@Lightening Emperor rest of them are true...but for open letter,the only reason for u to think him as anti modi is...he ask questions to leftists,is this the valid reason to call him pro modi?
@iTs Messiah these rss people never participated in the freedom struggle also but Nehru Gandhi ko criticise karna ho toh, they'll be ahead of the line.
For decline of Bengal, only person to be blamed is people of Bengal themselves..I have stayed and travelled across the country and world and being a Bengali myself can say this for sure..Our attitude our mindset..No party can improve situation in Bengal because the people themselves doesn't want to improve in any of the aspects..It might sound harsh but that's the sad reality...
Abhirup Guha Roy, I salute you for the responsibility taken by you. One more point I want to add when we choose our representatives in democracy, it is clear that majority party will rule the state and party will also lift the aspirations of majority only then he will come in power again and again. Jyoti Basu did the same. He also done many great works in begal for majority. There are many state which are not industrialised but their per capita income is higher than industrial states because of other source of income, low population density, migration of people to other place for better jobs, enterprising nature and where political rivalry are detached from social rivalry and not so staunch. I am from Bihar and lives in Gujarat for 20 years and conclusively say that if Gujarat is developed the major reasons are enterprising nature of Gujarati, no hesitation in migrating to other country and state, high investment and low lavish expenses, solution minded, less social conflict. Of course better infrastructure electricity by govt have been given but this is also main demand of people here.
I am Marathi person living and working in Mumbai/Thane, when I visit Kolkata I feel the city is in 80s or 90s, there is no concept of underground cables, Kolkata may have got first Metro in India but Delhi and Mumbai metro infrastructure is much better. My former Bengali boss used to say that any Bengali who has made fortune has made it outside of West Bengal. Edit: I'm not saying Mumbai or any other city or state is perfect, but genuinely thinks Kolkata have missed the bus somewhere which I am hopeful they will come back.
@@shardamohite2670 population density of Bengal is 4 times of Maharashtra. So people will come. No surprise. And Maharashtra wants them. We have seen during lockdown how Mumbai/ Nashik economy are so dependent on labours from North and East India
@@anjankumarchowdhury7379 I have many Bengali friends here in pune and they are not labrours, but very wise, Bajaj auto owner is also a Bengali by root who setteled in pune. just because the state is shit does not mean the people are at fault and the video shows that the CPI caused all the problems.
I being a young Bengali, living in Kolkata, West Bengal - I completely exactly agree with this video.... Nowadays, we get more information from good TH-cam channels than News channels.... Real truth explained by TH-camrs. Keep up your good work. 👌👌👌
@@subhajitdutta8563 Sorry, but I yet don't have the right to vote....exactly today I turned 14. (My bd 2nd April) Once I have the right to vote - I will vote for the party which has done things matching with my ideology....😎
@Bruce wayne I don't vote for Mamata Banerjee, my family we doesn't support TMC party....And I don't have the right the vote...I am 14years old. Besides, the vote of 1person does not decide which will be the RULING party....if you are an Indian citizen- I think you know that....most people here in Kolkata are voting for TMC (because it's their wish) & I can do nothing about that....
Can u imagine a State in India during 50's or 60's has it's own Engineers, Scientist, Doctors, Economist...Working in every sectors in India as well as in abroad.…! Bengal had all this capabilities at that time, that required for a state to sharply overshoot any state technologically, Educationally, Economically. No doubt that Before 70s Bengal was ahead of time.
Modern education came to Bengal earlier than other regions of India. Some of the oldest colleges and Universities were built in Bengal, many from early 1800s.
@@AJ56878 😏😏 But never think that it will continue for long. Bengal still has potential to overshoot any other states including Gujrate, UP, Karnataka or even Maharastra or may be as equal as Maharastra. It is Failed for poor administration of Left and now 10 years of corruption of TMC which leads to "brain drain" to other state or abroad. Let, a mature party come in Bengal. I can guarantee within few year it would be the most flourished state.
@Ansul Hackerman Unfortunately we don't have other option rather BJP. TMCs autocracy or u can say a kind of authoritarian rule has utterly destroyed the situation for emerging any other rival political party. If u do either you will shot dead or your house will be burn down and you will never get help from police, or if u go to police your family will be at high risk. You from other state so you will not understand that unless you come and stay here for at least 1 month. You can imagine the situation of this state that CM provoking people to attack CRPF. Hence only BJP is the answer as of now.
The most worst thing of West Bengal is that their is very few large cities but it has the fourth largest population in India and most people in countrysides depends upon Kolkata. No job,Totally corrupted state No system. I am from Kolkata..
Exactly there are semi built cities like durgapur and kalyani which if worked upon can easily become big enough cities to reduce the pressure from Kolkata. Also New town and Rajarhat is growing and in next 5 yrs can become what Noida is to Delhi. Heard that Kalyani is being developed but very skeptical considering how much it takes here to see actual development. But if they can then it would be a great prospect.
@@mohammedfayiz1905 kerela is a whole different story as compared to Bengal, Communism is the biggest reason for the downfall here and people have still not recovered from it.
@@mohammedfayiz1905 Communists in kerala aren't really communists , they are social democrats who like to pretend like they are highly ideological marxists. Plus kerala communists never used non-state paramilitary forces and goons to use political violence to the maximum amount.
@@mohammedfayiz1905 Kerela model is a failure if you compared them to other south indian states like Karnataka, tamil nadu and Andhra Pradesh. Only thing Kerela is good at is literacy and life expectancy but still Kerela is 100 times better than bimaru states.
@@harivatsaparameshwaran4174 anyone who understand basic economics will not support communism that's why you will find arts student mostly inclined towards communism while most science students and commerce students incline towards capitalism hence bjp.
This happened... Corrupt Politicians came on the other hand, Himachal has risen up from poorest to one of the best Despite Indian gov. ignoring us due to our less political significance, we are still going strong This basically proves Honest and Hardwork overpower Corruption
*_On News Channel there are so many debates on useless topics but no one talks on economy, development, literacy, unemployment, etc. Salute to such TH-camrs who show reality with detailed explanation._*
Economy , development , growth all are product of social structure . If you choose TMC and communist who only got business of changing demography and ruthlessly ruling people than how U would get economic growth . Ppl like U don't understand a peaceful society is a prosperous society . You cannot get economy or growth when U have 20 military n illegal extremist coming in state with help of ruling govt who are are destroying social structure .
The fact is people don't expect these things from Godi media. Mostly come for debate(big boss). The people who actually want to know what's happening in the country they somehow gather the news.
@@TM-vh1qg godi media kaha de agyi yaha? As if Wire, NDTV and quint toh propaganda felate nai hain. Left and right media are like yin and yang. The problem is the left is on the losing side because of their false narratives that they always put forward, right makes the most of it. Karlo dange.
Singur was a dream project If TATA did make factory there, one by one many businessmen will start business there. Singur would have been our next KOLKATA 😥
It's not that Bengal textile could not compete with Britain, the fact is Bengal textile industry was systematically destroyed by British, to flourish their textiles. They looted the raw materials produced in Bengal and sent to Britain, broke weaving machines, cut fingers of Bengali weavers. Million of weavers died out of poverty. What British did to bengalis was unimaginable.
even if that were the case, it still would have been impossible to beat industries in UK with high tech machines. I don't know why they went through the trouble of cutting the wings even if the birds were already inside the cage.
Good choice . Better than living in a state or place that literally kills your motivation and chances for being educated and skilled. Don't wry about the naysayers . You will find them aplenty . They are actually frustrated beacuse they are stuck in the hellhole themselves. They want to bring those who go up and do well in life as they themselves do not have the brains or guts to take risks in life.
@@rah8985 bhai sach bolu to there are 1.2 billion of us, making whites a minority in their countries will prove to be catastrophic in the future, i am also emigrating out of india, but to Singapore because there are than 2 billion asians and asian population is increasing
@@gottalovesaurav As long as you are contributing and are an asset to any community and society and country you are winner as a human being . Whichever country you go to it's important to live amicably and peacefully ine assimilate with the local population there . That's the only thumb rule .
this is not how it works, white countries were at their peak when they were majority white. Multiethnic and multicultural nations dont work for long for a reason, what you are saying would have perfect if white people always remained a supermajority, say 90%, and 10% of the remaining population was built up of high iq indians and east asians and latinos.
@@vinayb6444 The only one remotely close to johnny s production is mohak .He has improved his quality times fold in the last 8 to 10 videos. u cant even tell that this is the same soch as say 1 year ago . excellent work done by his and his team if there is one anyway
I live near Kalyani in West Bengal. It was once an economic hub. So many factories and so many workers were working. Now, most of the factories are like ruins. :(
Being a Bengali living in WB for almost 2 decade. Top 3 reason according to me; 1. Partition - Most of our industrial region went to Bangladesh. - Value of ports in Kolkata decreased. 2. Border issues - Illegal infiltration. - Illegal cross-border trade. - This results in stagnated growth in border areas. 2. Left rule - Lack in proper ideology (or no vision). - Almost no development since last 30 years.
But in the video this guy hinting Maharashtra and Gujarat for our economic failures. Current situation in Bengal has nothing to with those western states. Maharashtra infact got massive advantage of capitalism and cooperative sector, that's why they got largest economy in our country.
@Sujan Mondal brother,India's largest organised sector industries are in the states of Maharashtra and Karnataka because their were no left and communist government in the past and congress ruled this states for majority of time which stayed away from appeasement politics in the name of welfare schemes. So Maharashtra is largast contributor in direct taxes which is nearly 40% of total collected tax from states. Followed by delhi(11%) Karnataka (10%). But in case of BIHAR(0.65%)- third largest population, UP(3.5%)- largest population, Bengal (4%)-fourth largest population. You can see that they hardly contribute to direct tax revenue. If you doesn't improve tax base and tax collection how the government is gonna get money for development and infrastructure.
@@MayurK-ko9styou are talking about tax, first tell me how many toll pazzas or sea ports will you find in West Bengal ? First see total area of West Bengal below 1 sq. km. And how many toll pazzas are or sea ports are in Maharashtra? How many tourist spots? Taj Mahal is not located in West Bengal and also ISRO is not located in West Bengal and also Bombay High is not located in West Bengal. So mention all, if you want to talk about revenue of The Government or service sectors and don't forget Delhi is the capital of India.
@@MayurK-ko9st Up, Bihar, Wb has Huge population destiny.Karantaka, Gujarat 3 times bigger than bengal. But we are first ranked Rice, Potato, Joot, Fish production second rank tea production. Wb has Everything, Himalaya To Beach, Neighbourhood country. Okk.
@@AllInOne-bv1ti Thanks for information brother. But i here i was comparing economy of states. You know for Maharashtra Gujrat and karnataka they dont depend on agriculture economy But they also improved industrial and service sector which is prime driving force of their economy in which our Up, bihar and west Bengal lagging. In one of the above comments i talked about tax contributions from different states and in that how much our nothrn states like up, bihar, West Bengal are lagging because large percentage of population is involved in agriculture and primary base sectors. And you know in our country there is Tax on agriculture income. So these governments don't get enough money to develop our states like Gujrat, Karnataka and Maharashtra has developed.
I am from Bengal near santipur (which he mentioned in this video). My father told me about the strikes and lock out. Hope to see many more videos from you.
I have heard from a relative of bureaucrat in Bengal that people of Bengal especially in rural areas don’t want any kind of development to happen on their land they just want status quo. This kind of belief, environment and attitude has been inculcated in Bengali systems by local politicians and bureaucrats to keep the people deprived so that they can eat out the resources. That’s the main reason Bengal really needs political change.
@@jay-zy5bi Gujarat also one of the India's capitalist state. AMUL dairy brand which is India's one of the oldest and biggest company in co-operative sector started in 1946. Similarly In 1945 Late Vithalrao Vikhe Patil pioneered the first successful Co-operative Sugar Factory in the country at Pravaranagar in Ahmednagar District of Maharashtra which was commissioned in 1951. Maharashtra was ruled by congress for nearly 50 years under leaderships of Yashvantrao chavan, Sharad Pawar, Vilasrao Deshmukh, etc. These leaders really worked hard for development of Maharashtra. So you can see that these western states were already inclined towards capitalism instead of socialism of appeasement politics in the name of welfare schemes which you find rampant in northern part of India .
