Face Off Over Hindi Language Push: Is This Imposition Of Majority? | 6PM Prime
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ย. 2019
- As Union Home Minister Amit Shah's comments on Hindi as the national language of India continue to create an uproar, another South politician has raised their voice to stop Hindi imposition.
In a video uploaded by actor-turned-politician Kamal Haasan, he has said another language agitation will take place, which will be much bigger than the Jallikattu protests in Tamil Nadu.
Meanwhile, Karnataka Chief Minister, B.S Yeddyurappa has reacted to the Hindi language row saying that all official languages are equal and added that Kannada is the official language as far as Karnataka is concerned.
HindiLanguageRow #6PMPrime #IndiaToday
Subscribe to India Today for NEW VIDEOS EVERY DAY and make sure to enable Push Notifications so you'll never miss a new video.
All you need to do is PRESS THE BELL ICON next to the Subscribe button! India Today TV is India's leading English News Channel. India Today TH-cam channel offers latest news videos on Politics, Business, Cricket, Bollywood, Lifestyle, Auto, Technology, Travel, Entertainment and a lot more.
Stay tuned for latest updates and in-depth analysis of news from India and around the world!
Follow us: Official website: indiatoday.intoday.in/
Twitter: / indiatoday
Facebook: / indiatoday
we Maharashtrians will learn Tamil but not accept Hindi as national language. 🚩
Brother tamil has 347 alphabet it is not easy to learn
@@banty6350 bruh he's trying to make a pt. Not literally. Dis shows how ur BJP bhakts minds think
@@banty6350 it's 247, I think you have added 100 more from Hindi. English has lesser number of alphabets than Hindi. So it's easy to learn English than Hindi.
😆🤣
BJP is not uniting the india. Actually BJP is splitting our mother country.
It's good if South become a separate country. North is of no use and people are worst
If the govt. is hell-bent on promoting Hindi as the NL, it will create a linguistic tsunami in many states snd Union Territories: Tamilnadu, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, Telenganna, Kerala, Tripura, Assam, Himachal Pradesh, Arunachal Pradesh, Lakshadeep, Andaman & Niicobar, etc. Emtions will run high and mayhem will subsequently follow. The states (e.g. Karnataka, Tamilnadu) could decide to leave the Union of India and strive for independence. A grim possibility. The language conundrum leading to the fragmentation of a nation was very vividly illustrated by the genesis of Bangladesh in 1971. Source of the problem? West Pakistan wanted to ram the Urdu language, by force, down the throats of the Bengali-speaking East Pakistanis. Outcome? Civil war and the subsequent birth of Bangladesh. We should look at the stark reality of the potentially incendiary situation and learn from our two neighbours in terms of relatively recent history. Jai Bharat!
Communication gap can be remove by one language
@@adityajoshi1122 States in the South will not agree to the imposition of one language as the national language. Even if it is Tamil or Kannada - let alone Hindi. We sre on the cusp of amazing technological advances permeating every fabric of our society, at every nook and corner of the country. Forget about any one national language. Let English, the only NEUTRAL language in the equation, be the ONLY LINK LANGUAGE of our nation. The status quo of the twenty-two official lsnguages, should remain intact, as per the Constitution. People from North India SHOULD make it a point to learn Communication Kannada whilst working in a city like Bengalaru. Like wise, a person with roots in Karnataka should learn Hindi (communication Hindi) if he is assigned to New Delhi, for example. We do not have to ram one language down the throat of a non-speaker in the name of national unity and integration. In this day and age, there are so many language-based computer software incorporating voice synthesizers. Isn't life nowadays not complicated enough dealing with bread-and-butter issues? Do we need the language issue to retard our national unity movement along the lines of linguistic hegemony? Pakistan, China, JeM, Kashmir are issues that are very crucial to us. An existential threat to be dealt with effectively in the long run. Food for thought, huh? And let education and the study of the English language, at least at the primary and secondary levels, be accessible to all Indian citizens.
And one more thing. People should be given all support possible to learn another language (thitd language) or any one of the official Indian languages as per their whim. German, Mandarin, Bengali, Hindi, Tamil, etc. Jai Bharat!
Aditya Joshi English
Hindi movies are banned In Manipur last 3 decades. Manipuri is my mother tongue... Don't force me to learn and speak foreign Hindi language...
❤️ from Tamil Nadu
Manipur and nagaland culture, tradition, architecture, facial, histroy are more connected to southeast asia like Myanmar, Thailand, Laos, Cambodia, Southern Vietnam, Malaysia and Indonesia, architecture of manipur is unique, similar to burmese, roof architecture is used by eastern people, like china, japan, vietnam, korea, bhutan, sikkim, indonesia, thailand, myanmar and other southeast asian nation.
