@Black Goldyou can't just say anything you want and FYI we also have a lot of immigrants of Rohingya Muslims in Assam, West Bengal and Jammu & Kashmir, around 40,000 for the numbers
2010 Indian census registry stated there's over ten 10 million Muslims and four 4 million illegal immigrants from Bangladesh in Assam State in North-East. Nepal & North-East India used to be a land of Chinese looking Asiatic indigenous Native people, but now they have became minority on their own beloved mother land as South Asians took over. You are next, Myanmar!
Its more horrifying when these people think that name calling (its very hard to be polite to people wanting genocide on others) is a bigger sin than actual genocide and rapes. No joke. They also call these reporting as leftist media * facepalm *. The level of their humanity is in the negatives... Edit: Oh yeah, see that guy Xino Fiero at the bottom there? In another thread here, he just compared himself as being more poor compared to the Rohingya aka the people who are suffering from genocide to poor health conditions (dying from diarrhea) or suffer from human traffickers (held for ransom otherwise torture or death). @imgamerful Oh really? Come up with the numbers 1st instead of imaginary numbers that you think everyone can see.
no western media outlet will ever speak on kashmiri pandits issue. leave western ones ever saw indians talking about it. just imagine the outrage by left wingers if it was done by hindu or rss
It's one of the poorest, most densely countries in the world and she opens up while rich American and European countries whine about there not being enough space or food for a few thousand.
4zap7 myanmar is actually one of the asias biggest natural gas exporter, also they've been exporting petroleum since 1850's.. So it is Infact a very rich land @@
Depends. Is the current government selling oil to the US at a favorable rate and do these events affect oil production? If the answers are yes and no respectively then we'd probably sell them better weapons so they can kill people more effectively. Case in point: Saudi Arabia
The point still stands 50% of settlement burned is still a Government failing to protect people who are supposed to be within their jurisdiction - don't nitpick his words just because some schools allowed students who can't recall half of their lessons to succeed, since he did say it was all the schools he attended not all school or schools in general People these days...
@Emagination Productions its not about the religion, culture or history. we are sentient, progressive, and limitless. no matter how we change or remove our religion, culture or history nothing happens if people not, Its about us, if everyone can just be good nd do what is must..
Religion is just a belief, any belief has no solid proof, so if people are provoking people with their belief and the other side fights back then ultimately it was the provoking side's fault to begin with.
'Anglos caused most of the world's problems' (David Cameron, British Prime Minister, 2010-2016). Anglo caused centuries-long notorious global - - Slavery, - Colonialism, - Colonization, - World War I, - World War II, and the list goes on.
As a Malaysian, now we know why Myanmar did the Rohingya ethnic cleansing. Its not about religion. I'm Muslims myself and I despise their actions and attitudes.
@Travel 4k They don't care about people who gave them refuge. In Bangladesh lots of bangladeshi gave rohingya's shelter when they arrived here after persecution. Rohingya's are now threatening those bangladeshi life savers. Crime rate in Cox's bazar increased like 10 times after they arrived here. Our tourism sector, world's longest sea beach Cox's bazar is heavily damaged by them. Rohingya's have to go back to Myanmar as soon as possible.
Pisslamic Rapepublic of Porkistan oh my god. so all rohingya people are just bad? Maybe a couple have a bad attitude but there’s got to be good ones. I live in the US and is of Bangladeshi descent and I felt for those people. I had no idea they acted like that.
I am Indonesian. This is why Indonesia is not fond of them either, Their boats had been ping ponged between Indonesia and Malaysia because no one would take them in. The UN finally convonced Indonesia to take thousanfs of them in a promise that UN will find the third countries to take them in as Indonesia isn't part lf the refugee receiver nations. That is the last i heard about them.
As a Shan or as a minority in Myanmar, it is just so sad to see that the international only recognizes the case between Rohingyas and the Military. The latter was and is still causing violence in other minority states like Kachin, Kayin and Shan. The Military of Myanmar is the common enemy of both majority (Burmese) and all minorities. They've destroyed many lives and futures for their own good.
The Karen are a people native to the region. Not an Indian people imported by the British for act as their enforcers. What happens the the Karen people is very wrong. What happens to the "Rohingya" is the right course of action.
@Stark Industries Same here in Malaysia, last year the Rohinyan started a protest demanding citizenships, the right to votes and the right to start a political party. I think they forgot that we brought them in as refugees. We gave them shelter, food, water, electricity and now this is how they repay us.
Amad C Everything happens with a reason , it doesn't matter whether it was how/why the conflict started , retaliation , cruelty etc. Ironically , all those behaviour is what makes us human and butchering each other has been happening since recorded history.😔
EccoBabeTV As much as I want them to, unfortunately they can't. They are impoverished and do not have the necessary arms to do so. Plus, they are going against a military force.
As a Burmese let me tell you about the other side of the story. The military took control over the country in the name "national stability". During the military rule, they attacked not only the Rohingyas but also some ethics groups like Karen, Shan, and Arakanese. They have oppressed the Burmese citizens that they don't want to know what's beyond their world. The lack of internet access in Rakhine region makes it hard for the Burmese to know about this case. Also the tension between the Burmese and Arakanese causes problems for the Burmese media to go there. Because of that, the news about this has become one-sided. That gives the military an advantage that the current government would be blamed for that because of "the government controls the military" thing. The military doesn't listen to the government and they are still in charge of the country. In fact, the chief of defense staff is a remnant of the former Military Government. He got his position because of "if you want it, then you get it" thing. He can even de facto elect himself for his position. The Burmese government has to rule the country with the military's constitution (2008 constitution). Before 2016, they altered some laws to prevent Aung San Su Kyi from becoming the president. So the government had to ignore the military doings, waiting to reform the military in their second term and having to ignore the criticism regarding this case. TL;Dr: The military is the problem and they are trying to sabotage the government by any means. *Extra info*: It is also claimed/exposed that the Rohingyas are said to be Bengali people brought to the country and given "white cards" and the rights to vote by the military-backed party so that they could cheat in elections (2010 and probably 2015). So, this "ethnical cleansing" could be "getting rid of the evidence" and "an opportunity to sabotage Aung San Su Kyi's government".
@Stark Industries The Military Party deliberately call them Bengalis. It is still unclear, to the Burmese people, on the origin of the Rohingyas. Some claimed that they wanted recognition that they're a different ethnic group because they are just seen as Arakanese, some claimed that they didn't get on well with the Arakanese so they were just "pushed". I could see them as part of Myanmar's ethic group as Arakan was formerly multiethnical. I just hope that the government could settle the situation with those people when the military junta ends.
@Stark Industries The Military is not as strong as they were back then. They would need to rule the country via the party they founded (like in 2010-15) as the world has known about them. The Democratic government has made better development than the entire military regime in 5 years. This upcoming election is also kinda a bit of a problem because: 1. It's during the pandemic and they can't postpone it (if they postpone, the military will be ranting about it) 2. Instead of 2 major parties, there are now four (or three) 3. There is a risk in developing ethnical tension against Bamar people. But the Democratic party has full support throughout it's history and it has won in all elections held. The main challenge of the democratic government is replacing the constitution written by the military. In the parliament, 25% of the seats are assigned to the military personnel (no matter what the government is), which makes the problem more difficult. In presidential election, the military "representative" elects one of the two vice-presidents. They would take a long time to remove the military out of the parliament and they can finally operate as a true government. Edit: So technically people will be voting for 75%, instead of all seats of the parliament. And since there has been cities being shut down from election due to conflicts by the military, the seats are lost from the 75%. So, if there isn't a landslide victory, the military will decide who would become the president and what the winning party is. It's up to the people to give the Democratic party a landslide victory.
@@anxskhxn Aung San Su Kyi has also said that she would give them Burmese citizenship. However, due the immigration law the Rohingyas do not meet the criteria. So the government needs to change that law and she can grant them citizenship.
Salute,brother! I was about to explain and read through the comments. Our country and the relagion has been a game,played the media and former- military government over the decades. Well-explained!
Nick, that's complete garbage. Problems are caused by the people themselves and it has nothing to do with the Brits. You clearly don't know anything about history. The Brits didn't colonize Pakistan or India. Where are these British people? If they had colonize these countries their populations would be in the millions and there are zero Brits in p,I, or Myanmar. What the Brits did was control the sea ways and the leaders of the area alined with the Brits.
bhartley1024 You kinda have to have perspective though. Most of the Orient used to be Hindu-Buddhist. But after arrival of Islamic conquests many peaceful Buddhists were killed, and now Buddhism is a minority religion is Asia. Though obviously not practicing Buddhist teaching, the Burmese people are having a survival immune response to Islam. They fear having thier culture being wiped out by the agressive nature of Islam.
They're basically Isis,israel and the KKK they just ruin their religions' reputation and only take what they like from the religion and add what they want
檀 杏斗 Buddhism is one of the strongest religions out there also China forced the Dalai lama out of tibet I don't see any Buddhists burning Chinese people
It is given for political reasons, not humanitarian on a number of occasions. Do you think Obama, one of the creators of Syrian crisis, deserves to keep Noble Prize after the amount of dead children he's responsible for? It's a farce.
I’m am a son of a victim of Myanmar’s attacks. Not against these people but another kind called “Shan”. My mother and father had to move further and further from Myanmar because they repeatedly attacked them (and others). My parents became refugees in Thailand after multiple years of fearing for another attack. My older brother took matter into his hands and decided to come to the United States. I am grateful for what I have and hope that you, the person reading this comment, is as well. We all suffer, but some suffer more than others.
There are way too many internal conflicts in Myanmar. It's like Afghanistan of the South East. Hopefully Su Kyi will at least be able to bring peace to your people along with Karen, Kayah and other repressed groups. Unfortunately there is no hope for the Rohingya though. They have hogwashed the history of Arakan and put their own version to brand them as outsiders. Maybe they did it for winning over the Rakhines who are also oppressed and have their own militant group.
Tahmeed Tajwar I agree, way too many conflicts within the Myanmar borders. Su Kyi is just way too blind to see that. She says 50% of the villages are okay, but what about the other 50%?
This is what we Muslims also believe my man, how can you follow Islam and kill innocents? There are just crazy brainwahsed people who either enjoy killing or too stupid to know otherwise who justify their murders in the name of religion.
