its training. quoth Adam Neely ; "Repetition legitimizes Repetition legitimizes Repetition legitimizes Repetition legitimizes Repetition legitimizes Repetition legitimizes Repetition legitimizes Repetition legitimizes Repetition legitimizes " no, seriously. first your ears learn what a note is supposed to sound like, then you can call it on hearing it, then your muscle memory kinda learns what thing makes that note and so on. i´m somewhere around know what a note is supposed to sound like, but still having to search for it a short while.
There’s a good reason why people went crazy over this song; unlike most modern pop songs, this has a lot of “musicality” to it. There’s complex rhythms, a fantastic Motown-esque bassline, key changes, interesting chord progressions, textural variations, etc.
But the main reason why it got so popular and got a top 10 in the charts was because they still managed to make it sound modern and relevant to today’s music even with the 70s vibes and unique chords, with the lyrics and singing style. This song was so cleverly composed and recorded, Bruno Mars knows how to make a hit while still playing with his favourite styles of music
I have to comment again. Nothing makes me happier than to see this dude randomly and instinctively just JUMP IN and figure out the music AS he's listening to it, IMMEDIATELY adding things that he's hearing in his own head that match SO perfectly with the song. its CRAZY. Great job man.
Actually this line in “Versace on the floor” : “So baby let's just turn down the lights And close the door” is like saying “oh , NOW you can close the door after it was left open”😁 haha
Yeah. Guy can write and perform, but he also leads a band (The Free Nationals) when almost nobody but the Roots or the Dap Kings (with Amy Winehouse and Sharon Jones, both RIP) have gotten traction in this lane. It's a shame, but they're fixing the problem one song at a time.
You are the first white guy on TH-cam to even acknowledge Anderson Paak. Great job being a professional and also doing some homework on the artist involved in the project that you are reviewing.....keep up the good work
I stopped counting the amount of channels (even musicians) who didn't bother to look up Anderson and didn't even acknowledge him as if this isn't supposed to be a duo
You can say that again. He is a professional. Dude knows his music. Watched many reaction videos by so many who fail to acknowledge Anderson Paak even though he is literally the first voice you hear.. 😂.
The world's busiest music nerd Anthony Fantano would like a word with you. Also, thousands of people have seen him live. I saw him at Roots Fest in Philadelphia years ago and it was a life-changing performance. Guy doesn't just make music, he leads a great band, too.
@@vb8428 I mean on today’s standards yeah your right, but I haven’t heard one person say they don’t like the song or the sound..cause that sound does something to everyone
"The whole recording feels like I'm wrapped in a warm blanket.... Soul Seduction" Brilliant Name... Well Done!!! Everything you said, couldn't of said it better myself. You're a professional and I just love people like yourself, discussing the musicality of this fabulous tune. I'm a 70's child so this sound just brings it all back with great memories of a decade I loved for music... BRING THIS SOUND BACK!!!
Album of the Year. It’s Grammy time. But more importantly such a heartfelt, soulful piece of art. A combination of fun trolling, mad respect to the old school and flat out ridiculous musical talent all wrapped into a gift for all of us. I’m speechless. 🧡
Yes The ARRANGEMENT/ Production of this song is TOP notch; background vocals are layered and lush… and then the pounding at the bridge/ the crescendo - the juxtaposition is So DOPE- and beautiful! You need birth control listening to this song!👌🏽💫 REAL MUSIC. As always your JOY for music is a JOY to watch!
Only thing I wish is that they recorded these songs without a click track. This one is at 74bpm. I could feel that something was missing and didn't feel as good as it could and lo and behold - it was definitely recorded with a click. These musicians are so stellar that they absolutely do not need a click track and the music would ebb, flow and breath more and just overall groove harder if they just went free ballin! IMHO
Thank you for explaining why I had a weird reaction to this song. My reaction was very visceral- if that is the correct term. I had a physical and emotional reaction. I literally listened about 25 times nonstop after the first listen. This song puts me in a mood and the groove is real. Thanks again!
