If you want to know the true picture of WB today, take a look at the government employment cases hanging in various courts. Her party members are so corrupted that even she can't do anything about it. Take a look at various ministries and their corruption stories. Post-poll violence is not only in the media; it has become an everyday thing in WB. All the schemes introduced by the current government have complaints against them. Take a look at Tab for high school students. Do proper research, not just look at and believe the papers published by the government.
How much money u take from BJP Do not spred fake news about bengal All poorest state of India ruled by BJP UP Bihar Odisha Assam Chattisgarh MP Rajasthan Bengal can buy all these poor states
My grandfather had a plywood factory in Bengal. He was planning to shift his factory from Behala to howrah on a larger land size. The labour union set up a strike and didn’t allow us to move our machinery out, and didn’t let us enter our own land. Finally we had to give upto their demands and ultimately after few years our factory had to shut down and we moved to uttar pradesh and setup a unit there…This was in 1997
My family has a textile powerloom factory in Maharashtra. Since we’re not “marahashtrian” even though me and my father were born here , we can’t close the factory because the workers would get RPI party goons and demand 25% of the scrap value of my machines. The factory is barely profitable.
And there’s no use for the land there. Other than factory. Which no one would rent because the last time there was any sewage by the municipality here was 50 years ago
@@Gamers_yt759 I am from Bengal too and also a student how can you say we didn't grow in education?? The student of Bengal are lazy and maximum un plained and unsure of there paths so you are blaming the state for this ?? Many student can't desied there subject to chose after class10 will the state chose from them?? Many schemes of government of West Bengal are helping students though many are misusing the schems and not working hard. And many people of Bengal do not care for the state The people of Bengal care for there personal interest only many people who are involved in politics believe if BJP win the state election so they can get personal benifits for the BJP part to satisfy there own interest in there life and don't think of the rest of state but only for there self. Many people of Bengal are getting benifits of the TMC govt schemes but in public they support BJP . Maximum people of Bengal think they no poltics but in fact they are idiot in poltics . The people of Bengal do not take care to know what's happening in India and other states the maximum population of the state are dub in politics and economics thinking and special bad at think how there action will cost the state in the feature. At last the people of Bengal likes to blame others for there fault not thinking what they are doing.
@pratyaysaha government is made for the people and by the people. Bengal is not exception maximum government officer in deferent government office in Bengal don't like to work hard and even if they worked they take bribe form the people of Bengal. The Cpm part also did it in Bengal and now TMC and even if BJP win the state election they will also take bride from the people of Bengal because the people of Bengal working in the government like to take cut money from the people of Bengal. So the default is not in the government but in the people's mentality.
@@chaitalichakraborty4087 i am also a student . in here many cities[ like small , not too small ] have collages but not have many streams and student desired subject like ex: a collage have science in collage but only in few subjects . the west bengal govt can't notice that. they focus only politics . for only vote they gave many schemes .
I am from Kolkata, and i can say that i have witnessed my motherland's downfall because of her ulterior motives to gain political advantages. Loss of business, commerce and peace.. it's all her doing
@@rituparnarooj5388communism is only viable if you have complete power and genuine interest to develop neither of which the west bengal cpm ha.Kerala is working because it has much greater powers than bengal and peviously had dedicated leaders
Not really. I have been here in Gujarat for 4 years and I was born and brought up in Delhi and can say Gujarat is nothing in front of Mumbai and Delhi. There is no standard city and there is no civic sense, no public support to others. Open discrimination is being done by the gujaratis to the outsiders. These gujjus migrate to other states and live a peaceful life not vice versa. Get your info correct
@@AnubhavBiswas-sk5qm gujrat is safer than delhi and the river in gujarat is not a naala like yamuna and gujarat has good job opportunities and has way less pollution and is cleaner than delhi
@@Adolf_CHADler_16 gujarat has more manufacturing jobs rather than service sector. And outside the 5 cities there is almost nothing here. Sure Delhi is unsafe but how many people live in Ahmedabad and Delhi. Except the gujarati population other communities are non existent.
@@botkiller_Pishach this is the problem with you guys, because just due to their past, you guys won't let them change their future. Actually it's you guys who are the problem.
Mamta Banerjee is a copy paste master. She copied what Jyoti Basu had to do and replicated the model with enhancements, she tried to copy Gujrat model and othe much model too like free beea as was there in Tamil Nadu, Rajasthan etc.. but I don't think you can be a leader by following. And now Thik school appreciating Mamta Banerjee well, it puts me to doubts that all other things that they have brought forward, are those good to follow at all!
I am from Assam. I have witnessed people of Toofanganj ( West Bengal) taking temporary asylum in the adjacent district of Dhubri in Assam due to life threat from Trinamool Congress workers just because those innocent people were being suspected of not voting TMC in the elections . That's what the condition of West Bengal is right now.
So many things still didn't cover like Lokkhi Bhandar , Cutt-Money , Booth Capture , Chappa-Vote etc. People of bengal are not communist , they are mostly poor 😢
It's really disappointing to see channels like Think School presenting half-baked information. Since May 20, 2011, Mamata Banerjee has been the Chief Minister of West Bengal, which, as of November 13, 2024, totals 4,923 days in power. Isn’t that enough time to fulfill the promises of uplifting the state and making it a source of pride for the country? A true leader should encourage people to achieve excellence and prioritize the well-being of their state. Yet, instead of positive progress, West Bengal has seen repeated issues with law and order, instances of various scams, cases of rape and murder, an education scam, and other forms of corruption. It’s disappointing to witness these problems persist while the people were promised change. To the Think School team, please don’t compromise on integrity for the sake of viewership or profit. You built trust by deeply analyzing data and presenting balanced perspectives, and it’s disheartening to see a lapse in that standard. From today onwards, I will double-check the facts in your videos before accepting them. Please prioritize honest, fact-driven content that benefits both viewers and the country as a whole.
Bro, I think you're being biased again. You're not giving the full picture. She is inviting millions of refugees from Bangladesh to build her vote bank and is distributing Aadhaar cards to them. With limited jobs available, inviting more people is certainly a burden on the economy. Along with provisions like wheat, she's also catering to the minority vote bank by offering freebies to maintain their support. On top of that, there are issues like booth capturing, dirty politics, criminality, and hooliganism-many factors that you've left out.
The video is biased. As a Bengali I can confirm, people of Bengal never wanted Tata to get out from Bengal (not talking about poor farmers, they are brainwashed and have no idea about industry) and Mamata Banerjee's free subsidies instead of welfare, education system corruption, illegal immigrations are the reason of Bengal's downfall alongside the 34 years long communist reign. Every Bengali is fed up to the core. But can't do anything due to the threat culture happening here. Don't forget the RG kar case. Every single protest has been silenced and no justice is served. It's almost like a dictatorship going on in Bengal. I don't understand why Think school made this biased video.
This video is completely biased. I am from West Bengal. Corruption is the main cause of our downfall nd its because of mamata Banerjee. Buddhadev bhattacharya still brought many companies but mamata didi hasn't done any. Instead she is the one who stopped people, Brainwashed them to fight against TATA and other industry. singur, nandigram are examples. Nd trade unions are nowadays filled with illiterate , stupid, corrupted peoples. They provide u a job in exchange of lakhs of money. Govt exam can be cleared by those who can give around 20 lakhs to the people indirectly or directly connected to people. Nd here this person is saying it's not her fault. DADA kolkata asun. Stti ta dekhun
It's really disappointing to see channels like Think School presenting half-baked information. Since May 20, 2011, Mamata Banerjee has been the Chief Minister of West Bengal, which, as of November 13, 2024, totals 4,923 days in power. Isn’t that enough time to fulfill the promises of uplifting the state and making it a source of pride for the country? A true leader should encourage people to achieve excellence and prioritize the well-being of their state. Yet, instead of positive progress, West Bengal has seen repeated issues with law and order, instances of various scams, cases of rape and murder, an education scam, and other forms of corruption. It’s disappointing to witness these problems persist while the people were promised change. To the Think School team, please don’t compromise on integrity for the sake of viewership or profit. You built trust by deeply analyzing data and presenting balanced perspectives, and it’s disheartening to see a lapse in that standard. From today onwards, I will double-check the facts in your videos before accepting them. Please prioritize honest, fact-driven content that benefits both viewers and the country as a whole.
What's Laadli Behen Yojana? What is 6000/per annum to all the farmers yojana? What's food to 80 crore people? The list of freebies by Fekendra and his gang in centre& Bhajipaao ruler states, is never-ending. Y'all are okay with those Bhagwa Freebies. When the other party gives freebies, you'll start crying. Why being a hypocrite?
As a bengali eight main thing which i dont like and completely against is 1:- Appeasement Politics 2:- Gunda Raj 3:- Freebies rather than welfare and education (its obviously because of votebank) 4:- Just like CBI is a caged parrot West Bengal police is a caged parrot. 5:- No development is rural bengal ( in my village there is road of length almost 1 KM you wont believe people go down the road cuz the quality is too poor) 6:- Opposing Central gov welfare scheme like Ayushman Bharat ( though WB gov have Sasthya Sathi which is equivalent to the Central Gov Scheme but people are not benefited) 7:- corruption (you wont believe but the office of the district magistrate which is suppose to be the anti corruption department of the district, corruption are taking place there itself i swear i have personally faced it) 8:- lastly they opposition are suppressed and which is the most dangerous is democracy even you are only allow to speak till its in favour of the gov(and sadly in bengal congress have no future and for BJP i see suvendu adhikari as the face of CM but he also came in BJP by the washing machine method and hence no great leader to lead ) 🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂 we are literally FU*KED bro 😐😐😐😐
Don't even bother voting for a two faced snake like Suvendu Adhikari. This kind of people only join politics for money and power nothing else. Sadly, both in TMC and BJP there are many such members.
As a WB Resident let me tell you, She might done a lot to try to attract businesses in WB but she failed not because People of West Bengal are Communist rather it's because of Zero Law and Order, Rampant Corruption, Political witchhunt, Lack of stability because high illegal immigration of "particular Vote bank" etc etc are the reasons why Industries aren't coming. Cause you won't want to setup a factory where you have zero assurance of safety and will always have Local TMC Aspiring Leader who would always ask for Bribes or Ransom.
na she does nothing and his image is also a big anti-business type of image you also know what she did in Singur stop sugarcoating his misdeed and how somebody can invest in your state when she always demonized our businessman that's why Adani pulled up his 20000 cr investment for new deep sea port do you know how much employment that project can generate
Ok.....bsf kidhar gaya???? Agar ak bhi illegally a raha hain to failure centre ka hain.....border security centre k hat ma hain.... Last 10 year bjp k rule ma sabsa jyda illigal immigration hua hain........socha bhai....galti kiski hain.....?????????
