Edifier S3000Pro vs Edifier S2000Pro || Sound & Frequency Response Comparison
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ส.ค. 2024
- Edifier S3000Pro on amazon DE: amzn.to/2PCWdZr
Edifier S3000Pro on amazon UK: amzn.to/2jV3LuP
Edifier S3000Pro on bhphotovideo: bhpho.to/2CSBVow
Edifier S2000Pro on amazon DE: amzn.to/2ludl8i
Edifier S2000Pro on bhphotovideo: bhpho.to/2NTRrXI
Edifier S2000Pro on amazon UK: amzn.to/2lfgSr2
---------------------
Follow me on instagram for the latest updates and behind the scene look: / digitalstereophony
-----------------------------
All the tracks used in this video can be found here:
• Test Tracks
----------------------------
-Sound recorded using Zoom H6 recorder
-Frequency measurements done in semi treated room using UMIK-1 microphone
-Levels matched using SPL meter
-All tone controls set to neutral - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
![อยู่ได้แล้ว - LIPTA feat. Mirrr [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-9-hpntNym4/mqdefault.jpg)
S3000 PRO is the winner, no doubt. More crystal clear sound.
Maybe but double Price of the S2000..
Super i wielkie dzięki, że Ci się chcę to robić, dzięki Twoim filmom i blogowi kupiłem S2000Pro i nawet trochę nie żałuję , dźwięk rewelacja i subwoofer niepotrzebny.
Because of these beautiful review and sound comparison, I had just bought an Edifier S3000 Pro as my PC speaker.
Choosing between Edifier S3000 Pro & Edifier S2000 Pro, see the specification on their official website, Edifier S3000 Pro had double the power which makes the bass sound so powerful than the Edifier S2000 Pro.
By the way, wish to see the comparison between AirPulse A300 & Edifier S3000 Pro. If the sound comparison doesn't have much big differences, I still get another Edifier S3000 Pro for living room since left & right speaker work wireless.
Nice video & sound, from Malaysia :D
Keep going and bring us more review and comparison.
*DISCLAMER* S3000Pro was recorded in "Classic" DSP mode, not "Monitor" mode as I claimed before. Classic mode boosts the treble significantly. I am sorry for the confusion.
-> 10:08
I've had both of these - and the s3000 pro's are definitely better. Tighter, less boomy bass, with better low end extension - and even though I think the tweeter only changed in the shape of the wave guide, the highs are beautiful. I also think the s3000 pro's look classier for a living room setting. The s2000 pro's look nice - but I never loved the front grill, and removing it doesn't help much. The dark wood color of the s3000 pro's is just elegant.
That said, I still have the s2000 pro's. The s3000 pro's were returned when the wireless connection on my set started having dropouts. I think I got a faulty pair.
disagree. here is obvious: 2000 closer to the Source; lack bass. 3000 have problem on "sss" frequency (like 3000hz probably) where 2000 are perfectly close to the source.
Since that, not Airpulses, not 3000, but specifically 2000 are true jevels in edifier lineup. They just need subwoofer help.
extremumone - Just sharing my direct, in-person experience with both as they sound in my living room.
@@NeverStark so your room. Every room is different. There is VERY small probability that your room consumes excessive S sound of 3000.
And very high probability that you, as the most, prefer sound with coloration.
3000 can be "more fun" but actually "more fun" is no "better".
@@extremumone - One reason why I decided to find new speakers for my living room was actually the sibilant "s" sounds that I was noticing with my s2000 pro's. Contrary to what you're suggesting, I did not notice that behavior on the s3000 pro's. Their high frequency was crystal clear and defined. It really stood out to me as one of the hallmarks of these speakers over my s2000 pro's.
I've also never found the s2000 pro's to lack bass. Bass output from those smaller woofers has always impressed me for their size. It feels accentuated - like they have something to prove. I actually didn't think of it as boomy or excessive until I heard the s3000 pro's. I felt that the s3000 pro's controlled the bass much better in my living room - offering plenty of presence and power without dominating the rest of the frequency range. They definitely offered more low end extension (which you'd naturally expect from a larger woofer.)
I did notice that with some songs, male vocals felt recessed - which led me to wonder if the mid-range suffers a bit on the s3000 pro's. "Say Something" by Justin Timberlake is probably where I noticed it the most.