🤩🤩🙏🙏 love from west Bengal
You the guys are totally wrong , English is the foreign language not Hindi , tamil, Telugu , malyalam, kannada , bangali etc . You are the people reasan for spreading roumers among Indians
@@Pathshala260 apart from mother tongue all other languages are alien languages for all
I feel proud to be an Tamilian than Indian due to this Bjp government
pratap nagarajan
Would be more proud if Tamil Nadu is not part of India in the near future. Tamils will neither suppress any one nor let anyone suppress them.
Let us live with equal rights and freedom with mutual respect if we have to be part of India the nation created by the British for their administrative convenience.
Haha It's your nature reflecting in adverse conditions.
உண்மை
jai dravida nadu!!
Resently Kavijnar vairamuthu told ,if south want to know about north,you should learn Sanskrit and if North want to know south they should learn Tamil.He only realises in his this age .Then what about others?
Not only south states but also maharashtra and bengal have to worry and raise the voice against hindi imposition.
North east india..also
Marathis have tilted to Hindi long back
Actually culturally and racially they are closer to north Kannadigas and North Andhra
@@dcmhsotaeh bro I'm from North Karnataka and I think myself as dravidian so please don't categorize like that
What does mean?
Iam totally agree to you
the guy speak behalf of Karnataka , you should learn about current archaeologist studies ... Tamil not originated from Sanskrit
Bro that spokeperson from Karnataka is a big asshole ,he intimates modi in dressing, beard,hairstyle only because they might get any m.l.a, m.p seat , the debate was supporting b.j.p so they brought all b.j.p agents rather then public representative ,
Lets not Tamil & Kannada people fight, whatever is the origin of our languages everybody in our 2 states have a common culture of the south, Idli, Dosa, sambar, pongal Filter coffee & both of us learn each other languages without any problem, just come to shivaji nagar, its 30% Tamil, 30% Telugu & remaining 40% is kannada & urdu. We never face any problem in that area. The Problem is only with the HINDI WALAS!
Why should we learn 3 language? my 1st language is Bengali, 2nd language is English. Why should I add Hindi as 3rd? Will North Hindi medium people add Bengali as their 3rd Language
They have to learn all the regional languages 😂
@@HariKrishnan-pe3ft 😊😊😊😊😊 not practical for all
They won't..
must be all regional parties rulings they own state's.
iShuvam. Good.super
Amit shat is diverting from economic problem because the BJP government is running away from the real problem....economy down turn, unemployment, loss of opprtunities because of gross mimanagement.....
whose economic management was better? just so I know
No nationalist is living in caves and madarsa. We know very well the state of India and we also know what's the truth and what's the propaganda and the compete picture. We also know that secular opposition is more dangerous than Pakistan for the country but is speaking of economy 😛😛😛🤣
The encomic slow down is because all money is better white than in from congress days
And you can see crores of crores money out
Theses are their every where dye ti which economic slowdown
@@sriramvaidyanathan5094
Congress only had high gdp for 4 years that too because of high inflation and good global market and policies started by Vajpayee ji. After 2010 , it put Indian economy in drains with negative gdp and negative international ratings.
Well said!
Iam a TELUGU speaker.....I think govt is showing step mother love on non hindi speaking states ......
U r scientific knowledge u are NASA deserving human
How could you impose one language in the entire country. We most of south indians donot know hindi.we are proud of our language and Dravidian culture.
Please,that is negative, and egoism. Prosperity should be the vision, millions will want this too, as knowledge of another language is an advantage.
@Chand Koonja
Why should world know da?
Our language our culture our right
Make Hindi national language and see
Idiot, Hindi is your state language, why we want learn it. See you don't know about tamilians war against Hindi. It was happening 70 to 80. I think you people want it back.
I love my mother, i don't need to love your mother. We never compromise with our Tamil, Hindi is not a Indian's language. Mind it. South India is the states giving high GDP to this country without Hindi. Tamil Nadu is the secong highest rate in GDP. Mind it. You north people don't have anything including brain.
Maybe hindi is your language, But tamil is our life.
Chand Koonja hindi is spoken only in India. Tamil is spoken is most south Asian countries. I’m sure u dint know about that. Its a fact. You can google. E.g. tamil is Singapore’s official language. It shares an important staus in Malaysia and some other countries as well. Hindi is not officially recognised in any other county than India. FYI. I’m not saying tamil is important and hindi is not. Both are equally imp. I’m just responding to your fake comment about hindi being recognised outside India.
@Chand Koonja WTF... Who declared Hindi as language of Hindustan.... Tamil is being an official language in Singapore, Malaysia and Sri Lanka... Would you accept to learn Tamil if we impose saying it's being an official language across nation... You people are disturbing the diversity and violating secularism...