I visited Bangladesh once and Bangladesh is more developed than our West Bengal. So it's very funny that someone would come from there and stay They might do some kind of business import or export business.
I tried to setup a small manufacturing unit in my neighbor village of Hooghly (WB) in 2023. Got a good land attached to road, but after purchasing it faced severe problem from local clubs, cut money, goon leaders threatened me to pay hafta. Left the area and will never try to do something betterment for bengal.
Yes . To set a business here, u should have some political power or reference. Otherwise u have to pay lakhs of money as hafta . Nd then your profit margin will be very less. So ultimately no reason to start a business here.
i used to live in kolkata before 2015 at that time kolkata was a great city ,it was growing with good economy , then my family shifted to mumbai after 2015 , and recently i had a chance to visit kolkata after so many years due to a connecting flight , and man i was shocked , it feels like time has stopped there, its the same place even after so many years , here mumbai, banagalore and chennai changed their whole geography in last 10 years , but kolkata its still the same
@@norendermoody6509 come to mumbai man or even bangalore and chennai then you will understand , i have lived in all the major metro cities of india from my childhood due to my fathers job , so i can literally tell you the difference currently i am in chennai and its far better than kolkata
Watch Gaurav Thakur's interview with ex-RAW field agent ( who is an expert sniper operator ). He indirectly indicates that Dhruv Tatt! is working for German Intelligence to spread propaganda which suits Germany's foreign policy for India.
Siliguri is a geographical blessing for India which has 3 international borders near it can be equivalent to any tier 1 city, but no development in infrastructure and corruption practices has hault its growth.
Even i agree,today Guwahati has grown to become the commercial capital of North East whereas Siliguri which was once a famous wholesale market and started developing much earlier has gone down since then
It could be developed like a supergateway to himalayas but alas it is barely developed in comparison to other indian cities. Construct two malls begal people think oo so developed city it is
Just keep patting yourself "we're better than bihar" Honestly not by much now compared to 2000s And bihar is growing while wb is still the slowest growing state in eastern india Also isnt bengal the third biggest migrant contributor after up and bihar? Maybe look at yourself too instead of being enraged when someone points out wrongdoings
My friend had opened a cafe in Lake town after covid. He had to pay monthly cut money to police for parking, Monthly cut money to local club, Very high chanda for various function, Yearly Donation to tmc party funds. Recently, local MLA's men tried to shut his cafe by making allegations that women feel unsafe and eve teasing happens because of his cafe's crowd. He was forced to shut his shop. Now, he moved to different place to open cloud kitchen.
This is the same thing happening in kerala brother...!!! Issues like you open a busainess in kerala, they will run in loss because of strikes, parties or employee or labor strikes and they will move to a different state. Recently, Kitex a company which was doing good and offered a lot of jobs to people in kerala, had to shut their operations had to shut down as they were facing loss in business due to labour strikes and also with pressure from the trade unions and people their have not even understood their mistake. Even if they understand, the communalism will shut their eyes...!!!
As a resident of Bengal, we have seen first hand that Businesses are forced to pay Cut-Money (Hafta) for any steps they take to expand/setup their business, and the thing is the government is deeply invoived in this and thus nobody to help. The only thing I have seen improve are the road conditions in Village, other than that everything is way behind the National Standard.
I visited Kolkata in 1998, 2007, 2014 and 2024. Except some new areas, most of the Kolkata either remained exactly the same or looked deteriorated during this period. Other Indian cities that were far behind Kolkata back then like Ahmedabad, Bengaluru, Hyderabad and Pune outperformed drastically and left Kolkata today far behind in development.
West Bengal is a highly politics driven state, where people have forgotten to be ambitious. They depend on the Government schemes and the little money that gets credited to people’s bank accounts. Brain drain is a huge drawback. As Bengalis we are forced to leave Bengal to lead a standard life. Bengal’s work culture is substandard and doesn’t allow one to bloom.
I'm a Bengali yes Mamata did give several schemes for the people of bengal but they're not at all viable or beneficial rather they're vite gaining schemes where local leaders take bribes for inserting a name in that scheme. Btw no company invested in Bengal in recent years even if some did their amount is negligible like some paint based companies. Don't believe what the reports say the ground situation is way worse, debt ridden growth is not a good thing where you don't even have proper earning for the state govt. She polticised each and every institution available for the people of bengal like the police (they act like party cadres actually)
My uncle had opened a small production house in South Bengal in 2021 employing 120 people majority women but he has been threatened by TMC party mobs to for "weekly rangdaari" he payed for 2 years but eventually left Bengal and now he has Plant in Odisha
@@Primus_suspectus i am not i myself voted bjp also told the hold family to do so but unfortunately most bengali persist aspiration of poverty the leftist gov lost now for 13 years still mindset is same and also most bengali don't give a F about infiltration and even if some people vote for change their is huge amount of booth capturing and so on .. That is why i decided to leave bengal and go to other state
It's really disappointing to see channels like Think School presenting half-baked information. Since May 20, 2011, Mamata Banerjee has been the Chief Minister of West Bengal, which, as of November 13, 2024, totals 4,923 days in power. Isn’t that enough time to fulfill the promises of uplifting the state and making it a source of pride for the country? A true leader should encourage people to achieve excellence and prioritize the well-being of their state. Yet, instead of positive progress, West Bengal has seen repeated issues with law and order, instances of various scams, cases of rape and murder, an education scam, and other forms of corruption. It’s disappointing to witness these problems persist while the people were promised change. To the Think School team, please don’t compromise on integrity for the sake of viewership or profit. You built trust by deeply analyzing data and presenting balanced perspectives, and it’s disheartening to see a lapse in that standard. From today onwards, I will double-check the facts in your videos before accepting them. Please prioritize honest, fact-driven content that benefits both viewers and the country as a whole.
Why Don't we speak about HIMACHAL PRADESH. The government doesn't even have the funds to feed its own employees. What a shame. That's why most of the young generation is leaving India.
Each state gets talked about separately but still a great state like west bengal which is not land locked and had major industries lost it all in few decades is something to worry about compared to Himachal which is land locked with hilly terrain.
DIdnt u read the evidences that he showcased that Mamata is not the only reason? U urself keeping a blind eye and expect a right wing party will vanish all of the bengal problems
@@jishnuadhikari5234 Do you believe you're the only one entitled to question my understanding of CAG audits? I’ve been closely following the functioning of the CAG, including its audits of large public entities like the Indian Railways, and I understand both its strengths and its limitations. My criticism stems from observed inefficiencies and the retrospective nature of its processes, which sometimes fail to prompt meaningful reforms despite identifying significant issues.
@@outofcontextworld bro it is right but if a leader came from TMC how will you believe him you can understand the name of BJP leaders... They are not saint bro, just They are commenting from washing machine
It is rightly said that WB economic downfall is not a suicide but a planned murder. There was a time when people from all over India were migrating to Kolkata for jobs and better opportunities. Now educated people of WB are migrating to other states looking for jobs. Very sad indeed.
Such an insightful and well researched video. Kudos man, lovely to hear you and being a bengali and a person who is saddened by the downfall, whatever you say is absolutely true and I wish things to improve in near future.
Don't compare GUJARAT with Bengal.... Gujaratis are smart wise and business minded humble loving people. Being a malayali living in Gujarat since birth, I could say Gujarat just needed a right leader and we got Modiji and since then we never looked back. We Gujaratis WISELY CHOSE OUR LEADERS... We don't vote for freebies ❤
@adhnaanahmed5029 😂😂😂 I never understand why Ahmed, Muhammad, Ali, etc always have issue... Why can't u guys for a moment think as an Indian? Do pakistan give u food?
West Bengal consists of not even half of Bengal. Banga, which is the ancestral homeland of Bengalis. Consists of the modern borders West Bengal, Tripura, Parts of Meghalaya, Assam and Arakan (Myanmar) and of course Bangladesh. It is only fair to compare all of Bengal to all Gujarat to see real picture. That picture has been the same since times immemorial. When India was the most prosperous land on Earth. Bengal was it's richest! When you say not to compare Bengal with Gujarat. You're absolutely right! How can there be a comparison between a Elephant and a rat?!! In this world Bengalis are only behind the Chinese and Arabs on terms of the entire human civilization. Your Gujarat or even Maharashtra or both combined are still puny compared to us. You and your descendants will always live under our cultural domination just like your ancestors. Everyday you sing the national anthem. Know that you're singing a Bengali song. In every nooks and crannies you will find us and our heritage. Because you see Bengal doesn't came from India. But the idea of an independent India, Pakistan and its own independent state was all birthed by Bengal. That is the unapologetic truth of history and reality. Either you can swallow or not is up to you. There's an saying old saying in Bengali: "Whatever Bengal thinks today. India thinks tomorrow."
@@vinukrishnannair why don't u consider rest of 28 states as India when I speak for other 28 states,this tells how much u are infiltrated with hate mongering propaganda.baseless supporters of bjp proclaiming themselves as nationalists while statpading every economic development with gujarat.where is ur nationalist sentiment now? And you guys telling me I'm not nationalist when I talk about development in other states.
@@adhnaanahmed5029 Everything for gujrat are u kidding 😂.... ? Nano plat was not started in Gujarat, they were rescued by Gujarat. Similarly every BJP run state accepts development or let me rephrase, every state people who wants development go with BJP. I'm from Kerala and I know what govt does there and we malayali's are so controlled by leftist propoganda that we dig out own grave. India's achievements are not hidden to the world and u think that achievements in GDP, Defence, Aerospace, Space research, Startup ecosystem etc are achieved by just developing Gujarat.... I won't insist but try to speak logic and come out of this mindset. We need muslim brothers who idolize Shri APJ Abdul Kalam sir and not the one following Owasi or Pappu
Let go by reality, road conditions is pathetic in bengal compared to any state. This is with comparison to 16 states i have traveled this year. The immigration from Bangladesh is alarming high. Corruption is at peak this is not something i am making it up , as a common person visit any police station or govt office. Corruption and bribe is promoted openly and ego of govt staff is so high that common man leaves with guilt without any solution. All changes in Bengal are on paper and not implemented properly because of deep rooted corruption
@@sunnymitra6372 true But at least things are improving there faster than wb And people in bihar aren't hostile to big business (at least a lot less) unlike wb
Before bengal state election Bengalis be like: Bengal is falling downfall etc etc During election:They be like khela hobe... After election repeat That's all about bengal politics nothing else..