But mohammed was a disgusting human being ..like most muslims you never investigated islam properly,,,,,anyone who does it becomes an ex muslim like me
She won the nobel peace pride because she fought for democracy in myanmar with non violent methods even when the government is trying to suppress her and arrest her for it. There is still a lot to uncover why she has not acknowledged the Rohingya Genocide
as an indian, this is also causing problems in my country because they illegally enter india to escape the genocide, and there are lot of rohingya here too
@@bvc1922 these few thousands will multiply like pigs in future.. Already Northeastern states are facing huge employment problems bcu of Bangladeshis.. There is increase crime of rohingyas in Bangladesh itself they themselves dont want them so why should we?? We have enough problems already.. Let the 57 Islamic countries take them as refugees.
@@bvc1922 bcs it has so many mouths to feed, India is not developed nation like Europe that I can accomodate more refuge and those illegally entering india... And it's not in few thousand it's in millions + crime rate of this community is comparatively very high in India... **Just facts, no hate towards anybody or any community 🌺
@@bvc1922 who TF cares about Boobladesh?? Boobladesh and Rohingyas deserve each other. Even many boobladeshis are living illegally in India. You guys should leave our country. Beggars!
Actual its a racial conflict not a religious conflict The title gives the wrong informations There are also other muslim ethnic groups that lives peacefully with the burmes majority
Unfortunately medias don't show how Maldives and Indonesia became Muslim courtiers but times ago they were 100% Buddhist, Hindu countries. Islam is a threat in every country, especially in Buddhist countries. Fortunately Myanmar acted right.
@@ahuramazda1766 ISIS doesn't represent muslims, Do even know how isis was formed? Or their motives? It's just complex politics And if buddhists are really very peaceful then why jails in thailand, sri lanka are not empty?
Why china is not criticised. They are doing same thing with there Muslim. In Any story you can only become strong by wrong mean and brain. Best example is human and animal. Look what did ham did with animal. There is not lots of difference.
Willie L if you didn't know in 1971 we fought to have democracy and freedom.. It was Pakistan and India who said the country should be divided by religion.. We refused and we got attacked
"Monks, even if bandits were to carve you up savagely, limb by limb, with a two-handed saw, he who reacts with hate or violence towards them will not be following my teaching. Our minds will remain unaffected, and we shall say no evil words. We will remain compassionate, without hostility and without ill will. We shall show them loving-kindness, as we shall show the whole world loving-kindness." --- The Buddha (MN:21)
Lol yes, offer your head willingly to the butchers blade just so you can be "the better person". I hate when people take advantage of the peaceful nature of bhuddists.
Lel and about time too, for how long should the bhuddist suffer under the oppressiveness of abrahamic religions? A shame they didn't do this a thousand years ago, if they formed a resistance then, they wouldn't have to fight their own south asian people who were converted under sword-point. But you are probably a western idiot, who has no interest in history over 100 years ago, so its not like you would understand.
I feel so bad for them, i don't know how to express myself. Like Gandhi said, the world is enough for everything one's need, but not for everyone's greed.
Lol you talk about Gandhi's words? India denied Rohingyas refugee status to escape this ethnic cleansing by putting up a facistic-anti-Muslim bill which not only stop Rohingyas but put in question the legitimacy of Indian muslim citizenship. The world is moving towards theocratic and autocratic dictatorships. A huge Chunk of Southeast Asia is openly Xenophobic. It's disgusting.
@@suryasishtalukdar210 If you care about proper use of tax money, vote for a party who actually cares about expanding the Indian infrastructure. If you wish to pay less taxes in the process.... vote for someone who instead of changing currency overnight and causing chaos..... won't let people jump through hoops to avoid paying taxes.
Three Ministries,Defense,Home affairs,Border, are held by the Commander-in-Chief which meant the military hold three Ministries as power share.Commander-in-chief is the Chancellor of all armed groups in the nation.Aung San Suu Kyi was a State Consellor,which is just a High-rank advisor to the Union Cemtral Government,and who was served for Union Parliament.Actually,she has no power and no ways to save the Rohingya,which is a sad thing.
@@incredibleindians4872 They did a chaos and protes in the street without permit. Our police come and try to stop them. Plus now they demanding for equal with the local. Its all over the news bro... if you are Malaysian. We are in the quarantine states now. We hold all the flight and close border and suddenly they came into our border. Dont respect our rules and enter our country illegally. 90% Malaysian dont want them anymore. We help for those who already in here, but still they demanding and provoking us in social media. When they got caught, they ask for forgiveness (sigh) And again, this is viral in my country. I'm not making up this stories, it is true.. happening in Malaysia. They dont respect us as local, so we start to hate them and ask them to leave.
Man that's brutal! I thought Buddhists were peaceful group Edit: What I meant is I thought Buddhists(including their government) practice non violence very strictly.
buddism teaches peace like all religions which follow the "golden rule" but in the video it states that the government was taken over by a military coup and "promoted fierce nationalism based on the countrys Buddhist identity."
it is so awkward that whenever something happens against Muslim we talk about human rights but we ignored the things these muslin people does to other religious people
Is this a justification u used for rohingya problem ? I feel sorry for anyone that suffered from ethnic and religion conflict but for u, u are not more than animal. U are the ppl that made them suffer, shame on u !!
Thanks Vox for the clear timetable and explanation of the history. As Myanmar is facing crisis right now, and their leader who kept silent and detained as of the moment while the military in charge is known being against the Rohingyas for so long, the worst is about to come to them. I am hoping for peace and better change for everyone in Myanmar despite their diverse ethnicity.
There are literally genocides occurring at any point of time in the last few decades. World leaders are motivated by political expediency not morality.
"They supported the English colonialists back in the 2nd world war". Where are these colonialists now that they are in a difficult position in 2017-2018? As long as a country is a useful pawn to defend yourself against a common enemy, you are fine with this and now that an ally is in difficulty, where are you United Kingdom? Hell are for those who keep their neutrality in time of moral crisis...
They are standing the moral high ground to blame Burma but saying it's none of the business for this crisis. And they always ignore that Burma and Buddhist are the victims.
Ermm, they're dead, it was 60 years ago, and to Intervene would unjustifiable and incredibly expensive, dangerous and time consuming for the British soldiers, who they and their families do not want to go to a far away country to defend against a vulnerable ethnic group vs an entire nations army
@@BlackPanther-ji1bg but army's don't care about an unmilitarised ethnic group which used to be loyal to them, and Britain is already using its supplies in other countries, the last thing they'd want to do is spend even more money to protect a group of people they have no real reason to defend. I think they should defend them, but from the perspective of the prime minister or high ranking general, money is already stretched thin, and it seems like an unnecessary expense
@@jaego24c53 let be practical English colonists used them during the time of difficulties now they don't have any benefits from these people so they don't care .
@@prayagsridhar8833 Do you even know how Sharia law works? Sharia law asks muslims to follow the law of the land they live in. So please don't get your bakchodi here
@@brucewayne1636 there is brother , some instances that muslim should follow law of the nation where they live and in India. Sharia law is made up for only personal law of muslim
There are 57 muslim countries and no one came forward to take care Rohingya muslim people. These muslim countries have vast wealth due to oil money , but they dont spend single penny for muslim refugees , But dozens of money for building mosques in non muslim countries. This is how wealthy muslim treat their muslim refugees. But they let go for christian and buddhist countries. And thereafter critizing enormorously about defects of caring these refugees in those countries, with their MEDIA like al ljazeera , TRT WORLD etc and blame buddhists saying they are extremities. Never MENTION MASSACRE DONE BY rohigya in BURMA.
it won't be a sad thing when Hindus were killed in their own country by muslims. It won't be a sad thing when Pakistan kills Christians and Hindus and Buddhists in their country just because they're non-muslims
www.reddit.com/r/worldnews/comments/725wcn/grave_of_28_hindus_killed_by_rohingya_militants/ See how the "media" makes the headline, and the people's reaction. People are like sheeps going anywhere media want them to go.
Want to send a message? Sign this petition! Take back Aung San Suu Kyi's Nobel Peace Prize www.change.org/p/take-back-aung-san-suu-kyi-s-nobel-peace-prize
itz sotirissman So, you’re basically saying that you don’t care that these people are being persecuted. What I find quite amusing is when specimens like yourself always bring the “but the others did” excuse. Just so your backwards brain knows, this minority hasn’t been linked to any terrorist attacks against Myanmar. You’re against them for the simple fact that they’re muslim, which is a deeply flawed type of logic, ISIS itself using it for propaganda purposes.
Sam Y yeah mine too, then I remembered that they are Muslim and according to Islam religious persecution is actually fine. Yes, discriminatory taxation is persecution and it's not even the only thing they do.
Buddhist are peaceful people and I know personally Buddhist and Muslims, I say that it's not fault of Buddhist, it fault of Jihadi, they will try to impose sharia law in Myanmar, support for Myanmar
They (the rohingyas ) are not immigrants. *Actually these ppl are the ethnic native of this region and are part of myanmar bcz of the British* And because that was their land so the government of myanmar has no right to kick them out, they didnt "come to myanmar ", but they were already there. And indeed this is an ethnic conflict not religious one.
Dzikrina Saira *illegal Immigrants. Rohingyas are never, and never have been an ethnic group of Myanmar. You better check on the crisis with them and Malaysia first, so you will understand why Myanmar faced this.
@@avanibacardi6042 Please re-read my comment. I said that *they became part of Myanmar because of the British* . Back then, British (as the colonialist) divided the region and included them as part of Myanmar, whereas clearly their ethnicity, physical appearance, etc. are more similar to Bangladesh. And FYI, Myanmar used ethnicity as the basic foundation of the nation, which is the Burmese (the majority ethnics) deemed as the national identity. That's why many other minority ethnicities felt like they're being ignored and wanted to separate. And this separatist act made the Myanmar military junta government becoming so hard and repressive toward them. But actually, the real root of the problem is that they're being ignored and lack of welfare.
Dzikrina Saira That is the old time where Myanmar also fought so hard for their Independence Day from the British. Right now, and even after Myanmar got their independence, the group of rohingyas nor Bangladesh has nothing to do with Myanmar. They are never in the ethnic group of Myanmar. If the southeast Asian countries pity them so much, why most of the majority didn’t accept them? Malaysia did accept them and look what happened. The Myanmar government gave them equal rights when they entered, but later their behavior gets worse.
Dzikrina Saira about the minority ethnic groups that you mentioned were being “ignored,” there is always the biggest event in Myanmar for al the ethnic groups to gather and have the most wonderful night, with the music of their culture, and their traditional foods to enjoy. That ceremony was always a huge thing every year. And I for sure would like to inform that there were no Rohingyas or Bangladesh for centuries even during the times where royalty exist in Burma.
Hizkia Willhem I think they're simply dismissing Trump as having a first world problem, throwing a fit over something so small, while a genocide happen halfway around the globe.
