Hindi Debate: 'Unifier' Or 'Imposition'? | The Debate With Arnab Goswami
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ก.ย. 2024
- Republic TV is India's no.1 English news channel since its launch. It is your one-stop destination for all the live news updates from India and around the world. Republic TV makes news accessible for you at your convenience, at all times and across devices. At Republic we keep you updated with up-to-the-minute news on politics, sports, entertainment, lifestyle, gadgets and much more.
We believe in Breaking the story and Breaking the Silence. But most importantly, for us ‘You Are Republic, We Are Your Voice.’
Also, Watch ►
Republic TV Live News Updates ►bit.ly/Republic...
The Debate With Arnab Goswami ► bit.ly/TheDebat...
Patriot With Major Gaurav Arya ► bit.ly/PatriotF...
Exclusive Sunday Debate With Arnab Goswami ► bit.ly/SundayDe...
Checkmate With Major Gaurav Arya (Retd.) ► bit.ly/3EtPj0s
The Grand Strategy With Maj Gen G.D Bakshi (Retd) ► bit.ly/3EPZ6xF
R.Explained ► bit.ly/3sOLT5K
R.Uninterrupted ► bit.ly/34isZdh
You can stay connected with Republic TV on -
Facebook - / republicworld
Twitter - / republic
Website - www.republicwo...
Instagram: / republicworld
#republictv #republicworld #republictvlive #englishnews #news #arnabgoswami #arnabgoswamilive #arnabdebates #nationwantstoknow
Crow's population in India 287 Million
Peacock's population in India 100,000
Peacock is the "Official" National bird of India.
Crow should be the National bird of india because of population.
Why not mosquitoes if number is the game instead of quality. Jai Modiji for quality leadership.
@@jst875 maybe "Official" National Insect Since Mosquito is an insect not a Bird
@@jst875 first know the difference between birds and insects
agreed then are you OK to have Hindi as national language.
@@ravikodukula Bro I don't think u understand a concept in English Called Sarcasm (I do hope u google it after seeing my reply)
Tamil For All...who is with me??
Those Hindi speaking people who live n earn in TN Kerala n Karnataka can return to the North in case they too support Hindi as a language imposition
Capital punishment for you ? Who is with me ??
@@serpens9637 for what? Not speaking Hindi ... Tf 🤣🤣
What's Tamil? Oh...the language which 5% of India speak?
@@naiyayika Nope. The language which has an official language status in Tamil Nadu,Sri Lanka, Malaysia, Singapore and has minority language status in Australia, Canada, Mauritius and South Africa
The language which has very much similarities between Korean, Bahasa Indonesia, Bahasa Malay and even Japanese
@@naiyayika what’s Hindi? Oh the language with abusing families?
🙂
I don't know why Arnab become a Journalist or TV Anchor instead of Referee in Wrestling Ring. Every day he invited 10 people for 50 min program and we see the hate is spreading more deep and deeper into the people's mind.
All those people in India, I will ask a very simple question. Would you like to see a United India or Independent Tamilnadu?
Because anyone who asks for Hindi to be National one language of India is asking for war they can't win. And Tamilnadu is ready to fight this war to the last Tamil man standing.
Him and most of his panelists should be casted in the center fresh advert. Lap ...lap ..lap....
@40:49 - Kasturi to shouting Nupur --> Better to have a "Sir hangover" than a "Mughal hangover" :). LOL... the Tamil lady nailed it. Most commonly used words in Hindi (for example sabzee, chaaku, dimaag, galat, kurzi, khoon, dil, dost, kamra and countless others) are all Arabic or Persian. And most Hindi speakers aren't aware of them. Original Sanskrit words are more commonly used in South Indian languages like Kannada & Malayalam (where Mughal/Arabic influence was limited).
Here some people's are commenting nd thinking,tat tamilians are unpatriotic, nd hating hindi.....it is not the fact!!!!! Abdul Kalam, Abhinandan,isro chairman Sivan etc,they are also tamilian too,Our(tamilians) patriotism towards India is unquestionable!!!!! U guys must learn from us..... India means unity in diversity!!!!! If I learn hindi,will u learn my Tamil, Kannada or Telugu???
Even I'm a BJP supporter,but it doesn't mean to accept everything!!!!!!
Do u know one thing,in India,large number of people are learning hindi in Tamil Nadu through hindi prachar sabha in Chennai. Nearly 6.5 lakhs people's are studying hindi in Tamil Nadu. If people want,they learn anything any language,but if u stuff forcefully,they ll vomit!!!!!!!
JAI BHARAT!!!!!!!
JAI HIND!!!!!!!
INDIA not only belongs to hindi,it belongs to Tamil,Kannada,Telugu,Marathi Bengali etc,tat every languages are originated in India belongs to India....so pls stop this hindi imposition!!!!!!
BuT they are!! Dravidian bigotry towards North Indian's especially people from the Hinterland has totally gotten out of hand in recent years. I see it online all the time. No matter what an India related video/social media post or whatever is about, some southie will come and in and make it about south vs north then try to pretend like Kerela or Tamil Nadu is like southern California and UP and Bihar are sub Saharan Africa. This hatred for Hindi is part of that Bigotry.
Its beyond delusional some of the things they say and beleive in. They should just go and look at GDP production in the last fiscal year and where which state was and their delusions will dissapear...
But where is the imposition?
@@rakeshsarvabhotla4998 there is none, Amit Shah just gave them a good excuse to spit out the toxic vitriol against Hindi and its speakers and they grabbed it with both hands.
@@VimalKumar-iu2xf and weather u like it or not Hindi is the unifying language north of vindhyas de facto already. Go anywhere from Maharashtra to Kashmir and there is a very high chance of people u meet knowing Hindi already. Facts won't change just to make you happy.
My mother tongue is hindi but i have been brought up chennai and have being staying here for the last 28 years. Most of my close friends are all south indian. But from my experience after staying here for so many years, there are lots of people [localites] here who are educated and including the autowala, taxiwalas, etc even after knowing how to speak english and/ or hindi would never speak to other i.e. non-tamilans in that language but in tamil. These people say that if you are in tamil nadu you need to learn to speak in tamil because we stay in Tamil Nadu because they dont want to go beyond speaking tamil. These autowalas would also take advantage of charging double the amount from non-tamilians because they do not understand tamil.
I have passed out my 12th std from state board school in 2006 and I very clearly remember when I was in my 11th std, just few months before our annual exams the government had passed the rule stating that it is mandatory learn scientific tamil in state board or matriculation. After staying here for so many years I had learnt to speak tamil on my own will and wish. Though i was sick and had to stay in the house, my parents had encourage me to put in effort to learn to wright the basic words and letters through my uncle within one month before the tamil exams since i couldnt attend my school in order to pass that paper. But I am sorry to say that even localite &/ or the people who had choosen tamil as their second language found it difficult and the very next year they had removed it. So pls tell me then why am I being imposed to learn to wright tamil language, just because I choose to stay in chennai. Let me tell you I love the people and place because of their simplicity and non-interfearing in nature but I still dont agree with their decision to make it mandatory to learn tamil in the school.
