I tell my kids, "Say it once. When you say it 21 times it goes from being a command to being optional." And then they ignore me and tell the dog to sit 10 more times as she walks away.
Trying to teach my gf the same thing with our rescue pit. When we walk together, he looks to me for command even though she is holding the leash. I’m teaching her to be patient and confident but it’s her first time so it’s going to be a process for both of them.
The doorway method has transformed our walk - we also use it before going out the gate or going upstairs at night - we don’t have to say anything now - she just knows what to do. Even if she is all excited about the walk before hand once we’re at the door and follow procedure it’s instant calm down. Brilliant
I did wonder about the seemingly contradicting okays ques. But I was raised to follow directions, so I just did it, and it works. I am so glad you explained this. Now I know why it works, and I can see the success more clearly, from more than one angle or perspective. This overflows into so many other areas of my dogs interactions with me..You are brilliant. I wouldn't still have this street rescue dog if I hadn't found and followed your channel. Thank you for making my life so much easier.
I give the Okay command and he follows me 🤣 It’s our release word but he doesn’t run off, he sticks close. I don’t know how, or even if, I trained that 🤣 I’ve used your doorway method. He cannot just be allowed to run out an open door. It’s something we have worked on every single time the door is open and every time we are about to leave to go for a walk, consistently since we’ve had him (1/15/22). Even if it’s not perfect quite yet, he’s damn good. I give him the okay for sniffing around on the leash, instead of having to stay in the heel, like he is expected to during the rest of our walk. He understands the difference of what that Okay means when that leash is on. I’m pretty amazed. Dogs are brilliant.
@@TheHALLOOON He’s already 7 months old now and I plan on being consistent for the longterm. I’m not too worried. Although I know he’s going to inevitably go through the jerk rebellion stage around that time. No one escapes it 🤣
@@TheHALLOOON My dog is almost 10 months now. And we started using Joel's methods at day one. He actually is so well behaved now we are a little blown away. Not sure how these simple things work, but we're glad they do! Consistency is definitely key.
I agree with the doorway exit starts the tone of the walk.MY dog realizes when we walk that the correction comes from the leash ,not from me.It was very hard for me to shut up on our walks,but it helped a lot.
Yes it does in fact make sense. And what a beautiful dog! Yesterday I saw a puppy walking with someone on a leash. As they crossed the street then continued down the sidewalk it was totally aware of where the owner was. I was like Wow! They have been training with Beckmann !
My Golden was very laid back. Perhaps he was smart too. But ‘OK’ with him resulted in different behaviors. When I had thrown a retrieval toy and said it, full speed ahead. If I had just finished wiping his feet down after a walk while in the entrance way, it resulted in him slowly sauntering away. If he was going off leash, really a release from walking off leash beside me, it might be a happy trot. On a trail it could mean running ahead 30m or so. He looked at the situation and knew what was expected of him.
I love your channel and it has helped me control my walk with my older lab mix. He's improved a lot after the first 3 walks! Your method is the best for us! Thank you!
I cannot begin to tell you just how much our using the leash reactivity method has helped! There is no more pulling, lunging or barking at other dogs. You truly are an amazing trainer and person. I was skeptical in the beginning, having a small dog, I think we were uncertain about "be the boss", However, since we have been using your method, everything has changed. She looks to us before going outside, walking on a leash is now a pleasure, and not oh noooo, what is around the corner????? Thanks so much for your many informative videos and info. I learn something new with each video.
What verbal sounds do you have if you want your dog to go left / right or behind you down some snowy slippery stairs? Hand gestures/body language only work if the dog looks at you.
That makes so much sense. I use the same word, going out the door, release from heel and run free when I remove the lead at dog park. My dog knows OK. Five star explanation, many thanks 🙏🏻 🥰
I agree! My release cue is free but I use the same cue anytime there is a release at home, on walks, or at a dog park. It’s really just building consistency and better understanding for the dog. Love this gorgeous poodle!! 🌺✨
Joel now you have to show a video of this dog running. She is absolutely beautiful. Love how post April fools you put out a "talking video" but it's talking about real techniques that work. Got to go check out the Zak George video so I'll be ready for your take on it!
Thank you for addressing this matter, Joel -- Verbal cues and the human talking to the dog: I have been thinking about this a lot -- people talk to, or rant at, their dogs too much. Ex: 9-month-old pup has just grabbed some foul thing off the ground. Instead of giving two leash pops, or just saying: "uh-uh!" or "leave it !" The human says: "Hey! Drop that! I saaaiiid, *Drop that !* What are you doing !? That's disgusting ! How many times have I told you not to eat stuff off the ground ?! I can't believe how bone-headed you are ! WTF ! I can't *deal* with this ! " (Two minutes later, still ranting) "What is *wrong* with you?! Don't pick up stuff off the ground ! Ever !" . . . .
Awww I wanted to see her run. But thanks for the distinctions between leash and "ok." I picked this up, don't let my dog rocket off as soon as the leash is off. thanks.
Yes it works to have them think before the leash release. The dash off at “100 miles and out of their mind” so true. I see the light. I found I can call them back to me much better.
Re: Letting them go to the tree. When my dog was off leash beside me, he went where I indicated. He’d noticed me slow down, notice som3 pole or tree coming up and watch for some wave of my hand or turn of my body. There would be something really attractive to him occasionally but I’d sense him just as he would me. If I didn’t agree I’d ‘PSST’ him and he’d fall in step. Miss him every day.
You had a great relationship with your dog, It’s beautiful when your dog knows your body language, PSST saves a lot of useless talking. My furry baby didn’t have to be told twice, nor did I not notice what she wanted. ❤️
@@mariethompson7701 Exactly! I’ve got a new Golden pup. It can be frustrating at times, going from a dog that knew the ropes to one that is more interested in seeing if he said ropes are edible.
Your methods were really helpful with reducing my 1 year old gsd’s reactivity issues. One problem i still have and dont know how to fix is the fact that crossing the road throws him off. He always sits when were about to cross the road, and he even waits for me to start crossing it before releasing himself, but once were at the point of no return he just sprints like crazy and i cant correct him because were in the middle of the road.
Incorporating this idealogy starting tomorrow. My teenage dog (10mo) only listens to grass recently(everything smells so nice) and it's been very frustrating. I don't allow him to pull on leash because pulling means stopping and he doesn't like that. I think teaching him to only smells things when allowed may help my biggest frustrating. Hopefully also help with the pulling to go to others dogs as well.
