ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
Rough Ryder High Carbon Steel Canoe Pocket Knife RR1571
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 มี.ค. 2022
- Review of the Rough Ryder High Carbon Steel Canoe Pocket Knife. Model # RR1571 Black G10 micarta handles, brushed nickel-silver ringed bolsters, brass liners, nickel-silver pins and shield. 440 formula high carbon steel blades with titanium nitride coating. Closed length 3-5/8" UK Friendly.
#ThriftyKaniffy
![รอจะบอกคำนั้น - KARN The Parkinson x DAOU PITTAYA [LIVE SESSION]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wACfLFATe2Y/mqdefault.jpg)
Gotta love the carbon blades! It’s a sleek looking canoe without the R bolster
It's a handsome knife. It lends credence to the reasoning for many people wanting the "R" to go away.
I have Watched this Video on the Carbon Steal RR1571 Canoe as well as video's on the Black Micarta Canoe RR2209.
I decided to order the RR 1571 as you are right the Dark blade and brushed look with out the "R" on the bolster was simply the Classy Choice with a Carbon Steal Blade. Great Video, Thank you.
Fairly unique series that RR put out here. Thanks!
An excellent example of a great design. Beautiful. Thanks for showing. All the best.
Same to you Rhino. Glad you enjoyed the review.
That's the only canoe I've bought and it's a wonderful workhorse of a knife 👍 excellent for the whittling I've put it through
Thank you for your feedback Andrew.
That's one good looking canoe right there, buddy. Thanks for showing this one off!
Any time! Thanks David.
Mine arrived today. All round pretty much the same as yours; slight gapping at the big blade bolster end of no real concern. Blades are more in the middle than not, it's smooth and well made.....I'm not disappointed.
Happy to hear you found yourself an example your satisfied with. A very manly looking knife. Thanks ihopetowin.
The canoe is by far my favorite pattern. I have two and plan to get many more
That's great Jon. This one is well done. Thanks for watching.
That is a classy, handsome looking knife. Thanks for sharing.
You're very welcome KD.
Good looking canoe and looks similar to their titanium series. I’m definitely a fan of those
Yea, the series SMKW put out don't always differentiate much.
Another really good looking series from RR!! Great look at it TK!
Thanks BigRed.
Nice Canoe! I picked up the Rough Rider Classic Carbon II Canoe and really enjoy it.
Thanks ID Wolverine. Good choice, very similar knives.
Love your videos! Whenever I get a new knife, I buff it up real good with a cotton polishing drill pad and Flitz, add some Rem oil, clean that up with a little alcohol, and put a light wax on some of the smooth handles. I make the knife bolsters and edges shine, and I can even buff down rough spots and proud fasteners. In fact, I can’t wait to improve a knew knife when it first arrives! Only after going over it thoroughly, can I truly judge and admire it.
I do a lot of that as well. The budget knives can deinitely be inproved upon with a small amount of work. Thanks, DC.
Canoe great design - usually use the T10 on high carbon - sharpens up nicely
Thanks Chad. Glad you like the canoe pattern, it's up there on my list of favs.
Nice looking Canoe. Horse shoe tang stamp the square badge are nice, I assume its carbon blades otherwise no point in coating them, kinda funny a knife retailer can't list them correctly..Great review i like this one. Thanks TK
It's a nice looking knife. I don't doubt the blades are carbon, just not familiar with the particulars.
The Carbon steel canoe is a very nice one, then again i'm a canoe lover. But it looks pretty nice. Thank you for the review TK.
Thanks Jeroen. Simple, clean design.
That's a good looking Canoe TK. I like that one. 👍👍
Why thank you Steve.
Great knife! Thanks for the review.
Glad to help Pragmatic.
Great review, just ordered one!
Hope you enjoy it Jimmy.
Nice knife. Love the R-free bolster! I’m kinda tired of micarta, waiting for the cinnamon stag bones.
On order. You as well? Thanks Su.
G10 is a different material than micart. Beautiful knife and love the collection
You're right, thanks Jay. Welcome to the channel.