@Rory Awesome what should I watch?? The ganga fillded with dead bodies? People dying like ants??? Or rapists roaming free killing the victims whole family because they lodged a complaint???? You want muslims to die, non hindians to die, women to die, low casts to die, but now even you people are dying, those dead bodies floting in the ganga will be yours tomorrow. Atleast wake up now!!!
I'm kannadiga I have Bengali friends who works in Bengaluru and they say Kolkata roads are filled with beggers 😞😞 it is hard to believe once a rich state of India literally struggling today and I personally know many people who came to karnataka which is thousands of kilo meters away from home just for livelihood!!..Then there is no difference between Bimaru States and West Bengal now..really!😞😞
@Hitman well, i think cpim cannot come back easily as they are wiped out Cpm needs reforms. Too much of socialism backfires. Though I am a bjp inclined person but I still appreciate the buddhadeb for industrialisation which took pace during his rule as well as the industrialisation under mamta from past 2 - 3 yrs. But before that she created the mess and did blunders.
@@arc8244 Recently Mamata has begun with quite a bit of Industrialisation. Haldia port is being developed, Kalyani is being developed and a silicon valley of west bengal is also set in plan. Though I'm very skeptical about each of this considering that on paper they look good and a good start if they can be pulled of but even the metro network couldn't function properly since 2012. If they can't complete smtg like metro for 10 yrs how the hell are they going to make this work. Because these things would be of no use if they are completed 10-12 yrs later. Also the constant tussel with the center has not helped at all. First with CPIM and now Mamata.
This is happen for Jatyi basus great thinking who give a great speech "A computer can do 1000 labour's work" 😂🤣 Then it shift Bengal to bangalore and now see.... Where bengaluru and where Kolkata, 😭.... CPIM is the destroyer of golden Bengal
People who say Scandinavia is socialist are stupid. Scandinavia offers more Govt Welfare, which doesn't make it socialist. The money required to sustain those Welfare schemes is created because of Capitalism. Therefore, it is safe to say that Svandinavian economy is more free than US. Socialism is based on the assumption that there is unlimited money in the society, which of course is BS. The money and resources are limited, therefore only Capitalism can create more wealth than initial.
@@zfg07 talk about bengal not about Scandinavia....china & Scandinavia are fathers of capitalism now... Why left didn't brought industrialization in Bengal? Stop defending left... Nothing is left in left ...they only gave govt jobs to their wives & themselves roam with party flag
😂😆 Ditto. I just saw the title and knew the reasons straight away.. including the factor of partion . My father used to work in Calcutta ( now called Kolkata) and there is this one thing he said that still makes sense and resonates with me even today when I travel to Kolkata for some work - without the British and their construction and building ( heritage) Calcutta will look like any other Tier 4 city . The city looks like an old man about to die at the drop of the hat. The Bengal govt hasn't made a single memorable additional to the city post British colonial era.
Kerala has one of the highest living standards in india. Not to mention one of the best public education and universal health care. It's a far better place than any other state in the country to live. Both LDF and UDF did a good job. Nothing to blame
@@navjo1454 Dude it's quite true whatever you said but it's beacuse of all the foreign remittance that comes into the state. Otherwise what industry does Kerala have ? Like TN has a stong manufacturing hub or Karnataka and Telegana have IT and manufacturing .
Many will say that Bengal never received a good governance. But we forget that we the people of Bengal is directly responsible for this outcome. During the last election in 2021, we did had a chance for a change, but we preferred bangla nijer meyekei chai(bengal want its own girl). We all now know how it's gonna change the fate of Bengal for the coming years. Secondly, our mentality have changed drastically in recent years. From being the bravest people who fought for independence, to some lazy mindless and spineless people who prefer comedy and PNPC instead of dev talks. Hope things will change and bengal will shine with full colors.. 🥺
Bengalis don't give importance to economic development. Land was traditionally fertile in Bengal so food security was always there. They are more inclined towards cultural development, and TMC fits that bill perfectly. BJP may have a promise of economic growth, but was an outsider to Bengalis who will destroy their culture. Maybe Bengal needs the Tamil model, strong focus of economic uplifment along with cultural identity.
In this video - at one place, he said, freight equalization policy caused losses to economy , and at another place in this same video, he said removal of the same policy caused losses to economy??? Very poor analysis. Most places , he just said things , but did not explain how??
@@itss.b.5391 i think not political reasons but Hindus who always gave imp to other religions, disunited themselves with caste, language and never focused to development and safety of Hindus. Neta does what we want from them. If majority will be irrational , corrupt like Nehru, Duratma gandhi, mulayam , mamta, mayawati etc will keep coming.. no other community in the world is more apathetic to themselves than Hindus. This guy still doing same. He is just throwing illogical and inconclusive sentences here and there whatever he read from manipulated history and politics from school texts and anti india and anti Hindu media.
@@itss.b.5391 agree some truth is there.. but the way he criticize bjp and rss seems irrational... criticize no issues but give good logics not bad logics... i was just telling the real root cause of lagging inda lies in Hindus...not politicians... the politicians who were elected were elected by Bengali only.
@@TiwariAbhishek_ Of course. People of Bengal have decided. CPM , TMC destroyed west Bengal. Bjp will improve it. Look at bjp ruled states of Assam , Gujarat , MP , Haryana , UP , Maharashtra under previous rule and north eastern states.
@@nlgofficial76 You don't just agree but vote bjp And improve your image in India. People think Bengalis will vote bjp. Please keep up to our expectations
This might be unrelated to the video, but the worst thing about our history classes is that they teach nothing that happened after 1950. Edit: Damn, people started war in the replies 😂
Try visiting SonarUP....our India's pride...NASA has recently shifted it's headquarters there....the next Apollo mission is scheduled to be launched from Allahabad😘
@@orkkojit there are Biharis in Delhi and Mumbai too But there government has completely banned Even cycle rickshaws In Delhi all Bicycle rickshaws has been replaced by E-rickshaws whereas there has never been Rickshaws in Mumbai And in Kolkata it’s still using primitive Type of man pulling rickshaws not even bicycle rickshaws
Bengalis are intellectuals😀.. We discuss das kapital vs wealth of nations..but our work ethics is pathetic.. we can't deliver on the ground.. that's the sole reason for our downfall
@Lightening Emperor modi thori bengal election me khara ho rha hai jo modi ko vote de. BJP ke maximum mp aur mla ek number ke C hai. Dilip is busy taking out gold from cow milk🤣
@Dhruv tatti ye apke Papa ki photo hai na par beta apka surname galat hai whatsapp kam chalo or padai pe dyan do jo chahe ki photo laga lete Ho kya sach mai ye aisehi bina shirt ke apke ghar aye the jo sabko bata rahe Ho ye mere Papa hai isliye inki photo meri phechan
Bah bhai bhai, you r genius what a in depth analysis... Your channel must grow.. As a bengali we are also agree bengal become heaven to hell now.. ☹️☹️😡😡
@@Sagarjk333 I know bengali r good but how we can say if we can't select proper govt right from independent that's why our state economic drastically changes it goes heaven to hell all other parameters are also becoming same day by day.. Then when in born intelligence will take action whenever we can't sustain in future also..
Mujhe to ye nahi samajh aa raha ki jab *TMC & CPIM* jesi parties Bengal ka itna bura haal kar rahi hai......aur log is baat se agree bhi karte hain To 2021 election me phirse TMC ko phirse kyu jitaaye😐🤦
Couldn't agree more...and the Tata factory shutdown was actually a blow that shattered all our dreams... Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee was the only CM who actually cared about these horrible conditions but we couldn't have him for a long run in the office...💔
POLITICAL CORRUPTION & OVER POPULATION ARE BIGGEST PROBLEMS OF INDIA. INDIA MUST BE MADE CORRUPTION FREE AS COMMON MAN LIFE IS CRIPPLED DUE TO MASSIVE POLITICAL CORRUPTION FROM TOP TO BOTTOM. WHEN THAT DAY WILL COME. MODI GOVT IS JUST GIVING FALSE PROMISES SINCE 2014 WHEN HE BECAME PM BUT FORGET ABOUT CORRUPTION HE PROMISED TO WHOLE COUNTRY WHEN VOTERS OF INDIA HAVE GIVEN BJP ABSOLUTE MAJORITY BUT THE PEOPLE'S DREAM WAS NEVER FULFILLED BY MODI GOVT SO FAR. WHEN PEOPLE CAN LIVE IN PEACE & PROSPERITY IN THIS COUNTRY. WHILE THIS COUNTRY IS MADE GRAZING FIELDS BY CORRUPT & GREEDY POLITICIANS OF ALL POLITICAL PARTIES.
@PM Сен ақымақсың lol wtf? India is a highly capitalist country and under PM modi who has pushing forward his neo liberalism policies and ruining the entire country. Don't comment about things you don't know
@PM Сен ақымақсың 😂😂😂 wow you are one twisted nutjob. Please do some reading first. The govt up until the 90' was trying to reduce economic disparities.If you wanna call that socialism, sure whatever. After 90's India bake highly market oriented and has since always been skewed towards a free market economy.
Left destroyed the whole northeastern belt. First they did shit in WB. Then ultimately their impact was felt on Bihar leading to violence in 90s during the most important phase of liberalisation
As a bengali I want Bengal to become the the greatest state of india in every sectors...Although I am from Bangladesh I feel proud whenever I see Bengal doing good in anything...Love from Bangladesh.
We are always taught to be thankful to bengal for the help they provided to end the world war 2 and protect many British citizens. Unfortunately it caused deaths of many Innocent people. their loss will always be remembered. Thank you and heartfelt condolences ❤️🙏🏻 Jai hind✊🏻
I have never seen any Bengali or national media broadcasting behind the story of the current situation of Bengal with such detailed stats and figures. You have done an excellent job. And honestly, I, being a Bengali did not know many of the facts you share in this truly informative video. Kudos.
@SUPERHERO It would be better to vote for BJP this time and then some other party next time because variety is the spice of life as is none will be able to do anything
@@xiaoshen194 ok bro bina koi news source ke "talents" khatam kar diya, cool af. kal bolna ghar me machhar communism ki wajah se aare, baarish kam communism ki wajah se hori aur desh me kam hospital bhi communism ki wajah se hai.
I watched a video by vivek bindra on same topic..but that was full of hatred for bengali..he criticised everything ( pronunciation) and gave fake information .. But your video is appropriate and full of genuine research information . Thatswhy i like u mohak
intellectual?? so all you have to do is read news articles to show you are an intellectual? hmmm... no ground level knowledge i guess bass hawa mein baate karo lol
@@madtitanoboa462 it takes a certain level of intelligence, analysis and conviction to gather different information, make something out of it and connect the dots. I won't tell that he's an intellectual, but to claim that he has 'no ground knowledge' is just blatant understatement, or bullshit that is
As someone living in Bengal, the point mentioned in 12:29 perfectly explains one of the reasons behind the overcrowded trains heading into the city full of labourers from the suburban. Yes, I'm talking about the Bongaon local, Dankuni local and all the other similar trains.
Left front destroyed Bengal, U also missed the jyoti basu's English removal in primary education. This was one of the if not the biggest blunder he did. That decreased our potential in service sector which southern India enjoyed now. All the high paying jobs now gone
Tell that to the crores of farmers that got land from landlords and the teachers that got their salaries for the first time . English removal was a blunder . However , no Indian state except Nagaland had English in their state curriculum at that time .
@@pavelchakraborty9942 then what??the positives stop right thr...thr stay in power was justified until late 80s and early 90s..but after Liberalization of indian economy jyoti basu held on to power for nearly 10 long years though bullying tactics and electoral (mis) management until buddha babu took his place...but even he was paralysed as the grassroot cadres and local committes were not in synch with his industrial policies...bengal missed the bus for 10 long years..and that gap has increased over the years..i m not a fan of bjp or tmc..but left must have a deeper look into thr own crimes before pointing fingers...
the fact that infosys was turned way from bengal in the 80s and left protested against rajeev gandhi's IT based industrial policy shows that bengal govt at that time had no idea abt what they were doing...mindless obsession with one ideology despite its impractical application in a democracy like india while not taking advantage of newer technologies hurt bengal a lot...
@@AvanRoyOfficial Highest unemployment rate in modi raj According to ncrb data one girl is raped in every 15min in our country India's name now is on Hungery list,etc etc etc So why the hell we vote for bjp !