Wow, "More than 50% of the villages are intact." Amazing! I don't know how people manage going to work in the morning, and barely burning down any villages. She is quite the humanitarian. May we all strive to be so compassionate.
“Religion is an insult to human dignity. Without it you would have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, that takes religion.” Steven Weinberg was an American theoretical physicist and Nobel laureate in physics for his contributions with Abdus Salam and Sheldon Glashow to the unification of the weak force and electromagnetic interaction between elementary particles.
@@Shrikant_Darade No, they (the rohingyas ) are not immigrants. *Actually these ppl are the ethnic native of this region and are part of myanmar bcz of the British* And because that was their land so the government of myanmar has no right to kick them out. They didnt "come to myanmar " as immigrants, but they were already there. And indeed this is an ethnic conflict not religious one.
@@dzikrinasaira3475 the residence of Rohingyas came to exist only after, Mughal conquered Bengal region ( west Bengal state of India and Bangladesh) .after British came, according to their policy of divide and conquer many religious riots emerged in indian subcontinent and in Myanmar tension between Muslims and Buddhists increased as Buddhists faced persecution during muslim dominance in region in period of Mughals. And current outrage is result of above mentioned reasons. The main reason for hatred of Muslims is due to Islamic extremists who took part in communal activities. In Myanmar there is also hindus but they don't face violence. Also in Nepal Hindu (dominant country) Buddhists feel safe..but Islam face violence and hatred everywhere in world..my intentions was not to hurt your sentiments but, ask yourself what is the history of Islam? (do it as historian not as believer) ,how it spread so fast across world?, What ideologies Maulanas teaches in mosques?, Why Islam is hated by most liberal countries?
There’s nothing beautiful and clean about genocide. Edit- sadly, this genocide is still happening a few years after. Inshallah we can see an end to this horror.
auzzi pepper You realize that you just said that murder and killing people makes thing beautiful. What is wrong with you? In what case would taking a human life be justified
First of all, it is nobody's argument that what has happened to Rohingyas is not condemn-able or even justifiable to say the least. However, given the reality of the Rohingya jihadi secessionist insurgency that has been raging on since 1947 and the murder of many innocent Rakhine Buddhists as well, it is hardly an open and shut case of the persecutors versus the persecuted. There is more to this issue than meets the eye. I fear a horrendously sinister political game at play here (with Buddhist-Muslim tensions a mere spark to light the powder-keg), and somehow the great Sunni Wahhabi Islamic nexus of Pakistan and Saudi Arabia/Turkey/other GCC nations could be directly or indirectly involved. This video clearly omits some important facts about the Rohingyas. They forgot to mention that Rohingyas, who originally hail from the Chittagong region of the East Bengal region (which later became E-Pakistan and now is called Bangladesh), were initially brought in by the British during the Raj to fight the invading Japanese army during WW2 as well as the local Rakhine militia who were allied with the Japanese. They were settled in the Western Burmese region of Arakan or Rakhine state (esp. in it's northern most district of Maungdaw, which borders what is now South Eastern Bangladesh and where they form the majority) and were promised a Muslim state in that region for their belligerent services against the Japanese and the local Rakhine. When the Britishers failed to fulfil their promise, the Rohingyas formed armed Mujaheddin or Jihadi groups against the Burmese Govt. in order to obtain their Dar-al-Islam by seceding from the Dar-al-harb of Burma which was never theirs in the first place. These Rohingya jihadi groups, like RLP, RPF, RSO, ARIF, ARNO and now ARSA (since 2016) were/are being supported by Al-Qaeda/ISIS, Hezbi Islami (Gulbuddin Hekmatyar), Hizbul Mujahideen from Kashmir and Jamaat-e-Islami Bangaldesh and Pakistan's ISI in this 70 year-old civil war in Western Burma which has been going on since 1947 with the independence of the Indian Subcontinental states from Britain. In fact, when Jinnah's Pakistan dream was getting fulfilled by partitioning India, the various Rohingya jihadi groups and political leaders had petitioned Jinnah to annex the Rohingya dominated areas of Northern Rakhine region as part of East Pakistan.
This is what happens when we get to caught up on the sins of people who have been dead for decades. We need to judge people by who their are and do, not their parents or grandparents.
Thank you, Vox, for the detailed timetable and insightful explanation of Myanmar's history. Given Myanmar's current crisis, with its leader detained and the military in control, the Rohingya community faces grave concerns due to the military's longstanding opposition.
lmao awesome response Zhaoxun Yan ...these people are honestly so gullible that they are not so much as questioning that Buddhists ( the most peaceful people on the planet ) are at war with Muslims ( the most violent group for the last 1400 years and whose ideology/religion has literally been forcing submission globally the whole time ) and committing a genocide in this one place ...and yet Muslims are at war on every continent in dozens of conflicts with many religions and we have ACTUAL EVIDENCE of the genocide THEY are committing in those other places ...not just some story by a reporter we've never heard of ...by a news agency who has previously reported things that turned out to be utter bullshit ..and they just eat up the bullshit like its No Calorie Chocolate Cheesecake ..it boggles the mind . I have learned to never underestimate the stupidity of large groups of people with good intentions .
khosrow poor villagers who can barely even afford food are terrorists now? You bigots do not fail at me making me laugh. With your ideology I would say you are quite radicalized and should be on the terrorist watch hmmmm. Supporting a genocide against innocent poor people...
@@Thatguy_3362 first off, I’m Burmese and personally, i have nothing against the Myanmar military. Because no topic should be stereotyped. Every place has good and bad things included. Just because some side of a topic is shown to public doesn’t mean that everyone and everything included in that topic is the truth. People should start to see both the good and the bad of everything . So in conclusion, there is “bad” people and “good”people in the military but that doesn’t make Myanmar’s military stand out or anything because a good and a bad side is some every one and everything has.
Where are the rich muslim countries like saudi arab,turkey,qatar and other muslim countries in this issue and why the so called pakistan is silenced on this issue????
@@muktamalakar5771 the FK lmao they speak out about saudi Arabia and their princes that Saudi demand that Al Jazeera shuts down. They are the non bias maybe learn that before you say anything and this is coming from a Canadian Asian.
Bangladesh , Pakistan and Afghanistan has been doing the same thing to Hindus in those countries for years now. Myanmar doing the same in return for Rohingyas. What goes around comes around..
“As a rule, if a crime is committed by one group against another ethnic or religious group, it is nearly impossible for the perpetrator to punish itself.”
Seriously, the western society has dealt with the genocide trouble this way. Systematically or successfully, they hid what's real inside in the history. Colonization. In the same way, Belgium got away from the responsibility for the tragedy of the Eastern Africa in 1994. This video sucks, rarely mentioning the Britain's specific role throughout the colonization.
"Slavery, Colonialism & Colonization" are all evil things done and benefited by evildoers. Anglo West/Christian Europeans are major participants and benefactors of centuries-long global, - Slavery, - Colonialism, - Colonization worldwide, from North/South America to Australia/New Zealand to Siberia/Far-East Asia.
Rohingyas were living here in Myanmar for a long period of time, in a small amount. However, more and more arrived from Bangladesh illegally, and claiming they were Burmese. They created violence on local Buddhists and Hindus. They went back to Bangladesh because it was staged between them and ARSA to seem it like ethnic cleansing.
Ethnic groups are a scapegoat for unemployment blames. There is a reason that people in western countries despise immigrants because they are supposedly taking all of their jobs and thereby economically disenfranchise the native population.
they never talk about the struggle of anyone who isn't Muslim in Muslim theocratic countries like Saudi or Pakistan or Somalia or Egypt ect i cud go all day naming countries where your life might be at danger just for not being Muslim
Kerbal Space Program youtuber 123 its really shameful.....I mean u hate Muslims because of middle East conditions and attacks of 9/11,try to understand that the issue. Of terrorism is highly political and often used to overthrow govts,how u can can relate it to Islam
the UN does nothing either way, they can't force any country to do anything and they don't have any army of any sort. And the US? well good luck in convincing trump to give out aid to muslims
Kerbal Space Program youtuber 123 Why do you have to hate? As an atheist Turk having Muslim parents and some Christian and Jewish friends all I can say is that I love them and I respect all their religious beliefs. I understand your concerns about refugees and I had the similar ones when over 2 million Syrian refugees came to Turkey. But when you think about it, it's the fault of colonial powers of early 20th century. They left their colonies instantly after WWII, creating authority gaps which leads to formation of terrorist groups or violent behaviours to claim authority. Myanmar and Iraq was British colonies and Syria was a French colony. I am not saying that they wanted these things to happen when they left their colonies, but they could have done it in a better way by establishing governments in which their people can trust and by making this processes gradual rather than instant ones. For the rape situation, I am sorry that these things have happened and I can understand your feelings because I felt similarly when similar things have happened in Turkey. But I now know hatred is not the solution. We should punish rapists by our laws and give secular education to the innocent ones thus they can return to their countries in the future and make them better places. If you think they won't return to their countries consider this: did they want to come before war? Did they want to leave their homes, the places they grew up, the places they fell in love, the places they lived -by all meanings of the word? It's not about nationalities, not about religions, not about politics. It's about humanity. We MUST learn to love each other and respect each other, otherwise we will destroy each other. As Bertrand Russell said: Love is wise, hatred is foolish.
That woudnt happen bro I live in a country where their is no enforcement of minor Our country have highest number of Muslims in world. Except of some, here in India all live like brothers
So it is not myanmars fault they are killing them,burning their house. It is muslim countrys fault why are they not taking refugee. You know what. If something like this starts happening in bangladesh,pakistan,indoneshia against hindus then remember this. Dont blame us. We will say why arent india taking them. According to ur brilliant logic
Sinistait It was not Bangladesh idiot. It was east Pakistan. And then the leader, jinnah refused the proposal and said that he wouldn't provoke Burma's land.
+Sinistait Did you know that in civilised countries (e.g. Thailand), they get rid of the insurgents, and not entire ethnic populations? They also don't go around burning villages to weed out insurgents. That's inhumane and a horribly inefficient tactic. Also, did you know that the Rohingyas aren't the only insurgent group in Myanmar? For a single country, Myanmar has more insurgent groups formed by its minorities than most other countries. See: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_insurgent_groups_in_Myanmar The military junta has been oppressing all of them for decades. The difference is, the rest are citizens of Myanmar, while the Rohingyas have intentionally been prevented from being citizens.
Ummm syu ki is being locked in her own home by the government! Look she was just wettrying to make it better but the government was controlling everything!