Just like stock market,Some stocks jump to much in early nd then stops for many years . Nd suddenly again jumps nd beats the top performer. Look at trent . Every person nd MF betting on trent but now his time also gone. Like that Bengal will Again rise .I am trying to make Bengal own party then bengal will rise
@@adamlupu5885 Tomader sobai ke o nije ke sosoto hote hobe .. Keo ghore pore thakbe na Baire beroy tomra Physically fit hou ..gym koro or kono sports e angso nao . And govt exam er preparation sobai bondho koro Nd skills er dike takao .
West bengal people during 5 year says didi is weird .... West Bengal people during election:- no we don't want an outsider to rule our state #didi_is _best
Some points mentioned is wrong. During the late rule of Communist they wanted to partner with the big houses like TATA, but they were opposed by the then opposition now the ruling party. Also regarding job creation the last communist CM went on public to say that they need big corporations to come for their youth to stay back in West Bengal.
My father-in-law who lives in Bengal was a devoted supporter of communist party until 2008. Once left parties allowed Tata factory in Singur he switched his allegiance to Mamata and now he considers communist party as "gaddar". He thinks all large businesses should be govt owned/PSU and only reason states allow private companies is due to corruption. I think many people resonates with this thought process in India. It's just in most states it did not make central political agenda as cast/religion took over.
You see it is natural psychology to resonate with such because Communism is pretty romantic in its true sense. Think of your father in law during his young days, how these things were fed in his mind that "Samrajjobad er Dalal der Bhenge dao guriye dao, Turn the Capitalists to the ruins". Lot of left wing intellectuals have written books and poems to manipulate the young minds on top of Marxs Das Kapital. Many of those in their 60s in Bengal still believe that driving away Tatas were the right thing. It's all left wing romanticism that people especially students get easily attracted to. We Bengalis say "Hujuk e matha dhukiye dewa, going with the trend".
As a Bengali, I think the young generation is very capitalist, they see what is happening in other states and countries. The old generation like my father and uncles everybody I know are/were CPIM supporter & they still like CPIM( not necessarily vote them) without trying to understand what they did wrong, they just have a lingering feeling like those were the good times. I personally hate TMC but can see Mamta Banerjee is actually making some efforts to change but every single minister is rotten to their core ! Everyone is under investigation under some kind of scam or scandal or money laundering. And Mamta being their leader isn't doing anything to stop this, she is openly trying to save them! The main thing lacking currently in this state is Strong Opposition. Yes BJP is worse than them, at least TMC is united, but BJP is bickering among themselves. They have no connection to the common public they are failing to create the storm that Mamta created single handedly in 2011. But above all the people of Bengal are so used to being poor and living by just meeting basic needs they don't want any change! Lastly The Lakshmir Vandar scheme is the game changer. While I like the poor woman getting 1000 rupees a month which makes them somewhat self dependent, it pains me to think her son/daughter could have got a job if not for Didi !
It's been millennia the Bengali people have not seen prosperity , peace , proper justice , I just can't !!! Bengali people are the longest colonized ethnicity on earth
not millennia , rather 800 years from 1206 to 2024 and counting, most exploited, tortured, harmed and gen0cided race in the world, if someone actually analyzes the history they will realise even jews didnt have to suffer like this
19:58 i come from durgapur, a very wealthy city in west bengal. Also known for its steel production, it was one of the few back in time to produce wheels for trains. But as i grew up most of the industries are just on a verge of shutting down (even the public once) there's just a lot of scams going here and there, some getting busted some not. Moreover affecting the factories and the familes living here . 18:14 and speaking of mafias, from coal mafia to TMC booth mafias it's just shit out here and as students here, we just have the option to move out to other states for opportunities. I would like to conclude with bengal is just a better version of bihar.
I always wanted Asansol Durgapur Burdwan belt to be connected and developed into 3 city urban cluster a wide metropolitan area like Pune Pimpri Chinchwad
So true. Koto potential amder ediker but 😢. SAIL durgapur ar BARNPUR duto plant ea valo capex infused korar kotha ache. Auxiliary industry chi. Chemical industry chi. Foxconn er moto ekta jodi kichu asto. Sob dik theke ideal... But 😢😢
Being a resident of this state, I can vouch for all your statements. 1. The people of this state are just too uninformed and have a myopic vision for growth. 2. Industries are not proliferating due to unwarranted demands from labour unions which are nothing but just arms of political parties to keep control over the businessmen as well as the poor labourers. 3. The underutilisation and non expansion of its assests such as roads,metro rail, ports, connectivity to NE states and South East Asian. 4. The corrupt bureaucracy and politicians who have a lack of will for growth and development. Instead they keep luring the poor with freebies, which again in turn increases state expenditure. 5. Lack of a visionary leader with sufficient political support who can make revolutionary policies to attract businesses. 6. Once the biggest jute textile hub in the world, with hundreds of factories setup during the British Raj weren’t modernised and upgraded. The industry is still the backbone of the state but is in shambles due to the political labour unions. 7. The HATE for “OUTSIDERS” among the general populace. It is concerning that citizens of the same country feel that the brothers and sisters of the other states are “OUTSIDERS” to them, and the hatred is so evident that it’s just not the businesses who are not willing to come to WB, but now the people also don’t want to migrate to this state for jobs. It’s a deeply hurting and concerning that the state which has given the icons & leaders of the fight for an independent nation, has now lost it’s nationalistic identity. The Regional cultures and identity must be preserved but not by jeopardising the nationalist values. If people of other states are outsiders, then what will be the difference between WB and Bangladesh ?
I'm from Kerala, and I’ve noticed people here seem to dislike industries a lot. The communist government has been pretty tough on big companies, even forcing ones like Anna Aluminium and Kitex to leave. Kitex actually moved to Karnataka after their government sent a private jet to bring their manager over and convince them to invest there instead. Because of all this, big businesses don’t want to set up in Kerala. Plus, with fewer job opportunities, many general category students(mostly christians) are leaving India to find better options abroad.
@vineeshsv313 doesn't matter, if they are giving jobs, what's wrong with it, have some sense, communism is failed idealogy, capitalism works, that's why Tamil Nadu Karnataka Maharashtra are successful in producing highest employment opportunities while others are stuck with lowda chuslim divide and fighting for caste
@@vinayj1763 offcourse almost all the the ideologies are failure in this modern society. But i don't know why it "doesn't matter if they are giving job" even these communists also provide jobs
West Bengal is falling because of an egoistic woman, who thinks she cares for everyone but in reality she only cares for herself, her own ego and wants power. No matter she completely destroys the social fabric of the state. The fact is she has already exploited it.
17:38 Being born and bought up in Kolkata i can confirm that there are rampant cases of Political violence (especially murders). In college as well....if you are a party worker you will get 90% attendance (even never been to classes for a single day) whereas if you aren't you will get what teachers give. Politics is extremely dirty in Bengal
Hey @thinkschool, the picture at 8:14 is a mistake. It seems to be from Karnataka and not Kerala as the language on the sign is written in Kannada. Great content as always!
@SumitKumar-xh8tt Communist ideology hai isliye Bengal mai dusre states ke log itne Shanti se rehte hai, agar right with ideology hota toh Bengal ka haal bhi Karnataka ya Manipur jaise raciest hota. Lekin tumhare samajh se bahar hai ye sab .😆😆😆
@@Vidya_Upadhay97 neurological disorders Bengal me common hai. What about gdp declining contribution, illogical striking in the factory, bengal government involved in horrific crime. Not just citizens but doctors, ips officers are not safe in bengal.
@@Vidya_Upadhay97As an Indian it's there wish to travel and work any where they want. They are completely legal workers. Please get this low mentality shit out of your head.
Bhaiya I am a Muslim and the mamata police looted my 17k rs 😢 with goons in proper Kolkata which are all hindus Please don't fight for religion Both muslim and Hindus are victims under Mamta rule
I feel a growth rate of 6% is very low for an underdeveloped/developing state like West Bengal. Its lower than the national average. Bihar had a double digit growth for 3-4 years immediately after Nitish Kumar introduced reforms and improved law and order situation. You are partially correct in saying that WB is in a messy state not because of Mamta Banerjee alone, but massive reforms have to come about if investor confidence is to be restored and work culture (root cause of Bengal's economic downfall) is to be improved.
It doesn't matter if she tries to pretend to bring industrialization to bengal. The common people of bengal wants that. But the syndicate raaj and goons backed by her party won't let anyone do business there properly. Please do not say she has done anything for health and education of bengal. She and her party leaders (am talking about top tiers ) have destroyed it. Kindly do your ground research. She has opened flood gates of corruption
@k2indeed8998 not really Freight equalization has been gone for thirty years Every state in the east is growing faster than bengal Freight equalization was one of the reasons for backwardness The other reason- bad local policies are a big reason too Other states like odisha and even bihar and Jharkhand have improved it Not so much in bengal
@@aaryankumar8770 Every other finance minister are alone from Tamil Nadu followed by Maharashtra and then Gujarat... Isn't it surprising that the states which gave more Finance ministers ended up looting the other states while making Maharashtra and South India rich... Ask any East Indian state and they are still paying your cost... 🤣 Their development is not even 0.1% of your entire loot.
I really wonder what that'll be like, because sure (brainless) communism is terrible. but with slums right next to skyscrapers, unfettered free market capitalism ain't it either.
Because she supported them since so long for their communism strategy and now she gave them some advantages but only for her supporters and now, she has became their superstar.
Vote Ka Value hi Kidhar hai , humahara ? mei iha ka LS2024 ka Break Up bata deta Hu Mre Constituency ka Mere area Mei 48% vote gya tha CPIM ko , 40% gya tha BJP ko , aur baki TMC ko , but mere Area se 4km Duur inke Votebank(perticular Community) ne ekjut Hoke Vote dala , 97% Of them Voted for TMC , result - Mp From My Area is From TMC , this is their Model , Hindu k Vote ka hi jaruraat nhi hai inko , jitne k liye , aur jaha Hindu jyada hai uha pe Pre and Post Poll Violence krke Vote jit leta hai !
She did good in 1. Tourism 2. Social welfare Did bad in 1. Economy Management. But, political Unions is there in most of the companies. Even, also companies needs to pay hefty amount to party otherwise not able to do business. Worst in 1. Education. She literally single handedly broke the backbone of Education system. Don't surprise, after 15-20 years West Bengal may be a hub of goon & bad politician. 2. bureaucracy: Money needed for everything
See UP, utilising the potential of spiritual tourism and ganga ghat, developed it so much. Go to any of Kolkata ghats, you won't feel like visiting again. Tourism kaha se aaya 😂 Social welfare nahi, usse freebies kehte hain jo TMC karta hain. Votebank politics
Please don't judge West Bengal by its CM.... West Bengal has a lot to offer especially it's unexplored Northern Parts. I love North Bengal and you would love it too if u love nature....The Dooars region is the best place in West Bengal ,it's extensive,clean and best for tourism.