@I Love Democracy vai kiuki humko apna rights nahi khona hain na...industry tho china and north korea main bhi hain... ab -24% +gdp walo ko biswas kaise kar le...😐
@I Love Democracy bjp is not a solution...ofcourse it will be better until its in the center..but then what??bjp doesnt have credible leaders here and thr growth in bengal is not organic...as the video said that the policies of gst and demo has destroyed the unorganized and msme sectors which is a significant portion of bengal economy..so in a way lately bjp policies has hurt bengal a lot just like the freight equalization policy of the 60s....thr is also a fact that bjp's policies antagonize one section of bengal's population which is not a good thing for a developing state...bengal needs holistic development for msme sector and large scale industries along with significant public sector investment in human resource public health and infrastructure development..going by history bjp govts have a good track record of investment in infrastructure..but when it comes to public health and education...thr govts invest very less on them as those sectors r not a priority for them...
Very nice video. Being a bengali it breaks my heart to say that from being an economic powerhouse now people has to go outside to other states just to earn a livelihood. But this is what it is.
Man you speak fast... took about 2 hours to watch (stop, start, read subtitles, make notes, sit and ponder, smile) but worth every second! Phew India... ripping out by the roots doesn't even sum up this.... as removing the soil is downright despicable! The Spirit of a Bengal Cat brought me here.. ALL 9 of EM and a kit-TEN xxx
Socialism in capitalistic economics is the way to go. Socialism on itself is an utopia that doesn't work because humans are corruptible..unlike other states such as tamilnadu which has socialistic policies but has capitalistic outlook to it too. It's the delicate dance that most States have missed..
@@yethir7327 true, it is a delicate balance. One needs to study what happens in US compared to Nordic states which have higher standards of living but virtually every piece of tech we see around originates in US and a miniscule amount from Europe. Even in the US the states that give the most handouts and where there are more taxes have the highest number of homeless people. Socialism succeeded only in the Israeli kibbutzim, but people left kibbutz as more wealth got generated and today because of a free and democratic society, Israel has the most tech startups outside US.
@@Vpy2023 as long as you don't have AI, the problem is USA model thrives because of poverty outside the country that brings its own share of people who want to come to USA to succeed. USA has also has had a head start in several departments, but then look at the nature of development right now, is USA really building its wealth? The salary growth rate has been slow and the inflation adjusted income value shows lesser buying power to people. And no, countries like Switzerland or more innovative that USA and have socialistic outlook to their structure too. To dismiss Nordic countries which have the highest happiness index and then making a point about produce alone as the prime idea dismisses the other parts of USA such as invasion, exploitation etc. I do not see where you draw this parallel while comparing when you literally see development in south indian states where the socialistic policies have done good
@@Vpy2023 I am concerned that you haven't accepted that so many of our models are socialistic. Eduation, medicine etc are low cost here especially because of socialism, the medical cost of USA outs 600,000 people every year in poverty. Why don't we speak about that? What are the prices of important medical goods and services which are so high cost there that people literally come to India to do their treatment. Dismissing the merits of socialistic policies especially when job creation at an all time low because of AI induced job loss only creates net negative jobs. We have a unique situation right now.
Bengal was never socialist. It had a poorly developed capitalist economy with a communist party in power that was actually social democratic in nature. P.S. : read marx and check the massive industrial growth in USSR under handcore socialist planning and not Khrushchevite revisionist market socialism.
Fabulous video with in-depth research! Truly commendable job. And as a Bengali, it was really enlightening to know what all actually led to its downfall.
Communists were doing wrong then we change the government after 32 years (people understood lately) but now the ruling party is doing the same for 10 years (People understood this time)but this time people could not change the government. Current ruling party was the reason of TATA's shutdown in Singur.
Mujhe to ye nahi samajh aa raha ki jab *TMC & CPIM* jesi parties Bengal ka itna bura haal kar rahi hai......aur log is baat se agree bhi karte hain To 2021 election me phirse TMC ko phirse kyu jitaaye😐🤦
Gujrat had the highest number of Child deaths, and biggest per person economical gap, and least govt. sponsored health structure. It's the same Scenerio like today where the rich business mans gets more richer and the poor families gets even poor. You need to understand the whole context
Every state has its pros and cons Gujrat with the far right govt has achieved excellent economic progress but zero social progress. The whole scenario reverses for Kerala under the left. The manufacturing sector is almost inexistent though the service sector is improving
@@kavithviswanath1052 zero social progress? lol gujarat is a good state economically not great and decent state socially not as great as kerala but far better than many other indian states , its not the best state but it is not backwards neither socially nor economically like you are trying to portray it
@@adityaramachandran591 West Bengal is a part of India and the main decision makers are in Delhi. The coal and iron excise duty law and other kind of barriers put before the industrialization of West Bengal was by Delhi, not the voters who voted of "communists".
@@OkarinHououinKyouma created a toxic culture of political violence....made business difficult.... industries fled away...the richest state in India is now in this condition
Strikes and Lockouts were the worst gift that Left gifted everywhere. I am from Kanpur and I still see the graves of industries. BTW, your sources description method is good.
May be the next video should be on why Maharashtra and Gujarat are much more industrialized..this would give a true picture, what went wrong in east and what went right in west
The difference between GJ, MH and Bengal is In bengal society is build up politically but in other two states it is still in cast based like early 19th, 20th centuries. Because the society has build politically we are united to each other. You hv seen this TATA nano projects where lands were captured illegally and handed over to TATA. Whole state supported to this movement People from every villages, town join against TATA. There are multiple examples of that. But what problem with you is your society are not united. Divided into race, cast due to which no one care what is happening with farmers, vegitable vendors, labour, home less peoples. Not a single news network covers that except NDTV. Which expose the dark reality of behind richness of maharastra and gujrate.
In bengal we dont have farmers suicide case in last 5 years or 10 years or more. But your state Maharastra farmer suicide case tops in no 1 position. The bullet train project so called "development" displaced hundreds of farmers from their ancestral land, there land has been forcefully captured. They were crying infront of news camera and screaming for helps but again no one to help them. The only solution is to push the communism in these two states. Then it will be clear like day light about how this two states becoming richer by political mafias like BJP.
Yes we need more ambani and adani kind of folks . I mean free and fair competition required for development our country. Example Andhra Pradesh become adani Pradesh he bought by force all private owned sea ports majority of ports like Krishna patnam , gangavaram,machali patnam,bavana padu . Centralisation of resources in handful number of people leads to neo feudalism and creates economical and social imbalances in society. Socialism sucks but croni capitalism much worse then that. We all are going pay for this one day irrespective of political parties.
@@kohlidhoni1591 yes socialism only works in paper. The who behind Karl Marx Communist manifesto are same people who funded Hitler in world war 2. These people are known as London bankers/wall Street gang Socialism, capitalism and golbalism all these ism's ultimate goal is one thing divide and rule the masses which leads to to global autocracy.
@@chidambaranathans1975 Oo dear don't defend the other side all central govt irrespective of parties discriminate Eastern states from 1st .....What about Odisha , Bihar, Assam 🤷♂️
I am from Bengal and I loved big posters of Mamta Banerjee in every Durga Pandal. If it was of Modi I would have called it fascist but it's our Mamta Didi so it's okay😊
Left party ruled in kerala also, as a keralite who lived in North India, I strongly believe that ,its the reason why kerala is so literate and secular. The balance was kept between left and congress unlike in Bengal,where they dominated 35 yrs.
In Kerala, there's a culture of keeping the good policy of previous government & implementation of it by next government. There's less vengeful attitude in politics. Though there's priority over idealism exist but lesser in comparison to Bengal. This is the success story of Kerala & doom story of Bengal's.
Problem is TMC continued what left begin... tmc is more focused on freebies than infrastucture / long term development.... Law and order situation is every worst, i heard stories where people have pay money to TMC goons to contructure thier own house.... I hope things change soon... bengal was the power house of india’s development before.... we want to bengal to re start growth again, not just for bengal but for entire india
I live in West Bengal . Same applies for BJP too . Every party has their own goons. Here we need to pay BJP goons too for making house as BJP holds the municipality in our town .
@@Appollo2005 bjp is not even in power in west bengal. Those goons u are talking about must be goons from tmc in disguise. Becoz that cut money eventually goes to the ruling party's hand irrespective of whoever takes it. And they take full control of this aspect.
@@deborshibiswas9629 ever heard of MLA , MP ? Bjp gets much money as they hold the central govt. Accept or not , bjp too has many goons and they aren't disguised tmc goon . 🙄
@@Appollo2005 what nonsense!! Bjp has it's state govt in 14 states and no allegations as such has had been recorded thus far. And if your statement is true for west bengal then why the ruling tmc didn't order an investigation into the matter??.. And for your kind information MLA's belong from the ruling party and bjp is in opposition here in bengal.
Bengal is highly polluted because of the unregulated organizations. I live in a fairly clean township. 5 km east and I enter bengal with higher temperatures, high air and land pollution. It's saddening
The Wealth of Bengal used to flow from the river Ganges to the river Thames. Bengal was the worst effected state of India by British Imperialism. Britishers used to cut the fingers of Weaver of Dhakai Muslin Saree, the then most fine Saree in entire world. Even there was a gteat Famine in Bengal in 1943 that was artificially caused by Winston Churchill. Still after the independence Bengal flourished a lot so far as the Industries are concerned under Congress era but people were starving. The wealth was captured by few Rich. Then the violent Naxalite Movement took place by 70s and Industries started to fly away. Uniformed People assume that the trade union of CPIM party stopped Bengal's Industrial growth but it's false. The reason was Naxalite Movement, much before CPIM came to power in 1977. Even Naxalites used to kill CPIM leaders equally. Jyoti Basu massively decreed Lands from big Zamindaars and Distributed them amongst Landless Farmers that is called the famous land reform of Bengal, unique in India. And Bengal again started to flourish. Still Bengal's GDP is higher than the average GDP of rest of India. Thank You for making this video.
Oh yea land redistribution.. That always works out so well. Social polices have time and again brought down civilizations, cause of misaligned incentives. It does not incentivise innovation, but bigger government and imbalance of power which corrupt and power hungry people step up to take. It's a death spiral
Sad to say this but after todays election result, people of Bengal have rejected for a change, after suffering for so many years people should realize that gov change (Be is BJP or Congress) can get some changes to the society which will in turn make an impact on their children's future. There is no investment in Bengal for so many years, students are leaving the state to get IT jobs. I have many friends who are Bengali and they are supprised to see how developed Mumbai, Bangalore is. People are responsible they just dont want the change.
Bhai I am also from Bengal but living in Pune. Problem yahan ye hai k BJP ke paas achche local leaders nahi hain jo ki logon ki problems samjhe and address karein. Only hindutva mudda nahi hota, Bengal me real mudda industrialization tha, but unfortunately kisine address nahi kiya. Jaise aapke Maharashtra ke local leaders jaante the ke logon ko exactly kya chahiye, isliye itna developed hai Maharashtra.
During 2007 Bengal was leading in agri sector being top rice, vegetables and jute producers in the country. Then government decided ki bas agriculture se kuch nhi hoga state has to push for capex. Graduates are leaving the cities and going to other states. Asansol, singur, raghunath pur, haldia belt was selected. Mou were signed with compaies like Tatas, dalmiyas, Balajis and PSUs like NTPC, Bhel, DVC to make bengal a manufacturing hub. Increasing haldia port capacity would revamped the infa of entire eastern India. While cities were chosen as IT hub like Rajarhat, saltlake in South Bengal and siliguri in north bengal. The work did started with great response from the companies but land acquisition was the main problem. I am not going into politics. The Jyoti basu government use to practice such things like working more towards society than corporates. Land reform is an example where land from zamindars were distributed. Buddhadeb govt faced political dissent when opted for industrialisation.
Heard that siliguri has started again. And it would be turned into IT hub of North bengal. Rajarhat and salt lake has already progressed a lot. And plans of making a silicon Valley in New Town and Rajarhat is going on. Just hope development actually and not just stay on paper or initial phase.
@TH-cam Politics lol.. I don't have any idea about that.. But Gujarat and Maharashtra both are one of the richest state.. Faar better than Rajasthan,up and hat shitty Bihar.. And South India is better than this two states..
@@aquarianfighter5384 you north indians think the south is some fricking utopia? it's not that great here either. Maharashtra is just as good as the southern states if not better
@TH-cam Politics don't be a blind person.. All metro cities are equally good. Ahmedabad, Surat, Bangalore, mumbai,Pune etc Each city has there own unique speciality..