I'll tell you one thing. Whenever British left, they left it in strategic violence and tension.
@Black Gold kya ?!! What are you high on ?
@Black Gold I think you are mad
@Black Goldyou can't just say anything you want and FYI we also have a lot of immigrants of Rohingya Muslims in Assam, West Bengal and Jammu & Kashmir, around 40,000 for the numbers
@@AyushGupta-oi4ee india is not involved but yes india always support myanmar govt on rohingya issue
2010 Indian census registry stated there's over ten 10 million Muslims and four 4 million illegal immigrants from Bangladesh in Assam State in North-East. Nepal & North-East India used to be a land of Chinese looking Asiatic indigenous Native people, but now they have became minority on their own beloved mother land as South Asians took over. You are next, Myanmar!
Tsunami - t is silent
Honest- h is silent
Queue -ueue is silent
Ethnic cleansing - un is silent
deep*
Yes
ethic cleasig
The Japanese pronunciation of tsunami is not silent.
Islam - peace is silen-
wait it doesn't exist
Watching some of these people in these comments trying to justify the mass killing of a minority, smh.
clpfox I actually can't tell of you're joking or not, if it's a joke, it's a pretty bad one. It makes you sound extremely immature.
The Junks ... So these young 1-9 year olds are terrorists? nice
Xino Fiero that still doesn't justify the killings of the young children and women..
Kelvin Lee Theyre not a minority when theyre the majority.
Its more horrifying when these people think that name calling (its very hard to be polite to people wanting genocide on others) is a bigger sin than actual genocide and rapes. No joke. They also call these reporting as leftist media * facepalm *.
The level of their humanity is in the negatives...
Edit: Oh yeah, see that guy Xino Fiero at the bottom there? In another thread here, he just compared himself as being more poor compared to the Rohingya aka the people who are suffering from genocide to poor health conditions (dying from diarrhea) or suffer from human traffickers (held for ransom otherwise torture or death).
@imgamerful
Oh really? Come up with the numbers 1st instead of imaginary numbers that you think everyone can see.
Waiting for vox to make a video on uighar Muslim crisis in china or the genocide of Kashmiri pandits.....
Media houses are told with money to what to show them...
no western media outlet will ever speak on kashmiri pandits issue. leave western ones ever saw indians talking about it. just imagine the outrage by left wingers if it was done by hindu or rss
vox already did a video about muslim uighurs
@@SamtasticVids link
Me2
"If we can feed 160m people, we can feed 700 thousand refugees"
Bangladesh's PM is a pretty dope leader, better than most
Dude literally saved thousands of families whilst my country squabbles over a few boat people for years
Australia
when did she say this?
It's one of the poorest, most densely countries in the world and she opens up while rich American and European countries whine about there not being enough space or food for a few thousand.
I love you too
wonder if this happened in an oil rich land , just how different the response would be from a superpower
4zap7 myanmar is actually one of the asias biggest natural gas exporter, also they've been exporting petroleum since 1850's.. So it is Infact a very rich land @@
Raghav batra damn I stand corrected
Depends. Is the current government selling oil to the US at a favorable rate and do these events affect oil production? If the answers are yes and no respectively then we'd probably sell them better weapons so they can kill people more effectively. Case in point: Saudi Arabia
4zap7 sad but true
4zap7
Wait
What if
IT HAS UNTAPPED OIL IN IT!!
"In any school I went to, 50% is a failing grade." 😂😂😂😂 Well said man!
Aveejit Sengupta wut?
In School 50% is not a Fail Grade ...
That man is Feminist ...
Shashwat Verma What are you talking about? 50%=F grade
The point still stands 50% of settlement burned is still a Government failing to protect people who are supposed to be within their jurisdiction - don't nitpick his words just because some schools allowed students who can't recall half of their lessons to succeed, since he did say it was all the schools he attended not all school or schools in general
People these days...
Audie Liem Thank you for making that point. People make up the dumbest excuses ignore this genocide.
Ethnic cleansing is the most disgusting thing to happen
you know UN just lied about this
@madone 05 nah just full of lies
Legitness Daneil name a few lies.
@@stuarthastie6374 search the real rohyngya event
@@stuarthastie6374 you can also blame British for this crisis too
Nobel peace prize winner.....what a joke
Arunan Nachimuthu she was a noble winner . until its covered internationally :) . damn . 5 years . :O
Arunan Nachimuthu she doesnt agree with the military but they could kill her if they wanted, they dont like Syu ki at all
Just like Obama.
Aveejit Sengupta Good copy and pasting. Now give the sources you found the information from and no wikis please.
Aveejit Sengupta *
Genocide is genocide. I can't believe some people are heartless...
Ardani it's not a genocide but ethnic cleansing
Nup Pun you're right
Ardani complicated... all of it...
well bangladesh has a Silent hindu genocide
Mischievous please elaborate
It just goes to show: Any religion can become harmful. Even Buddhism. Why can't we all just live here together?
Emagination Productions When pushed to the limit even Buddhists will fight back. They didn't start this.
@Emagination Productions its not about the religion, culture or history. we are sentient, progressive, and limitless. no matter how we change or remove our religion, culture or history nothing happens if people not, Its about us, if everyone can just be good nd do what is must..
Now those illegal migrants starting problems in india
@@nekad2000 ur right I say this cause I'm Buddhist
Religion is just a belief, any belief has no solid proof, so if people are provoking people with their belief and the other side fights back then ultimately it was the provoking side's fault to begin with.
again the Brits involved 😦 they’ve been involved in a lot of state disputes (india pakistan, israel-palestine, hk-china) 🤦🏻♀️
Brits are omenious shadow
And many more
The wrong border created by the British once again caused a huge problem.
'Anglos caused most of the world's problems' (David Cameron, British Prime Minister, 2010-2016).
Anglo caused centuries-long notorious global -
- Slavery,
- Colonialism,
- Colonization,
- World War I,
- World War II, and the list goes on.
@@iqbaltuhin3342 they have too much land to Pakistan
As a Malaysian, now we know why Myanmar did the Rohingya ethnic cleansing.
Its not about religion.
I'm Muslims myself and I despise their actions and attitudes.
I am a bangladeshi muslim. I completely agree with you. Rohingya's are worst people in the world.
@@bluefairy7304 indian here 🙋
I heard that they killed around 40 people in some village and abducted women . Is that true ?
@Travel 4k They don't care about people who gave them refuge. In Bangladesh lots of bangladeshi gave rohingya's shelter when they arrived here after persecution. Rohingya's are now threatening those bangladeshi life savers. Crime rate in Cox's bazar increased like 10 times after they arrived here. Our tourism sector, world's longest sea beach Cox's bazar is heavily damaged by them. Rohingya's have to go back to Myanmar as soon as possible.
Pisslamic Rapepublic of Porkistan oh my god. so all rohingya people are just bad? Maybe a couple have a bad attitude but there’s got to be good ones. I live in the US and is of Bangladeshi descent and I felt for those people. I had no idea they acted like that.
I am Indonesian. This is why Indonesia is not fond of them either, Their boats had been ping ponged between Indonesia and Malaysia because no one would take them in. The UN finally convonced Indonesia to take thousanfs of them in a promise that UN will find the third countries to take them in as Indonesia isn't part lf the refugee receiver nations. That is the last i heard about them.
As a Shan or as a minority in Myanmar, it is just so sad to see that the international only recognizes the case between Rohingyas and the Military. The latter was and is still causing violence in other minority states like Kachin, Kayin and Shan. The Military of Myanmar is the common enemy of both majority (Burmese) and all minorities. They've destroyed many lives and futures for their own good.
Esacpe to thailand
The difference is Shan , kayin, Kachin are NATIVE to Myanmar rohingya is not they are Bangladesh
@@shthepanda4585apparently many trace their routes back to 15th century Burma so what’s your point.
I'm also from Myanmar. My ethnic group is called The Karen People. My family became refugees before I was born. Now I live in Norway.
So now we call you viking
The Karen are a people native to the region. Not an Indian people imported by the British for act as their enforcers. What happens the the Karen people is very wrong. What happens to the "Rohingya" is the right course of action.
@@Cl0ckcl0ck tell me where Buddha and Buddhism came from
“Karen people” lol😂😂
They pronouce the *karen* tribe as "Ka-yin". Not like the Karens of the world.
Maybe the rich Muslim countries should try to help/bring them in... oh wait they don't
@@betaz1000 What about the vast land in Saudi Arabia or Iran?
@Stark Industries Same here in Malaysia, last year the Rohinyan started a protest demanding citizenships, the right to votes and the right to start a political party. I think they forgot that we brought them in as refugees. We gave them shelter, food, water, electricity and now this is how they repay us.
Indonesia already helps them till now. Lots of Rohingya refugees have a new home. They'll never walk alone.
Simply said, it's a long journey, and we cant really just show up with boats or planes
@@danialabdullah29 like so many groups that migrate into USA ? Nothing new,,
No matter what skin, religion or language we speak. We are still humans and butchering other humans for no just reason is despicable and shameful.
True
Amad C Everything happens with a reason , it doesn't matter whether it was how/why the conflict started , retaliation , cruelty etc. Ironically , all those behaviour is what makes us human and butchering each other has been happening since recorded history.😔
Amad C Actually there us a reason. You're just too emotional to see it.
N2400X - Of course they are between nationalities. That's the definition of a war : a country attacking another country.
What about Rohingya butchering the Hindus Christians and Buddhists? You liberals simply assume all Muslims are fcking peaceful angels.
Silent genocide
Soufian 27 no, actually it's a pretty popular news in S.E Asia,Turkey,Saudi Arabia maybe more
the usa should do the same, imo.
The 'Rohingya' should take up arms and defend themselves!
EccoBabeTV As much as I want them to, unfortunately they can't. They are impoverished and do not have the necessary arms to do so. Plus, they are going against a military force.
EccoBabeTV yea the poor farmers should stand up to a traind military force with a great deal of funds ,weapons and training
Myanmar, a country controlled by the military.. What else did you expect?
venkat jaya deep You can expect PERFECT GIVING BACK POLICY.
And before that coup had a parliament and was the wealthiest nation in south Asia.
as long as they have to fight of the mullahs they will need that millitary.
As a Burmese let me tell you about the other side of the story.
The military took control over the country in the name "national stability".
During the military rule, they attacked not only the Rohingyas but also some ethics groups like Karen, Shan, and Arakanese. They have oppressed the Burmese citizens that they don't want to know what's beyond their world.
