ideas and actually rethink stuffs it really helped me understand as a Muslim outside off France what they are thinking there
Ummm, that's quite old ideas but thank you!
@@williambarylo lol u welcome :D
sadly im strongly againts muslim`s clothing in western world why? because:
- even if the muslim invidual is good person, dont wish violence to others and dont harass others... every single muslim in population are still a tools for islamists and political islam
- think about and check in history how islam conquered countries and forced them under islamic laws: through birth rates, westerner women`s wombs are the war zone. Thats why religion push the idea to get as many kids as they can to grow their % of the population so they can start to vote MUSLIMS in power, closer to important roles in society. Once there are enough muslims to vote right people... they will start to cancel/bann the laws what the current states has what is againts shaira laws. ( check iran`s islamic revolution )
also it is a way to keep people poor: more people, more poverty... and what poverty gives for the islamic and also western elite? opportunities to practise pedofilia and for islamic elite/rich their mostly banned tradition: dancing boys. Yes it is mostly forbidden but it is still practised behind the scenes among rich who can buy themselves out of trouble
so yes I highly support that we have 0 tolerance to special treatment. Same laws and rules for everyone. Not:
" rules for you but not for meee! I need for my own laws that differs from this country`s laws! " mentality.. soon we will have anarchy where everyone do whatever they pleace...
if they have the coin
look islamic states! how often muslims gave special treatment to THEIR MINORITIES? once we bring these up you are right away being called " ISLAMOPHOBEEEE" or "RACIIIST"
sadly nope you cant be racist towards muslims since:
1. muslim is not a race, anyone whatever the race can convert and believe in islam
2. being realist and checking facts about both sides is not racist
3. I see so much 2 faced moral with this muslim topic and once someone bring up how minorities are treated in
islamic states lol the immaturity with the answers is hilarious.
4. before someone start " b-but in western world this current transgender/nudity-" yes I dislike it too I dont like how
its being pushed on people but its political movement somebody try to manipulate us and wonder for what
it is our personal responsibility to keep ourselves out of bad influence so my advice: if you dont like
something or dont like someone`s company you can always walk away.
5. So yes I walk away from muslims because I dislike how you claim how peaceful and wonderful religion you have but when someone bring up
issues with a lot evidence what happens in islamic states where your lovely religion laws are:
people keep dying
sexually harassed,
women beaten up just because they dont wear hijab right.. in iran there are now a lot people on the streets with anger and hatred towards their muslim leaders yelling " death to dictator!"
" FIGHT,WOMEN, FREEDOM", youngsters rebelling with posting videos of doing things whats againts islamic laws such as taking off hijabs, eating pork etc these can be seen on tiktok/instagram. Some even protest with not wearing hijabs at all in public, some get arrested and violently beaten up but ofc so many do this that police cant catch everyone.
burning hijabs and taking them off as a symbol of fighting for women`s freedom..
and what kind of brain farts we see in france or europe?! I am ashamed since this topic " we must have right to wear these " or worse " hijab day " is absolute INSULT to
those women who are fighting for their lives in there. literally shitting on their face... and meanwhile there are some IDIOTS who demand the same, oppressive, violent
environment for women HERE. it makes me ANGRY!! I never accept or tolerate these fucked up ideas
when I bring these subjects up
the muslim I have met and had this convo couldnt stand 1 single criticism from their religion without throwing
tantrums and insults at me once they no longer couldnt disprove the facts I gave. when they no longer couldnt disprove or
try to twist truths " ISLAMOPHOBIC" "RACIST " " INFIDEL " tantrum start.
so yes I dont like to be around with people who are unable to be realistic with subjects and stay with facts whatever is it uncomfortable
or not. Talking about difficult subject without getting violent is a sign of maturity which sadly... havent seen much in muslims so far
6. Immigration should stop in generally and let all countries to focus to help their own people. Immigration can be good if well organized but the politics around it brought mostly just trouble for everyone.. and specially France politicians fucked it up
Historically, Most Christian-Crusaders were Frenchmen.
true!
Frenchmen were the only brave men to defend the pilgrims
French public schools bans religious attire, period 😁
I think they should ban ostentatious designer brands
@@williambarylo the uniform is on the way
@@williambarylo France will not be eaten so easily
@@rowenn1729 That could be a good idea
@@rowenn1729it's already have been eaten...french people have destroyed their identity and culture and have become so weak to the point that they are getting out of every part of Africa or so called ex colonies and have become weak in the world political table as their opinion doesn't hold any weight.. and after every failure french elite fool scumbags like you by driving their attention by these moves... it's actually funny when I see the fools themselves thinking somehow they are smart when they are being driven like donkeys 😂
Love this. This channel is only growing
Thank you!