If you go to any place in the north or north-east or to places like bombay/ pune/ hyderabad/ bangalore, etc, people know hindi [i am not talking about whether they can write hindi or not], they all &/ or most of them can converse in hindi. But here especially in tamil nadu, most of them neither encouage nor do they wanna learn other other languages and I am talking about uneducated people or politicians.
Let me also tell you that when these people go other states in India, they find it difficult to converse in those languages because they dont know any other indian languages other than tamil [pls i am also including the who people who know english] find it difficult to survive. Its even worse when these people go outside India, they are discriminated not only by foreigners but by fellow imdiands just because they don't know hindi and then they find it difficult to gel in with them just because of the language. This is the experiences which couple of my friends and/ or other young people had faced while staying in abroad and then they themselves are telling us that we should also learn and also encourage orthers to learn hindi in order to survive and are not be discriminated.
Lets understand what Mr. Shah had stated that he appreciates the fact that we Indians have so many reginal language which are equally importand, this means that we all believe in unity in diversity but it is also important to have one common language which we all can understand i.e. hindi since most of us can understand and converse in it. So pls tell me how many of you all including tamilian can understand &/ or converse in Malayalam, Telugu, Kannada, Marathi, Bengoli, Urdu, Gujrati, Tamil, etc. But you all still argue and/ or emphasize that we shouldn't make hindi as a common language just because you feel inferior but you want all the non-tamil speaking people to learn tamil just because we chose to stay in chennai or any other places in TN.
Kusturi good speech...
India will divide if we spoil diversity as Amit shah is doing
Did you listen to what Amit shah said?
I agree diving of India if any thing happens to my language..
@@krishnaraj7374 comments like this on social media gives chance to enemy countries to harbour separatism. Please refrain from commenting stuffs like this.
@@dineshdevjibishnoi in southern railway job 95%north Indians now most central government job given to north indian
Dinesh Bishnoi . No refain from comment a fact is a fact..
The lady in white and black is irritating and bugging..We don't need a language to unite us..I wanna gag her ..What united us is our understanding and respect we have for each other
Donkeys are more than Bengal Tigers....lets make Donkey as National animal😆😆😆😆
Hahahahha...like you!!
Atleast don't spoil the image of Saurav ganguly...
I will see which language comes out of your mouth the moment you would step out of Bengal!!
@@geetsharma6944 Hey pani puri....
Haha I am not a Bengali...
I am Tamilian....Even your grandfathers can't able to make Tamilians to speak single word in Hindi since 1965...
You idiots stop producing more babies which destroys Indian economy...
@@bharaths9071 Yes can't tolerate when they trying to impose the language which does not even have 500 years of history....Also the that language does not even have own script for writing....
Atleast we can learn if that language helps to get jobs like English but eveyday lacks and lacks of peoples coming to south to work as daily labours...They should implement Tamil, Kannada,Telugu and Malaiyalam in north indian schools because they are only coming here..
Instead of promoting Hindi they can provide education and jobs for Hindi speaking peoples....They just cheating them...
We south Indians are studying here and getting jobs here and going all over the globe with English....
They don't even have single reason or rights to ask South Indian to learn Hindi...
@@geetsharma6944 I will see what you will say when you come out of that cow belt 🤣🤣
@@venkateshdhanapal5991 this is all you can come up with?
Again I am telling doing spoil the image of Saurav ganguly...
See you are ugly as hell poor as pit..even if I want to try..can't help you bit!!
Getting food items shows your class..the way you are using them to prove your point again shows ..your class...and you are calling me Pani Puri!! There are so many southies in North..selling dosa idli..but I cant be harsh on them...why ?? Bcz they are doing their job...atleast respect food!!
But lack of exposure is the result of asses like you shitting here!!
Now go and get yourself fucked by your Tamil dildo!! And why would my grandfathers want to teach you Hindi?
Who are you? Other than being ugly and poor ( in every sense) who are you ..nobody...your language is as you claim ages old...may be early men spoke this language...then go back to that age!!! Humein baksho...chutiyo!!
I am sure even dogs can understand more than you asses!!
Arnab.. U said kamal is lying only because his statement is in english.. Then y the hell the whole debate is in English😂
When did he say that Kamal Hassan is lying because he is saying it in English, U should watch whole debate again, he said Kamal Hassan is lying, he is an actor, and he is lying, arnab never said that he is lying because he is speaking in English
Well said bro👍
You idiot. It's english channel
A foul........if the vedio was made in hindhi......then u mad people will only see the commends from hindhi speakers.......
Hahahaha
TAMILAN WILL NEVER EVER LEARN AND PROMOTE HINDHI TILL IT IS BEING IMPOSED ON US................
@@tomsad658 first learn english.
If a 6th class kid in Delhi don't learn Tamil ..
Why should a 6th class kid in Madurai should learn Hindi ?? 🤔😶
Both are not compulsory according to law 🤣
@@harisht3588 hindi is compulsory bro in north indian states especially in case schools
@@dravidkumar5845 it is even Compulsory I'm Telugu states-- Telugu,Hindi, English are compulsory upto 10th class....in 11 and 12 th telugus take Sanskrit and English for easy marks
@@parvatiparameswara
We Telugu people must fight against Hindi & remove this out of syllabus
@@pokemonitishere202 - this shows your mentality. Don't worry BJP will soon take over Andhra Pradesh and Telangana in the upcoming election and you will be taught Hindi.
Nation wants to know about Keeladi requesting Republic tv to talk about it.
Na! We ll talk more about Hindi!
praveen s they bring up these stupid topics to deviate from ground reality.
Arnab will report if they found modi photos there
santhosh kumar lol
Republic TV:
Sry no time ,
We will speak later.......😂😂
Wanna know the arrogance of hindi speakers... Just watch this debate... 😒😏... This debate provokes more hateredness towards hindi 💔
THARUEN SELVAN Hindi Imposers Ignorant Arrogant Hindi language Insufficient Iranian and Ionian English language has been Indianised and Ingleesh will stay for ever in south India Hindi IS a foreign language for all non Hindi Indians English is less foreign to Tamilians Kannadigas Telugu Malayalee Manipuris Meghalayans etc than Hindi
South Indians and north east people love English no northie can or should question our liking for English
Many northies love Persian Arabic do south people question North Indians liking Persian as a
Language of their former masters
Tamil Kannada Malayalee Telugu etc are foreign Languages in Hindi belt
That’s why they are not learning the South Indian languages
Dont worry bro.. they will screw their communities living down south.. i watch this video, and then i enjoy whole day humiliating pani puris.. i am a foodie..
@@dcmhsotaeh they r not learning South Indian languages because you r not learning Marathi, Bengali, Bhojpuri, Rajasthani, Gujarati, Kashmiri, Sindhi, Assamese, konkani, manipuri, mizo, urdu
@@dcmhsotaeh first u should think what u r saying, is there any base to that, or just speak whatever comes in ur head
@@rocketegg4454 they're teaching Bengali Marathi Gujarati Punjabi Bhojpuri in Bimaru Hindi belt schools??????????????????
