I Was WRONG About One Piece Live Action
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ก.ย. 2024
- One Piece Live Action really took me by surprise.
Support the channel by donating to my Ko-fi: ko-fi.com/lord...
Follow me on Twitter: / lordonimaru
#onepieceliveaction #onepiece #netflix
![🎤 จับฉลากร้องเพลง x P’ #XXSIVK [EP.1] (2/2) เพื่อนจับได้คำไหน..ต้องร้องคำนั้น เริ่ม! 💓🎶 #MXFRUIT](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1bJvMJXmeS4/mqdefault.jpg)
5:50 Love that detail from the manga regarding the nationality of the cast.
Well this definitely succeeded in getting me interested in the franchise. Hopefully Netflix will keep it going.
Also nice that you mentioned Oda’s take of the characters in live action. Maybe use of reference in the future.
Never was into One Piece knew about it and knew about people really into it. Never me. But now i am a fan ! just cant wait for season two!!! it needs to come ASAP!!! i just love the world building
Oh just you wait haha. The worldbuilding in the east blue is just the tip of the ice berg!
Go and watch the anime, 44 episodes to watch or read the manga (11 volumes) until you are on the same timeline. Good opportunity to fill in the blanks they had to remove because of the time restraint.
Just read it
Same here! I’m new to One Piece and the world building, story, and characters were so fun for me! It’s rare that I find a show or movie that I like as much as the live action One Piece.
@@jellydonuts2343 That’s awesome! What are your favorite characters/scenes?
sanji's backstory was amazing out of all of them to me lol
I think that this should have been 10 episodes instead of 8 episodes, mainly for Usopp's sake. With this series being only 8 episodes long that meant they they had under 8 hours to cover all of One Piece up to the Arlong Park arc, and in order to cover that much material in such a limited runtime it meant that they had to basically speedrun One Piece. Some things were fine like Nami being a part of Shells Town. Other parts though were just too rushed though... like Usopp's story.
Like I enjoy Usopp's character in this adaptation, but I don't understand what the hell he is doing being Straw Hat Pirate. In the manga and anime he put one foot in the grave and was willing to risk everything to save his town and Kaya. In the Netflix adaption he shot a single sling at Kuro... and that's about it. With an extra episode to properly adapting Syrup Village it would have served Usopp's character so much better. It also would have given them time to not leave out characters like Jango or Hatchan, or killing off Don Krieg early and leaving him out of the Baratie arc entirely.
That aside though this was all around a great adaption. It's not a replacement, but an amazing supplement to the One Piece franchise. I was honestly blown away by almost everything that this series did and that's because some clear love and care was put behind this adaption. Hopefully there will be a season 2 because I loved what I saw.
okay since I’ve red this thing with Ussop quite some times now, as someone who’s not all too familiar with the anime or manga and therefore the characters beforehand I think I might be able to give a different perspective since I obviously don’t have a comparison so,
I viewed it that way that Luffy on one hand simply sees the potential Ussop has at becoming the person of his storys and therefore living his dream (minus the captain part 😅😂) and that on the other hand Luffy was impressed by how loyal he was to Kaya and the Straw Hat gang right off the bat even tho he was scared.
To me it was like (and that was actually a recurring theme with every crew member) Luffy actually values a person‘s motivations and moral values more than anything and that even tho Zorro is a great fighter, Nami a skilled manipulator and navigator and Sanji again a great fighter as well as amazing cook, those were not the main reasons he recruited them to join their crew but it was their actions and motivations for those actions.
I think with the whole theme of him being inspired by people’s dreams and ambitions as well as the genuine kindness of their hearts Ussop fits in perfectly from Luffys perspective.
funnily though they did want 10 episodes but circumstances (time constraints and some interference from higher ups) didn’t allow them to do so
Mainly for Usopp’s sake, spot on dude! I like that the antagonists are better here than in the manga, but to toss aside Usopp in his own arc, come on. They did him dirty.
I"m sure they'll get more money for next season. 18 million per episode is a crazy budget
@@mrsfahrenheit there was so much taken out of ussops story/character. In the og, he was introduced as someone pretending to be a pirate captain with thousands of followers, next, he was actually ecstatic when he heard that luffy met his dad because he idolized his dad (the live action made him sad that his dad spent more time with luffy than him). Both these told us (and luffy) that he always wanted to go out to sea but he was scared. In the LA, i couldnt find the reason for his dream of becoming " a brave warrior of the sea".
His character development was also very much not there (nami got more development in his intro episodes). In the original, he decided to keep his lie of "pirates are coming" real by facing the black cat pirates himself despite being a coward.
Another thing that got lost in his character development is in the ussop vs chu (fishman). After he feigned dead, he tries to lie to himself, that he fought hard while rubbing dirt on himself to look like he worked hard, until he remembers his friends and what they are facing, he grits his teeth and calls for chu and fights him. While they attempted this fight in the LA, it felt more like he was just trying to trick him.
