Which 3D Printer is BEST! Creality K1, Bambu Lab P1P or K1 MAX?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 ก.ย. 2023
- So after having these 3 printers for a bit, I've put them all through the ringer! Print after print they're all proved to be true workhorses! So in this video, how about we compare the features and sizes of these 3 industry leading machines and see which one may be best for you?
Enjoy!
▼ MENTIONED IN VIDEO
K1 MAX Review | • Creality K1 Max Review...
K1 MAX |shrsl.com/4bmt4
Bambu P1P Review | • Bambu P1P Review - The...
Bambu P1P | tinyurl.com/h2xwzc7y
K1 Review | • Bambu P1P Review - The...
K1 | shrsl.com/4bmt6
K1 Camera | amzn.to/3RrYvvV
▼ SOCIAL MEDIA / CONTACT
Inquiries | bit.ly/3xQmgAS
Instagram | / frankly_built
TikTok | / frankly_built
Twitch | / frankly_built
Twitter | / frankly_built
Facebook | / franklybuilt
Reddit | / njtricker609
Discord Community | / discord
▼ SUPPORT THE CHANNEL!
Patreon | / franklybuilt
My Etsy | www.etsy.com/shop/FranklyBuilt
Frankly Built Merch | bit.ly/3AechHF
▼AFFILIATE AND DISCOUNT CODES!
AMAZING Discount Codes! | tinyurl.com/4au52zta
☞ Check here for Up to Date Discounts and Codes!
ELEGOO| tinyurl.com/3zrsm4pf
☞ Visit Elegoo for my favorite FDM 3D printers, from entry
level to advanced!
CREALITY | tinyurl.com/yhb9rbj9
☞ Visit Creality for a variety of FDM 3D printers, from entry
level to advanced!
BAMBY LAB | tinyurl.com/yhvvssd3
☞ Visit Bambu for a variety of FDM 3D printers, from entry
level to advanced!
DO3D | bit.ly/3zWo8tC
☞ Use Code “FBT20” at checkout for 40% off awesome
3D models and files!
AMAZON | www.amazon.com/shop/franklybuilt
☞ Visit my Amazon Store Front and explore my favorite printers,
filaments, build supplies and more!
SUNLU FILAMENT | bit.ly/3gXbSAo
☞ Use Code “VQLDTFWBMQ” at checkout for 10% off filament!
Disclaimer- This video is NOT sponsored by any brands mentioned in this video. Honesty is very important to me and my channel- all thoughts and opinions mentioned are my own. This video is NOT sponsored by any of the other brands mentioned above or throughout this video. The links provided above are affiliate links. Affiliate links allow me to make a small commission from purchases made on my recommendations, with no additional cost to the customer!
Thank you for supporting me!
▼TIME STAMPS
#3dprinting #3dprinter #review - บันเทิง
![ไม่ต้องมีที่ที่ให้ฉันอยู่ แต่ขอแค่มีฉันอยู่ก็พอ (Spaceless) - getsunova [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4N8idbxZ-7M/mqdefault.jpg)
Congrats on a million! Only a matter of time, you've entertained and helped sooooo many people with 3d printing and cosplay! 👍
You thank us in every video and for me, I thank you. What you've presented has taught me so much that I can't explain. Thank you for everything you do.
Got my P1P a week ago and I love using it. Still need to do some tuning and learning to do but that's why I've been binging your videos lately lol excited to print my first cosplay with this thing!
Great video. So close to pulling the trigger on one of these printers. I think I will try my hardest to be a little more patient and wait to see if there is a holiday sale. Congrats on almost 1mil subs.
I cannot wait for your 1 mil live video!!! You rock!! Me and my son will definitely be waiting to see when it comes out!!!
Thanks for making such high quality videos that explain everything people want to know!
So excited, my P1P comes in today. Can't wait to start cranking out props
Great review. Nice to see someone actually be honest rather than be a biased bambu fan. Plus not to mention you don’t blame the printers if something was actually your fault. Definitely will be coming here more often. Amazing work.
