@@joedavon3290 linkin parkj doesnt need a metal screamer , they needed a power vocalist which chester was , chester has not once screamed he always belted or yelled his message.
I agree the ones in this song work really well. The transitions also remind me a lot of the I Disagree album, with Concrete, Fill the Crown, and Bite Your Teeth having some pretty interesting heavy-to-pop and vice versa transitions.
@@Hewarya I love Nik's video's and was excited to watch this but he seemed overly critical of this tune. He said nothing was surprising but he literally was surprised and caught off guard by the first scream of the song. To each their own though. I respectfully disagree with him on this one. This song is a banger.
@@snakeeyes9246 I had to look it up, god the first half of november is full. I'm glad it's not only the week before, when both The Browning and Make Them Suffer come out on the 8th (and probably more)
There’s no pleasing the metal community at this point. When it’s proper metalcore, people asking for something different. When it’s weird and different, people saying it’s not proper metal. Hating for absolutely no reason. The song is a banger. Just say that and move on. Ain’t rocket science
literally poppy was a forerunner for experimental metal for a while and it didnt get her jack shit in return, so i understand the mainstream route shes taking this time. im happy either way i think shes killing it and negative spaces will be amazing.
This song may even be generally safe sonically for the metalcore scene. But it's not safe for Poppy. Her career still is 60% based and influenced by pop music bc of that her fan base does like pop music - just like Poppy (New Way Out is very pop influenced). In addition, you have industrial fans, her heavy stuff fans, etc, etc. All of her 6 albums have totally different sounds, and this has created a very diverse set of expectations of the public. I don't think she even cares about pleasing metalheads or anyone, but I don't think this can't be considered "safe" if we think about how amplified her audience is.
I love new way out. What it was missing was her drummer, Ralph Alexander. I hope we don't have Jordan's "machine gun drums" on every track. But yeah, NWO was like Britney x metalcore. Listen to the second verse, total britney spears vibe. It works really well!
tbh that's what i love about poppy fans. everyone has a different favourite song, and they aren't afraid to share their opinions on her music (except the mods on the discord server hah)
The only reason i think she might be playing it safe right now is that shes still not being accepted into the community after all of the "I'm poppy" years. idk. Im super digging it. its still WAY different from pre workformhome era....
Who is not accepting her? I'm confused. Also, what IS playing safe with her? 6th album and 6th time its something very different from everything she has done previously
@@nettlecider we all know there's those gate keepers who will never accept her or give her credibility. Unfortunately they are some of the loudest. I personally don't find it safe. It's fun, it's hard as shit with catchy as hell melody and chorus. But a lot of reactions have called it safe. Idk. I've always dug her so I might not be the best to judge.
I'm hoping the Knocked Loose feature helped to give her some of the acceptance she definitely deserves and has more than earned. Is there any reason other than gatekeepers being shitheads for her to not be accepted? I genuinely don't know and haven't heard of her doing anything reprehensible.
@@chasm9557 not that i know of. maybe some are just to scared to admit they like her. like they are closet fans. but we all have those artists that we will say we dont like, but once we are in out cars alone we all belt out like no one is listening.
@@chasm9557 well if talking 'contraversial' - back in her early youtube days and doing first dabbles in music - her persona was a carbon coppy of Mars Argo, a girl who worked with at the time Poppy's sorta manager guy or smth. Margo felt like her whole image was stolen and that guy was a shady mothaf* himself, but since Poppy left him he got cancelled and she started making music she wants. Also talked about his abuse etc. I know that there are still some people who for some reason consider everything HER fault and not his. Sadly, I think it costed her points for positive exposure in general but this has all been happening pre-metal era. So its weird reading comments about her not being accepted when old fans actuallh see her as finally accepted since her move to heavier stuff
It sounds exactly like a song would sound if it was produced by Jordan Fish of BMTH, and featuring songwriting by Knocked Loose. Pissed Metalcore to its finest.
I love this song. It fucking rules so much. From Poppy's passionate screams to her beautiful singing voice along with those driving guitars and drums. Goddamn. My song of the year by a lot.
I’m honestly surprised at how many people think this is her “first metal” song. Has nobody heard her album “I Disagree” that was a big middle finger to everyone who labeled her? Her song “Scary Mask” she collabed on with Fever333 was also HEAVY. Or even her recent song “Spit”. As a huge Poppy guy, y’all have homework to do lmao 😂
Apparently he covered Scary Mask and shit over it (people commented on it). I remember him covering Concrete. Even before then I remember X going around. Not sure why everyone is acting like she only started doing metal.
I think her marketing is pretty good by releasing these safer songs that will appeal to a wider audience first. The album will probably have heavier or more experimental sounds in it that may not appeal as much to broader listeners.