Being marathi I can say that what other states can learn from Bengal is never allow leftist or communist or so called socialist to rule your state/country
You have Wrong Idea About Communists Those Communists Were Ruled Bengal They Couldn't Work By Following the Ideology Because They thought CPIM Will Rule Bengal Forever. They were Frauds.If CPIM have honest Leaders State or Country Can Much Develop
please make this kind of detailed video on Odisha. It's really hard to find and it's time people of other states acknowledge that there is a state called Odisha.
Even though I am 19 y/o from Kokata. I didnot know so much about my state. Thank you so much for making us aware of the facts. Actually bengal has been politcally sound and the corruption in the last 10-15 years has increased a lot due to which the development of bengal has been affected. Big industries are no more coming to bengal. Whichever politicians come in power after this election should try to make things right and make imrovement. Also the young generation (including me) should start taking things i our own hand by starting big business and industries which shall employ a lot of people.
It is for Bengalis to make Bengal bright.. I see many Bengalis who are well off and highly educated moving out to other places.. many Bengalis have sacrificed to bring changes to the Indian society and in freedom struggle.. why don’t they start it again.. if Maharastra is better .. credit to a large extent have to be given to Maharashtrians .. similarly others
Being a Bengali and from Bengal I like how unbiasedly he just gave us the actual facts and a summary of a research going for many years❤️
@Sumit A yeah we know we are in a shitty situation. Just don't know if BJP will do anything to bring us out of it if they win.
Yes you are right he is way better than Vivek bindra👍
@Arijit Roy Hyderabad is better then Kolkata
Unbiased probably because he isn't a Bengali...
😂😂 Bengal is a failed state that's what happened when you vote for parties like left and TMC..
We are living in a date when TH-camrs giving information and News Media giving entertainment
Edit: Thanx for 3k likes :)
It's laughter therapy to put people out of depression from current situation
@Lightening Emperor his fanbase would think it😂
@Lightening Emperor I never said that....you are completely off topic
Absolutely.❤️
@Lightening Emperor rest of them are true...but for open letter,the only reason for u to think him as anti modi is...he ask questions to leftists,is this the valid reason to call him pro modi?
This type of content should in History chapters
Unlike Cramming all the history dates
Our HISTORY is FULL OF LIES.
@@div2954 aisa koi proof bhi hai, ki sirf rss ne bola isliye?
@iTs Messiah Exactly.
@@paradoxicalcitizen1139 wo rss ka worker hai kya??
@iTs Messiah these rss people never participated in the freedom struggle also but Nehru Gandhi ko criticise karna ho toh, they'll be ahead of the line.
For decline of Bengal, only person to be blamed is people of Bengal themselves..I have stayed and travelled across the country and world and being a Bengali myself can say this for sure..Our attitude our mindset..No party can improve situation in Bengal because the people themselves doesn't want to improve in any of the aspects..It might sound harsh but that's the sad reality...
You made a mistake by voting tmc
exactly same thoughts bro
We are so fond of our past that we always think and tell about it but not change the present
Abhirup Guha Roy, I salute you for the responsibility taken by you. One more point I want to add when we choose our representatives in democracy, it is clear that majority party will rule the state and party will also lift the aspirations of majority only then he will come in power again and again. Jyoti Basu did the same. He also done many great works in begal for majority. There are many state which are not industrialised but their per capita income is higher than industrial states because of other source of income, low population density, migration of people to other place for better jobs, enterprising nature and where political rivalry are detached from social rivalry and not so staunch. I am from Bihar and lives in Gujarat for 20 years and conclusively say that if Gujarat is developed the major reasons are enterprising nature of Gujarati, no hesitation in migrating to other country and state, high investment and low lavish expenses, solution minded, less social conflict. Of course better infrastructure electricity by govt have been given but this is also main demand of people here.
Absolutely. We are the main reason for our condition. 👍
I am Marathi person living and working in Mumbai/Thane, when I visit Kolkata I feel the city is in 80s or 90s, there is no concept of underground cables, Kolkata may have got first Metro in India but Delhi and Mumbai metro infrastructure is much better.
My former Bengali boss used to say that any Bengali who has made fortune has made it outside of West Bengal.
Edit: I'm not saying Mumbai or any other city or state is perfect, but genuinely thinks Kolkata have missed the bus somewhere which I am hopeful they will come back.
@@AllInOne-bv1ti then why bengali people come to work in maharashtra, your socialist state was not able to give them job or what
@@shardamohite2670 sorry for him as a bengali
@@shardamohite2670 non acceptance of reality is causing him migrate here.
@@shardamohite2670 population density of Bengal is 4 times of Maharashtra. So people will come. No surprise. And Maharashtra wants them. We have seen during lockdown how Mumbai/ Nashik economy are so dependent on labours from North and East India
@@anjankumarchowdhury7379 I have many Bengali friends here in pune and they are not labrours, but very wise, Bajaj auto owner is also a Bengali by root who setteled in pune. just because the state is shit does not mean the people are at fault and the video shows that the CPI caused all the problems.
I being a young Bengali, living in Kolkata, West Bengal - I completely exactly agree with this video.... Nowadays, we get more information from good TH-cam channels than News channels.... Real truth explained by TH-camrs. Keep up your good work. 👌👌👌
Vote for সংযূক্ত মোর্চা
@@subhajitdutta8563 Sorry, but I yet don't have the right to vote....exactly today I turned 14. (My bd 2nd April)
Once I have the right to vote - I will vote for the party which has done things matching with my ideology....😎
yes im from Bengal. i too agree
@goenje shuya কোনো ইনফরমেশন নেই এই ভিডিও তে।এই ছেলেটা বিজেপির দালাল।আগেও অনেক ভিডিওতে বিজেপির হতে দালালি করেছে মিশিনফর্মেশন ছড়াচ্ছে।
@Bruce wayne I don't vote for Mamata Banerjee, my family we doesn't support TMC party....And I don't have the right the vote...I am 14years old. Besides, the vote of 1person does not decide which will be the RULING party....if you are an Indian citizen- I think you know that....most people here in Kolkata are voting for TMC (because it's their wish) & I can do nothing about that....
Can u imagine a State in India during 50's or 60's has it's own Engineers, Scientist, Doctors, Economist...Working in every sectors in India as well as in abroad.…! Bengal had all this capabilities at that time, that required for a state to sharply overshoot any state technologically, Educationally, Economically. No doubt that Before 70s Bengal was ahead of time.
Modern education came to Bengal earlier than other regions of India. Some of the oldest colleges and Universities were built in Bengal, many from early 1800s.
Now a failed state🤣🤣
@@AJ56878 😏😏 But never think that it will continue for long. Bengal still has potential to overshoot any other states including Gujrate, UP, Karnataka or even Maharastra or may be as equal as Maharastra. It is Failed for poor administration of Left and now 10 years of corruption of TMC which leads to "brain drain" to other state or abroad. Let, a mature party come in Bengal. I can guarantee within few year it would be the most flourished state.
@Ansul Hackerman Unfortunately we don't have other option rather BJP. TMCs autocracy or u can say a kind of authoritarian rule has utterly destroyed the situation for emerging any other rival political party. If u do either you will shot dead or your house will be burn down and you will never get help from police, or if u go to police your family will be at high risk. You from other state so you will not understand that unless you come and stay here for at least 1 month. You can imagine the situation of this state that CM provoking people to attack CRPF. Hence only BJP is the answer as of now.
British der Calcutta main city chilo tai modern college ar schools protheme
The most worst thing of West Bengal is that their is very few large cities but it has the fourth largest population in India and most people in countrysides depends upon Kolkata.
No job,Totally corrupted state
No system.
I am from Kolkata..
Exactly there are semi built cities like durgapur and kalyani which if worked upon can easily become big enough cities to reduce the pressure from Kolkata. Also New town and Rajarhat is growing and in next 5 yrs can become what Noida is to Delhi.
Heard that Kalyani is being developed but very skeptical considering how much it takes here to see actual development. But if they can then it would be a great prospect.
few big city !!! only 1 we have it's Kolkata
Khela hobe
WE NEED TO WRITE LETTERS TO CM INDIVIDUALLY...
Totally agree ...
Being a Bengali I can only say, this is the only unbiased and simple explanation of Bengali Economy I have ever seen.
My grandfather once said, " Those who have seen the 34 yrs of CPIM rule will never vote CPIM again "
@@mohammedfayiz1905 You don't know how Bengalis suffered under CPIM rule
@@mohammedfayiz1905 kerela is a whole different story as compared to Bengal, Communism is the biggest reason for the downfall here and people have still not recovered from it.
@@mohammedfayiz1905 Communists in kerala aren't really communists , they are social democrats who like to pretend like they are highly ideological marxists. Plus kerala communists never used non-state paramilitary forces and goons to use political violence to the maximum amount.
@@mohammedfayiz1905 Kerela model is a failure if you compared them to other south indian states like Karnataka, tamil nadu and Andhra Pradesh. Only thing Kerela is good at is literacy and life expectancy but still Kerela is 100 times better than bimaru states.
@@harivatsaparameshwaran4174 anyone who understand basic economics will not support communism that's why you will find arts student mostly inclined towards communism while most science students and commerce students incline towards capitalism hence bjp.
As a Bengali, I 100% approve this video's accuracy.
@jithu krishnalol.
@jithu krishna Big LOL 😂
@jithu krishna development shayad kr bhi de bjp parr us k liye democracy ki kurbani ni denge
We need left again
I also live in Bengal and this video is true
This happened... Corrupt Politicians came
on the other hand,
Himachal has risen up from poorest to one of the best
Despite Indian gov. ignoring us due to our less political significance, we are still going strong
This basically proves Honest and Hardwork overpower Corruption
Let's give a chance to Aam Aadmi party
@@punnadebnath2214 4 saal 😥😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
@@ankittola8596vlo kichu pata gala wait kortai hoi go.... asabadi thako
@@punnadebnath2214 west bengal e wait korar diffirent meaning ache , project deadline r pore suru hoi ...🤣
@@punnadebnath2214 socialism in place of socialism will turn into a graveyard so only it needs globalisation to sustain
"Losing glory hurts more than breakup .."
- koi toh bola hoga
Koi to bola hoga 😂👍
Agent 47
Losing glory after breakup is over 3000
abra cadabra simple solution ..
bilkul sahi, bajud hi mitt jata hai.
*_On News Channel there are so many debates on useless topics but no one talks on economy, development, literacy, unemployment, etc. Salute to such TH-camrs who show reality with detailed explanation._*
Economy , development , growth all are product of social structure . If you choose TMC and communist who only got business of changing demography and ruthlessly ruling people than how U would get economic growth .
Ppl like U don't understand a peaceful society is a prosperous society . You cannot get economy or growth when U have 20 military n illegal extremist coming in state with help of ruling govt who are are destroying social structure .
Because it's boring
The fact is people don't expect these things from Godi media. Mostly come for debate(big boss). The people who actually want to know what's happening in the country they somehow gather the news.
@@TM-vh1qg godi media kaha de agyi yaha? As if Wire, NDTV and quint toh propaganda felate nai hain. Left and right media are like yin and yang. The problem is the left is on the losing side because of their false narratives that they always put forward, right makes the most of it. Karlo dange.
@@a9a9d lol controlling border comes under center you don't have this basic understanding you call yourself woke citizen who knows everything. Lol
Singur was a dream project
If TATA did make factory there, one by one many businessmen will start business there.
Singur would have been our next KOLKATA
😥
Yes it's our fault to stop the communists from developing Singur
@@nabhasvanchakravarty9292 Communists or Tata😏😏😏😏
@@yourfriend2344 A common citizen 😏😏
@@yourfriend2344 😏😏😏😏
@@nabhasvanchakravarty9292 In first reply you have written incorrect spelling of common citizen as Communists. Maybe autocorrect of your keypad 😏😏😏
It's not that Bengal textile could not compete with Britain, the fact is Bengal textile industry was systematically destroyed by British, to flourish their textiles. They looted the raw materials produced in Bengal and sent to Britain, broke weaving machines, cut fingers of Bengali weavers. Million of weavers died out of poverty. What British did to bengalis was unimaginable.
Why can't wait stop blaming 75 year old
I was also thinking that.
even if that were the case, it still would have been impossible to beat industries in UK with high tech machines. I don't know why they went through the trouble of cutting the wings even if the birds were already inside the cage.