Hindi one of the language of India like Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam not national language
no dude hindi is the superior
we in pakistan afghanistan and iran can unnderstand hindi
M4 Movies we are south india don't like hindi
@@flyingtoworld509noorkhan3 u know hindi so we learn hindi😠how dare u you learn my language ok 😠
@@flyingtoworld509noorkhan3 then please throw away hindi. I'm sure you can use english in so many countries including yours. But you can't survive in south India with Hindi.
Gujrat and Maharashtra lost their our mother language and identity.
Lol I am Gujarati and also know Hindi. I am proud of knowing both.
@sufi saleem Because she is an andh Bhakt!!
Gujarati is still the official language in Gujarat.
No my Brother , Not whole Maharashtra Lost Language and Identify
The One who Has true love for shivaji maharaj has marathi blood and culture
I am Marathi I know What is Condition of Marathi but it's in only few metro cities of maharashtra .The Spirit of Shivaji Maharaj is still is there in Marathi's.
@@Rutvi_patel_1111 mugael bag
all all india exams must be all language..............some one should file a case in the supreme court
Please vote bjp for civil war within country
U done already
@@Rekhashankar-89 in our state were going to have elections in few weeks for mla
@@abhijeetpandule5102 all the best
dont vote that idiots bro
Hindi being national language will be benefitting the native hindi speakers in national activities, be it in jobs, beuracracy, economic planning, political dialogues, which is inequality and that will be unbecoming of the INDIA as a nation. ( I speak 5 languages not by force but only by interest, that is what I felt proud of our Nation.) Dear central govt, please don't spoil our unity with such authoritarian ideologies.
I am a proud Indian and also a proud Bengali. No compromise on mother language. Jai Hind. জয় বাংলা
Most of the scientists are from tamil Nadu.
Pockran nuclear test was done by tamilans whose are Abdul kalam, santhanam and chidambaram.
Brahmos rocket belongs to sivathanu Pillai who is Tamil an.
Cryogenic rocket was done by Tamil an nambi Narayan an.
Chandrayan 1 & 2 were done by mayil Samy Anna durai and Sivan.
Risat 1c was done by valarmathi from Tamil community.
I can write much more an example. But I don't hurt any other.
Three persons got the Nobel prize for science and technology whose are from Tamilnadu. They are c. V. Raman, Chandrasekar and venkat Rama Krishnan.
Sunder pichai, a r rahman......
If Southern learns hindi, they will be zero in their life.
Mother tongue can only give analytical knowledge.
Non hindi speakers have to protect their identity.
BCCI was registered under the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act.
Super maccha
Amit Malviya is a liar if he says, Hindi is spoken in remote parts of TN. Blatant lies
raghu karthik 🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣
I'm from Tamil Nadu here all speaks Tamil ,only rare people know Hindi for my observation .that guy saying totally lie.
I think he counts "Bhaiya dho plate Pani poori dhedho" as Hindi knowledge.
@@pramodhchander6773 hehehe...yeah
This is governments way to divert attention from Economy.
Exactly
Every one knows there is no relationship between Mahatma Gandhi and Indira Gandhi. The same way no relationship between India and Hindi language. Hindi is one of the Indian languages - Not India's language
All those who want hindi please go to North India you guys don't deserve to stay in Southern states either respect the local languages or leave. Don't try to impose Hindi
people should not get hyper on this internally, because only that they bastards want...🙏
south India tumhare baap ka nahi hai , jo tax north India wale dete hai uska fayda tum tak bhi pahuchta hai , why every south Indian has such a low mindset
Québec ( french Canada) agrees too !
@@barkhajiya3663 Every state belongs to local peoples first...
If you can not respect local language..then leave....
@@barkhajiya3663 south indian highest tax payer hai . south indian nae hamin khalaya
Excellent speech Chatterjee. if we go to hind land then we have to learn hindi, if hindi people come here for a job that time also we should put effort to learn hindi to guide them. But they will not put any effort to learn the state language where they are working.
jinnah was a gujarati patel............he chopped indian subcontinent in to two parts..........modi and shah will finish what jinnah started.............
At 15.30.. Gentlemen... In tamilnadu, second language we prefer is English.... Not hindi... Don't say anything if you don't know!
Gujarathi and hindi have similarities but for tamilian both hindi and English are foreign languages we prefer English because it will be more useful global language than hindi
Arignar Anna's Quote:
A man had two dogs - a big one and a small one. He wanted his dogs to go in and out of the house freely without him having to keep the house door open all the time. So he built two "trap doors" - one big trap door for the big dog and one small for the small dog. Neighbors who saw these two doors laughed at him and called him an idiot. Why put a big door and a small door? All that was needed was the big door. Both the big and the small dog could use it!