Cristiano never used clear aligner. He treated his crooked tooth through conventional orthodontic braces treatment, unlike clear aligner. Gets your fact-check Cheers
Hi very well presented and broken down by stats and numbers. I loved the way you have the background and then progressed onto current situation. Something that TV doesn't tell us.
Mamata didn't banished TaTa. People of Singur Nandigram started the protest as a opposition mamata took the opportunity. Mamata's greatest power and failure is over politicization of everything.
As an odia who lives in Bangalore. We go and visit bhuvneshwar every year. Bhuvneshwar is undergoing massive development from before. From past few years bhuvneshwar is changing a lot
Last week CCTV has installed in few Govt hospitals & do you know what is the cost of a single CCTV? 1.5 lakhs to 3.5 lakhs. Yes! It is cost for a single piece.
Bengal doesn't have communist problem it has a big attitude problem, lack of basic infrastructure outside kolkata, law & order, corruption in the open.
You argued that communism destroyed socialist countries like USSR and CHINA but have you ever notiecd the significance of these countries worldwide and their economy, infustructure, and pubic welfare services are far more superior than that of India. India today has became a nation full of corruption, political hatred and is also engulfed by the crisis which the bourgeois inflicted upon its society. Karl Marx argued that the privated capital and money should be abolished, all must have an equal share of all the assets, no one shall be born rich or poor, only then the country can become a superior one. The proletarians strive to acheive financial success in their life, only to be of no use and they live in extreme poverty, misery and in distress.
Well first of all, Thank You Ganesh for making a simplified explanation of a deep complex topic. I am from Singur, West Bengal and I absolutely agree with each and every point you explained. I just only say, our generation are the direct victims of a policy failure and bad governance system, But the Irony is that the government justify their communism ideology through education system like The Singur Andolon (Revolution) is a part of Government School Text Books. That's why the majority people of Bengal don't understand the pros and cons between two systems and fall on the communism anti capatilistic mindset. Here I quote Mr Sanjeev Sanyal's Comment "People of Bengal has a proverty of aspiration" and that's the root cause of this problem. I watched the Mr Sanyal's podcast episode with you and trust me as a bengali I can also relate his pain and sadness when he talks about Bengal. After all he also is a Bengali guy. And lastly, talking about corruption and politics, just like before the 1992 pre-liberation era India has the black economy and mafia raj issue the same things we faced as a byproduct of the poor economic and communism mindset. The only beacon of hope in this tempest situation is that the younger generation of Bengal are thoughtful, they can understand the pros and cons of both systems due to the availability of free and quality information. As an optimistic person i am hopeful about the future of Bengal.
17:42 also about the health insurance, it just covers upto 5lakhs for a whole family for a year. Given the health costs it's beneficial for small Operations (like cataract and stuff) but in general is not that effective. And also there have been cases that hospitals are unwilling of perfoming operations on sastho sathi (the health insurance scheme).
toothsi teeth aligners straighten crooked teeth and close teeth gaps. Book your FREE teeth scan now: toothsi.makeo.app/48KqVYA
Discount code: TKL24TS
Request: please make a video on rajasthan
If you want to know the true picture of WB today, take a look at the government employment cases hanging in various courts. Her party members are so corrupted that even she can't do anything about it. Take a look at various ministries and their corruption stories. Post-poll violence is not only in the media; it has become an everyday thing in WB. All the schemes introduced by the current government have complaints against them. Take a look at Tab for high school students. Do proper research, not just look at and believe the papers published by the government.
Please make a same kind of video about Punjab economic crisis
Hello ThinkSchool,
Can you make a casestudy series for Pharmaceutical Companies?
How much money u take from BJP
Do not spred fake news about bengal
All poorest state of India ruled by BJP
UP
Bihar
Odisha
Assam
Chattisgarh
MP
Rajasthan
Bengal can buy all these poor states
My grandfather had a plywood factory in Bengal. He was planning to shift his factory from Behala to howrah on a larger land size. The labour union set up a strike and didn’t allow us to move our machinery out, and didn’t let us enter our own land. Finally we had to give upto their demands and ultimately after few years our factory had to shut down and we moved to uttar pradesh and setup a unit there…This was in 1997
😢
Where in behala did you guys had your factory
My family has a textile powerloom factory in Maharashtra. Since we’re not “marahashtrian” even though me and my father were born here , we can’t close the factory because the workers would get RPI party goons and demand 25% of the scrap value of my machines. The factory is barely profitable.
And there’s no use for the land there. Other than factory. Which no one would rent because the last time there was any sewage by the municipality here was 50 years ago
Good for you and us(Bangalee).Please don't come if you get a chance in future though...
Who said bengal is failing. Bengal is the top if you count corruption in India....
bengal did not grow in education . i am from west bengal.
@@Gamers_yt759 It was satire
@@Gamers_yt759 I am from Bengal too and also a student how can you say we didn't grow in education??
The student of Bengal are lazy and maximum un plained and unsure of there paths so you are blaming the state for this ?? Many student can't desied there subject to chose after class10 will the state chose from them??
Many schemes of government of West Bengal are helping students though many are misusing the schems and not working hard.
And many people of Bengal do not care for the state
The people of Bengal care for there personal interest only many people who are involved in politics believe if BJP win the state election so they can get personal benifits for the BJP part to satisfy there own interest in there life and don't think of the rest of state but only for there self. Many people of Bengal are getting benifits of the TMC govt schemes but in public they support BJP .
Maximum people of Bengal think they no poltics but in fact they are idiot in poltics .
The people of Bengal do not take care to know what's happening in India and other states the maximum population of the state are dub in politics and economics thinking and special bad at think how there action will cost the state in the feature.
At last the people of Bengal likes to blame others for there fault not thinking what they are doing.
@pratyaysaha government is made for the people and by the people. Bengal is not exception maximum government officer in deferent government office in Bengal don't like to work hard and even if they worked they take bribe form the people of Bengal.
The Cpm part also did it in Bengal and now TMC and even if BJP win the state election they will also take bride from the people of Bengal because the people of Bengal working in the government like to take cut money from the people of Bengal. So the default is not in the government but in the people's mentality.
@@chaitalichakraborty4087 i am also a student . in here many cities[ like small , not too small ] have collages but not have many streams and student desired subject
like ex: a collage have science in collage but only in few subjects . the west bengal govt can't notice that. they focus only politics . for only vote they gave many schemes .
Bengal died at 1977. You can't kill someone who is already dead.
I agree with you
Completely agree with you vai..
Economical, cultural, industrial , educational downfall কমিউনিস্ট রা আসার পর থেকেই স্টার্ট হয়েছে।
Who said? Prostitu-tion is big business growing in Bengal..
Sonagachi GDP will be more than your city.
🏆🏆👍👍
Bengal isn't a human. If it's dead, then how things are moving?
I am from Kolkata, and i can say that i have witnessed my motherland's downfall because of her ulterior motives to gain political advantages.
Loss of business, commerce and peace.. it's all her doing
😢 Once known as the intelligent hub of India is now losing everything. Sad to admit but it's true!
But here he is more interested in blaming communism
@@rituparnarooj5388communism is only viable if you have complete power and genuine interest to develop neither of which the west bengal cpm ha.Kerala is working because it has much greater powers than bengal and peviously had dedicated leaders
The downfall started from the communist Era....he is right
COMMUNISM WAS THE MAIN DESTROYER..SEE THE FACTS AND STATISTICS HE PRESENTED
Many Bengalis say Gujarat Model is a Failure, and then enjoy a peaceful life in Gujarat.
Not really. I have been here in Gujarat for 4 years and I was born and brought up in Delhi and can say Gujarat is nothing in front of Mumbai and Delhi. There is no standard city and there is no civic sense, no public support to others. Open discrimination is being done by the gujaratis to the outsiders. These gujjus migrate to other states and live a peaceful life not vice versa. Get your info correct
@@AnubhavBiswas-sk5qm idk about other things, but Delhi isn't topping the civics sense chart
@@AnubhavBiswas-sk5qm gujrat is safer than delhi and the river in gujarat is not a naala like yamuna and gujarat has good job opportunities and has way less pollution and is cleaner than delhi
@@Adolf_CHADler_16 gujarat has more manufacturing jobs rather than service sector. And outside the 5 cities there is almost nothing here. Sure Delhi is unsafe but how many people live in Ahmedabad and Delhi. Except the gujarati population other communities are non existent.
If gujarat remove ban on liquors and focus of service sector, it will be on another level.@@AnubhavBiswas-sk5qm
Bro I am from Bengal and have a request to you--- please make a case study on several exam scams in westbengal .
its a business channel not a political
@@surajraika7821 22:37 it is a business and political channel bro
@@surajraika7821 before lecturing me, change your dp with original photo.
But our odisha🗿💗 in eastern india🇮🇳🗿👌
Forget about getting a job brother. Ei sakchunni joto din ache, chakri pete hole TMC join koro and taka dao.
As a bengali I am ashamed of tmc and left government.. They both destroy West Bengal
Are you still in WB?
Na na tum unko hi vote do .......chand tak jana hoga tumko
@@botkiller_Pishach this is the problem with you guys, because just due to their past, you guys won't let them change their future. Actually it's you guys who are the problem.
✅️
Mamta Banerjee is a copy paste master. She copied what Jyoti Basu had to do and replicated the model with enhancements, she tried to copy Gujrat model and othe much model too like free beea as was there in Tamil Nadu, Rajasthan etc.. but I don't think you can be a leader by following. And now Thik school appreciating Mamta Banerjee well, it puts me to doubts that all other things that they have brought forward, are those good to follow at all!
I am from Assam. I have witnessed people of Toofanganj ( West Bengal) taking temporary asylum in the adjacent district of Dhubri in Assam due to life threat from Trinamool Congress workers just because those innocent people were being suspected of not voting TMC in the elections . That's what the condition of West Bengal is right now.
🤓
😢
that applies to all parties ...
Despite Bengal having such worst politics and such worst performance, they have to comment on biharis.
@AyushKumar-dz5jj much much better lol..
So many things still didn't cover like Lokkhi Bhandar , Cutt-Money , Booth Capture , Chappa-Vote etc.