I like this a lot. Even though it is brushed and matt in finish, it still kind of shines.
It's a classy looking canoe ihopetowin. Thanks for checking it out.
@@ThriftyKaniffy I've found one for sale in Australia.........I think I'll get it.
I haven’t tried one of these yet, but the cheap Chinese Buck I got was pretty shocking. One of the most perfect knives I have bought out of the box, and cheaper than dirt. I carry it a lot, very slim in the pocket.
Which model Buck what it Jon? Thanks.
@@ThriftyKaniffy Hi, Buck 389. Around $10 at Walmart, but a few years ago.
I also bought one of those lately. It is super nice. I gave like 11.37 for it on walmart online. The 420 J2 was a challenge to sharpen for me (probably just me), but when I got it sharp it really holds an edge.
So, I have this knife and it sure sharpens and strops like it is high carbon. Very forgiving compared to the "7/17 cro-mov", 420 HC, 440A, or the "carbon series RR" with the yellow Delrin handles. I can say this because I sharpened a lot of knives in a row till each one was hair popping sharp, not just shaving sharp. All these knives being basic RR, Gerber, Buck, Marbles, and Ocoee River. This knife sharpened a lot like an old yellow handled Case Trapper I have with the old Carbon steel blades on it. Literally 6 swipes each side on an Arkansas stone, six swipes each side with a strop (w green paste) and it shaves like a safety razor blade. It also has that "toothy", grabby, feel to the edge even when it is very fine and polished. It could be a great 440C....but if it is it is the best 440C I have ever sharpened. Just my two cents worth.
Thanks for the info Ras. Appreciate the response.
I’ve already ordered this knife for next week and you have shown me it’s as good as I expected. I’m also getting the Canoe in the Carbon II range which also looks pretty smart. Thanks for another great video my friend 👍.
Two carbon canoes. Very nice. Let us know how you like them Toad.
@@ThriftyKaniffy will do 👍
Good video TK!
You bet Stuart.
This model has been on Heinnie Haynes website for a long time, thought about getting it but didn't, wish they made them a little bit bigger just under three inch blade would be great, I have RR048 and longest blade bang on 2 and a half inches, the Canoe is a great pattern and others RR make are nice looking knives, I decided to stick with the one or else I would have a bunch by now, try not not to duplicate patterns.
Thanks for your rationale Lewis, always appreciated.
I have the RR carbon steel canoe in blue denim. It a great knife and well designed. However, I find it a tad weighty for it's size. I think I'd prefer it with just the main blade.
I have the high carbon half hawk which I love. Unfortunately, on my piece the blade was unevenly ground and with a biggish gap on the back. Mind you it came perfectly centered.
RRs are quite a bit more expensive in Europe, I'd say about double.
Thanks for the feedback Paul. I carry heavier knives quite often so I think that conditions me for anything lighter being a non-issue.
Probably 440c instead of the usual 440a, I haven't seen a t10 with a coating on it and the fact it says 440 leads me to believe it may be 440c high carbon stainless steel
Ok. Thanks Jorel
Great Review
Thanks HAKD, glad you liked it.
those RRs are pretty damn good
Thank you Prop. Love the action on this one.
Hey TK, I'd like to weigh in on the "high carbon" steel. Buck does the same thing with their steel. They use 420hc, for "high carbon". Their 420 has about 0.45 carbon in it. Rough Ryder 440a would contain 0.60 -0.75 carbon. So maybe Rough Ryder is just trying to get "Carbon steel" in the title for marketing.
Traditional knife users are used to "carbon steel" terms. Iron needs carbon to harden, therefore all knife steels will contain carbon. Stainless steels have chrome added. Hence stainless steel. Stainless steel can have high carbon amounts. Usually 0.45% on up to just over 1.00% for non-powder metal steels.
This is just a titanium coated 440A stainless blade. RR terminology can be really wonky at times. I have a lot of modern Bucks, yep 420HC for the US versions with the excellent Bos heat treat.