Indian government's arguments for making Hindi the National or link language of India are as ridiculous as the need for a big door and a small door for the big dog and the small dog. Indian government agrees that English is needed for communication with the world, and every school in India teaches English at some grade or other before one passes the high school. Why do people outside the Hindi states have to study Hindi for communications within India while they already study English for communication with the world?
No Need Hindi in Tamil nadu. I am Tamil speech indian
What garga chaterjee said is right, During independence 30% spoke hindi but now in 2019 44% speaks, well thats not our problem, because if these hindi people produce more babies the government must teach them to use condom or must to family planning.
read the history..how bangladesh became seperate nation from pakistan all because of language
I think they forgot about that and want another bangladesh again
We Bengali gave blood for our language. I respect Tamil brothers because they also love their language like us.
Amit Shah cant even say 'Bhasha' correctly. He calls its Bhaasa lol
Yes bro😂😂
To all who support Hindi from the north and shaming the south Indians; Do you know that you guys eat out of what the southern states drop in your begging bowls , as the majority of taxes are paid to the Indian government kitty by us? Do you know the history of hindi? Hindi is a bastard language, created by a mixture of Sanskrit (a dead language as of now) and Urudhu (again from persian) in the 15 th century (spoken by beggars and illiterates of those times), with no history or classical literature to claim. Be ashamed of your so called language rather than asking us to speak the so called language. The real languages of India are thousands of years old. Hindi is technically called a "PIGDIN" (Google it to know the meaning) like BAMBAIYA (A mix of marathi and hindi... spoken in Mumbai).
Hey, you don't have right to abuse. Please control your tongue while speaking. No one has given right to you to abuse anyone mother's tongue.
the north indians come like beggars to south india to get work.................
Hey you lazy bastard. You can't talk like this.
Pls i understand your anger..but in india anyone can work and move anywhere...refrain from denigrating the poor...by the way i am a telugu and completely oppose hindi imposition
@@dreammahe U BJP IT cell worker
Sorry yo northian friends
- tamilindian
@@pavanswaroop1712 these people think they own the republic of India by fake EVMs fraud elections...
South india language more than 2000year than hindhi
If i learn tamil i can use it in atleast 5 different countries whose national language is also tamil.
If I learn english i can use in all part of the world.
If I learn hindi i can eat only panni poori. Stupid hindi Wallas... Can't you understand.
First, ask BJP to teach proper hindi to their own kids Who are failing in hindi exams in UP.
Second, ask BJP to learn how to respect others, especially muslims & christians.
Third, ask BJP to wash the foot of Dalit's people for the sin they have done to them.
Fourth, ask BJP to learn how to think logically with evidence.
Fifth, ask BJP to take their RSS & brahmin friends to Pakistan (Leave my colourful country).
Once when BJP fulfills all the above conditions, then for next 2000 years serve the dalit brother's house as their servant.
Then come to tamilnadu and beg tamils to speaks in hindi. THEN WE MAY CONSIDER HINDI BUT ONLY IF YOU SING MAHABHARATHAM SONG IN ARABIC LANGUAGE
Hope hindi Wallas understand the anger inside non-hindi speaking people.
U r just 💥🖤
Do you know Chinese language.
It's only in their country still they are developed.
You are misguided by you corrupt politicians who don't want to let the country people unite.
@@sidharthkumar255 lol Chinese has only language Mandarin india has 1000+ languages you should learn what you want to learn bcz it's your choice of chosen and we non hindi people's won't learn any language if that impose on us mind it
BJP keeps diverting people from core issues by bringing new amendments to the constitution. We won't get deceived this time!
Did u listened the middle tamil bro, he is 🔥🔥🔥, that's the tamil spirit, that's the tamilah's.
A rice bag convert speaking about spirit
@@Rutvi_patel_1111 Dhokla bro, you shut up!!
@@Rutvi_patel_1111 wht rice bag?
@@Rutvi_patel_1111 okay communals
Tamil,telgu or Punjabi National language of India Hindi why
Sanskrit ?
Everyone proud of their mother tongue just like Hindi speakers are proud of Hindi. If people think a common language will unite the country it's a naive thought. When Aryans invaded or came in this land there was already a language in the nation, that was Tamil. Hindi was foreign language then. So if the country has to choose one language to unite the nation why not Tamil?
@Chand Koonja also you are in INDIA not HINDIA
Fool, your tamil language has come thousands years after the sanskrit, prakrit and pali languages.
@@sibudasbaishnab.6281 oh!! a wise man spotted:)how do you know it
@@sibudasbaishnab.6281 Tamil is the oldest language!
Example keeladi excavation
Thirukural
And many books which are written even before AD....
It's also said its even more older than Sanskrit!
However fools like you won't get this!