People of bengal are not communist , they are mostly poor 😢
They don't know anything about Bengal. Just making videos due to views.
@@travelacharjee9292 yes exactly
Still not accepted reality still Make lame excuses so downfall is necessary
Golden Era of bengali movies to Dev ! Minimum spot boy and crew members need to be hired for even small scene
It's really disappointing to see channels like Think School presenting half-baked information. Since May 20, 2011, Mamata Banerjee has been the Chief Minister of West Bengal, which, as of November 13, 2024, totals 4,923 days in power. Isn’t that enough time to fulfill the promises of uplifting the state and making it a source of pride for the country? A true leader should encourage people to achieve excellence and prioritize the well-being of their state.
Yet, instead of positive progress, West Bengal has seen repeated issues with law and order, instances of various scams, cases of rape and murder, an education scam, and other forms of corruption. It’s disappointing to witness these problems persist while the people were promised change.
To the Think School team, please don’t compromise on integrity for the sake of viewership or profit. You built trust by deeply analyzing data and presenting balanced perspectives, and it’s disheartening to see a lapse in that standard. From today onwards, I will double-check the facts in your videos before accepting them. Please prioritize honest, fact-driven content that benefits both viewers and the country as a whole.
Bro, I think you're being biased again. You're not giving the full picture. She is inviting millions of refugees from Bangladesh to build her vote bank and is distributing Aadhaar cards to them. With limited jobs available, inviting more people is certainly a burden on the economy. Along with provisions like wheat, she's also catering to the minority vote bank by offering freebies to maintain their support. On top of that, there are issues like booth capturing, dirty politics, criminality, and hooliganism-many factors that you've left out.
He is trying to whitewash his perceived image of supporting bjp by praising Mamta Banerjee. The improvement he showed isn't an improvement AT ALL.
Is this video a IPAC propaganda?
Oh yes bro. How could you forget that, yes!😂😂😂
correct
Are you from Bengal?
Before 2011 she say, she have every problems solution for West Bengal but now she is the biggest problem of West Bengal
yes
As an Indian citizen, I have never understood the mindset of West Bengal's citizens.
Sad to see such a downfall of a state.
The video is biased. As a Bengali I can confirm, people of Bengal never wanted Tata to get out from Bengal (not talking about poor farmers, they are brainwashed and have no idea about industry) and Mamata Banerjee's free subsidies instead of welfare, education system corruption, illegal immigrations are the reason of Bengal's downfall alongside the 34 years long communist reign. Every Bengali is fed up to the core. But can't do anything due to the threat culture happening here. Don't forget the RG kar case. Every single protest has been silenced and no justice is served. It's almost like a dictatorship going on in Bengal. I don't understand why Think school made this biased video.
@@fairytales3038 Dude by reading this, I feel in Tamilnadu we have a trillion times better life 🙂 tho I hate our Dravidian parties
You can't do anything because of the dictator Mamata Banerjee. If you do something against TMC then Police will arrest you...😂😂😂😂
This video is completely biased. I am from West Bengal. Corruption is the main cause of our downfall nd its because of mamata Banerjee. Buddhadev bhattacharya still brought many companies but mamata didi hasn't done any. Instead she is the one who stopped people, Brainwashed them to fight against TATA and other industry. singur, nandigram are examples. Nd trade unions are nowadays filled with illiterate , stupid, corrupted peoples. They provide u a job in exchange of lakhs of money. Govt exam can be cleared by those who can give around 20 lakhs to the people indirectly or directly connected to people. Nd here this person is saying it's not her fault. DADA kolkata asun. Stti ta dekhun
People’s of our Bengal are running after 500 and 2000 rs😢
Don't say this thing u are not from delhi or hindi states . U know reason for win . Fair election can easily counter her
@@ChakrabortyandSonsltd keep yapping
It's really disappointing to see channels like Think School presenting half-baked information. Since May 20, 2011, Mamata Banerjee has been the Chief Minister of West Bengal, which, as of November 13, 2024, totals 4,923 days in power. Isn’t that enough time to fulfill the promises of uplifting the state and making it a source of pride for the country? A true leader should encourage people to achieve excellence and prioritize the well-being of their state.
Yet, instead of positive progress, West Bengal has seen repeated issues with law and order, instances of various scams, cases of rape and murder, an education scam, and other forms of corruption. It’s disappointing to witness these problems persist while the people were promised change.
To the Think School team, please don’t compromise on integrity for the sake of viewership or profit. You built trust by deeply analyzing data and presenting balanced perspectives, and it’s disheartening to see a lapse in that standard. From today onwards, I will double-check the facts in your videos before accepting them. Please prioritize honest, fact-driven content that benefits both viewers and the country as a whole.
And so the people of maharshtra after 1.5k per month at the cost of all other schemes
@@ironick5883 we Maharashtrian want both high per capita income + all schemes because all are from our tax it is our right ok
The freebie politics of TMC destroyed West Bengal. Only top to bottom corruption 😢
Freebies not only in WB but also in most of the states.
What's Laadli Behen Yojana? What is 6000/per annum to all the farmers yojana? What's food to 80 crore people? The list of freebies by Fekendra and his gang in centre& Bhajipaao ruler states, is never-ending. Y'all are okay with those Bhagwa Freebies. When the other party gives freebies, you'll start crying. Why being a hypocrite?
+ too many Rohingya people
Goodluck with Bengal tuning a hell.@@nisargdhamecha8476
@@nisargdhamecha8476 there's Subhadra yojana in Odisha where they will waste 50000 crore on freebies to women over the next five years
As a bengali eight main thing which i dont like and completely against is
1:- Appeasement Politics
2:- Gunda Raj
3:- Freebies rather than welfare and education (its obviously because of votebank)
4:- Just like CBI is a caged parrot West Bengal police is a caged parrot.
5:- No development is rural bengal ( in my village there is road of length almost 1 KM you wont believe people go down the road cuz the quality is too poor)
6:- Opposing Central gov welfare scheme like Ayushman Bharat ( though WB gov have Sasthya Sathi which is equivalent to the Central Gov Scheme but people are not benefited)
7:- corruption (you wont believe but the office of the district magistrate which is suppose to be the anti corruption department of the district, corruption are taking place there itself i swear i have personally faced it)
8:- lastly they opposition are suppressed and which is the most dangerous is democracy even you are only allow to speak till its in favour of the gov(and sadly in bengal congress have no future and for BJP i see suvendu adhikari as the face of CM but he also came in BJP by the washing machine method and hence no great leader to lead )
🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂 we are literally FU*KED bro 😐😐😐😐
BJP is the change
Plus heavy communism and leftism
Don't even bother voting for a two faced snake like Suvendu Adhikari. This kind of people only join politics for money and power nothing else.
Sadly, both in TMC and BJP there are many such members.
@@ssr1857 😂 Their leaders in bengal are not, they are mostly corrupt
Btw, your 4,5 and 7 point applies to all the states of India.
Bengali here. Staying outside of Home town for last 10 years. Today I am scared to go back. Culture people zeal to work everything is lost.
I am also going out of WB for Jobs and i will never return.
90% of the students who leave the state, never think of coming back 😢
This is true !
True
Yea and there is a genuine reason.
India also fits in palce of bengal tbh
Very right
As a WB Resident let me tell you, She might done a lot to try to attract businesses in WB but she failed not because People of West Bengal are Communist rather it's because of Zero Law and Order, Rampant Corruption, Political witchhunt, Lack of stability because high illegal immigration of "particular Vote bank" etc etc are the reasons why Industries aren't coming. Cause you won't want to setup a factory where you have zero assurance of safety and will always have Local TMC Aspiring Leader who would always ask for Bribes or Ransom.
It all leads to communism
No changes will take place without bloodshed.
na she does nothing and his image is also a big anti-business type of image you also know what she did in Singur stop sugarcoating his misdeed and how somebody can invest in your state when she always demonized our businessman that's why Adani pulled up his 20000 cr investment for new deep sea port do you know how much employment that project can generate
this guy kisses the feat of congress and mamta everyday after he wakes up
She is bringing in MILLIONS OF MUSLIMS from Bangladesh
She will do as most politicians do
Vote bank
Ya BSF is stupid. They can’t see them entering.
Ok.....bsf kidhar gaya???? Agar ak bhi illegally a raha hain to failure centre ka hain.....border security centre k hat ma hain....
Last 10 year bjp k rule ma sabsa jyda illigal immigration hua hain........socha bhai....galti kiski hain.....?????????
I visited Bangladesh once and Bangladesh is more developed than our West Bengal. So it's very funny that someone would come from there and stay They might do some kind of business import or export business.
@@fakeabey5160 except it's really not but thank you.
I tried to setup a small manufacturing unit in my neighbor village of Hooghly (WB) in 2023. Got a good land attached to road, but after purchasing it faced severe problem from local clubs, cut money, goon leaders threatened me to pay hafta. Left the area and will never try to do something betterment for bengal.
😂😂
@@asuin190 There's nothing to laugh about bud
Yes . To set a business here, u should have some political power or reference. Otherwise u have to pay lakhs of money as hafta . Nd then your profit margin will be very less. So ultimately no reason to start a business here.
DISEASE: COMMUNISM🦠
PATIENT 1: BENGAL (1947-1977)
PATIENT 2: KERALA (1947- )
isn't tmc a sister of cpm only? Just look at the way they work and you will see they are exactly same as cpm.
tmc and bjp are different sides of same coins😂😂
Bjmool
Both are worst for bengal @@anweshadasgupta1178
@@anweshadasgupta1178I call TMC as CPIM 2.0
Bengal is worse than Kerala
atleast it is not bjp 2.0 which will make the state even more worse
i used to live in kolkata before 2015 at that time kolkata was a great city ,it was growing with good economy , then my family shifted to mumbai after 2015 , and recently i had a chance to visit kolkata after so many years due to a connecting flight , and man i was shocked , it feels like time has stopped there, its the same place even after so many years , here mumbai, banagalore and chennai changed their whole geography in last 10 years , but kolkata its still the same
I agree . I have been living in Bengal since my childhood and let me tell you nothing much big has changed in the past 20 years
Bro are you blind? 😂😂 kolkata is rising very fast open your eyes
@@norendermoody6509 come to mumbai man or even bangalore and chennai then you will understand , i have lived in all the major metro cities of india from my childhood due to my fathers job , so i can literally tell you the difference
currently i am in chennai and its far better than kolkata
@@norendermoody6509Look at Hyderabad, where it was and where it is now.