Abdul Kalam from Tamil and he don’t speak Hindi .. If we compare Hindi vs Tamil we can compare a lot .. don’t impose Hindi to south
saravana prakash I never knew this . Thanks 🙏
Our Andhrapradesh children's are learning hindi in our school. U hindi people can learn Telugu in schools ? Why ?
PRABHAKARA RAO we should not learn hindi in school also .. in Tamilnadu we won’t learn hindi in school
@@prabhu741181 😂😄
@@prabhu741181 chal be chutiye
we dont want pani puri languages in our southern states
Seriya sollitinga
@@धर्मेशकुमार-ष4स is it india is your father property???
Jai south india
@@amalpv5600 kala madrasi
@@धर्मेशकुमार-ष4स yes you north indians 🤣🤣 .jai south india..
Jai dravidanadu
@@amalpv5600 your mother is my wife 😂😂
Kasthuri we admire your passion, intellect and courage. We stand with you.
Awesome Kasturi 👍
Haha.. any reference??
Arnab, don't behave like absolute stupid. Have some neutral ground man.!.
Arnab is racist against south indian especially for tamilian, he never acted as neutral man south indians dont participate in the pro BJP TV debates, he is acting as RSS corporate wing secretary
Arnab is a chameleon , look at his attitude change and his blatant agenda once he quit times now 🥴
@Zinia Sarkar why are you sold out to Congress
If Kamal Hassan is acting what you, Modi, Amit Shah, BJP, RSS and all right-wing idiots are doing? The Battle lines are drawn by North, not by South.
I ask all South to unite and get ready for the battle. The battle must be fought for our language, tradition, culture, rights and protection of our history.
Modi,Amit Shah .International actors.
One correction. Not an international actor rather, an international joker
@@parthibanc9177 yes
Have a battle for urself in your mind..u need it so bad !!
North Indians are very powerful, they control the govt, Indian army and public services. So south Indians sooner than later may come out as losers. But North Indians will get hurt greviously as well, as their stand is completely wrong. English is the best choice.
I am typically North Indian and regular hindi speaker. I went and spend 5 month in Tamilnadu. I am requesting don't impose any language on anyone. Tamilians don't only speak Tamil rather they breathe. By imposing any language, soon or later definitely diminishes the identity of a particular region.
Agreed...
Please tell same thing to all bollywood peoples & hindi speakers migrated to Maharashtra to learn Marathi...
We wont talk hindi in our state for outsiders convinience...
Marathi is my identity...
It will be full blown war between Hindi and non hindi people
@@Ashish-G- Haha…. Do you know marathi??
thanks , you are so kind person
@@sairajpai9594 whats haha in this?
The problem with Republic TV debate is no one will understand, always Fighting.
totally agree...... they think this way they get TRP...
n I change the channel.
They intentionally do that
Yes 100% correct.....Debates in Republic is shouting match....Of late I stopped watching Republic debates...some times I just watch their news that's all.
Republic TV is the place of barking!
Watch NewsX..
Lol! this debate is in "ENGLISH"
Yes, because many South Indians don't speak Hindi.
It's just because it's an English channel. REPUBLIC BHARAT has it in Hindi.
@@dineshdevjibishnoi Yes :) That's another fact, that Republic TV started with an English channel, but not a Hindi ;)
@@coolguyqamar Yes, I myself am a south Indian :)
@R v Yes, I agree. Well said.
kasturi was most sensible and practical than others on this debate!
I speak telugu and it will always be mother tongue ...... Nobody can force me to speak Hindi 🥱
Telugu 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Keka sodaraa
Q : why hindi
Ans : for uniting india
Q : are we not united now
Ans: no we are always united then
Q : then why hindi
Ans : for better communication
Q : is English bothering you because it make a level playing field for both of us
Ans : But English is a foreign language... Don't be slave under English
Q : then why india is globalized... People are working in MNC'S... need for FDI.... People prone to western dressing style... Ideologies.... Get rid of our own culture and tradition... Etc.. Etc...
Ans : you are linguistic racist
Q : but its you want us to learn hindi
Ans : yes hindi is spoken by many people
Q : but why can't they learn English... How do they survive in this globalized world... Why hindi belt is weak in development and litreacy... And migrating towards south in lakhs... But why are you asking us learn hindi for your convenience..??
Ans : you are an anti indian
Q :,why there is no PM in from north eastern states and only a couple from south
Ans : because they don't know hindi
Q : so you people accept us only after when we know hindi
If answer is yes... Then it's not that important to liver with these kind of racist people
If answer is no.. Then they are wonderful and proven to be the best in accepting india's diverseness
Its all about them.. They are saying that we are not imposing... But repeatedly suggesting to ask us to learn hindi.and wants their language to spread... But we want all indian languages to be spread and recognized internationally... Need government funding without any partialities.
Govt is not funding hindi language it's more popular in more than half of country which is reality.
@@ravikodukula oh what is the matter deals with languages and population...!.. Its 400 crore for hindi.. Amd. Not even a single rupee for kannada or bengali
@@ravikodukula Single language being a unifying factor is a joke. People of Pakistan pretty much speak the same language as North Indians. LOL... Do they want to unite with India? Hindi being an Indian language is a misnomer. It is mostly the language of Islamic invaders (who were just as brutal or even more brutal than Britishers). Almost all the commonly used words in Hindi (for example kitaab, bachhaa, khaana, sabzee, chaaku, dimaag, galat, kurzi, khoon, dil, dost, kamra, khel, yaad, safed, nahaana, beewi, kaanoon, adaalat, aadmi, hawaa and countless others) are all Arabic or Persian words. One other thing - Hindi is much more foreign language in Tamil Nadu than English. English at least has a large presence in Tamil Nadu since last 400 years. Hindi (especially the Arabic/Persian Hindi) was never ever spoken here at all.
@@yuck4u only tamilians can find such illogical,foolish reasonings for anything, you can go for any extent to support Tamil and defame other ,. Tamil and other southern languages as of same generation,. 400 years of English only had popularity, usage by 10% of population in span India. If Pakistan want to join as per your logic then it's great welcome, but it's definetly not possible with Tamil, I think you agree with it.
@@ravikodukula 😂🤣😂 I am not a Tamilian. But your hatred & bigotry towards Tamilians & South Indians has come out. Your idiotic population % logic is immaterial because we have no desire to impose our languages (Tamil, Telugu, Kannada etc.) on you, or on rest of India. We are happy if they continue to speak their language and give us the freedom to speak ours. I genuinely admire your broad mindedness to Pakistanis though. Those people raped & looted your ancestors. Hindi-speaking Kashmiri Pandits were raped, killed & kicked out of their homeland. Even today they kidnap, rape & convert your Hindi-speaking Hindu sisters still living in Pak, but despite all this you still welcome them with open arms. That's really admirable. Next time you draw the map of India, feel free to exclude Tamil Nadu & Andhra etc., and include Pakistan. Hindi has never ever been spoken widely in our lands, and if any imposition is done, South will be more than happy to part from Indian Union.