Ever since she sunk the Titanic Sinclair, Poppy has been poppin' off. I'm really happy for her getting away from that freak show and doing her own thing.
@@drengoa8435 haha yeah, there’s her TH-cam videos, but then if you check out her music, she has gone back and forth between pop and metal quite a bit, starting with a couple of tracks on her Am I A Girl album. Quite a few on I Disagree and her EAT EP. Her cover of Spit is great too!
@@oaktowndimond668Nik hates poppy so much she doesn't even get on the main channel bro, I've started noticing this lately, he pushes bands he personally likes, that's no journalism as he claims to be lately, he's extremely biased, if you're will Ramos, sleep token or spiritbox hell promote and push the shit outta ya, if not he'll tear you apart lately
i think part of poppys style is abrupt transitions , thats her whole vibe no matter the genre pop , indie , rock , metal , edm , it is just abrupt switch up to anything
Her vocals give me that raw IOWA kind of vibe and the song structure made me think of the new darko album. Those hard cuts from aggressive verse to clean lofi chorus. I dig it
She's been sitting on this album for a little over a year. So these were done BEFORE the features with Bad Omens & Knocked. She said she had switched labels a few times but landed back on Sumeran who also did her last album. I think she's evolved even more since. I'm definitely looking forward to her journey if she stays on this path
Poppy is so mixed i cant say for certain she even has a genre. Afraid of Dying went hard af, and then Play Destroy was like a mix of generic pop with a slap in the face with screams and Metal. And then you have the Girls In Bikinis. I dont know man, Poppy can do anything and it will slap! Flux was a blast of a release aswell!
She's been heavy for a bout 6 months... where ya been bruh... she said in an interview I read not to long ago that she felt like metal was where she belongs...it's her new home...
Poppy doesn’t give a shit about satisfying the metalheads who complain about everything, she doesn’t commit to any genre and that’s why she’s such an outstanding artist
Honestly as someone who has known of Poppy since her very first TH-cam days, I fuckin love what she's doing. Going from essentially hosting a horror ARG, to making pop music, to blending metal and pop to fit the brand, to now just being a fully respected and fantastic metalcore vocalist and artist. I'll never understand people's resistance to Poppy, she's doing great stuff and we keep getting great music from her, both her own stuff and features. Some people need to shut up and just enjoy it. Also agree with others on the transitions, Poppy has been doing this for years, look at her song X from all the way back in 2018. It's part of her style in my opinion to just flip with no warning, it always has been. It's like a signature Poppy mark.
This is the first time I've heard the phrase "I need more WTF from poppy." That kind of IS the surprising aspect. Sometimes out of nowhere she'll just do a (relatively) direct song that's not absolutely insane. Which is quite unexpected. When she drops something, you have no idea what it will be like.
To think she started off as a pophead and now she’s come all this way The first time I ever heard of/saw her, it was on a stupid Nickelodeon commercial when I was just a kid, and now it’s this. Bravo I say, bravo
I had never heard of Poppy until a couple months ago and I saw her this past weekend at LTL, she's pretty damn good. She joined Spiritbox after her set to do a feature and that was awesome as well. New fan here, first song I heard from her was Violence Against Nature.
I love the hard cuts personally I thought it made the intense moments more intense and the feeling of flipping emotions from desperation to anger LOL could just be me though I probably have bad taste
7:18 Give it time, Nik. She's trying to find her footings in the genre. And playing it safe, I think, is the right approach here. These songs of her would be underwhelming if she had already done three metal albums. But she hadn't.
Nik had several wtf reaction moments on this and then complained that he didn't get surprised, idk what his problem is with poppy or maybe hes just having a bad day but he was so overly critical and negative on this one, genuinely made me unsubscribe from both channels, I've been a subscriber since 2018
@@oaktowndimond668bro hates her clearly, he cries about gatekeeping in the community, has he seen how negative his community is??? When he does shit like this no wonder
I met Poppy at the final show of the Never Find My Place tour, super short interaction but she was super nice. I used to watch her as a kid (I’m a teenager now) and I Disagree the album really helped me through shit and I love seeing her get heavier it’s so sick! So happy she’s getting the recognition she deserves because she’s been through so much to get to this point
thank you! Idk why he's so negative in this reaction, man calls out people for gatekeeping and lack of acceptance in the metal music industry and then does this.....😕
@@FrogWalrus fair point but you can not like the song without tearing every bit of it apart no? this dude is massively influential in the metal scene, there's not one part of this song he didn't criticize, just seemed overly negative for the sake of it, see how you can give her props, why can't Nik?
I won't actively listen to her myself but no denying her sheer talent and great style of music. Her screaming gives me that Dillinger Escape plan Greg Puciato era...like tearing into you with pure angst.