The lack of internet access in Rakhine region makes it hard for the Burmese to know about this case. Also the tension between the Burmese and Arakanese causes problems for the Burmese media to go there. Because of that, the news about this has become one-sided. That gives the military an advantage that the current government would be blamed for that because of "the government controls the military" thing.
The military doesn't listen to the government and they are still in charge of the country. In fact, the chief of defense staff is a remnant of the former Military Government. He got his position because of "if you want it, then you get it" thing. He can even de facto elect himself for his position.
The Burmese government has to rule the country with the military's constitution (2008 constitution). Before 2016, they altered some laws to prevent Aung San Su Kyi from becoming the president. So the government had to ignore the military doings, waiting to reform the military in their second term and having to ignore the criticism regarding this case.
TL;Dr: The military is the problem and they are trying to sabotage the government by any means.
*Extra info*: It is also claimed/exposed that the Rohingyas are said to be Bengali people brought to the country and given "white cards" and the rights to vote by the military-backed party so that they could cheat in elections (2010 and probably 2015). So, this "ethnical cleansing" could be "getting rid of the evidence" and "an opportunity to sabotage Aung San Su Kyi's government".
@Stark Industries The Military Party deliberately call them Bengalis. It is still unclear, to the Burmese people, on the origin of the Rohingyas. Some claimed that they wanted recognition that they're a different ethnic group because they are just seen as Arakanese, some claimed that they didn't get on well with the Arakanese so they were just "pushed". I could see them as part of Myanmar's ethic group as Arakan was formerly multiethnical.
I just hope that the government could settle the situation with those people when the military junta ends.
@Stark Industries The Military is not as strong as they were back then. They would need to rule the country via the party they founded (like in 2010-15) as the world has known about them.
The Democratic government has made better development than the entire military regime in 5 years. This upcoming election is also kinda a bit of a problem because:
1. It's during the pandemic and they can't postpone it (if they postpone, the military will be ranting about it)
2. Instead of 2 major parties, there are now four (or three)
3. There is a risk in developing ethnical tension against Bamar people.
But the Democratic party has full support throughout it's history and it has won in all elections held.
The main challenge of the democratic government is replacing the constitution written by the military. In the parliament, 25% of the seats are assigned to the military personnel (no matter what the government is), which makes the problem more difficult. In presidential election, the military "representative" elects one of the two vice-presidents. They would take a long time to remove the military out of the parliament and they can finally operate as a true government.
Edit: So technically people will be voting for 75%, instead of all seats of the parliament. And since there has been cities being shut down from election due to conflicts by the military, the seats are lost from the 75%. So, if there isn't a landslide victory, the military will decide who would become the president and what the winning party is. It's up to the people to give the Democratic party a landslide victory.
Brother thank u so much for the info, u just burst all the Islamophobs whom were justifying this ethnic cleansing!!!!
@@anxskhxn Aung San Su Kyi has also said that she would give them Burmese citizenship. However, due the immigration law the Rohingyas do not meet the criteria. So the government needs to change that law and she can grant them citizenship.
Salute,brother! I was about to explain and read through the comments. Our country and the relagion has been a game,played the media and former- military government over the decades. Well-explained!
Yet another dispute in the world where Brits had some relation in causing it.
Nick Kei Happens when u colonize half of the world...They did a lot of damage doing so...
Levis. H They were alive for one thing.
Islam is more obvious
The issues were caused poor management when leaving and doing things too quickly look at the partition of India
Nick, that's complete garbage. Problems are caused by the people themselves and it has nothing to do with the Brits. You clearly don't know anything about history. The Brits didn't colonize Pakistan or India. Where are these British people? If they had colonize these countries their populations would be in the millions and there are zero Brits in p,I, or Myanmar. What the Brits did was control the sea ways and the leaders of the area alined with the Brits.
Y'all are doing buddhism wrong
bhartley1024
You kinda have to have perspective though. Most of the Orient used to be Hindu-Buddhist. But after arrival of Islamic conquests many peaceful Buddhists were killed, and now Buddhism is a minority religion is Asia. Though obviously not practicing Buddhist teaching, the Burmese people are having a survival immune response to Islam. They fear having thier culture being wiped out by the agressive nature of Islam.
They're basically Isis,israel and the KKK they just ruin their religions' reputation and only take what they like from the religion and add what they want
檀 杏斗 Buddhism is one of the strongest religions out there also China forced the Dalai lama out of tibet I don't see any Buddhists burning Chinese people
you are big Mad 😐🖕
Abdulmohsen Aldamk it's because the Buddhist outside Tibet are zen Buddhist which don't associate with the Dalai Lama
Fun fact: Myanmar is one of the 3 countries that still use the Imperial system.
Ville with a V Karma
its not a fun fact
So that makes them inches closer to genocide.
Lol
Fun fact indeed
What did this woman win a Nobel prize? Her Nobel prize should be revoked.
It is given for political reasons, not humanitarian on a number of occasions. Do you think Obama, one of the creators of Syrian crisis, deserves to keep Noble Prize after the amount of dead children he's responsible for? It's a farce.
Exactly just like, Malala got one for no reason
Nobel prize itself is political. And especially the nobel peace prize is truely political.
Just asking what did malala do so much to get a peace prize. Same case with Obama.
I certainly agreed with u Lee Burmese goverment is wrong or the government can't control the military
I’m am a son of a victim of Myanmar’s attacks. Not against these people but another kind called “Shan”. My mother and father had to move further and further from Myanmar because they repeatedly attacked them (and others). My parents became refugees in Thailand after multiple years of fearing for another attack. My older brother took matter into his hands and decided to come to the United States. I am grateful for what I have and hope that you, the person reading this comment, is as well. We all suffer, but some suffer more than others.
There are way too many internal conflicts in Myanmar. It's like Afghanistan of the South East. Hopefully Su Kyi will at least be able to bring peace to your people along with Karen, Kayah and other repressed groups. Unfortunately there is no hope for the Rohingya though. They have hogwashed the history of Arakan and put their own version to brand them as outsiders. Maybe they did it for winning over the Rakhines who are also oppressed and have their own militant group.
Tahmeed Tajwar I agree, way too many conflicts within the Myanmar borders. Su Kyi is just way too blind to see that. She says 50% of the villages are okay, but what about the other 50%?
Same RizeAttack
Wishing your family for the best.
- a Thai friend
Life still hard after getting out of this situation
How can you be a follower of Buddha when he never condoned violence?
Self protection is allowed.
If they don't stop these Rihingyas, Mayanmer will soon be converted to a Muslim country. Learn from history.
This is what we Muslims also believe my man, how can you follow Islam and kill innocents? There are just crazy brainwahsed people who either enjoy killing or too stupid to know otherwise who justify their murders in the name of religion.
andrmn these aren't immigrants, they're a minority in a nation with a high birth rate
no replacement rate here
No they wont. On average Rohingya even before vast ethnic cleansing started emigrating out of the Myanmar.
But mohammed was a disgusting human being ..like most muslims you never investigated islam properly,,,,,anyone who does it becomes an ex muslim like me
She won the Nobel "Peace" Prize. What an irony!!
@Mm Mm called bengali for a reason
@Mm Mm u can trace back to the origin and they all come from Bangladesh
She won the nobel peace pride because she fought for democracy in myanmar with non violent methods even when the government is trying to suppress her and arrest her for it. There is still a lot to uncover why she has not acknowledged the Rohingya Genocide
You have so sympathy then take them to your country , these Bangladeshi are everywhere near their border , like in my country (India) also
@Mm Mm what do u mean by bengali Muslims....they r from Myanmar , difference is just they r Muslims...
Who’s here after Myanmar Military coup?
Me
Me 🙋🏻♀️
Sad world we living in, power and profit is all whats left
Me
Can someone explain to me what's going on in Myanmar, I dont know who side is on who side and who against who
as an indian, this is also causing problems in my country because they illegally enter india to escape the genocide, and there are lot of rohingya here too
Not as much as in Bangladesh. India is a country with f 1.3bn and already tired of few thousand.
They are not indigenous to Burma. Nobody wants Muslims including the rebels. They should be in their homeland in Bangladesh.
@@bvc1922 these few thousands will multiply like pigs in future.. Already Northeastern states are facing huge employment problems bcu of Bangladeshis.. There is increase crime of rohingyas in Bangladesh itself they themselves dont want them so why should we?? We have enough problems already.. Let the 57 Islamic countries take them as refugees.
@@bvc1922 bcs it has so many mouths to feed, India is not developed nation like Europe that I can accomodate more refuge and those illegally entering india...
And it's not in few thousand it's in millions + crime rate of this community is comparatively very high in India...
**Just facts, no hate towards anybody or any community 🌺
@@bvc1922 who TF cares about Boobladesh?? Boobladesh and Rohingyas deserve each other. Even many boobladeshis are living illegally in India. You guys should leave our country. Beggars!
Actual its a racial conflict not a religious conflict
The title gives the wrong informations
There are also other muslim ethnic groups that lives peacefully with the burmes majority
Oh. Interesting
Race is religion as well as skin colour
@@georgie4676 bruh so a white man from Argentina is muslim and now he isnt white???
It's actually an ethnic problem
Bengali speaking Rohingya and Burmese majority
@@georgie4676 lmao what?
Thank you, as a fellow ethnic group from Myanmar, I really appreciate the video. The world needs to know more about this issue.
Dude's packing an entire ethnic group, respect.
Issue taht military not efficient ? Yeah
Unfortunately medias don't show how Maldives and Indonesia became Muslim courtiers but times ago they were 100% Buddhist, Hindu countries. Islam is a threat in every country, especially in Buddhist countries. Fortunately Myanmar acted right.
Stop judging them, their citizens are happy with their religion. Why you are having a problem
Don't forget buddhism vanished from india too.
@@anilkatiyar2269 they are happy with their religion. I saw ISIS how happy they were, but others are not.
@@ahuramazda1766 ISIS doesn't represent muslims, Do even know how isis was formed? Or their motives? It's just complex politics
And if buddhists are really very peaceful then why jails in thailand, sri lanka are not empty?
@@ahuramazda1766 U are just a keyboard warrior no friends and dat get a life
They persicute Rohingyans regardless of their religion
Why china is not criticised. They are doing same thing with there Muslim.
In Any story you can only become strong by wrong mean and brain. Best example is human and animal. Look what did ham did with animal. There is not lots of difference.
@@baraml2590 Muslims are not necessarily bad news, just in some Nations with extremist views (Iran, Turkey etc.)
Becuz its all a racial conflict
For your kind information.
Rohingyas killed many Hindus
@@Ginger_Hrn and where are they?