Recently picked up a P1S for my first FDM printer and it's an absolute dream. Thanks for doing all the reviews it really helped me making an informed choice :)
Mine also just arrived, loving it. Have you had the failed to unload filament issue so far?
haven't had that issue myself yet - I've been switching between PLA and PETG, and pressing unload via the little screen pad on the machine itself. @@nibblesful
@@AI40Kany problems with the 3d printer? jus checking in
@@Mrshotalot1st It has been running flawlessly, except when i tried some sunlu rainbow filament which was a bit stringy but might just be the colder weather & settings still be on defaults!
Congrats on 1 mil🎉🎉🎉
thanks im now gonna get a Bambu LAB P1P ive decided thanks frank so much and congrats on 1M
Great content brotha, congrats on the Million!
Just found your channel - really great and very much appreciated!
Im waiting on my first Bambu p1s now! I cant wait. Could you do a review on the Voxelab Aquila x3? looks like some awesome upgrades over the older models. I'm considering upgrading my old aquilas to these
And as for the display on the Bambu P1S, I used it once when I first got the printer to print the boat. Maybe the scraper too. But other than that I just print from the slicer. So the little screen is just fine.
I was able to pick up the K1Max on sale and have loved it. The only issues I have had were like yours, user error, and a bad hot end that Creality sent me a replacement for. I love it, probably my new favorite printer. I really only use my Ender-5Pluss now to back it up or even larger parts.
People often say they have horrible customer service so it’s nice to know you had an issue resolved
@@cinful1 it's not a quick process. It took a few days but having dealt with creality customer service in the past I know exactly what they need so sent them what they needed the first message.
@@sjschauer4235 As long as I am able to get results is what matters. Not everyone can be Prusa or Elegoo
@@sjschauer4235 I would take a few days. response time. I got a faulty P1S delivered. Its been 2.5 half months and still have issues. It takes 7 days for Bambu support to reply. I am watching these reviews and compare videos. Most likely will be returning this and if they dont offer advance RMA, I will get the Creality.
I need to replace my CR10s for a high speed printer. Since I don’t buy anything with less than 300x300 bed, K1 max is the only option.
Thanks for the comparison!
My K1 Max was a disaster with bad first layers, tons of VFA, ghosting and ringing...Creality send me a new heat bed witch helped a bit but still crap first layers, so I took things into my own hands. I CADed some bushing to get the bed more level and I went from a 1.2-1.3mm variance to a .4mm and now my first layers are much better. I rooted the machine and did some proper input shaping witch made the ringing and ghosting about 80% better, not gone but better. The VFA got better by doing the Voron belt tensioning method. Also I have switched to OrcaSlicer and that alone helped with print quality. I had a ton of quality control issues from loose connectors to loose bolts and screws. I have 320 hours on my K1 max now and its as good as its going to get with this unit, I'm getting by with it. I have about 100 hours printing ASA and that chamber does get hot, i have seen temps from 50-60C depending the height of the print. I own 3 Bambu printers and 6 AMS units with 1500hrs between them with no issues since day one, just regular maintenance. The K1 Max is no Bambu and thats a fact in build quality, and print quality.
I will have to keep my eye out for sales. Thanks for the info
Wow 1 milion subs, congrats. Great videos
Once again another great video. Thank you.
Awesome video as always Frank!
It’s interesting as a consumer to come across two videos regarding the K1 Max in a couple of days both from what I would consider to be reliable sources and have the experience and opinions on the device be so completely different. I’m referring to the Galactic Armory video on the K1 Max which I think even mentions this channel in the video.
Yeah! I saw his video. It’s wild how different our experiences have been. He’s a smart guy too
I love your content! my P1P will be here tomorrow, upgraded from a ender 3 v2 Neo, had great luck with it just time to step up to the next level and wanting to make some bigger and better prints. What is your top 5 places for High quality Designs that dont break the bank?
Great Video!! Thank you will wait for Xmas or Black Friday Sale for a K1 Max
Great video. I always enjoy your videos. So if i hear right for large core xy, probably k1 max and for large bed slingers, for you an eleego neptune 3 max? Thank you for another good video.