@@sibudasbaishnab.6281 I m sanskrit n hindi literature student,n stdying about other languages history also, even modi said in some event that Tamil is oldest language, it ,it comes under classic language category like sanskrit only,n just study languages history Tamil existence older than sanskrit,n contributed to snaksrt as well,but sanskrit also important as all INDIANS languages have base from sanskrit accept Tamil,our necert textbooks needs to changed ,even many INDIANS rulers great history not taught ,plse note:(I m not Tamil or bengali speaker)I m not on no on e sides completely
I agree there has to be one national language. Let’s make it Tamil, the oldest language.
Typical DMK racist
There is no proof of this
@@MultiDringus if u impose hindi on us! And we protest make me seem like tamil racist!
Then u r nothing but a hypocrite! Like those hindi imposing political shitheads!!
And Btw there are many proof available internet itself recorded authentically that tamil is ancient then everything and presence of tamil words in more than 20 languages which including greek, , english, Spanish, french, Japanese...please use ur available source to know thetruth before shitting and blaming someone as racists
@@MultiDringus stupid. Without any basic of history you have started your conversation.
Go, study and come back for discussion
@@9942229577 Still waiting for your proof.
@@GOWTHAMRAJEEV There is zero proof. None. The oldest Tamil writing is 300 BC. That's it. You are no different than a Brahmin spreading lies.
Hindi people learn tamil because he selling paani puris panju mittai
Tamil people is all about = aiyayaoo..not anything
That BJP guy is registering a lie in this media. You can't find single person who speaks or understand Hindi in the rural part of Tamilnadu. It is clear that person like him make an overall assumption without knowing the fact about the country.
I am from maharashtra... I dont want Hindi as national language ...
Marathi is my national language...
fake information ur showing, where Hindi 43 Hindi+bhojpuri+rajastani+gujrati+haryanvi+punjabi+..etc=43.
Telugu 11
Tamil 8
Hindu effortlessly spoken in tamil nadu 😂😂😂😂 good one
garga bhattarjee hats off .. superb points.....
Im Sinhalese from Sri Lanka, and I support Tamil brothers stance. A non-native Hindi can't compete with a native Hindi, but English is foreign tongue to both parties, hence, it is equal.
Garga , you should be the national spokesperson for the anti Hindi imposition movement. I admire the way you put forward your facts and arguments . All the best to your guys.
We south Indians will never agree with that fellow Amit Shah, let him first learn our local language can these North Indians learn our languages
Totally agree with you brother. They never respect our South Indian languages and they never ever learn our languages. Every time and every where, we have to work hard, we have to learn everything. They get all the UPSC,SSC and Central Government Job Exams in Hindi only, which is very easy for them, but not for us. Most of the top most IIMs, IITs, NITs, IIITs are at North Side only, why like that? we just have one or two to the entire South India. This is the biggest un-justification to our South Indians.
Here are the core steps BJP will follow to successfully implement Hindi as the national language:
1) First all leaders will be detained.
2) Next, all communication ( internet, mobile phones, landlines etc.) will be shutdown.
3) Third, Amit shah will pass an article for language in both the houses(Lok Sabha & Rajya Sabha).
4) Next, Media (RepublicTV, TimesNow, AajTak etc.) will show everyone is celebrating..
5) Modi will give a statement on how language was a barrier to progress.
And it will be over..
Hindi theriyadu poda.......
"இந்தியாவில் உள்ள ஒவ்வொரு பள்ளியும் ஆங்கிலம் கற்பிப்பதால், அது ஏன் எங்கள் இணைப்பு மொழியாக இருக்க முடியாது? உலகத்துடன் தொடர்புகொள்வதற்கு தமிழர்கள் ஆங்கிலத்தையும் இந்தியாவிற்குள் தொடர்புகொள்வதற்கு ஹிந்தியையும் ஏன் படிக்க வேண்டும்? பெரிய நாய்க்கு பெரிய கதவும், சிறிய நாய்க்கு சிறிய கதவும் தேவையா? நான் சொல்கிறேன், சிறிய நாய் பெரிய கதவையும் பயன்படுத்தட்டும்!" ~ C. N. Annadurai
"Since every school in India teaches English, why can't it be our link language? Why do Tamils have to study English for communication with the world and Hindi for communications within India? Do we need a big door for the big dog and a small door for the small dog? I say, let the small dog use the big door too!" ~ C. N. Annadurai
During independence language freedom is guarsnteed, started with 13 and now it is 22, is BJP renegotiating the constitution, then there should referendum, whether all non hindi speaking wants to be part of india or be a separate country on their own.......
@@reconquistahinduism346 I think, you are gujarati or marathi who have sacrificed their own culture and languages to the hindiwalas. If you have guts, then why you are not supporting sanskrit as the national language. Because, every language has evolved from it.