I totally get what you’re saying, but I can see why people might get confused. I use “let’s go”, meaning controlled forward movement on leash….not necessarily a perfect heel, but loose leash. I also love the command “wait”….meaning “ hold on a sec”. My dogs always seemed to understand that fairly quickly. I use ok for release, but I do like what you’re saying about ok ON LEASH does NOT mean behave like an ass, do whatever you want
It might be cool to get prior clients like Charlie, Ava, Oso, Cooper, Luke, etc owners to send u 15-90sec follow-up vid (pay them $100?) even just playing with their respective families just as a fun dog-lover continuity thing. 🐾❤️
Hi Joel 👋 Absolutely correct!! I volunteer at an animal shelter and that’s the method we need to use when taking dogs out of the kennel for their walks as well. Reduce arousal and jumping when exiting, opening and closing the kennel door, waiting for ME to say ok. It’s hard for these poor dogs because they’re anxious to get out to go potty (if they’re potty trained), but if the dog is known to be hyperactive and leash reactive and a puller, a couple of minutes of this routine can help a lot. Same as on a walk- they pull, all forward movement stops and I become a tree. As soon as there’s slack in the leash, we move. Do you agree? Any other suggestions for walking shelter dogs is appreciated 🙏💜
Might be good to say, "This is a vid for ppl who hv watched a bunch of my vids already" and then explain simply "The leash supercedes any command." Showing Vivian loose-leash walking & u teased us about how she runs!! That all said, I adore ur channel & ur methods for ppl-reactive dogs hv turned my street-rescue pitbull into what my neighbors now call a "love junkie." 🐾❤️
Please do a video on how to help me train my English Bulldog puppy Humphrey (5 months old) to not "hunker down", or anchor as I call it, when on walks. It's not about the smelling pee on a tree and things, and just the stubborness. BUT maybe that's just a thing that I need to live with for this breed? He's my first bulldog, my last 4 dogs were European Dobe's (Brutus/Neo/Apollo/Kojack). So serious shoutout to Prince and Bosco. This is an extreme shift of gears for me. :)
My dog pulls like crazy but from what I remember you saying, I shouldn't expect him to heel until he's 8 or 9 months old. He's 6 months old now and 70 lbs. I'm going to get a gentle leader because the chest point harness only helps to not have my arm ripped off. I was using the E collar with the beep and vibration until you said that isn't a good thing to use. So what do you recommend I do for the next 2 or 3 months until he's out of full on puppy mode?
Gorgeous dog! So Joel, what type of collar do you recommend? I use martingales on my rescue dogs but I'm thinking I may have to use a different kind during training or is a martingale ok for training?
Vivian is my name also…lol. I like Joel’s method but need to know how long do u have to do the pop and stop do they eventually get it and another topic if dog on gentle leader how do you transition to collar
I have always used verbal abd hand signals to train my dogs off lease on leash i use a slight tug to get my current dogs to get his attention . I do like the hunker'n down ill try it. Bubba is a rescue abused i had to change my methods because of the abuse
I see way too many humans over communicating with Verbal and Eye contact without clear consistent communication, leaving the dog lost in translation. At a young age the dog will surely learn how to ignore these ques and eventually they will end up at your facility or inquiring me here in the city! Great video, Joel.
My dog is hyperactive and he is reactive frenchie. When going to dog park, I give him cue to stay but when I release him he fly 100 mile like you said and no recall at all. I tried to keep him calm but failed. I want to watch you full training, you do have them available in any platforms. I wish you’re in Australia so I could take my dog to you to train. Can you please recommend any trainer who specialises in reactive dog in Australia? I’ m based in Brisbane.
I've been taught I should give the dog a certain degree of freedom to smell around while on a walk without telling him when he can do it, would it be better to actually decide myself whether he can or not? Thinking about it, it might help with his walking in front of me most of the times but wouldn't it kinda cancel the distinction between walking and working? And about the vocal cue, they told me it should come either a fraction earlier or alongside the correction, is that a no go as well? Or it just doesn't work with my dog specifically and should try something else? Eventually he slows down and walks alongside me, but it's a struggle every day with those initial 5 minutes of corrections.
Hi, i use ok for everything also as comand after i placed the bowl with the food on the floor, am i doing it right or should i change the keyword? Would "OK" for you can go to smell the pee or the other dog would put him in an excited mode because he associates that word with the fact that he can get to the food? I live in Italy and i refuse to pay a positive reinforcing trainer as it's useless and it only got worse. The other kind of trainers here they seem to be hiding as they're covered with shame. Suggestions are wellcome, thank's.
I always laugh a little when I catch people speaking full sentences to their dogs. I understand. Giving sounds, single words, or short phrases sounds rude…there’s no please or thank you. Only “good dog”. The dog isn’t hurt by this.
It's fine to speak full sentences. They learn the language in time too. It builds relationship, even if they don't understand what you're saying, they feel included. And it's therapeutic for people. So it has a place, but not when you want them to act on it. Do it when you're sitting on the couch, when you see stuff coming by.
@@Flippokid If a car is coming when I want to cross the road, I tell my dog "Wait until the car goes by and then you can cross." When the car drives past, he crosses without me saying or doing anything. They can understand full sentences.
@@JoeR203 Eventually, and when they're paying attention to you. Not when they're focused on that other dog. The waiting till car goes by is also conditioned. Try not saying it, and not crossing when that car has passed. Your dog will cross the street if you're turned like you're gonna cross.
@@JoeR203 By the way they listen in on your conversations too. Me and my friend were making plans that involved his dog (for the first time I think, maybe the second) joining in my car on the way home. ("You take Gabber and then I take the stuff," he said) This was in the afternoon. He never jumped in my car before, even with my dogs jumping in and the doors being open. That night he jumped right in before we said anything.
Wanted 2 share a incident with u joel and would your advice. 3 weeks ago i was given a Pitbull rescue (3yr-neutered-Male) his obidience training was extensive but still very dog reactive based on distance. We were on a training walk and another owner was playing fetch with a Pitt Mastiff twice as big as my texas Red Nose / American Bully! As soon as he saw he made a bee-line for the schoolfield fence gateway, never takeing his eyes off of Ozzy! The lady there called his name 4 time b4 he stopped a few feet from the sidewalk. & was able to grab his harness. 😆 Ozzy stayed chill the whole time! Maintaining Heel right beside my hip😀. Ya kno there is a shit-ton of dog trainers on TH-cam who claim their the mesiah of dog training😕. You were the only one whos actions spoke louder than your words. Thank u 4 being so straight-up Sir.👌. Much luv from Canada eh.😊 btw Pepper spray is illegal in Canada. What would u recommend to stop two Pitbulls once the fight has started. Because that lady wouldn't b strong enough! Im 6ft 200lbs an im not sure id b strong enough 2 stop two raging pittys. Ive since changed the route for the afternoon 2km. But any insite u might have to help defend Ozzy & I from irresponsible power-breed owners/dogs, woild be very welcome eh
I would like to know this too. Also, some dogs (my pitt is one of them) is terrified of sprays of water from a spray bottle. It works for her but if someone else’s dog would not stop attacking, it would not help us then so I’m interested in other ideas.
A 'Doggie Don't' sound device that I bought on Amazon saved my dog from being attacked. I saw the free dog coming so got it ready from the open front pocket I always keep it in. Had it in my hand and gave the dog a verbal warning first, then used it. Of course it also scared my dog and I had to calm him down too, but the aggressor sprinted off back to his house like I'd actually zapped him with lightning. (My very nervous ex street dog calmed after about a minute of me petting him and him realizing the sound wasn't coming again. He also very quickly understood that I'd saved him and trotted along with his tail up for the remainder of the walk.) Please note that you still have to have a swivel head looking out for trouble, and be able to have the device ready. In particularly sketchy places or if a dog is coming (even on leash) that I am worried about and we can't avoid, I keep the device either in my hand ready or at least looped over my wrist on its strap. If you give an aggressor the benefit of the doubt and don't have the device in your hand, you won't have time to use it. It is only sound so you have to activate it as soon as you know the dog isn't going to back off. I would guess for a super aggressive dog, sound alone wouldn't reach their crazy brain if they'd already gone too far. I probably would also warn an owner and very clearly point it before pressing so the owner had another chance to do something. It is just sound but a nasty owner would freak out I guess. In the case above, the dog was about 100m from his house, free as a bird.