@@DonKrieg-382 due to rip politics many Rohingyas are currently living in India .
That's some solid journalism right there. Thanks Vox from Bangladesh.
Willie L still much better than the west
Willie L you ignorant degenerate. This isn't Saudi Arabia . This is Bangladesh
Willie L if you didn't know in 1971 we fought to have democracy and freedom.. It was Pakistan and India who said the country should be divided by religion.. We refused and we got attacked
Willie L just cause we don't have gays marching around and feminists running around naked dosent mean it's under dictatorship
Willie L the West is a shithole. With no culture or common sense
"Monks, even if bandits were to carve you up savagely, limb by limb, with a two-handed saw, he who reacts with hate or violence towards them will not be following my teaching.
Our minds will remain unaffected, and we shall say no evil words. We will remain compassionate, without hostility and without ill will.
We shall show them loving-kindness, as we shall show the whole world loving-kindness."
--- The Buddha (MN:21)
Lol yes, offer your head willingly to the butchers blade just so you can be "the better person". I hate when people take advantage of the peaceful nature of bhuddists.
C D look at that peaceful nature of bhuddists - literally burning fuxking villages
Lel and about time too, for how long should the bhuddist suffer under the oppressiveness of abrahamic religions? A shame they didn't do this a thousand years ago, if they formed a resistance then, they wouldn't have to fight their own south asian people who were converted under sword-point. But you are probably a western idiot, who has no interest in history over 100 years ago, so its not like you would understand.
Clint Sänger
Exactly this behaviour is responsibale for wiped out his own kingdom ....
And the buddhism from India
mrunal mhatre becoz of buddhism india turn into pisslam
I feel so bad for them, i don't know how to express myself. Like Gandhi said, the world is enough for everything one's need, but not for everyone's greed.
Can you like come up with like your own sick saying or quotes instead of copying other sick quotes made by lame people
Lol you talk about Gandhi's words? India denied Rohingyas refugee status to escape this ethnic cleansing by putting up a facistic-anti-Muslim bill which not only stop Rohingyas but put in question the legitimacy of Indian muslim citizenship. The world is moving towards theocratic and autocratic dictatorships. A huge Chunk of Southeast Asia is openly Xenophobic. It's disgusting.
@@tirthpatel1562 why should India allow these people ??
If u want to help them why don't pay alone for them not our tax money
@@suryasishtalukdar210 If you care about proper use of tax money, vote for a party who actually cares about expanding the Indian infrastructure. If you wish to pay less taxes in the process.... vote for someone who instead of changing currency overnight and causing chaos..... won't let people jump through hoops to avoid paying taxes.
100th like
President Aung San Suu Kyi has no power, just a name. The Military rules Myanmar.
Ramy
She isn't our president.
She's not the President. She's the State Counselor.
Three Ministries,Defense,Home affairs,Border, are held by the Commander-in-Chief which meant the military hold three Ministries as power share.Commander-in-chief is the Chancellor of all armed groups in the nation.Aung San Suu Kyi was a State Consellor,which is just a High-rank advisor to the Union Cemtral Government,and who was served for Union Parliament.Actually,she has no power and no ways to save the Rohingya,which is a sad thing.
Now we Malaysian know why Burmese does that.
Why? please let the world also know?
@@incredibleindians4872 because they were ungrateful.we let them to stay mas yet they still ask to be malaysian citizen.
@@incredibleindians4872 Yeah.. true. They came to our country but dont respect the local.
@@potpetinfo3668 are you monitoring them? with cctv? each of them?
@@incredibleindians4872 They did a chaos and protes in the street without permit. Our police come and try to stop them. Plus now they demanding for equal with the local. Its all over the news bro... if you are Malaysian. We are in the quarantine states now. We hold all the flight and close border and suddenly they came into our border. Dont respect our rules and enter our country illegally. 90% Malaysian dont want them anymore. We help for those who already in here, but still they demanding and provoking us in social media. When they got caught, they ask for forgiveness (sigh) And again, this is viral in my country. I'm not making up this stories, it is true.. happening in Malaysia. They dont respect us as local, so we start to hate them and ask them to leave.
Man that's brutal! I thought Buddhists were peaceful group
Edit: What I meant is I thought Buddhists(including their government) practice non violence very strictly.
Roshan Motwani No religion is truly peaceful they all have their bad sides
buddism teaches peace like all religions which follow the "golden rule" but in the video it states that the government was taken over by a military coup and "promoted fierce nationalism based on the countrys Buddhist identity."
Every religion teaches good things, the religion was never wrong, it's the people
dante reyna Agreed completely
Roshan Motwani you’d be wrong
it is so awkward that whenever something happens against Muslim we talk about human rights but we ignored the things these muslin people does to other religious people
Like what
Like what
So where were you guys while there was Tamil cleansing in srilanka,hindu cleansing from Pakistan just asking 🤷🏽♂️
Sorry brother there is no hindu cleansing in Pakistan, we are friends I'm from sindh
@@mohammedawais2849 then why 20% of hindu population reduced to 2% in Pakistan since independence ?
even if there was those cleansing is it okay to say this Rohingya cleansing is justified? Sad to see such arguments...
Is this a justification u used for rohingya problem ? I feel sorry for anyone that suffered from ethnic and religion conflict but for u, u are not more than animal. U are the ppl that made them suffer, shame on u !!
@@mohammedawais2849 Hindu population in Sindh was 25% at the time of independence now it's 8%
Now the same people protesting against the same military leaders who killed and dragged these Rohingyas ... Karma
I've waited so long for this
Many Islamists have been waiting for this video.
xlolstoicx I have waited since 2012
ASTON RAY Actually Islam is a religion of peace but people claim themselves Muslim and commit a terror attack
"Islam is a religion of peace" That's the propaganda, not the reality.
v
Thanks Vox for the clear timetable and explanation of the history. As Myanmar is facing crisis right now, and their leader who kept silent and detained as of the moment while the military in charge is known being against the Rohingyas for so long, the worst is about to come to them. I am hoping for peace and better change for everyone in Myanmar despite their diverse ethnicity.
True
after the holocaust we said “never again”. but again and again this keeps happening.
There are literally genocides occurring at any point of time in the last few decades. World leaders are motivated by political expediency not morality.
"They supported the English colonialists back in the 2nd world war". Where are these colonialists now that they are in a difficult position in 2017-2018? As long as a country is a useful pawn to defend yourself against a common enemy, you are fine with this and now that an ally is in difficulty, where are you United Kingdom? Hell are for those who keep their neutrality in time of moral crisis...
They are standing the moral high ground to blame Burma but saying it's none of the business for this crisis. And they always ignore that Burma and Buddhist are the victims.
Ermm, they're dead, it was 60 years ago, and to Intervene would unjustifiable and incredibly expensive, dangerous and time consuming for the British soldiers, who they and their families do not want to go to a far away country to defend against a vulnerable ethnic group vs an entire nations army
@@jaego24c53 they can provide aid and logistics that isn't very difficult as these people used to be loyal to them .
@@BlackPanther-ji1bg but army's don't care about an unmilitarised ethnic group which used to be loyal to them, and Britain is already using its supplies in other countries, the last thing they'd want to do is spend even more money to protect a group of people they have no real reason to defend. I think they should defend them, but from the perspective of the prime minister or high ranking general, money is already stretched thin, and it seems like an unnecessary expense
@@jaego24c53 let be practical English colonists used them during the time of difficulties now they don't have any benefits from these people so they don't care .
UN be like "don't do this or I will tell your mom"
If buddhist are holding gun against you , you need to introspect your self.
Well said
There is no such thing as "Buddhist nationalism", its an oxymoron.
How so?
Ali I mean you can use your whataboutism to help your point...
u wot? Don’t forget Bangladeshi Muslims also hate rohingya too
@u wot? No malays dont hate rohingyas because of their race but because they are immigrating in large numbers and not taking up any job
They are nationalists, and their religion is Buddhism. I fail to see the contradiction.
Indian muslims beware.. protect your rights at all costs
@@prayagsridhar8833 Do you even know how Sharia law works? Sharia law asks muslims to follow the law of the land they live in. So please don't get your bakchodi here
@@ashh7720 no , you're wrong. Sharia law is Islamic law.
@@brucewayne1636 there is brother , some instances that muslim should follow law of the nation where they live and in India. Sharia law is made up for only personal law of muslim
There are 57 muslim countries and no one came forward to take care Rohingya muslim people. These muslim countries have vast wealth due to oil money , but they dont spend single penny for muslim refugees , But dozens of money for building mosques in non muslim countries.
This is how wealthy muslim treat their muslim refugees. But they let go for christian and buddhist countries. And thereafter critizing enormorously about defects of caring these refugees in those countries, with their MEDIA like al ljazeera , TRT WORLD etc
and blame buddhists saying they are extremities. Never MENTION MASSACRE DONE BY rohigya in BURMA.
Don't blame us! Dic-tators gotta Dictat
I’m pretty sure Saudi Arabia is funding a number of refugee camps in bangladesh
I'm Chinese Mahayana Buddhist and I support Myanmar brothers. We must defend our religion! Namo Amitabha
I'm a burmese but we dont need your support and those people did nothing wrong to deserve it
@@jasonslatt2470 second to that, the upper guy has no idea about the actual situation
This is why I don't like people like you
Bro Chine doesn’t have religion
@@zd99z8 What oart of Im Chinese and Buddhist dont you understand? Buddha is the GREATEST person to ever live on this EARTH. PERIOD.
What a sad thing! thank U Vox
imthebadass bro To call you stupid would be an insult to stupid people!
it won't be a sad thing when Hindus were killed in their own country by muslims. It won't be a sad thing when Pakistan kills Christians and Hindus and Buddhists in their country just because they're non-muslims
It's really sad, these are time times when it's difficult to have faith in humanity,
www.reddit.com/r/worldnews/comments/725wcn/grave_of_28_hindus_killed_by_rohingya_militants/
See how the "media" makes the headline, and the people's reaction. People are like sheeps going anywhere media want them to go.
Mannnnnn......... Someone should tell those guys that they know a guy. Why I otta.
This breaks my heart
Want to send a message? Sign this petition!
Take back Aung San Suu Kyi's Nobel Peace Prize
www.change.org/p/take-back-aung-san-suu-kyi-s-nobel-peace-prize
x2
itz sotirissman So, you’re basically saying that you don’t care that these people are being persecuted. What I find quite amusing is when specimens like yourself always bring the “but the others did” excuse. Just so your backwards brain knows, this minority hasn’t been linked to any terrorist attacks against Myanmar. You’re against them for the simple fact that they’re muslim, which is a deeply flawed type of logic, ISIS itself using it for propaganda purposes.