Btw what are your thoughts on the safety and health worries with 3d printing now that you print everyday? Be interested in your thoughts on that and what you do to help midigate any concerns
All i need is an ams system for the k1 max. I've been debating a mosaic palette 3 for a bit to add multi material printing to my machines. But would love to see more companies follow in bambu's footsteps and make their own systems
Rumor is creality is working on one for the k1s actually
Thank you for a clear and to the point review. I was considering buying the Kobra Max but the enclosed k1 max enticed me due to me having to have the printer at my homeoffice. I am thinking fumes, microplastics and such. I am going to use it primarily to print cosplaystuff. Is it a manageble printer for a rookie or is there another large bed printer you recommend?
I will check out your etsy-store too. Have a great day.
Congrats on the upcoming 1 mil you deserve it ❤️❤️ idk if you watch Ashoka but Enoch’s helmet looks sick I don’t see anyone else making it, would love a vid on that 🙌🏻❤️
Can’t wait for the live stream man! I’ll make sure to be there :)
Another brilliant video thanks !
Just bought two K1 Max @ $650 at microcenter! Love this printer...
This video really help me pinpoint on my first printer I would like to go with. Thank you
What did you get?
Great vid like always, not just for this vid but in general where do you get your favourite 3d models? Curious bc you always find awesome ones and I can never find any
I have a whole video talking about 3D models actually
@@FranklyBuiltawesome thanks
Can’t wait for your live stream soon. Looking to get something like the reality k1 Max
I really enjoy your videos, especially the builds with the helmets. I currently have 2 x Anycubic Vypers and decided I wanted to do the Blue Beetle helmet after recently seeing the movie. I ended up having to scale the helmet up a little and splitting it up as it would print as a whole helmet. After doing some prep and trying to get it ready to paint I have come across a problem in that some of the lines that are cut into the face plate are either very faint or have disappeared. As a result I need to add these and have tried with a set of hook & pick tools and a dremel, though not really happy with the result. Have you had a similar problem and if so did you fix it and how? Would appreciate suggestions as I don't want to have to print again due to the time it takes.
Just purchased my K1 Max. I print smaller things. My Enders just don’t give me a smooth print. And I can’t honestly sell with any flaws. Thank you for your amazing videos. You are amazing
How has it treated you? I'm looking into one myself graduating from my 2 ender 3 v2 neo
thank you so much for everything you do your the best
If you hate the P1P interface the community are currently developing the P1Touch add-on for the P1P which adds an additional touch screen to the printer with additional functionality 😊
I did the P1Touch on my P1S, it's a good mod. Firmware is still being tinkered with, but it's definitely worth doing.
I own the P1S. The only time I use the screen is to turn off the internal light the which admittedly is a bit painful. Otherwise, everything is done either via Bambu Studio or Bambu Handy. The P1S is just a really fast and efficient machine. I have been printing for a long time now and what we are seeing now is almost a revolution in the market. Even cheap bedslingers are giving you great results for very little effort. We are almost at the push print and forget stage. Almost.
@@Clips_For_Lifeonly main difference is the enclosure
Hi Frank, Thank you for your comparison. I am an old Ender 3 Pro user, and printing random stuff. but recently also started printing mask for my daughter her cosplay. With my current ender 3 that is more difficult for the bed size. You mentioned the K1 max is the one to choose, but I am in a doubt, as the P1S with AMS sounds an ideal printer... I would love to go for the P1S, but have doubts if this is the one to choose, because of the bed size... Would love to get your opinion. thnx.
Franky! Love you bro, amazing machines!
Great to see competition in the market that isn't just about cost.
👍great info. What 3d printer would you recommend for printing armor? 😎
Just got a Sovol SV06 Plus as my first printer, and I'm really tempted to return it and pay extra for the Creality K1 Max... Feels like there's a huge difference between them.