I really enjoy both sets of these speakers - and had the s3000 pro's not developed connection problems, I would definitely still have them.
@@NeverStark well that was awesome explanation...
What connection problem did you experience?
Thank you for the countless comparisons. This has helped my decision making process immensely
Thank you for the comparison! ^^
Nice Work!
Great job bro but can you tell what I need to add a subwoofer & yes I know it doesn’t need one?! Lol
take a look at teufel stereo m: very interesting active speakers. I have them and they sound pretty nice
Brother can you compare edifier s1000db and f&d r60bt. The later is a replica of the former I reckon. Both are available in India with price ratio of 3:1. Almost same specs. I just want to make sure, will both perform the same.
Hi sir, I have followed your video for quite a while already.
I am looking at Edifier range of model. I'm torn between the s2000pro, s3000pro, a100 and a300.
Would you be able to recommend me which model would be good for music listening, and home movies?
Definitely the best review video I've seen on speakers, love how you get to hear the different music types and compare them seemlessly. I was almost sold on the S2000, but now leaning towards the S3000; only issue is I listen to a lot of metal, and that was the only music style that the S2000 came across better in. I love the isolation of sounds and the imaging of the S3000, but i think based on music preferences the S2000 may be the right choice. Wondering how much impact a good EQ would have here...
I noticed exactly the same thing! S2000 seems to sound better on metal :(
Get the Airpulse A300. I have 3 other speakers from Edifier's S series. The A300 is my favorite so far. Not the most bass, but man do they give a completely different experience.
@@sleeper1023 what do you mean by different experience?
what is the Edifier S3000Pro max volume in decibels please. thinking of getting some
great music and comparison )
This deserves more likes 👍🏼
Night and day through my system. I need quality and I need simplicity. My mom came by and she really loved my sound system and she realized the impact it has on your experience when listening to music. The Edifier S3000Pro could be an excellent option for her since it has a good amount of features without being complex.
wow that in-room FR is incredible. Down to 30hz. Much better than most 5 inch monitors
I have s3000pro and i like its sound with good highs and great lows
hi, please a comparison between s2000 pro sis2000mkiii
No downgrade with bluetooth connection between them?
I jz bought myself an Edifier s2000mk2. Been searching high and low on google and dont really have any info. Is the s2000mk2 also known as s2000pro?
have S2000 pair and they are sometimes to bright to me... So I usually do +few dbs in low freq.
And S3000 seems to be multiple times brighter than s2000 :D Would lovely have something between 2000 and 3000. But 3000 are definitely OVERBRIGHT.
went for the 3000 Pro's 🤩 came today, enjoying some Bob Marley 🎼🎸🎶🎵🤗 👍
Are you happy with the speakers? I m also planing on buying a pair
S3000 pro by far , would have liked to find a place in my area to test the S3000 however none , ended up going with KEF LS50Wii
Can someone explain the use of these comparison? I'm pretty sure the 3000 is better than the 2000, but the 2000 sounds nothing like in this video. I know because I played the video on my 2000s.
Please make review on jbl arena 130 vs edifier s3000pro!
what is better for you?
So…is it worth the $400 premium to jump from the 2000-3000pro?
the s3000 is the same as the 2k wound wise, but with much wider soundstage
The S3000 is tuned like a V Curve of an eq. while the S2000 has flatter response curve and more forward midrange ,that is why it sounds better on metal. Though the S2000 struggles on low bass while the S3000 is cleaner and tighter on low notes. I am now wondering if this 2 edifiers can compete with a pair of good passive bookshelfs on a good integrated amplifier at the same price point.
In this video the s3000pro is in the classic mode which boosts the treble.
It is flat in monitor mode.
Listening to this with my etymotic er4xr its obvious that the s3000pro has way more air. Its as if a veil is lifted when switching from the 2000s. I think it sounds even better then the original. Maybe a tad sibilant sometimes but then i just dial down the treble by 2 db or so. You are using the monitor preset on both right?
Because they both switch back to classic every time you change input or turn it of. I own the 3000s and the classic preset has a bit more treble then monitor.
I also have the s3000 pro and I didn't know that switch to classic everytime I change the input. Thanks!
@@fontsRealisticSliders-fifa I wish there was a way to keep the setting. I like the vocal mode best at the moment with -2 db treble on the dial. Another thing you might not know is you can hold the bluetooth button on the remote until it flashes once and it disconnects the device so you can connect to another.