Don't live in past.
While the city of Calcutta was starving London was flourishing.
I am Bengali, living in Canada...not only me but all my friends lives either in south like hydrabad, chennai, Bangaluru or in US, canada and Europe
Good choice . Better than living in a state or place that literally kills your motivation and chances for being educated and skilled.
Don't wry about the naysayers . You will find them aplenty . They are actually frustrated beacuse they are stuck in the hellhole themselves.
They want to bring those who go up and do well in life as they themselves do not have the brains or guts to take risks in life.
@@rah8985 bhai sach bolu to there are 1.2 billion of us, making whites a minority in their countries will prove to be catastrophic in the future, i am also emigrating out of india, but to Singapore because there are than 2 billion asians and asian population is increasing
@@gottalovesaurav As long as you are contributing and are an asset to any community and society and country you are winner as a human being .
Whichever country you go to it's important to live amicably and peacefully ine assimilate with the local population there . That's the only thumb rule .
this is not how it works, white countries were at their peak when they were majority white. Multiethnic and multicultural nations dont work for long for a reason, what you are saying would have perfect if white people always remained a supermajority, say 90%, and 10% of the remaining population was built up of high iq indians and east asians and latinos.
@@gottalovesaurav That is our problem if we don't keep a check on our population .
The editing is masterstroke
Johnny Harris is the benchmark to make such AE composition. Do check him out you will know why.
@@vinayb6444 Johny's videos are lit AF✨
@@vinayb6444 The only one remotely close to johnny s production is mohak .He has improved his quality times fold in the last 8 to 10 videos. u cant even tell that this is the same soch as say 1 year ago . excellent work done by his and his team if there is one anyway
@@dedsync Totally agree with you... We need such quality content in india 😎
Kudos to Mohak & Team for putting their best efforts.
Vox walo Ka copy karr rha ye Banda
I live near Kalyani in West Bengal. It was once an economic hub. So many factories and so many workers were working. Now, most of the factories are like ruins. :(
@Anirudh k Literally the entire Hooghly Industrial Zone (Shilpanchol) is in shambles.
I live in Kalyani Ablock A 8 house no 103
@Kaushal Batavia fir tho gau mutra & gobar wali BJP he ??
@@priyangshude9800 Compared to TMC, BJP toh accha hi hain.
@@white-demonn BJP west bengal me kab power me the ???
Being a Bengali living in WB for almost 2 decade. Top 3 reason according to me;
1. Partition
- Most of our industrial region went to Bangladesh.
- Value of ports in Kolkata decreased.
2. Border issues
- Illegal infiltration.
- Illegal cross-border trade.
- This results in stagnated growth in border areas.
2. Left rule
- Lack in proper ideology (or no vision).
- Almost no development since last 30 years.
But in the video this guy hinting Maharashtra and Gujarat for our economic failures.
Current situation in Bengal has nothing to with those western states.
Maharashtra infact got massive advantage of capitalism and cooperative sector, that's why they got largest economy in our country.
@Sujan Mondal brother,India's largest organised sector industries are in the states of Maharashtra and Karnataka because their were no left and communist government in the past and congress ruled this states for majority of time which stayed away from appeasement politics in the name of welfare schemes.
So Maharashtra is largast contributor in direct taxes which is nearly 40% of total collected tax from states.
Followed by delhi(11%) Karnataka (10%).
But in case of BIHAR(0.65%)- third largest population, UP(3.5%)- largest population, Bengal (4%)-fourth largest population. You can see that they hardly contribute to direct tax revenue. If you doesn't improve tax base and tax collection how the government is gonna get money for development and infrastructure.
@@MayurK-ko9styou are talking about tax, first tell me how many toll pazzas or sea ports will you find in West Bengal ? First see total area of West Bengal below 1 sq. km. And how many toll pazzas are or sea ports are in Maharashtra? How many tourist spots? Taj Mahal is not located in West Bengal and also ISRO is not located in West Bengal and also Bombay High is not located in West Bengal. So mention all, if you want to talk about revenue of The Government or service sectors and don't forget Delhi is the capital of India.
@@MayurK-ko9st Up, Bihar, Wb has Huge population destiny.Karantaka, Gujarat 3 times bigger than bengal.
But we are first ranked Rice, Potato, Joot, Fish production second rank tea production.
Wb has Everything, Himalaya To Beach, Neighbourhood country. Okk.
@@AllInOne-bv1ti Thanks for information brother.
But i here i was comparing economy of states. You know for Maharashtra Gujrat and karnataka they dont depend on agriculture economy
But they also improved industrial and service sector which is prime driving force of their economy in which our Up, bihar and west Bengal lagging.
In one of the above comments i talked about tax contributions from different states and in that how much our nothrn states like up, bihar, West Bengal are lagging because large percentage of population is involved in agriculture and primary base sectors.
And you know in our country there is Tax on agriculture income.
So these governments don't get enough money to develop our states like Gujrat, Karnataka and Maharashtra has developed.
I am from Bengal near santipur (which he mentioned in this video). My father told me about the strikes and lock out. Hope to see many more videos from you.
I learned somewhere that LIBERALS LOVE ECONOMY 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
And THEIR biggest enemy is socialist.and . communist..
Amio oi jaiga thekei shantipur er kachhe
I have heard from a relative of bureaucrat in Bengal that people of Bengal especially in rural areas don’t want any kind of development to happen on their land they just want status quo. This kind of belief, environment and attitude has been inculcated in Bengali systems by local politicians and bureaucrats to keep the people deprived so that they can eat out the resources. That’s the main reason Bengal really needs political change.
@@vishalrajyaguru2597 It's changing slowly after internet and jio boom. Before 2017 situation was total grave but now it is less grave.
I'm a resident of Dhakuria for the last 25 years
Never knew this
I was born in dhakuria. even i didn't know
Wtf. Same.
😂😂😂..
Hi bangali hi tui...😂😂
Wtf😂
Mamta AandNamazis
As a resident of WB I can say we have never got a good leader. All corrupt people. CPM was bad, TMC is even worse.
@@MayurK-ko9st what about Gujarat?
@@jay-zy5bi Gujarat also one of the India's capitalist state. AMUL dairy brand which is India's one of the oldest and biggest company in co-operative sector started in 1946.
Similarly In 1945 Late Vithalrao Vikhe Patil pioneered the first successful Co-operative Sugar Factory in the country at Pravaranagar in Ahmednagar District of Maharashtra which was commissioned in 1951.
Maharashtra was ruled by congress for nearly 50 years under leaderships of Yashvantrao chavan, Sharad Pawar, Vilasrao Deshmukh, etc. These leaders really worked hard for development of Maharashtra.
So you can see that these western states were already inclined towards capitalism instead of socialism of appeasement politics in the name of welfare schemes which you find rampant in northern part of India .
Ha anun bjp ke. Gorur gu mut khye acche din e thakbo..
@@BlackSakura33 who said anything about bjp?
@Rory Awesome what should I watch?? The ganga fillded with dead bodies? People dying like ants??? Or rapists roaming free killing the victims whole family because they lodged a complaint???? You want muslims to die, non hindians to die, women to die, low casts to die, but now even you people are dying, those dead bodies floting in the ganga will be yours tomorrow. Atleast wake up now!!!
I'm kannadiga I have Bengali friends who works in Bengaluru and they say Kolkata roads are filled with beggers 😞😞 it is hard to believe once a rich state of India literally struggling today and I personally know many people who came to karnataka which is thousands of kilo meters away from home just for livelihood!!..Then there is no difference between Bimaru States and West Bengal now..really!😞😞
@Hitman in 2008 mamta was busy in doing a blunder.
@Hitman well, i think cpim cannot come back easily as they are wiped out
Cpm needs reforms. Too much of socialism backfires.
Though I am a bjp inclined person but I still appreciate the buddhadeb for industrialisation which took pace during his rule as well as the industrialisation under mamta from past 2 - 3 yrs. But before that she created the mess and did blunders.
@@arc8244 Recently Mamata has begun with quite a bit of Industrialisation. Haldia port is being developed, Kalyani is being developed and a silicon valley of west bengal is also set in plan. Though I'm very skeptical about each of this considering that on paper they look good and a good start if they can be pulled of but even the metro network couldn't function properly since 2012. If they can't complete smtg like metro for 10 yrs how the hell are they going to make this work. Because these things would be of no use if they are completed 10-12 yrs later.
Also the constant tussel with the center has not helped at all. First with CPIM and now Mamata.
@@saptarshipal6743 haldia developed by CPM NOT TMC
This is happen for Jatyi basus great thinking who give a great speech "A computer can do 1000 labour's work" 😂🤣
Then it shift Bengal to bangalore and now see.... Where bengaluru and where Kolkata, 😭....
CPIM is the destroyer of golden Bengal
I was waiting for a video on WEST Bengal to come around
Same
What happened to Bengal's economy?
One Word: "Left"
People who say Scandinavia is socialist are stupid. Scandinavia offers more Govt Welfare, which doesn't make it socialist. The money required to sustain those Welfare schemes is created because of Capitalism. Therefore, it is safe to say that Svandinavian economy is more free than US.
Socialism is based on the assumption that there is unlimited money in the society, which of course is BS. The money and resources are limited, therefore only Capitalism can create more wealth than initial.
@@zfg07 talk about bengal not about Scandinavia....china & Scandinavia are fathers of capitalism now... Why left didn't brought industrialization in Bengal? Stop defending left... Nothing is left in left ...they only gave govt jobs to their wives & themselves roam with party flag
I m Keralaite and I knew the answer even before watching the video.
Wherever COMMUNISM grows industries tank, the well example is Kerala.
😂😆 Ditto.
I just saw the title and knew the reasons straight away.. including the factor of partion .
My father used to work in Calcutta ( now called Kolkata) and there is this one thing he said that still makes sense and resonates with me even today when I travel to Kolkata for some work - without the British and their construction and building ( heritage) Calcutta will look like any other Tier 4 city . The city looks like an old man about to die at the drop of the hat.
The Bengal govt hasn't made a single memorable additional to the city post British colonial era.
Sad that people in those states still choose those parties.
@@RIPHitchens Hitchens was a Trotskyist Socialist thug
So you should know why
PS: Read Mises not Marx
Kerala has one of the highest living standards in india. Not to mention one of the best public education and universal health care. It's a far better place than any other state in the country to live. Both LDF and UDF did a good job. Nothing to blame
@@navjo1454 Dude it's quite true whatever you said but it's beacuse of all the foreign remittance that comes into the state. Otherwise what industry does Kerala have ? Like TN has a stong manufacturing hub or Karnataka and Telegana have IT and manufacturing .
You didn’t talk about the IT sector and how it failed in Bengal while it was exploding in other states. Anyways great video!
Ya thanks to jyoti basu IBM was supposed to come in Bengal which is also a pioneer of making Banglaore a silicon valley
It sector has grown well in recent years. Even ecommerce and technology startups. Manufacturing is still lagging behind
One reason CPIM...
@@subhajitrouth5379 IBM American company h
@@SatishKumar-rc4pl ha toh kia hua??🙄sabiko pata hay wo
Many will say that Bengal never received a good governance. But we forget that we the people of Bengal is directly responsible for this outcome. During the last election in 2021, we did had a chance for a change, but we preferred bangla nijer meyekei chai(bengal want its own girl).
We all now know how it's gonna change the fate of Bengal for the coming years. Secondly, our mentality have changed drastically in recent years. From being the bravest people who fought for independence, to some lazy mindless and spineless people who prefer comedy and PNPC instead of dev talks.
Hope things will change and bengal will shine with full colors.. 🥺
Poor education and self jealousy and racism among eachother is responsible for decline of bengal...
Bengalis don't give importance to economic development. Land was traditionally fertile in Bengal so food security was always there. They are more inclined towards cultural development, and TMC fits that bill perfectly. BJP may have a promise of economic growth, but was an outsider to Bengalis who will destroy their culture.
Maybe Bengal needs the Tamil model, strong focus of economic uplifment along with cultural identity.
@@sandeepshah105 bjp is outsider? Can you explain how?
Drastic improvement. Reveal your editor, Mohak! Your mission to make 'Vox' level videos is becoming a reality.
In this video - at one place, he said, freight equalization policy caused losses to economy , and at another place in this same video, he said removal of the same policy caused losses to economy??? Very poor analysis. Most places , he just said things , but did not explain how??