@@sibudasbaishnab.6281
I am a Maharashtrian and I am fluent in all three languages , Hindi ,Marathi and English. We never compromised our culture , tradition and language but assimilated and integrated Hindi in our society. We change languages with ease and we don't have any enmity with Hindi. After all , Hindi people are 100 times better than Tamils and Malyalis. They are proud of Hinduism , Hindu culture and are staunch nationalists. They are bastions of Indian culture. And 100 times better than leftists , liberals , islamists , islamization , communists , Naxalite and anti nationals . With Hindi our culture only strengthens , with Muslims and Tamils its destroyed.
That's why BJP failed in Tamil Nadu and Kerala.. Silently these guys name all govt schemes in Hindi, pushes Hindi in CBSE school.. what a cowardism..??
Amit Shah ji One Nation One Language is foolish Step if you say Such Word then there's no difference between you and Pakistan. Indian's are horse's not donkey Different Languages, Religions, and Culture's are like Rainbows Every Culture, Launguage and Religion has it's Own Significant. We are like Colour's of Rainbow 🌈 Beautiful and together don't try foolish thing's we Support you on Pakistan, Kashmir and other issues that doesn't mean we Support you on Every issue that you say we as Indian's are perfect and understanding What to Support and what not to Support.
Well said
Nice strategy by BJP from diverting the economy crisis, first change in motor cycle act and not one language
How can the anchor say no national language as per our constitution 22 national languages
In interior parts of tamil nadu either bengal,if the people effortlessly talks a language other than native language is hindi,why should we learn again and why should it becomes our identity. You imposed hindi for bringing in your comfort. Anything outside our mother tongue is foreign matter whether its english or hindi.
You have a privilege of your language used in every sense and you get all the prospects whereas we struggle at everything atleast to learn the language itself. English is enough for linking us. Hindi never be the identity of india,true identity is our pluralism and multilingual.....
Everybody speaking in Tamil from chennai to kanyakumari..(Tamilnadu)...People who are came from other states only speak their language within themselves...This man Amit malvya is a lier.....
what is the problem that govt is trying to solve by making Hindi as a national language except creating useless controversy ? till now, every one is happy with their language.but now there is unnecessary controversy and conflict to divert the attention from actual issues and to polarize the voters based on language. our students in government schools are not getting quality education in the schools but that is not the problem for the government but how come language becomes the problem that needs to be fixed ?
Amit Shah - As South Indian, we support you on A370 and Kashmir. This decision of imposing Hindi as national language will take away your popularity & votes. Pls don’t take away your popularity.
We don’t want Hindi as link language.
Sir speak about our economy . This message to all media and our Home minister Amit sha .
I love you 😘 Karnataka kannada then Indian
If the impose Hindi on us and make hindi as national language then it would trigger the soul identity of us we won't agree with this hindi as national language
He started off with, “we respect all languages” how is that a threat ? North India must wake up. India is a continent full of different regions with different mother tongue 😛
well, donkey is majority than tiger make it a national animal!
There is some one Named, NaamTamilar Seeman ANNA and I want you guys to Learn from him. Why are you So called you the Media is avoiding him? One day you cannot avoid him. At least for once in your life Speak the Truth. Stalin/Kamal will back down from their statement but not My brother NaamTamilar Seeman.
All central government exam must ask in English and their state mother language not forcing to put Hindi, because we don't know. People whose mother tongue was Hindi will easily crack the exam because they study in their mother tongue.forcing Hindi is a curse.
Southern ppl only like to talk masala word(Hindia) 😀 rather than address real problem of language war.
please respect regional languages .
Similarity bw Modi and Ram ...
He left his wife .Went to jungle of corporates .......While later person left his pregnant wife into jungle .Full of dangerous animals ....
(To all Modi-bhakts ...Please accept the facts ..Otherwise next life .I pray u get father like modi ..).
There is no commercial value for Hindi
GARGA CHATTERJEE AWESOME ❤❤
JUST NAILED IT
Language in Hindi: Baasha(भाषा)
Language in Hindi pronounced by Amit Shah: Bhaasa(बासा)
I am Gujarati and I had learnt Hindi during my schooling. No harm in Hindi. The politician are twisting to gain their benefits. People are learning English but finds it hard for Hindi.
After 50 years.. Gujarati language will be wiped out & remain only as dialect of hindi
Well going... 👍
Hindi has already killed haryanvi, rajasthani languages...
There will be no identity called Gujarati after BJP rule ends in India. You will be called Hindirati..