I have to say, considering your dog's feelings is important. A bright and happy tone can lighten a dog's mood dramatically. I agree too many people assume their dog can understand language and yabber on and on to them. But conversely, an owner that doesn't acknowledge that a dog that is given positive feedback is a happy, relaxed and attentive animal is missing the importance of forming a relationship with the dog. It has to be guardian/ward relationship though, not child/parent. The subtle difference being that parents too easily loose the boundary between them and their child. A guardian is beholden to society to care for and school their ward. Take pride in and respect your dog, try to understand you are his whole world and he will do anything for you IF he feels he can rely on you and is safe in your presence.
I had to go to a metal chain leash because the fabric leashes were "tug toys." She is CRAZY out of her mind all the time. She will stand on two hind legs and scream when she sees another dog. She lives to play with other dogs. I rescued her at 14 months now she's 2. Husky /cattle dog mix super high energy and 100% crazy. I'm trying your methods but it is taking a long time which is ok, I have a lot of patience but I would welcome any other suggestions for my Crazy Girl. Thanks.
Hey Joel, I have an offtopic question for you... could you make a response video/comment on Zak's recent video? Video: "This Has to Be Said. What I Actually Think About So-Called “Balanced Dog Training” Would be nice to know what you have to say and your side on why you deal with the situations he exemplified in the video, in the way that you do, with some forms of 'punishment-based' corrections instead of going the positive reinforcement route as he showed.
Well I just watched it. I think Joel kind of addressed this already in a video plus, the April Fools video pretty much said what he thinks of purely positive. Zak George is a better trainer than most of us will ever be, but it's Joel Beckman that helped me understand how to get fantastic fast results with very large angry rescue dogs. Put it this way, I got no results from watching Victoria Stillwell or Zak George. The only other trainer I found that uses the same methods as Joel is called "The Dog Daddy" who is awesome.
@@KerriEverlasting same for me, when I first began watching dog training videos, I tried watching Victoria Stilwell and couldn’t see much training going on, but there was a lot of drama (and comments) about the owners, which I didn’t feel was related to training and some were so awful 😞 . It also lost me when a couple couldn’t get their dog to stop jumping on the bed so she put side rails on their bed. I watched a middle aged couple climbing into their bed from the bottom and thought, “really?”. Watching Joel has helped me so much.
If you watch a lot of his videos you get the idea of what he's doing and how to correct them, so if you keep watching them you should get the hang of it. Not sure if he has one exactly like that, but i know a lot of his videos have dogs who try to fight the leash which is basically the same thing as your dogs problem. I'm no expert, but ive had several dogs myself and recommend doing simple things everyday like making your dog sit and stay before he eats his food. Stuff that makes him obey you more in general, even if its simple. I'm guessing he doesn't respect your correction because he thinks he is alpha, or at least he doesn't respect you enough, or he is just a tough dog. I once walked a dog like that, his owner kind of spoiled him in some ways so when I did any corrections that he didn't like he would sometimes snarl because he wanted to get his way as he is used to. So just don't spoil your dog (if you spoil your dog). What you say goes. If you ever say a command, such as come, or get down from the couch, ALWAYS make him do it. A lot of problems come from owners who aren't consistent with their dogs. And it's a lot of help practicing being consistent like this with small stuff, so when you face something a bit more serious he will be more ready. He will see you as the boss, who doesn't let bad behavior slide. And i didn't invent these methods, I've heard many trainers including Joel talk about this stuff, so it is proven in the field.
Question ; Have you ever trained a dog to be aggressive ? I realize that question may be taboo but some of us do want working dogs. For example : personal protection or guard dog training. If you have I’d really appreciate the videos .
That isn't training aggression. Protection work is based off of prey drive and protective instincts, not aggression. You REALLY don't want an aggressive dog for protection because it's a loose cannon, and a liability. There are very specific characteristics that you need for protection work. If you're really serious about it, find a protection dog trainer near you, and ask them to help you pick a puppy out of a working line litter. You have to start them young so that they can be desensitized to EVERYTHING they might EVER encounter as an adult. You don't want a dog that is trained how to bite and latch to just lash out at a stranger because they think people wearing hats are scary. You'll want to work with a professional for about 2 years on average before your dog is "done". Once your dog is done you will need to do refresher training sessions on occasion so that they don't get rusty. You can't do this kind of training without help. You need training assistants to wear the bite suits and offer different stimulus and distractions to test your dog. It's a huge commitment. There is a reason why fully trained protection dogs cost +$40k
Binge-watch Joel’s videos. There is more information and other training than just what the title says. He does talk about sniffing/smelling while taking walks. So, look for the Loose Leash Walking videos; it, and a lot more, will all come together. Remember, you are doing the training, so you have to put the time and effort in. Cutting corners or going on a walk before your dog graduates from each step of the method will not work. In his videos, especially the earlier LLW ones, you’ll hear him say, “I’ll do this all day,” which he would do if needed. Also, reading the comments helped new too. Enjoy! 🌟
@@Washcloth_Peddler, also watch all the Doorway Method videos. You can do all of it. I know you can. He has helped so many people with their dogs. Watch the video titled “Get to know me and my.....(I can't remember the last part of the title.) I watched the videos about him as a person and a trainer first, so I got to know more about him. But, I'll tell you what, what we see is the real him. He hides nothing. He can be a bit hard nose, but he has to be sometimes. Reading the comments on his videos is so insightful and funny many times. His clients, after a videotaped session with Joel, will sometimes get on the comment page of the video that was their dog, and people would ask them questions about their dog or Joel. That reminds me, watch the videos titled something like “This is not the channel to blame the dog owners or something like that. It was good. Good luck.
I'm using the leash pulling technique, it is working but today my dog's collar broke while we were on walk and as soon as he realised that he ran off towards a street dog to fight completely ignoring my calls. I don't know how to deal with this, it's becoming frustrating.
Joel A referral of mine by the name of Pat Bella’s Melzer feels like she’s getting the push off but she would like to have you train her dog. She has called 3 times.
Is OK the only release cue you ever use? It always means release but watch out because I might be faking you out like the trick fake taking off the leash? I have always used OK when I let my dogs eat their food. They have to wait for that to eat. I had a trainer use "you're through" and I think I still use that sometimes. Have I heard you say, "you're free?" Great videos.
@@dbk7591 Yes, binge-watch as many of his videos as you can. It will all come together. It's hard just to watch a couple of them and not have tons of questions. All of your questions most probably will be answered in other videos. He can't answer all the comment questions that are asked. Though he might answer your particular question in a video coming up because he does try and read the comments. That would be his way of answering you.
today was the first time in a long time that my dog ignored my verbal cue to not go towards to this couple😒 He is pretty good at obeying, but today, not so much!