@@pranavchoudhary9319we don't want any demographics change in Mumbai or Bangalore, all states should develop and no demographics change should happen
Dhruv Rathee is a big fan of Bengal, he must be hurt 😅
😂
he doesn't really care about Bengal
He doesn't care.
He misled people on Bengal, time and again including the RG Kar incident
He might be happy because this guy said Mamta is working hard to improve wb 😂😂
Watch Gaurav Thakur's interview with ex-RAW field agent ( who is an expert sniper operator ). He indirectly indicates that Dhruv Tatt! is working for German Intelligence to spread propaganda which suits Germany's foreign policy for India.
I am from Singur & now all the residents of this area are realising what we had done with Tata😢
Worst decision ever that was .
" kolkata didn't die it was murdered by the communists" sanjeev sanyal
Mamata banarjee is arranging the funaral.
Siliguri is a geographical blessing for India which has 3 international borders near it can be equivalent to any tier 1 city, but no development in infrastructure and corruption practices has hault its growth.
you are right bro
Even i agree,today Guwahati has grown to become the commercial capital of North East whereas Siliguri which was once a famous wholesale market and started developing much earlier has gone down since then
Also Malda .. whole north bengal had nothing
Exactly
It could be developed like a supergateway to himalayas but alas it is barely developed in comparison to other indian cities.
Construct two malls begal people think oo so developed city it is
The labour of Bengal have achieved equality of poor
coming from a bihari migrant
Just keep patting yourself "we're better than bihar"
Honestly not by much now compared to 2000s
And bihar is growing while wb is still the slowest growing state in eastern india
Also isnt bengal the third biggest migrant contributor after up and bihar?
Maybe look at yourself too instead of being enraged when someone points out wrongdoings
Creating hate for biharis wouldn't solve 😢 our Bengal's problems
😂 Communism follows equality so they provide poor to everyone without any discrimination
😂😂😂😂
As a Bengali(বাঙালি), we know that our future is already in danger 😞
My friend had opened a cafe in Lake town after covid. He had to pay monthly cut money to police for parking, Monthly cut money to local club, Very high chanda for various function, Yearly Donation to tmc party funds. Recently, local MLA's men tried to shut his cafe by making allegations that women feel unsafe and eve teasing happens because of his cafe's crowd.
He was forced to shut his shop. Now, he moved to different place to open cloud kitchen.
Fir bhi toh log Bengal mai business karne ke liye marte hai😂😂😂
This is the same thing happening in kerala brother...!!! Issues like you open a busainess in kerala, they will run in loss because of strikes, parties or employee or labor strikes and they will move to a different state. Recently, Kitex a company which was doing good and offered a lot of jobs to people in kerala, had to shut their operations had to shut down as they were facing loss in business due to labour strikes and also with pressure from the trade unions and people their have not even understood their mistake. Even if they understand, the communalism will shut their eyes...!!!
As a resident of Bengal, we have seen first hand that Businesses are forced to pay Cut-Money (Hafta) for any steps they take to expand/setup their business, and the thing is the government is deeply invoived in this and thus nobody to help. The only thing I have seen improve are the road conditions in Village, other than that everything is way behind the National Standard.
True you need connections for everything
Bro that is the case everywhere, in my State also
I visited Kolkata in 1998, 2007, 2014 and 2024. Except some new areas, most of the Kolkata either remained exactly the same or looked deteriorated during this period. Other Indian cities that were far behind Kolkata back then like Ahmedabad, Bengaluru, Hyderabad and Pune outperformed drastically and left Kolkata today far behind in development.
Exactly that thought I share my friend, India's all city are growing rapidly, but Kolkata running in 30 years back.
West Bengal is a highly politics driven state, where people have forgotten to be ambitious. They depend on the Government schemes and the little money that gets credited to people’s bank accounts. Brain drain is a huge drawback. As Bengalis we are forced to leave Bengal to lead a standard life. Bengal’s work culture is substandard and doesn’t allow one to bloom.
I'm a Bengali yes Mamata did give several schemes for the people of bengal but they're not at all viable or beneficial rather they're vite gaining schemes where local leaders take bribes for inserting a name in that scheme. Btw no company invested in Bengal in recent years even if some did their amount is negligible like some paint based companies. Don't believe what the reports say the ground situation is way worse, debt ridden growth is not a good thing where you don't even have proper earning for the state govt. She polticised each and every institution available for the people of bengal like the police (they act like party cadres actually)
My uncle had opened a small production house in South Bengal in 2021 employing 120 people majority women but he has been threatened by TMC party mobs to for "weekly rangdaari" he payed for 2 years but eventually left Bengal and now he has Plant in Odisha
which district in odisha
Man as a Bengali was waiting for this a long thanks @ThinkSchool team
Stop being so leftist first.
@@Primus_suspectus i am not i myself voted bjp also told the hold family to do so but unfortunately most bengali persist aspiration of poverty the leftist gov lost now for 13 years still mindset is same and also most bengali don't give a F about infiltration and even if some people vote for change their is huge amount of booth capturing and so on .. That is why i decided to leave bengal and go to other state
@@UsernameCrashed1xdd Even onek manus vote deycha for 1000 in WB
@@ImNex09 exactly
It's really disappointing to see channels like Think School presenting half-baked information. Since May 20, 2011, Mamata Banerjee has been the Chief Minister of West Bengal, which, as of November 13, 2024, totals 4,923 days in power. Isn’t that enough time to fulfill the promises of uplifting the state and making it a source of pride for the country? A true leader should encourage people to achieve excellence and prioritize the well-being of their state.
Yet, instead of positive progress, West Bengal has seen repeated issues with law and order, instances of various scams, cases of rape and murder, an education scam, and other forms of corruption. It’s disappointing to witness these problems persist while the people were promised change.
To the Think School team, please don’t compromise on integrity for the sake of viewership or profit. You built trust by deeply analyzing data and presenting balanced perspectives, and it’s disheartening to see a lapse in that standard. From today onwards, I will double-check the facts in your videos before accepting them. Please prioritize honest, fact-driven content that benefits both viewers and the country as a whole.
I'm from bengal..and here corruption level is too high
Vote❌ Biryani ✅
Now Dabur is moving from west bengal to Tamilnadu
Ok
Great
Why Don't we speak about HIMACHAL PRADESH. The government doesn't even have the funds to feed its own employees. What a shame. That's why most of the young generation is leaving India.
Everyone is talking about Himachal Pradesh man, their Samosas are stolen so nation is eagerly waiting to see who stole it 😅
Each state gets talked about separately but still a great state like west bengal which is not land locked and had major industries lost it all in few decades is something to worry about compared to Himachal which is land locked with hilly terrain.
Chalo matlab you agree with this video 😂😂 butt hurt mindset at its peak 😂
Love how you are being safe and diplomatic by not calling out major cause of bengal downfall to Mamta Banerjee
He is right....
The cause of the downfall of west bengal is communism., Mamata Banerjee just nailed last pin!
I doubt there is any downfall.
Recently by election held in wb . TMC won all seats
DIdnt u read the evidences that he showcased that Mamata is not the only reason? U urself keeping a blind eye and expect a right wing party will vanish all of the bengal problems
Where are dhruv rathee and Akash baneerji 😂 they called gujarat model hoax and bengal model better such clowns 🤡
Kaha vai??
Dhruv Rathee has done well to attract unemployed and dumb youths of India into believing his agenda!
taking care of his baby aka chota rathee
Bharath is developing, It has the highest employment availability ever. If anything negative it's because of the states.
He didn't call bengal model better, it was Kerala, stop misleading people
Nobody talks about Jyoti basu era. Economical, industrial, cultural downfall starts from his time actually..
Yes jyoti basu is the pioneer of downfall in WB
ain't he massacred dalits in marichjhapi and supported suhrawardy who is responsible for great kolkata killings
Seems like we need a DOGE - Department of Government Efficiency in India too.
Fr
We already do, it's called CAG
@@KidsColorsPaints21it's there but needs further improvements. CAG officials are not so professional at times.
@@vofficial170says someone who doesn't know what an audit is😂
@@jishnuadhikari5234 Do you believe you're the only one entitled to question my understanding of CAG audits? I’ve been closely following the functioning of the CAG, including its audits of large public entities like the Indian Railways, and I understand both its strengths and its limitations. My criticism stems from observed inefficiencies and the retrospective nature of its processes, which sometimes fail to prompt meaningful reforms despite identifying significant issues.
This man is Sharp! Good knowledge! - Thank you ... Good works
Need an episode for what Mamta did with West Bengal?
It will be an episode of only misdeeds and corruption
Just like how Modi Government ignore the Bengal😂😂😂
Why is West Bengal facing an economic crisis? = Because of Mamta
bruh he says the opposite. Lmao
Watch the video, lol
i support bjp due to their policy but bootlickers like you are sick. Have you even watched the video?
@@outofcontextworld bro it is right but if a leader came from TMC how will you believe him you can understand the name of BJP leaders...
They are not saint bro, just They are commenting from washing machine
Only Bengalis are to be blamed for this. They don't know whom to vote. First Communist ruined bengal then came Mamta begam.
It is rightly said that WB economic downfall is not a suicide but a planned murder. There was a time when people from all over India were migrating to Kolkata for jobs and better opportunities. Now educated people of WB are migrating to other states looking for jobs. Very sad indeed.
WB is a net inward migration state, people mostly from Bihar come here to work unskilled jobs. Skilled jobs are not there.
Such an insightful and well researched video. Kudos man, lovely to hear you and being a bengali and a person who is saddened by the downfall, whatever you say is absolutely true and I wish things to improve in near future.
Day before a boy shoot a local business man & in police station he is saying "I am doing TMC party what you can do?
He is from bihar not a bengalee.
Don't compare GUJARAT with Bengal.... Gujaratis are smart wise and business minded humble loving people. Being a malayali living in Gujarat since birth, I could say Gujarat just needed a right leader and we got Modiji and since then we never looked back. We Gujaratis WISELY CHOSE OUR LEADERS... We don't vote for freebies ❤
Because we have prime Minister of gujarat not prime Minister of india😂😂
@adhnaanahmed5029 😂😂😂 I never understand why Ahmed, Muhammad, Ali, etc always have issue... Why can't u guys for a moment think as an Indian? Do pakistan give u food?
West Bengal consists of not even half of Bengal. Banga, which is the ancestral homeland of Bengalis. Consists of the modern borders West Bengal, Tripura, Parts of Meghalaya, Assam and Arakan (Myanmar) and of course Bangladesh. It is only fair to compare all of Bengal to all Gujarat to see real picture. That picture has been the same since times immemorial. When India was the most prosperous land on Earth. Bengal was it's richest!