English doesn't harm your Gujarati but Hindi does
NE 🖤🖤🖤🖤 Tamil nadu and kerala
THEY CAN LEARN FOREIGN LANGUAGE ENGLISH BUT NOT HINDI .... SALUTE TO SOUTH INDIA
I love English more then hindi 😹😹
Kamal u r the real hero
Tamil is the most ancient language.And has the oldest literature too.
Varghese Hittite is older. Australian aboriginal languages are more than 10,000 years old. Get rid of myths.
hindi speakers only can survive in hindistan (some northern regions of India). But Tamil is official language of Singapore, Sri Lanka, Tamil Nadu, Pondicherry, Andamaan and Nicobar Islands. Recognised minority language in Malaysia, Mauritius and South Africa. Widely spoken across Canada, Europe, Major American, Australian cities.
Make World's Classical Language, Tamil as Official Language of India.
2000 years ago everyone in India, speaks and trade in the medium of Tamil language. There are 1000s of archological evidences as proof. Rich Tamil Literature, will drive India to be a better place, compared to current state. நன்றி, வணக்கம் 🙏🏻
வாழ்க தமிழ்!
Comedy no:1 Hindi uniting India
My friend went to kerala and learnt malayalam then spoke to the people in malayalam . another friend came to chennai from karnataka learnt tamil and spoke tamil to all. what is mean by hindi uniting india to stop these people in speaking local people language just making malayali to speak in hindi with kannadiga is uniting india. Intention is making hindi people grab all opportunities and spread finally dominating india
Comedy no 2: People will be benefited by Hindi
Hindi people could not get proper job opportunity in theri hindi speaking states like UP and Bihar who are all coming to south india (non-hindi states). Hindi people themselves did not get any benefit
Comedy no3: Lets make hindi as national language
Initially states divided based on regional language then slowly added hindi as official languages , now they want hindi to dominate othe languages making it as national language.
Comedy No4: Hindi is not imposed.
But even LPG cylinder has safety instructions only for the customers who knows Hindi and English. So government forcing rural area customers to learn either english or hindi which means imposing.
Comedy No5: Hindi will be link language
So funny already i need a large link language connecting to global countries called english , can i speak hindi as link language when i visit USA ,Cannada or Australia. when i already have a large link language connecting whole world then why a small another link language specific to India, is India not in the world?
Comedy No6: 45% of Indian population speaks Hindi language
Great survey and census taken, So what. Did you take any survey to those 45% of the population whether they agree to make hindi as link or national language. please take that since there are lot of people among 45% hindi speaking population against this idea, example hindi speaking people in karnataka, maharastra, kerala, west bengal told they are against in making hindi as link or national language.
Comedy No7: Hindi is the only language can be made as National language to roam around India
Is it? Tamil is the national language is some countries but hindi is not attained national language in any countries. Even tamil has become highly recognized language in countries like fiji, mauritius, australia, karnataka, germany, USA, UK,China,etc. If we claim this way i bet all the hindi language state people will fire like anything if tamil do the same they will stamp as Chauvinist. but i never say any language of India should be made as National language since we believe in Language equality not uniformity
If Amit shah says English is an alien language, then by same logic, why is his own son the chair person for BCCI cricket board? Well cricket is Britishers game and why is Jay Shah not part of Kabaddi games? Bloddy hypocrite bjp... I am a Tamil speaking proud 🇮🇳 Indian.
Hindi will never unite the country
That Bengali guy is nailing it . Go on
Let me add to the broth, without the British Empire, there would be no INDIA, there might be a Mughal empire but the south would still be free and Tamil Nadu would still pose as a challenger. So No Hindi Please, LIVE AND LET LIVE.
My first word was அம்மா (amma-mother)
For me my language comes before my nation
Naa! For me my nation is first but for me my mother tongue is my national language .
JOY BHAROT ❤❤
JOY BANGLA ❤❤
He knows politics, dividing and ruling.
I am from Tamil Nadu, I have listed few details how imposition of Hindi will affect Tamil, this is applicable for other regional language.
Below I have provided explanation as to why the claim that Hindi is good for future survival of tamil culture and prosperity is a false propaganda by the Hindi belt politicians. Their agenda is to strength their political base in the south by imposing their language. In doing so, they will have a political future in the southern states at the expense of regional parties. Already we are losing the use of our language in several fields due to English, with Hindi there will not be any requirement of Tamil in the future.
Let us imagine Tamil language is in a coffin. I will list the nails that has been slowly added by the Indian politician to that coffin since the British and Indian independence .
1. Children who study in English medium schools, science, geography, physics, chemistry, history, maths, biology, engineering all are taught in English. English being the world language it is good for our future survival. People who take tamil as secondary language in english medium, will be able to read and write tamil at basic level. They’ll not be creators in tamil as their language of thinking would be English. Their knowledge creation would only be in English. These people live in the cities who jump from one city to another for their economic prosperity and survival.