Funnily enough I was wondering about the same use of the word ok. Commenting before watching the video, but I assume is to give the dog choice and context.
Joel, How do I separate or manage between when I allow my dog to sniff and pee and when she should walk by my side? She wants to constantly hunker down and smell (like 6 ft away) as we are in the city and 6 feet in any direction left or right is where all the dogs in the hood are peeing. How often do I alternate with giving her the opportunity to smell and potty and then walk by side? I always feel like obligated to constantly let her sniff. Am i wrong?
You're wrong then yeah. You decide when she's able to sniff around and go potty! Start with every 6 blocks maybe if it makes you feel better. The dog doesn't need to be so sniffy on walks. That makes them in charge and distracted from the goal. Loose leash walking.
@@SilentSaver Hi Thanks so much for replying. Really appreciate it. There is a lot of training information out there so it’s confusing as different trainers have various instructions - like the walk is for the dog not the owner. I have read that allowing them to sniff in many ways makes them less reactive in a way. However my dog is very SNIFFY. She’s pulls to sniff and very scent driven. She’s small (12lbs) so I feel badly pulling her to me although now I have switched her to a front harness. You are right …she is basically in control of the walk which is not the way it should be. Interesting, my do walker and my boyfriend do not have this issue. Could it be she knows she can take advantage of me? LOL
It definitely could be! I'm no trainer but I believe he has mentioned giving them an appropriate time to sniff and go potty! Otherwise the walk should be a nice, loose leash experience for both! My GSD is very sniffy and was the same exact way. Pulled to sniff everything. But I went for the pop it and "leave it" command and gave her appropriate sniffing breaks and potty breaks and she's moving along nicely. I hope you and your pup can make it to a nice walking experience! Much love!
Oh boy, I've been letting him pull towards other dogs or letting him have a sniff party or bite the heck of the sticks for half a year now. Anyone could fill me if I were to start restrict him now, will my dog dislike walking with me? My boy is 10mth old golden retriever who loves to greet almost every dog during our walk. However, when it comes to dog park, he doesn't enjoy like he used to (less than 5 mins, and I can sense that he wants to leave) so I normally bring him out for a sniff safari around the park instead. What I've been doing with the leash is, the second he pulls, I'll stand still like a lamppost. He'll walk back to me but never to a heel position. He always likes to be in front, and only when he is unsure of sth ahead, he'll look at me or come to stand beside. I never pet him nor do anything, jt continue walking like it's not a big deal.
My 4 month old doberman puppy obeys so well at home, but at the dog park, she's like... "nah." At the dog park, about a third of the time she will come to me or at least think about it; she is so overly excited everytime we go.... but her ignoring me, makes visiting the dog park stressful - especially when other dog owners are usually ignoring their dogs.
Most dogs don't listen in dog parks. She's a puppy and probably overstimulated. I stopped taking my dog to dog parks. Too many untrained and bullying dogs there that would attack my girl. It made her hyper-aware, nervous, and on the defensive, which is not what she needed to learn and not what I wanted to be done to her. It can make them reactive, and if it happens enough, it becomes learned behavior.
I just watched this video and the only thing I seem to have learned from it is, I'm very confused... no wonder I can't get my 100 lb. Pitbull to stop fricken pulling my 129 lb. self on our walks grrrr I'm that student sitting in the back of the class, trying not to be noticed, scratching my head and wondering how the heck the rest of the kids understood the lesson that was just given lol I think I'll go watch the video again and see if it helps. The part that is so confusing to me is the door/bush/other dog/tree thing. I know the concept is to use the same word, "okay," but... huh??? What other words would one use to let their dog know it was "okay" to do something? Did I miss something? Or am I just too naïve to comprehend? Arghhh I'm going back to watch it again now.
Hi Joel, I love your videos and they’ve helped me a lot. I was wondering though, what are your thoughts on a prong collar? I couldn’t find any videos of you with it in use or thought. Could you point me to one? I have no problems whatsoever walking our dog thanks entirely to you but my girlfriend always has. If we go out together then the dog is great, if she goes out with him then she always comes back with bruises or hurt due to the pulling. Hope you can read this comment and give me a piece of advice thanks!
He is against a prong and always advises people to use the gentle leader. It's like a horse halter except for dogs. It offers great control that your dog can't ignore and people are less likely to see you in public with one on and accuse you of animal abuse (there are a lot of crazy people out there who would do that)
He's against prong collars because they cause long term unpredictability in dogs behaviour. I tend to agree. The statement Joel makes "he has to EARN every meter you walk. If your dog is lunging and barking, what are you even doing there? If the dog isn't with you, the walk doesn't happen." Was THE single most important thing and completely negates any need for e collars or prong collars.
I love the prong! It helped soooo much with my GSD. Now I'm able to just use her collar but we used the prong for about 6 months! Really helped control her in regards to overly excited/stimulated. She can now walk by me and all I have to say is "ah ah" when she's to far ahead and she goes back into position! Very confident girl on her walks now.
Vivian is such a perfect name for that beauty. I can’t wait to see a video of her running!
I tell my kids, "Say it once. When you say it 21 times it goes from being a command to being optional."
And then they ignore me and tell the dog to sit 10 more times as she walks away.
The dog will learn to obey you, but not them.
@@sissyphussartre2907 Now if I could just get them to obey me, lol. And yes, when I say the command she does it.
Trying to teach my gf the same thing with our rescue pit. When we walk together, he looks to me for command even though she is holding the leash. I’m teaching her to be patient and confident but it’s her first time so it’s going to be a process for both of them.
@@84bonez that "Am I supposed to listen to her glance?" I know it well.
The doorway method has transformed our walk - we also use it before going out the gate or going upstairs at night - we don’t have to say anything now - she just knows what to do. Even if she is all excited about the walk before hand once we’re at the door and follow procedure it’s instant calm down. Brilliant
I agree, it has been life-changing. Even for getting in/out of the car. No more “flying”
I love the good student poodle paying attention to every word! hahhaha
I did wonder about the seemingly contradicting okays ques. But I was raised to follow directions, so I just did it, and it works. I am so glad you explained this. Now I know why it works, and I can see the success more clearly, from more than one angle or perspective. This overflows into so many other areas of my dogs interactions with me..You are brilliant. I wouldn't still have this street rescue dog if I hadn't found and followed your channel. Thank you for making my life so much easier.
I give the Okay command and he follows me 🤣 It’s our release word but he doesn’t run off, he sticks close. I don’t know how, or even if, I trained that 🤣 I’ve used your doorway method. He cannot just be allowed to run out an open door. It’s something we have worked on every single time the door is open and every time we are about to leave to go for a walk, consistently since we’ve had him (1/15/22). Even if it’s not perfect quite yet, he’s damn good. I give him the okay for sniffing around on the leash, instead of having to stay in the heel, like he is expected to during the rest of our walk. He understands the difference of what that Okay means when that leash is on. I’m pretty amazed. Dogs are brilliant.