Lakhs of Southerns can understand and can speak to some extent in Hindi. Tell us how many northerns can speak say Tamil
How many % of Indians speak Tamil??? I can speak Tamil but I never speak to Tamil addicted people. Tnrw idiots like u will say we want Tamil i. Defence also 😂😂😂
Zero
Northeners can speak their mother tongue plus Hindi also they can understand other northen languages and dont underestimate or look down on people who cant speak in English fluently. Talk about imposition ,south Indians hsyve imposed English which is a foreign language on others who cant speak tamil
@@lotuswolf1518 we know our mother tongue and we learn business language who ever need English. All said 43% of people speaking hindi but inside how many others mother tongue died. So Our generation pride to save our Tamil.. as of now we proved 3500 BC old.. we will surely learn Hindi who else need ...
@Bisnudatta Parhi English wil give jobs and providence me sustenance. What about your Hindhi will give us jobs? If not then keep your hindhi language with you. We are fine with our regional language which is our Identity and english our business language.
Kasturi scored sixer in this debate!!!!
Zero, she showed the world that how low self esteem person she is, her negative attitude 🤷
Ask her to represent Team India. Oh, sorry, Team Tamil Nadu.
@@rocketegg4454 lol.. Nupur is the one who had bad attitude. Kasturi answered every question she asked and also stated some logical statements but nupur is tired of shouting the same thing that she doesn't have any answers . She says that no one is imposing hindi and again says why can't you learn hindi
@@serpens9637 you go represent hindia
@@serpens9637 sure! Sir Abdul Kalam represented India more than anyone can yet with no Hindi! ( I love Hindi but not this attitude ).
Now I am convinced , arnub is undercover BJP agent
Spy undercover 🤣🤣🤣😂😅😆😁
Yes he is pro bhp..
Kasturi is soo cute..i am a big fan of this smart woman..arnab is falling for her too i think
BABY NIKABI ..Best comment in the entire thread ..👏👏
I am proud to be tamilan
I'm a proud Bengali toooooo❤
Good for you
Kasthuri was rocking!!! Hats off!!!
I support bjp but not on this..... we tamils learn french german japanese in chennai itself... thats our choice of langauage to learn....
@Bisnudatta Parhi neither i did say...... but i need not to learn hindi for your convince to rule me
Listen Batman Superman, I know you love challenging languages like french, german and japanese. What I don't get is your superiority complex by refusing to learn Hindi. There are many states which learn hindi along with their mother tongue. They don't have any issues with it. Do you think by learning hindi, your freedom is dictated? What sick mentality you have.
Makeup Googli we don’t Hve any sick mentality but why you guys are forcing us to learn Hindi????Are we guys forcing you to learn our language... Never!
@@serpens9637 see i have learnt sanskrit so that i can read and write hindi... and i have no issues to learn hindi.... u north indians do not know whats the ground level politics is going in tamil nadu..... there many schools in tn which make to pay fine when i speak in my mother tongue......if we accept to learn hindi there are many institutions are waiting to make only hindi....k tell me how many gujaratis, maratis, punjabis are good at their mother tongue.....? Many young generations are good at only hindi not on their mother tongue.... this s what we dont want in tn
@@proudmuslimah9121 Stupid girl, I am Marathi and Oriya. No Marathi and Oriya has ever said that Hindi is forced. Don't try to be a victim of Hindi capitalism.
ஏண்டி நேப்பூர் மோடி அமெரிகாவுல ஹிந்தில பேசுவரா
Hats off you Kasturi, fabulous..proud to be a tamilian..Dear my north people, never try to spoil/touch (in the name of Hindi) our own south cultures....
Are u a fool? This hindi imposition affects Bengali Gujarati Marathi Punjabi Assamese Odia etc ppl as much as it effects Kannada Telugu Tamil Malyalam ppl stop doing north south here also
Kasturi speaks total sense and speaks logically and puts forth her points politely!!
She shouldn't have stooped down to low levels and entered big boss in th3 first place ...she is far above that and way too talented!!
Dear Sir, I don't think she was being polite. There is a difference between logical and playing victim card of hindi oppression.
@@serpens9637 she was and she made a point that learning a language should be our choice. not be imposed on anybody 👍
@@Joshi-ew8zw It's like saying that bad mouthing about our country is our choice. No wonder, we can never progress as a nation.
@@serpens9637 first of all, India is not single Nation or country. Constitution of India says India the Union of States. Every state has their own culture, language, food, custom,etc. So, don't destroy it. That's why I India is called Sub-continent. All the states are like different countries. We're together with one condition.
I speak Telugu and I will treat my Telugu as my major language
Brother I am from Maharashtra and we speak Marathi only, but we also learn Hindi as an extra language, I don't see any cultural crisis and all the other things that your politicians were saying about Maharashtra, he just fooling u people and playing his political game so that he'll have large number of people for votes, I don't understand what u people think
@@rocketegg4454 we didn't said we will not learn Hindi,hindi is already thought in our 6th to 10th but now they are rubbing Hindi& English in every single industry even in banking,we are not allowed to speak our native language in a professional space ,by the way kamal Hassan is speaking for tamilians not Telugu people know the difference
@@rocketegg4454 that is why marthi is almost on the death bed in mumbai point is if hindi becomes national language all regional languages will have natural death in near future like awadhi bojpuri
I am from maharashtra, I dont need any third language like hindi in my state..
Hindi speaking outsiders are creating linguistic crisis in maharashtra also...
We are losing our linguistic identity due to this hindi...
I strongly oppose Hindi in our state Maharashtra....
@@universalman395 bang on point.👍
Hindi is killing regional classical languages.
Our marathi peoples are still unaware about threat of hindi... they are very naively accepting hindi because this hindi lobby politicians, bollywood lobby are brainwashing our peoples & sadly..Some Marathi people are falling for that..
Hindi is not our language....
Only Marathi in Maharashtra...
What waste of time....nobody heard anyones argument.
Praise arnab for having 10 participants
This isn't new he invites guests and ask questions and instead of listening what they are saying he shouts
i only watch first 3-4 min and then i left.
Nupur was clearly jealous over kasthuri's slang😂😂😂
South indians have there own native language which is superior than so called hindi in many ways.We dont want to downgrade ourselves.Most of them can speak good english too.The tag bharathiya doesnt mean that one has to learn hindi.We are a nation with diverse people who is bound together by cultural unity.
kasthuri totally defeated nupur , nupur was looking like a weak opponent, Nupur was an absolute joke, nupur was a total diffidence , while kasthuri exhibited confidence, bravo Kasthuri , im from maharashtra and i support you, i love my Marathi
don't impose Hindi to South..Telugu is more sweetest language.. we don't want any other lang to be imposed on us
I am also a Telugu person...and no one is imposing Hindi...only awareness is being spread
I also live in Hyderabad, nobody is imposing you anything
I agree with you...we don't need hindi
Then why u speaking English
@truth speaker Anthea antava bro
Very proud of Kasturi. வாழ்க.