The amazing part to me is how this guy just starts playing along with the song..lol..being able to know the keys and play automatically is crazy talent
David, as a keyboardist and song writer, this is the best reaction I've seen on this simply outstanding song. Man, you had me laughing, shaking my head in agreement, and when you said Soulful Seduction, I just lost it! Keep doing what you're doing. Peace, bro!!!
so grateful to see a professional musician properly appreciate and talk about the arrangement and theory behind it. This video deserves way more attention keep it up
Bruno Mars is such a perfectionist! That was an 11 performance and analysis. The la la la in the second half reminded me a little of Stevie Wonder’s “My Cherie Amour.” Great modulations.
As a kid, if my piano teacher gave me a tutorial like this before learning a Chopin or Bach piece, I would’ve been more interested haha thank you for this, sir! Great video!! New sub!!
@@MusicShed classical music is still great! I think learning all varieties of music is important for appreciating music as a whole, especially when trend-setters and new genres are derived from mixes or combinations of previous ones.
Excellent musical analysis. I fell in love with this song as soon as I heard it, and the love affair has only deepened since. Anderson .Paak and Bruno Mars have created a modern masterpiece that borrows only the best from the past. The Something else about this song struck me - it’s a post me too movement love song. So many love songs are disempowering and downright desperate “I’ll die without you...” “Leave the Door Open” is lush, playful, and direct but leaves the ball in the woman’s court. He wants her, adores her, loves her but what he wants is secondary to what she wants and chooses.
4:53 I HAD to smash "Subscribe" as you began breaking down the chord progression. It was like I was transported back to my music theory classes...except you explain things better! Wow!
I first heard this song a little before the grammys and (wildly out of touch) felt like I had stumbled onto this great little known musical treasure. Then I looked at the views and saw 535,000,000! Needless to say I was not even, vaguely, on any planet close to somehow discovering this. I am however thrilled that I'm finally on board with what-seemingly-much of the world recognizes as a great, extremely fun, extremely musical band. Nice reaction David.
Dang. First off this song is a masterpiece, I agree this should be Song of the Year. Your breakdown of the song + all those notes about the artists, your love for awesome Musicality really shows. I am definitely subscribing. One of the best reacts I've seen.
This song is epic! It oozes sensuality like Al Green, Marvin Gaye, or Barry White. But adding a sense of humor. I just love Bruno Mars...everything he touches turns to gold.
I thought I wouldn't hear a song that captured me like redbone by Donald glover... Than silk sonic dropped this soulful groove that just captured my heart . We needed this for 2021
This is more the Philly Soul Sound of Gamble, Huff, and Thom Bell. Love your reaction. Great advice for today's musicians. Im old school. I'm So overwhelmed with Anderson and Bruno. What an honor to the 70s greats
Just came across your channel by accident, and was so pleasantly surprised. As a retired Jazz drummer who's played with some jazz greats, Herb Ellis, Harry "Sweets" Edison & Eddie "Lockjaw" Davis, Alan Zavod, and Pete Condoli, I had almost given up on music, until I heard Bruno Mars. You, as a music teacher, are such a breath of fresh air to keep the hope of music alive and are to be commended for it. I've told several of my friends who know of my background, that as far as I was concerned, music as we know it, is dead. Hearing Bruno Mars, gave me hope that someone is still capable of producing a "Melody" and a "Bridge", and making a song with a melody that will stand the test of time. I think Bruno Mar's musical compositions will be just as relevant 20 years from now, as they are today when the rest of the crap is long forgotten. My last comment is, you should also talk about how Bruno Mars and his ensemble use "Dynamics" in creating the overall effect of the melody and its effect on the song. Also, not only is the melody a gas, but the rhythm is cookin.
I think that the reason that Bruno and Anderson have such a melodic synchronicity is because they are first and foremost MUSICIANS, then singers, dancers, songwriters, and producers. Hats off for their unashamed seduction through their music...lthix whole album is an instant classic! 🎼🎵🎶🎶🎶🎶
One of the best reaction reviews I have seen. You explained so well, why those Motown hits are STILL so much in rotation today, and are sampled sooooo much. That formula works! The background vocals and harmony is always a way to add musicality, and layer to a song. These varied layers, and musical variations in keys, all adds to those layers. Just a FANTASTIC song, and collaboration!! Whew!! I just love this song!