2. Children who study in tamil medium will have English as their secondary language and will be able to read/write English at basic level. These children live in secondary cities and villages. They find it difficult to pursue higher studies in science, geography, physics, chemistry, history, maths, biology in English when they join colleges. Forced to create new knowledge in English. To fix this the number of children in English medium in secondary cities and villages has increased in the last 50 years. With this increase, tamil in future will not be required to explain science, geography, physics, chemistry, history, maths, biology and would only be used for communication, basic reading and writing. If Hindi is going to be introduced, we don’t need tamil for communication, everyone would prefer Hindi after 3-5 generations.
3. In our society, Tamil is currently being used in religion, entertainment and literature (This will fade) with the growth of English and Hindi. Tamil literature will slowly decline as the number of reader move to English and Hindi. If there is no market for tamil literature there will no longer be any creative writing in it. Only copying and translation in the future.
4. No knowledge creation in tamil (i.e. scientific, technical paper, journal) in the following field science, geography, physics, chemistry, history, maths, biology, engineering. All scientific paper has to be published in English. Reference to knowledge is only available in English.
5. Administration will slowly move towards English/hindi.
6. High court in Tamil Nadu cannot use tamil language to interpret the law and provide judgement. Only English/hindi. Tamil vocabulary will not grow in this field of law.
The requirement of tamil language has been reduced to the following field
Communication, religion, entertainment and literature. This will also die in another few generation and would be replaced by other language English/Hindi.
Tamil requirement in science, technology, business and law field has been slowly eroded because there is an easy replacement (i.e. english). The question is do we accept that status quo. If we accept it and continue then slowly the tamil language will loose it significance as it’s vocabulary will not grow in the above field and because of that their will not be any new literature and knowledge in tamil language in the coming generation. So it will be avoided by the coming generation for their survival. BJP/RSS peoples are spreading false message through news channel regarding the benefits of learning Hindi, when there is none. I agree the state politicians for their selfish gain has given away the state rights, which is hurting the public. Why should we burden our son/daughter to learn additional language in their childhood when its benefits are minimal in the future, it would be required only for socialising and entertainment.
When we are paying taxes to the central government what has the central government done to promote the regional language so its usage can be strengthen in various fields. In high courts we can't use our language for arguments and judgement. There is a hidden agenda to reduce the use of regional language as official language so that usage of Hindi/English becomes the main language in trade, education, business and administration.
No spl status to hindi.we demand all the 14 constitutional languages to be used everywhere .
Kolkata man spoke good
Sir, we respect you but I want my vernacular language to be my official language in my state pls. Don't confuse the people like this.
We want Free Tamilnadu without Hindia.
The main issue is unemployment which is not talking any media.language is not problems who belongs from these area speaking according to their region that is not problems.finally we are all indian🇮🇳 and respect everyone.
# MyTake
Impressed from 2 non-hindi panelist's point of view. Superb logic gentleman.
1). Any language that is not a mother tongue is a foreign language for us. And if we were to choose one foreign language, then that should help me secure a career, that should be globally accepted, that should have access to all the fields like science, medicine, law etc., From all these thoughts, Its a No brainer to choose English to Hindi.
2). As far as respect, love is concerned, Hindi is respected like any other regional language. But, Necessity wise English is more necessary even more necessary to any mother tongue.
Yesterday one BJP minister said d that North Indian youths are incapable to get jobs. Do the North Indian politicians are capable?
The arabs belong to one race one religion one language But then why 22 countries ? Understand that Unity in diversity is the keyword for India .
I WANT BENGALI LANGUAGE AS EQUAL IN MY INDIA 🇮🇳
Just because some illiterate politicans don't know english,you cant impose hindi on non-hindi speakers
No one speak the original hindi, kintu, prantu while speaking. People speak mixture of Hindi and Urdu, not original Hindu.
its called hindustani.
m b g j k
there is no original hindi , hindi is form of hindustani with more sanskrit words
South Indians are lucky, at least your language is the language of majority in your respective states. We who speak Urdu as our mother tongue are a minority all over the country, before independence Urdu was the co official language at par with Hindi in most of the Hindi belt but after partition, Urdu was completely stripped and even after 1980s when it was reintroduced as an official language in UP, Bihar and Delhi, the same was made as a second official language (not co official) due to which it has ended up becoming an optional subjects in schools and colleges resulting in a slow death of Urdu in north India (it has gone down from 5.3% in 1981 to just 4% in 2011 with a decrease in absolute numbers from 51 million in 2001 to 50 million in 2011 (with the lost numbers going in favor of Hindi). Urdu should be reintroduced as at par equal co official language the way it was before independence in the hindi belt.
Becoz of hindi ,Non hindi students get loosing their time in school days ....