@@gullibleskeptic3237
I also like it with -2 or -3 db treble. But I normally use Dynamic. I will test in Vocal too. Thanks
The difference are minimal. Maybe it's possible to obtain the same curve with a simple equalization.
The s2000 almost sound more full where the s3000 sound thinner and brighter. I'm thinking the s3000 is in some mode that isn't helping it on some tracks. The mids sound reserve and the highs over powered. The s2000 sounds of muddy bass.
I don't think from this review I'll be changing out anything I have. I got the same feeling about the s3000 watching z review that the highs could easily become fatiguing. But when listening to the swans m300 the m300 sounded too reserved and bass heavy and the s3000pro sounded too many highs.
Highs on S3000Pro is more bright and pronounced. IMO only
Could I use the s3000pro as nearfield speakers to use with my pc for listening to music and gaming there? or should I rather buy some adam T5v for that purpose?
S3000 would be overkill for a desk setup. The T5v would be much better.
Disagrre. T5V is no less bulky on desk than S3000Pro, and has deeper box wich means you actually need more space in some cases. Plus S3000Pro is better on every level, including build and sound quality.
@@DSAUDIOreview my bad....
@@DSAUDIOreview Have you thought about reviewing the Swan M300s?
Yep, I thought about it. No plans for testing any time soon though
Wow! S3000Pro is cool!
prefer s2000pro. How is s3000pro an improvement over its predecessor?
finally!
please add edifier r1100
I own a pair of S2000Pro, the electronics inside are inferior to the S3000Pro which has a better woofer as well, no only the bass extension and also gives a fuller mid-bass.
A slight dip and then flatten at the high frequencies is designed to sound closer to a set of Hi_Fi speakers. This comment is applicable to S2000Pro. That's why I bought a pair but the electronics are a little disappointing but for the money I paid is OK. My pair of 2-way passive spkrs sounds much cleaner and has better clarity maybe because I have better electronics that drive these spkrs.
I have both the S2000pro and the S3000pro and this video is quite misleading.... here they sound pretty similar, and although the s2000pro are lovely sounding speakers, in real life the s3000pro is miles ahead, and are MUCH BETTER sounding speakers.
What do you mean similiar? The s2000Pro and S3000Pro in this video sound totally different with the S2000Pro sounding much warmer while the S3000Pro sounds sharper & thinner.
The S2000MKIII and S3000Pro sound extremely similiar (check this channel's test of them) but the S2000Pro sounds very different.
Was this in Vocal, monitor or dynamic mode?
natnut2008 that really matters cause for metal in vocal mode wouldn’t sound as good at minister or dynamic
both sound good on my $129 blaupunkt party speaker
S3000 sounds like the singer is live in front of you.
To be honest I don't see the difference of almost double the price... The s2000 sounds very nice, and on some songs sounded better
Night and day
My ears can prefer s2000 for long hours
A wszyscy wciąż czekają na Solo 7c ;) Takie porównanie z 6c, 2600 i 2730 to bym sobie obejrzał.
Ciekawe są jeszcze ESIO nEAR 05 Extreme, EVE Audio SC205, Prodipe Pro 5 V3, albo Adam Audio A5X.
Ogólnie to myślę że wszystkie te zintegrowane aktywne kolumny mają sztuczne wysokie.Moje Edifier R2000DB tak samo i dla Audiofila liczy się wzmacniacz zewn i nawet też w tej cenie monitory pasywne.To gra zupełnie inaczej. P.s R2000db są tak ciemne na średnicy i wyżej że bez korektora nie da się słuchać 😠
Wow what a difference.
To my ears via ATH AD2000X open back headphone:
Ahh! I have a set of S2000 but S3000 is the clear winner !
Deeper bass, better forward mids and overall better staging and clarity.
I know it is a bad comparison, but would you say it is better if I buy headphones (ad1000x~$400/2000x~$600) or speakers(s880~$250/s2000pro~$350)? Cause I always hear people say that at the same price range, speakers are better bang for the buck.
@@gotzilraaa7028Ahh, that's a classic headphone vs speaker scenario like the debate of apple Vs orange. Both are fruits that tastes good but very different.
