ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 พ.ย. 2019
- Air Pollution in Delhi vs Beijing: Beijing has turned around its pollution graphs. What was once the world’s number 1 most polluted city, has now come down to the 122nd most polluted city in the world. Here’s what Delhi can learn from it, says Divyani Rattanpal
Support The Quint's independent journalism. Become a member now: bit.ly/2mE6B8P
__
Check out The Quint for more news: www.thequint.com
The Quint in Hindi: hindi.thequint.com
For more videos, subscribe to our TH-cam channel: bit.ly/2aIcith
You can also follow The Quint here:
Facebook: bit.ly/1RXYIg5
Twitter: bit.ly/1tjFuxI
Instagram: bit.ly/1Piyc18
PM Modi didn't give a single statement regarding pollution.
Because it's not connected to nationalism, pakistan or kashmir... Stupid
@@souravdas-zs4qq true
12th jaise taise paas ho gya hoga hoga. Factor of population and resulation, various measures to control the pollution. Ye sb pr padhe likha log bol sakte hai, chondumal nhi.
@@souravdas-zs4qq well I wish those topics helped us in breathing fresh air.
Oh well said hmm aaj me samiha svachh bharat abhiyaan kejriwal ne introduce kiya tha tabhi delhi walo ne do baar vote dekar jitayaa. Smart delhi people...
Svachh bharat abhiyaan( isme sirf jhaadu,pochha nahi ata air pollution bhi ata hai) . 😅
People blaming the government while driving their private cars and dumping the waste on streets knowing that it will be burnt by someone... Irony
Law needs to be strict just like traffic laws
Exhaust from vehicles contribute to less than 5% of the world's population....
The main reason for pollution in delhi is the crop burning by farmers of haryana and punjab
The government can create awareness programmes more and more about cleanliness and sanitation.
The government can impose heavy duty fines for irresponsible garbage disposal thorough various forms and deal with offenders strictly.
The government should provide better ways of disposing waste.
There are hardly any dustbin available in many cities.
There is a lot of drainage problem in many cities.
There is a lot of human feces and animal feces on the roads and streets (which is really a disgusting thing and foreigners mock us a lot for that) which is due to unchecked animals roaming freely on the roads and also uneducated people.
While the central government can't do everything on it's own, it certainly can do A LOT rather than focusing on the useless issues.
Toh kya cycle chalaye
@@suhridguha2560 first go n get a name
If kejriwal cut the car purchase, nirmala sitaraman will blame him for slowing of automobile industry 😂😂😂😂
Waise 2018 me bola to tha air purification tower bna rhe hai dekhte hai
@Mansi Chandra delhi me bjp nhi hai bhai 😂😂
What a punch man...🤣🤣🤣🤣
Hats off..✌️
Modi should do it
😂😂😂😂
Comparing Beijing to delhi in terms of global city is like comparing Adidas to abibas ....what China has achieved cannot be achieved by India in 100 years
Bro It is like comparing Democracy with Autocracy. In Democracy 100 people are working, so it will take time to see the result. You'll see now china is already slowing down and india is slow right now but in future (or next 5 years) you'll see what India is truely capable of.
@@rishabhg6120 are you still sleeping 90 percentage of our mobiles are Chinese and many products we use are made in China and people like you are dreaming that India will be super power
@@bollinamohansatyabalakrish2076 well said . I guess he is some bhakt
@@rishabhg6120 We should thanks to chinese because of them we are able to use smart phones otherwise we would be using nokia 1100
@@pathaksmokes he's right u idiot even we studied that in dictatorship decisions can be taken fast and implemented
1:55 thank me later
MOHAMMED SADATH aasholes like you are responsible why this country is governed by an idiot group
Thanks bro.. saved a lot of time
😂😂😂thanks bro
abhishek sharma I am sorry for that.take care
@@abhisheksharma8515 what's wrong? he directly came to the point not bushing around first.
20 years back Beijing photo😂😂....the bird nest stadium was build for Beijing Olympics 2008....you just any how show the news and people blindly like it because you are insulting our own 😂😂😂
True!
Exactly.
Quint is too busy critising everything related with BJP. They don't know pollution is long term affect of steps taken by Congress in 2008-09
China is the biggest contributor of pollution in the world.
You might be right about Quint and Congress, but we cant deny the fact that we have pollution...
Let's not politicize this issue and battle this as a united country.