Wait till he is 9 months. Good luck.
@@TheHALLOOON He’s already 7 months old now and I plan on being consistent for the longterm. I’m not too worried. Although I know he’s going to inevitably go through the jerk rebellion stage around that time. No one escapes it 🤣
@@TheHALLOOON My dog is almost 10 months now. And we started using Joel's methods at day one. He actually is so well behaved now we are a little blown away. Not sure how these simple things work, but we're glad they do! Consistency is definitely key.
She even nodded 😳 😍
I agree with the doorway exit starts the tone of the walk.MY dog realizes when we walk that the correction comes from the leash ,not from me.It was very hard for me to shut up on our walks,but it helped a lot.
Yes it does in fact make sense. And what a beautiful dog!
Yesterday I saw a puppy walking with someone on a leash. As they crossed the street then continued down the sidewalk it was totally aware of where the owner was. I was like Wow! They have been training with Beckmann !
Poodle
She's a standard poodle
Less Talk and More Communication! Brilliant Joel.
My Golden was very laid back. Perhaps he was smart too. But ‘OK’ with him resulted in different behaviors. When I had thrown a retrieval toy and said it, full speed ahead. If I had just finished wiping his feet down after a walk while in the entrance way, it resulted in him slowly sauntering away. If he was going off leash, really a release from walking off leash beside me, it might be a happy trot. On a trail it could mean running ahead 30m or so. He looked at the situation and knew what was expected of him.
I love your channel and it has helped me control my walk with my older lab mix. He's improved a lot after the first 3 walks! Your method is the best for us! Thank you!
I cannot begin to tell you just how much our using the leash reactivity method has helped! There is no more pulling, lunging or barking at other dogs. You truly are an amazing trainer and person. I was skeptical in the beginning, having a small dog, I think we were uncertain about "be the boss", However, since we have been using your method, everything has changed. She looks to us before going outside, walking on a leash is now a pleasure, and not oh noooo, what is around the corner????? Thanks so much for your many informative videos and info. I learn something new with each video.
A few weeks studying the works of Beckmans Dog Training and not a word of a lie, I swear an unsuspecting passer-by would mistake us for normals!! 😁😍
Well I agree with you 110%. I communicate with my dog with hand gestures/body language and verbal sounds /not words/ - 2-3 different verbal sounds.
What verbal sounds do you have if you want your dog to go left / right or behind you down some snowy slippery stairs? Hand gestures/body language only work if the dog looks at you.
@@hakan8997 😂😂
We need another video with this stunning silver standard poodle
That makes so much sense. I use the same word, going out the door, release from heel and run free when I remove the lead at dog park. My dog knows OK. Five star explanation, many thanks 🙏🏻 🥰
I agree! My release cue is free but I use the same cue anytime there is a release at home, on walks, or at a dog park. It’s really just building consistency and better understanding for the dog. Love this gorgeous poodle!! 🌺✨
Joel now you have to show a video of this dog running. She is absolutely beautiful. Love how post April fools you put out a "talking video" but it's talking about real techniques that work. Got to go check out the Zak George video so I'll be ready for your take on it!
Thank you for addressing this matter, Joel -- Verbal cues and the human talking to the dog: I have been thinking about this a lot -- people talk to, or rant at, their dogs too much. Ex: 9-month-old pup has just grabbed some foul thing off the ground. Instead of giving two leash pops, or just saying: "uh-uh!" or "leave it !" The human says: "Hey! Drop that! I saaaiiid, *Drop that !* What are you doing !? That's disgusting ! How many times have I told you not to eat stuff off the ground ?! I can't believe how bone-headed you are ! WTF ! I can't *deal* with this ! " (Two minutes later, still ranting) "What is *wrong* with you?! Don't pick up stuff off the ground ! Ever !" . . . .
Awww I wanted to see her run. But thanks for the distinctions between leash and "ok." I picked this up, don't let my dog rocket off as soon as the leash is off. thanks.
Yes it works to have them think before the leash release. The dash off at “100 miles and out of their mind” so true. I see the light. I found I can call them back to me much better.
Thank you for the reminder to avoid lots of verbal commands. I can struggle with that! 🙃
Re: Letting them go to the tree. When my dog was off leash beside me, he went where I indicated. He’d noticed me slow down, notice som3 pole or tree coming up and watch for some wave of my hand or turn of my body. There would be something really attractive to him occasionally but I’d sense him just as he would me. If I didn’t agree I’d ‘PSST’ him and he’d fall in step. Miss him every day.
You had a great relationship with your dog, It’s beautiful when your dog knows your body language, PSST saves a lot of useless talking. My furry baby didn’t have to be told twice, nor did I not notice what she wanted. ❤️
@@mariethompson7701
Exactly! I’ve got a new Golden pup. It can be frustrating at times, going from a dog that knew the ropes to one that is more interested in seeing if he said ropes are edible.
Fantastic information.
Your methods were really helpful with reducing my 1 year old gsd’s reactivity issues. One problem i still have and dont know how to fix is the fact that crossing the road throws him off. He always sits when were about to cross the road, and he even waits for me to start crossing it before releasing himself, but once were at the point of no return he just sprints like crazy and i cant correct him because were in the middle of the road.
Incorporating this idealogy starting tomorrow. My teenage dog (10mo) only listens to grass recently(everything smells so nice) and it's been very frustrating. I don't allow him to pull on leash because pulling means stopping and he doesn't like that. I think teaching him to only smells things when allowed may help my biggest frustrating. Hopefully also help with the pulling to go to others dogs as well.
Ah man! I wanna see Vivian run like the wind!
I totally get what you’re saying, but I can see why people might get confused. I use “let’s go”, meaning controlled forward movement on leash….not necessarily a perfect heel, but loose leash. I also love the command “wait”….meaning “ hold on a sec”. My dogs always seemed to understand that fairly quickly. I use ok for release, but I do like what you’re saying about ok ON LEASH does NOT mean behave like an ass, do whatever you want
It might be cool to get prior clients like Charlie, Ava, Oso, Cooper, Luke, etc owners to send u 15-90sec follow-up vid (pay them $100?) even just playing with their respective families just as a fun dog-lover continuity thing. 🐾❤️
Joel: I like how you explained using the word for all situations. Makes total sense.
Great advice 👍
Looking forward to seeing Vivian run :D
Hi Joel 👋 Absolutely correct!! I volunteer at an animal shelter and that’s the method we need to use when taking dogs out of the kennel for their walks as well. Reduce arousal and jumping when exiting, opening and closing the kennel door, waiting for ME to say ok. It’s hard for these poor dogs because they’re anxious to get out to go potty (if they’re potty trained), but if the dog is known to be hyperactive and leash reactive and a puller, a couple of minutes of this routine can help a lot. Same as on a walk- they pull, all forward movement stops and I become a tree. As soon as there’s slack in the leash, we move. Do you agree? Any other suggestions for walking shelter dogs is appreciated 🙏💜
Might be good to say, "This is a vid for ppl who hv watched a bunch of my vids already" and then explain simply "The leash supercedes any command." Showing Vivian loose-leash walking & u teased us about how she runs!! That all said, I adore ur channel & ur methods for ppl-reactive dogs hv turned my street-rescue pitbull into what my neighbors now call a "love junkie." 🐾❤️
Feedback is a valuable tool. Talking (not cuing) and giving feedback is powerful and has a place in most situations.