@@asbisht4u He should make part 2 video, probably He said, political reasons finished everything.
@@itss.b.5391 i think not political reasons but Hindus who always gave imp to other religions, disunited themselves with caste, language and never focused to development and safety of Hindus. Neta does what we want from them. If majority will be irrational , corrupt like Nehru, Duratma gandhi, mulayam , mamta, mayawati etc will keep coming.. no other community in the world is more apathetic to themselves than Hindus. This guy still doing same. He is just throwing illogical and inconclusive sentences here and there whatever he read from manipulated history and politics from school texts and anti india and anti Hindu media.
@@asbisht4uBut this guy said something truth, I am also Bengali Hindu , I knew Why Tata left and why many companies failed, becse political reasons.
@@itss.b.5391 agree some truth is there.. but the way he criticize bjp and rss seems irrational... criticize no issues but give good logics not bad logics... i was just telling the real root cause of lagging inda lies in Hindus...not politicians... the politicians who were elected were elected by Bengali only.
Being a Bengali living in WB, I couldn't agree more with the accuracy of the video. Keep up the good work, Mohak!
So how Bengal improve?
Through BJP?
@@TiwariAbhishek_
Of course. People of Bengal have decided.
CPM , TMC destroyed west Bengal. Bjp will improve it. Look at bjp ruled states of Assam , Gujarat , MP , Haryana , UP , Maharashtra under previous rule and north eastern states.
Gracy I agree with you
@@nlgofficial76
You don't just agree but vote bjp
And improve your image in India. People think Bengalis will vote bjp. Please keep up to our expectations
Agree with you here, been in Bengal for a very long time, everyone is leaving this place for a better job and opportunities
This might be unrelated to the video, but the worst thing about our history classes is that they teach nothing that happened after 1950.
Edit: Damn, people started war in the replies 😂
Yeah... because the syllabus was designed by Congress itself...
I agree with u 100%
Bro true
Yeah even after 2000 we are still not considering recent history as a part of curriculum
Its very hard for goverments to admit about their disastrous economic policies, they will only glorify 1991 reforms
When I went Kolkata
I my heart was broken
Humans were pulling rikshaw like animals..
That happens in just some part. Mostly there are ambassador
Try visiting SonarUP....our India's pride...NASA has recently shifted it's headquarters there....the next Apollo mission is scheduled to be launched from Allahabad😘
Yes mostly bihari immigrants pull rickshaws there very sad Bihar should provide them jobs
@@orkkojit there are Biharis in Delhi and Mumbai too
But there government has completely banned Even cycle rickshaws
In Delhi all Bicycle rickshaws has been replaced by E-rickshaws whereas there has never been Rickshaws in Mumbai
And in Kolkata it’s still using primitive Type of man pulling rickshaws not even bicycle rickshaws
@@31pratimashyam West Bengal is the manufacturing hub for Eveichles mostly E Rickshaws and Bikes. Come to rural Bengal and see.
Bengalis then: Experts in Various fields
Bengalis now: Ami cobra😳
Bengali CM now : CHADA NADA FADA, HAMBA HAMBA TUMBA HUMBA HUMBA
Only one useless Mithun 🐍 cobtra
@Ashwini Desai his name is enough to understand why he hates bjp
We know that how Jyoti Basu destroyed our economy..
@@benzene1933 you are just spreading religious hatred 👍
Bengalis are intellectuals😀.. We discuss das kapital vs wealth of nations..but our work ethics is pathetic.. we can't deliver on the ground.. that's the sole reason for our downfall
Right. I have found bengali to be extremely well read but that's it. They theories a lot but don't get their hands dirty.
And what about Bengali Muslim
@@ibanbatuta2744 i find Bangladeshi muslims better than Indian Bengali Muslims
Correct you are. I am a Bangladeshi. Same things are seen on this side of the border.
A state where they romanticize "Lyadh" with Culture and Literature.. Ki ar bolbo!
I am a Bengali but I am feeling shameful that our community is going down 🥺😟☹️😰.
@Lightening Emperor No.
@Lightening Emperor why . Actually I am not above 18 😊. But my parents will vote him .I think this election they will win 😁
@@daredevil30000 ei lightning emperor dalal lagta hai , it cell wala hoga , har jaga sirf vote for bjp he kar raha hai
@Lightening Emperor mod vote doga to or nicha jayaga !!😂😂😂😂😂
@Lightening Emperor modi thori bengal election me khara ho rha hai jo modi ko vote de.
BJP ke maximum mp aur mla ek number ke C hai.
Dilip is busy taking out gold from cow milk🤣
I am a South Indian from Bangalore and I just love Kolkata. I love Bengali language and culture and food.
Thanks for that. Yes Bengal has a rich tradition and culture. But why South Indians particularly Tamil people hate North Indians?
@@ankitdas641 due to People like Periyar, fake theories like Aaryan Invasion, Flipping hypocrites like Rahul Gandhi, etc.
@@ankitdas641 Dont blame all south Indians. I am South Indian Hindu and my wife is Bengali Hindu
@@BipinBabu2024 Yes, I agree not all are like this but still it can happen anytime.
@@dhruva_tara Yes bro. There are parties like this who demand separate Dravida Nadu just for their dirty politics.
I'm from Bengal ....I love your channel so much
@Heisenberg Nahi wo to BJP ka neta banega
BHAI vote kisko dala
@Dhruv tatti ye apke Papa ki photo hai na par beta apka surname galat hai whatsapp kam chalo or padai pe dyan do jo chahe ki photo laga lete Ho kya sach mai ye aisehi bina shirt ke apke ghar aye the jo sabko bata rahe Ho ye mere Papa hai isliye inki photo meri phechan
@jithu krishna we are neither andh nor bhakt..we have brain and we know how to use it..
@Dhruv tatti Wah. Liberals ko Jihadi se link liya. Iska matlab conservatives ko me Nazis se link karu?
Seriously Bengal was the epicenter of Indian fashion industry ❤️
I love you
@Ex- Millionaire 🤣🤣🤣 Ekdam true love Bhai
@Indian Rhapsody yes, I commented this, only for meme point of view, So ab Yaha activist mat ban Jana ,Orr LADKI ke sammne hero mat banane lagna 🤦
😂😂😂
Yup ☺️
Everybody here praising the content and it's creator, nobody talking about how the left destroyed bengal
Because it's a common fact
Communism and socialism is when everybody becomes Poor
@@riteshkarmakar3597 to be specific it is Jyoti Basu. Another left CM buddhadeb belived in development and he provided SEZ to TCS, CTS and others
Exactly
@@SoumyaChowdhury24081995 I'll agree
Bah bhai bhai, you r genius what a in depth analysis... Your channel must grow.. As a bengali we are also agree bengal become heaven to hell now.. ☹️☹️😡😡
@@Sagarjk333 I know bengali r good but how we can say if we can't select proper govt right from independent that's why our state economic drastically changes it goes heaven to hell all other parameters are also becoming same day by day.. Then when in born intelligence will take action whenever we can't sustain in future also..
@@dulalrakshit3431 bhai mamta aagvi. You happy with tham
@@divyeshpatil9908 Nope. Not at all
Mujhe to ye nahi samajh aa raha ki jab *TMC & CPIM* jesi parties Bengal ka itna bura haal kar rahi hai......aur log is baat se agree bhi karte hain
To 2021 election me phirse TMC ko phirse kyu jitaaye😐🤦
@@just_a_curious_thinker Lack of strong opponent, same thing goes on with BJP in the Lok Sabha elections🤷
Couldn't agree more...and the Tata factory shutdown was actually a blow that shattered all our dreams... Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee was the only CM who actually cared about these horrible conditions but we couldn't have him for a long run in the office...💔
Yeah he had an out of the box ideology of globalisation but the past 24 years was the catastrophe brought in bengal
POLITICAL CORRUPTION & OVER POPULATION ARE BIGGEST PROBLEMS OF INDIA. INDIA MUST BE MADE CORRUPTION FREE AS COMMON MAN LIFE IS CRIPPLED DUE TO MASSIVE POLITICAL CORRUPTION FROM TOP TO BOTTOM. WHEN THAT DAY WILL COME. MODI GOVT IS JUST GIVING FALSE PROMISES SINCE 2014 WHEN HE BECAME PM BUT FORGET ABOUT CORRUPTION HE PROMISED TO WHOLE COUNTRY WHEN VOTERS OF INDIA HAVE GIVEN BJP ABSOLUTE MAJORITY BUT THE PEOPLE'S DREAM WAS NEVER FULFILLED BY MODI GOVT SO FAR. WHEN PEOPLE CAN LIVE IN PEACE & PROSPERITY IN THIS COUNTRY. WHILE THIS COUNTRY IS MADE GRAZING FIELDS BY CORRUPT & GREEDY POLITICIANS OF ALL POLITICAL PARTIES.
Politics ruins everything.
Even heaven.
That's why we need 100% Free Market Capitalist Globalised economy
@@ramannayyar6050 We already live on free market thought, and it's ruing the world.
@PM Сен ақымақсың lol wtf? India is a highly capitalist country and under PM modi who has pushing forward his neo liberalism policies and ruining the entire country. Don't comment about things you don't know
@PM Сен ақымақсың 😂😂😂 wow you are one twisted nutjob. Please do some reading first. The govt up until the 90' was trying to reduce economic disparities.If you wanna call that socialism, sure whatever. After 90's India bake highly market oriented and has since always been skewed towards a free market economy.
@@ramannayyar6050 😂 kuch bhi? Do you even know the consequences of a 100% Free market?
I'm from Asansol a coal mine is just 200 miters from my house .in past there were atleast 10 top class industries but now they are stoped .
কোন পার্টি সাপোর্ট করো?
I am also from west bengal
@@ankitadas1333 আপনাকে কেনো বলবে? কাকে vote দেবে সেটা তো privacy র মধ্যে পড়ে....
@@ankitadas1333 I'm not a voter till.but don't personaly support any party any one who is doing to make our country proud I'm in his support.
@Akshay 18 Not this time..........next time
As an Bangladeshi I fully support my my brother who has the same culture as us. I hope one day WB will be the richest state in India
There's no hope now. West Bengal is a violent state. No chance
@@Gmmmw13 lol.
@Ramesh Nagmoti Bengal ka koi future nhi hai
@@meenatiwari3777 pehle up Bihar ki chinta karo
This is the condition of a state from where two economist has achieved noble prize in economics.
Both on the left
IRONY
@@faizanmansoori abhijit binayak is not left.
Both got on poverty economics
Academics has nothing to do with economy otherwise Gujarat would not be so ahead in industries.
Left destroyed the whole northeastern belt. First they did shit in WB. Then ultimately their impact was felt on Bihar leading to violence in 90s during the most important phase of liberalisation
As a bengali I want Bengal to become the the greatest state of india in every sectors...Although I am from Bangladesh I feel proud whenever I see Bengal doing good in anything...Love from Bangladesh.
We are always taught to be thankful to bengal for the help they provided to end the world war 2 and protect many British citizens. Unfortunately it caused deaths of many Innocent people. their loss will always be remembered. Thank you and heartfelt condolences ❤️🙏🏻
Jai hind✊🏻
Same here 🇧🇩
Par tumara log illegaly bengal pe hai. Unlogoka hatana chayiye
@@chandrashekarshetty1141 ??
@@niranjandesai6766 bro there are lot of Bangaldeshis illegally living in india
I have never seen any Bengali or national media broadcasting behind the story of the current situation of Bengal with such detailed stats and figures. You have done an excellent job. And honestly, I, being a Bengali did not know many of the facts you share in this truly informative video. Kudos.
Singaporean pm in 1970 :
I want Singapore to be like kolkata
The rest is just history
Source please
Source ?
@Lightening Emperor No vote for BJP 😂
@SUPERHERO It would be better to vote for BJP this time and then some other party next time because variety is the spice of life as is none will be able to do anything
@SUPERHERO Good choice bro 🤘🤝
Most underrated channel
Living in Bengal, I've learned what is communism?
Main gareeb hoon and I'll make sure tum sab bhi hamesha gareeb raho. Gareebi hamara birth right hain
Chaap diya online website se?
Bengali talents ko khatam kardiya communism ne
@@xiaoshen194 ok bro bina koi news source ke "talents" khatam kar diya, cool af. kal bolna ghar me machhar communism ki wajah se aare, baarish kam communism ki wajah se hori aur desh me kam hospital bhi communism ki wajah se hai.