Finally, somebody reacting actually understanding how the key changes affect the musicality and how the song continuously is vibrant bc of this!! Good Job pal
I’m a fan of rap or hiphop, edm, reggae but listening to this song feels like my soul moved smooth ; perfect : sensational , breath taking thanks to both Bruno and Anderson bringing old vibes and we need more✌️❤️
The best reaction by far! Your breakdown was interesting & informative & gives more of an insight & background to the yesteryear sound My eyes lit up when you started playing on the keyboard lol Thanks Uso! One luv from New Zealand🤙
So Bruno and Anderson went back to the 70s and brought back some black lights in the basement music but they put a new twist on some Thom Bell arrangements and Gamble and Huff writing style love it.😃
I'm not in the music business, just a lover of all kinds of music, especially Rockabilly, Jump Blues, and Roots. I would describe this song as RICH. It's rich, smooth, satisfying and deep. Think dark chocolate mousse.
Your analysis is great. There’s a lot more detail in terms of influences, arrangement, and musical theory all in one video than many more famous TH-camrs.
As you went through the soul singers of the past and got to Marvin Gaye "Let's Get It On", I immediately heard that drum and said, Man, Anderson Paak has got it just like that.
Cheers to a fellow teacher. I agree with everyone who says this is a masterpiece. I'm not a music guy though, so as someone who barely understand what you're teaching, you are definitely a quality teacher. Engaging, informative, relatable and joyful. Well done.
I love this reaction. You were feeling the music in your soul I can tell lol NICE! This will be the best song of the year! They just set the bar to another dimension 🚀
Awesome analysis. I loved listening to you as well. Great record! Truly a masterpiece. Silk Sonic proved to be smooth and pleasing to the ears and to the soul. Kinda lives up to its name as a band.
This is THE jam, in fact the greatest jam I've heard in a long time - the greatest since........Uptown Funk. And then I see my two favorite albums of all time framed in the background (Songs in the Key of Life, Goodbye Yellow Brick Road) and it's a done deal: I subscribed!
I've watched this breakdown at least 20 times. Watching a true musician react to true musicians makes all the difference in the world. David your ear is phenomenal and your body interpretation is spot on. Excellent bro
Yes! This song has more key changes than the last 5 years worth of music :P I'm so excited about this song... I saw Paak on NPR Tiny Desk Concert, then live at an Amazon AWS trade show, and on Fortnite.. He's so amazing, and I can't think of anyone better than Mars to pair with. Paak is pushing Mars to use his full talents, finally!!
Anderson has been infusing his music with 70s funk for a while now. The collaboration is well suited but it's def a grouping of musical equals who share a great appreciation of the classics
13:35 though.. How you just came out with that like you were already part of the band.... JHEEEZE!!!! 😭😭😭😍😍😍 I'm so glad you love this song. It's absolutely incredible, absolute magic. Like a warm blend of Stevie Wonder, Earth Wind and Fire, Marvin Gate, Temptations, Michael Jackson.... All rolled into one. I've had it on repeat constantly!!
yo this is my first time viewing one of your videos and i must say the production level and your ability to easily explain and go into detail without overcomplicating things, amazes me, keep up the great work
I truly missed true R&B sound. Silk Sonic are a breath of fresh air. True music, sound, good energy/vibration. Music shed I love your analysis and musical awareness.
I have watched multiple reactions to this song. From vocal coaches, to musicians, all the way to your everyday normal person and I must say this reaction right here far exceeds all those I’ve seen. This is an incredible reaction, thank you @MusicShed! In fact I’ll go as far as saying this reactions is my favorite of any reaction to anything that exists wow🙌🏾
i will forever be impressed about how people can just recognize a note, name it, and play it instantly, really impressive
I thought I was the only one who peeped how he figured it out so quickly very impressive!!
These people feel music
@@pnw8836 Or it's perfect pitch
its training.
quoth Adam Neely ; "Repetition legitimizes Repetition legitimizes Repetition legitimizes Repetition legitimizes Repetition legitimizes Repetition legitimizes Repetition legitimizes Repetition legitimizes Repetition legitimizes "
no, seriously. first your ears learn what a note is supposed to sound like, then you can call it on hearing it, then your muscle memory kinda learns what thing makes that note and so on.
i´m somewhere around know what a note is supposed to sound like, but still having to search for it a short while.