Ah, yes, the echo command. Almost as common as using too many words habit.
Please do a video on how to help me train my English Bulldog puppy Humphrey (5 months old) to not "hunker down", or anchor as I call it, when on walks. It's not about the smelling pee on a tree and things, and just the stubborness. BUT maybe that's just a thing that I need to live with for this breed? He's my first bulldog, my last 4 dogs were European Dobe's (Brutus/Neo/Apollo/Kojack). So serious shoutout to Prince and Bosco. This is an extreme shift of gears for me. :)
My dog pulls like crazy but from what I remember you saying, I shouldn't expect him to heel until he's 8 or 9 months old. He's 6 months old now and 70 lbs. I'm going to get a gentle leader because the chest point harness only helps to not have my arm ripped off. I was using the E collar with the beep and vibration until you said that isn't a good thing to use. So what do you recommend I do for the next 2 or 3 months until he's out of full on puppy mode?
Gorgeous dog! So Joel, what type of collar do you recommend? I use martingales on my rescue dogs but I'm thinking I may have to use a different kind during training or is a martingale ok for training?
That hair 😲
your office is nicer than my apartment :(
That was funny. 🌟
Vivian is my name also…lol. I like Joel’s method but need to know how long do u have to do the pop and stop do they eventually get it and another topic if dog on gentle leader how do you transition to collar
Omg I needed to see this
I have always used verbal abd hand signals to train my dogs off lease on leash i use a slight tug to get my current dogs to get his attention . I do like the hunker'n down ill try it. Bubba is a rescue abused i had to change my methods because of the abuse
Brilliant 🔥
I see way too many humans over communicating with Verbal and Eye contact without clear consistent communication, leaving the dog lost in translation. At a young age the dog will surely learn how to ignore these ques and eventually they will end up at your facility or inquiring me here in the city! Great video, Joel.
My dog is hyperactive and he is reactive frenchie. When going to dog park, I give him cue to stay but when I release him he fly 100 mile like you said and no recall at all. I tried to keep him calm but failed.
I want to watch you full training, you do have them available in any platforms.
I wish you’re in Australia so I could take my dog to you to train. Can you please recommend any trainer who specialises in reactive dog in Australia? I’ m based in Brisbane.
I've been taught I should give the dog a certain degree of freedom to smell around while on a walk without telling him when he can do it, would it be better to actually decide myself whether he can or not? Thinking about it, it might help with his walking in front of me most of the times but wouldn't it kinda cancel the distinction between walking and working?
And about the vocal cue, they told me it should come either a fraction earlier or alongside the correction, is that a no go as well? Or it just doesn't work with my dog specifically and should try something else? Eventually he slows down and walks alongside me, but it's a struggle every day with those initial 5 minutes of corrections.
Hi, i use ok for everything also as comand after i placed the bowl with the food on the floor, am i doing it right or should i change the keyword? Would "OK" for you can go to smell the pee or the other dog would put him in an excited mode because he associates that word with the fact that he can get to the food? I live in Italy and i refuse to pay a positive reinforcing trainer as it's useless and it only got worse. The other kind of trainers here they seem to be hiding as they're covered with shame. Suggestions are wellcome, thank's.
Prince drinking 8 gals of water😸😸😸
I always laugh a little when I catch people speaking full sentences to their dogs. I understand. Giving sounds, single words, or short phrases sounds rude…there’s no please or thank you. Only “good dog”. The dog isn’t hurt by this.
It's not about the words, it's about the tone of voice and volume.
It's fine to speak full sentences. They learn the language in time too. It builds relationship, even if they don't understand what you're saying, they feel included. And it's therapeutic for people. So it has a place, but not when you want them to act on it. Do it when you're sitting on the couch, when you see stuff coming by.
@@Flippokid If a car is coming when I want to cross the road, I tell my dog "Wait until the car goes by and then you can cross." When the car drives past, he crosses without me saying or doing anything. They can understand full sentences.
@@JoeR203 Eventually, and when they're paying attention to you. Not when they're focused on that other dog. The waiting till car goes by is also conditioned. Try not saying it, and not crossing when that car has passed. Your dog will cross the street if you're turned like you're gonna cross.
@@JoeR203 By the way they listen in on your conversations too. Me and my friend were making plans that involved his dog (for the first time I think, maybe the second) joining in my car on the way home. ("You take Gabber and then I take the stuff," he said) This was in the afternoon. He never jumped in my car before, even with my dogs jumping in and the doors being open. That night he jumped right in before we said anything.
Wanted 2 share a incident with u joel and would your advice. 3 weeks ago i was given a Pitbull rescue (3yr-neutered-Male) his obidience training was extensive but still very dog reactive based on distance. We were on a training walk and another owner was playing fetch with a Pitt Mastiff twice as big as my texas Red Nose / American Bully! As soon as he saw he made a bee-line for the schoolfield fence gateway, never takeing his eyes off of Ozzy! The lady there called his name 4 time b4 he stopped a few feet from the sidewalk. & was able to grab his harness. 😆 Ozzy stayed chill the whole time! Maintaining Heel right beside my hip😀. Ya kno there is a shit-ton of dog trainers on TH-cam who claim their the mesiah of dog training😕. You were the only one whos actions spoke louder than your words. Thank u 4 being so straight-up Sir.👌. Much luv from Canada eh.😊 btw Pepper spray is illegal in Canada. What would u recommend to stop two Pitbulls once the fight has started. Because that lady wouldn't b strong enough! Im 6ft 200lbs an im not sure id b strong enough 2 stop two raging pittys. Ive since changed the route for the afternoon 2km. But any insite u might have to help defend Ozzy & I from irresponsible power-breed owners/dogs, woild be very welcome eh
I would like to know this too. Also, some dogs (my pitt is one of them) is terrified of sprays of water from a spray bottle. It works for her but if someone else’s dog would not stop attacking, it would not help us then so I’m interested in other ideas.
A 'Doggie Don't' sound device that I bought on Amazon saved my dog from being attacked. I saw the free dog coming so got it ready from the open front pocket I always keep it in. Had it in my hand and gave the dog a verbal warning first, then used it. Of course it also scared my dog and I had to calm him down too, but the aggressor sprinted off back to his house like I'd actually zapped him with lightning. (My very nervous ex street dog calmed after about a minute of me petting him and him realizing the sound wasn't coming again. He also very quickly understood that I'd saved him and trotted along with his tail up for the remainder of the walk.) Please note that you still have to have a swivel head looking out for trouble, and be able to have the device ready. In particularly sketchy places or if a dog is coming (even on leash) that I am worried about and we can't avoid, I keep the device either in my hand ready or at least looped over my wrist on its strap. If you give an aggressor the benefit of the doubt and don't have the device in your hand, you won't have time to use it. It is only sound so you have to activate it as soon as you know the dog isn't going to back off. I would guess for a super aggressive dog, sound alone wouldn't reach their crazy brain if they'd already gone too far. I probably would also warn an owner and very clearly point it before pressing so the owner had another chance to do something. It is just sound but a nasty owner would freak out I guess. In the case above, the dog was about 100m from his house, free as a bird.