@@ThriftyKaniffy thanks for the reply TK👍
Hi,
I have the very same knife, Mine has problems, much worse. bad gapping on the back plate spring, pitting on the spear blade and mis- sharpened. Heavy on one side. Cost me £19.95 and is going back to the supplier. Nice chat though.
Cheers
Steve
Bummer. Sounds like you got a lemon. Thanks for sharing Stephen.
Damn fine!
Right on LTC.
Mine had a massive gap which I understand was due to a bad production run - otherwise a hefty canoe.
Thanks Matthew. Good feedback.
I love Canoe knives 😁 steel is T10, it's almost like 1095 Carbon Steel 🤔
Thanks Crosswalker. Were you able to verify the type somewhere?
Got the Bow Trapper in the series just after the law change as it was close to the legal limit but they're not small insipid blades. That was the only one in the series available at the time. Had to give that one a flush too and the fit and finish isn't perfect. It's built like a tank, in the last couple of years of use the coating hasn't chipped or flaked off the blade. They sharpen very well, good user knives. Wouldn't buy a bow handle shaped knife again though, not a fan. Stick with the Canoe.
A sowbelly has all the more bow you need IMO. Not a huge fan of the boomerang trapper.
Yeah, the handle shape looks to be uncomfortable.
3:45 I could be wrong, but I've read that "high carbon" just means anything approaching .8 or 1% carbon content in steel. It doesn't necessarily mean "carbon steel". So for example there are high carbon tool steels but these still have chromium and other metals in them. The maker of this knife might be using 440c which has around 1% carbon and therefore they can say it's a "high carbon" blade and not be lying.
Ambiguous knife marketing is a pet peeve of mine. Just say what it is in detail and we don't have to guess. Thanks for the info Tinman it helps.
You could put a drop of vinegar on the sharpened edge & if it patina's it's carbon. If it doesn't, it's 440a.
It's for sure carbon. Thanks William.
@@ThriftyKaniffy SMKW said one of their knives was T-10. After 8 hours of vinegar with salt added, it didn't patina at all. Later Andy said they had T10 in their specifications, but the manufacturer used 440a. What I learned from that was 440a is highly corrosion resistant.
@@WilliamsKnifeLife Yea, I remember that now you mention it. Wasn't that the upswept bow trapper ?
The rough Ryder site say they a H C blades
yea high carbon.
Its is carbon steel, i have one i took the coating off of and it patinas
Seems that way. Thanks, Fila.
This is my first RR purchase and at $14 I am impressed. I’m thinking it is truly carbon because why would you coat blade on such a cheap knife if not for rust resistance.
Just for appearance. They are 440A stainless with a titanium coating. Thanks, Fritz.
This is funny. I have one of the originals that was released. Someone made a mistake and mine is marked 440 Razor Sharp Steel. But it is carbon because you have to keep it oiled. It will rust.
That's a neat error. Thanks for the comment, Karl.
I’m wondering if it isn’t 440c or 440b
Not sure the blade steel, all it says is they are titanium coated carbon blades .
It is t10 steel similar to 1095
They are very similar steels but the T10 has a bit more flex making it less brittle.
Hey Thrifty just came In SMKW go check out the Reserve line check out the single blade clip point lockback denim Micarta 50 bucks hop on it looks nice!!!!! Let me know what you think!!!!!!
Looking forward for the clasp knife when they release that model...
Just ordered one, thanks!
It's a nice looking knife. Just wish it had come out a little sooner just dropped some cash on other things.
The High Carbon Titanium series is a confusing one. 🤦♂️
Well the promotional materials don't help much.
I myself would not have a pocket knife made in China period
Pretty narrow minded considering all the great China made knives. To each their own.
I don't know about narrow minded.what I do know.is 50.000 Americans died in Korea.and we were fighting Chinese troops in Vietnam Nam also.so I would just rather buy an American knife.so after 21 months in combat.i became narrow minded!!!!!!!
Very nice knife 🔪 😊
Ahh yes, this is a nice Canoe. Thanks for taking a look at the video, I appreciate your patronage, Peter.