Poppy's been doing metal tracks since the end of her album Am I A Girl in 2018. And honestly a lot of that was more interesting because there was more genre mixing and surprises, especially on her album I Disagree. She got probably her heaviest and most abrasive on the Eat EP. Then on her album Flux she went a bit post-grunge in between some pop tracks. Zig was pretty much 90% darker pop. She's always changed things up but strangely this might be the most formulaic and safe material she's put out in a while. Jordan can write good metalcore tracks obviously, but these sound like BMTH leftovers, not like something catering specifically to Poppy's strengths and weirdness. I hope the rest of the album is a little weirder and she just stuck with the safer songs for the singles. Either way, glad people are noticing her, just hope they check her older shit out too. The Eat EP rips honestly.
Poppy got so much blowback for her album Zig. Truth be told, I was like "where's the rock Poppy?" But after listening multiple times after the album dropped, it's a wonderful record. I do think some of the songs could be longer and more fleshed out, but c'mon... I can't think of one female metal vocalist that would do justice on "Linger ". But yeah, if Jordan Fish takes arguably on if the most versatile post genre muses... And has her scream on 15 BMTH coded songs, he's not going to become the" super producer" he's expecting. Because if he can't break out of the BMTH mold with poppy. He's simply stuck to his one trick.
If it's done right like I think this is, safer songs are perfectly fine to me. Her career is still very pop-influenced as that's what her style originally was but I think she's just doing whatever she wants in terms of her music and I'm here for it because even when she does go for a safer-sounding song, she does it very well at least in my opinion. Flux is a great alternative rock album and I would've been down to hear more of that style from her because it weirdly kinda suited her but she's been carving her own niche in metal for the last 5 years and she is definitely at her best when she experiments, which because it's Poppy you could essentially classify as her playing it safe like others in here have said as she's been doing it her whole career.
Poppy has realized her potential, and is now beginning her journey into what we metal fans need. It might be rough for a little bit, but she's at least making music that doesn't sound like everyone else. I think she'll only improve as she narrows down her niche, but she clearly has range. I'd like to see her monopolize HER sound, and then do some crazy sh*t with collabs. Just my opinion, but I'm loving it. Her and Pretty Wild are doing amazing things.
I feel like she's just trying to make something more mainstream, to get her name out in the metal scene. Which I can respect, as long as her whole catalog isn't super safe.
I kinda like the harsh transitions and immediate full start to the song, it feels very whiplashy and kind of goes a long with the theme of the song. While it feels very "safe" for metalcore, this is different for her and is definitely her riskiest song. I think she's just starting and and will eventually come into her own vibe for metal. She's being very experimental in terms of dipping into different genres. As she does more stuff in this style, it will evolve. But as for this song, if feels safe yes, but its still very good.
It’s odd because I remember when she did metal songs like “X” she always did harsh transitions. Overtime I noticed them less in her albums. I can’t help but think this is like a callback to those previous songs, just more upgraded sounding wise. :)
Poppy is an extremely beautiful artist and human being who has so many special and positive messages to share with us as her audience. I am absolutely amazed by her brilliance as a musician and her versatility as a vocalist. Knowing about the terrible hardships that she experienced with her previous label and former manager, I am so glad that the metal community has given her a platform to express her authentic artistry, free from the pressures to conform to others' perceptions of what she "should be." As a metalhead goth, I absolutely welcome Poppy with open arms. Her album "I Disagree", which marked her transition into metal and alternative rock music was absolutely healing for me because I was experiencing a tremendous amount of challenges because of depression and bullying and it came out during a time in which I had felt completely at odds with my identity as a person because I was consistently being shamed and mistreated because of my choice to continue being darkly-inclined and expressing myself freely through my manner of dress. It came out exactly during a time in which I needed it the most and it saved me from so much suffering. It was because of Poppy that I was inspired to find hope again and it was because of her that I was inspired to become myself again. I abosolutely do believe that she is taking risks in her music, just that she is progressively exploring more nuances to her own sound, now that she is completely autonomous in her artistic vision and she is clearly so adept at building up heavy music atmospheres, and her cover of "Spit" by Kittie truly shows her genius as a metalcore vocalist.
To me, it feels like she is still discovering her sound in this space. There is not really a cohesion in the song. The parts on their own are good but it needs some more confidence in her own sound. And they are separated parts and not feeling like it's one song. But finding your sound, your rhythm and your confidence in that sound and rhythm can take years, so I have fate.
First Nik roasts poppy for being a wierdo with scary mask, Now he ripping into her for being generic. So poppy can't win in your book? Because that's what it sounds like. Nik, I would like you to react to these songs (just pick a few): - say cheese - bite your teeth - don't go outside - never find my place - stagger. All are completely different. I'm talking metalcore to dark pop (almost billie eilish like). If you have a problem with every song, then maybe you just don't like Poppy. That's fine, of course.