Instead of pointing fingers, we, as the citizens of this country, can try our best to limit our use of industrial technology
And THEN, when Delhi will be doing BETTER than Beijing, we can go back to pointing fingers 😂
Our country is busy in building statues
And changing names of cities
And banning food and things😴
Yes, we should adopt autocratic government.
Abi agar car ka quota 100000 kar deya gov ne tho tum sadko par utar aaoge.. AUTO INDUSTRY slow down kar di PM ne.. Gdp slow hoo gaya..
Fine bada dege tho bhi rote rate rahoge..
Kuch bhi karlo rona band nai karoge.
@@amitjain8108 the reason for pollution is burning off the leftover in punjab and haryana. The government has not taken a proper action. Moreover we just can't blame them. It has to start from us
Our politicians are so much illiterate that they even dont know how to fix this problem 😥
Arvind kejriwal is from IITK
and his son got admission in IIT DELHI
@@shanky_san1220 son in iit delhi ?
Konsi news dekhta h be
Kaushal Grover wahi toh problem hai na news bas modi ki godi ke bare mai jaanti hai
Kaushal Grover kejriwals’ son is in IIT delhi along with him there is one more kid who was not financially strong to take IIT coaching
But he got a rank in a exam and was given IIT level coaching at very low cost
And guess what?
That guy scored better marks than kejriwal’ son
Pls dont blame politicians we also responsible for that
For a model like Beijing to work in India you need a strong single party government and if that happens Quint will be the first saying democracy is in danger
@SKULLGAMINGYT not possible.
@SKULLGAMINGYT sorry bro. Democracy fails.
If that party is the BJP then democracy is definitely in danger.
@@uditpatwardhan😂😂
BJP rocks
@@uditpatwardhanexplain how?
It's very easy to blame it on the politicians!
1. Start carpooling (India's population is so high that this will have a major effect.)
2. Stop burning dry leaves and waste.
3. Dispose your waste properly.
4. Make pollution papers of cars compalsary and heavy punishment if not renewed or made.
5. And lastly stop screaming that government should do everything because that'll cut your noise pollution significantly!
Bird's nest stadium was built in 2007.
"This was Beijing 20 years back"
Lololol
Exactly lol
😂😂😂😂😂
True, but that's the only message you took from it? Priorities?
@@arpit4m I'm a Delhi resident my dude. And I live with a practical mind. None of this is going to be applied in Delhi. What needs to be done is curb on the rampant construction, potholes and broken roads, continue with Odd-Even, and push the industry out to the outskirts. Large air purifiers can't work in Delhi. And also it's not about priorities. I'm not interested in watching a poorly researched or edited video.
Exactly
BJP ministers have even denied the problems like pollution and severe water scarcity on a TV interview.
SAB CHANGA SI
What is delhi cm doing???
@@vampirexalpha he cant do anything about people burning fields in Punjab.
Nobody dude just shut up. Every time the discussion on pollution arises,you guys are so quick to put the blame on haryana and punjab. Like do you even know the amount of pollution delhi produces by itself? Various reports this year clearly said that not more that 25% of the total pollution in Delhi was caused by activities of neighbouring states. What about the other 75%? So work your ass off and do your homework. Particularly punjab is doing well each year in controlling the pollution during harvesting period, which cannot be dragged to zero immediately consider the support we get from central and state governments.
@@simranpreetsingh4195 Which reports are you pointing to? Can you link them?
Also Punjab and Haryana *were* doing a good job controlling harvesting a few years ago but nothing recently. And even when they *were* trying the results weren't there.
(Source, if you're curious: indpaedia.com/ind/index.php/Crop_stubble_burning:_India)
By the way, I don't know which Whatsapp msg you referred to when you made the 25% argument but here's a reality check
www.indiatoday.in/india/story/delhi-air-quality-aqi-pollution-smog-stubble-burning-haryana-punjab-1614888-2019-11-01
So instead of attacking people online with no basis whatsoever I suggest you follow your own advice and do your homework first.
I am a non-smoker smoking 50 cigarettes a day.
Isse accha hai try kar hi lu cigarette. Smoke toh jaa hi raha hai
50 cigarettes when AQI is at the peak (which is few seconds)
Bhai ganja pi
... Usse cigrate ka asar Kam hota h
Same Bhai main bhi non smoker hi hun Kya faida😒
Fukna suru kar de bhai
At least cigarettes have filter
Unfortunately this won't happen in India, the government is too corrupted
And people too..