Speaker:
Is there an intention to share your music listening experience with others at the same time? Like chilling lounging with friends together over some coffee or wine? Or simple movie watching with a buddy? To experience a true spatial stereo audio experience in the space of your living room and feel the vastness of the performance as the sound of applause comes to life.
Headphones:
Do you enjoy a personal one-person audio experience whereby the music is playable as loud as you want, whenever you want? Allowing your ears to pick up new audio details which in turns transforms the spatial musical experience only for you ? To hear the deepness of the bass and crispy sparks of high while being mesmerized by the mid vocals? Being yet so close to your ears, but yet feels so far?
Bearing in mind, a high end headphones like that of AD1000x/AD2000x would performs much much better with a good headphone amplifier or a dac-amplifier. If budget is of a constrain go with Audio Techinica MSR7, to my ears one of the best bang for the buck headphone.
If spatial musical sharing is your preference go with Edifier S2000 or S3000.
Either one both are great for musical enjoyments, just make sure you find the time to listen and relax. Many people buy high end gadgets (headphone or speakers) but they don't allocate time to enjoy, which is then a waste of money.
Fives vs s3000pro please
Not a good test as the S3000 Pro sounds so small. Not properly tuned.
Edi S3000 has a 6.5" driver and the S2000 has a 5.5" driver. The S3000 has a better tweeter and is more attractive looking. In Canada the S3000 -$1040CAD and the S2000- $500CAD. If you are on a budget then the S3000 is more than double price. There are many other powered speakers available at that price point. The powered speaker market is getting really competitive, however i believe the S3000's are overpriced.
when I heard the s1000 vs s2000 I was all for the s1000. Now I am leaning towards s3000. I would love a vs between s1000 and s3000 😁
We need a triple comparisson video.
Yeah in fact I was in the market a couple of years ago and his review of the s1000 vs s2000 made me lean towards the s1000 as they were cheaper at the time, but also I liked how they sounded better. I'm in love with the s1000 but I miss a bit of response on the low end, so I'm thinking about pairing them with a subwoofer, or maybe sell them and get the s3000.
But after watching this review I'm not that much impressed, I would like to see them against Klipsch's The Sixes, which are are about the same price, and I remember they totally destroyed the s1000.
S3000 is IT! The original track is great as well.
What do you mean original track is great
s3000 настолько крутые, что звучат лучше чем оригинал:))
S3000pro or the Airpulse A100s? Which is better?
There will be a comparison soon, but for now I will say A100 is still my favourite at this price point ;)
@@DSAUDIOreview thank you! These videos are great. I bought the r2000db for my bedroom because of your comparisons and will be using your videos as reference for my living room speakers (a100, S3000pro, or swans m300). Again thanks!
@@stevenjiang1423 All those three are excellent speakers, can't go wrong with either :)
s3000pro vs r2000db, please.
Yes im also please.
I had both in my house. Obviously the s3000 pro is better (punchy bass, defined treble, great soundstage...) but the r2000db is amazing for his price.
S3000pro vs a200, please.
Nubert nuPro a-200?
Crystal clear sound of S3000 Pro is just boosted treble and it invariably sounded less like the original.
what??
@@pedecia In my opinion S3000 = t o o b r i g h t
That's what.
@@KeenAesthetic1 you can adjust the treble with the apposite knob or with the use of a small equalizer but the power of the 3000 speakers is insane and also the woofer size allow a very good bass extension. Being speakers without a sub output the 3000 would be the only one I would purchase as a sub cannot be added. 💪
@@pedecia I'm just saying what I heard, its possible you could dial the s3000 to sound more natural
I suspect the recording doesn't reveal all. I listened to this on the S2000 Pro speakers. And the S2000 Pro in the video sounds much more anemic compared to the "original recording" while playing the video back on my S2000 Pro speakers. The S3000 Pro sounds much clearer and fuller. Hearing them in person I'd bet there's even more detail there.
Dont care about price, which one is better please
S3000PRO
If s3000 pro had boobs I would lick whip cream off of them on national television
rhe s3000 is better but not twice as good, and is does cost almost double than the s2000. So the 2000 gets the vote for value
I definitely like response graph of s2000 better. My ears pick up that high treble of s3000 and was fatigue my ears. Cool, I no have to buy new speaker. Good 😅👍
Indeed painfully sharp sounding. It's like a lack of mids is overcompensated with high amount of sharp treble at the S3000's
These or the Fives and why?