This is only the beginning of a beautiful metal career..... She is definitely an amazing singer but I'd prefer if she kept getting heavier and heavier. 👏👏👏🖤
Man that was a rollercoaster. From Slipknot vibes, to Spiritbox type choruses, To a bring me to the horizon type of break down... This is definitely metalcore lmao I'm not an avid Poppy listener so I had no idea she was going hard these days. I only really heard her feature in the track with Bad Omens
*Birb*
skibbidi birb
boywb
Wirb
Birds aren't real
the government made birbs, not birds
Let poppy cook this is just the beginning
She cooks so much better after she kicked Titanic Sinclair out of the f*cking kitchen. I'm so happy for her.
fair
"Wait a minute...someone cooked here" -walter white
@6lu5ky86and brought Jordan fish in ;)
@@6lu5ky86 fr
Poppy is seemingly exploring every genre of rock and metal. Post 2019 Poppy has been a trip.
Which Poppy era was not a trip lol
Poppy been carrying metal idc what anyone says best female screamer in the game rn LP should’ve had poppy over emily 😂
@@joedavon3290 linkin parkj doesnt need a metal screamer , they needed a power vocalist which chester was , chester has not once screamed he always belted or yelled his message.
emily is a power vocalist
@@jacobweatherford6438 Emily sounds like my niece trying to sing 🤣LP went from a good band to a shitty band cus of Emily and I’m a LP fan
I don't care about the transitions, I think they work
likewise. this track is fucking fire.
ChildCore
i dont agree either on the transitions part they work really well
I agree I think they work great
I agree the ones in this song work really well. The transitions also remind me a lot of the I Disagree album, with Concrete, Fill the Crown, and Bite Your Teeth having some pretty interesting heavy-to-pop and vice versa transitions.
Says there's no surprises. Freaks out over Poppy going BLEUGH! 1 min earlier
thanks you! I'm glad I'm not the only one who noticed how negative and overly critical Nik was here
Ya and also weirded out by the lack of transitions, then saying it's not weird.
@@Hewarya I love Nik's video's and was excited to watch this but he seemed overly critical of this tune. He said nothing was surprising but he literally was surprised and caught off guard by the first scream of the song. To each their own though. I respectfully disagree with him on this one. This song is a banger.
This is technically her second 'blegh'! Her first one was on Bite Your Teeth from her 'I Disagree' album
its actually her 3rd blegh the first one was 'Bite Your Teeth' and the second was 'Say Cheese'
i think the eugh eugh on new way out counts as half a blegh, so 2.5 ;)
people seem to have forgotten about that album, it's so damn good.
She's got a whole album coming out in November, and I have full faith there'll be plenty of weirdness contained there
Yep, on the same day as the Linkin Park album
'Phrost
@@NikNocturnalTwitchClipsIt's also the same day that As I Lay Dying is dropping their new album.
@@NikNocturnalTwitchClips damn she can do nothing right in your book bro....
@@snakeeyes9246 I had to look it up, god the first half of november is full. I'm glad it's not only the week before, when both The Browning and Make Them Suffer come out on the 8th (and probably more)
@@NikNocturnalTwitchClips that's gonna be a GOOD day let me tell you that
There’s no pleasing the metal community at this point. When it’s proper metalcore, people asking for something different. When it’s weird and different, people saying it’s not proper metal. Hating for absolutely no reason. The song is a banger. Just say that and move on. Ain’t rocket science
Rocket science is a fun unreleased poppy track🤭
Haha! @@respectable-username
literally poppy was a forerunner for experimental metal for a while and it didnt get her jack shit in return, so i understand the mainstream route shes taking this time. im happy either way i think shes killing it and negative spaces will be amazing.
@@someguyfromgoogle1481 I'm realistening to Zig. Fuck, flicker is amazing!
That's not today, metal has always been like this.
This song may even be generally safe sonically for the metalcore scene. But it's not safe for Poppy. Her career still is 60% based and influenced by pop music bc of that her fan base does like pop music - just like Poppy (New Way Out is very pop influenced). In addition, you have industrial fans, her heavy stuff fans, etc, etc. All of her 6 albums have totally different sounds, and this has created a very diverse set of expectations of the public. I don't think she even cares about pleasing metalheads or anyone, but I don't think this can't be considered "safe" if we think about how amplified her audience is.
I love new way out. What it was missing was her drummer, Ralph Alexander. I hope we don't have Jordan's "machine gun drums" on every track.
But yeah, NWO was like Britney x metalcore. Listen to the second verse, total britney spears vibe. It works really well!
tbh that's what i love about poppy fans. everyone has a different favourite song, and they aren't afraid to share their opinions on her music (except the mods on the discord server hah)
The only reason i think she might be playing it safe right now is that shes still not being accepted into the community after all of the "I'm poppy" years. idk. Im super digging it. its still WAY different from pre workformhome era....
