Shut Up Ya Kunal - Episode 26 - P. Sainath, Journalist & Author
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ก.ย. 2024
- Dive into India's agrarian crisis in this episode of Shut Up Ya Kunal, featuring award-winning journalist P Sainath. Explore the roots of inequality and the distinction between freedom and independence. Don't miss this eye-opening conversation, and deepen your understanding with Sainath's book, The Last Heroes.
Grab your copy of The Last Heroes: Foot Soldiers of Indian Freedom NOW! Immerse yourself in the untold stories of India's struggle for freedom. Click here to buy: amzn.to/42dpi24 📚✨
🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Special Thanks: Parth MN
Producer: Nidhi
Creative Direction: Oshosmemefolder
Edit - Shubham
Mix - Shreejith
Venue - The Habitat, Mumbai.
Subscribe for more episodes of 'Shut Up Ya Kunal' and other upcoming videos.
#shutupyakunal #PSainath #kunalkamra #journalism #farmersprotest
![[TH] RNT vs SPG - VCT Ascension Pacific - Day 1](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RUTkf8Detj8/mqdefault.jpg)
The recent 3 episodes with Suraj yengde, Kannan Gopinathan and P Sainath have been really resourceful, having read P.Sainath’s book “Everybody loves a good drought” and Suraj’s book “Caste matters”. These are the kind of people we need on podcasts to really understand the idea of India.
True that. Kunal kudos to make young minds informed
💯 true
Spot on comment a person after my own heart
These guys have absolutely no issues with hundreds of billionaires in European nations, US, Australia whose population is a fraction of the size of India.
@@1008apocalypse1008well u are a chapri leave billions u didnt have 1k in ur account u know
My conversion from bhakt to liberal was triggered due to SUYK episode with Kanhaiya and Umar. I was like, they don't seem anywhere close to their portrayal in pop media. How I wish I can strap my family to watch some of these episodes. You have outdone yourself multiple times, this was one of those. Was such a pleasure and heartache at the same time to go through this episode.
For what it is worth, Umar Khalid's father is founding member of terrorist organization called SIMI.
Usse din naam bhi change kr dena Saurabh se chutiya rakh Dena tha ... Koi na ab change kr de 🤣🤣
Great to see people change,Let the idea of india prevail ✊
i salute you for changing the way of your thinking.
Great comment but it's fake i am sure.
This enlightenment and conversion story are made up BS
Fun fact: He is the grandson of a Bharath Rathna and a former President of India (V.V. Giri). It's likely he had the resources to have a comfortable life but yet he chose to fight for the weakest in our society, rare to see such great people who not just talk but live their life with ideals.
He does have a comfortable life
I listened to Sainath Sir as a student at St Xavier's College, Mumbai in 2014 at Malhar Conclave. His truth bombs made me almost cry then and they still do. If you want to help him anyway, donate to PARI!
Kunal more respect for what you have started. More power to you and happy to help in any form possible. Please interview more such grass root fighters
Spell bounded listening to Sainath sir. Need of the hour for the young generation to know about authentic history, very informative & thank you Kunal for bringing in priceless gems in your programme.
These guys have absolutely no issues with hundreds of billionaires in European nations, US, Australia whose population is a fraction of the size of India.
@@1008apocalypse1008 chutiye tere ko abhi bhi samaj nahi aaya
@@1008apocalypse1008 stop spamming Abhinav
@@1008apocalypse1008O.K. compare the average wealth, living standards, education levels, with India. This is not to denigrate Indians, but its course correction.
Can't say anything, just wow wow wow, because I'm not that capable enough to comment anything on this. Best so far, hats off to P Sainath for his continuous efforts towards farmers issues. Thank you kunal for bringing these awesome talks.
Talking about education again the protesting farmers were anti Coporatization (Adani) of the farm laws. Very educated mindset, that's my opinion. Well done farmers!!!
v
This Episode moved me to Tears. Especially when Mr. Sainath was talking about the Freedom Struggle.
The way P.Sainath speaks, with such passion and conviction while being eloquent, erudite, and factual. He is, truly one of few remaining gold standards of Journalism in India.
Kunal... this has been so far the best episode. I was so engrossed watching, listening, understanding... I waited for the interview to get over to mention.
Thanks Kunal. Very good interview of P. Sainath. I have just finished reading this book. It's very good. Every body must read it
Listening to P Sainath is always a pleasure and a huge learning experience. Thanks Kunal for filling the void the conventional media has left.