Forcing little girls to ware mini skirts….so this is modernism🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤡
Indeed
******SOON MOTHER MARY'S HIJAB PORTRAITS
TO BE REPLACED WITH (astaghfirullah) !!!!!!******
Exactly
The "Great Replacement" conspiracy theory first emerged in France, and it wouldn't surprise me if a lot of French people fear the hijab and abaya precisely because they recall that age-old icon of motherhood that is Mary, and foments fear that Muslims are seeking to "out-breed" the secular French population.
Les français ne détestent pas les musulmans. Nous avons une tradition de laïcité dans nos institutions. C'est la neutralité religieuse. Tu es élève, professeur, policier, président....je ne veux pas connaître ta religion. La religion on garde ça pour la sphère privée en France. Chers amis anglais ou américain ou australien, si vous ne comprenez pas ça, c'est pas grave. Chez nous c'est comme ça depuis 120ans.
OK, so you have been a bunch of hypocrites for the last 120 years, intersting.
I'm commenting to boost visibility, this issue needs to be addressed!!
thank you!
Agreed with almost all you said.
Your only error was mentioning both Iran and Pakistan as nuclear powers.
Pakistan is the only Muslim-majority country to possess nuclear weapons. Iran does NOT possess nuclear weapons..At least not yet.
Please make a video about Geert Wilders' victory in the Netherlands elections, how he won using Islamophobia as the election issue.
You are always representing something with your clothing.
So it is ok to represent liberalism and secular values at school but not conservative values.
I don’t understand why grown men are so demanding when it comes to seeing girls and women’s hair and legs.
Very accurate observation!
Do you have any evidence that men are more likely than women to support banning Islamic dress?
The assassination on Samuel Paty in Oct. 2020 (a French teacher whose fault was to teach laicite in a public school) is only the last of a very long list of terror attacks in the name of the Coran. The fact that you omit mentionning this French trauma tells a lot.
Since 9/11, the world has been traumatised. The problem is that banning clothes and bombing countries has not ended these acts of violence - meaning that there must be a more effective solution to be found.
So banning women from wearing their modest dress. Is aa way for punishing the Muslim women for some random terror attack?
@@abirhossain183 Dear Hossain, as long as muslims will continue refusing to ask themselves why the Coran is by far terrorists' preferred book, we won't agree on anything. Today the Coran inspires more terrorists than Mein Kampf.
very accurate comment
he is cherry picking to whitewash the crimes of islam, its funny hiw he mentions pakistan but forgets to point out that, all the non muslims in pakistan are living a miserable life there, either they are forced to convert or they killed and raped(pls read the recent attacks on christans there). in 1947 the population of non muslims in pakistan was 24% and now less than 3%, this data says a lot, but liars and deceivors like tnis guy will defend it by saying that everybody accepts islam coz its so great. to lie , cheat and deceive in order to defend islam is written in quran by the pedo mohammad. shame on you for lying and making this propaganda video.
Une vidéo qui regorge d'informations et d'idées intéressantes, je viens de découvrir votre chaîne (nouvelle abonnée). Je tiens à ajouter à ce que vous dîtes que nombreuses personnes qui sont à la base islamophobes, se réjouissent de ce débat pour exprimer leur non acceptation des tenues "musulmanes" dans le paysage de leur pays, proposants aux musulmans de rentrer dans leurs pays (ce qui serait impossible pour certains vu qu'ils sont français de souche). Qu'en pensez-vous Dr Barylo?
Merci. Effectivement, je pense le débat de l'abaya est un prétexte. Techniquement, bannir toute tenue "Musulmane" voudrait dire bannir toute la gamme de chez Uniqlo. Ici, c'est un ciblage explicite des maghrébins qui, dans l'imaginaire collectif, n'ont rien à faire sur le territoire (même s'ils ne parlent plus la langue de leurs ancêtres ou ne sont pas Musulmans). Le problème est que le public ne parvient pas à voir le double jeu de l'Etat; qui se présente comme ferme défenseur des libertés à l'encontre de ses propres citoyens sans grand pouvoir (pour cacher des problèmes réels), mais parfaitement ouvert aux dictateurs du golfe et à leur argent, qui tuent des journalistes et violent les droits humains. Le Grand Remplacement, ce n'est pas par les Musulmans, c'est quand l'Etat a remplacé ses citoyens par le signe € sur les têtes de chacun.