Edit: not to say that it was bad, just saying that ussop and sanji got the bad end of the stick because they didnt get as fleshed out as the first three crewmates. This couldve been fixed with more episodes but they were limited to 8. Which also means that they had to make luffy instantly likeable when luffy in the og was neither good nor bad.
Haven’t seen the live action yet but might give it a go soon after this video
Do it bro, it's really good 🙏
You won’t regret it
One-of-us, one-of-us!
It blows, super hard to watch
@@jaynemo674huh
as a new fan I’m totally blown away by how good this show was! Easily one of the best tv productions I’ve ever seen, not gonna lie!
this show is honestly not even only a good adaptation, it really is one of the best tv shows of all time!🔥🔥🔥 and easy the best Netflix show (for me at leastj
Kew word NEW...They tender too much to new populace when yall havent even watches the actual show thats still on going and they fu ked up everything
This was believe it or not the boring Part.... Is that good
@@aristidess1190 that really is craaazy to think about.. I’ve heard y’all saying the East Blue arc was only the beginning of the beginning and that the real adventure hasn’t even started yet. I‘m dead If it’s actually going to be even better, seriously
@@mrsfahrenheitthen you are not ready for the next arc😂
you are gonna be blown away(pun intended)
You have no idea what's coming in the next seasons this just the beginning
Season One: I can honestly say that I'm pretty satisfied with the results. I was a little concerned when I learned that my all time favorite anime was going to get a live action series - even after I learned that Eiichiro Oda was working with the people working on this project, I was still skeptical. But after watching it, I can definitely see Oda's work while also trying out something a little different. I was pretty happy with the casting choice, as most of the actors did a fantastic job at portraying their respected characters - my favorites being the portrayal of Dracule Mihawk; despite his limited appearances in the anime and manga, he has always been one of my favorite characters (and I was more than happy to see him getting more screen time on this series). And while I did like Mackenyu as Roronoa Zoro, his portrayal at times came off as weak - I get that he was trying to capture the stern and seriousness of Zoro, but he doesn't really have the voice for it just yet, which is why I think he could have used just a bit more energy.
I get that there is only so much you can do with real people, and you have so much more room with animation, which is why plenty of stuff was cut out in the first season. But I really wish it had at least ten episodes, if it would have helped for us to see more of the characters we enjoyed - such as the battle between Luffy and Don Krieg. And while there were times when the choreography was obvious, most of the times it was done very well. And I don't object for diversity, just as long as it makes sense. I really do hope that Netflix keeps these people on their payroll, so they can continue bringing this amazing world to life.
I honestly love the show for what it is so far. I think this series will see major improvements as it moves along (in particular the acting with some characters). I think they did a great job at casting, buggy especially is a perfect fit. It’s a fun show, it’s good entertainment and I will gladly watch future seasons
OP fan?
@@royalfun1031 absolutely
I did start reading the manga after finishing episode 8...
You should read from starting cuz it is just like a trailer of what happened in that time .
read from the start the live action is not accurate especially Garp they made him look like a villian and made him look like he dosen't care about luffy and luffy hates him for some reason
I was so sad that I had to wait until season 2 to see more of these characters that I actually watched the first few episodes of the anime. Maybe I’ll continue, maybe not. What I can say is that anime shows can be kind of hit or miss for me, I love Attack On Titan, My Hero Academia, and Death Note, but I couldn’t get into Demon Slayer and it seems like One Piece is hitting me similarly. I was immediately grabbed by episode one of AOT and had the same experience with the live action One Piece, but unfortunately I’m finding that the anime isn’t really doing it for me. But that just makes me all the more appreciative of the fact that I now have the live action as a way to engage with the story of One Piece. I’m so glad season 2 has been confirmed! I can’t wait!
@@jellydonuts2343 It's because One piece anime is so old so first few arcs of one piece is outdated but i'll suggest you to continue because there are a lot of things live action missed and couldn't do right also the quality of the anime gets significantly better later on.
Btw i am also very excited for s2 and i think s2 will be the make or break of the series because of one particular character i hope they do him right
I am watching rn and its kind of goes crazy
I'm hoping it does get that far. after watching it, and realizing I LOVE it, now I can say with confidence what I look forward to seeing adapted. And next to Logia powers, I REALLY REALLY want to see the six powers in the show. I loved Enies Lobby and CP9.
I'm so glad Oda is involved
Oda said it was good, so i knew it would be 🥰👍 Great video, love your thoughts on it!
Even if they tone down some of the fights in the future I still beleive this could really work
Still recommend the actual anime. The fact that they stuck to the story was great. Just wish we saw Sanji watched Luffy fighting for his Dream.
Zoro too
I watched it as someone that never got invested in the original manga or anime. I'm pretty sure I saw one episode and was highly confused since it wasn't the beginning. It's kind of cool to see how specific the author was with his vision of the heritage for all his characters.
I don't blame you, Netflix Full metal live action still makes me cringe till this day
ED-OOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!
WINRY!!!!
As Brotherhood is one of my favorite anime I really tried to give the Live action a fair shot...but yeh cringe is the right word.