Brother thanks for this video, it is helping me become informed before I purchase. What fdm printer (i really dont want to do resin) would you recommend for printing miniatures, potentially commercially? I don't know if I should purchase 2 $150 printers or 1 $350 printer but I am concerned about being able to produce enough in a reasonable time frame to meet orders. I am looking at the elegoo neptune 4 pro for example. Any insight would be much appreciated. Thank you and well done
Hey Frank! Really enjoy the content you provide! Do you do anything special to get rid of the circular pattern at the highest point of you helmets?
Sand it haha
You're the man! Where can I get the P1P enclosure file? I know it's not a full enclosure but it looks awesome!
Congrats on 1m
thankyou this video helped a lot
Hi Frank, having dived into 3DP finally with a X1C purchase, I've gone from printing 3DBenchy's to a s Spiderman 2099 mask scaled to fit my grandson in just over a week! This is purely off the back of your content! Whilst having an tec background helps on the learning curve its the quality and enthusiasm of your content that stands out and has made the experience so much fun. I look forward to your Mk85 v2 series since as I will be using it to build myself a Mk85! Keep it up and thanks again.
Excellent comparison 👍
For a few months now, I've been researching which 1st printer to buy around my 50th bday this Nov. I made a comment in one of your videos (and others) that it's down to the P1S Combo and K1 Max since they are similarly priced with the K1 Max slightly cheaper with discounts and free shipping here in Canada. With only room and budget for 1 printer, I chose these 2 since it takes up less space than a bedslinger (have to account for the bed moving back and forth and screens that are way off 1 side on the slingers). The enclosure let's me print a wide range of materials. They are both fast and produce great quality prints. I am really impressed with your textured helmets without those layer rings on top. So, it really boils down to what are the things I will print the most which TBH, I still don't know as I want to print multi-colored things for myself, toys for the kids and to give as gifts (keychains, magnets, signs, light boxes, etc). But I also want to print cosplay stuff, not only for myself but for my kids too. The biggest future project is to print R2 and 3PO costumes for my twins while I dress in my Sandtrooper armour, so I can finally say, "I found the droids we're looking for!" 😂 Better if my wife dresses as Obi and I print parts, combined with cardboard, to make the stroller to look like a speeder.
I don't think the latest Bambu will be larger but it makes me think again. I can buy the P1S Combo now and IF I can get a 2nd printer, it will be one of the budget "Plus" bedslingers. OR buy the K1 Max, and wait for an AMS for it or buy the new Bambu if the price is below $500. Still have at least a month to make a decision.
The guys from Bambulab are going to give us some news on this 20th. We still don't know what is it. The "educated guess" is that's going to be a multiplexor to use multiple colors in any printer with the AMS. So my advice is wait for the 20th to make your final decision.
Ps: I bought a K1 Max but I'm still waiting for it. I'm in Chile so it's a loooong way for the printer 😆
@@multiversosdeleo3864 I believe it's a new printer. Rumors too say it's smaller than the current lineup. I think it was Nathan Build Robots who said it's not an AMS for other companies. The reason that convinced me it's not is - imagine the testing involved to make it compatible with different models of printers. It would be a nightmare and expensive! Why would they spend money for their competitors when they can get more customers to buy their products and ONLY their products? They sell parts, accessories for their printers and sell their own filaments. If it was a universal AMS for all, who gets blamed if it fails to produce a good print on, let's say, the K1 Max? Creality? Nope, Bambu Labs will be blamed. I don't think they will risk to tarnish their reputation.
So 1st, it will be a new printer, mostly like more affordable for everyone,
I am almost in the same predicament I am in a hard spot not sure if to buy the p1s combo with the ams or the k1 max I really want to print helmits like the spiderman and Deadpool plus certain parts for cars the only thing tripping me up is the size the k1 max is bigger but am having doubt and thinking the p1s with the ams but idk
I'm also just getting into it and unsure of what to get for first one....too many options, choices and brands... everyone has different opinions on what is best...I wish everyone would agree on one or two as the best to get all around printer but it seems experience, knowledge and personal taste affects the choice of which one...sigh it's so tough to choose
I got the k1 max a few months ago and haven't had a single failed print. It's so much faster than my cr10 and prints much nicer. I got mine on the black Friday sale for 30% off so it was basically the same price as the p1s and the bed size is worth it
happy 1mil frank i am a big fan
Great review, may i ask if you can print IronMan helmet as one piece, then the back and face
Also then later the suite in Bambu Lab P1?