Who is not accepting her? I'm confused. Also, what IS playing safe with her? 6th album and 6th time its something very different from everything she has done previously
@@nettlecider we all know there's those gate keepers who will never accept her or give her credibility. Unfortunately they are some of the loudest. I personally don't find it safe. It's fun, it's hard as shit with catchy as hell melody and chorus. But a lot of reactions have called it safe. Idk. I've always dug her so I might not be the best to judge.
I'm hoping the Knocked Loose feature helped to give her some of the acceptance she definitely deserves and has more than earned. Is there any reason other than gatekeepers being shitheads for her to not be accepted? I genuinely don't know and haven't heard of her doing anything reprehensible.
@@chasm9557 not that i know of. maybe some are just to scared to admit they like her. like they are closet fans. but we all have those artists that we will say we dont like, but once we are in out cars alone we all belt out like no one is listening.
@@chasm9557 well if talking 'contraversial' - back in her early youtube days and doing first dabbles in music - her persona was a carbon coppy of Mars Argo, a girl who worked with at the time Poppy's sorta manager guy or smth. Margo felt like her whole image was stolen and that guy was a shady mothaf* himself, but since Poppy left him he got cancelled and she started making music she wants. Also talked about his abuse etc. I know that there are still some people who for some reason consider everything HER fault and not his. Sadly, I think it costed her points for positive exposure in general but this has all been happening pre-metal era. So its weird reading comments about her not being accepted when old fans actuallh see her as finally accepted since her move to heavier stuff
For me Poppy has been cooking for years now, this is absolutely SICK as fuck
This song fucking slams. I don't need it to be "weird".
Poppy killed it with this song :)
bro what are you talking about...all the bands you like have transitions like that😂
A BMTH and Poppy collab would go hard ❗️
It would make too much sense
YESSS OMG i have a feeling this will happen for sure. or a poppy song with oli featuring!
It sounds exactly like a song would sound if it was produced by Jordan Fish of BMTH, and featuring songwriting by Knocked Loose.
Pissed Metalcore to its finest.
Cuz it is produced by Jordan Fish :D
You wouldn't believe this...
are we still acting like Jordan is doing this for a good reason?
@@caretakerrr123what is this supposed to mean
@@caretakerrr123 yapppp
What i like about her is that she doesn't give a fuck. She does what she wants. I hope it'll stay like that.
big fish does it again
I love this song. It fucking rules so much. From Poppy's passionate screams to her beautiful singing voice along with those driving guitars and drums. Goddamn. My song of the year by a lot.
I actually think Poppy dropped one of the best metal songs of the year. I was shocked beyond belief and had this song on repeat.
i like her scream flow
I’m honestly surprised at how many people think this is her “first metal” song. Has nobody heard her album “I Disagree” that was a big middle finger to everyone who labeled her? Her song “Scary Mask” she collabed on with Fever333 was also HEAVY. Or even her recent song “Spit”.
As a huge Poppy guy, y’all have homework to do lmao 😂
Don't forget "Say Cheese" or "Eat" ......
Apparently he covered Scary Mask and shit over it (people commented on it).
I remember him covering Concrete.
Even before then I remember X going around. Not sure why everyone is acting like she only started doing metal.
I think her marketing is pretty good by releasing these safer songs that will appeal to a wider audience first.
The album will probably have heavier or more experimental sounds in it that may not appeal as much to broader listeners.
Yes I agree but nonetheless I still love these pre released singles but I love any metalcore songs Poppy makes tbh
Ever since she sunk the Titanic Sinclair, Poppy has been poppin' off. I'm really happy for her getting away from that freak show and doing her own thing.
we got Poppy metalcore song beofre GTA 6
She’s been doing them for a while!
@@christophermccook8591 idk i rerember her like girl that is saying im poppy for 10 mins :D
@@drengoa8435 haha yeah, there’s her TH-cam videos, but then if you check out her music, she has gone back and forth between pop and metal quite a bit, starting with a couple of tracks on her Am I A Girl album. Quite a few on I Disagree and her EAT EP. Her cover of Spit is great too!
Um, the EAT EP???
if this was spiritbox nik would be eating it up like crazy…
You fucking KNOW IT!
Or sleep token, or will Ramos 💯
@@elijahrivera7045 💯
They would have created technicaly better track.
Well everyone's prayers have been answered. Just search Spiritbox "Soft Spine" ft. Poppy - Live from Louder Than Life
Safe doesn't seem like the right description.
Nik gave Poppy shit for scary mask years ago too. She can't win in his book, i suppose.