This is the problem with people just saying Netflix did all of these live actions, cause all off them have different people involved in all of the production. Literally all of them have different show runners, writers and everything. So it's not just oh Netflix. Netflix are primarily just financing it.
Oda being directly involved in the production process and having the authority to make the final calls is what saved live action One Piece.
You had the right to be jaded. I was actually worried...BUT THEN it blew my expectations away
i agree i know what happens up the newest chapter and yet as i was watching, i wanted to keep watching.
I have low expectation at first but after watching it 😮😮😮😮 i need netflix do it until oda finish the manga
0:17 Cowboy Bebop is a show about bounty hunters
2:44 okay, that one is also good
I disagree about the child actor part, especially Sanji.
Sanji and Zeff backstory segment was fantastic.
The only bad thing they did was they rush some of the things but then. it's not even their fault because it's only 8 episodes. and the problem could be solve by producing more episode.
Love it when a bunch of sceptical human in this universe turn out to love the franchise. It's just the Geniusity of oda sensei
The whole team
0:12 i liked it
Just believe in Oda sensei 🔥
One piece anime 5/10 live action -2/10
im just scared how they are gonna do the non-human characters, im scared of the cgi or puppets or whatever they are gonna do. how are the zaun users gonna look? are they gonna wear furry customes like some of the characters in these eps? im just praying its gonna look decent.
Yeah they minimized of how they uses their power as all of it are cgi and that is time consuming and hard to do is what I don't like about LA. Overall I enjoyed watching it and even the OPLA reactions to it.
The fish people looked alright, so it's possible they might nail the beastmen/anthropomorphic animal characters.
Though, characters like Carrot we will probably never see sense they are from so far later in the series, and as good as the live action adaptation is, I doubt it will last that long.
@@beauwalker9820 they shouldnt have dropped all 8 episodes at once. Could have been a whole 2 months of hype and revenue for netflix. They messed up not releasing it weekly.
@@bllllllllackbirdieMaybe ppl would've dropped it in that time who knows but u ryt
Am just mad they didn’t follow the manga like that .
Y did u expect that
In eight episodes? Lmao
Huh? You read One Piece?
Daym u
I loved it 😅
I whole heartedly disagree, its garbage.
man, the costume fot me so cringe, way too clean, it looked like cosplay. Nami's hair looks very un natural. luffys hat looks way too clean, i hope it looked like a straw hat from the time before
Have you watched One piece?
Because i question if you have with a nitpick that small and also would disagree with
The world of One Piece is at an alternate universe, not like the Pirate of the Caribbean, which is set in 17 or 18 century Europe. So, if you think the costume is too cringe or too clean, it is because you take it as a pirate film in 18 century, but in fact it is a totally different fantasy world. Like, did you consider the costume in Star War too cringe or too clean? IT IS NOT OUR WORLD.
They need to keep the colorful, cartoonish quality of the manga to capture the spirit of it.
Making them look weathered for the sake of realism may not work. It’s what they’ve done to most life action adaptations, dark and gritty, dull and boring.
Also, the costuming were great, they don’t look like cosplay at all because most of costumes in OP manga are already pretty laid back and casual to begin with, basic T-Shirts, hawaiian shirts, etc. the Navy uniforms look good, buggy’s costume looks good. My only problem is Nami’s hair, should’ve colored her natural hair instead of giving her a wig.
@@CarolSubListlooks better later on
Netflix added their diversity crap, casting was terrible, where they could have been faithful, they often just were not, I expect changes in pacing and logistics but not core story.
Buggy is not the joker or a psychopath, Garp is not an cold old Scottish man, Koby has much more backbone and is not a woman. Luffy does not need Nami to save his life.
Luffy defeats Morgan and Buggy, not Zoro or Nami or their "teamwork". Luffy is the hero of the show and the catalyst for change, not a side character like this show made him.
The relationships are never developed, Nami, Zoro and Luffy end up traveling together like a dysfunctional DND party. Luffy is supposed to earn Zoros respect before he joins, that never happens.
Even set design is crap, Luffys home town does not look like a Caribbean harbor, it's supposed to be a country village in European style (including ehm all villagers in the east blue). And somehow Shanks whole crew is now black.
And don't get me started on the camera work, music and other creative decisions. Everybody looks like a dead zombie with their makeup and colorless image.
I'm only two episodes in and I'm already baffled anyone can defend this insult of an adaptation.
Oh look, no one cares
@@tle398 I do. There is no use celebrating a mediocre product from a dying industry.
You clearly haven’t read the manga if you bothered to read SBS you would know one piece is inherently diverse so if you your complaining about diversity your watching the wrong series 😂
@@JOYBOYTEO It's the US definition of 'diverse' that is the problem. They are clearly checking boxes.
Don't feel bad, as goofy and all over the park, as one piece anime is... I didn't think they could make a go at a live-action either !! Boy was I wrong too !! Best live action anime I have ever seen !! I'm already Joneson for season 2....