100% agree. He played the melody at the end, and I ... I felt it.
I wish I could do that.
This song is a complete masterpiece. Instant classic.
Undisputed
It really is ❤️🙌🏾
Spans the generations and an absolutely amazing production.
The song could hop in a time machine and still be an instant classic. Forward or backwards.
@@seymourglass26 wow... well said
this song should be played around 12am to morning to boost the population 😂
boosting the population is bad tho lol
This is the most baby making song I've ever heard....
getting back population caused by cvd u mean? 🤣
No please we are overpopulated Rn
lot of pregnancy :D
Best song of 2021 hands down
Best song of 2021 so *far*
@@the_ZAMURAI nothing's passing this
This song deserves a grammy
@@codwawgamerzz another song from the album might pass this song
@@codwawgamerzz unless silk sonic releases an album
9-10 months from now A LOT of babies will be born because of this song.
Yes!!!!
hhahahaa !!
A sonic boom!
Absolutely 😂😂
The brought back the fade out! I miss the fade out so much.
big facts!!!
This is how you fade with leading vocals still on.. CLassic!
@@sanmarinojr I know that's right. Classic, babymaking ish.
last time I heard one was Redbone I think
me tooooooooooooooooooo
It's like Jackson 5 and the delfonics had a baby. Straight heaven 😊
Lololol!!! Yes
That's what I thought as well. Perfect analogy. J5 ballad like "Never Can Say Goodbye," Delfonics "Didn't I Blow You Mind."
@ItzMeNooby This song is chock full of Easter eggs like that...too many to list in a comment lest this turn into a thesis paper.
No bull, along with The Chi-Lites and Stylistics creating a baby beside them lol
Yes, there's more than a little Thom Bell/Linda Creed in there. All that's missing are the French horns, lol.
No 808, no auto tune. I like it...okay....I love it. Shout out to The Stylistics, without who this music wouldn't exist.
There’s a good reason why people went crazy over this song; unlike most modern pop songs, this has a lot of “musicality” to it. There’s complex rhythms, a fantastic Motown-esque bassline, key changes, interesting chord progressions, textural variations, etc.
so Talent? cus these guys have tons of it
And ooooh those harmonies!❤️
But the main reason why it got so popular and got a top 10 in the charts was because they still managed to make it sound modern and relevant to today’s music even with the 70s vibes and unique chords, with the lyrics and singing style. This song was so cleverly composed and recorded, Bruno Mars knows how to make a hit while still playing with his favourite styles of music
And humor! Such a badass groove and they got me laughing too!
Right on, brutha!
I have to comment again. Nothing makes me happier than to see this dude randomly and instinctively just JUMP IN and figure out the music AS he's listening to it, IMMEDIATELY adding things that he's hearing in his own head that match SO perfectly with the song. its CRAZY. Great job man.
Omg I was like yaaas that is cool I had to play back on that
Still listening in 2024!
Bruno storytelling on how her Versace got on the floor.
Yep
I said the same thing... I'm like leave the door open so this Versace can hit the floor🤷🏾 🤣🤣🤣
Actually this line in “Versace on the floor” :
“So baby let's just turn down the lights
And close the door” is like saying “oh , NOW you can close the door after it was left open”😁 haha
Hahahaha
And then had fun Straight Up and Down😍
Anderson Paak's live performance on Tiny Desk is one of THE BEST performances of that whole channel and his in general. Such an amazing artist.
Tiny Desk is great. Another two of my favs are St. Paul & The Broken Bones and Tank & The Bangaas.
Yeah. Guy can write and perform, but he also leads a band (The Free Nationals) when almost nobody but the Roots or the Dap Kings (with Amy Winehouse and Sharon Jones, both RIP) have gotten traction in this lane. It's a shame, but they're fixing the problem one song at a time.
It just so happens to be the most viewed Tiny Desk.
YES!!!! I couldn’t agree more with you Zach!
You are the first white guy on TH-cam to even acknowledge Anderson Paak. Great job being a professional and also doing some homework on the artist involved in the project that you are reviewing.....keep up the good work
I stopped counting the amount of channels (even musicians) who didn't bother to look up Anderson and didn't even acknowledge him as if this isn't supposed to be a duo
I was really starting to get upset by these reaction videos. I understand if you are not familiar with him but do not act like he not there.