There're reasons why Edifier S3000Pro is more expensive
Thx. Finally.
Who win? I have the s2000pro, I think the s3000pro win but not by big margin. What do you think? Should I need to regret not buying the s3000 instead of s2000 ?!!!
2000 sounds way closer to the original track.
S3000Pro is better, but S2000Pro is still solid so no reason to feel bad for your choice IMO ;)
S2000 sounds super "compressed". highs are terrible, seems like a big margin to me.
Digital Stereophony thx. Logic for s3000pro to be better, if it was 100$ difference I would regret, but it is double the price and i used them for my PC, i am not a audiophile with pro sound system. S2000pro is perfect for me.
Higher price for a reason, if you compare s3000pro to a 2000$ speakers they will sound bad, relativity
the 3000 are just the 2000 with the treble control on the 12:15 position; listening through TH-cam neither sounds particularly enticing
1:46 like when you close window
Honza Marek i felt that too
Wurzelbert84 I just receive them and must agree with you, they sometimes sounds too bright
S3000 слишком дохера верхов, далеко от оригинала, как будто нч динамик меньше за вч, либо вч накрутили на полную..
Edifier S3000Pro стоит своих денег ?,или лучше что то есть на рынке?
стоит. но 2000 натуральнее. 2000 с дополнительным сабом = идеальный звук.
А по-моему так дешевле и круче по звуку будет купить JBL lsr305 первого издания.
@@frozenspy тоже над ними думаю,но фонят говорят они
@@frozenspy 305 не то, чтобы говнище, но говницо. Они безбожно красят СЧ. Смотрим сравнение с iLoud - всё сразу видно.
I love edifier i own several of their products but here im sorry to say i didnt like any if them.
Why does Edifier S2000Pro sound boxy when comapred to Edifier S3000Pro ? It also sounds boxy when compared to Swans M200 MKIII. Watching various comparisions I feel like Edifier S1000DB has similar sound signature to S3000Pro, just with less depth and less detail of S3000Pro. Looks like S2000Pro was a mistake from Edifier, thats why the latest S2000MKIII has design changes and now looks similar to S3000Pro.
I would rate Edifier S3000Pro > Swans M200 MKIII > Edifier S1000db. I wouldn't even bother considering S2000Pro, its boxy sound and its trebles just put me off.
3000 sounds noticeably better
The 2000's have a much more detailed, almost British sound -- but it seems like it would get fatiguing after a fairly short interval. Like the difference between a pair of Linn Katans and, say, a pair of Ohm or B&W monitors of the same price-point. And I definitely hear the cabinets more with the 2000s.
Just Look at Frequency Response. you so wrong!
S2000 PRO the best
3000 more base punch
s3000 has way to much treble, just look at 10khz. Perfect in room response should be a 10db downard slope from 20hz to 20khz. S2000 sound more realistic even through my phone speaker. Easy to fool people these days by raising treble so that it seems like more detail and also putting shiny hi-res sticker.
Ron, what do you think about Airpulse A300 vs s3000Pro?
It all sounds like crap on my phone speaker.
I'm listening this on S3000 pro, so would that makes me listening to SS6000 pro pro? 🤣
)))))))))))
no just s3000^2
Can you recommend ? :)) thank you
@@pavelseifert8233 Yes definitely, I got these when it went discount at my country, i would say they are worth it, it might not be as good as those High End Bookshelf, but for the price, i think it's one of the best
@@JasperLTZ what was your price in discount ? In my country S3000pro are available only in one shop and the price is like whole one month sallary :D Big thank you for your responses :)
Ouch! Of course the S3000pro ate them, easily.
750 euros?! No thanks :(
Both sound artificial...urgh
Not very impressed with both, while at least S3000 is ok. Both need a sub, but S3000 could do without.
I love my S3000 pro's, wish my missus would go out a bit more so I could listen to them more often🙂
Mate , I’ve the same problem , as soon as the wife leaves the house I crank these babies up . The neighbours joke about it and are glad when she comes back .
@@glenn1826 luckily I live in a detached house so my neighbors aren't an issue but I do love to crank them right up. And I've got some decent headphones for when the missus gets back. I use the speakers as my television sound as well so they do get a lot of use, love them