Don't blame government for people polluting the surrounding, if government implies restrictions again people blame government for that too, stop blaming others and rectify your mistake
BJP is busy in making money " bharat petrol and bsnl " so sorry want help look for some other option jai bjp jai rss
Delhi is run by AAP party
@@rishabhg6120 delhi toh pakka sudhar ho jayega par gobar patra jaise neta ke baje se up , haryana ,punjab nahi suderega
Stop blaming bjp all the time
WTF 20 years ago there was no “bird’s nest” national stadium in Beijing. You have a poor team of cross checking facts, do admit that Quint.
In democratic country it is way too harder to execute any decision 😂
Why it Neta in delhi only.. What about the rest... Its everyone responsibilty. Govt should come up with hard measures and well planed policies. Its the responsibilty of state, center and the general public. Demand for your right....
Thing is Indians are very lazy. We bicker and complain but do nothing on our own..
Beijing also implemented electric vehicles. Point to be noted
That is just a tiny fraction of what else China has achieved. Go to any animated stats video on TH-cam and just take a look at China's sudden rise to number one position out of nowhere..
And Beijing is autocratic(well it is), Delhi is democracy
Quint I appreciate your efforts to spread awareness about air quality index. I, the youth of India, promise you to make my best efforts to improve the air quality of my town.
"We are small but strong" " Jai Hind🇮🇳"
Beijing did not achieve this only because of its government , they are chinese people and are very patriotic. They put country first above everything else. They don’t have religions they only worship there country. I’ve been in china for 4 yrs now and the biggest festival I’ve seen them celebrating is their national day , they have a full week off just to celebrate their national day, that has created a level of respect in every citizen for their country, removing all religions and putting country first
Sabse बड़ा SOLUTION ye h ki ghar me air sirf air purifier se hi आए isse ghar me insects problem permanently solve और घर के बाहर जाए toh ya तो air purifier वाली car me जाए or air purified public transport ya n95 mask lga kar जाए, ghar ke garden me charo taraf surplus tress and plants toh waha Beth सकते हैं they are natural purifiers.
Our netas doing something like this ? Maybe in dreams .
No no no.. we will keep comparing ourselves with Pakistan but not china...
Your percapita is 19k Pakistans is 15k comparable how on earth can u compare to China with 7K percapita
Let's compare Indian democracy with China, are you ready?
@@ExMuslimProphetMuhammad bhai kuch hadh tak tumhara point thik h lekin we enjoy more freedom than those countries
@@VaidyatheDr you guys dont want to really talk about "progress" in terms of living standard for people across the country .....then there comes the old cliche "democracy" when neighboring China name is mentioned....(fact of the matter is they dont want a comparison with India, )
At the same time there are so many countries in the world which is not democratic but still have a descent living standard better than India....
and Indian Democracy now looks like someone said ..."Democracy consists of choosing your dictators, after they've told you what you think it is you want to hear."-while we sit and think about other people what they are thinking, our neighbor is developing to the extend that the once mighty American Empire has started noticing their progress......
We can also contribute some efforts to this by just using electricity as less as we can. Using our vehicles(or atleast more public facilities like metro,bus)as less as possible for transportation
Quint : Delhi should learn from Beijing.
Also
Quint : govt can't say us what to do what not to its our decision, they're the killer of democracy.
They want everything whithout giving even one percent of their privileges... 😂
Discipline dedication commitment among humans is all it takes to make this world a better place.
Give stats. How many cars in Delhi? What was this, an opinion price or news?
Netas are not here watching your video, they are at home busy scratching their belly and counting notes.
In India everything everything is a shame compared to other competing countries. Pollution, corruption etc... Embarassing and annoying to live in India. No wonder why so many fight to get out of this country ASAP.
I thought Quint will tell us all the good measures Beijing took but it was all just emotional drama
"If Beijing can, you give Delhi clean air too. But for that you have to work really hard."
Bjp playing politics on pollution
Whereas kejriwal is very serious about pollution but no support from Punjab haryana up chief minister
And 60 % pollution is due to these 3 state
So trueee
He can install air cleaning towers instead of blame game..he wasted billion dollers on free water free bus and metro service to women and what not...in all that money he could have installed thousands of towers to clean the Delhi air like heaven...but looks like your asthma patient don't want to work
And still Delhi economic budget is on rise ( Doubled)
Better he could have utilized 3000 cr on statue 🤣
all the cities in india will have this problem soon
Not just this...delhi needs to learn in the aspect of women safety as well.
No we indian strongly believe in blaming politics...
Gomatha expells tons of oxygen from it's back . India need more cows in every street .Gomutra has enzymes that will purify Indian roads of pollutants . After extracting Gold from Gomutra we should air drop the leftover Gomutra in Delhi.