Very informative...rhank you
thank you!
Good job France
And yet they roll out the red carpet to Saudi Arabia...
What is good about that
@@lamingassama4474 I think it's sarcasm. France is renowned internationally for ridiculing itself with its anti-Muslim laws.
jeanbauberotlaicite.blogspirit.com/archive/2005/12/28/la-laicite-vue-de-l-etranger.html
Do you like looking at scantly dressed underage girls?
@@lamingassama4474 you have onlyfan
We teach in our high school that girls have the same right than boys. We don’t teach that they should cover because they are girls. If it is an issue I recommend to leave France and to go in Iran or Afghanistan. It is as simple as that. When in Rome…….
What if France taught freedom and democracy instead of copying Iran and Afghanistan?
@@williambarylo that is what France has been doing for 230 years. You can wear an abaya wherever you want but not in high school. It is the same for the other religions. You can be a Muslim without wearing an abaya. In fact you have millions of women who are Muslim and who don’t wear an abaya. You can be whatever you want. Jew, Christian, Buddhist etc…But when you are in a high school you are and foremost a student. Nothing less nothing more. There is no difference whether you are a boy or a girl. You are just a student.
@@leonidasthermopylae3378 yeah no difference between a girl or a boy, you can also identify as a cat now
@@williambarylo certainly no difference when it comes to education. You and I have a different opinion. You consider that girls are inferior to boys and should cover. I don’t.
Typical troll comment. Telling discriminated people elsewhere while pretending to care about human rights. You’re not in “Rome” which was autocratic bloody empire, nor are you living in the colonial era, fool.
It’s not a small white world where you impose your racist and secular delusions on others, hypocrite.
Gulf countries should stop visas for france and kick out french products
The political alliance between France and the Gulf is way too strong
Like this - " France lives in its colonial past ."
Indeed. Or I should have said the middle ages
Besides of the topic is interesting, i love his accent!
Oh no! But thank you
The most on point analysis on the situation about France I've ever watched great job.
Thank you. I'm sure there's better out there though! I'm just repeating other French academics!
Africa and Islam are taking over France slowly but surely, check the birth rate and also check how 70% of all “ white “ French have some African blood in their DNA !
This is whyAncestral DNA tests are banned in France !
Hahahah , All France is already African!
What I meant is where is the laicite when they receive those golf emirs and princes wearing turbans and Abaya at the elysee
They can't say no to them!
Zidane is Algerian Muslim.
Let that sink in Frenchies.
Sadly people don't care. Like Özil in Germany. German when he scores, Turk when he loses.
I have always wondered by France's secularism is nothing like that of US/Can/UK/Aus/Germany. France is really in a league of its own. A league of anti-religion in the name of secularism.
Question I ask, is the US not secular or less secular because they didn't follow France's lead ? Nope.
Great point
I'm a Muslim and there's a strict guidelines of what type of attire women should wear which is Niqab. That is compulsary and I see no problem with it, but shouldn't those people who've problem leave France and settle somewhere else? Perhaps they like France and the liberty it provides.
Not everyone is in a social or economic condition to do so, or can obtain work visa, or believe that the niqab is part of the religion
I wonder will you get beatings from your husband/relatives if you wont wear it
Just a small addition,where is the limited when French presidents and high dignitaries receive their golf kings emits and princes at the elysee palace.
exactly
Very interesting, thank you very much, I subscribed and will watch your videos from now on.
Djazakoum Allah kheer Dr.
Thank you
U R completely wrong.. you don't seem to realize that abayas are used to show and advertise islam in schools.. schools are for learning.. not for indirect proselytizing..
Incorrect. Read all the studies done on it by researchers since the early 20th century.
@@williambarylo , studies done by proislamists... like U.. not interested in reading those biased articles..
Hijab has been compulsory in many places in the world, for years ; uniforms is often the norm in many schools all around the world; why should France's ban on abayas in school be a problem ?
Some people feel it's denying rights just like imposing religious clothes like in Iran, Saudi and Afghanistan
@@williambarylo muslims dont seem to feel bad for denying rights for minorities though or for example burning chruches or people`s homes down or killing them because they are not muslims.. and here people complain about peace of clothing? at least heads are not dropping off here for now at least
how about ex muslims rights? who are protecting them from muslims who wants to kill them for apostasy? or girls who are in danger cause of honor killings?
is honor killing okay? what you think about ex muslims? did you ever heard them what happened and why?