I have to say, considering your dog's feelings is important. A bright and happy tone can lighten a dog's mood dramatically.
I agree too many people assume their dog can understand language and yabber on and on to them.
But conversely, an owner that doesn't acknowledge that a dog that is given positive feedback is a happy, relaxed and attentive animal is missing the importance of forming a relationship with the dog.
It has to be guardian/ward relationship though, not child/parent. The subtle difference being that parents too easily loose the boundary between them and their child.
A guardian is beholden to society to care for and school their ward. Take pride in and respect your dog, try to understand you are his whole world and he will do anything for you IF he feels he can rely on you and is safe in your presence.
I use break for my door exit and off leash
I had to go to a metal chain leash because the fabric leashes were "tug toys." She is CRAZY out of her mind all the time. She will stand on two hind legs and scream when she sees another dog. She lives to play with other dogs. I rescued her at 14 months now she's 2. Husky /cattle dog mix super high energy and 100% crazy. I'm trying your methods but it is taking a long time which is ok, I have a lot of patience but I would welcome any other suggestions for my Crazy Girl. Thanks.
I wanted to see Vivian run, since you said she was so pretty running.
Hey Joel, I have an offtopic question for you... could you make a response video/comment on Zak's recent video?
Video: "This Has to Be Said. What I Actually Think About So-Called “Balanced Dog Training”
Would be nice to know what you have to say and your side on why you deal with the situations he exemplified in the video, in the way that you do, with some forms of 'punishment-based' corrections instead of going the positive reinforcement route as he showed.
Well I just watched it. I think Joel kind of addressed this already in a video plus, the April Fools video pretty much said what he thinks of purely positive.
Zak George is a better trainer than most of us will ever be, but it's Joel Beckman that helped me understand how to get fantastic fast results with very large angry rescue dogs.
Put it this way, I got no results from watching Victoria Stillwell or Zak George. The only other trainer I found that uses the same methods as Joel is called "The Dog Daddy" who is awesome.
I just watched it. I think I’ll I make a response video. Just have to figure out how I want to word it.
@@BDTraining All right, thanks.
@@KerriEverlasting same for me, when I first began watching dog training videos, I tried watching Victoria Stilwell and couldn’t see much training going on, but there was a lot of drama (and comments) about the owners, which I didn’t feel was related to training and some were so awful 😞 . It also lost me when a couple couldn’t get their dog to stop jumping on the bed so she put side rails on their bed. I watched a middle aged couple climbing into their bed from the bottom and thought, “really?”. Watching Joel has helped me so much.
Wow Vivian has quite the hair doo
My Dog would hate the look of her
Joel, have you done a video on dogs who react to correction? When I correct my dog to stop pulling, he starts biting the leash and snarling 😯
If you watch a lot of his videos you get the idea of what he's doing and how to correct them, so if you keep watching them you should get the hang of it. Not sure if he has one exactly like that, but i know a lot of his videos have dogs who try to fight the leash which is basically the same thing as your dogs problem.
I'm no expert, but ive had several dogs myself and recommend doing simple things everyday like making your dog sit and stay before he eats his food. Stuff that makes him obey you more in general, even if its simple. I'm guessing he doesn't respect your correction because he thinks he is alpha, or at least he doesn't respect you enough, or he is just a tough dog. I once walked a dog like that, his owner kind of spoiled him in some ways so when I did any corrections that he didn't like he would sometimes snarl because he wanted to get his way as he is used to. So just don't spoil your dog (if you spoil your dog). What you say goes. If you ever say a command, such as come, or get down from the couch, ALWAYS make him do it. A lot of problems come from owners who aren't consistent with their dogs. And it's a lot of help practicing being consistent like this with small stuff, so when you face something a bit more serious he will be more ready. He will see you as the boss, who doesn't let bad behavior slide. And i didn't invent these methods, I've heard many trainers including Joel talk about this stuff, so it is proven in the field.
@@risky_.y8137 useful advice, thank-you 🙂
Does this apply to puppies? At what age should I start this method?
Question ; Have you ever trained a dog to be aggressive ? I realize that question may be taboo but some of us do want working dogs. For example : personal protection or guard dog training. If you have I’d really appreciate the videos .
That isn't training aggression. Protection work is based off of prey drive and protective instincts, not aggression. You REALLY don't want an aggressive dog for protection because it's a loose cannon, and a liability. There are very specific characteristics that you need for protection work. If you're really serious about it, find a protection dog trainer near you, and ask them to help you pick a puppy out of a working line litter. You have to start them young so that they can be desensitized to EVERYTHING they might EVER encounter as an adult. You don't want a dog that is trained how to bite and latch to just lash out at a stranger because they think people wearing hats are scary. You'll want to work with a professional for about 2 years on average before your dog is "done". Once your dog is done you will need to do refresher training sessions on occasion so that they don't get rusty. You can't do this kind of training without help. You need training assistants to wear the bite suits and offer different stimulus and distractions to test your dog. It's a huge commitment.
There is a reason why fully trained protection dogs cost +$40k
I wish there was a place to request a video about a certain topic. I’d love to see how to fix obsessive scavenging and constant overstimulation.
Binge-watch Joel’s videos. There is more information and other training than just what the title says. He does talk about sniffing/smelling while taking walks. So, look for the Loose Leash Walking videos; it, and a lot more, will all come together. Remember, you are doing the training, so you have to put the time and effort in. Cutting corners or going on a walk before your dog graduates from each step of the method will not work. In his videos, especially the earlier LLW ones, you’ll hear him say, “I’ll do this all day,” which he would do if needed. Also, reading the comments helped new too. Enjoy! 🌟
@@User7688.--_ Thank you. I’ll do just that.
@@Washcloth_Peddler, also watch all the Doorway Method videos. You can do all of it. I know you can.
He has helped so many people with their dogs. Watch the video titled “Get to know me and my.....(I can't remember the last part of the title.) I watched the videos about him as a person and a trainer first, so I got to know more about him. But, I'll tell you what, what we see is the real him. He hides nothing. He can be a bit hard nose, but he has to be sometimes. Reading the comments on his videos is so insightful and funny many times. His clients, after a videotaped session with Joel, will sometimes get on the comment page of the video that was their dog, and people would ask them questions about their dog or Joel. That reminds me, watch the videos titled something like “This is not the channel to blame the dog owners or something like that. It was good. Good luck.
Mate I always talk to my dog and am never going to stop i have American bull dog he listen to ever thing I say to him
I'm using the leash pulling technique, it is working but today my dog's collar broke while we were on walk and as soon as he realised that he ran off towards a street dog to fight completely ignoring my calls. I don't know how to deal with this, it's becoming frustrating.
Joel A referral of mine by the name of Pat Bella’s Melzer feels like she’s getting the push off but she would like to have you train her dog. She has called 3 times.