English must be imposed on UP, Bihar, MP etc. This way these states can develop.
Such a stupid comment. Not all Russians and Chinese know English and they are quite developed.
@@dineshdevjibishnoi Ok impose Chinese or Russian but not Hindi.
@@kanishkakushan761 can't help but ignore if you think opposing Hindi is your birthright. I know kannada, English and Hindi. And that doesn't mean I forgot my mother tounge. I'm now on way to learn Bengali. I also want to learn Tamil. We should respect and try to learn each other's language.!
PS: will not be replying further as you have showed your IQ. Not everybody wants to go to Russia and China if that's what you meant by that comment.
@@kanishkakushan761 😄 Good point. Ask these people to learn English. These people show only 2 countries that don’t know English. We have lot of other grown countries that know English.
Aravind Goswami is better actor then Kamal Haasan,
See the emotions we have accept as a actor, not a Anchor
not just Tamil. even Kannadigas are not in support of one unifying language. Jai Karnataka jai kannada jai hindh
Kasturi is the star ⭐️
See I am a Kannadiga and I speak Kannada as my mother language. Let me worship my Kannada and allow me to love Tulu, Kodava, Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam, Marathi, Gujarathi, Odia, Assamese, Bengali, Hindi, Kashmiri, Urdu, English, German, Hibrow, Spanish, etc. As a Kannadiga I am Indian and not as Hindi speaking person. Let us give that linguistic freedom to us🙏
I think the title should have been 44% hindi speaking v/s 56% other languages together . Take the percentage between North and south India divide That would have interpreted who is trying to impose or propose hindi.
No one said they will not learn hindi, but by changing the practice of writing exams of the Railways and the Postal exams in English and hindi only, is this not imposition? The milestones in tamilnadu was changed to English and hindi? Why not in Tamil and hindi? Why remove tamizh?
If you want to replace a foreign language English, then the above exams should have been in regional language and Hindi instead of English.
Who are the liars here?
Dear brother, railways exam is a central exam not state psc exam. Imagine each candidate frm each State writing in their resp languages. Hence d common languages of English and Hindi.
@@aniruddhajoshi2841
Dear Quaesitor luminis ,
Thanks for your reply with a dash of sarcasm/ ignorance that it was a not a state psc exam. Well, Nobody said so. Sorry for your level of comprehension about the issue and my comments therewith.
My reference was to the incident wherein three days before the written exams for recruitment of POSTMAN and other posts, the postal department WITHDREW the option of writing exams in any regional languages other than English and hindi . Are you aware of this? If not please read " times of India " dated 20 Feb 2019.
Then, upon the Madras high court's intervention on a PIL on 30 Jul 2019 the central government had to cancel those exams and later convinced the court that exams can be written in the regional languages as it used to be earlier !!!
Nobody opposed learning hindi, but like in this incident by removing the option of a regional language, do you call it as someone is proposing hindi or imposing hindi?
Your lame excuse of issues in correction of these papers falls flat as these regional languages are recognized and acknowledged as official languages as per our constitution, and we have adequate resource and structure to correct these papers.
If one feels that English is a foreign language and has to be discontinued, then English has to be removed and not the regional language, right? Do you still see proposing of hindi here and not imposing?
Moreover, if hindi is to be treated as a unifier within India, so would be English with the outside world and the regional language within the state, right?
Have you ever thought of the logic of why should a person for the position of a Postman write exams in hindi while he has to sort and deliver the letters written by the people in Tamil in this case ?
It is not that South Indians oppose hindi but the truth is hindi people oppose south Indian languages and wants to impose only hindi. How can we claim that we respect all the regional languages while we have only "Hindi divas" and what about " Kannada, Telugu, Malayalam,Tamil ( one of the oldest languages in the world) or any other regional language divas? Is this too difficult to comprehend my friend ?
Finally the solution to this issue may be 3 language policy :
1) Regional language within the state.
2) Maybe Hindi within the country (not mandatory )
3) English with the outside world.
This would lead to Unity in diversity, else the logic seems rubbish otherwise.
@@senthil4707 Tragedy is, nobody from Cow belt, who keeps pushing Hindi, is going to read or listen to anything we say.
Tasmac unites tamil culture and tamil language. Scamsters, womanisers, soul peddlars in the garb of politicians are expected to preserve Tamil language and culture. Tamil leaders are great. The fact is today Tamil language and literature is so corrupt that Lankans speak and write better than us. Promote tasmac to preserve our culture and language.
@@sridharsanthanam5284 Yes Tasmac culture is bad. But despite this we are better than 75% of Indian States :)
We are Telugu speaking parrots not Hindhi speaking Cows. We respect Telugu. Do not force us... We don't need Hindi...
Support from tn👌
Super tammu
@@viharvicky1165 den why english stupid ? we 1 language of our country if tamil will national language we dnt hv any problems we need 1 national language with our mother tongue language ...
@@prabhatsingh296 if ter is indeed a need for one language why hindi.have you ever the concept of unity in diversity.why do we need one language at first point.
@@viharvicky1165 u didn't got my point 1st read carefully I said if tamil language kannada languages bengali language be national language den I dnt hv problems .. tanu reach carefully
Why center is not conducting central exams in their mothertounge languages
Modiji and Amitsha cannot dictate South Indians in this language matter
Exactly why are these nethas not asking same point? Because they want people to be divided for their votes.
why my son will compete in Hindi with a Hindi speaking person? let both compete in English.
This is not about competition, it's about communication. That's why in colleges, we have English and not Hindi or other language.
Let Hindi be only in primary school, where kids learn a new language so they can communicate with most people of India. That's all.
@@MastiKaHathi THAT IS NOT THE BJP AGENDA MY DEAR.
@@MrPatrasanjit On one hand we give example of how China or USA is ahead of us in everyway......but like them doesn't want to have a one common language which every citizen understand and communicate.
If not Hindi then let it be Sanskrit, but we do need one Indian language which every Indian understands. It doesn't mean you should stop using English or any other language you know.
@@MastiKaHathi SEE, I DONT REPLY TO PEOPLE WHO DO NOT HAVE THE COURAGE TO GIVE THEIR REAL NAMES.A COWARD HAS NO VIEWS BECAUSE HE IS ASHAMED OF HIMSELF.
@@MrPatrasanjit derailing the issue at hand, still living under colonialism I guess. Anyway, you should get off of internet if you don't like other people's internet.
Also you yourself using prank name of Sambit Patra.
Amita Shah is a real cunning person First of all ask him what his agenda behind ...Because you are a devotee of Modi
I support Tamil but never vote for DMK!.
Although I support 3 language policy and not Hindi as the unifier (rather Sanskrit bcoz almost all languages have fundamentally common words matching with Sanskrit and it's also written in directive principals of our Constitution), but see how even Muslims across the country are taking interest in fueling the voice against Hindi when the fact is that almost all Indian Muslims cutting across different regions can speak very good Urdu and that too because of Islam which teaches them to not respect regional/ethnic/national/linguistic identities.