Your answer will determine if I will buy one
Hello. Very good videos as always. A question for you... the printer quality from K1 Max compared to X1C Carbon is too different? I mean, I saw a lot of reviews saying that X1C print quality is superior to K1 Max - is that really true?
I have an X1 Carbon but have seriously considered the K1 Max because I need a bigger build plate
About two weeks ago, Amazon had the K1 Max on sale for $708.11, so hopefully we'll see that price again.
Torn between the P1P/P1S and the K1 Max. Seems like lots of people are having issues with the K1 series but you seem to be doing well with it. Decisions decisions
Pretty much all of the issues were the earliest models sent out of the K1. The K1 max had an upgraded extruder and that was also offered for like 2 dollars to the K1 users to fix theirs. The new K1 shipping out I believe comes with the newer extruder. Other than that the only main issue with the K1 series is some people are getting broken glass when shipped but that also happens with the bambus. My K1 has been beyond great aside from 1 bad roll of filament and user error here and there. Best bet is P1S or K1 Max tbh.
I bought the K1 a week ago, got a new iteration extruder, and no problem at all.
Thank you 🙏 great info
I literally just bought the K1 max today. I watched a few videos, and this one waa the last one I needed to decide, since I'll be using it for cosplays 🤓
How about a video on general maintenance and upkeep for these printers? I'd really like to get one, but the design looks like it wouldn't be as easy to work with as an Ender or the like would be
What about the qidi x plus 3 or xmax 3?
Hey @FranklyBuilt, great video! Which Model did you use here for the Blue Beetle Helmet? Is that DO3D? It seems to come in parts and not as a whole
Do3d
I like this "review" ! I wish you had a Voron and also considered commenting and comparing on that :) Great video :)
Corona are cool but IMO it’s a waste of time now to build and dial them in when these exist. No point anymore
Thank you for all the videos, love your enthusiasm, energy and reviews. I noticed something weird with your audio recently, which throws me off a bit. With every cut it seems like your audio is loud and then gets quieter over time, till a new cut starts loud again. Not sure how this happens, very noticeable here: 10:08 7:28 7:40 8:09
Yeaaaaah it’s my Lav mic
@@FranklyBuilt interesting, wouldn't have guessed that, thought it might be something weird in editing! thanks and rock on :)
nice and fair review
Been following you for a while with hopes of one day being able to print cosplay helmets both myself and son just got into 3d printing just under a year now and learning all the time but with a 120x120x120 print bed we are restricted ☹️ news of the live competition brings us some hope on something bigger 😁 keep up the good work.
I’ve been working with a Dreamer NX and an Aquila D1 and I’m just about to pull the trigger on a P1P once a payment goes through on my credit card…. Then I saw the video and the giveaway…. OMG can’t wait to hear when it’s going to be.
Pro tip my guy- whatever editing software you're using, find the Normalize Audio button. Otherwise, thanks for a helpful comparison!
soo... in a long time i wanted the X1 carbon but then this video, now im thinking of the K1 MAX, witch one do you prefure? i mostly think the X1 because of the ams system.. thank you for the great video..
great fair comparison what mods or improvements could you make om the K1 max and will you be featuring them in an update.
also what time uk do you put out the live streams please.
None. Upgrading printers is a dead hobby IMO. No point
Would love to see a comparison vs the Qidi X-Plus 3!
Awesome review thanks a lot , Just wondering how much it cost in filament to print Mask or Mandalorian Helmet for example ? Also looking at P1S thanks to Your review. Subscribed..
Less than a roll per helmet
Thanks to tiktok I found this channel... these printers look epic I wish I had any of em. So far I have a ender 3v2 that's it
Man I just got the k1 max and it’s awesome
I love sunlu and i make a lot of cosplay mask do you stick with the pla+ or use the regular pla? i been mainly using pla but pla+ is $2 cheaper on Amazon, whats your thoughts?