Beijing should start insulting and criticising Delhi.
That would work.
Delhi is one of the best places to visit in winter season, but that's when the air pollution is at its worst. Hopefully a solution can surface soon enough to tackle this
Man you don't even know the major cause of pollution in delhi😂😂
You just saw beijing had a dip in pollution and rushed to make a video lol
Wait See Beijing now
Comparing Cow with dragon?
And the sarcastic comment award goes to......
@Be_with_ Me isi comment ki samne aneki baad sawal to banta hi hain............ 😅😅🤪🤪
T SANJAY RUCHI we are happy to be cows rather than dragon.Atleast people in my country are not treated like animals
@@sahilmalik8826 UP me jao bhai saab waha ladkia se jada safe to cows hain!
But Delhi's pollution is now a big Dragon isn't it ?
Delhi requires around 50-60 huge smog towers due to clean the air which would cost around 200 crore annually including mantainanace but Kejriwal won't do it. He is happy giving everything free. Electricity free, water free, bus free so take pollution free too.
1:31 that's a picture of Shanghai not Beijing lol
It's not only for Delhi but also for each India's metro city....precaution measures should take for each metro city
Bro i leave in Jalandhar we have the cleanest clear bright blue air as fuck but only in summer in winters air becomes dark and smoggy.
As an American who has to deal with the government denying climate change and pollution in my own country as we currently have an idiot as a president, I am deeply saddened by this current situation and I hope that we can all just work together. Please don’t argue. It starts with you. Don’t wait for the government or other people to do something. Or innocent people will die and continue to die. Your families, your future, your planet, and the next generations will suffer. This is problem all around the world.
Problem with clean energy, cost money to build renewable energy, cost money to replace gas cars with EV, and India needs economic growth that causes more pollution.
Problem is that the people who make these , they also travel to there home or commute by vehicles but wont other people to travel by public transport rather than they shoul also try to figure it out rather than comparing with the other countries or haan not to forget the ac that is on while shooting the vedio
If the government puts a limit on the cars that people can buy, everyone will come out and start blaming them for the downfall in auto sector, hypocrites
Bitter Truth, the wealthy and highly educated people would slowly leave India for countries with better environment and HDI. It's already happening that government of India wouldn't publish the total number of people renouncing their citizenship.
What will they do if they stopped them from entering in next 20 years Every developed country will start giving preferences to only their residents
@@dheerajnagraj8683
There will always be countries for Indians to migrate to in mass.
I’d love to see the government rationing new car registrations in Delhi or any other major city and the Quint making another video about it criticising the new policy and it’s impact on the already struggling economy cause that’s what it’s all about 🤷🏾♂️
The tragedy here is that in India we never learn from history/past. 😔
Video starts at 1:58
Seriously!
There is no point in making comparisons of communist gov and democratic gov.
Our so called netas might bring new policies for improvement of air pollution but normal citizens most of them don’t follow it and finds loop hole to escape the law.
So it should start from the home first.
Families should be strict and should have a positive approach towards this issue instead of being in comfort zone and putting the blame on the govt.
Stop blame game , reasoning , pointing out defaulters and start taking measures immediately
It is really sad to breathe smoke in place of air...
The cars problem is a tough one. Our public transport is a joke. We need some mindbreaking improvements in Public transport and accessibility to drastically change the picture of roads now.
as a science student I studied about this subject... PEOPLE day
India is a great Country...It's this it's That
........
Bit still IT is illeterate.....
We want cars to show-off
We are more educated in making tiktok rather than trying to study about aur environment
We say but they do NOT do
We are least bothered to plant a tree
But more bothered to take a new house and live there.....India has world's second MOST population control your needs.....
_As a school student I can't do more but Just plant a tree Please do whatever you want to save our country_
Save it for our future Generations...
Thank You.💜
You can't ban anything just to get rid of it.... we need solution
we do not need to skip the question....
What will you tackle- Delhi, Gurgaon, Ghaziyabad, Noida, Agra, Kanpur, Lucknow....all are world's most populous cities. Pollution is from the people, by the people and for the people.
It's going to be hard for India to cut down on burning coal. Meanwhile burning of crops can be reduced...
Weather is also not permitting in Delhi
After working with Environmental consultancy i understood that .. Government paid to not do any thing aginst industry.. if we do something the industries going to be close. Thts sad reality. 😕
A great message to the Indian netas
Delhi is prone to temperature inversion due to its geographical location. It is inevitable and lot of aspects have to be looked into closely.