I can understand my South Indian friends having problem with Hindi speaking people getting unfair advantage, and that's why Sanskrit is mentioned in the Constitution bcoz apart from a very very few people, everyone will have to learn Sanskrit on the basis of his/her mother language and that'll balance the unfair advantage which was otherwise to Hindi speaking people. Moreover I also understand Tamil is equally great but then forcing Tamil will also give an unfair advantage to Tamil speaking people...nah?
BTW we now have universal language translator as well which can even translate the sentiments using AI. So chill and don't make it my language vs yours. Already Aryan Dravidian Theory is gone. They now have this one thing left in their armor but sooner or later that too will fade away....India will find one way or the other...Deal with it...haha
@@avinashmishra7735 they shouldn't have a problem with Hindi though. No matter what their politicians say. Its simple logic, Hindi is spoken and understood across all northern states pretty much, its NOT just UP and Bihar as they like to say in a derogatory manner. Meanwhile pretty much all Languages are one state languages... (this UP/Bihar ridicule is another matter that needs to be addressed soon now. Its getting pretty bad across India with actual discrimination because of the narrative that has been spread. Ofc bastards who call themselves "liberal" will never speak against it cuz it doesn't suit their narrative!)
@@avinashmishra7735 Sanskrit will be a great choice but practically it is too difficult for all Indians to pick it up. So Hindi is a practical choice. it is similar to how English has become a global language even though most of the countries have their own native language i.e most people understand it. Another advantage is Hindi letters are close to Sanskrit and it is easy if anyone wants to learn Sanskrit additionally.I wish the day should come where Sanskrit is mainstream language at least between educated people.
Go srilanka singapore Malaysia some Arabic place speaking Tamil.. it means everyone learn tamil no .. no because english only help us to get a job . else
There is know mother language for Tamil because Tamil is mother for all languages you were saying about Sanskrit interrelated to all languages in India or world say me his it related to Tamil ? Tamil is different no word or verb can matches it in Sanskrit and for your information Tamil is world oldest living language so we don't want Hindi we need Tamil or Sanskrit .
I know kannada, english, C, C++ and Java. I want to learn kotlin and swift.
🤣🤣🤣
Good one mate!!
Actress Kasturi on fire😁
Kasturi the best part of the debate and Nupur the most disgusting and disgraceful .She did in fact exposed her own insecurities inferiority complex by making personal attacks on a co panelists
anand venkatesh, people who don't have valid points yell the most and throw ad hominem insults.
If u touch Language BJP never can root in South India....
Rightly said. It’s like kicking honey bee 🐝 hornet
Karnataka BJP.. teangana almost picking up . Ap tdp going to mergee party with bjp .. that's nothing. We have to unite to stop language barrier ... whether bjp or Congress or com are same bro .. we have to kick everyone .
.
Sheshadri Golla learning is different and Imposing is different. I too know Hindi .. No need to convert south culture to North culture.. it’s like religious conventions only.. Christians and Muslims wants to spread their religion.. same way this gvt wants to spread language..
Waran Magesh good point
Sheshadri Golla Karnataka is most cosmopolitan in south India. So it was easy for BJP it would be Never easier in Telangana & AP. Forget about Tamil Nadu. BJP has been a marwari hindi party and would remain so. 👎
கிந்திகாரர்கள் அதிகமாக இருந்தால் தனியாய் போய் தொலைங்கடா மற்ற மாநிலத்தவர்களாவது நிம்மதியா இருக்கட்டும்.
If Hindi is majority please go and form a separate country lets rest live in peace.
@Ankit Sharma
I explained in Tamil did u understand that?
But you understand so now you tell me does Tamil is Indian language or English is Indian language?
Each n evey Hindi people are studying in English medium only they themselves not ready to learn in Hindi medium.
If i am living Delhi I'll learn hindi/Punjabi if in Kolkata I'll Bengali so similarly if Hindi moves to tamilnadu u have learn Tamil moving to Karnataka learn Kannada but hindians are expecting others to speak Hindi thats the true imposition they themselves think that they are 1st class citizen and that's reason Hindi people being kicked off and they get killed in states like Assam.
@Ankit Sharma
You are wrong, Ankit u misunderstood me i don't hate any language. I'm saying we shouldn't impose any language all language should be equally treated.
U know something when was in Chennai airport a airport checking officer speaking me with me Hindi don't you think that was imposing and rude. All the Central govt exams are conducted only on Hindi and English are we not paying the Tax are we not the citizenship of india? This kind of partially makes us feel inferiority.
Nepal, srilanka are small country can Indian govt can impose Hindi on them population wise area wise they are smaller than Tamilnadu if they can stand and live us a separate country without Hindi imposition why tamilnadu can't be.
The passport is written in Hindi English it's not in my mother tongue Tamil If Indian govt can't speak my language then how can i feel proud that this is my country.
We don't want any national language . Don't supress any language. Our country is proud of it's diversity please keep it.
We dont need hindi in South India!!!
You need hindi😡😡😡😡 to order panipuri 'bhaiyya eik plate panipuri'😂
😂😂
@@samrudhshetty7687 this shows your hate .
Hindi had been the language of Sindhu part of pre-british and British India. Only educated people speak in hindi then.
Now that Sindhu is in Pakistan.
India belongs to Tamils.
Tamil should be the national language of Bharath.
Let politicians of North to speak in Hindi.
Tamil will Unify Bharath.
India should to have recollections for why Westbengal became separate by Language.
Arnab I want ask one thing to you. We don't know Hindi. We know Kannada, why can't you fight for Kannada as our National language. Most powerful language in the world.
This lady lawyer in Supreme court don't have any commonsense or knowledge. Who gave her permission to practice in SC? Ban her from practicing law.
She is a perfect hindi chavunist.. and a very good brain with nothing inside....she says she is proud to be indian as if no one is other parts of the india are not alive and only she is the patriot.. sharm anana he uska.. very bad way of persenting.. Only god knows she is parcticing law or not....
Switzerland population is 7 million and it has 4 official language. If someone cannot speak another official languages they stay and work in their states. Belgium has 3 official languages they do same to Switzerland.
Singapoor has 4 official languages but
India is a big country and they want only one language.
ModiJi wants everyone in the country to be enchanted by his speeches.😊
This is a 3rd rated channel with least rated people..no standard argument...
Kasthuri was awesome
Nobody is imposing anything "officially"... But, it is done unofficially by the politicians and the Hindi speaking people... Hence, this can fought unofficially by simply not speaking Hindi and when we have to speak with Hindi people make sure to not to speak in English as well... That's it.
Make Bengali as our national language, our national song and anthem are already in Bengali, why not national language??
Will hindi belt accept it??
As bengali is also an indian language,much older than hindi.
So,why should we??
If you agree to give Rosogollas to the rest of India, we will welcome it! LOL
Agree
@@venkateshramachandra560 haha... For the love of rosogollas,you're ready to sacrifice your mother tongue... Hats off to you,man!!