The filament turns brighter when it is printed at slower speeds. It is melted slower and makes it glossy
would be very interesting to see a comaparison with the Qidi xmax 3
Just started watching your video's, man I can't wait to get my own printer! I just wish I could afford one right now 😞
I've been printing those Pokemon in mini form for so long I never thought of printing them huge until now lol. Oh man that's gonna be fun.
Like your videos man. Was curious what kind of speeds you could get with each and keep the quality. I know the 500 and 600mm.s are just movement speeds but it would be nice to hit 300mm/s and keep great quality....yea, i want a lot...anyway hope you can cover that in a future video. Congrats on a million!
Also I am curious what features in a 3d printer can you not live without? For example, Wifi, auto leveling, lidar? What features do you find the most useful for efficiency and quality of life
I have an AnyCubic Kobra Max 2 coming in 3 weeks. It has the largest high speed bed size available under 500 bucks right now.
Thanks Frank for always doing a solid review this was excellent even if I was nervous going in because I'm a new p1p owner. I will say for what the LCD lacks you can do all of it on your phone app as well so that's handy.
Now that bambu revealed the A1 mini and ams lite, do you have any thoughts on that as first printer? The smaller bed size is the obvious potential downside, however given the overall bang for your buck, I'm curious if you think it's worth it even though it's on the smaller size. Any and all feedback is much appreciated.
The K1 AI camera is a special offer for 2$ with a bonus package after you buy the printer
Since when 2.99 is more like 2 not 3$?
Better hurry, that ends 9/21.
Question:
I have been printing for about 1 1/2 years so no where near an expert yet but slicing is the bane of my existence. I picked up a K1 Max and I love the printer overall but haven’t been able to figure out how to slice using the Creality slicer; e.g. the slicer freezes. I want to switch back to cura or any other slicer software but I don’t want to lose the functionality of high speed printing. Is this a sacrifice I have to live with if I print in any other filament/use any other slicer besides what Creality recommends? I hope this question makes sense…
Would you recommend the K1 Max or the new Anycubic Kobra 2 Max.
Wanna buy a new one in December and can’t decide.
Have you looked at qidi xmax 3, really interested in this one.
Thanks man!
I want your take on this; when I get a 3D printer I'm planning on printing the free DO3D iron man suit you have myself. After looking, I really like the P1S with the AMS system as not only does it keep the filament dry, it also will auto-swap filament if a spool runs out mid-print, making printing just that much easier (also supports multi-colouring but not sure if I would use that often). The P1S + AMS comes to the same price as the k1 max in my currency.
Would it be better to get the K1 max due to the build size (since you said iron man helmets would need a bigger size) or would it be best to just get the P1S + AMS, and just split the helmet in pieces to then fuse together?
Awesome video thanx for breakin it down. I wonder though, why Sunlu? Dont get me wrong I mostly use Sunlu's filaments.
They just work.
are you going to get the neptune 4 max? I'd be curious about your thoughts
Now looking at your video again as I am in the market for either a P1s or a K1 max. I don't really need AMS as i paint stuff and the K1 max does look interesting to sit next to my N3 max. I saw so many bad reviews for the K1 so think i'll skip that hence the K1 max.
Is any of these good as a starter printer or not? If not what do you recommend?
Looking forward to the live stream man
so close to that 1 milli, time to sub on my alt accts lol, early congratulations!
You didn't mention anything more about x1c carbon. I was looking to buy it. The bed being small is my only concern. Far as features and materials it sounds the best over all as a one time buy and no need to upgrade
Thanks so much for the awesome content! Can you please let me know how much power the k1 max consumes in an hour? I'd imagine it has to be close to the bamboo labs x1 carbon.
Is there a code I can put in to give you credit for the printer purchase directly through creality?
Thanks again for all the detail! Looking forward to getting my max soon!
Uhhh…there’s zero way for me to know that haha I’m sorry