@@oaktowndimond668Nik hates poppy so much she doesn't even get on the main channel bro, I've started noticing this lately, he pushes bands he personally likes, that's no journalism as he claims to be lately, he's extremely biased, if you're will Ramos, sleep token or spiritbox hell promote and push the shit outta ya, if not he'll tear you apart lately
@@Hewarya this should seriously be his last poppy reaction ever. I bet he'd shit all over "don't go outside" and "say cheese".
i think part of poppys style is abrupt transitions , thats her whole vibe no matter the genre pop , indie , rock , metal , edm , it is just abrupt switch up to anything
IMO by being "Safe" she was trying something different than what she normally does and I'm all for it. Loved this song.
But when Spiritbox writes safe Architects songs, it is sooooo amazing. Lol.
Seriously. Let me guess, Nik LOVED Curse!
This!!!
this isnt safe for poppy, new way out was tho
Her vocals give me that raw IOWA kind of vibe and the song structure made me think of the new darko album. Those hard cuts from aggressive verse to clean lofi chorus.
I dig it
She's been sitting on this album for a little over a year. So these were done BEFORE the features with Bad Omens & Knocked. She said she had switched labels a few times but landed back on Sumeran who also did her last album. I think she's evolved even more since. I'm definitely looking forward to her journey if she stays on this path
Poppy is so mixed i cant say for certain she even has a genre. Afraid of Dying went hard af, and then Play Destroy was like a mix of generic pop with a slap in the face with screams and Metal. And then you have the Girls In Bikinis. I dont know man, Poppy can do anything and it will slap! Flux was a blast of a release aswell!
I bet if nik listened to Bloom, he'd trash it.
The transitions are quite old school Fear Factory-esque, so it works for me.
A little bit of old school Fear Factory in transition/ending parts
the poppy goes arf arf 🐶🐕
dude, i've seen you years ago commenting on GMM videos. sick :) GMM + metal =
@@laura.franke hahah this is great 🤣🤘
Love Poppy really stoked for the new album!
She also put out a piano lounge like song recently too.
She's been heavy for a bout 6 months... where ya been bruh... she said in an interview I read not to long ago that she felt like metal was where she belongs...it's her new home...
I like her she can stay ❤
for about 4 years*
fixed!
She's been releasing metal songs since 2018 bruh
@@popsarg Metal =/ heavy bruh
She’s been heavy for freaking years yall gotta catch up
Poppy doesn’t give a shit about satisfying the metalheads who complain about everything, she doesn’t commit to any genre and that’s why she’s such an outstanding artist
Fun song, video was weird and avant-garde. Very Poppy.
Honestly as someone who has known of Poppy since her very first TH-cam days, I fuckin love what she's doing. Going from essentially hosting a horror ARG, to making pop music, to blending metal and pop to fit the brand, to now just being a fully respected and fantastic metalcore vocalist and artist. I'll never understand people's resistance to Poppy, she's doing great stuff and we keep getting great music from her, both her own stuff and features. Some people need to shut up and just enjoy it.
Also agree with others on the transitions, Poppy has been doing this for years, look at her song X from all the way back in 2018. It's part of her style in my opinion to just flip with no warning, it always has been. It's like a signature Poppy mark.
She is suddenly showing up everywhere it seems like, and every time I am more impressed with her.
This is the first time I've heard the phrase "I need more WTF from poppy."
That kind of IS the surprising aspect. Sometimes out of nowhere she'll just do a (relatively) direct song that's not absolutely insane. Which is quite unexpected. When she drops something, you have no idea what it will be like.
If he can't handle this, wait till he hears X
He already shit on scary mask 5 years ago.
He also reacted to Concrete. Not as harsh transitions, but still interesting and unique moments :0
Play Destroy would be a trip too lol
@@TabbyWithMittensplay destroy would have gotten metal back in the pop charts in 2018 if Grimes wasn't so problematic
To think she started off as a pophead and now she’s come all this way
The first time I ever heard of/saw her, it was on a stupid Nickelodeon commercial when I was just a kid, and now it’s this. Bravo I say, bravo
I had never heard of Poppy until a couple months ago and I saw her this past weekend at LTL, she's pretty damn good. She joined Spiritbox after her set to do a feature and that was awesome as well. New fan here, first song I heard from her was Violence Against Nature.
the break down kinda gave All our Gods vibes
Listen to her song Say Cheese from 2021, she's been heavy for a while. Plus one of the most crazy bridge choices I've ever heard lol
This is W I L D 🤣 was not expecting more of this from Poppy. Suffocate with KL was incredible tho.
Haha the confused head bobbing
1:45 Fun metal guitarist things
I love the hard cuts personally I thought it made the intense moments more intense and the feeling of flipping emotions from desperation to anger LOL could just be me though I probably have bad taste
I bet he would absolutely hate mahavishnu orchestra. John Mclaughlin was all about harsh transitions.
7:18 Give it time, Nik. She's trying to find her footings in the genre. And playing it safe, I think, is the right approach here. These songs of her would be underwhelming if she had already done three metal albums. But she hadn't.