@@krash4970
Eg. Dr subhash Mukhopadhyay
@@krash4970 Dr Subhas Mukherjee and many example
I watched a video by vivek bindra on same topic..but that was full of hatred for bengali..he criticised everything ( pronunciation) and gave fake information ..
But your video is appropriate and full of genuine research information . Thatswhy i like u mohak
Thik boleche..Vivek Bindra r moto motivational speaker er kache eta asha kora jayna.
Checkout his video on Biharis... it's worth a watch! 😃
Mohak is underrated intellectual person 😁😄
I don't think he is underrated...
Was underrated, not anymore
But still has far less subs than he deserves though
Bohot sahi rated hai apna bhai
Bilkul underrated nhi hai
intellectual??
so all you have to do is read news articles to show you are an intellectual? hmmm... no ground level knowledge i guess bass hawa mein baate karo lol
@@madtitanoboa462 it takes a certain level of intelligence, analysis and conviction to gather different information, make something out of it and connect the dots. I won't tell that he's an intellectual, but to claim that he has 'no ground knowledge' is just blatant understatement, or bullshit that is
As someone living in Bengal, the point mentioned in 12:29 perfectly explains one of the reasons behind the overcrowded trains heading into the city full of labourers from the suburban.
Yes, I'm talking about the Bongaon local, Dankuni local and all the other similar trains.
Yes, you're right!
Don't forget Budge Budge local
Kharagpur -gomo
Left front destroyed Bengal, U also missed the jyoti basu's English removal in primary education. This was one of the if not the biggest blunder he did. That decreased our potential in service sector which southern India enjoyed now. All the high paying jobs now gone
China hardly knows English but look at their success
Tell that to the crores of farmers that got land from landlords and the teachers that got their salaries for the first time .
English removal was a blunder . However , no Indian state except Nagaland had English in their state curriculum at that time .
@@pavelchakraborty9942 then what??the positives stop right thr...thr stay in power was justified until late 80s and early 90s..but after Liberalization of indian economy jyoti basu held on to power for nearly 10 long years though bullying tactics and electoral (mis) management until buddha babu took his place...but even he was paralysed as the grassroot cadres and local committes were not in synch with his industrial policies...bengal missed the bus for 10 long years..and that gap has increased over the years..i m not a fan of bjp or tmc..but left must have a deeper look into thr own crimes before pointing fingers...
the fact that infosys was turned way from bengal in the 80s and left protested against rajeev gandhi's IT based industrial policy shows that bengal govt at that time had no idea abt what they were doing...mindless obsession with one ideology despite its impractical application in a democracy like india while not taking advantage of newer technologies hurt bengal a lot...
@@Debarghaya_Mukherjee china has large scale manufacturing we don't we need english for our own good atleast right now
So True, living in Bengal is Hell now for us 😭
Bengal a failed state🤣😂
@@AvanRoyOfficial Highest unemployment rate in modi raj
According to ncrb data one girl is raped in every 15min in our country
India's name now is on Hungery list,etc etc etc
So why the hell we vote for bjp !
বেরা পশ্চিমবঙ্গ থেকে থাকেতে হবে না এখানে
বেরা পশ্চিমবঙ্গ থেকে থাকেতে হবে না এখানে
@@alisagir3127 😂😂😂
As a Bengali, I must tell yes this is the truth and this hurts a lot.
@I Love Democracy yeah....this election...we will vote for BJP
@@madrexertheboredtm7728 if modi destroyed democracy then why elections are happening in WB,kerala ,TN and assam ?
@@madrexertheboredtm7728 lol 😂 tumhe or unme koi farq nhi jo kehte h Hindu khatre me or ab Tum kehte ho democracy khatre me h
@I Love Democracy vai kiuki humko apna rights nahi khona hain na...industry tho china and north korea main bhi hain... ab -24% +gdp walo ko biswas kaise kar le...😐
@I Love Democracy bjp is not a solution...ofcourse it will be better until its in the center..but then what??bjp doesnt have credible leaders here and thr growth in bengal is not organic...as the video said that the policies of gst and demo has destroyed the unorganized and msme sectors which is a significant portion of bengal economy..so in a way lately bjp policies has hurt bengal a lot just like the freight equalization policy of the 60s....thr is also a fact that bjp's policies antagonize one section of bengal's population which is not a good thing for a developing state...bengal needs holistic development for msme sector and large scale industries along with significant public sector investment in human resource public health and infrastructure development..going by history bjp govts have a good track record of investment in infrastructure..but when it comes to public health and education...thr govts invest very less on them as those sectors r not a priority for them...
Most most most underrated channel
*overrated
@@vestigesoffreemarket6148 🙄
@@vestigesoffreemarket6148 👀👀
He isn't underated he got good following. Do checkout the open latter channel , he have even less subscribers him but he is really good.
@@PrabhatKumar-ly2ge open letter or soch?
Very nice video. Being a bengali it breaks my heart to say that from being an economic powerhouse now people has to go outside to other states just to earn a livelihood. But this is what it is.
Man you speak fast... took about 2 hours to watch (stop, start, read subtitles, make notes, sit and ponder, smile) but worth every second! Phew India... ripping out by the roots doesn't even sum up this.... as removing the soil is downright despicable! The Spirit of a Bengal Cat brought me here.. ALL 9 of EM and a kit-TEN xxx
Same story - socialism looks beautiful on paper but always fails !!
Socialism in capitalistic economics is the way to go. Socialism on itself is an utopia that doesn't work because humans are corruptible..unlike other states such as tamilnadu which has socialistic policies but has capitalistic outlook to it too. It's the delicate dance that most States have missed..
@@yethir7327 true, it is a delicate balance. One needs to study what happens in US compared to Nordic states which have higher standards of living but virtually every piece of tech we see around originates in US and a miniscule amount from Europe. Even in the US the states that give the most handouts and where there are more taxes have the highest number of homeless people. Socialism succeeded only in the Israeli kibbutzim, but people left kibbutz as more wealth got generated and today because of a free and democratic society, Israel has the most tech startups outside US.
@@Vpy2023 as long as you don't have AI, the problem is USA model thrives because of poverty outside the country that brings its own share of people who want to come to USA to succeed. USA has also has had a head start in several departments, but then look at the nature of development right now, is USA really building its wealth? The salary growth rate has been slow and the inflation adjusted income value shows lesser buying power to people. And no, countries like Switzerland or more innovative that USA and have socialistic outlook to their structure too. To dismiss Nordic countries which have the highest happiness index and then making a point about produce alone as the prime idea dismisses the other parts of USA such as invasion, exploitation etc. I do not see where you draw this parallel while comparing when you literally see development in south indian states where the socialistic policies have done good
@@Vpy2023 I am concerned that you haven't accepted that so many of our models are socialistic. Eduation, medicine etc are low cost here especially because of socialism, the medical cost of USA outs 600,000 people every year in poverty. Why don't we speak about that? What are the prices of important medical goods and services which are so high cost there that people literally come to India to do their treatment. Dismissing the merits of socialistic policies especially when job creation at an all time low because of AI induced job loss only creates net negative jobs. We have a unique situation right now.
Bengal was never socialist. It had a poorly developed capitalist economy with a communist party in power that was actually social democratic in nature. P.S. : read marx and check the massive industrial growth in USSR under handcore socialist planning and not Khrushchevite revisionist market socialism.
Fabulous video with in-depth research! Truly commendable job. And as a Bengali, it was really enlightening to know what all actually led to its downfall.
কারা পশ্চিম বঙ্গ থেকে দেখছেন?
Literally Aadha Public...
ভাই আমি
Ami bhai
Bhai ami Bangladesh theke🇧🇩❤️🇮🇳
অনেকেই আছেন, প্রায় অর্ধেক দর্শক ই পশ্চিমবঙ্গের।
Communists were doing wrong then we change the government after 32 years (people understood lately) but now the ruling party is doing the same for 10 years (People understood this time)but this time people could not change the government. Current ruling party was the reason of TATA's shutdown in Singur.
Bengal is going to face a civil war in near future....... until then the future is dumb
Mujhe to ye nahi samajh aa raha ki jab *TMC & CPIM* jesi parties Bengal ka itna bura haal kar rahi hai......aur log is baat se agree bhi karte hain
To 2021 election me phirse TMC ko phirse kyu jitaaye😐🤦
@@just_a_curious_thinker Gunda gardi
@Jame Williams no Bengali don't like bjp that's why they vote for tmx
@Jame Williams not really in west bengal the bjp leaders are so dump that people can't trust on them
Although I don't agree with all your videos but this one you have nailed the truth. The problem is most Bengalis don't know how the economy works.
9:27 this sums up Modis rule and why Gujarat progressed soo much
Exactly with BJP even UP has infrastructure like Delhi and gujrat.
Gujrat had the highest number of Child deaths, and biggest per person economical gap, and least govt. sponsored health structure. It's the same Scenerio like today where the rich business mans gets more richer and the poor families gets even poor. You need to understand the whole context
Every state has its pros and cons
Gujrat with the far right govt has achieved excellent economic progress but zero social progress.
The whole scenario reverses for Kerala under the left. The manufacturing sector is almost inexistent though the service sector is improving
@Heisenberg We don't have california's in this country , no state started off big. Look at the sustained economic growth that Gujarat achieved
@@kavithviswanath1052 zero social progress? lol
gujarat is a good state economically not great and decent state socially not as great as kerala but far better than many other indian states , its not the best state but it is not backwards neither socially nor economically like you are trying to portray it
Modern day bangladesh has almost claimed back the textile industry they once lost
Because it was not under the rule of New Delhi. It can take its own decisions.
@@prangos6072 you are fool 😡
@@srirathin957 You are a blockhead!
@@adityaramachandran591 West Bengal is a part of India and the main decision makers are in Delhi. The coal and iron excise duty law and other kind of barriers put before the industrialization of West Bengal was by Delhi, not the voters who voted of "communists".
Very well researched. Good use of data and research papers. Gained lot of insights on a complex issue.
We all accuse bjp.....but we forget what cmp.....has done to bengal
Cpim
@@OkarinHououinKyouma created a toxic culture of political violence....made business difficult.... industries fled away...the richest state in India is now in this condition
@@OkarinHououinKyouma sorry I read what was left done to bengal😂....I already imagined in my bjp has come to power😂
@@OkarinHououinKyouma kaha se ho?
@goenje shuya ayega to modi hi
On this election DAY... I got the exact fact about west Bengal why Bengal left behind
❤🔥
Strikes and Lockouts were the worst gift that Left gifted everywhere. I am from Kanpur and I still see the graves of industries.
BTW, your sources description method is good.
Modi ko Bhagao
Workers fighting for theri rights is a necessity whether you like it or not.
@@e40narayankartikay42 🤣
Just Now I watched Vivek Bindra's video on Bengal.🇮🇳🎯
Me also
আমিও (Ma Bhi)....
He is now funded by BJP
@kanhu pilu that man is funded by BJP
@@debasismandal1228 thik hai fir bhi facts hi bataye na usne.
We want a video on LG v\s delhi govt.
Wats lg?
@@mohdamanat6392 lieutenant government
@ashwin rustagi yes bro
Sorry
Ghalti se mistake
It will be dismissed by Supreme Court....
Note: this was not sponsored by BJP or TMC
this was definitely sponsored by BJP
or congress or left.
@I Love Democracy if Bengal did not have left then surely it would have been better off anyway.
@@muditbothra3266 Really ??? 😏
bjp wale chris gayle ko sponsor krte h , isko nhe kr skte , mohak bhai ko nhe kharid skte.
May be the next video should be on why Maharashtra and Gujarat are much more industrialized..this would give a true picture, what went wrong in east and what went right in west
@H J yup
The difference between GJ, MH and Bengal is In bengal society is build up politically but in other two states it is still in cast based like early 19th, 20th centuries. Because the society has build politically we are united to each other. You hv seen this TATA nano projects where lands were captured illegally and handed over to TATA. Whole state supported to this movement People from every villages, town join against TATA. There are multiple examples of that. But what problem with you is your society are not united. Divided into race, cast due to which no one care what is happening with farmers, vegitable vendors, labour, home less peoples. Not a single news network covers that except NDTV. Which expose the dark reality of behind richness of maharastra and gujrate.