You can say that again. He is a professional. Dude knows his music. Watched many reaction videos by so many who fail to acknowledge Anderson Paak even though he is literally the first voice you hear.. 😂.
The world's busiest music nerd Anthony Fantano would like a word with you. Also, thousands of people have seen him live. I saw him at Roots Fest in Philadelphia years ago and it was a life-changing performance. Guy doesn't just make music, he leads a great band, too.
🙌🏿🙌🏿🙌🏿
"The groove starts in your body." So true.
Anderson .Paak is so underrated! He’s one of the most talented artists we’ve got right now
It reminds me of that one bruce lee quote. He didn't practice a bunch of instruments, he practices on only one and mastered it.
I hope silk sonic changes music today to return to a era where music was truly music
unfortunately it's not an extremely massive hit
@@vb8428 I mean on today’s standards yeah your right, but I haven’t heard one person say they don’t like the song or the sound..cause that sound does something to everyone
@@trefadez The grammy reception was lukewarm too
music is truly music lmao fym
Absolutely
"The whole recording feels like I'm wrapped in a warm blanket.... Soul Seduction" Brilliant Name... Well Done!!! Everything you said, couldn't of said it better myself. You're a professional and I just love people like yourself, discussing the musicality of this fabulous tune. I'm a 70's child so this sound just brings it all back with great memories of a decade I loved for music... BRING THIS SOUND BACK!!!
Yessssss!
Great. Im 84 yo and 6ft tall and in love with Bruno Mars!!!
Apparently according to a Bruno interview... BOOTSY COLLINS named it "Silk Sonic"
Nice to hear someone acknowledge how hilarious the song is. They clearly had a ton of fun making this song. Can't wait for the album
They have the same sense of humor. They can make you laugh AND turn you on at the same time.☺️
Shamonn…
Album of the Year. It’s Grammy time. But more importantly such a heartfelt, soulful piece of art. A combination of fun trolling, mad respect to the old school and flat out ridiculous musical talent all wrapped into a gift for all of us. I’m speechless. 🧡
Yes The ARRANGEMENT/ Production of this song is TOP notch; background vocals are layered and lush… and then the pounding at the bridge/ the crescendo - the juxtaposition is So DOPE- and beautiful! You need birth control listening to this song!👌🏽💫 REAL MUSIC. As always your JOY for music is a JOY to watch!
Anderson Paak's voice sounds like the taste of fresh sprite
lmao
Sounds similar to Jame Brown
😂
Dang, thanks for ur help on describe A.P's voice. I was stuck to find a word for how fantastic his voice is 😂
Yessssss 🙌🏽👏🏽👏🏽 spot on 😂
“smooth like a newborn”
Bruno ends beard fashion right there🪒
😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Paak and Bruno are leaving the door open for 70's music again. What a great talent they are!!
Only thing I wish is that they recorded these songs without a click track. This one is at 74bpm. I could feel that something was missing and didn't feel as good as it could and lo and behold - it was definitely recorded with a click. These musicians are so stellar that they absolutely do not need a click track and the music would ebb, flow and breath more and just overall groove harder if they just went free ballin! IMHO
It makes me so sad to never see Paak get his flowers in the videos discussing this song. Thanks for highlighting his performance as well!
Thank you for explaining why I had a weird reaction to this song. My reaction was very visceral- if that is the correct term. I had a physical and emotional reaction. I literally listened about 25 times nonstop after the first listen.
This song puts me in a mood and the groove is real. Thanks again!
hhahahaha !! it was similar with me NB / Vienna
This song is for people who *feel music*
The amazing part to me is how this guy just starts playing along with the song..lol..being able to know the keys and play automatically is crazy talent
Whew! Music Teacher here. Finally someone who gets it. I need this song on headphones or surround sound. The way it just envelopes you. 🤗 ugh. Love.
David, as a keyboardist and song writer, this is the best reaction I've seen on this simply outstanding song. Man, you had me laughing, shaking my head in agreement, and when you said Soulful Seduction, I just lost it! Keep doing what you're doing. Peace, bro!!!