Nik had several wtf reaction moments on this and then complained that he didn't get surprised, idk what his problem is with poppy or maybe hes just having a bad day but he was so overly critical and negative on this one, genuinely made me unsubscribe from both channels, I've been a subscriber since 2018
@@Hewaryago watch nik's reaction to "scary mask". He gave poppy shit then too. That was too wierd. This isn't wierd enough. She can't win.
@@oaktowndimond668bro hates her clearly, he cries about gatekeeping in the community, has he seen how negative his community is??? When he does shit like this no wonder
She’s being doing this for years years!!!!
I met Poppy at the final show of the Never Find My Place tour, super short interaction but she was super nice. I used to watch her as a kid (I’m a teenager now) and I Disagree the album really helped me through shit and I love seeing her get heavier it’s so sick! So happy she’s getting the recognition she deserves because she’s been through so much to get to this point
The change ups are what make this song so great. I really enjoy your reviews, btw.
Poppy, don’t listen to him, I think it’s a great song!
thank you! Idk why he's so negative in this reaction, man calls out people for gatekeeping and lack of acceptance in the metal music industry and then does this.....😕
@@Hewarya maybe he just doesn’t like the song… I don’t either. Props to Poppy for doing this, but I don’t like it.
@@FrogWalrus fair point but you can not like the song without tearing every bit of it apart no? this dude is massively influential in the metal scene, there's not one part of this song he didn't criticize, just seemed overly negative for the sake of it, see how you can give her props, why can't Nik?
@@Hewaryahe crapped all over scary mask too.
bleauueaaarghhhh
I thought this was a banger. I'd love for her to go more into this stuff, it's fantastic love the abrupt transitions.
Poppy always makes cool catchy music! She has made my favorite pop song ever! (That Poppy - Lowlife)
She’s just getting started. Poppy is life. Poppy is light.
This is my favorite song. Love me some poppy.
I won't actively listen to her myself but no denying her sheer talent and great style of music. Her screaming gives me that Dillinger Escape plan Greg Puciato era...like tearing into you with pure angst.
I think this song is an absolute banger. And her voice on the chorus is so pretty
Poppy's been doing metal tracks since the end of her album Am I A Girl in 2018. And honestly a lot of that was more interesting because there was more genre mixing and surprises, especially on her album I Disagree. She got probably her heaviest and most abrasive on the Eat EP. Then on her album Flux she went a bit post-grunge in between some pop tracks. Zig was pretty much 90% darker pop.
She's always changed things up but strangely this might be the most formulaic and safe material she's put out in a while. Jordan can write good metalcore tracks obviously, but these sound like BMTH leftovers, not like something catering specifically to Poppy's strengths and weirdness. I hope the rest of the album is a little weirder and she just stuck with the safer songs for the singles. Either way, glad people are noticing her, just hope they check her older shit out too. The Eat EP rips honestly.
Poppy got so much blowback for her album Zig. Truth be told, I was like "where's the rock Poppy?"
But after listening multiple times after the album dropped, it's a wonderful record. I do think some of the songs could be longer and more fleshed out, but c'mon... I can't think of one female metal vocalist that would do justice on "Linger ".
But yeah, if Jordan Fish takes arguably on if the most versatile post genre muses... And has her scream on 15 BMTH coded songs, he's not going to become the" super producer" he's expecting.
Because if he can't break out of the BMTH mold with poppy. He's simply stuck to his one trick.
Banger of a song! Nothing wrong with safe, if she's still exploring the genre
Cmon nik get with it 😂 first you can’t keep up with the transitions, now she’s too safe, make up ur mind and don’t just be hatin!
Poppy is way more interesting when she adds hints of metal into her songs than just being another metal artist
If it's done right like I think this is, safer songs are perfectly fine to me. Her career is still very pop-influenced as that's what her style originally was but I think she's just doing whatever she wants in terms of her music and I'm here for it because even when she does go for a safer-sounding song, she does it very well at least in my opinion. Flux is a great alternative rock album and I would've been down to hear more of that style from her because it weirdly kinda suited her but she's been carving her own niche in metal for the last 5 years and she is definitely at her best when she experiments, which because it's Poppy you could essentially classify as her playing it safe like others in here have said as she's been doing it her whole career.
Fun fact: Suffocate is the reason i started to listen to Knocked loose and watching Nik's videos lol
Poppy has realized her potential, and is now beginning her journey into what we metal fans need. It might be rough for a little bit, but she's at least making music that doesn't sound like everyone else. I think she'll only improve as she narrows down her niche, but she clearly has range. I'd like to see her monopolize HER sound, and then do some crazy sh*t with collabs. Just my opinion, but I'm loving it. Her and Pretty Wild are doing amazing things.