In bengal we dont have farmers suicide case in last 5 years or 10 years or more. But your state Maharastra farmer suicide case tops in no 1 position. The bullet train project so called "development" displaced hundreds of farmers from their ancestral land, there land has been forcefully captured. They were crying infront of news camera and screaming for helps but again no one to help them. The only solution is to push the communism in these two states. Then it will be clear like day light about how this two states becoming richer by political mafias like BJP.
Mindset of people is also responsible every gujarati and Marathi wants to invest or start a business if they can
Gujarat's gdp per capita is twice that of Bengal! That is what 20 years of good governance can do, now gujarat has overtaken maharashtra in FDI.
Now 7 years of gud governance what is situation in india
@@ravitejatalasila3349 nahin bolega.
@@ravitejatalasila3349 better than it was under Congress
Overtook mh in fdi, not really
Fdi FY23
Mh - 14.8 billion
Gj - 4.3 billion
perfect unbiased video, loved it man 👍
That's why Ambani and Adani are very important for country . Stop hating them .
Yes we need more ambani and adani kind of folks . I mean free and fair competition required for development our country. Example Andhra Pradesh become adani Pradesh he bought by force all private owned sea ports majority of ports like Krishna patnam , gangavaram,machali patnam,bavana padu . Centralisation of resources in handful number of people leads to neo feudalism and creates economical and social imbalances in society. Socialism sucks but croni capitalism much worse then that. We all are going pay for this one day irrespective of political parties.
@@kommimaniteja7790 socialism is the biggest threat for economic development .
In capitalist society the best will always prevail .
@@kohlidhoni1591 nation like us can’t push to a capitalist nation seemingly in coming 3 decades
@@dharmatejareddy. baby steps forward .
@@kohlidhoni1591 yes socialism only works in paper. The who behind Karl Marx Communist manifesto are same people who funded Hitler in world war 2. These people are known as London bankers/wall Street gang Socialism, capitalism and golbalism all these ism's ultimate goal is one thing divide and rule the masses which leads to to global autocracy.
Freight equalisation policy destroyed development of East indian states such as WB , Odisha & Bihar .
Not really . Poorer states like Maharashtra had better ports and policies . West Bengal didn't even after being rich that time
@@chidambaranathans1975 Oo dear don't defend the other side all central govt irrespective of parties discriminate Eastern states from 1st .....What about Odisha , Bihar, Assam 🤷♂️
@@bibhuduttamisra6065 I see Assam developing at crazy pace after that BJP guy has took over as the CM...
Is short whole Bengal presidency
WB itself has a port....still they not able to retain companies then it's very shameful
I am from Bengal and I loved big posters of Mamta Banerjee in every Durga Pandal. If it was of Modi I would have called it fascist but it's our Mamta Didi so it's okay😊
Sarcasm or u really love it
Left party ruled in kerala also, as a keralite who lived in North India, I strongly believe that ,its the reason why kerala is so literate and secular. The balance was kept between left and congress unlike in Bengal,where they dominated 35 yrs.
In Kerala, there's a culture of keeping the good policy of previous government & implementation of it by next government. There's less vengeful attitude in politics. Though there's priority over idealism exist but lesser in comparison to Bengal. This is the success story of Kerala & doom story of Bengal's.
@Lightening Emperor Secularism se development aata hai, agar hum ek doosre ke sath ladte rahenge to development kaise hoga.b
Kerala also gets 40% of its gdp in Expat money from gulf. WB had none of that. That expat money helped with social welfare.
@@devashisdas5024 lol,Kerala economy depends on remmitance
@@amantiwari4987 This is also a sector. India's next door neighbor Bangladesh's 40% of economy depends on remittances.
Bengal once used to be the capital and a major powerhouse of india. So sad to see how it declined
Problem is TMC continued what left begin... tmc is more focused on freebies than infrastucture / long term development....
Law and order situation is every worst, i heard stories where people have pay money to TMC goons to contructure thier own house....
I hope things change soon... bengal was the power house of india’s development before.... we want to bengal to re start growth again, not just for bengal but for entire india
I live in West Bengal . Same applies for BJP too . Every party has their own goons. Here we need to pay BJP goons too for making house as BJP holds the municipality in our town .
@@Appollo2005 bjp is not even in power in west bengal. Those goons u are talking about must be goons from tmc in disguise. Becoz that cut money eventually goes to the ruling party's hand irrespective of whoever takes it. And they take full control of this aspect.
@@deborshibiswas9629 ever heard of MLA , MP ? Bjp gets much money as they hold the central govt. Accept or not , bjp too has many goons and they aren't disguised tmc goon . 🙄
@Ashwini Desai Before that left cadres got killed.
@@Appollo2005 what nonsense!! Bjp has it's state govt in 14 states and no allegations as such has had been recorded thus far. And if your statement is true for west bengal then why the ruling tmc didn't order an investigation into the matter??.. And for your kind information MLA's belong from the ruling party and bjp is in opposition here in bengal.
Really .. U have researched a lot .. Hats up for ur effort ..
Bengal is highly polluted because of the unregulated organizations. I live in a fairly clean township. 5 km east and I enter bengal with higher temperatures, high air and land pollution. It's saddening
Also, political crimes are very high in West Bengal.
@@rnilu86 yup
where do you live?
What a useless comment!!
What about Delhi, Kanpur, dharavi?? 😄😄
The Wealth of Bengal used to flow from the river Ganges to the river Thames. Bengal was the worst effected state of India by British Imperialism. Britishers used to cut the fingers of Weaver of Dhakai Muslin Saree, the then most fine Saree in entire world. Even there was a gteat Famine in Bengal in 1943 that was artificially caused by Winston Churchill. Still after the independence Bengal flourished a lot so far as the Industries are concerned under Congress era but people were starving. The wealth was captured by few Rich. Then the violent Naxalite Movement took place by 70s and Industries started to fly away. Uniformed People assume that the trade union of CPIM party stopped Bengal's Industrial growth but it's false. The reason was Naxalite Movement, much before CPIM came to power in 1977. Even Naxalites used to kill CPIM leaders equally. Jyoti Basu massively decreed Lands from big Zamindaars and Distributed them amongst Landless Farmers that is called the famous land reform of Bengal, unique in India. And Bengal again started to flourish. Still Bengal's GDP is higher than the average GDP of rest of India. Thank You for making this video.
Are you doing phd in History of Bengal?
gdp of bengal is higher than gdp of rest of india , what a joke compare per capita , its not much high than national average just accept the truth...
Lol 🤣 here comes a andhbhakt
Do you even Now the percapita income of waste Bengal
Oh yea land redistribution.. That always works out so well.
Social polices have time and again brought down civilizations, cause of misaligned incentives. It does not incentivise innovation, but bigger government and imbalance of power which corrupt and power hungry people step up to take. It's a death spiral
@@madtitanoboa462 please check 2018-19 data
I am from Bengal.
And this should be added in our books and syllabus so that we Bengalis don't repeat the same and grow.
Sad to say this but after todays election result, people of Bengal have rejected for a change, after suffering for so many years people should realize that gov change (Be is BJP or Congress) can get some changes to the society which will in turn make an impact on their children's future. There is no investment in Bengal for so many years, students are leaving the state to get IT jobs. I have many friends who are Bengali and they are supprised to see how developed Mumbai, Bangalore is. People are responsible they just dont want the change.
Bhai I am also from Bengal but living in Pune. Problem yahan ye hai k BJP ke paas achche local leaders nahi hain jo ki logon ki problems samjhe and address karein. Only hindutva mudda nahi hota, Bengal me real mudda industrialization tha, but unfortunately kisine address nahi kiya. Jaise aapke Maharashtra ke local leaders jaante the ke logon ko exactly kya chahiye, isliye itna developed hai Maharashtra.
@@divendughati6114 ekdam thik bolecho dada bjp r leadership bhalo noy
During 2007 Bengal was leading in agri sector being top rice, vegetables and jute producers in the country. Then government decided ki bas agriculture se kuch nhi hoga state has to push for capex. Graduates are leaving the cities and going to other states. Asansol, singur, raghunath pur, haldia belt was selected. Mou were signed with compaies like Tatas, dalmiyas, Balajis and PSUs like NTPC, Bhel, DVC to make bengal a manufacturing hub. Increasing haldia port capacity would revamped the infa of entire eastern India. While cities were chosen as IT hub like Rajarhat, saltlake in South Bengal and siliguri in north bengal. The work did started with great response from the companies but land acquisition was the main problem. I am not going into politics. The Jyoti basu government use to practice such things like working more towards society than corporates. Land reform is an example where land from zamindars were distributed. Buddhadeb govt faced political dissent when opted for industrialisation.
Vote for সংযূক্ত মোর্চা
Heard that siliguri has started again. And it would be turned into IT hub of North bengal. Rajarhat and salt lake has already progressed a lot. And plans of making a silicon Valley in New Town and Rajarhat is going on. Just hope development actually and not just stay on paper or initial phase.
@@saptarshipal6743 living in Newtown Kolkata
Starting me Vox ki feel aa gyi
Really great editing
Make something on Maharashtra and Gujarat..
@TH-cam Politics lol..
I don't have any idea about that..
But Gujarat and Maharashtra both are one of the richest state..
Faar better than Rajasthan,up and hat shitty Bihar..
And South India is better than this two states..
@@aquarianfighter5384 you north indians think the south is some fricking utopia? it's not that great here either. Maharashtra is just as good as the southern states if not better
@@kushal4956 ohk maybe true..
I have never been there but people say that..
@TH-cam Politics chup be gadhwa..
Mi pan marathich aaho..
Mala he watla te bol lo mi..
Burnol Swath law
@TH-cam Politics don't be a blind person..
All metro cities are equally good.
Ahmedabad, Surat, Bangalore, mumbai,Pune etc
Each city has there own unique speciality..
Being marathi I can say that what other states can learn from Bengal is never allow leftist or communist or so called socialist to rule your state/country
You have Wrong Idea About Communists
Those Communists Were Ruled Bengal They Couldn't Work By Following the Ideology Because They thought CPIM Will Rule Bengal Forever. They were Frauds.If CPIM have honest Leaders State or Country Can Much Develop
very true
please make this kind of detailed video on Odisha. It's really hard to find and it's time people of other states acknowledge that there is a state called Odisha.
Rightly said bro.the best state once.
JAI SHREE JAGANNATHA.
🕉️🕉️🕉️🕉️🙏🙏🙏🙏
We Don't like communist party in odisha and we don't want Bangali Hindu or Muslim to come and destroy our demography
Also Goa
@@prasmitkumarpradhan1497 nobody is going to ur isolated orissa. Lol. Be happy.
I love bengal & bengal culture . Specially bengali food .
Ha vai khana idhar mast hain...🤩🤩
Wish we could say the same 🤣
Pucha koi?
I love bengali girls! Peace
Me too...I think Bengali language is the sweetest.. I really want to learns bengali
Even though I am 19 y/o from Kokata. I didnot know so much about my state. Thank you so much for making us aware of the facts. Actually bengal has been politcally sound and the corruption in the last 10-15 years has increased a lot due to which the development of bengal has been affected. Big industries are no more coming to bengal. Whichever politicians come in power after this election should try to make things right and make imrovement. Also the young generation (including me) should start taking things i our own hand by starting big business and industries which shall employ a lot of people.
Vote for সংযূক্ত মোর্চা
@@subhajitdutta8563 cpim i to sesh krlo video ta dekheo kichhu bujhlen na
@@anirbanmallik1889 plz vote for left and save democracy.BJP and TMC are fascists.
@@anirbanmallik1889 he is bhakt of xi jumping he dont understand your language
Corruption was rampant in the CPM regime and TMC just continued it. Its not that it grew in 10, 15 years, it grew in back from 1990s.
It is for Bengalis to make Bengal bright.. I see many Bengalis who are well off and highly educated moving out to other places.. many Bengalis have sacrificed to bring changes to the Indian society and in freedom struggle.. why don’t they start it again.. if Maharastra is better .. credit to a large extent have to be given to Maharashtrians .. similarly others
12:37 - That Train BGM is a subtle thing which many may not notice but really gives feel while watching. Nice video, Mohak Bhai.
sir how you do such beautiful edited video. op editing 🤯
Bhai UPSC ke takkar ka content hai ye...🔥🔥🔥🔥
I am a bengali born and raised in mumbai.. People of Bengal deserves this.. Its their choice…