There were Covid Babies, now you got Silk Sonic babies!
so grateful to see a professional musician properly appreciate and talk about the arrangement and theory behind it. This video deserves way more attention keep it up
Bruno Mars is such a perfectionist! That was an 11 performance and analysis. The la la la in the second half reminded me a little of Stevie Wonder’s “My Cherie Amour.” Great modulations.
Perfectionist! Yes. I believe they started this while on tour in 2018. Finished it up during Covid So .. do the math.
I wish more people had caught and commented on that. I love that little call back to Stevie Wonder
And the whoo whoo whoo was homage to Jefferey Osborne (not sure people caught that)
As a kid, if my piano teacher gave me a tutorial like this before learning a Chopin or Bach piece, I would’ve been more interested haha thank you for this, sir! Great video!! New sub!!
That’s why so many students quit, they are not taught any music that is relevant to them in their life.
@@MusicShed classical music is still great! I think learning all varieties of music is important for appreciating music as a whole, especially when trend-setters and new genres are derived from mixes or combinations of previous ones.
Didn't know that BC was apart of this wow!! You still got it my man❤️❤️🧡🧡! Silk Sonic may have saved R&B! There I said it!!!!!!
11. Yep. Song is Perfection. No words. Thank you for your words.
When you break out and just start playing on the piano, I can tell you just love music and just wanna jam! Love to see it!
Your are amazing. The way you just randomly find the keys, start playing on the spot with the music. Pure talent
"Soulful Seduction" is a good name.
Perfect is the word. It's a perfect song.
Excellent musical analysis. I fell in love with this song as soon as I heard it, and the love affair has only deepened since. Anderson .Paak and Bruno Mars have created a modern masterpiece that borrows only the best from the past. The Something else about this song struck me - it’s a post me too movement love song. So many love songs are disempowering and downright desperate “I’ll die without you...”
“Leave the Door Open” is lush, playful, and direct but leaves the ball in the woman’s court. He wants her, adores her, loves her but what he wants is secondary to what she wants and chooses.
Amen! I’m recording a solo keyboard 🎹 version of it tomorrow!
Yeah. nicely said. that how its supposed ro be always.
4:53 I HAD to smash "Subscribe" as you began breaking down the chord progression. It was like I was transported back to my music theory classes...except you explain things better! Wow!
I haven't heard a song that gets you moving as much as this one, in sooo long
Maybe it’ll spark a new revolution
Music Shed here’s hopin
Truth!
I first heard this song a little before the grammys and (wildly out of touch) felt like I had stumbled onto this great little known musical treasure. Then I looked at the views and saw 535,000,000! Needless to say I was not even, vaguely, on any planet close to somehow discovering this. I am however thrilled that I'm finally on board with what-seemingly-much of the world recognizes as a great, extremely fun, extremely musical band. Nice reaction David.
Dang. First off this song is a masterpiece, I agree this should be Song of the Year.
Your breakdown of the song + all those notes about the artists, your love for awesome Musicality really shows. I am definitely subscribing. One of the best reacts I've seen.
Best concert I’ve ever been to was Bruno Mars. So fun ! They really all get into it . Brilliant
I've watched a bunch of reaction videos to this song. I think yours is one of my favorites. Great job.
This song is epic! It oozes sensuality like Al Green, Marvin Gaye, or Barry White. But adding a sense of humor. I just love Bruno Mars...everything he touches turns to gold.
I love the facts that slide in!
Anderson Paak is amazing! If you haven’t seen his NPR music..it’s amazing! The way he can play the drums and sing.
I’ve seen and reacted but it got blocked cause NPR blocks all
Retro Old School🎧🎤 took a Soul Train🚂 to Mars ☄️
Sweet Christmas, I didn’t know how much I needed this until hearing it just now. I love it.
I thought I wouldn't hear a song that captured me like redbone by Donald glover... Than silk sonic dropped this soulful groove that just captured my heart .
We needed this for 2021
This is more the Philly Soul Sound of Gamble, Huff, and Thom Bell. Love your reaction. Great advice for today's musicians. Im old school. I'm So overwhelmed with Anderson and Bruno. What an honor to the 70s greats
Yes!!!
O’Jays, Teddy Pendergrass, Lou Rawls...YES! I need to check out more of this music and that SOUND. Thank you sir.
Yes, also Blue magic, EW&F' slow songs even the Delfonics.