If that's the case,we are ready to provide you rosogollas every year haha😂😂
No imposition of language which been bastardise by Parsi, Sanskrit,and etc with a language of true indigenous language of India which is Tamil
Guna Seelan Sanskrit is not a Parsi language. It is the actual native language of India. Most words of Tamil are derived from Sanskrit. Sanskrit was not even a written language at first it was oral language used to create mantras. Later from that other languages was created like Tamil and Hindi. So many words of Tamil Hindi and Sanskrit are the same with changes in pronunciations.
Example: lion
In Hindi: Sima
In Tamil: Singam
Water
In Hindi: Pani
In Tamil: Thanee
Blood
In Hindi: Rakth
In Tamil: Ratham
Sad
In Hindi: Dukhi
In Tamil: Dhukam
Happy
In Hindi: Kush
In Tamil: Kushy
@@bkit5 and you seem to be pure illiterate becoz Tamil is older than Sanskrit PM Narendra modi accepted this see his speech
@@bkit5 And in the north Sanskrit has been Murdered. By the way Sanskrit and Tamil started at the same time. This concept of India is Hindi and Hindi is India is actually violating the constitution.
@@kartikmahajanashettar1705🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@bkit5 Dear These are not Tamil words but raped by Sanskrit lovers and mixed it here. Tamil has its one words which was written before Sanskrit evolved. Check archeological and literature based evidences on Indian languages., Tamil is the only language which is unique and stands alone even if you remove all Sanskrit based words keep in mind. For example. In Tamil: Singam No It is "Ari" but we use due to Indian states mixture. In Tamil: Thanee No we have "Neer" or "ozugu" (Malayalam use many many pure Tamil words thanks to them) , In Tamil: Ratham we have "Kuruthi". In Tamil: Dhukam we have "thuyaram " or more I believe. In Tamil: Kushy we have "!pulangakitham or ullamagizchi". It is still possible for us to remove all those Sanskrit based words which has no roots that was accepted by language researchers. But all Tamil words has its own root. Check again with language based research.
We have more crows than peacock.. Shall we make crow as a national bird huh😂😂
Make Sanskrit our National Language. This should end the debate. Because:
1) its the mother of all Bhartiya languages.
2) its the most scientific language.
3) learning sanskrit, you automatically learn Hindi. It makes it easy to learn other bhartiya languages.
Hindi Killed Sanskrit and it is no where now....
Make tamil national language
They will not make because 90% people illiterate Arabic culture following people. Then more influenced by Arab Persian Hindi language 😂 , then Indian food and culture. Which is Hindi.
BJP is more interested in Hindi language 😂. To gain Vote bank in Hindi heart land
@@paulkottam6238 They want to kill all other Languages
It looks like Arnab keeps auditions before choosing the panel experts.. the noise level they produce is unparalleled
PS : Hindi is indeed foreign lang for non hindi speakers... These North hindians just can't think of anything other than Hinduism, Cows and Hindi...
You don't have an Indian passport? You should be deported to Srilanka.
Kasthuri... Kasthuri 🔥🔥🔥
Hindi is as foreign as english to South India
Also to maharashtra
It was truly a super over for Kasthuri 🥳❤🤩
We learn english as unifier..
But hindi speaking people donot..
We cant bear the burden of illiteracy and population outburst of hindi belt...
We dont wanna be at disadvantage, we dont wanna be 2nd class citizens
Kasthuri marana adi 👍
Biggest jokers r ruling.. And they all speak Hindi. And say the corpse language Sanskrit as oldest language. 😂
They are from the Bullies Jokers Party! What do you expect?
Arnab.... Amit shah said Hindi should be the identity of india... But.. No single language can be the identity of a union of linguistic states i.e. INDIA.
Yes
Nothing wrong in learning Hindi as it is one of the most spoken language in India, but it's not nice making unnecessary agitation by this one nation one language concept ... Let their necessity tends them to learn other languages for their survival..
Excatly whats on our mind , we never said learn South India language to any of them , we do know Hindi ,we do communicate it that's the reason people who coming from north surviving here we never spread hate but this imposing will creat hate on Hindi speaking people rather then politics who want to do so it's like war inside nation,we know what to learn and how important is other language we do respect , but imposing never gone be succede, we have survived,success, developed,happy in our own language ,
Learn English that will be enough,not Hindi.
Make Tamil national language
@@muthu425
You say make Tamil national language one Maharashtra person says Marathi national language Karnataka says kannada Rajasthan say Mardwari or West Bengal says Bengali Mr. Amit Shah himself is a Gujrati person he belongs to Gujrat but he knows that his duties is not for only Gujrat but all BHARAT be not ask for his mother tongue but most of the Indian speaking language Tamil is speaking in only Tamil Nadu , kannada is speaking in Karnataka but HINDI is speaking in major part of the country you guys have to understand one thing in India even today everybody don't know English expect their own mother tongue and Hindi . Hindi language is just a bridge between you and non understanding English and regional language's it doesn't mean that Hindi take over your respected language please take some time to understand my point of view . Awakening India.
You need to remind anyone. This is what is happening for a long time. People who feel it's necessary to learn are learning it. It's like wearing a helmet while walking. You only need it when you ride bikes.
Huge respect to kasthuri....love u maam
If Hindi imposed... we need separate country... David nadu...all our taxes used by north Indian to population explosion
Lemme make this whole thing clear.........
U guys brought down bhojpuri, many dialects of bihari.... And a lot other dialects and individual languages very similar to hindi under an umbrella language Hindi and there you go 43% of Indians speak Hindi..... Now oh 43% of Indians speak Hindi and now the rest should learn that because it can be used for unification and strengthening of our country but you can learn and speak your language .......
Flash forward to 2050 if this act so to come in act 100% people in India speaks hindi so let's make it the only language of India ......
Same arguments.... Same repression....
Why is there even a debate? English should be used as the link language as it is used globally. Hindi is only used within the Indian subcontinent. Don't impose Hindi. Let those who want to learn Hindi learn it voluntarily.
Kasthuri making some quality points
I support Tamil but never vote for DMK!.
This mistake by BJP have to be ignored;if possible to be corrected!.
Muthukrishnan DIET Dear bro, have you gone through the exact statement of Amit Shah at all ? Or u are simply agitating based on what our politicians are saying ? Bro if u hear to what he has said, there is no imposition of Hindi at all. He has given due respect to all other regional languages and hoped that Hindi will one day keep any foreign language at bay. Foreign language means English here. Why u guys are so full of hated against BJP for this statement? I am too not a Hindi speaking guy.
@@lifethruvideos ,
Tamil media is searching for an issue to find fault with BJP!.
The BJP supporters are searching for the way to make inroads in Tamil nadu.
As everyone knows, the corrupt DMK was able to grow only because of the anti Hindi agitation,in the then Congress regime.
All the good works,done by the centre should not go waste by this unnecessary issue!.
Even though Amitsha, spoke with good intention,it is very hard to convince the Tamilians, since,it is very hard to learn a language other than the mother tongue.
@@muthukrishnandiet8459 but we have been brainwashed to accept English a foreign language very gloriously,rather then regional languages and it's not true in Mumbai people speak Marathi but knows Hindi so it's not wrong to learn Hindi at all.