Coming to the implementation of reforms our leaders simply aren't keen on doing so as cleaning the air cannot be monetized
Did you show bird's nest stadium Beijing 20 years back and now? I don't think bird's nest stadium existed 20 years back
The problem is. We tend to not use Engineering and technology to help us with our crises. We use odd-even rule and what not! I do understand that levels are high. But at the end, you have Engineers, you've got money, ask them to create such devices which suck in the bad air, and purify it. It's a simple concept, with technical challenges (which the engineers can well handle).
It's high time we use Science and technology to help us with our crises. Cutting down on number of vehicles running per day is a temporary solution. Next year, again the SPM rises and again Delhi is in the midst of an issue. And not to mention, the most sufferers are the children. They'll develop issues like COPD at a very early age.
You mean air purifiers for the city
Sorry but current science and technology is doesn't have efficient way to do that
Bird nest stadium of Beijing is built in 2007.
How will you get 20 years ago photo.
Fake video to promote awareness.
Shame on the quient channel
Log hi nhi chahte clean air ,to kaise aaegi
Sahi baat kahi hy tumne. Kyuki log khud vidhi vidhan ka atikraman karty hy.
A tamilnadu guy : I have nothing to do with it
But it's still India.
They have water crisis
HØPE个 VARD nope it's good now
Halsey xxxo but delhi people should take care of it. Because they are living there
We all are hypocrite when we discuss about these kind of topics
People we choose don't do anything and we also just don't do anything. Patriotism in India is just for show however in other countries they actually do something for it. If we actually so respect towards our country there will be change
Appreciating and we all together
Fools keep getting fooled untill they are not treated through their Root...same is here in the comparison
People here are blaming Netas and government. But they are not only to blame upon. Batao aapne kya kiya h aajtak isko sudharne ke liye? Asli galti toh hum sab ki hi hai.
(by not taking our environment seriously)
Video starts at 1.58
A scornful and finger pointing attitude like the one maintained by the anchor towards the government won't get us anywhere. We must consider the fact that China is an autocratic state, and can raze tracts of unauthorized colonies and lockup people for stubble burning on the whim. A practice that India cannot perform
Why do people in India always blame the government for their ill effect? It's the people who are corrupt and the government too. If people are aware and knowledgeable, the government will be better too.
Not properly researched..... You are telling to remove cars from the road like Beijing but also not telling how they overhauled their transport system by using electric vehicles and improving public transport system.... Where in India "bas band karwana ata hai, uski jagha kya chiye kisi ko nahi pata"
Not get your act together it's get your ass together to help fight pollution
1:58 solution
Start at 2.00
How can we forward these thoughts to state or central government?...these ideas seriously need to go further for implementation and not stuck to this TH-cam platform only...Well done Girl.
Internet can do anything bro you should tweet this
@@modiji3394 I m not on twitter bro..but I can try it on other social media platforms..I hope someone who is actually on twitter can do this for us.
@@swarnimsaxena9445 effort never goes unnoticed if one has the ability to never give up
India super power by 2020!
The Beijing National Olympic stadium that you showed in the starting stating it was 20 year ago, was actually built in 2008 which is 11 years go. Please don't distort facts.
That image of polluted Beijing was 10 years ago, not 20..
Actually, I hope that doesn't ever happen.
This is india,if the existing government does that, People would protest,here people want freedom for every bit of pollution they can do.
The opposition starts nagging the government if any such srict actions are taken!
Wait. That's the olympic stadium. It didn't exist 20 years back.
"Out of 10 cars we only use 4" 😂😂 that's a Delhiite for you, will mever grow up
Actual video starts at 2:00
Building the world's largest air purifier is not the solution for air pollution 😕
We should not blame the government for this
Another Bjakt spotted
That stadium was constructed in 2008 not 20 yrs back
Really we have to come together and government have to take really a huge step
Good job Quint. 💯
Take light.
*But that photo u showed saying "Beijing before 20 years..." That was a stadium constructed in 2008. B!tch whttt??!!*
Hellow people of india and my special request to people of Delhi
Please do something now we are on the edge, it's never too late to initiate something , we have to make sure that our future generations breath In pure air.
If you are still taking this issue lightly, don't forget you are also in the line
"Jab aag lagegi toh sirf hamara hi Ghar nahi jalega"
The government should start thinking about it💔
Everybody has to take maximum steps at their level.
But Anchor should have also compared GDP, Infrastructure and most important lifestyle of Beijing..