Absolutely the SOP!!
@@MusicShed it’s that Philly Sound! That Jazzmine Sullivan has in her veins too.
Just came across your channel by accident, and was so pleasantly surprised. As a retired Jazz drummer who's played with some jazz greats, Herb Ellis, Harry "Sweets" Edison & Eddie "Lockjaw" Davis, Alan Zavod, and Pete Condoli, I had almost given up on music, until I heard Bruno Mars. You, as a music teacher, are such a breath of fresh air to keep the hope of music alive and are to be commended for it. I've told several of my friends who know of my background, that as far as I was concerned, music as we know it, is dead. Hearing Bruno Mars, gave me hope that someone is still capable of producing a "Melody" and a "Bridge", and making a song with a melody that will stand the test of time. I think Bruno Mar's musical compositions will be just as relevant 20 years from now, as they are today when the rest of the crap is long forgotten. My last comment is, you should also talk about how Bruno Mars and his ensemble use "Dynamics" in creating the overall effect of the melody and its effect on the song. Also, not only is the melody a gas, but the rhythm is cookin.
You did a fantastic job of isolating the keys, chords, and harmonies. You really know your stuff. *Subscribed*
I think that the reason that Bruno and Anderson have such a melodic synchronicity is because they are first and foremost MUSICIANS, then singers, dancers, songwriters, and producers. Hats off for their unashamed seduction through their music...lthix whole album is an instant classic! 🎼🎵🎶🎶🎶🎶
Literally the reaction I've been waiting for with this song.
One of the best reaction reviews I have seen. You explained so well, why those Motown hits are STILL so much in rotation today, and are sampled sooooo much. That formula works! The background vocals and harmony is always a way to add musicality, and layer to a song. These varied layers, and musical variations in keys, all adds to those layers. Just a FANTASTIC song, and collaboration!! Whew!! I just love this song!
If the song "Versace on the floor" had a child .. I think "Leave the door open" is
This was the invite that came before the Versace hit the floor.
@@dmw1906 Leave the door open is a prequel? Awesome!
@@caseyaugust1846 I can't say for sure but both the message and sonically it could at least be implied.
😂
@@dmw1906 That's What I Like is prequel before Versace On The Floor.
It's so good that it won song of the year in 2022 for the Grammy's.
Finally, somebody reacting actually understanding how the key changes affect the musicality and how the song continuously is vibrant bc of this!! Good Job pal
The DNA is Philadelphia soul. Like mainlining seretonin...puts a smile on your face and sunshine in your heart.
Finely i found one quality reaction to this masterpiece.
Beautifully critiqued for such an amazing piece of art work in a song
Now THIS is a reaction. The appreciation, the breakdown, the knowledge! Amazing
I’m a fan of rap or hiphop, edm, reggae but listening to this song feels like my soul moved smooth ; perfect : sensational , breath taking thanks to both Bruno and Anderson bringing old vibes and we need more✌️❤️
I am going through a dark phase in my life and this song has just lift me right up. Thanks bruno, anderson and silk sonic
Let there be light for you!
i start smiling when you just sync with them with your keyboard! your amazing too man! great album too from SilkSonic, hoping for more!
The best reaction by far!
Your breakdown was interesting & informative & gives more of an insight & background to the yesteryear sound
My eyes lit up when you started playing on the keyboard lol
Thanks Uso!
One luv from New Zealand🤙
So Bruno and Anderson went back to the 70s and brought back some black lights in the basement music but they put a new twist on some Thom Bell arrangements and Gamble and Huff writing style love it.😃
For a reaction video, I didn’t expect such in depth breakdowns of the different elements in the song. Awesome video!
I'm not in the music business, just a lover of all kinds of music, especially Rockabilly, Jump Blues, and Roots. I would describe this song as RICH. It's rich, smooth, satisfying and deep. Think dark chocolate mousse.
Your analysis is great. There’s a lot more detail in terms of influences, arrangement, and musical theory all in one video than many more famous TH-camrs.
Refreshing someone knowledgeable reacting to the music
can we just appreciate that he went so much in depth about the song that he made a 15 min reaction vid on a 4 min song
As you went through the soul singers of the past and got to Marvin Gaye "Let's Get It On", I immediately heard that drum and said, Man, Anderson Paak has got it just like that.