Mr Sainath is perhaps the rarest breed of journalists that don't exist anymore. We have huge respect for him
He is still alive, thus exists
kinda sad no one discusses Bhagat Singh in detail. His life was truly honorable. He is a true inspiration to me as a 16 year old; showed me the path to atheism. His letters from jail (a book about it) were what got me into fighting for freedom. Seriously recommend reading about him. Other than this, this episode was really eye-opening in the sense that Mr. Sainath truly put in perspective how valuable the tribal communities were to the independence struggle.
Captain Bhau's instance made me emotional. Thanks to Mr. Sainath and Kunal for bringing this absolute wonder.
I hope that Bharat finds itself again. Jai hind.
My first exposure to P. Sainath sir is through his book Everybody Loves a Good Drought. Thanks Kunal for arranging this interview with him.
I'm from Purulia and a proud Purulian. Hearing about our district's history in freedom fighting from him is very much exciting to me.
Thank you for bringing out this gem of an episode
What a legend
its really pathetic that you didn't know about P.Sainath.
@@ageless1003 I read his articles on PARI
While you haven't learnt anything from sainath sir
He just focuses on highlighting issue and never talks in negative tone about the government, that's the need of the hour now ,somewhere issue gets sidelined in expressing hatred towards the govt among some other activist ,and government replies to the hatred rather than the issue
While here you are attacking me
sainath sir is a legend... a lot to learn from people like him.. thanks Kunal for such a moving and engaging talk❤❤
Thank you so much Kunal for bringing in P Sainath Sir to the episode ... What a man he is ...
Hats off Kunal! I feel owe you something for this episode of talking at length with P.Sainath!
While listening this episode we realise how much our generation is being mislead, how real history is being kept in the dark.
Kunal you are true genius. Hats off to you for interviewing a great man of our times Shri Sainath ❤
I really want to Thank Kunal for this video.
I come from Sangli, which is mentioned in this video.
I always wondered the heroic story behind 'Prati-Sarkar' which was so well executed in pre-independence era.
I also want to thank the team to put picture of Captain Ram Bhau from "Toofan Sena" and would urge all the viewers to read more about Krantisinha Nana Patil, and role of 'Prati-Sarkar' in independence movement.
I read Mr. Sainath's book 'Everyone Loves a Good Draught' and it resonated with me. The examples and analogues he gives from the rural heartland are exceptional and will stick with you. You will find yourself quoting it multiple times, just because the real stories are so authentic and hard hitting.
Thankyou Kunal for introducing this man with the youth.
After listening to this podcast, i went to read BHAGAT SINGH -THE READER again, this time when i read it, it hit differently, everything what Bhagat singh stood for has not been achieved, inequality is rising, imperialism got replaced by capitalist as he said white man will be replaced by brown men, in his times also he criticized newspapers that were communal, the solution he proposed for communalism was class consciousness of people. Even chandrashekar azad was against communalism - he said that its a propaganda of Shahi hindus and shahi muslims to divide the nation. Revolution the complete overhaul of the poltical system that Bhagat singh suggested sounds so pertinent in today's time. Be it hunger, poverty, unemployment, communalism it feels like india has come full circle. It's were we started. People who fought for india are in tears seeing this state of India.
Great episode. Listening to P. Sainath is always enriching. Pre-ordered and read the book in one go. It's an absolute must-read for every Indian.
Sainath sir spoke with a lot of passion & it's like an eye opener for us that we need to recognise the unsung heroes of our freedom struggle. So beautifully spoken & presented. Thanks again for bringing alive the beautiful history of our very beautiful India.
If this doesn't bring tears in your eyes, nothing can.
Hats off to your struggle....and what you enlightened us about freedom fighters.....lot of things to think about for our country but still...kisi ko faraq nai padta..we respect you sir .Thank you Kunal kamra sir for this chat and video... great effort 👍👍
Whenever I raise this topic with my Indian friends their eye balls roll. On your comment "faraq....". Always maintain if everyone repeats this phrase how can we improve people's lives
What a fantastic episode! It was such a pleasure listening to Mr. Sainath speak! You're doing a great job Kunal!! 😊
After this interview we actually understand how much we have deviated from the idea of Freedom. Thanks again Kunal!
This might be the best episode so far. Would like to see such legends being bought to limelight so our youth will understand history better.
Irony is that once upon time india had a PM who was reading news paper and taking its cognizance and now we all know our pm and his capabilities 😭
Now our Pm writes the newspapers.
@@navindersingh3653😂😂😂nice one
I was thinking the same thing, and words rang in my mind, 'history will be kinder to me. '
A must see for All journalists and people who call themselves nationalists ! Each Sainath conversation is brilliant ! ❤
If you really want to know about farmers and their issues, P.Sainath is the person you can look up to... Kindly support his initiative PARI as much as possible In whatever manner.