"France being the champion of human rights" is such a joke on those in power in France.
They just care about money and votes
Great analysis !
thank you
Can’t wear long dresses because it’s a religious symbol.. what kind of freedom is this !
One girl was sent home for wearing a japanese kimono. Says it all
Why would a sane minded muslim would live in france or travel there for tourism or invest there.
Some people don't have much choice due to economic and social circumstances. Many leave or try to leave for Québec, Australia or Dubai. Some live a happier life. Some other struggle even more because life is harder with no family or support network.
Hi I am Algerian national I lived in UK of many years never that I encountered racism or discrimination
Now I live in France for few years and I can tell you France has become very prejudice towards Islam,Arabs Algerians Marocans yet France during ww2 France has called up on North Africans to free it from Nazi Germany
Indeed!
@@qudsiyahibrahim7023 yes it's vicious in the UK, you can check my latest video where i talk about it!
WHY THE FRENCH POLICE DONT WEAR SHORTS OR STRINGS ITS FRREDHOME RIGHT ? WHEN YOU PROHIBIT PEOPLESS WAYS TO DRESS IS IN THE SAME TIME IMPOSE A WAY TO DRESS
France is a country where even the police is mistreated and neglected by the government. No wonder why the situation is so insane
Amazing and very insightful.
Thank you!
France could potentially lose a lot of its international reputation in the near future, which doesn't bode well for its economy. And I am all for it, I would love to see its downfall!
Since 2004 these laws have described as nonsensical by many other countries. And because of many other factors, lots of young skilled and talented individuals just leave to countries like the UK, the US, Canada, Australia where they have more chances of getting hired
Just move away from France, leave Europe forever. You'll be happy
Very informative
Thank you
Don't you think that the event with Charlie Hebdo, Samuel Paty or the riot of july (wich led to burning city hall, police station, vandalize school) may play a role in the position of france toward muslims/islam? That maybe, the motivation is not hate, but rational fear? Some people love to talk about how peaceful and loving Islam is and " don't understand" the negative view France, or others may held. Weirdly enough, I still haven't heard of buddhist attack against france. or taoist. or jewish. or Zoroastrianism. or Sikh. Do I go on?
Their is certainly some hatred coming from french people. However, why everything always have to be black and white, victims against persecutors. I don't think that looking at those problems from only one lense will lead to any solutions, as it will never represent a reality close from the truth. Their is an old saying that said that it take two to tango. I think it can be applied here.
Believe it, believe it not, Half of my family are muslims and I love them. I live in a country where their is a lot of muslims. A lot of my coworker are muslims and I appreciate them. Still, I understand that french people are starting to fear Islam. Because their is a growing extremism within Islam and the peaceful muslims act like it is not a real problem and are doing nothing about it . A minority group wich held extreme view and a majority in denial of the potentiel treath that they may represent. Those it sound familiar ? What History have to say about that and the potential outcomes ?
Definitely, this is the same phenomenon that happened after 9/11. But again, 9/11 awakened fears already present since the Crusades. It is easier for the human mind to attribute these act to a culture/religion rather than complex political motives.... and the same happens in Asia and Africa. When people see Trump enacting a "Muslim Ban", brandishing the Bible, they believe that Trump represents the whole imaginary homogeneous "Western/Christian/Euro-American bloc". It takes effort to make people understand that single people or extreme movements or political parties don't represent the whole population/culture/country they claim representing. People can claim that Trump, terrorists, white supremacists, dictators etc, don't represent them, that they condemn them, are not associated with them and say "not in my name" "not my president"; but as we've seen East and West, it has little impact on people's mind. Russian people disassociating from Putin doesn't stop the spread of anti-Russian sentiment, especially in neighbouring countries like Poland. People should be able to discern that governments/parties/extreme groups do not represent anyone but themselves, even if they act in the name of God/the Country/the Nation etc... and therefore it is not the duty of ordinary citizens to condemn any hateful statement/action enacted by these people who claim to represent them (they are endless). Thankfully most people understand and this is why we are not in World War 3... yet.
France on Abaya: "how dare you?!"
France on public nudity: "😮😁"
I think if anything this makes an even bigger case for modest clothing. They're fine with you being lusted over but ready to revolt if they're not allowed to do so.