At least have an option of Hindi in being as an option u know teach till class 8th so at least we would not have an missunderstandings.
@@akshit133 Bro!.
You are exactly correct!.
Tamil Nadu people are the only one,who are missing Hindi altogether!.
Infact, irrespective of the political support, they are not in a position to learn Hindi, even from 1967,when the two language formula was adopted!.
But,it became an opportunity to learn English, atleast in urban areas!.
It fetched better opportunities, in computer based software developments!.
Sure,we have to accept the opportunities grabbed by Tamilians, because of their mastery in English!.
Moreover, the technology development to translate any language to other, keeps a long distance between Tamil&Hindi!.
More over, their interest in Tamil cinemas are also responsible for the people, to keep distance from Hindi!.
Particularly in Taminadu, Politics & Cinemas are inseparable!.
@@muthukrishnandiet8459 we literally need to understand that Sanskrit and Tamil both are India's heritage and we should cherish it and not to mention it's still being spoken and not just in India all around the world even in Indonesia and they have it one of languages of the country I was surprised.
But it was bound to be it was a Hindu influence at some point but main thing it that it wasn't lost to Urdu on islamist invasion.
And I am not saying that English hasn't made us gained nothing it has but it's the hipocrate of those people and the so called stars they can't even make announcements in Tamil and say that our language I in danger such a way is a path to destruction and sooner or later Hindi will be there to benefit and the survey is of 2001 and what about now it muct surely have way passed that and no imposition but it's a little bit of necessities of the coming time and if I would go to South states then I would have to learn that regions language slowly but surely do erasing those differences and boundaries.
Like seriously we all celebrate diwlai ,Holi and other festivals tell me how were are so different.
English is the best language to communicate all India.but unfortunately 20% north Indians understand and speak English as a second language.But I think meximum 60% to 75% south Indians can speak English.
Your chennel itself is a english channel not hindi channel 😂😂😂
How apolitical and ironical.
Arnab's 'The Debate' starts with voice over from Kamal Hassan. A Tamilian giving a voice over in English for national channel anchored by Assamese born-Bengali speaking anchor who anchors in both English and Hindi from news studio in Marathi-speaking-Mumbai and Hindi-speaking-Delhi and panelists speaking pretty much most of Indian languages.
Isn't this what we can be proud of? C'mon people, rise above all this. I'm not in favour of imposing a particular language. A 1000 Indian rupee note will have more languages and inclusiveness than these politicians proposing a particular language.
Stop this b*^%$s$%t and continue with your lives. Jai Hind!
வணங்கும் மொழி தமிழ் , அதற்கு யாரும் இனை மொழி அடைகலம் கொடுக்க தேவை இல்லை, விருபம் இருந்த்தால் அல்லது தேவைபட்டால் நானே தேர்ந்தெடுப்பேன், தினிகும் முயற்ச்சிக்கு வழி வார்தை தேடவெண்டம், உங்கல் பேச்சின் உட்பொருளின் அர்தம் புரியாடவன் இல்லை தமிழன். தமிழ் எங்கள் மூச்சி.
Kasturi 100 thumbs up for u we dont want hindi even we dont try to teach hindi b, coz this kind people's mindset of hindi belt going to impose us to take over our cultural identity n im salute u from Manipur for ur beautiful thought keep it up go ahead we r support u
There's no national language in India. Supreme Court did clarifed the statement as clearly mentioned in constitution of India. They are only two official languages for official purposes. One is English and another is Hindi. There is no need to impose Hindi on southern and western states. Because India is a democratic country with secular state governments. Every state has their own official languages. Central Government should focus on economy instead of bringing another civil war in India just like United States. We must respect our constitution and our 75 years of freedom.
Hello arrogant Hindi lady I want to answer to the illogical and colonial era type question raised by you in 09:12 in the video! How dare you??? You asked to Kasthuri 'Do you like Hindi more or English more?' Are madamji you have to ask question like ''Do you like Tamil more or English more?' Because her mother tongue is Tamil. This is the problem with many Hindi people. They think that Hindi is India's mother tongue. NO NO...And why if you want to ask such question in combination like one Indian language and one Foreign language you have to modify question based on ethnicity of the person. If you ask to bengali you have to ask like 'Do you like Bengali more or English?'. And if you ask to every Indian only Hindi and English that's the problem with your attitude and wrong analogy. Hindi is just one language just like Tamil, Odia, Telugu etc. First ask the right question and actually you are still in the colonial mindset. And biggest fun is the Hindi lady talk too much and she has zero knowledge on any southern language. But see Kasthuri. She knows Hindi too. First she has to congratulate Kasthuri for knowing two Indian languages (Hindi and Tamil). Big mouth Hindi lady just knows only one Indian language!
Bjp can win in tamilnadu when they support tamil language just in tamilnadu only not even india ....This debate demolished future of bjp in tamilnadu....
If Hindi is going to be imposed on all states then this dictatorship move and against will of people against democracy peinciples. All non Hindi states should come together form separate union and let this so called Hindi speaking people form their own HINDISTAN.
Exactly
If i learn hindi... That will help me sell pani puri and bhel puri
😜🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Tamil nariyal pani😂😂🤣🤣👎👎
Ansu choudhary Kerala is known for nariyal paani foolish 😒
Yeah we will get jobs in panipuri multinational company......
@@Axesarvan 🤣🤣🤣
I am indian but I am not a hindi man first understanding My dear all hindi frds
தமிழ் வாழ்க
Kasuthuri you must have been spoken in Tamil on this interview
Great
Somebody, please recommend me a decent news channel debating on this issue. This channel is a crap. I feel disgusted with Host and the guest.
26:21 "Is this what you taught for 18 years" 😂🤣 Thug life kasthuri
Hi Arnab, its an wonderful debate.
Iam a kannadiga, studied in my own mother tongue till 10th std.
Lets be logical, I have taken so much of hard time learning english and sill struggling to learn different language other than my mother tongue.
Now if anyone want to make hindi as a Indian language and at the same time let me allow me to speak and work in Hindi only in all companies/employer including MNC’s.
This is the amount of effort i need to put into learn other than my mother tongue and it should be capable enough to give me to live life easily.
-Excuse me if any english word is wrong over here (still learning!)
Guru nanu kuda kannadigane... Kannada madhyamadalle odidavanu.. nanna prakara English basheya upayoga mahatva.. evarellaru hindi hindi anta heludu matra.. avara makkalella first class English school Alli odthare.. adare English kaliyudu tumba important as in a global platform...
This Delhi people are arragent. When I went to Delhi for visa purpose, in a big restaurant, that owner treat me badly since I don't know Hindi and I am from Tamilnadu!...
Karthick K This is exactly what the South Indians are fighting against
We feel the same in South, especially in TN! So it runs both ways! In fact, Delhi is the most cosmopolitan and welcoming cities in India and have a thriving population of Bengalis, North Eastern, Telugus, Punjabis, Kashmiris, etc.