When you say not to compare Bengal with Gujarat. You're absolutely right! How can there be a comparison between a Elephant and a rat?!!
In this world Bengalis are only behind the Chinese and Arabs on terms of the entire human civilization. Your Gujarat or even Maharashtra or both combined are still puny compared to us. You and your descendants will always live under our cultural domination just like your ancestors. Everyday you sing the national anthem. Know that you're singing a Bengali song. In every nooks and crannies you will find us and our heritage. Because you see Bengal doesn't came from India. But the idea of an independent India, Pakistan and its own independent state was all birthed by Bengal.
That is the unapologetic truth of history and reality. Either you can swallow or not is up to you. There's an saying old saying in Bengali:
"Whatever Bengal thinks today. India thinks tomorrow."
@@vinukrishnannair why don't u consider rest of 28 states as India when I speak for other 28 states,this tells how much u are infiltrated with hate mongering propaganda.baseless supporters of bjp proclaiming themselves as nationalists while statpading every economic development with gujarat.where is ur nationalist sentiment now?
And you guys telling me I'm not nationalist when I talk about development in other states.
@@adhnaanahmed5029 Everything for gujrat are u kidding 😂.... ? Nano plat was not started in Gujarat, they were rescued by Gujarat. Similarly every BJP run state accepts development or let me rephrase, every state people who wants development go with BJP. I'm from Kerala and I know what govt does there and we malayali's are so controlled by leftist propoganda that we dig out own grave. India's achievements are not hidden to the world and u think that achievements in GDP, Defence, Aerospace, Space research, Startup ecosystem etc are achieved by just developing Gujarat.... I won't insist but try to speak logic and come out of this mindset. We need muslim brothers who idolize Shri APJ Abdul Kalam sir and not the one following Owasi or Pappu
Let go by reality, road conditions is pathetic in bengal compared to any state. This is with comparison to 16 states i have traveled this year. The immigration from Bangladesh is alarming high. Corruption is at peak this is not something i am making it up , as a common person visit any police station or govt office. Corruption and bribe is promoted openly and ego of govt staff is so high that common man leaves with guilt without any solution. All changes in Bengal are on paper and not implemented properly because of deep rooted corruption
That sounds like any Indian state
So true
@@aaravgulati1194its just far worse in wb
Road Condition in Bihar is still the Worst
@@sunnymitra6372 true
But at least things are improving there faster than wb
And people in bihar aren't hostile to big business (at least a lot less) unlike wb
Before bengal state election Bengalis be like: Bengal is falling downfall etc etc
During election:They be like khela hobe...
After election repeat
That's all about bengal politics nothing else..
Bengal is not failing. People of Bengal like Bengal to be like that only.
Exactly.
Just like stock market,Some stocks jump to much in early nd then stops for many years . Nd suddenly again jumps nd beats the top performer. Look at trent . Every person nd MF betting on trent but now his time also gone. Like that Bengal will Again rise .I am trying to make Bengal own party then bengal will rise
bengal education system is falling. no development in education in west bengal its reality. i live in west bengal
@@SouravChakraborty-x8y bana bhai, bangla jatiyotabadi party r dorkar aj.
@@adamlupu5885 Tomader sobai ke o nije ke sosoto hote hobe ..
Keo ghore pore thakbe na
Baire beroy tomra
Physically fit hou ..gym koro or kono sports e angso nao .
And govt exam er preparation sobai bondho koro
Nd skills er dike takao .
Kerala got benefitted Mostly From Gulf Migration
How long this is going to last ?
@tbraghavendran starting to decline of that trend
West bengal people during 5 year says didi is weird ....
West Bengal people during election:- no we don't want an outsider to rule our state #didi_is _best
Totally well said.
As a Bengali, i cant even complain
God knows who the f gives them votes
Some points mentioned is wrong. During the late rule of Communist they wanted to partner with the big houses like TATA, but they were opposed by the then opposition now the ruling party. Also regarding job creation the last communist CM went on public to say that they need big corporations to come for their youth to stay back in West Bengal.
My father-in-law who lives in Bengal was a devoted supporter of communist party until 2008. Once left parties allowed Tata factory in Singur he switched his allegiance to Mamata and now he considers communist party as "gaddar". He thinks all large businesses should be govt owned/PSU and only reason states allow private companies is due to corruption. I think many people resonates with this thought process in India. It's just in most states it did not make central political agenda as cast/religion took over.
It wasn't left it was Budhhadev Bhattacharya who tried to change the fortune of the state...
“Brand Buddha ” still remember
No one's thought resonates with this nonsense
You see it is natural psychology to resonate with such because Communism is pretty romantic in its true sense. Think of your father in law during his young days, how these things were fed in his mind that "Samrajjobad er Dalal der Bhenge dao guriye dao, Turn the Capitalists to the ruins". Lot of left wing intellectuals have written books and poems to manipulate the young minds on top of Marxs Das Kapital. Many of those in their 60s in Bengal still believe that driving away Tatas were the right thing. It's all left wing romanticism that people especially students get easily attracted to. We Bengalis say "Hujuk e matha dhukiye dewa, going with the trend".
You rightly pointed out the root cause.
As a Bengali, I think the young generation is very capitalist, they see what is happening in other states and countries. The old generation like my father and uncles everybody I know are/were CPIM supporter & they still like CPIM( not necessarily vote them) without trying to understand what they did wrong, they just have a lingering feeling like those were the good times. I personally hate TMC but can see Mamta Banerjee is actually making some efforts to change but every single minister is rotten to their core ! Everyone is under investigation under some kind of scam or scandal or money laundering. And Mamta being their leader isn't doing anything to stop this, she is openly trying to save them! The main thing lacking currently in this state is Strong Opposition. Yes BJP is worse than them, at least TMC is united, but BJP is bickering among themselves. They have no connection to the common public they are failing to create the storm that Mamta created single handedly in 2011. But above all the people of Bengal are so used to being poor and living by just meeting basic needs they don't want any change! Lastly The Lakshmir Vandar scheme is the game changer. While I like the poor woman getting 1000 rupees a month which makes them somewhat self dependent, it pains me to think her son/daughter could have got a job if not for Didi !
We have now become "Waste" Bengal all thanks to the combined effort of Lal Salaam and the worst "Cheap" Minister of India till date, "Momo-ta". 😠😠
Gobhiji🤡
@@sagarpandey456kitna chillar Mila bhai😂
Everything was fine untill monstar (Jyoti babu) was coming.
This has happened due to Jyoti Basu not just Mamata. Jyoti Basu and the bloody CPM!!
In Bengal people are happy with low income. Very few people are enthusiastic about growth. They don’t like to work.
It's been millennia the Bengali people have not seen prosperity , peace , proper justice , I just can't !!!
Bengali people are the longest colonized ethnicity on earth
not millennia , rather 800 years from 1206 to 2024 and counting, most exploited, tortured, harmed and gen0cided race in the world, if someone actually analyzes the history they will realise even jews didnt have to suffer like this
19:58 i come from durgapur, a very wealthy city in west bengal. Also known for its steel production, it was one of the few back in time to produce wheels for trains. But as i grew up most of the industries are just on a verge of shutting down (even the public once) there's just a lot of scams going here and there, some getting busted some not. Moreover affecting the factories and the familes living here . 18:14 and speaking of mafias, from coal mafia to TMC booth mafias it's just shit out here and as students here, we just have the option to move out to other states for opportunities. I would like to conclude with bengal is just a better version of bihar.
I always wanted Asansol Durgapur Burdwan belt to be connected and developed into 3 city urban cluster a wide metropolitan area like Pune Pimpri Chinchwad
@-EIE--ShouvikBanerjee maybe in our dreams someday
Asansol Durgapur has more potential than our west, but booth capture won’t allow to do that
So true. Koto potential amder ediker but 😢. SAIL durgapur ar BARNPUR duto plant ea valo capex infused korar kotha ache. Auxiliary industry chi. Chemical industry chi. Foxconn er moto ekta jodi kichu asto. Sob dik theke ideal... But 😢😢
Being a resident of this state, I can vouch for all your statements.
1. The people of this state are just too uninformed and have a myopic vision for growth.
2. Industries are not proliferating due to unwarranted demands from labour unions which are nothing but just arms of political parties to keep control over the businessmen as well as the poor labourers.
3. The underutilisation and non expansion of its assests such as roads,metro rail, ports, connectivity to NE states and South East Asian.
4. The corrupt bureaucracy and politicians who have a lack of will for growth and development. Instead they keep luring the poor with freebies, which again in turn increases state expenditure.
5. Lack of a visionary leader with sufficient political support who can make revolutionary policies to attract businesses.
6. Once the biggest jute textile hub in the world, with hundreds of factories setup during the British Raj weren’t modernised and upgraded. The industry is still the backbone of the state but is in shambles due to the political labour unions.
7. The HATE for “OUTSIDERS” among the general populace. It is concerning that citizens of the same country feel that the brothers and sisters of the other states are “OUTSIDERS” to them, and the hatred is so evident that it’s just not the businesses who are not willing to come to WB, but now the people also don’t want to migrate to this state for jobs.
It’s a deeply hurting and concerning that the state which has given the icons & leaders of the fight for an independent nation, has now lost it’s nationalistic identity. The Regional cultures and identity must be preserved but not by jeopardising the nationalist values. If people of other states are outsiders, then what will be the difference between WB and Bangladesh ?
Feel free to leave
I'm from Kerala, and I’ve noticed people here seem to dislike industries a lot. The communist government has been pretty tough on big companies, even forcing ones like Anna Aluminium and Kitex to leave. Kitex actually moved to Karnataka after their government sent a private jet to bring their manager over and convince them to invest there instead. Because of all this, big businesses don’t want to set up in Kerala. Plus, with fewer job opportunities, many general category students(mostly christians) are leaving India to find better options abroad.
And then go to beg for jobs in other states and still calling Kerala as best state 😂
Christian Missionaries in Kerala what are they doing? Only convert people? Can’t they give Jobs ?
Say this too "The owner of Kitex has a political party too"
@vineeshsv313 doesn't matter, if they are giving jobs, what's wrong with it, have some sense, communism is failed idealogy, capitalism works, that's why Tamil Nadu Karnataka Maharashtra are successful in producing highest employment opportunities while others are stuck with lowda chuslim divide and fighting for caste
@@vinayj1763 offcourse almost all the the ideologies are failure in this modern society. But i don't know why it "doesn't matter if they are giving job" even these communists also provide jobs
Love the upgraded production! This video looks and feels amazing!🤗
Yea🎉
West Bengal is falling because of an egoistic woman, who thinks she cares for everyone but in reality she only cares for herself, her own ego and wants power. No matter she completely destroys the social fabric of the state. The fact is she has already exploited it.
this video said just the opposite, this channel is as fake as it gets
What an eye opening video it was.