Sam Y yeah mine too, then I remembered that they are Muslim and according to Islam religious persecution is actually fine. Yes, discriminatory taxation is persecution and it's not even the only thing they do.
Sarah Brit "I have looked this up on wiki"
Buddhist are peaceful people and I know personally Buddhist and Muslims, I say that it's not fault of Buddhist, it fault of Jihadi, they will try to impose sharia law in Myanmar, support for Myanmar
@araggon in ur dreams
@araggon LuL fight China first then u can try.
@araggon turkey is like a dog, always barking against India, Myanmar etc...
But can't fight them, India can invade turkey anytime..
U guys r terribly xenophobic fccc uuu
They are literally Orange Hitlers and you're supporting them.
What do you mean these Muslims want Sharia they don't have Shelter.
They (the rohingyas ) are not immigrants. *Actually these ppl are the ethnic native of this region and are part of myanmar bcz of the British* And because that was their land so the government of myanmar has no right to kick them out, they didnt "come to myanmar ", but they were already there. And indeed this is an ethnic conflict not religious one.
Dzikrina Saira *illegal Immigrants. Rohingyas are never, and never have been an ethnic group of Myanmar. You better check on the crisis with them and Malaysia first, so you will understand why Myanmar faced this.
@@avanibacardi6042 Please re-read my comment. I said that *they became part of Myanmar because of the British* . Back then, British (as the colonialist) divided the region and included them as part of Myanmar, whereas clearly their ethnicity, physical appearance, etc. are more similar to Bangladesh. And FYI, Myanmar used ethnicity as the basic foundation of the nation, which is the Burmese (the majority ethnics) deemed as the national identity. That's why many other minority ethnicities felt like they're being ignored and wanted to separate. And this separatist act made the Myanmar military junta government becoming so hard and repressive toward them. But actually, the real root of the problem is that they're being ignored and lack of welfare.
@@avanibacardi6042 And BTW, I know what happens in Malaysia bcz I live in Southeast Asia next door to Malaysia.
Dzikrina Saira That is the old time where Myanmar also fought so hard for their Independence Day from the British. Right now, and even after Myanmar got their independence, the group of rohingyas nor Bangladesh has nothing to do with Myanmar. They are never in the ethnic group of Myanmar. If the southeast Asian countries pity them so much, why most of the majority didn’t accept them? Malaysia did accept them and look what happened. The Myanmar government gave them equal rights when they entered, but later their behavior gets worse.
Dzikrina Saira about the minority ethnic groups that you mentioned were being “ignored,” there is always the biggest event in Myanmar for al the ethnic groups to gather and have the most wonderful night, with the music of their culture, and their traditional foods to enjoy. That ceremony was always a huge thing every year. And I for sure would like to inform that there were no Rohingyas or Bangladesh for centuries even during the times where royalty exist in Burma.
And Trump is getting pissy because some American football players are silently protesting by kneeling during their anthem.
I don't see the correlation to this atrocity
Mobius Because he's not addressing more important issues, duh
please connect the subject : rohingya to Trump
Hizkia Willhem I think they're simply dismissing Trump as having a first world problem, throwing a fit over something so small, while a genocide happen halfway around the globe.
I dont see asean regional leaders do anything much either. What makes you think trump is oblige to help
Wow, "More than 50% of the villages are intact." Amazing! I don't know how people manage going to work in the morning, and barely burning down any villages. She is quite the humanitarian. May we all strive to be so compassionate.
@auzzi pepper You sound like Adolf Hitler himself 🤣
Want to hear a joke?
"United" Nations
laughing way too much at this comment,
😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
雷肯佐 LOL
😂
@Azukaego Moemeka Google it
Aung san is the greatest disappointment to the nobel peace prize!!
Try obama
Not really, it's Malala Yousafzai....
Exactly
@@kushagrakapoor7890 Not really its rabindranath tagore and all indian Deo user nober winner
It's time to rethink why only one community is a problem across the globe
It's because of the British
@@haziqariffin1989 no absolutely a topiwalaw
“Religion is an insult to human dignity. Without it you would have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, that takes religion.”
Steven Weinberg was an American theoretical physicist and Nobel laureate in physics for his contributions with Abdus Salam and Sheldon Glashow to the unification of the weak force and electromagnetic interaction between elementary particles.
That would be lindus
*Not* so _silent_ *genocide*
FRANTIC 🖕
.......you are officially going to be the first person who will represent Dark side of Humanity to aliens.
-nice
the feeling is mutual.
hahaha
"Operation Clean and Beautiful Nation" Myanmar. Bruh.
can u show me the other side of buddhists why they are doing all of this...??
They will not do this... According do their logic every non muslim is an oppressor
@@pranav7240
It's classic targeted genocide.
Why did Hitler hate Jews? Why
@@Shrikant_Darade No, they (the rohingyas ) are not immigrants. *Actually these ppl are the ethnic native of this region and are part of myanmar bcz of the British* And because that was their land so the government of myanmar has no right to kick them out. They didnt "come to myanmar " as immigrants, but they were already there. And indeed this is an ethnic conflict not religious one.
@@dzikrinasaira3475 the residence of Rohingyas came to exist only after, Mughal conquered Bengal region ( west Bengal state of India and Bangladesh) .after British came, according to their policy of divide and conquer many religious riots emerged in indian subcontinent and in Myanmar tension between Muslims and Buddhists increased as Buddhists faced persecution during muslim dominance in region in period of Mughals. And current outrage is result of above mentioned reasons. The main reason for hatred of Muslims is due to Islamic extremists who took part in communal activities. In Myanmar there is also hindus but they don't face violence. Also in Nepal Hindu (dominant country) Buddhists feel safe..but Islam face violence and hatred everywhere in world..my intentions was not to hurt your sentiments but, ask yourself what is the history of Islam? (do it as historian not as believer) ,how it spread so fast across world?, What ideologies Maulanas teaches in mosques?, Why Islam is hated by most liberal countries?
shrikant darade the Burmese Empire invaded in 1775.
And Bangladesh muslims comes illegally in Assam, india
And making problems
What problems lol ?
There’s nothing beautiful and clean about genocide.
Edit- sadly, this genocide is still happening a few years after. Inshallah we can see an end to this horror.
Vritngh Ameen
auzzi pepper You realize that you just said that murder and killing people makes thing beautiful. What is wrong with you? In what case would taking a human life be justified
auzzi pepper I’m 100% certain you are from Bangladesh and you want to support your government it’s to obvious
First of all, it is nobody's argument that what has happened to Rohingyas is not condemn-able or even justifiable to say the least. However, given the reality of the Rohingya jihadi secessionist insurgency that has been raging on since 1947 and the murder of many innocent Rakhine Buddhists as well, it is hardly an open and shut case of the persecutors versus the persecuted. There is more to this issue than meets the eye. I fear a horrendously sinister political game at play here (with Buddhist-Muslim tensions a mere spark to light the powder-keg), and somehow the great Sunni Wahhabi Islamic nexus of Pakistan and Saudi Arabia/Turkey/other GCC nations could be directly or indirectly involved.
This video clearly omits some important facts about the Rohingyas.
They forgot to mention that Rohingyas, who originally hail from the Chittagong region of the East Bengal region (which later became E-Pakistan and now is called Bangladesh), were initially brought in by the British during the Raj to fight the invading Japanese army during WW2 as well as the local Rakhine militia who were allied with the Japanese.
They were settled in the Western Burmese region of Arakan or Rakhine state (esp. in it's northern most district of Maungdaw, which borders what is now South Eastern Bangladesh and where they form the majority) and were promised a Muslim state in that region for their belligerent services against the Japanese and the local Rakhine. When the Britishers failed to fulfil their promise, the Rohingyas formed armed Mujaheddin or Jihadi groups against the Burmese Govt. in order to obtain their Dar-al-Islam by seceding from the Dar-al-harb of Burma which was never theirs in the first place.
These Rohingya jihadi groups, like RLP, RPF, RSO, ARIF, ARNO and now ARSA (since 2016) were/are being supported by Al-Qaeda/ISIS, Hezbi Islami (Gulbuddin Hekmatyar), Hizbul Mujahideen from Kashmir and Jamaat-e-Islami Bangaldesh and Pakistan's ISI in this 70 year-old civil war in Western Burma which has been going on since 1947 with the independence of the Indian Subcontinental states from Britain.
In fact, when Jinnah's Pakistan dream was getting fulfilled by partitioning India, the various Rohingya jihadi groups and political leaders had petitioned Jinnah to annex the Rohingya dominated areas of Northern Rakhine region as part of East Pakistan.
Amazing research bro
Wow this comment is super dope.
Thank you for providing more information on this topic. Unlike this video which just states "Buddhist bad, Muslim good"
This is what happens when we get to caught up on the sins of people who have been dead for decades. We need to judge people by who their are and do, not their parents or grandparents.
Thank you, Vox, for the detailed timetable and insightful explanation of Myanmar's history.
Given Myanmar's current crisis, with its leader detained and the military in control, the Rohingya community faces grave concerns due to the military's longstanding opposition.
Nobel prize winner??? wtf??
Joaquín Clavijo search royangya terrizt acts agianst myanmar shame on u for not researching
please welcome Rohingya Muslims to your neighborhood, and I support you to win Nobel Prize. ; )
lmao awesome response Zhaoxun Yan ...these people are honestly so gullible that they are not so much as questioning that Buddhists ( the most peaceful people on the planet ) are at war with Muslims ( the most violent group for the last 1400 years and whose ideology/religion has literally been forcing submission globally the whole time ) and committing a genocide in this one place ...and yet Muslims are at war on every continent in dozens of conflicts with many religions and we have ACTUAL EVIDENCE of the genocide THEY are committing in those other places ...not just some story by a reporter we've never heard of ...by a news agency who has previously reported things that turned out to be utter bullshit ..and they just eat up the bullshit like its No Calorie Chocolate Cheesecake ..it boggles the mind . I have learned to never underestimate the stupidity of large groups of people with good intentions .
Tell me, what better way is there to promote peace other than killing terrorists and their offspring?
khosrow poor villagers who can barely even afford food are terrorists now? You bigots do not fail at me making me laugh. With your ideology I would say you are quite radicalized and should be on the terrorist watch hmmmm. Supporting a genocide against innocent poor people...
I know i'm from myanmar and i want all countries to get along and be happy together
This is so sad to believe actually😟
First get people in your country to get along and be happy together, then talk about other countries.
What do you think about the Myanmar military? I want to know.