I love how in every musician reaction video the reviewers end up either singing or playing
Cheers to a fellow teacher. I agree with everyone who says this is a masterpiece. I'm not a music guy though, so as someone who barely understand what you're teaching, you are definitely a quality teacher. Engaging, informative, relatable and joyful. Well done.
They created something this world needed! Can't wait to release the parody version of this song!
I love listening to intelligent, & knowledgeable people ✨
I love this reaction. You were feeling the music in your soul I can tell lol NICE! This will be the best song of the year! They just set the bar to another dimension 🚀
Awesome analysis. I loved listening to you as well. Great record! Truly a masterpiece. Silk Sonic proved to be smooth and pleasing to the ears and to the soul. Kinda lives up to its name as a band.
Never seen your channel before but man that part at the end with you playing the piano...
You seriously have SKILLS
This is THE jam, in fact the greatest jam I've heard in a long time - the greatest since........Uptown Funk. And then I see my two favorite albums of all time framed in the background (Songs in the Key of Life, Goodbye Yellow Brick Road) and it's a done deal: I subscribed!
also they pay homage and give the GOAT Sir Michael Jackson and Jackson 5 love : "SHA MON" !
Finally found a comment about this 👏🏽
I've watched this breakdown at least 20 times. Watching a true musician react to true musicians makes all the difference in the world. David your ear is phenomenal and your body interpretation is spot on. Excellent bro
Yes! This song has more key changes than the last 5 years worth of music :P I'm so excited about this song... I saw Paak on NPR Tiny Desk Concert, then live at an Amazon AWS trade show, and on Fortnite.. He's so amazing, and I can't think of anyone better than Mars to pair with. Paak is pushing Mars to use his full talents, finally!!
As soon as you brought in the motown sound clips I said to myself, "SELF," I can hang out with this dude! Great reaction bruh...
Just music artistry at its finest.
Jump into this time machine with me and experience true perfection and in the process a lesion in the lost art of romance. An absolute masterpiece!
You NEED to see the live performance if you haven't yet. It's perfection
The breaks in this give me goosebumps.
You are like the Bill Nye of music education! Instant sub!
Hip hop is 40+ years old and is tired.
The call went out to bring back the 70s and Bruno Mars delivered.
One door closed and another door opened.
I don’t think Hip Hop is tired, it would be fine if it stayed consistent with the 92-2006 era. The 70’s is timeless.
Anderson has been infusing his music with 70s funk for a while now. The collaboration is well suited but it's def a grouping of musical equals who share a great appreciation of the classics
@@brandonpryormusic u must be sleeping under a rock. Hip hop is in every genre of today's music.
hip hop is never gonna die? it only continues to evolve, this is a very dumb take
@@nawlinzkid5048 and thats the problem
13:35 though.. How you just came out with that like you were already part of the band.... JHEEEZE!!!! 😭😭😭😍😍😍
I'm so glad you love this song. It's absolutely incredible, absolute magic. Like a warm blend of Stevie Wonder, Earth Wind and Fire, Marvin Gate, Temptations, Michael Jackson.... All rolled into one. I've had it on repeat constantly!!
Careful with this one...lol!!!!
@@MusicShed LISTENNNN... All I'm saying is give it 9 months and we are gonna have a population crisis 😂😂😂😂😂 it's just... WOW.
First time I heard this song I almost jumped out my skin!! I actually screamed driving down the road!! This song is everything !!!
yo this is my first time viewing one of your videos and i must say the production level and your ability to easily explain and go into detail without overcomplicating things, amazes me, keep up the great work
I truly missed true R&B sound. Silk Sonic are a breath of fresh air. True music, sound, good energy/vibration. Music shed I love your analysis and musical awareness.
I have watched multiple reactions to this song. From vocal coaches, to musicians, all the way to your everyday normal person and I must say this reaction right here far exceeds all those I’ve seen. This is an incredible reaction, thank you @MusicShed! In fact I’ll go as far as saying this reactions is my favorite of any reaction to anything that exists wow🙌🏾
That made my day!
@@MusicShed watching all the way from South Africa 🇿🇦!
The camera work and editing for their video is perfect too.