I really like the way you deep dive into things and get a business angle into any topic
17:38 Being born and bought up in Kolkata i can confirm that there are rampant cases of Political violence (especially murders). In college as well....if you are a party worker you will get 90% attendance (even never been to classes for a single day) whereas if you aren't you will get what teachers give. Politics is extremely dirty in Bengal
Bro you've missed one thing which is important to "national security" you're being over neutral towards some governments... IYKYK
What is amit shah doing?
Hey @thinkschool, the picture at 8:14 is a mistake. It seems to be from Karnataka and not Kerala as the language on the sign is written in Kannada. Great content as always!
Bengalis vote her and come to Bengaluru just to say "amchi sonar bangla"😂
Lol 😂😂😂
Despite Bengal with such worst politics and such worst performance, they have to comment on biharis.
Stop illegal immigrants from Bangladesh
Also the excess migration from Bihar and UP should stop 😢😢
@BajrayoginiUpadhay97 average bot communists
@SumitKumar-xh8tt Communist ideology hai isliye Bengal mai dusre states ke log itne Shanti se rehte hai, agar right with ideology hota toh Bengal ka haal bhi Karnataka ya Manipur jaise raciest hota. Lekin tumhare samajh se bahar hai ye sab .😆😆😆
@@Vidya_Upadhay97 neurological disorders Bengal me common hai. What about gdp declining contribution, illogical striking in the factory, bengal government involved in horrific crime. Not just citizens but doctors, ips officers are not safe in bengal.
@@Vidya_Upadhay97As an Indian it's there wish to travel and work any where they want. They are completely legal workers. Please get this low mentality shit out of your head.
Bengal is experiencing a true dictatorship, but no one is paying any attention.
Politics has destroyed West bengal. Firstly CPIM for 30 yrs and rest by Muslim's Chief minister Mamata Banerjee 🤡
Bhaiya I am a Muslim and the mamata police looted my 17k rs 😢 with goons in proper Kolkata which are all hindus
Please don't fight for religion
Both muslim and Hindus are victims under Mamta rule
@@simplechemistry7518 Yet, still muslims vote for her...?
@@ArnavSingh-ps7os I don't know who vote her but I never voted her, and bjp is taking the same corrupted politicians of tmc 🤬
But our odisha in eastern part of India🇮🇳🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿👌 ❤jay jagannath🕉 🚩⚫❗⚫🛕🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🧡🚩
I feel a growth rate of 6% is very low for an underdeveloped/developing state like West Bengal.
Its lower than the national average.
Bihar had a double digit growth for 3-4 years immediately after Nitish Kumar introduced reforms and improved law and order situation.
You are partially correct in saying that WB is in a messy state not because of Mamta Banerjee alone, but massive reforms have to come about if investor confidence is to be restored and work culture (root cause of Bengal's economic downfall) is to be improved.
Bihar still has an average of 9% growth This last decade
Since covid growth has again picked up
Hopefully it stays 10%+ for at least 15 years
It doesn't matter if she tries to pretend to bring industrialization to bengal. The common people of bengal wants that. But the syndicate raaj and goons backed by her party won't let anyone do business there properly. Please do not say she has done anything for health and education of bengal. She and her party leaders (am talking about top tiers ) have destroyed it. Kindly do your ground research. She has opened flood gates of corruption
he has to monkey balance so that tmc goons online do not attack him
There is almost negligible investment in Bengal, Compared to southern states & Guj, UP etc
UP got nothing in comparison to Gujarat. And UP never got anything which Maharashtra and South India has got for decades since the Congress era.
@@k2indeed8998what about now?
The pace of growth of up is way higher than most states right now
@@aaryankumar8770 Still it nothing compared to the edge given to South India under Freight equilisation act.
@k2indeed8998 not really
Freight equalization has been gone for thirty years
Every state in the east is growing faster than bengal
Freight equalization was one of the reasons for backwardness
The other reason- bad local policies are a big reason too
Other states like odisha and even bihar and Jharkhand have improved it
Not so much in bengal
@@aaryankumar8770 Every other finance minister are alone from Tamil Nadu followed by Maharashtra and then Gujarat... Isn't it surprising that the states which gave more Finance ministers ended up looting the other states while making Maharashtra and South India rich... Ask any East Indian state and they are still paying your cost... 🤣 Their development is not even 0.1% of your entire loot.
❤ how beautifully you explained this topic ..
Hi Ganesh, this was again one of the masterpiece. I would love to see your next video on Concious Capatilasm & countries using this. Thanks 😊
Need an episode on Conscious Capitalism
I really wonder what that'll be like, because sure (brainless) communism is terrible. but with slums right next to skyscrapers, unfettered free market capitalism ain't it either.
Excellent work on the role of communism lacking economic growth
Very nice n clear explanation.
I had a serious double. Why wb people still vote for her despite her economic and illegal immigrants
Because she supported them since so long for their communism strategy and now she gave them some advantages but only for her supporters and now, she has became their superstar.
Cause they still haven't come outta communissm shadow plus the other alternatives are also filled with ex TMC leaders so where to go?
Because people with capitalists mindset mvoed out of bengal and only the communists remain who wote for her since they are too lazy to work.
west bengal have 30% Muslim population, all vote tmc bjp 0 vote
Vote Ka Value hi Kidhar hai , humahara ?
mei iha ka LS2024 ka Break Up bata deta Hu Mre Constituency ka
Mere area Mei 48% vote gya tha CPIM ko , 40% gya tha BJP ko ,
aur baki TMC ko , but mere Area se 4km Duur inke Votebank(perticular Community) ne ekjut Hoke Vote dala , 97% Of them Voted for TMC ,
result - Mp From My Area is From TMC ,
this is their Model , Hindu k Vote ka hi jaruraat nhi hai inko , jitne k liye , aur jaha Hindu jyada hai uha pe Pre and Post Poll Violence krke Vote jit leta hai !
She did good in
1. Tourism
2. Social welfare
Did bad in
1. Economy Management. But, political Unions is there in most of the companies. Even, also companies needs to pay hefty amount to party otherwise not able to do business.
Worst in
1. Education. She literally single handedly broke the backbone of Education system.
Don't surprise, after 15-20 years West Bengal may be a hub of goon & bad politician.
2. bureaucracy: Money needed for everything
Tourism? As a woman I would never visit West Bengal. I won't feel safe there. If you want to develop tourism first make that place feel safer.
Agree with you @@adrika_sharma
See UP, utilising the potential of spiritual tourism and ganga ghat, developed it so much.
Go to any of Kolkata ghats, you won't feel like visiting again.
Tourism kaha se aaya 😂
Social welfare nahi, usse freebies kehte hain jo TMC karta hain. Votebank politics
Please don't judge West Bengal by its CM.... West Bengal has a lot to offer especially it's unexplored Northern Parts.
I love North Bengal and you would love it too if u love nature....The Dooars region is the best place in West Bengal ,it's extensive,clean and best for tourism.
Hardly people got to West Bengal for tourism.
Cristiano never used clear aligner.
He treated his crooked tooth through conventional orthodontic braces treatment, unlike clear aligner.
Gets your fact-check
Cheers
Hi very well presented and broken down by stats and numbers. I loved the way you have the background and then progressed onto current situation. Something that TV doesn't tell us.
Mamata didn't banished TaTa.
People of Singur Nandigram started the protest as a opposition mamata took the opportunity.
Mamata's greatest power and failure is over politicization of everything.
Bengal mindset everybody should be equal so everybody should be poor 😅
It's funny how the east of India is has stopped contributing!
I am an Odia and I am not happy with our performance we need to do more.
As an odia who lives in Bangalore. We go and visit bhuvneshwar every year. Bhuvneshwar is undergoing massive development from before. From past few years bhuvneshwar is changing a lot
Odisha is way better than it was at one point it has a bright future ahead for which Patnaik deserves credit
Very well explained 😊
Last week CCTV has installed in few Govt hospitals & do you know what is the cost of a single CCTV? 1.5 lakhs to 3.5 lakhs. Yes! It is cost for a single piece.
hahaha,,,he wont show it brother
Bengal doesn't have communist problem it has a big attitude problem, lack of basic infrastructure outside kolkata, law & order, corruption in the open.
Very nice video
You argued that communism destroyed socialist countries like USSR and CHINA but have you ever notiecd the significance of these countries worldwide and their economy, infustructure, and pubic welfare services are far more superior than that of India. India today has became a nation full of corruption, political hatred and is also engulfed by the crisis which the bourgeois inflicted upon its society. Karl Marx argued that the privated capital and money should be abolished, all must have an equal share of all the assets, no one shall be born rich or poor, only then the country can become a superior one. The proletarians strive to acheive financial success in their life, only to be of no use and they live in extreme poverty, misery and in distress.
Well first of all, Thank You Ganesh for making a simplified explanation of a deep complex topic.
I am from Singur, West Bengal and I absolutely agree with each and every point you explained. I just only say, our generation are the direct victims of a policy failure and bad governance system, But the Irony is that the government justify their communism ideology through education system like The Singur Andolon (Revolution) is a part of Government School Text Books. That's why the majority people of Bengal don't understand the pros and cons between two systems and fall on the communism anti capatilistic mindset. Here I quote Mr Sanjeev Sanyal's Comment "People of Bengal has a proverty of aspiration" and that's the root cause of this problem.
I watched the Mr Sanyal's podcast episode with you and trust me as a bengali I can also relate his pain and sadness when he talks about Bengal. After all he also is a Bengali guy.
And lastly, talking about corruption and politics, just like before the 1992 pre-liberation era India has the black economy and mafia raj issue the same things we faced as a byproduct of the poor economic and communism mindset.
The only beacon of hope in this tempest situation is that the younger generation of Bengal are thoughtful, they can understand the pros and cons of both systems due to the availability of free and quality information. As an optimistic person i am hopeful about the future of Bengal.
talented people has to leave Bengal due to lack of job opportunities highlights how the state is rotten to core
same as Kerala
17:42 also about the health insurance, it just covers upto 5lakhs for a whole family for a year. Given the health costs it's beneficial for small Operations (like cataract and stuff) but in general is not that effective. And also there have been cases that hospitals are unwilling of perfoming operations on sastho sathi (the health insurance scheme).
Very insightful... the lessons were made Very well study....