Exactly!
nobody tells you to wear bikinis on the street. You can wear modest clothes, your choice
It seems that the difficulty of giving up north African countries by France is being 'paid' to the people from those countries living in France
France was very happy to have workers rebuild the country but didn't think of the consequences
It also goes the other way. Why muslims hate kafirs but love to live in non muslim countries
Because there's no Muslim countries in the first place
yes in generally all countries now should start to mind their own business and focus on helping their own people through bad times
@@williambarylo likely cause they want to escape terror and violence what happens in middle east and also spread their religion
I love the sincere rational mind. May Allah guide you brother and give you everything good in this life and the next. Muslims appreciate those who are sincere and speak the truth even if it is against their own self.
Thank you inshaAllah Ameen
interested to ask do you agree with child marriages and inbreeding, forcing women to wear hijab/burkha by laws?...
@@williambarylo
@@pastelmoon9118 these are laws most of which come from Saudi and other dictatorial regimes and I believe these countries should be boycotted. But instead our governments roll out the red carpet to them because they're too scared of saying no to the Gulf. These are political and cultural things that nothing to do with any religion.
@@williambarylo sadly you are a bit naive about this but I am glad your reply. Everything what comes to incest/pedophilia makes my blood boil.
Worst crime what human can do to other human and sadly that is why Im 100% anti-islam. The religion is heavily connected to their laws in islamic states, tool to use muslims to conquer new lands ( even if some muslims dont want to or support it they will try to push their agendas anyways ) the way how politicial side of it use muslims and how islam caused suffering to others
so yes in that way muslims ARE victims
Id rather not see both sides to suffer..
It was not in 2004 but in 1989 that the French Islamophobic regime banned the hijab at school.
That's the year of the first time two girls were excluded from school. The actual law came in 2004
@@williambarylo Although in England, Canada and the United States and also in other European countries, it is different : it is forbidden to prevent a citizen from doing something that is not prohibited by law. So no school can prohibit a girl from wearing the veil at school in Canada, United Kingdom, United States, etc., while in France it is the practical ban which takes precedence, which is practiced and which is propagated by Islamophobic French politicians and public media in order to put the practical ban into writing, by law.
In France it is necessary to distinguish between official prohibition and unofficial prohibition. In France it's like this: they harass and prohibit in practice, then a few months or years later they prohibit by law. What matters is the practical prohibition which reflects the future legislative prohibition, because the prohibition in itself means: preventing the existence of a thing. Since 1980, the French media and French politicians have propagated the ban on the veil, leaving schools free to choose to do so, while continuing Islamophobic propaganda for 10 years (1989) so that more and more schools ban the wearing. of the veil. It's not just two girls in 1989 who were banned from wearing the veil at school, that's just the case of two isolated girls that the French media talked about, but there were plenty of them. others before 1989 and after 1989. The number of students wearing the veil and having suffered the practical ban in 1989 from wearing the veil at school did not stop increasing until the practical ban became a legislative ban in 2004.
@@kurulusosman7105 that's an interesting perspective! Thank you
@@williambarylo Please excuse me if my English is not fluent and clear, because I used an automatic translator, because I am not French but French-speaking Belgian, I lived several years in France (Roubaix) and my wife is French converted to Islam, then lived for several years on the border between Belgium and France. I often go to France. I know this country, France, well, which is a deeply racist and Islamophobic country, I share the same language as France.
Even the former French Minister of Foreign Affairs, Bernard Kouchner said : “France is racist” th-cam.com/video/cdhwMbWmxp0/w-d-xo.html
Former UK Home Secretary Priti Patel had declared : “France is a racist country” The Times, Sunday, August 16, 2020.
British journalist Adrian Hamilton said : “France is a deeply racist country” The Independent, Friday, March 23, 2012.
American political scientist, linguist and historian Noam Chomsky responded to an interview by saying : “It is the same with Islam in France. It's shocking. In the suburbs where North African population lives, the racism they face is astonishing. Interviewed by Turkish teacher Mine Gencel Bek, Ankara Üniversitesi İletişim Fakültesi, Gazetecilik Bölümü.
The UN and the European Court of Human Rights have already condemned France several times for racism and Islamophobia but the Islamophobic French state does not care. France has been run by Islamophobic and racist fanatics for 30 years and their public media are all Islamophobic and racist. Not a day goes by in France without the French public media harassing and lying about Islam and Muslims. From morning to evening, for 30 years.