How can I missed d interview for so long...!!!😢 Great job Kunal....🎉❤
1:00 thanks for adding this heartfelt poetic section ❤️👏 I also from Vidarbha
What a man. Every time I watch him speak, I am refilled with an energy so different.
I was reading about the peasants movement which also comprises tribal movement and decided to take a break over dinner and this video came across; so grateful for this conversation, looking forward to reading the book.
Man! My wife caught me crying while watching this!
Kunal you have taken the bar high up. Suraj Yengde, Gopinathan, P Sainath. And such important issues of the society. And there are people doing interviews of carry*inati... As a phd scholar in sociology, it feels you are a more sociologist than me. Kudos to you. Thanks for such beautiful insights P Sainath.
What an incredible conversation. Respect Mr. Sainath.
This is such a great conversation, very important for the future of India.
This video deserves to heard by every youth,who has lost himself in prejudice of class,caste, gender,etc....let it make him awake ..if he want to get up
This interview must be shown publicly to children of all age groups, should be discussed extensively..may be also translated to Hindi and other regional languages for wide viewing..Thanks to Sainath sir and Kunal 👍👍
I learned many new thing from this video, so thankyou Mr.P.Sainath and Mr.Kunal for bringing real intelligent and rational thinkers on your platform .
Its would be great if you continue this series ,our youth really need to listen and understand people like him, Kannan, Yengde etc. Bcz youth is being hearded by the political propaganda which will lead them no where but worshipping them and then we shouldn't expect from the youth that someone will bcm Bhagat Singh and stand up and raise voice against the Politicians, filthy policies and Violation of constitution and law.
So for the sake of brushing up mind of youth please continue this series with intelligent, radical, revolutionary great people.
Thankyou Mr.Kunal Kamra
Superb just superb! Enriching, inspiring and humbling!
I m mesmerized by this conversation.. thank you Kunal for this
Kunal an excellent interaction with Mr. Sainath. Very refreshing and enlightening, thank you for it. Sainath is a great journalist and a great historian as well. Loved every bit of it.
One of the best videos I have watched on TH-cam. Bring such guests to your show Kunal, We are proud of you.
i love that kunal has stopped being lazy and embraced the thing he is most popular for…would love to see Vandana Shiva on this
Listening to P Sainath is consistently motivating. When I first heard him speak in 2013-2014 at the University of Hyderabad, he shared an important message that stuck with me: BJP is equivalent to congress plus cow. It's crucial that we shift our political discourse away from unnecessary topics such as Congress vs BJP, India vs Pakistan, Hindu vs Muslim, or National vs Anti-national and instead focus on rural vs urban and rich vs poor🤧
agree with u....and more importantly the concept of "discussion without biases and bigotry/ego " shd take the centre of society..basically open minded/liberal approach.
Anyways, dont see it happening anytime soon considering the limited rationality we indians have due to social conditioning...quality education on large scale may do the job but then how will corporate/politicians fool public?
So this scheme will never come from govt part...
P. Sainath sir is a true journalist and a legend who has enlightened us with his vast knowledge and experience ❤
Kunal…10billion minimum should be the number of views of these episodes of yours and I wish this becomes the beginning benchmark that only keeps on rising for these kinds of episodes.😊
So rich in philosophy and information needs to rewatched many times. Thank you Kunal for this.
Brilliant at all levels!! thanks for bringing P Sainath !
One of the best interviews I've ever seen. I'm so spellbound. The authenticity and the sheer passion is so inspiring.
Sending a big thanks to Kunal for making such an amazing video. Please keep creating more videos like this. ♥️🌼
Thanks Kunal for bringing such intellectuals and great guests. I have took a lot of learning from his one. Mr. P. Sainath if you are reading this a very heartfelt thank you and best wishes for what you are doing.
Thank you kunal ...you are doing the great job for us the Indians❤
What a mesmerising person his is! I heard about him but didn't listen him . Salute you sir
@KunalKamra plz know that u are appreciated more than u can ever imagine.
Thank u 4 inviting this gem of a person & making an effort to teach people real history which is not even taught in the best of schools.
& now that history is being rewritten 2 suit some people’s narratives; I pray & hope more & more people find this & share it with others.
Thank u.
God bless u.
Kunal, you're doing a great service to the people of India. What Mr Sainath truthfully conveys is invaluable information for ALL Indians. THIS MUST SEE A TRANSLATION considering the political dispensation's recent tampering with History!
Such interesting discussion with statistics and sources being cited ... Blessed to catch up live ...
The people watching your videos are genuinely interested in our country's history and the actual heroes. I watch it for the same reason. The country is deafened by the noise of corporate media which silences the call of heroes like him.
Every intellectual convention is not completed without dr. Ambedkar
👏👏👏🙌🙌
Many many thanks for video on Farmer.