Poppy has already done heavy before you guys are just ignorant one of those artists who always tries new things and sounds, she's always been great
I feel like she's just trying to make something more mainstream, to get her name out in the metal scene. Which I can respect, as long as her whole catalog isn't super safe.
I love Poppy screams and [BL]EGHs
I hope the safe & Octane path may be her intro into metal. Poppy has turned to the dark side, I LOVE IT!
ngl I love the transitions (or lack there of) I think they work really well w the song :] 🤘🏾
I just saw poppy with Fit For A King! I love her! ❤
her screaming is getting really good.
I kinda like the harsh transitions and immediate full start to the song, it feels very whiplashy and kind of goes a long with the theme of the song. While it feels very "safe" for metalcore, this is different for her and is definitely her riskiest song. I think she's just starting and and will eventually come into her own vibe for metal. She's being very experimental in terms of dipping into different genres. As she does more stuff in this style, it will evolve. But as for this song, if feels safe yes, but its still very good.
It’s odd because I remember when she did metal songs like “X” she always did harsh transitions. Overtime I noticed them less in her albums. I can’t help but think this is like a callback to those previous songs, just more upgraded sounding wise. :)
Poppy is an extremely beautiful artist and human being who has so many special and positive messages to share with us as her audience. I am absolutely amazed by her brilliance as a musician and her versatility as a vocalist. Knowing about the terrible hardships that she experienced with her previous label and former manager, I am so glad that the metal community has given her a platform to express her authentic artistry, free from the pressures to conform to others' perceptions of what she "should be." As a metalhead goth, I absolutely welcome Poppy with open arms. Her album "I Disagree", which marked her transition into metal and alternative rock music was absolutely healing for me because I was experiencing a tremendous amount of challenges because of depression and bullying and it came out during a time in which I had felt completely at odds with my identity as a person because I was consistently being shamed and mistreated because of my choice to continue being darkly-inclined and expressing myself freely through my manner of dress. It came out exactly during a time in which I needed it the most and it saved me from so much suffering. It was because of Poppy that I was inspired to find hope again and it was because of her that I was inspired to become myself again. I abosolutely do believe that she is taking risks in her music, just that she is progressively exploring more nuances to her own sound, now that she is completely autonomous in her artistic vision and she is clearly so adept at building up heavy music atmospheres, and her cover of "Spit" by Kittie truly shows her genius as a metalcore vocalist.
To me, it feels like she is still discovering her sound in this space. There is not really a cohesion in the song. The parts on their own are good but it needs some more confidence in her own sound. And they are separated parts and not feeling like it's one song.
But finding your sound, your rhythm and your confidence in that sound and rhythm can take years, so I have fate.
I have listened to this track so many times
HELL YEAH 🤘🏻 One of poppys best songs
I still want a whole Popped Loose EP.
First Nik roasts poppy for being a wierdo with scary mask, Now he ripping into her for being generic.
So poppy can't win in your book? Because that's what it sounds like.
Nik, I would like you to react to these songs (just pick a few):
- say cheese
- bite your teeth
- don't go outside
- never find my place
- stagger.
All are completely different. I'm talking metalcore to dark pop (almost billie eilish like).
If you have a problem with every song, then maybe you just don't like Poppy. That's fine, of course.
Poppy of the year!
Poppy is a great artist!
Poppy has been screaming for many years. She just has so much music it's not easy to find.
The whole ending goes hard af!
This is only the beginning of a beautiful metal career..... She is definitely an amazing singer but I'd prefer if she kept getting heavier and heavier. 👏👏👏🖤
Hi! Not sure if you check her out before but she covered and did quite of bit of metal before if you are interested. :)
Def a 2015 metalcore sound
Considering the only other song I ever heard of her was the one she became famous for, this is blowing my mind.
Nik rolls out of bed, puts on eye shadow, and metals. Respect
IT WAS THE BIRD
BWAAACK🤮 quoth the raven. Nevermore. NeverBWAAACK🤮.
This song feels like an unreleased hidden track that was made for a Call of Duty zombies map from way back in the day
Nik at 5:06 : "WHAT, that caught me so f*ckn off guard"
Nik at 7:06 : "there's no surprises?"
Poppy is perfect for me, honestly. Fuckin' weird as hell, that's what I love + she introduced me to Kittie so that's even better.
Have you guys listened to spit, it’s a cover poppy made from kitty but omg it’s so good
I think this song, and the rest of her singles, are fucking great.
Poppy is genreless. But as someone who was there for her youtube days i really do love her metal eras
Man that was a rollercoaster.
From Slipknot vibes, to Spiritbox type choruses, To a bring me to the horizon type of break down...
This is definitely metalcore lmao I'm not an avid Poppy listener so I had no idea she was going hard these days.
I only really heard her feature in the track with Bad Omens