@@Thatguy_3362 first off, I’m Burmese and personally, i have nothing against the Myanmar military. Because no topic should be stereotyped. Every place has good and bad things included. Just because some side of a topic is shown to public doesn’t mean that everyone and everything included in that topic is the truth. People should start to see both the good and the bad of everything . So in conclusion, there is “bad” people and “good”people in the military but that doesn’t make Myanmar’s military stand out or anything because a good and a bad side is some every one and everything has.
@@zunethi1764 What do you think about the coup?
I hate humans . I am an alien
ME TOO
me too
AN ILLEGAL ALIEN
Pfft aliens don't exists
*sweats profusely*
Come on man, didn’t u sign the confidentiality form that was handed out when we landed on earth??
Make a video on exodus of kashmiri pundits.
Video bn jany se wo wapis nhi ayen gy, they are got funked out of IOK😂😂😂
They will come back there for sure.... We won't let the heaven on earth destroyed by the bunch of jihadis.
Usama saleem shut up.... Just shut up okay article 370 is dead. Now wait and watch ✊✊
Thats a hoax...stop crying..
And a vedio on gujrat 2002 , mizzafnagar 2013 etc.
Where are the rich muslim countries like saudi arab,turkey,qatar and other muslim countries in this issue and why the so called pakistan is silenced on this issue????
Silence? Are you live under a rocks
Okay....but why getting facts from Al Jazeera dude?
Is Al Jazeera biased?
FOX news is Trump-biased
@@muktamalakar5771 the FK lmao they speak out about saudi Arabia and their princes that Saudi demand that Al Jazeera shuts down. They are the non bias maybe learn that before you say anything and this is coming from a Canadian Asian.
@@merc722 off course . A news channel with fund from an Islamic nation serves the purpose .
@@muktamalakar5771 not really they discuss problems with Islamic terrorism too
Vox, you are not representing the true picture. Please get your facts corrected and show a true picture.
All my deep condolences go to the victims of this tragic incident
Each religion's extremist are like this
What about Uighur Muslim?
It’s not about Muslim vs Buddhist
It’s Burmese vs Rohingyas
REMEMBER NALANDA?
Yep
🙋♂
What's that ?
@@معرفةوترفيه-ت2ظ Google it
Yep
Do keep guts to make similar videos on Kashmiri Hindu Pandits and Balochis 🙄🙄
I agree with you, world is filled with hypocrisy
Yes
Dumbass, none of that rhetoric can be used to justify the genocide of an entire community of people
@@devanshrathore9112 exactly! i don't understand why Hindus love comparing tragedies so much
@@broccolininja8950 where do u belong to mate😂
Bangladesh , Pakistan and Afghanistan has been doing the same thing to Hindus in those countries for years now.
Myanmar doing the same in return for Rohingyas.
What goes around comes around..
sailing smooth15 How has India been cleaning religious minorities?Pls explain that to me
“As a rule, if a crime is committed by one group against another ethnic or religious group, it is nearly impossible for the perpetrator to punish itself.”
Seriously, the western society has dealt with the genocide trouble this way. Systematically or successfully, they hid what's real inside in the history. Colonization. In the same way, Belgium got away from the responsibility for the tragedy of the Eastern Africa in 1994. This video sucks, rarely mentioning the Britain's specific role throughout the colonization.
In this specific case it's not our fault. The borders of Myanmar where like that before the Anglo Burmese war.
"Slavery, Colonialism & Colonization" are all evil things done and benefited by evildoers.
Anglo West/Christian Europeans are major participants and benefactors of centuries-long global,
- Slavery,
- Colonialism,
- Colonization worldwide, from North/South America to Australia/New Zealand to Siberia/Far-East Asia.
India needs to wake up and follow Myanmar. The threat of Islam is real.
You are only defaming my country 😡
Rohingyas were living here in Myanmar for a long period of time, in a small amount. However, more and more arrived from Bangladesh illegally, and claiming they were Burmese. They created violence on local Buddhists and Hindus. They went back to Bangladesh because it was staged between them and ARSA to seem it like ethnic cleansing.
Thank you for finally making a video on this. I requested this but probably didnt influence this video
It's the thought that count. I was glad to see Vox shedding a glimmer of lime light on this crisis.
We indian needed to do this post our independence in 1947. We wouldn't be facing the current terrorism
can't dictatorships find better scapegoats than ethnic groups, like unemployment?
Ethnic groups are a scapegoat for unemployment blames. There is a reason that people in western countries despise immigrants because they are supposedly taking all of their jobs and thereby economically disenfranchise the native population.
You can always lose your job, but you can't lose your ethnicity.
they never talk about the struggle of anyone who isn't Muslim in Muslim theocratic countries like Saudi or Pakistan or Somalia or Egypt ect i cud go all day naming countries where your life might be at danger just for not being Muslim
The sad part is that the UN and US alike are not going to a dam thing. Thats the sad part.
Kerbal Space Program youtuber 123 its really shameful.....I mean u hate Muslims because of middle East conditions and attacks of 9/11,try to understand that the issue. Of terrorism is highly political and often used to overthrow govts,how u can can relate it to Islam
Joseph Ybarra USA is not doing anything because it's a resource devoid place,they are interested in oil
we europeans are so tired we have housing crisis the british part has nhs problems france has problems grece has crisis ngo ships are invading italy
the UN does nothing either way, they can't force any country to do anything and they don't have any army of any sort. And the US? well good luck in convincing trump to give out aid to muslims
Kerbal Space Program youtuber 123 Why do you have to hate? As an atheist Turk having Muslim parents and some Christian and Jewish friends all I can say is that I love them and I respect all their religious beliefs. I understand your concerns about refugees and I had the similar ones when over 2 million Syrian refugees came to Turkey. But when you think about it, it's the fault of colonial powers of early 20th century. They left their colonies instantly after WWII, creating authority gaps which leads to formation of terrorist groups or violent behaviours to claim authority. Myanmar and Iraq was British colonies and Syria was a French colony. I am not saying that they wanted these things to happen when they left their colonies, but they could have done it in a better way by establishing governments in which their people can trust and by making this processes gradual rather than instant ones.
For the rape situation, I am sorry that these things have happened and I can understand your feelings because I felt similarly when similar things have happened in Turkey. But I now know hatred is not the solution. We should punish rapists by our laws and give secular education to the innocent ones thus they can return to their countries in the future and make them better places. If you think they won't return to their countries consider this: did they want to come before war? Did they want to leave their homes, the places they grew up, the places they fell in love, the places they lived -by all meanings of the word?
It's not about nationalities, not about religions, not about politics. It's about humanity. We MUST learn to love each other and respect each other, otherwise we will destroy each other. As Bertrand Russell said: Love is wise, hatred is foolish.
_"You know any school I went to 50% is a failing grade."_ - Phil Robertson
Deputy director, HRW Asia division
QUARTERMASTEREMI6 vry wrong to innocent people's
No,
Make a vdo about Kashmiri Hindus "Ethnic Cleansing".......oh u won't
Don't expect that
Respect for Myanmar and China increased!!!!
completely justified , myanmar would have been another indonesia.
And nothing is bad about Indonesia, tho?
so what? the rohingya are also the ethnic people there in the country. they have the right to be there
as indonesian , i mproud my ancestor , left hinduism- buddhism for beauty islam. 500 years ago
They are originally from Bangladesh. They are Muslim, Bangladesh is a Muslim nation and they look like Bangladeshi people
So their ancestors were originally Indian Muslims, then, of Bengali origin. But INDIA does nothing??
What are u trynna justify ??!!
supporting Buddhist from India
they are never wrong
from the bottom of my heart, i really hope you go through the same. Once an ignorant, always an ignorant.
That woudnt happen bro
I live in a country where their is no enforcement of minor
Our country have highest number of Muslims in world.
Except of some, here in India all live like brothers
oh yeah, Indonesia has more Muslims.
Astha Bisht Yeah right . That’s why millions of Muslims were tortured and then murdered in Gujarat
Why the muslim countries are not inviting them
Why India isn't taking the Sri Lankan Tamils who are being persecuted
Bangladesh, Malaysia, and Indonesia take them as refugees idk what u talking about
So it is not myanmars fault they are killing them,burning their house.
It is muslim countrys fault why are they not taking refugee.
You know what. If something like this starts happening in bangladesh,pakistan,indoneshia against hindus then remember this. Dont blame us. We will say why arent india taking them. According to ur brilliant logic
@@walrus6173 I thought there were 53 islamic countries but ok
@@ratulhasan165 'starts happening'
it already started long time ago
Can we also cover disappearance of hindus from Pakistan and Bangladesh?
they are safer than muslims in myanmar and india..
@@greenja4688 is that why there is no hindu left in Afghanistan, Pakistan, Bangladesh. And muslims have increased by 10x in India after the partition.
@@greenja4688 man muslims are just disgusting and you are an accurate representation of most muslims
While a good video, there is no mention of the fact that Rohingyas formed insurgencies to join Bangladesh when Burma first gained freedom..
Sinistait It was not Bangladesh idiot. It was east Pakistan. And then the leader, jinnah refused the proposal and said that he wouldn't provoke Burma's land.
RAJIT HASAN they still formed insurgencies, didn't they
+Sinistait
Did you know that in civilised countries (e.g. Thailand), they get rid of the insurgents, and not entire ethnic populations? They also don't go around burning villages to weed out insurgents. That's inhumane and a horribly inefficient tactic.
Also, did you know that the Rohingyas aren't the only insurgent group in Myanmar? For a single country, Myanmar has more insurgent groups formed by its minorities than most other countries. See:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_insurgent_groups_in_Myanmar
The military junta has been oppressing all of them for decades. The difference is, the rest are citizens of Myanmar, while the Rohingyas have intentionally been prevented from being citizens.
Nobel Peace Prize??? YOU MUST BE SHAME !!!
MhummadsWingedHorse Allahhas2Hands
Muslims are not a race idiot. If you think that killing innocents is okay then you are mentally ill.
Ummm syu ki is being locked in her own home by the government! Look she was just wettrying to make it better but the government was controlling everything!
So shame on you for being disrespectful!
Well this comment section will be fun
It really is.
A mixture of entertaining seeing the debated and sad seeing how cruel and empathy-lacking people can be online.
Su ki : Noble price of peace
Islam : Religion of peace
It's all coming back
?
@@innershadow3615
Both are lies
Both of them can't achieve piece
@@AdityaShinde-js1ft no this is your thinking but this is not true and Islam is always being targeted by people!
@@innershadow3615
Which country are you from..?