Hi Patricia, yeah we’re so backed up on calls and e-mails, I’ll look for her.
Is OK the only release cue you ever use? It always means release but watch out because I might be faking you out like the trick fake taking off the leash? I have always used OK when I let my dogs eat their food. They have to wait for that to eat. I had a trainer use "you're through" and I think I still use that sometimes. Have I heard you say, "you're free?" Great videos.
Oh, and I use OK on the leash now and at the door like you teach.
Just watched another of your videos , Why I use the same cue on leash and off leash. Understood more. Works for me!
@@dbk7591 Yes, binge-watch as many of his videos as you can. It will all come together. It's hard just to watch a couple of them and not have tons of questions. All of your questions most probably will be answered in other videos. He can't answer all the comment questions that are asked. Though he might answer your particular question in a video coming up because he does try and read the comments. That would be his way of answering you.
Hi Joel I have a standard poodle he walks okay in the house But he is different out side what do I do
Watch every single video even if it doesn't seem to relate to you.
today was the first time in a long time that my dog ignored my verbal cue to not go towards to this couple😒 He is pretty good at obeying, but today, not so much!
Funnily enough I was wondering about the same use of the word ok. Commenting before watching the video, but I assume is to give the dog choice and context.
I have made it a game to use almost all hand signals with my dog. We work together in silence for the most part.
Good work Tiffany
Joel, How do I separate or manage between when I allow my dog to sniff and pee and when she should walk by my side? She wants to constantly hunker down and smell (like 6 ft away) as we are in the city and 6 feet in any direction left or right is where all the dogs in the hood are peeing. How often do I alternate with giving her the opportunity to smell and potty and then walk by side? I always feel like obligated to constantly let her sniff. Am i wrong?
You're wrong then yeah. You decide when she's able to sniff around and go potty! Start with every 6 blocks maybe if it makes you feel better. The dog doesn't need to be so sniffy on walks. That makes them in charge and distracted from the goal. Loose leash walking.
@@SilentSaver Hi Thanks so much for replying. Really appreciate it. There is a lot of training information out there so it’s confusing as different trainers have various instructions - like the walk is for the dog not the owner. I have read that allowing them to sniff in many ways makes them less reactive in a way. However my dog is very SNIFFY. She’s pulls to sniff and very scent driven. She’s small (12lbs) so I feel badly pulling her to me although now I have switched her to a front harness. You are right …she is basically in control of the walk which is not the way it should be. Interesting, my do walker and my boyfriend do not have this issue. Could it be she knows she can take advantage of me? LOL
It definitely could be! I'm no trainer but I believe he has mentioned giving them an appropriate time to sniff and go potty! Otherwise the walk should be a nice, loose leash experience for both! My GSD is very sniffy and was the same exact way. Pulled to sniff everything. But I went for the pop it and "leave it" command and gave her appropriate sniffing breaks and potty breaks and she's moving along nicely. I hope you and your pup can make it to a nice walking experience! Much love!
So true! First again...😉
My dog chooses you as her trainer 😮
What if they are puppies?
We didn't see her run?!?
Imagine using different cues for "sit" depending on where you are andor what the dog is doing.
Maybe the most important advice to put into practice.
Oh boy, I've been letting him pull towards other dogs or letting him have a sniff party or bite the heck of the sticks for half a year now. Anyone could fill me if I were to start restrict him now, will my dog dislike walking with me? My boy is 10mth old golden retriever who loves to greet almost every dog during our walk. However, when it comes to dog park, he doesn't enjoy like he used to (less than 5 mins, and I can sense that he wants to leave) so I normally bring him out for a sniff safari around the park instead. What I've been doing with the leash is, the second he pulls, I'll stand still like a lamppost. He'll walk back to me but never to a heel position. He always likes to be in front, and only when he is unsure of sth ahead, he'll look at me or come to stand beside. I never pet him nor do anything, jt continue walking like it's not a big deal.
My 4 month old doberman puppy obeys so well at home, but at the dog park, she's like... "nah." At the dog park, about a third of the time she will come to me or at least think about it; she is so overly excited everytime we go.... but her ignoring me, makes visiting the dog park stressful - especially when other dog owners are usually ignoring their dogs.
Watch Joel’s puppy videos. You’ll be glad you did. Have a great week. 🌟
Most dogs don't listen in dog parks. She's a puppy and probably overstimulated. I stopped taking my dog to dog parks. Too many untrained and bullying dogs there that would attack my girl. It made her hyper-aware, nervous, and on the defensive, which is not what she needed to learn and not what I wanted to be done to her. It can make them reactive, and if it happens enough, it becomes learned behavior.
My dog doesn't care about lead snaps/corrections, even harsh ones and he's only small :(
Look for his videos with Bumie!
My dog is the one who stops in his tracks and won’t go my way. I can’t pull him cuz he’s too big.
And this is where a prong collar is usefull!! It will put pressure on him evenly and he will get up and walk and the pressure is gone.
I wonder if this is one of the positives of having a deaf dog?
You can't spell O K A Y without saying OK.
Comments
Yep, shut the heck up!! If we want our dogs to respond well to verbal cues we need to stop talking so much. Otherwise, they learn to tune us out.
guilty. i talk my dog to death some days. ;-))
I just watched this video and the only thing I seem to have learned from it is, I'm very confused... no wonder I can't get my 100 lb. Pitbull to stop fricken pulling my 129 lb. self on our walks grrrr I'm that student sitting in the back of the class, trying not to be noticed, scratching my head and wondering how the heck the rest of the kids understood the lesson that was just given lol I think I'll go watch the video again and see if it helps. The part that is so confusing to me is the door/bush/other dog/tree thing. I know the concept is to use the same word, "okay," but... huh??? What other words would one use to let their dog know it was "okay" to do something? Did I miss something? Or am I just too naïve to comprehend? Arghhh I'm going back to watch it again now.
Too much repetition without expanding the information.
Good advice..
Hi Joel, I love your videos and they’ve helped me a lot. I was wondering though, what are your thoughts on a prong collar? I couldn’t find any videos of you with it in use or thought. Could you point me to one?
I have no problems whatsoever walking our dog thanks entirely to you but my girlfriend always has. If we go out together then the dog is great, if she goes out with him then she always comes back with bruises or hurt due to the pulling.
Hope you can read this comment and give me a piece of advice thanks!
He is against a prong and always advises people to use the gentle leader. It's like a horse halter except for dogs. It offers great control that your dog can't ignore and people are less likely to see you in public with one on and accuse you of animal abuse (there are a lot of crazy people out there who would do that)
He's against prong collars because they cause long term unpredictability in dogs behaviour. I tend to agree. The statement Joel makes "he has to EARN every meter you walk. If your dog is lunging and barking, what are you even doing there? If the dog isn't with you, the walk doesn't happen." Was THE single most important thing and completely negates any need for e collars or prong collars.
I love the prong! It helped soooo much with my GSD. Now I'm able to just use her collar but we used the prong for about 6 months! Really helped control her in regards to overly excited/stimulated. She can now walk by me and all I have to say is "ah ah" when she's to far ahead and she goes back into position! Very confident girl on her walks now.