It is almost 12 yrs
And Mr Sainath still keeps me engaged.
Kunal don't have much to converse,but he patiently sits and listen
This is definitely among the best 3 episodes I have seen in all these years. It changes perspective about a lot of things.
This ep and the stories about the actual great women and men of our country has moved me to tears...
This video is perfect fodder for essays and descriptive writing in UPSC RBI NABARD.
The video is poetic and eye-opening for me.
Sometimes you have no words.. Wow! All I can say is that I am buying 30 copies of this book, 'The Last Heroes' tomorrow to gift & distribute among my colleagues at office.
Ordered the book. Thank you for this episode.
Thank you, than you , thank you so so so much P. Sainath sir and Kunal kamra. I am from the west bengal district of purulia. Born , brought up, studied.. my native, motherland. Felt so proud today.
A common saying goes "Garibo ke naath, P. Sainath". Those who read his book "Everybody Loves a Good Drought" knows why he is called by this name. Superb! Thanks Kunal! Thanks P. Sainath!
How great a host Kunal is, like the title of the show he'd just ask questions and shut up. How important is that to allow us, the audience, to hear uninterrupted trains of thought.
every time i watch each one of ur episodes .. there is if not more atleaest one moment when the thing/icident /idea being talked about does not give me goosebumps ...
u r doing a great job
What an amazing podcast. Spelled with his words, might be the best ep ever. Keep moving forward Kunal, we understand it's tough but very few source of light left to look upon in these tough times in the country.
P Sainath ♥️
Pleasant to listen to such an honest conversation... His book everyone loves a good drought is an incredible book on rural india!! India needs such inspirational personality
My great grandfather died right when he was released from jail, he was there in jail for 2 years for holding tricolor in a British congregation as a sign of protest. He was brutally thrashed by the British and eventually succumbed to his wounds. I love and respect my great grandfather and he's from whom I derive my essence and inspiration of freedom, independence, democracy and the urge to do something for the country where I'm virtuous to be born in. 42:30
I have been following Sainath sir since 2013 and proves he is a treasure for rural India and agriculture. If his research reaches every person, the people's wrong mindset on farmers and rural peoples will definitely go away.
One of the finest interviews we have ever been experienced on any platform❤❤❤👌👌👌👍👍👍🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏💐💐💐❤❤❤
i am living in SATARA city currently, Krantisinh nana patil was one of fighter who started Patri Sarkar or Parallel Gov.
Have no words.
Thanks P. Sainath and Kunal for your work.
best episode so far, so good to see such legends being bought to limelight
Thank you Kunal 🙏
I had watch a speech by Sainath Sir long ago during college days which was recommended to us by our teacher. Recently re-watched it again because of its relevance.
Can you please mention the speech of here
@@ramadhiee th-cam.com/video/Gj-K7hpsdKw/w-d-xo.html
Thank you P. Sainath for being gracious while explaining and answering such imperative questions.
This episode is so powerful. Thanks for making it and please continue doing this good work.
Am I the only one who feels like this country doesn't feel like home anymore 💔😅
It's always been apathetic and dystopian for the poor. We grew up upper/middle class and were insulated from these stories or realities. Now we have grown up and seek and and experience truths from all aspects and it doesn't fit our nostalgic viewpoint.
Its a sign that you are maturing if the truths make you uncomfortable. The question is what do we do about it
@@sanjotdalvi4195 very true..
P.Sainath has inspired my education journey and his stories continue to question and push you to do the right thing
Just want to say, thank you for such a vigilant and "transparent" debate which does opens up the possibility to learn real history, along with creating the sphere to visit and learn by ourselves. Thanks Kunal
Thankyou for bringin sensible people back to your videos Kunal! Loved this one!
Thank you Kunal for doing the important work of capturing all this information in video format.
My respect to Sainath sir and you.
You guys are the freedom fighters of this era.
This is one of the if not the best episodes of Shut up ya Kunal. We need more academics and thinkers like these!
Thank you Kamra for this great opportunity. I feel proud that I'm from Purulia which he mentioned several times.
What an articulate man. The precision and the passion with which he speaks is worth admiration. My idea of freedom struggle and freedom fighters has changed altogether.
The most striking thing I learned in a while is the difference between independence and freedom. What an enriching conversation!
What's the difference i still can't get it
Thank you Kamra for arranging this discussion...I'm glad you are born and are present in these times in order make everyone aware of the existence of these super legends
Love to watching all of your episodes. Thank you KUNAL.
Sainath is a dying breed of journalists....rooted to the ground
Mr. Sainath is an awe-inspiring man! Thank you for this episode
What an knowlegable man... for us he was a 2 mark qs in enterance examination...but today i got to know man behind PARI